WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION ORGANISATION MONDIALE DE LA SANTÉ
REGIONAL OFFICE FOR EUROPE BUREAU RÉGIONAL DE L'EUROPE
WELTGESUNDHEITSORGANISATION ВСЕМИРНАЯ ОРГАНИЗАЦИЯ ЗДРАВООХРАНЕНИЯ
REGIONALBÜRO FÜR EUROPA ЕВРОПЕЙСКОЕ РЕГИОНАЛЬНОЕ БЮРО
WHO Regional Office for Europe Country /2
Presence and Work Review: Member
State Virtual Consultations
3 May 2021
Original: English
Discussion paper
1. Purpose of the discussion paper
WHO/Europe’s commitment to increasing country focus and impact stands at the core of the European
Programme of Work 2020-2025 – United Action for Better Health in Europe (EPW). The EPW sets an
unprecedented level of ambition when it comes to putting the needs of Member States at the centre,
partnering with Member States and other stakeholders to leave no one behind and to rise to the
challenge of what citizens expect them to do.
This review is at the heart of the EPW and will help to deliver its third “how” – creating a fit-for-purpose
WHO/Europe that is aligned with its core priorities and focused on country needs. The review is aimed
at answering the overarching question:
How can WHO/Europe enhance its presence and work in countries to increase its relevance for all the
Member States of the WHO European Region?
This document will inform the review process, providing those involved with information on the
rationale and approach, and presenting a number of key questions for readers to reflect on. It is a living
document, with iterations being informed by engagements, consultations and other review activities.
Progress of the review will be reported to Member States at the 71st session of the Regional Committee
for Europe (RC71) in September 2021, with the objective of completion of the exercise by the 72nd
session of the Regional Committee in 2022.
2. Background – gaining a new perspective on country presence
As a Member State organization, WHO/Europe is committed to serve all 53 countries in the European
Region. Its impact and relevance hinges on its ability to respond to every country’s specific needs, and to
share the experience and learning of each for the benefit of all. For the purpose of this review, we are
looking at presence and work in countries with a broad perspective and using the opportunity together
to rethink the ways WHO/Europe works in and for countries for enhanced impact.
The global health and economic crisis caused by COVID-19 has altered citizens’ and government’s
recognition and expectations of health authorities and WHO. It has also put countries across the Region
on an equal footing – all have had to learn; all have lessons to share. This presents a unique and timely
opportunity for us to step back together and, through structured dialogue, create a strategic view to
enhance how WHO/Europe works for all Member States to leave no one behind.
Discussion paper
page 2
The health priorities and policy challenges faced by Member States and set out in the EPW are complex,
cross sectors and boundaries, and have a range of stakeholders and perspectives. These are set in
operating conditions that are often volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous.
Operating effectively under such conditions requires a strategic approach that is united and agile. These
principles are helping guide this review process, to ensure that Member States, partner organizations,
WHO staff and other key stakeholders gain a shared understanding of the needs dictated by the context
and collaborate to propose the best ways by which WHO/Europe can support countries.
The most appropriate form of WHO/Europe’s presence, function and work will be shaped by a mix of
modalities matched to the Member State’s needs and expectations. Some of these modalities will
already be employed in the Region, some will be innovative and developed through this review.
The Standing Committee of the Regional Committee for Europe (SCRC) subgroup on WHO/Europe’s
work at country level has guided the development of an iterative review process of co-creation,
including a systematic assessment of all countries’ expectations of WHO/Europe, an exploration of
existing and new modalities of WHO support to countries, and an assessment of the sustainability of
WHO/Europe’s country engagement.
Advisory groups for the review, including the SCRC subgroup, a WHO focus group and a stakeholder
focus group, have worked with the review’s core team to agree the approach and organise the process.
The review is now entering an exploration and innovation phase, drawing on all 53 Member States and
key stakeholders to identify the concepts and ideas that will enable the right ways forward.
Key questions and considerations relating to the background to the review
1. What do Member States expect from this country presence and work review and what would a good
outcome look like?
