Saatja: VARAM <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 06.03.2023 07:52
Adressaat: <"rtk info">; <"Ege.Ello3">; <"RAM Info">; <"Margarita Golovko">
Koopia: Iruma Kravale <
[email protected]>; Anna Djakova
<
[email protected]>; Anna Škabireva <
[email protected]>;
Vita Prokopoviča <
[email protected]>; Ilze Krieva
<
[email protected]>; Külli Kaare <
[email protected]>; Sandis Cakuls
<
[email protected]>
Teema: On actions to be taken in connection to Project Est-Lat 51 “Valga Valka Center”
Reģistrācijas numurs: 5-31/1322
Reģistrācijas datums: 03.03.2023
Ms. Ege Ello
Head of Managing Authority of
Estonia-Latvia Programme
Estonian State Shared Service Center
[email protected]
[email protected]
copy:
Ministry of Finance of the
Republic of Estonia
[email protected]
[email protected]
Dear Managing authority,
In response to your letter No. 11.1-13/23/468-2 of 23 February 2023 the Ministry of
Environmental Protection and Regional Development of Latvia (MEPRD) as the National
authority (NA) for the Estonia-Latvia programme (the Programme) strongly urges the
Managing authority (MA) to reconsider its approach on the execution of the financial
correction decision (FCD) in the Project Est-Lat 51 “Valga-Valka Centre”, concerning its
Lead partner – Valka Municipality (the LP or Valka).
The NA would like to draw your attention that Valka has acted in accordance with the
internal rules and guidelines of the Programme - steadily going through pre-court
procedures first and then applying to the court, which definitely connected with a certain
time needed to obtain the decisions of the Programme and prepare further
documentation (e.g. letter, appeal, claim etc). It is important to consider that Valka, when
challenging the MA decision and then appealing it to the court, has acted within the limits
of its rights and has not in any way, to our knowledge, infringed the laws of the Estonian
Republic or rules of the Programme, on the contrary. According to the fundamental
principle stated in law: “nobody should be punished for the opportunity to defend oneself”,
but in our opinion, the MA is punishing Valka for exercising and defending its rights.
Therefore, the mentioned principle is violated in the current case. We insist that the fine
for delay cannot be applied to the LP while it follows the Programme procedures to prove
its right to defend its opinion and complain against MA decision.
In the whole process after issuing the FCD the MA was not acting proactively, e.g. not trying
to communicate to the LP that the fine for the delay of repayment is going to be calculated
from a certain day, as well as not informed LP about the interest, not trying to warn the LP
of the financial outcomes and terms for them. We consider that in this situation MA did
not demonstrate all the possible measures to ensure transparent recovery arrangements.
The NA objects the approach to initiate calculation of the 60 days for the repayment after
the decision of the MA not to satisfy the complaint has been issued, since the LP steadily
took the next step after the pre-court procedure applying to court defending its rights. For
the LP it was not possible to avoid pre-court procedure due to the Programme
requirements and the length of this process did not depend on the LP, but on collaboration
of different authorities and established groups, e.g., the Complaint Panel, the Monitoring
Committee, NAs, MA, joint secretariat and the lawyers. Therefore, any fine cannot be
applied to LP at that period automatically, the same principle is relevant regarding court
proceedings. The interpretation of the “due term” for repayment stated in the Guidelines
for Financial Correction (Guidelines) needs to be reconsidered by MA since the LP was acting
sequentially following main proceedings requested in the Guidelines.
In NA’s opinion the “due term” has not yet started as the legal proceedings in the court
regarding the validity of the financial correction decision No 12 issued by the Managing
Authority on 17 June 2022 are still ongoing. As well as MA initiated communication with
LP on the repayment schedule and Valka municipality in its letter No.3.9/23/123 of 8
February 2023 informed MA on readiness to repay irregularly used ERDF funding to the
Programme and expressed its willingness to agree with MA on the repayment schedule.
The proposal to agree on the repayment schedule was not offered by MA in due time to
the LP as possible solution to avoid following financial consequences for the LP. We invite
the MA to agree with the LP now setting concrete repayment schedule and “due term”.
Before that punishing the LP with a fine applying article 2.7. of the Guidelines is not
grounded. The NA also considers that in case the Agreement on the repayment schedule
is concluded, the article 2.6. of the Guidelines should not be applied at all, and these terms
should be stipulated in mentioned Agreement.
Moreover, in light of the revealed shortcomings and weaknesses of the system and
procedure, LV NA would like to urgently initiate the revision of the Guidelines of the
Financial Correction of the period 2014-2020 and 20121-2027 respectively, especially
concerning articles 2.6. and 2.7.
LV NA is of opinion that article 2.7. and “application of fine in due term” should be
defined very precisely, foreseeing the procedure for agreement on the repayment
schedule without any sanctions (at least for State and municipal budget
organisations), as for example this mechanism is incorporated in Latvian legal acts
for Interreg programmes - Rules of the Cabinet of Ministers on irregularities and
recoveries ( Noteikumi par kārtību, kādā tiek sniegt - Latvijas Vēstnesis (vestnesis.lv)
- article 20.2.
Regarding article 2.6. of the Guidelines, it can be concluded from the analysis of
the current situation and example of Valka case, that it is disproportional to apply
interest, as the Programme is dealing mostly with public institutions that work in
the interest of the society and are able to repay from State or municipal budgets
within agreed schedule.
Indeed, most of the Programme beneficiaries are State or municipal budget institutions,
which are reliable and responsible institutions, participating in the Programme to improve
fulfilment of their main functions by searching for most efficient joint solutions, reducing
CBC obstacles and facilitating improvement of life conditions to both countries and their
inhabitants. Therefore, the management of the processes should be based on the risk
assessment of the beneficiary type - not treating State and municipal institutions as private
bank collector treats private sector debtors. Regarding point 2 of Article 122 of Regulation
(EU) No 1303/2013, it does not state any requirements or obligation for the Programme
to apply interest or regulate the procedures and amounts.
Best regards,
Sandis Cakuls
Deputy State Secretary