EESTI SUURSAATKOND
‘.-----
Maj andus- ja kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Suur-Ameerika 1
10122, Tallinn
6. aprill 2022
Nr. &
EDASTUS
Edastan Prantsuse transpordiministeeriumilt saabunud uuringute dokumendid hr Ahti Kunin
gale.
Heade soovidega
KOMMUNIKATSIOONiMINISTEERIUM
2. 04. 2022
NØW3
17, rue de la Baume / 75008 Paris / TIphone: + 33 1 56 62 22 00 / Tcopie: + 33 1 49 52 05 65 /
[email protected]
MINISTERE
CHARGC
DES TRANSPORTS
Lj&rtt
IgaIit6
Fnlt..,,it1
FRANCE22
00 SIDE MCI FRANCAISE
Le ministre
Paris, le 28 MRS 2022
Rf.: MT/2022-03/10631
Monsieur Ahti Kuningas
Ministre de I’&onomie et des infrastructures
Tallin, Estonie
CherCollgue, C4O
Le sommet de I’aviation de Toulouse des 3 et 4 fvrier 2022 consacr la d&arbonation de l’aviation
o j’ai eu le piaisir de vous accueillir, a I’occasion de prsenter une tude commande par mon
ministre sur les attentes des passagers de divers pays du globe.
Celle-ci a suscit un certain intrt, et engendr des demandes d’Iments plus dtaills. Aussi la
trouverez-vous en picejointe pour plus ample information.
Vous trouverez par ailleurs galement ci-jointe l’tude sur les biocarburants aronautiques durables
distribue lors de l’vnement.
Je vous prie d’agrer l’expression de ma considration distingue.
DJ E BBARI
246 boulevard Saint-Germain
75007 Paris France
-
TI 00 33(0)1 40 81 21 22
www ecologie.gouv fr.
Courtesy translation
Dear Colleague,
During Toulouse aviation summit 3rd
and 4th February 2022 dedicated to aviation decarbonization,
where 1 was pleased to meet you, a study on expectations of passengers of some countries over the
world launched by my ministry, was presented.
It creates some some interest and expectations of more detailed informations. Therefore please find it
attached.
You will also please find attached the study on substainable aviation fueis as a lever for decarbonizing
the transport sector which was performed by Roland Berger for the French ministry of transport in the
context of the preparation of the Toulouse summit.
Best regards
2
Report
RoLand Berger
01.2022
PARIS / FRANCE
Les carburants d’aviation
durabies
UN LEVIER MAJEUR DE DCARBONATION
DU TRANSPORTARIEN?
Ro’and
Berger
)
:
INTRODUCTION
ET CONTEXTE DE L’TUDE
e cabinet Roland Berger a röalisö une ötude dötaillöe sur les carburants
L d’aviation durabies, pour le compte du Ministöre franais des Transports,
levier majeur de döcarbonation du secteur du transport aörien å I’öchelle
mondiale. Les engagements de döcarbonation du secteur du transport
aörien pris å ce jour viennent majoritairement des industriels.
Les carburants d’aviation durablesfontface å des contraintes de production
qui rendent ces solutions trös coOteuses å ce jour pour les compagnies
aöriennes. Le potentiel d’incorporation de biocarburants diiföre selon les
rågions du monde du fait de röpartitions de ressources en biomasse et de
consommation de körosöne trås hötörogönes au niveau mondial.
La totalitö de la biomasse non alimentaire disponible å l’öchelle mondiale
n’est pas suifisante pour atteindre les 63 % d’incorporation de carburants
d’aviation durabies (objectif de ReFuel EU for Aviation). C’est pourquoi le
recours aux carburants de synthöse est nöcessaire. II s’agirait de dåvelopper
—2500 sites de production (tous types de carburants d’aviation durables),
produisant au total —500 Mds de litres de SAFs, pour un investissement
cumulå sur la pöriode 2025-2050 de 2200 Mds d’euros. L’afteinte de la
neutralitö carbone ä I’horizon 2050 repose sur un panier de mesures : parmi
les plus importantes d’entre elles, les carburants d’aviation durabies ont
vocation ä se döployer de maniöre accölöröe au niveau mondial.
LEXIQUE DES PRINCIPAUX TERMES UTILISS
ATJ (Alcohol-to-Jet) : route de synthöse permettant. å partir d’alcool (6thanol gänöralement) produit par
fermentation, de produire du carburant
Biocarburant conventionnel (G1) : carburant Iiquide utiIis pour le transport issu de la transformation de
eultures destin&s ä I’alimentation humaine ou animale, c’est å dire les piantes riches en amidon. lea piantes
sucrires ou lea piantes olagineuses, produites sur des terres agricoles å titre de culture prineipale. telles
que dfinies dana l’Article 2, second paragrsphe. point 40 de la Directive (UE) 2018/2001
Biocarburant avancö (G2) : carburant liquide produit partir de ressources biologiques non slimentsires,
dites Iignocellulosiques ou biomasse
Biocarburant de 3’ gönöration (G3) en phsse expårimentale. repose sur l’exploitstion de la biomasse
aquatique, en l’occurrence des aigues sutotrophes fonctionnant par photosynthse pour dIivrer un subatrat
csrbon
Biojet: carburant daviation cedifi contenant une psrt de biocarburant
Biomasse lignocellulosique : ensemble des mstiäres organiques d’origine vgätsIe (råsidus sgricoles.
dächets forestiers, cultures ddies telles que le miscanthus gant. aigues...) pouvant devenir une source
d’nergie par combustion
Carburants d’aviation durabies (ou SAFa poer Sustsinable Avistion Fueis) nom donnS sux csrbursnts
incorporables dans lea aviona. certifia durables psr des entits indäpendsntes et astisfaisant toutes les
exigences pour ätre utiIias sur es vois rguliers de psssagers (comme d&inies en normes adquates par
l’orgsnisstion mondiale de normslisation ASTM lnternstional ou la Stsndsrdiaation Dfense au Royaume
Uni). lis peuvent ötre dorigine biologique ou de synthäse
Carburants de synthöse: carburants produits å partir de la räaction chimique entre hydrogne et dioxyde
de carbone cf Power-to-Liquid
—
CHJ (Catslytic Hydrothermolysis Jet): hydrocsrbure synthtique ou m&snge d’hydrocarbures synthtiques
produit å psrtir de biomasse
0
Electricitö bas-carbone : &ectricit produite ä partir d6nergies renouvelsbles ou trs faiblement carbonäes
(ex. nuclåsire)
e
Fischer-Tropsch (FT) : route de synthse permettsnt. å partir d’un gaz de synthse, de produire un brut
synthötique appel syncrude, lui-m&me raffin pour produire du carbursnt d’aviation durables
t
HEFA (Hydroprocessed Estera and Fatty Acids) : hydrotraitement som&iaant dhuiles vegetales (HVO). 3
dhuiles uaes et graissea animales afin de produire des biocarbursnts 3
Power-to-Liquid : voie permettant de produire des carburants de synthse les carburants PtL sont
—
produits en combinant de l’hydrogne avec du dioxyde de carbone (CO,). Cet hydrogne est extrait de l’eau
par älectrolyse ä laide d’nergies renouvelabies. Cette combinaison dbouche sur un gaz de synthäse 0
convertible en carburant liquide aprs traitement
1 1 Engagements du secteur
Les engagements de dcarbonation du secteur du transport
arien pris ce jour viennent majoritairement des industriels
La plupart des experts s’accordent sur le fait que la d&arbonation durable du
secteur arien ne sera atteignable que par la conjugaison de diffrents Ieviers’
I’innovation technologique sur le produit, l’optimisation des oprations et des
infrastructures aroportuaires, le recours des carburants d’aviation durabies
et la mise en place de mcanisrnes de compensation. A
LES CARBURANTS D’AVIATION DURABLES VONT JOUER
UN RÖLE MAJEUR DANS LA DECARBONATION DU SECTEUR
Des objectifs ambitieux d’incorporation de carburants d’aviation durabies ont
dfinis dans l’industrie par quelques Etats pionniers dont la France.