2. How can we best learn from failures and successes from WHO/Europe’s presence in and work with
countries?
3. How do we improve the culture of review and improvement of WHO/Europe’s presence and work in
countries in a context of increasing complexities, uncertainties and volatility?
3. Country-level functions of WHO/Europe
The 13th General Programme of Work (GPW13) points to four core country level functions of WHO:
▪ Policy Dialogue – to support ethical and evidence-based policy options for health and development;
▪ Strategic support – to develop national health and development strategies, norms and standards;
▪ Technical assistance – to support programme implementation, and institution or capacity building;
▪ Service delivery – to fill critical gaps in service provision in the context of emergencies.
Typical activities and requests to fulfil these functions include convening and participating in
partnerships, stimulating national policy and research activities, and supporting the monitoring of health
and assessment of need in the population.
As well as these more traditional functions of direct support, WHO’s evolving role as a convener and
facilitator which harvests and disseminates expertise and experience from Member States to support
regional and global health development, is becoming ever more important.
The reach of WHO across sectors is also growing. With a recognition of the broad relevance of health
and its synergies across the SDGs, WHO is seen as a key partner for development in a cross-sectoral, all-
of-society and whole-of-government approach. This has been further reinforced by COVID-19, as the
world has witnessed the breadth of impact a public health emergency can have.
Discussion paper
page 3
COVID-19 has presented all countries with the need for intersectoral and international collaboration,
and learning from the experience of others. Every country has experienced the challenges and pressures
of public health decision making in a context of uncertainty; and the close interdependence of public
health, economy and social fabrics.
During the pandemic, WHO/Europe has strived to be a close partner to all Member States in the Region
and to adapt in an agile manner to the dynamic needs in countries. These experiences and changing
relationships across the Region will have affected the expectations of WHO/Europe for the long-term.
Key questions and considerations relating to country-level functions
1. How have Member States’ expectations of WHO’s role and functions changed through the COVID-19
pandemic, and which are the most critical and unique to WHO?
2. What should WHO do differently, do more of or do less of, to improve its collaboration with and
work in countries?
4. Different modalities in and ways of working with countries
Currently, WHO/Europe operates a hybrid model, with 30 country offices where technical assistance,
strategic support and policy dialogue are backstopped by the Regional Office, Copenhagen; and 23
countries without a permanent physical presence, where these functions are provided directly to the
country from the Regional Office, including Geographically Dispersed Offices (GDOs). In both cases,
backstopping by WHO Headquarters, Geneva is core to the three-level operating model.
The nature of WHO’s work at the country level can take many forms. Together these can be considered
along a spectrum, from informal interactions between the Regional Office and Member State, to a
permanent presence through a WHO Country Office and Representative.
These forms are not necessarily mutually exclusive nor pre-determined to country “types”. In practice,
multiple forms often co-exist in a country to enable WHO to deliver its expected functions and respond
to the dynamic nature of health and policy.
On this spectrum, the existing common modalities through which WHO/Europe functions include:
▪ WHO Country Offices, ranging from more than 50 staff and a WHO Representative, to nationally
recruited Liaison Officers with support staff;
▪ Strategic Desk Officers in the Regional Office, with a liaison function for National Counterparts in
countries without country offices, or as a backup to Country Offices;
▪ Support between groups of countries through technical hubs – a modality used successfully by the
WHO Emergency Programme;
▪ Targeted outreach through short-term missions to countries (via a virtual or physical presence) by
WHO Headquarters, the Regional Office and its GDOs;
▪ Networks of countries and other partners, such as the Small Countries Initiative, SEEHN and Regions
for Health;
▪ Outreach to countries through hosted partnerships (such as the European Observatory on Health
Systems and Policies) and WHO Collaborating Centres;
▪ Provision of support by partners through technical assistance networks, such as GOARN and ECDC;
▪ Participation of country experts and temporary advisors in sub-regional, regional and global
engagements with Member States, to address specific public health issues arising.
