Ref. Ares(2017)5943270 - 05/12/2017
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Research Executive Agency
B3 Unit
Head of Unit
Brussels,
Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY
AALBORG UNIVERSITET
FREDRIK BAJERS VEJ 5
9220 AALBORG
DENMARK
Subject: Horizon 2020 Framework Programme
Call for proposals: H2020-SC6-CULT-COOP-2016-2017 (H2020-SC6-CULT-
COOP-2017-two-stage)
Proposal: 770504 — PERICLES
Evaluation result letter — GAP invitation letter
Dear Madam/Sir,
I am writing in connection with your proposal for the above-mentioned call.
Having completed the evaluation, we are pleased to inform you that your proposal has passed this
phase and that the Agency would now like to start grant preparation.
Please find enclosed the evaluation summary report (ESR) for both stages of the evaluation, based on
the comments and opinion of the experts that evaluated the proposal for the Agency.
Please be aware that there may be differences between the ESRs, since stage 1 evaluations are done
on the outline of your proposal while stage 2 evaluations cover the full proposal.
Invitation to grant preparation
Grant preparation will be based on the following:
1. Proposal: 770504 — PERICLES
2. Topic: CULT-COOP-07-2017 — Cultural heritage of European coastal and maritime regions
3. Type of action: Research and Innovation action
4. Project officer: Ellen SCHRAUDOLPH
[email protected]
+32 22953447
Inclusive, Innovative and Reflective Societies
Please always use the Participant Portal messaging function (via your
1
Participant Portal account). Do NOT contact the project officer via other means (e-mail, letter,
etc) — unless explicitly asked to do so.
5. Maximum grant amount:
Requested EU contribution (according to proposal): 2,498,998.75 EUR
Maximum grant amount (proposed amount, after evaluation): 2,498,998.75 EUR
6. Duration of the action: 36 months
7. Action & budget:
The description of the action (DoA) (Annex 1 to the grant agreement) and the estimated
budget for the action (Annex 2 to the grant agreement) must be based on the proposal
submitted.
Please be aware that you may have to change your ‘description of the action’, in order to
address ethics and security issues.
Please note that you may normally NOT make changes to the project/project budget/
consortium composition (including linked third parties). Please immediately inform the project
officer (see above), if you need to make a change (e.g. because one of the consortium members
went bankrupt and can no longer participate).
8. Timetable & deadlines for grant preparation
Submission of grant data & annexes: 3 weeks after receiving this letter
Once the Agency has checked the information you have encoded, you will have 2 weeks to
submit your final version — to bring it in line with the comments of the project officer.
Signature of the declaration of honour (DoH): 6 weeks after receiving this letter
Grant signature: within 3 months after receiving this letter (indicative date).
Please note that repeated failure to respect deadlines may lead to the rejection of the
partner/proposal. (Lack of cooperation during grant preparation will be taken to mean that
you are no longer interested in the grant).
9. Fully electronic grant preparation via the Participant Portal
Please use your Participant Portal account to prepare your grant (including signature of the
agreement). Do NOT contact the Agency via other means (e-mail, letter, etc) — unless
explicitly asked to do so.
Please be aware that all linked third parties (that are part of your proposal) must be registered
and validated as legal entities in the Participant Portal Beneficiary Register.
Register them immediately, if not already done.
Please note that some of your legal and financial data in the Beneficiary Register is ‘read-
only’ and can be updated only by your LEAR (via your Participant Portal account on the
2
My Organisation(s) page). During grant preparation, you will therefore be asked to appoint
a LEAR.
Please note that the data (from your proposal, the Beneficiary Register or grant preparation)
may be used by the Agency for monitoring and statistical purposes.
10. Other information
Not applicable
For more information on grant preparation, see the Online Manual on the Participant Portal.
For British applicants: Please note that until the United Kingdom leaves the EU, EU law continues
to apply to and within the United Kingdom, when it comes to rights and obligations; this includes
the eligibility of United Kingdom legal entities to fully participate and receive funding in Horizon
2020 actions. Please be aware however that the eligibility criteria must be complied with for the entire
duration of the grant. If the United Kingdom withdraws from the EU during the grant period without
concluding an agreement with the EU ensuring in particular that British applicants continue to be
eligible, you will cease to be eligible to receive EU funding (while continuing, where possible, to
participate) or be required to leave the project on the basis of the termination provisions in the grant
agreement.
Please note that this letter does NOT constitute a formal commitment for funding. The final
decision by the Agency will only be taken at a later stage, since it depends on the finalisation of
grant preparation and the rest of the selection procedure (implying further checks, for instance, of
operational and financial capacity, non-exclusion, etc).
I would be grateful if you could inform the other members of your consortium of this letter.
For any questions, please contact the project officer via your Participant Portal account.
Yours faithfully,
Corinna AMTING
Head of Unit
Enclosures: Evaluation summary report (ESR)
3
Proposal Evaluation Form
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2017)5864162 - 30/11/2017
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Evaluation
Horizon 2020 - Research and Innovation Framework Programme
Summary Report -
Research and
innovation
actions/Innovation
actions
Call: H2020-SC6-CULT-COOP-2017-two-stage
Funding scheme: RIA
Proposal number: 770504-2
Proposal acronym: PERICLES
Duration (months): 36
PrEseRvIng and sustainably governing Cultural heritage and Landscapes in European coastal and maritime
Proposal title:
regionS
Activity: Budget split 1
Grant
N. Proposer name Country Total Cost % %
Requested
1 AALBORG UNIVERSITET DK 571,926.25 22.89% 571,926.25 22.89%
2 WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITY NL 469,385 18.78% 469,385 18.78%
3 UNIVERSITE DE BRETAGNE OCCIDENTALE FR 200,025 8.00% 200,025 8.00%
4 UNIVERSITY OF THE HIGHLANDS AND ISLANDS LBG UK 90,008.75 3.60% 90,008.75 3.60%
5 THE QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY OF BELFAST UK 296,971.25 11.88% 296,971.25 11.88%
6 UNIVERSIDADE DE AVEIRO PT 198,751.25 7.95% 198,751.25 7.95%
7 THE SCOTTISH ASSOCIATION FOR MARINESCIENCE LBG UK 381,056.25 15.25% 381,056.25 15.25%
8 Muinsuskaitseamet EE 155,000 6.20% 155,000 6.20%
9 Parc naturel régional du Golfe du Morbihan FR 70,000 2.80% 70,000 2.80%
10 ELLINIKOS GEORGIKOS ORGANISMOS - DIMITRA EL 65,875 2.64% 65,875 2.64%
Total: 2,498,998.75 2,498,998.75
Abstract:
PERICLES promotes sustainable governance of cultural heritage (CH) in European coastal and maritime regions through the development of a
theoretically grounded, multi-actor participatory framework. To meet this challenge, PERICLES has formed a strong interdisciplinary consortium
comprised of research institutions, regional government and heritage partners representing 15 different disciplines. PERICLES addresses the
following objectives: a) develop an in-depth, situated understanding of the CH of marine and coastal land/seascapes, including knowledge across
local, spatial, environmental, social and economic aspects; b), develop practical tools, based on stakeholder involvement and participatory
governance, for mapping, assessing and mitigating risks to CH and to enhance sustainable growth and increase employment by harnessing CH
assets; c), provide policy advice to improve integration of CH in key marine and environmental policies and the implementation of associated EU
directives; and d), develop effective knowledge exchange networks. To fulfill these objectives PERICLES uses a scientific approach guided by the
theories of: a) space, place, and identity; b) resilience and adaptation; and c) deliberative and participatory governance. We will apply a range of
participatory, deliberative and action research methods from the social sciences and arts directly involving decision-makers, stakeholders and the
public. PERICLES meets the needs of the work program by: contributing to European efforts to promote evidence-based research on the impact of
participatory approaches in CH policies and governance; using a multi- and transdisciplinary approach; addressing in/tangible CH in a
geographically balanced way; involving and developing CH networks of local stakeholders and policy makers; and contributing to improved
implementation of European policies on coastal zones and maritime areas and providing evidence on how to link environmental and cultural
policies.
Evaluation Summary Report
Evaluation Result
Total score: 14.50 (Threshold: 10)
Form information
SCORING
Scores must be in the range 0-5.
Interpretation of the score:
0– The proposal fails to address the criterion or cannot be assessed due to missing or incomplete information.
1– Poor. The criterion is inadequately addressed, or there are serious inherent weaknesses.
2– Fair. The proposal broadly addresses the criterion, but there are significant weaknesses.
3– Good. The proposal addresses the criterion well, but a number of shortcomings are present.
4– Very good. The proposal addresses the criterion very well, but a small number of shortcomings are present.
5– Excellent. The proposal successfully addresses all relevant aspects of the criterion.Any shortcomings are minor.
Criterion 1 - Excellence
770504-2/PERICLES-30/11/2017-11:26:56 1/3
Score: 5.00 (Threshold: 3/5.00 , Weight: -) Associated with document Ref. Ares(2017)5864162 - 30/11/2017
The following aspects will be taken into account, to the extent that the proposed work corresponds to the topic description in the
work programme:
Clarity and pertinence of the objectives
The proposal defines clear and well-formulated objectives. The objectives are pertinent to the major challenges and scope of the work
programme in addressing the need to strengthen resilience of European societies, provide a better understanding of Europe's diversity, and
the role of technology in promoting cultural heritage. These challenges are met in an excellent way through the proposal's focus on developing
a theoretically informed, multi-actor participatory framework that critically analyses governance practices and sets up a best-practice frame of
reference for the preservation of both tangible and intangible European coastal heritage. Further, the aim to bridge social and environmental
policies and highlight human-environment interactions, understood as integrated socio-ecological systems, is well explained and relevant to
meet the challenges. It is an important asset that relevant previous and ongoing EU-funded projects are taken into consideration in defining
the objectives.
Soundness of the concept, and credibility of the proposed methodology
The concept is sound and the proposal does an excellent job of framing the problem to be investigated, which is clearly embedded in a solid
intake of the cultural heritage literature, and by addressing pertinent concepts. The pillars around which the proposed research activities are
structured are described and analysed in a convincing manner.
The methodology is credible, with a focus on a participatory, multi-method and cross-disciplinary approach that is highly adapted to the
objectives. The case regions have a very good geographical distribution that enables comparison.
Extent that proposed work is beyond the state of the art, and demonstrates innovation potential (e.g. ground-breaking objectives,
novel concepts and approaches, new products, services or business and organisational models)
The proposal has a novel approach in how participation is understood, conceptualised and specified. The co-production of knowledge in
collaboration with stakeholders is in itself a progress beyond the state of the art. The combination of various methods represents a truly novel
approach. The proposed ecosystem management could lead to ground-breaking services and products. Individual case region demos are
relevant, and innovative tools to model particular coastal and maritime cultural heritage issues and their proposed comparison have the
potential to produce new services for the management of coastal areas.
Appropriate consideration of interdisciplinary approaches and, where relevant, use of stakeholder knowledge
The main aim as well as the specific objectives and expected impacts of the project are built on an interdisciplinary understanding that is well
justified. Social sciences and humanities as cross-cutting issues are integrated in an excellent way.
A particular strength of this proposal is the attention given to the involvement of stakeholders as co-producers and co-designers of knowledge,
including a special focus on the youth as stakeholders. Stakeholder involvement is very well explained and designed. The focus on third-order
goals for deliberations and social learning is a strong aspect. As follows, the framework and tools are very likely to be well received by
relevant stakeholders and of high relevance to the challenges of marine and coastal cultural heritage, even after the proposed research has
ended. Further, the commendable concern for the afterlife of the proposed research is also reflected in the weight put on network
establishment, including a wide range of stakeholders.
Criterion 2 -Impact
Score: 4.50 (Threshold: 3/5.00 , Weight: -)
The following aspects will be taken into account:
The extent to which the outputs of the project would contribute to each of the expected impacts mentioned in the work
programme under the relevant topic
The proposal demonstrates clearly how the proposed activities would lead to the expected impacts mentioned in the programme. Positive
effects are expected to be achieved in terms of knowledge-development on tangible and intangible heritage drawn from six regional seas.
Further, co-creation of relevant concepts to be used in participatory approach in order to feed European policies and governance is well
substantiated as an impact. The development of business activities in collaboration with SMEs, social enterprises and voluntary associations
is also a very likely impact. All of these expected impacts are carefully planned to be effective also after the duration of the project.
Of specific interest is the Impact Boards to be established in each study region to ensure the project develops in accordance with key
stakeholders' needs and thereby enhance the likelihood of significant impact. This a very promising, novel and commendable measure.
Any substantial impacts not mentioned in the work programme, that would enhance innovation capacity, create new market
opportunities, strengthen competitiveness and growth of companies, address issues related to climate change or the
environment, or bring other important benefits for society
One of the impacts not mentioned in the work programme is linked to the use and implementation of demos, thought of as tailor-made pilot
projects with implications across cultural, social, economic and policy dimensions, where the new tools, concepts and methodologies are put
into practice. This is likely to have a considerable impact at different levels in terms of network development, better understanding and
management of risks, and a better integration of cultural heritage into coastal management and climate change adaptation policy.
Quality of the proposed measures to:
- exploit and disseminate the project results (including management of IPR), and to manage research data where relevant
- communicate the project activities to different target audiences
The proposed measures to exploit and disseminate the project's results are well selected and relevant for the project. However, a minor
shortcoming is that the proposal does not put sufficient weight on publishing insights regarding the implementation of the stakeholder
approach to the scientific community.
The dissemination channels and the disseminated information are designed carefully to reach different target audiences in order to increase
the visibility of the research and results. There is a very good outline of indicators designed to measure changes and progress in the
communication activities.
Regarding data management, the issue of IPR is not addressed in sufficient specificity. Hence, it is not fully demonstrated how this relates to
the proposed research and how it will be taken care of.
Criterion 3 - Quality and efficiency of the implementation
Score: 5.00 (Threshold: 3/5.00 , Weight: -)
770504-2/PERICLES-30/11/2017-11:26:56 2/3
The following aspects will be taken into account: Associated with document Ref. Ares(2017)5864162 - 30/11/2017
Quality and effectiveness of the work plan, including extent to which the resources assigned to work packages are in line with
their objectives and deliverables
The work plan is well designed and it effectively integrates the objectives of the proposal. The division of WPs into tasks and activities is highly
effective. The work packages feed into each other in a logical and very good way. The deliverables are comprehensive and they are suitable
to the objectives. The timing of the different work packages, milestones and tasks is excellent. Overall, the work plan demonstrates clearly that
the project is credible and feasible within the time frame envisaged.
Appropriateness of the management structures and procedures, including risk and innovation management
The management structure and the chosen procedures are clearly articulated, coherent and well balanced. The complexity and scope of the
proposed research are aligned in an excellent way with the management structure in targeting the need for coordination of case regions and
work packages. The Coordinator has long-term experience in EU-funded projects and has the skills to coordinate a multidisciplinary research
project.
The proposal presents a good overview of the risks that might negatively affect the successful implementation of the project, and appropriate
measures have been designed to mitigate risk. A minor shortcoming is that not all potential risks are listed and discussed.
Innovation management measures are effectively selected, and they are well integrated into the management structure and the work plan.
Complementarity of the participants and extent to which the consortium as a whole brings together the necessary expertise
The members of the consortium represent an excellent combination of the social sciences, humanities, and spatial and environmental
sciences, which are truly relevant for the study of coastal and maritime cultural heritage from the perspective determined in the proposal. The
non-academic partners embody key elements of the research and management objectives in a very good way. The consortium has
experience of working with complex European or nationally funded research projects. However, a minor shortcoming is that there is not
enough information provided to fully assess this aspect for all partners.
The proposal does not give sufficient consideration to Technology Readiness Levels, which would be relevant.
Appropriateness of the allocation of tasks, ensuring that all participants have a valid role and adequate resources in the project
to fulfil that role
The budget is fairly distributed among the partners. The allocation of tasks matches the expertise of the partners in a very good way. All in all,
tasks and resources are distributed in an appropriate way for the proposed research.
Scope of the proposal
Status: Yes
Comments (in case the proposal is out of scope)
Not provided
Operational Capacity
Status: Operational Capacity: Yes
If No, please list the concerned partner(s), the reasons for the rejection, and the requested amount.
Not provided
Exceptional funding of third country participants/international organisations
A third country participant/international organisation not listed in General Annex A to the Main Work Programme may
exceptionally receive funding if their participation is essential for carrying out the project (for instance due to outstanding
expertise, access to unique know-how, access to research infrastructure, access to particular geographical environments,
possibility to involve key partners in emerging markets, access to data, etc.). ( For more information, see the Online Manual )
Based on the information provided in the proposal, I consider that the following participant(s)/international organisation(s) that
requested funding should exceptionally be funded:
(Please list the Name and acronym of the applicant, Reasons for exceptional funding and the Requested grant amount.)
Not provided
Based on the information provided in the proposal, I consider that the following participant(s)/international organisation(s) that
requested funding should NOT be funded:
(Please list the Name and acronym of the applicant, Reasons for exceptional funding and the Requested grant amount.)
Not provided
Use of human embryonic stem cells (hESC)
Status: No
If yes, please state whether the use of hESC is, or is not, in your opinion, necessary to achieve the scientific objectives of the
proposal and the reasons why. Alternatively, please also state if it cannot be assessed whether the use of hESC is necessary or
not because of a lack of information.
Not provided
770504-2/PERICLES-30/11/2017-11:26:56 3/3
Digitally sealed by the European Commission
Date: 2017.11.30 11:30:14 CET
This document is digitally sealed. The digital sealing mechanism uniquely binds the
document to the modules of the Participant Portal of the European Commission, to the
transaction for which it was generated and ensures its integrity and authenticity.
Any attempt to modify the content will lead to a breach of the electronic seal, which can
be verified at any time by clicking on the digital seal validation symbol.
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Horizon 2020
Call: H2020-SC6-CULT-COOP-2016-2017
(UNDERSTANDING EUROPE - PROMOTING THE EUROPEAN
PUBLIC AND CULTURAL SPACE)
SECOND STAGE
Topic: CULT-COOP-07-2017
Type of action: RIA
(Research and Innovation action)
Proposal number: 770504-2
Proposal acronym: PERICLES
Deadline Id: H2020-SC6-CULT-COOP-2017-two-stage
Table of contents
Section Title Action
1 General information
2 Participants & contacts
3 Budget
4 Ethics
5 Call-specific questions
How to fill in the forms
The administrative forms must be filled in for each proposal using the templates available in the submission system. Some
data fields in the administrative forms are pre-filled based on the previous steps in the submission wizard.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 1 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES
1 - General information
Topic CULT-COOP-07-2017
Call Identifier H2020-SC6-CULT-COOP-2016-2017
Type of Action RIA
Deadline Id H2020-SC6-CULT-COOP-2017-two-stage
Acronym PERICLES
PrEseRvIng and sustainably governing Cultural heritage and Landscapes in European coastal
Proposal title*
and maritime regionS
Note that for technical reasons, the following characters are not accepted in the Proposal Title and will be removed: < > " &
Duration in months 36
Fixed keyword 1 Cultural and economic geography Add
Fixed keyword 2 Environmental sciences (social aspects) Add Remove
Governance, in/tangible cultural heritage,land/seascapes, Blue Growth, MSP, ICZM, stakeholder
Free keywords
participation, maritime culture, tourism, policy, preservation, resilience, risk, sustainability
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 2 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES
Abstract
PERICLES promotes sustainable governance of cultural heritage (CH) in European coastal and maritime regions through
the development of a theoretically grounded, multi-actor participatory framework. To meet this challenge, PERICLES has
formed a strong interdisciplinary consortium comprised of research institutions, regional government and heritage partners
representing 15 different disciplines.
PERICLES addresses the following objectives: a) develop an in-depth, situated understanding of the CH of marine and
coastal land/seascapes, including knowledge across local, spatial, environmental, social and economic aspects; b), develop
practical tools, based on stakeholder involvement and participatory governance, for mapping, assessing and mitigating risks
to CH and to enhance sustainable growth and increase employment by harnessing CH assets; c), provide policy advice to
improve integration of CH in key marine and environmental policies and the implementation of associated EU directives; and
d), develop effective knowledge exchange networks.
To fulfill these objectives PERICLES uses a scientific approach guided by the theories of: a) space, place, and identity; b)
resilience and adaptation; and c) deliberative and participatory governance. We will apply a range of participatory,
deliberative and action research methods from the social sciences and arts directly involving decision-makers, stakeholders
and the public.
PERICLES meets the needs of the work program by: contributing to European efforts to promote evidence-based research
on the impact of participatory approaches in CH policies and governance; using a multi- and transdisciplinary approach;
addressing in/tangible CH in a geographically balanced way; involving and developing CH networks of local stakeholders
and policy makers; and contributing to improved implementation of European policies on coastal zones and maritime areas
and providing evidence on how to link environmental and cultural policies.
Remaining characters 10
Has this proposal (or a very similar one) been submitted in the past 2 years in response to a call for
proposals under Horizon 2020 or any other EU programme(s)? Yes No
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 3 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES
Declarations
1) The coordinator declares to have the explicit consent of all applicants on their participation and on the content
of this proposal.
2) The information contained in this proposal is correct and complete.
3) This proposal complies with ethical principles (including the highest standards of research integrity — as set
out, for instance, in the European Code of Conduct for Research Integrity — and including, in particular,
avoiding fabrication, falsification, plagiarism or other research misconduct).
4) The coordinator confirms:
- to have carried out the self-check of the financial capacity of the organisation on
http://ec.europa.eu/research/participants/portal/desktop/en/organisations/lfv.html or to be covered by a financial
viability check in an EU project for the last closed financial year. Where the result was “weak” or “insufficient”,
the coordinator confirms being aware of the measures that may be imposed in accordance with the H2020
Grants Manual (Chapter on Financial capacity check); or
- is exempt from the financial capacity check being a public body including international organisations, higher or
secondary education establishment or a legal entity, whose viability is guaranteed by a Member State or
associated country, as defined in the H2020 Grants Manual (Chapter on Financial capacity check); or
- as sole participant in the proposal is exempt from the financial capacity check.
5) The coordinator hereby declares that each applicant has confirmed:
- they are fully eligible in accordance with the criteria set out in the specific call for proposals; and
- they have the financial and operational capacity to carry out the proposed action.
The coordinator is only responsible for the correctness of the information relating to his/her own organisation. Each applicant
remains responsible for the correctness of the information related to him/her and declared above. Where the proposal to be
retained for EU funding, the coordinator and each beneficiary applicant will be required to present a formal declaration in this
respect.
According to Article 131 of the Financial Regulation of 25 October 2012 on the financial rules applicable to the general budget of the Union
(Official Journal L 298 of 26.10.2012, p. 1) and Article 145 of its Rules of Application (Official Journal L 362, 31.12.2012, p.1) applicants
found guilty of misrepresentation may be subject to administrative and financial penalties under certain conditions.
Personal data protection
The assessment of your grant application will involve the collection and processing of personal data (such as your name, address and CV),
which will be performed pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 45/2001 on the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal
data by the Community institutions and bodies and on the free movement of such data. Unless indicated otherwise, your replies to the
questions in this form and any personal data requested are required to assess your grant application in accordance with the specifications of
the call for proposals and will be processed solely for that purpose. Details concerning the purposes and means of the processing of your
personal data as well as information on how to exercise your rights are available in the privacy statement. Applicants may lodge a complaint
about the processing of their personal data with the European Data Protection Supervisor at any time.
Your personal data may be registered in the Early Detection and Exclusion system of the European Commission (EDES), the new system
established by the Commission to reinforce the protection of the Union's financial interests and to ensure sound financial management, in
accordance with the provisions of articles 105a and 108 of the revised EU Financial Regulation (FR) (Regulation (EU, EURATOM)
2015/1929 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28 October 2015 amending Regulation (EU, EURATOM) No 966/2012) and
articles 143 - 144 of the corresponding Rules of Application (RAP) (COMMISSION DELEGATED REGULATION (EU) 2015/2462 of 30
October 2015 amending Delegated Regulation (EU) No 1268/2012) for more information see the Privacy statement for the EDES
Database).
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 4 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES
List of participants
# Participant Legal Name Country
1 AALBORG UNIVERSITET Denmark
2 WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITY Netherlands
3 UNIVERSITE DE BRETAGNE OCCIDENTALE France
4 UNIVERSITY OF THE HIGHLANDS AND ISLANDS LBG United Kingdom
5 THE QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY OF BELFAST United Kingdom
6 UNIVERSIDADE DE AVEIRO Portugal
7 THE SCOTTISH ASSOCIATION FOR MARINESCIENCE LBG United Kingdom
8 Muinsuskaitseamet Estonia
9 Parc naturel régional du Golfe du Morbihan France
10 ELLINIKOS GEORGIKOS ORGANISMOS - DIMITRA Greece
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 5 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name AAU
2 - Administrative data of participating organisations
PIC Legal name
999904034 AALBORG UNIVERSITET
Short name: AAU
Address of the organisation
Street FREDRIK BAJERS VEJ 5
Town AALBORG
Postcode 9220
Country Denmark
Webpage www.aau.dk
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... yes Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... yes
International organisation .................................. no
International organisation of European interest ...... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... yes
Research organisation ..................................... yes
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... 23/05/2016 - no
SME self-assessment ...................................... 23/05/2016 - no
SME validation sme ......................................... 31/07/1963 - no
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 6 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name AAU
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
Department 1
Department name Department of Planning not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street Vestre Havnepromenade 5
Town Aalborg
Postcode 9000
Country Denmark
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 7 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name AAU
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Dr. Sex Male Female
First name Alyne Elizabeth Last name DELANEY
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Associate Professor
Department Department of Planning Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street Rendsburggade 14
Town Aalborg Post code 9000
Country Denmark
Website www.en.plan.aau.dk
Phone 1 +45 99403694 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Ann Caroline Hansen
[email protected]
Jakob Vester
[email protected] +4599403699
Kristen Ounanian
[email protected] +4599407372
Helle Sønderholt Christiansen
[email protected]
Flora CHAMPETIER
[email protected]
Mette Møller Jeppesen
[email protected]
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 8 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name WU
PIC Legal name
999981634 WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITY
Short name: WU
Address of the organisation
Street DROEVENDAALSESTEEG 4
Town WAGENINGEN
Postcode 6708 PB
Country Netherlands
Webpage http://www.wageningenur.nl/nl.htm
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... yes Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... yes
International organisation .................................. no
International organisation of European interest ...... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... yes
Research organisation ..................................... no
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... 12/04/2016 - no
SME self-assessment ...................................... 12/04/2016 - no
SME validation sme ......................................... unknown
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 9 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name WU
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
Department 1
Department name Social Sciences Group not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street Hollandseweg 1
Town Wageningen
Postcode 6706KN
Country Netherlands
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 10 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name WU
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Prof. Sex Male Female
First name Jan Last name van Tatenhove
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Personal professor Marine Governance
Department Environmental Policy Group, Social Sciences Group Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street Hollandseweg 1
Town Wageningen Post code 6706KN
Country Netherlands
Website http://www.enp.wur.nl
Phone 1 +31 317482447 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Ineke van Driel
[email protected] +31317485656
Hilde Toonen
[email protected] +31317484105
Loes Witteveen
[email protected]
Oscar VAN ROOTSELAAR
[email protected]
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 11 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name UNIVERSITE DE BRETAGNE OCCIDENTAL
PIC Legal name
999902676 UNIVERSITE DE BRETAGNE OCCIDENTALE
Short name: UNIVERSITE DE BRETAGNE OCCIDENTALE
Address of the organisation
Street RUE DES ARCHIVES 3
Town BREST
Postcode 29238
Country France
Webpage www.univ-brest.fr
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... yes Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... yes
International organisation .................................. no
International organisation of European interest ...... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... yes
Research organisation ..................................... yes
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... 24/04/2014 - no
SME self-assessment ...................................... unknown
SME validation sme ......................................... unknown
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 12 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name UNIVERSITE DE BRETAGNE OCCIDENTAL
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
Department 1
Department name UMR AMURE, IUEM not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street Rue Dumont d'Urville
Town Plouzané
Postcode 29280
Country France
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 13 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name UNIVERSITE DE BRETAGNE OCCIDENTAL
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Mrs Sex Male Female
First name Katia Last name Frangoudes
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Researcher
Department UMR AMURE, IUEM Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street Rue Dumont d'Urville
Town Plouzané Post code 29280
Country France
Website www.umr-amure.fr
Phone 1 0033290915621 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Nathalie Queffelec
[email protected]
Nicolas Roncin
[email protected]
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 14 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name UNIVERSITY OF THE HIGHLANDS AND ISL
PIC Legal name
991015633 UNIVERSITY OF THE HIGHLANDS AND ISLANDS LBG
Short name: UNIVERSITY OF THE HIGHLANDS AND ISLANDS
Address of the organisation
Street NESS WALK 12B EXECUTIVE OFFICE
Town INVERNESS
Postcode IV3 5SQ
Country United Kingdom
Webpage http://www.uhi.ac.uk
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... no Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... yes
International organisation .................................. no
International organisation of European interest ...... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... yes
Research organisation ..................................... no
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... 24/12/1993 - no
SME self-assessment ...................................... unknown
SME validation sme ......................................... unknown
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 15 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name UNIVERSITY OF THE HIGHLANDS AND ISL
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
Department 1
Department name Centre for Recreation and Tourism Research not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street Carmichael Way
Town Fort William
Postcode PH33 6FF
Country United Kingdom
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 16 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name UNIVERSITY OF THE HIGHLANDS AND ISL
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Dr. Sex Male Female
First name Steve Last name Taylor
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Manager
Department Centre for Recreation and Tourism Research Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street Carmichael Way
Town Fort William Post code PH33 6FF
Country United Kingdom
Website www.whc.uhi.ac.uk/research
Phone 1 00 44 1397 874217 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 17 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name THE QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY OF BELFAST
PIC Legal name
999992013 THE QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY OF BELFAST
Short name: THE QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY OF BELFAST
Address of the organisation
Street UNIVERSITY ROAD LANYON BUILDING
Town BELFAST
Postcode BT7 1NN
Country United Kingdom
Webpage www.qub.ac.uk
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... yes Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... yes
International organisation .................................. no
International organisation of European interest ...... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... yes
Research organisation ..................................... yes
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... 30/06/2014 - no
SME self-assessment ...................................... unknown
SME validation sme ......................................... unknown
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 18 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name THE QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY OF BELFAST
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
Department 1
Department name School of Natural and Built Environment not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street David Keir Building, Stranmillis Road
Town Belfast
Postcode BT9 5AG
Country United Kingdom
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 19 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name THE QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY OF BELFAST
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Dr. Sex Male Female
First name Wesley Last name Flannery
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Lecturer
Department School of Natural and Built Environment Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street David Keir Building, Stranmillis Road
Town Belfast Post code BT9 5AG
Country United Kingdom
Website
Phone 1 +44 2890974754 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Ciarán Prunty
[email protected] +442890973199
Pauline McCann
[email protected] +442890975460
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 20 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name UAVR
PIC Legal name
999865331 UNIVERSIDADE DE AVEIRO
Short name: UAVR
Address of the organisation
Street CAMPO UNIVERSITARIO DE SANTIAGO
Town AVEIRO
Postcode 3810 193
Country Portugal
Webpage www.ua.pt
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... no Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... yes
International organisation .................................. no
International organisation of European interest ...... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... yes
Research organisation ..................................... yes
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... 24/11/2014 - no
SME self-assessment ...................................... 01/01/1900 - no
SME validation sme ......................................... unknown
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 21 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name UAVR
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
Department 1
Department name Department of Environment and Planning not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street CAMPO UNIVERSITARIO DE SANTIAGO
Town AVEIRO
Postcode 3810 193
Country Portugal
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 22 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name UAVR
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Dr. Sex Male Female
First name Cristina Last name Pita
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Researcher
Department Department of Environment and Planning Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street CAMPO UNIVERSITARIO DE SANTIAGO
Town AVEIRO Post code 3810 193
Country Portugal
Website www.ua.pt
Phone 1 +351 919034396 Phone 2 +351 234 370 439 Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Maria Fátima Alves
[email protected] +351 234 370 831
Luisa Sal
[email protected] +351 234 370 848
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 23 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name SAMS
PIC Legal name
999738843 THE SCOTTISH ASSOCIATION FOR MARINESCIENCE LBG
Short name: SAMS
Address of the organisation
Street SCOTTISH MARINE INSTITUTE
Town DUNBEG OBAN
Postcode PA37 1QA
Country United Kingdom
Webpage www.sams.ac.uk
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... no Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... yes
International organisation .................................. no
International organisation of European interest ...... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... no
Research organisation ..................................... yes
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... 28/10/2008 - yes
SME self-assessment ...................................... 28/10/2008 - no
SME validation sme ......................................... 28/10/2008 - yes
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 24 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name SAMS
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
Department 1
Department name Laurence Mee Centre for Society and the Sea not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street Dunstaffnage
Town Oban
Postcode PA37 1QA
Country United Kingdom
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 25 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name SAMS
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Dr. Sex Male Female
First name Jasper Last name Kenter
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Principal Investigator in Ecological Economics
Department Laurence Mee Centre for Society and the Sea Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street Dunstaffnage
Town Oban Post code PA37 1QA
Country United Kingdom
Website www.sams.ac.uk/mc
Phone 1 +44 1631 559000 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 26 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name MKA
PIC Legal name
951666710 Muinsuskaitseamet
Short name: MKA
Address of the organisation
Street Pikk 2
Town Tallinn
Postcode 10123
Country Estonia
Webpage www.muinas.ee
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... yes Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... yes
International organisation .................................. no
International organisation of European interest ...... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... no
Research organisation ..................................... yes
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... unknown
SME self-assessment ...................................... unknown
SME validation sme ......................................... unknown
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 27 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name MKA
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
Department 1
Department name Restoration and Development Department not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street Pikk 2
Town Tallinn
Postcode 10123
Country Estonia
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 28 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name MKA
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Mrs Sex Male Female
First name Maili Last name Roio
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Senior Inspector of Underwater Heritage
Department Please indicate the department of the Contact Point above in the organisation Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street Pikk 2
Town Tallinn Post code 10123
Country Estonia
Website www.muinas.ee
Phone 1 +37 2640 3064 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 29 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name Parc naturel régional du Golfe du Morbihan
PIC Legal name
913565789 Parc naturel régional du Golfe du Morbihan
Short name: Parc naturel régional du Golfe du Morbihan
Address of the organisation
Street 8 boulevard des îles
Town Vannes
Postcode 56006
Country France
Webpage www.parc-golfe-morbihan.bzh
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... unknown Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... unknown
International organisation .................................. unknown
International organisation of European interest ...... unknown
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... unknown
Research organisation ..................................... unknown
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... unknown
SME self-assessment ...................................... unknown
SME validation sme ......................................... unknown
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 30 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name Parc naturel régional du Golfe du Morbihan
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
No department involved
Department name not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street Please enter street name and number.
Town
Postcode
Country
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 31 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name Parc naturel régional du Golfe du Morbihan
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Ms Sex Male Female
First name Monique Last name Cassé
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Director
Department Parc naturel régional du Golfe du Morbihan Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street 8 boulevard des îles
Town Vannes Post code 56006
Country France
Website http://www.parc-golfe-morbihan.bzh/
Phone 1 +00 33 2 97 62 03 03 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Ronan Pasco
[email protected]
Juliette Herry
[email protected]
Morgane Dallic
[email protected]
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 32 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name HELLENIC AGRICULTURAL ORGANISATIO
PIC Legal name
953814096 ELLINIKOS GEORGIKOS ORGANISMOS - DIMITRA
Short name: HELLENIC AGRICULTURAL ORGANISATION DEMETER
Address of the organisation
Street KOURTIDOU 56-58
Town ATHINA
Postcode 11145
Country Greece
Webpage www.elgo.gr
Legal Status of your organisation
Research and Innovation legal statuses
Public body .................................................... no Legal person .............................. yes
Non-profit ...................................................... yes
International organisation .................................. no
International organisation of European interest ...... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ....... yes
Research organisation ..................................... yes
Enterprise Data
SME self-declared status................................... 20/03/2012 - no
SME self-assessment ...................................... unknown
SME validation sme ......................................... unknown
Based on the above details of the Beneficiary Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 33 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name HELLENIC AGRICULTURAL ORGANISATIO
Department(s) carrying out the proposed work
No department involved
Department name not applicable
Same as organisation address
Street Please enter street name and number.
Town
Postcode
Country
Dependencies with other proposal participants
Character of dependence Participant
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 34 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES Short name HELLENIC AGRICULTURAL ORGANISATIO
Person in charge of the proposal
The name and e-mail of contact persons are read-only in the administrative form, only additional details can be edited here. To give access
rights and basic contact details of contact persons, please go back to Step 4 of the submission wizard and save the changes.
Title Dr. Sex Male Female
First name Manos Last name Koutrakis
E-Mail
[email protected]
Position in org. Senior researcher (Grade A)
Department ELLINIKOS GEORGIKOS ORGANISMOS - DIMITRA Same as organisation
Same as organisation address
Street KOURTIDOU 56-58
Town ATHINA Post code 11145
Country Greece
Website http://www.inale.gr/index.html
Phone 1 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx Fax +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Dimitra Mylona
[email protected] 0030 28310 50524
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 35 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES
3 - Budget for the proposal
No Participant Country (A) (B) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) (I) (J) (K)
Direct Other direct Direct costs of Direct costs of Costs of inkind Indirect Costs Special unit Total Reimburse- Max.EU Requested
personnel costs/€ sub- providing contributions /€ costs covering estimated ment rate (%) Contribution / EU
not used on the
costs/€ contracting/€ financial direct & eligible costs € Contribution/
beneficiary's
support to (=0.25(A+B-E)) indirect costs /€ €
premises/€
third parties/€ /€ (=A+B+C+D+F (=H*I)
+G)
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
1 Aau DK 333441 124100 0 0 0 114385,25 0 571926,25 100 571926,25 571926,25
2 Wu NL 307008 68500 0 0 0 93877,00 0 469385,00 100 469385,00 469385,00
Universite De
3 Bretagne FR 130020 30000 0 0 0 40005,00 0 200025,00 100 200025,00 200025,00
Occidentale
University Of
4 The Highlands UK 61757 10250 0 0 0 18001,75 0 90008,75 100 90008,75 90008,75
And Islands
The Queen's
5 University Of UK 183684 53893 0 0 0 59394,25 0 296971,25 100 296971,25 296971,25
Belfast
6 Uavr PT 115369 43632 0 0 0 39750,25 0 198751,25 100 198751,25 198751,25
7 Sams UK 237225 52500 18900 0 0 72431,25 0 381056,25 100 381056,25 381056,25
8 Mka EE 76000 48000 0 0 0 31000,00 0 155000,00 100 155000,00 155000,00
Parc Naturel
9 Régional Du FR 40000 16000 0 0 0 14000,00 0 70000,00 100 70000,00 70000,00
Golfe Du
Hellenic
10 Agricultural EL 3000 30500 24000 0 0 8375,00 0 65875,00 100 65875,00 65875,00
Organisation
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 20160323 Page 36 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES
Total 1487504 477375 42900 0 0 491219,75 0 2498998,75 2498998,75 2498998,75
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 20160323 Page 37 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES
4 - Ethics issues table
1. HUMAN EMBRYOS/FOETUSES Page
Does your research involve Human Embryonic Stem Cells (hESCs)? Yes No
Does your research involve the use of human embryos? Yes No
Does your research involve the use of human foetal tissues / cells? Yes No
2. HUMANS Page
Does your research involve human participants? Yes No
Does your research involve physical interventions on the study participants? Yes No
3. HUMAN CELLS / TISSUES Page
Does your research involve human cells or tissues (other than from Human Embryos/ Yes No
Foetuses, i.e. section 1)?
4. PERSONAL DATA Page
Does your research involve personal data collection and/or processing? Yes No
Does your research involve further processing of previously collected personal data Yes No
(secondary use)?
5. ANIMALS Page
Does your research involve animals? Yes No
6. THIRD COUNTRIES Page
In case non-EU countries are involved, do the research related activities undertaken in Yes No
these countries raise potential ethics issues?
Do you plan to use local resources (e.g. animal and/or human tissue samples, genetic Yes No
material, live animals, human remains, materials of historical value, endangered fauna or
flora samples, etc.)?
Do you plan to import any material - including personal data - from non-EU countries into Yes No
the EU?
Do you plan to export any material - including personal data - from the EU to non-EU Yes No
countries?
In case your research involves low and/or lower middle income countries, are any Yes No
benefits-sharing actions planned?
Could the situation in the country put the individuals taking part in the research at risk? Yes No
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 38 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES
7. ENVIRONMENT & HEALTH and SAFETY
Page
Does your research involve the use of elements that may cause harm to the Yes No
environment, to animals or plants?
Does your research deal with endangered fauna and/or flora and/or protected areas? Yes No
Does your research involve the use of elements that may cause harm to humans, Yes No
including research staff?
8. DUAL USE Page
Does your research involve dual-use items in the sense of Regulation 428/2009, Yes No
or other items for which an authorisation is required?
9. EXCLUSIVE FOCUS ON CIVIL APPLICATIONS Page
Could your research raise concerns regarding the exclusive focus on civil applications? Yes No
10. MISUSE Page
Does your research have the potential for misuse of research results? Yes No
11. OTHER ETHICS ISSUES Page
Are there any other ethics issues that should be taken into consideration? Please specify Yes No
I confirm that I have taken into account all ethics issues described above and that, if any ethics issues
✖
apply, I will complete the ethics self-assessment and attach the required documents.
How to Complete your Ethics Self-Assessment
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 39 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
European Commission
Research & Innovation - Participant Portal
Proposal Submission Forms
Proposal ID 770504-2 Acronym PERICLES
5 - Call specific questions
Declarations on stage-2 changes
The full stage-2 proposal must be consistent with the short outline proposal submitted to the stage-1- in particular with respect
to the proposal characteristics addressing the concepts of excellence and impact.
Are there substantial differences compared to the stage-1 proposal? Yes No
Extended Open Research Data Pilot in Horizon 2020
If selected, applicants will by default participate in the Pilot on Open Research Data in Horizon 20201 , which aims to improve
and maximise access to and re-use of research data generated by actions.
However, participation in the Pilot is flexible in the sense that it does not mean that all research data needs to be open. After
the action has started, participants will formulate a Data Management Plan (DMP), which should address the relevant aspects
of making data FAIR – findable, accessible, interoperable and re-usable, including what data the project will generate, whether
and how it will be made accessible for verification and re-use, and how it will be curated and preserved. Through this DMP
projects can define certain datasets to remain closed according to the principle "as open as possible, as closed as
necessary". A Data Management Plan does not have to be submitted at the proposal stage.
Furthermore, applicants also have the possibility to opt out of this Pilot completely at any stage (before or after the grant
signature). In this case, applicants must indicate a reason for this choice (see options below).
Please note that participation in this Pilot does not constitute part of the evaluation process. Proposals will not be penalised for
opting out.
We wish to opt out of the Pilot on Open Research Data in Horizon 2020. Yes No
Further guidance on open access and research data management is available on the participant portal:
http://ec.europa.eu/research/participants/docs/h2020-funding-guide/cross-cutting-issues/open-access-dissemination_en.htm and in
general annex L of the Work Programme.
1
According to article 43.2 of Regulation (EU) No 1290/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council, of 11 December 2013, laying down the rules for participation and
dissemination in "Horizon 2020 - the Framework Programme for Research and Innovation (2014-2020)" and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1906/2006.
H2020-CP-STAGE2-RIA-CSA-2016-v2.pdf Ver 1.00 2016032 Page 40 of 40 Last saved 13/09/2017 12:59:31
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
COVER PAGE
Preserving and sustainably governing Cultural heritage and Landscapes in
European coastal and maritime regions
PERICLES
List of participants
Participant No * Participant organisation name Country
1 (Coordinator) Aalborg Universitet DK
2 WU Wageningen University NL
3 UBO Universite De Bretagne Occidentale FR
4 UHI University Of The Highlands and Islands UK
5 QUB The Queen’s University of Belfast UK
6 UAVR Universidade De Aveiro PT
7 SAMS The Scottish Association for Marine Science LBG UK
8 MKA Muinsuskaitseamet EE
9 PNRgDM Parc naturel régional du Golfe du Morbihan FR
10 F.R.I. Hellenic Agricultural Organisation Demeter EL
1
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
1. Excellence
1.1 Objectives
European maritime and coastal regions are at the crossroads of connections and movement of diverse peoples
and cultures. These coastal zones are also historically rich with unique land/seascapes, tangible artefacts, and
intangible cultural heritage. “Cultural heritage [CH] is now widely appreciated as an essential part of Europe’s
underlying socioeconomic, cultural and natural capital” (DGRI 2015: 5). Realising the potential of CH in these
terms can generate prosperity, bring new jobs and improve environments in ways comparable to Blue Growth
initiatives. Yet, coastal cultural landscapes face risks from climate change, pollution, urbanisation, mass
tourism, demographic challenges in remote regions, the fundamental transformation of the European fishing
industry, and inconsistent policies of sea and shore conservation across governance scales and between
regions.
Responding to the call CULT COOP 2017-7: Cultural heritage of European coastal and maritime regions, the
overall goal of PERICLES is to support sustainable governance of CH in European coastal and maritime
regions through the development of a broad-scope, theoretically grounded, multi-actor participatory
framework.
To face the challenges of the call, PERICLES has formed a strong interdisciplinary consortium comprised of
research institutions, universities, regional government and heritage partners from seven Member States
(MS), bringing together practitioners and researchers from over 15 different disciplines.
With this interdisciplinary consortium, PERICLES’ overall aim is to support sustainable CH governance: a)
through the development of a theoretically grounded, multi-actor participatory framework; b) by critically
evaluating existing governance practices; and c) by developing a best practice framework for preserving
and sustainably utilising CH, including cultural, environmental, spatial and broader societal aspects.
PERICLES will address the following specific objectives to advance sustainable governance of CH:
1. Develop an in-depth, situated understanding -and provide a comprehensive picture of the societal
importance- of the CH of marine and coastal land/seascapes, covering both tangible and intangible
CH (WP2);
2. Develop practical tools, based on stakeholder involvement and participatory governance, for (a)
understanding, assessing and mitigating risks to CH and (b) enhancing sustainable growth and
increasing employment by harnessing CH assets (WP3);
3. Provide a comprehensive, participatory framework for sustainable management, conservation and
exploitation of European coastal and maritime cultural landscapes, which integrates knowledge
across local, spatial, environmental, social and economic aspects of CH (WP4);
4. Provide policy advice to improve integration of CH in key marine and environmental policies
and the implementation of associated EU directives (e.g. ICZM, MSP, IMP, MSFD) (WP5); and
5. Develop effective knowledge exchange networks among policy makers, stakeholders and scholars
to help achieve, communicate and disseminate the above, through direct involvement of practitioners
in the consortium supported by Associated Partners (APs) to create coherent and continuous
dissemination and impact pathway routes (multiplier effects, bridging gaps in geographical coverage)
(WP6).
1.2 Relation to the work programme
PERICLES relates to the Work Programme 2016 -2017, in the frame of “Europe in a changing world –
inclusive, innovative and reflective Societies” and refers to the call “Understanding Europe- Promoting the
European Public and Cultural Space,” and specifically addresses the challenges and scope of the topic CULT-
COOP-07-2017 “Cultural heritage of European coastal and maritime regions.”
The Work Programme detailed above focuses on achieving the following Societal Challenges:
1. Strengthened resilience and cohesion of European societies by researching narratives of beliefs,
identities and uncovering the drivers of and obstacles to the emergence of a European public sphere
and cultural space;
2
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
2. Better understanding of Europe's cultural, social unity and diversity of its past in order to reflect
on present challenges/opportunities and help find solutions for shaping Europe's future;
3. Better understanding of the role that technology can play in promoting of the richness of
Europe’s heritage and diversity AND provide solutions driven options; and
4. Linkages with the CO-CREATION and Cultural Heritage-related Topics of Societal Challenge 5.
The Work Programme and Societal Challenges build upon concerns for Europe’s future regarding its social
and economic strength and well-being. CH, much like environmental protection in the past, was often viewed
as a cost to society in terms of limited economic benefits, yet is now rightly understood to be a positive driver
for sustainable development (DGRI, 2015). Environmental management, in particular, has often been
separated from heritage management. And yet CH plays an important role in the sustainable development of
rural and urban cultural landscapes with many natural landscapes “teeming with all kinds of cultural heritage,
including archaeological relics, historical landscape features, architecture as well as more intangible values
such as traditions” (DGRI, 2015: 9).
The topic CULT-COOP-07-2017 “Cultural heritage of European coastal and maritime regions”
addresses the need for a broad perspective on cultural heritage, one which includes comprehensive
management for the most efficient use of resources and preservation of cultural and ecological assets and
includes the develop new tools, methods and approaches for planning and managing these complex dynamic
systems. A particularly challenging need that the call addresses is the harmonisation of environmental and
social policies, and the harmonization of policies across different scales. The strong divide between social and
environmental policies and separate management (e.g., European CH sites protected status under UNESCO
World Heritage and/or Special Areas of Conservation (Habitat Directive (92/43/EEC) and Special Protection
Areas (Bird Directive 79/409/EEC) may lead to the inefficient use of resources, the loss of cultural and
ecological assets, and insufficient recognition of their interrelations.
The topic highlights both the risks (e.g., climate change, rising seas, development, population growth and
development, mass tourism, lack of harmonisation among policies) and benefits (healthy societies, cultural
resilience, blue growth opportunities, tourism development, etc.) to in/tangible cultural heritage in Europe
(European Commission Decision C(2017)2468 of 24 April 2017). Being able to both preserve and utilize CH
requires research efforts which promote evidence-based research on the impact of participatory approaches
in CH policies and governance; multi-disciplinary approaches; addressing in/tangible CH in a
geographically balanced way; involving and developing CH networks of local stakeholders and policy
makers; and contributing to improved implementation of European policies on coastal zones and
maritime areas and providing evidence on how to link environmental and cultural policies.
PERICLES meets the scope of the topic by providing a comprehensive framework for the preservation of
European coastal and maritime cultural heritage and landscapes. PERICLES will map, characterise and
assess risks to CH and opportunities to exploit CH assets through the development of a broad-scope,
theoretically grounded multi-actor participatory framework for the sustainable governance of CH in
European maritime regions and seas). In addition, PERICLES will provide evidence, tools and practical pilots
on how to link environmental and cultural policies, thus contributing to a better implementation of European
policies on coastal zones and maritime areas, referring both to the 'Integrated Coastal Zone Management ICZM'
('Recommendation concerning the 'Integrated Coastal Zone Management' (2002/413/EC)) and to the
'Establishing a framework for maritime spatial planning' (Directive 2014/89/EU).
To do this PERICLES will engage, also through Citizen Science and Arts-Science tools and activities, with
the broader cultural heritage community (academia, including social sciences and humanities, applied
practitioners such as museums, public administrations and civil society) to exchange experiences, identify
strengths, weaknesses and best practices, encourage the development of new techniques and technologies, and
share information, knowledge and know-how in order to promote effective and sustainable cultural heritage
preservation and use activities across the EU’s maritime and coastal regions. Doing so contributes to European
efforts to promote evidence-based research on the impact of participatory approaches in cultural heritage
policies and governance, as suggested by the Council of the European Union's conclusions on participatory
governance of cultural heritage (2014/C 463/01).
3
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
PERICLES also complements previous and ongoing EU research on CH including by building upon and
linking with other initiatives, programmes, projects, policies. Examples include:
• The INSPIRE Directive (2007/2/EC) which aims to create a European Union spatial data
infrastructure for the purposes of EU environmental policies and policies or activities which may have
an impact on the environment. This European Spatial Data Infrastructure enables the sharing of
environmental spatial information among public sector organisations, facilitate public access to spatial
information across Europe and assists in policy-making across boundaries.
• Interreg Europe’s GIFS (Geography of Inshore Fishing and Sustainability) knowledge of broader
social and cultural values of fishing and their experience with using interactive maps and exchanges
between communities; HERICOASTs Management of heritage in coastal landscapes on spatial
heritage analysis, exchange of CH management good practice and participatory development of
regional action plans; MESFIDE on Mediterranean Small Scale Craft Fishery and Development; and
Leonardo da Vinci Europe’s Cultural Heritage Tourism network; BALTACAR (Baltic History
Beneath Surface: Underwater Heritage Trails In Situ and Online), demonstrating the tourism potential
of the underwater cultural heritage of the Baltic Sea by developing easy and convenient ways for
visiting our unique and well preserved underwater sites in situ; and BalticRIM (Baltic Sea Region
Integrated Maritime Cultural Heritage Management) which aims to improve the capacity of regional
and MCH planning agencies by developing, testing and implementing new planning solutions,
innovative ways of public participation as well as sectoral MCH concepts throughout the BSR.
• Regional linking projects, e.g. URBACT’s (Integrated Urban Development) transnational exchange
networks and capacity building experiences; EUHeritageTOUR’s community-based tourism work
across UNESCO sites;
• FP6-7 Projects: Spicosa, Sciences & Policy Integration for coastal system assessment; KNOWSEAS
(Knowledge-based Sustainable Management for Europe's Seas), integrating knowledge for coastal
management; HERCULES work on cultural heritage in European landscapes; SASMAP and ITACA
coastal and underwater archaeology and SPHERE, focused on space and place in European identities.
• H2020: COHERE (Critical Heritages) use of data and knowledge on how European people and
institutions use history to create a sense of belonging through museums, arts, tourism and food; and
and ROCK research on cultural heritage as a driver for sustainable growth and urban regeneration.
• Future relevant H2020 CULT-COOP, BG and other key cultural and environmental topic projects;
• MS level work such as Denmark’s CHIP (Cultural Heritage in Planning) which provides experience
on the importance of spatial planning and use of proper instruments in protecting CH, as does
InterSAVE, which introduced survey tools for integrated conservation and identifying and
documenting built heritage; Implementation of the MSFD in the North Aegean Sea; and the UK
National Ecosystem Assessment work on shared, plural and cultural values and cultural ecosystem
services and work on cultural ecosystem services under other ongoing national (e.g. Dutch, German)
ecosystem assessments;
• Transnational projects and programmes such the UNESCO-EU’s MedLiHer (Mediterranean Living
Heritage project) provide lessons on capacity-building, regional cooperation, and establishment of a
networks and developing web portals, and IPBES (Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on
Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services) in relation to better understanding and managing cultural values
of ecosystems.
1.3 Concept and methodology
a) Concept
Cultural heritage provides a sense of place, unity, and belonging. As such, it strengthens society. CH, rooted
in specific landscapes, seascapes, buildings, stories, traditions, language, and cultural practices, is a
fundamental part of every society. It connects people to each other and to the past and helps guide the
future. The loss of CH can weaken people’s societal attachments to place and to one another, thereby
increasing strife and a sense of anomie and decreasing cooperation and sense of identity. Protection and
advocacy for CH can strengthen identity and local community, thereby improving overall quality of life.
Culture and heritage are imperatives for the development of any society. CH is therefore intimately tied with
4
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
notions of space, place and identity. CH is at risk through diverse
drivers, such as climate change, non-CH sensitive economic and spatial
development (e.g. mass tourism), and demographic change (e.g. decline
and aging in rural areas and lack of recruitment to sectors important to
coastal and maritime CH such as inshore fisheries). With calls for
growth in different economic sectors, it is important for the project to
make an explicit connection between the value of CH, the risks it faces
and the benefits to developing a framework for its preservation to
safeguard its enjoyment for future generations. Preserving CH must
account for these risks and explore how CH resilience may be fostered.
However, CH should not be conceived of in a static sense but include
ongoing adaptation to new circumstances and opportunities, providing a
springboard for sustainable exploitation, including through community
development, tourism and creative sectors (e.g. arts, media) to provide
social and economic benefits and Blue Growth opportunities to local
communities. Scientists and tourists value CH but locals live and breathe Figure 1: Pericles Case Regions
it and their identities are formed by it. Their knowledge, connection, and enthusiasm must be included in any
work on CH and people should be provided with ways to channel their knowledge and creativity into CH
research. Through the adoption of participatory processes, PERICLES works with stakeholders and end-users
in both less conventional (e.g., consortium members, network organizers, policy analysis and evaluation) and
conventional roles (e.g., interviewees, advisory group members). Thus, the scientific concept underpinning the
PERICLES research is consolidated in three, interrelated pillars: Space, Place and Identity; Risk, Resilience
and Adaptation; and Deliberative and Participatory Governance.
Space, Place & Identity
CH links people to the past as it is a physical reminder of how the landscape that they now inhabit was once
perceived and lived in. Ideas of space, place and identity will be used to explore how the physical landscapes
in our study areas (spaces) also become cultural ones (places) and how this informs a sense of place and
identity. As people inhabit, experience and interact within the natural environment, physical landscapes
become imbued with meaning, memories and experiences. In other words, physical spaces become cultural
places with associated tangible objects, buildings and technologies and intangible practices, ideas and
language. Indeed, tangible and intangible cultural and natural heritage co-produce cultural ecosystem services
and co-construct coastal landscape values and identities (Kenter, 2016). Such human/environment interactions
can also be thought of as integrated socio-ecological systems, rather than social systems separate from
environmental ones (Folke, 2006). CH is both part of the landscape that informs a located socio-ecological
system and at the same time a product of that socio-ecological system. CH is therefore both a product of the
past and the present.
Although the role that the physical environment plays in determining the social constructs that arise around it
is debated, a reciprocal relationship exists whereby environment influences culture and culture influences the
environment (Stedman, 2003). For example, for fishers on the west coast of Scotland the act of working at sea,
rather than the act of fishing specifically, and a life largely shaped by this is a major part of their identity as
individuals and as a community (Nightingale, 2013). At the same time, any particular natural landscape can
generate multiple but concurrent cultural places as meaning is attributed differently by different people or
different cultural groups (Stedman 2003). PERICLES explores the different ways that spaces become places
and influence identities through case-study demonstrators (demos) that, for example, investigate industrial
heritage (Scotland-Ireland), inshore fisheries (Aegean and Wadden Seas and Scotland-Ireland), traditional boat
building (Portugal and Denmark), hunting practices (Malta), salt and seaweed production (Portugal and
Brittany) and distinctive practices such as those of the Kuhnu islanders’ (Estonia) amongst others.
Tangible CH has value both for what it is and for what it alludes to; by being visible, it draws attention to the
intangible in terms of the cultures, societies and circumstances that shaped landscape use and exploitation. For
example, historical and archaeological remains such as shipwrecks, salt-pans, coastal towers and submerged
fish traps are all indicators of how particular environments were once lived in. PERICLES will produce a
comprehensive online map of the tangible and intangible cultural heritage in all case-study regions. Tangible
5
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
cultural heritage as an indicator of past cultural practices is also further explored in regional demos; for
example, Aegean 1 will investigate fishing practices in antiquity through the archaeological record.
Against this backdrop, tangible and intangible CH is important on several levels in creating a sense of
individual and societal identity. People-place relationships are diverse and dynamic, complex and changeable.
Place attachment is a working theory which describes these relationships as ‘interactional processes’ anchored
in both activity and location (Adger et al., 2009). An individual’s attachment to place can be described as a
personal identity linked with the biophysical features of a place (including land/sea/townscapes and
ecosystems) and activities, for example fishing. The space where the activity takes place then becomes
embedded in individual identity (Urquhart et al., 2013). These interactions ripple out to wider communities
and society through social exchanges (e.g. personal communications such as story-telling, and wider media
coverage), creating a social identity with that space; a place and a culture (Bailey et al., 2016). Place attachment
includes interactions from the past – personal and collective memories and narratives associated with a space,
interactions which are in the present – current uses and identities, and future potential – expectation of what is
likely to happen (Bailey et al., 2016; Milligan, 1998). As such, past human-place relationships influence both
present and future relationships. Understanding the components of place attachment, both historical and
present is critical for maintaining positive collective and individual identities and can provide guidance for
management of cultural resources. (Hindmarsh, 2012). Moreover, it is being recognised as a key component
for the management of cultural heritage industries, as place attachment can lead to more sustainable behaviour
in tourists and visitors (Buonincontri et al., 2017).
Traces of the past are not just relics to be preserved, they engender contemporary and future meanings and
identity (Tengberg et al., 2012; Milligan, 1998) whether on an individual or a societal level, a process which,
in itself, produces and enriches CH. This connects to the use of place-based CH as a means for sustainable and
inclusive social and economic regeneration, where CH becomes ‘cultural capital’, intimately entwined with
natural capital (Cochrane, 2006). For example, on various islands and peninsulas in the Scottish-Irish case
region, reinvigoration of crofting cultures and conservation of cultural landscapes has gone hand in hand with
reclamation of communal land rights (Rennie & Billing, 2015), an attempt at slowing-down demographic
decline, nature conservation, renewable energy generation, and the development of new creative industries
where traditional practices, history and language (Mackenzie et al., 2004) are linked to modern artistic practice
and the opportunity to access global markets through new IT platforms and virtual networks (Mason & Rennie,
2004).
Risk, Resilience and Adaptation
Coastal areas experience intense and sustained pressures from a diverse range of social and environmental
sources, all of which have the potential to become risks to the preservation and utilisation of CH. Some
examples are: overdevelopment and over-exploitation, environmental change that results in flooding or
drought and abandonment when certain ways of life are no longer a viable means of making a living. Our
coasts host many of the EU’s major centres of commerce and are subject to the attendant pressures that emanate
from these cities (e.g. urban sprawl and rapid development).
Due to globalisation and resulting MacDonaldisation of cities, many urban centres are at risk of losing their
inherent uniqueness as waterfronts and high streets are increasingly designed to resemble each other and are
disembedded from their coastal heritage. For many of us, coasts are the preferred location to reside and to
sojourn for leisure, recreation and tourism activities (Martínez et al., 2007).
Coastal tourism and leisure both places CH at risk and offers potential opportunities for its preservation. Mass
tourism increases the pressure on popular coastal areas and often does not engage with local heritage beyond
viewing coasts as ‘sun and sea’ holiday locations. Tourism offers opportunities to develop strategies for the
sustainable exploitation of unique CH, as mass tourism markets become saturated and increasingly holiday-
makers are turning towards more sustainable forms of tourism (e.g. ecotourism, nature-based tourism). For
example, overdevelopment in response to mass tourism is evident in the Maltese Islands where little heed has
been paid to preserving the local character in the process and CH is constantly under threat from further
development. In light of this, the ability of the islands to preserve the natural and cultural landscape while
being dependant on tourism will be explored in depth, for example, in Malta.
6
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
The islands of the Gulf of Riga offer a different perspective on the link between cultural heritage and tourism.
Here, the Kihnu islanders have been very successful in maintaining their traditional cultural practices.
However, the increase in tourism, and reliance on income from it have led to a situation that limits the
community’s capacity to change naturally without economically damaging consequences. Extreme climatic
events, such as storms, can increase erosion resulting in the removal of coastal vegetation and the loss of
coastal land.
Coastal population growth, urbanisation and expanding coastal tourism development increases pressure on
coastal environments, resulting in ecosystem degradation (Duxbury & Dickinson, 2007) and the loss of
associated CH. Environmental change is also increasingly manifest in the type and quality of fish stocks
available for exploitation. The capacity of coastal and fishing communities to adapt to these changes and to
maintain continuity of practice, and therefore associated CH, will be explored in depth across different regional
seas, including the Atlantic, Celtic, Aegean and Mediterranean seaboards.
However, throughout history, coastal communities have responded to outside forces such as external markets
and trade, globalisation, environmental change, politics and governmental policies, through the rise and fall of
states, economies, and institutions, revealing an ability of the peoples of coastal and maritime zones to often
be resilient and adaptive.
PERICLES will assess and present knowledge on societal proclivity towards resilience, focusing on the
conditions enabling adaptation and innovation in European maritime and coastal regions. Adaptation and
resilience go hand-in-hand. In a socio-ecological sense, resilience is the capacity of a system to maintain social
institutions, social and ecological structures and functions and adapt to changes (Adger et al., 2005). The
resilience of coastal communities can be linked to broader, higher-scale, processes including cultural and
societal tendency for adaptation, innovation, and flexibility. Social science conceptualises adaptation in human
systems in terms of the ‘success’ or ‘survival’ of a culture suggesting that adaptation itself is based on
historically successful practices (Smit & Wandel, 2006). Thus, adaptation can be said to be an adjustment to
circumstances. Adjustments in circumstances may come in response to inherent instability or potential loss
due to some form of risk. Risk may come from external changes or pressures (e.g., climate change, air
pollution, geopolitical actions) as well as internal, societal ones (e.g., demographic changes, development
without consideration of local CH, power differential among cultural groups, etc.) Understanding risk, and
how it relates to resiliencies a key consideration for a sustainable framework.
PERICLES will combine results of research into examples of successes and failures in preserving and
maintaining intangible and tangible CH in the framework in order to tease out the conditions needed for success
whether they be through cultural, economic, political, or policy support. For example, lessons can be learned
from Kihnu Islanders (Estonia 2) who have managed to preserve a matriarchal society with unique dress,
music, and language despite political and economic changes and upheaval over time. Socio-ecological systems
are specific combinations of resources, people and institutions and it is essential that the specific dynamics of
any one SES is well understood by policy makers (Janssen et al., 2007). Otherwise there is a high risk that
policies designed to help make particular socio-ecological systems more resilient inadvertently undermine
them, or their components, by providing a threat or stimulus that cannot be absorbed or responded to positively
in the immediate and long term. PERICLES acknowledges this risk and participative deliberation will be used
extensively throughout the case-study regions.
PERICLES will develop a wide range of demos with cross-cutting implications across cultural, social,
economic and policy dimensions. For example, demos in Scotland and the Aegean will examine these
dimensions in the context of fishing communities, many of which have faced both long-term decline and
increasing pressure to explore innovative ways to prosper. Policy responses with environmental objectives,
such as quota regimes and marine protected areas, can support the preservation of fish stocks and are thus
important for the long-term sustainability of fisheries heritage. However, they can at the same time be
experienced as a severe stressor in the short term by inshore fishermen. Thus, environmental policies need to
be cognisant of direct and indirect cultural impacts and more finely tuned to recognise these to balance short
and long-term resilience and adaptation (Ranger et al., 2016). Demos will also explore how fishing, shipping
and maritime industrial narratives can form the focus of tourism experiences, as well as educational resources
with the potential to sustain these traditions (Aegean, Denmark, Ireland, Malta, Portugal). PERICLES will also
explore the potential of linking CH-sustainable tourism in increasing resilience and adaptation through the
7
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
development of coastal heritage paths and the promotion of local cuisine and practices (Denmark, Scotland,
Aegean, Malta, Wadden Sea and Brittany).
Risk, resilience and adaptation challenges vary according to specific threats and contexts and therefore require
different solutions. This is explored in PERICLES in demos that include adaption in the face of climate change
challenges (Malta and Wadden Sea), the challenges associated with growing demands on maritime and coastal
resources though Blue growth (Scotland and Denmark), and challenges to traditional ways of life (Estonia,
Malta, Aegean).
Deliberative and Participatory Governance
Participation is essential in governing both CH and landscapes (e.g. International Council on Monuments and
Sites, 1987; Convention on Biological Diversity, 2004), to ensure integration of diverse knowledge, values
and perspectives, ensure recognition of all salient risks, avoid or reduce conflict and find synergies between
different interests, and broadly improve the quality of decisions (Kenter et al., 2014). Governance is about the
rules of collective decision-making (Chhotray & Stoker, 2009; Kjaer, 2004). Governance and developments
in participation can be linked to the notion of ‘deliberative democracy’ (Cohen, 1998; Warren, 1999; Hajer &
Wagenaar, 2003), and empowered participatory governance (Fung & Wright, 2004), the ultimate aim of which
is the formulation of a common understanding (Van Tatenhove & Leroy, 2003). PERICLES will provide a
comprehensive, empowered participatory governance framework for sustainable management and
conservation of European coastal and maritime cultural landscapes, to assess and mitigate risks and integrate
knowledge across local, spatial, environmental, social and economic aspects of CH.
Core to our concept of empowered participation are group deliberation and social learning. Deliberation can
be defined as including the search for and social exchange of information and values to form and express
reasoned opinions, identification of options and solutions and their consequences and the formation of values
and reasoned preferences around these options (Kenter et al., 2016). Such a process intrinsically involves social
learning, in the sense of a change in understanding that goes beyond individuals to become situated in wider
social groups or communities (Reed et al., 2010). As a result, the potential for trust-building and commitment
is much enhanced.
We will expand our concept of deliberation beyond discussion group formats to include in situ (e.g., quayside)
deliberation and arts-led dialogue (Edwards et al., 2016), where deliberation and interpretation is linked to
place and identity through creative interventions and community based art production, for example through
the transformation of crowd sourced multimedia (video, sound, stories, poetry, imagery etc.) content into
artistic creations which then form the object of deliberation.
Building on the framework for goal-driven deliberation by Carcasson (2009), our approach to deliberation and
social learning has not just first but also deeper second and third order goals that are achieved through these
more in-depth and situated approaches to deliberation. First order goals include issue learning, improved
relationships, and enhancing the quality and legitimacy of research outputs. Second order goals include
improving institutional decision making, providing spaces to decide on collective action and for resolving
conflict, as well as intergenerational transmission of CH knowledge and know-how, and an ability to view and
connect challenges across issues, such as understanding interlinkages between CH preservation and climate
change adaptation. Third order goals include enhanced civic capacity not just to understand, preserve and
exploit CH but more broadly to collectively understand and engage with important social issues and solve
problems.
Participation and democratic deliberation are sometimes juxtaposed. For example, conventional consultation
in planning allows anyone with an interest in a decision to engage in consultation events. Other initiatives for
community participation, such as participatory budgeting schemes, are typically similarly open. This approach
is critiqued by deliberative democratic theorists and practitioners because it tends to attract ‘the usual suspects’.
Deliberative democratic methods such as citizens’ juries and deliberative polls work on the basis of or ‘mini-
publics’, quasi-random representations of people who are selected to represent a broader population in terms
of socio-economic and demographic characteristics. In environmental and landscape management a third
approach is typical; here participation takes place through structured approaches (typically deliberative
workshops) attended by invited stakeholders who represent particular interests, ideally selected through a
8
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
rigorous stakeholder analysis, which aims to ensure no significant interest is excluded or over-represented
(Reed, 2008).
PERICLES’ approach will interlink these three different perspectives: public participation; public deliberative
democratic deliberation; and stakeholder deliberation and participation to enable an effective broad scope
approach that ensures both inclusion of specific interests and broad democratic representation of citizens.
Specifically, our scope includes 1) participation of developers whose projects may pose risks to CH; 2)
participation of actors who exploit CH e.g. tourism, creative sectors and arts; 3) broader stakeholder
participation based on specific interests relevant to maritime and coastal CH, e.g. heritage conservation,
recreation, fisheries, shipping, ecosystem management; 4) public participation of citizens and local
communities across our demonstration regions, including through citizen science; 5) participation of policy
makers and planners in both the CH and marine governance arenas to ensure the project effectively informs
relevant decision-making contexts. These perspectives will be applied across case regions in a broad range of
Demos, as a well as project wide activities. For example, stakeholders and policy makers will be engaged in
exploring the integration of CH in marine spatial planning (Scotland, Ireland, Estonia, Portugal) and in climate
change adaptation policy (Malta, Wadden Sea, Brittany). Developers and citizens will be engaged in
understanding the threats and opportunities of blue growth to CH (Malta, Scotland, Estonia, Denmark). Both
stakeholders and citizens will be engaged project wide in a citizen science public participation mapping
campaign. We will work with businesses, social enterprises and the education sector in exploitation workshops
to develop the different economic and social potentials of maritime and coastal CH. PERICLES’ broad multi-
actor scope, where deliberations will effectively link different stakeholders and decision-makers, will enable
co-production of knowledge across sectors and interests and ensure improved integration of cultural and
environmental policy arenas. Our concept of participation, grounded in theories of deliberative democracy,
social learning, plural values and co-production, will thus underpin an effective multi-actor framework for
assessing risks and opportunities, and the adaptation and integration of existing techniques (e.g. multi-criteria
approaches, participatory mapping) as well as development of novel techniques that can enhance recognition
of CH in key policy appraisal venues (e.g. SEA, environmental and economic impact assessments) and
planning arena’s (MSP, ICZM) for the marine environment and coastal landscapes.
We also recognise the particular importance of youth participation (including also in dissemination and
communication). The conservation and exploitation of cultural heritage is a long-term process which depends
on transfer of capacities (skills, knowledge), identities and social institutions across generations. It has also
been argued that, in many instances, understanding of and respect for cultural heritage, and in particular a sense
of shared cultural heritage must be actively taught and learned (Copsey & Rowe, 2011). PERICLES will both
be cognisant of youth participation across its activities as well as specifically target youth.
b) Methodology
Introduction
PERICLES employs a participatory, multi-method and
cross-disciplinary research approach. This will enable a
wide range of qualitative and quantitative data and findings
to be gathered and analysed to inform the development of
policies and tools to sustainably manage and use both
tangible and intangible CH resources and land/seascapes.
The project will include eight pilot study and
demonstration sites across six case regions: the Atlantic,
Aegean, Baltic, Irish, Wadden and Mediterranean Seas (see
Figure 1). that will facilitate an in-depth understanding of
CH and will enable PERICLES to co-produce innovative
practical tools for the preservation of cultural landscapes.
Overview of the work packages
The work plan covers a 36-month period and the objectives
of the project will be achieved through a series of research Figure 2. PERICLES Work Plan
activities distributed over 7 work packages (WPs) as
9
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
illustrated in Figure 2. WP1 (Project management) covers the overarching task of project administrative and
coordinating activities including reporting of the project progress and communication with the EC. WP2
(Eliciting Understanding of CH) sets the stage for the research, with the scientific Understanding of CH
structured and guided by PERICLES’ Three Pillars (see above, 1.3a) organising both the scientific theoretical
work and the practical, case-study research. The work and outputs of WP2 feed into WP3 (Development of
Practical Tools). This work (WP3) culminates in templates for setting up tools feeding into WP4 (Co-
production of a Risk Assessment and Sustainable Exploitation Framework), WP5 (Policy integration)
and into WP6 (Development of Stakeholder Networks) which is oriented towards engagement with local
communities, civil society organizations, policy makers, economic stakeholders, and scholars. By connecting
WP2-6 to WP7 (Communication, dissemination and maximization of PERICLES impacts) on an ongoing
basis, we ensure knowledge transfer and impact generating activities and dissemination to the wider public.
Project impacts will be maximised through a robust communication, dissemination and monitoring strategy.
This will include strategic advice from the Impact Advisory Group comprised of International CH experts and
practitioners. PERICLES will include wide range of outputs aimed at maximising impact of the research,
which include a dedicated interactive website, social media, information sheets, CH tools, policy briefings
and academic papers. Research methods to be used in WPs 2-6 are detailed below.
WP2 Eliciting a Deep Understanding of Maritime and Coastal CH
With meeting sub-objective 1 (Section 1.1) in mind, this WP will develop an in-depth, situated understanding
of CH, both tangible and intangible, and provide a comprehensive picture of its societal importance. This WP
will create the necessary foundation for ensuing WPs, providing both a general and regionally-specific
overview of CH. It encompasses both academic and policy perspectives and stakeholder understandings of the
concept and investigates designation processes. Case studies will be grouped, compared and contrasted by key
indicators such as shared CH type (e.g., shipwrecks in the Mediterranean and Baltic regions; boat building
techniques in the Baltic and Atlantic; language and rituals in the Atlantic, Baltic and Scottish/Irish regions)
and/or cross-cutting themes such as fishing heritage and memory, intensity of tourism pressures, demographic
challenges and policy challenges such as marine planning. WP2 will work iteratively: firstly, developing our
three-pillar framework through literature and policy review and conceptual analysis to underpin work in other
WPs and across the case regions; and, secondly synthesising results to develop a deep, situated understanding
arising through application of the concepts.
Figure 3: Timeline of PERICLES work
WP3 Practical methods and tools
As highlighted in 2, this WP will review, develop and pilot practical methods and tools, based on the principles
of stakeholder involvement and participatory governance, to enable and facilitate both the preservation and
sustainable growth of CH assets. WP3 will both build on the conceptual framework developed by WP2 to
10
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
select and pilot appropriate tools, and then deliver the tools necessary to further work in WP2. The tools will
be presented in a web-based format that will facilitate both updates and dissemination; it will also act as a
knowledge exchange resource to endure beyond the life of the project. Main activities in this WP are the review
of existing methods and tools, and piloting a wide range in case regions. Methods and tools applied will include
Visual Problem Appraisal and ethnographic video methods; citizen science public participation mapping;
qualitative interviews; structured surveys; comparative policy analysis; historical and archaeological
approaches; DNA analysis; ecological models; expert input and knowledge exchange, training events and peer-
to-peer networking; innovation workshops to identify new products and services that can be used to sustainably
exploit CH; risk assessment; deliberative multi-criteria workshops; economic valuation methods to understand
consumer preferences for different products in local economies, which will help to identify indicators of
success and barriers; visioning exercises to identify ideas and ambitions; and artistic interventions, to help to
capture and portray heritage knowledge. This WP also develops a dedicated public participation mapping portal
and will work in conjunction with WP7 to organise a European-scale citizen science campaign to populate it;
and working with WPs 2, 4 and 5 to analyse, interpret and harness the data for effective action.