Ä I’cheI1e europ&nne, la Commission Europ&nne a fait des propositions ä
travers ReFuel EU (voletAviation du paquet Fit for 55) correspondant environ
5 % en 2030, 32 % en 2040 et 63 % en 2050. 4 B
1 Ces Ieviers peuvent ötre stimuIs par des outils conomiques (par exemple le prix du carbone) permettant
dorienter efficacement los investissements dans le secteur.
A 1 De multipies options ont ete identifiees pour decarboner le secteur du transport arien
d’ici 2050
Waypoint 2050 — Scnario Technologie et oørations [missions mondiales de C02; mt]
Emissions mondiales de C02 [millions de tonnes]
2000
1 500
1000
OO . ..-.‘-
500
..;‘
O
O
Net-Zero .
0
2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 Contribution å la rduction
des missions de C02
O Technologie O Oprations et infrastructures O Carburants d’aviation durables Compensation 2050
Source: Air Transport Action Group (ATAG) Waypoint 2050.
—
Roland Berger 3 Les carburants daviatiori durabies
Les constructeurs Boeing et Airbus sont en capacit d’adapter les fiottes avec
des moteurs permettant l’incorporation de 100% de SAFs d’ici 2030.
1
21 Production de carburants durabies
et contraintes
Les carburants d’aviation durabies font face ä des
contraintes de production qui rendent leur prix prohibitif
ä ce jour pour les compagnies ariennes
Les carburants d’aviations durabies (ou SAFs pour Sustainable Aviation
Fueis) se rpartissent au sein de deux familles les carburants durabies
d’origine biologique (les biocarburants d’aviation ou biojet) et les carburants
durabies de synthse, d’origine non biologique (les e-fuels). 4 C
Les biocarburants avancs (G2) ont aujourd’hui un coGt 1ev en raison de la
faible maturit des technologies de production, de la cornpIexit de la collecte
ainsi que de la chaine d’approvisionnement (> 1,3 euro/I compar å 0,44 euro/1
pour le krosne conventionnel en moyenne sur les dix dernires annes).
B1 Ä horizon 2050, les organisations mondiales et europeennes prevoient des mandats
d’incorporation ambitieux en SAFs de [50-65 %]
Ambitions d’incorporation en SAFs des diffrentes organisations [%; 2025-2050]
2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
63%
38%
17,5%
4,3% 15% 24% 27% 35%
Note: Le djffrentiel correspondant a un sous-mandat d’incorporation de carburants de synthse (e-fuel).
Organisations O ReFuel EU dont % de biocarburants (ReFuel EU) O IATA
Source: IATA, OACI, Refuel EU, IHS, Gouvemement am&icain, Roland Berger.
Rotand Berger 4 LOS carburants daviation durabies
Ii est thoriquement envisageabie de produire un biojet conventionnei (Gi)
suivant deux procds:
HEFAåpartird’oiagineuxteIsquel’huiIedecoIzaoudetournesoldirectement
(proc& maitris aujourd’hui destin au biodiesel routier, mais encore peu
—
utiiis car plus onreux que d’autres alternatives)
Aicohol-to-jet, bien que la technoiogie soit encore en phase pilote, å partir de
biothanoi GI (donc issu de mais, bi ou encore betterave...)
Mais le potentiel de certains biocarburants conventionnels issus d’oiagineux
(G1)pouri’aviation est iirnit du faitd’une moindre contribution larduction
des missions de gaz ä effet de serre compar aux biocarburants avancs (impact
indirect du changement d’usage des sois) et de la forte concurrence de i’usage
des surfaces ä destination de i’aiimentation humaine. Le potentiel de la flhire
ATJ, avec une ressource comrne le mafs ou Ja betterave, est galement, dans une
moindre mesure, iirnit et pose des probJmatiques similaires.
Les carburants de synthse durabie (d’ oligine non bioiogique) å base d’iectric it
renouveiabie ou bas-carbone sontgaJement une option srieuse pourdcarboner
le secteur du transport arien. lis sont produits partir d’hydrogne (H, issu
d’lectrolyse aJimente par de l’Iectricit renouvelable ou bas carbone) et de
dioxyde de carbone (C02) capt dans l’atmosphre, captur en sortie d’usines
ayant recours ä la fermentation d’intrants biologiques ou d’usines emettrices
de CO,.
Les grandes tapes dc cc processus dc conversion appei Power-to-Liquid
(lectroJyse de i’eau pour obtenir de l’hydrogne, capture du C02, conversion
de ces Jments en gaz de synthse par gaziflcation avant d’avoir recours des
procds teis que Fischer-Tropsch ou Methanol-to-Gasoline comme tape finaie
de fabrication de l’hydrogne) ont dj atteint Ja maturite dmonstrateur.
Tous les composants et mianges de carburants (hydrocarbures et alcools)
peuvent tre produits ä partir du Power-to-Liquid, mais ils complexifient le
raffinage et rendent certains produits plus cotiteux.
Le cot du e-krosne issu dc ia synthse Fischer-Tropsch pourrait baisser de
50 % entre 2020 et 2030 pour atteindre 1,5-1,9 euro par litre (contre 2,2 3,0 -
euro par iitre aujourd’hui) ia synthse MtG (Methanol-to-Gasoline) tant
—
quant å die igerement plus coCiteuse que ia synthse Fischer-Tropsch.
Les principaux freins au dveioppement dc Ja fiiire e-fueis sont actueiiement
ie cocit dc 1’iectricit renouveiable ou bas-carbone (permettant i’iectroiyse,
lectricit qui reprsente 80 % du cocit du e-fuei au litre), ia construction
d’usines intgres rassembiant iectroiyseurs, dispositifs dc capture/captage dc
CO,, dc gazification et dc synthse Fischer-Tropsch notamment, et ia capture
dc C02 renouveiabie (capt dans l’airambiant, issu dc fermentation dc biomasse
ou dc d&hets, ou en sortie d’usine suivant des modaIits ä dfinir).
