Saatja: <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 04.05.2022 10:39
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>
Koopia: <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; MKM info <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; Konkurentsiamet
<
[email protected]>
Teema: REGARDING BALTIC BALANCING MARKET DEVELOPMENTS
Manused: REGARDING_BALTIC_BALANCING_MARKET_DEVELOPMENTS.asice; REGARDING
BALTIC BALANCING MARKET DEVELOPMENTS.docx.pdf
Laba diena,
Siunčiame Jums elektroniniu kvalifikuotu parašu LITGRID AB pasirašytą
dokumentą 2022-05-04 registracijos Nr. 22SD-2044.
Dokumentą (-us) rasite šio laiško priede.
Laiškas automatiškai sugeneruotas ir siunčiamas iš LITGRID AB DVS,
prašome
į jį neatsakyti.
Kilus klausimams dėl dokumento turinio, prašome kreiptis į dokumento
rengėją.
Pagarbiai
Litgrid AB
Karlo Gustavo Emilio Manerheimo g. 8,
LT-05131 Vilnius.
Tel. +370 707 02 171
[email protected]
www.litgrid.eu
________________________________
Šis el. laiškas skirtas tik jo adresatui. Šio el. laiško ir bet kokių jo
priedų turinys gali būti konfidenciali informacija ir jos panaudojimas ar
atskleidimas yra ribojamas. Jeigu Jūs nesate adresatas ar gavote šį el.
laišką įvykus klaidai, Jūs neturite teisės šio el. laiško ar jo priedų
atskleisti kitiems asmenims, kopijuoti ar kitaip platinti. Apie gautą el.
laišką prašome nedelsiant informuoti siuntėją ir sunaikinti šį el. laišką
ir
bet kokius jo priedus, neišsaugant kopijų ir neatskleidžiant jo turinio.
This e-mail is for the exclusive use of the intended recipient. The
contents
of this e-mail and any attachments may be confidential and are privileged
or
otherwise protected from disclosure. If you are not an intended recipient
or
you have received this e-mail mistakenly, you are hereby notified that
any
disclosure, copying or distribution of this information is strictly
prohibited. Kindly inform the sender about this e-mail and delete the
document and any attachment without retaining copies or disclosing its
contents.
________________________________
Eesti Energia AS Ignitis Group Latvenergo AS Cc: Baltic regulatory authorities Baltic energy ministries 202 2 - 0 4 - REGARDING BALTIC balancing market Developments Baltic TSOs on the 11th of March, 2022 have received the joint letter from Eesti Energia AS, Ignitis Group, Latvenergo AS (hereinafter – the Parties) titled „Further measures for decreasing the dependence of the Baltic power systems from Russia“ ( hereinafter – the Letter). In the Letter the Parties note that considering the current geopolitical situation and the plans of the Baltic states to desynchronise from the BRELL system, the Baltic states should take measures for keeping electricity systems more accurately in balance and thereby reduce area control error volumes from Russia. The Parties are calling on Baltic TSOs to introduce the Baltic aFRR capacity and energy market and Baltic mFRR capacity market (in addition to currently available mFRR energy market) as soon as possible. Baltic TSOs note that Baltic mFRR / aFRR energy market development is foreseen to be done in 2 major milestones which corresponds to major changes to market participants: Milestone 1– joining MARI platform ( target date 2023 Q4) – changes in Baltic balancing setup shall be made according to the EU Electricity balancing guideline requirements concerning mFRR processes and for joining MARI platform and sequential implementation of related 15-minute data exchange capability on TSO-TSO, TSO-BRP and TSO-BSP business processes level . Milestone 2 with target date Q4 2024 – a) introduction of aFRR processes in Baltics for preparation to Synchronization and sequential joining PICASSO platform; b) 15-minute ISP measurement data collection on DSOs level according to national legislation. These two milestones have been chosen to mark important preconditions for proper 15-minute products / ISP implementation, i.e. finalization of 15-minute resolution implementation for data exchanges at TSO-TSO, TSO-BRP and TSO-BSP level (since MARI project implements overall data exchange standardization and 15-minute mFRR products) and taking into account the interdependencies as detailed below . Baltic TSOs joining MARI platform timeline is aligned with the Nordic TSOs plans for joining the platform. Joining MARI platform together with Nordic TSOs is important to further cooperation process and grant availability of balancing resources to ensure liquid balancing market and secure and cost-efficient Baltic power system balancing. It shall be noted that for TSOs participating in MARI platform the balancing exchange with TSOs which are not participating in MARI would be limited only to emergency support events. Therefore, Baltic TSOs connection time to the mFRR platform is conditional on the neighbouring TSOs . Baltic TSOs aim not to operate Baltic mFRR market inefficiently in the decoupled mode from other areas on the MARI platform. Considering mentioned above, Baltic TSOs can join MARI platform only together with Nordic or Polish TSOs have joined MARI platform. H istorical data analysis show s that significant part of available cross-zonal capacity for balancing energy is between Baltic – Nordic region. Considering this, in order to maintain liquidity of Baltic and Nordic balancing market cooperation in balancing energy exchange, it is crucial for Baltic TSOs to join MARI platform together with Nordic TSOs. According to updated (2 9 . 