1436370 0 DRAFT PROPOSALS – EUROPEAN DEMOCRACY CITIZENS INFORMATION, PARTICIPATION and YOUTH Objective 1 : Increase citizens’ participation and youth involvement in the democracy at the European Union level to develop a ‘full civic experience’ for Europeans , ensure that their voice is heard also in between elections, and that the participation is effective . That is why the most appropriate form of participation should be considered for each topic, for example by: Improving the effectiveness of existing and developing new citizens' participation mechanisms , in line with EU acquis, by better informing on them. Ideally, all the information about the participatory spaces should be summarized in an integrated official website with different features. A mechanism should be devised to monitor policy and legislative initiatives, which have emerged from participatory democracy processes; Participatory mechanisms should be inclusive and their commination able to reach a diverse public. Attention should be paid to content material, topics and moderators’ skills . They should include an analysis on the impact of the policies discussed on , inter alia , women and vulnerable persons . Increasing the frequency of online and offline interactions between EU institutions and its citizens through different means of interaction in order to ensure that citizens can participate in the EU policy-making process to voice their opinions and to get feedback, and creating a charter for EU officials on citizens’ participation; O ffering a user-friendly digital platform where citizens can share ideas, put forward questions to the representatives of EU institutions and express their views on important EU matters and legislative proposals, in particular youth. The platform should also allow for online polls ; Improving and streamlining existing mechanisms at the European, n ational, and local level, to make them more secure, accessible, visible and inclusive; Includ e organised civil society and regional and local authorities and existing struc tures such as the E uropean E conomic and Social Committee (EESC) and the Committee of the Regions ( CoR ) in the citizens’ participation process ; Create a system of local EU Councillors, as a way to reduce the distance between the EU institutions and European citizens; Holding Citizens’ assemblies periodically, on the basis of legally binding EU law. Participants must be selected randomly, with representativeness criteria, and participation should be incentivized. If needed, there will be support of experts so that assembly members have enough information for deliberation. If the outcomes are not taken on board by the institutions , t his should be duly justified ; P articipation and prior involvement of citizens and civil society is an important basis for political decisions to be taken by elected representatives. The EU is founded on representative democracy: with European elections, citizens give a clear mandate to their representatives and indirectly express themselves on EU policies ; Provide enhanced structural support, financial and otherwise, for civil society, especially for youth civil society and support local authorities in setting up local youth councils; t his could be achieved through a specific pillar in the European Democracy Action Plan for involvement of civil society and social partners, and a dedicated civil society strategy ; Introduce a “Youth-check” of legislation, including both an impact assessment and a consultation mechanism with representatives of young people, when legislation is deemed to have an impact on young people; Strengthening cooperation between EU legislators and civil society organisations to utilise the link between decision-makers and citizens which civil society organisations constitute ; Summarize elements of citizens’ participation in an EU Charter for the involvement of citizens in EU-affairs. Objective 2: Make the European Union more understandable and accessible and strengthen a common European identity, in particular by: Guaranteeing a minimum level of education on the EU and especially its democratic processes, including the history of European integration and European citizenship. People of all ages should be able to benefit from such programmes, which should be designed in an engaging and age appropriate manner, for instance through the development of specific programmes and educational mate rial for children and schools; and civil society organisations active in the field of non-formal education ; Making reliable information on the EU easily accessible in an inclusive manner to all citizens. EU institutions should use more accessible language and avoid using bureaucratic terms in the i r communication, while at the same time maintaining the quality and expertise of the given information and adapting the information to different communication channels and audience profiles . It should consider, for instance, creating a mobile application where information concerning EU policies is presented in a clear language. A special effort should be made to reach out to young people through digital media, youth movements and various ‘ambassadors’ (organisations and individuals) explaining the EU proje ct; Making a greater use of artificial intelligence and translation technologies to circumvent language barriers , ensuring the accessibility and usability of all the digital tools for people with disabilities; Defending and supporting free , pluralistic and independent media, and encouraging media outlets, including public broadcasters and public news agencies and European media, to cover European affairs more regularly while respecting their freedom and independence , to ensure regular and comprehensive covera ge across the EU Member States ; s tepping up the fight against disinformation and foreign interferences, and ensure the protection of journalists ; Bringing Europe closer to citizens by improving contact points and dedicated hubs, or “Houses of Europe”, at local level to provide resources, information and advice to citizens on EU matters, as well as listen to their concerns and engage in debates with associations to help spread cit izens’ views at European level ; Taking further steps to strengthen common identity among Europeans, for instance through an EU fund for supporting online and offline interactions (i . e. exchanges programmes, panels, meetings) of both short and longer duration between EU citizens, creating common sports events and teams, or making Europe Day (9 May) a n additional European publ ic holiday for all EU citizens . DEMOCRACY AND ELECTIONS Objective: Strengthen European democracy by bolstering its foundations, boosting participation in European Parliament elections, fostering transnational debate on European issues and ensuring a strong link between citizens and their elected representatives, in particular by: Ensuring the protection of EU values laid down in the treaties, including the rule of law and a strong social model , which are at the core of the European democracy , also abolishing the right of veto in the European Council established in Art.7.2 TEU . In its relationship with external countries, the European Union should firstly strengthen common democratic values in its borders. Only after achieving this, the European Union can be an ambassador of our democratic model in the countries that are ready and willing to implement it, through diplomacy and dialogue ; Conceiving a EU wide referendum, to be triggered by the European Parliament, in exceptional cases on matters particularly important to all European citizens; A mending EU electoral law to harmonise electoral conditions (voting age, election date, requirements for electoral districts, candidates, political parties and their financing) for the European Parliament elections, as well as moving towards voting for Union-wide lists , or ‘transnational lists’, with candidates from multiple Member States, having taken into account the views expressed among citizens across the EU Member States on th is issue. Some of the Members of the European Parliament should be elected through a European Union-wide list, the rest being elected within the Members’ States; This reform should also aim at facilitating digital voting possibilities and guaranteeing effective voting rights for persons wit h disabilities, The reform should ensure that young people are fully able to participate in the representative democracy by lowering the voting age to 16 and by harmonising the minimum age to stand for election with the voting age . Strengthening links between citizens and their elected representatives, taking into account national specificities and citizens’ desire to be closer to them and have a feeling that their concerns lead to specific action by elected representatives in the European Parliament and national parliaments . This is a universal issue and people o f all ages should be engaged ; European c itizens should have a greater say on who is elected as President of the Commission. This could be achieved either by the d irect election of the Commission President or a lead candidate system ; T he European Parliament should have the right of legislative initiative , in order to propose the topic s to be discussed and , subsequently , adopt the necessary texts to follow up on the recommendations that emerge from deliberations; European Parliament should decide on the budget of the EU as it is the right of parliaments at the national level; P olitical parties, civil society organisations, trade unions should be more lively and accessible in order for citizens to be more involved and engaged in European democracy. This would also contribute to stimulate the inclusion of EU topics in public debates via political parties, organised civil society and social partners, not only during European elections but ahead of national, regional and local elections as well; Democracy is embodied in the institutions and in society at large , including in the workplace through the role of social partners. EU DECISION MAKING PROCESS Objective: Improve the EU’s decision-making process in order to ensure the EU’s capability to act, while taking into account the interests of all Member States and guaranteeing a transparent and understandable process for the citizens, in particular by Reassessing decision-making and voting rules in the EU institutions, focusing on the issue of unanimous voting, which makes it very difficult to reach agreement, while ensuring a fair calculation of voting 'weights' so that small countries' interests are protected ; All issues decided by way of unanimity should be decided by way of a qualified majority. The only exceptions should be the admission of new membership to the EU and changes to the fundamental principles of the EU as stated in Art. 2 TEU and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union . Ensuring transparency of decision-making by allowing independent citizens ’ observers to closely follow the decision-making process, guaranteeing broader right of access to documents, and develop on this basis stronger links and an enhanced dialogue between citizens and the EU institutions ; The EU needs to improve the transparency of its decision-making process and institutions. For instance, the meetings of the Council and the European Parliament, including its votes, should be broadcasted online in the same way. This would allow interested citizens to follow EU policy-making, and hold politicians and policy-makers accountable ; the European Parliament’s right of inquiry should be strengthened; EU decision-making process should be further developed so that national, regional, local representatives, social partners and organised civil society are more involved . Inter - parliamentary cooperation and dialogue should be strengthened . National parliaments should also be closer involved in the legislative procedure by the European Parliament, e.g. by way of participation in hearings. In addition, a better involvement of the subnational level and of the Committee of the Regions helps to take better into account the experiences gained with the implementation of EU law. Considering changing the names of EU institutions to clarify their functions and respective role in the EU decisio n-making process for citizens; The EU decision making process should be based on a clearer and more understandable structu re, resembling national systems, explicitly reflecting the division of competences between the European institutions and the Member States; For example, the Council of the EU could be called the Senate of the EU and the European Commission could be called the Executive Commission of the EU. Enhance the European Union’s delivery ca pacities in key important areas; Ensure proper civil and social dialogue mechanisms and processes at every step of the EU decision-making process, from impact assessment to policy design and implementation. Reform the way the European Union works by better involving social partners and organised civil society. Strengthening the existing structures in order to better reflect the needs and expectations of EU citizens in the decision-making process, given their importance in the European democratic life. Within this framework, empower the EESC as facilitator and guarantor of participatory democracy activities like structured dialogue with civil society organisations and Citizens’ panels. A lively civil society is crucial for the democratic life of the European Union. Reopening the discussion about the constitution, where applicable, to help us align better on our values. A constitution may help to be more precise as well as involve citizens and agree on the rules of the decision-making process; SUBSIDIARITY Active subsidiarity and multilev el governance are key principles and fundamental feature s for the EU functioning and democratic accountability; The EU should review the mechanism allowing n ational Parliaments to assess whether new legislative proposals at the European level do not intrude on their legal competences and to be granted the possibility to suggest a legislative initiative to the European level. Such mechanisms should also be enlarged to all regional parliaments within the EU that have legislative power ; R eform the Committee of Regions to encompass adequate channels of dialogue for regions as well as cities and municipalities, giving it an enhanced role in the institutional architecture, if matters with a territorial impact are concerned; Systematic use of a subsidiarity definition commonly agreed by all EU institutions could help to clarify whether decisions have to be taken at European, national or regional level. S ocial partners and organised civil society should be better included in the decision-making process , given the ir importance in the European democratic life . A lively society is crucial for the democratic life of the European Union. We call on Euro pean Union institutions to make the conclusions of this working group a reality and effectively implement them. This could be realised through the possibilities the Lisbon Treaty already provides and, when necessary, by triggering the request of launching a European Convention.
To the Members of the Renew Europe Caucus,
Dear Colleagues,
I am glad to inform you about the conclusions of the Working Group on Democracy. I would like to
sum up the main elements of the final non-paper circulated on April 10.
First, the Members of the Working Group agreed to enhance the link between citizens and the Union,
by reinforcing the existing means of citizens’ participation and by creating new ones, such as the
holding of periodical citizens’ assemblies. The non-paper focuses as well on the need to improve
education on the EU and its democratic processes, to encourage the circulation of information on news
related to the EU in national media, and to support the liaising activity of the European Economic and
Social Committee, of the Committee of the Regions, of Civil Society Organisations and of civic and
social partners.
The Europeanisation of the elections to the European Parliament is another key pillar of our joint
work. First, the non-paper acknowledges the need to harmonise electoral conditions in Member States,
and to work towards the introduction of transnational lists, which would allow citizens to elect some
candidates from a European-wide constituency, and the rest from national lists. Second, it addresses the
issue of better linking citizens to the choice of the Commission President, thanks to either a system of
lead candidates, or a direct election.
Concerning the reform of European decision-making processes, we succeeded in our effort to include
the request for a right of initiative for the European Parliament, improved rights of inquiry, and the
strengthening of its budgetary powers. Furthermore, the overcoming of unanimity became the object of
an ambitious formulation, reflecting the citizens’ recommendations. The Working Group proposes
indeed to mainstream Qualified Majority Voting in every policy area, with the exception of the
accession of new Members to the EU and changes to the fundamental principles of the EU as stated in
Art. 2 TEU.
The non-paper recommends as well a renewed focus on the principle of subsidiarity, by means of a
reform of the Committee of the Regions, the creation of a web of EU Councillors at the local level, and
the promotion of increasing forms of cooperation and dialogue between national parliaments, namely
by granting them the right to suggest a legislation to the European level, the so-called “Green Card”.
In line with the priorities of our Caucus, the Working Group identified the launch of a Convention (ex
Art. 48 TEU) as one of the solutions to ensure the proper implementation of the abovementioned
proposals. My assessment of the final outcome of the Working Group’s activities is therefore very
positive, and I would like to thank all the colleagues and our advisors for their precious contribution.
Nonetheless, our job is not finished yet. We should stay vigilant and monitor the full translation of the
conclusions of the Conference into concrete policy projects, and play a pivotal role in the European
Parliament to trigger as soon as possible the procedure for Treaty revision ex Art. 48 TEU, to exploit
the momentum and achieve ambitious reforms in the short-term.
I look forward to discussing these matters further with you all in our Caucus and in the Conference’s
Plenary.
Kind regards,
Sandro Gozi
Saatja: Kristel Tänover <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 20.04.2022 11:03
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Silver Tammik <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: RENEW (COFOE) Caucus - Conclusions of the Working Group on
"Democracy" - on behalf of MEP Sandro Gozi
Tähtsus: Kõrgeim
From: Renew Europe Networking
<
[email protected]> Sent: Wednesday, April
20, 2022 11:00 AMTo: Kristel Tänover
<
[email protected]>Subject: RENEW (COFOE) Caucus - Conclusions
of the Working Group on "Democracy" - on behalf of MEP Sandro
GoziImportance: High
Dear Minister A. Sutt,
Minister of Entrepreneurship and Information Technology, ESTONIA
On behalf of MEP Sandro Gozi, please find attached to this email, the
final version of the non-paper endorsed by the Working Group on
"European Democracy", together with a note summing up its
proposals and Mr. Gozi's considerations on its content.
* In case of queries, please kindly contact Mr. Gozi's office ().
Thank you in advance for your attention.
Kindest regards,
Your Networking RENEW EUROPE. COFOE Team
Group in the European Parliament Rue Wiertz 60 I B-1047 Brussels -
Belgium
I I I
P Please do not print this e-mail unless absolutely necessarySave energy:
switch off your PC when you leave at night