May 2022
The state of youth engagement
in the implementation of the EU's
Just Transition Mechanism
Authors
Writing
Lorenzo Manca - Climate Justice Coordinator. Generation Climate Europe
Jens Hunsbeth Schreuder - Just Transition Officer. CEE Bankwatch Network
Research
Lorenzo Manca (GCE), Jens Hunsbeth Schreuder (Bankwatch), Emily
Bankert (GCE), Maria Constantinescu (GCE), Dan Dobre (Bankwatch), Petr
Franc (GCE), Katharina Hartmann (GCE), Jana Leggen (GCE), Maris Pedaja
(Bankwatch), Kristin Tsenkova (GCE), Zuzana Vondrová (Bankwatch)
Editing & Layout
Elisabeth Mauguy (GCE), Emily Gray (Bankwatch), Stephanny Ulivieri (GCE),
Angelica Giambalvo (GCE), Martina Razzaboni (GCE), Matthew Harris (GCE)
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the following collaborators for their insights on
youth engagement in their respective regions: Patryk Białas (Bomiasto,
Katowice City Council), Piotr Czerniejewski (Young Locals Association -
Konin), Anton Kroeber (JugendWandelStrukturen), Fons Janssen (Climate
Pact Ambassador), Agata Kuźmińska (Green Future Institute),
Antonio Lenti (Fridays for Future- Taranto), Teele Pehk (Rohetiiger), Alina
Pogoda (Polish Green Network), Jana Schelte (JuNaFo), Carlotta Scema
(City Councillor in Iglesias), Alessio Siciliano (Giovani Democratici - Sulcis),
Christina Thomas (Landesjugendring NRW), Sietse Vlas (Provincial Youth
Advisory Council of Groningen)
Date Published
5th May 2022
Content
Executive Summary………………………………………….................p. 4
Introduction……………………………………......…….......................p. 7
Section 1. The engagement of youth in the Just Transition…...........p. 12
Section 2. Situation of youth engagement for the Territorial Just
Transition Plans of twelve EU Member States ….………................... p. 15
Bulgaria………………………………............................................ p. 16
Czechia……………………………………..................................... p. 18
Estonia…………………………………………….......................... p. 21
France…………………………………........................................... p. 23
Germany…………………………………...................................... p. 26
Ireland………………………………………..……........................ p. 31
Italy…………………………………….......................................... p. 33
Luxembourg……………………………………............................ p. 36
Netherlands……………………….………................................... p. 37
Poland…………………………….…............................................. p. 39
Romania…………………………..……………............................. p. 44
Spain………………………….………..…..................................... p. 47
Summary table……………………..……..................................... p. 49
Section 3. Conclusions and recommendations………….............….. p. 51
About us…………………………………………………....................... p. 55
List of abbreviations
EIB……………….European Investment Bank
EU………………..European Union
JTF………………Just Transition Fund
JTM…………….. Just Transition Mechanism
NGO…………….. Non-governmental Organisation
TJTP……………. Territorial Just Transition Plan
Reference
Generation Climate Europe & CEE Bankwatch Network (2022). The state of
youth engagement in the implementation of the EU's Just Transition
Mechanism. GCE & Bankwatch: Brussels.
3
Executive Summary
The Just Transition Mechanism (JTM) is a regional development programme of the European
Union (EU) aiming to support decarbonisation in those regions whose economy depends on
the production or consumption of fossil fuels. Spearheaded by the €19.5 billion investments of
the Just Transition Fund (JTF), the JTM is supposed to create new low-emission economic
activities and reskill workers currently employed in fossil fuels-related sectors. Its intervention
is expected to diversify the economy of those regions and end their dependency on fossil fuels.
In order to access funding, Member States must prepare dedicated planning documents called
Territorial Just Transition Plans (TJTPs) for their regions that depend on fossil fuels. The
TJTPs must justify the need for investments in those regions and outline a clear pathway for
the phasing out of fossil fuels and the launch of new green economic activities. EU Member
States have been preparing their TJTPs throughout 2020 and 2021. Now, in the first half of
2022, the European Commission is expected to review and approve the TJTPs to start financing
the transitions they outline.
As it is required to access all regional development funds of the EU, the TJTPs are also
supposed to comply with the partnership principle, which requires the national governments
to prepare and manage their plans with inputs and support from local authorities, businesses,
social actors and civil society representatives. Since the economic restructuring envisaged in
the TJTPs will have long-lasting effects on the targeted communities, a strong implementation
of the partnership principle is fundamental to make sure the people living in these
communities are engaged in the decisions on their future from start to end.
In particular, young people aged 16-29, as the next generations to live in those territories,
have a central role to play in the development of TJTPs and the visions these plans outline -
a role that is recognised and actively promoted by the EU itself. However, the past reports from
Bankwatch on the state of TJTPs have revealed that the partnership principle has been applied
in very different ways across and within EU Member States, with several regions in which civil
society representatives have not been engaged. This poses the serious risk that even young
people in those communities will not have a say in the decisions impacting their own future
and career opportunities.
B 4
This report provides a first overview of the political youth engagement activities for the
development of Territorial Just Transition Plans of twelve EU Member States. For each
country, we look at the partnership processes set up by the national and local authorities in
preparation of their TJTPs and identify, wherever they are present, the specific activities for the
engagement of young people. For four countries, the information from institutional sources
was complemented with interviews to local youth activists active on the just transition at the
local level, whether they participated in the TJTPs writing directly or from outside.
Main Findings
Youth representatives were engaged in some form in the development of TJTPs only
in seven EU countries out of the twelve under analysis.
Most youth engagement processes consisted of providing feedback to already
consolidated drafts, which greatly limited the possibility to provide input and have a say
in the TJTPs from their inception. Most processes fall short of the basic conditions for
1
meaningful youth participation in the just transition defined by the European Commission.
Youth engagement proved particularly successful in those regions where the local
civil society had the capacity to mobilise and represent the voice of youth, which
creates a gap with other regions where the civil society had less resources and mobilisation
capacities.
1. See European Commission (2021). Youth for a just transition. A toolkit for youth participation in the Just
Transition Fund. EU, Brussels.
B 5
Recommendations
The engagement of youth in the TJTPs must be harmonised across and within all EU
Member States. The transition envisaged by the JTM cannot be truly just unless young
people provide input not just to a few, but to all TJTPs.
The national governments of EU Member States must provide for clear political youth
engagement activities in the upcoming implementation of the TJTPs, and equip civil
servants accordingly. The existing stakeholder engagement mechanisms must be revised
to welcome transparently-selected youth representatives, and a clear share of the projects
should be dedicated to young entrepreneurs, political youth engagement activities and
education programmes in schools and tertiary education.
The European Commission should evaluate the partnerships defined in the TJTPs and
provide recommendations on how to improve them, including specific measures to
promote youth engagement. Its technical support should provide concrete indications to
state authorities and civil servants to design meaningful youth engagement processes in
line with its "Toolkit for youth participation in the JTF".
The European Parliament should use its monitoring powers to their full extent to
ensure that the partnerships of TJTPs are meaningful, fair, inclusive and properly
implemented. It should open up to inputs from the civil society to complement the reports
from the Member States and the European Commission.
B 6
Introduction
Since the European Commission started its mandate in December 2019 under the presidency of
Ursula von der Leyen, the core of its programme has been the European Green Deal, a political
pathway to put the European Union on track to become carbon-neutral by 2050.2 The Green
Deal made clear that the transition it set in motion would be “just and inclusive”(p.1) by
supporting the people and businesses that would face the hardest challenges from the
abandoning of fossil fuels, which is the necessary precondition to achieve a carbon-neutral
economy.
In this context, the Green Deal put forward the Just Transition Mechanism (JTM) as a
dedicated financial programme to provide support to those regions that are particularly
negatively affected by the phasing-out of fossil fuels, usually because their economy is overly
dependent on the production and/or consumption of coal, oil and gas. The European
Commission already identified the NUTS 3 statistical regions across the EU that depend on
fossil fuels in the context of the European Semester 2020, and enumerated them in the Annex D
3
of each country report. To these and other regions justified by Member States, the Just
Transition Mechanism provides targeted support to the tune of €55 billion divided between
three “pillars”: (1) the Just Transition Fund (JTF), (2) a dedicated Just Transition scheme
under the InvestEU programme and (3) a new public sector loan facility consisting of EU
4
grants and loans from the European Investment Bank (EIB).
2. European Commission (2019). COM/2019/640 final. The European Green Deal. EU:Brussels.
3. European Commission (2022). 2020 European Semester: Country Reports. (Link. Last consulted: 13.04.2022).
4. European Commission (2022). Just Transition funding sources. (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022)
B 7
1. The Just Transition Fund (JTF)
The Just Transition Fund (JTF) is the leading pillar of the Just Transition Mechanism. First
proposed in January 2020 by the European Commission, the JTF is a territorial cohesion fund
financed by the EU Multiannual Financial Framework 2021-2027. The Regulation establishing
5
the JTF entered into force in July 2021, defining its structure and functioning.
