EEA and Norway Grants 2014-2021
Programme: Local Development
and Poverty Reduction
Selection Committee meeting
June 2, 2021
Open call for proposals
„Integrated services
to support health and safety in
home environment“
Overview
Project max duration: 24 months
Call amount: € 500,000
Project grant size: € 200,000 – 500,000
Project grant rate: 85%-90%
Eligible applicants: all legal persons under public or private law, non-governmental
organisation registered in Estonia.
SGS is financed from the NOR Grants FM
Eligible activities to reduce the risk of injury in home
environment (1):
establish a common methodology for assessing the risk of injury in
home environment and supporting tools;
agree on stakeholder cooperation and information exchange
mechanisms and responsibilities in reducing injuries in the home
environment;
pilot the methodology, tools, and mechanisms in at least two local
authorities, one with a minimum population of 30,000 and the other
with a maximum population of 10,000;
prepare a legal analysis regarding the exchange of necessary
sensitive personal data between authorities, map obstacles
concerning data exchange between stakeholders and make detailed
proposals to amend legislation to address identified problems;
Eligible activities to reduce the risk of injury in home
environment (2):
develop training materials and a training plan that can be used
in the future to train key stakeholders, and present the
developed materials to stakeholders;
prepare an impact assessment of the project;
carry out stakeholder outreach seminar(s) with a total of at
least 250 stakeholder professionals involved in reducing the
risk of injury to the home environment;
assemble at least 18 regionally differentiated teams
implementing the methodology of prevention of injuries in
home environment, of which one team must operate in North-
East of Estonia
Eligible activities to support families at risk with
infants and toddlers (1):
provide a validated assessment tool for identifying (incl. during
pregnancy) and monitoring families at risk;
describe the model of home visits suitable for Estonian
conditions, incl. integration of social visits into the social and
health care system, cost and funding;
prepare guidelines and training plans for the adaptation and
implementation of the model;
provide training to at least 40 competent specialists from all
over Estonia in order to carry out home visits;
Eligible activities to support families at risk with
infants and toddlers (2):
carry out a pilot of a model for identifying and supporting
families at risk with infants and toddlers with regard to at
least 40 risk group families across Estonia;
prepare an impact assessment of the project;
carry out the information events on the model for identifying
and supporting families at risk of infants and toddlers for a
total of at least 210 stakeholders involved in identifying and
supporting families at risk of infants and toddlers.
Targets (cumulative for the open call):
at least 500 specialists from all over Estonia trained to develop their knowledge
and skills in reducing the risk of injury in home environment and in identifying
and supporting families at risk with infants and toddlers
Number Expected programme results Indicator Baseline Baseline Target
value year value
Number of families that
have received early home 0 N/A 40
visitation interventions
Improved quality of during the pilot
integrated services and
Outcome 3 public health
interventions at local
level Number of operational
multi-sectoral teams 0 N/A 18
implementing the
integrated service model
Evaluation criteria of the open call
No Criterion Points %
Background and competence of the organisation and the
project team, involvement in project activities and inclusion
1 of partners 16 27,59%
Activity plan of the project, engagement of stakeholders and
2 target groups, and methods of involving participants 20 34,48%
3 Communication activities 3 5,17%
4 Risk factors 3 5,17%
5 Sustainability of project results and innovation 10 17,24%
6 Economic efficiency of the project 6 10,34%
TOTAL 58
Projects received within deadline:
Altogether 2 project proposals were submitted by deadline,
both in different focus areas
a) Estonian Rescue Board
b) Foundation Development Centre for a Child's Wellbeing
Evaluation of independent experts
Evaluator 1: Ms Gerli Lehe, Adviser, Department of Children and Families,
Ministry of Social Affairs;
Evaluator 2: Ms Triinu Purru, Community and Workplace Unit, Centre for
health and Welfare Promotion, National Institute for Health Development;
Evaluator 3: Ms Heidi Rätsep, family therapeut, supervisor dealing with risk
families, incl. underage mothers, Caritas Estonia
NB! Please note that evaluators No 2 and No 3 both evaluated only one project and
evaluator No 2 did not evaluate the focus area where her organisation is participating
as a project partner.
There were no project applications with points difference over 30% between the
scores given by experts, therefore a third evaluation was not necessary (point 20.5)
There were no project proposals receiving less than 50% of the total score, and
therefore would have received automatically a negative decision (point 20.6).
Ranking list of experts
Rescue Board
Development
Centre for a
Wellbeing
Estonian
Child's
Selection criteria
No Criterion Max score Average score Average score
Background and competence of the
organisation and the project team,
involvement in project activities and
1 inclusion of partners 16 13,0 13,5
Activity plan of the project, engagement
of stakeholders and target groups, and
2 methods of involving participants 20 17,5 17,5
3 Communication activities 3 3,0 2,0
4 Risk factors 3 3,0 3,0
Sustainability of project results and
5 innovation 10 10,0 10,0
6 Economic efficiency of the project 6 5,5 6,0
TOTAL 58 52,0 52,0
Selection Committee members
Voting members
Ms Triinu Täht– adviser to the Public Health Department, Ministry of Social
Affairs;
Ms Maarja Kärson – adviser to the Department of Children and Families,
Ministry of Social Affairs;
Mr Made Bambus – chief specialist of the Department of Primary Care
Services, Health Insurance Fund
Observers
The representatives of the National Focal Point and Programme Operator
Implementing Agency (both State Shared Service Centre) as well as the donor
states (Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Financial Mechanism
Committee) shall be invited to participate as observers.
Selection Committee tasks
The goal
to confirm the list of project applications suggested to be financed and the list
of project applications not to be financed and forward its decision to the
Programme Operator Implementing Agency (i.e. State Shared Service Centre)
for formal decision making.
The tasks
review the ranking list of project applications resulting from the
mathematical average of individual expert evaluation scores;
confirm the list of project applications suggested to be financed and the
list of project applications not to be financed;
modify the ranking list of the project applications or propose only partial
financing of projects in justified cases based on transparent criteria
recorded in the minutes of the committee meeting.
After the Selection Committee
Chairman of the Selection Committee and the PO will sign the minutes of
the meeting, where decisions are laid down in a transparent and
accountable manner describing which project proposals shall be awarded a
grant and which proposals will be rejected.
PO Implementing Agency will cast a decision to award a grant or decline
awarding a grant based on the written recommendation of the Selection
Committee.
Discussion and decisions
Aitäh! Takk!
Ülar Vaadumäe (
[email protected])
EEA and No rway Grants 2014-2021 Programme “Local Development and Poverty Reduction” Selection Committee meeting Date and time : June 2 , 202 1 from 1 5 : 00 to 17 : 0 0 (Estonian time) Venue: Cisco Meet web platform & MoSA , 3 rd floor, room Uluots ( Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn) Open call for proposals „ Integrated services to support health and safety in home environment “ Selection Committee voting members : Ms Triinu Täht – adviser to the Public Health Department, Ministry of Social Affairs; Ms Maarja Kärson – adviser to the Department of Children and Families, Ministry of Social Affairs; M s Made Bambus – chief specialist of the Department of Primary Care Services, Health Insurance Fund . Observers : M r Steinar Ingi Matthiasson – Financial Mechanism Office, Country and Bilateral Cooperation Department, Country Officer of Estonia, Greece and Slovenia ; also representing the Financial Mechanism Committee ; Ms Solfrid Johansen – representative of the donor programme partner, Norwegian Institute of Public Health; Ms Laura Pikkoja – representative of the National Focal Point; State Shared Service Centre; Ms Piret Marvet – representative of the donors, Royal Norwegian Embassy in Tallinn ; Ms Kelly Poopuu – representative of the PO Implementing Agency, State Shared Service Centre ; Mr Ülar Vaadumäe – Ministry of Social Affairs, Smart Development Department, chief specialist, PO. Minutes of the meeting Mr Ülar Vaadumäe gave an overview of the goals, targets and criteria of the call for proposals . Also, M r Vaadumäe introduced the submitted project s and explained the tasks of the Selection Committee. For more, please see Annex 1 (PO presentation). Altogether 2 project application s w ere received within the deadline ( April 1 , 202 1 at 17:00 o’clock local time) set for the call. As a result t he overall grant amount asked for is within the total grant amount available, i.e. 500 000 euros. Programme Operator Implementing Agency (State Shared Service Centre) has carried out the assessment of the project application s to the eligibility and administrative criteria set in the call text. The project s met the administrative and eligibility criteria and w ere forwarded for evaluation by two impartial, independent and reliable experts. These experts were: Evaluator 1 : Ms Gerli Lehe , Adviser, Department of Children and Families, Ministry of Social Affairs ; Evaluator 2: Ms Triinu Purru , Community and Workplace Unit, Centre for health and Welfare Promotion, National Institute for Health Development; Evaluator 3: Ms Heidi Rätsep , family therap ist , supervisor dealing with risk families, incl. underage mothers, Caritas Estonia. NB! Please note that evaluators No 2 and No 3 both evaluated only one project and evaluator No 2 did not evaluate the focus area where her organisation is participating as a project partner. There were no project applications with points difference over 30% between the scores given by experts, therefore a third evaluation was not necessary (point 20.5) There were no project proposals receiving less than 50% of the total score, and therefore would