WP4 Co-production of a Risk Assessment and Sustainable Exploitation Framework
This WP will co-produce with stakeholders a comprehensive, participatory framework for the sustainable
management, conservation and exploitation of European coastal and maritime cultural landscapes. Utilising
sites across the eight case study regions, this framework will integrate knowledge across local, spatial,
environmental, social and economic frames of CH. This WP will use a range of methods, such as the
innovation-oriented method of living labs which engage a mix of stakeholder to co-produce a sustainability
framework that addresses risks (e.g., demographic changes, rising seas, pressure from increased tourism) and
harnesses opportunities for using CH assets for sustainable growth and new business, career, education and
community development opportunities. One method used will be living labs. Through using living labs, a mix
of public and private sector and community stakeholders will be engaged to co-produce a sustainability
framework building on understanding gained through WP1 and using participatory, deliberative and co-
production tools developed in WP3. Living labs are purposely aimed to serve innovation in real life contexts.
WP5 Policy integration
In order to improve the integration of CH in key marine and environmental policies (e.g. ICZM, MSP and
MSFD) and assessments (EIA, SEA) as outlined in sub-objective 4, this WP will undertake policy analysis
through desk-based reviews and deliberation with decision-makers at multiple scales, to provide a suite of
policy recommendations. We will take stock of policies adopted on the preservation and use of CH to explore
the relationships between CH and EU and national maritime policies, building on WPs 2 and 4 to understand
how better policy integration can comprehensively address key risks to CH in different contexts and support
more effective harnessing of cultural assets for sustainable and inclusive growth. We will also conduct a semi-
quantitative valuation of the integration and coordination principles behind ICZM (Pickaver et al., 2004;
Ballinger et al., 2010; Martino, 2016), with special focus on coordination and integration of CH policies.
Moreover, demo’s will take place across several case regions where there are active marine plan developments
to directly put CH integration in practice in live decision-making contexts.
WP6 Development of Stakeholder Networks
As the development of effective knowledge exchange networks among policy makers, stakeholders and
scholars, and the facilitation of formative participation in the project is paramount (sub-objective 5), each
partner will engage policy makers, stakeholders and scholars and build and support such networks within their
case region and regional seas. Innovative engagement mechanisms will be used to connect with intellectual
investors, such as staging regional events, that celebrate and interrogate cultural histories; digital networking,
through the online portal and webinars; and engaged scholarship as a means of collaboration with identified
communities of interest. The project partners and APs will act as conduits for a transnational stakeholder
network to be a holistic dissemination and engagement instrument.
WP7 Communication, Dissemination & Maximization of impacts
PERICLES will develop robust communication, dissemination and maximisation strategies. These strategies
will ensure the timely transfer of research outputs to the general public, public and private sector stakeholders
(multiple-scale management and government bodies, industry, etc.) and the scientific community. Sustainable
11
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
pathways to maximising the impact of the project, which will endure beyond the project timeframe, will be
coproduced with stakeholders. Dissemination and Communication Plans will take into consideration all the
characteristics of the different target audiences (e.g. community, government, industry) of PERICLES. The
strategies developed to maximise the impact of the project will outline short-term impacts, and how they will
be achieved during the lifetime of the project, and long-term impacts, and pathways to achieving them beyond
the end of the project.
Overview of Case Regions and Demonstrators
At the heart of PERICLES are eight case regions across six European seas: the Aveiro lagoon on the central
Portuguese coast (Atlantic Ocean); the North-east Aegean Sea and Malta (Mediterranean Sea); Scotland,
Ireland & Northern Ireland (Atlantic Ocean and Irish Sea); the Wadden Sea; inshore coastal Denmark and
Danish islands (Baltic Sea); South-west coast of Estonia (Baltic Sea); and Brittany (Atlantic Ocean). In this
section, the case regions are described, presenting the geographic background, (tangible and intangible) CH
themes and key issues they face. Each of the case regions will develop an in-depth understanding of, and
spatially map multiple types of tangible and intangible maritime CH and explore different threats to CH and
opportunities for harnessing CH assets for sustainable and inclusive development and growth. This will be
achieved through a comprehensive dialogue between different scientific fields and extensive involvement of
citizens, policy makers and stakeholders. Activities in case regions are operationalized through region wide
activities and local and regional demonstrators (demos) that focus on specific themes or issues linking research
and innovation. In addition, a number of key approaches (public participation mapping, visual problem
appraisal and ethnographic video, and arts-science approaches, risk and vulnerability assessment and
comparative policy analysis) will be broadly applied across case regions supporting implementation of the
demos and enabling cross-regional and European scale outputs and impacts.
Table 1 Overview of case regions with key CH themes, issues and demonstration (demo) projects.
Case region CH Themes Issues Demonstrations (Demos)
Denmark Rich maritime and Low populations; limited D1: Integration of CH into
seafaring history; unique infrastructure; risk from out- development and Blue
heritage structures; migration; increased pressures Growth Plans/ strategies in
fishing; boat-building; from tourism; development transboundary decision-
cultural connections without regard to tangible CH; making
through fishing and poor stock status; deregulation D2: Using CH for
maritime navigation; of the strong protection of resilience and adaptation in
oral and folk traditions; coastal areas; increased port and landscape
seafaring & boatbuilding attention to maritime, tourism transitions
heritage and local development policies D3: Knowledge transfer of
boat building skills for
local development
D4: Maritime heritage and
tourism interactions
Estonia Underwater archaeology; Poor infrastructure; poor water E1: Integrating CH into
fishing communities; quality and sanitation; lack of maritime spatial planning
arts and crafts; cultural primary processing facilities in (region wide)
connections through fishing industry; Natura 2000 E2: Blue growth and
fishing and maritime site threatening development; coastal culture:
navigation; oral and folk increasing reliance on tourism; development-heritage
traditions; seafaring & depopulation, poor stock status interactions (Kihnu and
boatbuilding heritage Ruhnu Islands)
E3: E9 European Coastal
Path
Malta Historic architecture Hunting of birds; reliance on M1: Local, traditional and
(megalithic temples and tourism, summer especially; sustainable: Understanding,
catacombs); hunting and threats to fish stocks; climate preserving and exploring
trapping traditions; change; challenges for Maltese food CH through
12
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
tangible CH from agriculture and fishing; water gastro-tourism
multiple historic eras and resource issue and health M2: balancing cultural and
cultures; fisheries; concerns; refugee crisis; 'brain- natural heritage activities
fireworks culture drain' M3: Coastal developments
and climate change
adaptation
Aegean Sea Aquatic resources; Little exploration of ecological A: The story of fish:
fishing traditions; and biological background of Linking humanities and
intangible aspects of the marine resources; pollution; environmental science to
resource exploitation; touristic development of the explore fishing traditions
marine knowledge, coasts; overfishing; changes in and cuisine from antiquity
skills, legends and the hydrologic balance between to present
beliefs; development of fresh water discharge and salt A2: Preserving CH:
iconic fisheries; fish water; the financial crisis; Fishing communities in a
processing cultural prejudices changing world – mapping
resilience, adaptation,
abandonment and change
A3: Exploiting CH: The
“fishing stories” of the
Northeastern Aegean in
education, tourism and
industry
Portugal Traditions of salt Disappearance of salt pans; P1. Integrating CH into
production, seaweed erosion of social and cultural maritime spatial planning
gathering, agriculture; values, histories and cultural in the Aveiro region:
cod fishing and anthropogenic landscape; Preserving Aveiro lagoon
processing; boat- disconnection between tourism traditions
building; canning; industry needs and training P2. Integrating CH into
traditional extraction programs; impacts of climate coastal tourism: The
(beach nets, seaweed & change (e.g. coastal erosion); lagoon traditional boats
salt ponds); seafaring; urban sprawl (“moliceiros”) from
shellfish farming; transport to tourism
religious heritage; P3. Salt CH – from mono
Natura 2000 site to multifunctional
anthropogenic landscape
(lead by: Filomena Martins
and Carlos Costa)
P4. Culinary route in the
Aveiro lagoon region:
Understanding, preserving
and exploring fish food CH
through gastro-tourism
Scotland- Gaelic language; Decreasing and aging SI1: Integrating CH into
Ireland emigration and diaspora; population; declining base for coastal and maritime
tangible and intangible services and economic activity; spatial planning (region
Celtic Christian and pre- declining central government wide)– lead: Highland
Christian religious budgets under austerity policies; Council
heritage; smallholder- marine renewable energy and SI2: Exploring maritime
crofting culture; inshore aquaculture; post-Brexit industrial heritage
fisheries and industrial fisheries policy; poor (Belfast)
maritime heritage recruitment in fisheries; lack of SI3: Diversity in landings
sensitivity to CH in Blue and local food:
Growth developments rejuvenating inshore
fisheries heritage (West
13
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
coast of Scotland)
SI4: Blue growth and
coastal culture:
development-heritage
interactions (Inner
Hebrides and Galway Bay
and the Aran Islands)
Wadden Sea One of the largest Divided governance; past W1: Coastal adaptation
wetlands in the world; conflicts between exploitation planning
seafaring heritage; (gas extraction and fisheries) W2: Gastro tourism, local
fisheries and and nature conservation; identities, salty agriculture
mariculture; marine impacts of climate change; and the slow food
parks; landscape unsustainable development; movement
conservation coastal defence W3: International cultural
divergences between
Netherlands, Denmark and
Germany.
Brittany Built and landscape Overlooked fisheries heritage; B1: Climate change,
architecture of coastal top-down initiatives lacking coastal risks and CH
towns; marine parks; citizen participation; erosion; B2: Inventory and mapping
traditional extractive rising sea levels; pressure from of CH in the Gulf of
methods: fisheries and urbanisation and development; Morbihan
shellfish farming; Celtic oral tradition of Breton B3: Preserving and
tradition; sailing language compromises promoting the heritage of
heritage; prehistoric recollection Brittany seaweed tradition
settlements B4: Tangible CH and
landscape in land planning,
urbanisation and marine
spatial planning
B5: Social history of
women in fisheries as a CH
in Brittany
North-east Aegean Sea
The Aegean Sea with its extensive coastline and its archipelago of over 6000 islands, large and small, is
characterized by a remarkable environmental and cultural variability, which has been shaped by its complex
geological and long cultural history. This case study will focus on one aspect of CH: the exploitation of aquatic
resources. There are certain areas that developed very rich and long-lived fishing traditions which shaped the
identity and worldviews of coastal people, as well as complex economies that were based on the exploitation
of marine resources, their processing and their participation in regional and distant markets. The ecological
and biological background of these developments is little explored. The proposed case region focuses on the
North-east Aegean Sea, between Chalkidiki Peninsula and a line defined by the estuary of Evros River and
Samothrace island (which borders Turkey). Fishing, and its associated CH in this area is seriously threatened
by changes imposed by global environmental change, but also by human activities on a local and supra-regional
level: pollution, touristic development of the coasts and overfishing, as well as changes in the hydrologic
balance between fresh water discharge and salt water. In this case region we will focus on developing an in-
depth historical understanding of CH to provide administrators, the business sector and local communities with
knowledge and tools to pursue a sustainable development in this coastal and marine area.
Inshore coastal Denmark and Danish islands
Denmark has a rich maritime and seafaring history with the islands of southern Denmark supporting its position
as the gatekeeper of the Baltic. Such islands, like much of rural Denmark, are faced with demographic
challenges, limited infrastructure and limited employment opportunities. The islands also face increased
pressures from tourism. Contemporary Denmark continues to have links to shipping and transport, but also
14
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
looks to uncover its maritime heritage as a means for place-making and tourism. Moreover, many small coastal
ports and communities throughout Denmark, including the Limfjord area in the north, developed as trading
hubs and then transitioned into fishing communities. Fishing communities in Denmark have witnessed many
changes, but select communities have worked to preserve this way of life and the supporting industries (e.g.,
wooden boatbuilding craft) that allow fishing fleets to land in their local villages. Much of the region is rural,
and is faced with demographic challenges in terms of a decreasing and aging population. In this case region,
we will explore how local communities and peoples can adapt to contemporary conditions using their cultural
heritage to help tackle the challenges they face (e.g., strengthening societal awareness of maritime heritage for
tourism and community development, such as through citizen arts/science initiatives); while also investigating
how some initiatives such as blue growth development (renewable energy; aquaculture; water sports) may also
generate risks to cultural heritage and seascapes. We will consider policy challenges such as how Denmark
institutes marine spatial planning and regional development. We will also investigate how local, cultural
knowledge (e.g., traditional boat building; maritime navigation) can provide a platform for community
revitalisation, strengthened community identity, as well as tourism development. Activities in this case region
will include the large-scale citizen science CH mapping work common to all studies in PERICLES, a demo
focused on integrating CH into marine and coastal spatial planning and three targeted local pilots and demos
that deal with key threats and opportunities in relation to maritime and coastal CH.
South-west coast of Estonia
The case region, Pärnu Bay region and islands in the Gulf of Riga, is an important summer holiday destination
for Estonians as well as the country´s main coastal fisheries. For example, the catch of approximately14,030
tonnes accounted for over 84% of the country´s coastal fishing catch. However, the area suffers from poor
infrastructure as well as poor water quality and sanitation, while the fishing sector lacks equipment for primary
processing. Improvements in these areas are prerequisites for developing a local processing industry as well
as pursuing a strategy for diversification, in particular tourism. Almost the entire region is covered by Natura
2000, which also impacts development. The Pärnu Bay region and islands in the Gulf of Riga, including islands
such as Kihnu and Ruhnu, offer a meaningful case study of diminishing natural resources, a marine-based local
economy and locals’ relationship with new forms of tourism, such as heritage tourism and
yachting. Kihnu residents grapple with the UNESCO designation and increasing reliance on tourism and want
to drive their own development. They remain critical of those from outside looking to extract heritage
resources without offering ideas and initiatives that feed back into the island. In this case region, we will
develop participatory process aimed at incorporating CH into ongoing MSP efforts in the case study area and
investigate ways to ensure CH is protected. We also will include work on viable means to continue
development and employment for locals which includes and protects aspects of their unique culture. We will
produce 3D images of four wreck sites for promoting the European Coastal Path in a new, innovative
way.
Malta
The focus in this case region is to understand, preserve and harness CH in the Maltese archipelago. The
archipelago, of which the three largest islands (Malta, Gozo and Comino) are inhabited, is situated in the centre
of the Mediterranean Sea; its geographical position has given Malta strategic importance throughout history.
Malta is a very popular tourist destination, and the country depends heavily on its tourism industry in terms of
GDP. In 2015, 1.6 million tourists visited Malta, which was three times the number of residents. Malta also
has a rich natural heritage, attracting tourists such as divers, bird watchers, seafood lovers and recreational
fishermen. Both Gozo and Comino are known for some of the Mediterranean's best dive sites. Although the
country has very few resident birds, it is strategically located for birds migrating between European breeding
and African wintering grounds.
Like on many islands, there is concern about direct and indirect impacts of climate change, such as changes in
sea level and temperature, more variability and unpredictability in rainfall patterns and high(er) humidity and
air temperature, especially in summer. Climate change is however not only associated with threats (and
opportunities) for tourism; Malta also anticipates challenges for the agriculture and fishery sectors, and
foresees problems with water resources and its population's health. PERICLES will explore the role that CH
plays in balancing Malta’s multifaceted character as described above, how Malta can deal with the impact of
climate change on CH and the role that CH can play in climate change adaptation.
15
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Aveiro Lagoon, Portugal
The Ria de Aveiro coastal region integrates 11 municipalities and is characterized by the presence of an
extensive lagoon occupying about 11,000 ha. The lagoon is one of the largest, most biologically significant
coastal wetlands in Portugal (DGOTDU, 2004), and is classified under Natura 2000. The lagoon offers a unique
landscape and many traditionally economic important activities, such as fishing, salt production, seaweed
gathering, aquaculture and agriculture, as well as newer economic opportunities such as coastal and marine
sport and tourism (CCDR-C, 2015). The region’s population has a long tradition linked to the sea and to the
salt marsh lagoon, with fishing and salt production activities having always been important for the economic
development of the region. The fishing communities in the region used to be strongly involved in cod fishing.
The region was also the most important in Portugal in terms of preparing and processing cod, strongly related
to the enormous salt production in the lagoon. These traditional activities suffered a steep decline over the last
decades with a consequent disappearance of natural (in the case of saltpans), social and cultural values
associated with them. Some of these activities are now returning, with the emergence of new entrepreneurship
initiatives, focusing on traditional activities for tourist purposes. Several of these activities still face threats,
while new initiatives present risks/threats to cultural, natural and ethnographic/historic heritage. By developing
a deeper understanding of the region maritime and coastal CH in this case region, we will explore how
opportunities supported in CH-tourism and gastro-tourism can promote traditional activities adapted to new
demand.
The Coasts of Scotland, Northern Ireland and Ireland
This large-scale case region seeks to understand, preserve and harness CH across the Atlantic seaboard and
inner seas of the west coasts of Scotland and the Republic of Ireland and the coast of Northern Ireland. There
are strong ties between the Irish and Scottish coasts in terms of Gaelic and Irish language, history and culture,
emigration and diaspora, tangible and intangible Celtic Christian and pre-Christian religious heritage,
smallholder-crofting culture, inshore fisheries and industrial maritime heritage. Much of the region is rural,
and is faced with demographic challenges in terms of a decreasing and aging population. This generates a
vicious cycle of a declining base for services and economic activity, particularly in combination with declining
central government budgets under austerity policies. PERICLES will explore how traditional sectors such as
crofting and fisheries can adapt, how opportunities for blue growth based on CH, such as through CH-tourism,
gastronomy and creative industries can help to tackle these challenges, and how blue growth developments
such as marine renewable energy and aquaculture may generate risks to CH but also potentially generate new
CH. We will consider common policy challenges in terms of regional policy, such as the proposed Scottish
Islands Bill and cross-boundary marine and coastal planning as well as post-Brexit fisheries policy, that are
likely to have significant implications for CH. We will also investigate how urban industrial CH (shipbuilding)
can provide a platform for social regeneration. Activities in this case region will include the large-scale citizen
science CH mapping work common to all case studies, a region wide demo focused on integrating CH into
marine and coastal spatial planning and three targeted local demos that deal with key threats and opportunities
in relation to CH.
Wadden Sea
The Wadden Sea area is a vast coastal wetland area on the North Sea coast of major international importance,
comprising tidal flats, islands, salt marshes and other habitats. It covers almost 10,000 square kilometres in
extent and it is one of the largest wetlands in the world. The area stretches over 450 km along the North Sea
coast of the Netherlands, Germany and Denmark, which are cooperating since 1978 to protect the Wadden Sea
as an ecological entity, employing as the guiding principle “to achieve, as far as possible, a natural and
sustainable ecosystem in which natural processes proceed in an undisturbed way”. The Wadden Sea’s specific
national and international interest is expressed in its status as World Heritage since 2009, and its designation
as national park, and its nature reserves on various islands, hosting many migratory birds, therefore attractive
to bird watchers and other nature lovers. The Wadden Islands are very much “man-made”: they are inhabited
for thousands of years, salt marshes were turned into pastures and farmland, and dikes were built to protect
people, their livestock and belongings. This latter is still of key concern, especially with regard to climate
change. CH values in the area range from archaeological digs, traditional customs and sites such as the horse-
driven lifeboat on the island of Ameland, the commander houses of whale hunting captains, and the famous
Willem Barentsz school for navigation, to events such as Texel Culinair highlighting the culinary past and
present of the island. Coastal communities depend on fishing and (gastro-) tourism for their livelihoods.
Another economic sector with interests in the Wadden Sea is the gas and oil industry, but plans to drill for
16
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
natural gas are subject of fierce debates for many years. To facilitate information sharing and learning,
PERICLES will develop spaces for stakeholder dialogue and participatory conversations that will allow for
examine the importance of CH for the Wadden Sea, focussing on the complexities of coastal protection,
preserving and developing unique natural features and rich CH, as well as exploring the strengths and
challenges of collaboration between institutions in an international context in which socio-cultural differences
go beyond mere language barriers.
Brittany
Brittany is the premier maritime region in France, with 2,730 km of coasts along the English Channel, the
Celtic Sea and the Bay of Biscay, and its second most important touristic region. Evidence of prehistorical
human settlements along the coast have been found and standing stones constitute major heritage from that
period; megaliths are also found below sea level, which was lower in earlier times.
Following a long tradition in coastal and maritime fishing, Brittany is still today the most important region for
fishing, as well as shellfish culture, in France. This maritime tradition extends to both the merchant navy and
the navy, Brittany being home to major military harbours. Traditional sailing boats are valued in many places
and sailing, as a leisure activity, is a major component of the Brittany economy. Within Breton culture and its
Celtic tradition, maritime tangible and intangible heritage is extensive today and a key asset in the
attractiveness of Brittany’s tourism sector. Along the coast many signs of past activity can be found and much
effort is devoted to preserving these signs as the coast continues to be under strong pressure for further
development and urbanisation. Erosion and rising sea level threaten this coastal heritage. As the Breton
language lies for a large part in an oral tradition that has been suppressed in the first half of the 20th century,
the recollection of intangible CH has been, and still is, a challenge. Many of the maritime traditions of Brittany
are in museums, festivals and other activities in which relevant actors and the public are engaged. Our focus
within this case region will be to support the Marine Regional park in inventory and promote CH for marine
traditional activities (shellfish farming, traditional sailing boats, etc.). Within their landscape observatory
develop underwater landscape extension. Seaweed harvesting as heritage to support new ways to develop
seaweed sector.
Cross-case connections
In order to understand both the breadth of themes and issues that will be examined in each case region and the
cross-cutting connections between the case studies, Table 1 illustrates the CH themes and regional issues. The
table also outlines the regional demo projects. The implementation of these demos, is geared towards recording
and understanding CH at present and historically, testing novel analytic and practical approaches related to CH
preservation and exploitation, bringing together researchers, citizens, policy makers, industry, NGOs and other
stakeholders to develop in-depth research and concrete innovation and dissemination activities, building
capacity and generating lasting positive impact.
Example demonstratrations
PERICLES will undertake 29 demonstrations (demos) on a diverse range of CH challenges and opportunities.
Some demonstrators occur across the case study regions, while others afford the opportunity to explore in-
depth particular CH issues germane to specific areas. For example, 4 demos will examine how to integrate
CH into coastal and maritime spatial planning. These demos will develop participatory processes aimed at
incorporating CH into ongoing coastal and marine spatial planning efforts in their case regions (Scotland-
Ireland; Estonia, Portugal and Brittany). They will critically review existing MSP data and explore how
CH can be incorporated into these datasets. Through policy workshops, planners and stakeholders will work
together to identify culturally significant areas. Finally, through exploitation workshops, participants will
explore how MSP can play a role in helping them to sustainably use CH in the study areas.
Four demos will examine risk to CH across the study region. For example, B1, M1 and W1, focus on climate
change, coastal risks and CH in Brittany, Malta and the Wadden Sea. Here PERICLES will work at raising
awareness and developing tools adequate for the needs to address the issue of CH. Coastal path, buildings and
infrastructures that testimony past and recent uses of the coast as well as archaeological remains above and
below water are some components to be considered. W1-2 will use the Wadden Sea UNESCO site to develop
participatory approaches to support local communities and NGOs to contribute to the conservation and
17
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
management of the site, while W2 and SI3 will use CH to develop new opportunities linking gastronomy and
sustainable tourism focusing on sustainable island agriculture and inshore fishing respectively.
Other demos will explore the sustainable exploitation of CH, with a focus on tourism. For example, SI2 will
explore the maritime industrial heritage of Belfast and the potential to further develop tourism products in this
area. In 2016, Titanic Belfast was named as Europe’s Leading Visitor Attraction and World’s Leading Tourist
Attraction at the prestigious World Travel Awards. The aim of this demonstration project is to explore how
the post-industrial maritime of port cities can be sustainably exploited. It will review the factors that has made
Titanic Belfast a success and explore how this can be rolled out to include other aspects of the city's maritime
heritage. The demo project will do this through exploitation workshops with business and other stakeholders.
Using the example of lagoon traditional boats in Averio, P2 will examine how to integrate CH into coastal
tourism. The moliceiro is a traditional boat used, in the past, to transport “moliço” (a mix of vascular plants
and seaweed, that was used as fertilizer for agriculture). Nowadays it is the symbol of Aveiro city (the “water
city” due to its extensive network of canals) and is used to transport visitors around the city’s canals. These
boats trips allow visitors to see and link maritime and coastal heritage, and for synergies with other CH
hotspots, such as saltpans, gastronomy, and Art Nouveau buildings. This demo will aim to preserve and
promote the moliceiro CH for the next generations by documenting and analysing the moliceiro iconographic
importance and boatbuilding/ shipbuilding, using techniques and methodologies such as arts (photography and
other arts) video-recording, analysis of moliceiro industry socio-cultural impact for the community and the
residents/ visitors in the area. The research will be based in interviews, workshops and collaborative approach
with the stakeholders. Other demos (W2, M1 and P4) will focus on the potential of gastro-tourism, the positive
and negative interaction between tourism and coastal heritage (D4) and the development of new heritage
products, such as a European Coastal Path (E3). These demos will explore how CH offers an alternative to
mass tourism, how the development of site specific, culturally rich tourism experiences can preserve and
sustainably exploit the EU's rich coastal heritage and work with tourism providers to develop exploitation
strategies and the development and exchange of good practice.
Other demos will pilot and test approaches for balancing CH with other activities. For example, D1, E2, and
SI4 will specifically focus on the threats and opportunities for CH that will emerge through the implementation
of Blue Growth strategies in Denmark, Estonia and Scotland. For example, SI4 will look at the interactions of
aquaculture and marine tourism with cultural heritage. Risks include physical and aesthetic interactions with
tangible above and underwater heritage such as wrecks, reefs and landscape features, but also implications for
non-tangible spatially explicit heritage such as historic and mythological locations where development could
negatively affect place identity. We will also explore the opportunities these industries might present coastal
communities in being able to address demographic and economic issues and evolving their maritime heritage
to include these developing marine industries.
Methods and tools
Table 2 (below) illustrates, within the context of the PERICLES project as a whole, the matrix of methods and
tools employed within the project as a whole and within case region demos. The broad range of methodological
approaches is apparent, while cross-cutting methods enables the identification of parallel tools for demo
comparisons. We will below briefly highlight several key approaches to be used: participatory, deliberative
and co-production methods; citizen science public participation mapping; artistic and arts-science approaches;
Visual Problem Appraisal (VPA); arts-science methods; coupled ecological economic approaches; and risk
and vulnerability assessment.
18
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Table 2. Overview of key methods and tools
Case Participatory, Economic & Ecological Qualitative and Historical and Arts-Science Document and Policy
Region deliberative and co- quantitative Methods Ethnographic Archaeological Methods Analyses
production methods social methods Methods Methods
Project- Citizen science Interviews Arts-science Desktop reviews of:
wide Public collaboration policies, plans,
participation mapping for online academic and grey
GIS portal, mapping literature; GIS
Participatory risk portal integration of spatial
analysis, Policy data in online portal
integration workshops,
exploitation workshops,
other deliberative
techniques (e.g.
visioning &
backcasting,
multicriteria tools)
Scotland Mediated stakeholder Market Ecological Visual Arts-led SWOT analysis
and participation Research, Modelling ethnography/visual dialogue
Ireland Sustainable problem appraisal Creative
Livelihoods interventions
Approach,
Choice
experiments
Estonia Ethnographic data Arts-science Review of existing
collection collaboration data, 3D
documentation and
modelling of wrecks
Denmark Mediated stakeholder Oral histories, Visual Arts-science SWOT analysis
participation ethnography/visual collaboration
problem appraisal
Aegean Paeleoecological Ethnographic data Fish bone and DNA Arts-science
data collection, analysis, archival collaboration
audio/visual research
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
interviews. Oral
histories
Portugal Mediated stakeholder Market Ethnographic Arts-science SWOT analysis
participation Research documentation, collaboration
Visual
ethnography/visual
problem appraisal
Malta Adaptation strategy Questionnaires Ecological data Visual
workshops on fisheries ethnography/visual
impacts problem appraisal
Brittany Adaptation strategy Use of social Historical document CH inventory analysis,
workshops networks to collect analysis (social legal analysis,
intangible heritage, history), historical Institutional analysis
photo analysis (long
term landscape
obervation)
Wadden Mediated stakeholder Visual Institutional analysis
Sea participation, ethnography/visual
Adaptation strategy problem appraisal
workshops
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Deliberative, participatory and co-production methods
Building on Pillar 3, Participatory and Deliberative Governance, a wide range of approaches to participation,
deliberation and knowledge co-production will be central to PERICLES’ methodology. As outlined in Section
1.3a, PERICLES’ approach will interlink these three different perspectives: public participation; public
deliberative democratic deliberation; and stakeholder deliberation and participation to enable an effective
broad scope approach that ensures both inclusion of specific interests and broad democratic representation of
citizens. In addition to individual forms of participation, such as engagement through the interactive mapping
portal, interviews and questionnaires, a central tool will be the use of various kinds of deliberative workshops.
These will bring together a quasi-random sample of citizens, a politically representative group of stakeholders
recruited on the basis of stakeholder analysis, or specific groups such as fishermen or policy makers. Example
tools that can be used include brainstorming, visioning and backcasting, story mapping, Delphi, deliberative
multicriteria approaches and other forms of deliberative options appraisal, structured problem analysis,
conceptual system modelling, walking discussion, SWOT analysis, sand boxes, participatory scenario
development and evaluation, bow tie risk assessments and collaborative planning.
Several project staff are professional facilitators experienced in application of these techniques and group
process design, and WP3 will design a range of templates that can then be adjusted to local contexts through
the Demos. In many cases, deliberative and participatory workshops will be used as a synthesis tool where
different forms of evidence are presented, such as document analysis, interview data, ecological and economic
models, and expert opinion; providing a platform for integrating scientific evidence with local knowledge. A
particularly important example of deliberative workshops are Exploitation workshops where we will bring
together public and private sector and community stakeholders to develop pathways to exploiting CH assets
as a form of cultural capital (discussed in more detail in 2.2). These will build on the risk assessment and
sustainable exploitation framework developed by WP4 using a Living Labs approach, focused on serving
innovation in (evolving) real life contexts. Co-creation and co-designing are key notions, allowing a multitude
of stakeholders to work together on complex challenges through user-driven processes of exploration,
experimentation and evaluation. By using several techniques, such as a feasibility assessment (a judgmental
forecasting procedure) and constraint mapping information will be gathered and discussed in different rounds
(creative round; smart choices round).
An important aspect in the design of deliberative tools is the emphasis on social learning, in the sense of a
change in understanding that goes beyond individuals to become situated in wider social groups or
communities, where social processes are a catalyst to changes in values, beliefs and understanding and better
recognition of each other’s perspectives and concerns across sectors. Process design will explicitly focus on
enabling social learning, achieving not only first but also second and third order goals such as enhanced civic
capacity to address pertinent problem.
Citizen science public participation mapping and online portal
In addition to workshop-based participation, PERICLES will develop an interactive, multimedia online CH
mapping platform that will enable collection of data and analysis of the distribution of tangible and intangible
CH. The aim is to generate a resource to better understand CH, particularly in the way that it is situated within
marine and coastal land- and seascapes, provide an opportunity for citizens to engage with CH in an easily
accessible and stimulating format both as contributors and viewers, and provide a resource for analysis of
opportunities and threats in a spatially explicit way. The portal will be developed through several steps: 1.
Technical development of the platform; 2. Artistic graphical user interface design; 3. Collation and integration
of existing map data layers; 4. A citizen science campaign to crowd source further data; 5. Analysis and
reporting of results; 6. Knowledge exchange and training; and 7. Continuing development. A subcontractor
will be engaged to develop a graphical user interface that is intuitive, accessible and aesthetically highly
appealing and engaging – for an example see below. The interface will encompass a front end to view and add
data and a back end to moderate, output and analyse data. The platform will be multilingual to reflect
participation across PERICLES’ case regions (at least Danish, Dutch, English, Estonian, French, Greek, Irish,
Maltese, Portuguese) with the option to add further languages in future development. It will incorporate
bathymetry and scientific base data, conventional point and polygon layers and text markers, audio and video
recordings, graphics and animations, fiction literature references, poetry and other artwork. This will be
collected through review and incorporation of existing GIS layers for the case region (e.g. wrecks and
monuments) and public participation mapping. Here we will work closely with APs and other stakeholders to
21
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
develop a media and social media campaign (focusing on the case regions but not excluding other areas of
Europe) to mobilise citizens in submitting all kinds of material (moderated online by the research team);
including a range of communication activities such as school visits and prize contests (see Section 2.2). The
portal will then be used in demonstrators across the case regions, such as in assessing how blue growth
developments can take place in a way that is more sensitive to CH, or in considering how CH can be better
integrated into marine spatial planning.
A Europe wide analysis will also be undertaken to investigate broad patterns in the localisation of CH. Data
submitted will be submitted to hotspot analysis for different categories of CH to consider key locations and
areas for particular types of CH, and to consider in what way biophysical and cultural features of the
land/seascape interact with particular forms of CH.
Figure 4. Sea Stories – Mappingthesea.net, a previous SAMS project, illustrates some of the potential
of the mapping portal in terms of conceiving of the portal as an arts-science project with an intuitive
and highly attractive interface, and organising and displaying a wide range of creative media.
Artistic and arts-science approaches
Artistic approaches will play a central role in enhancing engagement, more effective representation and
communication and stimulating new understanding and ways of seeing. Our artistic scope will include digital
media, design and video, as well as tangible art work through multiple media. Our concept of the role of art is
not just as a means to represent, but also to challenge and open debate. In particular, art will be used as a way
to both represent and challenge scientific knowledge. For example, we will link art and deliberative methods
by using creative interventions in workshops where people’s views are provoked through art work. Here we
will draw on concepts of socially engaged art and arts-led dialogue (Edwards et al., 2016). In this sense, the
artwork is not a finished ‘product’ as traditionally understood, but the dialogue with a community of
participants becomes a central component of the art work. Dialogues venture in ways that are creative with the
potential for understandings and solutions that are unlikely to have emerged through more conventional
deliberation. Concretely, an artist in residence will be chartered at SAMS to support artistic engagement across
the project. Creative collaborations and dialogue interventions will be used in several demos, and several film
makers will be engaged in linking qualitative, deliberative and artistic methods through Visual Problem
Appraisal (see below). As noted above, the mapping portal will be designed as an art work, and at the same
time will also seek to engage amateur artistic representations through the crowd sourcing campaign.
Visual Problem Appraisal (VPA)
Visual Problem Appraisal (VPA) is a film-based learning strategy with ethnographic, deliberative and artistic
aspects, which aims to enhance the problem analysis of complex issues and to facilitate the development of
22
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
actions. We will develop a VPA that aims to create a space for social dialogue that enhances the inclusion of
underrepresented stakeholders (e.g., women, youth, ageing population, remote professions) and increases the
quality of problem analysis and policy design as argued by Witteveen et al (2009). The VPA will be applied
in workshop settings focusing on learning and change. The core of a VPA is based on ‘mediated stakeholder
consultations’. Diverse stakeholder filmed narratives create platform to meet stakeholders of the area or
indirect stakeholder in policy and management positions in a mediated manner to explore and act on competing
or conflicting interests. We will produce the VPA in the Wadden Sea, Aveiro lagoon, the Danish Islands and
the West Coast of Scotland. The resulting VPA will seek to represent narratives and stories of CH in coastal
communities that are relevant to be used across Europe. Representativeness refers both to common themes
such as fisheries and the portrayal of social imaginaries which are commonly recognised such as youth
searching for contemporary social connectivity and the role of CH in relation to this.
A VPA set is made up of a series of filmed stakeholder portraits and accompanying documentaries. The
PERICLES VPA will portray a diversity of stakeholders to provide an overview of current issues and
perspectives, that covers key issues such as interrelations between land/seascapes and different types of CH,
space, place and identity; different challenges and risks tod different types of CH; conceptions of resilience
and sustainability; opportunities and their social and economic feasibility; participation and deliberative
governance; and the wider international context. The VPA will follow the argument elaborated by Fabinyi et
al. (2010) that recognising complexity requires further unravelling of the diversity of, and nuance in opinions
and views to countervail often assumed homogenous interpretations of important actor groups like fishers,
locals, tourists and policy makers.
The VPA can then be used in diverse arenas such as policy making and education in a structured way,
consisting of three phases: (1) A scoping stage where participants become familiar with subject matter and
issues through facilitated individual and group study and deliberation; (2) A simulated stakeholder
consultation, where participants select and view a selected number of interviews and provide feedback.
'Meeting' a number of stakeholders allows the participants to learn about the different perspectives of these
interviewees and the way they frame their problems. (3) In an ‘action’ stage, participants interpret and organize
confusing, contrasting, and contradicting information and formulate recommendations for action. This can take
various shapes such as scenario development, policy design or elaborated project proposals. The life time of
earlier VPA productions show a lengthy use in Higher Education as dynamic changes in the context do not
immediately affect its relevance for use education in relation to learning about wicked problems and
stakeholder dialogue.
Coupled ecological-economic approaches
Coupled ecological economic approaches will be used to understand environment – CH – economic linkages.
Ecopath with Ecosim (EwE) is an established ecological modelling package which concentrates on time
dynamic, spatially averaged, food web interactions. Ecospace, a partner package to Ecosim, allows simple
food web interactions to be simulated in space as well as time. We will use these models with several policy
scenarios in the Scotland-Ireland region to forecast impacts of different policy scenarios on fish stocks. These
will be coupled with economic data to consider how stock supply of poses risks to CH of the inshore fisheries
fleet and how CH, fisheries, tourism and local economics could be supported by policies aimed at rebuilding
the inshore whitefish stocks to diversify the availability of locally caught seafood species and preserve and
strengthen the cultural heritage of inshore fisheries. We will investigate how the range of fish available is
marketed by the seafood sector in a number of regionally important fisheries ports, evaluate the supply chains
in terms of whether customers value ‘local’ produce and the extent to which they feel that it is important for
sustainability, are aware of links to the local fishing industry, and whether provenance affects their purchasing
decisions, using market research and discrete choice experiments (conjoint analysis). This will be coupled with
ethnographic data and ecological data to feed into deliberation with stakeholders and policy makers to consider
how CH will be affected by potential policy changes as discussed above. More broadly, market research will
be used in the project to investigate new business opportunities such as gastronomic innovation based on
maritime CH assets. Biological data layers (e.g. species and habitat data, fishing data) will also feed into the
online mapping portal / GIS to help inform a better understanding of the spatial interactions between
biophysical land/seascape aspects and CH.
