dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel
Otsing›Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

Kiri

Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium · 26. aprill 2022
Viit
24.1-6/2022/3034-1
Registreeritud
26. aprill 2022
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
WiseEuropa
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
24.1 EL ja rahvusvahelise koostöö korraldamine
Sari
24.1-6/S Rahvusvahelise koostöö korraldamisega seotud kirjavahetus (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
24.1-6/2022
Vastutaja
Timo Tatar (Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium, Kantsleri valdkond, Energeetika ja maavarade valdkond)

Failid

  • 📎CCS4CEE Estonia.pdf816 KB
  • 📎CCS4CEE Latvia.pdf1232 KB
  • 📎CCS4CEE Lithuania.pdf1237 KB
  • 📎CCS4CEE_Ukraine_Final_with disclaimer.pdf1110 KB
  • 📎E-kiri.pdf77 KB

Sisu (failidest)

The Building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the CEE region project is funded by Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway through the EEA and Norway Grants Fund for Regional Cooperation. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Ba o doda Assessment of current state, past experiences and potential for CCS deployment in the CEE region ESTONIA Hendrik Ploom | Veeli Oeselg | Maarja Sau 0 The building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the CEE region project is funded by Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway through the EEA and Norway Grants Fund for Regional Cooperation. BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION Table of contents Used acronyms and definitions .................................................................................................................................. 2 Chapter 1. CCS and CCU: current state and past experiences in Estonia ...................................................... 3 1. Description of relevant domestic economic sectors ..................................................................................... 3 2. Assessment of geological potential for CCS ................................................................................................. 8 3. Description of implemented and planned projects ....................................................................................... 9 4. Legislation and regulation relevant for CCS deployment ......................................................................... 10 Chapter 2. Estonia's outlook for CCS and CCU ................................................................................................... 12 1. Summary of stakeholder engagement ......................................................................................................... 12 2. Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU ........................................................................................................ 13 3. In-depth stakeholder perceptions of the CCU and CCS landscape ........................................................ 14 4. Stakeholder recommendations for CCU/CCS .............................................................................................. 15 Chapter 3. CCS and CCU: Public acceptance in Estonia .................................................................................... 18 1 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION Used acronyms and definitions CCS Carbon capture and storage CCU Carbon capture and usage CHP Combined head and power/cogeneration ETS European Union emissions trading system IVIA Ida-Viru Industrial Areas Foundation – public development organisation in Ida-Viru region KNC Kunda Nordic Cement – Cement producer in Estonia OIL SHALE Sedimentary rock used for energy and oil production PCC Precipitated calcium carbonate – speciality mineral used as a functional filler in many industries 2 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION Chapter 1. CCS and CCU: current state and past experiences in Estonia 1. Description of relevant domestic economic sectors Out of the industries that have potential for CCS and CCU, most are situated in the north-eastern region of Estonia, in Ida-Virumaa County. Most of Estonia’s emissions come from the oil shale industry, which is the main source of electricity throughout the country and also provides the raw material for a few companies in the chemical production sector. The use of fossil-based fuels in energy production is the main cause of CO2 emissions in Estonia. Oil shale energy production dates back to the 20th century and is the main energy source of Estonia to this day. Despite a significant decrease in carbon emissions in Estonia, 96% of all emissions still come from the carbon heavy oil shale mining and processing industries. As the oil shale mines in Estonia are located in the eastern part of the country, the majority of the ETS regulated emitters are located in the same area. The map of the biggest CO2 emitters is presented in Figure 1 below. Figure 1. Location of biggest emitters and cities with central heat production in Estonia Source: Civitta The map presents the locations in Estonia that have industries with heavy emitters. Green areas represent energy and heat producers using both oil shale and shale oil; the red area represents a single round glass producer, and light blue, paper and pulp production. Dark blue areas represent major municipalities and/or cities with central heating or CHP plants. A more detailed description of each economic sector is provided in the next chapter. 3 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION During the past six years, Estonia has significantly cut its emissions levels. With the adoption of newer, more ambitious climate goals in 2019, Estonia adopted a detailed plan - “General Principles of Climate Policy until 2050” (GPCP2050)1 - to follow in order to reach climate neutrality by 2050 and decrease the emissions by 40% by 2030. The emissions have decreased on average by almost 14% between 2015 and 2020, while the decrease between 2019 and 2020 was 34% 2. These trends in 2019 and 2020 were caused by emission decline in the energy sector, due to limited electricity production from oil shale, mainly due to high EU ETS prices. The country's leading energy producer Eesti Energia increased its renewable energy production significantly in 2019 and 2020. The majority was provided by its subsidiary Enefit Green, which is the largest wind energy producer in the Baltic states. Renewable energy production also increased in Ida-Virumaa thermal power plants, where the company produces electricity from wood waste. Figure 2 presents the total emissions between the years 2015 and 2020. Figure 2. Total emissions in Estonia 2015-2020 (thousand tonnes) Source: Estonian Environmental Board When looking at the annual emissions data for the ETS regulated companies in Estonia, more than 90% of all the emissions are created by three energy/oil groups that use oil shale to produce power. As a direct consequence of using oil shale for energy production, the emitted CO2 is different in its formula and needs additional investments in purification stations before it can potentially be stored or used in other industries. 1.1. Carbon-intensive sectors of the Estonian economy The following presents an overview of carbon intensive industries in Estonia: power, cement, pulp and glass. In addition, an overview of previous activities of a company from the chemical sector is included as carbon capture and utilisation was implemented within their activities. All other industries have emissions below 10 000 tonnes of CO2 per annum, and are therefore outside of consideration for capture potential. 1 “General Principles of Climate Policy until 2050” (GPCP2050) <link> 2 Environmental Board of the Estonian Republic. <link> 4 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION POWER PRODUCTION Power production is the biggest industry with the highest emissions in Estonia. According to the Environmental Board of the Estonian Republic, the heating and power sector make up around 70% of all the CO2 emissions in Estonia. This is a direct consequence of most of the production coming from fossil-based fuels, primarily oil shale. This is constantly changing however, and energy producers, mainly the government-owned Eesti Energia (internationally Enefit), are looking for ways to substitute oil shale with other fuels in order to discontinue the usage of oil shale for electricity production completely. In total, Estonia produces around 8000 GWh of electricity, out of which approximately 70% is produced from oil shale or oil shale gas. Out of the total electricity production, approximately 85% of the total is produced by three powerplants: Auvere, Eesti and Balti electric power plants. Around 15-20% of the total electricity output is produced in cogeneration (CHP) power plants in the bigger cities such as Tallinn and Tartu, which frequently use other types of fuels in the process such as natural gas, pulp, waste etc. Regarding heat production, the total amount reaches approximately 5000 GWh, out of which 25% is produced from oil shale products. However, the majority of heating is produced by CHP plants using biomass for fuel and other renewable sources such as wind and sun energy, significantly decreasing the carbon footprint of the heating and electricity industry. An overview of the main energy production units is presented in table 1 below. Overall, energy producers are gradually shifting to renewable energy sources by decreasing the amount of fossil fuels, but at the same time trying to find ways to extract more energy out of oil shale. Around 80% of the oil shale's energy potential can be used; this includes the usage of shale gas for production in the second round. The CO2 emitted through the process of burning oil shale in Estonia is chemically different to most other cases. In order to somehow redirect the carbon to either storage or usage, it needs to be cleaned of all other chemical compounds. This creates, next to capturing technologies, the need for cleaning technologies in order for the captured carbon dioxide to be eligible for usage. Some of the biggest energy blocks are able to use multiple types of fuels depending on demand. For example, Auvere (the biggest energy production unit in Estonia) can substitute 50% of oil shale with biomass, 20% with peat and 10% with shale gas. Recent developments in decreasing total emissions have led to the biggest energy producer (Enefit Power) discontinuing the direct use of oil shale for electricity production by 2025. Energy production in Enefit is shifting to using shale gas as a by-product from chemical production by 2030, after which any use of oil shale is discontinued. Table 1. Main Estonian energy production units PRODUCTION LOCATION CO2 EMISSIONS FUEL FUTURE PROSPECTS UNIT Eesti Power North-East 1,650 kilotonnes Oil shale, 50% can By 2025, Enefit will stop energy production Station (1615 Estonia, Narva be substituted with from oil shale and will continue with shale MW) biomass gas, a by-product from oil production. Auvere Power North-East 799 kilotonnes Oil shale, 50% can By 2025, Enefit will stop energy production Station Estonia, Auvere be substituted with from oil shale and will continue with shale (300 MW) biomass gas, a by-product from oil production. Põhja Power North-East 629 kilotonnes Oil shale, natural gas Future prospects unknown, however, a Station Estonia, Kohtla- decrease in the use of oil shale is set by the (95 MW) Järve Estonian energy management plan. 5 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION PRODUCTION LOCATION CO2 EMISSIONS FUEL FUTURE PROSPECTS UNIT Utilitas Tallinn Four CHP stations 96 kilotonnes Wood chips Tallinn power stations will continue (46 MW elec., in Tallinn, Estonia Peat operating on fuels with smaller emissions 143 MW heat) and are upgrading technologies to make the process more efficient. Iru Power Tallinn Estonia 7 kilotonnes Natural gas Iru power plant has been using household Station Household rubbish waste since 2013 and is continuing to (190 MW) generate power and heat for Tallinn. CEMENT PRODUCTION In addition to heat and power generation, one of the major polluting industries until 2020 was cement production, as one producer – Kunda Nordic Cement (KNC) – used clinker in their cement production plant located in the north-eastern part of Estonia. The production of clinker from raw material needs high temperatures and fuel for burning, and is therefore highly polluting. The company discontinued its clinker production in 2020. The major change in the product portfolio was caused by outdated and polluting technology and high production prices. Currently, the usage of clinker as a raw material is at the minimum and it is being imported from neighbouring countries. As a direct result of discontinuing a polluting product line, the total emissions were cut by 600 000 tonnes or a 7% decrease in Estonia's total emissions in 2020.3 The fact that the cement industry no longer produces raw materials in- house due to higher prices of old technology, does not imply that there is no potential for a new company starting the production of cement using the clinker method. The competitive environment allows for new entrants into the market, therefore the potential for CCU potential in the cement industry has not vanished. GLASS PRODUCTION Regarding the glass industry, there is a glass producer in Estonia participating in the ETS trading system. O-I Estonia is the major producer of glass packaging (primarily bottles). In the Estonian plant around 65 tonnes of glass products are produced annually and the main target markets are Estonia, Latvia and Finland. The glass producer does not disclose any information publicly and did not express interest in participating in a discussion concerning CCS/CCU potential. The company itself contributes around 34 000 tonnes of CO2, which is 0.4% of Estonia's total annual emissions. PRODUCTION OF PULP The biggest producers of paper and pulp in Estonia are Estonian Cell and Horizon Pulp and Paper. Combined, the two companies account for 0.5% of total Estonian CO2 emissions. As pulp and paper production is considered to be harmful to the environment, companies in Estonia are making large investments towards sustainability and environmental goals. For example, both have invested in their on-site CHP stations. PRODUCTION OF AMMONIA The only ammonia producer In Estonia – Nitrofert, discontinued their activities in 2015 due to the challenging economic situation. At the time the company was first of its kind to implement CCU solutions. They were producing urea from the leftover CO2, and additionally CO2 on a small scale for usage in the food and beverage industry. Since 2015, ammonia is imported from Russia. The 3 Press release from company website <link> 6 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION main reason for halting production in Estonia was the high cost of production compared to neighbouring countries. It is expected that production will not return to Estonia as the usage is relatively low and the production costs are too high. 1.2. Major CO2 emitters in Estonia After a company-specific evaluation of emissions, it can be concluded that three companies operating in the oil shale sector are responsible for around 93% of all the emissions in the country and can therefore be declared as the main stakeholders for any CCS and CCU potential in Estonia. A more detailed split of companies contributing to emissions is presented in Figure 3 below. Figure 3. Total emissions by ETS regulated company in thousand tonnes, 2020 Source: Civitta (data from the Estonian Environmental Board) All of the three companies with the biggest emissions are energy and chemical producers who use oil shale. These companies are considered an extremely significant part of the economy in the north-eastern parts of Estonia. Each of the three companies have more than 600 employees and their combined tax footprint is more than EUR 116 million. The three companies are depicted on the map below as follows: • Enefit Power (Power producer from oil shale) - 3.6 M tonnes of CO2 • Viru Keemia Group (Power and oil producer) - 1.4 M tonnes of CO2 • Kiviõli Keemiatööstus (Oil product producer) - 0.2 M tonnes of CO2 7 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION 2. Assessment of geological potential for CCS Estonia is located on the eastern edge of the Baltic sedimentation basin. The Baltic basin extends over the three Baltic countries and varies in thickness. In Estonia, the depth varies between outcrops and reaches 800 metres in certain areas. Suitable aquifers require a depth of more than 800 metres and due to this, the geological potential for carbon storage is limited in Estonia. The closest more suitable places for carbon capture and storage are in Latvia and Lithuania, as seen from the geological cross section in Figure 5. In addition to unsuitable sedimentary rock thickness in Estonia, any potential aquifers in the region contain potable water, which for purity purposes, could not be contaminated with any amount of CO2. Figure 4. Potential geological sinks in the Baltic Region Source: Shogenova et al. 20084. Major aquifers are indicated by red dotted lines. Np3, Ediacaran (Vendian); Ca, Cambrian; O, Ordovician; S1, Lower Silurian (Landovery and Wenlock series); S2, Upper Silurian (Ludlow and Pridoli series); D1, D2, and D3, Lower, Middle, and Upper Devonian; P2, Middle Permian; T1, Lower Triassic; J, Jurassic; K, Cretaceous; Q, Quaternary. As Estonia produces the largest amounts of CO2 in the region due to oil shale, some producers have considered opportunities for CCS and CCU potential to aspire to the climate neutrality target. According to several studies (Šliaupa et al. 2008, Shogenova et al. 2009 and 2011), the nearest location for the storage of Estonian emissions is in Latvia, more specifically in the Cambrian aquifers in western Latvia. A highly theoretical opportunity mentioned by some stakeholders to store Estonian CO2 in Latvia would require a pipeline that would extend over 800 km between the biggest cities of the two countries. Currently, the development of such a solution would be 4 Shogenova et al. 2008. Industrial Carbon Dioxide emissions and potential geological sinks in the Baltic States <link> 8 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION an extremely expensive investment for any company, and when considering the country's sentiment on any bigger investment, such initiative would most probably not get the support of the wider public. 3. Description of implemented and planned projects As CO2 storage within the depths of the earth is forbidden in Estonia, except for the purpose of scientific research and development (see chapter 4: Legislation and regulation relevant for CCS deployment), no projects that would involve carbon capture have been implemented. Furthermore, due to the lack of geological potential for CCS, there are no ongoing projects by any stakeholders to deploy CCS technologies in Estonia. There are discussions regarding possible projects related to carbon heavy industries and CCU potential – mainly related to oil shale as this is the cause of most CO2 emissions in Estonia. This topic has also been investigated through state-level research and development projects, which are described below. PRODUCING PRECIPITATED CALCIUM CARBONATE FROM OIL SHALE ASH Regarding CCU projects, a Scandinavian circular economy company is going to develop an alternative technology for the production of precipitated calcium carbonate (PCC). R-S OSA Service OÜ, a subsidiary of Ragn-Sells, is engaged in research projects on the value of oil shale ash. This project is based on ash valorisation technologies developed in Sweden, and in cooperation with Estonian researchers, they have developed a way to re-use the majority of Estonian leftover oil shale ash. The technology uses both leftover oil shale ash from the oil shale industry and captures the CO2 from the burning process. Together with the capturing and cleaning of CO2, the project can produce a high-quality end-product from waste materials that are otherwise either landfilled or emitted to the atmosphere. The produced calcium carbonate could be used in industries such as paper, plastics or construction, or even in the food or pharmaceutical industry as a functional filler to enhance product quality. The technology allows CO2 to be captured during the process and directed into the formation of precipitated calcium carbonate. As a big difference compared to the traditional production method of PCC, the raw material limestone does not need to be mined. The technology uses already landfilled oil shale ash as the raw material for PCC production. It is estimated that approximately 600 M tonnes of oil shale ash has been landfilled in Estonia, indicating that in the long run, the technology does not need to depend on the energy sector. Avoiding the limestone mining process, the PCC made from oil shale ash creates a saving of approximately 300 000 tonnes of captured CO25. It is however important to note that the PCC production uses CO2 from the energy sector that originates from the combustion of fossil fuels. Therefore, the exact climate benefit cannot be estimated as the CO2 in all cases might not be permanently stored in the final product and at the end of the life cycle and still be emitted. RITA RESEARCH PROJECT CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION WITH CCS AND CCU TECHNOLOGIES A research and development project funded by the RITA programme and implemented by Tallinn University of Technology was completed in early 20216. The main goal of the project was to evaluate the applicability of various CO 2 capture technologies for use in the oil shale industry and to develop scenarios for their implementation in the Estonian oil shale industry based on the best information available. Additionally, the aim was to analyse the environmental impact of the most suitable solutions and the technological and economic ability of the Estonian industrial sector to utilise captured CO2. The research project provides the following conclusions: As a result of the study, it was found that, based on the technological aspects of the oil shale industry, the most suitable CO2 capture technologies in the near future are absorption and oxyfuel combustion. Depending on the CO2 capture technology selected, the CO2 footprint of electricity production would fall from 1026 kg CO2 eq/MWh to 169 kg CO2 eq/MWh (absorption) or 146 kg CO2 eq/MWh 5 Ida-Viru county CO2 use Development Strategy 2021-2030 + <link> 6 Climate change mitigation with CCS and CCU technologies <link> * Represents the views of the RITA report not the views of the CCS4CEE project 9 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION (oxyfuel combustion), using the Auvere plant as a reference. CO2 capture would not be financially feasible under the current market conditions – CO2 capture, cleaning, transportation, and storage (total at least 76-88 EUR/t CO2 assuming full capacity operation) would significantly exceed the current alternative of CO2 emission quota cost (approx. 40 EUR/t as of March 2021) and environmental charges. Feasibility of state aid for investments into CO2 capture technologies or for operating these would be questionable as it would mean higher taxes or transferring the cost to the private sector, thereby reducing the overall competitiveness of the Estonian economy. Also, an increase in the CO2 emission quota tariff or in the cost of CO2 capture and storage would mean an additional cost component in electricity generation, and thus be a competitive disadvantage for CO2 emitting producers of energy from fossil fuels, including oil shale.* Briefly, the research concluded that CO2 capture is not financially feasible in Estonia due to the CO2 emission quota tariffs being less costly in comparison to developing any CCS/CCU technologies. AUVERE AGROPARK Auvere Agropark is a planned project of the Ida-Viru County Industrial Areas Development Foundation (IVIA). The main goal of IVIA is to create new jobs in Ida-Viru County. The Auvere Agropark project involves the construction of a carbon dioxide (CO 2) capture plant, which would allow the captured gas from the Auvere power plant to be sold or reused in the greenhouses used for crop husbandry of the planned agropark. The parties involved in the project believe that the cost of technology itself is going down, and operating costs are declining in the same way. The cost of the carbon capture plant is estimated to be EUR 200 million. According to preliminary estimates, phase I of the agropark could be used to achieve a capacity of up to 294 tonnes of CO2 per day, making a maximum annual consumption of almost 110,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide. After all stages are carried out, the annual consumption potential could reach almost 0.5 million tonnes of CO2. Currently Auvere Agropark is in the planning phase, the with first expected companies starting operations between 2027-2031. 4. Legislation and regulation relevant for CCS deployment The legal landscape of CCS deployment in Estonia currently has some inconsistencies that leave room for misinterpretation. Regulations relevant for CCS deployment can be found in three legal acts: the Atmospheric Air Protection Act7, the Earth's Crust Act8 and the Water Act9. All of the mentioned legislative documents provide information related to carbon dioxide storage but there is no coherency in the information provided across the documents. The main incoherence lies in the information provided in the Atmospheric Air Protection Act, which seemingly allows the storage of carbon dioxide, while the other two documents prohibit these actions. Each of the acts are described as follows. The Atmospheric Air Protection Act establishes the rights, duties and responsibilities of either private or legal persons in the exploration, transporting and storing of any potential carbon dioxide. Division 7 of the Act additionally sets the requirements for reporting standards, disclosure of information and the assessment of geological locations for storage. The Atmospheric Air Protection Act defines and regulates the overall carbon dioxide storage topic and by reading this, one could get the impression that the storage of carbon dioxide is allowed. The Earth's Crust Act of 2016, section 105 states that “Geological storage of carbon dioxide in accordance with the Atmosphere Air Protection Act in the territory of the Republic of Estonia and under the continental shelf of Estonia is prohibited.” This ban does not 7 The Atmospheric Air Protection Act <link> 8 The Water Act <link> 9 The Earth's Crust Act <link> 10 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION apply if the total volume of geologically stored carbon dioxide is less than 100,000 tonnes and the storage is undertaken for research, development or testing of new products and processes. In addition to the Earth's Crust Act, the Water Act, Chapter 5 “Use and Protection of Marine Environment”, section 34, prohibits any storage of carbon dioxide in marine areas. In the act, the storage of carbon dioxide in marine areas means placing carbon dioxide into a water column in a marine area or onto the seabed for the storage of CO2 in geological formations under the seabed. 11 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION Chapter 2. Estonia's outlook for CCS and CCU This chapter reflects the CCU and CCS landscape in Estonia according to the data gathered through background research and expert insights from stakeholders involved. 1. Summary of stakeholder engagement 15 stakeholder representatives, including all major emitters, were mainly approached and engaged through interviews and also seminars and workshops. Three academic (a), two public (b), eight industry (c) and two civil society and NGO representatives were contacted. These stakeholders were chosen based on: their impact on (a) research performed in theory and in practice, their current emissions, relevance and interest in reducing CO2 emissions (b) and, finally, on the impact of (c) the approached institutions on discourse concerning CCS/CCU. Chapter 2: Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU provides a detailed overview of the opinions presented by the stakeholders who agreed to be interviewed. The engaged stakeholders were as follows: • Enefit Power (Eesti Energia AS) • Estonian Cell (AS Estonian Cell) • Estonian Green Movement • Ida-Viru Industrial Areas (IVIA (SA Ida-Virumaa Tööstusalade Arendus)) • RS-OSA Service (RS-OSA Service OÜ) • Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) • The Geological Survey of Estonia • Ministry of the Environment • University of Tartu • Viru Keemia Grupp (Viru Keemia Grupp AS) • Keemiatööstuse Liit (Chemical Union) – not interviewed • Kunda Nordic Cement (AS Kunda Nordic Tsement) – not interviewed • Kiviõli Keemiatööstus (Kiviõli Keemiatööstuse OÜ) – not interviewed • Estonian Environmental Research Centre – not interviewed 12 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION 2. Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU The overall position regarding CCU/CCS in Estonia is relatively modest. The major stakeholders in the field are represented by the academic institutions who have performed research on the matter in Estonia but nevertheless conclude that the potential is minimal. The representation from the industry is twofold; there are companies who actively try to develop new solutions for tackling high emissions, however at the current state these stakeholders conclude that there is just no financial or economical reasoning to develop the technologies due to high prices and the cold acceptance of the topic. Public institutions and civil society also take a similar position: from a political point of view it is a necessary topic, however due to a lack of inter-sectoral framework and cooperation, geological potential for storage and the high price of technologies and relatively low current prices of emissions and environmental taxes, the stakeholders have no clear incentives to follow through with the solutions. STAKEHOLDER POSITION ROLE ACADEMIC INSTITUTIONS Tallinn University of Experts from the research centre engaged in geological research see their role Pacesetter Technology as an advisory and informational partner to other institutions as at the current moment there is not much room for research due to non-existent CCS potential. The research centre has had experience in the past of collaborating with scientists from other companies and various institutions in Europe. University of Tartu As claimed by other academic institutions, the main researcher in the field from Pacesetter the University of Tartu also deems the potential for any CCS and CCU technologies as limited. Can be considered as a pacesetter because of the emphasis on the subject. After continued research and projects, CCU would have more potential, but only approximately 1% of all emissions could be reused because of the technology and the specificity of Estonian CO2. INDUSTRY REPRESENTATION Enefit Power The biggest energy producer and emitter (3.6 Mt of CO2) that considers it Pacesetter important to find alternative technologies, even though the outlook is currently not very positive. Currently trying to select 1-2 technologies to develop further. This would allow one to change the current production to some extent without having to implement completely new technology. Viru Keemia Grupp Major oil shale producer and the third largest emitter (200 kt of CO2) that is Foot-dragger familiar with the technology and is informed of the academic research. Have performed their own small-scale in-house analysis on how production could be improved. The stakeholder is not optimistic because the CO2 from their production is very specific and is not emitted from a single place. The current ETS price also makes them less optimistic, because capturing is so expensive, making it more cost-effective to continue paying for the quotas. Estonian Cell Pulp producer, the annual emissions of which are relatively low (26 kt of CO2), Fence-sitter but are still regulated. No development towards carbon capture or utilisation technologies. They are tackling the issue from the other side and are aiming to change their natural gas fuel for biogas, which would be more environmentally friendly. RS-OSA Service Leading Estonian circular economy company that is constantly researching and Pace-setter developing new technologies that reuse and recycle existing materials creating a positive environmental effect. RS-OSA is developing a technology that uses the oil shale industry's leftover ash and CO2 as raw materials to create high-quality 13 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION STAKEHOLDER POSITION ROLE precipitated calcium carbonate, which is used as a filler substance in many different industries and products. Even though the production of PCC mainly solves the problem of oil shale ash, they also bind around 300 kg of potential CO2 per 1 tonne of produced material. In the stakeholder's view this is one of the few developments in Estonia that has higher potential. Ida-Viru Industrial Areas The entity represents an industrial area developer that focuses on bringing Pace-setter relevant players and technologies to the area to create new, innovative and sustainable solutions. IVIA promotes movement in the region towards carbon neutrality and is supporting the ideas of oil shale ash PCC production and the Agropark solution. Even though both methods can use relatively small amounts of CO2 from the total Estonian emissions, the two projects would still carve a new path and mentality for the industry that would create new opportunities to develop capture and usage technologies further. PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS AND CIVIL SOCIETY Estonian Ministry of the Represents the overall idea, that the potential in Estonia is limited and the Pacesetter Environment industries are not very active. Emphasises the issue and the importance, but due to a lack of funds, there are more important areas in Estonia that need to be developed as a priority. Can still be considered as the lead role from the public sector side and they are planning different communication strategies to inform the wider public about climate issues in general. Geological Survey of The problem is acknowledged by the organisation similarly to other Fence-sitter Estonia stakeholders, but the entity is not actively engaged in activities relevant to the topic. One of the main identified issues according to the Geological Survey is related to a lack of motivation from the industry players' side, because currently it is more economically feasible to pay for the emissions tax. Estonian Green The organisation acknowledges the issue but raises concerns over how the Foot-dragger Movement problem is tackled or approached. They stress the point that CCS/CCU technologies are meant for industries where heavy pollution is unavoidable. In their view, the Estonian energy sector usage of oil shale is unavoidable, therefore the overall approach should be to find alternatives. However, the issue lies deeper, as publicly most stakeholders support CCS/CCU development, however from a closer view, no-one really finds the solutions feasible, mainly due to the costs and the complexity of the chemical formation of the CO2 that is emitted. 3. In-depth stakeholder perceptions of the CCU and CCS landscape 3.1.1. Overall prospects for CCS/CCU in target country The overall prospects for CCS/CCU are relatively low in Estonia. The low potential is twofold: the country lacks the geological potential for any storage of carbon dioxide, and the readiness for high-potential carbon capture and usage technologies are too expensive for any industry participant to develop them. Another issue regarding CCU potential is the specificity of the gases emerging from the oil shale industry. The gas needs to be purified from any additional elements to use it in other potential industries. 14 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION 3.1.2. The role of CCS/CCU in sector integration The major emissions come from the energy sector, which is already fairly integrated in Estonia. Three major companies have good ties, but developing CCS/CCU solutions together could benefit the whole industry. All three major companies need to tackle a similar issue in close geographical proximity in the north-east of Estonia, however the level of cooperation is low. Currently, out of the three, one is a pace-setter aiming to adopt any carbon capture technologies, one is pessimistic about the technologies but is taking some form of statement in favour of future development towards alternatives, and the third major player did not wish to provide further comments regarding CCS/CCU potential within their activities. 3.1.3. Awareness of EU policy and financial instruments for CCS/CCU The stakeholders have a clear understanding and awareness of EU policy and convergence towards climate neutrality by 2050. For Estonia, the mid-target of reducing emissions on a national level by 70% compared to 1990 levels has been brought to 2030 and the companies are aware of it. This leads to the companies' overall mentality that developing CC technologies in Estonia will take significantly longer than for other countries and will be solved much later. The stakeholders are aware of the financial instruments and support potential for the research and development of the technologies, however, the whole process of capturing, cleaning, and re-using CO2 is not considered economically feasible. Even with a sudden increase in the ETS price, at current technological readiness it is more cost efficient for a company to pay for the quota. 3.1.4. Perceived deployment barriers and risks The biggest barrier is the price of finding any alternative use to CO2. In today’s political climate, the storage of CO2 both inshore and offshore is prohibited. Any potential of shipping it to other countries needs to be validated in high detail. Estonia is at the furthest end of the Baltic Sea; thus, transportation becomes increasingly more expensive. Another major barrier comes from the infeasibility of land transportation. To store Estonian emissions, a pipeline of over 800 km would need to be built and maintained on a yearly basis, including building liquefaction plants. 4. Stakeholder recommendations for CCU/CCS 4.1. Regulations The stakeholders see no critically important changes in the regulation that would lead toward CCS/CCU technology development. Even if carbon storage were allowed within the depths of the earth or under the seafloor, there would not be much change in activity as all the stakeholders are aware of the non-existent potential of CCS in Estonia. 4.2. Technology Two main technologies would need development or government support: specific CO2 capture devices and CO2 cleaning technology. Emission structures within different industries require in-depth knowledge concerning different methods of capturing carbon. As previously mentioned, CO2 in Estonia is chemically different to most other cases. This is a direct consequence of burning from oil shale, and redirecting the carbon into storage or usage requires cleaning it from other chemical compounds. This creates, next to capturing technologies, the need for cleaning technologies. CO2 could only be directed elsewhere after the cleaning process. While some companies may just wait for developments from other players, the major industry companies will be more inclined to perform small-scale pilot projects and find the best technology for their own needs. At the current price levels, it is not economically viable to implement investments towards CCS/CCU technologies. Costs of capturing, cleaning and transporting carbon are also a 15 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION major issue as the long-distance hauling of clean CO2 and the liquefying process take the price per tonne to very high levels, making the companies not interested in pursuing this. 4.3. Infrastructure Currently, no widely used infrastructure for CCS/CCU or even CO 2 transportation is implemented in Estonia. None of the industry participants have constructed any infrastructure that could catch and transport emissions coming from the production facilities. In any scenario, significant investments for capture, cleaning and transport need to be made. Pipelines would be the most difficult form of infrastructure, expanding through multiple territories and counties. If Estonia were to cooperate with Latvia and transport the CO2 to their deposit sites, this would require the construction of the longest pipeline, exceeding 800 km together with a liquefaction terminal. As the potential for the storage of Estonian CO2 in Latvia is low, another option in theory is to export the gas by sea transport. The closest port to the region with the most emitters is approximately 50 km away from the plants. This would once again require a proper pipeline and a liquefaction plant in the terminals. State involvement in establishing CO 2 transportation infrastructure would provide incentives for private companies to move forward with CCS/CCU projects. 4.4. Market The most pertinent question for the CCS/CCU market is the quantity and the price per tonne of CO2. Currently, the price of one tonne is EUR 5310. Several industry stakeholders stated that this price has significantly increased over the past year but is still below the point that would encourage some movement in the direction of CCU. At the current level, companies engaging in carbon capture activities would bear significant costs for capturing, cleaning and re-using. Therefore, at the current price, the majority of stakeholders would only continue current operations and seek new technologies after the ETS price reaches more than EUR 100-120 per tonne. 4.5. Financial frameworks Financial frameworks and grants for pilot projects would incentivise companies to prioritise carbon capture on their agenda. The EU's Taxonomy initiative might be one of these options: The EU taxonomy is a classification system, establishing a list of environmentally sustainable economic activities11. Carbon capture and storage (CCS) qualifies as a taxonomy-eligible sector. The report states that “CCS can be eligible in any sector/activity if it enables that primary activity to operate in compliance with the threshold - for example, steel, cement or electricity production.” This system is an important enabler to scale up sustainable investment and to implement the European Green Deal. Notably, by providing appropriate definitions to companies, investors and policymakers on which economic activities can be considered environmentally sustainable, it is expected to create security for investors, protect private investors from greenwashing, help companies to plan the transition, mitigate market fragmentation and eventually help shift investments to where they are most needed. In the view of the participated stakeholders, CCS and CCU solutions could be one of the activities that are classified as a part of the EU taxonomy incentive. 4.6. Inter-sectoral and regional collaboration Different types of collaboration would have an impact on CCS/CCU: regional collaboration can help with the dissemination of scientific research and possible benefits of CCS/CCU, while Inter-sectoral collaboration can help reduce the risks and costs of implementing projects related to CCS/CCU. Estonian policy makers would like to see major emitters in the energy production industry working together in finding a suitable technology for their level of emissions. As oil shale remains one of the most important fuels in Estonia, 10 Ember Daily EU ETS carbon market price <link> 11 EU taxonomy for sustainable activities <link> 16 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION some steps for negative climate effect mitigation need to be made. As the majority of the energy and chemical industry is located in North-East Estonia, there is great potential for regional collaboration between heavy polluting energy and chemical producers. 4.7. Social aspects CCU/CCS deployment requires the active public participation of scientists and experts. Communication of factual data and results of research could help disseminate realistic information, not opinions of stakeholders. This could help with showcasing the benefit of CCS/CCU to business, climate and local communities. 17 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION Chapter 3. CCS and CCU: Public acceptance in Estonia Relying on currently available information, it can be concluded that no definite public image has been formed in connection with CCS/CCU technologies as these have not been heavily implemented In Estonia. No research or surveys have been conducted on this specific topic, and the interviewed stakeholders also expressed that public discourse regarding CCS/CCU in Estonia remains non- existent. When discussing the potential discourse in a scenario where CCS/CCU technologies would be implemented, the stakeholders believed that the general public would most likely not oppose it, as reducing CO2 emissions would be seen as a positive matter. Nevertheless, some stakeholders were of the opinion that opposing views (so-called NIMBYism) would most likely be seen from the habitants of specific areas where new plants, CO2 transport infrastructure etc. would be built. Such attitudes have been witnessed in relation to wind farms being built in Estonia as locals in the vicinity are concerned about the noise they produce. Regarding Estonians' general perception of climate change and cutting carbon emissions, the proportion of those who see global warming as a problem is still one of the lowest in the European Union. According to the 2019 Eurobarometer study 12 on EU climate and energy policies, 59% of Estonian respondents consider climate change to be a “very serious” problem, while the European Union average is 79% (Figure 6). Figure 5. How serious of a problem do you think climate change is at the moment? 79% Very serious 59% 14% Fairly serious 25% 6% Not serious 14% EU Estonia Source: Eurobarometer 2019 12 2019 Eurobarometer study on EU climate and energy policies <link> 18 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION Estonia is also the only country in the European Union where less than half of the respondents - 48%, agreed with the statement that reducing the import of fossil fuels can increase energy security and be economically beneficial for the EU. The EU average was 72% (Figure 6). Figure 6. Reducing fossil fuel imports from outside the EU can increase energy security and benefit the EU economically 72% Totally agree or tend to agree 48% 15% Totally disagree or tend to disagree 18% 13% Don't know 33% EU Estonia Source: Eurobarometer 2019 When asked whether more public money should be allocated for the transition to clean energy, even if it meant reducing fossil fuel subsidies (Figure 7), Estonian respondents agree with this somewhat less (74%) than the EU average (84%). In addition, Estonia had the lowest share who totally agreed with it (27%), while the EU average was 44%. Figure 7. More public financial support should be given to the transition to clean energies, even if it means that subsidies for fossil fuels should be reduced 84% Totally agree or tend to agree 74% 9% Totally disagree or tend to disagree 9% 7% Don't know 17% EU Estonia 19 BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION Source: Eurobarometer 2019 These notions indicate that while people in Estonia are becoming more concerned about the impact of climate change, it is not seen as an immediate threat and there is a significant number of people who do not see reducing the use of fossil fuels as a solution. According to the stakeholders involved, further societal education is needed as many people in Estonia do not have a good understanding regarding the country's approach to tackling climate change. Furthermore, the different actors involved pointed out that people feel quite disconnected from the topic as they do not see the impact on their personal lives or they have unreasonable fears associated with innovation in climate change mitigation. Publications in media The concepts of CCU and CCS are not widely published in the Estonian media. During recent years, news has been published on the research carried out as well as some interviews with experts in the field, but as the overall perception of CCS/CCU in Estonia is quite minimal, the media houses do not put significant emphasis on the matter. Opinion articles from politicians on the matter have been published, indicating that CCS/CCU in the oil shale industry could become the next big development area in Estonia, however without the proper support or understanding from the major stakeholders regarding the fact that CCS/CCU in Estonia is difficult to develop, especially at the current stage, these media publications have not been repeated. 20 The Building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the CEE region project is funded by Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway through the EEA and Norway Grants Fund for Regional Cooperation. BUILDING THE BUILDING MOMENTUM MOMENTUM FORFOR THETHE LONG-TERM LONG-TERM CCSCCS DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT IN THE IN THE CEECEE REGION REGION 21 The Building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the CEE region project is funded by Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway through the EEA and Norway Grants Fund for Regional Cooperation. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Ba o doda Assessment of current state, past experiences and potential for CCS deployment in the CEE region LATVIA Valts Ulmanis | Madara Zvirgzdiņa 0 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Table of contents Used acronyms and definitions ................................................................................................................................. 2 Chapter 1. CCS and CCU: current state and past experiences in Latvia ........................................................ 3 1. Description of relevant domestic economic sectors .................................................................................... 3 1.1. Carbon-intensive sectors of the Latvian economy ............................................................................... 3 1.2. Major CO2 emitters in Latvia ...................................................................................................................... 4 2. Assessment of geological potential for CCS ................................................................................................. 6 2.1. Onshore geological sites ............................................................................................................................. 7 2.2. Offshore geological sites ............................................................................................................................. 9 3. Description of implemented and planned projects .................................................................................... 11 4. Legislation and regulation relevant for CCS deployment ......................................................................... 12 4.1. Role of CCS and CCU in national planning documents ..................................................................... 12 4.2. Main legal and regulatory framework in the field of CCS and CCU .............................................. 14 Chapter 2. Latvia's outlook for CCS and CCU ..................................................................................................... 20 1. Summary of stakeholder engagement ......................................................................................................... 20 2. Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU ....................................................................................................... 21 3. In-depth stakeholder perceptions of the CCS and CCU landscape ....................................................... 25 4. Stakeholder recommendations for CCS and CCU ...................................................................................... 26 Chapter 3. CCS and CCU: Public acceptance in Latvia ..................................................................................... 29 1. Public opinion on curbing carbon emissions ............................................................................................... 29 2. Public perception on CCS/CCU and related projects ................................................................................. 31 Annex A: List of largest CO2 emitting companies in 2019 ................................................................................ 33 1 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Used acronyms and definitions BASTOR The Baltic Sea CO2 storage project CCS Carbon capture and storage CCU Carbon capture and usage CCUS Carbon capture and storage CEE Central and Eastern Europe CHPP-1 Combined heat and power plant in Riga (TEC-1) CHPP-2 Combined heat and power plant in Riga (TEC-2) EU ETS European Union Emissions Trading System R&D Research and development 2 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Chapter 1. CCS and CCU: current state and past experiences in Latvia 1. Description of relevant domestic economic sectors For the total amount of CO2 emissions, statistics on atmospheric emission accounts can be used, which summarise the atmospheric emissions of the national economy (economically active enterprises and households) by economic activity sectors that have caused the emissions. According to data, 16.7 Mt of CO2 emissions were recorded in 2018 (6.64% increase compared to 2017) and this distribution by sectors can be seen in Figure 1. Figure 1. CO2 emissions of the national economy by economic activity sectors in Latvia in 2018, kT Energy 2 776 3 881 Transport and storage 1 651 2 916 Manufacturing 3 228 Other sectors 125 1 431 Agriculture, forestry and fisheries 699 Households Industry Source: Civitta (data from Central Statistical Bureau) As CCS (carbon capture and storage) and CCU (carbon capture and utilisation) solutions are more relevant for the energy industry and manufacturing, these sectors will be analysed in the further sections. 1.1. Carbon-intensive sectors of the Latvian economy Two major industrial carbon-intensive sectors can be distinguished in Latvia – energy production and cement production. A more detailed breakdown by companies in these sectors and statistics on CO2 emissions by company and sector is available in section 1.2. 3 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION ENERGY PRODUCTION The largest CO2 emitter both in the energy sector and among Latvian companies is Latvenergo. The state-owned company is one of the largest energy service providers in the Baltics and is involved in the production and sale of electricity and heat, the sale of natural gas, and the distribution of electricity. CO2 emissions mainly arise from combined heat and power plants CHPP-1 and CHPP-2 in Riga, which use natural gas as fuel and produce electricity and heat in cogeneration mode. Various improvements, such as the modernisa- tion of gas turbines in CHPP-1 and development of a heat storage system in CHPP-2, have been carried out in combined heat and power plants. Certain development directions, such as the development of solar and wind power technologies and further energy efficiency improvements, are planned by the company, which will improve the efficiency of operations and reduce the carbon inten- sity of electricity. Regarding the future plans of the company, it was acknowledged during the stakeholder interview that although the role of both combined heat and power plants is likely to decrease in the future, these power plants will retain a vital role in ensuring the security of energy supply in times of renewable energy supply fluctuations. Currently the produced electricity from thermal power plants is significantly influenced by factors such as the amount of electricity generated in the Daugava hydropower plants (also owned by Latvenergo). Various other energy companies are among the other major emitters of CO2 at the company level. These heat and electricity produc- ing companies are mostly located in different parts of Latvia (largest settlements), where there is a need for district heating. During the interview with the Latvian Association of Heating Companies, various approaches of these companies in reducing CO 2 emissions were mentioned. The number of boiler houses using wood biomass as heating fuel increased from 241 in 2010 to 306 in 2018, and the installed thermal capacity has increased from 597.6 MW to 994.2 MW, respectively.1 Greater emphasis on biomass ensures lower CO2 emissions and this type of fuel is currently excluded from the EU ETS (European Union Emissions Trading System). The future role of biomass in the context of the EU ETS is important for the further development of the sector. State aid to this sector will continue in the near future for example by providing free allowances to companies to modernise, diversify and sustainably transform the energy sector.2 However, it should be noted that the free allowances will gradually be phased out from 2026 for Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism sectors, including the electricity sector. The transition to renewable energy sources (including biomass) in the energy sector is also emphasised in the long-term planning documents – Strategy of Latvia for the Achievement of Climate Neutrality by 2050 emphasises that the share of fossil energy sources by this time will be reduced to a minimum and biomass, hydropower and solar energy will be the most important forms of renewable energy sources at this time.3 CEMENT PRODUCTION In the production of cement, all emissions are generated by the company Schwenk Latvija. Investments in the construction and improvement of processes have helped the company to reduce the amount of CO2 emissions by 33% during the last ten years. Along with other CO2 reduction goals, the company has set the goal of becoming the first CO 2 neutral cement plant in Schwenk Group by leveraging technologies presently developed in the field of CCS and CCU. The stakeholder interviews on this topic also show interest in the development of these technologies, as well as in advancing this question further in Latvia. 1.2. Major CO2 emitters in Latvia The amount of CO2 emissions can be analysed at the company level – Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre com- piles statistics where information is submitted by organisations that have been issued permits for polluting activities (as well as meets 1 Latvia’s National Energy and Climate Plan 2030 2 Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development of the Republic of Latvia. “Bezmaksas emisijas kvotu piešķiršana elektroenerģijas ražotājiem”. https://www.varam.gov.lv/lv/bezmaksas-emisijas-kvotu-pieskirsana-elektroenergijas-razotajiem 3 Strategy of Latvia for the Achievement of Climate Neutrality by 2050 4 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION certain requirements of EU regulation related to polluting activities). Figure 2 indicates the largest CO2 emitting companies in Latvia in 2019. Figure 2. Largest CO2 emitting companies in Latvia in 2019, kT/a Latvenergo | Energy 1 219 SCHWENK Latvija | Cement manufacturing 794 Rīgas Siltums | Energy 168 Rīgas Bioenerģija | Energy 117 LATGRAN | Wood products manufacturing 88 Liepājas enerģija | Energy 68 Daugavpils siltumtīkli | Energy 45 Fortum Daugavpils | Energy 43 Rēzeknes siltumtīkli | Energy 41 LATNEFTEGAZ | Energy 39 Other (946) 1 154 Source: Civitta (data from Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre) More than half (53.87%) of Latvia's CO2 emissions at the company level are produced by the 2 largest companies – Latvenergo (energy production, 32.62% of all CO2 emissions produced by Latvian companies in 2019) and Schwenk Latvija (cement production, 21.25% of all CO2 emissions produced by Latvian companies in 2019). 4 Out of the 28 largest CO2 emitting companies (covering more than 80% of the total CO2 emissions from the listed companies), 20 are related to electricity or centralised heating production. The rest of these companies have their core activity in fields such as wood product manufacturing, energy transmission and storage, glass fibre manufacturing, building material manufacturing, transhipment, and food production (list of these companies, their main industries and amount of CO2 are indicated in Annex A). The number of companies included in this data is very large (956 in 2019), and for most of the included companies CCS or CCU solutions are not relevant due to their relatively low CO2 emission level and technological feasibility, so the largest CO2 emitting companies are analysed further. Similarly, the largest companies in the energy sector (and less frequently companies in other sectors) have a geographical dispersed distribution of CO2 emission sources, for example, a district heating company may have several plants in large cities, so the CO2 emissions per one plant are lower. For this reason, a breakdown is shown by structural units – in Figure 3 the geographical distribution is shown, where the location of the structural units of the largest CO2 emitting companies and the CO2 emissions they generate are indicated. For example, Latvenergo is divided into 2 combined heat and power plants – CHPP-1 and CHPP-2, but, in the case of Liepājas enerģija, the amount of CO2 emitted is smaller than indicated in the previous graph, as about two 4 Until 2016, another major emitter of CO2 was the metallurgical company Liepājas metalurgs. Due to financial difficulties, the com- pany stopped production in 2013 and was later sold to foreign investors. Further operation was unsuccessful and in 2016 the com- pany was declared insolvent. According to the information in the mass media, in 2021 there is interest from foreign investors to resume steel production on the premises of the former company. If such a project is implemented, it may also be relevant in the field of CCS/CCU in the future. 5 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION thirds of CO2 is produced in one power plant, but the rest of the energy and CO2 are produced in smaller power plants. In this analysis, structural units with one or more installations producing more than 40 000 tonnes of CO2 per year were identified in total.5 Figure 3. Geographical location of structural units with one or more installations that produce more than 40 000 tonnes of CO2 per year in total, 2019 Source: Civitta (data from Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre) Geographically, the largest amount of CO2 in structural units of companies, where the total amount is at least 40 000 tonnes of CO2, is produced in Riga. The largest contribution here is Latvenergo CHPP-2 (61.9%), followed by Latvenergo CHPP-1 (22.1%). All four of these structural units are related to energy production. The location of Schwenk Latvija, where a large amount of CO2 is emitted, is the second place. In other places (Liepāja, Jēkabpils, Daugavpils and Krāslava) the amount of emitted CO2 emissions is proportionally smaller. 2. Assessment of geological potential for CCS Regarding the storage potential of CCS in Latvia and the surrounding region, several studies have been conducted that indicate the most prospective structures for CO2 geological storage in the Baltic region that are available in Latvia, represented by a number of onshore and offshore anticline structures. 5 This emission volume has been chosen as an assumption where CO2 capture could be potentially applicable and feasible. This amount may vary depending on different sources and assumptions, so the number of structural units of companies included in this analysis may also change, although in general it gives an idea of the potential scope for CCS/CCU solutions. 6 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 2.1. Onshore geological sites The most favourable geological conditions for CO2 and natural gas storage in Latvia are found in the Middle Cambrian reservoir, sealed by Ordovician clayey carbonate rocks. Suitable structures (deep saline aquifers) in those geological formations have been identified and shown in Figure 4. Figure 4. Identified locations of prospective onshore storage structures in Latvia Source: Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre In 1968, the Inčukalns underground natural gas storage was established in the largest Cambrian structure. This underground natural gas storage can store up to 2.3 billion m3 of natural gas, which fully covers the region's requirements for natural gas.6 This structure is planned to be used in the future for the same purpose. In addition to the currently used Inčukalns underground structure, there are several other prospective structures that could be suit- able not only for underground natural gas storage facilities, but also for the storage of CO2. The main criteria used for the identifica- tion of the prospective structures are the local highs determined by seismic data; the size and depth of the trap; reservoir properties and reliable cap rock. Based on these criteria, 16 prospective onshore structures are identified: Dobele, Ziemeļblīdene, Blīdene, Snēpele, Dienvidkandava, Degole, Lūku-Dūku, Kalvene, Vērgale, Ēdole, Ziemeļkuldīga, Viesātu, Aizpute, Usma, Liepāja and Ziemeļlīgatne.7 All these structures are located in the western and central part of Latvia. 6 Conexus Baltic Grid. “Inčukalns UGS”. https://www.conexus.lv/pazemes-dabasgazes-kratuve 7 Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre. “CO2”. https://www.meteo.lv/lapas/geologija/zemes-dzilu-resursi/per- spektivie-resursi/co2/co2?id=1496&nid=494 7 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Several years ago, the possible creation of another underground natural gas storage facility in Latvia was discussed. Out of the avail- able structures, the underground structure in Dobele was the most studied and was recognised as suitable for the creation of a natural gas storage facility. Studies showed that the development of this facility would create one of the largest storage facilities in the EU in terms of capacity, with a potential capacity of around 7.74 billion m3 of natural gas (the most optimistic estimate was 20 billion m3).8 Although the above-mentioned studies have been carried out, further plans for natural gas storage in this structure have stalled and no further development has been observed in this project, as so far, the storage capacity in Inčukalns meets the existing needs. Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre notes that these structures still need to be studied in detail to confirm their geological suitability for CO2 storage.9 This problem was also highlighted in the stakeholder interviews – geological research regarding such issues was mainly conducted during Soviet times in the 20th century. For potential oil extraction, onshore seismic surveys, and deep drilling (mainly in western Latvia) were carried out in two stages: from 1958 to 1971; and from 1986 to 1993. Previously men- tioned local highs were discovered and analysed, but as no significant oil deposits and accumulations were discovered and funding was insufficient, further seismic and drilling operations were interrupted. As the existing research is more based on historical data, more up-to-date geological research would provide an opportunity to obtain more accurate information, including data about geo- logical structure, dimensions, and fracture characteristics.10 Obstacles to further geological exploration, which involves drilling boreholes up to the bedrock to determine the composition of underground rock composition, are related to the large amount of funding required – one such drillhole could cost up to a million euros. The relatively low level of interest in this type of research is also a hindering factor. Further analysis of the economic feasibility of storage projects is also necessary. For some structures, such assessments have already been carried out, for example, the Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre highlights the economic assessment for the creation of CO2 storage structures in Dobele and Blīdene/Ziemeļblīdene, where it was concluded that the costs of the creation of such storage facilities in Latvia are too high, which makes such projects economically unprofitable. It is also noted that after conduct- ing new studies in this field, other geological structures found in Latvia can be marked as potential objects for CO 2 storage.11 Previously mentioned 16 potential structures could potentially store around 404 Mt CO2 in total (790 Mt in the most optimistic scenario). Table 1 shows a more detailed breakdown by structure. 8 Cabinet of Ministers. “On the Energy Development Guidelines for 2016-2020”. https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/280236-on-the-en- ergy-development-guidelines-for-2016-2020 9 Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre. “CO2”. https://www.meteo.lv/lapas/geologija/zemes-dzilu-resursi/per- spektivie-resursi/co2/co2?id=1496&nid=494 10 Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre. “Hydrocarbon exploration history”. https://www4.me- teo.lv/vgd_oil_page/exploration_history.htm 11 Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre. “CO2”. https://www.meteo.lv/lapas/geologija/zemes-dzilu-resursi/per- spektivie-resursi/co2/co2?id=1496&nid=494 8 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Table 1. Identified onshore storage structures and their capacity Structure Area, km2 CO2 capacity, Mt (optimistic scenario) CO2 capacity, Mt (conservative scenario) Aizpute 51 31 14 Blīdene 43 112 58 Ziemeļblīdene 95 142 74 Degole 41 41 21 Dobele 67 105 56 Ēdole 19 16 7 Kalvene 19 27 14 Liepāja 40 31 6 Lūku-Dūku 50 75 40 Ziemeļkuldīga 18 21 13 Ziemeļlīgatne 30 41 23 Dienvidkandava 69 82 44 Snēpele 26 31 17 Usma 20 5 2 Vērgale 10 9 5 Viesātu 19 21 10 Total 617 790 404 Source: Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre One of the problems emerging from existing research is the potential competition between natural gas storage and CO2 storage. For example, Shogenova et al. (2011) in the study “Economic modelling of the capture–transport–sink scenario of industrial CO2 emis- sions: the Estonian–Latvian cross-border case study” provide an overview of the potential to store CO2 produced in Estonia in Latvian geological structures. Here the potential of two structures (Lūku-Dūku and Dienvidkandava) is studied, with the remark that these two structures are not among the most prospective structures studied in Latvia, and they are not the closest to Estonia. The most prospective structures in Latvia (best studied and with the largest capacity) have already been planned for natural gas storage (and for the storage of Latvian CO2 emissions).12 However, as mentioned in the stakeholder interviews, other potential uses may not be such a significant barrier in this case. 2.2. Offshore geological sites In the territory of Latvia there are not only onshore sites available for potential CO2 storage, but also offshore sites in the Baltic Sea. Geologically, both onshore and offshore sites are basically the same in terms of their composition. In connection with potential oil extraction opportunities, geological exploration in the Baltic Sea was started in 1976 in the offshore territory of Latvia. About 24 500 km of common depth point (CDP) seismic lines were acquired from 1976 to 1991, covering practically 12 Alla Shogenova, Kazbulat Shogenov, Raisa Pomeranceva, Inara Nulle, Filip Neele, and Chris Hendriks. “Economic modelling of the capture–transport–sink scenario of industrial CO2 emissions: the Estonian–Latvian cross-border case study”. Energy Procedia, 4 (2011), pp. 2385-2392 9 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION all the Latvian sector of the Baltic Sea with a 2x2 km seismic grid. From 1993, due to insufficient funding, both offshore and onshore seismic and drilling operations were interrupted.13 The topic of potential geological sites was highlighted in the BASTOR project (the Baltic Sea CO2 Storage project), which focuses on identifying and characterising potential sites for CO2 storage in the southern Baltic Sea region. A visual representation of identified structures in the surrounding region is displayed in Figure 5. Figure 5. Offshore wells, structures, and faults in the southern Baltic Sea region Source: O’Neill et al., Geological Storage of CO2 in the Southern Baltic Sea In the BASTOR project a compilation of available digital data from well logs, seismic line data interpretations, mapped structure outlines and published material from existing hydrocarbon fields was used to identify and map potential geological structures in the southern Baltic Sea region. This research also evaluated storage capacity in the project region, based on the GeoCapacity methodology. The regional storage capacity for Cambrian sandstones below 900 m (identified as the principal regional potential storage target with the Dalders Mono- cline as the most promising area) was estimated at a total of 16 Gt with 2 Gt for the Dalders Monocline. Theoretical storage estimates 13 Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre. “Hydrocarbon exploration history”. https://www4.me- teo.lv/vgd_oil_page/exploration_history.htm 10 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION for individual structures for the Baltic Sea regions include 760 Mt for the Latvian structures and the Dalders Structure, 9.1 Mt for the structures located in Poland, 31 Mt in Lithuania and 170 Mt in Kaliningrad. However, it is noted that these estimates could be im- proved as new research in this field is being performed. A more detailed analysis of this study was also carried out for potential structures, such as Dalders Monocline, Dalders Structure, the E6 and the E7 structures, for which individual static reservoir models were developed.14 However, regarding potential offshore storage capacity, Šliaupa et al. (2012) estimates CO2 storage capacity in the Latvian territory of the Baltic Sea at about 400 Mt. Combined with the identified approximate capacity of the onshore structures, in 2012 it was estimated that it would be sufficient for the needs of Latvia for about 350 years.15 To clarify the total potential storage capacity and suitability of these structures for CO2 storage, previously mentioned geological surveys at a more detailed level are important. 3. Description of implemented and planned projects Practically implemented projects in the field of CCS and CCU in Latvia have not been identified, but it is possible to identify studies in this field on various issues. The identified studies and related projects in this area will be highlighted further in this chapter. Schwenk Latvija is one of the industrial partners in the EU Horizon project GENESIS, which tests carbon capture technologies. The project aims to develop and upscale IPOSS (polyPOSSimide hybrid organic-inorganic) and MOF (Metal-organic framework) membrane systems for CO2 capture and demonstrate their performance, durability, and reliability in industrial environments. The GENESIS pro- ject intends to scale up the most promising technologies by demonstrating a 0.45 MWe capture process for pre-combustion and 2 post-combustion applications and plans to achieve at least 90% of CO 2 recovery at a cost of 15 EUR/MWh in the cement and steel industries.16 Schwenk Latvija also emphasises the existing pilot projects of the Schwenk Group's cement plants in this field and the possible transfer of technologies if they are successful on an industrial scale: ● Mergelstetten cement plant in Germany – first semi-industrial-scale carbon capture unit (using oxyfuel technology) in Schwenk Group; ● Carbon utilisation pilot projects (mainly in Germany) – possibility to create different products from CO2 is researched, such as hydrocarbon fuels, “drop-in” diesel, etc. From 2021 to 2023, researchers from the Institute of Energy Systems and Environment of Riga Technical University are implementing the project “Integrated Decarbonisation Solutions for Effective CO2 Valorisation in Regions (CO2 Deal)”. The overall objective of this project is to develop a guide for decision makers on efficient CO2 valorisation in Latvian regions in a flexible and business-based way, respecting the principles of a low-carbon economy. It is planned to examine decarbonisation solutions in a wide range of sectors, including energy and industry, as well as agriculture, land use, forestry, and waste management. Several studies and international projects on the geological storage possibility, economic feasibility and the operation of the system as a whole can be identified. Researchers such as Shogenova A., Shogenov K. (Tallinn University of Technology), Šliaupa S., Šliaupienė R. (Nature Research Centre of Lithuania), Gušča J., Blumberga D. (Institute of Energy Systems and Environment of Riga Technical University) have written several papers on these topics about the situation in Latvia and the Baltic states. 14 Richard Vernon, Nicholas O’Neil, Riccardo Pasquali, and Matti Nieminen. “Screening of prospective sites for geological storage of CO2 in the Southern Baltic Sea”. VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, VTT Technology No. 101 15 Saulius Šliaupa, Rasa Šliaupiene, Uldis Nulle, Inara Nulle, Alla Shogenov, Khazbulat Shogenov (March 6-7, 2012). Geological poten- tial of CO2 storage in Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia. BASREC conference on Carbon Transportation and Storage 16 European Commission. “High performance MOF and IPOSS enhanced membrane systems as next generation CO 2 capture tech- nologies”. https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/760899 11 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION During several stakeholder interviews and a workshop, the option of CCU was emphasised more than CCS, which was identified as a more optimal option for the CO2 emission volumes produced in Latvia and would more comply with the principles of the circular economy. Various utilisation options were mentioned in the discussions, such as the use of CO2 in greenhouses for growing plants or the production of biofuels. Institute of Applied Chemistry of Riga Technical University and Schwenk Group are researching fuel pro- duction from CO2. In addition to the sectors mentioned above, CO2 has utilisation potential in sectors such as the food industry, chemical industry, polymer production, cement production and other industries. The main obstacles to the use of CO 2 are related to higher production costs compared to traditional methods, as well as the duration of carbon storage – some technologies only provide the temporary storage of CO2 in the utilised product. 4. Legislation and regulation relevant for CCS deployment The current and planned situation regarding CCS/CCU can be observed both through various policy planning documents and through different regulatory enactments. 4.1. Role of CCS and CCU in national planning documents To understand the role of CCS/CCU in national planning documents, it is first necessary to cover the framework of national planning documents in the field of climate policy. According to the information from the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development, which is the ministry responsible for climate policy planning, the planned structure of national policy planning docu- ments after 2020 is shown in Figure 6. Figure 6. Framework of national climate policy planning documents after 2020 Source: Civitta (data from the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development) LATVIA'S STRATEGY TO ACHIEVE CLIMATE NEUTRALITY BY 2050 Latvia's strategy to achieve climate neutrality by 2050 is a long-term policy planning document, which has been developed to increase the economic competitiveness of the Latvian economy while at the same time limiting and reducing climate change, as well as en- suring a safe living environment for the Latvian population. 12 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Deployment of CCS as one of the main drivers of reductions of greenhouse gas emissions in the energy sector is identified. Although, the low efficiency for the development of CO2 storage sites is highlighted: “[…] upon determining the potential geological storage sites in Latvia and modelling prices, it was concluded that the efficiency of the creation of CO2 storage sites (CCS) is too low and such a solution would not be economically feasible at the moment. However, it is necessary to continue the research of the suitability and economic feasibility of CCS technolo- gies in different industrial processes.”17 This strategy also further mentions CCU and its potential: “In turn, CCU technologies provide for the processing of the captured carbon for further use, for example, in manufacture of plastic, concrete, or fuel. The CCU potential in reduction of carbon should be evaluated throughout the life cycle.” 18 NATIONAL ENERGY AND CLIMATE PLAN The issue of CCS/CCU is also briefly addressed in the National Climate and Energy Plan 2021-2030. This document sets out the basic principles, goals and directions of Latvia's energy and climate policy for the next ten years. One of the activities highlighted in this plan is R&D (research and development). Innovative solutions for carbon capture and reuse are identified as one of the priority areas in the energy sector. It should be noted, however, that in Latvia this sector is not among the priority sectors that are set out in the Strategic Energy Technology Plan (European level) for R&D activities. Latvia's share of planned investments in the energy R&D priorities of the Strategic Energy Technology Plan are shown in Table 2. Table 2. Latvia's investment in Strategic Energy Technology Plan priorities (share of investment of total R&D investment in the energy sector) Actual value Target value Priorities of the Strategic Energy Technology Plan 2014–2018 2021–2027 Renewable energy 10% 15% Smart energy system 26% 20% Energy-efficient system 28% 38% Sustainable transport 15% 20% CCUS 0% 2% Nuclear energy 0% 0% Energy management and market 20% 5% Source: National Climate and Energy Plan 2021-2030 As can be seen, investments for CCUS (carbon capture and storage) are expected to increase from 0% to 2% of total R&D investments in the energy sector, but compared to other sectors mentioned here, it can be concluded that the potential of this sector is considered to be relatively small. It should be noted that the developers of this plan provide an opinion on this topic and its relatively minor role in response to com- ments made by other institutions during the drafting process of this plan: 17 Strategy of Latvia for the Achievement of Climate Neutrality by 2050 18 ibid. 13 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION “The plan covers the period until 2030, when the entry of CCS technologies into the Latvian energy system is not planned/forecast, considering the high costs of these technologies and the unassessed environmental impact. […] Carbon storage in the territory of Latvia and on the shelf is prohibited at present and no such permission is envisaged in the future, therefore at present Latvia needs to emphasise carbon capture & use technologies.”19 The remaining national planning documents in the field of climate from Figure 6 should also be mentioned: Latvian National Plan for Adaptation to Climate Change Until 2030 does not address the topic of CCS or CCU and the Environmental Policy Guidelines for this period (starting from 2021) are currently in the development process. 4.2. Main legal and regulatory framework in the field of CCS and CCU PROHIBITION OF GEOLOGICAL STORAGE OF CO2 At this moment, the main obstacle affecting CCS development in the regulatory framework is the prohibition on the storage of carbon dioxide in onshore and offshore geological structures, as referred to in the Law on Pollution. “Storage of carbon dioxide in geological formations, as well as in the water column is prohibited in the territory of Latvia, the exclusive economic zone and continental shelf thereof”20 It must be noted that this section has not been included in the original version of this Law, which has been in force since 2001. Instead, the first version of this prohibition was valid from August 2011 to December 2012, but the second (current) version is in force from March 2013. The prohibition mentioned above is based on a proposal submitted by the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Devel- opment in the Economic, Agricultural, Environmental and Regional Policy Committee of the Saeima (parliament of the Republic of Latvia), where the draft of this law was reviewed. In relation to this proposal, the Cabinet of Ministers provided information about the main considerations, which argue in favour of this prohibition. The following considerations identify supporting and opposing arguments for the storage of CO2 in Latvian geological structures in 2011. Identified supporting arguments: ● There is a possibility that in the future CCS is mandatory for large power plants (above 300 MW, theoretically no sooner than in 2018); Latvian operators could save the costs of transporting CO2 by pumping it into local geological structures. ● Latvia could provide storage services to the owners of combustion plants in neighbouring countries, primarily to Estonia, because it does not have adequate geological structures. ● During the exploration of potential storage sites, new and more accurate information on the subterranean depths of Latvia may be obtained.21 Identified opposing arguments: ● Since CCS is a new technology that is not yet available on the market and has not been tested on an industrial scale 22, the environmental impact of CO2 storage in the subterranean depths has not been sufficiently verified, thus the risks to the 19 Statement of objections in delivered opinions, National Climate and Energy Plan 2021-2030 20 Law “On Pollution” (Section 8.2). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/6075-on-pollution 21 Informative report “On prohibition of carbon dioxide storage” 22 This argument is in contrast with the fact that the Sleipner project in the North Sea was already operational at that time. The Sleipner field, the world's first commercial CO2 storage project, has been operational since 1996. 14 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION long-term environmental and human health impacts of stored CO2 have not been identified. Currently available CO2 capture technologies reduce the efficiency of energy generation by approximately 20%. ● The storage potential in Latvia is indicative, no special study has been carried out with a view to determining the suitability of subterranean structures for the safe storage of CO2. ● There are legal barriers to the practical commercial use of large geological structures in Latvia. Under the law, subterranean depths are owned by the landowner, so the storage operator would have to enter into contracts with a large number of landowners, which also entails significant costs. In addition, landowners may object to the use of subterranean depths for CO2 storage or require compensation. ● The economic assessment carried out by the experts from Riga Technical University shows that the deployment of CCS technologies is not economically viable for existing Latvian power plants. For example, for a natural gas power plant with a capacity of 300 MW, CCS costs at the time of research were around 55-130 EUR/tCO2. The quota price in 2011 was 17 EUR/tCO223, but the European Commission forecast from this period for the year 2020 – an average of 29 EUR/tCO2. ● Geological structures that are used for CO2 storage can no longer be used for other purposes (storage of natural gas, use of geothermal energy, etc.). At the same time, the state has a long-term obligation to monitor the storage site and prevent leakage. ● As there is currently no demand for CCS exploration or subsequent storage permits for entrepreneurs in Latvia, real launch- ing activities in this sector are not expected in the next 10 years. Consequently, the administrative burden of large-scale legislative development and adoption is excessive compared to the efficiency.24 Based on the considerations of 2011 listed above, it is acknowledged in the informative material that other priorities should be set for the use of the Latvian subterranean depths and CO2 storage is currently prohibited.25 By amending the above-mentioned prohibition to the current version in 2012, an initial impact assessment was prepared by the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development for the changes in this law, which also justified this CO2 storage prohibition. It was based on several arguments: ● Risk of leakage; ● Harm to nature and human health; ● Risk of drinking water contamination; ● A tonne of CO2 leaked in the future may have a larger warming effect than now; ● Environmental costs and responsibilities in terms of time are similar to nuclear waste storage – it is undertaken by the whole society and the state, not by the private sector; ● Financial barriers; ● Technological barriers; ● CO2 storage is currently prohibited in virtually all countries in the Baltic Sea region. 26 Despite this prohibition, the Law “On pollution” also mentions the role of the Cabinet of Ministers in regulating the performance of polluting activities: 23 Authors` note: The CO2 price at the time when the assessment of CCS prohibition was on the agenda 24 Informative report “On prohibition of carbon dioxide storage” 25 ibid. 26 Initial impact assessment on the draft law “Amendments to the Law “On Pollution”” 15 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION “The cabinet shall regulate […] the procedures by which transportation of carbon dioxide stream by pipelines to the stor- age sites shall be ensured, as well as the criteria for the purity of carbon dioxide stream and the procedures by which disputes regarding access to transport networks and storage sites shall be examined”27 In relation to this section of Law, separate regulation of the Cabinet of Ministers “Carbon dioxide stream transportation procedures” are in force. This regulation ensures the implementation of certain requirements of Directive 2009/31/EK of the European Parliament and of the Council. The annotation of this regulation identifies and considers the situation of the above-mentioned prohibition on geological carbon dioxide storage: “However, notwithstanding the ban on CO2 storage, it must be ensured that captured CO2 can be transported safely and in an environmentally sound manner to storage sites in countries where it is permitted.”28 Although such CO2 export solutions have not been implemented in practice, this regulation provides a framework for this issue. SUBTERRANEAN DEPTHS AND LAND OWNERSHIP Land ownership is an essential legal aspect of CCS deployment. This aspect is addressed in the Law “On Subterranean Depths”. The overall purpose of this law is to ensure the comprehensive, efficient, environmentally friendly, and sustainable use of subterranean depths, as well as specify the requirements for the protection of subterranean depths. The law generally states the ownership of the land: “Subterranean depths and all mineral resources present therein shall be owned by the landowner”29 However, the law further states the possibility of alienating land in connection with certain needs: “The land may be alienated from owners in accordance with the Law “On the Expropriation of Immovable Property” for the State or Public Needs for national security, environment and subterranean depths protection needs, use of mineral resources and deposits of national significance, as well as use of sections of subterranean depths of national significance, arrangement and exploitation of structures of national significance.”30 The law also further determines the types of use of subterranean depths: “1) Geological, hydrogeological, engineering geological, geo-ecological or geophysical exploration. 2) Establishment of a monitoring system of subterranean depths or performance of monitoring. 3) Prospection, exploration, or extraction of mineral resources. 4) Use of useful properties of subterranean depths. 5) Establishment, conservation and liquidation of boreholes, except establishment of boreholes using the subterranean depths in the way referred to in Clauses 1 and 2 of this Section.”31 27 Law “On Pollution” (Section 11, Subsection 2). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/6075-on-pollution 28 Initial impact assessment on Cabinet of Ministers Regulation No. 780. “Carbon dioxide stream transportation procedures” draft 29 Law “On Subterranean Depths” (Section 3, Subsection 1). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/40249-law-on-subterranean-depths 30 Law “On Subterranean Depths” (Section 5, Subsection 3). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/40249-law-on-subterranean-depths 31 Law “On Subterranean Depths” (Section 7). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/40249-law-on-subterranean-depths 16 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION As can be seen, both the useful properties of subterranean depths and the possibility to alienate the land for the use of sections of subterranean depths of national significance have been mentioned above. In 2010 this law was supplemented with regulations di- rectly related to the use of sections of subterranean depths of national significance. The difference between the use of mineral resources and deposits and the use of sections of subterranean depths is that the depos- its/resources are mined, but no extraction of deposits/resources takes place in the “useful properties” section: it makes use of the useful properties of the subterranean depths, such as underground voids or rock porosity.32 Such properties allow the storage of gaseous substances, but it should be noted that the above-mentioned amendments to the law have more been made in connection with the establishment of potential natural gas storage facilities. This law also states that the Cabinet of Ministers is responsible for the determination of sections of the subterranean depths of national significance and the development of regulations: “The provisions for the use of a section of the subterranean depths of national significance shall be determined by the Cabinet separately for each section”33 Possible restriction cases for proprietary rights are also stated further: “Restriction for proprietary rights of subterranean depth may be specified in the sections of subterranean depths of na- tional significance, if it is necessary in the interests of public and State to use useful properties of subterranean depths or obtain ground water. The Cabinet shall decide separately regarding each restriction of proprietary rights and each case of the use of subterranean depths or properties thereof.”34 RELATION TO THE ENERGY LAW Previously, the use of underground storage facilities was mentioned more in connection with gas storage – currently in Latvia, natural gas is stored in the Inčukalns gas storage facility, and other prospects for natural gas storage have also been identified. Various aspects related to natural gas storage are considered in the Energy Law, such as ownership: “Strategically important energy supply objects – the underground part of underground natural gas storage facility (geo- logical structure in subterranean depths) – shall be retained as State property.”35 Other regulatory aspects related to underground natural gas storage are also considered in this law, focussing more on the only current underground gas storage facility, such as land expropriation, the role of the natural gas system operator, access to the natural gas storage site and infrastructure as well as other related issues. As CO2 can be stored in places where natural gas storage is also suitable, several aspects specified in this law may also be considered in connection with CO2 storage. However, the conceptual differences between the industries must also be considered. 32 LSM. “Zemes dzīļu izmantošanā – jaunas un labas nianses”. https://lvportals.lv/skaidrojumi/213682-zemes-dzilu-izmantosana-jau- nas-un-labas-nianses-2010 33 Law “On Subterranean Depths” (Section 10, Subsection 8). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/40249-law-on-subterranean-depths 34 Law “On Subterranean Depths” (Section 121, Subsection 1). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/40249-law-on-subterranean-depths 35 Law “Energy Law” (Section 20). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/49833 17 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT AND ITS RELATION TO CCS Aspects related to carbon capture are mentioned in the Law “On Environmental Impact Assessment”. Purpose of this law/assess- ment: “[…] prevent or reduce the negative impact of the implementation of the intended activities of natural persons and legal persons or of a planning document thereof on the environment”36 Impact assessment is to be divided into two parts: ● “Environmental impact assessment (hereinafter also – impact assessment) – the procedures to be performed in accordance with the procedures laid down in this Law in order to assess the possible impact of the implementation of intended activities or a planning document on the environment and to develop proposals for the prevention or decrease of negative effects or to prohibit the initiation of an intended activity in cases of the violation of the requirements laid down in laws and regula- tions.” ● “Initial impact assessment (hereinafter also – initial assessment) – the procedures to be performed in accordance with the procedures laid down in this Law for an intended activity, which may have a substantial impact on the environment, in order to assess the significance of the potential negative impact of such activity and to decide on application of impact assess- ment.”37 Further, the law lists the objects that require an environmental impact assessment: “Objects requiring impact assessment: […] 22. Pipelines with a diameter of more than 800 millimetres and a length of more than 40 kilometres: 1) for the transport of oil, gas, and chemicals; and 2) for the transport of captured carbon dioxide streams to the storage site, including booster stations associated with the network of pipelines. […] 31. Storage sites of carbon dioxide arranged in geological structures that are located in the territory of Latvia, exclusive economic zone and on the continental shelf thereof. Impact assessment is not required for storage sites where carbon dioxide is stored for research, development or testing of new products and processes if a total intended storage amount of carbon dioxide is less than 100 000 tonnes. 