ERAELU KAITSE JA RIIGI LÄBIPAISTVUSE EEST
Tanbir Mahmud Sarif Yours: 16.11.2023 nr
[email protected]
Ours: 06.12.2023 nr 2.1.-5/23/2923-
4
Answer to request
The Estonian Data Protection Inspectorate has received Your letter. Thank You for Your detailed
questions. Please note that personal data protection is regulated in Estonia primarily through
the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the Estonian Data Protection Act (DPA).
I will address each of your questions accordingly.
1. Is the collection of the specified personal data categories (name, age, gender, and political
opinions) in line with GDPR regulations, and are there any special considerations for each
category?
The collection of personal data should be in accordance with the General Data Protection
Regulation (GDPR), as long as the data controller (in this case, the researcher) follows the
general principles of data protection1 has specified the purpose of collecting data to the data
subjects and chosen and justified a valid legal basis under article 6(1) GDPR. For the purpose
of conducting of a research project, the appropriate legal basis may be either the consent2 of
the data subject or processing for scientific or historical research purposes, if sensitive
personal data is collected.3 The consent of the participants must be a freely given, specific,
informed and unambiguous indication of their wishes by which they signal agreement to the
processing of their personal data.4 The GDPR distinguishes between ordinary personal data,
and sensitive personal data. Personal data is any information relating to an identified or
identifiable natural person. The name, age, and gender of the data subjects fall under the
category of ordinary personal data. You indicated that You intend to collect political opinions
from Your participants, which fall under the category of sensitive personal data. As the data
controller, You must fulfil additional requirements in order to safeguard sensitive information
about the person(s) to whom the data relates.5 Gathering sensitive personal data for a research
project requires the explicit consent of the data subject. Explicit consent differs from ordinary
consent in the manner that the data subject must give an express statement of consent (written
or oral) to the processing of their data. A simple affirmative action (e.g. clicking a button on a
form that they consent to data processing) is not sufficient to prove explicit consent.
Furthermore, the DPA specifies elements to be considered for personal data processing in
academic research: §6(1) DPA allows Personal data to be processed without the consent of the
data subject for the needs of scientific and historical research and official statistic, in particular
in a pseudonymised format or a format which provides equivalent level of protection. Prior to
transmission of personal data for processing for the needs of scientific and historical research
or official statistics, personal data shall be replaced by pseudonymised data or data in a format
which provides equivalent level of data protection. Regarding sensitive personal data, §6(4)
1
Article 5 GDPR
2
Article 6(1)(a) GDPR
3
Article 9(2)(j) GDPR
4
Article 4(11) GDPR
5
Article 9(1) GDPR
Tatari tn 39 / 10134 Tallinn / 627 4135 /
[email protected] / www.aki.ee
Registrikood 70004235
DPA elaborates that if scientific and historical research is based on special categories of
personal data, the ethics committee of the area concerned shall first verify compliance with the
terms and conditions provided for in this section. If there is no ethics committee in the scientific
area, the compliance with the requirements shall be verified by the Estonian Data Protection
Inspectorate.
2. What lawful basis for data processing should be considered when collecting this data? Is
consent sufficient, or are there alternative bases to consider?
For academic research, a controller should consider consent or processing for scientific or
historical research as the legal bases. The ethics committee of your university should be further
consulted for guidance on legal basis of Your research proposal.
3. What are the requirements for informing data subjects about the purposes of data collection,
how their data will be used, and their rights in this context?
The data controller must inform the participants of their rights relating to the processing of their
personal data in a concise, transparent, intelligible, and easily accessible form, using clear
and plain language.6 If the participants are children, special attention must be paid to make the
information explicitly clear and provided in a simple manner to a child. Where You collect data
directly from the participants of Your research project, You shall provide them with at least the
information listed in article 13(1) and 13(2) GDPR: these include Your identity and contacts
details (as the data controller), the purposes of the processing for which the personal data is
intended and the legal basis (purpose would be academic research and legal basis would be
consent or scientific or historical research), the recipient of personal data (any other persons or
organisations that You share the personal data with), data retention period (how long You will
keep the personal data – in Your case this might be until the end of the project), the existence
of their rights to request access to their data, their right to rectification or erasure of their data
or right to restriction of processing (and other rights found in articles 16-21 GDPR), their right
to withdraw their consent or explicit consent at any time, and the legal basis and purpose any
further processing of personal data for purposes other than the original purpose that You intend
to undertake (if applicable).
4. Do I need to implement any additional security measures to safeguard the collected data,
given its sensitive nature?
As referred to in our answer to Your first question, special attention shall be paid to the
information to be provided for the collection of sensitive personal data and the collection of
consent from the participants in a clear and informed manner. We emphasise, that once data is
obtained from the data subjects, and prior to transmission for research, the personal data must
be pseudonymised or put in a format which provides equivalent level of data protection.7 This
is necessary to ensure the principle of data minimisation.8
5. Are there any specific obligations or notifications required when processing data from both
Estonian and EU residents?
The same clear, concise, and transparent information shall be provided to the data subjects
regardless of nationality. It is important that information is provided to data subjects clearly and
plainly in a language that they understand.9
6. Should I appoint a Data Protection Officer (DPO) or submit a Data Protection Impact
Assessment (DPIA) for this research project?
The appointment of a Data Protection Officer (DPO) will not be necessary for a personal
research project. A DPO is required where processing is carried out by a public authority or
body, or where the core activities of the controller consist of processing operations that require
regular and systematic large scale monitoring of data subjects, or where the controller’s core
activities consist of large scale processing of sensitive data or data relating to criminal
6
Article 12(1) GDPR
7
§6(1) DPA
8
Article 5(1)(c) GDPR
9
Recital 39 GDPR
2 (3)
offences.10 This is usually only necessary for public entities and companies whose services
involve large scale data processing. A Data Protection Impact Assessment (DPIA) will neither
be necessary for the performance of a research project. A DPIA is necessary where a type of
processing is likely to result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of the data subjects. 11 This
is unlikely to result from a research project.
Best regards
Aari Helmelaid
Legal assistant
authorized by Director General
10
Article 37(1) GDPR
11
Article 35(1) GDPR
3 (3)