have received automatically a negative decision (point 20.6). Please see also Annex 2 (Ranking list of experts). Discussion Mr Vaadumäe opened with a remark that one project proposal has been submitted for both focus area s . The impartial evaluators have concluded that these project proposals are quite strong and worthwhile considering for financing . Focus area to reduce the risk of injury in home environment : Estonian Rescue Board project application “ Development and Piloting of a Methodology for the Assessment and Reduction of the Risk of Injury in the Home Environment and Supporting Activities ”; in partnership with Tartu city government and Lüganuse , Saue and Muhu municipalities . Ülar Vaadumäe reflected the evaluators’ comments regarding especially the evaluation methodology and -instrument – the ownership of the tool should be clarified (Rescue Board, social services, homeowner etc). Additionally the evaluators reminded that the target group should be engaged already during the development phase of the evaluation methodology and inquired which expertise would be compiled into the 18 teams implementing the methodology of prevention of injuries in home environment . Ms Triinu Täht was satisfied that the project proposal meets the targets set and is in a way a well composed right project in a right place. Still, the ownership question raised is also relevant. The reach of the project has good potential to be amplified all across Estonia, with piloting with 4 municipalities gives essential feedback how to move on. Ms Made Bambus explained that creating methodology needs evidence - based approach and a research institution would be important to be consulted here. She also indicated that there is no approach addressing specific target groups – injuries due to poisoning, injuries with kids etc. Ms Täht answered that the objective of designing the call was to seek for a comprehensive evaluation instrument to be used across sectors in raising “red flags” – social services, health care, rescue. Ms Maarja Kärson referred to the applicant that they have in general terms promised to engage National Institute for Health Development and Academy of Security Services, but it would be good to clarify that point. She considered it important for larger engagement of target groups to acquire a better understanding of the wider range of obstacles for different target groups. Ms Täht agreed that the current evaluation practice is not systemic, but rather case based. Ms Kärson also stressed that the timeline for impact analysis is only 2 months and that seems unrealistic. Ms Solfrid Johansen proposed that the applicant would find some good practices from movement European Safe Communities and the Norwegian Safety Forum https://www.skafor.org/norwegian-safety-forum/ . Ms Piret Marvet commented that neither of the applicants have donor partners. Mr Ülar Vaadumäe noted that this is the unfortunate reality. We had included the bonus points in the evaluation criteria for donor partnerships, but the application period for this call fell into the hardest Covid-19 crisis in Estonia (Feb-March 2021), so – while not knowing the concrete reasons – one might assume that because of the high uncertainty, risk and carefulness from both sides, maybe the donor partnership search was not the highest priority set by the applicants. Focus area to support families at risk with infants and toddlers: Foundation Centre for A Child’s Wellbeing project application “ Home Visits by Midwives During the First Years of Life “; in partnership with Estonian Association of Midwives, Tartu University Hospital, Tallinn University, Tartu Health Care College, National Institute for Health Development ; Viljandi and Rakvere city governments as well as Põltsamaa and Türi municipalities. Mr Ülar Vaadumäe again reflected the evaluators’ comments – as a new innovative approach it is not yet clear how the model is integrated into the social sector as well the target group remain s to o general without differentiating specific needs of women with disabilities or teenage moms etc. Ms Maarja Kärson found the project to include all major players in the field in Estonia – health care institutions, midwives ´ association, NIHD, municipalities. Especially important is the partnership of Tartu Health Care College that trains new midwives and therefore can change the approaches for the future. Although all women giving birth are considered as target group, then Ms Kärson agreed tha t specific consideration should be paid to more vulnerable target groups – including women with disabilities and very young mothers. This is also relevant for designing the project’s communication activities. The integration of systemic support of women after childbirth into the social sector is a part of model development and the project promoter has made this aware for itself. Ms Triinu Täht was in favour of the project – it has good reach and has included all important stakeholders in Estonia. Ms Made Bambus a brought out that a wide - range assessment tool for supporting the health and wellbeing of mothers and children is of utmost importance and the project is building a bridge between health and social sectors. As this is a new approach, then the full and effective integration is of worry. Until now, the home visits have been considered as completely a health issue, additionally the state budget financing has been separated for health and social sectors (respectively Health Insurance Board and Social Insurance Board). Therefore, a real - life change would be hard to achieve. Ms Täht was a bit optimistic saying that at the