Siseministeerium
[email protected] Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
[email protected] Meie 17 . 01 .202 2 nr 4/ 9 Balti kaubandus kodade ühispöördumine seoses tööjõuprobleemidega Lugupeetud ministrid ! Eesti Kaubandus-Tööstuskoda , Läti Kaubandus-Tööstuskoda ja Leedu Kaubandus-Tööstuskoda pöörduvad Teie poole seoses Balti riikide tööturuga ja sisserändega seotud teemadega. Leiame, et Balti riikide tööturgudel on tungiv vajadus kvalifitseeritud tööjõu järele ning teeme ühispöördumises mitmeid ettepanekuid selle probleemi leevendamiseks. Näiteks peaksid Balti riigid tegema senisest rohkem omavahelist koostööd, et tagada riikide regulatsioonide võrreldavus ning suurem ühtsus rände küsimustes . Balti kaubanduskodade ühispöördumisega , milles on täpsemalt kirjeldatud probleemi olemust ning ettepanekuid olukorra leevendamiseks, saate tutvuda kirja lisas. Lugupidamisega /allkirjastatud digitaalselt/ Mait Palts Eesti Kaubandus-Tööstuskoja p eadirektor Lisa: Balti kaubanduskodade ühispöördumine seoses tööjõuprobleemidega Koostanud: Marko Udras
[email protected] 6040070
THE BALTIC STATES: RECOVERY, LABOUR MARKETS,
IMMIGRATION. THE VIEW OF CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE
AND INDUSTRY, AND POLICY PROPOSALS
The European Union and its Member States, including the Baltic States are facing
general economic recovery after turbulent two years. Eurochambres economic survey
for 2022 with total 52000 enterprises participated shows positive sentiment for the next
year. Employment levels are expected to remain stable in the coming year.
Nonetheless, a closer examination of labour markets reveals a pressing need for skilled
labour, the shortages of which are a major source of concern for business. The concern
is even higher in the Baltic States. Lack of skilled workers pointed out 70% of LTU, 75%
LVA and 64% EST businesses.
Wages are expected to increase at high levels as a result of supporting mechanisms
introduced by the national governments in response to COVID-19 pandemic and overall
recovery of the economy. Additionally, growing skill mismatches are an unavoidable
consequence of the labour market's changing structure due to technological
innovation (e.g. digital advancement or the green economy). Given the long-standing
skills shortages in ICT and digital skills in general, as well as the fluctuating demand in
certain sectors such as hospitality, construction, manufactoring or transport, the Baltic
States labour markets will continue to struggle to fill the skills gaps over the next year.
Because of the preasure in the labour market, labour costs associated to that
businesses ranked as a problem also very high.
The three Baltic States Chambers (further – Chambers) assessed the current situation.
Labour force as a production factor could be considered as a bottleneck to deploy other
production factors, or simply speaking, not resolving the issue of mismatch of labour supply
and demand could hamper the overall development of our economies.
General remarks
According to the EU 2019 Ageing Report, almost one fifth of the population living in the EU-
28 at the start of 2018 was aged 65 years or more. The report forecasts that, during the next
three decades, the number of older people in the European Union (EU) is projected to follow
an upward path; their relative share of the total population will also gradually increase and is
projected to reach 28.5 % in 2050. Similar if not worse paths projected for the Baltic States.
With this in mind, coupled with the gaps identified in the labour market, a new legal migration
policy is one of the four pillars of a balanced EU migration management. The European
Commission acknowledges the benefit that legal migration brings to society and the economy.
While Member States retain the right to determine volumes of admission of third country
nationals coming from third
countries to their territory for employment purposes, there is an opportunity to address the
gaps in the labour market whilst offering those workers the right opportunities and working
conditions that are so often denied.
Indeed, the EU labour market as well the Baltic States labour markets face specific skills
shortages in different sectors, be it low, medium and high level sectors. In the recently
published Skills Agenda for Europe, the European Commission said it would work with
Member States on modern and comprehensive national skills strategies and join forces with
national public employment agencies to realise them. Here, it also suggests that this can be
coupled with a more strategic approach to legal migration, oriented towards better attracting
and keeping talent.
The decline of fertility in a number of European countries, including the Baltic States has led
and continues to lead to much smaller cohorts of new labour-market entrants.
The Chambers believe in the principle that migration is normal and that people are constantly
on the move; acknowledge the contribution that Third Countries Nationals (TCN) make to our
societies, economies and cultures and stresses that migration needs to be managed in an
orderly, safe and regular manner; believes that to establish new avenues for legal labour
migration, both in the EU and the Baltic States should set ambitious and future-proof goals,
while simultaneously making effective use of and improving the existing legal and policy
framework. Takes the view that, if well-designed and well-managed, legal labour migration
can be a source of prosperity, innovation and growth.
The Chambers admit that majority of current employees from TCN in our states are
« economic » immigrants, not asylum seekers, ready to work and impose low external costs
for the societes and public budgets.
Already today in the majority of EU countries 13 % of key workers are immigrants on average,
while in the Baltics that figure is around 3%.
Policy proposals
- The EU legal labour migration acquis regulates the conditions of entry and residence
and the rights of third country national workers, which includes the Blue Card Directive, the
Single Permit Directive, the Seasonal Workers Directive, the framework of an intra-
corporate transfer (the ICT Directive), etc. There is no legal basis in the current Treaties
and frameworks for a common migration or labour policy. Member States have the
sovereign right to determine volumes of migration. That competence must be fully
respected. Hoewer, EU legal labour migration acquis is under the review. Chambers
encourage national governments of the Baltic States to actively participate in the
regulations reviewing processes.
- legislation on legal migration is highly fragmented in different EU countries. The patchwork
of different rules and regulations makes the EU’s framework unclear and unattractive for
both TCNs and Member States employers organisations. Whilst it
remains the competence of Member States to decide what their market needs are and how
many work permits should be granted, increased coordination and cooperation is highly
welcome. Three Baltic States must therefore forge closer cooperation between
themselves to ensure the regulations in each country are comparable and even unified as
much as it is possible that the benefits of better regulation would benefit business, especialy
crossborder business.
- Development of an EU and the Baltic States talent pool initiative. It could be matching
platform to serve as a one-stop shop for TCN workers, Baltic states employers and national
administrations. ; We note the Commission’s plan to explore the development of such a
talent pool; We recommend that this should cover all sectors of employment for low-,
medium- and highly skilled workers, Moreover, we encourage to consider developing an
EU-wide scheme to attract selfemployed people and entrepreneurs.
- Posted workers. The number of third-country nationals that are posted from one Member
State to another has increased significantly over the past years; whereas a third-country
national worker who obtained a work and residence permit in one Member State can be
posted by their employers to any other. We consider some posted workers are result of
different procedures, different time needed to fulfill the requirements in different countries.
That is why unification of procedures in the Baltic States would be beneficial both for
job seekers, as well as for the employers.
- Qualifications and practical experience. We are drawing attention to that problem in
our countries. We emphasise the need to improve the existing regulatory system of
recognition of professional qualifications and recognition of practical experience among
the Baltic States, as difficulties in recognition of foreign qualifications and practical
experience remain a substantial obstacle for employment matching, which hampers
mobility and employability.
- Flexibility of labour relations regulations. The current economies are facing huge
changes: sustainability requirements, digitalisation, remote workplaces, digital platform
jobs, etc. Such dynamic changes make impossible to timely update Labour Code and
related legal acts regulations. The governments should allow and encourage employees
and employers to agree upon the working aspects more freely.
President of the Association of Lithuanian Chambers of Commerce, Industry and Crafts
Rimas Varkulevicius
President of the Latvian Chamber of Commerce and Industry
Aigars Rostovskis
Director General of the Estonian Chamber of Commerce and Industry
Mait Palts
Saatja: Marko Udras <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 17.01.2022 08:57
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>; MKM info <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Mait Palts <
[email protected]>
Teema: Balti kaubanduskodade ühispöördumine seoses Balti tööturu ja
sisserändega
Tere!
Edastan Balti kaubanduskodade ühispöördumise seoses Balti tööturu ja
sisserändega seotud teemadega. Leiame, et Balti riikide tööturgudel on
tungiv vajadus kvalifitseeritud tööjõu järele ning teeme ühispöördumises
mitmeid ettepanekuid selle probleemi leevendamiseks. Näiteks peaksid
Balti riigid tegema senisest rohkem omavahelist koostööd, et tagada
riikide regulatsioonide võrreldavus ning suurem ühtsus rände küsimustes.
Balti kaubanduskodade ühispöördumisega, milles on täpsemalt kirjeldatud
probleemi olemust ning ettepanekuid olukorra leevendamiseks, saate
tutvuda kirja lisas.
Parimate soovidega
Marko UdrasPoliitikakujundamise ja õigusosakonna juhatajaEesti Kaubandus-
Tööstuskoda
E-post
Tel +372 604 0070