In response to a fundamentally changing health and development context and the operating
environment, a variety of new forms of presence and work in countries could be developed, including
the establishment of more flexible, time limited country response teams; posting WHO staff in
countries, in other UN agencies, organizations and ministries; and closer links between WHO staff and
the Ministry of Health for a country without a Country Office.
Discussion paper
page 4
To further strengthen the modalities of collaboration between WHO/Europe and Member States, our
joint approach can draw on the principles that will help to create the united action set out in the EPW:
creating a shared understanding and sense of purpose based on open dialogue involving multiple
stakeholders; building trust between partners; fostering ownership, responsibility and leadership; and
being ready to improve through ongoing iteration and learning.
Key questions and considerations relating to ways of working in countries
1. Which modalities or approaches to collaboration are particularly useful and which are less useful,
and why?
2. What are the examples of innovative modalities that WHO/Europe could consider (including
modalities that are complementary or an alternative to permanent country presence)?
5. Finding the optimal match of functions and modalities to setting
The varied and evolving scope of functions and more flexible approaches to collaboration has significant
implications both for WHO’s potential value and for its ways of working in and with countries.
There should be no “set menu” pre-determined to suit certain “types” of countries. Instead, a more
sophisticated presentation of WHO/Europe’s function, scope and value that can be adapted to suit the
nuanced needs and expectations of each Member State, and that accounts for the complex operating
environment, will help optimise the impact WHO/Europe has on the health of a country and the Region.
At the individual country level, WHO’s strategic collaboration is agreed through Biennial Cooperation
Agreements (BCA), which outline the shared priorities and expected WHO operational activities in a
country for a two-year period; Country Cooperation Strategies (CCS), which outline the agreed strategic
directions for collaboration for a period of around four to six years; and Basic Agreements, which
regulate WHO presence in a Member State with a Country Office.
Currently, WHO/Europe has a BCA with 23 countries (focusing these mostly on Member States with a
Country Office), a CCS with 8 countries (focusing these mostly on Member States without a Country
Office) and Basic Agreements in all countries with a Country Office.
Reviewing these Agreements and other governance processes which have the purpose of creating a
joint understanding for WHO’s presence and work in countries, will need to be incorporated into the
overall review process to help understand and facilitate change.
Key questions and considerations relating to matching functions and modalities to setting
1. Which modalities of presence and ways of working in countries are best suited to meet which
functions and expectations?
2. How do we jointly determine the most appropriate mix of presence and ways of working in a given
country?
3. How can we track and demonstrate the impact of matching modalities and functions on health for
our populations?
6. Taking the next steps along the country presence review
As the review process enters a phase of innovation and exploration, the focus is shifting to gaining an in-
depth understanding of what WHO’s presence and work in countries means to Member States and key
stakeholders, and how we can jointly begin to improve impact.
Discussions with Member States and key stakeholders at the Regional level will be complemented with
in-depth discussion in a number of countries. From this consultation and co-creation, the ideas and
suggestions being generated will be presented to Member States at RC71.
Saatja: euro-presence-review <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 07.05.2021 09:44
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; Elen Ohov <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Triin Uusberg <
[email protected]>; SM Info <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; KÖHLER, Kristina <
[email protected]>
Teema: EST: Invitation to the WHO National Counterpart and a representative from the
Permanent Mission in Geneva (with Country Presence)
Manused: image001.jpg; EURO County Presence Review Discussion_iteration for MS cons
210502 Eng.pdf; EURO County Presence Review Letter for NC PM_Eng.pdf
Please see the attached correspondence sent from the World Health Organization, Regional Office for
Europe. One or more attachments may be included.
Country Support, Emergency Preparedness and Response
World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe
UN CITY, Marmorvej 51, DK-2100 Copenhagen, Denmark
Phone +45 4533 6719
European Region web site: http://www.euro.who.int/en/home
Global web site: http://www.who.int/en/
Tähelepanu! Tegemist on välisvõrgust saabunud kirjaga.
Tundmatu saatja korral palume linke ja faile mitte avada.