Saatja: Kristel Tänover <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 17.01.2022 18:41
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Letter to the Commission
From: ZLOGAR Katarina <
[email protected]> Sent: Monday,
January 17, 2022 6:02 PMTo: Kristel Tänover
<
[email protected]>Cc: HIESINGER Stefanie
<
[email protected]>; GLOWACKA Barbara
<
[email protected]>; Timo Tatar
<
[email protected]>Subject: RE: Letter to the Commission
Dear Ms. Tanover,
Thank you kindly for transmitting the letter from Mr. Taavi Aas, Estonian
Minister of Economic Affairs and Infrastructure to Executive Vice-
President Frans Timmermans and Commissioner Kadri Simson. Please find
attached their joint reply with the kind request to transmit it to the
Minister at your earliest convenience.
Thank you in advance,
Katarina ZLOGAR
Assistant
Cabinet of Executive Vice-President Frans TIMMERMANS
European Green Deal
European CommissionBERL 12/253 (B-1049 BXL)
+32 229 97760
Visit Frans Timmermans' personal , and page!
From: Kristel Tänover <> Sent: Wednesday, September 15, 2021 11:25
AMTo: TIMMERMANS Frans (CAB-TIMMERMANS) <>; SIMSON Kadri (CAB-
SIMSON) <>Cc: Timo Tatar <>Subject: Letter to the Commission
Dear Mr Timmermans, Ms Simson,
Please find attached letter form the Estonian Minister of Economic
Affairs and Infrastructure Mr Taavi Aas.
Best Regards,
Kristel Tänover
Assistant
+372 625 6311
| Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn 10122
Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
Frans Timmermans Kadri Simson
Executive Vice-President of the European Commission Member of the European Commission
Brussels, 17/01/2022
Thank you for your letter of 15 September 2021 in which you express your concerns about the
trends in energy prices and the increased carbon price under the EU Emissions Trading System
(ETS). Please accept our apologies for the delay in replying to you.
Let us start by thanking you for your steadfast support of the European Green Deal and by
congratulating Estonia on achieving its climate ambitions for 2020. The continued development of
renewables, including offshore wind in the Baltic Sea, will be of key importance in decarbonising the
Estonian economy.
As you rightly note, the ETS provides a crucial incentive to businesses and consumers to reduce
their emissions. This is not just theory: installations under the ETS have reduced their emissions by
almost 43% between 2005 and 2020.
You comment that turbulent times in global energy markets combined with economic recovery have
revealed shortcomings in the ETS. The Commission shares your concerns about the impacts of
energy prices on households and businesses and aims, as a matter of priority, to help mitigate
these impacts. However, in order to do so, it is important to clearly identify the causes of the energy
price rise and to put in perspective the relative impact of the carbon price compared to that of other
commodities.
./..
The energy price rise is first and foremost the result of the increase in global fossil fuel prices.
The EU’s vulnerability to such global trends is a stark reminder of the need to implement the
European Green Deal and reduce our dependence on expensive, foreign fossil fuels.
Mr Taavi Aas
Minister of Economic Affairs and Infrastructure
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
Republic of Estonia
E-mail:
[email protected]
The increased carbon price under the ETS is not a major contributor to increased costs of electricity
for consumers. The impact of the gas price increase is nine times higher than that of the carbon
price increase.
Furthermore, there is consensus that the increased carbon price signal primarily reflects the
EU’s agreed increase in ambition which resulted in the ‘at least 55%’ 2030-target. Increased
economic activity has further pushed up emissions and therefore demand for allowances. Moreover,
the unprecedented surge in the prices of gas also has a strong impact on the carbon price by
making coal relatively more profitable to use in power production, thus increasing emissions and the
demand for allowances.
A meaningful carbon price signal remains indispensable to achieve our commonly agreed
55% reduction goal for 2030. Nevertheless, the Commission requested the European Securities and
Markets Authority (ESMA) to investigate the EU carbon market. Based on the preliminary report
adopted on 18 November 2021, ESMA has not found any proof of abuse in the EU carbon market
and a more in-depth analysis will follow in 2022.
At the same time, the Commission takes action to address the increasing energy prices. We have
published a Communication on the situation, containing a toolbox with measures that both Member
States and the Commission can and will take to better protect European businesses and citizens
against the impacts of high energy prices. The work now focuses on assisting Member States to
implement the toolbox measures.
Yours ,
Frans Timmermans Kadri Simson