Laura Pikkoja
Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus
[email protected] Meie 30.03.2022 nr 24.4-7/17-0504/2307-1
Programmi "Green ICT" 2021. aasta aruanne
Austatud Laura Pikkoja
Edastame Eesti-Norra koostööprogrammi „Green ICT“ 2021. aasta aruande.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Joonas Pärenson
strateegilise planeerimise osakonna juhataja
Lisa: APR EE-INNOVATION 2021.pdf
Lisaadressaat: Ettevõtluse ja Innovatsiooni Sihtasutus
Tanel Tomson
639 7642
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 625 6342 /
[email protected] / www.mkm.ee
Registrikood 70003158
ANNUAL PROGRAMME REPORT
FM14-21
Estonia
EE-INNOVATION Competitiveness
2021
1
A. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Green ICT programme objective is increased value creation and sustainable growth in Estonia’s
private sector. Programme aims to stipulate and develop innovation-led long-term business
cooperation between Estonia and Norway by initiating bilateral cooperation projects and events.
Programme has three focus areas: Green Industry Innovation, ICT and Welfare Technology.
The Programme is implemented through two Small Grant Schemes, two Main Calls and two
pre-defined projects. This report consists of the overview of the reporting period 2021 and
progress on the results framework.
Second Main Call was carried out in the reporting period, which resulted in 12 contracted
projects under the focus areas of Green Industry Innovation and Welfare Technology. Total
grant awarded to the projects was 6,375,554.71 euros. Second Small Grants Scheme was
st th
launched on November 1 and closed on January 17 , 2022.
Second Main Call did not significantly affect the results framework as some of the set indicators
have not been met. Only the “number of SMEs supported to develop new green
products/services/processes” and target for the Welfare Technology developments have been
achieved. The indicators set for large companies, SME-s for application of new technologies
and bilateral targets remained unachieved. Two first Main Call projects were completed during
the reporting period, therefore some progress has been made towards the results framework.
One bilateral event was organised during the reporting period, which contribute to strengthening
bilateral relations between Norway and Estonia.
Green ICT programme website www.eas.ee/norratoetus (in Estonian) and
www.eas.ee/norwaygrants (in English) include programme scope, calls, events, application
information and relevant deadlines.
Programme had several media coverages, including press releases and articles on launching the
calls and supported projects in national newspapers and online media. As a good practice, press
releases were prepared as a trilateral cooperation between the Programme Operator (hereinafter
PO), Implementing Agency (hereinafter IA) and the Royal Norwegian Embassy in Tallinn, to
ensure that the information reaches relevant target groups; and have the maximum media
coverage in Estonia.
B. PERFORMANCE
1. Programme context
The spread of the coronavirus from the start of 2020 has had a major impact on the performance
of the Estonian economy as elsewhere in the world. After 2% drop in 2020 the Estonian
economy managed to grow rapidly (approx. 8%) in 2021. Growth has been fast due to effective
engagement of production inputs left idle during the pandemic crisis. The rapid growth in the
economy in 2021 came primarily from a sharp rise in hours worked and from more intensive
utilisation of equipment. Growth from such factors never lasts for long though, as the available
resources run out.
1
Growth in the economy is being hindered by supply-side problems. Pan-European surveys of
industrial companies show that industrial output in Estonia is being restrained most by labour
shortages, while the greatest concern in Europe as a whole is access to equipment and materials.
Production capacity utilisation in manufacturing was extraordinarily high in October (approx.
86%), meaning there is now little free production capacity that could support faster growth.
Supply difficulties in turn mean it may be hard to increase production capacity.
Growth in the Estonian economy will slow after its rapid recovery. The growth of 8% in 2021
will be replaced by growth of 2.8% in 2022. The growth will slow primarily because the short-
term spurt of growth during the exit from the slump will fade.
Rapid increase of energy prices has been a concern.
On one hand, the rapid rise in energy prices will restrain demand. Demand was boosted in 2021
by the rapid recovery of the economy, increased confidence among consumers, but this effect
will fade. The large rise in energy prices will make it harder for households to consume in the
near future. It is hard to cut energy consumption in the short term, so the higher energy prices
will reduce demand for other goods and services and restrain growth in the economy.
On the other hand, the Estonian companies are obliged to occupy all the resources in
manufacturing even more efficiently to consume less energy and in addition find new ways for
using cheaper and greener energy.
Due to uncertainty towards the future, participation of Estonian and Norwegian entrepreneurs
in open calls of Green ICT programme has been a bit less active than predicted. Still, many
companies have decided to turn their products, services and solutions greener and thus have
found their way to opportunities offered in Green ICT programme financed from the budget of
Norway Grants.
2. Programme results
Outcome 1: Increased competitiveness of Estonian companies within focus areas Green
Industry Innovation, ICT and Welfare Technology
The reporting period is characterized by significant progress in the implementation of the
Green ICT programme, with an officiated second Main Call and the launch of the second
Small Grant Scheme.
Second main call
Second main call was launched on November 16th, 2020 and closed on February 1st, 2021.
Companies were invited to submit applications to the Green Industry Innovation and Welfare
Technology focus areas in the following budgetary details:
1. Green Industry Innovation, available budget 4,779,956.05 euros.
2
2. Welfare Technology, available budget 2,457,246.20 euros.
The interest towards the second call can be considered modest compared to the first call, with
total of 18 applications submitted.
Green Industry Innovation: 14 applications (2 bilateral partnerships) in grant amount of
7,269,829.15 euros.
Welfare Technologies: 4 applications (1 bilateral partnership) in grant amount of 1,689,644.41
euros.
The evaluation of the applications took place from February until May 2021. Each application
pervaded first compliance check, followed by the environmental impact assessment, evaluation
for bilateral cooperation and evaluation criterion. Cooperation Committee meeting took place
on June 6th, 2021, resulting with the proposal to the Management Board of IA to grant 12
applications in total sum of 6,511,260.25 euros.
Selection Committee proposed IA to fund 12 applications with 2 projects remaining in reserve
list due in Green Industry Innovation call to the budget deficit. PO initiated a modification to
Programme Agreement to merge all funds released from previous calls (I main call, Small Grant
Scheme) into II Main Call budget. The new version of the Annex II to the Programme
Agreement entered into force on July 2, 2021with final budgetary details for the call as follows:
1. Green Industry Innovation budget 5,214,501.00 euros.
2. Welfare Technology call budget 1,296,759.25 euros.
By early July 2021, IA approved the proposition of the Selection Committee and contracted 12
projects in total grant of 6,375,554.71 euros. Projects’ implementation period was therefore
considered eligible starting from the contracting dates signed between IA and project promoters.
All II Main Call projects must be finished by April 30th, 2024, at the latest.
After two main calls there were 34 supported main call projects.
I main call: 44 submitted applications, 22 supported projects (14 bilateral partnerships), grant in
amount of 19,397,597.55 euros.
II main call: 18 submitted applications, 12 supported projects (3 bilateral partnerships), grant in
amount of 6,375,554.71 euros.
3
Second Small Grant Scheme
Additional Programme Agreement entered into force on October 15, 2021 and reallocation of
savings within programme was made - within Green Industry Innovation focus area and from
management costs to Green Industry Innovation. Modification was done prior to the launch of
the second Small Grant Scheme to allocate more funds for projects.
st th
Second Small Grant Scheme was launched on November 1 , 2021 ending on January 17 , 2022
(at 12:00 local Estonian time). Companies were invited to participate in two focus areas: Green
Industry Innovation and Welfare Technology. Call budget is 2,636,915.33 euros.
Minimum amount of the grant is 50,000 euros per project and maximum amount is 200,000
euros. Implementation period of the SGS projects is up to 24 months. The evaluation of the
second Small Grant Scheme is set on the period January-March, following by Selection
Committee and project contracting in April 2022.
Progress on results framework
Second main call presented some progress on achievements of the results framework. Regarding
the output 1.1. “Enterprises supported to develop or apply innovative green products, services
and processes” only the “number of SMEs supported to develop new green
products/services/processes” has been achieved with 6 additional projects (target “5”, total
achievement “20”). The indicators set for large companies remained unachieved, both the
number of large enterprises supported to apply new green products/ services/ processes (I call
“1”, II call “1” with total of “2” out of targeted “5”) and number of large enterprises supported
to develop new green products/services/processes (“0” from both calls out of targeted “2”). The
indicator for SMEs that supported to apply new green products/services/processes (new-to-the-
enterprise) also remained unachieved (I call “2”, II call “2” with total of “4” out of targeted
“15”).
Output 1.2 “Enterprises supported to develop innovative ICT products, services and processes”
remained unchanged as no ICT projects were supported during the II Main Call. Output 1.3
“Enterprises supported to develop innovative welfare products, services and processes” has
exceeded the set target of “5” to number of SMEs supported to develop new welfare technology
products/services/processes with total of “7” supported SMEs.
Progress on project implementations
The reporting period resulted with 3 Main Call project terminations:
1. EE-INNOVATION-0064 “Development of the full-scale logistics management tool
Intepia.com to improve the efficiency of logistics companies” by Intepia OÜ was terminated on
4
February 12th, 2021 based on termination application submitted by Project Promoter. The
termination was caused by difficulties that Project Promoter was facing to finance the project.
Funding of the project had been affected by the economic burden of the COVID-19 situation
and the Project promoter had been trying to find additional funding, but unsuccessfully. Project
has been terminated with no payments done. The budget surplus of 476,221.5 euros was merged
with second Open Call budget.
2. EE-INNOVATION-0055 “Development of autonomous street cleaning robots” by
Autonoomne Robot OÜ was terminated on February 19th, 2021 based on termination
application submitted by Project Promoter. The termination was caused by financial difficulties
to cover the development costs and self-financing of the project. As additional resources have
not been mobilised and competing solutions are emerging on the market, Project Promoter has
decided to discard the grant. Project has been terminated with no payments done. The budget
surplus of 627,082.53 euros was merged with second Open Call budget.
3. EE-INNOVATION-0066 “Well4Seis” by Ragnarock OÜ was terminated on September 8th,
2021 based on termination application submitted by Project Promoter. The circumstances of the
termination are related to the inability of the Project Promoter and partner to carry out the project
activities nor achieve the objectives set to the project. Project has been terminated with no
payments done. The budget surplus of 270,000 euros was merged with second Small Grant
Scheme budget.
In the reporting period two first Main Call projects were completed and therefore some progress
has been made to green impact results.
Project “Green 44” by ALFA Yacht Production OÜ (EE-INNOVATION-0060) has been
completed on July 31st, 2021. First 44-foot performance sailboat prototype was developed and
built during the project by using maximum amount of ecologically sustainable materials and
solutions. 1 permanent job was established during the one-year project period. The estimated
annual growth in turnover and net operational profit were well achieved as the protype was
successfully launched and sold after the development. Project promoter presented IA pre-order
statements for the future productions.
For green impact results the Project Promoter presented the Impact Assessment Report, which
indicated the need to increase the amount of material during the implementation process. As
traditional materials were replaced with new sustainable materials, the targets for CO2 savings
were also increased. Based on the calculations the total savings over the useful life (15y) of one
yacht is 70.91 tons of CO2 eq. For each yacht the 0.48 MWh energy reduction is calculated.
