168, Avenue de Tervueren – Box 3
B-1150 Brussels, Belgium I +32 2 777 05 60
@RechargeEurope I www.rechargebatteries.org
EU Transparency Reg. 673674011803-02
April 2022
Towards a future-proof Batteries Regulation:
Policy Recommendations for the trilogue negotiations
With the aim of paving the way for sustainable batteries for a circular and climate neutral economy, the proposed Batteries
Regulation is the next step in delivering on the European Strategic Action Plan on Batteries. The Batteries Regulation has the
real potential to translate the EU’s battery vision into a meaningful legislative framework.
Given the strategic role of batteries and the relevance of the Batteries Regulation to European industrial and sustainability
policies, RECHARGE – the leading association representing the advanced rechargeable and lithium batteries value chain in
Europe – would like to encourage the negotiating teams to pay particular attention to the industry concerns and
recommendations outlined in this paper.
In a changed geopolitical context, the EU must decrease its dependencies in strategic value chains to ensure that potential
future crises would not be a detriment to the bloc’s ambitious climate objectives and its crucial industries. Batteries are a key
technology for the energy and digital transitions, yet Europe is particularly dependent on imported batteries from non-EU
countries, while the European battery manufacturing industry is still nascent.
The European battery value chain is making significant investments and has the potential to become one of the largest battery
industries globally, as well as one of the most sustainable and innovative at the same time. However, the regulatory framework
needs to support this ambition and ensure the sustainability objectives enable EU’s competitiveness. Only a strong and leading
European battery industry will be able to set sustainability standards for the rest of the world.
With this paper, RECHARGE proposes concrete recommendations based on an assessment of the Commission proposal and
the two negotiation positions of the Council and the European Parliament which will allow the batteries value chain to deliver
on enabling the energy and digital transitions, as well as the decarbonisation of our economy and society.
Key recommendations are presented in detail in the following pages and invite to:
1. Clarify definitions of battery, battery categories and battery model;
2. Allow the placing on the market of spare batteries for vehicles or appliances already in service, as well as the placing
on the market of batteries designed before entry into force of this Regulation to equip newly manufactured mass-
transit metro, train or aircrafts from existing designs;
3. Not to go against product and transport safety laws and hamper longevity with too prescriptive design requirements;
4. Ensure (waste) batteries are placed under the responsibility of the right actor;
5. Avoid that an enlarged scope combined with a lack of enforcement and market surveillance feasibility jeopardises
the overall ambition and success of the Regulation;
6. Include strong review clauses and safeguard measures against the risks connected to ex ante specified minimum
recycled content and material recovery targets;
7. Disregard the proposal for introduction of a mandatory review of all hazardous substances in batteries using criteria
which are not aligned with the newly adopted restriction process and a date which is inadequate.
In addition to these seven key recommendations, we would like to raise the issue of a legal concern of the industry as in
regards to the obligations as stated in Article 49 (take-back obligation of all waste batteries from the same type/category by
producers) and Article 57 as in the Council text (obligation to accept all waste batteries for recycling by recyclers), and we
strongly advise to get a legal opinion on these Articles by the Commission or Council legal services.
The following pages present a concise overview of RECHARGE’s concrete suggestions in view of the Commission proposal and
the two negotiation positions of the co-legislators and to further contribute to facilitate the debate:
2
1. Clarify definitions of battery, battery categories and battery model: The definition should refer to finished products
which are ready to use. To ensure a high level of safety with regards to the repair and replaceability of a battery, definition (1)
in Article 2 must clearly define a battery as a final article ready for use and include definitions for battery pack and battery
model.
Furthermore, to avoid confusion attached to the definitions of ‘battery’, ‘battery model’ and ‘categories’,
RECHARGE recommends to follow the Council definitions in Article 2 for ‘batteries’ (1), for the definition of
categories of batteries – and in particular regarding the clarifications for ‘portable batteries for general use’ (8)
and for ‘light means of transport battery’ (9), as well as the Council’s ‘battery model’ definition (17). However,
definition (1b) of ‘battery modules’ considered as batteries must be corrected.
2. Allow the placing on the market of spare batteries for vehicles or appliances already in service, as well as the placing
on the market of batteries designed before entry into force of this Regulation to equip newly manufactured mass-transit
metro, train or aircrafts from existing designs: to ensure a long use phase and avoid unnecessary early retirement of appliances
and vehicles already in service, end-users and professional repairers need to be able to source spare parts which may not be
redesigned to comply with the new requirements (“repair as produced”). Furthermore, mass transit systems such as air and rail
transportation systems which require batteries to supply high reliability back-up power for emergency situations (said batteries
are therefore a key component of passenger safety), designed before entry into force of this Regulation and manufactured
after, must be able to be fitted with batteries as originally designed for this application.
A grandfather clause has to be drawn up to cover both these situations and a sufficient transition period has to be foreseen
after entry into force to avoid millions of already produced batteries going straight to recycling without ever having been put
into service.
The European Parliament (EP) intends to take this industry concern into consideration with the adopted
Amendment 117 which introduced the repair as produced clause. RECHARGE recommends adopting this
amendment into the final Regulation with an extension to all battery categories, as otherwise replacement
batteries for i.e. household appliances, power tools or light means of transport would not be covered.
A second part to this amendment 117 shall read: “Industrial batteries designed before the entry into force of
this Regulation may be placed on the market and are exempted from the requirements of chapter II and
chapter IV insofar as (1) they are supplied to the manufacturer or the operator of an air or rail or underground
mass-transportation system which has been designed before entry into force of this Regulation and (2) said
batteries provide back-up power for the safety of the mass-transportation system and its passengers in an
emergency situation”.
RECHARGE also support the EP Amendment 86, exempting equipment specifically designed for the safety of
nuclear installations as well as Amendment 87 serving as a grandfather clause for batteries produced before the
entry into force of this Regulation.
3. Do not go against product and transport safety laws and hamper longevity with too prescriptive design requirements:
The safety risks, which are attached to the Parliament’s amendments on Article 11, are serious, particularly when it comes to
the replacement of cells inside batteries. Nearly every unqualified change of components, such as the replacement of individual
cells of a battery pack or the BMS, causes the loss of conformity with the safety tests. The Parliament’s suggested proposals,
such as replaceability of batteries outside the category of portable batteries of general use, repairability of battery packs and
removability of cells put the safety control at risk.
Due to their energy releasing and chemical properties, batteries must fulfil a series of international, European and national
safety requirements during their production, transport, storage, use and end-of-life management. Safety of the product and
the consumer is, hence, a key priority for the European battery industry. Any requirements compromising the safety of batteries
cannot be accepted. Therefore, only batteries (packs) and not individual battery cells shall be subject to Art. 11.
3
The proposed Parliament’s Art. 11a ‘Removability and replaceability of automotive batteries, electric vehicle batteries and
industrial batteries’ does not consider the broad variety of industrial batteries. Industrial back-up batteries are used in for
example nuclear power plants, high speed trains, airplanes, offshore platforms, etc. and can have each very different
requirements (duration of back-up, service life, ability to withstand temperature, shock and vibrations, ability to perform
additional services). The design requirements for removability, replaceability and disassembly of the case, of individual battery
cells or other key components of such batteries are simply not adequate.
Furthermore, the Parliament’s proposal for a new Art. 11b ‘Safety of repaired automotive batteries, industrial batteries, light
means of transport batteries and electric vehicle batteries’ suggests introducing non-destructive tests for repaired batteries –
this goes directly against international and European safety legislation mandating UN type approval test series which include
destructive tests. Moreover, “repair” is not defined and would give leeway to safety-critical operations on batteries by
incompetent actors.
RECHARGE respectfully asks to consider debating this important issue during the negotiations and invites to
remove safety-critical wording. RECHARGE is particularly concerned regarding the EP Amendments 162, 172,
173, 174 which create a clear safety issue and are going against the durability requirements of batteries.
RECHARGE welcomes the Council text on Article 11 Paragraph 1 excluding cells from the removability and
replaceability requirements and 1a with the safety wording included and considerations for appliances
designed to operate in wet environment.
Furthermore, RECHARGE also positively notes the Council text on a new Article 44a ensuring that economic
operators comply with any relevant product, environmental and human health protection and transport safety
requirements in other legislation.
4. Ensure (waste) batteries are placed under the responsibility of the right actor: For batteries placed on the market in an
appliance or vehicle, the definition should assign producer status to the appliance or vehicle original equipment manufacturers
(OEM), irrespective of the location of the battery manufacturer. A serious deficiency of the proposed Regulation is the issue of
the producer definition, which RECHARGE stressed on multiple occasions. The producer definition in the Commission proposal
as well as Council text creates discrepancies in the internal market due to uneven rules with regard to the application of the
extended producer responsibility (EPR) for battery producers selling to an OEM in the same or a different Member State (MS).
