dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Rahandusministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

Final Report

Rahandusministeerium · 9. märts 2023
Viit
10-2/1808-1
Registreeritud
9. märts 2023
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
European Commission
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
10 VALITSUSE SISEKONTROLLISUSTEEMI KOORDINEERIMINE NING EUROOPA LIIDU TOETUSTE JA VÄLISABI AUDITEERIMINE
Sari
10-2 Kirjavahetus riigiasutuste ja organisatsioonidega
Toimik
10-2/2026
Vastutaja
Anu Alber (Rahandusministeerium, Kantsleri vastutusvaldkond, Finantskontrolli osakond, I auditi talitus)
Lahendamise tähtaeg
29. märts 2023

Failid

  • 📎Cover letter +Final Report.pdf839 KB
  • 📎E-kiri.pdf73 KB

Sisu (failidest)

Ref. Ares(2023)1681292 - 08/03/2023 EUROPEAN COMMISSION DIRECTORATES-GENERAL EMPLOYMENT, SOCIAL AFFAIRS AND INCLUSION REGIONAL AND URBAN POLICY Joint Audit Directorate for Cohesion – DAC – The Director Brussels, EMPL.REGIO.DAC.5/MK/ak(2023)9914842 Subject: EPM 'Review of the work of audit authorities / Compliance Audits (2014-2020) – Final Audit Report Operational Programme: 2014EE16M3OP001 - Ühtekuuluvuspoliitika fondide rakenduskava 2014-2020 Ref.: Audit No DAC514EE1363 (to be used in all correspondence) EC letter communicating draft audit report Ares(2022)5406483 27/07/2022 MS Reply to the draft audit report Ares(2022)6544636 22/09/2022 and Ares(2022)8811061 19/12/2022 Dear Mr Siruli, I am writing to inform you that the Joint Audit Directorate for Cohesion of Directorates- General Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion and Regional and Urban Policy has analysed the reply received from the audit authority to the draft report of the above- mentioned audit. Please find enclosed the final audit report setting out the Commission auditors’ final findings and related actions and recommendations. As the irregular expenditure detected, presented in Annex III to the audit report, has been accepted by the Member State, and the Member State has implemented all audit recommendations including the required financial corrections, no further action will be taken by the Commission services. The audit is therefore closed. The Commission auditors take note that all the findings, actions and recommendations, as presented in the enclosed report, have been accepted. The national authorities are herewith requested to inform the Commission auditors on the implementation of these actions and recommendations within the deadline(s) specified in this report under the Kaur Siruli Head of the Financial Control department Ministry of Finance Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn 15006, Estonia Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË — Tel. +32 22991111 findings concerned, starting with the date of submission of the national language version of this final audit report via SFC2014. The irregular expenditure detected during the audit where financial corrections have been accepted by the Member State is presented in Annex III to the audit report. Furthermore, the national authorities are reminded to ensure that findings, which have a financial impact on the EU budget exceeding EUR 10 000, are reported to OLAF in the IMS system for reporting irregularities. Yours faithfully, Electronically signed Franck Sébert Enclosure: Final audit report + annexes c.c.: HE Mr Aivo Orav Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Permanent Representation of Estonia rue Guimard 11–13/Guimardstraat 11–13 BE-1040 Bruxelles/Brussel Ms K. Ivankovic- Knezevic, Director, Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion, Directorate D Mr A. Andrulis, Head of Unit, Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion, Unit D.5 Mr S. Tokarski, Director, Directorate-General for Regional and Urban Policy, Directorate D Mr A. Von Busch, Head of Unit, Directorate-General for Regional and Urban Policy, Unit D4 Mr A. Mathison, Acting Director & Head of Unit Directorate-General for Maritime Affairs and Fisheries, Unit E.1 Ms C. de Buggenoms, Head of Unit, Directorates-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion, Regional and Urban Policy, Unit DAC.5 European Court of Auditors (Chamber II –Investment for cohesion, growth and inclusion) 2 EUROPEAN COMMISSION DIRECTORATES-GENERAL EMPLOYMENT, SOCIAL AFFAIRS AND INCLUSION REGIONAL AND URBAN POLICY Joint Audit Directorate for Cohesion – DAC.5 - Audit V Brussels, EMPL.REGIO.DAC.5 FINAL AUDIT REPORT Audit No. DAC514EE1363 ENQUIRY: Review of the work of audit authorities / Compliance Audits (2014-2020) FUND(S): CF 2014, ERDF 2014 and ESF 2014 MEMBER STATE: Estonia OPERATIONAL PROGRAMME: 2014EE16M3OP001 - Ühtekuuluvuspoliitika fondide rakenduskava 2014-2020 KEY REQUIREMENTS AUDITED: KR16: Adequate audits of operations KR18: Adequate procedures for providing reliable audit opinion and for preparing the annual control report AUTHORITIES AUDITED: AA - Ministry of Finance ADDRESSEES OF THE REPORT: Head of the audit authority DATE OF AUDIT: 19/04/2022 - 26/04/2022 DG/UNIT CHEF DE FILE: DAC.5 PRINCIPAL AUDITOR: Milan Kovacs ASSOCIATED AUDITORS: Hatem Soua Peter Marosvari Beatrice Stanciu EXTERNAL FIRM: No Please treat this report and its annexes as confidential until the follow-up procedure has been closed. If the whole or part of the report is transmitted to persons/entities concerned by this procedure to enable them to provide comments, please provide them with the same instruction. 3 Table of Contents LIST OF ACRONYMS ....................................................................................................... 5 1. LEGAL BASIS ............................................................................................................ 6 2. OBJECTIVES ............................................................................................................. 6 3. AUDIT SCOPE ........................................................................................................... 7 4. APPROACH ................................................................................................................ 8 5. FINDINGS AND ACTIONS TO BE TAKEN/ RECOMMENDATIONS................. 9 SYSTEM FINDINGS.................................................................................................. 9 EXCESSIVE PROCEDURES AND RULES WHICH CONSTITUTE ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN ............................................................................... 12 RELIABILITY OF PERFORMANCE DATA (SYSTEM LEVEL) ........................ 12 PROJECT FINDINGS .............................................................................................. 12 RELIABILITY OF PERFORMANCE DATA (PROJECT LEVEL) ....................... 15 6. AUDIT CONCLUSIONS AND AUDIT OPINION ................................................. 15 AUDIT CONCLUSIONS ...................................................................................... 15 6.2 AUDIT OPINION ................................................................................................ 16 ANNEX I - IMPORTANCE OF RECOMMENDATIONS .............................................. 18 ANNEX II – SUMMARY OF AA AND EC AUDIT RESULTS PER OPERATION AUDITED.......................................................................................... 19 ANNEX III - SUMMARY OF FINANCIAL CORRECTIONS ACCEPTED BY THE MEMBER STATE ........................................................................................... 21 4 LIST OF ACRONYMS AA Audit authority AAR Annual Activity Report AC Assessment Criteria CA Certifying authority CPR Regulation (EU) No 1303/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 December 2013 EC European Commission ECA European Court of Auditors ECJ European Court of Justice EMPL Directorate – General Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion EPSA Early Preventive System Audit ERDF European Regional Development Fund ESF European Social Fund EU European Union FEAD Fund for European Aid to the Most Deprived IB Intermediate Body KR Key Requirement MA Managing authority MS Member State MCS Management and Control System OP Operational Programme REGIO Directorate – General for Regional and Urban Policy of the European Commission SGEI Services General Economic Interest TER Total Error Rate RTER Total Residual Error Rate 5 1. LEGAL BASIS The legal basis for the Commission audits in the Member States in relation to structural and investment actions expenditure is provided by Articles 75 (1) and (2) of Regulation (EU) 1303/2013. This provision sets out the Commission powers and responsibilities under shared management. 2. OBJECTIVES The audit was performed in the context of the Enquiry Planning Memorandum 'Review of the work of audit authorities / Compliance Audits 2014 - 2020'. The overall objective of the enquiry is to seek, via review of the work of the audit authority, reasonable assurance that no serious deficiency in the management and control system1 remains undetected, unreported and therefore uncorrected once the accounts have been submitted to the Commission services. In order to reach this overall objective, the audit work carried out under this enquiry aims at:  obtaining reasonable assurance that the work carried out by the audit authority (together with the work carried out by other audit bodies on which the audit authority places reliance, if applicable) is compliant with the requirements of the CPR, in particular its Article 127  and consequently, assessing the degree of reliance to be placed on the results of audit authority's audit work presented in the annual control reports and annual opinions, as part of the overall assurance for the AAR, in particular on the functioning of systems, the legality and regularity of expenditure and the reliability of performance indicators. Indirectly, through the re-performance of audits of operations the Commission auditors are also able to conclude on serious weaknesses affecting the effective functioning of KR4 (management verifications). The specific objectives of this audit are:  (KR 16): to verify, on the basis of a sample of audits of operations, whether the AA’s methodology is in line with applicable regulations (namely the CPR and Implementing Regulations), follows the relevant Commission's guidance, provides for selection of a proper sample of operations to be audited and provides for sufficient coverage of all the legality and regularity aspects of the operation (eligibility, public procurement, reality of expenditure, etc.).  (KR 16): to assess whether the AA’s methodology was correctly applied and the audit strategy was complied with. 1 The key requirements of the management and control system and their assessment criteria are further explained in the Guidance for the Commission and Member States on a common methodology for the assessment of management and control systems in the Member States (EGESIF EGESIF_14-0010 of 18/12/2014). 6  (KR 16): to conclude on the quality and the reliability of the audit work, its compliance with international auditing standards, including sufficient audit trail of the work carried out.  (KR 18): to verify that the conclusions reached by the AA and disclosed in the ACR and in the audit opinion are based on sufficient audit work (systems audits, audits of operations, audits of accounts) and can be relied upon Additionally, the auditors aimed at identifying "processes and procedures which constitute excess administrative burden and cost, or can be simplified without undermining the overall assurance and effectiveness of the management and control system"2. 3. AUDIT SCOPE The audit focused on audit work performed by the audit authority as defined in Article 127 of Regulation (EC) No. 1303/2013. In particular, following key requirements were covered by the audit on the spot: 1. KR 16: Adequate audits of operations 2. KR18: Adequate procedures for providing reliable audit opinion and for preparing the annual control report The audit work carried out included: 1) The review of the audit authority's methodology in relation to the above mentioned key requirements; 2) The review of the audit authority's working papers from 8 selected audits of operations carried out on the expenditure declared to the Commission in the accounting year [1/7/2020 – 30/6/2021 (list of audited operations is provided below); 3) The re-performance of 8 selected audits of operations. The audit work was carried out at the level of the audit authority. The following operations audit files were subject to the audit: No Expenditure Project/operation Project/operation Fund Beneficiary declared to the code name EC 1 2014-2020.5.04.18- Modernisation of the ERDF City of Viljandi 96,738.00 0304 public space of the Viljandi City Centre 2 2014-2020.6.01.19- Reconstruction of CF City of Pärnu, 270,237.61 0507 apartment building at Oja tn 37 Oja tn 37, city of Pärnu apartment associations 2 Cf. point 26 of the " Council Conclusions on the implementation challenges of the cohesion policy 2014-2020" – 9622/1/15 REV 1 – 23 June 2015 7 3 2014-2020.4.02.16- Startup Estonia 2016 ERDF KredEx 376,632.20 0049 4 2014-2020.12.01.003. Institutional and ESF Ministry of 89,537.93 01.15-0002 organisational capacity Finance building 5 2014-2020.2.02.001. Welfare services to ESF Ministry of 245,237.40 01.15-0002 support labour market Social Affairs participation 6 2014-2020.2.04.19- Modernisation of the ERDF East-Viru 1,232,929.63 0085 central hospital Central Hospital infrastructure in the risk area 7 2014-2020.10.01-01- State Road 4 (E67) CF Transport 1,804,506.22 0044 Tallinn — Pärnu — Authority Ikla Kernu bypass 8 2014-2020.10.01.003. Improvement of the CF As Tallinna 3,213,786.33 01.15-0020 environmental status of Airport the air traffic area of Tallinn Airport and improvement of aviation safety The operations subject to re-performance audit were selected from the sample of 42 operations audited by the audit authority (out of a total population of 7598 operations) for the accounting period 2020-2021. The AA applied one-period standard MUS methodology. The AA’s sample, covered 6% of the overall population (i.e. positive expenditure declared for the accounting year 2020-2021) and 4.63 % of the auditable population upon application of the article 148 of CPR. The Commission carried out a re-performance audit for 8 operations. These operations cover 20.8% of the value of the AA’s sample and 1.2% of the overall population (positive expenditure declared for the accounting year 2020-2021). The EC sample was selected taking into account the different priority axes/measures, amounts of the expenditure certified, type of beneficiary and operations in order to obtain an adequate coverage of operations for the audit re-performance. 4. APPROACH The audit work was carried out in accordance with the methodology (including standard checklists) set out in the above-mentioned Enquiry Planning Memorandum. After finalising the on-the spot work the EC auditors requested additional clarifications to the national authorities on 26 April and received a complete reply on 24 May. Therefore, the reporting deadline of Article 75.2.(a) is extended by 26 days. The audit was performed in line with ISSAI 4000 (compliance audit standard from INTOSAI)3. 3 This standard is available here: https://www.issai.org/pronouncements/issai-4000-compliance-audit- standard/ 8 5. FINDINGS AND ACTIONS TO BE TAKEN/ RECOMMENDATIONS SYSTEM FINDINGS Finding 01 Key requirement: KR16 - Adequate audits of operations Assessment criteria: AC 16.6 Shortcomings in the documentation of the audit authority’s work The Commission auditors identified several shortcomings concerning the documentation of the AA for its audits of operations. In particular, the following issues were noted: 1. Improvements in AA's checklists needed In several cases, but particularly for the project 2014-2020.4.02.16-0049 Startup Estonia, the AA’s replies in the checklists were either lacking of explanations of the assessment of each question or only references to supporting documents were given with no comments on what has actually been checked or without justification of the auditor’s reply. 2. Incomplete audit trail and justification of proposed financial corrections According to ISSAI 1230 (audit documentation), “the audit documentation should be prepared in a way that is sufficient to enable an experienced auditor, having no previous connection with the audit, to understand significant matters arising during the audit, the conclusions reached thereon, and significant professional judgments made in reaching those conclusions.” Several other audit standards also further refer to the audit evidence and audit trail. a) The Commission auditors noted incomplete audit trail for the audited operations with respect to various versions of the draft and final audit reports. For example, for operation 2014-2020.4.02.16-0049 Startup Estonia, the documentation of the AA does not allow an external reviewer properly retracing the work carried out and reach the same conclusions as those drawn by the AA. In particular, no documentation was available on the contradictory procedure when discussions of applicable correction rate are held with the MA/IB. The Commission auditors identified lack of justification for the applied financial correction rate and no reference to legal grounds for the rate in the audit report. b) With respect to project 2014-2020.6.01.19-0507 Reconstruction of apartment building at Oja tn 37, city of Pärnu, the version of the draft audit report of 14.10.2021 states: Since the contract has been carried out in the public procurement register, we consider it appropriate to apply a financial correction rate of 5 % to the contract in the event of a given infringement. In the opinion of the auditors, a correction rate of 1 % cannot be applied due to a number of non-compliances. As a result of the weaknesses identified, 5 % of the eligible costs of EUR 669 700.26, or EUR 33 485.01, included in the project are ineligible. While the draft’s version of 23.11.2021 deems appropriate a correction of 1%, with the following justification: With regard to the shortcomings described in the finding, the auditors consider that the circumstances referred to in Paragraph 21(2) of Regulation No 143 of 1 September 2014 (hereinafter ‘the Omnibus Regulation’), which have the effect of 9 reducing the aid granted to the contract by 10 % if the beneficiary or partner which is not a contracting authority within the meaning of the Law on public procurement has failed to fulfil the obligation referred to in Paragraph 26(6) of the Law on structural aid. Depending on the seriousness of the infringement, a financial correction rate of 1 %, 5 %, 25 % or 50 % may be applied. Since the contract was carried out in the register of public contracts, we consider that it is appropriate to apply a financial correction rate of 1 % to the contract in the event of a failure to fulfil obligations, with regard to the rejection of an incomplete tender from the two tenders received. As a result of the weaknesses identified, 1 % of the eligible costs of EUR 669 700.26 or EUR 6 697.01 included in the project are ineligible. Firstly, the AA does not explains the professional reasoning and path followed to decide on the applicable level of correction, neither for the initial proposed of 5% nor the final one of 1%. Secondly, in the opinion of the EC auditors, the AA does not provide sufficient explanation on the reason for decreasing the proposed financial correction. Action to be taken/recommendation Recommendation 01.01 The audit authority should improve its procedures to thoroughly document the audit steps followed and the subsequent reviews performed. The audit authority is requested to clearly describe in the audit checklists the verifications performed, as well as make reference to the pertinent analysed documentation and / or the applicable legislation. The audit authority is requested to improve the quality of the audit reports as well as of the documentation and working papers so that they contain sufficient information to enable an experienced auditor, having no previous connection with the engagement, to understand the nature, timing, extent, and results of the procedures performed, evidence obtained, and conclusions reached, and comply with internationally accepted auditing standards, in particular ISA 1230, specifically relating to determination of the applicable error rate for particular finding. Importance: Important Body responsible: AA - Ministry of Finance Deadline for implementation: 2 months. Position of the Member State: Recommendation 01.01: Accepted The AA has analysed the circumstances in the finding and amended its methodology accordingly. The methodology was complemented with the requirement that the applied correction rate must be thoroughly justified both in the working papers and in the audit report. The changes/additions of the audit methodology were presented to the AA auditors, and it will be ensured that all audit steps are thoroughly documented henceforward. 10 Conclusion of the Commission: The recommendation 01.01 is Closed The Commission services acknowledge the actions taken and close the finding. Finding 02 Key requirement: KR16 - Adequate audits of operations Assessment criteria: AC 16.6 Shortcomings in the public procurement checklist of the audit authority The Commission auditors identified the following shortcomings in the public procurement checklist of the AA: 1. Preliminary market consultations The AA checklist did not contain any specific questions concerning preliminary market consultations implemented by the contracting authority (in accordance with Article 40 of Directive 2014/24/EU) and whether such consultation – in case they have been carried put -adequately respected the principles of equal treatment, transparency and non- discrimination. 2. Remedies Similarly, no specific questions have been identified as to whether – in relation to the procedure audited – any tenderer submitted a complaint or appeal to the contracting authority/other relevant bodies and whether the final decision concluding these appeals is in line with the legal framework established by the Directives. Action to be taken/recommendation Recommendation 02.01 The audit authority is requested to complement its public procurement verification checklists with the points identified in the finding, notably with questions linked to the preliminary market consultation and on appropriate remedy processes. Importance: Important Body responsible: AA - Ministry of Finance Deadline for implementation: 2 months. Position of the Member State: Recommendation 02.01: Partially Accepted 11 AA partially agrees with the finding and recommendation made. It is explained that the public procurement verification checklist was complemented in line with the recommendation and questions were added related to the preliminary market consultations. The public procurement checklist will be further extended with question whether any tenderer submitted a complaint or appeal in relation to the audited procurement. The AA further explained that in Estonia a tenderer, candidate or economic operator interested in participating in public procurement may contest actions of the contracting authority by filing a respective request for review with the Review Committee. Public Procurement Review Committee operating at the Ministry of Finance is an extrajudicial body for settling disputes that carries out the review procedure set out in the Procurement Act according to the grounds and the procedure set out in the law. During the audit the AA takes into account and analyse the circumstances stated in the submitted complaint, but it does not assess whether the final decision of Public Procurement Review Committee is in line with the legal framework established by Directives. Conclusion of the Commission: The recommendation 02.01 is Closed The Commission services acknowledge the actions taken by the AA and take note of the information provided on the appeal system. Thereby the finding is closed. EXCESSIVE PROCEDURES AND RULES WHICH CONSTITUTE ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN The issue of excessive procedures and rules constituting administrative burden is adequately covered by the AA. In addition, the auditors have not identified any further procedures and rules in this respect. RELIABILITY OF PERFORMANCE DATA (SYSTEM LEVEL) The Commission auditors have not identified any deficiencies in the methodology and work of the AA in relation to performance data reliability. PROJECT FINDINGS Finding 03 Category: Public Procurement - Contract notice and tender specifications Sub-category: Insufficient definition of the subject-matter of the contract Project code and name: 2014-2020.6.01.19-0507 - Korterelamu rekonstrueerimine aadressil Oja tn 37, Pärnu linn Incorrect quantification of public procurement error - project 2014-2020.6.01.19-0507 Reconstruction of apartment building at Oja tn 37, city of Pärnu 12 The AA proposes in its audit report related to the above mentioned operation a financial correction of 1%, in compliance with the national rules as stated in Regulation No 143 of 1 September 2014 for the following non-compliances: a) Negotiations with the successful tenderer leading to a change in the subject-matter of the contract, while, according to the tender notice, it was permissible to negotiate the price and the time-limit for the performance of the contract. As a result of the negotiations, the successful tenderer has submitted a new price offer which has reduced prices than the initially contracted once and cancelled part of the initial contractual works; b) The contracting authority has not requested the guarantee provided for in the tender documents for the duration of the works at the moment of the signature of the contract. After analysing the two non-compliance cases detected, the tender documentation and the arguments presented during the contradictory procedure with the MA/IB, the Commission auditors consider that the description in the contract notice and the tender specifications is insufficient in a way that may result in unequal treatment between tenderers. With respect to first non-compliance, the Commission’s auditors are aware that the beneficiary is not a contracting authority as defined by the directives for public procurement and that it complied with national applicable rules for private entities receiving financial support from ESI Funds. In addition, the national auditors acknowledged in their report that it was not clearly regulated for non-contracting authorities whether and to what extent negotiations may be conducted, and that according to the national legislation, any contracting authority can enter into negotiation to modify the contract by up to 15 % if the general nature of the contract, such as the subject matter’s one, is not altered. Moreover, according to arguments presented by the beneficiary concerning the exclusion of the abnormal tender, it was evidenced that the two offers were not always covering the same budget items and the AA auditors could identify some works which had to be cancelled from the winning offer. With respect to second non-compliance, the AA stressed out in its report that the paragraph concerning the guarantee requirement is worded in such a way that the tenderer was not in a position to determine whether and when it is required to provide the contracting authority with those documents. In the opinion of the national auditors, the requirements must be written in tender documentation in such a way that all bidders can understand them unambiguously. The Commission’s auditors agree with the national auditors on the nature of the non- compliances detected and acknowledge that the contract under question is regulated by the national legislation, nevertheless disagree with the level of financial correction proposed by the national audit report (flat rate 1%) as the procurement procedure carried out failed to ensure fair and equal treatment between the tenderers resulting from the insufficient clarity in the contract notice and the tender specifications. Action to be taken/recommendation Recommendation 03.01 a) Having in view that the description in the contract notice and the tender specifications was insufficient leading to unequal treatment between tenderers, a 10% financial correction should be applied in compliance with the Commission Decision [C(2019) 3452 final] laying down the guidelines for determining financial corrections to be made 13 to expenditure financed by the Union for non-compliance with the applicable rules on public procurement of 14.5.2019, irregularity type nr. 12 of the Annex 1. b) The AA is requested to recalculate the TER and RTER by taking into account the value of the new financial correction. Adequate corrections should be made in order to ensure the RTER below the materiality level, if applicable. Importance: Very Important Body responsible: AA - Ministry of Finance Deadline for implementation: 2 months. Recommendation 03.02 The AA should assess the adequacy and compliance with the EU rules for all cases where a flat rate of 1% or 5% was used and provide information to the Commission on the measures undertaken. Importance: Very Important Body responsible: AA - Ministry of Finance Deadline for implementation: 2 months. Position of the Member State: Recommendation 03.01: Accepted AA agrees with the finding and recommendation made. The level of financial correction for the contract concerned will be adjusted in line with applicable correction rate in line as per the Commission Decision [C(2019) 3452 final laying down the guidelines for determining financial corrections for non-compliance with the applicable rules on public procurement]. The AA has also recalculated the TER and RTER by taking into account the value of the new financial correction. Recommendation 03.02: Accepted The AA informed that the flat rates used for financial corrections have been duly assessed and non-compliance cases – similar to the ones identified in the current finding – have not been detected. Conclusion of the Commission: The recommendation 03.01 is Closed 14 The Commission services acknowledge the acceptance of the financial correction by the AA and also agree with the recalculated the error rates (final TER at 1.67% and RTER 1.63%). Thereby the finding is closed. The recommendation 03.02 is Closed The Commission services acknowledge the actions taken by the AA and take note of the information provided on the result of the review. Thereby the finding is closed. RELIABILITY OF PERFORMANCE DATA (PROJECT LEVEL) The auditors have not identified any issues in the performance data reported for the audited projects. 6. AUDIT CONCLUSIONS AND AUDIT OPINION AUDIT CONCLUSIONS Based on the audit work carried out as described in section 3, the audited part of the management and control system is provisionally assessed in Category 2 "Works, but some improvement(s) are needed "of the Guidance on a common methodology for the assessment of management and control systems in the Member States 2014-2020 programming period4. Preliminary assessment of the audited key requirements is as follows: Audited KR16 KR18 KRs Category 2 2 4 Cf. Annex IV of Regulation (EU) No 480/2014 [if applicable] Category 1. Works well. No or only minor improvement(s) needed. There are no deficiencies or only minor deficiencies found. These deficiencies have no, or minor impact on the functioning of the assessed key requirements / authorities / system. [if applicable] Category 2. Works, but some improvement(s) are needed. Some deficiencies were found. These deficiencies have a moderate impact on the functioning of the assessed key requirements / authorities / system. Recommendations have been formulated for implementation by the audited body. [if applicable] Category 3. Works partially; substantial improvement(s) are needed. Serious deficiencies were found that expose the Funds to irregularities. The impact on the effective functioning of the key requirements / authorities / system is significant. [if applicable] Category 4. Essentially does not work. Numerous serious and/or wide-ranging deficiencies were found which expose the Funds to irregularities. The impact on the effective functioning of the assessed key requirements/ authorities/ system is significant – the assessed key requirements/ authorities/ system function poorly or do not function at all. 15 In addition, taking into account the preliminary finding(s) described in section 5, the total error rate and residual total error rate for the expenditure certified in the accounting year 01/07/2020 – 30/06/2021 as reported by the audit authority in the annual control report submitted on 1 March 2022 is recalculated by the Commission auditors as follows: Audit European Commission authority Based on desk review of the assurance Based on package (Ares(2022)3100797) compliance audit5 Total error rate (TER) 1.66% 1.43% 1.67% Residual total error rate 1.62% 1.38% 1.63% (RTER) 6.2 AUDIT OPINION Qualified Opinion: Based on the audit work performed as described in chapter 3 (Scope) of the audit report, the Commission auditors have obtained reasonable assurance that the work carried out by the audit authority is compliant with the requirements of Article 127 Regulation (EU) 1303/2013 in particular with regard to KR 16 and KR 18 and the Commission thus can place reliance on the results of the audit work presented by the audit authority in its annual control report and audit opinion except for the following aspects related to the functioning of the management and control system under KR 16 and KR 18:  The audit authority should improve its procedures to thoroughly document the audit steps followed and the subsequent reviews performed in particular reference to the pertinent analysed documentation and / or the applicable legislation should be added.  The audit authority should complement its public procurement verification checklists with questions linked to the preliminary market consultation and on appropriate remedy processes.  The audit authority should improve its processes so that the financial corrections proposed for public procurement related irregularities are in compliance with the relevant EC recommendations. It is estimated that the impact of the qualification(s) is limited. 5 As the Commission services have not re-performed the entire sample of the audit authority, the figure reported is the re-calculated TER of at least the percentage disclosed. 16 Signatures of the EC audit team Electronically signed Electronically signed Milan Kovacs Hatem Soua Peter Marosvari Beatrice Stanciu (Principal auditor) (Associated auditor) Electronically signed Electronically signed Milan Kovacs Cendrine De Buggenoms Head of sector Head of unit 17 ANNEX I - IMPORTANCE OF RECOMMENDATIONS System findings Critical: Corrective action is needed to address a fundamental weakness in key controls, which puts in question the reliability of the whole or part of the management and control systems, and has led or may lead to widespread irregularities. There is a substantial risk to the reliability of (financial and other) reporting for the programme, the effectiveness and efficiency of the operations and activities and the compliance with national and EU regulations. Very Important: Corrective action is needed to address a significant weakness in key controls, affecting the reliability of a significant part of the management and control systems, which has led or may lead to irregularities. There is a high risk to the reliability of (financial and other) reporting for parts of the programme, the effectiveness and efficiency of some of the operations and activities and/or the compliance with national and EU regulations. Important: Corrective action is needed to address a weakness or deficiency in the management and control systems, which has a moderate impact at the programme level but which, combined with other weaknesses, may lead to irregularities. Improved controls would benefit the implementation of the programme and/or allow for greater effectiveness and/or efficiency. Project findings Critical: Corrective action is needed to address a serious irregularity (including irregularity of systemic nature) with high financial impact. Very Important: Corrective action is needed to address an irregularity with medium financial impact. Important: Corrective action is needed to address a weakness or an irregularity with no or limited (potential) financial impact 18 ANNEX II – SUMMARY OF AA AND EC AUDIT RESULTS PER OPERATION AUDITED Operations/ AA reported results EC results from re-performance Deviation Projects Number of detected Number of detected Amount of error and Amount of error and Project Number/ Title irregularities/ nature irregularities/ nature yes/no* level of error in % level of error in % etc. etc. 2014-2020.5.04.18-0304/ - - - - Modernisation of the public Operation 1 no space of the Viljandi City Centre 2014-2020.6.01.19-0507/ EUR 2 511.38/ 0.93% 1/ incompliance with EUR 25 114/ 9.29% 1/ incompliance with yes Reconstruction of apartment public procurement public procurement Operation 2 building at Oja tn 37, city of rules rules Pärnu 2014-2020.4.02.16-0049/ EUR 10 583.7505/ 5/ *incompliance with EUR 10 583.7505/ 5/ *incompliance with no Startup Estonia 2016 2.86% public procurement 2.86% public procurement rules, *incorrect rules, *incorrect salary Operation 3 salary calculation, calculation, *double *double financing of financing of asset asset purchase purchase 2014-2020.12.01.003. 01.15- - - - - no 0002/ Institutional and Operation 4 organisational capacity building 2014-2020.2.02.001. 01.15- - - - - no 0002/ Welfare services to Operation 5 support labour market participation 2014-2020.2.04.19-0085/ EUR 123 292.96/ 10% 2/ incompliance with EUR 123 292.96/ 10% 2/ incompliance with no Modernisation of the central public procurement public procurement Operation 6 hospital infrastructure in the rules rules risk area 19 2014-2020.10.01-01-0044/ - - - - no Operation 7 State Road 4 (E67) Tallinn — Pärnu — Ikla Kernu bypass 2014-2020.10.01.003. 01.15- - - - - no 0020/ Improvement of the environmental status of the air Operation 8 traffic area of Tallinn Airport and improvement of aviation safety Number of operations with deviations/number of audited operations: 12.5% (1/8) Total amount Total amount of error Total amount of error Difference (in %): EUR 7 637 256.06 EUR 136 388.09 EUR 158 990 audited: by AA: by EC 17% TER/RTER reported originally by AA: 1.66% / 1.61% Difference (in TER/RTER TER/RTER calculated TER/RTER 1.66 %/ 1.61% 1.67% / 1.63% percentage points): recalculated by COM by EC: 0.24% 0.25% after the assessment of 1.43% / 1.38% the assurance package: * “yes” if any additional issues were detected by the EC auditors (both with and without an impact on the error rate for the operation as reported by the AA). 20 ANNEX III - SUMMARY OF FINANCIAL CORRECTIONS ACCEPTED BY THE MEMBER STATE The amounts indicated in the table below are estimated based on the information available [at the time of the audit/during the follow up procedure etc.]. The Member State is requested to verify these amounts and if necessary amend according to the exact amount of expenditure declared to the Commission in relation to the irregularities in question. Finding N° Project Amount of irregular Fund % Rate of EU expenditure % Financial Amount of /operation expenditure in EUR assistance7 correction financial N° (Basis for calculation correction in of financial EUR correction)6 (a) (b) c=(a*b) (d) e=(c*d) 3 2014- 669 700* ERDF 85% 569 245 10% 56 924 2020.6.01.19- 0507/ Reconstruction of apartment building at Oja tn 37, city of Pärnu TOTAL 669 700 569 245 56 924 *calculated on the basis of the full contract amount (10% instead of the 1% proposed by the AA) not on the basis of the amount audited by the AA for the ACR at hand. The total error in the payment claim audited amounts to EUR 25 114. 6 Amount of ineligible expenditure declared to the Commission 7 Co-financing rate of the relevant priority axis 21 Electronically signed on 08/03/2023 12:28 (UTC+01) in accordance with Article 11 of Commission Decision (EU) 2021/2121 Saatja: EC DAC5 SECRETARIAT <[email protected]> Saadetud: 08.03.2023 15:28 Adressaat: <"RAM Info">; <"Kaur Siruli"> Koopia: (European Court of Auditors (Chamber II – Investment for cohesion, growth and inclusion)) <ECA-ETE-COMMISSION-AUDIT- [email protected]>; (Permanent Representation of Estonia = Représentation permanente de l'Estonie) <[email protected]>; ORAV Aivo (Permanent Representation of Estonia = Représentation permanente de l'Estonie) <[email protected]> Teema: MAPAR Audit DAC514EE1363 CCI 2014EE16M3OP001 Ühtekuuluvuspoliitika fondide rakenduskava 2014-2020 - Compliance Audits (2014-2020) - Final Report - Ares(2023)1681292 Manused: Cover letter +Final Report.pdf Please find attached document Ares(2023)1681292 from Franck SÉBERT (DAC) dated 08/03/2023. Please note that no paper copy will follow. For any questions/comments, please send an email to: [email protected] Best regards, Unit DAC5 DAC – Joint Audit Directorate for Cohesion policy DG Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion DG Regional and Urban Policy
Allikas: Rahandusministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel