18 February 2022
Mr Taavi Aas
Minister of Economic Affairs & Infrastructure
AIRPORTSCOIINCIL Ministry of Economic Affairs & Infrastructure
INTERNATIONAL 11 Harju Street
15072 Tallinn
ESTONIA
Olivier Jankovec
Director General
CC : Mr. Kaido Padar, Director General of Civil Aviation, Estonia
Ms Maria Alajoe, Counsellor, Permanent Representation of Estonia to the
EU
Dear Minister,
I am writing to you express the concerns of the European airport industry as
regards claims made by a specific airline group regarding the currently applicable
alleviation measures to airport slot usage rules.
According to these claims, these alleviation measures would oblige airlines to fly
empty or near empty flights for the sole purpose of keeping their slot portfolio at
airports. More flexibility would therefore be needed to avoid this situation, in the
form of a further reduction in the airport slot usage threshold.
These claims have remained unsubstantiated as no detailed data has been
provided by the above-mentioned airline group. Moreover, along with airport slot
coordinators not confirming the occurrence of empty or near-empty flights being
operated solely to protect slot portfolios, other airlines have actually denied this
practice being a reality.
Yet, the issue has attracted significant media coverage, casting an unfavourable
light on the environmental credentials of the aviation sector. This is unfortunate,
especially given the ambitious commitments and intensive work being done by all
aviation industry stakeholders to achieve Net Zero CO2 emissions by 2050.
Also quite worrying is the fact that a number of EU Member Statesll have most
recently echoed the above-mentioned claims - calling on the European Commission
to reconsider the alleviation measures adopted for the Winter 21 and Summer 22
seasons and reduce further the slot usage threshold.
ACI EUROPE would therefore like to oppose such calls and reiterate its full support
for the alleviation measures adopted by the European Commission (EC):
Through the Delegated Act currently in place for the Winter 21 season, the
airport slots usage threshold is set at 50% - while that for the Summer 22
season sets a threshold of 64%. Both are significantly lower than the 80%
which is applicable in normal times and are designed to reflect the
uncertainties inherent to the current phase of the pandemic.
" Joint Statement by Belgium, Denmark, Finland and Italy circulated by the General Secretariat of the
EU Council on 26 January.
Airports Council International - European Region AISBL
37-40 Boulevard du Regent-1000 Brussels, Belgium - tel: +32 (0)2 552 0972 - fax: +32 (0)2 505 56 37
www.aci-europe.org - TVA: BE 431.887.748
A crucial additional pillar of the alleviation measures and flexibility afforded
to airlines is the "Justified Non-Use of Slots" (JNUS) provisions. These are
specifically designed to address the COVID-19 pandemic, and cover not
only outright travel bans, but also restrictions of movement, quarantine or
isolation measures which impact the viability or possibility of travel or the
demand for travel on specific routes. The recent guidance adopted by the
European Airport Coordinators Association on a uniform approach and
application of the JNUS rules underlines their importance. This uniform
approach from coordinators is based on an interpretation of the Regulation's
JNUS provisions which is balanced, proportionate and appropriate, and as
such supported by ACI EUROPE.
As a result, airlines are indeed very well protected from the current uncertainties
and have been granted the necessary flexibility to avoid operating empty or near
empty flight for the sole purpose of maintaining their slot portfolio.
It would therefore be unjustified and wholly inappropriate to further reduce the
threshold in place or amend other alleviation measures.
Doing this would not only jeopardise fair competition within the European aviation
market, but also significantly hinder connectivity at a crucial point in the recovery.
In this regard, it is crucial to keep in mind that slot usage affects the entire
European airport network and not just those airports which qualify as "coordinated"
- ie. where slot allocation is required. Looking at the forthcoming Summer 22
season, Europe will have 106 out of a total 198 Level 3 (i.e. coordinated) airports
worldwide in the S22 season, a higher number and percentage (53.5%) compared
to pre-COVID (50.1% in S19, or 104/204). Furthermore, while usage requirements
only apply at those airports, the decisions taken around them affect all airports with
a connection to a coordinated airport and any which are influenced by airlines'
wider network management decisions.