Roland Bergef 5 Les carburants daviation durables
C ui existe plusieurs routes de synthese permettant de produire du biojet å partir d’huiles,
de sucres/cer6aies mais aussi de biomasse
Usage d’intrants par route de synthse du carburant d’aviation durable
Matieres Limites sur Traitement Cle Route Limites Cot actuel
premieres les intrants initial interm6diaire de synthese technolo- estim vs.
giques carburant
fossile
(0)
1- Huiles Neutralisation Lipides —*2 å *3
z G1 vgtates’
D
Canne å sucre Comptition Fermentation Biothanol —*2 a x3
Betterave alimentaire,
0 impact ILUC
0
Mais, bl.. Fermentation Biothanol
Utilis6es
G 2 aujourdhui Graisses Prtraitement
animales Quantits
pour la
disponibles, —*1,5 ä *3
production
de biojet tragabilit des Prtraitement
Huiles de
huiles
cuisine usagees
(UCO)
Biomasse Rsidus Prtraitement Gasde FT
forestiers/ synthse
agricoles (gazification)
Collecte de
sapplique
la biomasse
directement
(faible
å sMP +
concentration
hydrogne
gogra
phique),
ch&ne d’ap
ou —*3’ 4
Biomasse Cultures provisionne Extraction de Bio- ATJ
nergtiques ment ineffi I’huile/cellulose thanol
cace. coCits de
transport et ou
de stockage...)
Dchets3 Sparation Lipides ‘E-CHJ
G3 Algues Quantits Extraction Lipides
cultivables, de Ihuile
coQts de
production
cow Capture du
I-(0 CO2eteau Electrolyse H2 (issu d’lec
z iu Non bio C02, coCit de
trolyse å base
<1 (sans nergie l’Iectricit de leau
disponible) renouvelable d’Iectricit
bas-carbone) —*7’ xo
ou bas
cU) carbone, + c02
<ui transport de
oc l’hydrogne
1 Faisabilite selon la longueur des chanes carbones des huiles (e.g. Colza, Tournesol...), ne fonctionne pas avec toutes.
2 High Hydrogen Content Synthetic Paraffinic Kerosene.
3 Les biodchets constitus des dchets alimentaires et des autres dechets natureis biodgradables peuvent tre utilises.
Source: Roland Berger.
Roland Berger 6 Les carburants d’aviation durabies
31 Potentiel mondial de
Le potentiel d’incorporation de biocarburants diffre selon
les rgions du monde du fait de situations de ressources
en biomasse et de consommation de krosne trs
htrognes dans le monde
Nous avons modlis l’incorporation thorique maximale en biocarburants
d’aviation durabies par grande rgion du monde en confrontant les variabies
suivantes: l’offre mondiale, c’est--dire la quantit dc biomasse disponible,
collectable et orientable vers le biojet dans le monde.
Cette quantit est estime environ 1 Md dc tonnes en 2050, dont les deux tiers
sont issus de rsidus agricoles, principalement en Asie etAfrique. Cette biomasse
pourrait permettre une production thorique d’environ 185 Mds de litres de
biojet l’horizon 2050 (soit 1’quiva1ent de 20 % d’incorporation sur la base
d’une croissance mondiale annuelle moyenne de la consomrnation de krosne
de 2,7 % pour une consommation d’environ 970 Mds de litres en 2050).
Un examen attentif des volumes de matires premires olagineuses ou dc
bioethanol disponibies en Europe et dans le monde pourrait &re effectu. Dans le
respect des plafonds actuels et en incluant les volumes lib&s par la transition
nergtique du secteur routier, notamment par l’lectrification croissante des
vhicules, nous pourrions identifier une capacit d’ incorporation additionnel le
thorique en biojet d’environ 10 % en France horizon 2050 par exemple. Cet
exarnen devrait permettre d’identifier et mesurer plus prcisnient les avantages
et inconvnients dc flcher ces ressources ainsi libr&s vers un unique secteur tel
que le transport arien ou maritirne, en veillant attentivement ä viter tout eifet
marginal dc concurrence avec des doubies usages alimentaires.
Pour evaluer Je potentiel d’incorporation en biocarburants avancs, il
convient d’estimer l’voIution dc la demande en krosne pa r grande rgion
du monde’. La demande est exprimee en volumes dc krosne n&essaires
et considre l’volution du trafic arien et des gains d’efficacit nergtique
prvus par les avionneurs. Les hypotbses dc croissance annuelle suivantes
ont utilises pour les calculs : Europe et Amerique du Nord : 1 %,
Amrique latine : 3 %, Afrique : 3,4 %, Asie et Oceanie : 3,9 %.
Les chiffres prsents ci-contre incluent l’incorporation maximale dc
biocarburants avancs. 4 D
En rsum, dc fortes disparits sont prvoir entre les rgions.
2 Source utiIise: US Energy Information Administration.
Roland Berger 7 Lea carburants davialion durabies
D/ En 2050, l’Afrique et l’Amerique pourraient incorporer [—60-100 %] de biojet (G2) —
lncorporation plus faible en Europe & Asie [—15-30 %J
lncorporation thorique1 de biocarburants avancs par rgion [2030; 2050; %]
59%
Europe
82%
Amrique
du Nord Asle
& Ocanie
LAmrique
Latine
TOTAL
O 2030 2050 MONDE
1 Correspond å la pari de la demande pouvant tre couverte par les biocarburants en production thorique maximale hors e-fuel. Hypothse d’incorporation sur le
—
continent dc production du carburant daviation durable le transport de biocarburants est envisageable mais avec des colts supplmentaires et un impact
-
additionnel sur les missions dc gas eifet dc serre. Augmentation des niveaux d’incorporation dc G2 dc 2030 2050 due au nouveaux sites de production
installes pendant la priode. Le constat peut tre reIativis par les possibilits dchanges internationaux.
Source: Forum economique Mondial, Roland Berger.
41 Infrastructures et investissements
necessai res
A l’cheIle mondiale, plus de 2000 usines de production
de biocarburants avancs (produisant chacune —100 m L
de biocarburants par an) seraient ncessaires afin d’exploiter
la totalit de la biomasse non alimentaire disponible.
Or pour atteindre 63% d’incorporation de carburants
d’aviation durables (objectifde ReFuel EU for Aviation),
ces ressources biologiques ne sont pas disponibles en
quantit suifisante. C’est pourquoi le recours aux carburants
de synthse est ncessaire. II s’agirait de dvelopper
500 sites Power-to-Liquid, chacun avec une capacit de
—550 m L d’e-fuels par an, pour un investissement total
estim å 1 700 Mds d’euros.
Rorand Berger 8 Les carburants daviation durabies
Pour produire I’offre thorique maximale en biojet avanc dans le monde telle
que modlis& ci-dessus, ii faudrait ouvrir 2 100 usines3 dc production dc
biocarburants avancs d’ici 2050, dont 250 en Europe (x 10 par rapport aux
capacits actuelles), cc qui n&essiterait un investissement d’environ 500 Mds
d’euros4 entre aujourd’hui et 2050.
Le surcofit annuel dc production (OpEx additionnelles en plus de la production
de carburants fossiles) imputable a l’incorporation des biocarburants
avancs (G2) pourrait approcher 33 Mds d’euros en 2030 et 123 Mds d’euros
en 2050.
Pour raliser au niveau mondial l’ambition dc la Commission Europeenne
et cellc dc IATA (soit 65 % de carburants d’aviation durabies dans l’arien
horizon 2050), plus dc 500 usines Power-to-Liquid (carburants de synthse)
seraient requises (dont 75 en Europe) en complment des sites dc production de
biocarburants d’aviation durabies, disposant d’une capacit nominale d’environ
550 millions de litres (pour produire 300 Mds dc litres d’e-fuels).
Dc fortes contraintcs psent gaIcmcnt sur la localisation des sites dc
production intgrs (intgrant 1ectrolyseurs, dispositifs de capture/captage
du CO, et sites de production dc carburant) : pour que le C02 soit renouvelable,
ii doit tre capt dans l’air ambiant (voie Direct Air Capture), ce qui rcprsente
un processus cofiteux, ou issu dc fermentation dc biomasse ou dc dchets (CCUS
pour Carbon Capture, Utilization and Storage) donc å proximit directe dc
distilleries ou dc centres dc traitements.
La construction d’usines intgres Power-to-Liquid pourrait n&essiter un
investissement cumul d ‘environ 1 200 Mds d’eu ros6 l’horizon 2050— dont
—160 Mds en Europe et 20 Mds en France (pour 11 usines PtL intgrcs et
l’quivaIent en GW dc capacit installe en lcctrolyscurs).
Le dvcIoppemcnt d’une tclle capacit dc production prsentc gaIement
dc grands dfts techniques tant le besoin associ en hydrognc et en dioxyde
dc carbone captur/capt est consequcnt (600 GW dc capacit insta1lc7,
intgrant le rendement thorique dc 60%, en lectrolyse pour produire
suffisarnment d’hydrogne, alors que la capacit dc production mondiale en
nergie renouvelable cst en 2021 d’environ 2800 GW).
3 Production thorique unhtaire de 100 m L de biocarburants par an.
4 Hypothse de colt dinvestissement unitaire pour une usine intgröe de type ATJ de 240 m d’euros.
5 Prise en compte des colts de production Iis aux technologies et aux matires premieres uniquement,
ne prend pas en compte le colt du carbone.
6 Sur la base dun investissement unitaire dc 2,7 Mds d’euros en 2040 avec des hypothses dc CapEx
pour une usine tant dcomposs comme suit: —1,2 Md d’euros pour les electrolyseurs dune capacite
dl GW, —1 Md d’euros pour Ie site dc synthse Fischer-Tropsch et —0,4 Md d’euros pour Ie dispositif dc
captage du C02 via une technologie Direct Air Capture) Baisse des colts d’investissement estims å
—
20 % entre 2040 et 2050.
7 Hypothse de duree dc vie dun lectrolyseur instaIl en 2025 au-delä de 2050.
Roland Berger 9 Les carburants daviation durabies
Le monde dispose de larges ressources Iignoceltulosiques exploitables
(biomasse), permettant de produire des volumes consquents de
biocarburants d ‘aviation durahies dans iesprochaines &cennies. Les
industriels, actfs notamment en Europe, aux Etats-Unis, en Afrique
dii Sud, soni galement å lapointe de la recherche sur les carburants
desynthse (grandsprojetsd ‘lectrolyseursetavancestechnologiques
sur les disposit(fs de Direct A ir Capture) pour venir compkter 1 ‘offre
de biocarburants, qui se rvle insuffisante dans un objectf de
neutralit carbone å horizon 2050. 1
Mais ces technotogies restent naissantes et par consquent encore
coiteuses. Une industriatisation dc ta production permettra dc tisser
tes coits dc R&D &evs et defaire baisser les coits dc production dc
manire signficative. Par ailteurs, dans te cas des carburants dc
synthse, 1 ‘accs å une tectricit bas-carbone conomique est vitat
pour atteindre des coi2ts dc production proches du krosne
conventionnel ii terme. Cette convergence des coits dc production ne
saurait se faire sans un soutien public fort perrnettant dc susciter
1 ‘int&et des investisseurs privcs.
L ‘adoption d’un LTAG (Long Term Aspirational Goal) par 1 ‘OACI
apparait aujourd’hui comme une .ncessit. Ii permettrait, en
soulignant te röle essentiel des carburants alternatifs durabies pour
1 ‘aviation, de donner une visibilit å long terme indispensable pour
dtclencher les investissements industriels consquents etfaire baisser
les cofits de production. L ‘Europe a te choix entre plusieurs
&canismes de soutien stimuler 1 ‘offre, å 1 ‘image des Etats-Unis qui
.
ont instaur des mesures fortes de soutien å la production depuis
ptusieurs annes (‘å travers te Biorefinery assistance program, ou via
diffrents avantages fiscaux comme des crdiis d ‘impåts, pouvani
&tre conjugues avec des mesures compkmentaires jouant sur la
demande de type obtigations rgtementaires et d ‘ventuelles inesures
dc soutien aiix acheteurs.
II permettrait galement de donner un cadre juridique mondiat en
instaurant un level playing field entre les Etats .s ur les ci itres dc
durabilit des carburants avancs ei d ‘accs harrnoniscs aux
ressources «acilitant å terme tes changes enire ptaieforrnes
amportzIaires au niveau europen et mondial par des systmes dc
type book & cluiin) pour timiter les distorsions de concurrence lies
å des disparits en maiire dc rcgtementations env ?rnentales.
Roland Berger 10 Les carburanls davi
AUTEURS
Didier Bröchemier
1 Senior Partner
+33 1 53 67 09 26 didierbrechemierroIandbergercom
Franois Guönard
- Partner
±33 1 70 394118 francois.guenardroIandberger.com
Erwan Gaudemer
44 Project Manager
+33 1 70 39 41 32 erwan.gaudemer©rolandbergercom
Antoine Aubert
Senior Consultant
C
+33 1 70 92 88 88 antoine.aubertroIandberger.com
-
Soutiane Benbouazza
Consultant
c
+33 1 70 92 89 38 soufiane.benbouazzaroIandbergercom
CONTACT ROLAND BERGER
Anne Corteggiano
Directrice des Aifaires Extärieures et de IEngagement
+33 6 74 45 74 69 anne.corteggianoroIandbergercom
Les auteurs accueillent vos questions, commentaires ou suggestions
www.rolandberger.com
Cette publication a prpare ä titre indicatif seulement. Le lecteur ne doit prendre de däcision
au regard des informstions prsentes dsns cette publicstion sans avoir regu un avis professionnel
sp&ifique. Roland Berger GmbH ne peut tre tenu responsable des dommages rösultant de
l’utilisation des informstions contenues dans cette publicstion.
© 2022 ROLAND BERGER GMBH. TOUS DROITS RSERVS.
1
II
ROLAND BERGER est le seul cabinet de conseil de direction gnraIe
d’origine europenne qui ait une prsence forte ä I’international.