23
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
CH risk and vulnerability assessment
In order to evaluate how CH is spatially represented in marine management approaches (i.e. MSP/ ICZM), a
variety of related digital data will be collected from several agencies/ public authorities within each of the
selected case regions (Agapiou et al., 2017). A directory of data will be compiled comprising as much spatial
information on ecosystem components as possible, such as marine habitats and species (protected and
commercial), geodiversity, and ecosystem services (including shipping, fisheries, aquaculture, renewable
energy, coastal infrastructure dredging and disposal, mineral resources, tourism and recreation, and CH)
(Shucksmith & Kelly, 2014).
Potential compatibilities and conflicts between different activities taking place in the sea and coastal zones
will be identified based on the legislative review and best practice. Each activity will be cross-compared with
each other in a matrix, to determine potential conflict. Spatial analysis will be conducted to map and identify
current conflicts among the various activities. The analysis, is expected to incorporate Boolean algebra, as well
as distance proximity, density and interpolations analysis between the various activities (Agapiou et al., 2017).
The final results will be presented as conflict maps for each activity. CH assets with a spatial extent will then
be incorporated into the analysis to examine current and future potential pressures from other activities, and
spatial overlap and potential for impact on CH within the marine and coastal zone.
A vulnerability assessment, will include the use of historical maps and orthophotos to establish a baseline of
CH features and identify key landscape dynamics and changes in a study area (Nicu, 2017). Using spatial
analysis tools such as buffer and density analysis, vulnerability maps will be generated and classified (low,
medium and high) in accordance with expert judgement and local knowledge (Nicu, 2017). A vulnerability
index will be calculated, based on quantitative indicators, representing a measure of the exposure of CH sites
to risks.
Tangible CH tend to have a spatial relationship with the surrounding environment (e.g., buildings and historic
places, monuments, artefacts, etc.) and usually have a footprint or geographical reference. Intangible CH have
less of a spatial connection and are usually associated with traditional festivals, oral traditions, oral epics,
customs, ways of life, traditional crafts, etc. Therefore, non-spatial explicit risks must also be considered in
any kind of decision regarding intervention on CH. Verbal articulation alongside spatial identification can be
used to quantify marine –related values and threats (Klain & Chan, 2012). People whose profession and/or
means of livelihood are linked to the marine environment will be interviewed to gain insight about non-
monetary values based on the cultural ecosystem services, such as how the individual came to have a profession
related to the ocean, the possible links between the ocean's health and personal and community well-being, the
value they ascertain to the ocean, and threats to marine resources and their activity. Interviewees will also be
asked about cultural ES, specially about the connection between values associated with place and heritage,
identity, activities including subsistence food collection, spirituality, art, education and intergenerational
bequests.
Gender issues
The marine domain is male dominated, including economic sectors and in policy domains. This influences
decision-making. Where possible, PERICLES will put special focus on gender aspects; what is the role of
gender in the case studies; in what ways does gender affect decision-making related to CH; and what
innovations can be proposed to increase gender-balanced strategies? With this in mind, in interviews and focus
groups meeting, PERICLES will work to ensure equal representation between women and men. Gender aspects
will also be taken into account at the level of decision-making in the project. One member of the PERICLES
Steering Committee will serve as the “Gender observer” throughout the project, producing an annual report
how the gender dimension is taken in account during the different actions of the project. The gender balance
of the consortium has been considered; the consortium consists of 22 women and 16 men with women leading
5 of 7 WPs. Additionally, the project coordinator is a woman.
Interdisciplinary Integration
PERICLES is built upon interdisciplinarity. The 37 scientists and participants represent more than 15
different fields of study and expertise. Disciplinary backgrounds include social sciences (e.g, anthropology,
sociology, geography, governance, planning, political science, economics, and tourism studies), humanities
(e.g., history, film, art, linguistics, law), and spatial and environmental sciences (e.g., geoinformatics,
24
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
ecology, marine and fisheries science, biology). Expertise includes communication, spatial planning,
stakeholder engagement, technology, and innovation. Participants come from complementary worlds of
research (2), academia (6), Heritage (1) and regional governmental agencies (1). Participants also have
extensive experience working in inter- and multi-disciplinary contexts and on projects through planning, policy
advice, research, and public engagement.
Such interdisciplinarity is written into PERICLES’ work and research plan, with all WPs and Demos
integrating knowledge and methods from different disciplines.
1.4 Ambition
PERICLES will go beyond the state of the art in science and policy by pursuing its key aim of supporting
sustainable management of CH by developing a novel participatory framework for CH assessment,
conservation and exploitation and by supporting the integration of social science, humanities and
environmental research, and environmental and cultural policy. Our ambition addresses key gaps in research,
policy and practice, including the integration of participatory approaches to CH conservation and the
development of appropriate tools and techniques; the integration of ecosystems’ and socio-cultural knowledge,
particularly for marine systems; the inclusion of CH in marine and coastal management; and the extension of
socio-ecological resilience thinking to CH, and understanding of the role of CH in such resilience in the face
of environmental, social and economic change.
Thus far, there has been little penetration of theory and methods relating to participatory governance and
deliberative democracy in the CH field, and there is limited bottom-up knowledge on how CH of marine and
coastal landscapes should be valued and governed (Claesson, 2011). Current CH governance tends to
disseminate normative representations of universal values imposed from above, marginalising some
community groups. There is a hegemony of normative understandings of heritage over more nuanced and local
understandings (Waterton & Smith, 2010), limited understandings of heritage as a process of engagement
(Smith, 2006), and a need for research into how power and politics impact meaningful or alternative
participation (Crooke, 2010). There is a clear need for novel research and practice in relation to participatory
and deliberative approaches that highlights and challenges issues of legitimacy, hegemony and power in
CH management.
Despite the long-standing twinning of cultural and natural heritage through the 1972 UNESCO Convention,
the research and management of landscapes and ecosystems on the one hand, and CH on the other have been
largely disparate fields. For example, in nature conservation and ecosystems management, the assessment of
cultural values has been very limited (Hicks et al., 2015), particularly in western contexts (Raymond & Kenter,
2016), and in the study of ecosystem services, cultural services have significantly lagged behind provisioning
and regulating services (Milcu et al., 2013). Environmental management is primarily guided by natural science
while the Arts and Humanities, in particular, have played a negligible role in influencing ecosystem
management. Recent EU and MS-level maritime and coastal policy, including the turn towards marine spatial
planning and Blue Growth, have been largely devoid of attention to CH.
Also, an important frame of understanding in environmental management is that of socio-ecological resilience
and adaptation, but there has been very limited attention to the role of CH in resilience as well as the application
of resilience thinking to CH despite the fact that cultural land- and seascapes, are social–ecological systems.
Finally, the stakeholder, policy and research communities around CH and marine and coastal landscape and
ecosystems management are largely isolated from each other.
Given these clear research and policy needs, PERICLES is ambitious and innovative in developing a multi-
and transdisciplinary approach, bringing together approaches and methodologies from the CH preservation,
social sciences (anthropology, sociology, geography, marine governance, political science, economics and
tourism studies), humanities (history, art, film, linguistics) and environmental (ecology, marine and fisheries)
sciences. This ambition of PERICLES will result in a comprehensive participatory governance framework for
sustainable governance and management of CH, which goes beyond the state of the art by bringing together
a core set of theoretically grounded concepts related to space, place and identity, resilience and
adaptation, and deliberative and participatory governance.
25
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
PERICLES will translate this framework to support the integration of CH into key environmental, marine
(incl. Blue Growth) and coastal policies and planning venues, and a participatory governance approach which
brings together different researchers, decision-makers, stakeholders and communities, enabling co-production
of knowledge and deliberative policy analysis, formation and evaluation. Our highly innovative hybrid
approach to participation combines the advantages of interest-based stakeholder participation with
deliberative democratic public participation in research and governance. This will be combined with a range
of innovative methods and tools, such as visual problem appraisal and mapping techniques to capture and
portray CH through the use of art, storytelling, poetry and multimedia, brought together in an interactive online
portal combining researcher and crowd-sourced data. By co-producing CH knowledge with diverse
communities and stakeholders surrounding 6 European regional seas, we will generate extensive new
understanding of how CH relates to maritime and coastal landscapes and how it can be conserved,
governed and sustainably exploited for a broad range of societal benefits.
2. Impact
2.1 Expected impacts
PERICLES will enable geographically balanced, interdisciplinary, mixed-method data gathering across key
European maritime and coastal regions in six regional seas (Atlantic Ocean and Aegean, Baltic, Irish,
Mediterranean, and Wadden Seas), that will provide in-depth, situated knowledge on the tangible and
intangible CH of European coastal and maritime regions. We will engage with a diverse array of coastal
landscapes and seascapes, including urban, peri-urban and remote rural, mainland and island. This
understanding will extend to tangible CH such as lighthouses; castles and defence works; religious monuments;
boats, docks, ports and boat yards (both (post)industrial and small-scale fishing); underwater heritage such as
wrecks, artefacts and submerged landscapes; iconic coastal towns and villages and modern CH such as modern
iconic buildings and works of art. It will extend to intangible CH in terms of language and literature, practices,
traditions and identities, capacities and skills.
This understanding will be both effectively enabled and communicated through the publically accessible
online, multi-media portal that will incorporate data that is researcher gathered, data layers sourced from APs
and stakeholders, and crowd sourced (citizen science) data and will be designed to endure beyond the project
duration. Co-creation and co-designing are key notions, allowing a multitude of stakeholders to work
together on complex challenges through user-driven processes of exploration, experimentation and
evaluation. Recognising the value and richness of local and regional stakeholders and citizen voices, the project
will use an engaged, participative approach to both data-gathering and the co-production of a sustainability
framework that places local lives and livelihoods centrally in the CH of land- and seascapes. Building on our
theoretically well-grounded conceptual framework around the concepts of ‘Space, place and identity’,
‘Deliberative and participatory governance’ and ‘Resilience and adaptation’, PERICLES will develop new
understanding of how CH interacts with landscapes (WP2) and how these heritages are preserved and used
by their inhabitants, potentially delivering profound new approaches to CH preservation that link to key
landscape and ecosystem management frameworks such as the Ecosystem Approach, adaptive governance and
social-ecological resilience.
To support this situated and integrated understanding of coastal and maritime CH, we will develop a broad-
scope, theoretically grounded multi-actor participatory framework based on deliberation, social learning
and co-production of knowledge and values across fields and sectors, and between research, policy, the public
and stakeholders (WP3). This framework will directly contribute to European efforts to promote evidence-
based research on the impact of participatory approaches in CH policies and governance, as suggested
by the Council of the European Union's conclusions on participatory governance of CH (2014/C 463/01).
PERICLES’ concept of participation and deliberative governance (Section 1.3a) is a central pillar to the
proposed activities involving broad-scope co-creation with (1) developers whose projects may pose risks to
CH; (2) actors who exploit CH, e.g. tourism, creative sectors and arts; (3) broader stakeholder participation
based on specific interests relevant to maritime and coastal CH, e.g. heritage conservation, recreation,
fisheries, shipping, ecosystem management; (4) public participation of citizens and local communities across
our demonstration regions, including through citizen science; (5) participation of policy makers and planners
in both the CH and marine governance arenas to ensure the project effectively informs relevant decision-
26
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
making contexts.
We will place particular emphasis on youth participation within all relevant activities (e.g. in our project wide
citizen science mapping campaign) and through dedicated activities such as school visits. This will deliver
impacts in terms of improved youth participation and representing young peoples’ perspectives within
CH and landscape governance, as well as intra- and intergenerational social learning and support for
intergenerational transmission of CH, which is essential for sustainable CH preservation.
More broadly, and beyond the required impact of the topic, our concept of goal-driven deliberation and
learning (Section 1.3a) will deliver a range of first, second and third order goals including issue learning, trust
building and improved relationships between stakeholders, improved institutional decision making
through enhanced participation, new democratic spaces to decide on collective action and for resolving
conflict, enhanced ability to view and connect challenges across issues such as understanding
interlinkages between CH preservation and climate change adaptation, and finally, enhanced civic
capacity not just to understand, preserve and exploit CH but more broadly to collectively understand and
engage with important social issues and solve problems. Our focus on not just first but also deeper second
and third order goals will enhance and ensure sustained impact beyond the duration of the project.
WP3 will underpin the basis of new methodologies and tools on how to maintain and exploit European
CH based on public and stakeholder involvement and participatory governance. A balance will be struck
between finding tools that are generally applicable and the need to customise tools to specific contexts. Each
methodology and practical tool will be adapted to, tested and evaluated in several case study regions through
collaborative demonstrator projects, with the citizen science mapping campaign applied across all case regions.
The use of collaborative research and arts-science approaches in conjunction with public participation GIS and
spatial mapping will see partners working directly with local communities to collect and produce various
type of creative materials (for example photos, graphics, sound, film, stories, poetry, other literature, digital
and digitised artwork) to be collected in the interactive, on-line mapping and display portal and feed into
activities such as exhibitions and festivals. Demos will act as tailor-made pilot projects to put in practice
the proposed new tools, concepts and methodologies. The concepts and tools developed will be cornerstones
to lasting impact, providing targeted, evidence based guidance on CH preservation that can make a real
difference in Europe and beyond. Adoption of collaborative, creative and artistic approaches will ensure that
impacts are maximised and absorbed by stakeholders. Furthermore, review of innovative practice will help
identify ‘what works’ and this will be communicated via the website, information sheets, an Impact Advisory
Group and other networks ensuring that the most appropriate audiences are addressed. Thus, the concepts,
methods and tools developed and demonstrated will have both regional and European policy relevance and
make a major contribution to international research on CH.
The knowledge system produced in WP4 will enable us to systematically map, characterise and assess risks
to CH and opportunities to exploit CH assets. By working directly with developers, policy makers and
communities PERICLES will develop effective mitigation options to ensure CH preservation from a wide
range of threats including different kinds of development, climate change, demographic changes and policy
externalities. WP4 will identify: drivers of change; risks and threats; opportunities; response options;
evaluation of response options; mitigation measures, including interventions; and policy implications/action
planning.
The impact of WPs 3-4 will be further enhanced by working with SMEs, social enterprises and other business,
public and third/voluntary sector stakeholders to exploit CH assets to develop new business and career
opportunities, and by working with public and third sector initiatives, e.g. in terms of harnessing CH for
education, social care and community development. These activities are strengthened by the inclusion of
national (Muinsuskaitseamet), and regional government agencies (Regional Natural Park Golfe du Morbihan)
agencies’ participation in our consortium and strong support by a diverse inclusion of APs.
Special attention will be given to better understanding the interrelation between tangible and intangible
CH in terms of local know-how, particularly as it relates to the interaction between CH and the coastal
environment, and to consideration how this understanding can be preserved and exploited. For example,
we will consider how iconic tangible CH associated with inshore fisheries and intangible CH in terms of
27
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
fisheries practices and skills and gastronomy have changed because of changes in (management of) fish stocks,
and how this in turn affects demand for sea food, and in turn coastal tourism, and how different approaches to
marine management can threaten skills and know-how or, conversely, support it and enable new opportunities
in gastro-tourism.
Building on WP2-4, WP5 will highlight gaps and opportunities and discussing measures to implement
these recommendations at various policy levels, e.g. using multi-scale/level analysis and ex ante evaluations.
Drawing upon elements such as the project case region demos, good practice documentation and cross-regional
comparison will also enable cross-sectoral policy synergies to be identified. WP5 will work with policy makers
and planners to develop guidelines that will enable improved integration of CH into key appraisal (SEA,
environmental and economic impact assessment) venues, and will contribute to a better implementation of
European policies on coastal zones and maritime areas, particularly in relation to ICZM
(Recommendation 2002/413/EC) and MSP (Directive 2014/89/EU). This work will identify potential
institutional reform that could enhance the effectiveness of policy.
PERICLES’ participatory framework will underpin the formation of new networks linking previously
disparate sectors and fields associated with CH and management of the marine environment and coastal
landscapes (WP6). For example, we will build networks between researchers, practitioners, policy makers,
NGOs and businesses in relation to tangible and intangible CH, education, creative sectors, tourism, marine
and coastal ecosystems, marine policy, marine spatial and town and countryside planning, coastal zone
management, environmental management, biodiversity conservation, community resilience and climate
change adaptation, fishing, social and economic development (coastal, rural, urban) and blue growth sectors
such as energy, aquaculture and tourism. Here we will target multiple scales: local, regional, interregional
(i.e. bringing together representatives from our different case regions) and European, and feeding into global
networks and organisations such as UNESCO, UNEP, FAO, IUCN, UN University and the World Business
Council for Sustainable Development. The new stakeholder networks will create opportunities for an
exchange of good practice and other experiences between stakeholders and will be used as vectors for
dissemination of policy advice on the preservation and exploitation of maritime CH, on integration of CH
and marine and coastal environmental management, on enhancing participation within CH governance and on
the use of key tools and techniques to achieve these objectives. This wider network will be the forum for
creating a range of stakeholder facing activities throughout the project (e.g. workshops, exchanges, training
sessions, webinars and participation in the online portal) including a large-scale, EU wide event engaging a
trans-national audience of scholars, policymakers and other participants, to widen the impact potential of
PERICLES and further ensure that its impacts endure beyond the end of the project through enhanced
capacity across sectors.
Table 3, below, provides examples of how Demo’s will generate impact in accordance with, and beyond,
the requirements of the topic.
Demos Activity Key impacts
Aveiro 4 and These demos will combine ecology, video • New participatory methods
Scotland- ethnography and economics, working closely with and tools piloted
Ireland 3: fisheries & tourism sectors and taking a whole supply • Building networks between
rejuvenating chain approach. We will seek to understand the role marine, CH and tourism
inshore of provenance and traditional practices in seafood stakeholders
fisheries demand juxtaposed with ecological and policy • Better understanding of risks
heritage questions of supply (stock health, quota regimes etc.). to inshore fisheries heritage
through Evidence informed deliberation with stakeholders & • Informing better
gastronomy policy makers will develop action plans how CH, implementation of European
fisheries, tourism and local economics should be marine policy
supported by policies aimed at rebuilding inshore
• Working together to find
stocks to diversify availability of locally caught
ways to exploit CH assets
seafood species and preserve and strengthen inshore
for new business & career
fisheries CH.
opportunities
• Exchange of good practice
28
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Wadden Sea 1 These demos will consider the threats of climate • Piloting a participatory
and Malta 3: change to CH through vectors such as coastal erosion, framework for risk
CH and sea level rise, extreme weather & flooding, and assessment
coastal changes in under water biodiversity and fish stocks. • Better integration of CH into
adaptation The role of different actors and governance levels coastal zone management
planning will be contrasted between the single-nation and and climate change
trilateral demos in developing risk assessments and adaptation policy.
seeking integrated adaptive planning solutions for CH • Identify cross-sectoral
preservation based on social-ecological resilience and policy synergies
participation. • Exchange of good practice
• First, second and third order
deliberative learning
Aegean 2 and These demos will consider the challenges faced by • Possible leveraging of
Estonia 2: communities who strive to maintain continuity of historical ‘lessons’ – see
maintaining practice in the face of rapid change imposed from the Aegean 2 description of re-
continuity of outside. In investigating differences in community introduction of old
practices in a adaptation and resilience, these demos will combine technologies
changing historical analysis with ethnographic methods, • Introduce key elements of
world deliberative participation and citizen science CH into tourism sector
campaigns and will work closely with the (thematic tours, local
communities involved as well as the relevant policy marine gastronomy), as
bodies so as to empower local communities and to means of public awareness
promote community led continuity of practice. and experience of issues of
environmental problems
and sustainability
2.2 Measures to maximise impact
PERICLES has formulated a comprehensive communication, dissemination and knowledge exchange strategy
consisting of a Data Management Plan (DMP) (WP1) and Communication and Dissemination Plan (CDP)
(WP7) to ensure the wide dissemination and exploitation of our results among research and academia,
governmental, and societal stakeholders. The plan includes proactively managing impact activities,
disseminating research results (2.2a), and communication activities (2.2b). The participatory nature of
PERICLES means that numerous activities are intertwined and complementary.
a) Dissemination and exploitation of results
Target Audiences
PERICLES will include stakeholders in the project at the earliest stage. The scope of the dissemination plan
will be focused on those individuals or groups who are linked to the use of the coastal and marine areas and
CH can:
• give an insight into how coastal and marine CH may be promoted and preserved;
• benefit from integration of activities in the same marine area;
• facilitate and enable close collaboration between different marine users;
• facilitate and enable close collaboration between different categories of users (without being users of
the space themselves - government agencies, legislators, etc.);
• facilitate and enable amendments of the legislation framework related to coastal and marine planning
and CH.
The following stakeholders will be included in the dissemination process:
Dissemination to public authorities and policy makers: European Commission, international organisations,
policymakers at European and national level, regulatory, administrative or public authorities including
29
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
planners, operators and users of marine space (e.g. local authorities, law enforcement authorities). Different
types of contributions will be scheduled such as technical papers, workshops, and policy briefs (WP6 and
WP7).
Dissemination to stakeholders involved with different cultural heritage activities: Manufacturers,
suppliers, service providers, vendors, tourism industry, industry associations. The PERICLES consortium
partners have an extensive database of stakeholders, which ensures an extensive and targeted dissemination of
the project results. The content of the dissemination towards members of the wider European cultural heritage
community will be based on the opportunities and barriers mapped identified in WPs 3 and 6.
Dissemination to the general public, Professional organizations (POs) / Non-governmental organizations
(NGOs): PERICLES will take advantage of well-established social media tools (Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn,
YouTube, Instagram) that have substantial followers, to achieve a wide outreach within the community.
Dissemination to the wider public will also be achieved with short videos and through local workshops at the
case study and pilot sites.
Dissemination to the scientific community: The majority of PERICLES dissemination and communication
will take place through public routes. Nevertheless, some scientific and policy-relevant articles will be
published on Open Access platforms and scientific journals (e.g. Marine Policy; Maritime Studies (MAST)).
Impact and exploitation through participation and co-production
WP7 will proactively manage impact activities, ensuring this is effectively pursued in each WP and evaluate
the ongoing impact of the project through a living impact register (an online spreadsheet actively populated by
the WP and case region leaders and managed by WP7). Our conceptual pillar focusing on deliberative and
participatory governance seeks active participation of key stakeholders throughout the project, from
developing and synthesising concepts and understanding (WP2) to applying tools and frameworks across the
case regions (WP3-4) to ensuring policy integration (WP5) and networking (WP6), communication,
dissemination and exploitation (WP7). Each demonstrator across the different case regions will actively seek
to put the PERICLES three pillar concept developed by WP2 into practice by applying a range of tools that
are either novel or applied in new ways. For example, work in the Aegean region will include zoo-
archaeological analysis of fish remains from key sites in the area, archival work for Medieval, Ottoman and
Early modern periods, ethnographic documentation of key fishing technologies using visual and audio tools
and analyses of modern fisheries data. This will be combined with ancient and modern fish DNA analysis
providing a highly innovative example of knowledge integration between natural science and humanities
approaches in CH research.
The concept of demonstrations seeks to incorporate both concepts and methods for understanding, preserving
and exploiting CH, integrating research, innovation, application, and impact analogous to TRL levels 1 (basic
concepts) to 6 (tools demonstrated in the relevant environment). By replicating similar tools across similar
themes across more than one demo, we are able to draw broader and more robust conclusions around their
benefits and limitations, delivering a rigorously tested toolkit as a key project output. To further maximise this
impact, demo’s each directly involve key stakeholders actively co-producing outputs. For example, Demos
SI1 and E1 focusing on integration of CH in marine spatial planning in Ireland, Scotland and Estonia will be
operationalised through deliberative workshops with policy makers, key business stakeholders (e.g. fisheries,
tourism, developers) and direct engagement of PERICLES in regional marine planning and spatial plan
development for the Argyll, Highlands, Galway Bay and the Gulf of Riga, regions. These regional experiences
will then be fed sideways and upwards through effective inter-regional and EU-scale dialogue, stakeholder
networking and dissemination delivered by WPs 6-7. Moreover, we will work actively with stakeholders in
exploitation and policy integration workshops.
Exploitation workshops
These workshops will be organised across case regions to operationalise the risk assessment and sustainable
exploitation framework developed by WP4. The workshops will present results from WP2 and WP3 in terms
of how CH can be understood and their relation to space and place situated within coastal and marine
land/seascapes. Participants will be invited to work with multilayers, multimedia maps in the online portal,
30
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
video material from VPA and ethnographic video work, and to engage with relevant Demo projects focused
on exploitation both from within their own region and other areas of Europe. This will be combined with tools
such as brainstorming, visioning and rich pictures to explore opportunities for harnessing CH assets for new
products and services (both commercial and non-commercial); e.g. gastronomy, tourist trails and events, arts
and media, new approaches to branding and marketing, social care and therapeutic services and education
initiatives. Particular attention will be paid to how visible and invisible, tangible and intangible, and above-
and below-water CH can be harnessed in tandem; and how natural and cultural heritage can come together. As
in all our deliberative activities this will not be a top-down approach but provide new spaces for social learning,
including exchange of best practice and example innovations across different sectors and geographies.
Policy integration workshops
WP5 will organise workshops at both the European scale and the case region scale focused on integration of
CH and environmental policy in areas such as ICZM, terrestrial and marine spatial planning, strategic
environmental assessment and environmental impact assessment, and conservation policies; targeting both the
policy and consultancy sectors. Again, this will focus on learning, here between CH and environmental sectors,
comparing and contrasting planning, impact, risk assessment and stakeholder and public engagement and
participation approaches. Again we will draw on learning from theory and international fieldwork to
disseminate results around the co-emergence of natural and cultural heritage assets, including through cultural
ecosystem services, and co-produce knowledge with practitioners in exploring where there are synergies, gaps
and conflicts, where there are opportunities for greater integration; how this translates to potential for more
effective environmental and cultural conservation and resource efficiencies; and guidelines for best practice.
Impact boards
Each case region will be accompanied by its own impact board consisting of business, government, NGO and
community APs and stakeholders. Example members are listed in Table 4. Selected members of case region
Impact Boards. The activity of these boards across sectors will ensure that the project effectively draws on
the experience and reference frames of the key stakeholders and that any output relates closely their needs,
thus enhancing the likelihood of significant impact.
Table 4. Selected members of case region Impact Boards
Name Region Type/Sector
Thisted Kommune Denmark Local government
Marstal Søfartsmuseum Denmark Museum
Han Herred Havbåde Denmark Business / Harbour
Galway County Council Ireland-Scotland Local government
Heritage Council Ireland Ireland-Scotland National government / CH
Marine Conservation Society Ireland-Scotland NGO / Nature conservation
Highland and Islands Enterprise Ireland-Scotland Business (general)
Visit Scotland Ireland-Scotland Business / Tourism
Din l-Art Ħelwa Malta NGO / CH
Fish4Tomorrow Malta NGO / Nature conservation
Malta National Aquarium Malta Business / Tourism
Aveiro Region Portugal Regional government
Ilhavo Maritime Museum Portugal Museum
Ilhavo Council Portugal Local government
Turismo Centro Portugal Portugal Tourism
Wadden Academy Wadden Sea Research-education
Wadden Sea Forum Wadden Sea Tri-lateral stakeholder forum
Assoc. of Wadden Sea Coastal Municipalities Wadden Sea Local government
Wadden Sea Marinas Foundation Wadden Sea Business / Tourism
The Wadden Association Wadden Sea NGO / Nature conservation
Shell Wadden Sea Business / Developers
Fishermen's Association Agios Nikolaos Aegean Business / Fisheries
Abdera Museum Aegean Museum
31
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Ephorate of Antiquities of Kavala Aegean Government agency / CH
Regional District of Eastern Macedonia and Thrace Aegean Regional government
Liivi Lahe Kalanduskogu Estonia Nature conservation NGO
University of Tartu Estonia Research-education
Kihnu Cultural Space Estonia CH Foundation
Kihnu Parish Estonia Local government
The benefits of these impact activities will be maximised by a communication, dissemination and knowledge
exchange strategy that ensures the widest possible engagement with stakeholders, who will, in addition to
engagement with regional demos and project wide deliverables such as the public concrete participation
mapping campaign, will in demo’s have an ongoing dialogue with the research team via a dedicated resource
exchange section on the project’s website, through social media and short video documentaries. Public areas
of the website will explain the project and make the interactive mapping portal and all publications available.
Policy outputs will be disseminated via key project partners and through a range of media outlets, supported
by close collaboration between partners’ PR and Public Engagement departments and a dedicated impact
officer. Throughout the project we will monitor its impact through quantitative and qualitative models of
evaluation - across each WP we will ensure that activities, events and engagements undertaken (whether
planned, or unplanned, formal or informal) record and assess the opportunities for impact. For example,
building on our participatory framework we will link explicit learning outcome evaluation to the use of all
participatory tools and methods. Where possible we will conduct ‘exit interviews’ and make use of evaluation
forms to capture information on our various audiences. Data collected will be used to ensure that we are
reaching as broad a range of audiences as possible and will inform activities to ‘target’ any underrepresented
groups. We will use online tracking software (Twitter searches, Google Analytics) and tools such as Scoop.It
or Storify to enhance and evaluate impact. Key points of evaluation will also include: engagement with the
online mapping and resource portal; event participation; uptake of project knowledge into policy formation
and evaluation; increased incorporation of research into decision making, social learning outcome measures,
and published references to the project outcomes.
Dissemination activities
A PERICLES Website, which will serve as a central point of disclosure for the results. We will register a
domain and will use it to host the project website. This website will be managed by Aalborg University and
will be clearly identified by the PERICLES logo and name. The website will be used as the key platform to
explain and disseminate the project activities to the public, to provide information about the project, specific
news, information and links to partners and provide access to all public deliverables. Videos distributed
through the PERICLES YouTube and Vimeo Channels and podcasts will be used to convey the information
to users in the most accessible possible way. Website visits will be monitored to assess its effectiveness. This
Website will likewise be integrated with social media (Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube, Instagram)
Stakeholder workshops, which main objective will be the engagement with the stakeholders, knowledge
transfer, and production of outcomes for the final action plan will be included within WP3, WP4, and WP6
planned activities.
Participation in EU and international activities such as technical groups, conferences and scientific
workshops is planned to gather and share knowledge on the themes and topic important for PERICLES such
as CH and participatory governance, EU marine policies, etc.
Co-operation with other projects and initiatives will be undertaken as a means to further disseminate
PERICLES results and to create added value.
Dissemination channels
1. Advisory Board Members´ networks through international and regional organizations;
2. Use of EU Commission channel: Articles and Magazines such as Futuris Magazine, Research EU
results magazine, Horizon Magazine, Futur Enviro, etc.
3. Conferences, seminars, events like European Maritime Day, MARE People and the Sea (2019)
32
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
4. FARNET, Fisheries Area Network. FARNET implements Community-Led Local Development
(CLLD) under the European Maritime and Fisheries Fund (EMFF). This network brings together
Fisheries Local Action Groups (FLAGs), managing authorities, citizens and experts from across the
EU to work on the sustainable development of fisheries and coastal areas. PERICLES shall
disseminate results through their publications, website, and transnational seminars and conferences.
5. European Enterprise Network (EEN) brings together 600 business support organizations from more
than 50 countries to help small companies seize business opportunities in EU. PERICLES will
disseminate the results and guidelines generated in the project through video presentations/posters and
leaflets.
6. The web pages of the project and the partners and other social network will provide links to the videos
and other dissemination of PERICLES.
b) Communication activities
With its communication activities, PERICLES will raise public awareness and enhance social acceptance of
Blue Growth activities among local communities and society-at-large.
Main objectives of the Communication Plan:
• To inform the targeted audience and to generate interest in PERICLES and related events, such as
planned events, published reports, the project website or PERICLES social media presence.
• To use appropriate communication channels to ensure the interconnection between policymakers,
business, society, SMEs and the stakeholders, by combining classical media approaches with modern
social media techniques.
• Enhance awareness of policymakers, business sectors and local communities of the opportunities for
integrated Blue growth, the understanding of the benefits of co-location, the actions, approaches and
measures for reducing negative impacts on the environment, and enhance social acceptance of multi-
use near-shore and offshore platforms.
Table 5 Key audiences, with example messages and means
Audience Key message Means
Citizens CH is of value and interest Social media
Research Community To protect & utilize CH, more conferences, articles
applied work should be done
CH sector & NGOs Connections with other CH Social media, networking
stakeholder groups strengthens workshops
one’s own work
Environment NGOs CH found in seascapes Workshops,
Marine planners and coastal CH should be included in Policy brief, demo activities
zone managers planning processes
Developers CH can be utilized while being meetings
protected
Tourism & gastronomy
Fisheries CH is living heritage Workshops, social media
Creative sector CH adds life and value through Social media, citizen-arts
art activities
Policy makers at EU & CH has intrinsic worth, but Policy meetings, policy briefs,
member state level also tangible value for opinion pieces
employment and development
Specific activities:
• Project’s corporate image and brand development. A corporate design (logo, templates and
newsletter) will be developed by M3 to ensure that dissemination and outreach materials have a
33
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
uniform and recognizable image. The PERICLES logo and templates will incorporate the project
values and their European dimension.
• A PERICLES multimedia communication tool package. PERICLES will produce appealing
multimedia material to be used by the consortium and the EC in various events. This tool package will
include periodical newsletter, brochures, leaflets, posters, etc.
• This material will be a showcase of the project, so it will be downloadable from the project website
and from other widely visited media portals. We will consider the viewings of the videos as an
indicator of effectiveness.
• PERICLES social media accounts (Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube, Instagram). This will
complement the website, and provide a forum for discussing the developments within the PERICLES
project allowing anyone to comment and discuss the PERICLES developments.
• External communication activities. The project will also contribute to newspapers and magazines,
and will generate regular press releases to communicate the main activities and results of the project
to the mass media. The Project Office (supported by all partners and AAU public relations) will
prepare different articles to release to the media with project results that can be of interest to the general
public. These activities will be performed during the entire project. A collection of press clipping will
be undertaken to monitor the action effectiveness.
These activities will target the following audiences:
• Public authorities and policymakers: the European Commission (DG Mare and Environment),
international organisations, policymakers at European and national level (ministries of agriculture and
aquaculture, tourism, energy and environment, etc.); regulatory, administrative or public authorities
including planners, operators and users of marine space (e.g. local authorities, law enforcement
authorities etc.).
• Stakeholders belonging to Cultural Heritage and Blue Growth sectors and industry associations, to
ensure continuity and robustness beyond the end of the project. Brochures, leaflets, newsletters, posters
and promotional videos will be major means of communication with stakeholders.
• General public will have access to the project through the website, press releases, blogspots,
promotional videos, social media, etc.
• Scientific community, such as institutes working on environmental protection and management, social
and economic development.
Communication channels:
• Consortium partners, stakeholders and networks of advisory board members, internal communication
channels and specialized mass media (business media, regional media and marine industries
periodicals)
• Social Media: Social media can engage a large network of businesses in the marine and coastal sector,
so project results will reach relevant groups.
The table below provides examples indicators and thresholds of some planned dissemination tools.
Table 6. Examples of Indicators and thresholds of the planned dissemination tools
Tool Indicator Means of verification Thresholds
PERICLES website Number of visits Visitor counter Increasing over time
Social media Shares and likes Counter of activity Increasing over time
External communication Number of essays Listed on staff VBN pages Consistency
Exploitation workshops Number held Reports, meeting notes Milestones reached
c) Data Management Plan
The partners involved have well developed and quality assured processes for data management, in compliance
with national funders’ polices, to which all researchers will adhere. The partners involved carry the necessary
and appropriate levels of indemnity for research involving human participants, giving cover for both negligent
34
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
and non-negligent harm. They have policies and procedures that govern the collection, storage, quality
assurance and security of data. The study will involve analyses of data from semi-structured interviews,
surveys, visual documentation, focus groups and policy documents. The research team has extensive
experience of gathering and managing data of this nature. The Data Management Plan (Task 1.5/Deliverable
1.3) will be designed and uploaded on the Partner’s area of the website, with Individual Data Plans submitted
by each partner. In the individual plans, each partner will assume responsibility for data integrity and quality.
At the midpoint of the project, the DMP will be reviewed, to ensure roles and responsibilities of the researchers
on data quality, compliance, and safety. As a part of the DMP, governance and ethics will be developed and
agreed.
The project will collect a wide range of quantitative and qualitative data. Quantitative data will include
economic and market research and quantitative social questionnaires. Qualitative data will include perceptions,
opinions and experiences of individuals collected through a wide range of methods. Biological data will
include DNA samples/analysis. Data will also be mapped in a GIS portal. This includes a wide range of data
layers which may harbour its own usage restrictions. Some basic demographic data (e.g. age) will be collected
from study participants but will be separated and results will be reported anonymously as per standard social
research ethics guidelines enforced through ethics committees of the academic partners involved.
The partners involved have robust processes for the oversight and governance of research, in particular,
research involving human participants. All data used as part of this research will comply with all relevant legal
requirements and codes of good practice. Confidentiality and disclosure risk are controlled through the
application of information security and data handling policies contained in relevant partner policies. Where
necessary, data will be anonymized and participants’ confidentiality maintained throughout. Participants will
be allocated a unique ID which will be used to identify all their paper and electronic records. The Lead
Researchers will be responsible for maintaining separate, confidential registers which will match each
participant’s unique ID with their name. These will be stored securely and separately from other data, with
access limited to designated persons. All databases will be designed to ensure completeness, accuracy,
reliability and consistency of data. The policies and procedures ensure that there is no deletion of entered data;
a list is maintained of those individuals authorised to make data changes, and all data changes are documented.
Quality control measures will be applied to each step in the data management process to assure that the
necessary level of data quality is maintained throughout.
Requests for data by outside parties will be handled on a case-by-case basis. Where appropriate, some data
(e.g., images) may be available under Creative Commons license. Where submissions are made to the online
portal through citizen science, users will also be asked to submit data under a CC license. Where data cannot
be appropriately anonymised to maintain confidentiality, and protect the rights of the research participants, it
will be not be made publicly available.
The project will comply with the partners’ policies on management of physical research data and on working
with electronic data. Any data held on portable equipment such as laptops, memory sticks or portable hard-
drives will be risk assessed, taking into account the sensitivity of the information. All portable equipment will
be risk assessed and securely encrypted, taking into account the sensitivity of the information. All data will be
transferred to partner data repositories where they will be stored on a secure server which is protected against
unauthorised access by user authentication and a firewall. All identifiable data will be stored in an encrypted
format. Access to the room where the servers are kept is restricted to designated IT staff. Daily backup
procedures are in place and copies of the data are held in separate locations. A specified group of research staff
will have read-only access to the data files containing confidential information; only database officers can alter
the confidential personal data files. Paper records of contact sheets, registration documents, and consent forms
will be archived in separate locations to the electronic data.
Anonymised data sets will be made publicly available through appropriate data portals as part of an Open Data
Policy that will be further developed in our Data Management Plan.
d) Project legacy
PERICLES has developed robust networks and communication and dissemination strategies to ensure project
impacts continue beyond the life of the project. There are 3 primary pathways developed to this end:
35
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
1. Activities co-produced with stakeholders
2. Policy advice
3. Resource materials published and dissemination
A key sustainable pathway for PERICLES’ lasting impact is the co-production of activities, events, and outputs
with stakeholders. Education and enthusiasm are key to lasting impacts. CH related activities include youth
awareness and education events, conferences, course projects with University students, and capacity building
courses—getting young people interested- and educating people-- means you have interested people for
decades to come. Furthermore, enthused citizens share their enthusiasm and interests with others in their
networks. And by building capacity for those involved in tourism to maximize CH exploitation means
successful initiatives which, once successful, will have these groups and others desiring to duplicate their
success. Our Stakeholder Networks are also developed from the bottom up. With co-development comes “buy
in” and dedication to continuing, especially when the network involves stakeholders from disparate groups
which complement and strengthen one’s own expertise. Heritage Europe was chosen as a SAC member
precisely for their experience and expertise in developing and maintaining networks for a length of time
(including beyond the initial project period).
PERICLES will provide policy advice for improving the integration of CH in key marine and environmental
policies and the implementation of associated EU directives (e.g. ICZM, MSP, IMP, MSFD). This advice stems
from the real-world experiences of the demonstrations and pilots, in collaboration with local and regional
governmental stakeholders on planning with takes CH into account, as well as the participatory framework for
sustainable management, conservation and exploitation of CH.
As all projects, PERICLES will publish research results. Key for long lasting impact will be the types of
publications and dissemination. PERICLES will develop a handbook for understanding, preserving and
sustainably exploiting marine CH—both open access and in print form, which is targeted at CH practitioners,
policy makers, and private sector businesses who can benefit from exploiting CH. PERICLES’ citizen science
initiatives and on-line mapped portal will also ensure the project outputs are available long after the project is
complete. The academic peer-reviewed article(s) will also ensure the PERICLES CH concept is available for
reference and building upon.
3. Implementation
3.1 Work plan — Work packages, deliverables and milestones
PERICLES activities will be pursued through a total of 7 Work Packages (WP1-7), organized through a
structured array of horizontal linkages, modulated and coordinated by Work Package 1 (Figure 5).
WP1, is designed to produce a strong governance structure where all partners are represented, where the key
aspects of the project are effectively tackled by design, where the articulation of collaborative work, decision-
making and communication is swift and most adequate to achieve the project goals and where quality assurance
and risk management are systemized from the beginning within the project management tools and procedures.
WP2 sets the stage and develops a holistic and in-depth understanding of tangible and intangible CH of marine
and coastal land- and seascapes, laying the necessary foundation for WPs 3-7. Work will be organized along
the scientific concepts of a) Space, Place, and Identity; b) Resilience and Adaptation; and c) Deliberative and
Participatory Governance. A review of case region themes and indicators will feed into WP3, while a review
of participatory governance and overall feeds into WP4 and WP5. WP2 ends just after the first year
The purpose of WP3 is to provide the link between the insights derived in WP2 (deep understanding of
maritime and coastal CH) and a) the position and enactment of CH in coastal preservation, risk mitigation and
sustainable growth (WP4); and b) integration of CH in key policy domains (WP5). This is a significant amount
of fieldwork takes, place, where tools will be initially reviewed, then tested and operationalized in case regions
and demos and then evaluated. This WP will also establish the server infrastructure necessary to host the online
public participation mapping portal and the mapping is a key activity of this WP.
36
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
WP5 will undertake policy analysis through desk-based reviews and deliberation with decision-makers at
multiple scales, to provide a suite of policy recommendations. We will take stock of policies adopted on the
preservation and use of CH to explore the relationships between CH and EU and national maritime policies,
building on WPs 2 and 4 to understand how better policy integration can comprehensively address key risks
to CH in different contexts and support more effective harnessing of cultural assets for sustainable and inclusive
growth. This includes synthesizing the demos as they relate to policy. Stakeholder workshops, including with
policy makers and mangers are a significant activity in this WP.
WP6 is a key WP as it focuses on developing stakeholder networks networks. Stakeholder will be brought
together to exchange their experiences, in regions, as well as at the annual meeting. We will also establish EU-
wide networks. Lessons learned will be used to bring stakeholder engagement into policy practices -- to
provide stakeholder-determined evidence for holistic and integrated management of CH and the marine
environment directly linking in with key EU policies and directives including MSP, MSFD, IMP and ICZM.
Each project partners and APs will also each act as conduits for a transnational stakeholder network.
WP7 is our communication and dissemination WP and focuses on transferring the outputs and knowledge
generated by the project to the general public, stakeholders and scientific community. PERICLES puts a great
deal of effort in this area to ensure the long-lasting success of the project. In addition to traditional pathways
such as webpages and articles, we will organize community events, capacity building courses, distribute a
Tools Handbook, as well as travel with our Ethnographic documentary.
All of these activities in WPs 2-7 and their interactions will be coordinated, modulated and monitored through
WP1, dedicated to the functional and administrative management of the project.
In order to allow an efficient flow of information and new knowledge among the WPs, as well as to coordinate
workshops and activities which are connected and co-organized by connected WPs,) work packages will
overlap in time, under an “in parallel” scheme. PERICLES will last 36 months according with the following
GANTT chart (Figure 6).
Detailed description of the objectives, work (divided in tasks), personnel effort, deliverables and milestones
per each WP are reported below (Table 3.1).
Figure 5: PERT Diagram illustrating the structure of PERICLES proposal and the interaction among the
different components/structures of the project.
37
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
38
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
year 1 year 2 year 3
Year: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36
WP1 Project coordination and management
Task 1.1. Establishment of the Project Management Office (PMO) D1.1?
Task 1.2 Establishment of the Steering Committee
Task 1.3 Managing organisation of events
Task 1.4 Establishment of the Project Management Plan D1.2
Task 1.5 Establishment of the Data Management Plan D1.3
Task 1.6 Ensuring Gender equity within the project D1.5 D1.8 D1.9
Task 1.7 Represent PERICLES D1.1?
Task 1.8 Coordination and Preparation of periodic and interim reports for the EC D1.4 D1.6 D1.7?
Task 1.9 Coordinating preparations for the final conference
Task 1.10 Overseeing after-life dissemination of the final project result D1.10
WP2 Eliciting a Deep Understanding of Maritime and Coastal CH
Task 2.1 Global review of current understanding of maritime and coastal CH D2.3
Task 2.2 Overview of CH and land/seascapes in PERICLES case regions D2.1
Task 2.3 CH through a literature review of “Space, Place, and Identity”
Task 2.4 Review of how processes of resilience and adaptation can impact and preserve CH
Task 2.5 Overview of deliberative and participatory governance for sustainable management and conservation D2.2
Task 2.6 Operationalising Case Regions D2.4
Task 2.7 Synthesis of Results of Tasks 2.1-2.6
WP3 Practical methods and tools
Task 3.1 Mapping portal infrastructure D3.1
Task 3.2 Spatial data review D3.2
Task 3.3 Initial tool review D3.3
Task 3.4 Tool application
Task 3.5 Citizen science European public participation mapping
Task 3.6 Final tool review D3.4
WP4 Co-production of a Risk Assessment and Sustainable Exploitation Framework
Task 4.1 Review threats to CH and risk management strategies D4.1
Task 4.2 Identify and analyze gaps between expert knowledge and social representations of CH at risk D4.2
Task 4.3 Methodologies in participatory risk assessment and design of risk management strategy D4.3
Task 4.4 A risk assessment framework for sustainable exploitation of maritime culture heritage D4.4
WP5 Policy Integration
Task 5.1 Critical policy analysis D5.1
Task 5.2 Semi-structured policy and practice stakeholder interviews D5.2
Task 5.3 Semi-quantitative valuation of the integration and coordination of CH policies within ICZM and MSP D5.3
Task 5.4 Synthesis of Demos as they related to policy D5.4
Task 5.5 Policy good practice lesson drawing workshops D5.5
WP6 Development of Stakeholder Networks
Task 6.1 Bring stakeholders together and exchange of experiences D6.1
Task 6.2 Establish a network of CH stakeholders in all PERICLES CS, expanding to other EU MS D6.2
Task 6.3 Bringing stakeholder engagement into policy practices D6.3
WP7 Communication, Dissemination & Maximisation of Impacts
Task 7.1 Elaboration of a communication, dissemination and exploitation plan
Task 7.2 Project website
Task 7.3 Communication and dissemination to stakeholders
Task 7.4 Booklet and e-booklets D7.1
Task 7.5 Capacity building courses
Task 7.6 Organization of symposia & conferences
Task 7.7 Community and youth awareness and education events D7.2
Task 7.8 Tools Handbook D7.3
Task 7.9 Ethnographic documentary D7.4
Figure 6: GANTT chart illustrating the structure of PERICLES.
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Table 3.1a: Work package descriptions
Work package 1 Lead AAU
number beneficiary
Work package title Project coordination and management
Participant number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Short name of AAU WU UBO UHI QU UAV SAMS MKA PNRgDM FRI
participant B R
Person months per 18 2 2 1 2 2 8 1 2 1
participant
Start month 1 End month 36
Objectives
The purpose of WP1 is to establish and maintain for the whole project life a strong governance structure where
all partners are represented, where the key aspects of the project are effectively tackled by design, where the
articulation of collaborative work, decision-making and communication (inside and outside the consortium,
i.e. with the EC, is swift and most adequate to achieve the project goals and where quality assurance and risk
management are systemized from the beginning within the project management tools and procedures. A case
study coordinator (UHI) will coordinate the case studies in order to optimize the cooperation and synergy
effects between the other WPs.
Primary Objectives are:
• To achieve the project goals with the required technical and financial quality level and timing.
• To ensure an effective, efficient and expeditious management of the resources, as well as efficient
communication with all partners and with European Commission, providing on time all deliverables
and reports.
• To perform the overall management of the project and coordination among the different WPs
• To establish the communication flow and methods for reporting, monitoring and quality assurance,
including risk management, innovation management, gender equity management and ethics
management
• To coordinate the reporting to the European Commission
• To manage the knowledge and intellectual property rights
• To encourage networking with other related projects and building construction/energy platforms and
initiatives
• To promote gender equality
• To develop measures for avoiding risk regarding financial, legal, administrative and technical co-
ordination of the whole project and to establish contingency plans if needed.
Description of work
Task 1.1 Establishment of the Project Management Office (PMO) that will ensure the preparation and
timely finalization of the Consortium Agreement. The PMT will include the Coordinator, the Project Manager
and AAU administrative, financial and legal managers. Lead: AAU (month 1)
Task 1.2 Establishment of the Steering Committee in conjunction with the Kick-Off Meeting. Lead: AAU:
Participants: all WP co/leaders, Case Study Coordinator (UHI). (month 1)
Task 1.3 Managing organisation of events: i) kick off meeting with the Steering Committee and
establishment of Scientific/Stakeholder Advisory Committee (SAC); ii) annual meetings (at the end of each
year) and; iii) SC meetings (every six months), using also videoconferences. The PMO will prepare the agendas
and take care of invitations, logistics and prepare financial information and reporting guidelines. Lead: AAU,
Participants: Partners hosting the annual meetings. (months 1-24)
39
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Task 1.4 Establishment of the Project Management Plan to detail internal procedures and communication,
thus ensuring timely, consistent, and robust communication between case regions and work packages (Lead
AAU/UHI). (months 2-4)
Task 1.5 Establishment of the Data Management Plan. AAU, with input from the Steering Committee, will
produce the first release of the DMP at M6 (D1.1). This deliverable will evolve during the lifetime of the
project in order to present the status of the project's reflections on data management. To be updated in month
18. Lead: AAU; Participants: all WP co-leaders. (months 3 – 6; updated month 16-18).
Task 1.6 Ensuring Gender equity within the project – work, research, and activities. This activity will be
overseen by Sylvette Dénefle of the Scientific-Impact Advisory Committee. (months 1-36)
Task 1.7 Represent PERICLES by coordinating participation of partners in conferences and meetings;
contacting other relevant scientific projects and networks. Lead: AAU, Participants: WP co-leaders, with
inputs from all partners. (months 1-36)
Task 1.8 Coordination and Preparation of periodic and interim reports for the EC, preparation of
templates for planning/reporting and guidelines for collating information and reports. Lead: AAU;
Participants: WP co-leaders, with inputs from all partners. (months 1-36)
Task 1.9 Coordinating preparations for the final conference (months 24-36)
Task 1.10 Overseeing after-life dissemination of the final project result. Led by AAU (month 36 onward)
Deliverables
D1.1 PERICLES Intranet with project templates and guidelines (AAU) PU DEC (M3)
D1.2 Project Management Plan (AAU) R PU (M4)
D1.3 Data Management Plan (AAU) R PU (M6)
D1.4 Minutes of the Kick-Off including the establishment of the SIAC (AAU) (M6)
D1.5 First Annual report on gender dimensions of PERICLES (R PU) (M12)
D1.6 Minutes of the first Annual Meeting (R PU) (M13)
D1.7 Minutes of the second Annual Meeting (R PU) (M25)
D1.8 Second Annual report on gender dimensions of PERICLES (R PU) (M25)
D1.9 Third Annual report on gender dimensions of PERICLES (R PU) (M36)
D1.10 Summary of the final meeting (R PU) (M36)
Milestones
M1.1 First management templates, guidelines and DoW available for download in the partners’ area on the
webpage (AAU) M2
M1.2 Kick off meeting held and management bodies established (Minutes of the meeting downloadable from
the partner area and summary available on the webpage for public and media) (AAU) M2
M1.3 Project Management Plan available on the partners’ area of the website
M1.4 Data Management Plan available on the partners’ area of the website
M1.5 First Annual Meeting held (Minutes of the meetings downloadable from the partner area and summary
available on the webpage for public and media) (AAU) M13
M1.6 Second Annual Meeting held (Minutes of the meetings downloadable from the partner area and summary
available on the webpage for public and media) (AAU) M25
Work package 2 Lead AAU
number beneficiary
Work package title Eliciting a Deep Understanding of Maritime and Coastal CH
Participant number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Short name of AAU WU UBO UHI QUB UAVR SAMS MKA PNRg FRI
participant DM
40
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Person months per 6 4,5 6 1 3 5 8 5 1 2
participant
Start month 1 End 13
month
Objectives
The purpose of WP2 is to develop a holistic and in-depth understanding of tangible and intangible CH of
marine and coastal land- and seascapes, laying the necessary foundation for WPs 3-7. Work will be organized
along the scientific concepts of a) Space, Place, and Identity; b) Resilience and Adaptation; and c) Deliberative
and Participatory Governance. Combining understandings of these three concepts (a-c) with CH is key for the
sustainable utilisation and governance of CH for the benefit of society. Only once the importance of coastal
spaces and places and how they form identities are known; how cultures and society are vulnerable or resilient
and can adapt; and how good governance takes place, can a framework for using CH to the benefit of society
and enabling blue growth be successfully formed.
Specific Objectives include:
1. Provide an overview of CH and its relation to land/seascapes from academic, policy, and stakeholder
perspectives.
2. Use the concepts of space, place and identity to explore how CH engenders contemporary meaning
and identity, connecting to the use of place-based CH as a means of supporting sustainable and
inclusive societies.
3. Use the concepts of resilience and adaptation to investigate the conditions enabling CH-related
continuation, adaptation and innovation in European maritime and coastal regions.
4. Provide a review of participatory governance for the PERICLES framework for sustainable
management and conservation of European coastal and maritime CH and landscapes
In addition to the broad, international literature review, research will zoom in on the six case regions, allowing
us to bring out broader patterns of practical understanding both derived from and illustrated by situated case
examples.
Description of work
The work in WP2 will consist of the following tasks:
Task 2.1: A global review of current understanding of maritime and coastal CH will be undertaken which
encompasses both academic and policy perspectives. (Lead AAU; Participants: WU, UBO, UAVR, SAMS,
FRI, MKA). (months 1-12)
Task 2.2 Overview of CH and land/seascapes in PERICLES case regions. The work will be undertaken by
the Case Region Coordinator (UHI) and case region leaders. Case regions will be grouped, compared and
contrasted by key indicators such as shared CH type (e.g., shipwrecks in the Mediterranean and Baltic regions;
boat building techniques in the Baltic and Atlantic; language and rituals in the Atlantic, Baltic and
Scottish/Irish regions); cross-cutting themes such as fishing heritage and memory; pressures, threats and
risks, such as intensity of tourism pressures, demographic challenges; policy integration challenges such as
marine planning; and opportunities through harnessing CH assets for sustainable growth, new career and
business opportunities, community development etc Lead UBO; AAU; WU, QUB, UAVR, SAMS, FRI,
MKA, PNRgDM), feeding into WPs3-5. (months 2-8)
Task 2.3 CH through a literature review of “Space, Place, and Identity” and how they inform CH
perspectives. Heritage engenders contemporary and future meanings and identity on both individual and
societal levels. This connects to the use of place-based CH as a means of supporting sustainable and inclusive
societies where CH becomes ‘cultural capital’, intimately entwined with natural capital. (Lead: SAMS; AAU
UBO). Feeds into D2.3. (months 2-8)
41
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Task 2.4 Review of how processes of resilience and adaptation can impact and preserve CH and its
relation with land/sea-scapes. The work encompasses both academic and policy perspectives of the concept.
(Lead: QUB; UBO, AAU, UAVR, SAMS). Feeds into D2.3. (months 2-9)
Task 2.5 Overview of deliberative and participatory governance for sustainable management and
conservation of European coastal and maritime CH and landscapes. Stakeholder participation is essential to
ensure integration of diverse knowledge, values and perspectives, ensure recognition of all salient risks, avoid
or reduce conflict and find synergies between different interests, and broadly improve the quality of decisions.
(Lead: WU; SAMS, UBO, UAVR, AAU). Feeds into WP5. (months 2-10)
Task 2.6 Operationalising Case Regions through fieldwork in pilot study areas, linking to WP3 and WP4.
Ethnographic fieldwork and qualitative interviewing in preparation for methods and tools development (WP3)
Lead: AAU; UBO. (months 2-11)
Task 2.7 Synthesis of Results of Tasks 2.1-2.6 to integrate the concepts of CH, including findings from the
case regions. Lead: AAU; WU, QUB, UAVR, SAMS, MKA, FRI. Feeds into D2.3 (months 9-13)
Deliverables
D2.1 Internal report of the key indicators and cross cutting themes in PERICLES CS. R PU M8
D2.2 An internal report providing input from Task2.4 for the participatory governance framework R PU M12
D2.3 Synthesis paper (publishable quality journal manuscript) of the three pillars concept for sustainable CH
utilization R PU M12
D2.4 Internal report, synthesizing results of Tasks 2.1-2.6 for internal use in WPs 3, 4 and 5. R PU M13
Milestones
M2.1 Completed literature review of academic, policy, and stakeholder understandings of cultural heritage,
M12
M2.2 Completed literature review of Space, Place, and Identity and how they inform CH, M8
M2.3 Completed Literature review of resilience & adaptation in coastal cultures and societies, M9
M2.4 Completed Literature review of models of deliberative and participatory governance for preservation
and utilization of European coastal and maritime CH and landscapes M10
M2.5 Ethnographic Interviews complete M 11
M2.6 Completed Synthesis of results with literature review and case study results, internally feeding into WPs
4 & 5 M13
Work package 3 Lead SAMS
number beneficiary
Work package title Practical methods and tools
Participant no. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Short name of AAU WU UBO UHI QUB UAVR SAM MKA PNRg
participant S DM
Person months per 7 14,5 5 3 5 11 20 5 4
participant
Start month 4 End 33
month
Objectives
The purpose of WP3 is to provide the link between the insights derived in WP2 (deep understanding of
maritime and coastal CH) and a) the position and enactment of CH in coastal preservation, risk mitigation and
sustainable growth (WP4); and b) integration of CH in key policy domains (WP5). WP3 will achieve this by
developing practical tools, based on stakeholder and citizen involvement and participatory governance. A
broad set of tools will be developed for understanding and mapping CH, for conserving CH and assessing and
42
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
addressing risks, and for exploiting CH for sustainable and inclusive development and CH-based blue growth.
Tools will be initially reviewed, then tested and operationalized in case regions and demos and then evaluated.
This WP will also establish the server infrastructure necessary to host the online public participation mapping
portal.
Description of work: (broken down into tasks, lead partner and role of each contributor).
Task 3.1 Mapping portal infrastructure (Lead: SAMS, Collaborators: AAU, UAVR) (Months 4-9). We will
create an interactive, online GIS to facilitate understanding of the distribution of coastal and maritime CH,
tangible and intangible, above and below water. A mapping interface will be generated with a series of
baselayers (topography, bathymetry, political boundaries etc.) and a means to upload audio, video, image, and
text content by the consortium, APs and stakeholders and members of the public. Georeferencing will be
automatically extracted from metadata where available or can be manually added or corrected in the form of
point, line, or polygon shapes or by selecting predefined areas (e.g. political/statistical boundaries based on
NUTS regions) where the object being added relates to a larger scale spatial entity or its exact spatial location
is uncertain. A graphic artist will be subcontracted to design an artistic interface that is immediately engaging
and highly intuitive to understand and navigate. The system will also be able to automatically conduct and
display basic analysis and content reports. The portal will be integrated by Aalborg into the project website
(Task 7.1). Layers from the underlying GIS database system can also be served to other users and websites
(such as regional and national public authorities’ GIS mapping and planning portals) via WMS & WMF
services hosted on the SAMS GeoServer framework. While the portal will be up and running by Month 9, it
will be subject to technical support by SAMS over and for at least 5 years beyond the duration of the project.
Task 3.2 Spatial data review (Lead: SAMS; Collaborators: UAVR, MKA, PNRgDM, AAU, WU, QUB, FRI)
(Months 4-9). We will conduct a data review to collate existing spatial data on tangible and historic heritage
(e.g. wrecks, coastal monuments such as lighthouses), as well as ecological and social-ecological data to
provide a backdrop to the coastal landscape, such as underwater habitats and conservation features, Natura
2000 sites and marine protected areas, etc. where possible directly integrating GIS layers available on existing
mapping servers (for example, Scotland’s National Marine Plan Interactive), where they are serving web-based
mapping services such as WMS & WMF. While we will focus on the case study regions, in many cases larger
scale spatial data will be available providing use for the portal in other areas.
Task 3.3 Initial tool review (Lead: QUB; Collaborators: WU, AAU, MKA, UBO, SAMS, PNRgDM) (Months
6-14). We will scope potential practical methods and tools through a questionnaire survey with all partners,
APs and stakeholders across the case regions and a workshop session at the first PERICLES international
conference (Task 1.3), and literature review to produce a draft handbook covering understanding, preserving
and exploiting CH, building on the CH conceptual framework (Task 2.3-2.5 / Deliverable 2.3.) and feeding
into the risk assessment framework (Task 4.4/Deliverable 4.4). Likely categories for tools include risk
assessment, ecological, economic, ethnographic, historical and archaeological, arts-based, participatory and
deliberative (incl. citizen science), and document analysis tools. A number of key tools that will be used across
all or most of the case regions will be reviewed in detail, including Public Participation Mapping, Visual
Problem Appraisal (VPA) and similar ethnographic video approaches, Deliberative Risk Analysis Workshops,
and Deliberative CH Exploitation Workshops. Here, a number of templates will be developed for application
across Demo’s in different case regions. For example, building on WP2, we will create an outline VPA
framework that covers key issues such as interrelations between land/seascapes and different types of CH,
space, place and identity; different challenges and risks tod different types of CH; conceptions of resilience
and sustainability; opportunities and their social and economic feasibility; and participation and deliberative
governance.
Task 3.4 Tool application (Lead: UHI, Collaborators: MKA, UAVR, UBO, WU, UAVR, AAU, PNRgDM)
(Months 15-27). Key methods and tools across different categories will be applied across demos in case study
regions in close collaboration with APs and stakeholders. Key tools such as those listed under Task 3.3 will be
applied in multiple instances to enable comparison and contrast in different geographic and thematic contexts
whilst applying a broad range of tools and ensuring efficient use of resources, in a process undertaken across
the consortium overseen by the case study coordinator (also in the lead of task 2.2 (UHI)).
43
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Task 3.5 Citizen science European public participation mapping (Lead: SAMS; Collaborators: AAU,
UAVR, WU, MKA, UAVR, UBO, PNRgDM) (Months 10-18). A large-scale campaign will be orchestrated
in collaboration with WP6 (Task 6.1) to encourage citizens to document and upload CH-relevant data in the
form of a wide variety of content, including: place names, stories, poetry and literature fragments/references,
art work, photography, other images and local ecological knowledge, which will be categorised based on the
conceptual framework developed by WP2. Citizen mobilisation will take place through announcements in
local, regional and national media, social media, school visits in case studies to demonstrate the portal, use of
APs and stakeholders’ member/supporter lists and communication channels as vectors, and prize incentives.
Submissions will be moderated for inappropriate content. Data submitted will be submitted to hotspot analysis
for different categories of CH to consider key locations and areas for particular types of CH, and to consider
in what way biophysical and cultural features of the land/seascape interact with particular forms of CH.
Task 3.6 Final tool review (SAMS: Collaborators: AAU, UAVR) (Months 28-33). A formal evaluation of
methods and tools applied and lessons learned will be drawn across the case studies including SWOT analysis,
again through a consortium and stakeholder survey and workshop at the second annual PERICLES
international conference (Task 1.3). In collaboration with WP7, the results will be drawn into a practical, easily
accessible, handbook (D7.8) for understanding, preserving and sustainably exploiting marine CH available
digitally (open access) and in print, targeted at CH practitioners and policy makers, and private sector
businesses who can benefit from exploiting CH (tourism, creative sectors, food & drink etc.). This will also
report on data gathered in the PERICLES mapping portal and how it can be used effectively in combination
with other tools.
Deliverables
D3.1 Interactive online CH mapping portal DEC PU (M9).
D3.2 Portal data layer summary report R PU (M9).
D3.3 Internal Report on Initial method and tool review R PU
(M14).
D3.4 PERICLES VPA (M28).
Milestones
M3.1 Portal infrastructure complete M9
M3.2 Initial Tool Review complete M14
M3.3 Citizen science campaign begun M 10
Work package 4 Lead UBO
number beneficiary
Work package title Co-production of a Risk Assessment and Sustainable Exploitation Framework
Participant 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
number
Short name of AAU WU UBO UHI QUB UAVR SAMS MKA PNRgDM
participant
Person months per 4 4,5 12 5 2 5 12 7 6
participant
Start month 1 End 30
month
Objectives
Threats to CH should be addressed as a primary condition for sustainable exploitation, in the sense of CH
preservation, social interest raising and, eventually, commercial use. The many and varied components of CH
face different types of threats among which the loss of memory or poor appreciation of their value, pressure
from urban and economic development, improper conservation regulation and policy, natural hazards and
many others. The lack of recognition of these threats and of resources to address them often lead to CH
44
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
abandonment together with the loss of social, and potentially commercial, benefits that their exploitation could
provide. The general objective of this WP is to provide a comprehensive, participatory framework for
sustainable management, conservation and exploitation of European coastal and maritime cultural landscapes,
which integrates knowledge across local, spatial, environmental, social and economic aspects of CH
WP 4 specific objectives are to:
1. Review threats that the different types of CH commonly face and applied risk management strategies,
2. Provide generic information about CH risk assessment and risk management to support the work to be
conducted by PERICLES partners in case regions so that threats to sustainable exploitation are
addressed in demo activities,
3. Engage the expertise of PERICLES partners, and of the stakeholder associated with the activities of
the project, to develop a documented and illustrated framework for “risk assessment and sustainable
exploitation” under a living-lab format.
4. Document the gaps between experts appreciation and different social representations of threats to CH.
5. Facilitate women and youth engagement in CH risk management.
Description of work
Task 4.1 Review threats to CH and risk management strategies
Based on literature review and interviews with maritime CH experts and managers, produce a review of major
threats to the different components of CH and risk management strategies that are commonly applied for
mitigation or adaptation to these threats. The network of PERICLES partners and stakeholders in case regions
will be mobilized to gather data. Lead: QUB; Partners: SAMS, UBO, MKA, PNRgDM) (months 3-9)
Task 4.2 Identify and analyze gaps between expert knowledge and social representations of CH at risk
A great discrepancy is often observed between expert knowledge (managers, technicians, consultant or
scientists) and representations among politicians, stakeholders and the public in regard to risk assessment and
risk management. Managers operating at local level consider that elected local politicians and others groups
of stakeholders don’t have a clear vision of the potential of cultural heritages and their threats, this despite the
availability of evidences. This lack of awareness, as well as short term approach, impacts implementation of
adaptive actions. This task will select a series of examples from case studies and socio-anthropological
methods (literature review of historical and current sources, semi-structured interviews) will be applied to
confront local experts knowledge and representations by other actors through stakeholder workshops,
connected with WP6. Lead: UAVR ; Collaborators: AAU, UBO, MKA, (months 9-18)
Task 4.3 Methodologies in participatory risk assessment and design of risk management strategy
Risks affecting CH are of different nature. Building on the review conducted in task 4.1, further bibliography
and interviews (in coordination with 4.2. field work), methodological guidelines for maritime CH related risk
assessment and adaptation management will be drafted. A participatory approach will be applied to develop
these guidelines. In methodological terms particular emphasis will be given to the multidimensionality of
both cultural heritage and threats, the role of legal and institutional frames, the importance of and ways to
engage stakeholders in sustainable CH exploitation and social issues such as the inclusion of women and
youth. Lead: WU; Collaborators: QUB, UBO, UAVR (months 9- 26)
Task 4.4 A risk assessment framework for sustainable exploitation of maritime culture heritage
Guidelines developed under task 4.3 will be distributed in the project for empirical testing. In collaboration
with WP3, tools of interest for risk assessment will be integrated. Feedback from case-studies and further
engagement of managers and stakeholder will lead to the production of a framework, including
methodologies, guidelines, specific tools and examples, for CH related risk assessment. Partners in WP4 will
disseminate the framework in cooperation with other WPs under the coordination of WP6. Publication and
training in the format of a workshop will be organized. Lead: UBO; Collaborators: AAU, UAVR, SAMS,
PNRgDM, MKA (months 26-36)
Deliverables
45
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
4.1 The maritime cultural heritage at risk; A review of CH at risk and commonly applied risk management
strategies R PU M10
4.2 Expert knowledge and social representations of maritime cultural heritage at risk : an empirical gap
analysis R PU M18
4.3 A participatory risk assessment and sustainable exploitation framework for maritime cultural heritage
(draft) R PU M20
4.4 A participatory risk assessment and sustainable exploitation framework for maritime cultural heritage
(final) R PU M30
Milestones:
M4.1 Data gathering on threats to CH and risk management strategies complete M9
M4.2 Local experts list compiled for interviews and stakeholder workshop on knowledge (managers,
technicians, consultant or scientists) and representations among politicians, stakeholders and the public in
regard to gaps and representations of risk M 12
Work package 5 Lead QUB
number beneficiary
Work package title Policy Integration
Participant number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Short name of AAU WU UBO UHI QUB UAVR SAMS MKA
participant
Person months per 4 9,5 4 1 10 5 10 5
participant
Start month 1 End 36
month
Objectives:
WP5 will undertake policy analysis based on both desk-based study and deliberation with decision-makers and
stakeholders, to provide a suite of policy recommendations. Objectives for this WP will include (1) developing
an in-depth understanding of the relationships between CH and EU and national maritime policies, (2)
understanding how CH is understood by coastal and marine policy makers and practitioners and the role it
plays in their decision-making; and (3) identifying and sharing good practice examples of policy integration
Description of work:
Task 5.1 Critical policy analysis A critical policy analysis, conducted through a discourse analysis, will
identify critical narratives concerning CH in key coastal and marine policies. This will evaluate how CH is
understood and how it finds expression in policy arenas such as marine spatial planning policy, integrated
coastal zone management and climate change adaptation. (Lead: WU, QUB, Collaborators: MKA, AAU,
UAVR) (months 1-15).
Task 5.2 Semi-structured policy and practice stakeholder interviews While Task 5.1 will illustrate the
explicit policy connections between CH and other coastal and marine polices, it is critically important to
develop an in-depth understanding of policy integration (both formal and informal) in practice. Therefore,
semi-structured policy and practice stakeholder interviews, with key stakeholders from central and local
government, private providers and NGOs will be conducted. The interviews are aimed at evaluating: how CH
is understood by policy makers and practitioners; what informal practices are in place that encourage or
discourage integration; what are the institutional, cultural, knowledge or professional obstacles more integrated
policies and practices. Interviews will explore more fully how CH and coastal and marine institutions
collaborate to create the necessary integration and evidence required for effective policy. Tied with Task 4.2
(Lead: QUB, Collaborators: WU, MKA, AAU, UAVR) (months 6-18).
46
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Task 5.3 Semi-quantitative valuation of the integration and coordination of CH policies within ICZM
and MSP The semi-structured policy and practice stakeholder interviews (Task 5.2) will be integrated by a
stocktaking of the policies adopted on the preservation and use of CH following the ICZM national scale
valuation carried out in 2003 (Stocktaking working group, 2003). Relationships between CH and other coastal
policies (blue growth, marine spatial planning and marine framework directive, mainly) will be considered.
Main development plans and SEA affecting CH will be considered to assess the measures adopted to mitigate
impacts and the level of success. The semi-structured stakeholder interviews will be addressed to assess how
CH policies are integrated and coordinated within national or regional ICZM strategies by adopting a semi-
quantitative approach to the valuation of the integration and coordination of policies as proposed in Pickaver
et al. (2004), Ballinger et al. (2010), and Martino (2016). (Lead: SAMS, Collaborators: QUB, WU) (months
9-21).
Task 5.4 Synthesis of Demos as they related to policy This task will consist of a synthesis of policy related
aspects of all demonstrations undertaken as part of the project. The synthesis will be conducted in 2 stages. A
desktop review and a synthesizing workshop, which will bring together the leaders of all policy-focused
demonstrators to critically review demonstrator findings. This task will inform a final policy report, with main
research findings from all policy-focused demonstrators informing the project’s overall evidence-base for how
best to understand to integrate CH into existing policy and highlighting critical policy gaps. (Lead: SAMS,
Collaborators: UBO, QUB, MKA, UAVR) (months 12-26).
Task 5.5 Policy good practice lesson drawing workshops Tasks 5.1 and 5.2 will highlight innovative policy
integration practices in particular regions. Confronted with common problems, policymakers can learn from
the actions of their counterparts in other countries or regions. If a policy or programme of integration is found
to be effective in one institutional setting, it may be successfully transferred to another, with necessary
adaptations to make it fit within legislative frameworks (Rose, 1991). If a policy or programme is found not to
work, policymakers in other districts can learn what not to do when formulating their own course of action.
Lesson-drawing typically addresses the question: under what circumstances and to what extent can a
programme that is effective in one place transfer to another. Lesson-drawing, however, is more than an
evaluation of a programme in its own context; it also entails analysis of the transferability of these lessons to
other contexts and areas (Rose, 1991). Lesson-drawing typically addresses the question: “under what
circumstances and to what extent can a programme that is effective in one place transfer to another” (Rose,
1991, p. 3). It may also conclude with an analysis of what would need to change in order to facilitate the
successful implementation of a programme imported from elsewhere. Task 5.5 will evaluate the innovative
practices, policies and programmes (identified in task 5.1 and task 5.2) with stakeholders in deliberative
workshops to develop an understanding of their transferability. (Lead: QUB, Collaborators: WU, MKA, AAU)
(months 24-30)
Deliverables (brief description and month of delivery):
D5.1 Comprehensive policy review report R PU M15.
D5.2 Internal Report on stakeholder interviews R PU M18.
D5.3 Report on the integration of and coordination of CH policies within ICZM and MSP R PU M21.
D5.4 Report on policy related aspects of the demonstrations R PU M26
D5.6 Policy brief, identifying good practices of policy integration of CH and maritime policies R PU M36
Milestones
M5.1 Deliberative workshop with stakeholders to develop understanding of the transferability of innovative
practices and polices (M30)
Work package 6 Lead PNRgDM
number Beneficiary
Work package title Development of Stakeholder Networks
47
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Participant no. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Short name of AAU WU UBO UHI QUB UAVR SAM MKA PNRg
participant S DM
Person months per 5 1,5 2 1 2 2 8 2 6
participant
Start month 3 End 36
month
Objectives:
As the development of effective knowledge exchange networks among policy makers, stakeholders and
scholars, and the facilitation of formative participation in the project is paramount, each partner will engage
policy makers, stakeholders and scholars and build and support such networks within their case region and
regional seas. Innovative engagement mechanisms will be used to connect with intellectual investors that
celebrate and connect cultural histories; digital networking, through the online portal and webinars for
collaboration with identified communities of interest. The project partners will act as conduits for a
transnational stakeholder network to be a holistic instrument for CH stakeholder engagement.
WP 6 specific objectives are to:
1. Bring together stakeholders participating in PERICLES CS together to exchange experiences about
the process on the understanding of CH, tools and policies developed by the different stakeholders.
2. Establish a network of stakeholders working at all CS levels, extending this to include actors working
both within PERICLES CS and elsewhere in Europe.
3. Bring stakeholder engagement into policy practices
Description of work
Task 6.1 Bring stakeholders together and exchange of experiences
Engage stakeholders (tourism, local managers of CH and conservation, different users of the coast and of
CH) involved in the different CS of PERICLES with the objective to exchange about their experiences
within the project is the first task of this work. Exchanges between stakeholders about the current practices
of CH, tools, risk and policies in a common debate without the local and national borders. Pericles different
methodological tools (WP3) are based on participatory approach will be discuss also at EU level during these
meetings in a way to be understand, valid by stakeholders in a way to be used by them during and after the
project. First international “experience-sharing” stakeholder workshop to be held in connection with the first
Annual Meetings (Task 1.3, M 12). (Lead: PNRgDM, collaborators: UAVR, AAU, UBO, UHI, SAMS)
(months 3-24).
Task 6.2 Establish a network of CH stakeholders in all PERICLES CS, expanding to other EU MS
Through the exchanges between stakeholders during the first meeting the objective is to create a network to
promote Pericles participatory principles and tools. Develop innovative mechanisms which will connect
stakeholders. These will include 1) staging regional events, that celebrate and cross-examine CH; 2) digital
networking, through the online portal and webinars; 3) engaged scholarship as a means of collaboration with
identified communities of interest. The project partners will act as conduits for a local and a transnational
stakeholder network to enable holistic dissemination and engagement across all stakeholders. This task
connects with WP 7, tasks 7.2, 7.4, and 7.6. Space on the on-line portal will be set up to foster communication.
The Second international workshop held in conjunction with the second Annual Meeting, M24. (Lead: AAU,
collaborators: UAVR, PNRgDM, WU, SAMS) (months 3-36).