According to the applicant, the increase in materials did not have a calculated significant effect
on energy consumption and thus remained the same. Therefore, the estimated CO2 emissions
reductions for the project was 70,91 tons of CO2 equivalents and estimated annual decrease of
energy consumption is 0,48 MWh.
5
Total payment of 385,224.93 euros was done to project promoter with budget surplus of
2,686.32 euros.
Project “Development of a fully-automated edible insect mass rearing and production
technology” by BugBox OÜ (EE-INNOVATION-0050) was completed on September 30th,
2021. Project is considered successful, the IT-platform and sensors were developed, which are
core components of fully automating the insect mass rearing and production process. As a result
of the project, the reactors are now fully managed by an IT-platform. Project was implemented
with a Norwegian partner Prediktor Instruments. Cooperation has been assessed as fruitful and
is expected to continue in the future. In addition, the Project Promoter has taken steps to register
the intellectual property with German patent company Stellbrink & Partners.
6 permanent jobs were established during the project period (01.08.2020 - 30.09.2021). The
estimated annual growth in turnover and net operational profit were not yet fully manifested as
the marketing and sales activities have been planned to the post-project period. According to the
IA standard procedures, the achievement of economic indicators is verified 1 year after the end
of the project (follow-up report submitted by 30.09.2022).
With the final report, the Project Promoted submitted a report of the green impact on production
and technology. The project was carried out with a test rig and the results are scaled to a 1 m3
reactor equation. According to the calculations provided, the results are better than expected:
CO2 reduction is 48tons of CO2 emissions (40 tons of CO2 initially targeted) and energy saving
have also increased resulting with 6.4MWh instead of the planned 2MWh.
Total payment of 365,108.15 euros was done to project promoter with budget surplus of
11,635.69 euros.
Pre-defined project(s)
Two pre-defined projects are being implemented under the Green ICT programme:
EE-INNOVATION-0001 “Open Cyber Range (OCR)” implemented by the Estonian Ministry
of Defence, and
EE-INNOVATION-0002 “Health Sense” implemented by Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs.
Project promoter of EE-INNOVATION-0001 “Open Cyber Range (OCR)” has agreed the
details for implementation of project with partners and started project activities. The project
consortia has taken the very first steps so far, therefore, there are no major payments made yet.
Project activities must be finished by April 2024.
6
Project promoter of EE-INNOVATION-0002 “Health Sense” project has suggested
modification of project contract for initiating a new activity – development of
serialization/deserialization tool, necessary for changing health data anonymous, while giving
it out to interested stakeholders. Cost of some equipment initially planned to procure within
“Health Sense” project has been covered from other financing and there is no more need to use
project’s funding for buying the equipment, therefore it is possible to use it for development of
serialization/deserialization tool. Total budget of project will not change. There might be a need
for extention of project implementation period due to large amount of Covid-19 related activities
in project promoter's organisation.
Bilateral Outcome: Enhanced collaboration between beneficiary and donor state entities
involved in the programme
Analysis of bilateral relations and achievements
After the two main calls, the bilateral output 1 “Bilateral partnerships supported” has not been
achieved. Second call added only 3 bilateral partnership projects to the 16 reached in the first
Main Call (with total of “19” out of targeted “45”).
Norwegian universities continued to provide sectoral expertise to the Estonian companies,
especially in Welfare Technology focus area. This is well reflected in project EE-
INNOVATION-0074 “Implementation of polygenic risk score guided breast cancer precision
prevention (AnteNOR)” implemented by Antegenes OÜ. Antegenes has registered and CE-
certified a breast cancer genetic risk test AnteBC that is based on polygenic risk scores
technology. AnteBC allows to differentiate women’s genetic predisposition to breast cancer and
to make more specific recommendations for the prevention and early detection of breast cancer.
The general objective of the project is to implement AnteBC test as part of a breast cancer
screening routine in Norway. Current breast cancer screening is only age based but can decrease
mortality by around 20% if invitations account for AnteBC results. The project activities deploy
AnteBC to Norwegian healthcare: a consortium of partners assesses the test performance in the
Norwegian population, conducts a clinical pilot study and assembles technical documentation
to prepare for public reimbursement. Project is implemented in close cooperation with Oslo
Cancer Cluster, Osly Universitetsykehus, Vestre Viken Hospital Trust and Oslo University. See
more at project website: https://antegenes.com/green-ict/
Project EE-INNOVATION-0085 “Fuel cell and Li-ion capacitor power system for construction
industry” implemented by Power Up Fuel Cells OÜ is implemented with Norwegian companies
Beyonder AS and Nordic Batteries AS. Project aims to develop a portable fuel cell-based
generator that supplies clean energy to areas that need an uninterrupted energy supply. The
generator uses hydrogen gas as a fuel and is a pollution-free solution, hence it assumed to be a
good replacement for polluting and heavy-duty diesel generators. With an expertise provided
by Beyonder AS, the world's leading developer of Li-ion capacitors, the innovative solution will
be targeted to the construction sector first.
7
Third bilateral partnership project is EE-INNOVATION-0082 “Demand response combination
with energy storage system” implemented by Fusebox OÜ in cooperation with Norwegian
partner Pixii AS. The aim is to develop a technological service that enables large electricity
consumers to participate in the electricity market by regulating their demand (the so-called
virtual power plant). Pixii is a Norwegian company that focuses on various battery-based storage
solutions. The aim of the bilateral cooperation is to reduce the carbon intensity of the energy
sector and increase the overall efficiency of the energy system.
In addition to the project level partnerships, the programme contributed into bilateral activities
by organizing a webinar under the focus area of Welfare Technology on December 14th, 2021.