En tant que socitä indöpendante, dtenue exclusivement par nos
partenaires, nous disposons de 50 bureaux sur tous les grands
marchs. Nos 2 400 emplofls offrent une approche unique, combinant
analyse et empathie. Anims par nos valeurs d’entrepreneuriat et
d’excellence, nous sommes convaincus,chez Roland Berger, que
le monde a besoin d’un nouveau paradigme durable, qui prenne
en compte l’ensemble du cycle de valeur. Gräce å des €quipes
diversifiäes, avec des comp&tences pour tous les secteurs d’activit et
fonctions, nous sommes en mesure d’apporter la meilleure expertise
possible pour relever les profonds dfis d’aujourd’hui et de demain.
diteur:
ROLAND BERGER
62-64, Rue de Lisbonne
75008 Paris
France
+33 1 53670320
Roland
Berger
Citizens’ expectations on the
decarbonization of the air transport
sector
Friday, the 4th of February 2022
This international survey assesses the perceptions and expectations of citizens
regarding the decarbonization of the air transport sector
Qbjectives and methodology of the survey
Context and objectives Methodology
O This survey conducted for the French Ministry of Transport aims at . Administration of questionnaires to travelers and non-travelers sampies by
understanding the expectations expressed by citizens regarding the independent polling company Dynata in 12 countries between October and
decarbonization of air transport and the efforts expected from the sector December 2021, via the Internet and translated into Iocal languages
as a whole . Analysis of the results by Roland Berger
O Major topics addressed:
—Main purposes for air travel / reasons for non travelling World population World air traffic
—Perception of the economic importance of the air transport sector
—Perception of the sectors contribution to giobal C02 emissions
46% 44%
—Preferences between different decarbonization Ievers
—Perception of carbon offsetting and biofueis
—Price sensitivity of citizens regarding additional costs linked to carbon
offsetting and biofueis
54% 56%
O Study panel Rest of the world
Source: Dynata, UN, Roland Berger Roland Berger 2
Travelers only
After the crisis, travelers in 11 out of 12 countries intend to travel at Ieast as much
as before
How often do you pian to fiy once the heaith restrictions reiated to the COVID-19 outbreak have been iifted?1)
Less than before As much as before More than before
IND 17% 33% 50% 83%
O TUR 45% I” 34%
USA 25% 48% 27% Z 75%
BRA 26% 52% 22% 74%
• RUS 26% 57% 17% 74%
FRA 27% 62% 11% Z 73%
• GER 28% 59% 13% 72%
29% 39% 32% Z 71%
O CHI w. 44% Z 69%
SA 32% 45% 68%
fUK
39% 47% 14% Z 61%
IDN 52% 25% 23% Z48%
% of travelers among respondents
1) Consolidation of responses from Private and ‘Business travelers
Source: Dynata, Roland Berger Roland Berger 3
wIøuuuu —.
2. 2. m C) w cz cz -n C, C’ —1 0
C CI C) m t Cf) 7 ? > = —.
> >
0 (.
°) —
-,
1f
1 1
CD
(.3
0) 3
CD
0
II =
0
0)
=
-‘ — -
0
m
•1
. =
CD
-‘
0
=
CD
‘3-
=
0)-
On average, two-thirds of respondents perceive the air transport sector as a major
contributor to CO2 emissions
In your opinion, what is the estimated contribution of air transport to giobal C02 emissions?1)
77% 0
76/o 750/
72%
0
66% 65%
26% 25%
0 61h 60%
31%
57%
33% 24%
36% 27%
31%
30%
27%
1 1 1 45% . Ø 37%
FRA SA GER TUR IND UK BRA USA IDN RUS CHI EGY
•
— •
Responsible for 4-8% of giobal C02 emissions O Responsible for >8% of giobal C02 emissions
1) Consensus on the contribution of the aviation sector to C02 emissions at -2.5O% according to the Giohal Carbon Atias
Source: Dynata, ICAO, CarbonMap, Giobal Carbon Atias, Roland Berger Roland Berger 1 5
Q)
0)
CD
( .-1
-‘
=
0
O CD CD
(1)
0•
CD 0
D CD
0
Ci)
0
i.
D
CD
CD
Oc’ -4
-‘
D
(‘3
=
0 C/)
0
CD
(13
K -
CD
(1,
D
-o
3
0
CI)
CD
0
0
•1
CD
CD =
•1 CD
CD
3 0
= 0
0
-‘ 0
(1)
3
CD
0
CD
CD
:3
CD
:3-
CD
0
•1
CD
0
0
:3 0
0
3
0 0 -‘
CD
= =
0
1 CD 2.
0
0
=
:3-
CD -3
C5
0
0
:3
-‘
0
=
yO
=
0
D
1
1
0•
CD
(D
(0
0)
A large share of respondents expect additional decarbonization efforts from the
aviation sector
Should the air transport sector make further efforts to reduce its emissions in the coming years?
1 83%
80% “%
72%
61%
IND BRA TUR IDN SA FRA CHI EGY UK GER USA RUS
• w
a
O Share of respondents who think the air transport sector should make further efforts to reduce its C02 emissions
Source: Dynata, Roland Berger Roland Berger 7
.,
_____________
Biofueis and technological innovations are the main Ievers put forward to decarbonize
the aviation sector
Among the following elements, which ones do you think are the most important Ievers for 002 reduction? Rank them in
order of importance (from 1 to 9, 1 being the most important)
Important Moderately important Not important
Biofueis 47% 35% 19%
Hydrogen/electric engines 44% 35% 21%
ii Optimization of trajectories
24% 47% 30%
and improvement of control .4
Ja’ Carbon offsetting 24% 43% 33%
Lighter cabins and aircraft 19% 44% 36%
Individual carbon budget/
20% 42% 38%
individual carbon quota
Modal shift to rail
J (public policies)
19% 40%
Tax on tickets 12% 22% 66%
‘I’ Technical Ievers, to be used by industry players Actions taken directly by travelers
Note: Levers were ranked in order of importance by respondents Irnportant: lst or 2nd; Moderately irnportant: 3rcI to 5th; Not important: 6th to 9th
-
Source: Dynata, Roland Berger Roland Berger 8
r•_)
o
(3
CD
c’
:3
—.
0
1—
CD
65
.
-
6 IO+; 1
(1
Ilo
0 m
-.‘
0>
CD0
•‘:: N
—
CD
> m 0
-<
=1
ci,
0( —
0 -‘
= =
65
D
DC
CD
w 0
0.
CD
33:3 CD =
CD 00
CD 0
CD
CD ;- r-I-Q =
0
3
•0
0
•0
0
6)
=
:3
3,
CD OCD 0
0•
CD
CD
03
0
= =
(.
CD 0
— :3
=
CD
0 0
0
=
0
3’-, CD
II
:3
=
0
0•
CD
6)
CD
==
0
6)
CD
0
05
0
CD
0
0
—-
0 3
0
L1)
CD
05
0•
0
(0
3 -
:3-
0
=
S2.
•1
o — 0
CD
CD 0
z
CD
=
C,)
CD
•h
0
C)
0 CD
cc
= CD
CD
=
0
0
.-J
CD
XI
3
0
6)
:3
CD
Cl
CD
Cl
=
0
o
•1
-‘
0 —o
D) 0 =
0
o•
0
0
= CD
(0
= CD
0 0
cl -
= =
0
0
0
0
-o CD
0 0
0
(1) •0.
0
= Cn
0• CD
cTc
-Q
= —
0
CD CD
•1
0
0
cn — ø.
(0
CD
—ii.
-4i<
—.
0
=
•1 0
CD 0
C/)
0
= -
=
0
-h
=
•1
CD
CD (1)
-‘
0
=
=
=
r43
0
lc
0
0•
07
(0
(0
cl
However, there are significant differences between countries
In your opinion, who should bear the additional cost of biofueis?