The JTF is entitled to finance investments in new businesses, research & innovation, renewable
energy, sustainable mobility, district heating, digitalisation, decontamination and circularity.
To complement such investments, the JTF can also finance projects on the reskilling and
upskilling of workers from the fossil fuels sector, as well as job-search assistance, education
and social inclusion activities.
The Fund is endowed with €17.5 billion in 2018 values (roughly €19.5 billion in 2021), which
have been allocated to all 27 EU Member States in precise quotas. The top five recipients are
Poland (20%), Germany (13%), Romania (11%), Czech Republic (8.5%) and Bulgaria (6.7%),
which combined account for 59.2% of total funding.
2. Dedicated scheme under InvestEU
The second pillar of the JTM is a dedicated Just Transition scheme under InvestEU. InvestEU is
an EU programme to support sustainable investment, innovation and job creation which is
expected to mobilise around €372 billion under the current Multiannual Financial Framework
2021-2027.6 The dedicated Just Transition scheme under InvestEU was launched in January
2020 and is expected to mobilise €10-15 billion, mostly in private sector investments. Projects
in regions supported by the JTF can benefit from the scheme, provided such investments are
key to the transition outlined in the relevant TJTP [see again footnote 4].
5. EU (2021). Regulation (EU) 2021/1056 establishing the Just Transition Fund. EU: Brussels.
6. European Commission (2022). InvestEU. (Link. Last consulted: 19.04.2022).
B 8
3. Public sector loan facility
The third pillar of the Just Transition Mechanism is a new public sector loan facility leveraged
by the European Investment Bank (EIB). It comprises €1.5 billion in grants from the EU budget
and €10 billion in loans from the EIB. The facility will exclusively target public entities,
providing support to projects in the regions targeted by the JTF that do not produce a sufficient
stream of revenues to be financed commercially. It is expected to mobilise roughly €25-30
billion in public investments [see footnote 4].
Access to funding and the partnership principle
According to the JTF regulation, Member States seeking to receive project funding for their
eligible regions must deliver Territorial Just Transition Plans (TJTPs) to the European
Commission. The TJTPs are documents that must include a justification for identifying the
concerned territories as particularly negatively affected by the phasing-out of fossil fuels, and
outline detailed investment strategies towards a climate neutral economy, in line with the EU
emissions reduction targets for 2030 and 2050.
Each EU Member State designates a national ministry to oversee the writing of one or more
TJTPs in their respective country. It is up to each government to decide how many TJTPs they
want to present to the Commission and for which regions, as long as they can justify it.
However, the regions already identified by the Commission seem to have higher chances of
approval. Upon request, the Commission provides technical assistance to the ministries, which
is then carried out by external partners such as academic institutions and consulting firms.
For all its regional development funds, the EU has been embracing the partnership principle,
which requires that Member States manage the decisions and implementation measures
connected to the funds together with local authorities, economic and social partners, civil
society representatives and academic institutions.7 For the TJTPs, all relevant regulations and
8
internal EU documents underline the importance of partnerships and transparency.
7. Heinelt, H., & Petzold, W. (2018). "The structural funds and EU cohesion policy". In Handbook of European
Policies. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing. doi: https://doi.org/10.4337/9781784719364.00015
8. See the Common Provisions Regulation (2021/1060), the JTF Regulation (2021/1056) and the internal
document of the Commission on Territorial Just Transition Plans (SWD(2021) 275 final).
B 9
In particular, the JTF regulation provides that the preparation and implementation of the
TJTPs must be deliberated in cooperation with the relevant partners mentioned above.
However, so far the partnership principle has been deployed very differently from region to
region. The TJTPs are usually drafted by the competent national ministry with the assistance of
national and/or local working groups composed of government officials, representatives of the
European Commission, local authorities, business associations, academics, trade unions and
NGO representatives. On top of the working groups, state authorities may decide to consult
stakeholder groups through a variety of formats, such as workshops, conferences, calls for
projects, surveys, bilateral meetings and public consultations. All these partnership
instruments often have widely diverging degrees of influence on the development of the TJTPs,
sometimes even from region to region within the same country.
State of play
The following figure provides an overview of the steps undergone by the JTM so far and those
yet to come.
As of April 2022, the majority of JT regions are still in the programming phase. This means that
their TJTPs are still in the process of being drafted and negotiated between national
authorities and the European Commission. This process lacks transparency, as the Commission
has always avoided to publish the draft TJTPs and its exchanges with Member States despite
the repeated requests of several stakeholders. As a result, it is not possible to know the
development stage of each TJTP, and it is expected that they will be published only after the
Commission will approve their final version.
B 10
The European Commission is expected to give its approval to TJTPs throughout 2022. Once a
TJTP is approved, the authorities of the Member State can begin the implementation phase,
which consists of preparing project proposals to be financed by the three pillars of the JTM. In
line with the content of the TJTPs, projects can be used for economic diversification and the
upskilling and reskilling of workers employed in the fossil fuels sector. Funding can also be
given to projects that fall out of the scope of greater economic diversification provided it is
directly linked to specific objectives of the JTF or clearly contributes to the
implementation of the TJTP. This can include investments on fields such as renewable
energy, energy efficiency or research and innovation. The use of this clause will require
particular attention, as it could be used by Member States in opaque ways that go against the
purpose of the just transition, such as compensating coal industries or paying for the
environmental damage they caused.
In conjunction with implementation, relevant authorities will also monitor the use of the JTM.
This involves reporting on the state of the projects that receive funding, the degree to which
they fulfil indicators, and how they align with certain criteria set out in the relevant EU
regulations and in the TJTPs. Relevant stakeholders are supposed to be involved in this phase
as well, and according to Bankwatch sources Member States will likely do so through dedicated
monitoring committees.
B 11
Section 1. The engagement of the youth
in the Just Transition Mechanism
The ambitious objective of the JTM is to reshape the socio-economic future of entire regions in
the EU. Given the magnitude of the envisaged change, next generations are a key
stakeholder as the citizens who are expected to inherit what the JTM will build in terms of
job opportunities, socio-economic conditions, infrastructures and environmental
restoration. It is hardly conceivable that the future of a community is decided without the
people who will live in it. The engagement of young people in the just transition is thus
necessary to ensure the JTM achieves its objectives, serves the future of the communities it is
supporting, and guarantees intergenerational justice in the decisions that are made.
The European Commission is the EU institution tasked by the JTF Regulation with coordinating
the implementation of the TJTPs and providing technical support to Member States. In this
role, the Commission has addressed the engagement of civil society in the drafting of TJTPs,
including the engagement of young people as a specific stakeholder group within civil society.
This section will present the main documents and positions of the Commission on youth
engagement in order to provide a background to our analysis of their implementation country
by country covered by Section 2.
EU efforts to include youth in the just transition
The European Commission has made considerable efforts to have young people included
in the just transition from the beginning by sponsoring their participation in the development
of the TJTPs.
In January 2021, when most Member States already started working on TJTPs, the
Commission published a guidelines document called “Youth for a Just Transition. A toolkit for
youth participation in the JTF”, whose stated aim is achieving a participation of young people
9
to the TJTPs that is “ambitious, meaningful and numerous” (p.9). We will expand on its
content and its role further in this section.
9. European Commission (2021). Youth for a just transition. A toolkit for youth participation in the Just Transition
Fund. EU: Brussels.
B 12
Later on, in September 2021, the Commission reiterated the fundamental role of youth
10
participation in an internal document on the TJTPs and their evaluation. In the document, the
Commission highlighted that the partnership principle is a key feature of cohesion policy, and
that “the JTF is about inventing a new economic and social future for these areas, and young
people must play an active role in this” (p.20). Although such statements are not binding for the
evaluation of TJTPs, they serve as a politically relevant acknowledgement from the EU
institution that coordinates the implementation of the JTM.
Now, when it comes to suggest concrete measures to apply its call for “meaningful youth
participation", the Commission does not provide a specific definition of what it is exactly
intended when using this concept. However, its Toolkit for Youth Participation in the JTF does
specify that youth participation is meaningful provided that it respects some basic conditions,
divided in three pillars:
1) Before you start - Adapt and enable
Treating young people as equals
Setting up a youth engagement process with clear goals and a precise scope
Co-creating the rules of the process with youth representatives
Communicating and advertising the process through the right instruments (awareness
raising, social media etc.)
Building partnerships with local actors connected to youth (schools, associations etc.)
2) Youth participation - Work with them, not for them
Involving youth representatives across all stages of the process
Giving youth representatives a real role in the debate and projects
Recognising that youth is not a homogenous group
10. European Commission (2021). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT on the territorial just transition plans
SWD(2021) 275 final.