The main objective of the event was to attract Estonian and Norwegian companies to form new
partnerships and participate in the ongoing Small Grant Scheme. Webinar can be re-watched in
Green ICT website www.eas.ee/norwaygrants. Event was organised in close cooperation with
IA and donor programme partner Innovation Norway (DPP) and proved to be a success in terms
of holding a professional virtual event during the continuous times of Covid-19 crisis.
Cooperation with DPP demonstrated to be close and effective. DPP has taken strong initiative
to arrange “umbrella” events under the bilateral activities that involve several beneficiary
countries. This provides various matchmaking opportunities and sets a ground basis for partner
search in all participating countries. In terms of DPP involvement in programme, the
comprehensive knowledge and experiences has sufficiently supported the evaluation process of
the second open call. IN was responsible of evaluating the bilateral partnerships in the
applications, which resulted with timely and thorough assessments. Due to DPP active
involvement in Cooperation Committee meetings, all the essential topics are mutually
deliberated prior any enforcements.
In 2021, two Cooperation Committee meetings were organised. Cooperation Committee
meeting in June was mainly focused on second Main Call results, but also on upcoming bilateral
events and preparations towards the second Small Grants Scheme opening in November 2021.
Second Cooperation Committee meeting was held in the framework of the Welfare Technology
webinar on December 14th, 2021.
3. Implementation
Cooperation with International Partner Organisations (IPOs)
Cooperation with IPOs is not foreseen in the programme.
C. LEARNING
1. Monitorings carried out
8
IA monitors project promoters granted under the Programme through verification of reports,
procurements, and payment claims, also conducting on-the-spot inspections and follow-up
inspections (during implementation of main call projects). Upon verification of payment claims,
reports and procurements and conducting on-the-spot inspections, IA internal procedures
“Inspection activities” shall be followed, as stated in the Management and Control Systems.
Inspection activities include on-the-spot activities according to the programme’s risk
assessment, control on procurement activities and results control (including examination of
results and involvement of experts, if necessary, for more complex projects). The main purpose
of the on-the-spot inspection is to obtain additional assurance on the eligibility of costs, the
progress of the project results and the objects, services or developments supported, where it is
not possible to verify without a site visit. On-site inspections are carried out by IA monitoring
specialists and project consultants usually at the end of the project activities.
Based on Green ICT programme risk assessment, IA monitoring unit shall conduct on-the-spot
inspections for 50% of the projects in the focus areas of Green Industry Innovation and ICT.
That means that half of the financed projects shall pass the on-site control procedures in addition
to the customary control procedures in IA. Considering the higher maximum grant amount for
Welfare Technology projects, the percentage for the on-the-spot inspections is 100%, which
means that all projects financed under WT shall pass the on-site control procedures in addition
to the customary control in IA (cost verification, compliance, results control etc). In the
reporting period, on-the-spot inspection was carried out to the project EE-INNOVATION-0060
(Alfa Yacht Production “Green 44”). No deficiencies were identified during the on-site
inspection. In 2022, five (5) on-the-spot inspections are planned according to the completion of
the main call projects.
Notifying of irregularities shall be based on Regulation No. 143 of the Government of the
Republic of Estonia of 1 September 2014 “Conditions and Procedure for Deeming Costs to Be
Compensated for out of Structural Assistance of the Period 2014–2020 as Eligible, Payment of
Support and Making Financial Corrections” and recovery of the grant shall be based on the
Performance Agreement (signed between PO and IA), Programme Agreement and Regulation
on the Implementation of the Norwegian Financial Mechanism 2014–2021.
One irregularity in first Small Grant Scheme project and one in first Main Call has been notified
in the reporting period:
1. Irregularity (EAS/2014-2020/21/289) for project no EE-INNOVATION-0007 Industry62
“Preliminary studies for Next Generation Organizational Engagement System NGOES”.
Irregularity case was caused by incorrect accounting of staff costs and was discovered during
the cost verification process. IA initiated financial correction proceedings on 16.02.2021 for the
ineligible amount of 2201.97 euros as the amount of one month’s salary was considered
ineligible in sum of 2201,97*52,45% (grant rate) = 1154.93 euros. Therefore, the grant to the
amount of 1154.93 was reclaimed from the Project Promoter. Financial correction decision
adopted on 22.03.2021. The Project Promoter has already paid the recovery during the hearing.
Therefore, the irregularity case has been closed.
2. Irregularity (EAS/2014-2020/21/339) for project nr EE-INNOVATION-0053 Eziil Production
Intelligence OÜ “Development of Eziil production software for product-based production
companies”. Irregularity case was caused by incorrect accounting of staff costs and was
9
discovered during the cost verification process, whereas one employee of partner company has
a difference in the calculation of the social tax. The company has paid social tax at a reduced
rate, this has not been considered when calculating the total eligible staff cost. Non-eligible cost
in total of 109.13 euros. The grant to be recovered is 109.13*40% (grant rate) = 43.65 euros.
The financial correction decision is being drafted.
