dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

Kiri

Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium · 18. veebruar 2022
Viit
24.1-6/2022/1352-1
Registreeritud
18. veebruar 2022
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
Valdani Vicari & Associati
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
24.1 EL ja rahvusvahelise koostöö korraldamine
Sari
24.1-6/S Rahvusvahelise koostöö korraldamisega seotud kirjavahetus (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
24.1-6/2022
Vastutaja
Katrin Andre (Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium, Kantsleri valdkond, Transpordi valdkond, Teede- ja raudteeosakond)
Lahendamise tähtaeg
20. märts 2022

Failid

  • 📎Country Report of Estonia.docx163 KB
  • 📎E-kiri.pdf173 KB
  • 📎Endorsement letter Study on Regulation 1370-2007 (Grimaldi) _ MB Signed (1).pdf267 KB

Sisu (failidest)

457200 5502910 Country Report of Estonia Study on the implementation of Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007 and on developments in the provision of public passenger transport 0 0 Country Report of Estonia Study on the implementation of Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007 and on developments in the provision of public passenger transport 4500 339725 center 2900 90900 Introduction 1.1 Public Passenger Transport Market in Estonia Estonian public passenger market is constituted mainly by road mode transportation, which plays a major role compared to rail way , waterway and air modes combined. Due to historical reasons, public passenger transport market structure in Estonia is mainly composed by some large state-owned or municipal-owned companies - internal operators- companies and, especially in the road transportation subsector, by some large operators which arose from the privatization of former state-owned companies. At the municipal and intermunicipal levels, there are some other privately-owned road transportation companies as well. A reason for concern is that there is not a sufficient level of competition in the market segment of long distance and international lines for public passenger road transports. Estonia is a country in the Baltic region of Northern Europe with total area of 45,277 km 2 . Estonia has over 2,000 islands (the biggest are Hiiumaa and Saaremaa). In 2017 took place the administrative reform, where the rural municipalities merged. Therefore, now there are 15 towns and 64 rural municipalities (i.e. in total of 79 local governments compared to the previous number of 213 local governments). Estonia has a population of 1.33 million inhabitants, with a population density of 30.6 people per square kilometre. The GDP per capita is about 21,219 EUR. Approximately one third of the population lives in the only big city, the capital Tallinn. The rest of the country has a very low population density, one of the lowest in the EU. In Estonia, in overall, there is registered 905,353 vehicles with the average age of 14,82 years , which includes 1,201 buses (M2 category vehicle, which weighs less than 5 tons and seats over 8 passenger) and 4,103 buses /coaches (M3 category vehicle, which weighs over 5 tons and seats over 8 passenger). The short overview of the Estonian transportation (incl. road, marine, aviation and rail transport sectors) policy is stated on the website of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications. In 2019, Estonian transport enterprises served nearly 222 million passengers, which is 6% more than the previous year. The carriage of passengers increased in road, rail and water transport, but decreased in air transport. Please see the detailed info in the table below: Type of transport Passengers carried, million Passenger traffic volume, million pkm-s 2018 2019 2018 2019 Road transport 190.5 203.3 2 924.1 3 240.0 Sea transport 9.4 9.5 1 322.5 1 299.2 Rail transport 7.8 8.4 416.8 391.7 In 2019 compared to 2018, the number of passengers who used road transport grew by 7%. The majority were carried by bus – in total 203.3 million passengers, who mostly used urban transport, including trams and trolleybuses. Compared to the previous year, urban passenger transport increased by 2% (167.7 million passengers), and there was a 42% increase in the number of passengers using county or municipal lines (24.7 million passengers). Passengers numbered 3.9 million on domestic highway lines and 1.6 million on international lines. The passenger traffic volume of road transport reached over 3.2 billion passenger-kilometres. Estonian sea transport enterprises served over 9.5 million passengers. Likewise, in previous years, the majority of passengers were carried in international sea traffic. In domestic sea traffic, the number of passengers carried was 2.6 million. The passenger traffic volume was 1.3 billion passenger-kilometres, of which international sea traffic accounted for 98%. Passenger travel by rail also increased last year, reaching nearly 8.4 million passengers. Around 8.3 million were carried in domestic rail and 112,000 in international rail traffic. The passenger traffic volume of rail transport enterprises was 391.7 million passenger-kilometres. 