WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION
ORGANISATION MONDIALE DE LA SANTÉ
WELTGESUNDHEITSORGANISATION Date: 23 June 2021
ВСЕМИРНАЯ ОРГАНИЗАЦИЯ ЗДРАВООХРАНЕНИЯ
REGIONAL OFFICE FOR EUROPE Ms Elen Ohov
BUREAU RÉGIONAL DE L’EUROPE
REGIONALBÜRO FÜR EUROPA
Adviser
ЕВРОПЕЙСКОЕ РЕГИОНАЛЬНОЕ БЮРО European Union Affairs and International Co-
Head office:
operation Department
UN City, Marmorvej 51, Ministry of Social Affairs
DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark Suur-Ameerika 1
Tel.: +45 45 33 70 00; Fax: +45 45 33 70 01
Email:
[email protected] 10122 Tallinn
Website: http://www.euro.who.int Estonia
Our reference: Your reference:
Notre référence: Votre référence:
Unser Zeichen: Ihr Zeichen:
См. наш номер: На Ваш номер:
Dear Ms Ohov,
Web-based consultation on the Response to the COVID-19 pandemic:
lessons learned to date from the WHO European Region
The World Health Organization (WHO) Regional Office for Europe presents its compliments to the
Member States in the WHO European Region and has the honor of inviting them to a web-based
consultation on the “Response to the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons learned to date from the WHO
European Region” that will be included in the updated version of the WHO European Region’s Action
Plan to Improve Public Health Preparedness and Response in the WHO European Region 2018–2023,
to be presented at the 72nd session of the WHO Regional Committee for Europe (RC72).
Building on the independent reviews established by the WHO Secretariat related to COVID-19 – which
are led by the Review Committee on the Functioning of the International Health Regulations (2005)
during the COVID-19 Response, the Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response, and
the WHO Health Emergencies Programme Independent Oversight and Advisory Committee – this
document seeks to present the lessons learned by WHO European Member States, basing it on WHO’s
European Programme of Work, 2020–2025 – “United Action for Better Health in Europe” (EPW).
Under EPW, core priority 2 (protecting against health emergencies), a triple agenda is proposed,
including documenting lessons learned, providing tailored support to countries, and reinforcing regional
preparedness and capacity to respond to emergencies.
The “Response to the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons learned to date from the WHO European Region”,
incorporating a consolidated feedback received through this web-consultation, will be presented to the
71st session of the Regional Committee for Europe in September 2021.
In order to participate to this WHO web-based consultation on the lessons learned during the COVID-
19 pandemic in the WHO European Region, I kindly invite you to provide the comments you may have
as soon as possible and no later than 9 July 2021, submitting one response per country based on a multi-
sectoral assessment of relevant national stakeholders. My team and myself remain at your disposal to
address any questions or clarifications you may have by writing to
[email protected].
UN City, Marmorvej 51 Tel.: +45 45 33 70 00 Email:
[email protected]
DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø Fax: +45 45 33 70 01 Website: http://www.euro.who.int
Denmark
I want to take this opportunity to once again express my gratitude for your continued support.
