This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
ECHO AUDIT FRAMEWORK CONTRACT
DRAFT AUDIT REPORT
CIVIL PROTECTION FINANCIAL INSTRUMENT
AUDITED ORGANISATION: Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Communications of the Republic of
Estonia (MEA)
GRANT AGREEMENT AUDITED: ECHO/ESI/2020/C/003/835010
AUDIT REFERENCE NUMBER: 21-BA236-03
AUDIT DATES: 30/06/2021 - 18/08/2021
AUDITOR’S LOGO
The views expressed herein are those of the independent auditor and do not necessarily
represent any official view of the Commission
1/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
Table of Contents
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .............................................................................3
1.1. Audit opinion .........................................................................................3
Responsibility of the Beneficiary for the Financial Statements ............3
Auditors’ Responsibility........................................................................3
Additional Conditions ...........................................................................4
Opinion 5
1.2. Audit adjustments and recommendations for systems improvement ....7
Audit findings and adjustments .............................................................7
Observations and Recommendations for systems improvement ...........7
2. GENERAL INFORMATION .........................................................................9
2.1. Information on the audited organisation ................................................9
LEGAL STATUS ........................................................................................9
SUMMARY FINANCIAL FIGURES ..............................................................9
ACCOUNTING SYSTEM AND BASIS ...........................................................9
2.2. Description of the audited action .........................................................10
3. AUDIT WORK AND FINDINGS ................................................................11
3.1. Direct costs of personnel .....................................................................11
3.2. Direct costs of travel and subsistence ..................................................11
3.3. Direct costs of subcontracting .............................................................11
WORK PERFORMED ..............................................................................11
FINDINGS .............................................................................................11
3.4. Other direct costs .................................................................................12
3.5. Indirect costs ........................................................................................12
3.6. Receipts / Interest on pre-financing .....................................................12
FINDINGS .............................................................................................12
3.7. Coordinator role and money distributed to associated beneficiaries ...12
4. ANALYSIS OF THE BENEFICIARY'S COMMENTS ..............................13
5. ANNEXES TO THE AUDIT REPORT .......................................................14
Annex 1 - Costs claimed and audit adjustments............................................15
Annex 2 – Recommendations for systems improvement ..............................16
Annex 3 - Analysis of direct personnel costs ................................................18
Annex 4 – Follow-up of previous audit recommendations ...........................19
Annex 5 – Working programme ....................................................................20
1. DIRECT COSTS OF SUBCONTRACTING: ...................................20
2. RECEIPTS / INTEREST ON PRE-FINANCING .............................21
Annex 6 – Audit Sample ...............................................................................22
Annex 7 – Comments of the Beneficiary ......................................................23
2/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.1. AUDIT OPINION
The auditors have audited the financial statements as set out in the table below submitted
to the services of the European Commission by Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Communications of the Republic of Estonia (MEA) (the “Beneficiary”):
Grant agreement name Transport operation of medical items to respond to
COVID-19 crisis
Grant agreement no. ECHO/ESI/2020/C/003/835010
Period From 11/05/2020
audited To 14/07/2020
Total amount accepted EC EUR 591,351.56
Co-financing rate 100.00%
RESPONSIBILITY OF THE BENEFICIARY FOR THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
The Beneficiary is responsible for the preparation and fair view of the financial statements
in accordance with the grant agreement and for maintaining adequate accounting records
and documentation to support and justify the costs reported. The Beneficiary is also
responsible for such internal controls as are necessary to enable the preparation of financial
statements that are free from misstatement, whether due to error or fraud.
AUDITORS’ RESPONSIBILITY
The auditors' responsibility is to express an independent opinion, based on their audit
procedures, on the financial statements of the above-mentioned grant agreement (GA) only
as to whether the costs have been properly incurred and are eligible costs, as defined under
the grant agreement.
The auditors conducted their audit taking into account the provisions of the audited grant
agreement under the Civil Protection Financial Instrument and in accordance with
International Standards on Assurance and Audit Engagements as they are applicable solely
in relation to the special scope of this engagement only. Those standards require that the
auditors comply with ethical requirements and plan and perform an audit to obtain
reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free of material misstatement. An
audit engagement involves performing relevant procedures to obtain evidence about the
amounts claimed in the financial statements. The procedures selected depend on the
auditors' judgement, including the assessment of the risks of material misstatement of the
financial statements.