higher political level it has been a vision for some time already that the future relies in the integrated services. So, there is some good preconditions set. Ms Kärson brought out that currently there are changes being planned in the child protection services, so the timing is quite favourable also for the project activities. She highlighted that the project promoter is well aware of the financing complications and has described that it will deal with the issue during the piloting. Ms Solfrid Johansen compl i mented the project and informed everybody that a similar project with the same focus is currently running in Lithuania with the support of EEA and Norway Grants. Via a pre-defined project a methodology has been developed and via calls there are grants given to stakeholders for implementation. The baseline is the N urse -F amily P artnership programme. Mr Steinar Ingi Matthiasson stated that it is good to see two strong projects but inquired on the low number of project applications submitted. Mr Vaadumäe figured that partly it was related to the build-up of the call text and criteria – as emphasis was put on wide national reach, then it demanded also bigger players to be involved that have this capacity. Also, in home visits focus area the current proposal has gathered all the main stakeholders into one project (big partnership), so there wouldn’t be a serious alternative proposal with the same quality of expertise to be compiled for another project. Selection Committee decision s Approve a project grant to the following project applications as requested with the following suggestions : Estonian Rescue Board project “ Development and Piloting of a Methodology for the Assessment and Reduction of the Risk of Injury in the Home Environment and Supporting Activities ” in the amount of 293 602,92 euros with the following suggestions to be followed by the project promoter: the ownership of the evaluation methodology and -instrument should be clarified (Rescue Board, social services, homeowner etc ) ; the development of the methodology should follow evidence - based approach and therefore to ensure th at experts from research institutions should be involved ; the target group (homeowners) should be engaged already during the development phase of the evaluation methodology . L arge engagement of target groups is important to acquire a better understanding of the wider range of obstacles for different target groups ; it should be clarified which expertise would be compiled into the 18 teams implementing the methodology of prevention of injuries in home environment ; the timeline for impact analysis is only 2 months and that seems unrealistic ; good practices for project activities could be found from movement European Safe Communities and the Norwegian Safety Forum https://www.skafor.org/norwegian-safety-forum/ . Focus area to support families at risk with infants and toddlers: Foundation Centre for A Child’s Wellbeing project “ Home Visits by Midwives During the First Years of Life ” in the amount of 200 000,00 euros with the following suggestions to be followed by the project promoter: specific consideration should be paid to more vulnerable target groups , including women with disabilities and very young mothers. This is also relevant for designing the project’s communication activities ; for the sustainability and success of the project it is very important to strive for the full and effective integration of services into social sector , including necessary changes in financing model . Until now, the home visits have been considered as completely a health issue, additionally the state budget financing has been separated for health and social sectors (respectively Health Insurance Board and Social Insurance Board) and social services are largely also funded by local governments . Therefore, achieving a real - life change needs engag ing many stakeholders ; it would be useful for the project promoter to exchange best practices with a similar project with the same focus currently running in Lithuania with the support of EEA and Norway Grants. https://www.norwaygrants.lt/en/programmes/projects/program/23/id/38/development_of_home_visitation_early_intervention_model . Mr Ülar Vaadumäe thanked everybody for their input and closed the meeting. Meeting chaired by (digitally signed) minutes taken by Triinu Täht ( digitally signed ) Ül ar Vaadumäe
Martin Karro
Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus
[email protected] Meie 11.06.2021 nr 2-6.3/1958-1
Avatud taotlusvooru "Integreeritud teenused
tervise ja turvalisuse toetamiseks
kodukeskkonnas" hindamiskomisjoni otsused ja
rahastamiseks kinnitatud projektitaotlused
Lugupeetud Martin Karro
Palume Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskusel kui Euroopa Majanduspiirkonna ja Norra toetuste 2014–
2021 programmi „Kohalik areng ja vaesuse vähendamine“ rakendusüksusel langetada
toetuse rahuldamise otsused avatud taotlusvooru „Integreeritud teenused tervise ja
turvalisuse toetamiseks kodukeskkonnas“ raames laekunud projektitaotluste suhtes, mille on
kinnitanud 2. juunil 2021. aastal kohtunud taotlusvooru hindamiskomisjon.
Palun rakendusüksusel edastada taotlejatele hindamiskomisjoni soovitused ja kommentaarid
ning paluda vajadusel taotlejatel täpsustada oma projektikirjeldusi (lisatud).
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kristiina Hunt
nutika arengu toetamise osakonna juhataja
Lisa: Minutes of the SC meeting (June 2 2021)_FINAL
Ülar Vaadumäe 626 9249
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 626 9301 /
[email protected] / www.sm.ee / registrikood 70001952