Task 6.3 Bringing stakeholder engagement into policy practices Tasks 6.1 results will be brought together
under this task to provide stakeholder-determined evidence for holistic and integrated management of CH and
the marine environment directly linking in with key EU policies and directives including MSP, MSFD, IMP
and ICZM assessed under WP5. EU wide event engaging a trans-national audience of scholars, policymakers
and other participants, to widen the impact potential of PERICLES and further ensure that its impacts endure
48
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
beyond the end of the project through enhanced capacity across sectors to be held at closing conference (M36)
(Lead: SAMS; QUB, AAU, UAVR, PNRgDM ) (months 30-36)
Deliverables (brief description and month of delivery)
D6.1. Internal Annotated Table relevant stakeholders within each case study. R PU M6
D6.2 Space created on the online portal for stakeholder interactions across the project and within each case
study, i.e. it is an output of Tasks 6.2 and 6.3 (Month 12) DEC PU M12
D6.3 Report on good practice for CH management with evidence from application and policy measures, i.e.
an output of Tasks 6.4 and 6.5. R PU Month 34
Milestones
M6.1 First international experience sharing workshop, M12
M6.2 Stakeholder area on the web portal on-line (M12)
M6.3 Second International stakeholder workshop M 24
M6.4 Case study, case specific workshops on bringing CH stakeholder together completed (M30)
M.7 EU wide event engaging a trans-national audience of scholars, policymakers and other
participants, to widen the impact potential of PERICLES and further ensure that its impacts endure
beyond the end of the project through enhanced capacity across sectors.
Work package 7 Lead UAVR Co-lead: AAU
number beneficiary
Work package title Communication, Dissemination & Maximisation of Impacts
Participant 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
number
Short name of AAU WU UBO UHI QUB UAVR SAMS MKA PNRgDM
participant
Person months per 6 4,5 1.5 1 2 9.5 8 2 6
participant
Start month 1 End 36
month
Objectives:
WP7 will focus on transferring the outputs and knowledge generated by the project to the general public,
stakeholders (local management and government bodies, tourism industry, etc) and scientific community. A
robust communication and dissemination strategy will be created to maximizing the impacts of the project,
and a wide range of activities and materials will be developed to promote the uptake of project results. WP7
will also facilitate and enhance the dialogue between different stakeholders, and will develop capacity building
and training to improve professional competences for end-users, and enhance knowledge and skills in the blue
economy sector.
This WP includes dissemination, knowledge transfer, communication tasks, capacity building/training
initiatives and stakeholder-focused actions designed to ensure uptake of findings and to provide feedback from
stakeholders on project actions.
Task 7.1. Elaboration of a communication, dissemination and exploitation plan Under this task a
communication, dissemination and exploitation plan will be developed, which will include a wide range of
outputs aimed at maximizing impact of the research. It will include the elaboration of a plan to disseminate
materials to different user groups and case studies, including summaries of key findings and best practices
exploiting marine CH, articles in the popular media and social media; education materials. A plan for an
49
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
efficient communication and dissemination at target events will also be elaborated, such as talks in schools,
universities and local communities, organization of panels in conferences, and film screenings. A range of
measures to enhance exploitation of results will be included in collaboration with WP 4, and dissemination
through stakeholder networks will be discussed in conjunction with WP5. (Lead: AAU; Collaborators: WU,
UBO, QUB,UAVR, UHI, SAMS, MKA, PNRgDM) (months 1-6).
Task 7.2. Project website A project website will be developed which will host, inter alia: project background
information and videos; all project dissemination materials and other deliverables marked for public
dissemination; a password protected section for other deliverables; the interactive mapping portal (Tasks 3.1,
3.6); a resources and tools section for stakeholders (linking to Tasks 3.3 and 3.7). (Lead: AAU; Collaborators:
SAMS) (months 1-4).
Task 7.3. Communication and dissemination to stakeholders
Permanent communication will be established with stakeholders in each case study to ensure the widest
possible engagement (WP6). Directed stakeholder dissemination events will be organized in each case study
area along the duration of the project, as well as workshops during project meetings/conferences where
engagement with stakeholder, and dissemination project results, will take place. Events will be in person and
via webinars and different formats will be chosen tailored to stakeholder audiences – for example at the
European scale breakfast events in Brussels. These events will be designed to fit the stage of the project and
create ‘windows of opportunity’ to maximize impacts of the project. (Lead: AAU; Collaborators: UAVR, WU,
UBO, MKA, PNRgDM, UBO) (months 3-36).
Task 7.4. Booklet and e-booklets
Results from the projects will be summarized into booklets for public dissemination at the local level (for
locals and visitors). These materials will be individual to each case study and inform the public about CH trail
in the local area. The booklets will be produced in the language of the respective case study and English, and
available in print and digitally. (Lead: SAMS ; Collaborators: AAU, QUB, WU ) (months 12-36).
Task 7.5. Capacity building courses (Lead: UAVR; Collaborators: UHI, PNR GdM) (Months 24-36).
This task will consist of a set of capacity building/training initiatives for stakeholders involved in the tourism
industry to maximize the exploitation of CH. This stakeholder-focused actions will be designed to ensure
uptake of findings generated by the project. (months 18-36)
Task 7.6. Organization of symposia & conferences This task will consist of organizing panels in conferences
in order to disseminate project results to the scientific community. Panel sessions on coastal and maritime CH
will be organized, at events such as, for example, the 2019 MARE conference “People and the Sea”,
Amsterdam, EU Maritime Day, etc. Precise conferences and timing is dependent on the project start date.
(Lead: AAU; Collaborators: UAVR, MKA, WU, SAMS PNRgDM, UBO) (months 12-36).
Task 7.7. Community and youth awareness and education events
This task will consist of developing educational materials and organizing talks in schools, universities and
local communities to increase awareness and understanding about the importance of CH. Education materials
(in the language of the case study regions) will be prepared, covering topics such as tangible and intangible
marine and coastal CH, risks, preservation and sustainable exploitation of CH, and career opportunities in CH.
(Lead: SAMS, Collaborators: UAVR, AAU) (months 18-36).
Task 7.8. Tools Handbook
Linking to Task 3.7, a formal evaluation of methods and tools applied and lessons learned will be drawn across
the case region demonstrators, stakeholder surveys and workshop. The results will be compiled into a practical,
easily accessible, handbook for understanding, preserving and sustainably exploiting marine CH available
digitally (open access) and in print, targeted at CH practitioners, policy makers, and private sector businesses
who can benefit from exploiting CH (tourism, creative sectors, food & drink etc.). (Lead: SAMS,
Collaborators: AAU, UHI, FRI) (months 28-33).
50
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Task 7.9. Ethnographic documentary This task will consist of the preparation and dissemination of an
ethnographic documentary, and subsequent screening at schools, university, itinerary local and regional
expositions and festivals, building on the Visual Problem Appraisal work undertaken in WP3 and ethnographic
work in WP2 and 3. The documentary will likely cover key issues such as interrelations between
land/seascapes and different types of CH, space, place and identity; different challenges and risks to different
types of CH; conceptions of resilience and sustainability; opportunities and their social and economic
feasibility; and participation in CH governance. (Lead: WU, Collaborators: AAU, SAMS, UAVR) (months 1-
36).
Deliverables
D7.1 Booklets and e-booklets with CH trails R PU M14
D7.2 Education materials R PU M18
D7.3 Handbook with education material about practical methods and tools for understating, preserving and
benefiting from CH. R PU M33
D7.4 Ethnographic documentary DEC PU M36
Milestones
M7.1 Website on-line (M3)
M7.2 Panel session at the MARE conference (M16* depends on project startdate)
M7.3 Booklet and e-booklets ready M30
M7.4 Capacity building courses prepared M33
M7.5 Handbook ready M33
M7.6 Ethnographic documentary finished M30
51
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Table 3.1b: List of work packages
Work Work Package Lead Lead Person- Start End
package Title Participan Participant Months Month month
No t No Short Name
1 Project 1 AAU 39 1 36
coordination and
management
2 Eliciting a Deep 1 AAU 41,5 1 12
Understanding of
Maritime and
Coastal CH
3 Practical methods 7 SAMS 74,5 4 33
and tools
4 Co-production of a 3 UBO 57,5 1 30
Risk Assessment
and Sustainable
Exploitation
Framework
5 Policy integration 5 QUB 48,5 1 36
6 Development of 7 PNRgDM 29,5 3 36
Stakeholder
Network
7 Communication, 6 UAVR 40,5 1 36
Dissemination &
Maximization of
impacts
Total person- 336
months
52
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Table 3.1c: List of Deliverables1
Delivery
Work Short name
Deliverable Dissemination date
Deliverable name package of lead Type
(number) participant level (in
number
months)
D1.1 PERICLES 1 AAU PU DEC 3
Intranet with
project templates
and guidelines
D1.2 Project 1 AAU R PU 4
Management Plan
D1.3 Data Management 1 AAU R PU 6
Plan
D1.4 Minutes of the 1 AAU R PU 6
Kick-Off
including the
establishment of
SIAC
D1.5 First annual report 1 AAU R PU 12
on gender
dimensions of
PERICLES
D1.6 Minutes of the 1 AAU R PU 13
first Annual
Meeting
D1.7 Minutes of the 1 SIAC R PU 25
second Annual
Meeting
D1.8 Second annual 1 AAU R PU 25
report on gender
dimensions of
PERICLES
D1.9 Third annual 1 AAU R PU 36
report on gender
dimensions of
PERICLES
D1.10 Summary of the 1 AAU R PU 36
final meeting
D2.1 Internal report of 2 AAU R PU 8
the key indicators
and cross cutting
1
If your action is taking part in the Pilot on Open Research Data, you must include a data management plan as a distinct
deliverable within the first 6 months of the project. This deliverable will evolve during the lifetime of the project in
order to present the status of the project's reflections on data management. A template for such a plan is available in
the H2020 Online Manual on the Participant Portal.
53
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
themes in
PERICLES CS.
D2.2 An internal report 2 AAU R PU 12
providing input
from task 2.4 for
the participatory
governance
framework
D2.3 Synthesis paper 2 AAU R PU 12
(publishable
quality journal
manuscript) of the
three pillars
concept for
sustainable CH
utilization
D2.4 Internal report, 2 AAU R PU 13
synthesizing
results of task 2.1-
2.6 for internal use
in WPs 3,4 and 5
D3.1 Interactive online 3 SAMS PU DEC 9
CH mapping
portal
D3.2 Portal data layer 3 SAMS R PU 9
summary report
D3.3 Internal report on 3 SAMS R PU 14
initial method and
tool review
D3.4 PERICLES VPA 3 SAMS R PU 28
D4.1 The maritime 4 UBO R PU 18
cultural heritage at
risk; A review of
CH at risk and
commonly applied
risk management
strategies
D4.2 Expert knowledge 4 UBO R PU 12
and social
representations of
maritime cultural
heritage at risk; an
empirical gap
analysis
D4.3 A participatory 4 UBO R PU 20
risk assessment
and sustainable
exploitation
framework for
54
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
maritime cultural
heritage (draft)
D4.4 A participatory 4 UBO R PU 30
risk assessment
and sustainable
exploitation
framework for
maritime cultural
heritage (final)
D5.1 Comprehensive 5 QUB R PU 15
policy review
report
D5.2 Internal report on 5 QUB R PU 18
stakeholder
interviews
D5.3 Report on the 5 QUB R PU 21
integration of a
coordination of
CH policies within
ICZM and MSP
D5.4 Report on policy 5 QUB R PU 26
related aspects of
the demonstrations
D5.5 Policy brief, 5 QUB R PU 36
identifying good
practices of policy
integration of CH
and maritime
policies
D6.1 Internal annotated 6 PNRgDM R PU 6
table relevant
stakeholders
within each case
study
D6.2 Space created on 6 PNRgDM PU DEC 12
the online portal
for stakeholder
interactions across
the project and
within each
casestudy
D6.3 Report of good 6 PNRgDM R PU 34
practice for CH
management with
evidence from
application and
policy measures
D7.1 Booklets and e- 7 SAMS R PU 14
booklets with CH
trails
55
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
D7.2 Education 7 UAVR R PU 18
materials
D7.3 Handbook with 7 SAMS R PU 33
education material
about practical
methods and tools
for understanding,
preserving and
benefiting from
CH
D7.4 Ethnographic 7 WU PU DEC 36
documentary
3.2 Management structure, milestones and procedures
The PERICLES partnership has formed a strong interdisciplinary consortium comprised of research,
academic, regional government and heritage partners from seven Member States (MS) with skills
spanning from ethnography to science dissemination and communication to marine spatial planning and
resources management.
PERICLES is an intricate project with multiple objectives, thus requiring specifically targeted management
strategies. In particular, due to the cross-cutting nature of the participatory methods and tools, case and pilot
studies, demonstrations, stakeholder networks, and the framework development, PERICLES requires well
established communication channels and strategic leadership positions (below) and also efficient, structured
and flexible communication among partners and stakeholders.
Figure 6. PERICLES management structure
Control of resource use, accounting, monitoring of progress and scientific quality will be achieved through
the streamlined management structure outlined below, to ensure good progress towards the aims of the
project and timely reports to the Commission. Due to the applied and stakeholder driven nature of the work,
intense communication with stakeholders and end users is needed. This is an important task for the
Coordinator, WP leaders, and Communications and Impact (C&I) Manager.
The leadership and overall coordination of the project will be ensured by the Coordinator, assisted by the
Deputy Coordinator and supported by the Project Office. The Coordinator and her deputy will be further
supported by the Steering Committee. This will be composed of the above plus WP leaders, the Case
56
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Region Coordinator and the C&I Manager. WP leaders will be supported by deputies ensuring resilience
and reducing performance risks. The project will be further supported by a central Science-Impact Advisory
Committee (SIAC) and regional Impact Boards. All partner staff involved in the project plus the SIAC will
together comprise of the General Assembly. The functional linkages among the different bodies of
PERICLES management are illustrated in in Figure 6 and members of the project Steering Committee and
main project leadership roles are detailed in Table 3.1.
Table3.1. Members of the project Steering Committee and main project leadership roles
Role (WP) Applicant (Partner number), Name (Gender)
Country
Coordinator (and WP1 Lead) AAU (1), Denmark Alyne Delaney (F)
Deputy Coordinator (and WP1 SAMS (7), UK Jasper Kenter (M)
Deputy Lead)
Case region Coordinator UHI (4), UK Steve Taylor (M)
Communications and Impact UAVR (6), Portugal Cristina Pita (F)
Manager
WP2 Lead FRI (9), Greece Dimitra Mylona (F)
WP2 Deputy Lead AAU (1), Denmark Kristen Ounanian (F)
WP3 Lead SAMS (7), UK Jasper Kenter (M)
WP3 Deputy Lead WU (2) the Netherlands Jan van Tatenhove (M)
WP4 Lead UBO (3), France Katia Frangoudes (F)
WP4 Deputy Lead PNRGDM (9), France Juliette Herry (F)
WP5 Lead QUB (5) Northern Ireland Wesley Flannery (M)
WP5 Deputy Lead MKA (8), Estonia Maili Roio (F)
WP6 Lead PNRGDM (9), France Morgane Dallic (F)
WP6 Deputy Lead SAMS (7), UK Elaine Azzopardi (F)
WP7 Lead UAVR (6), Portugal Cristina Pita (F)
WP7 Deputy Lead AAU (1), Denmark Alyne Delaney (F)
The Coordinator will have the following overall tasks:
1. Acting as the official point of contact with the EC
2. Monitoring partner compliance to their obligations and reviewing and ensuring project progress
3. Overall responsibility for the scientific direction of the project
4. Scheduling and chairing the Executive and Steering Committee
5. Regular liaison with the SIAC and scheduling its meetings
6. Managing internal communication
7. Scheduling of the project conferences and annual meetings
8. Actively engaging in external communication, dissemination and exploitation
9. Actively monitoring risks and ensuring mitigation actions are taken promptly if necessary
10. Arbitration in any conflicts
The Coordinator, Assoc. Prof. Alyne Delaney (Aalborg University) has participated in EU funded projects
for 15 years during FPV, FPVI, FPVII, and H2020 programmes serving roles of responsibility as WP and
task leader, and gained extensive experience coordinating multidisciplinary international research teams. She
has also coordinated international projects (e.g., CGIAR Program) and has lengthy experience working on
57
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
interdisciplinary advisory committees (e.g., the STECF). She has extensive experience working with
stakeholders in coastal and fishing communities.
The Deputy Coordinator, Dr Jasper Kenter (Principal Investigator, Scottish Association for Marine
Science) will support the Coordinator in tasks 4-9 above as delegated by the Coordinator. He has played
leading roles in highly transdisciplinary projects funded by the EU, UK Research Councils and the
Norwegian Research Councils, he is a Certified Associate in Project Management, and has extensive
experience of stakeholder and public participation in research and innovation.
The Project Office will consist of a part-time project manager supported by administrative and legal staff at
Aalborg University. The Project Office will:
1. Take care of the administrative aspects of the project management (also acting as a bridge between
the administrative contacts of PERICLES partners and EU officers);
2. Facilitate a timely and efficient communication among partners (via their principal scientific
contact) and between partners and the Coordinator;
3. Centralise and manage all activities related with scientific and financial reporting. The Project Office
will respond to the needs and requests between the PERICLES partnership and the EU, and react
promptly to operational or administrative issues raised.
4. Ensure that all activities and outcomes of the project comply with the obligations under the Grant
Agreement.
5. Support the scheduling and note keeping of Steering Group and SIAC meetings
6. Day to day maintenance of the project website, in liaison with the C&I manager.
7. Support the Coordinator and Steering Group members in their tasks where appropriate.
The Case Region Coordinator, will:
1. Continually liaise with case region leaders to ensure there is a continual flow of information between
the Steering Committee and individual WPs and case regions.
2. Ensure a concerted rather than disparate approach to implementation of the WPs across the case
regions
3. Support the coordinator in monitoring progress and implementation across different regions
4. Liaise with WP leaders to ensure that case regions are receiving the necessary support in
implementation from WPs
5. Ensure common structuring between case regions and demo’s
The leader of WP6 will also act as Communications and Impact Manager. In addition to the delivery of
WP6, she will:
1. Ensure communication, dissemination and exploitation activities are effectively pursued and
integrated across the case regions and at project scale
2. Ensure communication and dissemination activities are effectively recorded across partners.
3. Maintain an impact register (with support from the Project Office) in accordance with the specified
impacts of the topic and other key impacts mentioned in 2.1
4. Actively and continuously seek opportunities for communication, dissemination and enhancing
impact and liaise these opportunities to other members of the steering committee, and to the case
regions
5. Support case region leaders in liaising with Regional Impact Boards
6. Support the coordinator in liaising with the SIAC in terms of communication, dissemination and
exploitation.
7. Be responsible for Innovation Management (see below).
The Steering Committee, chaired by the Coordinator and assisted by the Project Office, will include all WP
leaders and their deputies, case region coordinator and C&I manager; representing all partners within the
consortium (ten individuals as a result of multiple roles). Project progress will be monitored closely by the
Steering Committee, with particular attention to the timely release of deliverables (Table 3.1c) and milestones
achievement (Table 3.2 below). The Steering Committee will have thus a high level of responsibility in the
58
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
project progress and will represent a stage for the exchange of information between the coordinator and the
whole partnership, as well as strategic decision making. The Steering Committee will be responsible for taking
decisions about progress and implementation of the project objectives and outcomes and will be also in charge
of coordinating the project implementation with administrative issues. The Steering Committee will be
responsible for all practical decision making and planning—with each Steering Committee member having 1
vote and decisions made by a 2/3 majority. The Steering Committee will have physical meetings at once a year
(linked to the project’s conferences and annual meetings) and intermediate meetings at least bimonthly via
videoconferences, to pave the way for an efficient functioning of the project, to ensure a short reaction time
from the whole partnership in case the need of major deviations to the project’s actions and expected results
would emerge. The Steering Committee will also orient the communication, dissemination and networking
actions and ensure quality. Every deliverable will be peer reviewed by a member of the SC – all experts in
their field – and modified where necessary before release, and where appropriate referring to the SIAC for
further review and advice.
The SIAC, composed of four renowned external experts in fields related with the topics and expected results
of PERICLES, will act as a scientific auditing panel aimed at ensuring the best scientific direction and output
of desk and field activities of the project. The SIAC will be established during the Kick-Off Meeting (KOM)
and will meet twice per year; once in person during the PERICLES annual meetings and once via
teleconference. The SIAC will be moderated by the PERICLES Co-ordinator, will analyse the intermediate
outcomes of the project and will provide advice to the whole partnership on how to ameliorate, redirect or
implement the scientific plan of the project. The SAC includes:
1. Sudharshan Seneviratne, Sri Lanka. Archaeology, Director UNESCO Heritage Site and Projects.
Recent work includes “Total Museums and Sustainable Tourism: Seascape and landscape interface
for Heritage Initiatives”
2. Sylvette Dénefle, France. Architecture. Director of La Maison des sciences de l'homme , University
of Tours. Recent work Renovation urban recomposition: territorial management: heritage and
solidary economy
3. Brian Smith, England. Secretary General of Heritage Europe (European Association of Historic
Towns and Regions)
4. Matt Gubbins, Scotland. Chair of the ICES Working Group on Marine Spatial Planning. Expert in
Risk Assessment.
The SIAC will also help the Consortium to maintain direct linkages to, and get early input from, different
stakeholders (i.e., historic ports and towns, NGOs, academia, industry) and, at the same time, will provide
input on how to adjust project plans and improve its outputs. Rather than appointing a large and comprehensive
but relatively inactive, pro forma advisory committee, we have decided to appoint a small core advisory team
of highly dedicated experts who will be genuinely active throughout the project as critical friends and act as
vectors to liaise with other global research and practitioner expertise tailored to specific circumstances and
requests, which we believe to be a more genuine, effective, and resource-efficient approach.
Impact Boards will be established per case region as described under 2.2 involving a wide range of APs and
key stakeholders across sectors. Their main aim is act as a communication vector both to enable participation
across different interests in the project activities and to disseminate results. They will be regularly consulted
on key activities by case region partners; and regular communication with regional impact boards will be
ensured by the C&I manager. All members of impact boards are also invited to participate in the first and third
year project conferences.
The General Assembly will meet annually, in the first and last project year as part of the PERICLES
Conference and in year two as an independent meeting. The General Assembly will provide valuable
opportunities for knowledge exchange across disciplines, internal capacity building, coordination and joint
evaluation.
The multitude of objectives and tasks need a continuous exchange of information among partners within each
WP, across WPs, according to the logical flow of information and data, and among the different bodies
coordinating, managing and monitoring all activities and outcomes of PERICLES.
59
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Internal WP meetings. To facilitate the internal WP communication within WPs, WP leads and participants
will liaise in between Steering Committee meetings and in person during the annual meeting. The internal WP
meetings will be dedicated to organize and coordinate activities within each task: the first internal meeting for
each WP will be held during the Kick-Off meeting (KOM) at M1. Internal meetings will be then dedicated to
analyse the tasks progress, implement actions and eventually review the work plan. In case of any other issue
emerging during the lifespan of the project, additional meetings will be heldin presence of and moderated by
the Coordinator. The outcomes from each internal WP meeting will be reported timely to the SC, and annually
to the SIAC.
Crosscutting meetings. Cross-cutting sessions will be organized during the entire lifespan of the project
whenever needed (as established by the SC and bottom-up initiatives from WP co-leaders) and, compulsory,
during the Annual Meetings. These crosscutting meetings will facilitate the project work flow in relation to
cross-WP tasks in Case Regions and Demo’s and to ensure data and information from the Scientific WPs 2-5
to the Networking, Communication and Dissemination WPs 6-7.
Conflict management. If a conflict arises within the project within a single WP, this will in first instance be
arbitrated by the WP leader; if it involves the WP leader, by the deputy leader. If the conflict cannot be resolved
within the WP, or if it goes across more than one WP, the conflict will be arbitrated by the Coordinator; if it
involves the Coordinator, by the Deputy Coordinator. If this still does not resolve the conflict, the conflict will
be decided by the Steering Committee; if the conflict involves members of the Steering Committee, they will
be excluded from its decision.
Innovation management. Innovation in PERICLES will consist of development of new scientific
methodologies as well as applied tools for CH preservation and sustainable exploitation. In addition,
participatory co-production work with stakeholders, for example through exploitation workshops, may
generate innovation in terms of new product and service concepts. This work will provide insight on market
and technical needs, opportunities and constraints which is the basis for any further exploitation of results by
the consortium or any of its members. These potential exploitation activities shall abide by the Consortium
Agreement where all issues related to Intellectual Property Rights will be detailed. Innovation management
will be a responsibility for the C&I manager who will track and register innovation in the impact register,
supported in particular by the WP 3 leads (Methods and Tools) and Case Region Coordinator.
Critical risks relating to project implementation
The complexity of PERICLES and the relatively short time frame of the project represent a certain level of
performance risk. Nonetheless, the potential consequences of such risks are expected to be counterbalanced
by the capacity of PERICLES to produce not only science-based knowledge and a participatory framework
for sustainable governance of CH, but also to develop new tools, develop stakeholder exchange networks, and
provide policy advice to improve integration of CH into key marine and environmental policies. The size of
the PERICLES consortium (10 partners) makes project organisation manageable, though the complexity of the
tasks required to ensure a genuinely participatory framework means there will be a large number of actors
involved in PERICLES’ successful delivery. Associated risks will be managed through a clear management
structure and procedures with ongoing monitoring by the Coordinator and Steering Committee supported by
the Project Office (see above).
The PERICLES implementation could be subjected to (limited) risks of delay for some aspects of the tasks.
These risks are mostly related to the timing of the project initiation which could affect the development of
tools and period of the year (e.g. some CH events occur only once a year) . To overcome these risks, the timing
of tasks, particularly of WP3-4, have been designed and spread over the project lifespan in order to facilitate
(with eventual minor changes in the temporal framing) inclusion of specific and intended CH activities (e.g.,
rituals and festivals, thereby enabling the conclusion of the project within three years.
There are also limited risks associated with difficulties in framing the results obtained from local and regional
small-scale demo projects to the larger European scale. This risk will be mitigated by the use of common
formats and templates for reporting under supervision of the Case Region Coordinator. Case Regions and
Demo’s will also rely on common concepts and frameworks established by the WPs early on in the project and
explicit synthesis tasks have been set to ensure upward integration towards the end of the project. Regions and
60
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
demo’s have also been consciously identified to balance diversity as well as comparison. This structure enables
a combination of both tailored, place based approaches and generating common understanding and upscaling.
61
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Table 3.2b: Critical risks for implementation
Description of risk Work package(s) involved Proposed risk-mitigation measures
Delay in field activities generated 2-5 Potential delays have been already
by the timing of project initiation considered in the timing of the project.
and natural variability Eventual deviations will be
(seasonality) (Medium; residual counteracted through a revision of
risk: low) operative WPs.
Low engagement and 2-6 Many stakeholders covering several
participation of stakeholders sectors have already committed to
(Medium; residual risk: low) being involved in the project. Regional
Impact Boards with large number of
pre-committed APs will act as vectors
for engagement and participation.
Low public participation rate in 3 Impact Boards ensure engagement
citizen science campaign to with large number of membership
crowd source distribution of CH organisations to encourage public
(Medium; residual risk: Low) participation; contests/prizes; work
with artists to make portal highly
attractive/accessible; integration of
existing data into mapping portal.
Poor communication between All Proactive management of
WPs and Case regions and communication by Case Region
challenges in up-scaling results Coordinator; use of common templates
(High; residual risk: Low) for reporting; use of common concepts
and frameworks from WPs; explicit
synthetic tasks in WPs 2-5; demo’s
chosen to enable compare & contrast.
Poor integration between 2-5 Demonstrator projects specifically
academic disciplines (High; designed for interdisciplinary work.
residual risk: Low) Many lead roles filled by those with
substantial experience of
interdisciplinary leadership.
Delay in completion of 2-5 Number of dependencies is limited
foundational work (WP 2-5 between initial tasks in WPs 2-5 so
reviews/frameworks) cascades delays are less likely to cascade.
into critical delay to Demos.
(Medium; residual risk: Low)
Staff absence All Resilience in project delivery through
appointment of deputies to
coordination and WP lead tasks.
Tables for section 3.2
Table 3.2a: List of milestones
Milestone Milestone name Related work Due date (in month) Means of
number package(s) verification
M1.1 First management 1 2
templates, guidelines
and DoW available
for download in the
62
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
partners’ area on the
webpage
M1.2 Kick-off meeting 1 2
held and
management bodies
established
M1.3 Project Management 1
Plan available on the
partners’ area of the
website
MI4 Data Management 1
Plan available on the
partners’ area of the
website
MI5 First annual meeting 1 13
held
MI6 Second annual 1 25
meeting held
M2.1 Completed literature 2 12
review of academic,
policy, and
stakeholder
understandings of
cultural heritage
M2.2 Completed literature 2 8
review space, place,
and identity and how
they inform CH
M2.3 Completed literature 2 9
review of resilience
and adaptation in
costal cultures and
societies
M2.4 Literature review of 2 10
models of
deliberative and
participatory
governance for
preservation and
utilization of
European coastal
and maritime CH
and landscapes
M2.5 Ethnographic 2 11
Interviews
completed
M2.6 Completed synthesis 2 13
of results with
literature review and
case study results,
internally feeding
into WPs 4 and 5
M3.1 Portal infrastructure 3 9
complete
63
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
M3.2 Initial tool review 3 14
complete
M3.3 Citizen science 3 10
campaign begun
M4.1 Data gathering on 4 9
threats to CH and
risk management
strategies complete
M4.2 Local experts list 4 12
compiled for
interviews and
stakeholder
workshop on
knowledge
M5.1 Deliberative 4 30
workshop with
stakeholders to
develop
understanding of the
transferability of
innovative practices
and policies
M6.1 First international 6 12
experience sharing
workshop
M6.2 Stakeholder area on 6 12
the web portal
online
M6.3 Second international 6 24
stakeholder
workshop
M6.4 Case study, case 6 30
specific workshop
on bringing CH
stakeholder together
completed
M6.5 EU wide event 6
engaging a
transnational
audience of scholars,
policymakers and
other participants, to
widen the impact
potential of
PERICLES and
further ensure that
its impact endure
beyond the end of
the project through
enhanced capacity
across sectors
M7.1 Website online 7 3
M7.2 Panel session at the 7 16
MARE conference
64
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
M7.3 Booklet and e- 7 30
booklets ready
M7.4 Capacity building 7 33
courses prepared
M7.5 Handbook ready 7 33
M7.6 Ethnographic 7 30
documentary
finished
3.3 Consortium as a whole
PERICLES brings together a multidisciplinary Consortium, combining approaches, methodologies and skill
sets from CH preservation, social sciences (anthropology, sociology, geography, governance, planning,
political science, economics, and tourism studies), humanities (history, film, art, linguistics), and spatial and
environmental sciences (ecology, marine and fisheries science), communication, dissemination, and
stakeholder engagement, all coming from complementary worlds of research (2), academia (6), Heritage (1)
and regional governmental (1) organisations.
The Partnership Consortium included in the Stage 1 submission has altered slightly with two substitutions: the
Fisheries Research Centre, Kavala (Greece) is replacing INSTAP due to funding ineligibility (confusion
resulting from the fact INSTAP has a PIC# but are not eligible due to the legal address in New York, not the
Greek address). HOWEVER, the lead researcher for FRI, Dimitra Mylona, is the same as our main contact at
INSTAP. Thus the scientific skills remain the same and in addition, she now brings additional colleagues with
added biological expertise. Also, a governmental stakeholder partner, The Highland Council (Scotland) was
forced to withdraw from the project due to administrative changes within their organisation. To replace them,
an affiliated governmental agency stakeholder partner, Golfe du Morbihan Natural Regional Park (PNRgDM),
in Brittany, France, has now joined PERICLES as a full partner. PNRgDM is currently conducting their own
work on inventorying CH, as well as conducting their own a risk assessments, making them an excellent
replacement.
All Partners taking part in PERICLES come from countries eligible for funding in the present call. Half of the
Partner come from “northern” MS (e.g., Denmark, Northern Ireland, the Netherlands and Scotland) and half
from “southern” or “new” MS (Estonia, France, Greece, and Portugal).
The entire consortium will work jointly in a collective and complementary manner to achieve all project
objectives. This confident expectation is based on the fact that all partners have been identified and invited to
take part in PERICLES based on their scientific excellence and specific experience on the multifaceted array
of topics covered by PERICLES (e.g., CH, communication, environmental policies, governance, methods
development, stakeholder engagement, etc. Moreover, the partnership has been built in order to include
partners and participants that will:
1. be able to share common languages and understanding to implement the cultural exchange needed
among varying disciplines using basically different approaches;
2. make available, mine and collect empirical data as well as uncover new and innovative methods
and tools for a sustainable framework for CH (WPs 1-5)
3. provide robust analyses of theory and data produced on the theoretical underpinning of PERICLES
(CH; space, place and identity; risk, resilience, and adaptation; on deliberative and participatory
governance (WP2), on methods and tool development (WP3); on a CH sustainable exploitation
framework (WP4); and on policy integration (WP5);
4. create, maintain and implement a two-way dialogue with CH stakeholders through co-development
of knowledge, tools, methodologies, and networks (WP6);
5. create, maintain and implement all actions needed to communicate and disseminate the results of
the project (WP7).
65
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
The close collaboration among teams from Universities, Research Institutions, Heritage and regional
governmental Associations will ensure liberal coverage of the expected outcomes delineated in the Call and
envisaged in the present proposal. The Universities involved in PERICLES will allow a tight linkage between
evidence-based research and participatory governance envisaged in the present proposal and the young
generations of students, at the same time guaranteeing high levels of scientific reputation. The Research
Institutions taking part in MERCES will ensure connections and working experience with national and
international policy and governance bodies, ensuring better implementation of European policies on coastal
zones and maritime areas (e.g., ‘Integrated Coastal Zone Management” (ICZM) and ‘Establishing a
framework for maritime spatial planning’ (MSP) thus providing evidence and means for linking environmental
and cultural policies. The presence of heritage and regional governmental associations enables PERICLES
to enter and learn from the world of direct CH preservation, managing data, balancing, stakeholder and
governmental policies and regulations, and with experience disseminating and communicating CH to the
public. Finally, the involvement of all with the input from the SAC will ensure PERICLES improves upon and
keeps alive the attention and awareness of the EU citizenship about issues and opportunities of coastal and
maritime CH, acting as a skilled team of people dedicated to the dissemination and communication of the
project results.
The consortium is arranged in a uniquely inter- and transdisciplinary way and is definitely capable of
conducting the complex and comprehensive CH project across Europe. The PERICLES Consortium has 37
core participants (22 women, equal to 59% details are given in the description of partners) but will also appoint
young researchers to take part in PERICLES as possible. Training of students and mentoring young researchers
is important aspect of the PERICLES project.
In addition to the core team of participants in PERICLES, public and private stakeholders are included in
participatory workshops, citizen science initiatives and communication strategies with the goal of enabling
mutual learning for sustainable and good governance of CH utilization. This close collaboration of the
PERICLES Consortium with stakeholders will allow the swift take-up of cultural heritage themes identified
in the project by society and researchers, and the delivery of policy objectives for utilizing and preserving CH
for growth, job creation, and development, according to the to the aims and expectations declared in the EU’s
Blue Growth Strategy.
3.4 Resources to be committed
Table 3.4a: Summary of staff effort
WP1 WP2 WP3 WP4 WP5 WP6 WP7 Total Person-
Months per
Participant
1 AAU 18 6 7 4 4 5 6 50
2 WU 2 5 15 5 10 2 5 44
3 UBO 2 6 5 12 4 2 1,5 32,5
4 UHI 1 1 3 5 1 1 1 13
5 QUB 2 3 5 2 10 2 2 26
6 UAVR 2 5 11 5 5 2 9,5 39,5
7 SAMS 8 8 20 12 10 8 8 74
8 MKA 1 5 5 7 5 2 2 27
9 PNRgDM 2 1 4 6 0 6 6 27
10 FRI 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 3
Total Person Months 336
66
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
67
PERICLES
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
4. Members of the Consortium
4.1 Participants (applicants)
Name Aalborg University Partner
number: 1
Country Denmark Acronym IFM / AAU
Innovative Fisheries Management (IFM) is part of Department of Planning at Aalborg
Description – legal entity, main tasks
University (AAU). IFM is a research and advisory centre working with marine
management, cultural heritage and coastal community development. In particular, IFM
focuses on questions of governance and is specialised in cross-disciplinary collaboration
and is frequently teaming up with colleagues from other disciplines or external
stakeholders in order to develop suitable solutions. In this project IFM has joined forces
with the Danish Centre for Spatial Planning (DCSP), also in the Dept. of Planning,
AAU. DCSP researches spatial change processes and their governance, in particular
place-based development approaches and innovations in planning. The Department of
Planning, http://www.en.plan.aau.dk, is leading, internationally, in generating
interdisciplinary knowledge concerning policy-making and planning for sustainable
development solutions at all geographic and government levels. The department has a
staff of approx. 200 and is involved in a variety of research and study programmes
ranging from social science aspects of development (technological, environmental,
governance) to spatial and sector planning, land and mobility management.
Dr. Alyne Delaney (female; Assoc Prof), PERICLES Coordinator and PI. She is IFM’s
Head of Research, is on the Management Committee of the EU’s COST Action Ocean
Governance for Sustainability (Fisheries Governance WP co-leader) and serves on the
International Boards (e.g., Centre for Maritime Research. She holds a PhD in
Anthropology, qualified in Cultural and Physical Anthropology, Socio-linguistics and
Archaeology. Dr. Delaney has 14 years’ experience working on EU Framework/ H2020
projects on issues of coastal culture and development, fisheries and marine governance.
She has contributed to more than 40 ISI-indexed articles, book chapters and reports and
holds a biennial PhD seminar on Cultural Heritage. She had completed one documentary
film on small scale coastal fishing culture in the Baltic Sea.
Key Personnel
Dr. Kristen Ounanian (female), Assistant Professor of Marine Governance & Coastal
Community Development, expert in fisheries management, natural resource dependence,
and coastal community transition. Dr. Ounanian’s research also investigates the
opportunities, challenges, and linkages within coastal tourism, fishing heritage, and
working waterfronts
Dr. Carsten Jahn Hansen (male) is Associate Professor, Director of the Danish
Centre for Spatial Planning (DCSP) and the Danish contact point (ECP) in the EU
based ESPON network. He is an expert in spatial governance and planning processes,
place-based innovation and is currently involved in a national research council project
on integrated coastal zone management and planning.
Dr. Lars Bodum (male) is Associate Professor at Aalborg University (AAU). He holds
a PhD in applied geoinformatics. He is an expert in geospatial solutions and
datamodeling. Among the projects he has worked on are advanced modeling with 3D
geodata and use of virtual reality in geospatial science. His research spans from spatial
data infrastructure and standards for smart cities to implementation of open data portals.
1
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
He was director and one of the founders of Centre for 3D Geoinformation (3DGI) before
he took on the job as Head of Department at AAU for 6 years (2010-2016).
Un-named Post-doc will be hired to serve as the Project Manager in the Project
Management Office. The candidate will have a background in academia related to
coastal culture or governance, and also experience with stakeholders. A post-doc is
chosen for training and increasing activities with younger researchers. Dr. Ounanian is
also newly hired and a young assistant professor.
1. Arthur, R., Macfadyen, G., Cappell, R., Delaney, A., Triantaphyllidis, G., Caillart,
Relevant Publications/Products/ Services
B., et al. 2011. Regional social and economic impacts of change in fisheries-
dependent communities. FINAL REPORT. Lot 4: Impact Assessment Studies
related to the CFP No. Fish /2006/06) European Commission.
2. Delaney, A., K. Frangoudes, and S. Ii. “Society and Seaweed: Understanding the
past and present” in Fleurence and Levine (eds.) Seaweed in Health and Disease
Prevention. Elsevier Press.
3. Hadjimichael, M. and A. Delaney, M. Kaiser, and G. Edwards-Jones. (2012)
“Using a resilience framework to link institutional arrangements and ecological
dynamics in two European inshore fisheries Socio-Ecological Systems (SESs).”
Ambio 42(8): 1037-1046.
4. Hansen, C. J. & Stokke, K. B. (2017) Protection or Development? Integrated
Coastal Zone Management in Denmark and Norway, paper at PLANNORD
conference, August, Helsinki.
5. Ounanian, Kristen. “In Place of Fishing: Coastal Communities in Transition.” PhD
diss., University of Rhode Island & Aalborg University, 2016.
1. ‘PlanCoast’, Norwegian research council project on integrated coastal zone
management and planning, 2016-2019,
https://www.nmbu.no/prosjekter/node/27846.
2. ‘Stedkvaliteter, Erhvervsudvikling og Vækst’, 2014-2016: A project focusing on
place-based innovation and local development in North Denmark. Funded by the
Relevant Projects
Region of North Denmark and all its 11 municipalities.
3. BONUS EEIG, GOHERR: Integrated governance of Baltic herring and salmon
stocks involving stakeholders, 2015-18. Project on governance but also the
sociocultural importance of the stocks and fishing heritage. WP Lead
4. “Too Big To Ignore (TBTI): Global Partnership for Small-Scale Fisheries Research
(SSF)” http://toobigtoignore.net/ Gobal Network addressing sustainability of SSF,
especially social aspects.
5. CEC Research, ODEMM: Options for Delivering Ecosystem-Based Marine
Management. Governance research in ecosystem based management including EU
policies. WP leaders
The Department of Planning at AAU, including IFM and DCSP, offers a wide range of
Infrastructure/ Equipment
study programmes, about half of them international programmes, that merges various
disciplines in the pursuit of tailoring situation and place-specific sustainable
development policies, plans and solutions. Programmes of particular relevance are
concerned with environmental management, techno-anthropology, integrated food
studies, geography, urban planning and management, land management, sustainable
cities as well as sustainable energy planning and management. These programmes are
all in English and entails a strong international profile with many international students.
In addition, Aalborg University is world leading in Problem-based learning approaches,
e.g. the Dept. of Planning hosts a UNESCO chair, The Center for Problem Based
Learning. PERICLES work will connect with many of these students and programs.
2
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Name Wageningen University Partner
number: 2
Country Netherlands Acronym WU
WU is part of Wageningen University and Research (WUR), which is a leading
international knowledge institute in the fields of nutrition health, sustainable agricultural
systems and environmental quality. The Environmental Policy Group
Description
(ENP)(http://www.enp.wur.nl/UK) of WU is part of the Social Science group
(SSG)(approximately 750 employees). ENP is international leading in the field of
environmental social science and policy research (15 staff members and 45 PhD students)
and has organized its international research program around five core research innovation
themes: sustainable urban infrastructures, marine governance, sustainable food
transformations, governing environmental mobilities and governing climate futures. The
Marine Governance group consists of 3 staff members and 18 PhD students
Prof. dr. Jan P.M. van Tatenhove (male), Professor of Marine Governance, expert in
Key Personnel
EU integrated marine governance initiatives, such as Marine Spatial Planning, director of
MARE and Honorary professor MSP at Queens’ University Belfast (UK),
Dr. Hilde M. Toonen (female), Post doc and lecturer, environmental and marine
governance, expert in informational governance and Marine Spatial Planning.
Dr Loes Witteveen (female) guest researcher, Knowledge Technology & Innovation,
expert in visual research methods, co-creation for policy design in mediated realities
Van Tatenhove, Jan P.M. (2017), Transboundary Marine Spatial Planning: a reflexive
marine governance experiment?. In: Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning
(online first)
Wesley Flannery, Geraint Ellis, Geraint Ellis, Wesley Flannery, Melissa Nursey-Bray, Jan
P. M. van Tatenhove, Christina Kelly, Scott Coffen-Smout, Rhona Fairgrieve, Maaike
Relevant Publications/Products/ Services
Knol, Svein Jentoft, David Bacon & Anne Marie O’Hagan (2016) Exploring the
winners and losers of marine environmental governance/Marine spatial planning: Cui
bono?/“More than fishy business”: epistemology, integration and conflict in marine
spatial planning/Marine spatial planning: power and scaping/Surely not all planning is
evil?/Marine spatial planning: a Canadian perspective/Maritime spatial planning – “ad
utilitatem omnium”/Marine spatial planning: “it is better to be on the train than being hit
by it”/Reflections from the perspective of recreational anglers and boats for
hire/Maritime spatial planning and marine renewable energy, Planning Theory &
Practice, 17:1, 121-151,
Toonen Hilde M. (2013), Sea@Shore. Information governance in marine spatial conflicts
at the North Sea. PhD thesis Wageningen University
Lie, Rico and Loes Witteveen, Loes (2017), Visual informed consent: informed consent
without forms, International Journal of Social Research Methodology 20 (1). - p. 63 –
75
Witteveen, L.M., Lie, R. (2012). Learning about “wicked” problems in the Global South.
Creating a film-based learning environment with “Visual Appraisal” MedieKultur:
Journal of Media and Communication Research 28 (52). - p. 81 - 99
3
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
- Horizon 2020 PADDLE-RISE (Planning in A liquiD world with tropicaL StakEs:
solutions from an EU-Africa-Brazil perspective). Research and Innovation Staff Exchange
Scheme (RISE), start 1 July 2017
- Horizon2020 MERCES (Marine Ecosystem Restoration in Changing European Seas),
Relevant Projects
Coordinator of WP 6
- NWO Polair programma Post doc project Developing benefit-sharing standards in the
Arctic: Toward coexistence of oil and gas companies and traditional indigenous
communities.
- “Engaging Science in Dynamic Decision Making for the Wadden Sea” funded by NWO-
ZKO (The Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research Sea and Coast Research) – (2
PhDs)
- Natuurmonumenten. VHL Sustainable river management. River flows. An artistic approach
towards community resilience, participation and social learning in natural resource
management (research and co-creation project with MSc students)
Recognising the importance of disseminating knowledge and expertise, WU offers
students from around the world a wide range of educational programs and facilities. WU
is a leading educational institution in the Netherlands that offers the possibility to
Infrastructure/ Equipment
integrate natural and social sciences. Study programs cover the full range from plant
sciences, food technology and health to supply chain management, from environmental
sciences to sociology and economics. WU offers students from abroad a special
international Master of Science Program as well as a post-graduate program. WU is a
well-established University with a large number of lecturers, researchers and other
employees are based at Wageningen Campus. Wageningen Campus is a centre where
expertise and talent come together. Scientists and students carry out globally pioneering
research here or train to become professionals who will make breakthroughs in
knowledge and technology in. SSG is very experienced in the coordination of EU
projects; PUREFOOD (Marie Curie FP7-PEOPLE-2010-ITN); Supurb Food (KBBE,
2012-2015); Glamur (KBBE 2013-2016) and Quarisma Marie Curie IAPP (2009-
2013)(SSG not coordinating) the future
4
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Name Université de Bretagne Partner
Occidentale number:3
Country FR Acronym UBO
The Université de Bretagne Occidentale (UBO) is a multidisciplinary university based in
Brest; France. Two research units of UBO are participating in the project: AMURE-Centre
for the law and economics of sea (www.umr-amure.fr) established in 2008 as a joint
research unit between CEDEM/UBO, the Maritime Economics department of Ifremer
(www.ifremer.fr) and CNRS, and LABERS, laboratory of studies and research in
sociology (www.univ-brest.fr/labers). AMURE research work focuses on the study of
economic and legal dimensions of public policies related to maritime activities,
development and sustainability of these activities, property rights and responsibility in
Description
marines resources/spaces and socio ecosystems/territories management strategies. UMR
AMURE is member of the European Institute for Marine Studies (www.univ-
brest.fr/IUEM). More than 70 researchers, post-doctoral researchers and doctoral students
in economics and law are working in the unit. AMURE has a long experience in a
multidisciplinary cooperation with natural and others social sciences under international
and national projects. It has been involved in several EU and national funded projects.
LABERS focuses its research work on health and society, territories and mobility and
sociology of culturalities. It is regrouping 40 researches, post doc and PhD students. UBO
is experienced in European projects management since the FP4 and is involved in eight
H2020 research projects (2,5M€), in twenty FP7 projects (6 M€) and fifteen Interreg
programmes (5 M€).
Dr. Katia Frangoudes (Female) PhD in Political sciences, researcher at AMURE has
worked since 1993 on the institutions and governance of fisheries in European Union.
Coordinator of Elsa-Pêche, COASTMAN projects under the 4th FP and the thematic network
FEMMES, (gender equality in EU fisheries) under the 5th FP. Since she was involved in
many other European and national projects VECTORS, DISCARDLESS, MEDAID,
NETALGAE, etc.
Key Personnel
Nicolas Boillet (Male) PhD in law, researcher at AMURE has as main research themes
ICZM and MSP, coastal heritage. He organized the symposium “Patrimoine maritime: entre
patrimoine culturel et patrimoine Naturel” in June 2016 in Brest in collaboration with G.
Goffraux Callebaut.
Muriel Taillens (Female), PhD in law, researcher at AMURE is working on the social
aspects of maritime activities and on seaweed harvesters in Brittany. Seaweed harvesting is
now part of the national CH inventory in France.
Nicole Roux, (Female) sociologist, is conducting her research within LABERS
laboratory. She is teaching environmental sociology and her main research is focusing on
territories and mobility and gender relations.
5
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Relevant Publications/Products/ Goffaux-Callebaut G, Boillet N., 2017, Patrimoine maritime : entre patrimoine culturel et
patrimoine naturel, Proceedings of the Symposium organised in Brest in June 2016
(forthcoming)
Boillet N., 2013, La gestion intégrée des zones côtières et le patrimoine culturel » in VertigO
- la revue électronique en sciences de l'environnement [En ligne], Hors-série 18 | Décembre
Services
2013.
Frangoudes K., E. Keromnes, 2008. Women in Artisanal Fisheries in Brittany, France, in
Development 2008, 51, 265-270
Roux N., 2014, "Habiter autrement, un autre rapport au temps", Ecologie et politique, N°48/1,
Presses de Sciences Po, p. 37-47.
Taillens M., 2017, L’encadrement juridique de la récolte d’algues de rive: la
professionnalisation d’une activité locale ancestrale in Le Droit Maritime Français,
(forthcoming)
- COASTMAN, Comparative Analysis of Institutional Arrangement Experiences and Needs
for ICZM in three European Countries: France, Norway and Greece, ENV-CT97-0045, FP
Relevant Projects
4,
- FEMMES, Women in Fisheries in Europe, FP 4
- SPICOSA, Sciences and Policy Integration for Coastal System Assessment, EU FP 6.
- MEDAID, Mediterranean Aquaculture Integrated Development, H2020.
- COREPOINT Capacity building for Integrated Coastal Zone Management (interreg IIIB
NOE, http://corepoint.ucc.ie)
- IMCORE, Tools to support local strategies for adaptation to climate change (interreg
IVB NOE, www.imcore.eu)
Infrastructure/
Equipment
UBO/AMURE/LABERS have all the necessary facilities, equipment and expertise
necessary for the projects. It includes office space, laboratories, basic and more specific
equipments to acquire and analyze data. AMURE has access to National Library on
Marine Sciences (Bibliothèque La Pérouse).
6
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Name University of the Highlands Partner
and Islands number:4
Country UK Acronym UHI
UHI’s Centre for Recreation and Tourism Research (CRTR) is one of the UK’s leading
tourism research centres. Affiliated to the School of Adventure Studies, which teaches
courses in Adventure Tourism and Ecotourism, CRTR has undertaken a wide range of
Description
tourism knowledge exchange and consultancy projects, both in the UK and overseas. It is
a founder member of the Adventure Tourism Research Association, with worldwide
membership – as such it is recognised widely as a major player in the industry. Staff
members have managed, or been involved in, numerous EU-funded projects on culture,
heritage and tourism, through the Interreg programmes, the Joint Programming Initiative
and Leader, for example.
Dr Steve Taylor (male) is the Head of Centre for CRTR, responsible for academic
output, research and tourism consultancy services. Developing and managing knowledge
exchange and EU-funded projects, management of the centre and writing academic
papers and articles are core responsibilities. He obtained his PhD at the Department of
Key Personnel
Tourism, University of Otago, New Zealand. His qualitative research explored the issue
of participation in autonomously-controlled, non-commodified adventure sports, using
mountain biking as a case study. The primary aim of his thesis was to establish the range
of factors that influence people’s participation in such an activity, from participants’
motivations to the environmental attributes that attract them to locations at which their
motivations can be realised.
Sara Mair Bellshaw (female) is the Centre’s Projects Manager, with responsibility for
delivering the Centres involvement in three EU-funded (ERDF) heritage/tourism
projects.
Varley, P., Huijbens, E.H., Laven, D. and Taylor, S. (under development) Slow adventure:
tourism for the 21st century consumer.
Publications/Products/
Rowsell, B., Maher, P.T., Taylor, S. and Mullins, P.M. (2014) Mountain Bike Tourism
Under the Midnight Sun. In Viken, A. & Granas, B. (eds). Destination Dynamics. Turns
Relevant
Services
and Tactics. Franham, Ashgate.
Taylor, S., Varley, P. and Johnston, T. (eds.) (2013) Adventure Tourism: Meaning,
Experience and Learning, Abingdon, Routledge.
Taylor, S. (2010) ‘Extending the dream machine’: Understanding people’s participation in
mountain biking. Annals of Leisure Research, 13(1 & 2), 259 – 281.
SAENE Northern Periphery and Arctic Programme project on extending the marketing
reach on slow adventure micro-businesses
Relevant Projects
LANDsARE was a transnational LEADER project on the theme of landscape approaches
to developing rural areas
The Gastrocert project explored the role of gastronomy in promoting and preserving
local culture and heritage
CRTR’s role in the Nevis Landscape Partner Lottery-funded project included the
development of training, learning and participation programme to engage locals in
landscape protection and promotion
tructu
Infras
Equip
ment
re/
N/A
7
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Name Queen's University Belfast Partner
number: 5
Country UK Acronym QUB
Queen’s University Belfast (QUB) has been ranked in the top 1% of universities in the
world according to the QSW world University Rankings. QUB is a member of the Russell
group – a group of 24 leading UK research intensive universities and is a top university in
the UK. The group involved in this proposal is the Institute for Spatial and Environmental
Description
Planning (ISEP), is based within the School of Planning, Architecture and Civil
Engineering. ISEP is a cluster of 14 research active staff involved in a wide range of
environmental planning research and has been ranked 7th for research intensity in
environmental planning in the UK’s Research Evaluation Framework 2014. Marine
planning and renewable energy are two of the research foci of the school and the group.
The ISEP have conducted a number of marine planning projects using stakeholder
workshops.
Dr. Wesley Flannery (male), Lecturer in Marine Spatial Planning Marine and expert in
stakeholder participation. Has published widely on the topic of marine spatial planning
and advise the Marine Institute (Ireland) on the development of an MSP framework for
Ireland. In MOMOP coordinator of WP2. Full profile here: http://goo.gl/AuyEEu
Key Personnel
Prof. Geraint Ellis (male), Prof Geraint Ellis, Chair of Environmental Planning and
Director of Research, School of Planning, Architecture and Civil Engineering, Queen’s
University, Belfast, expert in spatial planning, renewable energy planning, social
acceptance and energy transition. Ellis’s full profile is here: http://t.co/LLKp7Xf96G
Dr. Brendan Murtagh (Male), Dr. Brendan Murtagh is a Chartered Town Planner and
Reader in the School of Natural and Built Environment at Queens University Belfast. He
has researched and written widely on economic and cultural planning: Murtagh's full
profile is here: https://goo.gl/EqqYkq
Flannery, W., Ellis, et al (2016). Exploring the winners and losers of marine
environmental governance, Planning Theory & Practice, 17:121-151
Relevant Publications/
Flannery, W., O’Hagan, A.M., O’Mahony, C., Ritchie, H. and Twomey, S. (2015)
Products/ Services
Evaluating Conditions for Transboundary Marine Spatial Planning: Challenges and
opportunities on the Island of Ireland, Marine Policy, 5, pp. 86–95.
Flannery, W., Lynch, K. and Ó Cinnéide, M (2015) Consideration of Coastal Risk in the
Irish Spatial Planning Processes, Land Use Policy, 43, pp. 161–169.
Ellis G. (2015) Rebuilding the Idea of the Commons. Town and Country Planning, Nov
30;84(11):488-490.
Murtagh, B., Boland, P., & Shirlow, P. (2017). Contested heritages and cultural tourism.
International Journal of Heritage Studies. DOI: 10.1080/13527258.2017.1287118
The School has hosted a range of major funded projects including UK Research Councils,
Infrastruct Relevant Projects
directly commissioned by Government, charities and private sector projects. Under
Framework 7 (EU) QUB participated in 137 projects worth a total of €38.5M (including
the Marine Renewables Infrastructure Network (MARINET) Project). QUB participates
in 34 H2020 projects (coordinator of 5). This includes ICT collaborative projects plus 13
Marie Skłodowska Curie Actions: 3 ITN (coordinator of 2), 10 Individual Fellowships, 2
RISE projects (coordinator of 1).
Equipment
The project will be hosted in state-of-the-art facilities based in the School of Planning,
ure/
Architecture and Civil Engineering, QUB. The research infrastructure is supported by
expertise in a wide range of planning and marine energy issues.
8
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Name University of Aveiro Partner
number: 6
Country Portugal Acronym UAVR
Founded in 1973, the University of Aveiro (UAVR) is ranked among the 100 best young
universities according to the Times Higher Education index. The Centre for Environmental
and Marine Studies (CESAM) is an Associated Laboratory of the UAVR and one of the
few interdisciplinary research units connecting environmental and marine sciences in the
Iberian Peninsula. CESAM currently integrates 216 PhD researchers and ca. 189 PhD
Description
students, working on the functioning, biodiversity and quality of coastal and marine
ecosystems. Over 1700 papers have been published during the last 5 years in international
indexed journals, half of which were in collaboration with foreign institutions. The
research unit on Governance, Competitiveness and Public Policies (GOVCOPP) integrates
social sciences research developed in UAVR, and develops work on governance and
tourism. In 2013, this unit was assessed as Excellent, being one of the top 6 units in social
sciences in Portugal. GOVCOPP integrates 118 PhD researchers and 59 PhD students,
working on, amongst other topics, economics a tourism in coastal areas.
Dr. Cristina Pita (female), primary responsible researcher in UAVR, is an
interdisciplinary researcher with a PhD in Social and Environmental Sustainability. She is
a researcher in the Department of Environment and Planning (DAO) and CESAM. Dr.
Pita has 18 years’ experience, and has been/is involved in several international and
national projects, on issues of coastal and marine recreation activities, fisheries and marine
protected areas, she has contributed to 35 ISI-indexed publications and book chapters, and
takes part on several committees at the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea
(ICES).
Dr. Ana Lillebo (female) has a PhD in Biology (speciality in Ecology). She is a Principal
Researcher at UAVR and the Scientific Coordinator of CESAM. She has recognised
experience in ecology, biodiversity and ecosystem services of coastal ecosystems, and
contributions to the integrated management of coastal zones taking into account Science-
based knowledge, environmental policies and stakeholders. She has contributed to 90 ISI-
Key Personnel
indexed publications, 25 book chapters and edited 3 books.
Dr. Fátima Lopes Alves (female) has a PhD in Sciences Applied to the Environment.
She is professor in DAO and researcher in CESAM. She has >24 years’ experience in
Integrated Coastal and Marine Planning and Management, Spatial Planning of Protected
Areas, and Strategic Planning. She has been/is involved in national and international
research projects on the topic of ICZM, MSP and Environment and Socioeconomic
Assessment and consultancy for public and private organizations. She has edited 7
books, co-authored 15 book chapters and 28 papers in ISI journals.
Prof. Carlos Costa (male), PhD in Tourism, is the head of Economics and Tourism
Department (DEGEIT), head of the Tourism Research Group in GOVCOPP, and
coordinator of the PhD Tourism Programme of UAVR. He has >25 years’ experience in
Tourism and planning. Since 2008, he is the Scientific Coordinator of the “idtour-unique
solutions” - tourism spin-off company (private sector) from UAVR, responsible for the
transference of knowledge and innovation to the tourism sector. Prof. Costa is involved
in several national and international projects in the areas of tourism planning,
development, innovation and management, and education and research in tourism. He
was responsible for the evaluation of the European Tourism Framework, between 1999-
2000, for the program Tourism and Cultural Heritage.
9
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Relevant Publications/Products/ Rodrigues et al. (inc. Pita & Lillebø). 2017. Marine and Coastal Cultural Ecosystem
Services: knowledge gaps and research priorities. One Ecosystem 2: e12290.
Lillebø et al. (inc. Pita). 2017. How can marine ecosystem services support the Blue
Growth agenda? Marine Policy 81: 132-142.
Fernandes et al. (inc. Alves). 2016. Design Policy Options supported by Marine and
Services
Coastal Ecosystem Services Assessment and Valuation: a Case Study in
Portugal. Journal Of Coastal Research. 977-981.
Sousa et al. (inc. Alves & Lillebø). 2016. Ecosystem services provided by a complex
coastal region: challenges of classification and mapping. Scientific Reports 6.
Lillebø et al. (inc. Alves). 2016. Assessment of Marine Ecosystem Services Indicators:
Experiences and Lessons Learned from 14 European Case Studies. Integrated
Environmental Assessment And Management. 12, 4, 726-734.
SIMNORAT - Supporting Implementation of Maritime Spatial Planning in the Northern
European Atlantic (DG MARE)
Relevant Projects
TPEA: Transboundary Planning in the European Atlantic (DG MARE),
AQUACROSS: Knowledge, Assessment, and Management for Aquatic Biodiversity and
Ecosystem Services across EU policies (H2020),
LAGOONS: Integrated water resources and coastal zone management in European
lagoons in the context of climate change (FP7),
MCES: The economic valuation and governance of marine and coastal ecosystem
services (Gulbenkian Ocean Initiative, Foundation Calouste Gulbenkian)
LTER-RAVE – Ria de Aveiro Long-Term Ecological Research site that is part of the
national LTER network and infrastructure; it is also one of the Virtual Access (VA)
Infrastructure/
Equipment
sites in the H2020 project eLTER.
ECOMARE - Innovation and Sustainability Laboratory of Marine Biological Resources
of UAVR that aims at contributing to preserve and stimulate biodiversity and natural
heritage, and produce, organize and boost knowledge on marine environment;
CESAM - Centre for Environmental and Marine Studies boat and laboratory facilities
10
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Name Scottish Association for Marine Science Partner
number:
7
Country UK Acronym SAMS
SAMS is one of the world’s oldest marine research institutes with extensive expertise in
both deep sea and coastal research. It hosts the Laurence Mee Centre for Society and the
Description
Sea (LMC): a research and innovation centre that brings together social and natural
science to further the understanding of marine and coastal social-ecological systems in
close collaboration with public and private sector partners across a wide range of sectors
such as fisheries, tourism, energy, heritage and nature conservation. SAMS will co-lead
the consortium, lead WP4 (Methods and Tools), develop an online public portal for the
project and lead the Scottish-Irish case region.
Dr Jasper Kenter (male) is Principal Investigator in Ecological Economics with a
specialisation in cultural ecosystem services and participatory methodologies for valuing
and managing ecosystems. He has >30 peer-reviewed publications with >1000 citations.
He recently edited a Special Issue of the journal Ecosystem Services on Shared, Plural
and Cultural Values, lead a UK National Ecosystem Assessment chapter on the same
topic and co-lead the FP7 MERIKA project on marine renewable energy.
Paola Arce (female) is a Computing & Informatics Analyst with experience in GIS
visualization tools and services using technologies such as ArcGIS, QGIS, Geoserver and
PostGIS. She also has experience in developing web-based GIS applications using
Openlayers and Web Map Service (WMS).
Dr Suzannah-Lynn Billing (female) is a postdoctoral research associate in marine social
science focusing on local scale community interactions of different marine resource uses
Key Personnel
and policies, with particular reference to social licence to operate and sustainable rural
development. She is a member of the ICES Working Group for the social and economic
interactions of aquaculture.
Elaine Azzopardi (female) is a maritime archaeologist with experience in marine and
terrestrial cultural heritage. She has an active interest in cultural landscapes and cultural
ecosystem services.
Dr Clive Fox (male) is the Prinicpal Investigator in Fisheries. He has worked extensively
with the local industry on the west coast of Scotland as well as projects covering Europe
and N. America. He has produced over 100 peer reviewed and non-peer reviewed
publications and sits on several national and international fisheries related committees.
Lucy Greenhill (female) is a research fellow in marine policy focusing on the role of
marine spatial planning in enabling adaptive governance to address complex socio-
ecological challenges. She was a steering group member of the EC Ocean Energy Forum
and expert adviser to the Commonwealth Secretariat on the Blue Economy.
Dr Simone Martino (male) is a research fellow in Natural Resource Economics with
experience of coastal management, ICZM, and ecosystem services valuation across a
wide range of habitats (marine and terrestrial).
• Azzopardi & Gambin (2012). Archaeology and the sea in the Maltese Islands.
Products/ Services
Midsea Books.
Publications/
• Azzopardi (2013). The Shipwrecks of Xlendi Bay, Gozo, Malta. The International
Relevant
Journal of Nautical Archaeology 42: 286–295.
• Kenter, 2016. Shared, plural and cultural values. Ecosystem Services 21, 175-183.
• Jobstvogt, Watson, Kenter (2014). Looking below the surface: The cultural
ecosystem services values of marine protected areas. Ecosystem Services 10, 97-
110.
11
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
• Kenter, et al. (2014) Shared, Plural and Cultural Values: A Handbook for Decision-
Makers. UK National Ecosystem Assessment. UNEP-WCMC, Cambridge.
• UK National Ecosystem Assessment Follow-On work packages on Cultural
Ecosystem Services and Shared, Plural and Cultural Values –
Relevant Projects
www.sharedvaluesresearch.org
• Sgeulachdan na Mara / Sea Stories - an online cultural map of the sea -
http://www.mappingthesea.net/barra/
• EU H2020 AquaSpace – Social and cultural interactions of aquaculture
development – http://www.aquaspace-h2020.eu/
• EU EMFF – Scottish Inshore Fisheries Integrated Data System – Assessing the
Socio-economic and Cultural Characteristics of the Scottish Inshore Fishery –
http://www.masts.ac.uk/research/emff-sifids-project/
SAMS hosts an existing server mapping platform that will underpin PERICLES’ public
Infrastructure/
participation CH mapping portal. OpenGeoSuite will provide the Geographic
Equipment
Information system (GIS), which is a complete web-based opensource software stack
containing a GIS database (PostGIS), a Javascript library to display map tiles in a
webpage (Openlayers) and a mapserver for sharing geospatial data (Geoserver). All the
layers will be stored in PostGIS, served via Web Map Service (WMS) and styled using
Openlayers.
12
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Name National Heritage Board of Estonia/ Partner
Muinsuskaitseamet number
ex:8
Country Estonia Acronym MKA
The National Heritage Board of Estonia (MKA) is a governmental authority operating in
the area of government of the Ministry of Culture and representing the state in the
performance of its duties. Its main duty is to organize heritage conservation work. The
mission of MKA is emphasizing the value of cultural heritage, including environments of
cultural value, and ensuring their preservation for future generations.
The MKA is a member of the Monitoring Group on Cultural Heritage in the Baltic Sea
State - http://mg.kpd.lt/, of the working group of the Baltic Sea Region Underwater
Cultural Heritage Protection and of the European Archaeological Council Underwater
Description
Heritage working group. The MKA holds experience with underwater data acquisition by
using non-destructive methods and has placed great emphasis on trying to increase public
awareness of the importance of preserving underwater cultural heritage. The MKA is
directly connected to the relevant national maritime spatial planning processes.
The MKA has been a lead partner in several international projects for example the lead
partner in a Central Baltic INTERREG IVA Programme: Shipwreck Heritage: Digitizing
and Opening Access to Maritime History Sources“, SHIPWHER, 2010-2013. The MKA
has been the lead partner for two seed money projects: 1) Evaluating the Universal Value
of the Submerged Heritage of the Baltic Sea (USHer), 2014-2016 and Collaboration and
Development of new Methods for the Preservation of Underwater Cultural Heritage
(CODEUCH) 2014-2015.
Maili Roio (female) She has acquired a Master’s Degree in the University of Tartu on
the topic of the protection of underwater cultural heritage. She has been working at the
Estonian National Heritage Board since 2004. Her assignment is to organize the
management of underwater cultural heritage, which includes documenting and
monitoring underwater monuments, evaluating the preservation status and conducting
Key Personnel
surveillance. She has coordinated activities in Project Shipwreck Heritage: Digitizing
and Opening Access to Maritime History Sources (SHIPWHER) in 2010-2013; in roject
Evaluating the Universal Value of the Submerged Heritage of the Baltic Sea (USHer)
and Collaboration and Development of new Methods for the Preservation of Underwater
Cultural Heritage (CODEUCH). Starting from 2017 she is coordinating the project
Baltic History Beneath Surface: Underwater Heritage Trails In Situ and Online
(Baltacar).
She has delivered courses in Underwater Archaeology at the University of Tartu and
Tallinn University
13
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Relevant Publications/Products/ Services
1) Roio, Maili; Lõugas, Lembi; Läänelaid, Alar; Maldre, Liina; Russow, Erki; Sillasoo,
Ülle (2016). Medieval ship finds from Kadriorg, Tallinn. Archeological fieldwork in
Estonia, 2015, 139−158.
2) Roio, Maili; Baburin, Andri; Kriiska, Aivar (2016). Archaeological survey in the
northern and north-western parts of Lake Peipsi. Archeological fieldwork in Estonia,
225−234.
3) Roio, Maili (2014). Maritime History Sources: Publishing and Possibilities of Usage.
The Changing Coastal and Maritime Culture. The 5th Baltic Sea Region Cultural
Heritage Forum in Tallinn 18-20 September 2013. Tallinn, 88−91.
4) Roio, Maili (Ed.). 2013. Shipwreck Heritage: Digitizing and Opening Access to
Maritime History Sources. Tallinn.
5) Kriiska, A.; Roio, M. 2011. Prehistoric Archaeology of Wetlands in Estonia. In:
Pranckėnaitė, E. (Ed.). Wetland Settlements of the Baltic. A Prehistoric Perspective
(55−73). Vilnius: Center of Underwater Archaeology.
1) Archaeology, authority & community: cooperation to protect archaeological heritage
(AAC) (http://www.aac-project.eu/), 2012-2014. The main aim of the project was
protection and preservation of archaeological heritage, especially in the project area –
the contacting border regions of Estonia, Latvia and Russia – and developing cross-
border cooperation in this field. The main project activities concentrated upon the
preservation of archaeological heritage, both in the landscape and in collections, and
upon its popularization. An important aim is developing international co-operation and
exchange of experience and information.
2) Shipwreck Heritage: Digitizing and Opening Access to Maritime History Sources,
2010-2013. Shipwrecks represent a part of the international cultural heritage. The history
of one ship is commonly linked to many different countries (e.g. the country where the
ship was built; where the crew was from; by the cargo of the ship; the shipwreck
location etc.). Many shipwrecks have preserved only partially and therefore a thorough
analysis of the records found from different archives play a very important role in
Relevant Projects
identifying the shipwrecks. The archival records and shipwrecks are sources which
complement each other and together form a whole. One aim of the project was to create
an internet-based database which will be linked with the already existing databases of
project partners, making it possible for divers and non-divers alike to obtain an overall
picture of shipwrecks in the Baltic Sea.
3) Baltic History Beneath Surface: Underwater Heritage Trails In Situ and Online
(BALTACAR), 2017-2019. The underwater landscape of the Baltic Sea is a unique
ecological and cultural-historical environment resulting from the combination of a long
seafaring history and good preservation conditions. The remains of shipwrecks in
Estonian, Finnish and Swedish waters, are well preserved and give us an unique
opportunity to take a glimpse into the everyday life that froze sometimes even hundreds
of years ago. In this aspect, the Baltic Sea is a giant underwater museum waiting to be
visited. The project The project aims to demonstrate the huge tourism potential of the
underwater cultural heritage of the Baltic Sea by developing easy and convenient ways
for visiting our unique and well preserved underwater sites in situ.
4) Evaluating the Universal Value of the Submerged Heritage of the Baltic Sea (USHer),
2014-2016. The main aim of the project USHer was to strengthen cooperation when it
comes to raising public awareness of the environment of the Baltic Sea, its unique
underwater cultural heritage and good preservation conditions. We are convinced that
14
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
the submerged cultural heritage of the Baltic Sea is a potential candidate for the World
Heritage List (http://muinas.ee/ush).
5) Collaboration and Development of new Methods for the Preservation of Underwater
Cultural Heritage (CODEUCH). 2014-2015. (http://muinas.ee/codeuch-1)
The objective of the project was to intensify the cooperation between the Baltic Sea
States in order to ensure the preservation of the underwater cultural heritage of the Baltic
Sea. The goal of project CODEUCH was to map the current practice of the Baltic Sea
States regarding the protection of underwater monuments. The emphasis placed on
large-scale cross-border development projects and marine spatial planning.
1) National Registry of Cultural Monuments (Database)
Equipmen
Infrastruc
2) Side Scan Sonar system
ture/
t
3) Remotely Operated Vehicle (ROV).
4) Diving equipment.
15
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Name SYNDICAT MIXTE DE GESTION DU Partner
PARC NATUREL RÉGIONAL DU GOLFE number: 9
DU MORBIHAN (PNR Golfe du Morbihan)
Country FR Acronym PNR GdM
The Syndicat Mixte for the management of the Regional Natural Park of the Gulf of
Morbihan (PNR Golfe du Morbihan) is a grouping of local authorities that have
approved the charter of the Regional Natural Park and that is responsible to administer it.
The members are Brittany Region, Morbihan Department, 29 municipalities and 5 public
institutions for inter-municipal cooperation (EPCI). The PNR was created by ministerial
decree in 2014, after 20 years of cooperation to protect and promote natural and cultural
assets under the leadership of the inter-municipal syndicate for the development of the
Gulf of Morbihan (SIAGM). Objectives and orientations of the Park are set by its
charter. (www.parc-golfe-morbihan.bzh/listes/le-parc-naturel-regional).
The PNR annual’s budget is around 1 300 000 €. The technical team is composed of 16
technicians and engineers.
According to its status, the regulatory tasks of a park are:
• to protect the heritage, in particular through the appropriate management of natural
environments and landscapes;
• to contribute to land use planning;
• to contribute to social, cultural and quality of life economic development;
• to ensure the reception, education and information of the public;
• to carry out experimental or exemplary actions in the fields mentioned above and
Description
contribute to research programs.
PNR will participate in transversal activities that deal with understanding of maritime
and coastal cultural heritage , the production of a Risk Assessment and Sustainable
Exploitation Framework and development of stakeholder networks. It will also lead or
participate in demonstration activities in the Brittany case-study in collaboration with
UBO.
Located on the southern coast of Brittany in France, the Gulf of Morbihan (“small sea”
in breton language) is one of the 41 bays of the club “the most beautiful bays in the
world” (world-bays.com). It is a closed bay with two inhabited islands and numerous
islets. Being one the first touristic destinations on the French Atlantic coast, the Gulf of
Morbihan also enjoys exceptional natural and cultural heritages, including unique
archeological sites and Breton culture intangible heritage, of which many are classified.
The Regional Natural Park covers a total area of 64.200 ha on land and 17.000 ha on sea
for a population of 170.00 inhabitants and 1,5 million visitors every year.
PNR, and before that SIAGM, have worked for more than 20 year in the area of
protecting and promoting cultural heritages, with a particular focus on maritime and
coastal components. Its experience and dynamism will provide bench marking references
for many of the tools to be developed in the project and a unique laboratory for new
developments in the areas of mapping and inventories, risk assessment, education and
awareness raising, promotion through branding and stakeholders involvement.
16
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Monique CASSE (female) is the director of the PNR. She is graduated from the
National School of Agrosup Dijon as agricultural engineer. Thanks to its professional
experience, she has a real expertise in consultation and management of territorial
projects.
Ronan PASCO (male) holds a diploma in advanced studies in maritime economics and
Key Personnel
Politics, obtained in 1999. Responsible for the "sea and coastline" pole of the PNR. Its
fields of competence are professional maritime and leisure activities, coastal
development, Integrated Coastal Zone Management.
Juliette HERRY (female) is an engineer in agronomy, specialised in coastal
management and adaptation to climate change. She participated in European research
projects on climate change adaptation and assessment of ecosystemic services.
Morgane DALLIC (female) holds a diploma in History and criticism of the arts. She is
responsible of the “Culture, heritage, education” pole of the PNR. She works on cultural
and landscape heritage. She coordinates an inventory of the maritime built heritage
around the Gulf of Morbihan
The park is engaged in active collaboration with research institutions as a mean to
support its action and to disseminate its experience. It has more than 15 years of
collaboration records with UMR AMURE of the University of West Brittany in the
Relevant Publications/
fields of building capacity for ICZM (COREPOINT, interreg IIIB NOE,
Products/ Services
http://corepoint.ucc.ie), tools to support local strategies for adaptation to climate change
(IMCORE, interreg IVB NOE, www.imcore.eu), assessment of marine ecosystem
services (VALMER, Interreg IVA Channel, www.valmer.eu). UBO and PNR have
signed, together with the University of South Brittany (UBS), a partnership agreement to
cooperate in the areas of research, training and expertise. Many researchers at UBO,
including UMR AMURE, are member of the scientific council of the park. The
following present activities of the park are relevant to the project: inventories of cultural
coastal and maritime heritages, landscape observatory, CACTUS a participatory tool for
assessment of coastal risks and adaptation strategies, "Regional Natural Park Values"
branding of companies and activities, “School of the Park”, collection of maritime songs
Briandet C., 2003, Landscape diagnosis of the Gulf of Morbihan Regional Nature Park
project. Project of Gulf of Morbihan Regional Natural Park
Relevant Projects
Pasco R. et Herry J., 2012. Diagnosis of the shellfish farming activity in the Gulf of
Morbihan. Project of Gulf of Morbihan Regional Natural Park.
Herry J et Pasco R., 2014, Diagnosis of the professional fishery embarked in the Gulf of
Morbihan. Project of Natural Regional Park of the Gulf of Morbihan.
Lacombe C., 2015, Inventory sheet Intangible Cultural Heritage: the professional clam
fishery. Regional Natural Park of the Gulf of Morbihan.
Danto A ., 2016, Inventory sheet Intangible Cultural Heritage: professional cuttlefish
fishery. Gulf of Morbihan Regional Natural Park
Infra
N.A.
struc
ture/
Equi
pme
nt
17
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Review Hellenic Fisheries Research Institute Partner
Name number
10
Country Greece Acronym F.R.I.
HAO Fisheries Research Institute (F.R.I.) is one of the five specialized research institutes
of N.AG.RE.F, being responsible to conduct research and to promote technological
development in the fishery sector in Greece. The Institute is located at the centre of a
marine area with rich fishery grounds and high biodiversity in the surrounding lagoons,
lakes and rivers. The research activities of F.R.I. cover a wide range of fields in the marine
Description
and coastal research and applications sector. F.R.I. participates in many research
programmes (European Community and National programmes), which consist the main
funding source for its research activities. It co-ordinates the Greek National Fisheries Data
Collection Programme that collects all data on and monitors professional and articinal
fisheries, fish farming, processing industry and the socio-economic variables of fisheries.
F.R.I. is particularly suitable host for the proposed program because of its previous
research on areas relevant to coastal heritage (e.g. MESFIDE, COASTAL) and its strong
contacts with both the fishing communities and local and national stakeholders that it
developed since its establishment in 1993.
Dr. Manos Koutrakis (male) is a Senior researcher at the Fisheries Research Institute
of the Hellenic Agricultural Research Foundation since April 1996. Currently he is head
of the Laboratory of Inland Waters of the Fisheries Research Institute of Kavala. In the
last 25 years he is working in the fields of management of lagoons and wetlands,
Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM) and ecohydrology. He is author of more
than 300 publications (papers, books, conference proceedings, etc), 50 of which in
journals included in the Science Citation Index, reviewer in several international peer
reviewed scientific journals and member of the Editorial Committee of the Transitional
Waters Bulletin (Italy). He was coordinator of several EU and national research
projects, such as the Strymonikos Project, an EU Demonstration Programme on ICZM
and the Beachmed-ICZM-MED for the Mediterranean and he participated as an expert
in many research projects review committees (European Commission DG XI, DG XII).
Since 2005 he was invited to participate in the UNESCO/UNDP Ecohydrology task
Key Personnel
force that promotes ecohydrology as a new tool for sustainable management of river
catchments and coastal areas. Since 2009 he is also member of the EIFAC Working
Party on Fish Passage Best Practices (FAO). He is also expert of the Scientific,
Technical and Economic Committee for Fisheries of the European Commission, and
since 2002 member of the sub group for the research needs evaluating member states’
national projects regarding data collection (STECF-SGRN). Currently he is Scientific
Responsible for the National Programme for the Collection of Fisheries Data (2017-
2019), of the Ministry of Rural Development and Food, in order to implement the Data
Collection Framework (DCF & EU MAP) in the frame of the Common Fisheries Policy
(CFP). Moreover he works on developing indicators of surface water quality (inland and
transitional waters), being member of the Mediterranean Geographical Intercalibration
Group (MED GIG) for the implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive (WFD
2000/60). The main fields of research interest are the fisheries biology, fish fauna, fish
assemblages, ecohydrology, management of lagoons and wetlands, interaction of
cetaceans with fisheries, Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM).
Dr. Dimitra Mylona (female) is a researcher at the Institute for Aegean Prehistory,
Study Center for East Crete (INSTAP). She has a PhD in archaeology and her research
18
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
focuses on ancient fisheries and on social, economic and ideological aspects of fishing
communities of the past. She specializes in the analysis of archaeological fish bones and
marine mollusks. Her work has a very broad chronological scope (Mesolithic to
Byzantine), a wide geographical spread in Eastern Mediterranean and a particular
emphasis on inter-disciplinarity and on the use of non quantifiable historical data in
fisheries research and conservation. She has participated in a number of international
and European research bodies and projects on the above topics. She has participated in
EU funded research programs and actions that focused on fishing tourism, sustainability
of marine resources and the value of marine resources to European communities of the
past. Also, she worked on the marine aspects in a large number of archaeological
projects in Greece and abroad. She authored one book and published 49 peer-reviewed
papers and book chapters. She participated in over 30 international conferences and
workshops. She currently co-organizes an international conference on Fish Processing
in Ancient Mediterranean, Oxford, 6-9 September 2017.
Prof. Aristidis (Aris) Tsantiropoulos (male) is an Assistant Professor at the University
of Crete, Department of Philosophy and Social Sciences. He has a PhD in Social
Anthropology. Additionally, he is a professional photographer and uses the photography
as an ethnographic research tool. His research interests focus on economic and social
transformations of small communities, on social (or collective) memory, and on social
conflicts (blood feud) and conflict resolution. He teaches, among others, Greek
ethnography, material culture, discourse analysis. He is working closely with local
communities and various institutions on topics of his expertise. He has conducted
extended fieldwork on mountainous Crete on aspects of social transformation of pastoral
societies on mountainous Crete, and also on the insular communities of the small Greek
Island of Gavdos. He has presented his work in 17 conferences and has given a large
number of lectures to academic and wider audiences. He has authored two books, 18
peer-reviewed papers and book chapters and a number of articles in public media. He
participates in a number of national and international research programs.
Dr. Argyrios Sapounidis (Male) is an Assistant researcher at the Fisheries Research
Institute (FRI) of the Hellenic Agricultural Research Foundation since the early of 2017,
but worked as a Scientific collaborator at FRI for the past 12 years. His main field of
expertise is the study of the species ecology, the implementation of the WFD
2000/60/EC, the Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM) and the study of the
coastal lagoon’s fish fauna. He participated in 24 research projects and studies, in the
preparation of the proposals submitted and then in the organization and conduct of
sampling, processing data and writing technical reports. His published work consists of
64 publications (papers, books, conference proceedings, etc), 12 of which in
international SCI journals. He completed his Doctorate Thesis, which was co-funded by
the European Union - European Social Fund (ESF) & National Sources, in the
framework of the program “HRAKLEITOS II” of the “Operational Program Education
and Life Long Learning” of the Hellenic Ministry of Education, Life Long Learning and
Religious Affairs, in 2014, on the “Morphological and genetic analysis of River Nestos’
fish fauna species”.
Since 2012, he is also expert of the Joint EIFAAC/ICES/GFCM Working Group on Eels.
Dr. Chrysoula Gubili (female) has a Ph.D. in Molecular Biology and is a Researcher at
the Fisheries Marine Institute (F.R.I.) specialising in evolutionary biology and
conservation. Dr. Gubili is using genetics as a tool to study the ecology, evolution and
behaviour of diverse species, from benthic fauna to large predators. She has been involved
as primary researcher and collaborator in several international projects and has authored
15 publications in ISI journals and one book chapter.
19
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
1. KOUTRAKIS E.T., MACHINO Y., MYLONA D. & C. PERDIKARIS, 2009.
Crayfish terminology in ancient Greek, Latin and related languages. Crustaceana, 82
Relevant Publications/Products/ Services (12), 1535-1546.
2. KOUTRAKIS E.T., 2011. Fisheries in the lagoons of northern Greece: cultural aspects
and indicators of biological integrity. In: Culture & wetlands in the Mediterranean:
an evolving story, Th. Papayannis & D. Pritchard (eds), Med-INA-Mediterranean
Institute for Nature and Anthropos, 161-171.
3. MYLONA, D., 2008. Eating Fish in Greece from 500 BC to AD 700. A story of
impoverished fishermen or lavish fish banquets?”. BAR International Series 1754,
Archaeopress, Oxford.
4. MYLONA D., 2016. Fish and seafood consumption in the Aegean: variations on a
theme. In The Inland Seas: towards an ecohistory of the Mediterranean, T. Bekker-
Nielsen & R. Gertwagen (eds), Franz Steiner Publishers, Stuttkard, 57-84.
5. FONTAINE M.C., SNIRC A., FRANTZIS A., KOUTRAKIS E., BIRKUN A. JR., ÖZTURK B.,
ÖZTURK A.A., AUSTERLITZ F., 2012. A history of expansion and anthropogenic
collapse in a top marine predator of the Black Sea estimated from genetic data. PNAS-
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.
Published online September 4, 2012, E2569–E2576,
www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1201258109.
1. COASTLEARN: Development of transnational networks (FRI Coordinator).
Participants: European Union for Coastal Conservation (NL, Coordinator) NAGREF-
FRI (GR), Southampton Institute (UK), Arhipelaag (EE), University of Klapeida (LT),
University of Latvia (LV) IHE Delft (NL), RIKZ- Coastal Zone Management Centre
(NL), EUCC Poland (PL), University of Szczecin (PL) Institute for Integral
Development and Environment (SI), National Institute for Marine Research and
Development (RO). Funding: E.C., DG V, Leonardo da Vinci. (2003-2005).
2. BEACHMED-ICZM-MED: Concerted actions, tools and criteria for the integrated
coastal zone management of the Mediterranean (Koutrakis -Scientific responsible).
NAGREF-FRI, CIRSA (ΙΤ), Litorale SPA (ΙΤ), Dip. Di Ecologia e Sviluppo
Economico Sostenibile UniTuscia (ΙΤ), Università degli Studi di Genova–
DIP.TER.IS. (ΙΤ), ICCOPS – Landscape Natural and Cultural Heritage (ΙΤ),
Relevant Projects
Université de Montpellier 1 CEP/LASER (FR), BRL (FR). Funding: EE, INTERREG
IIIC – Sud (2006-2008).
3. MARE NOSTRUM: Bridging the implementation gap: Facilitating cross-border
ICZM implementation by lowering legal-institutional barriers in the MSB. Funding:
ENPI-CBCMED: Cross-Border Cooperation within the European Neighborhood and
Partnership Instrument (ENPI), Mediterranean Sea Basin Joint Operational
Programme, EC Decision C (2008) 4242. Priority 1 - Topic 3 - Integrated Coastal
Zone Management (2013-2016).
4. EU MAP-National Working Plan: National Programme for the Data Collection on
Fisheries (2017-2019). HEO, FRI, HCMR, Agricultural Economics Research Institute
(Koutrakis - Scientific responsible). Funding: ΕU & Ministry of Rural Development
and Food (2017-2019).
5. OPP – Oceans Past Platform. Action aiming to measure and understand the
significance and value to European societies past and present, of living marine
resource extraction and production to help shape the future of coasts and oceans by
promoting the merging of human, social and natural sciences and integrating
historical findings of scale and intensity of resource use into management and policy
frameworks. (Mylona: National Representative). Funding: EU (COST).
20
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Infrastructure/ The Fisheries Research Institute has all the necessary field equipment in order to
Equipment conduct samplings in lagoons and lab equipment for the study of fish biology.
Moreover, Fisheries Research Institute has facilities for organizing meetings, an
amphitheatre and student accommodations. Also it hosts the national Data Collection
on Fisheries database.
21
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
4.2. Third parties involved in the project (including use of third party resources)
Does the participant plan to subcontract certain tasks (please note
that core
tasks of the project should not be sub-contracted)
Y
Subcontracts are made for additional support in the following 3 specific tasks:
SAMS (7) for an artist in residence (to be procured) who will be supporting art-science
collaborations and will develop the design of the mapping portal, and for a market research
company (to be procured) who will be gathering choice experiment interview data for Demo
SI3; and, FRI (10), will sub-contract an anthropologist (Dr. Aris Tsantiropoulos) from
the University of Crete, due to his expertise and experience in working with oral history
and on social conflicts in situations of transition from “tradition” to modernity; also for his
skills as a professional photographer. He will design and conduct the interviews and the visual
documentation in our case study. Such specialties are not available at F.R.I.
Does the participant envisage that part of its work is performed by
linked third parties
N
If yes, please describe the third party, the link of the participant to the third party, and
describe and justify the foreseen tasks to be performed by the third party
Does the participant envisage the use of contributions in kind
provided by
third parties (Articles 11 and 12 of the General Model Grant N
Agreement)
If yes, please describe the third party and their contributions
22
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
5. Ethics and Security
5.1 Ethics
The PERICLES project will not raise ethical concerns related to human embryos, human cells,
environmental health, dual use, potential misuse or other ethics issues.
Data collection and communication with stakeholders and research teams outside the consortium will be
conducted according to the most rigorous ethical standards and principles related to data collection and
data storage involving the informants. Any data related with human subjects raised during the socio-
economic analysis or stakeholder interactions will be processed in order to ensure data quality and to
fulfil the relevant EU requirements related with data protection (EU Directive 95/46/EC). PERICLES
will also adopt rigorous procedures for the processing of any sensible data eventually collected and
stored during the project, complying with the legislation in force during the project at levels spanning
from national to EU standards, including those related with the protection of animals used for scientific
purposes (EU Directive 2010/63/EU), the processing of personal data and the protection of privacy in the
electronic communications sector (EU Directive 2002/58/EC), and retention of data generated or
processed in connection with the provision of publicly available electronic communications services or
of public communications networks (EU Directive 2006/24/EC).
In terms of data retention, it is worth noting that for reaching the overall goal of supporting sustainable
CH governance through a participatory framework by evaluating existing governance practices and
including cultural, environmental, spatial and broader societal aspects, sociocultural and some minimal
quantitative social and economic data will be collected either from the literature (respecting the use and
duly citing of the data sources) or from individuals with the ability to give an informed consent,
complying with the EU relevant guidelines (EU Directive 95/46/EC; EU Directive 2010/63/EU).
Informed participants to the collection of data will be free to withdraw their consent at any time. Any
information containing or linkable to personal data will be maintained both in paper and electronic
records at an appropriate level of security and electronic encryption, compliant with European and data
security regulations of the country hosting the documents and thereafter destroyed, after the appropriate
holding period.
Wherever not impairing the open accessibility to the project outcomes from the public, as foreseen and
detailed in the description of PERICLES dissemination and exploitation of results (2.2a; Technical Annex
1-3), PERICLES partners will respect the confidentiality of the data.
5.2 Security
PERICLES will not involve activities or results raising security issues, nor “EU-classified information”
either as background or results.
23
This proposal version was submitted by Alyne Elizabeth DELANEY on 13/09/2017 16:54:03 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Participant Portal Submission Service.
Digitally signed by sealingservice.grants.ec.europa.eu
Date: 2017.09.13 19:34:14 CEST
Reason: Acknowledgment of Receipt
This electronic receipt is a digitally signed version of the document submitted by your
organisation. Both the content of the document and a set of metadata have been digitally
sealed.
This digital signature mechanism, using a public-private key pair mechanism, uniquely
binds this eReceipt to the modules of the Participant Portal of the European
Commission, to the transaction for which it was generated and ensures its full integrity.
Therefore a complete digitally signed trail of the transaction is available both for your
organisation and for the issuer of the eReceipt.
Any attempt to modify the content will lead to a break of the integrity of the electronic
signature, which can be verified at any time by clicking on the eReceipt validation
symbol.
More info about eReceipts can be found in the FAQ page of the Participant Portal.
(http://ec.europa.eu/research/participants/portal/page/faq)
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
MUINSUSKAITSEAMET
KESKLINNA LINNAOSA PIKK TN 2
TALLINN
10123 HARJUMAA
VÄLJAVÕTE
PÕLLUMAJANDUSE REGISTRITE JA INFORMATSIOONI AMET
PEADIREKTORI
OTSUS
Tartu 20. detsember 2017 nr 17-6/525
Euroopa Merendus- ja Kalandusfondi
rakenduskava 2014 - 2020 meetme 8.3
"Merekeskkonna alaste teadmiste parendamise
toetus" raames antava toetuse taotluste
rahuldamine
Võttes aluseks kalandusturu korraldamise seaduse § 30 lg 5 ja maaeluministri 27.06.2017 määruse nr 49 "Merekeskkonna alaste teadmiste parendamise toetus" §
10 lg 1, amet otsustab:
1.. määrata toetus kogusummas 1 556 286,00 eurot vastavalt otsuse lisale 1.
Toetuse saaja kohustused:
2.. Toetust makstakse üksnes nende abikõlblike kulude hüvitamiseks, mis on tehtud meetme määruse § 4 lõikes 1 ja 2 nimetatud tegevuskavas toodud tegevuste
elluviimiseks ja tegevuskavas asjakohase tegevuse rahastamiseks ettenähtud vahendite ulatuses ning kulud peavad olema mõistlikud ja vastavuses heade
finantsjuhtimise põhimõtetega, eelkõige ökonoomsuse ja tasuvuse põhimõttega.
3.. Toetuse saaja peab tagama toetuse väljamaksmise aluseks olevate dokumentide nõuetekohasuse ja kulude abikõlblikkuse.
4.. Toetust makstakse üksnes siis, kui toetuse saaja on tegevuse elluviimisel järginud kõiki asjakohaseid nõudeid, sealhulgas toetuse kasutamise kavas ettenähtud
nõudeid.
5.. Töö ja teenus, mille kulude hüvitamiseks taotletakse toetuse maksmist, peavad olema lõpetatud ning toetuse saaja peab olema need vastu võtnud ja nende eest
tasunud.
6.. Toetuse saaja on kohustatud kasutama toetust sihtotstarbeliselt ja mõistlikult ning kõige säästlikumal viisil, järgides toetatava tegevuse elluviimisel
kalandusturu korraldamise seaduses, meetme määruses ja toetuse kasutamise kavas sätestatud asjakohaseid nõudeid.
7.. Toetuse saaja on kohustatud täitma Euroopa Parlamendi ja nõukogu määruse (EL) nr 508/2014 artikli 10 lõigetes 1 ja 2 sätestatud nõudeid.
8.. Toetuse saaja peab taotlema toetuse kasutamise tingimuste muutmiseks taotluse rahuldamise otsuse muutmist ja jätkama toetuse kasutamist seniste tingimuste
kohaselt kuni taotluse rahuldamise otsuse muutmiseni.
9.. Toetuse saaja peab selgelt eristama oma raamatupidamises toetuse kasutamisega seotud kulud ning neid kajastavad kulu- ja maksedokumendid muudest kulu-
ja maksedokumentidest.
10.. Toetuse saaja peab järgima tegevusega seotud hangete tegemisel riigihangete seaduses sätestatud nõudeid, kui toetuse saaja on hankija riigihangete seaduse
tähenduses, või meetme tingimustes sätestatud nõudeid, kui toetuse saajale ei kohaldata riigihangete seaduses sätestatud nõudeid.
11.. Toetuse saaja peab esitama hiljemalt koos viimase maksetaotlusega PRIA-le lõpparuande, mis sisaldab peamiste tegevuste ülevaadet ning teavet tegevuse
eesmärgi ja tulemuste saavutamise kohta.
12.. Kui toetatav tegevus ei ole täielikult ellu viidud, peab toetuse saaja esitama iga 9 kuu tagant PRIA-le vahearuande, milles sisalduvad järgmised andmed:
elluviidud tegevuste ülevaade, hinnang toetatava tegevuse eesmärgi ja tulemuste saavutamise kohta.
13.. Toetuse saaja peab esimese vahearuande esitama üheksa kuu möödumisel arvates toetuse taotluse rahuldamise otsuse saamisest.
14.. Toetuse saaja peab võimaldama teostada auditit, järelevalvet ja muid toetuse saamisega seotud kontrolle ning osutama selleks igakülgset abi, sealhulgas
võimaldama viibida toetuse saaja kinnisasjal, ehitises ja ruumis ning läbi vaadata dokumente ja vara kohapeal.
15.. Toetuse saaja peab esitama auditi, järelevalve või muu kontrolli tegemiseks vajalikud andmed ja dokumendid määratud tähtaja jooksul, mis peab olema
vähemalt kolm tööpäeva.
16.. Toetuse saaja peab näitama, et tegemist on fondi toetuse abil elluviidava tegevusega, kasutades selleks ettenähtud sümboleid ja teavitustegevusi vastavalt
maaeluministri 14.04.2016 määrusele nr 22.
17.. Toetuse saaja peab teavitama taotluse rahuldamise otsuse teinud asutust taotluses esitatud või tegevusega seotud andmete muutumisest või tegevuse
elluviimist takistavast asjaolust, sealhulgas pankrotimenetlusest, likvideerimismenetlusest, tegevuse odavnemisest või kallinemisest ning tegevusega seotud vara
üleandmisest teisele isikule või asutusele.
18.. Vastavalt kalandusturu korraldamise seaduse § 34 lõikele 2 on toetuse saaja kohustus säilitada kulu abikõlblikkust tõendavaid dokumente ja muid tõendeid
neli aastat alates selle aasta 31. detsembrist, millal 30. juuni seisuga on kõikide projektis abikõlblikuks loetud kulude alusel toetus välja makstud ja tagama
dokumentide kättesaadavuse järelevalvet teostavale isikule investeeringuobjekti sihtotstarbelise kasutamise tähtaja jooksul. Dokumentide säilitamise tähtaja
algusest ja lõpust teavitab PRIA toetuse saajat pärast viimase toetuseosa maksmist oma veebilehel tabelis EMKF toetuse saajad. Toetuse väljamaksmise otsustega
on võimalik tutvuda veebikeskkonnas e-PRIA.
19.. Toetatav tegevus peab olema ellu viidud kalandusturu korraldamise seaduse § 31 lõike 3 punktis 1 ettenähtud tähtaja jooksul.
Euroopa Merendus- ja Kalandusfondi rakenduskava 2014 - 2020 meetme 8.3 "Merekeskkonna alaste teadmiste parendamise toetus" raames antava toetuse
taotluste rahuldamine
Jrk nr Taotleja nimi Taotleja ID Viitenumber Tegevused Abikõlbulik Toetuse sh EU sh EE
maksumus summa toetuse toetuse
summa summa
4 MUINSUSKAITSEAMET 615298 883017780001 Keskkonnaohtlike vrakkide kaardistamine, 300000.00 300000.00 225000.00 75000.00
dokumenteerimine ja riskide hindamine
Käesolevat otsust on võimalik vaidlustada KTKS § 35 sätestatud korras, st enne halduskohtule kaebuse esitamist tuleb läbida vaidemenetlus haldusmenetluse
seaduses sätestatud tingimustel ja korras 30 päeva jooksul otsusest teada saamise päevast arvates vaide esitamisega PRIA-le aadressil Tähe 4, 51010 Tartu või e-
posti aadressil pria[at]pria.ee.
Jaanus Hämmal VÄLJAVÕTE ÕIGE
12458588
Aile Mäe;
[email protected]; 737 1356
„Merekeskkonna alaste teadmiste parendamise toetus“ TOETUSE TAOTLUSE NÄIDISVORM 1. Andmed taotleja kohta Taotleja nimi Muinsuskaitseamet Esindaja ees- ja perekonnanimi, ametikoht Siim Raie, peadirektor Aadress Maakond Harju maakond Vald/linn Tallinn Alevik/küla Pikk 2 Postiindeks 10123 Telefon +372 640 3 05 0 e-post
[email protected] Taotluse menetlemise ajaks määratud kontaktisik (ees- ja perekonnanimi, ametikoht, postiaadress, telefon, e-post) M aili Roio, veealuse pärandi vaneminspektor, Pikk 2, 10123 Tallinn, +372 5572041,
[email protected] 2. Tegevuse kohta esitatavad andmed Eesmärk E esmär giks on välja selgitada keskkonnaohtlik ud vrak id Eesti vetes , mis on uppunud 20. sajandil. Tegevuse nimetus Keskkonnaohtlike vrakkide kaardistamine, dokumenteerimine ja riskide hindamine . Tegevuse elluviimise aeg 1.11.2017-31.12.2019. Selgitus, kuidas aitab tegevus kaasa Eesti merestrateegia meetmekavas nimetatud meetme elluviimisele. Tegevus aitab kaasa Eesti merestrateegia meet mekavas nimetatud meetme te 11 ( Merereostustõrje võimekuse tõhustamine hädaolukordadele ja keskkonnareostusele reageerimiseks merel ) (HKS tunnus D8b) ja 13 ( Sadamates mereprügi, sh hüljatud kalapüügivahendite, vastuvõtmise korraldamise analüüs ja tegevuskava väljatöötamine ) eesmärkide täitmisele. Keskkonnaohtlike vrakkide kaardistamine arhiiviuuringute ja välitööde käigus annab teadmise 20. sajandil uppunud sõidukite kohta, mis võivad täna kujutada keskkonnaohtu (kütus, lõhkekehad ja kummitusvõrgud) . Kogutud andmete põhjal koostatud riskianalüüs on aluseks edaspidiste tegevuste planeerimisel . Tegevuse üksikasjalik kirjeldus Eesti vetes 20. sajandil, sh I ja II maailmasõja käigus uppunud vrakid võivad kujutada endast keskkonnariski kolmes aspektis: 1 ) Kütuse olemasolu , vrakkide aastatega lagunev ad kere d võivad põhjustada lekkeid ja sellega ohustada merekeskkonda , sh hävitada kalavarusid. 2 ) Lõhkeainete olemasolu , I ja II maailmasõja vrakkide juures leidub lõhkekehasid, samaaegselt on tegemist ajalooliste vrakkidega, mille vastu on suur avalik huvi. Lõhkekehad kujutavad endast k eskkonnaohtu ja otsest ohtu inimestele, kes sukelduvad vrakkidele või teostavad tr aalpüüki. 3 ) Kummitusvõrkude olemasolu . Kalurite poolt kaotatud nn kummitusvõrgud kahjustavad merekeskkonda ja kalavarusid kujutades endast üha suurenevat mereprügi . Vrakid on olulised kalade elupaigad ja seetõttu satuvad v rakkide külge takerdunud võrkudesse veel aastaid hiljem erinevad kalaliigid ja mereimetajad. Veeteede Amet haldab hüdrograafia infosüsteemi, kuhu on seniste hüdrograafiliste mõõdistuste tulemusena kantud üle 400 laevavraki. Neist umbes 230 on vrakid, mis on identifitseerimata. Hinnanguliselt võib Eesti vetes o lla säilinud üle 1000 vraki. Ülevaade 20. sajandil uppunud sõidukite kohta seni puudub ja seetõttu ei ole võimalik hinnata ka võimalikku keskkonnaohtu. Muinsuskaitseamet haldab kultuurimälestiste riiklikku registrit, kus leidub ligikaudu 30 veealust mälestist, mis pärinevad 20. sajandist. Tegevus koosneb järgmistest osadest: 1) arhiivi- ja kirjalike materjalide uuring eesmärgiga koostada nimekiri 20. sajandil uppunud aluste kohta ja hinnata võimalikke kütuse-ja lõhkeainete koguseid vrakkidel, sh määrata hukukohad ning last ja hinnata uppumisasjaolude tagajärjel tekkinud vigastusi. Selgitada selle põhjal välja võimalikud keskkonnaohtlikud vrakid. 2) Välitööd vrakkide dokumenteerimiseks. Koosneb sonariuuringutest ja 3D videodokumentatsioonist. V õimaliku k eskkonnaoh uga vrakkide dokumenteerimine eesmärgiga saada ülevaade tegelikust seisukorra st. Sonariuuringud annavad ülevaate leiukohast laiemalt , sh eraldunud detailide paiknemisest . 3D video dokumentatsioon annab infor matsiooni nii vraki purustustest, mille põhjal saab hinnata lekete võimalikkust, nähtavatest lõhkeainetest kui ka kummitus võrkudest . 3) Riskide hindamine . Sisaldab ülevaadet 20. sajandi vrakkide keskkonnaohust, infot iga vraki ohutaseme, kultuuriväärtuse ja edasiste tegevuste kohta. Riskide hindamisel kaasatakse erinevate valdkondade eksperte. Oodatav tulemus, sh praktili se väärtuse kirjeldus Projekti tulemusena on välja selgitatud konkreetsete vrakkide ohutase ja koostatud riskianalüüs 20. sajandil uppunud aluste kohta . Vrakkide ohutaseme hindamisel võetakse aluseks HELCOM-i riskiklassifikaator. Vrakkide kaardistamine ja riskianalüüs omavad praktilist väärtust järgnevatel riigiasutustele: 1) Keskkonnaministeerium – vrakkide keskkonnaohu välja selgitamine. 2) Politsei- ja Piirivalveamet – keskkonnaohtlike vrakkide nimekirja saab PPA lisada oma seireprogrammi ja teostada neile regulaarseid kontrollreide tõstes sellega valmisolekut reageerimiseks. 3) Merevägi – saab ülevaate lõhkekehad e kohta ja planeerida edasisi vajalikke tegevusi nende kahjutuks tegemiseks. 4) Muinsuskaitseamet – saab kogutud materjalide põhjal menetleda kultuuriväärtusega vrakkide, sh merehaudade kaitse alla võtmist. Eesti vetes asuvate vrakkidega on seotud erinevate riigiasutuste huvid ja kohustused , mis on planeeritud tegevusega esindatud, sh parendades merekeskkonnaalaseid teadmisi ja riigiasutuste omavahelist koostööd keskkonnaohtlike vrakkidega seotud küsimuste lahendamisel. Tegevuse elluviimise etapid kuude ja aastate arvestuses 1.11.2017 – 30.06.2018 arhiivi- ja kirjalike materjalide uuring 20. s ajandil uppunud vrakkide kohta. 1.02.2018 -30.10.2019 sonari uuringud ja 3D video dokumentatsioon võimalikest keskkonnaohuga vrakkidest. 1.05.2019 - 31.12.2019 riskianalüüs . Selgitus, kuidas kasutatakse tegevuse raames soetatud põhivara pärast toetatava tegevuse elluviimist T egevuse elluviimise käigus ei soetata põhivara . 3. Tegevuse kavandatav eelarve (üksikasjalik, selgelt kirjeldatud ning põhjendatud) Tegevuse eelarve 300 000 EUR. 30 000 EUR - arhiivi- ja kirjalike materjalide uuring 20. sajandil uppunud vrakkide kohta. Arhiiviuuringud sis aldavad ka töid välisarhiivides (ennekõike Venemaal ja Saksamaal), milleks kaasatakse väliseksperte. Uuring on vajalik, et saada teada palju on Eesti v etes 20. sajandil uppunud veesõidukeid, millel oli p ardal kütus ja/ või lõhkeained. Kalkulatsiooni aluseks on võetud Muinsuskaitseameti senised kogemused ekspertide teenuste kasutamisel erinevate projektide käigus, sh on arvestatud saksa eksperdi teenus 15 000 EUR (3 kuu töö koos erinevate arhiivide külastustega) ja vene eksperdi teenus 7000 EUR (4 kuu töö koos arhiivide külastamisega), eesti eksperdi teenus 8000 EUR (4 kuu töö koos arhiivide külastamisega). 250 000 EUR – välitööd, 3D dokumentatsioon võimalikest keskkonnaohuga vrakkidest . 3D dokumentatsioon annab ülevaate vraki leiukohast sh infot vraki seisukorrast, lõhkeainetest ja kummitusvõrkudest. Uuring on vajalik, et hinnata tegelikku olukorda ja keskkonnaohtu. Tööde teostaja selgitatakse välja riigihanke käigus, mis on planeeritud välja kuulutada novembris 2017. Riigihanke tulemustest sõltuvalt koostatakse sonariuuring ja 3D video dokumentatsioon hinnanguliselt 20 – 30 vraki kohta. Dokumenteeritavate võimaliku keskkonnaohuga vrakkide nimekiri koostatakse koostöös Keskkonnaministeeriumi ja Politsei-ja Piirivalveametiga. Andmete järeltöötlust (3D mudelite loomist) teostab Mui nsuskaitseamet oma vahenditest. 20 000 EUR – riskianalüüs. Riskianalüüsis kasutatakse arhiiviuuringute ja välitööde tulemusi. On vajalik keskkonnaohu määratlemiseks ja e dasiste tegevuste planeerimisel sisaldades ka edasist seireprogrammi. Riskianalüüsi koostamisel tuleb kaasata erinevate valdkondade eksperte. Kinnitus: kinnitan, et täidesaatva riigivõimu asutus järgib Euroopa Parlamendi ja nõukogu määruse (EL) nr 508/2014 artikli 10 lõike 1 punktides c ja d nimetatud nõudeid ega ole pannud toime sama artikli lõikes 3 nimetatud pettust. Taotluse esitamise kuupäev 08.09.2017 Taotluse esitaja allkiri Siim Raie /allkirjastatud digitaalselt/
Kultuuriministeerium
Suur-Karja 23
15076 Tallinn Kuupäev digiallkirjas nr 1.1-8/489
Sildfinantseerimisvahendite taotlus
Muinsuskaitseamet palub sildfinantseerimisvahendite toetust INTERREG Kesk-Läänemere
programmi projektile "Baltic History Beneath Surface: Underwater Heritage Trails In Situ and
Online" (BALTACAR), EL teadusuuringute ja innovatsiooni raamprogrammi HORISONT
2020 projektile PrEseRvIng and sustainably governing Cultural heritage and Landscapes in
European coastal and maritime regionS (PERICLES, projekti kestvus mai 2018 – aprill 2021)
ning Euroopa Merendus- ja Kalandusfondi rakenduskava 2014 - 2020 meetme 8.3
"Merekeskkonna alaste teadmiste parendamise toetus" projektile „Keskkonnaohtlike vrakkide
kaardistamine, dokumenteerimine ja riskide hindamine“ (Keskkonnaohtlikud vrakid, projekti
kestvus 01.2018-31.12.2019).
Muinsuskaitseamet kui juhtpartner taotleb projekti BALTACAR raames sildfinantseerimist
summas 304 490 eurot, mille otstarve on partnerite kinnitatud kulude korrektne eristamine
SAP-is. Välistoetuse 2018. aasta vahendite eeldatav laekumise tähtaeg II poolaasta.
Aruandlusperiood on 6 kuud.
Muinsuskaitseamet taotleb projekti PERICLES 2018. aasta kulude katteks sildfinantseerimist
30 000 eurot. Välistoetuse 2018. aasta vahendite eeldatav laekumise tähtaeg on 2019. aasta II
poolaasta.
Muinsuskaitseamet taotleb projekti Keskkonnaohtlikud vrakid 2018. aasta kulude katteks
sildfinantseerimist 160 000 eurot. Välistoetuse 2018. aasta vahendite eeldatav laekumise
tähtaeg on 2019. aasta II poolaasta.
Lugupidamisega
/allkirjastatud digitaalselt/
Siim Raie
Peadirektor
Pikk 2 / 10123 Tallinn / + 372 640 3050 /
[email protected] / www.muinsuskaitseamet.ee
Registrikood 70000958
Rahandusministeerium 28.02.2018 nr 6-2/535-1
[email protected]
Välisabi sildfinantseerimise taotlus
Kultuuriministeerium taotleb sildfinantseerimist Muinsuskaitseameti projektidele 2018.
aastaks planeeritud kulude katteks.
INTERREG Kesk-Läänemere programmist rahastatud projektile „Baltic History Beneath
Surface: Underwater Heritage Trails In Situ and Online" taotleme 2018. aastaks
sildfinantseeringut summas 304 490 eurot Muinsuskaitseameti kui projekti juhtpartneri poolt
teistele partneritele edasikantava toetuse eristamiseks SAPis. Projekti arvestuse kood SAPis
on 9M20-BALTACAR. Toetus kantakse projekti partneritele edasi alles pärast selle
laekumist välisabi andjalt. Sildfinantseeringu arvelt projekti partneritele toetuse väljamakseid
ei tehta. Taotletud välisabi sildfinantseerimise ulatuses ei ole välisabi laekumine kahtluse all
ning see tagastatakse Rahandusministeeriumile pärast vahendite laekumist välisabi andjalt,
hiljemalt 30.09.2018.
EL teadusuuringute ja innovatsiooni raamprogrammist HORISONT 2020 rahastatud
projektile „Preserving and sustainably governing cultural heritage and landscapes in
European coastal and maritime regions“ taotleme 2018. aastaks sildfinantseeringut
välistoetuse arvelt tehtavate kulude katteks summas 30 000 eurot. Projekti elluviimise aeg on
mai 2018 - aprill 2021. Projekti arvestuse kood SAPis on 9M20-PERICLES. Taotletud
välisabi sildfinantseerimise ulatuses ei ole välisabi laekumine kahtluse all ning see
tagastatakse Rahandusministeeriumile pärast vahendite laekumist välisabi andjalt, hiljemalt
30.09.2019.
Euroopa Merendus- ja Kalandusfondi rakenduskava 2014 - 2020 meetmest 8.3
"Merekeskkonna alaste teadmiste parendamise toetus" rahastatud projektile
„Keskkonnaohtlike vrakkide kaardistamine, dokumenteerimine ja riskide hindamine“
taotleme 2018. aastaks sildfinantseeringut välistoetuse arvelt tehtavate kulude katteks
summas 160 000 eurot. Projekti elluviimise aeg on jaanuar 2018 - detsember 2019. Projekti
arvestuse kood SAPis on 3M20-VRAKID. Taotletud välisabi sildfinantseerimise ulatuses ei
ole välisabi laekumine kahtluse all ning see tagastatakse Rahandusministeeriumile pärast
vahendite laekumist välisabi andjalt, hiljemalt 01.05.2019.
Suur-Karja 23/ 15076 Tallinn/ 628 2222/
[email protected]/ www.kultuuriministeerium.ee/ Registrikood 70000941
Tähtaegselt tagastamata sildfinantseerimise summa palume Rahandusministeeriumil kinni
pidada Kultuuriministeeriumi eelarvest kokkuleppel Kultuuriministeeriumi volitatud
esindajaga.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Paavo Nõgene
kantsler
Lisad:
Lisa 1 Muinsuskaitseameti taotlus sildfinantseerimisvahendite kasutamiseks
Lisa 2 Projekti „Preserving and sustainably governing cultural heritage and landscapes in
European coastal and maritime regions“ taotlus, teavituskiri ja hindamisaruanne
Lisa 3 Projekti „Keskkonnaohtlike vrakkide kaardistamine, dokumenteerimine ja riskide
hindamine“ taotlus ja rahastusotsus
Reet Tallo 6282240
[email protected]