In making those risk assessments, the auditors consider internal controls relevant to the
entity’s preparation and presentation of the financial statements in order to design audit
procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances relevant for the scope of this
engagement, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the
entity’s internal controls as a whole.
3/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
An audit also includes evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies used for the
preparation of the financial statements submitted to the European Commission services as
well as evaluating the overall presentation of these financial statements.
The auditors believe that the evidence obtained is sufficient with respect to the objectives
relevant for their engagement and appropriate to provide a basis for their opinion.
ADDITIONAL CONDITIONS
The auditors' work has been undertaken so that the auditors might state to the European
Commission those matters which they are required to state in their audit report and for no
other purpose. The auditors are thus responsible solely to the European Commission for
their work and the opinion that they have formed. To the fullest extent permitted by law,
the auditors do not accept or assume responsibility to anyone other than the European
Commission unless such responsibility has been expressly accepted.
The primary responsibility for the prevention and detection of fraud and error rests with
those charged with the governance and management of the Beneficiary. It is the
responsibility of those charged with the governance of the Beneficiary to ensure, through
oversight of management, the integrity of the accounting and financial reporting systems
and that appropriate controls are in place. It is the responsibility of the management of the
Beneficiary to establish a control environment and maintain policies and procedures to
assist in achieving the objective of ensuring, as far as possible, the orderly and efficient
conduct of the Beneficiary’s affairs. This responsibility includes implementing and
ensuring the continued operation of accounting and internal control systems which are
designed to prevent and detect fraud and error. Such systems can only reduce but not
eliminate the risk of misstatements, whether caused by fraud or error. Management retains
responsibility for any remaining risk. It should be understood that if we detect fraud or
other coercive practices, we are obliged to report this to the responsible services.
The auditors' work is not designed specifically to identify incidences of fraud.
Accordingly, fraud may occur and not be detected.
The auditors have nevertheless obtained representations made by the Beneficiary in
relation to the authenticity and completeness of the supporting documentation provided to
them.
The auditors' work in assessing the necessity of costs incurred for the implementation of
an action is limited to verifying, to the extent that they are qualified and able to, that those
costs have been incurred solely for the intended purpose of the grant agreement. This
normally implies verifying that specific costs are provided for in the budget proposals sent
to the European Commission services prior to grant agreement signature and that those
costs when actually incurred are processed, validated and approved within an accounting
system and related internal control structure that would meet or exceed the generally
accepted international principles of sound financial management.
The work performed by the auditors is not a value for money or performance audit. The
audit work performed relating to the verification of the economy of the costs is limited to:
4/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
verifying that claimed costs are incurred in line with the usual administrative and
management practices of the Beneficiary and;
assessing whether these costs, in pure monetary terms, are evidently reckless or
unreasonable as defined within the grant agreement terms and conditions.
This is a report by exception. As such, it cannot normally create legitimate expectations on
the conformity of the costs declared or the methods of calculation used.
OTHER MATTERS
Due to the on-going Covid-19 pandemic, the fieldwork has been completed wholly on a
remote basis. This has not hindered our ability to obtain the evidence necessary to support
our opinion and our opinion is not modified because of our audit being conducted remotely.
OPINION
During our audit the auditors noted the following adjustments:
Amount Amount Amount
Action reference claimed accepted EC eligible after Adjustments
(EUR) (EUR) audit (EUR)
ECHO/ESI/2020/C/003/835010 591,351.56 591,351.56 591,351.56 -
TOTAL 591,351.56 591,351.56 591,351.56 -
These are set out in the Summary of Audit Adjustments presented in the section 1.2.
In our opinion, except for the effect of the matters as detailed in the section 1.2, the audited
financial statements properly reflect eligible costs, receipts and interests, which:
are actual;
have been incurred by the Beneficiary during the duration of the action and in the
financial periods audited;
have been indicated in the estimated budget;
have been incurred in connection with the action as described in the GA and
necessary for its implementation;
have been determined in accordance with the usual accounting and management
principles and practices of the Beneficiary;
have been used for the sole purpose of achieving the objectives of the action and
its expected results, in a manner consistent with the principles of economy,
efficiency and effectiveness;
5/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
have been recorded in the accounts of the Beneficiary;
are exclusive of any non-eligible costs established in Article 19.4 of the General
Conditions of the grant agreement with the European Commission.
Based on our audit and except for the matters as described in the section 1.2 below, the
auditors can conclude that the financial management of the action was carried out in an
acceptable manner and in compliance with the requirements of the grant agreement.
Signed
Audit Company
Date
6/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
1.2. AUDIT ADJUSTMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR SYSTEMS
IMPROVEMENT
AUDIT FINDINGS AND ADJUSTMENTS
The adjustments required to the costs accepted by the European Commission services are
summarised below:
Transport operation of medical items to
Grant agreement: name respond to COVID-19 crisis
Grant agreement: no ECHO/ESI/2020/C/003/835010
Co-financing rate 100.00%
Adjustments (EUR)
Cost categories:
1 Personnel -
2 Travel and subsistence -
3 Sub-contracting -
4 Other direct costs -
TOTAL -
ECHO CONTRIBUTION -
Receipts -
Interest on pre-financing -
As a result of the testing procedures carried out, no financial findings were identified.
OBSERVATIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR SYSTEMS IMPROVEMENT
Observation 1: The auditor identified one payment outside the implementation period. This
related to an advance payment on 28/04/2020 for air transportation of medical items
undertaken on 12/05/2020. The implementation period of the Action was between
11/05/2020 and 14/07/2020. As the activities in relation to the payment took place during
the implementation period, no financial finding has been raised.
Recommendation 1: It is recommended that all costs are incurred and paid within the
implementation period of the Action to ensure compliance with the terms of the Grant
Agreement.
Observation 2: We were provided with the contract signed between the Beneficiary and
the supplier DSV for the delivery of the services. However, the costs for DSV’s services
were not agreed in advance and therefore not included in the contract. The Beneficiary
advised us that the costs for services were discussed and agreed before each specific service
was provided, and formalised in the invoice.
7/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
Recommendation 2: It is recommended that prices for services are included as part of the
contract. This could be done by including a maximum contract spending after which the
contract is reviewed for extension, or by agreeing to fixed prices for specific services which
are to be applied for the full contract period. It is recommended that for unforeseen but
required services, where the pricing is negotiated separate to the contract, the agreed prices
are formalised via a contract amendment, in order to prevent potential disputes. It is further
recommended that invoices and cost breakdowns are compared to contract prices to ensure
no overcharges have occurred.
8/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
2. GENERAL INFORMATION
2.1. INFORMATION ON THE AUDITED ORGANISATION
Audited Organisation Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
of the republic of Estonia (MEA)
Address of Beneficiary Suur-Ameerika 1
Tallinn, 10122
Estonia
Persons present – Beneficiary Yana Laurand - Counsellor at the EU and
International Co-operation Department
Persons present – Auditors Francesca Visconti – Assignment Leader
LEGAL STATUS
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications of the republic of Estonia (MEA) is a
Government Institution founded in 2002.
MEA’s main objective is to create overall conditions for the growth of the competitiveness
of the Estonian economy and its balanced and vital development through the drafting and
implementation of Estonian policy and evaluating its outcomes.
SUMMARY FINANCIAL FIGURES
Financial Information (‘000’ Year 2020 Year 2019 Year 2018
Euro) – taken from financial
statements
Total revenues for the year 238,931,013.00 254,991,781.00 233,827,818.00
EU grants 160,286,731.00 188,506,445.00 177,552,560.00
EU grants in % of revenues 67.08% 73.93% 75.93%
Financial information provided by the Beneficiary and audited by National Audit Office
of Estonia. Our engagement did not constitute an audit or a review of these financial
summary figures.
ACCOUNTING SYSTEM AND BASIS
Accounting System SAP
Basis of accounting Accrual
SAP was implemented in 2011. It is a fully integrated package able to perform complex
analysis if required.
MEA’s accounting is undertaken by the State Shared Service Center (SSSC). The
Beneficiary checks all documentation for accuracy and signs all documents as evidence of
review before sending them to the SSSC.
The segregation of duties is adequate with regards to purchasing.
9/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
The Business Software Development Department of the SSSC manages and develops
various information systems necessary for its core business:
- business software SAP, which performs both personnel and payroll and financial
accounting, i.e., it is the most important tool for the accountants of SSSC.
- SSSC customers have access to the web-based reporting environment SAP BO, in
which more than 200 different standard reports have been implemented and which
give them an overview of the accounting in the business software.
- An e-support environment for the Structural Funds has been created to apply for
funding from various sources.
- Structural Funds Operational System (SFOS), which is a tool for SSSC employees
as well as employees of other agencies involved in the implementation of grants.
In addition, SSSC mediates the e-invoice processing environment, for which Fitek AS is
currently the cooperation partner.
Payment process
The procurement procedure of the MEA is followed. MEA’s procurement procedure is in
line with national procurement rules. The procurement specialist carries out the specific
procedure. A certificate for service completion is signed when the work has been
completed. When the work is approved, the supplier sends MEA an e-invoice, which is
approved by the Deputy Secretary General and the Head of the department. The invoice is
then sent to the accountant of the SSSC, which imports it into the accounting information
system SAP. The invoice will be paid according to the payment deadline.
2.2. DESCRIPTION OF THE AUDITED ACTION
The “Transport operation of medical item to respond to COVID-19 crisis” action took
place between 11 May 2020 and 14 July 2020. It was funded under the Emergency
Response Instrument. The main activities undertaken related to cargo transport (e.g.
assistance and relief items) into the European Union (EU) and within the EU, transfer of
patients within the EU and from the EU and transport of medical personnel and teams
within the EU and into the EU, as well as operational support for mobile medical response
capacities. The main items transported under the action were KN95 masks, surgical gowns,
disposable surgical medical masks, medical goggles and isolation clothing.
10/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
3. AUDIT WORK AND FINDINGS
3.1. DIRECT COSTS OF PERSONNEL
N/A – No personnel costs were claimed by the Beneficiary.
3.2. DIRECT COSTS OF TRAVEL AND SUBSISTENCE
N/A – No travel and subsistence costs were claimed by the Beneficiary.
3.3. DIRECT COSTS OF EQUIPMENT
N/A – No equipment costs were claimed by the Beneficiary.
3.4. DIRECT COSTS OF SUBCONTRACTING
WORK PERFORMED
The tests were performed on a full scope basis during our audit work according to the
working programme, as summarised in Annex 5 (section 3) to this audit report.
FINDINGS
The Beneficiary follows the procurement thresholds as set out by the Estonian Public
Procurement Act. For expenses exceeding EUR 30,000 a negotiated procedure is required
and for those surpassing EUR 60,000 a public procurement must be undertaken.
Article 49 of the Estonian Public Procurement Act states that, in cases of extreme urgency
or events unforeseeable by the contracting authority with time limitations, a negotiated
procedure without public procurement can be undertaken instead of public procurement.
The Beneficiary followed a negotiated procedure without public procurement in line with
the Estonian Public Procurement Act when selecting DSV Estonia AS as the sole service
provider for this action. No issues were identified in this regard.
It was noted that the price for most of the services provided had not been agreed in advance
and therefore not included as part of the contract with DSV Estonia AS. Costs for services
were informally discussed via e-mails and calls before each specific service was provided.
The Beneficiary was unable to provide supporting documentation for the informal
communication undertaken with DSV. Furthermore, it was noted that for four of the six
transactions tested, no breakdown of invoiced costs was available. The invoice does not
breakdown items such as distance for the transport, number of items transported, custom
costs or costs for storage pre- and post-transfer. Therefore, it was not possible to compare
most of the invoiced costs to prices agreed with DSV. Recommendation 2 has been raised
in this respect.
One payment outside the implementation period was identified. This related to an advance
paid on 28 April 2020 for air transportation of medical items undertaken on 12 May 2020.
As the activities in relation to the payment took place during the implementation period,
11/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
this has not resulted in a financial finding. However, recommendation 1 has been raised in
this regard.
3.5. OTHER DIRECT COSTS
N/A – No other direct costs were claimed by the Beneficiary.
3.6. INDIRECT COSTS
N/A – No indirect were claimed by the Beneficiary.
3.7. RECEIPTS / INTEREST ON PRE-FINANCING
The tests were performed according to the working programme, as summarised in Annex
5 (section 5) to this audit report.
The auditors obtained representations from the Beneficiary by letter of (DD/MM/YY),
confirming that all financial transfers or their equivalent from third parties, contributions
in kind from third parties and income generated by the audited actions have been taken
into account in the financial statements.
FINDINGS
No findings were noted as a result of our audit work.