1.2 Legal and Regulatory Structure The public transport is regulated at the national level with several laws. The laws authorize ministries to regulate the specific public transport related subjects in greater detail. The main act is Public Transport Act, which was reformed in 2015 (incl. implementing the EU’s regulations). The relevant legal acts are stated in Appendix 1 . The Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications develops and implements the basic national development plan for public transport and its main program; organizes nationwide public transport surveys; develops the national public transport route network by establishing the requirements for the preparation of domestic and international long-distance timetables and the approval or authorization of the procedure for submission, review, amendment and approval thereof by national government authorities Additionally, develops the methodology of calculations of the public transport work and service provider obligatory for state and local government agencies and carriers organizing public transport, service level standards for public inter-county regular transport and recommended standards for public local regular transport; develops the right of proposals for the approval of the tariff or vehicle ticket price for vehicle lines on the routes where are the subsidies used and supervises over the public service contract and administrative contracts entered into by him or her. The local authorit y directs and coordinates the development of public transport, elaborates and implements relevant development plans financed out of the budget of the local authority, the state budget and earmarked appropriations made by persons in private law; organises surveys ; drafts public transport route networks , etc. The local authorities may establish the regional public transport centre , which ensures that the residents of the territory prescribed by the founders of the centre, regardless of the administrative division of such territory, are provided with less expensive and economically more efficient public transport, which is based on an integrated route network, coordinated timetables and an integrated ticket system. Please note that t he regional public transport centre cannot perform the functions of a carrier. The Estonian Transport Administration co-ordinates the development of county and nationwide public transport; organizes regional passenger transport by ferries to the islands and organizes regional passenger transport by air to three islands. The Public Transport Department of the Estonian Transport Administration is responsible for planning and organizing public transport according to demand and promoting use of public transport by that reducing society's social and economic costs for transport, energy and infrastructure. Case law Supreme Court ruling No 3-3-1-2-14 (direct contract, railroad) : Dispute over the legality of a direct agreement entered into by the state with AS Eesti Liinirongid for the provision of passenger transport services by rail. The Supreme Court explained that the relevant national and European Union legislation authorizes the State to enter into a direct contract, as AS Eesti Liinirongid is a state-controlled company. The Supreme Court relied on Article 5 (2) of EU Regulation 1370/2007, which in itself regulates the conclusion of direct contracts in the case of local, not national passenger transport. The Supreme Court found, referring to the preamble of the ruling, that neither Estonian nor European law prevents the conclusion of direct agreements with a national scope in railway traffic. The purpose of the obligation to organize a procurement procedure would be, above all, to avoid distortions of competition resulting from the State's arbitrary preference for one private undertaking over another when ordering services. However, the purpose of public procurement law is not to increase the market share of the private sector at the expense of services provided by the public sector. Where the State considers it appropriate to carry out a public task itself or through companies wholly controlled by it, public authorities or public companies should not compete on an equal footing with private companies. The Supreme Court also explained when the company could be considered state-controlled. It is not important that the state has a 100% share in the association. It is enough that the influence of the public sector is predominant. It is important for the state to be able to influence the company's strategic decisions and important individual decisions. However, the state does not have to be able to intervene in all details of a company's activities. On the basis of the above, the Supreme Court concluded that AS Eesti Liinirongid is a state-controlled company. Supreme Court ruling No 3-1-1-65-16 (not disclosing taxi price list): On 5 November 2015, the senior inspector of the Tallinn Municipal Police Board of the Tallinn City Government prepared a misdemeanour report on taxi driver Indrek Pallo, according to which the person failing to fulfil the obligation to place a price list on the right side of the vehicle dashboard Thus, I. Pallo violated § 3 (4) and (5) of Regulation No. 20 “Tallinn Taxi Transport Requirements” (hereinafter also the Regulation) adopted by the Tallinn City Council on 15 October 2015 and which entered into force on 1 November 2015, and committed a misdemeanour provided for in subsection 86 (1) of the Public Transport Act (PTS). Supreme Court ruling No 3-17-1329 (not disclosing properly the timetable at the bus stations): On 5 October 2015, the Architecture and City Planning Board of the Narva City Government and AS ATKO Bussiliinid entered into the Narva City Public Bus Service Agreement No. 179. On 14 November 2016, the Narva City Government's Architecture and Urban Planning Board sent the applicant a notice No. 1-13 / 4602 regarding the breach of contract, together with the acts of non-compliance with the quality of service and reduction of the amount of support. According to them, the applicant was fined a total of EUR 1800 for 36 infringements (EUR 50 for each infringement), as the applicant violated the obligation set out in clause 5.1.18 of the contract to install valid timetables at bus stops with weatherproof information boards and to ensure the availability and orderliness of information boards. During the inspection, the respondent established that there are no timetables valid at bus stops from 1 November 2016. Information on key provisions 3.1 SCOPE (ART 1(2)): 3.1.1 Optional application of the Regulation Option to cover: National choice: Comments: Inland waterways Option used In accordance with the Article 1(1) of PTA. National seawaters Option used In accordance with the Article 1(1) of PTA. 3.1.2. C onditions of application of the Regulation to cross-border public transport services There are no “hybrid” cross border services provided under PSO in Estonia. If there would be the need in the future, the general PSO regulation (i.e. Chapter 3 of PTA) shall be applied. 3.2 COMPETENT AUTHORITIES (ART 2(b), (c)): Authority Level Mode of transport concerned Staff Number The Government of the Republic; National A ll modes N/A 14 The Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications National All modes N/A The Transport Administration National All modes N/A 11 R egional public transport centres Regional Road N/A Local authorities Local Road At least 79 79 3.3 SPECIFICATION OF PSO (ART 2(e) , ART 2a(1)) 3.3.1 Adoption of methodology and processes for the specification of PSO In Estonia , methodology and processes for the specification of PSO have been adopted . The procedure - The competent authority shall choose the operator for the PSO in the public procurement procedure in accordance with the Public Procurement Act. The operator that fulfils the requirements and has made the best offer in the public procurement procedure, shall be chosen for the PSO. The methodology - While drafting the terms and conditions for the public procurement, the competent authority shall take into account the principles stated in the Public Transport Act for the effective public transportation, development plan(s) for public transport, feedback from the public transport surveys, planned transport route, results and conclusion of fulfilling the supervision obligation, advises given other national authorities, results of other independent survey and analysis (if any). Please refer to the competences in the articles described in Section 1.2 in this Report . 3.3.2 Level of detail of PSO specification The level of detail of PSO specification is high , quite detailed and objectively understandable. According to the Article 20(2)(1) of PTA, the PSC must also contain the public service obligation which includes a list of the routes to be serviced along with a calculation of the distance to be travelled on the routes and a calculation of the cost of the transport service per cost entry. The PSOs are defined in the terms as follows: 1) the public service obligation which includes a list of the routes to be serviced along with a calculation of the distance to be travelled on the routes and a calculation of the cost of the transport service per cost entry; 2) the grounds of and procedure for payment of subsidies to regular services; 3) the procedure for reporting on the use of the subsidies; 4) the granting of use of public transport vehicles and route facilities for the provision of transport services, and requirements concerning the use and return thereof; 5) the term of validity of the contract; 6) the grounds of and procedure for the expiry or termination and amendment of the contract; 7) the conditions for insuring passengers and property; 8) sanctions in the event of a breach of the contract. 3.3.3 P ublic transport policy documents and policy objectives relevant for PSO s Relevant documents setting policy objectives for the purpose of Article 2a(1) Development Plan for 2014-2020; Transport and mobility development plan for 2021+ elaborated by the Ministry Assessment on policy objectives set in public transport policy documents I n relation to PSO, they seem sufficiently “S.M.A.R.T.” considering the size of the local authorities and the clarity of the PSOs. The Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications has described the main objectives and activities of transport in Development Plan for 2014-2020 on its webpage in English as well. The transport and mobility development plan for 2021+ is being drawn up to set long-term goals in this area by the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications. The ministry have conducted workshops, gathered ideas from the locals, participated in the public debate at “Arvamusfestival” , etc (the detailed list is stated here ). The similar approach ha s also the local authorities, where they carry out relevant surveys, analysis (incl. taking into consideration other countries’ similar cities analysis, etc.), reports and then draft development plan, which also includes the need for PSOs. The vast majority of documents and information are in Estonian. These documents are analysis, development plans, which have confirmed on the local authority or national level. Pursuant to Article 2a(1) the PSO objective shall be described in detailed manner to the level that the obliged entity shall understand its obligation stated in the PSC. 3.3.4 C ompetent authorities ’ economic assessment to underpin the necessity and proportionality of PSO specification In Estonia , the competent authorities underpin the necessity and proportionality of PSO specification with an economic assessment as defined in Article 26 of PTA (planning of subsidising regular services provided under public service contract). 3.3.5 C ompetent authorities ’ ex ante evaluations on the need for PSO given the existence of a commercial offer (existing or potential ) The competent authority carries out the ex-ante analysis for the evaluation on the need for PSO based on the costs and reasonable profit for the operator. 3.4 MAXIMUM TARIFFS FOR ALL OR FOR CERTAIN CATEGORIES OF PASSENGERS (ART 3(2), ART 3(3)): General rules for PSOs which aim at establishing maximum tariffs The general rules applicable to tariffs are set out in Article 34 of PTA: on a domestic route, the carrier is required to carry the following persons free of charge by road, water and rail: a child who has not attained the age of seven years by October 1 in the current academic year; a child whose commencement of the compulsory school attendance has been postponed; a disabled person of up to 16 years of age; a person with a profound disability and at least 16 years of age; a person with a severe visual disability; a person accompanying a person with a profound or severe visual disability; or the guide dog or assistant dog accompanying a disabled person. The carrier does not receive any compensation for the carriage of the passengers of these categories. Number per mode 7 covering all modes . Purpose The aim of settling max imum tariffs is to give access to public transportation for all including less beneficial population groups . Compensation No General rules outside the scope of Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007 (Art 3(3)) 7 Experience with their application compared to the use of PSC N/A On a domestic route, the carrier is required to carry the following persons free of charge by road, water and rail: a child who has not attained the age of seven years by October 1 in the current academic year; a child whose commencement of the compulsory school attendance has been postponed; a disabled person of up to 16 years of age; a person with a profound disability and at least 16 years of age; a person with a severe visual disability; a person accompanying a person with a profound or severe visual disability; or the guide dog or assistant dog accompanying a disabled person. The carrier does not receive any compensation for the carriage of the passengers of these categories. On 21 November 2018, the Parliament passed an amendment to the Income Tax Act, which, among other things, amended subsection 48 (51) of the Income Tax Act. According to this, from 1 January 2020, the compensation of the price of public transport tickets used for transport between the place of residence and the place of work of the employees will not be taxed as a special benefit. The employer can compensate the tickets of public transportation to their workers and it is a general cost of the agency : https://www.numeri.ee/blogi/uhistranspordi-piletihinna-huvitamine/ There are additional passenger modes, which are additional compensate (Article 36 of PTA above) on provision of regular services under a PSC, a pupil, the person accompanying a person having a profound disability and the person accompanying a disabled person of up to 16 years of age is granted a travel fare concession of up to 100 per cent of the ticket price on an intra-city or other domestic train route, provided that the point of departure and the destination are located within the borders of one city, as well as upon carriage by road and water. Upon provision of regular services under a PSC, the owner of a state or municipal school may also compensate a pupil for up to 100 per cent of the ticket price on a domestic train route, and on an air route that connect the Estonian mainland to the islands and small islands. 3.5 CONTENT OF PSC ( ART 2(i), ART 4): 3.5.1 Type and duration of PSC Type of PSC Duration Typical duration Extensions (Art 4(4)) Contract Road - The duration typically varies from 3 to 5 years. No Rail - The duration is 5 years. Waterway - The duration is 10 years. Air - The duration is 4 years. 3.5.2 E xclusive rights In Estonia, there are no cases, where the exclusive rights are granted and defined. 3.5.3 T ypical arrangements per mode for the risk allocation For all transport modes in Estonia , t he typical arrangement for the risk allocation is mainly mixed (i.e. terms include net and gross cost conditions ) contracts . 3.5.4 S taff protection and quality requirements Usually there are not specific requirements set out for the staff protection. There have been contracts, where there is obligation to assure the staff protections in accordance with the Collective Agreements Act. Requirements on sustainable and clean mobility in PSCs No, however de facto usually there is possibility to carry bicycle on board (e.g. on train, ship, even bus). Staff protection and staff transfer to a new operator General rules Conditions for transfer of staff Monitoring of compliance with requirements Use of social and qualitative selection criteria N/A N/A N/A No 3.5.5 S ubcontracting Subcontracting may be used in all transport services . However, there is an obligation to receive a prior consent from the authority to use a subcontractor or the service provider must guarantee that the subcontractor shall fulfil the obligation with the same quality as the service provider. 