The producer definition as proposed by the Commission, as well as the revised definition in the Council text, create the following
problem: battery manufacturers which sell batteries to OEMs located in their MS will have to report the products as placed on
this market, irrespective of where the OEM places the end-product (vehicle or appliance) on the market. This will lead to ill-
reporting and skewed producer responsibility for batteries within one Member State even if those reported batteries are no
longer in the said MS. Furthermore, exported batteries will have to be reported again when placed on the market in another
MS where they have been imported to, leading to double counting. Therefore, producer responsibility needs to lie with the
economic operator that knows where exactly the batteries are placed on the market for end-use.
This issue needs to be addressed in the Commission’s guidelines for implementation and a solution found whereby the EPR
always lies with the economic operator that sells batteries to end-users either incorporated in vehicles or appliances, or as
“naked objects”. OEMs should take over end-of-life responsibilities as they are closer to the market where the vehicle or the
appliance will be placed and are therefore in a better position to efficiently organise the end-of-life management.
We recommend maintaining the Commission proposal definition (37) ‘producer’.
The Council proposal for the producer definition causes a problem in so far as batteries are not EEE products
always intended for an end user.
4
5. Avoid that an enlarged scope combined with a lack of enforcement and market surveillance feasibility jeopardises the
overall ambition and success of the Regulation: Since the Commission put forward its legislative proposal, RECHARGE has
welcomed the sustainability leadership ambition overall and the proposed legislation addresses all necessary tools for this
objective. It is important to consider that the carbon footprint (Article 7) and recycled content (Article 8) measures could
become useless and merely paperwork if not implemented and enforced correctly at Member State level. The selection of the
applicable scope when deciding about a sustainability measure is decisive. The size of the scope (the number of models to which
the measure is applicable) must be understood to make sure that the measure can be applied and enforced correctly. A too
ambitious initial scope, which cannot be verified and controlled effectively (or which is technically not possible), can
unintentionally encourage greenwashing.
RECHARGE has published recently an analysis on the number of battery models placed on the EU market and the number of
declarations needed for the sustainability requirements depending on the scope of the measure (here).
For Article 7, the scope, as proposed by the Commission, would already represent more than 20,000 battery
models for which carbon footprint declarations would be required. This scope should not be further extended
without an impact assessment, especially given carbon footprint calculations are application dependent and
cannot follow a one-size-fits-all approach. In the same way, the Due Diligence scope should not be extended
from the “supply chain” to the “value chain” without feasibility clarification.
RECHARGE welcomes the Council suggested changes to the Commission proposal regarding the staggered
implementation timeline as well as the removal of the wording ‘batches’ (as the proposed scope of Article 7 is
too burdensome to implement for all industrial batteries and manufacturing batches).
When it comes to the recycled content measure, battery waste, including production scrap, has reached significant volumes in
Asia, making it easier for Asian companies to access recycled battery materials. Volumes of available secondary raw materials
in Europe are low, and a too ambitious recycled content obligation would jeopardise the competitiveness of European batteries.
In the next 10 to 15 years, a recycled content obligation will steepen EU dependency on third country (secondary) raw materials.
Meaningful targets for recycled content should be assessed in a few years from now based on the future availability of
secondary materials and driven by clear recycling targets as well as end-of-waste criteria.
Similarly to Article 7, the scope of Article 8 needs to be carefully considered and the Commission’s scope should
not be further extended, especially given that no impact assessment has been done based on extension of the
scope and levels of targets.
Also for Article 8 RECHARGE recommends following the Council’s suggested implementation timelines as well
as the removal of the wording ‘batches’.
6. Include strong review clauses and safeguard measures against the risks connected to ex ante specified minimum
recycled content (Article 8) and material recovery (Annex XII) targets: The proposed measures and targets should be designed
to benefit the environment without creating an uneven level playing field and without unduly increasing the carbon footprint
of batteries put on the market.
The environmental benefits of the recycled content provision are too low, an economic assessment is not possible at this point
of time, access to secondary raw materials is uncertain for the next years and the battery chemistries are still developing too
diversely. Hence, a very cautious approach is necessary, including strong review clauses and safeguard measures against the
risks connected to ex ante specified minimum recycled content targets. Too early high recycled content targets might bring
shortages of battery raw materials in the EU resulting in production stops in the EU or forcing European manufacturers to source
secondary raw materials from non-European producers, or unnecessarily push to recycling of batteries potentially usable in a
second life. Any eventual future extension of this obligation requires a thorough impact assessment.
Although RECHARGE has advocated for the recycled content to be implemented on a voluntary basis first, we
welcome that the targets have not been increased compared to the Commission proposal by none of the co-
legislators. The Council furthermore established a reasonable implementation timeline proposal.
5
As for the metals recovery targets, these must be carefully balanced. Excessive requirements beyond the optimised recovery
targets increase the global carbon footprint, as they imply additive resource-intensive (energy, water, solvents) chemical
recycling processes. Mandating much higher targets will always increase resource use, with a reduced marginal benefit for the
circular economy. Recycling targets should be defined based on state of the art and optimised criteria.
The newly proposed lithium recovery targets in the EP Amendments 487 and 488 risk going beyond the optimum
point when the material recovery from the recycling process has a positive environmental impact, and we
recommend to maintain the Commission and Council proposed targets.
7. Disregard the proposal for introduction of a mandatory review of all hazardous substances in batteries using criteria
which are not aligned with the newly adopted Restriction process and a date which is inadequate: The EP Amendments 122
requires the Commission to conduct by December 31st, 2025 a review of all hazardous substances in batteries. However, criteria
proposed to conduct this review are misaligned (“potential risks” and “availability of suitable alternatives”) with the
requirements of the newly adopted restriction process spelled out in Article 6(2) (“unacceptable risk” and “need to be addressed
on a Union-wide basis”). For this reason, this amendment should be rejected as it creates confusion regarding the situations
the Restriction process is supposed to address.
Likewise, EP Amendment 4 should be rejected for the following two reasons: (1) it introduces further requests to the
Commission review which are even more remote to the Restriction process than those introduced in Amendment 122, and (2)
it also targets a subset of substances which have been widely studied and regulated, and for which no unacceptable risk level
requiring that they be addressed on a Union wide basis could be demonstrated.
A process for Restriction dossiers as well as criteria for dossier selection have already been spelled out in the
draft Regulation. Therefore, there is no need to entrust the Commission with the task of generating a report
using criteria that are inconsistent with the Restriction process already established in the appropriate chemical
legislation. For this reason, RECHARGE recommends the rejection of EP Amendments 4 and 122 of the
European Parliament.
The window of opportunity is short, as the next three to five years will be vital for developing a strong and competitive
European batteries value chain. The new Batteries Regulation will set the legislative framework and conditions.
In 2020, in the context of the EU Industrial Strategy update, the European Commission reviewed a number of areas that can be
considered strategic for Europe’s interests: Lithium batteries were identified as one of the strategic areas of interest for the EU.
The industry is ready to deliver, provided the Regulation sets an enabling framework.
This paper is intended to support policymakers' efforts to achieve a final text that supports the EU's climate and
competitiveness objectives.
RECHARGE is the leading industry voice of the advanced rechargeable and lithium batteries value chain in Europe. Founded in
1998, it is our mission to promote advanced rechargeable batteries as a key technology that will contribute to a more empowered,
sustainable and circular economy. RECHARGE’s unique membership covers all aspects of the advanced rechargeable battery value
chain in Europe: From suppliers of primary and secondary raw materials, to battery, equipment and original equipment
manufacturers, to logistic partners and battery recyclers.
To receive the complete RECHARGE amendments to the proposed Batteries Regulation,
please contact:
[email protected].
You can read the RECHARGE position paper here and find further related information as well as recent papers here.
Saatja: Kinga Timaru-Kast <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 14.04.2022 16:04
Adressaat: Taavi Aas <
[email protected]>
Koopia: MKM info <
[email protected]>; Moonika Parksepp
<
[email protected]>
Teema: Batteries Regulation | RECHARGE policy recommendations
Dear Minister Aas
(The Advanced Rechargeable & Lithium Batteries Association) the
leading voice of the European batteries value chain would like, with the
attached letter, to draw your attention to the need to establish a
successful European batteries value chain and reduce the EUs dependency
on imported batteries.
Decreasing the blocs dependencies in strategic value chains would ensure
that potential future crises would not be a detriment to the EUs
ambitious climate objectives and its crucial industries. Batteries are a
key technology for the energy and digital transitions, yet Europe is
particularly dependent on imported batteries from non-EU countries, while
the European battery manufacturing industry is still nascent.
The European batteries value chain is making significant investments and
has the potential to become one of the largest battery industries
globally, as well as one of the most sustainable and innovative at the
same time. However, the regulatory framework (the new European Batteries
Regulation) needs to support, along with sustainability objectives, also
the EUs competitiveness.
In an attached paper you can also find RECHARGEs assessment and concrete
policy recommendations for the upcoming interinstitutional negotiations
on the Batteries Regulation. RECHARGE is calling on policymakers to
thoroughly take into account the value chains positions during the
trilogue negotiations. Only a strong and leading European battery
industry will be able to set sustainability standards for the rest of the
world.
RECHARGE remains at your disposal for any questions, comments or further
information you may need.
Sincerely,
Kinga Timaru-Kast
Kinga Timaru-Kast
Director, Public Affairs & Communications
The Advanced Rechargeable & Lithium Batteries Association
Avenue de Tervueren, 168 - Box 3 I 1150 Brussels, Belgium
T. +32 2 777 05 60 I M. +32 486 996 870 I EU Transparency Reg.
673674011803-02
I I I
168, Avenue de Tervueren – Box 3
B-1150 Brussels, Belgium I +32 2 777 05 60
@RechargeEurope I www.rechargebatteries.org
Subject: Existing dependencies in the energy sector should not be replicated in the case of batteries
– the necessity to create a competitive and leading European batteries value chain
14/04/2022
Dear Minister Aas,
The current geopolitical context related to Russia’s war on Ukraine has demonstrated the vulnerability
of our energy system and the crucial necessity for the European Union to reduce its dependencies in
value chains of strategic importance. Such an approach will be essential to prevent potential future
crises from detrimentally impacting key industries as well as the EU’s ambitious climate objectives.
Importantly, existing dependencies in the energy sector should not be replicated in the case of
batteries.
A key technology for the bloc’s energy and digital transitions, batteries offer solutions to store
renewable energy, power electric vehicles (EVs) as well as mobile communication devices. Batteries
will, thus, provide a decisive contribution to facilitate a carbon-neutral economy and society. The
recent history of the European photovoltaic industry has shown that policy mistakes can damage
efforts to foster European businesses in the sector. Today, policymakers are seeking a way to ‘return’
this industry to Europe. Such a scenario must altogether be avoided for batteries.
RECHARGE, as the leading voice of the European advanced rechargeable and lithium batteries value
chain, is calling to consider the need for a swift development and strengthening of the batteries
industry on our continent. Against the background of this new context, which highlights the urgency
of fostering industrial resilience, the EU must decrease its high dependency on imported batteries.
Notably, today, Europe accounts only for a small share of around 6% of the global battery production,
while China alone holds around 71% of the market.
When moving away from oil and natural gas, both in the energy and transport sector, Europe should
simultaneously become more autonomous and support the electrification and renewables
development with a European battery ecosystem. Creating a strong industry will depend on two main
pillars – long-term investments and a fit-for-purpose regulatory framework.
Regarding the first prerequisite, there has been a significant positive development: Currently, there
are 111 notable battery projects across the EU with a total value chain investment of €127 billion. In
addition, about 800,000 new jobs are expected to be created by 2025 alone. By 2030, a well-developed
European value chain could provide annual added value of around €625 billion.
Concerning the second pillar, the new EU Batteries Regulation, as the main legislative framework,
needs to support this industrial dynamic and ensure a competitive and leading European value
chain, able to set sustainability standards for the rest of the world as well as decrease European
dependency on imported batteries. However, the intrinsic difficulty of enforcing several of the
proposed design requirements is likely to create an uneven playing field, in which the EU industry will
bear the burden of the regulatory constraints, while control of compliance with the sustainability rules
by imported products is expected to be insufficient. Measures which may disproportionally benefit
non-European battery industry need to be amended in a way to rather reinforce the creation and the
investments for a thriving European battery ecosystem.
168, Avenue de Tervueren – Box 3
B-1150 Brussels, Belgium I +32 2 777 05 60
@RechargeEurope I www.rechargebatteries.org
Both the geopolitical context and the climate emergency accentuate the short timeframe for the
development of our strategic industry. Enshrining too many constraints and regulatory hurdles within
the Batteries Regulation would risk setting back value chain efforts and planned investments and could
ultimately endanger reaching the EU’s strategic climate and industrial objectives.
Thus, RECHARGE is calling on policymakers to thoroughly take into account the value chain’s positions
on the future Batteries Regulation during the trilogue negotiations between the Council of the EU and
the European Parliament.
Respectfully,
Dr. Claude Chanson
RECHARGE General Manager
RECHARGE is the European industry association for advanced rechargeable and lithium batteries. Founded in
1998, it is our mission to promote advanced rechargeable batteries as a key technology that will contribute to a
more empowered, sustainable and circular economy by enabling decarbonised electricity and mobility, and
cutting-edge consumer products. RECHARGE’s unique membership covers all aspects of the advanced
rechargeable battery value chain: From suppliers of primary and secondary raw materials, to battery and original
equipment manufacturers (OEMs), to logistic partners and battery recyclers: www.rechargebatteries.org
RECHARGE Membership