3.8. COORDINATOR ROLE AND MONEY DISTRIBUTED TO ASSOCIATED
BENEFICIARIES
N/A - MEA was the sole Beneficiary.
12/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
4. ANALYSIS OF THE BENEFICIARY'S COMMENTS
(To insert)
13/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
5. ANNEXES TO THE AUDIT REPORT
ANNEX 1 Costs claimed and audit adjustments
ANNEX 2 Recommendations for systems improvement
ANNEX 3 Analysis of direct personnel costs
ANNEX 4 Follow up of previous audits recommendations
ANNEX 5 Working programme
ANNEX 6 Audit Sample
ANNEX 7 Comments of the Beneficiary
14/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties without the written approval of the European Commission
ANNEX 1 - COSTS CLAIMED AND AUDIT ADJUSTMENTS
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications of the republic of Country
Beneficiary
Estonia (MEA) Estonia
Grant agreement name Transport operation of medical item to respond to COVID-19 crisis Maximum ECHO contribution
Grant agreement reference ECHO/ESI/2020/C/003/835010 591,351.56
From 11/05/2020 Co-financing rate:
Period Consolidated
To 14/07/2020 100.00%
Cost categories Amount Budgeted Amount Claimed Amount Accepted EC Amount Eligible Adjustments
1 Personnel - - - - -
2 Travel and subsistence - - - - -
3 Equipment
4 Sub-contracting 591,351.56 591,351.56 591,351.56 591,351.56 -
5 Other direct costs - - - - -
Indirect costs/overheads - - - - -
TOTAL 591,351.56 591,351.56 591,351.56 591,351.56 -
ECHO CONTRIBUTION 591,351.56 591,351.56 591,351.56 591,351.56 -
Potential recovery -
Receipts - - - - -
Interest - - - - -
15/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties without the written approval of the European Commission
ANNEX 2 – RECOMMENDATIONS FOR SYSTEMS IMPROVEMENT
We make the following recommendations1 for systems improvements. The recommendations highlight weaknesses in the system of internal controls of the
Beneficiary in the view of the auditors. ECHO would like the Beneficiary to identify the actions necessary to address these weaknesses and to take such
action, or to state why the recommendations will not be implemented. ‘Urgency’ in the table below refers to the time by which the Beneficiary should
begin the implementation process.
NUMBER RATING RECOMMENDATION URGENCY ACCEPTED BY BENEFICIARY’S RESPONSE, ACTION
(MONTHS) BENEFICIARY PLANNED, TIMEFRAME PROPOSED
(Y/N)
SUBCONTRACTING
1 2 It is recommended that all costs are incurred and 2 Y BENEFICIARY’S RESPONSE ON THE ISSUE
paid within the implementation period of the WAS PRESENTED TO AUDITOR.
Action to ensure compliance with the terms of PROPER ACTION WILL BE TAKEN IN
the Grant Agreement. OTHER PROCUREMENTS IN THE FUTURE.
2 3 It is recommended that prices for services are 2 Y BENEFICIARY’S RESPONSE ON THE ISSUE
included as part of the contract. This could be WAS PRESENTED TO AUDITOR.
done by including a maximum contract PROPER ACTION WILL BE TAKEN IN
spending after which the contract is reviewed OTHER PROCUREMENTS IN THE FUTURE.
for extension, or by agreeing fixed prices for
specific services which are to be applied for the
full contract period. It is recommended that for
1
Ratings are: 4 – Critical
3 – Very Important
2 – Important
1 – Relevant
16/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties without the written approval of the European Commission
NUMBER RATING RECOMMENDATION URGENCY ACCEPTED BY BENEFICIARY’S RESPONSE, ACTION
(MONTHS) BENEFICIARY PLANNED, TIMEFRAME PROPOSED
(Y/N)
unforeseen but required services, where the
pricing is negotiated separate to the contract, the
agreed prices are formalised via a contract
amendment, in order to prevent potential
disputes. It is further recommended that
invoices and cost breakdowns are compared to
contract prices to ensure no overcharges have
occurred.
17/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties without the written approval of the European Commission
ANNEX 3 - ANALYSIS OF DIRECT PERSONNEL COSTS
N/A – No personnel costs were claimed by the Beneficiary.
18/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties without the written approval of the European Commission
ANNEX 4 – FOLLOW-UP OF PREVIOUS AUDIT RECOMMENDATIONS
N/A – There are no prior reports to review.
19/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
ANNEX 5 – WORKING PROGRAMME
1. DIRECT PERSONNEL COSTS
N/A – No personnel costs were claimed by the Beneficiary.
2. DIRECT COSTS OF TRAVEL AND SUBSISTENCE, EQUIPMENT AND OTHER
N/A – No travel and subsistence, equipment and other costs were claimed by the
Beneficiary.
3. DIRECT COSTS OF SUBCONTRACTING:
The auditors have reconciled the breakdown of subcontracting costs with the
claimed costs.
The auditors have reconciled the costs charged with the analytical accounts of the
action.
The auditors have confirmed that the sampled costs are recorded in the accounting
books in accordance with the relevant standards and the Beneficiary's usual
accounting practices. When available, reliance was put on the statutory auditor's
report.
The auditors have reconciled in monetary terms the tested costs to the specific
underlying documents.
The auditors have verified whether the general eligibility conditions laid down in
Article 19.1 and 19.2 of the General Conditions applicable to the GA were met.
The auditors have checked that ineligible items, as set out in Article 19.4 of the
General Conditions of the GA were properly eliminated by the Beneficiary.
The auditors have verified that the costs were incurred during the implementation
period as set out in Article 1.2 of the special provisions of the GA.
The auditors have reviewed invoices, especially for date of invoicing and nature
of subcontracting.
The auditors have checked that costs for subcontracting were substantiated by
proofs of payment.
The auditors have checked for the existence of later altering events (e.g. credit
notes, invoice cancellation, etc.) that could possibly impact on the claimed
subcontracting costs.
The auditors have checked that the accounting supporting documentation is in
accordance with the relevant applicable accounting standards.
20/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
The auditors have checked whether the other direct costs were charged without
VAT, if VAT is deductible for the Beneficiary according to the national tax law.
The auditors have checked that original underlying documents bear exclusive
reference to the EU action under audit.
The auditors have checked the subcontracting costs against the description of
tasks and the costs estimated in the EC Grant Agreement.
The auditors have reviewed the existence of contract agreements between the
Beneficiary and its subcontractors.
The auditors have checked that subcontracting agreements were not conducted
with a Beneficiary in the same Grant Agreement.
The auditors have checked if the Beneficiary's internal written procedures foresee
measures for avoidance of conflict of interest.
The auditors have verified that the applicable national law on public procurement
was correctly applied.
The auditors have verified that the amounts have been converted into euro using
the appropriate rate in accordance with Article 4.6 of the Special Conditions of
the GA.
4. INDIRECT COSTS
N/A – No indirect costs were claimed by the Beneficiary.
5. RECEIPTS / INTEREST ON PRE-FINANCING
The auditors enquired about the existence of any revenues related to the action.
If assets were sold, the auditors verified that the proceeding have been properly
declared as receipts.
The auditors verified whether there was any interest generated by the pre-
financing to the coordinator.
6. COORDINATOR ROLE AND MONEY DISTRIBUTED TO ASSOCIATED BENEFICIARIES
N/A – There were no associated beneficiaries.
21/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
ANNEX 6 – AUDIT SAMPLE
Number of transactions Amount of transactions
Cost Category
sampled sampled (EUR)
Personnel - -
Travel and subsistence - -
Equipment - -
Subcontracting/external assistance 6 591,351.56
Other direct costs - -
Indirect costs - -
Total Sampled Transactions 591,351.56
Total Costs as per Financial Report 591,351.56
Coverage (%) 100.00%
22/23
Restricted use
This report is the property of the European Commission and should not be distributed to third parties
without the written approval of the European Commission
ANNEX 7 – COMMENTS OF THE BENEFICIARY
MEA responded to auditor's questions and take into account the auditor's proposals in a
sufficient extent in accordance with Public Procurement Act.
MEA present’s also its gratitude to the auditors on the good cooperation.
23/23
Restricted use
15.02.2022 nr 24.1-1/2022/1198
PKF Littlejohn LLP
15 Westferry Circus
Canary Wharf
London
E14 4HD
DG Humanitarian Aid & Civic Protection (ECHO)
European Commission
B-1049
Brussels
Belgium
Dear Sirs,
Financial Audit of the project “Transport operation of medical items to respond to COVID-
19 crisis” – ECHO/ESI/2020/C/003/835010 funded by the European Commission
Directorate-General for European Civil Protection and Humanitarian Aid Operations
(ECHO)
As requested by you, we confirm that:
1. This letter is provided in connection with your financial audit for the above grant agreement.
2. We note that your audit was carried out in accordance with the dispositions of Article 11 of
the Council Decision 2007/162/EC of 5 March 2007 concerning the Civil Protection Financial
Instrument, OJ L 71, 10.3.2007) and in accordance with applicable International Standards on
Auditing and has included substantive testing of a sample of transactions relating to the grant
agreements detailed above. Audit provisions are further set out in Article II.27 Part B - General
Conditions to the grant agreement.
3. We acknowledge our responsibility for the following:
3.1. Maintaining an adequate system of financial internal control and proper accounting
records that record all financial transactions entered into by the organisation and all of its
assets and liabilities;
3.2. The prevention and detection of fraud;
3.3. The safeguarding of the organisation’s assets;
3.4. Compliance with the requirements and conditions of the grant agreements referred to
above.
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 625 6342 /
[email protected] / www.mkm.ee
Registrikood 70003158
3.5. Providing DG ECHO and you as auditors acting on behalf of DG ECHO with all
information and explanations required.
Taking into consideration our responsibility to express adequately the eligible costs, as mentioned
in Article II.19 of Part B – General Conditions to the grant agreement with DG ECHO, we hereby
confirm the information supplied to you concerning the financial statements over the period from
11/05/2020 to 14/07/2020 for project ECHO/ESI/2020/C/003/835010 amounting to EUR
591,351.56 for the following points, after having made such enquiries of the staff and officers of
the organisation as we deemed appropriate and to the best of our knowledge:
1 We have provided you with all relevant accounting records and details of all the transactions
undertaken have been properly reflected and recorded in the accounting records.
2 All other records and relevant information which might impact upon or otherwise affect the
contractual eligibility of the costs claimed under the various grants noted above (including
minutes of relevant management meetings) have been made available to you and no such
information has been withheld.
3 We have provided you with all the supporting documentation relating to the sample of costs
claimed in the financial statements selected for detailed testing by your firm.
4 There have been no transactions with or otherwise involving the management or employees
of the grant holder (or other entities in which they have an involvement) which might
otherwise be deemed or construed to be a “related party transaction” as defined by
International Accounting Standard No. 24 (Related Party Disclosures) that are relevant to the
audit of these financial statements.
5 The expenditure transactions recorded in respect of the financial statements subject to audit
were met solely from funding received from DG ECHO or from the grant holder’s own
reserves, and not from funds received from other funding agencies or institutions.
6 The expenditure transactions recorded in the financial statements subject to audit were not
claimed as costs from other funding agencies or institutions.
7 The expenditure has been declared according to the type of activities in which it is involved.
8 We have acted in compliance with the conditions and agreements as set out in the grant
agreement.
9 No events after 14/07/2020 have occurred which would have a significant financial impact
upon the costs originally claimed in the financial statements over the period from 11/05/2020
to 14/07/2020 for project ECHO/ESI/2020/C/003/835010.
10 Nothing has come to our attention that during the period of the financial statements under
review, including management actions and/or other matters of material importance, that might
be considered to represent financial irregularities, fraud or an illegal act that would have a
consequential impact upon the eligibility of the costs as originally claimed. Nevertheless if
such actions and/or matters have occurred, sufficient measures have been taken to correct
them and to prevent repetition, and they have all been fully disclosed to the auditors.
Suur-Ameerika 1/ 10122 Tallinn / 625 6342 /
[email protected] / www.mkm.ee
Registrikood 70003158
2 (3)
We have read the draft of your audit report and:
In respect of the potential adjustments set out in your report, we have noted the amounts
involved and the reason for these potential adjustments.
We have also noted the recommendations you have made.
We are in agreement with the content and in particular we accept the proposed adjustments and
the recommendations made and will be implementing the latter as soon as practicable.
(e-signed)
Ando Leppiman
kantsler
Enclosures: Draft Audit Report
Yana Laurand
+372 639 7623
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1/ 10122 Tallinn / 625 6342 /
[email protected] / www.mkm.ee
Registrikood 70003158
3 (3)