3.5.6 PSC features for a competitive award? (yes/no) All important features of the PSC provided in the tender documents for a competitive award are included. Bidder’s opinion: N/A . 3.6 AWARD OF PSC (ART 5): 3.6.1 Optional t ypes of awards Type of award Prohibited by national law Allowed by national law Legislative reference/comments Award to internal operators (Art 5(2)) X Article 21 (3)(2) and 21(4) to (6) of PTA Exemption for exceptional circumstances (Art 5(3a)) X N/A “Light” competitive procedure (Art 5(3b)): X N/A De minimis award (Art 5(4)) X N/A Rail exemption (Art 5(6)) X N/A Award to internal operators (Art 5(2)) Compliance with conditions Use of subcontracting Awarding authority Yes/No Mode of transport Share in the transport volume covered by the PSC Yes Yes Road, rail. The law does not specify for what transport services the subcontracting may be used or not. The national expert has identified the right to use subcontract examples for road and rail transportation (please see the underline references , ). That volume is rather minimal. National c ompetent authority or local competent authority. Exemption for exceptional circumstances (Art 5(3a)): PSC awarded on this legal basis Motivations put forward for such awards Frequency of use of Art 5(3a) . Yes N/A In one occasion (contract between the Republic of Estonia and AS Eesti Liinirongid (entity,which belong solely to the Estonia) ) De minimis award (Art 5(4)) Thresholds applied N/A Emergency award (Art 5(5)) Motivations Duration Use for Covid-19 According to the Article 22(1) of PTA, this measure may be taken only where the renewal of a public service contract specified in clause 1 of subsection 3 of § 21 of PTA or the direct awarding of a public service contract specified in clause 2 of subsection 3 of § 21 of this Act fails. In rail and bus and coach sector the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications has not used Art 5(5) for awarding PSC. N/A No Art 5(1) awards for transport by bus and by tram Share based on public procurement law in total awards of PSC for bus and tram services The share is about 63%. 3.6.2 Competitive award (Art 5(3)) N ational laws on which the procedural rules for such competitive awards are based on : Article 21(1) of PTA states that the competent authority chooses a carrier in accordance with the Public Procurement Act (PPA) and taking into account the specifications provided for in this section and, regarding the carriage of passengers by rail and road, in Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007 of the European Parliament and of the Council. R elative importance of the different procedures of competitive award : The open procedure (Article 51 of PPA) is the main procedure used for competitive awards in Estonia . There is possibility to apply: • Restricted Procedure (Article 53 of PPA); • Innovation Partnership (Article 57 of PPA); • Competitive Dialogue (Article 63 of PPA); • Competitive Procedure with Negotiation (Article 67 of PPA); • Negotiated Procedure without Prior Publication (Article 72 of PPA). P rocedures for the award of cross-border PSC : According to the Article 44(6) of PPA, where several contracting authorities from different Member States of the European Union have set up a joint entity, a decision of the competent body of the joint entity sets out the applicable national public procurement law which may be either the public procurement law of the Member State where the joint entity has its registered office or the public procurement law of the Member State where the joint entity is carrying out its activities. T ypical trends in terms of outcome of competitive award procedures : In rail sector we do not use competitive award procedures. The Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications uses Art 5(6) which states that unless prohibited by national law, competent authorities may decide to make direct awards of public service contracts where they concern transport by rail. In bus and coach sector the number of tenders received is 5 to 9. 3.6.3 Legal review procedure (Art 5(7) and Recital 21): The Public Procurement A ct (PPA) contains several provisions ensuring review of public tenders in several phases. In all phases of tenders, bidders may apply to the jury whenever their rights have not been respected. A tenderer, candidate or economic operator interested in participating in public procurement may contest actions of the contracting authority or entity by filing a respective request for review with the Public Procurement Review Committee , where it finds that an infringement of the PPA by the contracting authority or entity infringes its rights or adversely affects its interests. The decision of the Review Committee enters into force after the expiry of the time limit for having recourse to the court where none of the parties to the proceedings filed a claim with the administrative court. In the case of partial contestation of a decision of the Review Committee, the decision enters into force to the extent not covered by the appealed part. Upon adjudicating the case, the court is bound by the decision of the Review Committee to the extent that it has not been contested. National legal base: To the Administrative Court (Article 22(5) of PTA or Article 2(1) or 268(1) of Code of Administrative Court Procedure). To the Public Procurement Review Committee (Article 185(1) of PPA). Assessment of awards pursuant to Art 5(4a) and Art 5(4b): Independent body assessing awards Judicial review Publication of the results of assessments Frequency of request for assessment of an award The Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications Yes Yes, at the court final ruling decision session the decision is declared and later on it is published the national webpage Riigi Teataja (Articles 173(1) and 175(1) of Code of Administrative Court Procedure). Not very often. 3.7 ACCESS TO RAIL ROLLING STOCK (ART 5a) : 3.7.1 Competent authorities’ assessments of non-discriminatory access to rolling stock : Preparation of assessments: In Estonia , the c ompetent authorities have not prepared assessment of non-discriminatory access to rail rolling stock. However, the Estonian Competition Authority has made an assessment about the competition on the public railroad (main focus on the rolling stock, not the passenger transport) , where it is concluded also that: The Estonian public railway freight market is dominated by high structural barriers to entry, which manifest themselves in particular in: the high cost of acquiring the equipment necessary for the provision of the service, the acquisition must be taken into account also Estonian railway with a width of 1520 mm ; lack of free freight volume; high charges for the use of railway infrastructure due to rail congestion. C riteria and methodology applied : N/A Publication of assessment’s results: N/A P ossibility to use second-hand market rolling stock : No. C ompetent authority has bought all the necessary rolling stock for PSO. Definition of technical and/or other binding requirements when requiring the use of new rolling stock to help placing this rolling stock on the market after the expiry of the PSC : N/A/ . Type of concrete measures consequently adopted to ensure access to rolling stock : The new Railways Act came into force on 01.01.2021, which is in accordance with the Fourth railway package and therefore include a lot of different rules regarding non-discrimination. Railway undertakings have the right to use public railways without discrimination with regard to user fees for railway infrastructure, and the time and other conditions of use of railway infrastructure. The right includes also access to the railway infrastructure connecting maritime and inland ports and service facilities, and to the railway infrastructure serving or potentially serving more than one final customer. 3.7.2 T ypical financing arrangements and financial institutions involved (please explain) The Republic of Estonia shall pay the subsidies for services and buying rolling stocks according to PSC between the Republic of Estonia and AS Eesti Liinirongid . F inancial institutions involved in the financing of rolling stock earmarked for the provision of public transport services by rail are the State budget and financing provided by manufacturer. 3.8 PUBLIC SERVICE COMPENSATION (ART. 4, ART. 6, ANNEX): 3.8.1 Amount of PSO compensation per mode, per PSC In 2019, for : transport by bus 43,619,913 EUR; transport by ferry 22,363,902 EUR; transport by plane 2,975,559 EUR. 3.8.2 C ompensation parameters The parameters are defined in detail as per the section 3 of direct PSC for rail passenger services , section 3 of direct PSC for ferry and section 2 and 3 of PSC for bus transport . The main parameters are: annual timetable, planned passenger turnover, the de facto costs of operator, reasonable expected profit, exclusion of de facto commercial profit from potential compensation . Also is used specific mathematical formula, which is agreed upon. T he PSCs does rely on a compensation formula or on a Profit and Loss Account (or equivalent) . 3.8.3 M ethodologies used for calculating compensation In rail transport PSCs, the compensation is calculated according to the ANNEX of Regulation 1370/2007. In bus and coach sector tenders for a direct award shall be taken from at least 3 carriers and shall be based on the minimum price per route kilometre, less ticket revenue and local government support, and the remainder shall be compensation. If the compensation exceeds the budget possibilities or differs from the average contractual indicators in the public service market, the contract will not be awarded under this tender procedure. 3.8.4 Use of operational, financial and economic parameters used for the calculation of compensation The calculation may use the following : line work volume; calculation of the costs of regular transport performed on the basis of a public service contract; ticket revenue; compensation paid from the budget of the local government; calculation of the need for targeted support from the state budget; other sources of covering the costs and necessary profit of regular public transport in addition to those specified in clauses 3) –5) of this subsection. Also, the parameters depend on the specifics of the service in the direct PSC (e.g. incl. the changes in fuel price, the percentage change in the consumer price index, Average gross wages and salaries in transport and storage estimated by Statistics Estonia, etc.). 