Sincerely yours,
Dr Dorit Nitzan
Regional Emergency Director
Encls:
- “Response to the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons learned to date from the WHO European Region”
Copy for information to:
Ms Triin Uusberg, Head, European and International Coordination Department, Ministry of Social Affairs,
Suur-Ameerika 1, 10129 Tallinn, Estonia
H.E. Ms Katrin Saarsalu-Layachi, Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary, Permanent Representative,
Permanent Mission of the Republic of Estonia to the United Nations Office and other international
organizations in Geneva, Chemin du Petit-Saconnex 28A, CH-1209 Genève, Switzerland
H.E. Mr William Mart Laanemäe, Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary, Embassy of the Republic of
Estonia, Frederiksgade 19, 4th floor, 1265 Copenhagen K, Denmark
Ms Kristina Köhler, Liaison Officer, WHO Country Office, Estonia, Paldiski Road 81, 10617 Tallinn, Estonia
–2–
Regional Committee for Europe EUR/RC 71/x 71st session Virtual session, 13 – 15 September 20 21 21 June 20 21 210693 Provisional agenda item x ORIGINAL: ENGLISH QUESTIONS FOR WEB-CONSULTATION “ Response to the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons learned to date from the WHO European Region ” You are kindly asked to provide your input, based on issues learned from your country’s perspective. Please, r eview the following draft document " Response to the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons learned to date from the WHO European Region " . We would highly appreciate your important comments and proposed changes to the text Before starting, could you please indicate the following information: Your country Your name, title and affiliation Questions: Would you suggest to change any of the issues mentioned? Can you please propose the changes you would like to see? Please, incorporate your suggested amendments in the body of the text, using “track changes”. Response to the COVID-19 pandemic: l essons learned to date from the WHO European Region The COVID-19 pandemic will be remembered for generations as an event that impacted significantly on human lives and livelihoods. Health systems were forced to adapt to the far-reaching needs of the people they serve . Health, society and the economy were shown to be inextricably linked . We were reminded that health is the foundation of a functioning society and that all other forms of human progress hinge on its resilience. As our collective health quickly became a global concern , values such as equity, solidarity and collaboration rose to the forefront. The concept that “no one is safe until everyone is safe” has been rooted in this response. Building on the independent reviews established by the WHO S ecretariat related to COVID-19 – which are led by the Review Committee on the Functioning of the International Health Regulations (2005) during the COVID-19 Response , the Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response, and the WHO Health Emergencies Programme Independent Oversight and Advisory Committee – this paper seeks to operationalize the lessons learned by European Member States , basing it on WHO’s European Programme of Work , 2020–2025 – “United Action for Better Health in Europe” (EPW). Under EPW c ore p riority 2 ( p rotecting against health emergencies) , a triple agenda (documenting lessons learned , providing tailored support to countries , and reinforcing regional preparedness and capacity to respond to emergencies) is proposed. The lessons learned that are presented in this document were developed in consultation with WHO Member States and partners to enhance approaches for improving national and community resilience against health emergencies and for safeguarding regional and global health security. This document is based on the idea that we are at risk from multiple hazards (the “ all- hazards approach”), and it is therefore impossible to predict with certainty which hazard will appear next and what its impacts will be. Resilience against emergencies is considered central to the U nited N ation s Sustainable Development Goals and is integrate d into each of the EPW flagship initiatives , all of which have been at the forefront during COVID-19: the Mental Health Coalition ; Empowerment through Digital Health ; the European Immunization Agenda 2030 ; and Healthier behaviours: incorporating behavioural and cultural insights. Future public health emergencies of international concern might not follow the same paths as the current one . V accines or therapeutics may not be available or effective . B ut comprehensive and holistic systems-based learning from the COVID-19 pandemic would allow Member States and WHO to better prepare the ir systems and the capacity of their societies to better absorb the shocks that future emergencies may bring . The Standing Committee of the Regional Committee for Europe is invited to provide feedback on th is working document to help shape the relevance of the lessons learned for Member States of the WHO European Region. Contents TOC \o "1-2" \h \z \u Purpose and development of this document: building resilience and readiness for the future PAGEREF _Toc74560291 \h 4 The human toll of the COVID-19 pandemic PAGEREF _Toc74560292 \h 5 Where we stand now: 10 lessons drawn from the COVID-19 pandemic so far PAGEREF _Toc74560293 \h 6 Framing the way forward: rebooting emergency preparedness and readiness PAGEREF _Toc74560294 \h 8 Conclusions PAGEREF _Toc74560295 \h 13 Purpose and development of this document: building resilience and readiness for the future This document outlines the lessons learned that will be incorporated in an updated version of the WHO European Region ’s Action Plan to Improve Public Health Preparedness and Response in the WHO European Region 2018–2023 , to be presented at the 72nd session of the WHO Regional Committee for Europe (RC 72 ) . The document incorporates the recommendations made by the global review committees and the lessons learned from the Member States of the WHO Europe an Region , obtained through meetings