Airlines and their passengers Fuel manufacturers Public funding
r
IDN 72% -___
IND 67% 22%
im GER 56% 20% 24%
1* UK 55% 25% 20%
-_______________________
1. CHI 50% 20% 29%
L•
flFRA 29% 25%
* TUR 20% 36%
- USA 41% 24%
SA 39% 38% 23%
BRA 38% 24%
41%
O RUS 20% 30% 51%
—
— Countries where the majority of respondents put the airlines and their passengers as primary players to bear the extra costs
Souce: Dynata, Roland Berger Roland Berger 1 ii
Travelers only
-‘90% of travelers are willing to pay more for air travel to contribute to
decarbonization
What additional cost, as a percentage of your ticket price, would you be willing to pay to limit the climate impact of your air
travel?
related to carbon offsetting related to biofueis
(existing solution) (solution to be developed)
24% 23%
27%
27%
19% 21%
8% 9%
Proportion ot accepted 0% +1% O +5% O +10% O > +20%
additional cost
Source: Dynata, Roland Serger Ro(and Serger 1 12
Travelers only
Travelers’ wiilingness to pay the additional cost related to the decarbonization of
the aviation industry increases with the distance of the journey
Proportion of ali traveiers wiiling to pay for the additionai cost reiated to...
.the use of biofueis .the use of carbon offsetting mechanisms
Short-haul Medium-haul Long-haul Total Short-haul Medium-haul Long-haul Total
17%
30%
31%
27%
28% 27%
22% 28%
22%
27%
21% 23%
20% 18% 17% 16% 19%
11% 8% 8% 9% 9% 7% 7% 8%
Price increase ampiitude 0% +1% +5% O +10% O > +20%
Source: Dynata, Roland Berger RoLand Berger 13
Report
Ro[and Berger
Sustainable aviation fueis
A MAJOR LEVER FOR DECARBONIZATION
OF AIR TRANSPORT?
Roland
Berger
INTRODUCTION AND
CQNTEXT OF THE STUDY
he Roland Berger consulting firm has carried out a detailed study on
T sustainable aviation fueis on behaif of the French Ministry of Transport
—
—
a major lever for decarbonizing the transport sector on a giobal scaie.
Decarbonization commitments made to date in the air transport sector
are mainly from the industry.
Sustainable aviation fueis face production constraints that make them
very expensive for airiines today. The potential for incorporating biofueis
differs from one region to another due to very heterogeneous biomass
resources distribution and kerosene consumption across the globe.
The woridwide avaiiabie non-food biomass is not sufficient to meet the
63% sustainabie aviation fuel incorporation target(ReFuei EU forAviation
objective). Therefore, the use ofsynthetic fueis is necessary. This wouid
invoive developing —2,500 production sites (ali types of sustainabie
aviation fueis) , producing —500 bn L of SAFs in totai, for a cumuiative
investment of EUR 2.2 triiiion over the 2025-2050 period, a sum in excess
of EUR 70 biilion per year. Reaching carbon neutraiity by 2050 depends
on a paekage of measures: among the mostimportant of them, sustainabie
aviation fueis are set to deploy faster on a giobal scaie.
LEX1CON OF THE MAIN TERMS USED
ATJ (Alcohol-to-Jet): synthesis process aliowing to produce fuei from alcohol (generaliy ethanol) produced
by fermentation
Gonventional biofuel (G1): iiquid fuel for transport derived from the transformation of food and feed crops,
meaning starch-rich crops. sugar crops or oiI crops produced on agricultural land as main crops. as defined
in in Articie 2, second paragraph, point 40 of Directive (EU) 2018/2001
Advanced biofuel (G2): iiquid fuel produced from non-food biological resources calIed Iignoceiiulosic or
biomass
3rd
generation biofuel (G3): experimentai fuel based on the exploitation of the aquatic biomass. specifically
autotrophic aigae deiivering a carhonaceous substrate by photosynthesis
Biojet: certified aviation fuel containing a proportion of biofuel
Lignocellulosic biomass: ali organic matter of piant origin (agricuiturai residues. forestry waste. dedicated
crops such as giant miscanthus. aigae...) which can become a source of energy by combustion
Sustainable Aviation Fueis (SAFa): name given to fueis that can be incorporated into aircraft as an
alternative to conventional aviation fueis, certified as sustainabie by independent entities (such as voluntary
schemes in Europe) and meeting ali the requirements to be used on scheduled passengerflights (as defined
in adequate standarda by the giobal normalization organization ASTM International or the UK Defence
Standardization). They can be of bioiogical or synthetic origin (also cailed efueis)
Synthetic fueis: fueis produced from chemicai reaction between hydrogen and carbon dioxide see Power
-
to-Liquid
CHJ (Cataiytic Hydrothermoiysis Jet): synthetic hydrocarbon or aynthetic hydrocarbons mix produced from
biomass
Low-carbon electricity: eiectricity produced from renewabie or iow carbon-emitting energy aources (e.g.
nuciearenergy)
Fischer-Tropsch (FT): synthesis process ailowing to produce a synthetic crude from a synthesis gas caiied
syncrude. which is refined to produce sustainahle aviation fuel
HEFA (Hydroprocessed Esters and Fatty Acids). isomerizing hydrotreatment of vegetabIe oils (HVO), waste
oiis and animal fats to produce biofuels
0
Power-to-Liquid: process to produce synthetic fueis PtL fueis are produced by combining hydrogen with
-
carbon dioxide (C02). This hydrogen is extracted from water by eiectroiysis using renewabie energies. This
combination leada to a synthetic gas convertibie into Iiquid fuel after treatment 0
11 Industry commitments
Decarbonization commitments made to date in the air transport
sector are mainly from the industry
Most experts agree the sustainable decarbonization of the air transport sector
wiII only be attainable through a combination of different Iever&: product
technological innovation, optimization ofairport operations and infrastructures,
use of sustainable aviation fueis and the impiementation of offsetting
mechanisms. —*A
SUSTAINABLE AVIATION FUELS WILL PLAY A MAJOR ROLE
IN DECARBONIZING THE SECTOR
Ambitious targets of incorporation of sustainable aviation fueis have been
defined in the industry and by a few pioneering States such as France. At
European level, the European Commission proposed targets through ReFuel
EU-Aviation (component of the Fit for 55 package) corresponding to about 5%
in 2030, 32% jo 2040 and 63% in 2050. B
1 These Ievers can be stimulated with economic tools (carbon price for example) allowing to efficienhly direct
investments in the sector.
A 1 Multiple options have been identified to decarbonize the air transport sector by 2050
Waypoint 2050 — Technoloav and ooerations scenario [Giobal C02 emissions; mt]
Giobal C02 emissions [million tonsi
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
Net-Zero
0
2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 Contribution to the
reduction of C02
O Technology O Operations & infrastructure 0 Sustainable aviation fueis 0 Carbon offset emissions by 2050
Source: Air Transport Action Group (ATAG) Vypoint 2050.
-
Ro’and Berger 3 Sustarnable aiation fueis
Manufacturers Boeing and Airbus are able to adapt fleets with engines allowing
a 100% SAFs incorporation level by 2030.