3.8.5 Requirements on independent evaluation/expertise to approve, or review, the financial arrangements foreseen in the PSC No , in Estonia the independent evaluation/expertise to approve, or review, the financial arrangements foreseen in the PSC is not obligatory. But the state supervision is applied (Chapter 12 of PTA) . 3.8.6 Risk level in the calculation of the reasonable profit It is stated in the PSC. E.g. the clause 3.12 of "Direct contract for public passenger transport services by rail" concluded between the Republic of Estonia and AS Eesti Liinirongid , that: “ A reasonable profit is considered to be the normal return on capital of this sector in Estonia or another Member State of the European Union with a similar market, which takes into account the risks caused to the Carrier or the absence of risks based on the effects of concluding the Agreement. ” 3.8.7 Calculation and monitoring of compensation in case of general measures In case of general measures, the compensation is calculated and monitored through applied compensation parameter and periodic reporting (incl. reasoning) obligation. 3.8.8 M ethodology for monetising the value of exclusive rights when calculating the compensation amount No exclusive rights have been granted in Estonia. 3.8.9 N etwork effects Ways network effects are taken into account: N/A Data and IT systems used to assess network effects: Reports from the transport services, independent research and www.peatus.ee IT system. 3.8.10 Transport services combining open access and PSO services Metrics used to properly allocate cost and revenues i n case of transport services combining open access and PSO service : No specific metrics are published. IT systems used by operators (or available on the market) to ensure a proper separation of accounts for these hybrid services : The operator has obligation to separate accounting of regular services provided under public service contract from other business operations for the purpose of prevention of cross-subsidisation and purposeful use of the subsidies allocated to the public regular services from the state budget or the budget of the local authority (Article 23 of PTA). https://transport.tallinn.ee/#tallinna-linn/map/en 3.8.11 O vercompensation and under - compensation Ex-ante and ex-post over - compensation check in case of direct awards in case of competitive awards Yes. Yes . Resulting claw-backs N /A Evidence for over-compensation or under-compensation (including delays of compensation payments to the public transport operator) No 3.8.12 A ccounting separation requirements (point 5 of the Annex) Accounting separation requirements are respected . 3.8.13 Feedback from public transport operators on the way competent authorities calculate and pay PSO compensation Internal operators are satisfied with the way compensation has been paid. 3.8.14 E fficiency incentive schemes Application: Yes . Specification: The social and economic feasibility of the use of resources and reduce social and economic costs on transport, energy and infrastructure incurred by society is applied as general principle. Usually, more detailed schemes are specified in the terms of the public procurement carried out. Effectiveness: Yes. 3.9 PUBLICATION (ART 7): 3.9.1 Publication of annual Art 7(1) reports Publication of annual Art 7(1) reports by the various competent authorities : Yes. Chapter 10 of PTA states the legal ground for the national public transport register, which should include the necessary information, which must be disclosed. However, the www.peatus.ee does not include all the relevant information. F eatures included in the reports : The report includes: The name of the regional public transport centre or county; The name of the entity who provides the service; Contract start date; Contract due date; Contract volume; The amount of revenue compensated; All the revenue in total. F acilitation to access reports : Yes : There is direct access under the Bus Transportation, through the webpage of the Estonian Transport Administration. https://transpordiamet.ee/uudised-ametist-ja-kontakt/trukised-ja-valjaanded/trukised-ja-ettekanded#statistika 3.9.2 Publications as per Art 7(2) and Art 7(3) Yes , for rail and bus PSCs. 3.9.3 R equests for issuing the reasons of direct awards (Art 7(4) ) Requests for issuing the reasons of direct awards have not been received by competent authorities for rail, bus and coach PSCs. 3.10 TRANSITION (ART 8): Application of Art 5 Time Act Before 3 December 2019 Yes Public Transport Act (already in redaction, which came into force on 01.20.2015). PSC in force pursuant to Art 8(3) a-c) Number Until when No N/A Saatja: Daniel Stoyanov <[email protected]> Saadetud: 18.02.2022 14:53 Adressaat: Riigikantselei <[email protected]>; MKM info <[email protected]> Koopia: <[email protected]> Teema: Country Report Estonia Study on the implementation of Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007 and on developments in the provision of public passenger transport Tähtsus: Kõrgeim Dear Madame/Sir, In January 2021, the Consortium composed of Grimaldi Studio Legale, VVA SPRL and Wavestone, has been awarded by DG MOVE of the European Commission a &quot;Study on the implementation of Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007 and on developments in the provision of public passenger transport&quot;. The Study aims to assess how key provisions of the Regulation have been concretely applied and what have been the likely impacts on the provision and performance of public transport services in the EU Member States, based on the findings from desk research, direct consultation with national stakeholders (competent authorities and market operators) and responses to an on-line survey. All these findings are summarised in Country Reports, one for each Member State. The Final report of the Study, which is due to be published by the Commission, is in the process of being prepared by our team. It will include data from the Country Reports, and it is therefore of the outmost importance that the information contained thereto is accurate. In this context, we would highly appreciate a confirmation from the national authority responsible for public passenger transport policy that you agree with the content of Country Report for Estonia. The document that we attach for your perusal, contains the information collected that we would like you to confirm. Please pay particular attention to the answer to question 3.5.3 Typical arrangements per mode for the risk allocation where the national expert concluded that for all transport modes in Estonia, the typical arrangement for the risk allocation is mainly mixed (i.e. terms include net and gross cost conditions) contracts and the Commission asks for confirmation of that information. Also please pay attention to the table on p. 11 stating that National or local authorities are competent to award to internal operators public service contracts as Art 5(2) stipulates that normally the internal operator is controlled by a local competent authority (not national). We need a verification that both, ex-ante and ex-post checks are applied in case of direct and competitive awards. As we need to submit to the Commission the Country Report in the first half of March, we would kindly ask you to provide us with your feed-back by the 4th of March at the latest. In case of non-response, the information, as it is, will be published. Looking forward to a positive response concerning your availability, we thank you in advance for your time and remain at your entire disposal. Kind regards, Daniel Stoyanov Technical Expert M: &#43; 3598 99 474112 BRUXELLES - Avenue des Arts 11 - 1210 Bruxelles - Phone: &#43;32 2 2237926 MILAN - Palazzo Stampa di Soncino - Via Torino, 61 - 20123 Milano - Phone: &#43;39 02 72733.1 Web: LinkedIn : ________________________________ We only collect and use your personal data to the extent permitted by law. Please read our here. This message may contain information which is confidential or privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, please immediately notify us and destroy this message and any attachments without retaining a copy. Any unauthorized use of the content of this message can expose the responsible party to civil and/or criminal penalties. Ref. Ares(2021)1269288 - 15/02/2021 EUROPEAN COMMISSION DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR MOBILITY AND TRANSPORT Deputy Director-General Directorate A – Policy Coordination Acting Director Brussels, Dear Sir/Madam, Subject: Study on the implementation of Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007 and on developments in the provision of public passenger transport - Mandate granted to the Grimaldi, VVA, and Wavestone consortium The European Commission, Directorate-General for Mobility and Transport (DG MOVE) has launched a “Study on the implementation of Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007 and on developments in the provision of public passenger transport (MOVE-A4-2020-136)”. The objective of the study is to provide the Commission with relevant factual and analytical information on the implementation of key provisions of the Regulation and of main developments/patterns observed in public passenger transport in EU Member States. Based on this information, the Commission expects to obtain a better understanding of how key provisions of the Regulation have been applied and what have been the likely impacts on the provision and performance of public transport by rail and by road, with a view to compiling the report foreseen in Article 11 of the Regulation. The contract for this study has been awarded to a consortium consisting of Grimaldi, VVA, and Wavestone. The consortium has extensive experience in working with evaluations and will treat with the strictest confidence all the information or documentation you will provide. The study comprises various types of data gathering activities, including desk research, interviews, and online consultation/questionnaire with stakeholders. Access to relevant actors, data, information and experience is vital for the success of this study. The consortium may contact you to collect information via email enquiry, interview and/or surveys. I would very much appreciate it if you could collaborate and facilitate the consortium’s work. Your valued support will contribute to the production of a high-quality report, which in turn will help drive an effective and correct application of EU law as well as future policymaking. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact Mr. Jan Scherp ([email protected]). Yours faithfully, Maja BAKRAN MARCICH Electronically signed on 15/02/2021 16:26 (UTC+01) in accordance with article 11 of Commission Decision C(2020) 4482
Allikas: Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel