Questionnaire concerning a framework
for quality apprenticeships
At its 334th Session (October–November 2018), the ILO Governing Body decided
to place on the agenda of the 110th Session of the International Labour Conference (2021)
an item related to apprenticeships (standard-setting). 1
The Governing Body noted a regulatory gap in relation to the topic of
apprenticeships as a result of the juridical replacement of a range of ILO instruments,
including the Apprenticeship Recommendation, 1939 (No. 60), and the Vocational
Training Recommendation, 1962 (No. 117), which has not been addressed in later
Recommendations. Furthermore, since the onset of the 2008 global economic and
financial crisis, and more recently in public debates on the future of work, apprenticeships
have become increasingly important for facilitating school-to-work transitions and
improving the quality of training systems and their relevance to labour market needs. A
new standard on apprenticeships would provide a comprehensive normative framework
with respect to the design and implementation of apprenticeship systems.
The purpose of this questionnaire is to request the views of member States on the
scope and content of the possible future instrument or instruments, after consultation with
the most representative organizations of employers and workers. Replies received should
enable the International Labour Office to prepare a report for the Conference. Replies
should reach the Office by 30 April 2020. Respondents are encouraged, where possible,
to complete the questionnaire in electronic format and to submit their replies electronically
to the following email address:
[email protected]. Respondents may also submit
their replies in hard copy to the Skills and Employability Branch, Employment Policy
Department, International Labour Office, Route des Morillons 4, 1202 Geneva,
Switzerland.
1 GB.334/PV, para. 42(b).
ILC.110/IV/1 1
A framework for quality apprenticeships
I. Form of the international instrument
or instruments
1. Should the International Labour Conference adopt an instrument or instruments
concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
There is already a Council Recommendation on the European Framework for quality
and effective apprenticeship,
2. If so, should the instrument or instruments take the form of:
(a) a Convention?
☐
(b) a Recommendation?
☒
(c) a Convention supplemented by a Recommendation, as two separate
instruments, or as a single instrument comprising binding and non-binding
provisions?
☐
Comments:
As apprenticeship is national competence, it could be a recommendation.
II. Preamble
3. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments note that global youth
unemployment rates continue to be high and that rapid transformations in the world
of work are resulting in skills mismatches, requiring people of all ages to reskill and
upskill continuously to access and remain in employment?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
2 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
4. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments recognize that apprenticeships
vary widely in different contexts and face significant challenges in many countries,
perpetuating gender inequality, offering low-quality training and inadequate
protection to apprentices, and deterring participation of enterprises, in particular
small and medium-sized enterprises?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
The apprenticeships may vary from country to country, but we do not have
knowledge of the scale of the problems in other countries.
5. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments acknowledge that quality
apprenticeships can constitute effective and efficient responses to current challenges
and provide lifelong learning opportunities to enhance productivity, resilience,
transitions and employability and meet current and future labour market needs?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Yes, when apprenticeships offer curricula and training of different lengths that meet
the needs of both learners and employers.
6. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments underline that an effective and
successful framework for quality apprenticeships requires apprenticeships to be well
regulated, sufficiently funded, socially inclusive and free from discrimination,
provides adequate remuneration and social protection coverage, recognizes
qualifications and enhances employment outcomes?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
7. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments recognize the particular
relevance of the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work,
1998, and the ILO Centenary Declaration for the Future of Work, 2019, for the
promotion of quality apprenticeships and the effective protection of all apprentices
and trainees, particularly in the light of the profound transformations in the world
of work?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
ILC.109/IV/1 3
A framework for quality apprenticeships
4 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
8. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments recall the provisions of other
relevant ILO instruments, particularly the Employment Policy Convention (No. 122)
and Recommendation (No. 122), 1964, the Human Resources Development
Convention, 1975 (No. 142), the Employment Policy (Supplementary Provisions)
Recommendation, 1984 (No. 169), and the Human Resources Development
Recommendation, 2004 (No. 195)?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Don´t not have a position
III. Definitions and scope
9. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “apprenticeship”?
If so, should the term “apprenticeship” be defined as any form of education and
training, which is governed by an apprenticeship agreement, and enables a person
(the “apprentice”) to acquire the competencies required to work in an occupation
through structured training consisting of on-the-job learning and supplemented by
off-the-job learning and leading to a recognized qualification?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Apprenticeships are defined differently in different countries. One option is to define
practical learning by proportion.
10. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “enterprise”?
If so, should the term “enterprise” be defined as a business, undertaking, economic
unit or organization, whether public or private?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
11. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “intermediary”?
If so, should the term “intermediary” mean an individual or an entity, other than the
host enterprise or educational institution, which assists in the provision,
coordination or support of an apprenticeship?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Different countries have different apprenticeship systems, not everyone has an
intermediary.
ILC.109/IV/1 5
A framework for quality apprenticeships
12. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “recognition of prior
learning”?
If so, should the term “recognition of prior learning” be defined as a process of
identifying, documenting, assessing and certifying a person’s competencies,
acquired through formal, non-formal or informal learning, based on established
qualification standards?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
13. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “traineeship”?
If so, should the term “traineeship”, which includes internship, be defined as any
form of on-the-job learning, which enables a person (the “trainee”) to acquire work
experience with a view to enhancing their employability?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
14. Should any other terms be defined by the instrument or instruments? If so, please
specify.
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
15. Should the instrument or instruments apply to all apprenticeships and traineeships
in all enterprises and sectors of economic activity?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
6 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
16. Should the instrument, if it takes the form of a Convention, provide that Members
could, after consulting with the most representative organizations of employers and
workers, limit its scope of application where special problems of a substantial nature
arise?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
IV. Regulatory framework for quality
apprenticeships
17. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should establish
regulatory frameworks for quality apprenticeships through social dialogue and that
the social partners should be involved in the design, implementation, monitoring and
evaluation of quality apprenticeship programmes?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Apprenticeship and curriculum development are structured and regulated differently
in different countries.
18. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should establish or
designate one or more authorities to regulate apprenticeships and that the social
partners should be represented in these bodies?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Apprenticeship and curriculum development are structured and regulated differently
in different countries. This should be decided nationally.
19. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should ensure that the
competent regulatory authorities have clearly defined responsibilities and work in
close cooperation with other authorities or institutions responsible for regulating or
delivering education and training, labour inspection, social protection, occupational
safety and health, and public and private employment services?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This should be decided nationally.
ILC.109/IV/1 7
A framework for quality apprenticeships
20. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should adopt a process
for recognizing an occupation as being suitable for quality apprenticeships, taking
into account:
(a) the competencies needed to work in that occupation?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Depends on labour market demand and vocational training curricula.
(b) the appropriateness of an apprenticeship as a means of acquiring such
competencies?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) the duration of the apprenticeship required to acquire such competencies?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
The most flexible model should be maintained/achieved to allow the creation of
curricula of different lengths to meet the needs of the labour market. Moreover,
the apprentice's previous knowledge and skills must be taken into account.
(d) the current and future demand for skills and employment potential in that
occupation?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) any other factors? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
21. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should establish
occupation-specific standards for quality apprenticeships, which provide, among
others things, for:
(a) the minimum age for admission?
☐ Yes ☒ No
8 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) the educational qualifications or prior learning needed for admission?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) the ratio of apprentices to workers in the workplace?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) the minimum and maximum duration of the apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
The duration of the apprenticeships study depends on national curricula.
(e) the extent to which the normal duration of the apprenticeship could be reduced
on the basis of any prior learning or progress made during the apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) learning outcomes and curricula?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) the ratio of off-the-job learning to on-the-job learning?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(h) the conditions under which apprentices should be released from on-the-job
learning to undertake off-the-job learning?
☐ Yes ☒ No
ILC.109/IV/1 9
A framework for quality apprenticeships
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(i) vocational guidance and career counselling?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(j) the mentoring and supervision of apprentices?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(k) the procedures for assessing and certifying the competencies acquired?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(l) the qualification(s) acquired on successful completion of the apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(m) any other elements? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
22. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members may establish standards
for quality apprenticeships through national laws and regulations, collective
agreements, decisions of competent regulatory bodies or in any other manner
consistent with national practice?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
10 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
23. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
ensure that there is a fair and transparent process for transferring an apprentice
from one enterprise to another when this is considered necessary or desirable for
the completion of the apprentice’s training?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Exchange of forms of study should also be involved. For example, school-based
learning may be more appropriate for a student.
24. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take appropriate
measures to ensure that apprentices:
(a) are adequately remunerated?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
(b) are not required to work hours that exceed specified limits?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
The conditions of employment, including in the traineeship agreement, are regulated
nationally .
(c) are entitled to holidays with pay?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
The conditions of employment are regulated at the national level. Depends on who
and on what basis pays the renumeration
(d) are entitled to paid leave for absence due to illness or accident?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
The conditions of working are regulated at the national level. Depends on who and
on what basis pays the renumeration
(e) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of discrimination and violence and harassment?
☒ Yes ☐ No
ILC.109/IV/1 11
A framework for quality apprenticeships
Comments:
Equal treatment is elementary, it should not be necessary to include such points..
(f) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of occupational safety and health?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Equal treatment is elementary, it should not be necessary to include such points.
(g) are entitled to compensation for work-related injuries?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(h) are eligible for any other benefits? If so, please specify.
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Paid study leave to pass exams.
25. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should prescribe
conditions under which:
(a) enterprises may offer apprenticeships?
☐ Yes ☒ No
(b) educational and training institutions may provide off-the-job training?
☐ Yes ☒ No
(c) intermediaries may assist in the provision, coordination or support of
apprenticeships?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
26. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
continuously develop and strengthen the capacity of government agencies and the
social partners to respond to challenges affecting quality apprenticeships, such as
technological changes and the emergence of new forms of work arrangements?
☐ Yes ☒ No
12 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
27. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
ensure that apprenticeship systems and programmes are regularly monitored and
evaluated?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
V. Apprenticeship agreement
28. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should ensure that all
apprenticeships are governed by a written agreement which is concluded between
an apprentice and an enterprise or an intermediary, and which, if so permitted by
national laws and regulations, may also be signed by a third party, such as an
educational or training institution?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
29. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should ensure that an
apprenticeship agreement:
(a) clearly identifies the parties’ respective roles, rights and obligations, with
reference to the relevant occupation-specific standards?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) contains provisions governing matters such as apprenticeship duration,
remuneration, working hours, leave entitlements, occupational safety and
health, social security, dispute resolution and the termination of the
apprenticeship agreement?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) is registered under conditions established by the competent authority?
ILC.109/IV/1 13
A framework for quality apprenticeships
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) is signed on the apprentice’s behalf by a parent, guardian or legal
representative, where the apprentice is a minor, as may be required by national
laws and regulations?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) contains any other elements? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
30. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should develop a model
apprenticeship agreement to facilitate consistency, uniformity and compliance?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This should be a national competence to decide together with the social partners.
Minimum requirements are sufficient.
VI. Equality and diversity in quality
apprenticeships
31. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
promote gender equality in apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
32. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
promote equality, diversity and social inclusion in apprenticeships, special account
being taken of the situation and needs of:
(a) persons with disabilities?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
14 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
Double-click to type comments
(b) persons in the informal economy?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) older persons?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) long-term unemployed persons?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) persons belonging to disadvantaged minorities?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) migrants, refugees, internally and forcibly displaced persons, and other
persons in vulnerable situations?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) any other persons? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
ILC.109/IV/1 15
A framework for quality apprenticeships
33. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
promote access to formal education and training, including quality apprenticeships,
especially for persons in the informal economy, through recognition of prior
learning?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
VII. Promotion of quality apprenticeships
and international cooperation
34. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
create an enabling environment for promoting quality apprenticeships, including by:
(a) developing and implementing strategies, setting national goals and allocating
adequate resources for quality apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) mainstreaming quality apprenticeships in national development strategies and
in employment, education and lifelong learning policies?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) providing incentives, such as cost-sharing, tax exemptions or subsidies for
social security contributions, to enterprises, especially small and medium-sized
enterprises?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) encouraging intermediaries, including through financial support, to
participate in the provision, coordination and support of apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
16 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
(e) undertaking awareness-raising activities and promotional campaigns at
regular intervals to improve the image and attractiveness of apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) establishing pre-apprenticeship programmes?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Can be decided nationally, f.e. linked to the pre-vocational selection year pilote
programme.
(g) facilitating access to further vocational and higher education opportunities for
apprentices?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(h) using new technologies and innovative methods to improve effectiveness and
efficiency in delivering and managing quality apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(i) adopting any other measures? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
35. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
enhance international cooperation and exchange of good practices, in all aspects of
quality apprenticeships, including through offering expanded learning opportunities
to apprentices and recognizing competencies acquired through apprenticeship
programmes or prior learning?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
National decision
ILC.109/IV/1 17
A framework for quality apprenticeships
36. Should the instrument or instruments provide that, with a view to promoting quality
apprenticeships in the informal economy, Members should:
(a) strengthen the capacity of micro and small economic units by facilitating
access to business development and financial services, improving occupational
safety and health conditions, and enhancing the technical, pedagogical and
entrepreneurial competencies of master craftspersons?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
National decision
(b) ensure that apprentices have access to off-the-job learning and may
complement their on-the-job learning through intermediaries or in other
enterprises?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Regulated
(c) strengthen the capacity of associations of micro and small economic units,
including through financial support, to perform the role of regulators and
quality assurance bodies?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
National decision
VIII. Traineeships
37. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures,
in accordance with national laws and regulations, to ensure that trainees:
(a) have a written traineeship agreement concluded between themselves and a host
enterprise?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) are adequately remunerated?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
18 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
Regulated nationally. Traineeships are part of the study provided for in the
curriculum. The duration of the traineeship is short, unlike apprenticeships, and
its remuneration is not obligatory. Adding constraints to employers reduces the
supply of traineeships and thus the quality of training.
(c) are not required to work hours that exceed specified limits?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Regulated.
(d) are entitled to holidays with pay?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Regulated nationally. Traineeships are part of the study provided for in the
curriculum. The duration of the traineeship is short, unlike apprenticeships, and
its remuneration is not obligatory. Adding constraints to employers reduces the
supply of traineeships and thus the quality of training.
(e) are entitled to paid leave of absence for illness or accident?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Regulated nationally. Traineeships are part of the study provided for in the
curriculum. The duration of the traineeship is short, unlike apprenticeships, and
its remuneration is not obligatory. Adding constraints to employers reduces the
supply of traineeships and thus the quality of training.
(f) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of discrimination and violence and harassment?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of occupational safety and health?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
ILC.109/IV/1 19
A framework for quality apprenticeships
(h) are entitled to compensation for work-related injuries?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Regulated nationally. Students have health insurance, traineeships are part of the
study.
(i) are eligible for any other benefits? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
20 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework
for quality apprenticeships
At its 334th Session (October–November 2018), the ILO Governing Body decided
to place on the agenda of the 110th Session of the International Labour Conference (2021)
an item related to apprenticeships (standard-setting). 1
The Governing Body noted a regulatory gap in relation to the topic of
apprenticeships as a result of the juridical replacement of a range of ILO instruments,
including the Apprenticeship Recommendation, 1939 (No. 60), and the Vocational
Training Recommendation, 1962 (No. 117), which has not been addressed in later
Recommendations. Furthermore, since the onset of the 2008 global economic and
financial crisis, and more recently in public debates on the future of work, apprenticeships
have become increasingly important for facilitating school-to-work transitions and
improving the quality of training systems and their relevance to labour market needs. A
new standard on apprenticeships would provide a comprehensive normative framework
with respect to the design and implementation of apprenticeship systems.
The purpose of this questionnaire is to request the views of member States on the
scope and content of the possible future instrument or instruments, after consultation with
the most representative organizations of employers and workers. Replies received should
enable the International Labour Office to prepare a report for the Conference. Replies
should reach the Office by 30 April 2020. Respondents are encouraged, where possible,
to complete the questionnaire in electronic format and to submit their replies electronically
to the following email address:
[email protected]. Respondents may also submit
their replies in hard copy to the Skills and Employability Branch, Employment Policy
Department, International Labour Office, Route des Morillons 4, 1202 Geneva,
Switzerland.
1 GB.334/PV, para. 42(b).
ILC.110/IV/1 1
A framework for quality apprenticeships
I. Form of the international instrument
or instruments
1. Should the International Labour Conference adopt an instrument or instruments
concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
2. If so, should the instrument or instruments take the form of:
(a) a Convention?
☐
(b) a Recommendation?
☒
(c) a Convention supplemented by a Recommendation, as two separate
instruments, or as a single instrument comprising binding and non-binding
provisions?
☐
Comments:
As apprenticeship is national competence, it could be a recommendation.
II. Preamble
3. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments note that global youth
unemployment rates continue to be high and that rapid transformations in the world
of work are resulting in skills mismatches, requiring people of all ages to reskill and
upskill continuously to access and remain in employment?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Preamble should mention green and digital transition of the labour market and the necessity to
ensure that all young people have access to quality, inclusive and fair apprenticeship in companies
which can help them with facilitating to be employed. Upskilling and reskilling links more to
employee training than to apprenticeship which should ensure access to the profession and
qualifications.
2 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
ILC.109/IV/1 3
A framework for quality apprenticeships
4. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments recognize that apprenticeships
vary widely in different contexts and face significant challenges in many countries,
perpetuating gender inequality, offering low-quality training and inadequate
protection to apprentices, and deterring participation of enterprises, in particular
small and medium-sized enterprises?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
It should also highlight that apprenticeship differ from country to country and social
partners play a crucial role in developing and improving apprenticeship
systems. Without the effective involvement of the social partners there is a high
possibility that the apprenticeship systems fail.
5. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments acknowledge that quality
apprenticeships can constitute effective and efficient responses to current challenges
and provide lifelong learning opportunities to enhance productivity, resilience,
transitions and employability and meet current and future labour market needs?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
6. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments underline that an effective and
successful framework for quality apprenticeships requires apprenticeships to be well
regulated, sufficiently funded, socially inclusive and free from discrimination,
provides adequate remuneration and social protection coverage, recognizes
qualifications and enhances employment outcomes?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
the systems need to be developed and monitored within effective social dialogue with the social
partners.
7. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments recognize the particular
relevance of the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work,
1998, and the ILO Centenary Declaration for the Future of Work, 2019, for the
promotion of quality apprenticeships and the effective protection of all apprentices
and trainees, particularly in the light of the profound transformations in the world
of work?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
4 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
Double-click to type comments
ILC.109/IV/1 5
A framework for quality apprenticeships
8. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments recall the provisions of other
relevant ILO instruments, particularly the Employment Policy Convention (No. 122)
and Recommendation (No. 122), 1964, the Human Resources Development
Convention, 1975 (No. 142), the Employment Policy (Supplementary Provisions)
Recommendation, 1984 (No. 169), and the Human Resources Development
Recommendation, 2004 (No. 195)?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
?
III. Definitions and scope
9. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “apprenticeship”?
If so, should the term “apprenticeship” be defined as any form of education and
training, which is governed by an apprenticeship agreement, and enables a person
(the “apprentice”) to acquire the competencies required to work in an occupation
through structured training consisting of on-the-job learning and supplemented by
off-the-job learning and leading to a recognized qualification?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
With reference to the ETUC (European Trade Union Confederation) answer
According to the EU Council Recommendation on EFQEA: “apprenticeships are
understood as formal vocational education and training schemes that a)
combine learning in education or training institutions with substantial work-
based learning in companies and other workplaces, b) lead to nationally
recognised qualifications, c) are based on an agreement defining the rights and
obligations of the apprentice, the employer and, where appropriate, the
vocational education and training institution, and d) with the apprentice being
paid or otherwise compensated for the work-based component.
ETUC’s priority is to protect the achievements of the Council Recommendation
which was developed from the European trade unions’ proposal for a European
Quality Framework for Apprenticeship. For ETUC it is essential that the ILO
quality framework builds on this Council Recommendations and not alters it
or reduces its importance.
Cedefop, the European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training has
proposed the following definition: “systematic, long-term training alternating
periods at the workplace and in an educational institution or training
institutions. The apprentice is contractually linked to the employer and receives
remuneration (wage or allowance). The employer assumes responsibility for
providing the trainee with training leading to a specific occupation.
6 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
10. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “enterprise”?
If so, should the term “enterprise” be defined as a business, undertaking, economic
unit or organization, whether public or private?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
11. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “intermediary”?
If so, should the term “intermediary” mean an individual or an entity, other than the
host enterprise or educational institution, which assists in the provision,
coordination or support of an apprenticeship?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
12. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “recognition of prior
learning”?
If so, should the term “recognition of prior learning” be defined as a process of
identifying, documenting, assessing and certifying a person’s competencies,
acquired through formal, non-formal or informal learning, based on established
qualification standards?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
The regulatory framework should include a requirement for qualified educators and
teachers to assess the individual’s prior learning to establish the ‘starting point’,
or baseline, of the apprentice and to ensure that the apprenticeship is an
appropriate training programme for the individual.Double-click to type
comments
13. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “traineeship”?
If so, should the term “traineeship”, which includes internship, be defined as any
form of on-the-job learning, which enables a person (the “trainee”) to acquire work
experience with a view to enhancing their employability?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
It is important to distinguish traineeships and internships from apprenticeships to
ensure that the different programmes are not misused or abused.
ILC.109/IV/1 7
A framework for quality apprenticeships
On-the-job learning should also comprise the mentoring/coaching of trainees and
interns. ouble-click to type comments
14. Should any other terms be defined by the instrument or instruments? If so, please
specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
?
15. Should the instrument or instruments apply to all apprenticeships and traineeships
in all enterprises and sectors of economic activity?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
16. Should the instrument, if it takes the form of a Convention, provide that Members
could, after consulting with the most representative organizations of employers and
workers, limit its scope of application where special problems of a substantial nature
arise?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Apprenticeship is a national competence in Europe and is related to VET regulations
and collective agreements. Therefore, it should be also a national competence
on how to implement the standards together with the social partners.
IV. Regulatory framework for quality
apprenticeships
17. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should establish
regulatory frameworks for quality apprenticeships through social dialogue and that
the social partners should be involved in the design, implementation, monitoring and
evaluation of quality apprenticeship programmes?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
8 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
The social partners should be involved in the overall governance of quality
apprenticeship programmes, including in the design, implementation,
monitoring, and evaluation.
Regulatory frameworks for quality apprenticeships should be established through
social dialogue and collective bargaining.
18. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should establish or
designate one or more authorities to regulate apprenticeships and that the social
partners should be represented in these bodies?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This should be decided nationally.
19. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should ensure that the
competent regulatory authorities have clearly defined responsibilities and work in
close cooperation with other authorities or institutions responsible for regulating or
delivering education and training, labour inspection, social protection, occupational
safety and health, and public and private employment services?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This should be decided nationally.
20. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should adopt a process
for recognizing an occupation as being suitable for quality apprenticeships, taking
into account:
(a) the competencies needed to work in that occupation?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
With reference to the ETUC answer: The question should ask how to ensure that the
apprenticeships are suitable to ensure that all the necessary skills and competences are acquitted to
access an occupation/profession, and not reverse. It could suggest that updating occupational
/professional profiles and national level need to be done together with the social partners and it
should also update the necessary requirements from the apprenticeship related to the profession.
Duration of the apprenticeship, quality and appropriateness, and any other factors need to be
decided in relation to this update.
(b) the appropriateness of an apprenticeship as a means of acquiring such
competencies?
☐ Yes ☐ No
ILC.109/IV/1 9
A framework for quality apprenticeships
Comments:
See above
(c) the duration of the apprenticeship required to acquire such competencies?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
See above
(d) the current and future demand for skills and employment potential in that
occupation?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
See above
(e) any other factors? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
See above
21. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should establish
occupation-specific standards for quality apprenticeships, which provide, among
others things, for:
(a) the minimum age for admission?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
EAKL agrees with ETUC answer: The question is not about standards of
apprenticeship but occupation-specific, which is the competence of the sectoral
social partners. In Europe apprenticeship is a national competence. Minimum
age, required skills and qualifications, duration of apprenticeship, required
learning outcomes, and workplace learning:school-based learning ration need
to be decided at national level with the social partners. These are not quality
standards but quantitative elements, therefore they are not needed in the ILO
standard. Workers:apprentices ratio is also not a quality standard and differ
from country to country. Double-click to type comments
(b) the educational qualifications or prior learning needed for admission?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
See above
10 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
(c) the ratio of apprentices to workers in the workplace?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
See above
(d) the minimum and maximum duration of the apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
See above
(e) the extent to which the normal duration of the apprenticeship could be reduced
on the basis of any prior learning or progress made during the apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
See above
(f) learning outcomes and curricula?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
See above. For establishing general standards for apprenticeship it is important to
include the learning outcomes in the final certificate
(g) the ratio of off-the-job learning to on-the-job learning?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
See above
(h) the conditions under which apprentices should be released from on-the-job
learning to undertake off-the-job learning?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
See above.
(i) vocational guidance and career counselling?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
ILC.109/IV/1 11
A framework for quality apprenticeships
See above
(j) the mentoring and supervision of apprentices?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(k) the procedures for assessing and certifying the competencies acquired?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(l) the qualification(s) acquired on successful completion of the apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(m) any other elements? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
22. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members may establish standards
for quality apprenticeships through national laws and regulations, collective
agreements, decisions of competent regulatory bodies or in any other manner
consistent with national practice?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Yes, and this should mention the abovementioned quality indicators (contract,
remuneration, defined learning outcomes, qualifications of trainers and
mentors, quality assurance, recognition, etc),
23. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
ensure that there is a fair and transparent process for transferring an apprentice
from one enterprise to another when this is considered necessary or desirable for
the completion of the apprentice’s training?
☒ Yes ☐ No
12 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
Comments:
Refferring to ETUC: Collaborative apprenticeship indeed needs to be taken into
account. Fair and quality apprenticeship should be ensured in all companies
which provides the place to one single apprenticeship to ensure that all
necessary skills and competences for a profession / occupation can be acquired
by the apprentice.
24. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take appropriate
measures to ensure that apprentices:
(a) are adequately remunerated?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) are not required to work hours that exceed specified limits?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
It should be defined in the work/apprenticeship contract and overtime should be paid.
Working hours and working conditions must be defined together with the
social partners
(c) are entitled to holidays with pay?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
(d) are entitled to paid leave for absence due to illness or accident?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of discrimination and violence and harassment?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
ILC.109/IV/1 13
A framework for quality apprenticeships
(f) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of occupational safety and health?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) are entitled to compensation for work-related injuries?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(h) are eligible for any other benefits? If so, please specify.
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
25. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should prescribe
conditions under which:
(a) enterprises may offer apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
(b) educational and training institutions may provide off-the-job training?
☒ Yes ☐ No
(c) intermediaries may assist in the provision, coordination or support of
apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
26. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
continuously develop and strengthen the capacity of government agencies and the
social partners to respond to challenges affecting quality apprenticeships, such as
technological changes and the emergence of new forms of work arrangements?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
14 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
27. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
ensure that apprenticeship systems and programmes are regularly monitored and
evaluated?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
V. Apprenticeship agreement
28. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should ensure that all
apprenticeships are governed by a written agreement which is concluded between
an apprentice and an enterprise or an intermediary, and which, if so permitted by
national laws and regulations, may also be signed by a third party, such as an
educational or training institution?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
29. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should ensure that an
apprenticeship agreement:
(a) clearly identifies the parties’ respective roles, rights and obligations, with
reference to the relevant occupation-specific standards?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) contains provisions governing matters such as apprenticeship duration,
remuneration, working hours, leave entitlements, occupational safety and
health, social security, dispute resolution and the termination of the
apprenticeship agreement?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) is registered under conditions established by the competent authority?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
ILC.109/IV/1 15
A framework for quality apprenticeships
(d) is signed on the apprentice’s behalf by a parent, guardian or legal
representative, where the apprentice is a minor, as may be required by national
laws and regulations?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) contains any other elements? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
This should be a national competence to decide
30. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should develop a model
apprenticeship agreement to facilitate consistency, uniformity and compliance?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
This should be a national competence to decide together with the social partners.
VI. Equality and diversity in quality
apprenticeships
31. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
promote gender equality in apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
32. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
promote equality, diversity and social inclusion in apprenticeships, special account
being taken of the situation and needs of:
(a) persons with disabilities?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
16 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
(b) persons in the informal economy?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) older persons?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) long-term unemployed persons?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) persons belonging to disadvantaged minorities?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) migrants, refugees, internally and forcibly displaced persons, and other
persons in vulnerable situations?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) any other persons? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
ILC.109/IV/1 17
A framework for quality apprenticeships
33. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
promote access to formal education and training, including quality apprenticeships,
especially for persons in the informal economy, through recognition of prior
learning?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
VII. Promotion of quality apprenticeships
and international cooperation
34. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
create an enabling environment for promoting quality apprenticeships, including by:
(a) developing and implementing strategies, setting national goals and allocating
adequate resources for quality apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) mainstreaming quality apprenticeships in national development strategies and
in employment, education and lifelong learning policies?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) providing incentives, such as cost-sharing, tax exemptions or subsidies for
social security contributions, to enterprises, especially small and medium-sized
enterprises?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
These have to be defined with the social partners.
(d) encouraging intermediaries, including through financial support, to
participate in the provision, coordination and support of apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
These have to be defined with the social partners. Intermediaries need to be defined.
18 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
(e) undertaking awareness-raising activities and promotional campaigns at
regular intervals to improve the image and attractiveness of apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) establishing pre-apprenticeship programmes?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
?
(g) facilitating access to further vocational and higher education opportunities for
apprentices?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(h) using new technologies and innovative methods to improve effectiveness and
efficiency in delivering and managing quality apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(i) adopting any other measures? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
?
35. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
enhance international cooperation and exchange of good practices, in all aspects of
quality apprenticeships, including through offering expanded learning opportunities
to apprentices and recognizing competencies acquired through apprenticeship
programmes or prior learning?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
ILC.109/IV/1 19
A framework for quality apprenticeships
36. Should the instrument or instruments provide that, with a view to promoting quality
apprenticeships in the informal economy, Members should:
(a) strengthen the capacity of micro and small economic units by facilitating
access to business development and financial services, improving occupational
safety and health conditions, and enhancing the technical, pedagogical and
entrepreneurial competencies of master craftspersons?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
(b) ensure that apprentices have access to off-the-job learning and may
complement their on-the-job learning through intermediaries or in other
enterprises?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) strengthen the capacity of associations of micro and small economic units,
including through financial support, to perform the role of regulators and
quality assurance bodies?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
This depends on national circumstances and decisions with the social partners.
VIII. Traineeships
37. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures,
in accordance with national laws and regulations, to ensure that trainees:
(a) have a written traineeship agreement concluded between themselves and a host
enterprise?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) are adequately remunerated?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
20 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
Double-click to type comments
(c) are not required to work hours that exceed specified limits?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) are entitled to holidays with pay?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) are entitled to paid leave of absence for illness or accident?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of discrimination and violence and harassment?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of occupational safety and health?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(h) are entitled to compensation for work-related injuries?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(i) are eligible for any other benefits? If so, please specify.
☒ Yes ☐ No
ILC.109/IV/1 21
A framework for quality apprenticeships
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
22 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework
for quality apprenticeships
At its 334th Session (October–November 2018), the ILO Governing Body decided
to place on the agenda of the 110th Session of the International Labour Conference (2021)
an item related to apprenticeships (standard-setting). 1
The Governing Body noted a regulatory gap in relation to the topic of
apprenticeships as a result of the juridical replacement of a range of ILO instruments,
including the Apprenticeship Recommendation, 1939 (No. 60), and the Vocational
Training Recommendation, 1962 (No. 117), which has not been addressed in later
Recommendations. Furthermore, since the onset of the 2008 global economic and
financial crisis, and more recently in public debates on the future of work, apprenticeships
have become increasingly important for facilitating school-to-work transitions and
improving the quality of training systems and their relevance to labour market needs. A
new standard on apprenticeships would provide a comprehensive normative framework
with respect to the design and implementation of apprenticeship systems.
The purpose of this questionnaire is to request the views of member States on the
scope and content of the possible future instrument or instruments, after consultation with
the most representative organizations of employers and workers. Replies received should
enable the International Labour Office to prepare a report for the Conference. Replies
should reach the Office by 30 April 2020. Respondents are encouraged, where possible,
to complete the questionnaire in electronic format and to submit their replies electronically
to the following email address:
[email protected]. Respondents may also submit
their replies in hard copy to the Skills and Employability Branch, Employment Policy
Department, International Labour Office, Route des Morillons 4, 1202 Geneva,
Switzerland.
1 GB.334/PV, para. 42(b).
ILC.110/IV/1 1
A framework for quality apprenticeships
I. Form of the international instrument
or instruments
1. Should the International Labour Conference adopt an instrument or instruments
concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Council recommendation of European Framework for Quality and Effective
Apprenticeships is sufficient
2. If so, should the instrument or instruments take the form of:
(a) a Convention?
☐
(b) a Recommendation?
☒
(c) a Convention supplemented by a Recommendation, as two separate
instruments, or as a single instrument comprising binding and non-binding
provisions?
☐
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
II. Preamble
3. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments note that global youth
unemployment rates continue to be high and that rapid transformations in the world
of work are resulting in skills mismatches, requiring people of all ages to reskill and
upskill continuously to access and remain in employment?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
2 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
4. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments recognize that apprenticeships
vary widely in different contexts and face significant challenges in many countries,
perpetuating gender inequality, offering low-quality training and inadequate
protection to apprentices, and deterring participation of enterprises, in particular
small and medium-sized enterprises?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
It should also highlight that apprenticeship differ from country to country and social
partners play a crucial role in developing and improving apprenticeship
systems. Without the effective involvement of the social partners, there is a
high possibility that the apprenticeship systems fail.
5. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments acknowledge that quality
apprenticeships can constitute effective and efficient responses to current challenges
and provide lifelong learning opportunities to enhance productivity, resilience,
transitions and employability and meet current and future labour market needs?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
6. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments underline that an effective and
successful framework for quality apprenticeships requires apprenticeships to be well
regulated, sufficiently funded, socially inclusive and free from discrimination,
provides adequate remuneration and social protection coverage, recognizes
qualifications and enhances employment outcomes?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
The contribution of enterprises and the qualifications of supervisors are also
important.
7. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments recognize the particular
relevance of the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work,
1998, and the ILO Centenary Declaration for the Future of Work, 2019, for the
promotion of quality apprenticeships and the effective protection of all apprentices
and trainees, particularly in the light of the profound transformations in the world
of work?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
no position
ILC.109/IV/1 3
A framework for quality apprenticeships
4 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
8. Should the Preamble of the instrument or instruments recall the provisions of other
relevant ILO instruments, particularly the Employment Policy Convention (No. 122)
and Recommendation (No. 122), 1964, the Human Resources Development
Convention, 1975 (No. 142), the Employment Policy (Supplementary Provisions)
Recommendation, 1984 (No. 169), and the Human Resources Development
Recommendation, 2004 (No. 195)?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
no position
III. Definitions and scope
9. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “apprenticeship”?
If so, should the term “apprenticeship” be defined as any form of education and
training, which is governed by an apprenticeship agreement, and enables a person
(the “apprentice”) to acquire the competencies required to work in an occupation
through structured training consisting of on-the-job learning and supplemented by
off-the-job learning and leading to a recognized qualification?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
as apprenticeships are defined differently in different countries, they should be
defined in terms of characteristics (for example, a large part of the training
takes place in a company, the apprentice receives remuneration)
10. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “enterprise”?
If so, should the term “enterprise” be defined as a business, undertaking, economic
unit or organization, whether public or private?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
11. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “intermediary”?
If so, should the term “intermediary” mean an individual or an entity, other than the
host enterprise or educational institution, which assists in the provision,
coordination or support of an apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
ILC.109/IV/1 5
A framework for quality apprenticeships
countries have different apprenticeship systems and some countries do not have an
intermediary.
12. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “recognition of prior
learning”?
If so, should the term “recognition of prior learning” be defined as a process of
identifying, documenting, assessing and certifying a person’s competencies,
acquired through formal, non-formal or informal learning, based on established
qualification standards?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
13. Should the instrument or instruments include a definition of “traineeship”?
If so, should the term “traineeship”, which includes internship, be defined as any
form of on-the-job learning, which enables a person (the “trainee”) to acquire work
experience with a view to enhancing their employability?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
14. Should any other terms be defined by the instrument or instruments? If so, please
specify.
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
superivisor, renumeration
15. Should the instrument or instruments apply to all apprenticeships and traineeships
in all enterprises and sectors of economic activity?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
it must take into account sectoral specificities and also different national specificities
6 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
16. Should the instrument, if it takes the form of a Convention, provide that Members
could, after consulting with the most representative organizations of employers and
workers, limit its scope of application where special problems of a substantial nature
arise?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
IV. Regulatory framework for quality
apprenticeships
17. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should establish
regulatory frameworks for quality apprenticeships through social dialogue and that
the social partners should be involved in the design, implementation, monitoring and
evaluation of quality apprenticeship programmes?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Apprenticeship and curriculum development are structured and regulated differently
in different countries.
18. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should establish or
designate one or more authorities to regulate apprenticeships and that the social
partners should be represented in these bodies?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Apprenticeship and curriculum development are structured and regulated differently
in different countries. This should be decided nationally. .
19. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should ensure that the
competent regulatory authorities have clearly defined responsibilities and work in
close cooperation with other authorities or institutions responsible for regulating or
delivering education and training, labour inspection, social protection, occupational
safety and health, and public and private employment services?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This should be decided nationally.
ILC.109/IV/1 7
A framework for quality apprenticeships
20. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should adopt a process
for recognizing an occupation as being suitable for quality apprenticeships, taking
into account:
(a) the competencies needed to work in that occupation?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) the appropriateness of an apprenticeship as a means of acquiring such
competencies?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) the duration of the apprenticeship required to acquire such competencies?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) the current and future demand for skills and employment potential in that
occupation?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) any other factors? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
21. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should establish
occupation-specific standards for quality apprenticeships, which provide, among
others things, for:
(a) the minimum age for admission?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
8 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
a general or vocational educational standard is sufficient. Minimum age, required
skills and qualifications, duration of apprenticeship, required learning
outcomes, and workplace learning:school-based learning ration need to be
decided at national level with the social partners. These are not quality
standards but quantitative elements, therefore they are not needed in the ILO
standard.
(b) the educational qualifications or prior learning needed for admission?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) the ratio of apprentices to workers in the workplace?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) the minimum and maximum duration of the apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) the extent to which the normal duration of the apprenticeship could be reduced
on the basis of any prior learning or progress made during the apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) learning outcomes and curricula?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) the ratio of off-the-job learning to on-the-job learning?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
ILC.109/IV/1 9
A framework for quality apprenticeships
(h) the conditions under which apprentices should be released from on-the-job
learning to undertake off-the-job learning?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(i) vocational guidance and career counselling?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(j) the mentoring and supervision of apprentices?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(k) the procedures for assessing and certifying the competencies acquired?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(l) the qualification(s) acquired on successful completion of the apprenticeship?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(m) any other elements? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
22. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members may establish standards
for quality apprenticeships through national laws and regulations, collective
agreements, decisions of competent regulatory bodies or in any other manner
consistent with national practice?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
10 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
Double-click to type comments
23. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
ensure that there is a fair and transparent process for transferring an apprentice
from one enterprise to another when this is considered necessary or desirable for
the completion of the apprentice’s training?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
exchange of forms of study should also be involved. For example, school-based
learning may be more appropriate for a student.
24. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take appropriate
measures to ensure that apprentices:
(a) are adequately remunerated?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) are not required to work hours that exceed specified limits?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) are entitled to holidays with pay?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level. depends on who and on what basis
pays the renumeration
(d) are entitled to paid leave for absence due to illness or accident?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level. depends on who and on what basis
pays the renumeration
(e) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of discrimination and violence and harassment?
ILC.109/IV/1 11
A framework for quality apprenticeships
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of occupational safety and health?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) are entitled to compensation for work-related injuries?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level. depends on who and on what basis
pays the renumeration
(h) are eligible for any other benefits? If so, please specify.
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Unemployment benefits may be considered, but this depends on the type of
remuneration and national legislation.
25. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should prescribe
conditions under which:
(a) enterprises may offer apprenticeships?
☐ Yes ☒ No
(b) educational and training institutions may provide off-the-job training?
☒ Yes ☒ No
(c) intermediaries may assist in the provision, coordination or support of
apprenticeships?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
26. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
continuously develop and strengthen the capacity of government agencies and the
12 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
social partners to respond to challenges affecting quality apprenticeships, such as
technological changes and the emergence of new forms of work arrangements?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
27. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
ensure that apprenticeship systems and programmes are regularly monitored and
evaluated?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
V. Apprenticeship agreement
28. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should ensure that all
apprenticeships are governed by a written agreement which is concluded between
an apprentice and an enterprise or an intermediary, and which, if so permitted by
national laws and regulations, may also be signed by a third party, such as an
educational or training institution?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
29. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should ensure that an
apprenticeship agreement:
(a) clearly identifies the parties’ respective roles, rights and obligations, with
reference to the relevant occupation-specific standards?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) contains provisions governing matters such as apprenticeship duration,
remuneration, working hours, leave entitlements, occupational safety and
health, social security, dispute resolution and the termination of the
apprenticeship agreement?
☒ Yes ☐ No
ILC.109/IV/1 13
A framework for quality apprenticeships
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) is registered under conditions established by the competent authority?
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
competent authority definition and role needs clarification
(d) is signed on the apprentice’s behalf by a parent, guardian or legal
representative, where the apprentice is a minor, as may be required by national
laws and regulations?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) contains any other elements? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
30. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should develop a model
apprenticeship agreement to facilitate consistency, uniformity and compliance?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This should be a national competence to decide together with the social partners.
Minimum requirements are sufficient.
VI. Equality and diversity in quality
apprenticeships
31. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
promote gender equality in apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
14 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
32. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
promote equality, diversity and social inclusion in apprenticeships, special account
being taken of the situation and needs of:
(a) persons with disabilities?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) persons in the informal economy?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) older persons?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) long-term unemployed persons?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(e) persons belonging to disadvantaged minorities?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) migrants, refugees, internally and forcibly displaced persons, and other
persons in vulnerable situations?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) any other persons? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
ILC.109/IV/1 15
A framework for quality apprenticeships
Double-click to type comments
33. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
promote access to formal education and training, including quality apprenticeships,
especially for persons in the informal economy, through recognition of prior
learning?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
VII. Promotion of quality apprenticeships
and international cooperation
34. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
create an enabling environment for promoting quality apprenticeships, including by:
(a) developing and implementing strategies, setting national goals and allocating
adequate resources for quality apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) mainstreaming quality apprenticeships in national development strategies and
in employment, education and lifelong learning policies?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(c) providing incentives, such as cost-sharing, tax exemptions or subsidies for
social security contributions, to enterprises, especially small and medium-sized
enterprises?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
(d) encouraging intermediaries, including through financial support, to
participate in the provision, coordination and support of apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
16 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
This needs to be decided at the national level.
(e) undertaking awareness-raising activities and promotional campaigns at
regular intervals to improve the image and attractiveness of apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(f) establishing pre-apprenticeship programmes?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
needs clarification
(g) facilitating access to further vocational and higher education opportunities for
apprentices?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(h) using new technologies and innovative methods to improve effectiveness and
efficiency in delivering and managing quality apprenticeships?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(i) adopting any other measures? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
35. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures to
enhance international cooperation and exchange of good practices, in all aspects of
quality apprenticeships, including through offering expanded learning opportunities
to apprentices and recognizing competencies acquired through apprenticeship
programmes or prior learning?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
ILC.109/IV/1 17
A framework for quality apprenticeships
This needs to be decided at the national level.
36. Should the instrument or instruments provide that, with a view to promoting quality
apprenticeships in the informal economy, Members should:
(a) strengthen the capacity of micro and small economic units by facilitating
access to business development and financial services, improving occupational
safety and health conditions, and enhancing the technical, pedagogical and
entrepreneurial competencies of master craftspersons?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
(b) ensure that apprentices have access to off-the-job learning and may
complement their on-the-job learning through intermediaries or in other
enterprises?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
(c) strengthen the capacity of associations of micro and small economic units,
including through financial support, to perform the role of regulators and
quality assurance bodies?
☐ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level.
VIII. Traineeships
37. Should the instrument or instruments provide that Members should take measures,
in accordance with national laws and regulations, to ensure that trainees:
(a) have a written traineeship agreement concluded between themselves and a host
enterprise?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(b) are adequately remunerated?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
18 ILC.109/IV/1
Questionnaire concerning a framework for quality apprenticeships
Double-click to type comments
(c) are not required to work hours that exceed specified limits?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(d) are entitled to holidays with pay?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level. depends on who and on what basis
pays the renumeration
(e) are entitled to paid leave of absence for illness or accident?
☒ Yes ☒ No
Comments:
This needs to be decided at the national level. depends on who and on what basis
pays the renumeration
(f) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of discrimination and violence and harassment?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(g) are afforded the same protection and receive the same training as others in the
workplace in respect of occupational safety and health?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
(h) are entitled to compensation for work-related injuries?
☒ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
ILC.109/IV/1 19
A framework for quality apprenticeships
(i) are eligible for any other benefits? If so, please specify.
☐ Yes ☐ No
Comments:
Double-click to type comments
20 ILC.109/IV/1