Indeed, the need to restore connectivity and airline competition across the airport
network is at the core of ACI EUROPE's support for the progressive reinstatement
of slot usage requirements. The alleviation measures of the past two years, while
necessary, have nonetheless given airlines cover to reduce frequencies, while
maintaining their slot pomolios. This has been particularly hard-hitting for regional
airports which have seen valuable connections to hub airports eroded.
As a result, incumbent airlines at major airports were able to prevent entry from
competitors, by maintaining slot portfolios which are protected by waivers and
alleviation measures, while only effectively using some of these slots. This
compromises vital air connectivity and its economic and social benefits, as well as
having a clear detrimental impact on free competition and airports' abilities to
generate revenue.
Apart from being key reasons for the progressive reinstatement of usage thresholds
as part of the response to the current COVID-19 situation, these issues also point
to the continued necessity of a revision of the EU Airport Slot Regulation for the
longer term.
2
ACI EUROPE's Position Paper on Slot Allocation'2 sets out our vision for a future
Slot Regulation which prioritises connectivity and competition, and serves the
needs of passengers, airports and their regions. The future Slot Regulation will
need to ensure that connectivity of airports and their regions is paramount and
minimise the risk to this connectivity from crises such as COVID-19.
The European Commission has rightly included revision of the EU Airport Slot
Regulation in its current transport policy priorities, and Europe's airports look
forward to a proposal at the appropriate moment, as Europe exits the COVID-19
crisis and seeks to build a sustainable aviation system which is fit for the future.
The aviation market has developed in ways which were unthinkable when the
current Regulation was adopted - back in 1993. In particular, as airline business
models have diversified, airports themselves have become competitive businesses
in their own right with an increased focus on efficiency. At the same time, air
connectivity has acquired a new strategic relevance for Europe along with the need
to limit aviation's negative externalities - in particular environmental impacts.
It is therefore the case that current issues relating to slot allocation are being
addressed in the immediate term by the Commission's balanced package of
alleviation measures, while the systemic problems in slot allocation underline the
necessity of a revision of the Slot Regulation so as to ensure connectivity and
competition for the future.
I thank you for your attention on this matter, and remain at your disposal for any
further information.
Yours sincerely
12https://www.aci-europe.orz/component/attachments/attachments.html?id=277&task=download
3
Saatja: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 22.02.2022 07:41
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Slots
From: Stéphanie Coppin <> Sent: Monday, February 21, 2022 3:40
PMTo: Taavi Aas <>Cc: Olivier Jankovec <>; ; Subject: Slots
Dear Minister,
Please find attached a letter from Mr Olivier Jankovec, ACI EUROPE
Director General, regarding airport slot usage rules.
He thanks you in advance for taking it into consideration and remains a
your entire disposal should you have any queries.
With his very best regards,
Stéphanie Coppin
Stéphanie COPPIN
Head of Resources & PA to the Director General
ACI EUROPE (Airports Council International)
37-40, Boulevard du Régent (5th floor), 1000 Brussels, Belgium
Tel: +32 2 552 09 70 Website:
Fax: +32 2 502 56 37 Twitter:
For information on airports & their carbon emissions:
This message and any possible attachments are transmitted for the
exclusive use of the intended recipient(s). Should you receive this
message by mistake, please notify ACI EUROPE or the sender at once by
telephone or return e-mail and delete it from your system. Moreover, any
form of reproduction dissemination, copying, disclosure, modification,
distribution and/or use of this message - or part of its contents, as
well as its possible attachments by any unauthorized person or legal
entity, is strictly prohibited. The nature of the Internet means that the
integrity of this message cannot be guaranteed. ACI EUROPE and the sender
therefore disclaim any liability whatsoever in the event of this message
having been intercepted and/or altered.
P Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail