Ref. Ares(2023)2146053 - 24/03/2023
European
Commission
ELISA FERREIRA Rue de la Loi, 200
MEMBER OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION B-1049 Brussels
Tel. +32-2 295 10 50
COHESION AND REFORMS
Elisa. Ferreira@ec europa.eu
Brussels, 24, 03, 2023
Ares(2023)3044554
Dear Ministers,
I thank you for your letter of 1 March 2023 (ref. 9.2-4.3/21-27/01/1544-1) concerning the
European Commission’s decision C(2019)3452 of 14.5.2018 laying down the guidelines for
determining financial corrections to be made to expenditure financed by the Union for non-
compliance with the applicable rules on public procurement. In this letter you refer in
particular to the application of financial corrections based on these guidelines in case of
beneficiaries who are not public sector procurers.
As indicated in these Commission guidelines, the purpose of this document is, among others,
to promote the consistency of the treatment of public procurement errors among the
Commission services in accordance with the principle of equal treatment. As Member States
are responsible, in first instance, for detecting and auditing irregularities and for implementing
the required financial corrections, it is recommended to the competent national authorities to
apply the criteria and financial correction rates set out in the guidelines whenever correcting
irregularities detected by competent services.
Where the EU-directives on public procurement do not apply, as indicated in section 1.2.2 of
the guidelines, the guidelines are equally applicable if there is a certain cross border interest
or if there is a clear breach of the national public procurement law for the contract at stake.
The guidelines also apply if the national rules explicitly require the beneficiaries of EU funds
to comply with national public procurement rules or similar rules, even if those beneficiaries
are not themselves contracting authorities as defined in the directives mentioned. In addition
they may also apply when a beneficiary who prima facie is not subject to public procurement
Ms Annely Akkermann
Minister of Finance
[email protected]
Ms Riina Solman
Minister of Public Administration ’h /
[email protected] [ /
rules based on the EU or national public procurement legislation, is required to comply with
the procurement rules based on the provisions/procedures applicable to the programme (e.g.
such an obligation may be included in the call, grant agreement, national or programme
specific eligibility rules).
Under the Directives, even if the beneficiary is not a public body, it may be subject to the
directives or the national public procurement law based on the public procurement provisions.
This applies e.g. in accordance with Article 13 of Directive 2014/24/EU to contracts which
are subsidised directly by contracting authorities by more than 50 % and the estimated value
of which is above specific thresholds.
I sincerely hope that this reply helps answer your questions. My colleagues in the Joint Audit
Directorate for Cohesion (DAC) remain at the disposal of your services for any further
clarifications needed.
Yours faithfully,
■sa FERREIRA
Electronically signed on 24/03/2023 11:00 (UTC+01) in accordance with Article 11 of Commission Decision (EU) 2021/2121
Saatja: PEIXOTO Lidia (VDL-CA-17) <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 24.03.2023 14:16
Adressaat: <"RAM Info">; SOLMAN Riina (GOVERNMENT OF ESTONIA)
<
[email protected]>
Teema: R/: Call to review corrections on irregularities to non-procurers
- Ares(2023)2146053
Manused: Ares(2023)3044554 Reply_Call to review corrections on
irregularities to non-procurers.pdf
Dear Madam, dear Sir,
Please find attached a letter from Commissioner Elisa Ferreira on the
above
mentioned subject.
With kind regards,
Cabinet of Commissioner Elisa Ferreira