CERTIFICATION OF THE MEMBER STATE * (applicable only for ASR and for beneficiaries established in the European Union) Name Position Entity Telephone Nº E-mail In compliance with Article II.23.1 ( or SESAR FPA II.23.1b) of the GA, it is certified that the information provided by the following Beneficiary( ies ) in the ASR is full, reliable and true. Transport Administration Date and signature Stamp ( optional) * In line with the terms of Art. 22 of the CEF Regulation
REQUEST OF FURTHER PRE-FINANCING PAYMENT
INEA/CEF/TRAN/M2018/1
Grant Agreement Nº
767529
Action number 2018-EE-TM-0029-M
Dynamic traffic and truck
Action title
parking management
Beneficiary name Transport Administration
Financial information for the Action
A. Maximum EU contribution (Art. 3) 1,900,000.00 €
B. Pre-financing rate (Art. 4.1.2) 40.00 %
C. Maximum pre-financing payment (Art. 4.1.2)
760,000.00 €
(=B*A)
D. Maximum ceiling for the sum of pre-financing
1,520,000.00 €
and interim payments (Art 4.1.3) (=80%*A)
E. Sum of previous pre-financing payments 234,705.44 €
F. Sum of interim payments 17,220.64 €
Dear Sirs,
Along with the submission of the 2022 ASR for the Action in subject, we hereby
submit a request for further pre-financing. Please find enclosed:
the amount of the previous pre-financing used to cover costs of the Action,
the amount of the requested further pre-financing;
the allocation of the amounts to be paid to each beneficiary and the
methodology used (if applicable)
the financial guarantees (if applicable)
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220215_1249_Transport
Administration
ENCLOSED
Amount of the previous pre-financing used to cover costs of the Action
G. Total estimated direct eligible costs incurred until the end of
the previous reporting period 341,014.88 €
H. 70% of previous pre-financing payments (=70%*E) 164,293.81 €
Condition of 70% fulfilled (G>=H) Yes
I. Reduction of further pre-financing, if G<H (= H-G) 0.00 €
Amount of the requested further pre-financing
J. Total estimated direct costs eligible declared
until the end of the on-going current report
period 5,632,239.76 €
K. Total cumulated financing needs until the
end of the on-going current report period 2,513,313.62 €
L. Further pre-financing payment (=B*K-E)
770,620.01 €
L1. Revised further pre-financing payment if the
condition of the 70% is not fulfilled – article
II.24.1.3 (L-I) 770,620.01 €
L2. Revised further pre-financing if the total
pre-financing exceeds the maximum pre-
financing payment (E+L1<=C) 525,294.56 €
L3. Revised further pre-financing if the sum of
the pre-financings and interim payments
exceeds the ceiling (E+F+L2<=D) 525,294.56 €
M. Final further pre-financing to be paid (=L3) 525,294.56 €
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220215_1249_Transport
Administration
Indrek Gailan
Majandus- ja
Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
[email protected] Meie 16.02.2022 nr 5.2-1/21-968/3545-
Suur-Ameerika tn 1 1
10122, Tallinn, Harju maakond
Riigi kinnituskiri projekti 2021. aasta
vahearuandele
Austatud hr Gailan
Seoses Tallinna ringtee „Dynamic traffic and truck parking management” projektiga peab
Transpordiamet esitama eelmise perioodi (jaanuar 2021 kuni detsember 2021) vahearuande, mille
üheks osaks on riigi kinnituskiri. Palume tutvuda vahearuande raporti ja selle lisadega ning seejärel
Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumi esindajal täita ja käsitsi allkirjastada kinnituskiri
(dokument pealkirjaga „MS certification ASR_2021”) ning saata originaaldokumendina tagasi.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Mari-Liis Sepp
intelligentsete transpordisüsteemide projektijuht
arendusteenistus
Lisa: Report ASR_2021, Request of further pre-financing payment_2021, Financial Annex
ASR_2021, MS certification ASR_2021, Annex 1_ Eligible costs for Action Dynamic traffic and
truck parking management, Annex 2_timetable
Mari-Liis Sepp
58502984,
[email protected]
Valge 4 / 11413 Tallinn / 620 1200 /
[email protected] / www.transpordiamet.ee
Registrikood 70001490
European ASR-2022-2018-EE-TM-0029-M-
Commission
Dynamic traffic and truck parking
European Climate,
Infrastructure and management
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 -
Environment
Executive Agency
(CINEA) 31 December 2021
Connecting Europe
Facility
1. INFORMATION ON THE ACTION
Grant Agreement Nº INEA/CEF/TRAN/M2018/1767529
Action number 2018-EE-TM-0029-M
Action title Dynamic traffic and truck parking management
PCI (for energy and
synergy only)
Author of the report
Name Mari-Liis Sepp
Position ITS Project Manager
Entity Transport Administration - Development Division
Telephone Nº +372 5850 2984
E-mail
[email protected]
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
2. INFORMATION ON THE PROGRESS OF THE
ACTION (GA II.23.1.1.c or SESAR FPA II.23.1b.c)
2.1. Overall progress of the Action until the end of the previous reporting
period
Overall
Planned dates (GA) Previous ASR dates Actual dates
technical
progress
achieved at
the end of
Start End Start End Start End the
previous
reporting
period (%)*
31/12/202
01/06/2019 01/06/2019 31/12/2023 01/06/2019 31/12/2023 35.00
3
*Please explain how the percentage of the progress achieved has been estimated/calculated
Calculated according to Annex III of the "Guidance for poor or partial completion": SUM(Technical
Progress Per Activity Per Year * (GA EU Contribution Per Activity / Total GA EU Contribution)).