of the WHO Regional Director for Europe with h ealth ministries . I n addition, l essons learned from an online consultation with Member States to be held in June 2021 will be incorporated in the final version . The recommendations from the Pan-European Commission on Health and Sustainable Development and lessons learned from the intra-action and after-action reviews undertaken at country level a re included , as is the advice of experts, networks and WHO staff. This document is anchored in decisions of the governing bodies, including the global review committees, as well as those of previous r egional c ommittees , and is guid ed by the European Programme of Work, 2020–2025 ( EPW ) in the following ways : Guiding WHO/Europe’s overall work on emergencies is r esolution EUR/RC68/R7, the A ction P lan to I mprove P ublic H ealth P reparedness and R esponse in the WHO European Region , 2018–2023, adopted at RC68 in 2018. Evidence has been collected through reviews and commissions on the COVID-19 response. This includes global initiatives such as the Review Committee on the Functioning of the International Health Regulations (2005) during the COVID-19 Response , the Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response, and the WHO Health Emergencies Programme Independent Oversight and Advisory Committee, as well as regional initiatives. At the European level, the Pan-European Commission on Health and Sustainable Development was established to draw lessons from how different countries’ health systems have responded to the COVID-19 pandemic and to make recommendations on investments and reforms to improve the resilience of health and social care systems. The remainder of this document has been developed using the findings of these independent bodies, supplemented with data from several other sources: ( i ) lessons identified directly by Member States during policy - level round tables on COVID-19 and during nationally led intra-action reviews ; (ii) input from meetings of the Standing Committee of the Regional Committee for Europe ; (iii) a virtual consultation process involving all WHO European Member States; and (iv) review by an external technical advisory group. The lessons and identified pathways set out for WHO and for Member States will be used to update and upgrade WHO’s regional Action Plan to Improve Public Health Preparedness and Response in the WHO European Region to reduce the human toll of future pandemics. The human toll of the COVID-19 pandemic The pandemic has shown that preparedness pays. Countries in the Region were quick to repurpose their influenza pandemic preparedness and response platforms into core pillars of the COVID-19 response. The same was true for scientific collaborations , where WHO and partners leveraged existing networks early on , to research, develop and deploy new vaccines in record time. Operational partnerships that were established before the pandemic (e.g. the Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network , emergency medical teams , collaborating cent re s, and reference laboratories) brought expertise and know-how beyond borders and lines. Collaboration s at all levels of society and among the health workforce have been remarkable. P latforms borne out of s olidarity have been established for funds, vaccines, diagnostics and medicines. Nevertheless, in September 2019, the Global Preparedness Monitoring Board had warned that the world was not yet prepared for a fast-moving, virulent respiratory pathogen pandemic. Indeed, the COVID-19 pandemic has shown that health is interconnected with political, economic, and social and health systems and that all can deteriorate rapid ly . The SARS-CoV-2 virus has cut deeply into the fabric of our interconnectedness , to its own advantage, revealing the fragilities and vulnerabilities of our intertwined , complex social norms, values, systems and functions. It has strained health systems , as well as social safety and emergency management architecture , around the world . Once again, we have learned that health is at the centr e of development, as a determinant of individual and collective growth, social cohesion and resilience. Health’s central position in supporting the achievement of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals , with its seven accelerator themes , especially during times of crisis, has proven that stronger collaboration contributes to better health. Front line health and essential social services workers have worked tirelessly and risked their lives in responding to the need for surge capacities. Health systems have been faced with ethical dilemmas on who can receive what type of care. Peer-to-peer, community-to-community and country-to-country support have helped manage patient care. Our lives , with all their interlinkages and relationships , were severely disrupted as we were directed to stay physically apart to reduce infection . Billions of people were asked to stay at home; many lost their livelihoods and support networks. Children and young adults have been un able to continuously attend schools and universities, putting their well -being and future accomplishments at risk. The mental health consequences of these disruptions have been severe, and a longer-term impact is expected . The EPW M ental H ealth Coalition flagship initiative is timelier than ever. In some countries, the pandemic has revealed and exacerbated inequities and gaps that existed for people at the margins even before the virus arrived . The requirement to pay out of pocket for diagnostic s and care during pandemics harms those in need , and the most vulnerable groups , and puts humanity at risk . Such inequities d emonstrat e the importance of l eaving no one behind, as emphasi zed in the EPW. The pandemic has laid bare the struggle s public health systems undergo in gaining access to and sharing real-time data on infection prevalence, health system performance, health workforce capacities, public health and social measures, procurement and supply chains , and other critical health metrics. Data, analytics and forecasting are key to inform ing evidence-based decisions for impact in the immediate and longer terms. WHO’s COVID-19 Strategic Preparedness and Response Plan sets as its central goal to “end the COVID-19 pandemic and build resilience and readiness for the future” . It is time to take stock of the lessons learned so far , embrace new ways of thinking and act swiftly to improve resilience in all levels of societ y , for this and for upcoming health emergencies. Where we stand now: 10 lessons drawn from the COVID-19 pandemic so far As we begin to think about recovery and “building back better”, several key lessons to consider in moving forward have been identified . This list is not comprehensive and will continue to evolv e with the changing nature of the pandemic . Recognize that h ealth emergencies impact the whole of society , including its soci o economic systems. Investments in preparedness and in improving essential public health functions and primary and hospital services yield long-term dividends , directly saving lives and preventing human suffering, while protecting the economy and fostering trust in governments in times of vulnerability. Prioritize k nown capacity gaps. Existing international frameworks are a powerful operational backbone, yet many countries in the Region have not made the most of the m . The pandemic has highlighted the strengths of many aspects of the International Health Regulations ( IHR ) (2005) and r esolutions such as the Nagoya Protocol on Access to Genetic Resources and the Fair and Equitable Sharing of Benefits Arising from their Utilization to the Convention on Biological Diversity . It has validated the importance of preparedness efforts towards combating pandemic influenza by implementing lessons learned from previous outbreaks (e.g. Ebola, SARS, MERS - CoV , and Zika). However, there is more work to be done. As countries seek to equip themselves with tools to withstand health emergencies at all levels of society, we must address the gaps identified in the IHR (2005) and in existing frameworks and pursue a diversified portfolio of whole-of-government and whole-of-society preparedness and response. Ensure that response systems are functional long before emergencies strike . Emergency preparedness activities have proven to be critical for a swift, comprehensive response, but having functional response frameworks and systems prior to the pandemic enabled countries to achieve better organi z ed and coordinated action. I ndividual technical public health and IHR (2005) core capacities (laboratory, surveillance, etc . ) alone did not fully represent the needed emergency preparedness and readiness. To improve preparedness and response , IHR (2005) core capacities need to be fortified by capabilities and competencies at all levels of governance, by services and by communities. , , Transform scientific discoveries into accessible public health goods. The expedience and collaboration demonstrated by the global scientific community in isolating and sequencing SARS-CoV-2 within the first 10 days of 2020, and delivering a vaccine from bench to bedside within the subsequent 12 months , was unprecedented and exemplif ies the rapidly evolving breakthroughs emerging in biotechnology, genetics and epidemiology in particular, and in health care and medicine in general. Going for ward , further investment in early identification, diagnostics, medicines and vaccination technologies, and sharing know-how and ensuring access for all , are the necessary next steps in building on these historic achievements. Leverage health information for immediate and robust action. The role that health and social data collection, analyses and distribution can play in driving decision-making has been long underestimated , and such data have therefore been underutilized. Data sets rapidly shared across health care and civic institutions, both within domestic borders and beyond, enabled practical and responsible COVID-related policy - making. However, the true life-saving potential of leveraging troves of data has yet to be uncovered. B uilding the resilience of health systems to future pandemics requires a paradigm shift in how health data are sourced, governed, accessed, certified, protected and shared. Recognize the interdependence of health systems and emergency preparedness . Health systems must be placed at the centr e of national agendas, while emergency preparedness needs to be at the core of all health system s ’ functions . The argument that the IHR (2005) requirements be embedded into each of the health system functions is, looking through the COVID-19 lens, now a case in point. The resilience and preparedness of h ealth system s are necessary precondition s to building wider resilience against health emergencies, but neither is sufficient alone. In the future, to avoid crippling effects such as those that COVID -19 has had on our societies, this dual relationship must be reflected and implemented in national agendas. Anchor all actions in a trusted social contract. Equity, solidarity and responsiveness must be the basis of actions to improve health, social and educational services with financial protection . Thus, a national health architecture anchored in all levels of government must encourage participation, be sensitive to cultural norms and be responsive to the individual’s needs. Safeguarding such an intricate and interconnected health and social system requires strong governance structures, clear sets of national priorities, and plans for health emergency readiness that are included in all policies. Integrate public health services and universal health c overage . Countries with universal health coverage based on strong public health and primary health care services were more agile, adaptable and ready to deliver a comprehensive response to the pandemic . The experience of these countries can serve as a model for how to provid e continuous and quality dual-track (emergency-related and routine) services , help people avoid ou t of-pocket payments, repurpos e a digital health information system to implement basic response measures (e.g. testing, tracing, and isolating or quarantining), and integrat e core health program me s such as those on mental health into emergency management. Invest in health care infrastructure and workforce . Increased training for and material support to front line health workers must be provided alongside new mechanisms for activating required surge capacity. Additional workforce for emergencies, including volunteers and those from civil society organizations (CSOs) , should be trained in advance to support emerging needs in real time. Investing in the emergency and dual service health care workforce would allow for the continuity of all health and social services during emergencies. Prioritize resilience. Resilience is the ability of a system, community or society , when exposed to hazards , to resist, absorb, accommodate and recover in a timely and efficient manner, while retaining and restor ing its essential basic structures and functions . Resilient infrastructures can shield societies by making systems more robust, keeping communities more connected, and keeping people healthier. Emergencies provide opportunities for deep systemic reviews , followed by changes that are needed to build resilience. The COVID-19 pandemic is therefore an opportunity to switch from bouncing back to bouncing forward , and from just coping to anticipating and transforming. Only when societies are well prepared and ready will responses become timelier and more effective, and will the adverse human, economic and societal consequences of emergencies be significantly reduced. Framing the way forward: r ebooting e mergency p reparedness and r eadiness The basic steps to ensur ing emergency preparedness and resilience in societies include having the legal and financial mechanisms ready with a preset command – control – coordination (CCC) architecture that is rooted at all levels of governance, and integrated and coordinated health systems. Other critical components for ensuring emergency preparedness and response include health information, intelligence, surveillance and early warning systems; risk communication and community engagement; health and social service provision ; access to essential packages (public health services, primary care, hospitals, home care, and long-term institutional care); and relate to the areas of surge capacities; medicines, technology, supply chains, enhanced local production, and stockpiling; points of entry; expert teams and academic institutions; innovation, research and development; multisectoral collaboration ; One Health (zoonotic, environment, antimicrobial resistance , and food safety); c hemical, radiological , nuclear and explosive hazard s; laboratories; safe infrastructures and settings; and global solidar it y , with international support. Bringing these ingredients together in a manner that creates a system that is greater than the sum of its parts relies on the integration of two critical determinants of preparedness: broader governance capacities and capabilities that govern emergency response; and immediate accessibility of the surge capacities and resources (human, financial and material) that are needed for a comprehensive and quality response. Moving away from approaches that focus on technical core capacities alone is critical to understanding how well a country is prepared and ready to respond to the known and unknown hazards it may face. As preparedness needs to be rooted in the whole of society, work must start at the community level. Preparedness efforts for the very first responders mean listening to and engaging communities and civil society : Responding to the pandemic require s actions beyond responding to the virus. Insights into human behaviour and cultural norms have been harnessed in unprecedented ways to address the so-called infodemic , “COVID fatigue” and “COVID frustration”. S cientifically sound measures are only effective when communities are involved and listened to and when the measures are culturally and socially acceptable. Trust building cannot start with a crisis. Crises do not build trust; crises test trust. Trust building requires strategic and functional planning of long -term , steady and good governance measures with community engagement at all times , before, during and long after an emergency has ended. Crises can only be overcome with community engagement. Special attention needs to be given to the vulnerable and marginalized to ensure that their voice s are listened to, respectfully. During the pandemic, some groups have been overlooked, blamed and stigmatized. Basic core human values can serve as the compass for leaders, decision-makers and stakeholders. Engagement with different stakeholders allows decision-makers to understand and internalize various cultural norms , values, concerns, stance s and needs and to tailor actions accordingly . Making information accessible and inviting communities to participate in such decision-making processes would help in adapting actions in safe, accessible and inclusive ways. Gender is a key consideration for all actions. All assessments, planning and actions require disaggregated and/or stratified data on gender, age and other population groups. Such data would be needed, for example, for actions intended to prevent and respond to gender and child violence; ensure access to sexual and reproductive health within the essential package of health and social services; and shield and support health care workers – mainly women – in relation to their working conditions and work – home balance. Engaging with non- S tate actors and CSOs is key to involving communities. Accelerating investment in volunteering infrastructure, including through digital tools, supports the health and social sectors, as well as communities , and contributes to solidarity and unity. It can also support skill s development and employability in the post-COVID-19 era. It is necessary for volunteers to be trained, certified and active and to engag e with non-State actors and CSOs during peaceful times . In addition, p ublic – private partnerships should be encouraged. T ogetherness needs to be fostered through collaboration and partnerships with CSOs and the private sector, using the whole-of-society approach at all stages , from planning to monitoring and evaluation. Invest ing in a f it-for-purpose workforce, medical countermeasures, and safe, intelligent health facilities of tomorrow is crucial : F orecasting tools should be used in strategic planning for future scenarios, enabling the prioritiz ation of essential health services provision . The focus must remain on maintaining fully functional public health and primary health care services that are person and community centred and that continue across all other health and care services. It has been learned that to be ready for emergencies, medical countermeasures need to be in place and ready for activation. The systems that deploy medical countermeasures need to be designed for emergency response but also remain part of routine , day-to-day health service delivery , and should include the following : Hurdle-free access to diagnostics and care for all, including the marginalized and vulnerable . Safe, efficient and intelligent health care settings for all hazards (e.g. outbreaks, as well as natural and hu man - made threats ) . Safe and effective patient triage and referral, at all levels, while following the norms of physical distancing , as well as infection prevention and control protocols , depending on the health emergency . Strengthened public health services ( encompassing their functions, operations, workforce, resources and structures ) that are ready to marshal emergency preparedness and response, including for outbreak surveillance and response . Agile public health care , primary care, hospitals and laboratories that are equipped to handle extraordinary influxes of patients associated with all-hazards emergencies: A health workforce optimized through redistribution, repurposing and recruitment . Enhanced s urge capacity within a trained health and social care workforce that is ready to expand capacities to provide life-saving interventions and emergency and urgent care services while ensuring continued access to safe and quality essential health services for all (“dual-service provision”), using innovative and flexible delivery of services . W ell-regulated private health services incorporated to maximize the effectiveness and efficiency of the response. T echnical skills and knowledge built continuously through e-learning and other innovative platforms. S c alable emergency and critical care capacities (beds, medicine s , equipment and technology, supplies, and logistics), including provisions for step-up and step-down facilities . W ell-equipped and modern diversified laboratories that follow international principles of quality and biosafety, with experts trained in modern technology, and that are connected to patient data and surveillance system s. P opulation , personal and health care infection prevention and control measures . M echanisms for sending and receiving medical countermeasures and deploy ing health care to areas of acute need . Strengthened comprehensive health information and digital solutions that are people centred, lifelong, and community based and that are aligned , linked and integrated across all services (e.g. clinical management, laboratory, surveillance, investigations, and contact tracing). Expertise to analy s e and present the data to all is key for policy - making, risk communication and community engagement. The system s should be ready to adapt rapidly to demand challenges and should provide secure and ethical tools for remote patient care, surveillance, tracing and contacting . A well- resourced supply chain and operational support capability : U p-to-date stockpiles for at least three months to allow for essential health service provision, while responding to hazard-specific needs . M odernized procurement systems, supply chain mechanisms and quality control for uninterrupted health logistics supply, including through increased local production, ensuring the continued provision of essential services . I mprov ed distribution infrastructure for essential pharmaceutical , technology, personal protective equipment and other supplies , including for risk-specific interventions . I nvest ment in local industry for production of medical countermeasures, including personal protective equipment , vaccines and medicines. Models of care that listen, learn and adapt to changes in perceptions , knowledge and evidence : S trong risk communication and community engagement that is embedded in good governance . Research and development including in the areas of medicine, epidemiology, and social sciences, and the accelerated development of diagnostics, treatments and vaccines. I nnovative approaches to advance, share and assess research . Investing in identifying threats and harnessing information and intelligence for policy and prescient actions is important : Timely and accurate data are important for predicting the emergence of future pandemics, as well as for driving policy - and decision-making, risk communication , and community engagement, resulting in improved compliance with public health actions and measures. The national health information infrastructure should meet the highest ethical and security standards, protecting privacy, gender rights and human rights. Real-time, digitalized, comprehensive and appropriate use of information and data is vital to inform successful COVID-19 polic ies , decisions and measures. Countries with inclusive surveillance systems, including One Health, syndromic, sentinel and e arly w arning s ystems with integrated laboratory diagnostics , were ready to respond earlier. Such systems must be well resourced and coordinated by an expert workforce, with up to-date technology and finances. Some of the contested and disputed areas in the R egion can be seen as “blind spots” , as they are not fully integrated into the IHR (2005) . R esilience against health emergencies cannot be achieved without solutions that allow for access, training and provision of tools for data and information sharing in these areas . Financing mechanisms must be available throughout the emergency life cycl e : Funds are not only essential to the core public health actions associated with the response to health emergencies but, as demonstrated throughout this pandemic, are required to offset the losses incurred by communities and individuals if they are expected to adhere to the social measures put in place. Nowhere more clearly has this been see n than in the requirements for healthy persons potentially exposed to COVID 19 to quarantine for extended periods of time, often repeatedly and with immediate consequences for their livelihoods. Whil e the case for investment in preparedness has been made repeatedly, the case for investing in people during a response has not been made as forcefully. This lesson has immediate implications for the way we plan for emergencies, provide safety nets and incentivize participation in our responses. L eadership and governance must be enhanced : National programmes, policies, plans and legislation to support prevention, preparedness, response and recovery efforts: The pandemic calls for a harmonized approach to improve governance for multisectoral preparedness, including IHR (2005) implementation through whole-of-government and whole-of-society approaches. The development of national policies and action plans for health emergency preparedness and resilience that clearly define the relevant accountability framework and address roles, responsibilities, deliverables and timelines is key. When necessary, the revision of relevant legal and regulatory frameworks and the establishment of mechanisms to ensure coordination and sharing of information between sectors (e.g. food and agriculture, economy, finance, transport, tourism, education, defen c e, and health) , which is in fact already called for under the IHR (2005) , should take place. CCC architecture: The IHR (2005) call for the institutionalization of a whole-of-government structure that directs and coordinates action across sectors, enabling those sectors to respond to any type of emergency. Experience has indicated that countries with agile , “ready-to-act” CCC architecture rooted in evidence and tailored to communities’ needs are better able to provide timely and comprehensive responses. Such systems are driven by the availability of timely and high-quality data , and function irrespective of the national political organization ; they are also adaptable to the requirements of emergency response. The CCC architecture should lead all phases of the emergency management cycle , from prevention to planning and response to recovery. The r ole of public institutions includ es the capacity to adapt and learn; to align public services with citizen s’ needs; to govern resilient production systems; and to govern data and digital platforms . In line with the EPW on empowering health leadership , WHO /Europe can support cross - border , p an-European CCC coordination. Governance of data and digital technology use: A key lesson learned from the pandemic is that it is necessary to establish and update digital health platforms. Having well-articulated principles, standards and governance of data and digital technologies during a pandemic is vital to ensuring that trust is established in their use and , in turn, for the delivery of an effective and proportionate public health response. Accountability and oversight mechanisms need to be included as part of good governance , in addition to the monitoring and evaluation of the public health impact. The role of publicly owned digital platforms should be strengthened to ensure public trust in and security of public data. Conclusions Resilience against health emergencies requires applying the lessons described above . The changes should be buil t from the bottom up , and should be based on societal norms and values . A whole-of-government and whole-of-society approach should invest in stronger health systems . To achieve this resilience, adequate preparedness of the health sector, other systems and sectors, communities , and individuals is critical. In line with the EPW, WHO/Europe is committed to working with full accountability on improving policy, platforms, resources, tools, processes and actions to support Member States and CSOs in improving their resilience to health emergencies. Building on the lessons learned during the pandemic, the Regional Committee will be asked at RC71 to note this present document and approv e the development of a revised action plan, which will replac e the A ction P lan to I mprove P ublic H ealth P reparedness and R esponse in the WHO European Region , 2018–2023 . The new five -year a ction p lan and its r esolution will be presented at RC72 .
Saatja: EURO Regional Emergency Director's office <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 25.06.2021 14:49
Adressaat: Elen Ohov <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Triin Uusberg <
[email protected]>; SM Info <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; KÖHLER, Kristina <
[email protected]>
Teema: Web-based consultation on the Response to the COVID-19 pandemic:
lessons learned to date from the WHO European Region
Dear Ms Ohov,
Please find attached a correspondence from the Regional Emergency
Director for the WHO European Region related to the web-based
consultation on the Response to the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons learned to
date from the WHO European Region.
We kindly ask you to provide the comments you may have on this document
as soon as possible and no later than 9 July 2021, submitting one
response per country based on a multi-sectoral assessment of relevant
national stakeholders. Further information is included in the attached
letter.
Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us at
this generic email:
Yours sincerely,WHO Health Emergencies Programme Secretariat