21 Production of sustainable fueis
and constraints
Sustainable aviation fueis are facing production constraints
that make their price prohibitive to date for airlines
Sustainable aviation fueis (SAFs) are divided into two families: sustainable
fueis of biological origin (aviation biofueis or biojet) and sustainable synthetic
fueis ofnon-biological origin (e-fuels). 4 C
Advanced biofueis (G2) are currently very expensive due to Iow maturity of
production teclinologies, complexity of collection as weII as supply chain
(> 1.3 euro/I compared to 0.44 euro/I for conventional kerosene on average
over the Iast ten years).
B1 By 2050, giobal and European organizations are planning ambitious SAF incorporation
mandates of [50-65%]
SAF incorporation ambitions of the different organizations [%; 2025-2050]
2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
175%
•
2%
•
2%
5%
4.3%
5%
15%
1 24%
Note: The diiferential corresponds to a sub-mandate for the incorporation of synthetic fueis (e-fuel).
27% 35%
Organizations O ReFuel EU B ofwhich % biofueis (ReFuel EU) IATA
Source: IATA, ICAO, Refuel EU, IHS, US Govemment, Roland Berger.
Roland Berger 4 Sustainable aviation fueis
it is theoreticaiiy possibie to produce a conventional biojet (GI) following two
processes:
O HEFA from oilseeds such as rapeseed oli or sunfiower directiy (mastered
process now used for road biodiesel, but not yet widely adopted due to
—
cheaper alternatives)
O Alcohol-to-jet, aithough the technology is stili in the pilot phase, fiom GI
bioethanol (from corn, wheat, or beet...)
But the potentiai of some conventional oilseed biofueis (Gi) for aviation is
Iimited due to a iower contribution to the reduction ofgreenhouse gas emissions
compared to advanced biofueis (indirect impact of land use change) and to
strong competition with food crops iii the Iand use. Similarly but to a iesser
extent, corn or beet based ATJ potential could aiso be Iimited.
Sustainable synthetic fueis (of non-bioiogical origin) based on renewable or
low-carbon electricity are also a serious option for decarbonizing the airtransport
sector. They are produced with hydrogen (H2 from eiectrolysis powered by
renewabie or iow-carbon electricity) and carbon dioxide (CO,) from the
atmosphere, captured at plants using fermentation of bioiogicai inputs or CO,
emitting piants.
The mainstepsofthis conversion processcalled Power-to-Liquid (eiectroiysis
of water to obtain hydrogen, CO, capture, conversion of these elements into
synthetic gas by gasification before using processes such as Fischer-Tropsch
or Methanoi-to-Gasoiine to produce hydrogen) have aiready reached
demonstrator maturity. Ali components and mixtures offueis (hydrocarbons
and aleohois) can be produced from Power-to-Liquid, but they make the refining
process more compiex and some products more expensive.
The cost of e-kerosene from the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis couid decrease by
50% between 2020 and 2030 to reach 1.5-1.9 euro per liter (compared to 2.2-
3.0 euros per 111cr today) the MtG (Methanol-to-Gasoiine) synthesis being
-
slightly more expensive than the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis.
The main obstacies to the development of the e-fueis sector are currentiy
the cost ofrenewabie or low-carbon eiectricity (aiiowing eiectrolysis, eiectricity
representing 80% of the cost ofe-fuel per liter), the construction ofintegrated
piants with electroiyzers, devices for CO, capture, gasification and Fischer
Tropsch synthesis in particular, and the capture ofrenewable C02 (from the air,
from fermentation of biomass or waste, or at the exit of piants according to
modalities to be defined).
Roland Berger 5 Sustainable aniation ftiels
____________
C 1 There are several synthesis processes to produce biojet from oils, sugarslcereals but
also biomass
Use of inputs by synthesis process of sustainable aviation fuel
Input Input Initial Reactants Synthesis Technological Current
constraints treatment process constraints estimated cost
vs fossil fueis
0
-J Vegetal ojis’ Neutralization Lipids
uJ G1
D
LL 1
0
Sugar cane Food Fermentation Bioethanol -x2 to x3
Beet competition,
ILUC impact
Corn, wheat... Fermentation Bioethanol
G 2 Today
used for
Animal fat Pretreatment
Volume
biojet
production available, —xI,5 to x3
traceabihty
Used cooking Pretreatment
ofojls
oils (UCO)
Biomass Forestry/ Pretreatment Synthetic -).FT
agriculturai gas
waste (gasification)
directly apply
to input +
hydrogen
OR -.x3 to x6
Biomass Energy crops OiI/ceilulose Bio- ATJ
extraction ethanol
OR
Waste3 Separation Lipids E-CHJ
G3 Algae Oil extraction Lipids
00
j::11 Nonbio C02 and water Water H2 (electrolysis
(without electrolysis based on
i•11• available low-carbon
..x7 to xjO
z energy) electricity)
>-
0
+c02
1 Feasibility depending on the length of carbon chains in the oils (e.g. rapeseed, sunflower...), does not work with ali of them.
2 High Hydrogen Content Synthelic Paraffinic Kerosene.
3 Biowaste consisting of food waste and other biodegradable natural waste can be used.
Source: Roland Berger.
Roland Berger 6 Sustainable aeation ftiels
31 Giobal production
The potential for biofuel incorporation differs by geography
due to very heterogeneous biomass resources and
kerosene consumption situations across the giobe
We modeled the theoretical maximum incorporation of sustainable aviation
biofuel by major geography by comparing the following variabies:
The worldwide supply, i.e. the quantity of biomass available, collectable
and usable for biojet production giobally.
This quantity is estimated to be around 1 bn tons in 2050, two thirds ofwhich
are derived from agricultural residues, mainly Iocated in Asia and Africa. This
biomass could allow a theoretical production ofabout 185 bn Iiters ofbiojet by
2050 (i.e. equivalent to a 20% incorporation level based on a 2.7% growth of
the average annual giobal kerosene consumption and a 2050 kerosene
consunlption ofabout 970 bn liters).
Acareful examination ofoilseed raw materiais and bioethanol volumes available
in Europe and in the world could be done, within current Iimits and including
raw materiais made available due to the energy transition of the road transport
sector (mainly food and feed crops resources). Such approach would identify
a theoretical additional biojet incorporation capacity ofabout 10% in France for
example. Such careful examination should allow to identify and assess benefits
and drawbacks of directing newly available resources towards a single sector
such as air or maritime transport while carefully making sure to avoid marginal
,
competition effect with food double uses.
To assess the potential for advanced biofueis incorporation, ii is necessary
to estimate the evolution of kerosene demand by major geography2. The
demand is expressed as volume ofkerosene required and takes into account
the evolution ofair traffic and energy efficiency gains planned by aircraft
manufacturers. The following annual growth assumptions have been used
for the calculation: Europe and North America: 1%, Latin America: 3%,
Africa: 3.4%, Asia and Oceania: 3.9%.
The figures shown above include the maximum incorporation of advanced
biofueis. D
In a nutshell, strong disparities are expected between geographies.
2 Source used: US Energy Information Administration.
Roland Berger 7 Sustolnable aiation fueis
D 1 By 2050, Africa and America could incorporate [-60-100%] of biojet (G2) —
Lower incorporation in Europe & Asia [‘-15-30%]
Theoretical1 incorporation of advanced biofueis by region [2030; 2050; %]
26%
North
America Asia
& Oceania
Latin
America
TOTAL
O 2030 2050 WORLD
1 Corresponds to the share of demand that can be met by biofueis in maximum theoretical production exduding e-fuel. Assumption of incorporation in the
-
sustainable aviation fuel production continent transportation of biofuels is feasible but with additional costs and impact on greenhouse gas emissions.