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 2
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Overview of progress since the start of the Action
The overview should include a description of the actual progress of the Action and
per activity since the start of the Action until at the end of the previous reporting
period, referring to the main issues, milestones and events that affected the
progress.
Which activities started, were ongoing, complete?
Activities 1 (project management), 2 (communication and dissemination), 4 (pilot
implementation 1), 5 (pilot implementation 2) were ongoing and Activity 6
(Implementation of dynamic traffic management system E265 in sections km 0-10
and km 20-30) started in the previous reporting period (01/01/2021-31/12/2021).
Which milestones were planned to be complete and were finally completed?
The following milestones have been finished:
Contract signed Pilot 1 (design) planned date 31/01/2021; actual date 03/01/2021
Contract signed Pilot 1 (building) planned date 31/01/2021; actual date 12/10/2021
Contract signed Pilot 2 (building) planned date 31/01/2021; actual date 15/11/2021
Action Status Report (ASR) planned date 31/03/2021; actual date 23/03/2021
PM and SG joint meeting no 4 planned date 30/06/2021; actual date 02/09/2021
Publication of tender E265 km 0-10 and 20-30 planned date 01/11/2021; actual
date 21/06/2021
PM and SG joint meeting no 5 planned date 31/12/2021; actual date 18/11/2021
Assessment of offers E265 km 0-10 and 20-30 planned date 01/02/2022; actual
date 02/09/2021
Contract signed for E265 km 0-10 and 20-30 planned date 30/04/2022; actual date
12/10/2021
Reasons for delays for milestones and/or activities if any and the impact for
activity’s/Action’s end dates or other activities?
Some of the milestones delayed in 2021: Pilots 1 and 2 were divided into two parts
(design and building), thus in the building process the same date remains as starting
the design process. Although, Pilot 1 and Pilot 2 implementations will be delayed few
months but will be done within next ASR reporting period. The expected end date of
Pilot 1 implementation is 30/09/2022 and for Pilot 2 is 30/11/2022. In addition, PM
and SG joint meeting no 4 and 5 were delayed due to the amount of information to
share.
Any task not foreseen initially but needed to achieve the Action’s objectives/scope?
Pilot 1 and 2 tenders are divided into two: design and building process. During the
reporting period the pilot 1 and 2 tender included design tender. The building tender
and process for both pilots started in 2021 and will end within next reporting period.
The expected end date of Pilot 1 implementation is 30/09/2022 and for Pilot 2 is
30/11/2022.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 3
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
2.2. Progress per activity
Overall technical
progress achieved
Previous ASR Start/end
Activity 1 Title Planned Start/End date (GA) Actual Start/End date until the end of the
dates
previous reporting
period (%)*
Project management 01/06/2019 31/12/2023 01/06/2019 31/12/2023 01/06/2019 31/12/2023 41.00
*Please explain how the percentage of the progress achieved has been estimated/calculated
SUM(Technical Progress Per Activity Per Year * (GA EU Contribution Per Activity / Total GA EU Contribution))
Milestone
Title1 Planned completion date (GA) Previous ASR date Actual completion date Reached (Y/N)
no
PM and SG joint meeting
1 30/06/2019 20/11/2019 20/11/2019 Yes
No 1
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The project manager was hired in September 2019. There was not a project manager nor actual need to hold PM and SG joint meeting No 1 before that.
PM and SG joint meeting
2 31/12/2019 07/05/2020 07/05/2020 Yes
No 2
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 4
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
The meeting was organised a week later due to the participants' schedule.
PM and SG joint meeting
3 30/06/2020 17/09/2020 17/09/2020 Yes
No 3
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The meeting was organised two weeks before due to the participants' schedule.
PM and SG joint meeting
4 31/12/2020 13/05/2021 02/09/2021 Yes
No 4
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The meeting was organised four months later due to the minimal information to share and to the participants' schedule.
PM and SG joint meeting
5 30/06/2021 30/06/2021 18/11/2021 Yes
No 5
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The meeting was organised five months later due to the minimal information to share and to the participants' schedule.
PM and SG joint meeting
6 31/12/2021 31/12/2021 30/04/2022 No
No 6
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The first PM and SG joint meeting was postponed and thus all previous meeting were also postponed. PM and SG joint meeting No 6 will be held in 2022.
PM and SG joint meeting
7 30/06/2022 30/06/2022 21/08/2022 No
No 7
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The first PM and SG joint meeting was postponed and thus all previous meeting were also postponed. PM and SG joint meeting No 7 will be held in 2022.
PM and SG joint meeting
8 31/12/2022 31/12/2022 31/12/2022 No
No 8
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The first PM and SG joint meeting was postponed and thus all previous meeting were also postponed. PM and SG joint meeting No 8 will be held in 2022.
PM and SG joint meeting
9 30/06/2023 30/06/2023 30/06/2023 No
No 9
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The first PM and SG joint meeting was postponed and thus all previous meeting were also postponed. PM and SG joint meeting No 9 will be held in 2023.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 5
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
PM and SG joint meeting
10 31/12/2023 31/12/2023 31/12/2023 No
No 10
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The first PM and SG joint meeting was postponed and thus all previous meeting were also postponed. PM and SG joint meeting No 10 will be held in 2023.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 6
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Overall technical
progress achieved
Previous ASR Start/end
Activity 2 Title Planned Start/End date (GA) Actual Start/End date until the end of the
dates
previous reporting
period (%)*
Communication and
01/06/2019 31/12/2023 01/06/2019 31/12/2023 01/06/2019 31/12/2023 32.00
dissemination
*Please explain how the percentage of the progress achieved has been estimated/calculated
SUM(Technical Progress Per Activity Per Year * (GA EU Contribution Per Activity / Total GA EU Contribution))
Milestone
Title1 Planned completion date (GA) Previous ASR date Actual completion date Reached (Y/N)
no
Project opening press /
11 31/12/2019 20/11/2019 20/11/2019 Yes
kick off meeting event
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Actual completion date was before planned completition date.
Project communication
12 31/10/2019 14/10/2019 14/10/2019 Yes
plan
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Actual completion date was before planned completition date.
Communication support
13 31/05/2020 20/04/2020 20/04/2020 Yes
materials
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 7
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Actual completion date was before planned completition date.
Project finalization press /
14 31/10/2023 31/10/2023 31/10/2023 No
final meeting event
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 8
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Overall technical
progress achieved
Previous ASR Start/end
Activity 3 Title Planned Start/End date (GA) Actual Start/End date until the end of the
dates
previous reporting
period (%)*
Transport and ITS study
for preparation of pilot 1 01/09/2019 01/09/2020 02/09/2019 09/09/2020 02/09/2019 09/09/2020 100.00
and 2
*Please explain how the percentage of the progress achieved has been estimated/calculated
SUM(Technical Progress Per Activity Per Year * (GA EU Contribution Per Activity / Total GA EU Contribution))
Milestone
Title1 Planned completion date (GA) Previous ASR date Actual completion date Reached (Y/N)
no
Publication of Tender
15 Transport and ITS study 01/11/2019 02/12/2019 02/12/2019 Yes
report
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Project manager was hired in September 2019 which was the reason the tender was published a month later.
Assessment of offers
16 Transport and ITS study 01/01/2020 10/01/2020 10/01/2020 Yes
report
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Due to the holidays period the assessment process was pushed forward.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 9
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Contract signed Transport
17 01/02/2020 23/01/2020 23/01/2020 Yes
and ITS study report
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Since there was only one tenderer the process of signing the contract was shorter than expected.
Transport and ITS study
18 01/06/2020 04/06/2020 04/06/2020 Yes
interim report
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The interim report was few days late due to the COVID-19 situation.