32. Arrangement of installations for the capture of carbon dioxide in order to store carbon dioxide in geological structures: 1) if carbon dioxide is captured from the activities (installations) covered by this Annex; and 2) if the total yearly capture of carbon dioxide is 1.5 megatonnes or more.”38 The law also lists the objects that require an initial impact assessment: “Activities requiring an initial assessment: […] 3. Energy industry: […] 10) the installation of such installations for the capture of carbon dioxide not covered by Annex 1 to this Law. 36 Law “On Environmental Impact Assessment” (Section 2). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/51522 37 Law “On Environmental Impact Assessment” (Section 1). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/51522 38 Law “On Environmental Impact Assessment” (Annex 1). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/51522 18 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION […] 10. Infrastructure projects: [...] 18) the installation of such pipelines for the transport of carbon dioxide streams that are not covered by Annex 1 to this Law, including booster stations associated with the network of pipelines.”39 As can be seen, the need for assessment is also mentioned for the storage sites of carbon dioxide arranged in geological structures. This requirement is based on directive 2009/31/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on the geological storage of carbon dioxide. It should be noted, however, that this requirement is included in the law after the introduction of the above-mentioned prohibition on CO2 storage. As a result, a situation arises where the law (complemented by the requirements from the EU directive) specifies assessments required for the development of a potential CO2 storage site, although this type of storage is prohibited under the above-mentioned Law on Pollution. According to the results of the initial impact assessment, these activities may also be subject to an environmental impact assessment. It can be described as a multi-stage procedure, the application of which is necessary before the construction of significant facilities that may have adverse effects on the environment. The public also has a significant role to play in the evaluation process. Also, in relation to the environmental impact assessment, the regulatory enactments set a requirement for all newly built combustion plants with an electricity generation capacity of 300 MW and more: “If the installation of a combustion plant with an electricity generation capacity of 300 MW or more and for which a permit for the increase of electricity generation capacity or introduction of new generation facilities has been issued after 25 June 2009, the initiator of the intended activity, in accordance with regulatory enactments regulating environmental impact assessment, prepares an assessment of the possibilities for carbon capture and use. If the technical and economic feasi- bility of capturing carbon dioxide is confirmed, the initiator shall provide a suitable site for carbon capture installation.”40 The regulatory enactments also further define the criteria for this assessment. The relevant requirements are included both in Cabinet of Ministers Regulation No. 17 of 7 January 2021 “Regulations on Limitation of Air Pollution from Combustion Plants”, as well as Cabinet of Ministers Regulation No. 18 of 13 January 2015 “Procedures for Assessing the Environmental Impact of a Proposed Activity and Accepting a Proposed Activity”. POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS AND INCENTIVES FOR THE NATIONAL CONTEXT Interviews with stakeholders suggest that the cancellation of the above-mentioned prohibition would not be enough to introduce these technologies in practice. The legal framework addressing various aspects of this issue would be required. From the information obtained during the stakeholder interviews, it can be concluded that a working group is being formed at the national level to address this issue. The Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development does not rule out the possibility that this issue could also be addressed in the forthcoming Climate Law. 39 Law “On Environmental Impact Assessment” (Annex 2). https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/51522 40 Cabinet of Ministers Regulation No. 17 “Regulation on Limitation of Air Pollution from Combustion Plants” (Section 11). https://lik- umi.lv/ta/id/320182-noteikumi-par-gaisa-piesarnojuma-ierobezosanu-no-sadedzinasanas-iekartam 19 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Chapter 2. Latvia's outlook for CCS and CCU 1. Summary of stakeholder engagement 22 stakeholders were approached and invited to the interviews, chosen based on their amount of emissions, their relevance and interest in reducing CO2 emissions and their role in the CO2 emission reduction process in Latvia. 11 of the approached stakeholders (13 – including stakeholders who are both board members of the Latvian Association of Heating Companies and representatives of other relevant sector companies in Latvia) agreed to be involved and take part in an interview. Among the invited parties were two non-governmental organisations involved in environmental protection, but they did not respond to the invitation for an interview on this matter. Industry: ● Latvenergo – Latvia`s biggest energy generation company providing trade of electricity, thermal energy, and natural gas (state owned enterprise); ● Schwenk Latvija – cement plant (also stakeholder of Akmenes Cement in Lithuania); ● Liepājas enerģija – the main heat supply service provider in the city of Liepaja; ● Fortum Latvia/Fortum Jelgava41 – district heating system operator with three branches in Latvia; ● Conexus Baltic Grid – unified natural gas transmission and storage operator in Latvia; ● “Ventspils nafta” terminals – the largest and most technologically advanced crude oil and petroleum product transhipment company in the Baltic states. Association: ● Latvian Association of Heating Companies – a public professional organisation, which unites district heating companies, manufacturers and suppliers of heating equipment and devices, as well as separate individual members – energy experts. Governmental institutions: ● Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development of the Republic of Latvia – responsible for implementing policy in three areas – environment protection, regional development as well as digital transformation; ● Ministry of Economics of the Republic of Latvia – the leading public administration in the field of energy, industrial and service policy, business policy and tourism policy. Academia: ● University of Latvia; ● Riga Technical University. 41 In 2021, Fortum sold its district heating business in the Baltic states to the global private market firm Partners Group. Since 30 July 2021, the legal name of Fortum Latvia has been changed to Gren Latvija, and since 5 August 2021, the legal name of Fortum Jelgava has been changed to Gren Jelgava. 20 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 2. Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU The above-mentioned stakeholders were engaged in interviews and asked about CCS/CCU and invited to take part in a workshop for discussions. Summary of stakeholder positions can be found in Table 3 (See Table 3: Positions of stakeholders in Latvia on CCS and CCU). Many of the companies with the biggest emissions engaged in the project were energy generation companies with geographically dispersed heat generation plants; as a result the CO2 emissions per one plant are lower. Low emissions per power plant, the economic viability, low political initiative, and support to introduce CCS/CCU technologies as well as competitive technology developments that support the decrease or elimination of emissions, increase the stakeholders’ sceptical view on the introduction of CCS/CCU technol- ogies. On the other hand, the representatives of the biggest cement plant in Latvia provided a clear vision to introduce carbon capture technology within the next 10 years. Their further concern is related to the storage or utilisation option of CO2. Stakeholders are concerned that CCS does not comply with the circular economy principle and expressed a more positive attitude towards CCU technologies. Public authorities in Latvia and some other stakeholders, including some heat generation companies, consider CCS as the last option to decrease CO2 emissions after the exploitation of the full potential of other competitive technologies such as renewable energy resources and innovative technologies, natural carbon sinks and CCU. Consequently, there is no funding, and it is not planned to devote national funding to CCS/CCU in the future. Table 3. Positions of stakeholders in Latvia on CCS and CCU Role (pace- Institution Specific position on CCS/CCU setter/foot- dragger/fence-sitter) Latvenergo Perceived barriers to investment: The price and development of new technologies Fence-sitter (CCS, CCU and other competitive technologies for the abatement of carbon emis- A certain position for sions) will determine how emissions are dealt with. Even though new technologies or against the CCS and are developing, it might still be difficult to meet the continuous energy demand in CCU has not yet been times of renewable energy supply fluctuations without the combined heat and taken. powerplants CHPP-1 and CHPP-2, which are the main producers of heat in Riga and are running on natural gas. Furthermore, even though CO2 prices are rising, the level is still not sufficient to start seriously considering CCS/CCU projects. There is also a concern regarding the loss of efficiency when using CCS/CCU tech- nologies. Although, considering that new technologies are developing, their prices are decreasing and the EU policy regarding CCS/CCU and future CO2 emission man- agement is not completely clear, it is rather challenging at this point to predict which direction the company will choose. Role of sectoral integration: There is a plan to produce hydrogen and oxygen through the electrolysis of water. And one of the alternatives is to use hydrogen in combination with the captured CO2 to produce synthetic fuel (although further research and pilot projects are needed). Further collaboration might be possible to provide oxygen produced through elec- trolysis to Schwenk Latvija (the leading building material producer and cement plant in Latvia) for the CO2 capture process. Infrastructure: It might be relevant to involve Conexus Baltic Grid (natural gas stor- age operator in Latvia) in the management of CO2 transportation and infrastruc- ture management. Social aspects: In general, society supports the development of environmentally friendly technologies, until they are supposed to pay more on a daily basis (through tax or energy tariffs) for their implementation. 21 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Role (pace- Institution Specific position on CCS/CCU setter/foot- dragger/fence-sitter) Schwenk Latvija Prospects: CO2 capture is already taking place in Schwenk Group (in Germany) that Pace-setter could further be adopted by other group members, for example the Schwenk Lat- Company has an inter- vian branch. The next steps are to think about what to do with it – either utilise it est in introducing and or store it somewhere (in Latvia, collaborate with the Longship CCS Project in Nor- developing CCS and way or find other options). CCU technologies Proposed recommendations: within next 10 years to Perceived barriers to investment: In other sectors in general the emission price is achieve both the com- currently too low to consider the introduction of CCS/CCU technologies. A major pany`s own and EU impact overall would be if the allowances were no longer available for free after goals. 2030. Regulatory: It would require targeted public policy on this issue for the heat indus- try in Latvia to take a positive decision regarding CCS/CCU. Further discussions are needed with the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development of the Republic of Latvia on the current restrictions in the regulation and support possibilities. Further research: To implement CCS technology, detailed geological research needs to be performed, and a business plan should be developed. Inter-sectoral and regional collaboration: There needs to be collaboration be- tween the main players in Latvia and in the region. Infrastructure: It should be developed both for CO2 and hydrogen transmission. Social aspects: There is a need to inform wider society about available technolo- gies and their impact (not only for CCS but also in general about the importance of the decarbonisation processes), providing a clear vision to increase public aware- ness and understanding. Liepājas enerģija Perceived barriers to investment: The company has free emission allowances Fence-sitter available for 2 large boiler houses. Currently the usage of fuel materials is about Lack of knowledge 67% wood chips and 33% natural gas. about the subject mat- There are concerns about the economic viability of the CCS/CCU for this company ter does not allow a considering the overall small scale of the company and its emissions. specific position to be Financial framework: if such technologies were to be introduced, state support taken. and incentives at a national level would be very important. Fortum Latvia / Stakeholder overview: The company will be sold to Partners Group Ltd (second Fence-sitter Fortum Jelgava quarter of 2021) and it is unclear what the new owner’s position towards CCS/CCU The ownership change technologies will be. of the company has It is planned to implement a project that will allow one to replace 30% of the bio- put several strategic mass with waste. In addition, the company has a pilot project producing hydrogen decisions on hold. that can further be used for CCU. EU regulatory framework: What CCS and CCU will be implemented in Latvia and how, depends on the point of view formulated by the EU. After the EU clearly pre- sents the position and policy framework towards the technologies, the discussion could be continued further in Latvia. Inter-sectoral and regional collaboration: Collaboration between different stake- holders will be needed. Financial framework: Revenues from the sale of CO2 allowances should be linked to the further development or implementation of technologies supporting decar- bonisation processes. 22 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Role (pace- Institution Specific position on CCS/CCU setter/foot- dragger/fence-sitter) Conexus Baltic Stakeholder overview: The biggest emissions of the company are from the Fence-sitter Grid Inčukalns gas storage facility. It mainly emits CO2 in the summer during the gas Argument why CCS is injection season when the gas pumping compressors are in operation, which is neutral: around 150 days a year. CCS should rather be The company is instead looking towards a compensatory measure to reduce the seen as a business emissions using modernised and more efficient technologies. niche for Norway. Perceived barriers to investment: Considering the fact that the emissions are only Latvia should better generated for three months a year, the carbon capture technology would be left look towards CCU and to rust for the rest of the year. discover complemen- The future for CCU and CCS technology development depends on how the natural tary technologies to gas market will develop in the future and at what level it will still exist. decrease emissions. Investments in CCS/CCU technologies would increase the price of the gas service and therefore costs for consumers, creating greater obstacles to those who must already make investments to change their business to decrease emissions. Proposed recommendations: Before implementing CCS in Latvia, it is necessary to evaluate the potential for CCU, envisage how other complementary technologies will develop and how that could help to decrease emissions and develop the en- ergy sector as a unified energy system. EU regulatory framework: The EU position on CCS/CCU is not clear. "Ventspils nafta" Stakeholder overview: The stakeholder is not an emitter but is interested in CCU Pace-setter termināls and in processing the captured CO2 and utilising it to produce synthetic natural As transit flows from gas, e-methane, and e-methanol. the east decrease, Role of sectoral integration: The production of e-fuels requires a large amount of they are looking for a CO2 and hydrogen, therefore the CO2 from industrial activities could be reused. An new niche and cur- independent source of CO2 could be developed through collaboration with rently evaluating how Schwenk Latvija (the leading building material producer and cement plant in Lat- oil products and fossil via). fuels can be replaced Proposed recommendations. in the future. Perceived barriers to investment: Transport fuels are currently not covered under the EU ETS. Including both the transport and building sector under the EU ETS would stimulate the transport sector to offset CO2 and use other fuels. Overall development: It is expected that CO2 might eventually become a market commodity. But for this to happen state support and subsidies for technology de- velopment are needed, legislation needs to support the inclusion of e-fuels in the transport fuel portfolio, the development of synthetic fuel production should in- crease, and a framework that promotes the use of these fuels in transport is needed. Energy: CO2 capture, transport, hydrogen production and alternative fuel produc- tion are energy intensive processes. Therefore, it is important to develop and speed up renewable energy production in the country. Infrastructure: Company`s unutilised oil pipelines could potentially be used for the transportation of CO2 or hydrogen. A study should be conducted on technical as- pects as well as how the supply chain and ecosystem can be formed, to discover the best cooperation models and the best set up (centralised or decentralised sys- tem). 23 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Role (pace- Institution Specific position on CCS/CCU setter/foot- dragger/fence-sitter) Latvian Heating Stakeholder overview: Most of the companies the association represents are gen- Foot-dragger (CCS); Companies Asso- erating heat using biomass and are not included in the EU ETS. Therefore, the in- Pace-setter (CCU) ciation terest in the development of carbon capture depends on whether biomass will be The policy towards included in the EU ETS in the future and what other technologies will be developed CCS is not clear, nei- that will allow one to cut back emissions, further decreasing the attractiveness of ther in Latvia nor in CCS/CCU. the EU. Most of the Perceived barriers to investment: District heating companies have mainly chosen district heating com- to reduce emissions by changing the fuel – from coal to either gas, biomass, or panies switch to re- other renewable resources. Therefore, the emissions are so low that CCS/CCU newable energy technologies are not financially viable now. sources, which does It should also be considered that CCS does not comply with the principles of the not fall under the EU circular economy. In this case CCU would be more suitable. ETS. While CCU is con- Prospects: Several waste-to-energy projects are in the pipeline that might need sidered and studied. CCS/CCU technologies. Knowledge: Member of the Latvian Heating Companies Association board and a representative of Riga Technical University provided information about his sys- temic modelling research, looking at CCU in the context of ethanol plant develop- ment and the transport sector. Regulatory: The position of the policy is not clear – not in the EU and therefore not in Latvia either. Financial framework: CCS and CCU could be implemented at a time when it is fi- nancially viable – the cost per tonne of CO2 produced is higher than the cost of capturing a tonne of CO2. Ministry of Envi- Perceived barriers to investment: The priority is to reduce emissions at source, Fence-sitter ronmental Pro- increase efficiency, replace fuel materials with less polluting ones or use natural Reasons are the lack tection and Re- CO2 sinks, such as forests. of economic justifica- gional Develop- Regulatory: In Latvia it is prohibited by law to store CO2 in onshore and offshore tion, security concerns ment of the Re- geological formations, as well as in the water column. of CCS and the un- public of Latvia Prospects: There are sectors where the emissions cannot be further decreased. tapped potential of al- Therefore, discussions could be considered to develop a framework in which com- ternative technologies panies could act in relation to CCS and CCU. However, CCS will not be a priority and methods that sup- and the economic reasoning and justification would have to be profound. port decarbonisation Knowledge: Proficient and more detailed geological research should be carried processes. out to understand the potential sites for CCS. Financial framework: Currently there is no funding for CCS, and no plans have been made for this in the future. Ministry of Eco- Perceived barriers to investment: The solutions to decrease emissions will primar- Fence-sitter nomics of the Re- ily be sought through increasing the efficiency of technologies, production pro- Lack of economic justi- public of Latvia cesses, energy generation, the use of BIO-CCS (bioenergy with carbon capture and fication, security con- storage) and CCU. It is important to consider that renewable energy resource tech- cerns of CCS and the nologies are increasingly able to operate independently and fully compete in the potential of unused al- market without support. ternative technologies Regulatory: The main factor influencing the introduction of CCS and CCU technol- and methods that sup- ogies is the prices of CO2 emission allowances, which in turn are influenced by their port decarbonisation availability. The European Commission is working on this, and more detailed processes. Priority trends and insights will be available in July 2021, when the European Commission's given to CCU. proposal on this issue arrives. Knowledge on country development perspective: It is planned to develop a sys- tem integration model to increase the capacity and sustainability of the energy sector. The model will evaluate the needs of the country and innovation niches and assess different technologies and their potential in reaching climate goals. 24 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Role (pace- Institution Specific position on CCS/CCU setter/foot- dragger/fence-sitter) University of Lat- Geology prospects: Favourable geological conditions are found for CO2 storage in Fence-sitter via Latvia in the Middle Cambrian reservoir, sealed by Ordovician clayey carbonate Funding for rocks. detailed geophysi- Perceived barriers to investment: However more detailed geophysical/seismic re- cal/seismic research is search is required to mark the underground geological structure, dimensions, and required to be com- fracture characteristics in order to be completely sure about the possibility of CCS pletely sure about the potential. Overall, this research is relatively inexpensive, but it does not provide possibility of CCS po- information on the composition of the rocks. Therefore, drilling boreholes up to tential. the bedrock is required. In Latvia it can be even more than a kilometre deep un- derground, which increases the costs. One such well could cost up to a million eu- ros, which is the main obstacle. Riga Technical Knowledge: Research and multiple studies have been conducted related to CCS Pace-setter University and CCU on integrated decarbonisation solutions for efficient CO2 valorisation in Several CCS and CCU regions, geological mineralisation of CO2 and its storage options, impact of CO2 research projects con- storage processes, CO2 Capture Technologies for Small Scale Cogeneration Plants ducted and ongoing. in Latvia, and systemic modelling of CCU in the context of ethanol plant develop- ment and the transport sector. Prospects: CO2 must be seen as waste and therefore either used or stored. How- ever, it is a stable molecule, and a large amount of energy is needed for it to be incorporated into some processes. Source: Civitta 3. In-depth stakeholder perceptions of the CCS and CCU landscape OVERALL PROSPECTS FOR CCS/CCU IN LATVIA Overall prospects for CCS/CCU are moderate in Latvia, as only one of the main emitters has shown confidence that they could trans- form their main activities and capture CO2. However, the biggest concern would be the storage possibilities. While the representa- tives of Schwenk Latvija emphasised that the geological storage potential and CCS in general is a topical issue for the company, in the rest of the stakeholders` interviews and during further discussion in the workshop, the CCU option was highlighted more. Therefore, CCU might also be a suitable solution for the situation in Latvia. THE ROLE OF CCS/CCU IN SECTOR INTEGRATION Through the interviews and during the discussion of the workshop, it was acknowledged that stakeholder cooperation between the stakeholders within the country, as well as between the Baltic states and beyond, is important for the successful development of CCS/CCU solutions. All the stakeholders admitted that the costs of CO2 capture technology, the infrastructure of transportation, and the storage development are so high and the required expertise in the management of the storage facility are so complex that no company in Latvia could implement CCS and CCU solutions alone. During the workshop of Latvia, stakeholders showed an interest in collaborating with each other on CCU to discover more about the usage of each other's resources. Latvenergo and Fortum informed that they are looking towards generating hydrogen, Latvenergo proposed an oxygen offer to Schwenk Latvija for CO2 capture, while “Ventspils nafta” terminals notified that they are looking towards the generation of synthetic fuels, using hydrogen and CO2. 25 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION AWARENESS OF EU POLICY AND FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS FOR CCS/CCU While climate targets and energy transition regulations were clear to the stakeholders, several stakeholders commented that the EU policy position regarding CCS/CCU was not clear, therefore there is concern about whether the implementation of the technologies would be supported. Most of the stakeholders stated that state support or a grant is needed in the beginning for the pilot projects to be developed. Only afterwards, if commercialisation and economics are handled correctly, might investors be interested in investing in further develop- ment. Few stakeholders knew about the possibility to use the EU Innovation fund to support CCS/CCU, while Schwenk Latvija has been considering this fund for development in the future. PERCEIVED DEPLOYMENT BARRIERS AND RISKS During the Interviews and discussions in the workshop, various barriers and risks were highlighted: ● Storage of carbon dioxide in geological formations, as well as in the water column is prohibited in Latvia due to the lack of economic justification and security concerns. ● Under the law, the landowners own the subterranean depths that are the potential CO 2 storage areas. The landowners may object to the use of subterranean depths for CO2 storage, or the storage operator would have to enter into contracts with a large number of landowners, which also entails significant costs. Although in such cases there is a possibility to alienate the land, it is often quite a complicated process. ● The existing infrastructure is not suitable for transporting CO2 – relatively large investments are required. ● The costs of development of CCS storage infrastructure are rather high. ● There are various risks to CO2 storage that need to be researched and analysed in more detail. ● Further research and pilot projects are needed to develop CCS/CCU technologies and get more data on the geology for- mations and the potential for CCS. ● For smaller CO2 emitters, CCS and CCU solutions are less relevant – more attention is paid to switching fuel sources and to the evaluation of what the largest CO2 emitters are doing regarding this issue. ● It is difficult for companies to implement such solutions alone, so they need support from the state in some form and cooperation between industry and foreign stakeholders. ● By using captured CO2, it is possible to produce synthetic fuels, such as methanol, but the issue might be related to demand for such fuels (experience of Fortum in Jelgava could be an example, where currently planned hydrogen production is on hold, due to changes in demand in the transportation sector). ● CO2 capture, transport, hydrogen production and alternative fuel production are energy intensive processes that require a large amount of energy, so it is important to develop and speed up renewable energy production in the country. ● Synthetic methanol is currently not mentioned in the planned amendments to the Energy Law and the transport sector does not fall under the EU ETS, which hinders the development of alternative fuels. 4. Stakeholder recommendations for CCS and CCU REGULATION Since 2012, the storage of carbon dioxide in geological formations, as well as in the water column is prohibited in Latvia due to the lack of economic justification at the time and security concerns. To consider making changes to the law there needs to be clear justification, clarification of who the stakeholders that would need this solution are, and how many stakeholders in Latvia cannot survive without this solution even after they have implemented all other possible emission cutting solutions. 26 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION By law, the landowner owns the subterranean depths within their property. Therefore, the storage operator would need to reach an agreement with the landowner on the land being used for the storage of CO2. This would require entering into contracts with a large number of landowners, and it is possible that compensation will be needed. CCU is allowed in Latvia and regulation provides a framework for the transportation of CO 2 to other countries. If no agreement and allowances are reached for CO2 storage in Latvia, stakeholders consider CCU or the transportation of CO2 to other countries. A stakeholder working group should be formed where the ministry representatives and various stakeholders with the biggest emis- sions discuss possible solutions, the framework and required changes and amendments to the regulation and law that would provide a framework on how to deal with emissions. TECHNOLOGY For CCS and CCU to be deployed, pilot project technologies of CO2 capture, transportation and utilisation/storage should be devel- oped. The development requires national or EU financial support. Many of the energy sector stakeholders are considering alternative options to decrease emissions and are following the development of renewable energy technologies, therefore CCS and CCU tech- nologies should be able to be as competitive or bring greater added value than alternative technologies. For the industry stakeholders where alternative technologies are not an option, CO2 capture is more relevant. Therefore, in Germany one of the Schwenk Group cement plants is in the process of implementing CO 2 capture using an oxyfuel technology pilot project. After it operates on an industrial scale, it could be transferred to other group cement plants, including Schwenk Latvija. Stakeholders admitted that CCU is considered as a more valuable solution. Therefore, further research and pilot projects are recom- mended to develop CCU technologies. INFRASTRUCTURE The CCS and CCU infrastructure are non-existent; therefore, the infrastructure and logistics plan should be developed using trains, trucks, ships, or pipelines. There is potential to adopt the existing oil or gas grid for CO 2 transportation. While the gas grid is used, there is an unutilised oil pipeline that could potentially be used for transportation. However, further research Is needed to understand the detailed technical specifics. There are no storage sites devoted to CO2 storage; therefore, if the legislation of the prohibition of storing CO 2 underground is changed, then technologies need to be developed to store the CO2 and a business plan needs to be introduced and agreed that will maintain the security of the storage in the long term. MARKET CCS/CCU implementation possibilities are mostly affected by the price of CO2, as well as by the activities and innovations of technol- ogies that would be important for the introduction of CCS/CCU. CO2 prices are rising, though this level is still not enough to start seriously considering CCS/CCU projects. It is possible that after 2030, allowances will no longer be available for free, which would have a major impact overall. The development of alternative technologies, for example renewable energy technologies, play a significant role in the implementa- tion process of CCS/CCU. Energy related business sector can switch to alternative energy generation methods and decrease their emissions; as a result the CCS/CCU solutions become irrelevant for them. On the other hand, other industry sectors can use cheap and available renewable energy to implement CCU. 27 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION FINANCIAL FRAMEWORKS The stakeholders did not have an agreement on the financial framework for CCS/CCU. It has been recommended that the revenue of the CO2 allowances be linked to the further development of CCS/CCU technologies. CCS/CCU are new technologies and most of the projects would be pilot projects that need support to be implemented. The business sector stated that there should be grants, national subsidies, or EU funding in the beginning to develop possible CCS and CCU pilot projects. And if the pilot project and its business model is developed and commercialised successfully then at a later stage, investors would be interested in investing in further development. While Schwenk Latvija suggested that the CO2 capture part could be finan- cially managed from their side, the transportation and, if possible, storage should be supported and managed by the state as the company does not have the relevant experience and expertise regarding gas transportation or storage. The governmental sector on the other hand argues that on a national level there is no funding specifically for CCS and it has not been planned in the future. INTER-SECTORAL AND REGIONAL COLLABORATION All stakeholders agreed that collaboration is necessary and first-hand analysis should be conducted on how the ecosystem and supply chain could be formed (CO2 captured in one place, transported, and used or stored in another), and a potential business model should be drawn up to discover the economic viability and to understand the best cooperation models for this process and the best set up – a centralised or decentralised system. This study would give the support and justification to the need to make changes in the national regulation. Further cooperation regarding CCU involving the necessary resources is possible and many stakeholders showed an interest in col- laborating and exchanging available resources (oxygen, carbon dioxide and hydrogen). SOCIAL ASPECTS There have been no discussions at the society level on CCS/CCU. However, considering stakeholder experience, the main concerns of society regarding CCS/CCU could be related to the safety of CO2 storage, environmental issues, financial viability, and possible additional costs related to the implementation of such projects. In general, society supports the development of environmentally friendly technologies, although they are more concerned about issues that affect them specifically, such as noise, odours, and other types of pollution. Mostly, the development of such projects is supported until society needs to pay more daily (through tax or energy tariffs) for their implementation. Communication of clear factual data, based on research and pilot project experience from other countries’ programmes is required for society to be informed and understand the benefits of CCS/CCU to the environment, society, and the economy. 