B 13
Reaching out to marginalised groups and individuals within youth itself
Mapping, listing and connecting local youth actors to empower them
Adapting communication to the style of young people
3) Close the circle
Providing for follow-up processes to allow youth to be informed on how their input was
used
Making participation continuous to make sure youth are engaged throughout the policy-
making processes linked to the just transition
The Toolkit illustrates these basic conditions with a number of examples of practical actions
and some best practices from past political participation activities involving youth in EU
policies. While the presence of a practical definition of youth participation would have
provided more context to these principles and examples, the content of the Toolkit does cover
most practical challenges of engaging youth in policy. It is particularly positive that it clarifies
that youth is not a homogeneous group, and several minorities and individuals within it are
often left behind in political engagement processes. However, the use of the word
"participation" seems to imply a consultative and less direct role of youth in the political
decisions as an external actor in a process run by the authorities. We would rather use the word
"engagement", as we do in this report, because it implies an empowered role where youth is
supposed to be an insider in all decisions and actions, as the partnership principle requires.
Overall, the principles and actions defined in the Commission’s Toolkit are a good first step to
empower young people to provide a concrete input to the TJTPs of their region. However,
while the Commission has shared the Toolkit with the Member States, local authorities and
other stakeholders through its distribution channels, as of April 2022 it has not yet carried out
an assessment of whether and how the Toolkit has been implemented in the making of TJTPs.
This report aims to fill the lack of a EU-wide assessment on the meaningful engagement of
youth in the TJTPs by providing an overview of the youth engagement activities reported by
the EU Member States and complementing them with the insights from youth climate activists
from the regions included in the just transition.
B 14
Section 2. Situation of youth engagement for
the Territorial Just Transition Plans of twelve
EU Member States
This section will outline the engagement activities specifically dedicated to young people in the
decision making and writing of the Territorial Just Transition Plans in twelve EU Member
States: Bulgaria, Czechia, Estonia, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the
Netherlands, Poland, Romania and Spain.
The countries included in the report were chosen based on their weight within the JTF funding
allocation and a varied geographical coverage of EU Member States. The regions we focused on
are those first identified as beneficiaries of the JTF by the European Commission in the Annex D
of the country reports for the European Semester 2020. Any other regions for which Member
States are writing TJTPs have not been considered since the approval of their application is not
assured and they might have to be excluded from future reports if the Commission rejected it.
Wherever information is available, the situations of the single regions that are applying for
funding under the JTM are dealt with in as much detail as possible. The information used for
the country and region profiles comes mostly from publicly available official sources,
including reports from the European Commission, national and regional authorities and the
consultancies that supported the governments with the TJTPs. The previous Bankwatch
reports on the state of TJTPs provided much of the context information.11
For the sake of including the voice of youth representatives themselves and conveying their
experiences on the engagement processes, GCE complemented the information from the
Member States with interviews with local youth climate activists active on the just
transition in the targeted regions. Nine interviews could be conducted between January and
April 2022, covering five countries (Poland, Germany, Italy, Estonia and the Netherlands) and
nine regions (Eastern Wielkopolska, Upper Silesia, Lower Silesia, Lausitzer Revier, Rheinisches
Revier, Sulcis, Taranto, Ida Viru and Groningen). Some of the interviewees participated in
person in the youth engagement activities of their state authorities, while others are
knowledgeable about the just transition process but could only follow it from outside owing to
a lack of youth engagement activities. The resulting country profiles will follow now in
alphabetical order.
11. All reports are accessible at the web page https://bankwatch.org/project/just-transition#project-publications
B 15
Bulgaria
In the 2020 country report, the European Commission indicated that the just transition in
Bulgaria is mostly supposed to focus on the major mining area of Maritsa, in the Stara Zagora
Province. Maritsa accounts for 85% of all jobs in the coal sector of the country, with over 10.700
workers in the mines and 1.800 in the energy plants. The Commission also suggested to include
the second Bulgarian coal mining area by size near the town of Bobov Dol, in the Province of
12
Kyustendil, where around 1.500 jobs depend on the brown coal industry.
Following this input, the Bulgarian government decided to draft a TJTP for the Stara Zagora
Province and one for the Bobov Dol coal area, spanning the Provinces of Kyustendil and Pernik.
The overseeing and drafting of the TJTPs in Bulgaria is entrusted to the national Ministry of
Energy. The consultancy firm PriceWaterhouseCoopers (Pwc) provides technical assistance in
the process. The partnership with relevant stakeholders is managed mostly by Pwc at the
national level and the local authorities in the two targeted coal regions. In early 2021, the
consultant first set up an ad-hoc national working group of 15 experts and former directors of
coal industries. After that, throughout 2021 it reached out to national and local authorities,
businesses, trade unions and environmental NGOs to consult them via bilateral meetings. In
most cases, these meetings aimed at illustrating the strategy and progress of the working
group, with the possibility for participants to give feedback. No multi-stakeholder meetings
were organised to exchange views and gather proposals.
12. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Bulgaria 2020. SWD/2020/501 final.
B 16
Youth associations did not feature among the stakeholders approached by the consultant
to provide feedback on the TJTPs, but in its final report they were indicated as a potential
13
stakeholder for the implementation phase.
When it comes to the local authorities, from 29-30 September 2021 the local Development
Agency of Stara Zagora and WWF Bulgaria organised the 4th meeting of the EU-wide Forum of
Mayors for the Just Transition in Stara Zagora city. The hybrid event mustered officials from the
European Commission and various local authorities from other EU States together with local
Bulgarian stakeholders to discuss the state of the just transition through thematic debate
sessions. One of the sessions did include four youth representatives from student associations
and NGOs to discuss the future of the Bulgarian coal areas.14 However, apparently the event was
not part of a more structured consultation process, and no follow-up processes were revealed,
so it is likely that the engagement of youth representatives was limited to that event,
without a real possibility to provide input to the TJTPs.
As of April 2022, the Ministry of Energy has not yet published the results of the consultations
with stakeholders or the drafts of the TJTPs, so that it is still not possible to know the content
of the plans and whether the feedback from stakeholders was included in them.
13. Pwc Bulgaria (2021). Assistance in the preparation of territorial plans for a just transition in the Republic of
Bulgaria – Stara Zagora region. 14.12.2021. (Available at link. Last consulted: 10.04.2022)
14. WWF & SZREDA (2021). 4th Forum of Mayors on Just Transition. Agenda. (Available at link. Last consulted:
10.04.2022).
B 17
Czechia
The just transition in Czechia is targeting the two coal mining regions spanning the three
provinces (kraj) of Moravskoslezský, Ústecký and Karlovarský which together are home to over
21.000 people working directly in mines and energy plants, plus around 19.000 indirect jobs.
15
The national Ministry of Regional Development oversees the development of the three Czech
TJTPs, with technical assistance provided by the Frankfurt School of Management and Finance
and the Technical University of Prague.
Bílina coal mine. Ústecký Region. ©Milan Jáhna
15. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Czech Republic 2020. SWD/2020/502 final.
B 18
The Ministry structured its partnership with relevant stakeholders around a national working
group called Transformation Platform, established in October 2020. The working group is
supposed to provide stakeholders with a means to influence the drafting of the TJTPs. It is
composed of 39 members from national ministries, local authorities and representatives from
business and trade unions. Civil society representatives were initially not included in the
Platform. However, after some repeated petitioning, a single representative from the NGO
Centre for Transport and Energy was allowed to join in 2021 with a mandate to represent the
entire civil society.16 According to a written reply we received from the Czech government,
youth is represented in the national Czech working group through representatives of the
Czech Council for Children and Youth.
Despite the inclusion of youth representatives in the meetings, the format of the consultation
in the working group is problematic. The meetings are structured for one-way communication
from the Ministry about the current state of the TJTPs draft. A first draft was presented to
participants already during the first meeting in October 2020. Following each meeting,
participants are given a one week deadline to submit feedback on the information they receive.
The short deadline and the lack of direct communication during meetings significantly inhibits
the possibility of providing meaningful comments. However, the working group did provide
feedback for the TJTPs, and some of it was taken up from one version of the draft to another.
Besides the working group, the contact person from the Czech government mentioned to us
that local youth engagement activities were organised in the three coal regions. However,
neither the website of the Ministry nor the three dedicated websites of the regional
17
governments report any consultation activity with local stakeholders. As a result, there are no
confirmed engagement activities for the TJTPs dedicated to youth at the local level.
16. Bärbel Rösch, L. & Epifanio, D. (2022). Just transition in 7 central and eastern European countries. What works
and what does not. CEE Bankwatch: Prague.