10 .2021) r oadmap Nordic TSOs are expected to join MARI platform no earlier than Q4 2023. Following , the Baltic balancing (aFRR and mFRR) capacities market establishment by 2024 Q4 has been predetermined on the feasible timeline s for the critical implementations objective ly need ed to ensure reliable Baltic power systems operation considering foreseen Baltic synchronization with Continental Europe Network ( CEN ) in 2025. Baltic mFRR/aFRR balancing energy and capacity market developments require significant IT solutions . B altic TSOs IT systems need to be designed, updated and implemented to ensure reliable interconnection and operation with MARI and PICASSO platforms for sustainable and efficient physical cross-border balancing exchanges . The extensive scope and complexity of the needed IT solutions for TSO-TSO, TSO - BSP/BRP processes implementation leads to the extensive timing required to development, update of existing and implementation of new Baltic TSO s IT solutions. It is important to note that for the start of aFRR utilisation and market operation the critical infrastructure for Load-frequency control (LFC) including automatic generation control (AGC) needs to be implemented . Baltic TSOs currently do not hold the IT infrastructure to perform functions necessary for LFC and AGC. Baltic TSOs has started project s to implement LFC control , e stimated feasible go-live of the system is by 2024 Q2. T he practically feasible cri tical infrastructure implementation timelines lead to the above detailed mFRR/aFRR energy and capacity market implementation dates . In response to Parties request , it is worth to notice that Baltic TSOs are analysing feasibility to make the required preparations by the end of year 2023 in order to enable testing of the aFRR balancing activation s in 2024 . Following l ocal aFRR balancing market pilot projects are foreseen to be carried out in 2024. Within the local pilot project s LFC controller shall be enabled and mFRR / aFFR activations and market operations shall be tested. A critical factor in development of balancing markets is technical readiness of market participants to provide respective services. At the end of last year Baltic TSOs carried out public consultation on “Harmonised principles for Baltic LFC reserve prequalification”. It is expected that in the second half of this year the prequalification process of reserve providing units can be started. Baltic TSOs call on market participants to take part in the prequalification process as this would be one precondition for practical implementation of new balancing markets and products. Baltic TSOs thank the Parties for the proposal s and welcome encouragement for Baltic balancing market developme n t s to take place as soon as possible. Baltic TSO s note that TSOs are taking into account the developments and Baltic power systems interdependencies with all neighbouring systems . TSOs are assessing all the context, feasibilities, actions and balancing market development timing needed to ensure safe reliable and efficient operation of Baltic power systems /markets . TSOs note, that by 2022 Q3 Baltic TSOs foresee to communicate to the market further details of the foreseen Baltic balancing capacities market developments incl. Baltic TSOs proposal for Baltic balancing capacity market pursuant with Article 33(1) and Article 38(1) of EU Electricity balancing guideline. Elering AS Taavi Veskimägi , CEO AS “Augstsprieguma tīkls” Gunta Jēkabsone , Chairperson of the management board Gatis Junghans , Member of the Management Boar d LITGRID AB Rokas Masiulis, CEO
Eesti Energia AS 2022-04-
Ignitis Group
Latvenergo AS
Cc: Baltic regulatory authorities
Baltic energy ministries
REGARDING BALTIC BALANCING MARKET DEVELOPMENTS
Baltic TSOs on the 11th of March, 2022 have received the joint letter from Eesti Energia
AS, Ignitis Group, Latvenergo AS (hereinafter – the Parties) titled „Further measures for
decreasing the dependence of the Baltic power systems from Russia“ (hereinafter – the Letter).
In the Letter the Parties note that considering the current geopolitical situation and the plans of
the Baltic states to desynchronise from the BRELL system, the Baltic states should take measures
for keeping electricity systems more accurately in balance and thereby reduce area control error
volumes from Russia. The Parties are calling on Baltic TSOs to introduce the Baltic aFRR capacity
and energy market and Baltic mFRR capacity market (in addition to currently available mFRR
energy market) as soon as possible.
Baltic TSOs note that Baltic mFRR / aFRR energy market development is foreseen to be
done in 2 major milestones which corresponds to major changes to market participants:
Milestone 1– joining MARI platform (target date 2023 Q4) – changes in Baltic balancing
setup shall be made according to the EU Electricity balancing guideline requirements
concerning mFRR processes and for joining MARI platform and sequential implementation
of related 15-minute data exchange capability on TSO-TSO, TSO-BRP and TSO-BSP
business processes level.