28 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Chapter 3. CCS and CCU: Public ac- ceptance in Latvia 1. Public opinion on curbing carbon emissions Public opinion on curbing carbon emissions can be determined through various public opinion polls conducted on the subject. At the EU level, the Eurobarometer survey is organised on the topic of climate change. The most recent available results for this topic are from 2019 (Eurobarometer 490: Climate Change) and from these results it is possible to determine the public attitude towards cli- mate change in general, as well as compare national results with EU-level results on this topic. Climate change is considered to be a very serious problem in Latvia by 59% respondents (EU average result – 79% respondents), but the percentage of respondents that consider this as a fairly serious problem is 28% (EU – 14%).42 To understand public opinion on the need to transition to clean energies, it is possible to use one of the questions used in the survey (Figure 7). 42 European Commission. “Special Eurobarometer 490: Climate Change. Latvia, April 2019” https://ec.europa.eu/clima/sites/de- fault/files/support/docs/lv_climate_2019_en.pdf 29 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Figure 7. Attitude towards transition to clean energy Source: European Commission As it can also be seen in this figure, support for the transition to clean energies by reducing subsidies to fossil fuels is supported by 74% of respondents (answers “totally agree” and “agree”). Although it should be noted that support in this issue is lower than in the EU. In comparison to the EU, Latvia also has a higher proportion of respondents who do not have an opinion/answer to this question (15% and 7%, respectively).43 An insight into public opinion on the use of various natural resources in energy can also be gained from the survey conducted by the research centre SKDS on public attitudes towards various energy issues in 2008. Within this study, support for various natural re- sources in electricity generation is analysed. Natural resources such as wind energy (85.7% of respondents evaluate this natural resource very positively or rather positively), solar energy (84%), hydropower (80.2%) and biomass (75.7%) are rated positively. Sources such as gas (48.1%) and coal (45.2%) are assessed less positively, while sources such as nuclear energy (29.2%) and oil (28.5%) have the lowest assessment.44 Therefore, it can be concluded that public acceptance is generally placed on the further use of green natural resources, rather than fossil fuels (nuclear energy being an exception), although more recent research on this topic would be desirable in order to see the recent situation and trends on this issue. During the interviews various stakeholders have expressed the view that, although society in general is supportive about reducing emissions, such support is generally maintained as long as society does not have to pay extra for such reductions of emissions and the transition to more environmentally friendly technologies. The general attitude towards this issue is also influenced by the fact that the society in Latvia has little experience with practical examples of climate change and its consequences, as CO2 pollution cannot be observed in the same way as other types of pollution. 43 ibid. 44 SKDS „Sabiedrības attieksme pret dažādiem enerģētikas jautājumiem: Latvijas iedzīvotāju aptauja, 2008. gada marts”. http://petijumi.mk.gov.lv/sites/default/files/file/EM_Sabiedribas_aptaujas_Sab_attieksme_pret_daz_energetikas_jaut_re- zult_2008.pdf 30 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 2. Public perception on CCS/CCU and related projects Based on currently available information, no definite public image has been formed in connection with CCS/CCU technologies, as this sector has not been developed in Latvia so far. It should be mentioned that the Latvian media mentions some articles about common trends in the world in the field of CCS/CCU, but the prevailing public opinion in these articles is more about the necessity to solve the root of this problem, rather than making large investments to combat the consequences. Public opinion on this issue can be identified from experience with similar energy and industrial projects. Similar projects that gener- ated more public interest and involvement are identified and described in the following sections. SKULTE LNG TERMINAL Within the project, it is planned to place a liquefied natural gas terminal – floating regasification unit in the area of Skulte port (2.5 km from the seashore). It is also planned to establish a 34 km gas pipeline connection to the Inčukalns underground gas storage facility. As a result, the terminal will be able to accommodate cargo ships with liquefied natural gas, which would later be transported to the Inčukalns storage facility.45 Public opinion is divided on this project. The biggest concerns are about the damage to the environment: noise that could occur from the operation of the terminal; possible gas leaks; damage to the landscape of Saulkrasti as a resort town; and risks of disasters or explosions. Opponents of the project also emphasise that gas consumption in Latvia has decreased by 30% in recent years, therefore the project would primarily serve business interests rather than public interests. In this and other large-scale energy projects, there are public concerns that the implementation of such projects will contribute to rising electricity prices. The process of collecting signatures against this project has also been started – more than 4 thousand signatures have currently been collected.46 Geopolitical interests and political lobbying can be identified in this project, which also influence the development of this project. This aspect was also emphasised in one of the stakeholder interviews – it is concluded that in such cases it is more difficult to gain public acceptance. DOBELE WIND FARM In 2013, the Swedish company Eolus Vind AB announced their intention to build the largest wind farm in Latvia near Dobele and Tukums by installing 51 wind turbines. It was planned that the wind farm will be able to produce approximately 0.7 TWh of electricity per year, which would be approximately 10% of Latvia's annual electricity consumption. More details about this project appeared in 2018, when an environmental impact assessment was carried out and public discussions about this project were organised.47 After more information appeared around this project, a relatively high level of public opposition was observed. The collection of signatures was started against the implementation of this project. The local initiative group, which is against the project, has listed several reasons why wind farms are unacceptable in the planned territory. The most common objections are about the large size of generators, damage to human health due to turbine vibration, noise and shadow flicker, massive death rates of birds and bats and declining property values. Opposition also notes that the electricity generated by the wind farm will be too expensive and that resi- dents will overpay for this. Also, this project will place an additional burden on state and local municipality budgets in the future. It is also questioned whether the wind is strong enough in this region. Several major entrepreneurs in Dobele also oppose the wind 45 Skulte LNG Terminal. “The Project”. https://skultelng.lv/lv/ 46 Ir. “Žurnāls: Ko nozīmē būvēt gāzes termināli pie Saulkrastiem?”. https://ir.lv/2019/07/18/zurnals-ko-nozime-buvet-gazes-termi- nali-pie-saulkrastiem/ 47 LSM. „Par aptuveni 250 miljoniem eiro būvēs Latvijā lielāko vēja parku”. https://www.lsm.lv/raksts/zinas/ekonomika/par-aptu- veni-250-miljoniem-eiro-buves-latvija-lielako-veja-parku.a292231/ 31 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION farm. However, opinions were also published in the media, arguing against a large part of the identified disadvantages and their impact.48 Both in the Skulte project and Dobele project, involvement and interest from local initiative groups is much higher than from the largest NGOs that are working on environmental issues. The current version of the project has significantly reduced the number of allowed turbines and several restrictions. Despite the changes, the two involved municipalities have not supported the implementation of this project. OTHER CASES AND OVERALL PUBLIC / INSTITUTIONAL DISCOURSE The projects described above are some of the most notable examples of large-scale projects with relatively high-level public involve- ment. In other projects of such type, public involvement and attitudes may vary. For example, several years ago, when the idea of natural gas storage facility development in Dobele was relevant, the analysis of available information did not identify any significant kinds of public opinion in the media on this issue. The issue of CCS/CCU is basically not raised in the public debate (the only exception is Schwenk Latvija, which has informed the public about the activities in this direction to achieve its future goal – a CO2-neutral cement plant). Thus, the views of various institutions can be characterised using the opinions and information from stakeholder interviews. In general, the interviewed stakeholders are relatively well informed about this issue and know its basic principles. However, most of the stakeholders for whom the introduction of such technologies could be relevant, have a reserved position in relation to this technology. This is mainly due to the economic aspects regarding the implementation of CCS/CCU technologies, as well as other limiting aspects. The exception is Schwenk Latvija, which is generally very well informed about this topic, and is in favour of developing such technologies and framework at the national level. As there is no clearly identifiable public discourse on CCS/CCU technologies specifically, it is not possible to determine the importance of scientific evidence in such discussions. However, during interviews with stakeholders, it was expressed that public opinion is more influenced by factors such as the reluctance to see an increase in fossil fuel usage, the reluctance to see greater dependence on foreign energy resources, and the principle of NIMBYism49. However, it should be noted that in the above- mentioned project examples, supporters and opponents of specific projects are also using various studies and calculations that confirm the opinion of the party. 48 LSM. „LSM.lv skaidro: Ko iedzīvotājiem nozīmētu jaunais vēja parks Dobeles un Tukuma pusē”. https://www.lsm.lv/raksts/zi- nas/latvija/lsmlv-skaidro-ko-iedzivotajiem-nozimetu-jaunais-veja-parks-dobeles-un-tukuma-puse.a298205/#comments-article- 298205 49 NIMBYism – the practice of objecting to something that will affect someone or take place in one's locality 32 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Annex A: List of largest CO2 emitting companies in 2019 No. Name Industry where most of the CO2 emissions are produced CO2 emissions, t 1 Latvenergo Energy production 1 218 669 2 Schwenk Latvija Cement manufacturer 794 019 3 Rīgas Siltums Energy production 167 975 4 Rīgas Bioenerģija Energy production 117 005 5 LATGRAN Wood product manufacturing 87 811 6 Liepājas enerģija Energy production 67 906 7 Daugavpils siltumtīkli Energy production 44 679 8 Fortum Daugavpils Energy production 42 883 9 Rēzeknes siltumtīkli Energy production 41 330 10 LATNEFTEGAZ Energy production 38 735 11 Juglas jauda Energy production 33 581 12 Conexus Baltic Grid Energy transmission and storage 31 775 13 Valmieras stikla šķiedra Glass fibre manufacturer 30 092 14 Ventspils siltums Energy production 29 697 15 Stiga RM Wood product manufacturing 25 680 16 KNAUF Building material manufacturer 23 969 17 Valmieras enerģija Energy production 22 118 18 Jēkabpils siltums Energy production 21 222 19 Ošukalns Energy production* 20 308 20 Krāslavas nami Energy production 19 925 21 Cēsu siltumtīkli Energy production 19 528 22 Preiļu siltums Energy production 18 045 23 B.L.B. Baltijas Termināls Transhipment 17 890 24 Preiļu siers Food production 16 812 25 Vārpa Wood product manufacturing 15 928 26 AD Biogāzes stacija Energy production 15 334 27 Jūrmalas siltums Energy production 13 160 28 Līvānu siltums Energy production 12 682 Source: Civitta (data from the Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre) * The core business of the company is in wood product production, but most of the emissions reported in the statistics are related to energy production in a cogeneration powerplant. 33 The Building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the CEE region project is funded by Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway through the EEA and Norway Grants Fund for Regional Cooperation. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 34 The Building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the CEE region project is funded by Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway through the EEA and Norway Grants Fund for Regional Cooperation. THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Assessment of current state, past experiences and potential for CCS deployment in the CEE region LITHUANIA Ervinas Škikūnas Darius Krulikovskis 0 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Table of contents Glossary ............................................................................................................................................................................ 2 Chapter 1. CCS and CCU: current state and past experiences in Lithuania ................................................... 3 1. Description of relevant domestic economic sectors ..................................................................................... 3 1.1. Carbon-intensive sectors of the Lithuanian economy .............................................................................. 4 1.2. Major CO2 emitters in Lithuania ..................................................................................................................... 5 2. Assessment of geological potential for CCS ................................................................................................... 6 2.1. General Information .......................................................................................................................................... 7 2.2. Geological formations fit for CO2 storage ................................................................................................................ 7 3. Description of implemented and planned projects ..................................................................................... 11 4. Legislation and Regulation Relevant for CCS Deployment ....................................................................... 11 Chapter 2. Lithuania's outlook for CCS and CCU................................................................................................. 13 1. Summary of stakeholder engagement .......................................................................................................... 13 2. Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU ........................................................................................................ 14 3. In-depth stakeholder perceptions of the CCU and CCS landscape ........................................................ 16 4. Stakeholder recommendations for CCU/CCS ............................................................................................... 17 Chapter 3. CCS and CCU: Public acceptance in Lithuania ................................................................................ 19 1 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Glossary Term Definition AB Joint stock company (LT: akcinė bendrovė) CC Carbon capture CCS Carbon capture and storage CCU Carbon capture and utilisation CO2 Carbon dioxide DNA Deoxyribonucleic acid EC European Commission EU European Union EUR Euro, the currency used in the European Union Gt Giga tonne (one billion tonnes) KN Klaipėdos nafta KTU Kaunas University of Technology (LT: Kauno technologijų universitetas) LNG Liquified natural gas LS Larvik Shipping MOL Mitsui O.S.K. Lines MPa Mega Pascal (one million Pascal units) Mt Mega tonne (one million tonnes) PET Polyethylene terephthalate PET Polyethylene terephthalate SĮ Municipality company (LT: savivaldybės įmonė) UAB Limited liability company (LT: uždaroji akcinė bendrovė) 2 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Chapter 1. CCS and CCU: current state and past experiences in Lithuania 1. Description of relevant domestic economic sectors Lithuania's industry contribution to the gross domestic product is about 20%, and industrial goods account for more than 80% of Lithuania's exports. In terms of production volume, the country's industry is dominated by the manufacturing, chemical production, furniture and wood, clothing and textile, and electronics industries. Concerning CO2 emissions, the main sectors of interest are fertiliser production, cement production, oil refining, and heating and electricity production. FIGURE 1: MAIN INDUSTRY CO2 EMISSION SOURCES IN LITHUANIA Source: Environment protection agency of Lithuania, 2019 3 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 1.1. Carbon-intensive sectors of the Lithuanian economy In addition to the main industry emitters, a significant part – 38% – of total emissions in Lithuania comes from heat and power generation. So, the main carbon-intensive sectors of the Lithuanian economy are: • Fertiliser manufacturing and related chemical processes (1 plant in the central part of Lithuania, 250 km from Klaipėda port); • Oil refinery and oil processing (north-west Lithuania, 60 km from the cement plant, 130 km from port of Klaipėda); • Cement manufacturing (north-west Lithuania, 60 km from the cement plant, 160 km from port of Klaipėda); • Heating and energy production (one emitter above 0.2 million tonnes per year in Klaipėda, 10 km from the port of Klaipėda). Out of the industrial players, five companies emit the majority (67%) of CO2. FIGURE 2: INDUSTRY EMISSIONS BY COMPANY IN LITHUANIA, M TONNES, 2019 Source: Environment protection agency of Lithuania Top 5 main CO2 emitting entities - and major stakeholders withing the CCU/CCS context - are the following: 1. Achema - 2.5 M tonnes of CO2. Achema is a producer of nitrogen fertiliser and other chemical products; 2. Orlen Lietuva - 1.6 M tonnes of CO2. Orlen Lietuva is an oil refining company; 3. Akmenės cementas - 0.97 M tonnes of CO2. Akmenės cementas is the largest cement manufacturer in Lithuania; 4. Vilniaus Šilumos tinklai - 0.62 M tonnes of CO2. Vilniaus šilumos tinklai is Lithuania's largest provider of heating and hot water; 4 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 5. Fortum Klaipėda - 0.27 M tonnes of CO2 1. Fortum Klaipėda generates heat and electricity using sorted municipal and in- dustrial waste. 1.2. Major CO2 emitters in Lithuania Companies that emit more than 50 thousand tonnes of CO2 are shown in Table 1. TABLE 1: INDUSTRY EMISSIONS BY COMPANY IN LITHUANIA, 2019 No. COMPANY/OBJECT NAME SECTOR CO2 EMISSIONS, 2019, '000 1. AB “Achema” Fertilisers 2,486 2. AB “Orlen Lietuva” Oil refining 1,599 3. AB “Akmenės Cementas” Cement 968 4. AB “Vilniaus šilumos tinklai” District heating 625 5. UAB “Fortum Klaipėda” District heating 271 6. AB “Šiaulių energija” Šiaulių Pietinė katilinė District heating 238 7. AB “Grigeo Klaipėda” Paper production 216 8. UAB “Idex Paneriškės” District heating 180 9. UAB “Neo Group” katilinė PET resins and polyol 159 10. AB Roquette Amilina (buvusi UAB “Lignoterma”) Grain processing 142 11. AB “Panevėžio energija” Panevėžio RK-1 District heating 124 12. UAB “Utenos šilumos tinklai” Utenos rajononė katilinė District heating 91 13. UAB “Mažeikių šilumos tinklai” Mažeikių katilinė District heating 89 14. UAB “Litesko” filialas “Marijampolės šiluma” Marijampolės ra- District heating joninė katilinė 88 15. UAB “Idex Biruliškės” District heating 83 16. AB “Kauno energija” Petrašiūnų elektrinė Electricity production 80 17. AB “Ignitis gamyba” Elektrėnų kompleksas Electricity production 78 18. AB “Klaipėdos energija” Klaipėdos rajoninė katilinė District heating 70 19. AB “Panevėžio energija” Rokiškio RK District heating 66 20. UAB “Paroc” Building materials production (rockwool) 62 21. AB “Jonavos šilumos tinklai” Girelės rajoninė katilinė District heating 61 22. UAB “Litesko” filialas “Druskininkų šiluma” Druskininkų katilinė District heating 61 23. SĮ “Visagino energija” District heating 59 24. UAB “IKEA Industry Lietuva” Furniture production 59 25. AB “Kauno energija” “Šilko” katilinė District heating 55 26. UAB “Hoegh LNG Klaipėda” LNG terminal 50 27. Other, smaller emissions (total - 61) - 787 1 Amount of CO 2 emissions shows total emissions from fossil fuels (0.14 M tonnes) and biomass (0.13 M tonnes). 5 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 2. Assessment of geological potential for CCS Lithuania is located in the eastern and central parts of the Baltic sedimentation basin; the thickness of the sedimentary cover varies from 200 metres in the southeast of the country to 2.3 km on the Baltic Sea coast. The section is characterised by a variety of lithological composition and hydrogeological conditions. The upper part of the sedimentary cover is in the zone of active water exchange; deeper transition and stagnant zones are distinguished. Overall, the Baltic countries are situated within the Baltic sedimentary basin that contains a number of regional-scale aquifers. However, only two of these, the Lower-Middle Devonian (marked D1 and D2 respectively) and Middle Cambrian reservoirs (marked Cm), meet the basic requirements for CO2 storage. Offshore options of CCS for Lithuania are limited, and their storage potential has low estimates2. FIGURE 3: INDUSTRIAL CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS AND POTENTIAL GEOLOGICAL SINKS IN THE BALTIC STATES Geological cross-section across Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. Major aquifers are Indicated by dots. V - Vendian (Ediacaran), Cm - Cambrian, O - Ordovician, S - Silurian, D1, D2 and D3 - Lower, Middle and Upper Devonian, P2 - Middle Permian, T1 - Lower Triassic, J - Jurassic, K - Cretaceous, Q - Quaternary. Source: Feasibility study. Carbon capture, transport and storage in geological formations, taking the provisions of the draft Directive, 2008, UAB Cowi Baltic and UAB Krige Investicija into account. As a result of these conditions, two carbon capture and storage scenarios are suitable for Lithuanian conditions, which require different assessment strategies. The first group of potential objects consists of anticline-type structures, including oil fields. The second type includes monocular-type saline aquifers. Anticline-type structures are the safest, but their potential is limited compared 2 Šliaupa S., Lojka R., Tasáryová Z., Kolejka V., Hladík V., Kotulová J., Kucharič L., Fejdi V., Wójcicki A., Tarkowski R., Uliasz-Misiak B., Šliaupienė R., Nulle I., Pomeranceva R., Ivanova O., Shogenova A. and Shogenov K. (2013) CO2 storage potential of sedimentary basins of Slovakia, the Czech Re- public, Poland and the Baltic States. Geological Quarterly, 57 (2):219–232, doi: 10.7306/gq.1088 6 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION to monoclonal aquifers. As the experience of long-term research in Lithuania shows, higher closed elevations are only common in the Cambrian aquifer. 2.1. General Information A number of parameters were evaluated when studying the CO2 disposal potential of Lithuanian depths. Temperature measurement data of 160 deep wells were used to determine the temperature regime (Šliaupa, 2002), hydrostatic pressure information was re- viewed. The reservoir porosity database consists of over 10,000 porosity and permeability measurements (Šliaupa et al., 2003), and the Devonian collector database contains several hundred measurements. The water mineralisation database consists of: Cambrian collector - 170 wells, Lower Devonian and Pärnu collector - 75 wells, Upninkai-Šventoji - 1300 wells. Other aquifers are not analysed because they are in unfavourable thermobaric conditions. Assessing the potential of local traps in the Cambrian collector, 72 struc- tures on land and 30 structures in the Baltic Sea were inventoried. 2.2. Geological formations fit for CO2 storage According to the conditions of temperature and pressure, there are two promising saline aquifers in the territory of Lithuania - Cam- brian and Pernu-Kemeriai (Lower Devonian and Lower Middle Devonian). Other aqueous layers common in the Lithuanian sedimen- tary section are lower in temperature and pressure than required, therefore CO 2 burial is not possible in them. According to the thermobaric characteristics, the Cambrian aquifer shows the most favourable conditions. The critical isotherm of 32 oC is in central Lithuania. In the west of the country the temperature reaches 70-85 oC. This high-temperature area roughly coincides with the pres- sure range higher than 7.8 MPa, and in western Lithuania it reaches up to 20 MPa. Thus, the entire western side of Lithuania is promising in this aspect - here the CO2 will be in a supercritical state. In the eastern part of Lithuania, CO 2 is in the gas phase, and it will only reach liquid state (between the 32 oC isotherm and the 7.8 MPa isobar) in a small area. The Cambrian collector consists of Middle Cambrian Deimena regional floor sandstone, and in central Lithuania there is also suitable lower Cambrian sandstone3. The thickness varies from 20-30 to 60-70 m. Cambrian sandstone is characterised by decreasing porosity and permeability to the west, which is associated with greater depths of deposition. The open porosity varies from an average of 25% to 16% at a depth range of 400-1800 m. 3 Ibid. 7 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION FIGURE 4: REGIONAL STORAGE CAPACITY OF CAMBRIAN AND LOWER DEVONIAN AQUIFERS, ONSHORE LITHUANIA. Source: EU GeoCapacity, 2009 In the Pernu-Kemeri aquifer, CO2 can be buried in western Lithuania, where the temperature and pressure exceed 32 oC and 7.8 MPa. The maximum temperature on the ridge reaches up to 45 oC, the pressure - 9 MPa, in some places (e.g. near Syderiai, along the lowered Telšiai fracture wing) it exceeds 10 MPa. CO2 will be in a supercritical state here, while in central and eastern Lithuania it will be in a gaseous consistency. In the transition zone, CO2 is in the liquid phase. The thickness of the aquifer reaches up to 190 metres in the northern part of western Lithuania (Paluknė-1 borehole). The Gargždai series below is characterised by poor collector proper- ties, low-permeability siltstones predominate, abundant layers of clay and sandstone form a small part of the section. The aquifer of Pernu-Kemeri has good collector properties, the section is dominated by weakly cemented sandstone, the porosity of which is usually 25-30 percent. The permeability of sandstone is 0.5-4 millidarcy - these are very good collector properties. Sandstone makes up 62- 67% of the aquifer section. The largest structures in the territory of Lithuania are Syderiai and Vaškai. Another large structure stands out in the Baltic Sea near the coast (5 km). The CO2 storage potential of these structures is shown in the table below. TABLE 2: MAIN GEOLOGICAL STRUCTURES FIT FOR STORAGE IN LITHUANIA. Aquifer structure X coordinates (WGS-84) Y coordinates (WGS-84) Capacity (MtCO2) Syderiai 22.43 55.92 21.5 Vaškai 24.25 56.07 8.7 Baltic Sea structure (D11) 20.9 56.02 11.3 Source: Feasibility study. Carbon capture, transport and storage in geological formations, taking the provisions of the draft Directive, 2008, UAB Cowi Baltic and UAB Krige Investicija into account. SYDERIAI On the basis of seismic research, one Syderiai well was drilled in the centre of the structure. The amplitude of the structure reaches 80 m, the collector of the middle chamber is at a depth of 1458 m. The structure is oblong in shape, 8 by 11 km in size. From the south and east, it reaches fractures. The southern fracture is a part of the large Telšiai fracture zone, the eastern - an accompanying smaller fracture, the amplitude of which exceeds 75 m. The thickness of the collector is 57 m. It consists of Middle Cambrian Deimena series sand dunes with an average porosity of 16% and an effective water horizon of 0.75. A clay layer about 10 m thick divides the 8 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION collector into two parts. The average porosity of the upper sandstone is 18% (27 m thick), the lower - 15% (12 m thick). The temper- ature of the layer is 50 oC. Water mineralisation - 122.4 g / l (sodium-chloride type water). The Syderiai elevation can hold 21.5 Mt CO2. Syderiai elevation is close to the gas pipeline, which increases the potential of this structure. However, it should be emphasised that this structure is one of the most promising for the development of an underground gas storage facility in Lithuania, therefore a conflict of interest is possible here. VAŠKAI The structure in Vaškai is located in Pasvalys district, 10 km northwest of Pasvalys City. Between 1992 and 1999, seismic surveys were carried out in 168 km of the area and 5 wells were drilled based on its results. No significant geothermal studies have been carried out here, one can only guess from the general regional situation that the temperature of the chamber is about 30 oC, so it may be a bit too low to maintain a supercritical state in the reservoir. The carbon dioxide will be in the liquid phase, which is heavier than the pore water, so it will migrate downwards, erupting from the structure. The Vaškai structure could store 8.7 Mt CO2. The advantage of this structure is that it is close to gas pipelines and the simple geometric shape of the structure. Weaknesses of the Vaškai structure - 1) underground gas storage facilities are planned in the perspective, 2) unclear fracture closure; 3) there is a lack of temperature measurement data that would allow one to substantiate the supercritical state of CO2 in the Cambrian aquifer. BALTIC SEA STRUCTURES The aforementioned two promising salty aquifers extend into the Baltic Sea. Geological and geophysical surveys have also been carried out here in the past, mainly related to oil exploration. Seismic intelligence data identified 45 structures for which the CO2 storage potential was calculated. The highest elevation highlighted is named D11, located 5 km from the shore. Its potential is esti- mated at 11 Mt. Other structures range from 100,000 tonnes to 7.8 Mt. No promising structures were found in the Devonian strata, as on land, so the prospects for this aquifer are virtually nil. VARĖNA SERPENTINITE Geological formations provide prospective sinks for CO2 sequestration - essentially the main storage options in Lithuania. Alterna- tively, mineral carbonation, which is a process of converting naturally occurring minerals such as magnesium- and calcium-based silicates into stable carbonate minerals, has great potential. Different minerals can be potentially used for the immobilisation of carbon dioxide. The ultramafic rocks have been identified as the most suitable rock media. However, they are rather rare and can only provide limited reserves for CO2 sequestration. Alternatively, serpentinite rocks are abundant in the world and can serve for the immobilisation of CO2. The large serpentinite province was mapped in the Palaeoproterozoic crystalline basement of southern Lith- uania. Serpentinites associate with high-quality iron ore, which provides the opportunity for the cascade utilisation of these for- mations. The volume of the serpentinites in the largest Varena Iron Ore Deposit is estimated to be as large as 1-2 Gt. Consequently, the sequestration potential is evaluated to be as high as 0.5-1 Gt. It is equal to 200-500 years of CO2 production by the major south- eastern Lithuanian carbon dioxide emission cluster. The other serpentinite bodies identified in south-eastern Lithuania are much smaller. Assuming the total capacity of the rest objects is roughly equal to the Varena Iron Ore Deposit, they provide large potential for the mineral sequestration of carbon dioxide. However, one of the major problems in using rock material for CO 2 immobilisation is related to the volume of resources used and waste created. Also, logistical Issues of transporting CO2 to the location of serpentinite deposits can be a serious hurdle. As a result, these technologies, compared to e.g. hydrodynamic trapping in saline aquifers, are rather immature and need considerable development. The main prospective structures and serpentinite deposits are shown in Figure 5. 9 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION FIGURE 5: MAIN PROMISING GEOLOGICAL STRUCTURES AND SERPENTINITE DEPOSITS. Source: Feasibility study. Carbon capture, transport and storage in geological formations, taking the provisions of the draft Directive, 2008, UAB Cowi Baltic and UAB Krige Investicija into account. 10 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 3. Description of implemented and planned projects As of writing this report, the injection and storage of carbon dioxide in natural and artificial underground cavities and aquifers is prohibited within the depths of the earth in Lithuania (small-scale projects, up to 10 thousand tonnes of CO2 are allowed). (See 4. Legislation and regulation relevant for CCS deployment). Because of this, key stakeholders are holding back on planning CCS-related projects. Transportation of carbon dioxide to storage locations outside of Lithuania is permitted, but logistical costs and geographical challenges exist as the major emitters would need transportation for large amounts of CO 2 and the only viable option is transporting by ship. So, hypothetical discussions are taking place concerning CCS, but without restoring the legal ability to develop the storage aspect of the CCS sector, these discussions will not be realised as active projects within Lithuania. Currently, several companies have shown an interest or taken part in steps for pre-feasibility study evaluations. This allows for small- scale calculations and experiments which do not come at a large cost. One concrete example of this interest - Klaipedos nafta (KN), Larvik Shipping (LS), and Mitsui O.S.K. Lines (MOL) will carry out a feasibility study for a liquefied CO2 and hydrogen project in Klaipeda, Lithuania. KN, LS and MOL acknowledge the potential of CCUS and have reached an agreement to develop liquefied CO2 (LCO2) loading facilities at KN’s existing infrastructure in Klaipeda, Lithuania. The overall vision is to develop an LCO2 logistics and value chain from Lithuania and potentially the Baltic region with the seaport of Klaipeda at the centre. The main task of the feasibility study will be to identify an optimal configuration to export CO2 to one or more sequestration facilities within Europe. It also includes the pos- sibility to produce blue hydrogen as an important and necessary solution to reach a zero emissions economy. Full list of stakeholders and their positions can be found in section 2 of chapter 2 (see 2. Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU). 4. Legislation and Regulation Relevant for CCS Deployment Title of legislative Relevance to CCS/CCU document Law of Depths of the The legal landscape of CCS deployment in Lithuania currently has a significant discrepancy. First, the Earth and CO2 Storage Law on Geological Storage of Carbon4 establishes the rights, duties and responsibilities of persons in the exploration, transportation of CO2, use and closure of geological storage facilities for CO2, state management of geological storage of carbon dioxide, selection of geological storage facilities for car- bon dioxide, permits for the storage of carbon dioxide in the territory of the Republic of Lithuania. It also provides legal requirements for the conditions of issuance, renewal and cancellation in the Lithu- anian exclusive economic zone and the continental shelf, obligations related to the operation, closure and post-closure of the geological storage of carbon dioxide, as well as dispute settlement and inter- national cooperation procedures. Secondly, Chapter IV of the Law on the Depths of the Earth 5 provides guidelines for the use of the resources of the Earth's depths and cavities. However, the amendments to Article 14 of this Chapter, introduced in 2019, stipulate that the introduction and/or storage of carbon dioxide in natural and/or artificial subsoil cavities and/or aquifers is outright prohibited. In the same Article it is also prohibited to use natural underground cavities for the disposal and/or storage of waste, radioactive and hazard- ous to human health and the environment, waste from the extractive industries, except for the return of brine extracted during exploration and/or exploitation to the same hydrocarbon tank subsoil. This results in the Law on the Depths of the Earth effectively renouncing the possibility of geological storage of carbon. 4 https://e-seimas.lrs.lt/portal/legalAct/lt/TAD/TAIS.403288 5 https://e-seimas.lrs.lt/portal/legalAct/lt/TAD/TAIS.19879/asr 11 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Title of legislative Relevance to CCS/CCU document National Climate Plan Use of hydrogen in energy, industry and transport is an additional promising area for the development of energy innovations and the use of energy competencies, research and experimental development results in other areas of the economy, including the promotion of export growth and the development of new businesses in the country. The European Innovation Fund will provide more than € 10 billion in support in five strategic areas between 2020 and 2030, two of which are directly related to CO2 storage. Comprehensive Plan of In the context of the EU's climate change and energy policy set out in Directive 2009/31/EC on the the Territory of the implementation of geological storage of carbon dioxide, Lithuania should continue to assess the con- Republic of Lithuania ditions and prospects for CO2 capture, transport and geological storage, focussing on the supercritical site and alternative geological storage technologies and opportunities. The territory of the supercritical state is marked in the drawing Complex infrastructure and reservation of territories for the needs of the state. Despite this statement being in the Comprehensive plan, current research on the depths of the Earth is mostly prohibited, unless it does not intrude on the various cavities and formations under- ground. Conclusions The geological and legal landscape seems fitting for CCS, but certain articles in the Law on the Depths of the Earth have forbidden CO2 storage underground. Experiments and tests in small amounts are permitted, but the results of these cannot provide relevant or useful results to stakeholders who would be interested in CCS. Transportation is legal and regulated by the law on CO2 storage and other general transportation and safety requirements. 12 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Chapter 2. Lithuania's outlook for CCS and CCU This chapter will capture the CCU and CCS landscape in the target country, as per the Country Template guidance document (Theme 2, section 1). It will be informed by background research and expert insights from targeted stakeholders. 1. Summary of stakeholder engagement 14 stakeholder representatives were approached and engaged mainly through interviews and also seminars and workshops. Two academic (a), three public (b) and nine industry (c) representatives were engaged. These were chosen based on: their impact on (a) research done in theory and in practice, their current emissions, relevance and interest in reducing CO 2 emissions (b) and, finally, on the impact of (c) the approached institutions on discourse concerning CCS/CCU. The full list of engaged stakeholders: • Achema - one of the top 5 companies by industry emissions. Produces nitrogen fertilisers and assorted chemical products; • Akmenės cementas - one of the top 5 companies by industry emissions. Produces cement and related products; • District heating association - a voluntary public organisation that represents the interests and rights of the Lithuanian Dis- trict Heat utilities, organisations and other associated energy structures in the district heating sector; • Fortum Lietuva - one of the top 5 companies by industry emissions. Generates heat and electricity using sorted municipal and industrial waste; • Ignitis - Ignitis is the largest supplier of electricity and gas in Lithuania; • Klaipėdos nafta is an oil and liquefied natural gas terminal operator based in Klaipėda, Lithuania; • Kaunas university of Technology is one of the leading universities in Lithuania, with specialisations primarily in engineering, technologies and physical sciences; • Lithuanian Geology Survey - this institution, which organisationally is under the Ministry of Environment, is a state institu- tion intended for the investigation of underground regulation, its use and protection; • Minijos nafta - the primary activity of the Lithuanian and Danish joint venture Minijos Nafta is oil extraction; • Ministry of energy oversees government policy in fuel, electricity, thermo-energy production and supply for Lithuania's economy; • Ministry of environment oversees the environment and natural resources in Lithuania; • The State Scientific Institute Nature Research Centre is a public legal entity operating as a state budget institution and performing long-term research and experimental (social and cultural) development activities according to research trends established in the Articles of Association of the Nature Research Centre and significant for the state, society, international communication and business; • Orlen Lietuva is one of the top 5 companies by industry emissions. Orlen Lietuva is an oil refining company; • VIlniaus šilumos tinklai is one of the top 5 companies by industry emissions. This company is Lithuania's largest provider of heating and hot water. 13 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 2. Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU The aforementioned stakeholders were engaged in interviews, asking them about CCS/CCU. All stakeholders acknowledged that CCS in Lithuania is underdeveloped due to the restrictions on storing carbon dioxide underground. Companies that are the largest emit- ters or whose technological processes cannot forgo emitting CO2 (like cement manufacturing) noted that they would be highly inter- ested if the financial conditions permitted continuing with CCS development. There is also academic interest in CCS from a govern- mental research organisation (Nature research centre) and from a university (Kaunas Technology university). Detailed stakeholder positions can be found in Table 3 (See Table 3: Positions of stakeholders in Lithuania on ccs and ccu). TABLE 3: POSITIONS OF STAKEHOLDERS IN LITHUANIA ON CCS AND CCU STAKEHOLDER POSITION ROLE ACADEMIC INSTITUTIONS Nature research centreExperts from the research centre see their role as an advisory and informational Fence-sitter partner to other institutions as at the current moment they are unable to perform scale-relevant research due to restrictions on CCS. The research centre has had experience in the past collaborating with scientists from other companies and various institutions in Europe - they noticed interest from large companies such as Klaipėdos Nafta with regard to the possibilities of developing the CCS sector in Lithuania. Kaunas Technology While KTU does not have extensive research into CCS/CCU, previous research Fence-sitter university (KTU) not only shows potential for geological storage, but also for combining CO2 with serpentinite, which could produce a carbonate that can be used for road infrastructure. The feasibility of this option, as with other relevant options in Lithuania, depends highly on the infrastructure for CO2 transportation. INDUSTRY REPRESENTATION Achema Being the largest emitter in Lithuania, Achema has always analysed and looked Pace-setter at the possibilities of reducing their carbon footprint. Currently, Achema seeks this by offsetting activities and providing a part of CO2 emissions to the local beverage industry. Around 3.3% of Achema's yearly emissions (1.5 M tonnes of CO2) are turned over to beverage producers. Current ETS carbon prices (EUR 50 per tonne) are not sufficient (based on their previous calculations) to push Achema into developing CCS and CCU solutions. Despite this, Achema is collaborating with KTU and are looking into CCU options - creating products to be used in construction or related sectors. Achema is more inclined to possibly create new products with CCU, but CCS abroad is also a possibility they are willing to investigate. Akmenės cementas The main cement producer in Lithuania does not currently see an opportunity Fence-sitter for CCS for several reasons. First, current capture technologies are not well-es- tablished in Akmenės cementas and they require more information and best practice examples. Secondly, transportation and storage costs outside of Lithua- nia might be too much of a financial burden. Finally, as storing CO 2 in Lithuania is forbidden, the best option would be utilising it to create new products, but they are not yet sure of CCU potential. Orlen Lietuva Orlen group has prepared a strategy that foresees becoming climate neutral by Fence-sitter 2050 through CO2 capture or offsetting measures. Orlen Lietuva are currently looking at the financial and logistic opportunities of CO2 capture and transportation offshore, with the most likely destination being Norway. Taking the amount of time needed for large-scale changes in their industrial line into consideration, Orlen Lietuva would install carbon capture technologies in around 2027 when their machinery is under general repair. 14 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Vilniaus Šilumos tinklai Vilnius heating networks does not have a direct interest in CCS/CCU as by 2030 Fence-sitter (Vilnius heating the company is planning to phase out gas through switching to biofuel and networks) lowering of temperature (from 110 oC to 65 oC or so) in the system, harvesting excess heat from industrial users in Vilnius, and introducing heat accumulation devices and heat pumps. The prerequisite for this transformation is a significant renovation of apartment housing. Worst-insulated houses require large temperatures and consume disproportionally large amounts of energy during the coldest days. By 2040 the company foresees that biomass will be phased out in favour of electricity for two reasons. The first one - EU taxonomy directive, that will potentially remove CO2 exception for biomass. Second reason - use of electricity will lower the temperature in the system even more and electricity (heat pumps) can be equivalently efficient and even easier to maintain the energy source. Criteria for success in this scenario is LT implementing its climate goals and a fully renovated housing stock. Fortum Lietuva Fortum Lietuva has gained insight from their group counterparts in Norway, Pace-setter Oslo, who have enacted pilot projects capturing CO2. Based on those projects, Fortum Lietuva would be inclined to conduct their own pilot projects and they would help determine the most appropriate CO2 capture technology, since the waste produced in Lithuania is quite different from Norway. Overall, Fortum Lie- tuva would be inclined to be a first mover in the CC market, but they do not see this as financially feasible in the current situation. Their pilot project would re- quire extensive investments, so they will either receive governmental support or wait for the price of carbon to reach $ 100 per tonne. Ignitis Ignitis has two main options for becoming carbon neutral: to stop burning fuels Pace-setter that emit GHG, or to catch the CO2 that their fuel emits. Currently, the ETS price of carbon is not high enough to merit large-scale actions, so they are considering small pilot projects with specific power stations and collecting data about the costs of carbon capture, evaluating the costs of carbon transportation and possi- ble shipment to CO2 storage sites. District heating In Lithuania most of the heat is produced from biomass, and if renovation will Fence-sitter association move forward, there will be far less consumption peaks and it is reasonable to expect gas usage (main C02 emission source) to be below 5% of total heating en- ergy, and below 10% if conservative predictions are made. CO2 from biomass is only relevant as the transportation of biomass consumes non-renewable fuels, but the actual burning of wood is not a problem as it is considered CO2 neutral and will remain as such. District heating companies will not do anything about capturing this CO2. The only municipality that currently has any significant emis- sions is Vilnius. Minijos nafta The company is interested in conducting research into carbon storage, but the Pace-setter current legal regulations do not allow one to use volumes of CO2 that would provide meaningful results for this company. Minijos nafta also evaluates that their oil reserves are depleting and having the possibility to use CO 2 for enhanced oil recovery could help in prolonging their activity. Klaipėdos nafta The company is interested in CO2 capture, storage and utilisation and actively Pace-setter seeks opportunities to use its terminal infrastructure to diversify their portfolio and load more liquid energy-related products, including liquified CO2. They have been talking with main CO2 emitters, which are Orlen Lietuva, Akmenės cementas, and Achema, about collaboration in the CO2 transporting topic. Klaipėdos nafta has an active feasibility study that looks into transporting CO2, with a partner company that is “one of the main CO2 emitters in the country”. Based on current CO2 emissions, there are probably 3 potential clients that they could feasibly cater to. Does not see any breakthroughs regarding allowing CO2 storage underground in Lithuania, mainly looking into the stance of government 15 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION institutions. Also interested in hydrogen transportation, which for them will likely be a more lucrative business. PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS Ministry of environment Representatives from the ministry stated that the current legal base determines Foot-dragger their low involvement in CCS. Considering changes in the relevant laws, the ministry does not see themselves as agenda setters and are not proactive in raising the discussion about CCS. Ministry of energy Representatives from the ministry stated an interest in hydrogen, which is Pace-setter reiterated In the National Climate Action plan and National Energy Independence strategy. Considering hydrogen as a prospective resource, the ministry sees the need of CCS as a key component in delivering clean hydrogen, which Is seen as a 'green' fuel. CCS can help to reduce the carbon emissions of processes that manufacture hydrogen as a usable resource, i.e. store the CO2 from the reforming process of natural gas. The ministry is willing to start discussions among key stakeholders in small-scale discussions, workshops and seminars. Lithuanian geology The geology service sees the ban on CCS as a disservice to their research and Pace-setter service possibilities for business to reduce their CO2 emissions. If the possibility were to return, they would conduct research projects on the prospects and capabilities of CCS in Lithuania. Concerning the safety and risks of CCS, the representatives from the service see them as minimal taking the geological structure in Lithuania into account. 3. In-depth stakeholder perceptions of the CCU and CCS landscape 3.1. Overall prospects for CCU/CCS in target country Overall prospects for CCU/CCS are high in Lithuania, as the main emitters have shown confidence that they could transform their main activities and both capture and store the CO2. CCS is viewed with hesitance by main actors in Lithuania due to the legal situation and a lack of commercial business cases. CCU is less known and accentuated during the interviews. 3.2. The role of CCU/CCS in sector integration CCU/CCS has the potential to integrate a qualified majority of companies that emit the highest amounts of CO 2. This integration can be realised through common projects storing, transporting or utilising captured CO2. 3.3. Awareness of EU policy and financial instruments for CCU/CCS Several stakeholders commented about foreign companies or public institutions who relayed that there are various financing possi- bilities, especially considering the European Green Deal and projects related to carbon neutrality. Certain aspects in EU policy are not fully understood or disclosed (EU Taxonomy), so their final effect on CCU/CCS is to be determined. 3.4. Perceived deployment barriers and risks The largest hurdle is the transportation cost of CO2, which also has the additional issue of requiring a substantial amount of local storage. Another challenge is for each company to decide on and choose specific carbon capture technologies for each specific sector - currently some companies can draw from knowledge that their counterparts in other countries have gained (Fortum) and others can look at sectoral examples that are essentially identical in terms of industrial processes (Akmenės cementas). 16 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 4. Stakeholder recommendations for CCU/CCS 4.1. Regulation The first and most important aspect for change in the legal landscape is the backtracking of the 2019 prohibition of CO2 storage. Besides this one redaction, other laws and regulations are equipped to handle CCS and CCU developments. For this reason, several stakeholders did not see much need for enabling storage in Lithuania, as there are enough possibilities to store CO 2 outside Lithuania or propagating CCU solutions. 4.2. Technology Two main technologies need development or government support: specific CO2 capture devices and chain of transportation for CO2. Different emissions structures within different industries require in-depth knowledge concerning different methods of capturing car- bon. While some companies may just wait and see what others use, the major industry companies will be more inclined to perform small-scale pilot projects and find the best technology for their own needs. The cost of transporting carbon is also a major issue, since carrying carbon over long distances requires significant infrastructure investment and storing it onshore before shipment requires terminal utilities. 4.3. Infrastructure Currently, no widely used infrastructure for CCS/CCU or even CO2 transportation is implemented in Lithuania. Achema has stated that they have the capabilities to capture CO2, but only 3% of it is utilised by the beverage industry. The most pertinent infrastructure questions surround CO2 transportation, since the most likely outcome is that the major emitters in Lithuania will export their captured CO2. State involvement in establishing CO2 transportation Infrastructure would provide incentives for private companies to go for- ward with CCS/CCU projects. 4.4. Market The most pertinent question for the CCS/CCU market is the ETS allowance price per tonne of CO2. Currently (at the time of writing) the price of one tonne is EUR 536. Several industry stakeholders have stated that this price is not yet enough to start moving towards CCS/CCU, but a price closer to EUR 100 per tonne would mandate them to take action. It is important to note that CCS chain devel- opment takes at least 5 years, so to avoid substantive financial costs due to CO 2 emissions, governments and key companies that would benefit from CCS should think ahead and prepare for the price of carbon to reach the critical mark of EUR 100 per tonne. 4.5. Financial frameworks Financial frameworks and grants for pilot projects would incentivise companies to prioritise carbon capture on their agenda. The EU's Taxonomy initiative might be one of these options: The EU taxonomy is a classification system, establishing a list of environmentally sustainable economic activities7. This system is an important enabler to scale up sustainable investment and to implement the Euro- pean Green Deal. Notably, by providing appropriate definitions to companies, investors and policymakers on which economic activi- ties can be considered environmentally sustainable, it is expected to create security for investors, and protect private investors from greenwashing, help companies to plan the transition, mitigate market fragmentation and eventually help shift investments where they are most needed. CCS/CCU could be one of the activities that are classified as a part of the EU taxonomy. 4.6. Inter-sectoral and regional collaboration 6 https://ember-climate.org/data/carbon-price-viewer/ 7 https://ec.europa.eu/info/business-economy-euro/banking-and-finance/sustainable-finance/eu-taxonomy-sustainable-activities_en 17 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Different types of collaboration would have an impact on CCS/CCU: regional collaboration can help with the dissemination of scien- tific research and possible benefits of CCS/CCU, while Inter-sectoral collaboration can help reduce the risks and costs of implementing projects related to CCS/CCU. 4.7. Social aspects CCU/CCS deployment requires the active public participation of scientists and experts. Communication of factual data and results of research could help disseminate realistic information, not personal opinion. This could help in showing the benefit of CCS/CCU to business, climate and local communities. Conclusions Currently, CCS/CCU in Lithuania has few prospects due to the legal changes in recent years. This is countered by timid hope from various stakeholders that this might change. In any case, stakeholders from the side of industry have taken into account the fact that carbon capture is unavoidable in the future and some of them have preliminarily evaluated the possible costs of transporting CO2 offshore (i.e. the North Sea). CCU is another option that keeps stakeholder's hopeful of reaching a financially viable way of capturing carbon, even though the actual effectiveness in emission reduction is not yet fully known and the detriments of different CCU pro- cesses might even be worse for the climate but in separate ways. 18 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Chapter 3. CCS and CCU: Public ac- ceptance in Lithuania Public acceptance of CCS and CCU in Lithuania was mostly formed by statements of public officials, especially ones that overstated the negative aspects, thus causing the public to get agitated without even analysing any factual Information. Thus, the overall aware- ness of the public on the topics of CCS and CCU is limited at best and negatively skewed at worst. One of the three most CO2-emitting companies have made public statements about the future and possible use of CCS/CCU. “Com- pared to 1990, we have achieved 25% lower CO2 emissions, they have decreased from 3 million to 0.8 million tonnes. All of our previous investments in new technologies have focused on this. We are now preparing for the second step. We will abandon the use of fossil fuels - coal - as much as possible, we will replace it with an alternative, so that by 2030 we will reduce emissions by 55%. This is not easy and will require large investments - we hope that we may have the opportunity to use the DNA (Deoxyribonucleic acid) Plan of the Future Economy or the Fair Transformation Fund.” says Artūras Zaremba, CEO of the cement production company Ak- menės cementas8. In the next three years, Akmenės Cementas will be able to abandon fossil fuels and replace them with alternative ones at a cost of about EUR 15-20 million. However, these investments will not determine everything. Fuels account for about 40% of total CO 2 emis- sions, with the remaining 60% being from raw materials. Limestone emits carbon dioxide when exposed to high temperatures. And there is nothing to change in the production of limestone cement yet. "By 2050, we will have to achieve zero CO2 emissions. The technology (CCS) is there, but it is not very widespread - in Europe, the new technology is currently being installed in one factory, apparently with the support of the Norwegian government. Then we will see how this technology works,” says the head of the company9. Doubts about CCS have been put forward both by institutional representatives and NGO's. The former minister of environment has stated10 that: "Landfilling of carbon dioxide is a rather dubious project. (...) If scientists emphasise that CO2 buried in the ground can cause additional problems due to carbonation, acidification, other chemical reactions, and knowing that Lithuania's groundwater resources are huge, the threat to groundwater resources and quality is really in first place.” Several members of parliament expressed their concerns publicly, showing doubt about the benefit of CCS and deliberated about alternative costs11: “Today, the territories of western Lithuania are rich in geothermal water, which can be successfully applied in various areas in the future, but by turning these territories into landfill storage, we prevent any other innovations. With the installa- tion of carbon storage in these areas, in order not to damage the tightness of the storage, we could hardly extract oil further in the deeper layers of the earth.” Fear about the safety of underground water reserves was a resounding argument amongst the propo- nents of forbidding CCU/CCS, with some suggesting that storing CO2 would be carried out as deep as underground water reserves are found, and this could cause harm to these reserves12. 8 https://www.vz.lt/pramone/2020/12/08/akmenes-cementas-nulines-tarsos-kaina&template=api_article 9 Ibid. 10 https://www.vz.lt/pramone/energetika/2019/07/04/k-mazeika-co2-laidojimas-zemeje-keltu-gresme-vandens-istekliams 11 https://www.delfi.lt/news/ringas/politics/kestutis-bacvinka-ar-lietuva-paversime-co2-saugykla.d?id=82257543 12 https://www.lrt.lt/naujienos/verslas/4/1105669/draudimas-zemes-gelmese-laidoti-anglies-dioksida-vieni-mato-pavoju-kiti-pasiusta-neigiama- zinia-verslui 19 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION In the discussion surrounding CCS doubts were raised about the relevance of CO2 in global warming. Concerns were raised due to the lack of scientific research13: "This is a matter for one firm or private individual. The plans that are being drawn up and made with the aim of reducing emissions are too optimistic. But no scientist has yet answered whether the increase in CO 2 is due to rising global temperatures or whether rising temperatures are due to rising CO2. There is a fundamental question here, but there is no answer.” These doubts are renounced by most major climate change institutions, academic circles, and various multilateral organisations. Amidst the discussion about the safety and necessity of CCS, some politicians saw possible private interests being put ahead of public interests. This was over a feasibility study for a new gas-fired power plant in Lithuania. The use of so-called zero-emission technologies in a 300 MW gas-fired power plant were being considered, i.e. the CO 2 captured would be buried in the depths of the earth rather than released into the atmosphere, thus avoiding huge pollution charges. But after Seimas passed amendments to the law restricting the use of CCS technologies in Lithuania, American investors were forced to bury their plans and retreat from their planned projects. Public organisations and non-profits related to circular (or green) economy idea propagation criticise industrial companies for not paying enough to offset the damage they enact on the environment 14. This is further strengthened with comparisons of taxes paid per tonne of CO2, showing that the largest polluters pay significantly less taxes than the effect their emitted CO2 has on the environ- ment. Provided demands or, rather, recommendations are to use fewer polluting fuels or exchange the produced products into more sustainable alternatives. Conclusion As of writing this report, public awareness and the public image of CCS/CCU technology in Lithuania is not favourable. This is in part due to statements of public figures that were widely deliberated, and the opinions of researchers and geologists were pushed to the sidelines. No research or surveys have been conducted on this specific topic and the interviewed stakeholders also expressed that public discourse regarding CCS/CCU is lacking. Looking at the context of legal changes in 2019, public acceptance of CCS/CCU was formed in a negative manner due to the communication of several actors that tried to accentuate risks and problems with related technology and projects. However, both the increasing activity of industry leaders and the EU’s agenda on transitioning to a carbon- neutral economy will surely increase the flow of information from multilateral sources. As a result, both discussions and possible project implementations should have a more nuanced evaluation in terms of public acceptance. This can be best done together with academic and research personnel that have long-term experience in topics of CCS/CCU (Nature Research centre, Lithuanian Geology service) and industry leaders who plan to be pace-setters of CCS development in the region. 13 Ibid. 14 http://www.circulareconomy.lt/10-daugiausiai-prie-klimato-kaitos-prisidedanciu-imoniu-lietuvoje- 2020/?fbclid=IwAR3PvBHXHEUqW7HKqGMXF5Hzzdd8sR0AH7aY0gwIhE_hOw8nz7g59xvAhxY 20 THE BUILDING MOMENTUM The Building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT CEE region project is funded by Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway IN THE CEE REGION through the EEA and Norway Grants Fund for Regional Cooperation. 21 The Building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the CEE region project is funded by Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway through the EEA BUILDING MOMENTUM and Norway Grants Fund for Regional Cooperation. FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Ba o doda Assessment of current state, past experiences and potential for CCS deployment in the CEE region UKRAINE Civitta Ukraine BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Table of contents Glossary ............................................................................................................................................................................ 4 Disclaimer ........................................................................................................................................................................ 5 Chapter 1. CCS and CCU: current state and past experiences in Ukraine .................................................... 6 1. Description of relevant domestic economic sectors ............................................................................... 6 1.1. Carbon-intensive sectors of the Ukrainian economy ........................................................................... 9 1.2. Major CO2 emitters in Ukraine ................................................................................................................. 15 2. Assessment of geological potential for CCS ........................................................................................... 16 2.1. General Information ................................................................................................................................... 16 2.2. Geological formations fit for CO2 storage ............................................................................................ 17 3. Description of implemented and planned projects ............................................................................... 18 4. Legislation and regulation relevant for CCS deployment ................................................................... 19 4.1. CCS/CCU deployment regulation ............................................................................................................ 19 4.2. National strategy of low-carbon economy development ................................................................. 19 4.3. Nationally determined contribution ....................................................................................................... 19 4.4. National emission reduction plan of major pollutants from large combustion plants ............ 19 4.5. Technical regulation of gas in the transmission system ................................................................... 20 4.6. CCS in strategies of State-owned enterprises (SOEs) (Naftogaz) .................................................. 20 Chapter 2. Ukraine’s outlook for CCS and CCU .................................................................................................. 21 1. Summary of stakeholder engagement ..................................................................................................... 21 2. Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU ................................................................................................... 21 3. In-depth stakeholder perceptions of the CCU and CCS landscape .................................................. 23 4. Stakeholder recommendations for CCU/CCS ......................................................................................... 24 Chapter 3. CCS and CCU: Public acceptance in Ukraine .................................................................................. 26 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Glossary CBAM Carbon border adjustment mechanism CCS Carbon capture and storage CCU Carbon capture and usage CEE Central and Eastern Europe CHP Combined heat and power CO2-eq Carbon dioxide equivalent ETS Emission trading system GDP Gross domestic product GHG Greenhouse gas SOE State-owned enterprise TPP Thermal power plant BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Disclaimer This report brings a comprehensive analysis of the situation in Ukraine regarding the existing situation, past experiences, and po- tential for CCS deployment till October 2021. From February 2022, the Russian invasion in Ukraine has left a heavy, lasting and, for now, fully unpredictable impact on the situation in Ukraine in all areas of life, including the aspects described in this report. Thus, it is clear that this war and its consequences will have a strong impact on the situation described further in this report. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Chapter 1. CCS and CCU: current state and past experiences in Ukraine 1. Description of relevant domestic economic sectors Industry accounts for almost 30% of Ukraine's GDP (gross domestic product) and is a key source of foreign exchange earnings. The production and export structure are dominated by goods with a low level of processing: materials and semi-finished products which are highly energy intensive. The key groups of process manufacturing are the alloys and chemical industry. During the last 30 years their share has decreased due to the decline in global demand and the presence of competitors with much lower production costs. The introduction of new tariff and non-tariff restrictions, including the CBAM (Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism) in the EU places additional pressure on producers through the carbon footprint of each product. Ukrainian companies are expected to lose a significant share of export to the EU if they are not able to modernise from a mid-term perspective. Modernisation implies a signifi- cant number of investments and there is a lack of legally established public financial instruments in Ukraine to support the environ- mental modernisation of business. There is also no regulation in Ukraine of waste trade, exchange of emission quotas and other instruments that are popular in other countries. Industry can be divided into two key blocks: mining and process manufacturing. The mining industry accounts for 6.6% of Ukraine's GDP, while the processing industry accounts for more than 22%. The processing industry, in turn, can be divided into metallurgy, mechanical engineering, chemical industry, construction materials production, light industry, food industry, woodworking and other sectors. From 1990 to 2019, industrial production in Ukraine decreased significantly in all key product groups due to the collapse of the USSR that led to the breaking of strong trade and production ties between Soviet countries. For example, steel production in 2019 was only 39.6% of 1990 production, and similarly, the figure for cement in 2019 was 42.6% of 1990 values. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION FIGURE 1.1. DYNAMICS OF PRODUCT OUTPUT VOLUME IN 1990-2019, KILOTONS, STATE SERVICE FOR STATISTICS OF UKRAINE The financial crises, weak trade position, as well as a lack of transparency in the privatisation process, are factors that led to the further decline of the industries. In addition, constantly changing policy and government incentives forced companies to continue with the old technologies and use the advantages of a cheap workforce and relatively cheap energy resources, which resulted in low energy efficiency in the production process. However, in some categories, production is showing recovery. The production of nitric acid from 2015 to 2019 increased by 33% as Ukraine ceased the import of Russian fertilisers and most current agricultural companies made a shift to Ukrainian fertilisers. In addition, the improved access to capital for small agricultural producers and farmers has improved, which resulted in a 7% annual growth of fertiliser consumption over the period of 2016-2019. The cement industry showed 8.6% growth over 2015-2019 as the government started a programme of building renovation. FIGURE 1.2. DYNAMICS OF GDP AND GHG EMISSIONS OF UKRAINE IN 1990-2030, CENTRE FOR ECONOMIC RECOVERY According to the National Economic Strategy of Ukraine 2030, the growth of the industrial sector will accelerate in the coming years. Although the largest increase is in the low-carbon sectors (services, IT, engineering), relatively rapid growth is expected in steel (about BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 3.5% per year based on global demand and the forecast of the demand on the global market, driven by the energy infrastructure modernisation that is expected to increase from 2021 due to the Regulatory Asset Base (RAB) tariff being introduced in 2020. The cement industry is expected to grow at a rate of 5-8% annually according to the government plans for the active renovation of buildings until 2030. FIGURE 1.3. MAIN INDUSTRIAL-EMITTERS CO2-EQ It is important to consider the overall dynamics of greenhouse gas emissions in Ukraine. Over the last 30 years, greenhouse gas emissions in the industrial sector have decreased by 66%. However, it should be noted that the general trend involves several cycles of growth (1995-2007, 2009-2011, 2017 so far). Such cycles are firmly tied to the industry growth rate. Given the projected growth of such rates in the coming years, greenhouse gas emissions will also increase. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION FIGURE 1.4. DYNAMICS OF GHG EMISSIONS FROM PROCESSING INDUSTRIES IN UKRAINE, KT CO-EQ 1.1. Carbon-intensive sectors of the Ukrainian economy ENERGY GENERATION Energy (heat and electricity) generation is the biggest sector, generating over 50 million tonnes of CO2 from electricity generation and almost 40 million tonnes of CO2 from heat generation in 2019. Transition from coal and the increase in renewable energy gener- ation in the energy mix will lead to a decrease in CO2 emissions by 2030 of up to 77 million tonnes of CO2. FIGURE 1.5. GHG EMISSIONS FROM ENERGY AND HEAT GENERATION IN THE UKRAINE, 1990-2030, UKRAINE’S GREENHOUSE GAS NATIONAL INVENTORY REPORT, 2019 BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION METAL PRODUCTION Metal production is one of the main sources of greenhouse gas emissions in Ukraine. It is estimated that in 2020 the share of this sector in the overall structure of emissions from processing was almost 71%. The chemical industry (11.3%) and the production of non-metallic minerals (14.3%) make a significant contribution to the overall structure of emissions. Among the latter, cement plays a key part (accounting for 8% of emissions and its share will gradually increase), as well as the production of lime and glass materials. FIGURE 1.6. STRUCTURE OF CO2 EMISSIONS IN UKRAINE GENERATED FROM DIRECT AND INDIRECT EMISSIONS BY SECTOR (PROCESSING INDUS- TRIES), 2020 (ESTIMATED), UKRAINE’S GREENHOUSE GAS NATIONAL INVENTORY, 2019 Although Ukraine does not currently have a single project using CCS (carbon capture and storage) or CCU (carbon capture and utili- sation) technologies, many industries are already considering this option from a medium- or long-term perspective. Several large Ukrainian companies, both state-owned and privately owned (e.g., DTEK, Naftogaz, ArcelorMittal, etc.) have published their strate- gies to become carbon neutral by 2040-2050. Given the specificities of production, energy efficiency, technology and renewable energy cannot fully meet these goals. This means that companies are already considering carbon storage or utilisation technologies, mostly gas production companies, thermal power plant operators and metallurgy producers. The major industrial producers are in the eastern part of Ukraine and are at a reasonable distance from potential CO2 storage facilities. Companies such as Naftogaz and Arcelor Mittal have indicated a strong interest in CCS and CCU technologies as part of the strategy that will ensure carbon-neutrality. At the same time, it is necessary to consider the factors that hinder the development and introduction of such technologies in Ukraine. First, we are talking about the low profitability of technologies for Ukrainian industry. High costs, as well as a lack of financial incentives and available alternatives reduce the interest of companies. However, this is not a feature of Ukraine alone. These factors indicate that CCS/CCU technologies may be of interest to large companies in some industries in the long run. We will consider these sectors separately in the next section. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION CRUDE OIL AND NATURAL GAS PRODUCTION Sector description: Ukraine has low oil production, but a significant and promising natural gas production industry. Annual natural gas production is about 21 billion cubic metres, and a positive development scenario shows an increase in production to 30 billion cubic metres by 2030. The production potential is about 780 billion cubic metres. Almost 80% of natural gas production is extracted by the SOE (state-owned company) Naftogaz. TABLE 1.1. CO2 EMISSIONS, NATURAL GAS AND OIL PRODUCTION, UKRAINE’S GREENHOUSE GAS NATIONAL INVENTORY, 2019 1990 1995 2003 2005 2010 2015 2019 1990-2019 2015-2019 3023.8 2013.8 1932.4 2259.2 2144.9 2132.5 2138.8 -30% +0% CCS/CCU potential: The introduction of new restrictions on the purity of natural gas during its supply to the gas transmission system is currently being discussed. The new rules will provide for a much higher degree of purification, including from CO 2. This presumes a change in CO2 emissions within the gas processing industry – most of the CO2 will be extracted before entering the gas transmission system. As such emissions also mean additional carbon taxes for producers, and companies are considering CCS/CCU technologies. The use of carbon capture technology is simplified by the low cost of this process in the gas production industry. In addition, high territorial concentration, and the presence of large players in the market simplifies the logistics of extracted CO 2. Most of the natural gas production wells are in the Poltava region, while Naftogaz owns around 70% of the gas production market. The industry is mostly interested in carbon capture and storage technology. In the entire market, this is the only industry that really has a strong interest in using such technology in the long run. In addition, there is some potential for CCU technologies. This is mainly the case for the use of CO2 in crude oil production. However, because the amount of Ukrainian crude oil production is relatively low, the CCU potential is much smaller. Key challenges: 1. Large amounts of extracted CO2, which no one can consume. The amount of CO2 that will be extracted from gas exceeds demand by 4 times. In this case, storage is considered a strong option. 2. Lack of regulation for CCS technologies – companies are afraid of being penalised for using such technologies before any regulation of CO2 well usage. 3. Expensive infrastructure requires state investments. Even though the potential CO2 storage facilities are located within a reasonable distance from the key gas wells, transportation of CO2 is one of the key challenges as it requires significant investment in the transportation of CO2. CHEMICAL INDUSTRY Sector description: Ukraine produces a wide range of chemicals from oil refining to ammonia production. One of the key product groups is fertilisers: two-component and nitrogen. Even though the chemical industry had been demonstrating a significant decline in production, as most oil refinery production facilities were closed between 1990 and 2015, the military conflict with the Russian Federation has given a new push for the substitution of imported fertilisers with Ukrainian ones. Due to high demand from the agricultural sector, fertiliser producers are working entirely on the Ukrainian market. Over the last 5 years fertiliser consumption by the Ukrainian agricultural sector has shown a compound annual growth rate of 7%. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION FIGURE 1.7. DYNAMICS OF CO2 EMISSIONS IN THE CHEMICAL INDUSTRY OF UKRAINE, UKRAINE’S GREENHOUSE GAS NATIONAL INVENTORY, 2019 CCS/CCU potential: The chemical industry is interested in CCS/CCU technologies for two key reasons. First, the production of ammo- nia yields almost pure CO2, which can be stored directly without additional purification. Existing production chains can produce suf- ficiently concentrated CO2 at the output, and technologies to achieve a concentration of more than 95%, while capturing more than 90% is relatively cheap (in comparison to other industries). Secondly, due to the existing production processes, the use of CCU technology can continue the production chains of the chemical industry itself, in the production of biofuels for example. CCS technology, which is already planned to be used in the Russian produc- tion of nitrogen fertilisers, is also popular for the chemical industry. However, representatives of the Ukrainian chemical industry prefer other types of CO2 reduction which imply basic energy efficiency measures that lead to a lower consumption of energy per unit produced and as a result reduce the carbon footprint of the product. Industry representatives note the potential for the use of hydrogen and have their own proposals to reduce the cost of its production using renewable energy or nuclear energy. Key challenges: 1. Low profitability of CO2 processing and utilisation. 2. Cheaper and more efficient alternatives are available. ALLOYS AND METAL REFINING Sector description: Metal production is one of the important components of the Ukrainian economy. The leading place in this indus- try in Ukraine is occupied by steel production. Every year Ukraine produces about 21 million tonnes of steel, which makes it the 13th largest producer of this product in the world. Steel accounts for more than a quarter of Ukrainian exports and affects a significant part of domestic production. The decline in emissions from the metal industry of 52% since 1990 has been mostly due to a decline in production. Still, the compa- nies expect to increase the production volumes until 2030 as there is a significant demand on the internal market. At the same time, metal production is a key pollutant in Ukrainian industry. This sector accounts for more than 71% of all industrial emissions. Steel is a key pollutant among metallurgical products. Ukraine is one of the few countries that still uses open-hearth furnaces, and the num- ber of electric arc furnaces is less than 15%. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Figure 1.8. Dynamics of CO2 emissions from alloys and metal refining, Ukraine’s Greenhouse Gas National Inventory, 2019 CCS/CCU potential: Steel production is one of the key producers of greenhouse gases. Emissions in steel production are divided into two key categories: blast furnace energy and the chemical process. In the latter, CO 2 emission reductions require significant invest- ments that are not attractive based on the current regulatory framework and the environmental tax rate, so CCS/CCU technologies are of interest to the industry. International practice shows that due to the method of production and the location of steel plants, CCU is a more interesting technology than CCS. However, Ukrainian companies note that today emissions can be reduced in much cheaper and more efficient ways. Energy efficiency of the production process, as well as the issue of Scope 2 emissions (emissions that occur during the production of energy, which is then used in the further industrial process) is the key focus of industrial companies. Representatives of the industry emphasise that the modernisation of these components will be the main source of CO 2 reduction in the near future (5-10 years). The metallurgy companies expect to invest around 1.5 billion euros annually into the modernisation of the blast furnaces (improvement of the fil- tration system, blower system replacement, blow supply device replacement) and if the government will generate sufficient stimulus and a stable regulatory base for companies to consider investing in reducing the emissions of sulphur and nitric oxides and dust, through the construction of new coke batteries with additional investments of around 2.5 billion euros. In addition, the process of capturing carbon in the production of metals is somewhat more complex than in the extraction of natural gas or the chemical industry. This means significant investment in carbon capture technology. Key challenges: 1. Expensive technologies that are less profitable than alternatives. The companies consider CCS/CCU technologies as a po- tential solution after 2030. BUILDING MATERIALS (CEMENT, BRICK, MINERAL WOOL, ETC.) Sector description: The construction sector showed rapid growth between 2014 and 2018 due to delayed demand for real estate because of the 2013–2014 crisis, as well as changes in the ease of doing business in the market, which caused a significant increase in new building supply. The main changes were the simplification of the general scheme for obtaining construction permits and the BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION reduction of stages from 55 to 5, reduced time for obtaining such permits to 60 days, and the general reform of the State Architectural and Construction Inspectorate system. The share of employment in the construction sector in total is 4.2%, employing 699 thousand people. The share of the construction sector in GDP is 8% (EUR 5.2 billion). The share of construction in tax revenues is 3.1%, EUR 0.5 billion. Steady investment demand has contributed to the high growth rate of construction works in all segments. High growth rates of construction of civil engineering and non-residential buildings are caused by active funding from the state and local budgets, funds from international donors, and the funds of enterprises. A significant supply of newly built housing in previous periods and the low effective demand of the population has contributed to a gradual decline in construction. Under unstable economic conditions and exchange rate fluctuations, investors are more actively investing in economy class apart- ments. The greatest demand is for small apartments, as the number of square metres affects the total purchase price. As a result, the average area of apartments in Ukrainian newly erected buildings decreased from more than 120 square metres to almost 80 square metres in 8 years. The construction sector can become a powerful multiplier for the economy, and 1 Ukrainian hryvnia (UAH) invested in construction gives 6 UAH of GDP growth The industry creates demand for products of 5–7 related industries and stimulates the inflow of invest- ment. The growth of investment in construction can increase the annual growth rate of industrial production by 3–5% per year, due to the multiplier of housing investment. Construction of new energy efficient houses and the thermal modernisation of old ones will help reduce heat use by 30%. The state can create an additional almost 465 thousand jobs because of thermal modernisation through the creation of the institute of energy auditors and jobs in related sectors of the economy (builders, administrators, construction material producers). FIGURE 1.9. CO2 EMISSIONS, MINERAL MATERIALS, UKRAINE’S GREENHOUSE GAS NATIONAL INVENTORY, 2019 CCS/CCU potential: A high share of potential CCS/CCU projects in the EU is concentrated in the cement sector. Like steel production, cement (clinker) production creates emissions in two ways: due to energy consumption and due to the chemical reactions involved. CCS/CCU technologies are often used to capture the carbon which is released during the chemical reaction in the production process. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Ukrainian cement producers show much less interest in CCS/CCU technologies, arguing that they are inefficient. Modernisation to reduce CO2 emissions is achieved more cheaply and efficiently through more environmentally friendly energy production for the production process. Representatives of the cement industry emphasise that cement production can dispose of certain types of house- hold and industrial waste without leftovers (and with zero CO2 emissions). Prospects for the use of carbon capture technologies in the industry are low, even in the long run. Key challenges: 1. Low efficiency and high price with cheaper alternatives available. 2. High cost of CO2 transportation and storage infrastructure. 1.2. Major CO2 emitters in Ukraine In terms of greenhouse gas emissions, 3 companies, Metinvest, ArcelorMittal and ISD, account for more than 50% of all emissions. The biggest emitter is the heat and electricity generation sector, with the key emitters being the heat power plants that generate over 90 million tonnes of CO2 from electricity and heat production. The key reason for high emissions is the dominance of coal in the energy mix of heat power plants, which has a high emission factor. The emissions from heat and electricity generation are projected to decline by up to 75 million tonnes by 2030 because of the gradual phasing out of coal powered generation. 1. Centerenergo (3 Thermal Power Plants: Trypylska, Zmiivska, Vyhlehirska) – 8.2 million tonnes CO2. 2. DTEK-Shidenergo (2 Thermal Power Plants: Kurahivska, Luganska) – 10.69 million tonnes CO2. 3. DTEK-Zahidenergo (3 Thermal Power Plants: Burshtynska, Ladyzhynska, Dobrotvirska) – 15.53 million tonnes CO2. 4. DTEK-Dniproenergo (3 Thermal Power Plants: Zaporizhzka, Prydniprovska, Kryvorizhzka) – 15.9 million tonnes of CO2. The introduction of CCS/CCU technologies for Ukrainian TPPs (thermal power plants) and CHP (combined heat and power) plants is not seriously considered, as Ukraine plans to phase-out a significant number of power plants. The approved national emissions re- duction plan has a schedule for phasing out TPPs and CHP plants in Ukraine. Already in 2021, there will be a stoppage of 8 blocks of Dniprovska CHP and Khersonska CHP. A significant number of power plants will be closed by 2023 (7094 MW). Over the next period until 2033, 21245 MW of power plants will be phased out according to the plan. This is a significant challenge, as TPPs and CHP plants comprise the key balancing capacity within the Ukrainian energy system, ensuring the coverage of peaks and the deficit in winter, when renewable energy sources generate less energy. The second biggest polluters after Ukraine's thermal power plants are its ferrous metallurgy plants. The key industrial pollutant plants (and their parent companies) can be distributed as follows: 1. “Ilyich iron and steel works” (Metinvest): 2.04 million tonnes CO2. 2. “ArcelorMittal Kryvyi Rih” (ArcelorMittal): 2.35 million tonnes CO2. 3. “Azovstal iron and steel works” (Metinvest): 2.1 million tonnes CO 2. 4. “Dnieper Metallurgical Combine” (Industrial Donbas Union): 1.28 million tonnes CO2. 5. “Zaporizhstal” (Metinvest): 1.89 million tonnes CO2. 6. “Southern Mining and Processing Plant” (Metinvest): 0.65 million tonnes CO2. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION FIGURE 1.10. MAP OF THE MAIN INDUSTRIAL CO2 EMITTERS IN UKRAINE, UKRAINE’S GREENHOUSE GAS NATIONAL INVENTORY, 2019 Most metallurgy plants are in the eastern part of Ukraine and have access to a developed sea and railway infrastructure, thus enabling the opportunity to transport the CO2 from the source of emissions to the storage facility. 2. Assessment of geological potential for CCS Ukraine has several options for carbon storage. In fact, there is potential for storage by physical absorption and residual trapping mechanisms (whereas soluble absorption and mineralisation mechanisms are less likely). The reason for the greatest benefit from the first two is the potential of using natural gas wells as carbon storage methods. However, in the Donetsk basin there are Devonian saline aquifers in combination with impermeable salt deposits, which are best suited for CO2 storage in the immediate vicinity of large industrial and energy sources of CO2 emissions. There is potential for the use of deep coal seams to store carbon in the western region. 2.1. General Information In Ukraine, there are prerequisites for starting work and research projects on CCS. Depleted gas reservoirs within the eastern, western and, to a lesser extent, southern oil and gas areas should be considered as possible carbon storage sites. Rocks that have stored natural gas in their pores for millions of years can also serve for storing CO2. In addition, depleted reservoirs are already equipped with the necessary infrastructure for injection, including boreholes and pipe- lines. Also, one option to consider is the injection of CO2 into deep highly mineralised aquifers, which have a regional distribution, high filtration capacity and are reliably isolated from aquifers and oil and gas formations by regional reservoirs. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 2.2. Geological formations fit for CO2 storage According to the assessment of the State Service of Geology and Subsoil of Ukraine, of all the options for carbon storage for Ukraine, the most appropriate is the use of depleted oil and gas reservoirs. Creating wells of this type will not only be the cheapest, but most likely the safest and most scalable option. It will help to achieve the faster spread of technology without additional development costs. FIGURE 2.1. OIL AND GAS REGIONS IN UKRAINE, POTENTIAL FOR CARBON STORAGE, STATE SERVICE ON GEOLOGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES The use of depleted gas wells has several advantages: 1. The natural origin of the well with a sufficiently strong mineral cap, as well as necessary infrastructure at the site of storage. 2. Territorial proximity of the gas production basin (and potential carbon storage site) to major pollutants. 3. Existing gas transmission infrastructure (with direct access to wells) that can be used for CO2. The ability of the gas trans- mission system to transport the CO2 has not been studied. Currently, the gas transmission system operator is analysing the ability of the system to transport the hydrogen. According to estimates by the State Service of Geology and Subsoil of Ukraine, the best locations for carbon storage could be the depleted gas fields in Hlinsko-Rozbyshivsk, Novo-Hryhorsky, Sagaidatsky and Malosorochynsky. The estimated capacity of the de- pleted gas fields for CO2 storage exceeds 2.4 billion tonnes of CO2 stored. In addition, alternatives to depleted gas sources may be the use of CO2 to intensify oil production (for example, for the Myhyryn field with a complex production process) or storage in deep highly mineralised horizons that do not contain drinking water. The gas transportation system (38 550 km in total) is considered as potential infrastructure to transport CO2. Operator of the trans- mission system is currently studying the opportunity to transport the hydrogen through this system. The ability of the gas transmis- sion system to transport CO2 has not been studied. Currently, the gas transmission system operator is analysing the ability of the system to transport hydrogen, with the primary analysis results showing the opportunity to transport a mixture of gas and hydrogen with only up to 3% of hydrogen within the mix. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION The regional gas infrastructure is also currently under assessment regarding hydrogen transportation potential. The Regional Gas Company (regional gas infrastructure operators) has managed to test, and the company is planning to supply a mixture of gas and hydrogen in a test project. Additionally, Ukraine has an ammonia transportation system and Ukrainian scientists claim that the production of ammonia from hydrogen would allow one to transport more energy, as ammonia contains 3 times more energy per 1 cubic metre. Ukraine has a strong transportation system with strongly developed offshore transport, which is the cheapest form of transport (river transport is 2 times cheaper than railway transport and 4 times cheaper than road transport in Ukraine). Ukraine has 18 seaports and 11 river ports, which ensure the transhipment of over 170 million tonnes of products annually. Sea transport is strongly developed as agricultural companies and metallurgy companies export their products to European and African countries. On the other hand, river transportation has shown a decline from 60 million tonnes annually to 18 million tonnes. The key reason was due to regulation of the government-owned river ports that made the income accumulated on the balance of the parent company and not reinvested in the development of river infrastructure. This neglected investment from transportation is currently at the very beginning of recov- ery, as the regulation was established and the interest from investors rose. Over the last several years the situation has improved, as private companies started to work in the public-private partnership format and develop river infrastructure. 3. Description of implemented and planned projects There are currently no implemented or planned carbon storage projects in Ukraine. At the same time, several industries (ferrous metallurgy, gas production) are considering plans to implement carbon capture and storage projects in the long run (the strategy of ArcelorMittal implies the consideration of CCS/CCU after 2030). In July 2021, one of the biggest steel producers – Metinvest signed a memorandum of cooperation with the Austrian research centre K1-MET, which is focused on the decarbonisation of metallurgy and possesses strong expertise in CCS technologies. Cooperation will be focused on the implementation of projects that ensure a reduction in carbon footprint. In March 2021, UNECE (United Nations Economic Commission for Europe) developed the Roadmap for Hydrogen Infrastructure in Ukraine, which sees the development of CCS technologies as an opportunity to reach carbon neutrality by producing hydrogen with the usage of carbon capture technologies. The earlier research (2012-2013) of Bellona regarding the development of CCS technologies of Ukraine defined the potential CO2 storage regions in Ukraine and developed the model for CO2 transportation from production facilities to potential storage capacities in the eastern part of Ukraine. On the governmental level, during the recent visit of the President of Ukraine to the US, Ukraine established strategic dialogue in the sphere of Energy and Climate, and one of the points of cooperation is the capture, storage, and utilisation of CO2. According to the Association of Gas Companies and the European Business Association, some companies are launching projects to study the profitability and affordability of carbon capture and storage technologies. And while these studies show significant costs, carbon capture technologies could become cost-effective in the next 10-15 years due to effective energy modernisation, regulatory change, cheaper technologies as well as other factors. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 4. Legislation and regulation relevant for CCS deployment 4.1. CCS/CCU deployment regulation To date, there is no framework legislation on carbon capture and storage, carbon trading, technological and geological qualities of carbon capture equipment, carbon well safety, etc. The Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of Ukraine, after appropriate consultations with the State Service of Geology and Subsoil of Ukraine, concluded that it is necessary to introduce separate legislation that regulates the capture, storage, and disposal of carbon. According to the analytical note of the State Service of Geology and Subsoil of Ukraine, such regulation should be based on similar European regulation and features of the Ukrainian landscape (based on research of Ukrainian Geological institute). It should be noted that at present Ukraine has implemented some documents of international law, which indirectly relate to the issue of carbon capture and storage. For example, Directive 2006/32/EU and other similar documents. Although these documents do not determine the direct legal status of participants in the process and the market of carbon capture and storage, they form a conceptual framework that simplifies the further development of legislation. 4.2. National strategy of low-carbon economy development One of the key strategic documents of Ukraine in the field of reducing greenhouse gas emissions is the Strategy of low-carbon devel- opment of Ukraine until 2050. The document covers several strategic measures to reduce carbon emissions and bring certain sectors of the economy to carbon neutrality. In the section on support for design and technological developments, the Strategy includes “support for research, development, projects and implementation of advanced demonstration projects”. Such support includes car- bon capture, storage, and reuse technologies. The document emphasises that the introduction of innovative technologies, in particular, smart grids, innovative nuclear energy technologies, technologies for the capture, storage and reuse of carbon, industrial production and the use of hydrogen, the latest agricultural technologies, in addition to policies and measures in the field of energy efficiency and renewable energy, will allow GHG (greenhouse gas) emissions to be cut by 35 million tonnes of CO2-eq annually in the period 2020-2050. 4.3. Nationally determined contribution Another important medium-term strategic document (Nationally determined contribution of Ukraine under the Paris Climate Agree- ment) also notes the importance of using carbon capture, storage and use technologies. The document defines the climate targets of Ukraine that the country plans to reach by 2030. The target is a reduction in emissions from the base year (1990). Ukraine has set an ambitious goal to reach a reduction in CO2 emissions by 65% from 1990 levels. The document identifies the key measures that can support the transition to clean technologies. However, the document only identifies CCS/CCU technologies as potential tools and does not further assess the effects and cost of implementation. 4.4. National emission reduction plan of major pollutants from large combustion plants The National emission reduction plan implies the phase-out of coal power plants. The plan clearly defined the years when the block of a power station should be closed over the period of 2018-2033. Already, in 2021 a closure of Dniprovska CHP and Khersonska CHP are scheduled. Such changes in the energy system require new investments in order to substitute the closed power generation with the new one. In addition, Ukrainian energy system is characterised by the deficit of the balancing capacities. The thermal power plants play the key role in ensuring the flexibility of the energy system as they are able to quickly increase the generation volume. Another problem is that As a result currently the National emission reduction plan is under revision and is expected to be updated based on the financial opportunities of Ukrainian energy companies and the need in the new generation capacities. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION 4.5. Technical regulation of gas in the transmission system The new technical regulation of gas within the gas transmission system implies that the concentration of CO2 in the gas transmission system must not exceed 2.5% after 2025, thus raising a significant issue for national gas mining companies that expect to supply at least 6 billion cubic metres of gas that does not meet the criteria of the CO2 share. The regulation is introduced as European traders require such technical parameters of gas, and the transit contract with the EU possesses the same parameter. Such a challenge is driving mining companies to consider various options to capture, store and utilise CO2. 4.6. CCS in strategies of State-owned enterprises (SOEs) (Naftogaz) It is worth mentioning the inclusion of carbon capture and storage technologies in some strategies of state-owned corporations. The key one is the strategy of the Naftogaz group of companies (the group includes the production, transportation and sale of natural gas and has a monopoly in the gas production market of Ukraine). Naftogaz is the only SOE that is considering implementing CCS technologies in the future. The other SOEs do not have long-term strategy planning with a horizon exceeding 5-7 years. The company's strategy in the environmental safety section includes the use of carbon capture and storage technologies. As the company plans to achieve carbon neutrality by 2040, and gas production and purification technologies provide for large volumes of CO2, the use of carbon capture and storage technologies is indeed an unavoidable option in the company's toolset in the long run. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Chapter 2. Ukraine’s outlook for CCS and CCU 1. Summary of stakeholder engagement All the stakeholders have been actively engaged. According to responsibility, the interest in and potential impact on the stakeholder sector can be divided into three key categories: 1. Government bodies. Responsible for the introduction of effective regulation, creating incentives for the development of the industry, as well as balancing the positions of the public and business. The group includes Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources of Ukraine, State Service of Geology and Subsoil of Ukraine (under the Ministry of Environment and Nat- ural Resources of Ukraine). 2. Business representatives. Form demand for the introduction of carbon capture and storage technologies, develop industry strategies, studies and incorporate technologies, attract funding (including national and international). The group includes GMK Center, Union of Chemists of Ukraine, Ukrcement, Association of Gas Production Companies of Ukraine). 3. Civil society and activists. Form environmental requirements for business and government, as well as monitor the safety of technology implementation. The group includes the NGO Eсodiya. 4. Academic and experts. Provide expertise on the potential technology solution that may be applied. The group includes: Naftogazbudinformatyka, Ivano-Frankivsk National Technical University on Oil & Gas. 2. Stakeholder positions on CCS and CCU TABLE 2.1. POSITIONS OF STAKEHOLDERS IN UKRAINE ON CCS AND CCU Stakeholder Description Position State Service of Geol- Governmental body. The State Service op- The State Service of Geology and Subsoil of Ukraine supports the idea of stor- ogy and Subsoil of erates the access to mineral resources in ing carbon in depleted oil and gas wells. In addition, the organisation supports Ukraine Ukraine. The service conducts auctions, the idea of providing fiscal incentives to enterprises for CO2 emissions if they monitoring and control of mining in store carbon in geological formations (or use it to intensify oil production from Ukraine. wells). At the same time, the organisation emphasises the problem of financ- ing these facilities, as well as the need for scientific and technological cooper- ation with European countries for the more rapid development of the technol- ogy in Ukraine. The Service suggests the need to establish proper regulation for the CCS and underlines the importance of the introduction of the Emission trading System or increase of carbon tax. Clear government support and long- term guarantees would help to implement CCU/CCS technologies. The Service announced an interest in creating the official working group on the develop- ment of CCS technologies. Ministry of Environ- Governmental body. The Ministry also supports the idea of carbon storage in highly mineralised ment and Natural Re- formations (to minimise the risk of leakage). The problem of funding and the sources of Ukraine need for international cooperation for the implementation of effective pilot projects are also noted. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Stakeholder Description Position GMK Center Think tank with a focus on metallurgy. Representatives of the association of producers of molasses products note that carbon storage projects are interesting, but not a priority. It is noted that even with the accelerated pace of energy modernisation, carbon storage and use technologies will only become interesting for the industry from a 10-20 year perspective. Union of Chemists of Business association. The leading associa- The Union emphasises the long-term interest in CO2 storage and use technol- Ukraine tion that represents the biggest chemical ogies. Now, such innovations are not profitable from the point of view of the producers in Ukraine. euros invested in reducing emissions. In this sense, energy modernisation will be at least 3-4 times cheaper. Ukrcement Business association. The leading associa- Ukrcement considers CCU technologies as an option from a long-term per- tion that represents the majority of build- spective, as they are currently able to reduce their CO2 emissions by reducing ing material producers in Ukraine. the amount of coal used and by using RDF (Refused Derived Fuel), thus reduc- ing the amount of CO2 emissions from coal burnt and increasing the reuse of processed wastes that would otherwise by stored and emit CO2. CCS is not considered by Ukrcement as the best solution to reduce the amount of CO2 emissions. In contrast they see potential in using the CO2 for purposes such as methanol production. In addition, Ukrcement considers CCS as an initiative that does not stimulate the reduction of emissions within the production pro- cess. Association of Gas Business association. The leading associa- Representatives of the gas industry are interested in carbon storage technol- Production Compa- tion of gas mining companies covers over ogies. This is prompted by the new technical regulation on gas quality within nies of Ukraine 92% of gas mined in Ukraine. The associa- the gas transmission system, which forces companies to clean the natural gas tion is actively looking at the opportunities from CO2 at the entrance to the gas transmission system, as well as the prox- to reduce CO2 emissions and to store the imity to potential carbon storage wells. At the same time, the industry is wait- CO2 in exhausted mines. ing for government decisions on the regulation and financing of the sector and is wary of possible negative perceptions by citizens. Eсodiya Activists, think tank. Ecodiya is one of the The non-governmental environmental organisation Eсodiya made a statement leading environmental think tanks in about the negative attitude towards prioritising the topic of carbon capture Ukraine. and storage. According to the organisation, the state is not able to guarantee the safety of such wells. In addition, the cost of the technology and additional emissions during the implementation process raise doubts about the long- term potential of carbon capture and storage technologies. Naftogaz Public, government-owned company. The Naftogaz sees a big opportunity in CCS as a business for Naftogaz, as the com- leading gas mining company, which oper- pany is the biggest operator of abandoned gas mines that are suitable for stor- ates the largest number of mines, is ac- ing gas. tively seeking opportunities to mine shale gas in the Black Sea and is the biggest holder of the exhausted or closed mines in Ukraine. DTEK Private. The leading energy sector com- DTEK is the most innovative energy company in Ukraine. The company an- pany that covers gas, oil and coal mining, nounced climate ambitions to reach carbon neutrality by 2050. They were the power generation, electricity infrastruc- first to introduce battery storage capacities and now they are leading the pro- ture, distribution. cess of hydrogen technologies development in Ukraine. In addition, they con- sider CCS/CCU technologies as a potential solution to reach carbon neutrality. The introduction of the Emission Trading System or increase of the carbon tax, regulation of the CO2 storage and clear government support and long-term guarantees, would help to implement the CCU/CCS technologies. Metinvest Private. The leading vertically integrated Metinvest is currently considering various options to reduce CO2 emissions, as holding focused on metal and ore mining they must export products to the EU and there is a serious threat to get under and on metallurgy production. The vast the CBAM. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Stakeholder Description Position majority of Metinvest products are ex- The key short-term measures that will be implemented by Metinvest are fo- ported to the EU. cused on energy efficiency measures. On the other hand, from a long-term perspective, Metinvest is seriously searching for innovative solutions that can be scaled to industrial use, as most innovative solutions are currently pilot pro- jects. The most prospective are hydrogen technologies that will help to reduce emis- sions from burnt fuel. The company expresses strong interest in CCU/CCS tech- nologies as well, but as a regulatory framework is still not established and the ETS (Emission Trading System) has not been introduced, the company is con- sidering the implementation of such technologies after 2030. Naftogaz- A leading organisation in providing tech- Naftogazbudinformatyka currently sees big potential in the implementation of budinformatyka nical services to gas production and gas in- new technologies. The primary focus is now on hydrogen and the organisation frastructure companies. The organisation claims there is a need to develop infrastructure to transport hydrogen on a local level (form the internal market). The organisation sees potential in pro- is currently assessing the gas pipelines for ducing green hydrogen using renewable energy generation. hydrogen transportation. The organisation points out that the market of CO2 is quite small, and that storage of the captured CO2 is required. The organisation also mentioned that the high level of CO2 in the gas system leads to the erosion of gas tubes. The organisation expresses strong interest in studying the transportation opportunities of CO2 to ensure the implemen- tation of CCS/CCU technologies. Ivano-Frankivsk Na- A leading educational institution with a The university sees great potential for CCS development in Ukraine as Ukraine tional Technical Uni- specific focus on the gas production and will have to reach carbon-neutrality and given that fact that Ukraine has many versity on Oil & Gas gas transportation industry. The univer- big polluters such as power generation, metallurgy, fertiliser producers and the cement industry. The captured gas should be utilised and stored in de- sity has a strong research department as pleted gas fields. well as high-quality educational pro- The university claims that there is currently no regulation on the usage of CCS grammes. technologies and there are no fiscal incentives for the companies to capture and store CO2. 3. In-depth stakeholder perceptions of the CCU and CCS landscape OVERALL PROSPECTS FOR CCU/CCS IN THE TARGET COUNTRY In general, most of the interviewed experts are interested in carbon capture, storage, and utilisation technologies, but note that the technologies are only interesting in the long run. The lack of a description of specific projects for these technologies, even in long- term strategic documents (for example, companies' plans for carbon neutrality until 2040) suggests a cautious attitude and observa- tion of the dynamics of such projects in other countries. Sectors are divided in their attitudes towards the following technologies: while some note strategic prospects, others are sceptical and see the technology as problematic due to potential difficulties with public perception and regulation. Most sectors consider CCS technologies, while CCU is only considered in certain types of production (in particular, the chemical industry). The accounting of emissions for environmental tax is much lower than in EU countries. Few companies in Ukraine have calculated their carbon footprint and they have never really been focused on the climate agenda. Ukraine plans to introduce the ETS in around 2024, but currently, there is no clear vision of how the system will work and where finances generated from ETS will be directed. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION THE ROLE OF CCU/CCS IN SECTOR INTEGRATION CCS/CCU technologies look promising for production clusters (due to the strongly developed Ukrainian gas transportation system and potential CO2 storage sites). It is important to note the potential for the development of industrial parks, which is included in the current National Economic Strategy of Ukraine 2030. CCS/CCU infrastructure can be an additional bonus for members of industrial parks. AWARENESS OF EU POLICY AND FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS FOR CCU/CCS Even though Ukraine is not a member of the EU, most of the industry representatives focus on the European regulation of CCS/CCU technologies. The lack of even initial regulation of the sector in Ukraine encourages businesses to consider European practices as most appropriate in the medium and long term. At the same time, Ukraine has limited access to European funding instruments in the field of carbon capture and storage. The tools that are available for Ukraine now and will be available in the next 5 years are focused on carbon and energy modernisation in production. On average, investments in such modernisation in Ukraine are 4-5 times more efficient than in CCS/CCU technology. PERCEIVED DEPLOYMENT BARRIERS AND RISKS Despite major issues in terms of project profitability compared to energy efficiency measures, the biggest risk remains the lack of appropriate regulation of the field. Companies do not want to take the risk of even planning such projects before understanding the rules and potential limitations of the system. On the other hand, large companies are ready to publicly support CCS/CCU technologies and address the need of the regulation and incentives to government. 4. Stakeholder recommendations for CCU/CCS REGULATION The lack of framework legislation in the field of carbon management (as well as transparent regulation of trade in industrial waste) creates uncertainty in the market. It is necessary to create framework legislation to regulate the field, as well as clear rules (technical, environmental, social) for the creation, maintenance, and storage of potential wells. In addition, clear and transparent regulation of carbon trading is needed. Ensuring that CCS/CCU technologies lead to the exemption of environmental tax on the amount of CO2 captured and utilised/stored or that are regulated within the ETS would create a stimulus for the development of such technologies. Business representatives believe that the “default solution” may be the implementation of European directives, which can be further finalised in terms of the Ukrainian market. TECHNOLOGY Technologies for injecting carbon into used natural gas wells, aquifers and coal seams are absent and costly for Ukraine. Represent- atives of the companies emphasise the need for cooperation with the EU and other countries (Norway, USA) for the effective appli- cation of such technologies in Ukraine. Carbon capture technology is also an important issue. While in some areas (natural gas production and the chemical industry) they are simpler, in others (ferrous metallurgy) they require significant costs and additional development. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION INFRASTRUCTURE All the company representatives interviewed note that the issue of transport infrastructure and carbon storage infrastructure should be an exclusively governmental issue. Ukraine has significant potential to use the existing gas transportation infrastructure (pipelines, gas storage facilities, distribution points) with moderate investments. MARKET First, it is necessary to legalise carbon trading and regulate such relations. In addition, market incentives need to be considered for companies that use (recycle) purchased carbon. FINANCIAL FRAMEWORKS Companies expect to receive certain preferences through fiscal and other government measures. At the same time, the main stimulus for industry will be public investment in CO2 transportation and storage infrastructure. Grants or other financial incentives are ex- pected to establish carbon capture installations in the production process. Other financial incentives may include easing environmental taxes for companies implementing next-generation carbon technologies (including carbon capture, storage, and recovery technologies). INTER-SECTORAL AND REGIONAL COLLABORATION Gas companies point to the potential for cooperation within the sector. The joint use of infrastructure due to regional and techno- logical proximity will help reduce the cost of individual projects (however, it should be noted that in Ukraine the natural gas industry is concentrated within one large and several medium-sized companies). In the long run, the chemical industry may use CO2 in the production of fuels, polymers, or raw materials for certain chemical prod- ucts. However, now the sector is not ready to use even its own captured carbon emissions (due to the high price of capturing tech- nologies). There is potential for cooperation with the agricultural sector, which is growing at a high pace in Ukraine. There are technologies for the use of CO2 as fertiliser in greenhouses (the CO2 is captured from the air and injected into the greenhouse to stimulate the produc- tivity of fruits and vegetables). There is potential for connection to the CO2 capture and transport infrastructure of new industrial parks. This will reduce the cost of transportation and attract more medium-sized enterprises. SOCIAL ASPECTS Some business representatives point to the risks of negative public perceptions of technology. This risk can be crucial for the gas industry, where most of the market is held by a state-owned company. Environmental organisations and activists are sceptical of carbon capture and storage technologies and negative about the introduc- tion of such technologies into existing strategies for developing a carbon-free economy. BUILDING MOMENTUM FOR THE LONG-TERM CCS DEPLOYMENT IN THE CEE REGION Chapter 3. CCS and CCU: Public ac- ceptance in Ukraine The interest in carbon capture and storage technologies has shown robust growth in 2020 and 2021 since the Ukrainian media started covering them. Several companies (Metinvest, DTEK, Naftogaz) publicly expressed interest in studying CCS/CCU technologies and their development in Ukraine. In addition, the government of Ukraine established strategic dialogue with the US on cooperation in the Energy sector and Environment, also mentioning the CCS/CCU technologies as a point of cooperation. The biggest attention of the media has been paid to the coverage of projects and initiatives around the world and showing the CCS project as a potential solution in decarbonisation. The overall tone of the articles is neutral, with scepticism related to the high price of the technologies and low The most discussed document has been the report of the International Energy Agency, where carbon capture and storage technolo- gies are considered as an effective solution to ensure carbon neutrality. During the interview the State Service of Geology and Mineral Resources of Ukraine are ready to publicly express support for the development of CCS/CCU technologies. The Service sees clear opportunities for the development of CO2 storage and claim that providing tax incentives to industrial producers would stimulate the capture and storage of CO2. On the other hand, there is opposition from environmental experts that are strong supporters of a much cheaper solution for Ukraine. A reputable Environment Policy NGO, Ecodiya, has expressed a public position, criticising the introduction of CCS/CCU projects in Ukraine. The association of gas mining companies meanwhile has publicly stated that the technologies of CCS/CCU are the only option for gas production companies as they need to align the quality of the gas produced with the technical regulation, which from 2025 requires that gas does not exceed 2.5% containment of CO2. Ecodiya stresses renewable energy and energy efficiency as the top priorities for Ukrainian decarbonisation. The key argument is that Ukraine has big potential in decarbonisation via energy efficiency measures and a significant increase of renewable energy, which are cheaper than carbon storage technologies. The primary reason is that carbon storage does not stimulate industrial producers to reduce fossil fuel consumption, “The key threat in the use of carbon storage technologies is that they do not stimulate the abolition of the usage of fossil fuels and as a result we cannot consider such measures as a sustainable solution.” In addition, Ecodiya claims that the carbon capture process on HPP requires a significant amount of water and Ukraine struggles with sufficient amounts of water, holding 32nd place among 40 European countries regarding water supply per person. The final argument is that there is a significant risk of CO2 leakage, which can have a negative impact on the environment. Saatja: Ewa Korzeniowska <[email protected]> Saadetud: 26.04.2022 10:42 Adressaat: Ewa Korzeniowska <[email protected]> Koopia: Ewa Korzeniowska <[email protected]> Teema: Building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the CEE region - national reports Dear Sir or Madam, we are happy to share with you national reports on the long-term CCS deployment in Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia. The Building momentum for the long-term CCS deployment in the CEE region project (CCS4CEE) aims to reignite the discussion on carbon capture and storage (CCS) in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE). 11 countries in the region are covered by the project scope, assessing the current state of CCS, and developing roadmaps for implementation in the different states. The intended outcomes of the project include improved stakeholder communication at national and regional level, concrete plans for national or regional pilot projects and input into policymaking to accelerate deployment of CCS projects in participant countries. The national reports set a baseline for incipient discussions on implementing CCS projects in the CEE region. Its main aim is to assess the current state of CCS in the participant countries. Project partners in each participating country achieved this aim through a combination of desk-based research (evaluating the carbon intensity of national economies, geological potential for CO2 storage, history of CCS projects, relevant legislative frameworks, and social acceptance of CCS) and stakeholder engagement (interviews and a workshop with relevant stakeholders. The attached reports prepared by Civitta, present the relevant issues of CCS deployment in Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia and Ukraine such as: * CCS and CCU: current state and past experience * Geological potential for CCS deployment * Legal framework * Stakeholder engagement * Public acceptance The reports about other CEE countries are available here: We are at your disposal to respond to any questions or to provide additional briefings and welcome any comments. Kind regards, Ewa Korzeniowska Ewa Korzeniowska Specjalistka ds. Komunikacji i PR // Communication &amp; PR Specialist WiseEuropa Ul. Królewska 2/26 // 00-065 Warszawa tel.: &#43;48 22 513 14 18 // fax: &#43;48 22 350 63 12
Allikas: Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium dokumendiregister →