17. See dedicated websites of Moravskoslezský, Ústecký and Karlovarský
B 19
As of April 2022, the latest drafts of the TJTPs are publicly available on the website of the
Ministry. In the TJTPs drafts, no mention is made of youth engagement activities for the
18
implementation and monitoring phases. Although the reply we received from the Czech
government claimed that a public consultation is expected by the mid of the programming
period, mentioning youth engagement activities in the TJTP would make for a stronger
guarantee that young people will be included in the future.
Overall, although young people have been included in the partnership with relevant
stakeholders in Czechia, there are still several critical points both on the functioning of the
partnership itself and on how meaningful the role of youth representatives is.
18. DotaceEU (2022). Transformační platforma. (Available at link. Last consulted: 10.04.2022).
B 20
Estonia
Just Transition Region - Ida-Viru County
The Ida-Viru County is the only region targeted by the Just Transition Mechanism in Estonia.
Located on the border with Russia, it is the main centre of shale oil production in the Baltic
state, generating some 75% of Estonia’s energy production and 69% of its greenhouse gas
emissions. 20.000 jobs are estimated to be connected to the shale oil sector in the region.19
Shale oil plant. Ida Viru County. ©Jaak Nilson Photostock
19. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Estonia 2020. SWD/2020/505 final.
B 21
The Ida Viru TJTP is managed by the national Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communication,
which has been developing it throughout 2021 and the beginning of 2022. Across the process,
the Ministry has regularly consulted policy makers, businesses and NGOs through a national
steering committee in Tallinn, a local one in Ida Viru, and a final round of consultations in
20
October-November 2021.
Concerning the engagement of youth, ahead of the final round of consultations the Ministry
was approached by the NGO Rohetiiger to organise a citizens assembly of randomly selected
local young people and provide feedback to the draft TJTP. According to our interviewee from
the organisation, Rohetiiger is a national NGO that regularly organises citizen assemblies on a
variety of policy issues. In the context of a call for funds focused on youth, they decided to use
their format to allow young people from Ida Viru to provide feedback to the TJTP.
Out of a random sample of 3000 local youths aged 16-29, Rohetiiger selected 33 people and
organised some meetings with them where experts introduced them to the TJTP and
stimulated the discussion to come back with feedback. Since over 70% of the County’s
population are native Russian speakers, the assembly has linguistic facilities for both Estonian
and Russian speakers.
The main outcome of the citizen assembly were 26 feedback proposals on the draft of the
TJTP, mostly concerning environmental restoration and public amenities (parks, green areas
etc.). Some participants founded a follow-up NGO to monitor the future uptaking of the
proposals in the TJTP and their implementation.
As of April 2022, the national Ministry has not yet published the draft TJTP, so that it is not yet
possible to assess how the ministry has used the feedback received from the youth assembly.
In conclusion, although young people could only provide input to a consolidated draft, the
engagement activity in Ida Viru seems to have been a good first step that might lead to
more meaningful engagement if a good follow-up is implemented.
20. CEE Bankwatch Network (2021). Status of the Territorial Just Transition Plans in central and eastern Europe.
Bankwatch:Prague.
B 22
France
The Just Transition in France was initially proposed by the European Commission to focus on
the departments (local circumscriptions) of Bouches-du-Rhône, in the Provence-Alpes-Côte
d’Azur (PAC) Region, and Nord, in the Hauts-de-France Region. The two areas have a high
concentration of energy-intensive industries, particularly chemical and steel plants, making
them the most emissions-intensive parts of the country while providing for over 153.000 local
21
jobs.
According to the National Recovery and Resilience Plan,23 the French TJTPs are coordinated by
the National Agency for Territorial Cohesion (ANCT) of the French Government with support
from the consultancy firm Technopolis and the authorities from the administrative regions
where the targeted departments are located. On top of the two departments identified by the
Commission, the French government decided to write four extra TJTPs for eight departments
22
located in the regions of Normandy, Pays de la Loire, Grand Est and Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes. As
a result, six TJTPs are being developed in France. Their implementation will be managed by the
Regions when it comes to investments (70% of all funding from the JTF), and by the Ministry of
Work when it comes to reskilling and upskilling projects (30%). The partnerships with relevant
stakeholders are managed at the local level by the Regions.
21. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report France 2020. SWD/2020/509 final.
22. Seine Maritime, Loire Atlantique, Moselle, Meurthe et Moselle, Pas de Calais, Isère, Haut Rhin and Rhône.
23. French Government (2021). National Plan of Recovery and Resiliency. Link. Last consulted: 11.04.2022).
B 23
Just Transition Region - Bouches-du-Rhône
The Bouches-du-Rhône department, located in the Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur (PAC) region of
Southern France, hosts several petrochemical and steel industries, with tens of thousands of
24
job places depending on them.
The TJTP for the department is managed by the PAC Region. The Region first presented the
JTM to the public in November 2020 to gather feedback and project proposals, and then
elaborated the TJTP throughout 2021. Two working groups with representatives of the local
and national authorities were set up, and non-institutional stakeholders were consulted via
bilateral meetings. No list of the consulted stakeholders has been revealed. A final public
25
consultation was carried out between 7 December 2021 and 4 January 2022 by making the
draft TJTP and the accompanying assessments available on the website of the region.
According to the final report on the consultation, no contribution was received from the public.
26
The Bouche-du-Rhone Department has also got its own Youth Council, which apparently was
not involved in the making of the TJTP. Overall, youth were not properly engaged in the local
consultation, as much as civil society in general.
24. Maregionsud.fr (2022). Fond Transition Juste. Processus d'élaboration.(Link.Last consulted: 11.04.2022).
25. PAC Region (2021). Just Transition Plan Model. (Link. Last consulted: 11.04.2022).
26. PAC Region (2022). Plan de Transition Juste de la Région Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur 2021-2027 - Synthèse de
la consultation du public.(Link. Last consulted: 11.04.2022).
B 24
Just Transition Region - Nord & Pas de Calais
The Nord and Pas-de-Calais Departments, located in the Hauts-de-France Region of Northern
France, are home to several electro-intensive industries in the sectors of metallurgy, chemical
and petrochemical production. The Region estimates that around 63 000 people are directly
27
employed by such industries.
28
The TJTP for the two departments was managed by the Hauts-de-France Region. Initially, the
Commission only included the Nord Department in the just transition, but the TJTP
geographical coverage was extended to the neighbouring Pas de Calais Department. According
to the official draft [see note 27], the Plan was elaborated by the regional authorities
throughout 2021 in cooperation with representatives from the industry and trade unions, but
no actors from the civil society are mentioned. A public consultation on the resulting Plan was
carried out from 1 April 2022 to 1 May 2022 on the website of the Hauts-de-France Region
dedicated to European funding. The draft TJTP and the accompanying environmental
29
assessments were published on the website and opened for feedback from the public. As of the
publishing date of this report, the results of the consultation are not yet available.
The general lack of engagement of the civil society in the drafting of the TJTP was
reflected in the role of youth, which was also absent.
27. Region Hauts-de-France (2022). Plan de Transition Juste Hauts De France pour les territoires du Nord et du Pas
de Calais. https://europe-en-hautsdefrance.eu/download/plan-territorial-de-transition-juste-hdf/
28. Region Hauts-de-France (2022). Concertation sur le Plan Territorial de Transition Juste 2021-2027. (Link. Last
consulted: 14.04.2022).
29. Region Hauts-de-France (2022). Avis d'ouverture de consultation publique relative au Programme
Opérationnel FEDER-FSE+-FTJ Hauts-de-France 2021-2027. (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022).
B 25
Germany
With most of its energy needs still satisfied by coal, and with the remnants of a considerable
coal extraction industry, Germany is the second major recipient of funding from the Just
Transition Mechanism, with €2.5 billion from the JTF alone, accounting for 13% of the total
30
capital of the fund. In 2020, Germany decided to phase out coal production and consumption
by 2038.31 To achieve its goal, the federal government plans to support the transition in the coal
regions through the investment regulation which is part of its dedicated Structural
Strengthening Law. The first pillar of this support for economic diversification projects provides
€14 billion for coal areas until 2038. The second pillar supports measures and projects on the
federal level with another €26 billion for the affected regions until 2038. The funding from the
32
JTM comes as an additional support to coal regions, but Germany is probably the only country
covered by this report where national investments on a just transition overshadow those
coming from the EU.
The intervention of the JTM focuses on the three territories (German: “Revier”) where most
workers employed in the coal industry are still concentrated, spanning the Eastern federal
states of Brandeburg, Saxony and Saxony-Anhalt as well as the Western federal state of North-
Rhine Westphalia.
30. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Germany 2020. SWD/2020/504 final.
31. German Bundestag (2020). Kohleausstiegsgesetz (Link. Last consulted: 15.04.2022).
32. German Ministry of the Economy and Energy (2022) Kohleausstieg und Strukturwandel (Link. Last consulted:
16.04.2022)
B 26
These three just transition regions do not coincide with a specific administrative division, and
the two Eastern ones even span the territory of two federal states at the same time (see region
profiles below).
The TJTPs of the three territories are coordinated by the Federal Ministry for Economy &
Climate Protection, and written by the federal states where the target coal regions are located.
In the context of the national strategy for cohesion policy 2021-27, the JTF is planned to be
implemented through five multi-fund Operational Programmes associated with two other EU
33
funds: the European Regional Development Fund and the European Social Fund.
When it comes to partnering with relevant stakeholders for the drafting of TJTPs, the
information disclosed by the state and federal authorities is quite limited and fragmented.
From what is published on official websites, the consultations for the TJTPs, when they took
place, have been based mostly on written feedback to already consolidated drafts (see region
profiles below). The relatively limited size of the funding from the JTF compared to federal
sources and its association with two other EU funds might have greatly influenced the quality
of the partnerships for the German TJTPs. Unlike what is disclosed for the TJTPs, consultations
with several stakeholders and multiple formats were regularly carried out for the two funds the
JTF is associated with, the Regional Development Fund and the Social Fund Plus. It is not clear
though if the consultations were carried out separately or together for the three funds.
33. German Government (2022). EU-Kohäsions- und Strukturpolitik. (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022).
B 27
Just Transition Region - Lausitzer Revier
Spanning the federal states of Brandenburg and Saxony, in Eastern Germany, the Lausitz
mining area is a major producer of brown coal. According to the Commission, the phasing out
of fossil fuel in the area could endanger the 8.300 direct employees of the coal industry plus an
extra 4.900 indirect workers.
The TJTP is managed by the Lausitz Coordination Unit of the two federal states. According to
the dedicated webpage of the Brandenburg EU funding website, the TJTP was developed
throughout 2021, and opened to written feedback on the website around November 2021. As of
April 2022, no draft of the TJTP or report of the consultation is available on the webpage, and it
34
is not possible to assess whether they were on the page in November as stated.
Given the lack of a report, it is not possible to say whether youth organisations or activists
could provide feedback to the Lausitz TJTP. However, providing feedback to an already
consolidated draft falls short of the meaningful conditions for youth engagement defined by
the European Commission.
Despite this lack of insight in to the creation of the TJTP, other local plans and programmes for
economic diversification do exist in Lausitz, and they seem to have involved different actors
from the federal state and its administration, to representatives of local authorities,
businesses, trade unions and the civil society, including the German Foundation for Children
35
and Youth in Berlin.
In Autumn 2019, interested citizens were able to participate in online consultations for a new
Development Strategy 2050 (Entwicklungsstrategie 2050). Following the initiative from the
University of Lüneburg, in November 2021 young people could take part in a workshop on how
to shape the phasing out of coal in the affected region. The ideas are currently being bundled
into a report which was meant to be handed over to the regional and federal governments by
36
Spring 2022.
34. Land Brandenburg (2022). Just Transition Fund. (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022).
35. Land Brandenburg (2022). Lausitz. Aktuelles. (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022)
36. Jugend Politik Beratung (2022). Planathon “Jugend gestaltet Strukturwandel. (Link. Last consulted:
16.04.2022)
B 28
Just Transition Region - Mitteldeutsches Revier
Located between the Laender Saxony and Saxony-Anhalt, the region hosts the smallest share
of direct and indirect jobs in brown coal mining among the three German regions supported by
the JTM, representing only 0.3% of the local workforce. However, the Commission deems that
the region needs investments due to its low level of innovation and rapidly ageing population.
No Information on the development of a TJTP for the Mitteldeutsche Revier could be found in
the websites of the two federal states. When it comes to federal funding though, the
Mitteldeutsche Revier is expected to receive €8 billion until 2038. The implementing Structural
Development Programme is a result of recommendations by the board of federal and state
governments as well as different state strategies such as the regional innovation strategy.37
Next to other working groups, the governmental Structural Change Unit convened the
consortium "Social Participation”, composed of representatives of organised civil society from
various stakeholder groups (e.g. youth, senior citizens, migrants, people with disabilities and
impairments) to discuss citizen participation in the just transition. In June 2021, the Structural
Development Programme then received inputs from these stakeholder engagement activities
conducted by the governmental Structural Change Unit. It is not clear from the final text of the
Programme what the specific contribution of youth representatives was. However, the
document contains criteria for future participation and acknowledges that young people
38
should play a special role in the participation process.
Such plenty of information on national programmes as compared to EU funds might show the
unique approach Germany is taking in its just transition and the fact that national funding
greatly overshadows the JTM.
37. Land Sachsen-Anhalt (2022). Strukturentwicklungsprogramm. https://strukturwandel.sachsen-
anhalt.de/perspektiven/strukturentwicklungsprogramm/ (Last consulted: 24.04.2022).
38. Land Sachsen-Anhalt (2021). STRUKTURENTWICKLUNGSPROGRAMM. Mitteldeutsches Revier Sachsen-Anhalt.
(Link. Last consulted: 24.04.2022).
B 29
Just Transition Region - Rheinisches Revier
Located in the federal state of North-Rhine Westphalia (NRW), the area spans the
circumscriptions of Düren, Rhein-Erft-Kreis, and Rhein-Kreis Neuss, and it hosts brown coal
mines employing around 8,960 direct workers and supporting 5,380 indirect jobs. Among the
three German regions, it is considered the fittest to adapt with its own resources by the
Commission.
The local TJTP was developed by the authorities of the federal state NRW. On top of the
circumscriptions identified by the Commission, the TJTP also covers the cities of Aachen and
Bottrop and the district of Recklinghausen.39 As in the case of the Lausitzer Revier, the dedicated
webpage of the federal state claims that the documents related to the JTF were published
there from February to March 2022 and opened to feedback from users. As of April 2022, no
document is published on the webpage, nor is it possible to assess if it ever was.40
The lack of engagement of stakeholders for the TJTP of the Rheinisches Revier was confirmed
by an interviewee belonging to one of the major youth networks of the federal state. Despite
the youth organisation’s connection and regular interaction with the local Ministry of Youth
and the Ministry of Environment, the Just Transition Fund was never mentioned in discussions.
None of the youth associations that are part of the umbrella organisation interviewed has been
involved in discussions on the TJTP, even in the context of the existing platforms to discuss the
phasing out of coal in the region.
The partnership for the TJTP appears in an even worse light if compared to the one for the
Regional Development Fund, for which the federal state carried out extensive consultations
with local stakeholders throughout 2019 and 2020. A wide range of formats were used, such as
meetings, a survey and a dedicated conference. It is not clear if the JTF was treated in such a
consultation, but since it was finalised in 2020 this is quite unlikely to be the case.
41
39. Land NRW (2022). Just Transition Fund. (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022)
40. Land NRW (2022). Strategische Umweltprüfung für den Just Transition Fund (JTF) des Landes Nordrhein-Westfalen
(JTF.NRW 2021-2027) in der Förderperiode 2021-2027 (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022).
41. Land NRW (2022). Konsultationsverfahren zum EFRE.NRW 2021-2027. (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022)
B 30
Ireland
Just Transition Region - Midlands
The only area to be included in the just transition in the Republic of Ireland is the Midlands
region, in the centre of the island. Its economy strongly relies on the production and use of peat
42
to produce electricity, with around 4.000 jobs connected to the sector.
Credits: Peat mine field in the Irish Midlands. ©geograph
42. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Ireland 2020. SWD/2020/506 final
B 31
Ireland launched its National Just Transition Fund for the Midlands worth €11 million already in
2019.43 The JTF will bring €84 million more to the region alongside the national programme. The
TJTP for the Midlands was drafted throughout 2021 and early 2022 by the Department of
Environment of the Irish Government with support from the consultancies AARC Ltd and
EnvEcon.
44
Ireland started an extensive partnership with relevant stakeholders already when running its
National Just Transition Fund in 2020. The government used engagement formats such as
workshops, research reports and a major conference in October 2020. There was a wide variety
of engaged stakeholders, including the National Youth Council, which presented its own Youth
45
Manifesto for Climate Justice during the conference.
The consultants drew from such past experience and some extra consultations carried out in
early 2021 to present a proposal for the stakeholder engagement for the TJTPs. The National
Youth Council was indicated as the main youth-related stakeholder to be contacted for the
partnership.
46
An extensive public consultation on the final draft of the TJTP was carried out from December
2021 to February 2022 through online surveys and three virtual workshops. One of the
workshops was specifically dedicated to young people aged 16-24, but as of April 2022 it is
not clear from the sources of the national government if the workshop is still to take place or
has already been finalised. As a result, it is not possible yet to assess how meaningful the
47
engagement process was and if it had any impact on the draft of the TJTP.
43. Irish Government (2022). National Just Transition Fund. (Link. Last consulted: 11.04.2022).
44. Irish Government (2022). EU Reports to Inform Ireland’s Territorial Just Transition Plans. (Link. Last consulted:
11.04.2022).
45. National Economic & Social Council (2020). Delivering a Just Transition for All. 28th EEAC Annual Conference. Irish
Government: Dublin.
46. AARC & Envcon (2021). Report on Governance Mechanism and Stakeholder Engagement. (Link. Last consulted:
11.04.2022).
47. Government of Ireland (2022). Public Consultation on the EU Just Transition Fund.
https://www.gov.ie/en/consultation/352c3-public-consultation-on-the-eu-just-transition-fund/. Last consulted:
24.03.2022
B 32
Italy
The just transition in Italy is focused on the energy intensive industries of the Southern city of
48
Taranto and the last coal mining area in the country in the south of the island of Sardinia.
The preparation of the TJTPs for the two regions is managed by the Department for Territorial
Cohesion of the Presidency of the Italian Government, with support from the consultancy
PriceWaterhouseCoopers (Pwc) and project inputs from the regional and municipal authorities
49
of the two areas.
Pwc carried out the preliminary work to inform the writing of the TJTPs between March and
May 2021, and since then the Italian government was supposed to work on the final drafts. As
of April 2022, the Italian government has not published any further details on the state of the
two TJTPs.
When it comes to consultations with local stakeholders, they were mostly managed by Pwc,
which was tasked to consult with local policy makers, business representatives and trade
unions from the two regions. Civil society representatives were not targeted as potential
interlocutors. The only other engagement activity was a call for projects in Taranto, but
generally the engagement of the civil society, including youth, has been extremely
lacking for both TJTPs.
48. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Italy 2020. SWD/2020/511 final
49. Pwc (2021). Just Transition in Italy. Meeting with institutions on 15.01.2021. (Link. Last consulted: 24.04.2022).
B 33
Just Transition Region - Taranto, Puglia
The city of Taranto, in the Southern Italian region of Puglia, houses the biggest steel mill in
Europe, generating extreme levels of pollution while accounting for around 20.000 direct and
indirect jobs in a city of 200.000.
Credits: Taranto's steel mill ©tripadvisor.it
During the preliminary work, Pwc consulted stakeholders through bilateral meetings with
selected local policy makers, businesses, trade unions and academics. The consultation took
place in May 2021, and it aimed to identify the main areas of action for the just transition and
gather ideas for projects. The outcome was presented in September 2021.
50
In June 2021, Puglia regional authorities launched on its website its own public call for
projects, open to all users. By the closing of the call in December 2021, two projects were
51
presented by local NGOs. Our local interviewee confirms that neither the regional nor the
municipal authorities did properly reach out to the local NGOs to advertise and support in this
call for projects. Since the civil society in general was not engaged in the writing of the
TJTPs, the same inevitably goes for youth.
50. Pwc (2021). Just Transition Fund. Il contributo del fondo sul territorio della Provincia di Taranto.Workshop 27
September 2021. Link. Last consulted: 04.04.2022
51. Puglia Partecipa (2022). Just Transition Fund -Taranto. Link. Last consulted: 04.04.2022.
B 34
Just Transition Region - Sulcis Iglesiente, Sardegna
The area of Sulcis Iglesiente, in the South-West of the island of Sardinia, hosts Italy’s last coal
mine, with around 350 workers, and performs extremely poorly in terms of quality of life,
employment levels and ageing population.
Also in this case, Pwc carried out a consultation with local stakeholders between March and
April 2021. The actors that were involved represented local authorities, businesses and trade
unions. No representative from the civil society, including youth, is mentioned to have been
52
approached. The consultancy reported on the outcome of the consultation in July 2021.
According to our two local interviewees, there was initially some considerable interest with the
potential of the just transition among the municipal authorities and civil society of the Sulcis
area. The Sardinian regional authorities, however, did not prioritise the collection of projects
for the TJTPs. Only after some pressure from local mayors did the Region launch a call for
projects in May 2021, with extremely close deadlines for local municipalities to present their
projects by July. As a result, most municipalities assembled their projects very quickly in the
space of two months and no public consultation was possible. As a result, youth was not
engaged at all in the making of the TJTP for Sulcis
52, Pwc (2021). Just Transition Fund. Draft Piano d’Azione per il Sulcis Iglesiente. Workshop informativo 08 Luglio
2021. Link. Last consulted: 04.04.2022.
B 35
Luxembourg
Just Transition Region - Rumelange and Esch-sur-Alzette
In Luxembourg, the just transition is going to focus on the electro-intensive industries based in
Rumelange and Esch-sur-Alzette, whose plants account for 69% of the country’s industrial
53
emissions.
Luxembourg set up the governance of its TJTP around various ministries of the central
government. According to the final draft, the plan was developed internally by various
departments of the government throughout 2021. No stakeholders external to the government
are mentioned to have been involved, and no implementation of the partnership principle is
mentioned either.
54
When it comes to public consultations, the TJTP final draft and accompanying environmental
assessment were published on 21 January 2022 on the national EU funding website and
55
opened to written feedback from the general public for a period of 45 days.
As of April 2022, the results of the public consultation have not been revealed yet. However, it is
clear that such a top-down process without a real partnership with non-governmental
stakeholders would be highly insufficient to ensure meaningful engagement even in the
case youth organisations had participated.
53. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Luxembourg 2020. SWD/2020/515 final.
54. Government of Luxembourg (2022). Project for a Territorial Just Transition Plan for Luxembourg. Luxembourg.
55. Government of Luxembourg (2022). Consultation publique - Evaluation environnementale stratégique. (Link. Last
consulted: 23.03.2022).
B 36
Netherlands
The just transition in the Netherlands is going to focus on six energy-intensive industrial
clusters across the country: Groningen, IJmond, Groot-Rijnmond, West Noord-Brabant,
Zeeuws-Vlaanderen and Zuid-Limburg.56 Groningen in particular, with its dependence on
natural gas production and over 20.000 jobs at risk from its phasing out, is going to receive
€330 million out of the total share of €623 million allocated to the Netherlands by the JTF.
57
However, TJTPs are being developed for all the six areas.
The TJTPs of the Netherlands are coordinated by the national Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Climate, and developed by the governments of the Provinces where the six industrial clusters
are located: Groningen, North Holland, South Holland, North Brabant, Zealand and Limburg.
The Ministry plans to create an overarching national Just Transition Plan that will finance the
projects under the six TJTPs.58 The national and territorial Just Transition Plans were developed
throughout 2021, and submitted to the European Commission on 22 March 2022.
59
56. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Netherlands. 2020.SWD/2020/518 final.
57. Dutch Government (2020). Letter to the States General. Distribution of resources between the Dutch envelopes
ERDF and JT. (Link. Last consulted: 11.04.2022).
58. Dutch Government (2022). Submission of partnership agreement and overview and appreciation outcome of
negotiations between EU funds under Cohesion Policy. (Link. Last consulted: 11.04.2022).
59. Stimulus (2022). Factsheet. Just Transition Fund. (Link. Last consulted: 11.04.2022).
B 37
Just Transition Region - Groningen
The Province of Groningen, in the North of the Netherlands, is the main focus area of the just
transition in the country owing to the heavy reliance of the local economy on the production of
natural gas and the presence of energy-intensive industries.
The local TJTP was developed by the Province of Groningen throughout 2021. The Province has
a permanent Youth Advisory Council that can be consulted on policy matters. Our local
interviewee is one of the representatives sitting in the Council. According to his account, the
drafts of the TJTP were not submitted to the advisory body. However, the youth
representatives from the Council were invited to a general public consultation event with
several local stakeholders that took place around August 2021. During the event, the Province
officials and several experts exposed to the public the draft TJTP. The stakeholders that
attended were asked to provide written feedback after the event.
Given the highly technical content of the proposal, the youth representatives that
attended, including our interviewee, did not feel capable of providing any meaningful
feedback. The Youth Council was not invited to any follow-up activity or event, and to our
interviewee’s best knowledge no such activities were held at all. To conclude, the youth
engagement process in Groningen was very superficial, and did not fully use the potential
of the existing youth representation bodies present in the region.
B 38
Poland
As home to more than half of the whole coal mining workforce in the EU, and with a national
energy system strongly reliant on coal, Poland is the main recipient of investments from the
Just Transition Mechanism. From the JTF alone, the country has been allocated €3.5 billion in
2021 prices, i.e. 20% of the entire capital of the fund.
Belchatow mine and energy complex, Central Poland
©Independent.co.uk
B 39
The European Commission initially planned to include three Polish coal mining areas in the just
transition (Eastern Wielkopolska, Upper Silesia and the Wałbrzych District in Lower Silesia), but
the Polish government has prepared TJTPs for four more in the hope they will also be approved
60
(Lubelskie, Łódzkie, Western Małopolska and the Zgorzelec District of Lower Silesia).
There are two types of Just Transition Plans in the country: a National Plan developed by the
Ministry of Climate and Environment, and local TJTPs coordinated by the Ministry of
Development Funds and Regional Policy. The latter were developed in each of the above-
mentioned regions by the Marshal of the local voivodeship through the Local Development
Agencies.
In the process, all Marshals regularly consulted the local civil society by setting up ad hoc
working groups gathering national and local policy makers with businesses, trade unions and,
with one exception, NGOs. However, there were some remarkable differences in the way
consultations were carried out in each region, both in terms of instruments (meetings,
workshops, written submissions) and the type of actors involved.
Just Transition Region - Eastern Wielkopolska
Eastern Wielkopolska covers the Eastern part of the Voivodeship of Greater Poland around the
city of Konin. The region hosts 6.000 people employed in brown coal extraction and electricity
production. On top of job losses, the local open-pit mines pose several environmental
challenges.
Public consultations for Eastern Wielkopolska ’s TJTP have been extensive and regular. Even
before the Just Transition Mechanism saw the light in late 2019, the transition from coal mining
had been a key debate topic in the region, with informative meetings and public debates
organised by the authorities.
60. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Poland. SWD/2020/520 final.
B 40
Thus, when it came to consult the civil society on the TJTP, several rounds of consultations
were held by the authorities throughout 2020 and the first half of 2021. The format was
meetings and workshops with a variety of economic, social and non-governmental
stakeholders, whose input was included in the final TJTP.
Concerning youth engagement, there was initially no specific attempt from the Marshal Office
or the Local Development Agency to reach out to young people specifically. However, when a
representative from the local branch of Fridays for Future attended the public consultation
meetings regularly, the Development Agency approached his organisation to let them
participate in some meetings of the stakeholder working group and, in parallel, set up a
committee of young people to come back with proposals for the TJTP. The committee was
held, and many of its proposals, particularly on education, were eventually included in the final
TJTP, which was presented to the European Commission in July 2021. According to our
interviewee, even inside the working group the attitude of other stakeholders, such as miners,
gradually opened up to the proposals of youth representatives.
In the end, the engagement of youth in the drafting of the TJTP in Eastern Wielkopolska
proved to be quite meaningful, constant and open to inputs. However, a downside of the
Plan submitted to the Commission is that it does not specify any governance mechanism to
keep engaging youth in the implementation phase.
A meeting of the youth committee in October 2020.
Konin, Eastern Wielkopolska. ©Fridays for Future
B 41
Just Transition Region - Upper Silesia
Silesia is by far the biggest coal extraction area in the whole EU bloc. Half of all coal miners in
the EU are based in the region, with over 78.000 jobs across 18 mines. Given the massive
number of workers involved, the transition is expected by the Commission to require massive
investments in both big and small businesses.
Murcki mine, Silesia, Poland ©flickr
The local Marshall Office and Development Agency structured the consultations with
stakeholders around multiple rounds. A first round of project collection took place in 2020, and
the resulting draft was published online to gather written feedback from the public. For the
third round, in summer 2021, the Marshal Office organised meetings with specific categories of
actors (businesses, trade unions, NGO etc.). None of these meetings included youth
representatives.
In this context, the local NGO Bomiasto, which is active on urban regeneration projects in the
Silesian capital, Katowice, started its own youth engagement activities. According to our
interviewee from the organisation, Bomiasto was receiving funding for an awareness raising
project on urban regeneration and environmental issues with a range of stakeholder groups.
B 42
Their format is organising trainings and workshops where experts spread knowledge on such
topics to gather inputs from citizens. In the context of such activities, Bomiasto gathered
around 30 Silesian youth associations to hold a workshop where they could get to know
more about the EU just transition and provide their input. In the end the workshop came up
with a document of proposals on climate mitigation measures needed for Silesia, and
Bomiasto made it public through its media contacts. Some officials from the local authorities
reacted to the document, but no meeting with Bomiasto and the youth NGOs was organised.
Since the TJTP was not published before being submitted to the Commission in July 2021,
there is no way to assess whether the proposals from Bomiasto's workshop were
considered by the authorities.
Just Transition Region - Wałbrzych District, Lower Silesia
Like the rest of Silesia, the economy of Lower Silesia used to be based on coal extraction, but
an unfinished transition away from it has left the region with above-average levels of
unemployment, poverty and pollution.
According to a written response we received from the city office of Wałbrzych, the local
authorities tried to reach out to youth in the process of preparing their Social Territorial Just
Transition Plan (which was the basis for TJTP written in Lower Silesian Marshal Office), but
they did not manage to involve any youth representative.
B 43
Romania
In Romania, the Just Transition Mechanism is going to support six counties across the country:
Hunedoara, Gorj, Dolj, Galați, Prahova and Mureş. Hunedoara and Gorj host the main coal areas
of Romania, employing over 28.600 people in mining and electricity production while
accounting for over 30% of the total Romanian emissions. The other four counties host the
main energy-intensive industries in the country (chemicals, metals, fertilisers etc.), accounting
61
for 35% of its total emissions.
The six Romanian TJTPs, one per county, are coordinated by the national Ministry of
Investments and European Projects, with technical assistance from the Frankfurt School of
Management and Finance. The Ministry decided to prepare an overarching national
Operational Programme for the Just Transition (OPJT) that will finance the projects of the
TJTPs, which are written in coordination with the local Regional Development Agencies and
County Councils of the six targeted counties.
The partnership with the relevant stakeholders is managed through a national working group
and six local working groups set up in each of the target counties since October 2020. Each
working group gathers representatives of the national government, local authorities,
businesses, trade unions and academia. Some of them also include environmental and social
NGOs. No working group currently includes youth organisations or youth representatives.
61. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Romania. SWD/2020/522 final.
B 44
In the first half of 2021 the consultant of the government also carried out some bilateral
consultations with stakeholders, mostly businesses and trade unions. Youth organisations
were not approached for such meetings, and no joint meetings gathering more stakeholders
at the same time were organised.
In April 2021, the consultant published a report on the state of the partnerships with
stakeholders for the just transition process. Their main findings were that there were several
flaws in their functioning of the local working groups, from the way they were organised to the
number and type of partners included, and the lack of expertise on development planning. The
consultant found remarkable differences from county to county in the advancement of the
work and in the number and type of members of each working group. The consultant’s advice
was to contain the number of participants in order to facilitate the work while opening up to
new stakeholders, particularly NGOs, and making the whole output of the working groups
transparent and accessible to the general public. Moreover, the consultant created a matrix of
Coal facilities in the Jiu Valley, Hunedoara. ©Viktor Macha
B 45
over 290 stakeholders to facilitate the future engagement activities of the government. Youth
associations were included in the matrix, with a recommendation to engage them in the future
62
partnerships.
After the publishing of this report, the Ministry of Investments proceeded with finalising the
63
TJTPs and submitted them to the European Commission on 26 July 2021. No further public
consultation or reform of the working groups was done in the meantime, so that the voice of
youth has remained unrepresented in the six Romanian TJTPs.
62. Frankfurt School (2021). Report on Proposal for a Stakeholder Engagement Strategy. MIEP: Bucharest.
63. MIEP (2022). Mecanismul pentru o Tranziție Justă. https://mfe.gov.ro/mecanismul-pentru-o-tranzitie-justa/. Last
consulted: 08.04.2022.
B 46
Spain
Spain has fourteen operative coal-fire energy plants supporting 3.300 direct and 10.000 indirect
jobs. The country is the only one in the EU with a national Just Transition Strategy, and it
closed down its last coal mines already in 2018. The JTF in Spain is going to complement the
national strategy in the eight areas where the coal plants and the former coal mines are located
across the country: Asturias, León and Palencia (Castilla y Leòn), A Coruña (Galicia), Cádiz,
64
Córdoba and Almería (Andalusia), and Teruel (Aragon).
A single national TJTP was elaborated by the Institute for the Just Transition of the national
65
Ministry of Ecological Transition.
The partnership to gather the input of relevant stakeholders for the TJTP is structured around
nineteen local working groups called Just Transition Covenants. Managed by the local
municipalities of the areas targeted by the just transition, each local working group organises
workshops, calls for proposals and surveys with local authorities, businesses, trade unions and
NGOs. No working group managed to include youth associations or representatives. On
top of the regions identified by the Commission, the Ministry decided to launch Covenants also
66
for the areas of Zorita, in Castilla-La-Mancha, and Alcudia in the Balearic Islands.
64. EU (2020). COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Country Report Spain. SWD/2020/508 final.
65. Spanish Government (2022). ACUERDO DE ASOCIACIÓN DE ESPAÑA 2021-2027. (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022).
66. Just Transition Institute (2022). Convenios en marcha. (Link. Last consulted: 14.04.2022).
B 47
Young people aged 16-30 were the target group of a specific national consultation
between September and October 2021. The consultation consisted of an online survey and a
series of seven online workshops targeting most of the areas covered by the working groups. As
of April 2022, the results of the consultation or the drafts of the TJTPs have not been published
yet, so that it is not possible yet to assess how meaningful the youth engagement activities
67
were and what impact they had.
67. Instituto para la Transición Justa (2022). Participación Juvenil.
https://www.transicionjusta.gob.es/Convenios_transicion_justa/Participacion_Juvenil-ides-idweb.asp Last
consulted: 24.03.2022.
B 48
Summary table
Regions covered Youth included Input adopted
Country Format
by a TJTP in partnership? in TJTP?
Bulgaria Stara Zagora Yes Panel discussion Unknown
Moravskoslezský National Working
Czechia Yes Unknown
Ústecký Karlovarský group
Estonia Ida Viru Yes Citizen assembly Unknown
France Bouche-du-Rhône No
Nord + Pas de Calais No
Germany Lausitzer Revier No
Mitteldeutsches
No
Revier
Rheinisches Revier No
B 49
Ireland
Ireland Yes Virtual Workshop Unknown
Midlands
Italy Taranto No
Sulcis No
Luxembourg No
Stakeholder
Netherlands Groningen Yes Unknown
workshop
Stakeholder
Eastern
Poland Yes workshops + Youth Yes
Wielkopolska
committee
Stakeholder
Upper Silesia Yes Unknown
workshop
Lower Silesia No
Hunedoara, Gorj,
Romania Dolj, Galați, No
Prahova, Mureş
Asturias, León,
Palencia, Cádiz,
Online survey +
Spain A Coruña, Yes Unknown
virtual workshops
Córdoba,
Almería, Teruel
B 50
Section 3. Conclusions and
recommendations
Although there are differences from country to country and from region to region, a common
feature that clearly emerges from this overview is that young generations have not been
considered by state authorities as a key stakeholder to approach for the writing of TJTPs.
Only in two countries, i.e. Ireland and Spain, did the authorities provide for youth engagement
instruments from the beginning in their partnership for the development of the TJTPs.
Most other countries either did not engage youth altogether, like France, Romania and Italy, or
did so in a very superficial way through feedback to already consolidated drafts, as was the
case for the Netherlands. Moreover, even in those few cases where youth was meaningfully
engaged and could put forward concrete inputs for the TJTPs, like Eastern Wielkopolska,
Silesia and Ida Viru, this happened mostly after a internal mobilisation within civil society, with
the authorities in the position to endorse or ignore such efforts. Finally, with the notable
exception of Eastern Wielkopolska, the impact of the inputs of youth engagement activities was
hard to assess in all countries owing to a general lack of transparency in the publication of the
various drafts of the TJTPs.
Overall, considering both the activities that were organised and the impressions of our
interviewees, the authorities of the EU Member States under analysis do not appear
particularly interested in, and equipped to, engaging young people in the TJTPs. Excluding the
cases of Ireland and Spain (whose state-run activities remain to be assessed, though) youth
engagement was possible only in those regions where NGOs and youth activists had the
mobilisation capacity and the will to make young people’s voice heard over the lack of
specific engagement activities of the state authorities. This gave rise to new inequalities
among young people in the different regions, as the level of organisation of the local NGOs
decided whether their voices were considered in the development of the TJTPs or not.
Such a state of things goes against most of the basic conditions defined in the “Toolkit for the
participation of youth in the JTF” of the European Commission. The Toolkit called for youth
representatives to be treated as equals to all stakeholders, be engaged throughout the process,
represent also marginalised youth sub-groups and be informed on the way their input is used
for the TJTPs.
B 51
Across the twelve EU States, young people were not treated as equals to other stakeholders
like businesses and trade unions, which were almost always and constantly engaged. Youth
representatives were also mostly not included in the design of the partnership process itself,
and there were no real efforts to reach out to marginalised young people. Even the few youth
representatives that managed to provide input to the TJTPs were mostly already engaged in
politics and activism. Finally, even when young people did provide inputs to the TJTPs, only in
Eastern Wielkopolska was the input managed transparently enough to assess that it was
implemented in the TJTP. In all other regions, the final drafts of the TJTPs were handled quite
opaquely, with no real opportunity to access them and assess whether the input from youth
was considered or not. Overall, the Commission's Toolkit remained largely unheard and
unapplied by the Member States.
As TJTPs are being submitted to and evaluated by the European Commission, the JTM is now
entering a crucial phase. What emerged from our analysis is that there were huge differences
in the way youth engagement was implemented across the twelve EU Member States. In
the context of a programme with the core goal to reduce the inequalities emerging from
decarbonisation, such differentiated engagement has the potential to induce new inequalities
between those young people that had a say in the future of their community and those that
were either not asked or not listened to.
There is still time for the EU and its Member States to address this gap in order to prevent
it from becoming a structural issue that affects the implementation and monitoring of the
entire Just Transition Mechanism. The EU institutions have the capacity to highlight the
significant lack of youth engagement in the TJTPs and demand changes, and Member States
have the capacity to redress the lack of meaningful youth engagement on the ground.
B 52
In particular, we want to put forward the following recommendations to the main political
actors:
To EU Member States:
To integrate specific plans for youth engagement activities in the sections of the
TJTPs defining the governance of stakeholder engagement for the implementation
and monitoring phases.
To create formation courses for the civil servants of the authorities tasked with the
implementation of TJTPs to get acquainted with, and learn how to implement, the
Commission’s “Toolkit for the participation of youth in the JTF”.
To include youth representatives, appointed with a transparent and inclusive
process, in the existing governance mechanisms set in place to manage the
partnership with relevant stakeholders (working groups, conferences etc.). At this
stage, this should especially include the monitoring committees.
To dedicate a precise share of the projects of the implementation phase to youth
entrepreneurship, political youth engagement activities in the just transition, and
education projects in schools and tertiary education.
To the European Commission:
To include in the evaluation of TJTPs an assessment of the past and envisaged
partnerships with civil society stakeholders, including youth, with concrete
recommendations on how to improve their engagement in the implementation phase.
To use the existing support mechanisms for state authorities, such as the Just
Transition Platform and the Technical Support Instrument, to promote the
implementation of the “Toolkit for the participation of youth in the JTF”.
To ensure full transparency of the just transition process by making public and
easily accessible the TJTPs of Member States as well as the approval criteria and the
individual evaluations of each Plan.
B 53
To the European Parliament:
To make use of all its monitoring powers to make sure the partnership principle
remains at the core of the implementation of the Just Transition Mechanism, ensuring
in particular that young people are meaningfully engaged in the process.
To commission and disseminate independent monitoring reports on the state of
the engagement of stakeholder groups, including youth, in the implementation of
the Just Transition Mechanism.
To regularly welcome local civil society actors and monitoring NGOs to its debates
on the state of the just transition to get first-hand views on how the Just Transition
Mechanism is being implemented on the field and what are the main challenges for
non-state stakeholders.
B 54
About us
Generation Climate Europe is the largest coalition of
youth-led networks on climate and environmental issues at
the European level. GCE unites the largest youth-led
networks in Europe bringing together 381 national
organisations across 46 countries in Europe. We are
guided by the voices of over 20 million young Europeans.
Uniting European youth networks, GCE creates a platform
for the youth to advocate for a just and green transition in
Europe.
Bankwatch is the largest network of grassroots,
environmental and human rights groups in central and
eastern Europe. We monitor public finance institutions
that are responsible for hundreds of billions of
investments across the globe.
The banks and funds we watch are often obscure but
always important entities that function outside public
scrutiny. Together with local communities and other NGOs
we work to expose their influence and provide a
counterbalance to their unchecked power.
B 55
Saatja: "Climate Justice Coordinators" <
[email protected]>
Saaja: "MKM info" <
[email protected]>
Teema: NEW REPORT - Youth engagement in the EU just transition
Kuupäev: 2022-05-11 06:00
Dear staff of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communication,
In the days of the Just Transition Platform, it's my pleasure to share
with you the newly published joint report of the youth coalition
Generation Climate Europe and the monitoring NGO Bankwatch assessing the
engagement of young people in the writing of the Territorial Just
Transition Plans across twelve EU Member States, including Estonia.
Read it here 👉 https://bit.ly/youthinjt
We hope you will enjoy the reading and that this report can inform the
debate on youth engagement across the entire Green Deal. Feel free to
share it!
Best wishes,
--
Lorenzo Manca | Climate Justice Coordinator
Website Twitter Instagram Facebook Linkedin
Subscribe to our Newsletter and listen to our Podcast!