Milestone 2 with target date Q4 2024 – a) introduction of aFRR processes in Baltics for
preparation to Synchronization and sequential joining PICASSO platform; b) 15-minute ISP
measurement data collection on DSOs level according to national legislation.
These two milestones have been chosen to mark important preconditions for proper 15-
minute products / ISP implementation, i.e. finalization of 15-minute resolution implementation
for data exchanges at TSO-TSO, TSO-BRP and TSO-BSP level (since MARI project implements
overall data exchange standardization and 15-minute mFRR products) and taking into account
the interdependencies as detailed below.
Baltic TSOs joining MARI platform timeline is aligned with the Nordic TSOs plans for joining
the platform. Joining MARI platform together with Nordic TSOs is important to further
cooperation process and grant availability of balancing resources to ensure liquid balancing
market and secure and cost-efficient Baltic power system balancing. It shall be noted that for
TSOs participating in MARI platform the balancing exchange with TSOs which are not
participating in MARI would be limited only to emergency support events. Therefore, Baltic TSOs
connection time to the mFRR platform is conditional on the neighbouring TSOs. Baltic TSOs aim
not to operate Baltic mFRR market inefficiently in the decoupled mode from other areas on the
MARI platform. Considering mentioned above, Baltic TSOs can join MARI platform only together
with Nordic or Polish TSOs have joined MARI platform. Historical data analysis shows that
significant part of available cross-zonal capacity for balancing energy is between Baltic – Nordic
region. Considering this, in order to maintain liquidity of Baltic and Nordic balancing market
2
cooperation in balancing energy exchange, it is crucial for Baltic TSOs to join MARI platform
together with Nordic TSOs.
According to updated (29.10.2021) roadmap Nordic TSOs are expected to join MARI platform no
earlier than Q4 2023.
Following, the Baltic balancing (aFRR and mFRR) capacities market establishment by 2024
Q4 has been predetermined on the feasible timelines for the critical implementations
objectively needed to ensure reliable Baltic power systems operation considering foreseen Baltic
synchronization with Continental Europe Network (CEN) in 2025. Baltic mFRR/aFRR balancing
energy and capacity market developments require significant IT solutions. Baltic TSOs IT systems
need to be designed, updated and implemented to ensure reliable interconnection and operation
with MARI and PICASSO platforms for sustainable and efficient physical cross-border balancing
exchanges. The extensive scope and complexity of the needed IT solutions for TSO-TSO, TSO -
BSP/BRP processes implementation leads to the extensive timing required to development,
update of existing and implementation of new Baltic TSOs IT solutions. It is important to note
that for the start of aFRR utilisation and market operation the critical infrastructure for Load-
frequency control (LFC) including automatic generation control (AGC) needs to be implemented.
Baltic TSOs currently do not hold the IT infrastructure to perform functions necessary for LFC
and AGC. Baltic TSOs has started projects to implement LFC control, estimated feasible go-live
of the system is by 2024 Q2. The practically feasible critical infrastructure implementation
timelines lead to the above detailed mFRR/aFRR energy and capacity market implementation
dates.
In response to Parties request, it is worth to notice that Baltic TSOs are analysing
feasibility to make the required preparations by the end of year 2023 in order to enable testing
of the aFRR balancing activations in 2024. Following local aFRR balancing market pilot projects
are foreseen to be carried out in 2024. Within the local pilot projects LFC controller shall be
enabled and mFRR / aFFR activations and market operations shall be tested.
A critical factor in development of balancing markets is technical readiness of market
participants to provide respective services. At the end of last year Baltic TSOs carried out public
consultation on “Harmonised principles for Baltic LFC reserve prequalification”. It is expected
that in the second half of this year the prequalification process of reserve providing units can be
started. Baltic TSOs call on market participants to take part in the prequalification process as
this would be one precondition for practical implementation of new balancing markets and
products. Baltic TSOs thank the Parties for the proposals and welcome encouragement for
Baltic balancing market developments to take place as soon as possible. Baltic TSOs note that
TSOs are taking into account the developments and Baltic power systems interdependencies with
all neighbouring systems. TSOs are assessing all the context, feasibilities, actions and balancing
market development timing needed to ensure safe reliable and efficient operation of Baltic
power systems/markets. TSOs note, that by 2022 Q3 Baltic TSOs foresee to communicate to the
market further details of the foreseen Baltic balancing capacities market developments incl.
Baltic TSOs proposal for Baltic balancing capacity market pursuant with Article 33(1) and Article
38(1) of EU Electricity balancing guideline.
Elering AS AS “Augstsprieguma tīkls” LITGRID AB
Taavi Veskimägi, CEO Gunta Jēkabsone, Rokas Masiulis, CEO
Chairperson of the
management board
Gatis Junghans, Member of
the Management Board
3