MEMORANDUM
January 17, 2013
TO: The Honorable Märt Rask
Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Estonia
RE: 2013 CONFERENCE OF CHIEF JUSTICES OF CENTRAL AND
EASTERN EUROPE SURVEY
Dear Chief Justice:
You probably have attended conferences of chief justices at which the speaker
has never been a Chief Justice. Such a conference may be helpful when the subject
matter deals with a statute or case law, but is rarely helpful in assisting a Chief Justice
with the vast administrative responsibilities that ordinarily go with that office. Such
a person advising Chief Justices about administrative matters is like a person advising
how to do brain surgery without attending medical school.
At our next conference of Chief Justices of Central and Eastern Europe, which
is currently planned for June 2013, in Montenegro, we hope to have presentations
from the experts (Chief Justices) discussing how and why they handle administrative
matters the way they do. Thus, your vital attendance will not only be as a teacher but
as a listener. The outcome should be that each Chief Justice will learn from other
Chief Justices and pick up ideas that the Chief Justice may want to consider upon
returning home. While this type of Chief Justice conference will require some
preparation by you and/or your administrative assistant, we believe that you will find
it worthwhile in the long run as you gain comparative experience with other Chief
Justices dealing with similar problems.
To make this effective and provide you with some comparative data, enclosed
is a questionnaire with 37 questions. Remember that each of the other Chief Justices
will be answering the same questions, which will allow you to compare how you
function as an administrator with other Chief Justices who are dealing with similar
problems. We will tabulate the responses and provide summary sheets so that
comparisons can be easily made.
In addition, certain of the subjects selected for the upcoming conference will
be taken from this data and allow us to sharpen our focus on certain subjects and ask
questions of members of the group about specific areas of interest. This too will
enliven our social discussions as you will have in mind certain Chief Justices who
seem to be saving time and you may want to engage them in discussions to evaluate
whether their system would be relevant to your administrative challenges.
In short, while there will be some preparation required of you, it should yield
excellent results for the next Conference of Chief Justices of Central and Eastern
Europe. We request that you complete the questionnaire as soon as you can so that
we can make adequate preparations for the Conference. Please send your completed
response (in English) to Judge Wallace at the contact information listed at your
earliest convenience.
Looking forward to an excellent conference.
We are very truly yours,
JOHN WALKER
United States Court of Appeals
J. CLIFFORD WALLACE
United States Court of Appeals
J. CLIFFORD WALLACE
Senior Judge
Chief Judge Emeritus
United States Court of Appeals
940 Front Street, Suite 4192
San Diego, CA 92101
voice: 619.557.6114
fax: 619.557.6887
[email protected]
SURVEY ON THE
ROLE AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE
CHIEF JUSTICE OF THE HIGHEST COURT
DECEMBER 2012
1. Country:
2. Name of Chief Justice:
a. Number of years served as Chief Justice:
b. Number of years on highest court:
c. Name of highest court:
d. Number of judges on highest court:
e. How is the Chief Justice selected?
3. Position of Chief Justice is established by:
a. Constitution:
b. Statute:
c. Other:
4. List the document(s) where the power and authority of the Chief Justice are
outlined and attach a copy:
-1-
5. Does the authority of the Chief Justice extend to courts other than the
highest court in the nation?
a. Over trial courts?
b. Over intermediate appellate courts?
c. Describe the authority:
6. Is the Chief Justice responsible for all administration within his/her
jurisdiction?
7. In addition to administration, does the Chief Justice decide the same number
of cases as other judges of his/her court? If not, what percentage
does he/she decide in comparison with the rest of the court?
8. Does the Chief Justice have authority to take action when a justice of his/her
court fails to discharge his/her work with reasonable efficiency?
a. What is the extent of that authority?
b. Does the Chief Justice have the same authority for other appellate
courts? For trial courts?
9. Does the Chief Justice determine the distribution of judicial workload for the
-2-
court?
a. If not, who does?
10. Does the Chief Justice have authority to interfere with another justice’s case
decision procedure?
11. Does the Chief Justice have oversight authority over the pace towards the
disposition of a case?
a. If so, how is it exercised?
12. If any dispute arises between the Chief Justice and another justice (judicial
or extrajudicial), how is it resolved?
13. Does the Chief Justice or the Supreme Court use committees to which are
delegated administrative responsibility, supervision, or oversight?
a. How many committees?
b. The names of each:
-3-
14. Does the Chief Justice speak for the country’s judiciary?
a. Must he/she secure the approval of the court or any other body to
announce policy decisions?
i. If another body, what body?
15. Does the Chief Justice provide an annual report with statistics?
a. To whom is it sent?
b. Is it available to the public?
16. Is the Chief Justice responsible to communicate with the public?
17. Is the Chief Justice responsible to communicate with the media?
18. Does the Chief Justice have an interest in and continuing obligation for the
welfare and development of judges, including health, working conditions,
and continuing education?
19. Are there rules of judicial conduct that can be enforced against a judge?
a. Are they in the Constitution, statute, or rule?
i. Please attach a copy.
b. What role does the Chief Justice play in the discipline of judges?
-4-
20. Does the Chief Justice have power to transfer judges?
a. What is the procedure for transferring judges?
21. What role does the Chief Justice play in securing an adequate budget for the
judiciary?
a. What role does the Chief Justice play in being sure the funds are
properly spent?
22. Is the Chief Justice involved in developing judicial education programs?
-5-
a. In what way?
23. Does the Chief Justice have responsibility for space and facilities for the
judiciary?
a. In what way?
24. Does the Chief Justice play a role in liaison with:
a. the executive
b. the legislative
c. the bar
d. If so, in what way?
25. Does the Chief Justice hold court meetings to discuss administrative
matters? How often?
-6-
26. Did the Chief Justice receive training on how to perform as a Chief Justice
before beginning service?
a. If so, describe the training:
b. Answer similarly for specific training since becoming Chief Justice:
27. What specific training would be helpful for new Chief Justices?
a. What specific training would be helpful for a sitting Chief Justice?
28. Approximately what percentage of the Chief Justice’s time is spent on the
-7-
following activities?
a. Judicial responsibilities: %
i. Deciding cases: %
ii. Case management: %
b. Administrative responsibilities: %
i. Finances (e.g., setting budget): %
ii. Personnel (e.g., appointments, advancement, staffing): %
iii. Reviewing proposed legislation or policies affecting the
judiciary: %
iv. Meeting with government officials from other branches: %
v. Disciplinary matters: %
vi. Judicial training programs: %
c. Public relations responsibilities: %
i. Meeting with judiciary’s communications officer: %
ii. Press conferences: %
iii. Public speaking: %
d. Other (please specify) : %
29. Of the total time spent in administrative duties, what percentage of the Chief
Justice’s time is devoted to:
-8-
a. Supreme Court administration: %
b. Administration of judiciary as a whole: %
30. Do any of the following persons/groups assist the Chief Justice in Supreme
Court administration?
a. Other Supreme Court justices? If yes, what type of
assistance?
b. A judicial administrator? If yes, what type of assistance?
c. Other (please specify) What type of assistance?
31. Do any of the following persons/groups assist the Chief Justice in
administering the judicial system as a whole?
a. Other Supreme Court justices? If yes, what type of
assistance?
-9-
b. Judicial administrator? If yes, what type of assistance?
c. Committee of lower-court judges? If yes, what type of
assistance?
d. Other (please specify) What type of assistance?
32. Does the Chief Justice hold regular council meetings with these groups to
coordinate judicial administration? How often do these meetings
take place?
33. Does the Chief Justice hold regular meetings with the heads of the lower
courts to coordinate judicial administration? How often do these
-10-
meetings take place?
34. Do any of the following groups assist the Chief Justice in representing the
judiciary to the public, the media, or other branches of government?
a. Other Supreme Court justices? If yes, what type of
assistance?
b. Committee of lower-court judges? If yes, what type of
assistance?
c. Media or public relations liaison? If yes, what type of
assistance?
-11-
d. Other (please specify) What type of assistance?
35. Does the Chief Justice hold regular council meetings with these groups to
coordinate the judiciary’s public relations? How often do these
meetings take place?
36. If the Chief Justice has a role representing the judiciary in addition to
administrative and judging duties, what percent of the Chief Justice’s time is
consumed by the representational role? %
a. List representational duties
37. Does the Chief Justice hold regular council meetings with the head of the
subordinate courts to assist in administration?
-12-
a. If so, how many meetings per year?
Please return to Judge Wallace at either:
Email:
[email protected]
Fax: (619) 557-6887
-13-
-----Original Message-----
From:
[email protected] [mailto:
[email protected]] On
Behalf Of
[email protected]
Sent: Thursday, January 17, 2013 7:47 PM
To:
[email protected]
Subject: 2013 CONFERENCE OF CHIEF JUSTICES OF CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE
SURVEY
Please see the attached memorandum and survey.
J. CLIFFORD WALLACE
|-------------+------------------------------------|
|(Embedded | |
|image moved |J. CLIFFORD WALLACE |
|to file: |Senior Judge |
|pic07470.jpg)|Chief Judge Emeritus |
| |United States Court of Appeals |
| |940 Front Street, Suite 4192 |
| |San Diego, CA 92101 |
| |voice: 619.557.6114 |
| |fax: 619.557.6887 |
| |
[email protected] |
|-------------+------------------------------------|
(See attached file: CJ Märt Rask - Estonia.pdf)(See attached file: CJ
SURVEY FINAL.pdf)