On programme level, two ongoing irregularities in management costs have been identified:
1. During the verification of the project costs in 2020-2021, the Certifying Authority (CA)
established that the IA has calculated the special incentive fee in the amount of 407.06 euros in
the payment application, but the correct amount is 262.76 euros. The difference of 144.30 euros
occurred because some of the calculated special incentive tax was counted double in the
payment application. Therefore, the difference of 144.30 euros is not eligible. The irregularity
is being processed and soon to be closed, the ineligible cost shall be recovered by IA.
th
2. On February 10 , 2021 CA discovered that the fringe benefit in the amount of 3136.95 have
been incorrectly calculated at the expense of the opening event of Green ICT on 15.10.2018
whereas the correct amount was 190.92 euros. The difference of 3,136.95 euros is due to
incorrect calculation of the social security and income tax amounts. The difference of 3,136.95
euros is therefore ineligible. In addition, the payment claim erroneously submitted a mentoring
fee of 42.82 euros in December 2018, which is an ineligible cost. Furthermore, indirect costs
based on ineligible mentoring fee in amount of 6.42 euros are ineligible. The program operator
will apply a financial correction to these amounts and will consider the ineligible expenditure
to be 3,186.19 euros. The irregularity is being processed and soon to be closed, the ineligible
cost shall be recovered by IA.
2. Evaluations carried out
There are no evaluations carried out at this stage.
Final evaluation (ex post) of the programme’s implementation/impact will be carried out in
2024.
3. Lessons learned from monitoring, evaluation and implementation
Considered as force majeure, the Covid-19 global pandemic proved to be a continuous challenge
when building new partnerships. Organising face to face meetings internationally was difficult
or even impossible. Without the direct communication, the trust between the newly established
partnerships remained rather weak to submit a joint application, especially for partners with very
short communication history. In some cases, electronic communication channels could be used,
but not always. As a lesson learned we see that limited communication has negatively affected
the bilateral cooperation in the programme. That is also reflected in the results of the second
Main Call as well as bilateral indicators not achieved.
D. ANNEXES
1. Updated achievements in the results framework
2. Communication summary
3. Overview of contracted projects
10
4. Risk management
5. Monitoring plan
6. Evaluation report
7. Agreement conditions
11
Annex 1: Updated achievements in the results framework
Objective: Increased value creation and sustainable growth
Outcome 1: Increased competitiveness of Estonian companies within focus areas Green Industry Innovation, ICT and Welfare Technology
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2021
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
Estimated annual CO2 emissions reductions Annual Annual result of two finalised
0.00 0 (APR 2020) - - 118.91 25,000.00
(tons of CO2 equivalent per year) number projects.
Only two projects have finished
Estimated annual growth in turnover of
Percentage N/A - 0 0 - 5.00 % their activities recently. Result
supported enterprises
will be reported in next APR.
Only two projects have finished
Estimated annual growth in net operational
Percentage N/A - 0 0 - 5.00 % their activities recently. Result
profit of supported enterprises
will be reported in next APR.
Estimated annual decrease of energy Only two projects have finished
consumption of supported enterprises (in Percentage - - 0 0 - 5.00 % their activities recently. Result
MWh) will be reported in next APR.
Number of products/services/processes tested Cumulative No results to report yet as PDP
0 0 (APR 2020) - - 0 10
in the Open Cyber Range security platform number is at early stage.
Number of new products/services/processes Projects on application of
Cumulative
applied (new-to-the-enterprise) (disaggregated 0 0 (APR 2020) - - 0 20 products/services/processes
number
by sector) have not been finished yet.
Number of registered applications for Cumulative No IPP applications registered
0 0 (APR 2020) - - 0 5
Intellectual Property Protection number yet.
Cumulative
Number of jobs created 0 83 (IFR 2021) - - 90 100 Result of two finalised projects.
number
Gender
Female - - - - - 3 - -
Male - - - - - 4 - -
Not specified - - - - - 83 - -
12
Age
Children and youth (0-17) - - - - - 0 - -
Young adults (18-29) - - - - - 2 - -
Adults (30-64) - - - - - 5 - -
Elderly (65+) - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 83 - -
Number of new products/services/processes Cumulative
0 0 (APR 2020) - - 2 25 Result of two finalised projects.
developed (disaggregated by sector) number
Output 1.1: Enterprises supported to develop or apply innovative green products, services and processes
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2021
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
Number of large enterprises supported in SGS Cumulative It's a final result. No change
0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 15
to prepare projects for main call number foreseen.
Number of large enterprises supported to apply Cumulative
0 2 (IFR 2021) - - 2 5 No improvement.
new green products/services/processes number
Number of SMEs supported in SGS to prepare Cumulative It's a final result. No change
0 13 (IFR 2021) - - 13 30
projects for main call number foreseen.
Number of SMEs supported to apply new green
Cumulative
products/services/processes (new-to-the- 0 4 (IFR 2021) - - 4 15 No improvement.
number
enterprise)
Number of SMEs supported to develop new Cumulative
0 20 (IFR 2021) - - 20 5 No improvement.
green products/services/processes number
Number of large enterprises supported to
Cumulative
develop new green 0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 2 No improvement.
number
products/services/processes
Output 1.2: Enterprises supported to develop innovative ICT products, services and processes
Achievements Achievements until end of December
Unit of
Indicator Baseline until end of 2021 Target Comment
measurement
previous Numerator Denominator Value
13
reporting
period
Number of SMEs supported in SGS to prepare Cumulative It's a final result. No change
0 20 (IFR 2021) - - 20 25
projects for main call number foreseen.
No improvement as there was
Number of SMEs supported to develop ICT Cumulative
0 4 (IFR 2021) - - 4 8 no call for proposal in the focus
products, services and processes number
area of ICT.
Number of large enterprises supported in SGS Cumulative It's a final result. No change
0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 6
to prepare projects for main call number foreseen.
No improvement as there was
Number of large enterprises supported to Cumulative
0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 5 no call for proposal in the focus
develop ICT products, services and processes number
area of ICT.
Output 1.3: Enterprises supported to develop innovative welfare products, services and processes
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2021
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
Number of large enterprises supported in SGS Cumulative It's a final result. No change
0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 2
to prepare projects for main call number foreseen.
