Rue Véronèse 73 • 1000 Brussel • Belgium
[email protected] • www.ecma.eu
Brussels, 1 May 2023
Ministry of Finances
Suur-Ameerika 1
10122 Tallinn
Estonia
ECMA’s opinion regarding “Maksuseaduste muutmise seaduse eelnõu”
Dear Sir/Madam,
ECMA, the European Cigar Manufacturers AssociaAon, is the trade associaAon of
cigar/cigarillo manufacturers in the Member States of the European Union (EU). ECMA
members together account for over 80% of the tradiAonal cigars/cigarillos produced in the
European Union. ECMA represents 19 cigar/cigarillo producing companies with 23
manufacturing plants in the EU1. Together these companies directly employ close to 6,000
persons in their cigar and cigarillo businesses in the European Union and another 33,000 in
countries outside the European Union. ECMA boasts fiOeen family-owned companies as part
of its membership. Of the full 19 ECMA member companies, 6 fall under the definiAon of small
and medium sized enterprises.
Cigars/cigarillos consAtute a niche, stable and predictable category, with 8 million sAcks placed
on the Estonian market in 2021 – compared to 1,48 billion sAcks for cigareVes. As such, the
distribuAon chain involved in the trade of cigars/cigarillos is also composed of a myriad group
of smaller businesses, including importers, distributors, retailers and very oOen specialised
stores.
One of our Estonian importers informed of us on ongoing discussions regarding the draO law
amending the Alcohol, Tobacco, Fuel and Electricity Excise Act (‘ATKEAS’) and other Acts. In
that regard, it is our understanding that the Estonian authoriAes are considering increasing
the minimum rates applicable for cigars/cigarillos and imposing a three-month limitaAon on
the validity of tax stamps following an excise increase. We would therefore like to comment
on both these points considering what ECMA believes to be the insufficient quality of the
impact analysis of the measures for the category. The impact analysis, unfortunately, also
includes factual mistakes.
1 – Proposed increase of the rates applicable for cigars/cigarillos
While we understand that all minimum rates applicable to tobacco products will be increased
by 5% on an annual basis unAl 2026, the Government should nevertheless reconsider the
expediency of the tax increase on cigars/cigarillos discussed in the impact analysis. In this
1
Full list of ECMA members is accessible on ECMA’s website: www.ecma.eu
Rue Véronèse 73 • 1000 Brussel • Belgium
[email protected] • www.ecma.eu
regard, and in contradicAon with the spirit of DirecAve 2011/64/EU and in comparison, to the
vast majority of the fiscal structures used in other EU Member States, cigars/cigarillos in
Estonia are excised at a higher rate than any other tobacco product category. This approach
also disregards the substanAal and well-documented manufacturing process and costs of
producing cigars/cigarillos and does not take into account the very different tax-bearing
capacity of cigars/cigarillos compared to mass-produced tobacco products2.
In this regard, ECMA does not understand why the overwhelmingly dominant tobacco product
on the Estonian market, namely factory-made cigareVes, should benefit from lower taxaAon
while being responsible for most of the smoking prevalence in Estonia, especially among
young people.
Further, the claim on page 5 of the Explanatory LeVer jusAfying the excise increase offers
absolutely no evidence when it asserts that "the increase in the excise duty on cigarillos is
important, given that the popularity of these products can grow among young people. Unlike
other tradi<onal tobacco products, flavoring of cigars and cigarillos is not prohibited under EU
rules".
As niche products within a much larger manufactured tobacco market, cigars/cigarillos are
enjoyment products and contribute only marginally to smoking prevalence across the EU.
AddiAonally, the smoking prevalence of cigars EU-side has been constantly decreasing,
parAcularly since the younger consumers seldom enter this market3. Only 2% of smokers in
Estonian smoke cigarillos, cigars or pipe tobacco on a daily basis4. These tobacco products are
also more likely to be smoked only on an occasional basis or tried only once or twice. Instead,
there is ample documentaAon showing that cigars/cigarillos typically appeal to more mature
consumers, who tend to be higher income, well-educated, and aware of the health risks
associated with smoking. The latest Eurobarometer report from 2021 also confirms that
cigars/cigarillos are not products associated with smoking iniGaGon. Among all respondents
in Estonia who have tried tobacco products, the most common first experience with tobacco
is by far cigareVes (79%), with only 5% menAoning cigars and just 1% menAoning cigarillos5.
This fact was again recently confirmed in the European Commission’s Support Study to the
report on the applicaAon of DirecAve 2014/40/EU, which found pracAcally no use of cigars
and cigarillos in the under-25 age group in the EU6. Similarly, the German Federal StaAsAcal
Office 2021 micro census also determined that cigars/cigarillos are predominantly consumed
2
European Commission, Study on Council Direc1ve 2011/64/EU on the structure and rates of excise duty
applied to manufactured tobacco, January 2019 (hereina<er EA 2019), p. 99.
3
EA 2019, p. 76.
4
Eurobarometer, AFtudes of Europeans towards tobacco and electronic cigareIes - Country Factsheets - Estonia,
no 506, February 2021.
5
Ibidem.
6
European Commission, Final Report: Support Study to the report on the applica1on of Direc1ve 2014/40/EU,
May 2021, p. 290 (hereina<er ‘ICF Study 2021’)
Rue Véronèse 73 • 1000 Brussel • Belgium
[email protected] • www.ecma.eu
by those in the 45-75 age group, with the proporAon of males comprising close to 80% of that
cohort7.
ECMA also understands that the Estonian government might be considering other, non-excise
related maVers when assessing the cigar/cigarillo category within the framework of the
revision of the Alcohol, Tobacco, Fuel and Electricity Excise Act, for example, the presence of
flavours in cigarillos.
As already noted above, cigarillos conAnue to only represent an extremely small and
decreasing fracAon of the total consumpAon of tobacco products, even with the existence of
flavoured cigarillos8, and here, too, there is no evidence that they act as a gateway to youth
or smoking iniAaAon9. ECMA would also note here that European Commission reported that
cigarillos did not “[reach] the threshold that would mandate the Commission to trigger [the
substanAal change of circumstances clause]”10 and jusAfy a revocaAon of the condiAonal
exempAon for flavours in cigarillos. ECMA also would like to point out that no issues were
reported with regards to compliance for tradiAonal flavours used in cigarillos11 in the
European Commission’s ApplicaAon Report of DirecAve 2014/40/EU12.
Considering all the above, ECMA believes it is quite clear that the claim that these products
are increasingly popular among younger people is factually wrong and does not jusGfy an
increase in their minimum rates.
Finally, ECMA also considers the tax increase unnecessary as cigars and cigarillos already
consAtute the least affordable tobacco products on the Estonian market. As explained in the
Government jusAficaAon, the 2022 weighted average retail price of one cigar is €6.06, one
cigarillo €0.57 and one cigareVe €0.23.
7
BdZ, Indicators of smoking behavior - Microcensus 2021 (published in 2023) on smoking habits of the popula1on
aged 15 and over by gender and age, accessible here: hNps://www.zigarren-verband.de/die-zigarrenbranche-
wirtscha<liche-kennzahlen/#kennzahlenrauchverhalten
8
ICF Study 2021, p. 191.
9
European Commission, AFtudes of Europeans towards tobacco and electronic cigareIes, Special
Eurobarometer 506, February 2021, pp. 97-98.
10
European Commission, Report to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social
CommiIee and the CommiIee of the Regions on the applica1on of Direc1ve 2014/40/EU concerning the
manufacture, presenta1on and sale of tobacco and related products, 20 May 2021, COM(2021) 249 final, SecYon
10.2 p. 16 (hereina<er ‘COM 2021’).
11
As presented in 2012, the three main flavours used in cigars/cigarillos are coffee, vanilla and caramel-like
flavours. See European Commission, Staff Working Document Impact Assessment, accompanying the document
Proposal for a Direc1ve Of The European Parliament And of the Council on the approxima1on of the laws,
regula1ons and administra1ve provisions of the Member States concerning the manufacture, presenta1on and
sale of tobacco and related products, 19 December 2012, SWD(2012) 452 final, Part 3, p. 5.
12
COM 2021, SecYon 3.4 p. 6.
Rue Véronèse 73 • 1000 Brussel • Belgium
[email protected] • www.ecma.eu
ECMA therefore respecnully requests that you reconsider the proposed approach and instead
enact a more moderate, jusAfiable, evidence-based and proporAonate increase.
2 – Proposed Gme-limitaGon of the validity of tax stamps for cigars/cigarillos
§ 28 (41) of ATKEAS, in conjuncAon with the proposed draO, will result in the requirement that
within 3 months of the tax increases coming into effect from 01.01.2025 and from 01.01.2026,
all cigars/cigarillos with tax stamps from previous years would need to be either returned or
destroyed.
ECMA believes that this element of the draO proposal effecAvely consAtutes an unreasonable
sales ban and would create disproporAonate obstacles to sales of cigars/cigarillos, to the point
which this disrupAon could be considered a distorAon of compeAAon. Cigars/cigarillos do not
turn over anywhere near as quickly as factory-made cigareVes on retailers’ shelves, which for
many cigars/cigarillos can be many months and even years for premium handmade cigars.
While this fact is explicitly recognised in page 6 of the Explanatory LeVer, the draO proposal
only foresees an exempAon to the sale restricAon for 2024. ECMA would also draw your
aVenAon to § 859 of ATKEAS, according to which, as an excepAon to the provisions of § 28,
paragraph 41 of § 28 of ATKEAS, cigars/cigarillos placed on the market for consumpAon before
1 January 2011 were allowed to be sold within 12 calendar months from the date of entry into
force of the new tax label design. This clearly indicates that Estonian legislators previously
considered it reasonable and necessary to allow a sales period of at least 1 year before
applying the sales restricAon foreseen in § 28, paragraph 41 of ATKEAS. ECMA would then ask
that this approach also be taken when considering the validity of tax stamps under the
proposed ATKEAS amendments.
ECMA believes the proposed changes will also have other serious market consequences, given
that current sellers of cigars/cigarillos may refrain from carrying them at all if they are
perceived as risky due to the validity periods of tax stamps and the possibility that they may
not be sold before having to scrap them. This is especially true considering the smaller sales
volumes associated with cigars/cigarillos. And these risks would also disproporAonately
impact smaller sellers in parAcular. The amended Act would thus create unfair and completely
unnecessary market distorAons and, in the long term, a decrease in tax revenue associated
with cigars/cigarillos.
If cigars/cigarillos with older tax stamps will need to be returned, these products would very
likely need to be destroyed upon return as it is extremely difficult to remove or swap tax
stamps once they are placed on cigars/cigarillo packaging. Cigars/cigarillos are packaged in a
diversity of sizes, formats, and materials which far exceeds that of factory-made cigareVes,
not only in variety but also complexity. Cigar/cigarillo packaging materials can include
cardboard, plasAc, metal, and wood. Packages themselves have mulAple sizes and formats –
split boxes, fold-out boxes (in both cardboard and plasAc), insert boxes, Ans with both
aVached and removable covers, and wooden boxes with sliding, removable or aVached tops
Rue Véronèse 73 • 1000 Brussel • Belgium
[email protected] • www.ecma.eu
and that range from basic to high-end in their design and the type of wood used in their
manufacture.
However, the most problemaGc aspect of this Gme limitaGon for tax stamps aKer 2026 is
linked with the upcoming entry into force of the EU traceability system for cigars/cigarillos
in May 2024, which clearly allows a transiAon period unAl May 2026 for products already
placed on the market. Contrary to what is stated in page 6 of the Explanatory LeVer, most
cigars/cigarillos sold in Estonia are not affixed with tax stamps in Estonia. While this might be
the case for some imported handmade cigars, most cigars/cigarillos placed on the Estonian
market are produced within EU factories outside Estonia, and it is in those factories where tax
stamps are affixed. In fact, it was ECMA’s understanding that the Estonian government for this
very reason plans to use tax stamps for cigars/cigarillos as the Security Feature required under
ArAcle 16 of DirecAve 2014/40/EU.
Taking into account all of the above, ECMA would ask that the Estonian government
acknowledge these specific consideraAons, as well as the niche status of the cigar/cigarillo
sector, and either dispense with the proposed Ame validity restricAons for tax stamps or,
alternately follow an approach that allows for a market-clearing period similar to that as
foreseen in § 859 of ATKEAS.
3 – Price accuracy on tax stamps for cigars/cigarillos
Finally, ECMA takes note that Clause 23 of § 1 of the proposal adds a second sentence to §
62 subsection 3 that seeks to establish greater price accuracy when reporting the maximum
retail price of tobacco products. The communicated aim, according to page 6 of the
Explanatory Letter “is to reduce the number of different prices for cigars/cigarillos”. ECMA
objects to this approach, which we believe is not only in breach of Directive 2011/64/EU, but
also ignores the market and manufacturing realities of the cigars/cigarillo sector.
Recital 3 of Directive 2011/64/EU states clearly that “One of the objectives of the Treaty on
European Union is to maintain an economic union, whose characteristics are similar to those
of a domestic market, within which there is healthy competition. As regards manufactured
tobacco, achievement of this aim presupposes that the application in the Member States of
taxes affecting the consumption of products in this sector does not distort conditions of
competition and does not impede their free movement within the Union”. In this regard, the
proposed new second sentence to § 62 subsection 3 would prevent manufacturers,
wholesalers, distributors and retailers from freely setting prices attached to corresponding
products.
Secondly, the Explanatory Letter seems to suggest that the “huge number of different prices”
applied to cigars/cigarillos – as opposed to factory-made cigarettes – necessitates an
individual decision by each tobacco outlet to set “a suitable price for itself”. This statement
and reasoning demonstrate a very profound misunderstanding of and disregard for the
Rue Véronèse 73 • 1000 Brussel • Belgium
[email protected] • www.ecma.eu
pricing mechanics of the cigar/cigarillo market. Also already noted, cigars/cigarillos are not
standardised products and are produced and packaged in a diverse array of sizes, formats,
and materials which far exceed factory-made cigarettes in variety and complexity. Hand- and
machine-made cigars/cigarillos vary significantly in length, weight, shape, and diameter as
well as the types of tobacco leaves used to manufactured them where the terroir aspect has
a preeminence value for consumers. This diversity of considerations and approaches in the
production of cigars/cigarillos naturally results in a greater number of SKUs placed on the
market, with similarly different attributes that are reflected in their pricing.
ECMA thus also respecnully requests that the Estonian government remove the proposed
second sentence to § 62 subsecGon 3.
In conclusion, and considering the number of mispercepAons and outright errors that ECMA
has encountered in the proposed changes to cigar/cigarillo excise in Estonia, we would
welcome an opportunity to meet with you in Tallin where we would be pleased to offer our
experAse and perspecAve regarding cigar/cigarillo manufacturing and consumpAon.
Sincerely,
Paul Varakas
ECMA Director General