Martin Karro
Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus
[email protected] Meie 19.05.2021 nr 2-6.3/1022-2
Väikeprojektide avatud taotlusvooru "Taastava
õiguse arendamine Eestis" hindamiskomisjoni
otsuse muudatus
Lugupeetud Martin Karro
Palume Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskusel kui Euroopa Majanduspiirkonna ja Norra toetuste 2014–
2021 programmi „Kohalik areng ja vaesuse vähendamine“ rakendusüksusel langetada
toetuse rahuldamise otsus Sotsiaalkindlustusameti projektitaotluse „Vahenduse mudeli ja
koolitussüsteemi arendamine“ suhtes summas 146 967 eurot. Nimetatud otsus muudab 11.
märtsil 2021. aastal kohtunud väikeprojektide avatud taotlusvooru „Taastava õiguse
arendamine Eestis“ hindamiskomisjoni otsust (vt meie 22.03.2021 kiri nr 2-6.3/1022-1) ja
põhineb hindamiskomisjoni kirjalikul menetlusel perioodil 13.–18.05.2021.
Palun rakendusüksusel võtta rahastusotsuse langetamisel arvesse, et taotleja täiendaks
eelnevalt oma projektikirjeldust ja eelarvet hindamiskomisjoni viidatud tingimustel, mis
kajastuvad täpsemalt hindamiskomisjoni protokollis (lisatud).
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kristiina Hunt
nutika arengu toetamise osakonna juhataja
Lisa: Minutes of the SC meeting (WRITTEN PROCEDURE)
Lisaadressaat:
Justiitsministeerium
Ülar Vaadumäe 626 9249
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 626 9301 /
[email protected] / www.sm.ee / registrikood 70001952
EEA and No rway Grants 2014-2021 Programme “Local Development and Poverty Reduction” Selection Committee meeting No 2 Date and time : May 13 , 202 1 – May 18, 2021 Venue: written pr o cedure via e-mail Small Grant Scheme „ Developing restorative justice measures in Estonia “ Selection Committee voting members : Ms Laidi Surva – project manager, Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of Justice; Ms Anu Leps – adviser to the Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of Justice; Mr Andres Aru – Head of Children’s and Youth’s Rights Department, Chancellor of Justice. Observers : Ms Gudrun Gudmundsdottir – Financial Mechanism Office, Senior Sector Officer, Health, Children and Youth, also representing the Financial Mechanism Committee Ms Laura Pikkoja – representative of the National Focal Point; State Shared Service Centre; Ms Piret Marvet – representative of the donors, Royal Norwegian Embassy in Tallinn. Ms Kelly Poopuu – representative of the PO Implementing Agency, State Shared Service Centre. Mr Ülar Vaadumäe – Ministry of Social Affairs, Smart Development Department, chief specialist, PO. Minutes of the meeting Mr Ülar Vaadumäe convened the Selection Committee via written procedure. On March 11 , 2021 , the committee decided to grant financial support to 3 project proposals: Social Insurance Board project proposal “ Development of a mediation model and training system ” à award a grant for 128 585 euros; Police and Border Guard Board project proposal “ A community based on the principles of restorative justice ” à award a grant for 78 575 euros; NGO Prevention Centre project proposal “ Development and implementation of Family Group Conference (FGC) method as an approach to restorative justice ” à award a grant for 125 708 euros. While the latter two projects have been contracted, then Social Insurance Board is struggling with the conditions set by the Selection Committee (please see the minutes of March 11, 2021 ). More specifically, the condition to lower the wages considerably “ lower the additional salary for the project manager to 400 EUR and project coordinator to 300 EUR (leaving them both with highly generous overall salaries when compared to similar positions in the public sector) – savings of 46 200 EUR + additionally in indirect costs´ savings of 6 930 EUR. Social Insurance Board has argued that in order to successfully execute the project there needs to be full control (the project is 21 months) and therefore a full-time project manager is in order. As the main project manager Ms Annegrete Johanson is already involved at the pre-defined project “ Establishment of Specialised Youth Justice Approach ”, then her input to the project could be divided between the projects 50% – 50%, and therefore the project would need another project coordinator with a workload of 50%. Applicant would also like to keep 2 900 euros “ involving international experts ” as it was side-lined for the project donor partner Sekretariatet for Kofliktrådene. Financially, the applicant has lowered the monthly salary foreseen to the project manager by approx. 24% (as it was the argument of the Selection Committee that the salary costs per month are quite high) and consequently the salary admin personnel costs in connection with 15% of indirect costs have been cut by 10 948 euros. Additionally, the applicant has cut: 14 800 euros from budget lines No 27-28 and 33-34, but financing these activities outside the project budget from their own resources; 10 500 euros from basic training pilot as it would be redundant to keep . However, they would implement the pilot in regard to restorative justice in specific training modules as this focus is novel in Estonia and should be tested before training roll- out ; 7 500 euros by cancelling the restorative justice summer school because it is already being organised in cooperation between MoJ and the Social Insurance Board; 3 600 euros by using a similar flat rate for all trainers throughout the project (400 EUR/person/day ); Nevertheless, the outcome of these changes is that the Social Insurance Board would need a slightly bigger budget / grant than the one decided on March 11, 2021. Additional need would be 18 382 euros mounting up to the total budget / grant of 146 967 euros. In principle, the call budget has the resources available. The decree of the Selection Committee states that the Selection Committee shall be in place until all financing decisions have been cast by the State Shared Service Centre. Taking account all of the above, Mr Vaadumäe turned to the Selection Committee for their view and a possible review of the original decision cast towards Social Insurance Board. Are the arguments presented acceptable and would the Selection Committee be in favour of offering the applicant a greater grant in the amount of 146 967 euros? Please see also annexed to the minutes the updated detailed budget of Social Insurance Board . Ms Anu Leps, Ms Laidi Surva and Mr Andres Aru were all in favour of the changes proposed. Selection Committee decision Selection Committee decided to: revoke its decision made on March 11, 2021 to award a grant for 128 585 euros to Social Insurance Board’s project proposal “ Development of a mediation model and training system ”; approve a project grant in the amount of 146 967 euros to Social Insurance Board’s project proposal “ Development of a mediation model and training system ” , taking into account the following: the salary costs of the project manager (50% workload ) will be lowered to 1 300 euros per month; activities described in budget lines No 27-28 and 33-34 will be carried out, but will be financed outside the project budget from other resources of the applicant; basic training pilot will be removed from the activity list as redundant (savings 10 500 euros), while keeping and implementing the pilot in regard to restorative justice in specific training modules; restorative justice summer school will be cancelled (savings 7 500 euros) because it is already being organised in cooperation between MoJ and the Social Insurance Board; similar flat rate will be used for all trainers throughout the project (400 EUR/person/day). Meeting chaired by (digitally signed) minutes taken by Laidi Surva ( digitally signed ) Ülar Vaadumäe