Transport and ITS study
19 01/09/2020 09/09/2020 09/09/2020 Yes
final report
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The final report was few days late due to the COVID-19 situation.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 10
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Overall technical
progress achieved
Previous ASR Start/end
Activity 4 Title Planned Start/End date (GA) Actual Start/End date until the end of the
dates
previous reporting
period (%)*
Pilot implementation 1:
dynamic traffic
01/09/2020 01/06/2022 22/10/2020 01/06/2022 22/10/2020 30/09/2022 41.00
management system in
E265 section km 10-20
*Please explain how the percentage of the progress achieved has been estimated/calculated
SUM(Technical Progress Per Activity Per Year * (GA EU Contribution Per Activity / Total GA EU Contribution))
Milestone
Title1 Planned completion date (GA) Previous ASR date Actual completion date Reached (Y/N)
no
Publication of tender Pilot
20 01/10/2020 22/10/2020 22/10/2020 Yes
1
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
There were discussions in the Estonian Road Administration how to formalise the tender since the transport and ITS study showed the need of bigger budget.
The tender was divided into two tenders - design and building process tenders. The decision-making took some time which is the reason of the milestone
daley.
Assessment of offers Pilot
21 31/12/2020 04/12/2020 04/12/2020 Yes
1
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 11
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
The tender took less time than expected.
22 Contract signed Pilot 1 31/01/2021 03/01/2021 03/01/2021 Yes
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The contract signing took less time than expected.
Pilot 1 implemented
23 01/06/2022 01/06/2022 30/09/2022 No
solution is in operation
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Pilot 1 delays few months due to the questions during the procurement and thus additional time in the procurement process, so building contract signing time
was also delayed. The building time was not shortened, it will take 52 weeks to install equipment.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 12
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Overall technical
progress achieved
Previous ASR Start/end
Activity 5 Title Planned Start/End date (GA) Actual Start/End date until the end of the
dates
previous reporting
period (%)*
Pilot implementation 2:
smart (safe and secure)
01/09/2020 01/06/2022 06/05/2020 01/06/2022 06/05/2020 31/12/2022 38.00
truck parking area in
E265 km 1,5
*Please explain how the percentage of the progress achieved has been estimated/calculated
SUM(Technical Progress Per Activity Per Year * (GA EU Contribution Per Activity / Total GA EU Contribution))
Milestone
Title1 Planned completion date (GA) Previous ASR date Actual completion date Reached (Y/N)
no
Publication of tender Pilot
24 01/10/2020 17/08/2020 17/08/2020 Yes
2
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The activity was started earlier so there will be enough time to process the building permit after the design process.
Delivery of the scoping
25 decision and subsequent 31/12/2020 06/05/2020 06/05/2020 Yes
environmental permits
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
The environmental permit was delivered earlier so we could start the design tender process.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 13
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Assessment of offers Pilot
26 31/12/2020 22/09/2020 22/09/2020 Yes
2
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Tender took less time than expected.
27 Contract signed Pilot 2 31/01/2021 13/10/2020 13/10/2020 Yes
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Contract signing took less time than expected.
Pilot 2 implemented
28 01/06/2022 01/06/2022 31/12/2022 No
solution is in operation
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Design process and building permit took longer time than expected. Although, pilot 2 implementation will end within next reporting period.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 14
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Overall technical
progress achieved
Previous ASR Start/end
Activity 6 Title Planned Start/End date (GA) Actual Start/End date until the end of the
dates
previous reporting
period (%)*
Implementation of
dynamic traffic
management system 01/11/2021 01/09/2023 01/11/2021 01/09/2023 21/06/2021 31/08/2023 0.00
E265 in sections km 0-10
and km 20-30
*Please explain how the percentage of the progress achieved has been estimated/calculated
SUM(Technical Progress Per Activity Per Year * (GA EU Contribution Per Activity / Total GA EU Contribution))
Milestone
Title1 Planned completion date (GA) Previous ASR date Actual completion date Reached (Y/N)
no
Publication of tender E265
29 01/11/2021 01/11/2021 21/06/2021 Yes
km 0-10 and km 20-30
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Since the tender was with pilot 1 implementation also, we started the tender earlier.
Assessment of offers E265
30 01/02/2022 01/02/2022 02/09/2021 Yes
km 0-10 and km 20-30
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Since the tender was with pilot 1 implementation also, we started the tender earlier.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 15
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Contract signed for E265
31 30/04/2022 30/04/2022 12/10/2021 Yes
km 0-10 and km 20-30
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
Since the tender was earlier, the contract signing was too.
E265 section solution km
32 0-10 and km 20-30 is in 01/09/2023 01/09/2023 31/08/2023 No
operation
Explanation for any deviation from planned completion date
All the documentation will be done by September 2023.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 16
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
2.3 If total actual costs/units deviates >5% compared to latest Grant
Agreement in force, please explain why
Activity 1 Project management
The salary of project team is smaller than expected.
Activity 3 Transport and ITS study for preparation of pilot 1 and 2
Transport and ITS study showed that the implementation will be more
expensive. Since there was a budget surplus the remaining amount should be
added to Activity 4 and 5 budgets.
Activity 4 Pilot implementation 1: dynamic traffic management system in E265
section km 10-20
Although the Transport and ITS study showed that the cost for
implemantation is much higher the final offers and signed contract showed
lower increase. The costs in 2021 for Activity 4 were lower than stated in the
GA. It is because the desing process was in 2021 and the equipment installing
tender was in contract in October 2021. So there were no big costs for this
Activity. The main costs are in 2022. The cost for 2021 includes design project
for both activity 4 and 6. The cost for 2022 includes besides ITS equipment
installation also electrical connections installment and owner supervision
service costs. If there will be a budget surplus between project activities, the
surplus can be put in Activity 4.
Activity 5 Pilot implementation 2: smart (safe and secure) truck parking area in
E265 km 1,5
The costs in 2021 for Activity 5 were lower than stated in the GA. It is because
the design was in 2021 and the building tender was in the end of 2021. So
there were no big costs for this Activity. The main costs are in 2022. The
building is more expensive than expected, due to the local government's
conditions and that the parking area had to be bigger to serve 100 truck
parking places. The over budget cost will come from Transport Administration
budget. Although, if there will be a budget surplus between project activities,
the surplus can be put in Activity 5.
Activity 6 Implementation of dynamic traffic management system E265 in
sections km 0-10 and km 20-30
Although the Transport and ITS study showed that the cost for
implemantation is much higher the final offers and signed contract showed
lower increase. The costs are less than in GA because the tender results
costed less than expected. The cost for year 2022 includes besides ITS
equipment installation also electrical connections installment and for year
2023 owner supervision costs.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 17
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
2.4. Description of the Action's and activities' progress planned in the on-
going reporting period and until the end of implementation of the Action
a) Provide a description of the planned progress of the activities in the on-going
reporting period and, where applicable, beyond the on-going reporting period up until
the end of the implementation of the Action (if the on-going reporting period is not the
last one).
b) Highlight and explain any deviation (e.g. on objectives of the Action, the
completion of the planned activities, the cost-breakdown, Action's end date, etc.) in
comparison to the latest grant agreement in force and, where applicable, latest ASR.
c) Identify any expected/foreseen risk(s) that may challenge the actual end date of
the Action and the associated mitigation plan(s).
Which activities will start, continue, be completed?
In the next reporting period (from 01/01/2022 until 31/12/2022) the
implementation of E265 km 0-10 and 20-30 is on-going until year 2023 and pilot 1
and 2 will be completed in year 2022.
In the last period (from 01/01/2023 until 31/12/2023) the implementation of E265
km 0-10 and 20-30 will be done and the project finalisation press/final meeting
event will be held.
Which activity/milestone/task will never be completed and the reasons why
(reduction of scope)?
There aren’t any activities/milestones/tasks that will never be completed.
Which any expected/foreseen risk(s) that may challenge the actual end date of the
Action and the associated mitigation plan(s)?
a) Provide a description of the planned progress of the activities in the on-going
reporting period and, where applicable, beyond the on-going reporting period up
until the end of the implementation of the Action (if the on-going reporting period is
not the last one).
All the contracts were signed in the last reporting period so it is more or less known
when the activities will end. Although, there could be some delays due to the
delivery time of different components. The interim deadlines keep the works
schedules in order so the risk of the end date of the Action delay is minimum.
b) Highlight and explain any deviation (e.g. on objectives of the Action, the
completion of the planned activities, the cost-breakdown, Action's end date, etc.) in
comparison to the latest grant agreement in force and, where applicable, latest ASR.
As explained in the previous ARS Pilot 2 (truck parking area) is divided into two
parts: design project and building the area. The design part is finished and the
building permit was signed 14/09/2021. After that the building tender for pilot 2 was
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 18
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
publicised. The contract was signed 12/10/2021 and the contract period is 12
months. The pilot 2 implementation will be done during the on-going reporting
period, by the end of October 2022. It is few months later than stated in the GA but
it the Activity will be done by the end of next reporting period.
In addition, the pilot 1 and E265 km 0-10 and 20-30 are taken as one tender but
divided into two parts: design and building process. The design process included
E265 km 0-30 and was not divided. The cost for design process is under Activity 4.
The building tender for pilot 1 and E265 km 0-10 and 20-30 was publicised and
contracts were signed on 12/10/2021. The implementation time for Activities 4 and
6 are few months different as stated in the GA but they do not pose a risk for the
actual end date of the Action.
Some Activities cost less and some more. The budget surplus for Activity 6 can be
used to cover the expenditure for Activity 4. Since the Activity 5 is well over budget
the budget surplus from all Activities could be put there to ease the expenses.
All the costs include VAT 20%. In the first interim financial statement the VAT 20%
was not stated as eligible costs. Please see document for futher explanation "Eligible
costs for Action Dynamic traffic and truck parking management" in the supporting
document section.
The units for E265 km 10-20 and 0-10; 20-30 equipment are different than it is
stated in the Agreement. The difference is in the sections and in overall numbers.
Agreement stated that Transport and ITS study will secify equipment numbers.
Please see the following numbers for the equipment units:
Activity 4: Pilot 1 (km 10-20)
Large variable message signs (VMS) in the Agreement 6 units --> installing 4 units
Traffic measuring/accident detectors (TMD) in the Agreement 3 units --> installing 6
units
Road weather stations (RWS) in the Agreement 3 units --> installing 3 units
Traffic cameras (CAM) in the Agreement 4 units --> installing 2 (+3) units
V2I/I2V sensors in the Agreement 4 units --> installing 4 units
Barrier gate system for re-routing in the Agreement 1 unit --> installing 1 unit
Activity 6: km 0-10
Large variable message signs (VMS) in the Agreement 4 units --> installing 7 units
Traffic measuring/accident detectors (TMD) in the Agreement 3 units --> installing 2
units
Road weather stations (RWS) in the Agreement 1 unit --> installing 3 units
Traffic cameras (CAM) in the Agreement 3 units --> installing 3 (+3) units
V2I/I2V sensors in the Agreement 4 units --> installing 3 units
Km 20-30
Large variable message signs (VMS) in the Agreement 3 units --> installing 6 units
Traffic measuring/accident detectors (TMD) in the Agreement 2 units --> installing 3
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 19
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
units
Road weather stations (RWS) in the Agreement 1 unit --> installing 1 unit
Traffic cameras (CAM) in the Agreement 3 units --> installing 2 (+1) units
V2I/I2V sensors in the Agreement 4 units --> installing 2 units
Total km 0-30
Large variable message signs (VMS) in the Agreement 13 units --> installing 17
units (added 4 units)
Traffic measuring/accident detectors (TMD) in the Agreement 8 units --> installing
11 units (added 3 units)
Road weather stations (RWS) in the Agreement 5 units --> installing 7 units (added
2 units)
Traffic cameras (CAM) in the Agreement 10 units --> installing 7 units (decreased 3
units, although RWS have also cameras in the set, so there will actually be 7 units
more, so totally added 4 units)
V2I/I2V sensors in the Agreement 12 units --> installing 12 units (amount is the
same)
Barrier gate system for re-routing in the Agreement 1 unit --> installing 1 unit
(amount is the same)
c) Identify any expected/foreseen risk(s) that may challenge the actual end date of
the Action and the associated mitigation plan(s).
Since all the main Activities are in contract the end date of each Activity is known.
These dates do not challenge the actual date of the Action.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 20
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
3. VISIBILITY OF UNION FUNDING (GA II.23.1.1.i or
SESAR FPA II.23.1b.i)
What measures have been taken within the previous reporting period to
publicise the Action, including EU funding (GA II.7.1)?
There have been two press releases and Facebook posts regarding signing contracts
for Activities 4 and 6 and 5. The numbers are as of 11 January 2021.
Press release about Activities 4 and 6:
https://transpordiamet.ee/uudised/transpordiamet-toob-nutikad-liikluslahendused-
tallinna-ringteele
On Transport Administration Facebook page 11 364 people saw it, 51 likes and 4
shares.
On Transport Administration homepage 111 views.
Media coverage in other platforms 3 news: Postimees
(https://www.postimees.ee/7370732/tallinna-ringteel-muutub-liiklus-2-7-miljoni-
euro-eest-nutikaks), BNS-is, Pealinn
(https://pealinn.ee/2021/10/26/transpordiamet-toob-tallinna-ringteele-nutikad-
liikluslahendused/).