-
Increase of G2 incorporation leveis between 2030 and 2050 due to new production sites. This observation can be put into perspective by the possibilities
of international exchanges.
Source: World Economic Forum, Roland Berger.
41 Infrastructures and investments
required
More than 2,000 advanced biofueis production plants
(each producing —100 m L of biofueis per year) would be
required woridwide to exploit ali available non-food biomass.
However, those biologicai resources are not available in
sufflcient quantity to reach 63% of sustainable aviation fueis
incorporation (the goal of ReFuei EU for Aviation). The use
of synthetic fuels is therefore necessary. The development
of 500 Power-to-Liquid piants, each with a capacity of
—550 m L e-fuels per year, for an estimated totai investment
of 1,700 bn euros is required.
Roland Berger 8 Sustainable aviation fueis
To produce the maximum theoretical supply ofadvanced biojet in the world as
modeled above. it would require the opening of 2,100 advanced biofueis
production plants3 by 2050, including 250 in Europe (xIO cornpared to
current capacities), which would require an investment of about 500 bn euros4
between now and 2050.
The additional annual production cost (additional OpEx to the production
offossil fueis) due to the advanced biofueis (G2) incorporation could reach
33 bn euros in 2030 and 123 bn euros in 2050.
To achieve the ambition of the European Commission as weII as the one of
IATA at a giobal level (i.e. 65% ofsustainable aviation fueis in air transport by
2050). more than 500 Power-to-Liquid (synthetic fueis) plants would be
required (including 75 in Europe) to complernent the production sites of
sustainable aviation biofueis, with a namepiate capacity ofapproximately 550
million liters (to produce 300 bn Iiters ofe-fueis).
There are also strong constraints on the Iocation ofintegrated production
sites (integrating electrolyzers, CO., capture devices and fuel production sites):
for CO, to be renewable, it must be captured in the air (Direct Air Capture),
which is a costly process, from biomass or waste fermentation (CCUS for
Carbon Capture, Utilization and Storage) in direct proximity to distilleries or
processing centers.
The construction ofintegrated Power-to-Liquid plants may require a 1,200
bn euros6 cumulated investment by 2050— ofwhich —160 bn in Europe and
—20 bn in France (for II integrated PtL plartts and the GW equivalent ofinstalled
electrolysers capacity).
The development of such a production capacity is a major technological
challenge considering how significant the requirements in hydrogen and
carbon dioxide are (600 GW ofinstalled capacity7, integrating the theoretical
yield of 60%, iii electrolysis to produce sufficient hydrogen, while the world’s
renewable energy production capacity in 2021 is approximately 2,800 GW).
3 Theoretical unit production of 100 m L of biofueis per year.
4 Assumption of unit inve5tment cost for an integrated ATJ type ptant of 240 m euros.
5 Based onty on technology-retated and raw materiais production costs. excluding carbon costs.
6 Based on a unit investment of 2.7 billion euros in 2040 with CapEx assumptions for a plant broken down
as follows —1.2 bn euros for electrolysers with a capacity of 1 GW, —1 bn euros for the Fischer.-Tropsch
synthesis site and —0.4 bn euros for the C02 capture device via Direct Air Capture technology) 20%
—
estimated decrease in investment costs between 2040 and 2050.
7 Life-expectancy of an electrolyser installed in 2025 assumed to go beyond 2050.
Rand Berge- 9 Sustn,le avwtion fueis
The worldhas large exploitable lignocellulosic resourees (biomass),
allowing the production of large volumes of sustainable aviation
biofueis in the coming decades. Manufaclurers, particularly active
in Europe, the United States, in South Africa, are also at the cutting
edge ofresearch on syntheticfuels (major electrolyser projects and
advances in technology onDirectAir Capture devices) to supplement
the supply ofbiofueis, which isproving insufficientfor the objective
ofcarbon neutrality by 2050.
Butthese technölogies are stillatearly-stage andtherefore ex/’c’n.vii’c.
Industrialization of the production will allow to smooih on! high
R&D costs and to signficantly decrease production cosls. Io,co t’i:
in the case of synthetic fueis, access to economical1’ viab/c low
carbon electricity is vital to reach production costs similc,r io tho.vc
of conventional kerosene in the long run. ThIs con’it’rgence of
production costs will not materialize without strong public support 1
to encourage the interest ofprivate sector investors.
Adoption ofa LTAG (Long Term Aspirational Goal) by the ICAO
today appears as a necessity. By emphasizing the essential role of
sustainable alternativefuelsfor aviation, it would enable long-term
visibilily which is crucial to trigger substantial industrial investments
and decrease production costs. Europe can choose between several
support mechanisms: (1) supply stimulation, as in the United States
which have introduced strong support measures for production for
several years (through the biorefinery assistance program, or via
various tax benefits such as tax credits) or (2) regulatory obligations
which can be combined with complementary measures stirnulating
demand such has supporting demand, completed with strong State
support mechanisms.
A LTAG would thusprovide a much-neededglobal legalframework
in establishing a levelplayingfield between states on the criteria of
sustainability ofadvancedfuels and harmonized access to resources.
This would eventually facilitate exchanges between air transport
platforms at a European and giobal .scale thanks to the use ofbook
& claim type systems, and limit distortions ofcompetition related to
disparities in environmental regulations.
Roand Berger 10 Sustainable aation fueis
AUTHORS
Didier Bröchemier
1 Senior Partner
+33 1 53 67 09 26 didier.brechemierroIandbergercom
, Franois Guönard
Partner
4 a
-‘-33 1 70 39 4118 francois.guenardroIandberger.com
Erwan Gaudemer
Å Project Manager
+33 1 70 39 41 32 erwan.gaudemerroIandberger.com
Antoine Aubert
r Senior Consultant
+33 1 70 92 88 88 antoine.aubertroIandbergercom
Soufiane Benbouazza
Consultant
+33 1 70 92 89 38 soufiane.benbouazzarolandbergercom
ROLAND BERGER CONTACT
Anne Corteggiano
Director of External Affairs and Engagement
+33 6 74 45 74 69 anne.corteggianoroIandberger.com
We welcome your questions, comments and suggestions 1 www.rolandberger.com
This publication has been prepared for general guidance only. The reader should not act according to any
information provided in this publication without receiving specific professional advice. Roland Berger GmbR
ahall not be liable for any damages resulting from any use of the information contained in the publication.
© 2022 ROLAND BEROER GMBH. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
a
ROLAND BERGER is the oniy management consultancy of European
heritage with a strong international footprint. As an independent firm,
solely owned by our Partners, we operate 50 offices in ali major
markets. Our 2400 employees offer a unique combination of an
analytical approach and an empathic attitude. Driven by our values
of entrepreneurship, excellence and empathy, we at Roland Berger
are convinced that the world needs a new sustainable paradigm that
takes the entire value cycie into account and enabies us to meet the
profound chailenges of today and tomorrow.
Publisher:
ROLAND BERGER
62-64, Rue de Lisbonne
75008 Paris
France
+33 1 53670320