Number of enterprises supported in SGS to Cumulative It's a final result. No change
0 11 (IFR 2021) - - 11 8
prepare projects for main call number foreseen.
Number of SMEs supported to develop new
Cumulative Three projects added in
welfare technology 0 7 (IFR 2021) - - 7 5
number comparison to APR 2020.
products/services/processes
Output 1.4: Open Cyber Range (OCR) is operational
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2021
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
14
Number of SMEs supported to test new
Cumulative No results to report yet as PDP
products/services/processes in the Open Cyber 0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 15
number is at early stage.
Range
Cumulative
Number of professional staff trained 0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 100 Trainings have not started yet.
number
Gender
Female - - - - - 0 - -
Male - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Roma
Roma - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Output 1.5: Health Sense data management platform developed and operating
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2021
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
Data collection, and publishing environment
architecture and data analysis environment Binary No No (IFR 2021) - - No Yes Work in process, no result yet.
architecture developed and published
Data collection and publishing
Binary No No (IFR 2021) - - No Yes Work in process, no result yet.
procedures/tools in place and documented
Data analysis procedures/tools in place and
Binary No No (IFR 2021) - - No Yes Work in process, no result yet.
documented
Number of data mining/Artificial Intelligence Cumulative
0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 3 Work in process, no result yet.
pilot projects successfully finished number
Cumulative
Number of professional staff trained 0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 10 Work in process, no result yet.
number
Gender
Female - - - - - 0 - -
Male - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
15
Roma
Roma - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Bilateral Outcome: Enhanced collaboration between beneficiary and donor state entities involved in the programme
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2021
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
6.50,
4.5,
Based
Target is
on the
≥4.5, and
survey
5.08 (APR an
Level of satisfaction with the partnership Scale 1-7 carried - - 5.22 -
2020) increase
out on
on the
behalf
baseline
of the
value
FMO
State type
Beneficiary State - - - - - 4.67 - -
Donor State - - - - - 5.78 - -
Not specified - - - - - - - -
6.55,
4.5,
Based
Target is
on the
≥4.5, and
survey
Level of trust between cooperating entities in 5.25 (APR an
Scale 1-7 carried - - 5.33 -
Beneficiary States and Donor States 2020) increase
out on
on the
behalf
baseline
of the
value
FMO
State type
Beneficiary State - - - - - 4.67 - -
Donor State - - - - - 6 - -
16
Not specified - - - - - - - -
50.00 %,
Share of donor business partnerships which Target is
Percentage N/A - - - - -
continue after project implementation period minimum
50%
Number of jointly registered applications for Cumulative No IPP applications registered
0 0 (APR 2020) - - 0 3
Intellectual Property Protection number yet.
Donor State
Norway - - - - - 0 - -
Iceland - - - - - 0 - -
Liechtenstein - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
50,
Share of cooperating organisations that apply
100.00 % (APR Target is
the knowledge acquired from bilateral Percentage N/A 6 6 100.00 % -
2020) minimum
partnership
50 %
State type
Beneficiary State - - - 3 3 100.00 % - -
Donor State - - - 3 3 100.00 % - -
Not specified - - - 0 0 - - -
Bilateral Output 1: Bilateral partnerships supported
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2021
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
We have reported 18 donor
partnership projects earlier.
Unfortunately project EE-
Number of projects involving cooperation with Cumulative
0 18 (IFR 2021) - - 17 45 INNOVATION-0066 was
a donor project partner number
terminated. Termination was
initiated by the project
promoter due to incapability to
17
carry out the project activities
nor achieve the objectives set
to the project.
Donor State
Norway - - - - - 17 - -
Iceland - - - - - 0 - -
Liechtenstein - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Cumulative No staff in exchanges to be
Number of staff from donor states in exchanges 0 0 (IFR 2021) - - 0 5
number reported.
Donor State
Norway - - - - - 0 - -
Iceland - - - - - 0 - -
Liechtenstein - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Gender
Female - - - - - 0 - -
Male - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Type of exchange
Online - - - - - 0 - -
Physical - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
18
Annex 2: Communication summary
1. Best practice examples
The project "Development of a climate panel for R8tech digital operator" of R8 Technologies
OÜ financed with grant in amount of 335,720.25 euros focuses on green transition in the real
estate sector.
The aim of the Green ICT project is to develop climate models for better operation of the indoor
climate of buildings. Based on climate models, an addition to the R8 Digital Operator will be
created in the form of a climate panel, which will allow buildings’ managers to adjust the indoor
climate in real time, taking into account the impact of changes on the energy consumption of
buildings.
See more information about the project on R8 Technologies website (https://r8tech.io/green-
ict/).
2. Best bilateral cooperation examples
Cooperation project between Estonian start-up Fusebox and the Norwegian company Pixii in
grant amount of 691,600 euros under Green Industry Innovation focus area for development and
supplementing energy storage systems with consumption-side flexibility. The project between
electricity consumers, energy storage and energy systems will enable real-time communication
in order to maximise the use of renewable energy sources and address the challenges of volatile
energy production. See more information about the project on Fusebox website
(https://fusebox.energy/fusebox-and-pixii-joined-forces/).
The technology developed in the project of Antegenes OÜ, financed under Welfare
Technologies focus area in amount of 761,360 euros, enables precision prevention of breast
cancer based on a novel genetic test. The novel breast cancer genetic test relays on polygenic
risk score technology, which makes it possible to distinguish between women's genetic
predisposition to breast cancer and provide accurate recommendations for breast cancer
prevention and early detection. The partners of the project are the University of Oslo, Oslo
University Hospital, Vestre Viken Hospital Trust and the Oslo Cancer Cluster. All partners are
centres of excellence in the field of oncological diseases, both in Norway and internationally,
with a very strong scientific and clinical background. See more information about the project
on Antegenes website (https://antegenes.com/green-ict/).
3. The programme in a nutshell
Green ICT programme financed by Norway Grants is an excellent
What is the added
opportunity for Estonian and Norwegian companies to increase their
value of this
competitiveness through enhancement of the economic cooperation
programme?
between Estonia and Norway.
Quote 1
Include up to two
quotes about this There are many attentive and smart entrepreneurs in Estonia who will get
the opportunity to boost their venture with the help of the support
programme.
programme. It is possible to develop completely new solutions, but also to
Please include the
introduce solutions that are already successfully operating elsewhere in
19
name, last name and the world by adapting to the needs of the company, thereby increasing the
title of the person. competitiveness of both the company and Estonia in the industrial sector
and in the field of health technologies.
Name Title
Author Minister of Entrepreneurship and
Andres Sutt
Information Technology
Quote 2
Estonia and Norway are both digitally highly developed societies and this
creates a good basis for cross-border cooperation despite the exceptional
situation.
Name Title
Author Else Berit Ambassador of the Kingdom of Norway
Eikeland to Estonia
4. Visibility of the Grants and the Donors
Communication plan 2017-2024 describes the Green ICT Programme communication goals,
target groups and main messages. Focus of the communication is on promoting Green ICT
programme: the focus, content, and business opportunities for companies via bilateral
cooperation. The main channel for the programme specific information is
www.eas.ee/norwaygrants, which contains updated information about the calls, application
documents, events etc.
Website of PO https://www.mkm.ee/et/tegevused-eesmargid/valisvahendid/norra-ja-euroopa-
majanduspiirkonna-finantsmehhanismid provides the main information on Norway Grants and
programme “Green ICT”. It refers to the NFP website https://eeagrants.fin.ee and IA
Programme website www.eas.ee/norwaygrants, which includes more specific information on
programme, such as scope, calls, events, application information and relevant deadlines.
IA social media channels https://www.facebook.com/EnterpriseEstonia/ and LinkedIn profile
https://www.linkedin.com/company/enterprise-estonia are used to promote programme events
and activities (articles, good examples, events). IA Youtube channel
https://www.youtube.com/user/EnterpriseEstonia is used to present video material and best
practices (i.e., project examples).
NFP website http://eeagrants.fin.ee/en/ reflects a short description of the Green ICT programme
with links to the IA website for more detailed information.
5. Media coverage
Example 1
Coverage Type National
“Thermory new thermo complex completed” in Forestry news on
Description December 3rd, 2021 and Construction News on December 6th, 2021
20
Description of new improved production facility at Thermory for
producing painted and fireproof thermally modified products for use on
wooden façades.
https://www.metsamajandusuudised.ee/uudised/2021/12/03/thermory-uus-
Relevant links
termokompleks-alustab-tood
Example 2
Coverage Type National
“Estonia's environmentally friendly hydrogen sailboat Clean Energy is
Description going to conquer the world” in online newspaper Postimees on August
19th, 2021
https://merendus.postimees.ee/7318511/eesti-keskkonnasaastlik-
Relevant links
vesinikupurjekas-clean-energy-laheb-maailma-vallutama
Example 3
Coverage Type National
“The new roofing material looks like a plain tin roof, but cleverly
Description
generates electricity from the sun” in Genius on August 2nd, 2021
https://kodu.geenius.ee/sisuturundus/uus-katusematerjal-naeb-valja-kui-
Relevant links
tavaline-plekk-katus-aga-nutikal-moel-toodab-see-paikesest-elektrit/
Example 4
Coverage Type National
“The Estonian company Fusebox is developing an energy storage system
Description
responsive to Norwegian consumption” in Goodnews on June 15th, 2021
https://majandus.goodnews.ee/eesti-firma-fusebox-arendab-norralastega-
Relevant links
tarbimisele-reageerivat-energiasalvestussusteemi/
Example 5
Coverage Type National
“The Estonian migraine app launched a clinical trial and successfully
Description completed the first round of investments” in Delfi on December 22nd,
2021
https://arileht.delfi.ee/artikkel/95470953/eesti-migreeniapp-kaivitas-
Relevant links
kliinilise-uuringu-lopetas-edukalt-esimese-investeerimisvooru
6. Website and social media
6.a. Links to the programme website and social media accounts
21
Link to programme website
https://eas.ee/teenus/norwaygrants/?l...
Change in Change in
number of (page Total number of unique number of (page
Total number of page
views) compared visitors in the reporting visitors)
views in the reporting year
to the previous year compared to the
year previous year
7368 -4946 5654 -3470
Specific
Posts Total likes in Total Total shares/Re- Followers
link or
published in the comments in tweets etc. in gained since
handle
the reporting reporting the reporting the reporting programme
for the
year year year year launch
account
https://www.facebook.com/EEANorwayGrantsEstonia
Facebook
40 134 13 41 649
https://www.linkedin.com/company/enterprise-estonia/
LinkedIn
1 3 0 1 0
6.b. Results of website and social media activities
Several media campaigns for introduction of projects under programme has been organised in
cooperation with National Focal Point.
Social media posts have been published mainly for promoting open call for proposal.
Press releases are usually prepared and published in cooperation between Programme
Operator, Implementing Agency, Donor Programme Partner and National Focal Point.
7. Visuals
Should add some visuals to media library in 2022, when more projects' results are coming in.
22
Annex 3: Overview of contracted projects
# of % of
donor Amount outcome
Outcome Projects #
project contracted budget
partners contracted
Outcome 1: Increased Pre-defined 2 3 € 5,331,765 20.96 %
competitiveness of Contracted through
38 21 € 18,535,770 72.88 %
Estonian companies open calls
within focus areas Contracted through
Green Industry 45 1 € 828,451 3.26 %
small grants scheme
Innovation, ICT and
Welfare Technology Total Outcome 1 85 25 € 24,695,986 97.11 %
Programme Total 85 25 € 24,695,986 97.11 %
23
Annex 4: Risk management
Programmatic risks
Risk
Risk description Risk related to Likelihood Consequence Response type Validity
score
Reducing social
and economic 2 3 2.45 Mitigate
disparities
Description of
Programme is vaguely targeted and assessment Observation of projects continues.
planned response
criteria does not support the outcomes.
Description of
Projects are contributing to programme outcomes.
actual response
Planned future
Observation of project results.
response
Both objectives 2 3 2.45 Transfer/Share
Description of
PO and IA keep track on reaching the targets.
Programme implementation is obstructed due to planned response
many players and mixed interest. Risk could result Description of Project activities and planned results are all supporting the achievement of
in unachieved programme (outcome) targets. actual response programme outcomes.
Planned future
PO and IA regularly keep track on reaching the targets.
response
Strengthening
3 3 3.00 Transfer/Share
Insufficient bilateral interest to implement joint bilateral relations
cooperation projects. Could result in low level of Description of Organising additional partner search activities for contracted projects could be
project cooperation and failure in achieving the planned response considered.
bilateral outcome. Description of Despite our efforts the interest towards bilateral cooperation has been lower
actual response than initially expected.
24
Planned future Organising bilateral seminars and conferences for entrepreneurs to create
response more bilateral contacts between Estonian and Norwegian companies.
Both objectives 2 3 2.45 Transfer/Share
Description of Necessity of additional targeted call will be discussed in mid 2021 to have
Opening of calls delayed. planned response sufficient time for implementation of projects.
Because of the long description please consult Description of Additional Small Grant Sceheme projects will have 24 months for
original document as uploaded. actual response implemantation of projects.
Planned future Planning additional funding round for already financed projects to enhance the
response project results in autumn 2022.
Operational risks
Risk
Risk description Risk related to Likelihood Consequence Response type Validity
score
Both objectives 1 2 1.41 Mitigate
Public procurement conditions not clear for Description of
Rules of procurement are being introduced on regular basis.
Project promoters. Ref. Regulation Art 8.15. planned response
Description of As a result of consulting project promoters are well aware of public
Because of the long description please consult actual response procurement conditions.
original document as uploaded. Planned future
Rules of procurement are being introduced on regular basis.
response
Reducing social
and economic 2 3 2.45 Mitigate
disparities
State aid rules not clear for project promoters. Risk
Description of
could result in project irregularities (i.e. Councelling of applicants continues in implementation phase.
planned response
miscalculated eligible activites, costs and aid
Description of All the state aid rules have been explained in understandable way to project
intensity).
actual response promoters.
Planned future
Councelling of applicants on state aid issues is a standard procedure.
response
25
Reducing social
and economic 2 3 2.45 Mitigate
Transfer of application and monitoring process disparities
into centralised information system administered Description of Implementing Agency seeks for automated solution in cooperation with
by National Focal Point may cause need for planned response National Focal Point.
additional manual data insertion by Implementing Description of
No major errors detected.
Agency, which may cause errors in data. actual response
Planned future
Data quality in information system is being monitored annually.
response
Projects are cancelled or activities not started due Both objectives 3 3 3.00 Mitigate New
to the lack of project promoter's co-financing, thus Thorough assessment of project promoter's financial capability before
Description of
grant cannot be paid to project promoter and set granting and continuous monitoring of project promoter during the
planned response
targets are not met. implementation phase.
Overall risk of the programme
Risk
Likelihood Consequence
score
OVERALL RISK OF THE PROGRAMME 2 3 2.45
26
Annex 5: Monitoring plan
Please note this Annex is uploaded separately and is not visible in this document. Please
download and print separately if needed.
Annex 6: Evaluation report
Not Available
27
Annex 7: Agreement conditions
28
Monitoring plan for Green ICT programme
Project # Project name Monitoring action Planned timing: Criteria for Risk issue with Comments
Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4 monitoring the project (if
(especially applicable)
for site visits)
All main call projects All main call projects Risk assessment of Q2 - 2022 Programme risks will be re-evaluated twice a
programmatic risks. Q4 - 2022 year.
All main call projects All main call projects Risk assessment of Q1 - 2022 All the Site visit decison is made according to
projects. Q3 - 2022 contracted existing risk level.
projects.
All main call projects All main call projects Proactive information Q2 - 2022 All project promoters are invited to
seminar organised by participate in seminar in order to inform
Enterprise Estonia on them about the specifics of the
key project implementing rules.
implementation issues.
All main call projects All main call projects Everyday Q1 - 2022 All the
communication and Q2 - 2022 projects with
consultation between Q3 - 2022 signed
Implementing Agency Q4 - 2022 contract.
and project promoters.
All projects All projects Checking the outputs Q2 - 2022 All the results
and results in RF of Q4 - 2022 of the
programme in programme.
Cooperation
Committee meeting.
All projects All projects Q1 - 2022 All the
Examination on the
Q2 - 2022 projects with
activity reports to
Q3 - 2022 signed
ensure the
Q4 - 2022 contract.
implementation of the
activities set out in the
application (incl.
prepared documents,
for example project
plan, environmental
impact analysis).
All projects All projects Q1 - 2022 All the
Verification of the
Q2 - 2022 projects with
payment claims,
Q3 - 2022 signed
including cost eligibility
Q4 - 2022 contract.
check and compliance
with the objectives of
the programme.