Press release about Activity 5:
https://transpordiamet.ee/uudised/tallinna-ringtee-aarde-rajatakse-104-kohaline-
veoautode-parkla
On Transport Administration Facebook page 17 526 people saw it, 114 likes, 10
shares and 24 comments.
On Transport Administration homepage 568 views.
Media coverage in other platforms 7 news: Autonetis (https://auto.pub/rekajuhid-
saavad-104-kohalise-parkla-vao-liiklussolme-juurde/), BNS-is, Ehitaja
(https://station.ee/#42141935), Auto24
(https://www.auto24.ee/uudised/uudised.php?uid=64807), Postimees
(https://station.ee/#42032604), Ehitusuudised
(https://www.ehitusuudised.ee/uudised/2021/11/26/tallinna-ringtee-aarde-
rajatakse-104kohaline-veoautode-parkla), Logistikauudised
(https://www.logistikauudised.ee/uudised/2021/11/26/tallinna-ringtee-aarde-
rajatakse-104kohaline-veoautode-parkla)
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 21
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
4. OTHER SOURCES OF EUROPEAN UNION FUNDS
(CEF-E and Synergy only, GA II.23.1.1.m )
If applicable, provide information about other sources of EU funds (CEF,
ERDF, Cohesion Fund, H2020, TEN, EEPR, EIPA, etc.) used for the project of
common interest (e.g. previous or subsequent phases not covered by the
Grant Agreement).
Not applicable
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 22
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
5. COMPLIANCE WITH EU LEGISLATION
(GA.II.23.1.1g and h, or SESAR FPA II.23.1b.g and h)
5.1. Overview of environmental aspects, compliance with EU and national
legislation, issues during the implementation of the Action and measures
taken.
According to the Grant Agreement the implementation of this Activity is subject to
the acquisition of the necessary environmental permission, which will have to be
requested and obtained in advance by the beneficiary. The environmental permission
was declared and signed by Environmental Board on 06/05/2020.
5.2. Where relevant, information on the compliance with EU legislation
notably on procurement:
- information on the contracts awarded or planned for the implementation
of the Action and on compliance with the requirements set out in GA II.9
and II.10
- regarding other matters, notably public procurement, competition,
regulatory matters, (CEF-E only) the update of the CBCA decision, etc.
There were 4 procurements in the previous reporting period (01/01/2021-
31/12/2021).
Activity 5 road safety audit’s procurement was below EU thresholds. The
procurement type was restricted, which means that price request with tender
documents was sent to four companies and the company with the lowest offer was
declared compliant. The procedure followed the Transport Administration's internal
arrangements. There were five offers: Lindvill OÜ 1 785,00 + VAT 20%, Stratum OÜ
2 660,00 + VAT 20%, ERC Konsultatsiooni OÜ 5 910,00 + VAT 20%, ViaVelo
Inseneribüroo OÜ 5 010,00 + VAT 20% and AS Infragate Eesti 8 500,00 + VAT
20%. Tender documents included three objects’ road safety audits thus the sum for
contract is bigger than stated in the report. The contract with lowest bidder Lindvill
OÜ was signed 21/12/2020 and work was done by February 2021. With this
procurement Activity 5 the Pilot 2 design project passed the audit.
Activity 4 project’s expertise procurement was below EU thresholds. The
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 23
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
procurement type was restricted, which means that price request with tender
documents was sent to seven companies and the company with the lowest offer was
declared compliant. The procedure followed the Transport Administration's internal
arrangements. There were two offers: OÜ Maanteed 20 300€ + VAT 20% and AS
Taalri Varahaldus 8888€ + VAT 20%. The contract with lowest bidder was signed
26/04/2021 and work was done by June 2021. With this procurement Activity 4 the
Pilot 1 design project passed the examination and was declared compliant.
Activity 5 Pilot 2 truck parking area building procurement was published 31/08/2021.
Please see the tender in the system: https://riigihanked.riik.ee/rhr-
web/#/procurement/3580916/general-info There were nine offers and the lowest
bidder was AS Tref NORD. The contract was signed on 15/11/2021 with price 2 654
533,80€ + VAT 20%. The budget for Pilot 2 has been exceeded because of the size
of parking area and local governments restrictions. The budget deficit is financed by
Transport Administration. The works will be done by the end of November 2022.
In addition, the owner supervision service for building the truck parking area was
also procured. Please see the tender: https://riigihanked.riik.ee/rhr-
web/#/procurement/3674076/general-info The costs for this contract are financed
by Transport Administration 100%.
Activity 4 (Pilot 1) and Activity 6 tender for equipment installation was published
21/06/2021. Please see the tender: https://riigihanked.riik.ee/rhr-
web/#/procurement/3317816/general-info For both Activity had to make an offer
and for both there were two offers. The lowest bidder for both was KiirWarren.KL
OÜ. The contracts were signed on 12/10/2021 with prices 798 488,08 € +VAT 20%
(Activity 4) and 1 464 531,62 € + VAT 20% (Activity 6). The works will be done by
end of September 2022 (Activity 4) and end of August 2023 (Activity 6).
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 24
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
6. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE, GOVERNANCE
AND MONITORING, OTHER RELEVANT
ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS (GA II.23.1.1.k and l, or
SESAR FPA II.23.1b.k and l)
6.1. In the first ASR, information on implementation schedule, such as
critical path, key performance rates and risk analysis; in subsequent ASR,
information on any modifications and, if applicable, on the progress of the
implementation of the arrangements referred to in previous ASR. If there
are changes in the Action timetable as compared to the latest planning
(Grant Agreement or previous ASR), attach an updated Gantt chart.
Action’s implementation schedule is attached as an Excel file under the name
“timetable”. There is one critical bath which is the whole project’s milestones and
timeline. The Action’s risk analysis is also attached under the name “risk assessment
grid by activities” which was also in the proposal and updated if needed.
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 25
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
Action's implementation technical progress (cumulated %)
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
Action Current Current Current Current Current
Previous ASR Previous ASR Previous ASR Previous ASR Previous ASR
level ASR ASR ASR ASR ASR
0 0 8 8 35 35 88 88 100 100
Current Current Current Current Current
Activity Previous ASR Previous ASR Previous ASR Previous ASR Previous ASR
ASR ASR ASR ASR ASR
1
4 4 18 18 41 41 71 71 100 100
2
6 6 25 25 32 32 66 66 100 100
3
0 0 100 100 N/A 100 N/A 100 N/A 100
4
N/A 0 0 0 41 41 100 100 N/A 100
5
N/A 0 0 0 38 38 100 100 N/A 100
6
N/A 0 N/A 0 0 0 50 50 100 100
All the activities and the Action will achieve 100% of technical progress by their actual end dates
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 26
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
6.2. In the first ASR, information on governance and monitoring of the
Action, such as organizational structure, internal coordination,
communication and reporting, and decision making process; in subsequent
ASR, information on any modifications and, if applicable, on the progress of
the implementation of the arrangements referred to in previous ASR.
The Estonian Transport Administration in-house project team consists of the
following Estonian Transport Administration employees:
• Project manager – is responsible for coordinating and organizing project
activities in Estonia. Regular reporting to INEA.
• Head of traffic management centre – implementing traffic and other technical
solutions in the ITS area of the project.
• Financial controller – accounting for project costs, arranging bridge financing
and advising on the management of expense receipts.
• IT architect – preparation of project IT solutions and architectural requirements
and implementation monitoring.
• Communication expert – arranging public communication for the project.
The Estonian Transport Administration in-house team has monthly meetings.
Depending on the progress of the project and which Activities are on-going, the
necessary team members will be involved with the meetings. In addition, other
support staff will be included if necessary.
During the period which have contractors project manager will attend the weekly
meetings with them and brings information to the in-house team, if necessary, other
will attend the meeting as well.
In Estonian Transport Administration there is also weekly briefing between the
departments where information about the project will be discussed if necessary.
6.3. In the first ASR, information on other relevant administrative
provisions, such as quality controls and audits; in subsequent ASR,
information on any modifications and, if applicable, on the progress of the
implementation of the arrangements referred to in previous ASR.
There aren’t any extra quality control measures in the Estonian Transport
Administration. Although, a process map (for example the procurement process
describes which activities are in the process and how they should be done) is similar
to quality standard and it is followed. This Action hasn’t been audited.
ANNEX: Financial information (GA II.23.1.1.d to f or SESAR FPA II.23.1b.d to f)
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 27
Reporting period: 1 January 2021 - 31 December 2021
CERTIFICATION OF THE MEMBER STATE*
(applicable only for ASR and for beneficiaries established in the
European Union)
Name
Position
Entity
Telephone Nº
E-mail
In compliance with Article II.23.1 (or SESAR FPA II.23.1b) of the GA, it
is certified that the information provided by the following
Beneficiary(ies) in the ASR is full, reliable and true.
Transport Administration
Date and
signature
Stamp (optional)
* In line with the terms of Art. 22 of the CEF Regulation
2018-EE-TM-0029-M_ASR2022_1_draft_20220216_0955 28