15/12/2017
Ref.: CL/4223
Subject: First Consultation on the implementation of the 2015
Recommendation concerning the Protection and Promotion of
Museums and Collections, their Diversity and their Role in Society
The “Recommendation concerning the Protection and Promotion of Museums and
Collections, their Diversity and their Role in Society” was adopted by the 38th
session of the UNESCO General Conference in 2015. This new standard-setting
instrument highlights some fundamental aspects of the role of museums in
contemporary societies, contributing to our collective effort to achieve sustainable
development and intercultural dialogue. It aims to assist Member States in the
development and implementation of adequate policies and provisions relating to
museums, to preserve heritage in all its forms, stimulate creativity, and serve as a
transformative power in the cultural, social and economic fields.
Unlike Conventions, Recommendations do not require a ratification procedure.
Utmost consideration should be given to the integration of their directives into
national legislation and practice, therefore.
To this end, Article VIII of the Organization’s Constitution requires Member States
to report on the legislative and administrative provisions made, as well as on any
other measures taken, to implement UNESCO Conventions and
Recommendations. In accordance with this requirement, the Secretariat will submit
to the 40th session of the General Conference (2019) the first consolidated report
on the implementation by Member States of the 2015 Recommendation, together
with the comments of the Executive Board’s Committee on Conventions and
Recommendations on said report.
With this in mind, the 202nd session of the Executive Board, held in October 2017,
approved the reporting guidelines, which should be carried out through a survey
prepared by the Secretariat (202 EX/Decision 24.VII), and requested the
Secretariat to submit the first consolidated report to its 206th session, in spring
2019.
I am pleased, therefore, to address to your Government the attached guidelines,
as well as the survey, both of which are available online at the following Internet
address:
http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0025/002527/252798E.pdf (pages 54-77)
I would be most grateful if the survey could be completed by the competent
authorities in line with the instructions provided in the survey document, and
returned to UNESCO at the address indicated below by 30 August 2018.
7, place de Fontenoy
75352 Paris 07 SP, France
Tél. : +33 (0)1 45 68 10 00
Fax : +33 (0)1 45 68 55 55
www.unesco.org
CL/4223 – page 2
This first exercise is of particular importance, as it will provide the Secretariat with
recent data concerning statistics and activities, policies and good practices at the
national, regional and international levels, thus allowing for an evaluation of the
challenges faced by the global museum sector as a whole. Moreover, it will point
to priority fields for possible multilateral cooperation through UNESCO and partner
networks.
The outcomes of the survey will be analysed carefully, and then will be shared with
Member States in the form of a consolidated report that will be submitted to the
40th session of the General Conference.
For your ease of reference, all documents relating to the adoption process of the
Recommendation, as well as past decisions in that regard, can be consulted at the
following Internet address:
http://www.unesco.org/new/en/culture/themes/museums/recommend
ations-on-the-protection-and-promotion-of-museums-and-collections/
Should you require any additional information or further assistance on the reporting
process, we invite you kindly to contact the Moveable Heritage and Museums
Section within the Culture Sector by e-mail at:
[email protected], or by post at
the following address:
UNESCO Culture Sector
Division for Heritage
(Attn Bernards Zako)
7 Place de Fontenoy
75352 Paris 07 SP
France
With my renewed thanks for your unerring cooperation and invaluable support,
I ask that you please accept, Sir/Madam, the assurances of my high consideration.
Audrey Azoulay
Director-General
Enc.
cc: National Commissions for UNESCO
Permanent Delegations to UNESCO
CL/4223
Annex
ANNEX
Guidelines for the preparation of the reports from
Member States on the application of the UNESCO 2015
Recommendation concerning the Protection and Promotion of
Museums and Collections, their Diversity and their Role in Society
UNESCO’s Member States are invited to send to the UNESCO Secretariat information on their
implementation of the 2015 Recommendation concerning Museums and Collections.
Please send the completed survey, by 30 August 2018 at the latest, by email to:
[email protected] and/or by postal mail to: Mr Bernards Zako, Division for Heritage, Culture
Sector, UNESCO, 7 place de Fontenoy 75007 Paris, France.
I. Introduction
A. About the Recommendation
1. The UNESCO Recommendation concerning the Protection and Promotion of Museums and
Collections, their Diversity and their Role in Society was adopted by the UNESCO General
Conference in 2015 and calls upon Member States to guarantee an enabling environment for
museums and related institutions to fulfil their cultural, social, educational and economic roles in
contemporary societies.
2. The Recommendation provides definitions of museums, heritage and collections, and
recognizes the challenges faced by Member States in guiding museums and related institutions to
fulfil their missions. It recommends the implementation of policies and measures strengthening the
primary functions of the museums - preservation, research, communication and education – as well
as fostering the multifaceted roles of museums in contemporary contexts, considering the effects of
globalization, economy and quality of life, as well as the advent of information and communication
technologies (ICTs).
3. The General Conference (38 C/Res 49) “invites Member States to take the appropriate steps
to adapt this new instrument to their specific institutional and socio-cultural contexts; disseminate it
widely across the territories under their jurisdiction and their control; facilitate its implementation
through the formulation and adoption of supporting policies and guidelines, as well as to monitor its
impact on the protection and promotion of museums and collections” and “encourages Member
States and relevant local authorities to identify, within their specific contexts, the critical steps
required to implement the new instrument, which may include the following:
(a) undertake comprehensive surveys and mapping of museums and collections in the
territories under their jurisdiction or their control, analysing their general conditions
relating to socio-economic and other pressures;
(b) explore the modalities for adapting their existing legal, administrative and institutional
frameworks and/or developing appropriate principles and guidelines through
consultations, especially with museum authorities, stakeholders and other partners;
(c) assess the specific conditions of museums and collections, especially from the point of
view of preservation (conservation, inventory and storage) and institutional vulnerability
(human resources, management, financial means) in order to better guide the process
of adapting the existing frameworks in light of their specificities;
(d) integrate museums and collections into a wider framework of national and regional
cultural policy development, which shall provide indications of fields that require careful
CL/4223
Annex – page 2
attention when planning, designing and implementing projects relating to museums and
collections;
(e) prioritize actions for the preservation and development of museums and collections.”
4. The 2015 Recommendation is applicable to museums and related institutions owing
collections, judged important by Member States for their character of representing diversity of their
heritage of all forms. In addition to the museums’ contribution to some of the fundamental missions
of UNESCO, their roles also concern areas covered by the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable
Development 1 to build a more sustainable and peaceful world.
B. Reporting obligations
5. In accordance with Article VIII of UNESCO’s Constitution, “Each Member State shall submit to
the Organization […] reports […] on the action taken upon the recommendations and conventions
referred to in Article IV, paragraph 4.”
6. Following the adoption of the 2015 Recommendation, and in accordance with the Specific
multi-stage procedure for the monitoring of the implementation of UNESCO conventions and
recommendations for which no specific institutional mechanism is provided, as adopted by the
Executive Board at its 177th session (177 EX/Decision 35.I) and amended at its 196th session (196
EX/Decision 20), the first consolidated report on its implementation is to be submitted by the
UNESCO Executive Board to the 40th session of the UNESCO General Conference.
7. The UNESCO Secretariat provides assistance to facilitate the monitoring of the implementation
of the Recommendation, placing it within the larger context of efforts to contribute towards the
achievement of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable
Development.
8. All Member States, given their commitment to implementing the 2015 Recommendation and
their reporting obligations, should provide information on the legislative and other measures that
have been taken pursuant to the 2015 Recommendation and the ways in which national legislations,
policies and programmes correspond to its provisions. Information supplied by Member States
should demonstrate how national laws, policies and practices comply with international commitments
under the 2015 Recommendation, describing legal norms as well as actual implementation.
9. For the full text of the 2015 Recommendation please follow this link:
http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0024/002463/246331m.pdf
C. Definitions of terms
10. For the purpose of this survey, the following definitions of “museum”, “collection” and “heritage”
have been adopted on the basis of the 2015 Recommendation. (Chapter I, paras. 4-6)
11. The term “museum” is defined as a “non-profit, permanent institution in the service of society
and its development, open to the public, which acquires, conserves, researches, communicates and
exhibits the tangible and intangible heritage of humanity and its environment for the purpose of
education, study and enjoyment. As such, museums are institutions that seek to represent the
natural and cultural diversity of humanity, playing an essential role in the protection, preservation
and transmission of heritage.”
12. The word “collection” is defined as “an assemblage of natural and cultural properties, tangible
and intangible, past and present. Every Member State should define the scope of what it understands
by collection in terms of its own legal framework, for the purpose of this Recommendation.”
1 http://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/development-agenda/
CL/4223
Annex – page 3
13. The term “heritage” is defined as “a set of tangible and intangible values and expressions that
people select and identify, independently of ownership, as a reflection and expression of their
identities, beliefs, knowledge and traditions, and living environments, deserving of protection and
enhancement by contemporary generations and transmission to future generations. The term
heritage also refers to the definitions of cultural and natural heritage, tangible and intangible, cultural
property and cultural objects as included in the UNESCO culture conventions.”
D. Main issues
14. While the Recommendation covers a wide range of issues that can affect the fulfilment of
museums of their recommended roles, this survey concentrates on the most significant issues
notably in achieving UNESCO’s fundamental missions and the contribution to the 2030 Agenda for
Sustainable Development.
15. Primary functions: The Recommendation stresses the importance for museums to fulfil their
fundamental functions to safeguard the heritage of humanity. This is also a prerequisite to contribute
further to the development of societies in terms of social, educational, cultural and economic aspects.
Museums’ primary functions were defined as:
– Preservation (acquisition, creation and maintenance of professional inventories,
collection management, risk analysis, development of preparedness capacities,
emergency plans, security, preventive and remedial conservation, restoration, while
optimizing the conditions for the integrity of the collections in use and in storage) (para
7-8);
– Research (study of collections, by museums or in collaboration with other institutions to
explore the full potential of museums) (para. 9)
– Communication (interpretation, dissemination of knowledge on collections, monuments
and sites, organisation of exhibitions, public events, cultural activities and interaction with
the public in physical and digital means, access and social inclusion) (paras. 10-11)
– Education (formal and non-formal education, lifelong learning, development and
transmission of knowledge, educational and pedagogical programmes, partnerships with
other institutions notably schools, about civic life, preserving heritage, and fostering
creativity and other related social topics) (para. 12)
16. Museums and Society: The Recommendation highlights four issues which have the most
impact on the functioning and modalities of museums’ activities and provides directives to address
them:
– Globalization (mobility of collections, professionals, visitors and ideas, increased
accessibility, homogenization) (para. 13)
Globalization allows a greater mobility of resources and fertile exchanges across borders
and this very internationalization may lead to a certain trend toward homogenizing
museums, collections and styles of management for the purpose of market profitability.
– Economy and quality of life (museums as economic actors and generators of incomes,
tourism economy, projects contributing to quality of life, social inclusion) (paras. 14-15)
Museums are not only agents of public policies but they also increase the connection
with a variety of stakeholders, including urban planning and development project
partners and owners in private sector and civil society. Their economic roles are
therefore to be well-adjusted but without compromising the primary functions of
museums. The ways in which museums and collections are managed could be
CL/4223
Annex – page 4
conducted in harmony amidst the needs for maximizing self-sustainability and ensuring
integrity of their assets.
– Social role (factor in social integration and social cohesion, strengthening social ties,
citizenship, collective identities, openness, physical and cultural access to all, spaces for
reflection, debate on historical, social, cultural and scientific issues, foster human rights
and gender equality, dialogue with indigenous people) (paras. 16-18)
The social role of museums has been recognized, but significant challenges remain to
optimize their potential. Means to develop programmes and activities benefitting all
segments of societies require long-term strategies, human resource development and
proper allocation of resources and infrastructures. Partnerships and dialogues in
developing museums’ activities and collections are recommended especially for
museums wishing to provide opportunities to offer themselves as forums on a variety of
historical and contemporary issues.
– Information and communication technologies (ICTs) (enhanced opportunities for
preservation, study, creation and transmission of heritage and related knowledge)
(para. 19)
Advanced technologies are fundamentally changing the relationship between museums,
professionals and audiences. These technologies are also changing economic outreach
and offer an increased possibility of linking museums and cultural industries. Business
models and practices are still emerging. From preservation viewpoints, these
technologies have enabled museums to record, store and exchange state-of-the-art
information on collections and related knowledge. They also allow museums to reach
out to new audiences around the world, while an unfilled digital divide persists among
museums, with differing degrees of access to these technologies and capabilities relating
to them.
17. Museums and the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development: The 2030 Agenda indicates the
importance of pursuing together the building of a world of universal respect for human rights and
human dignity, of respect of cultural diversity, gender equality and permitting the full realization of
human potential (para 8). Museums can contribute to these overarching goals and especially for:
o Fostering knowledge and awareness of topics closely related to sustainable
development such as food security (Goal 2), water (Goal 6), modern energy (Goal 7),
economic growth (Goal 8), infrastructure, industrialization and innovation (Goal 9),
consumption and production patterns (Goal 12), climate change (Goal 13), ocean and
marine ecosystem (Goal 14), terrestrial ecosystem and biodiversity (Goal 15),
technologies (Goal 17);
o Encouraging the acquisition of knowledge and skills needed to promote sustainable
development, including, among other, through education for sustainable development
and sustainable lifestyles, human rights, gender equality, promotion of a culture of peace
and non-violence, global citizenship and appreciation of cultural diversity and of culture‘s
contribution to sustainable development (Goal 4.7);
o Ensuring women’s full and effective participation and equal opportunities for leadership
at all levels of decision-making in political, economic and public life (Goal 5.5);
o Devising and implementing policies to promote sustainable tourism which creates jobs
and promotes local cultures and products (Goal 8.9) and developing tools to monitor
these benefits (Goal 12.b);
CL/4223
Annex – page 5
o Empowering and promoting the social, economic and political inclusion of all, irrespective
of age, sex, disability, race, ethnicity, origin, religion or economic or other status (Goal
10.2);
o Strengthening efforts to protect and safeguard the world’s cultural and natural heritage
(Goal 11.4);
o Providing universal access to safe, inclusive and accessible, green and public spaces,
in particular for women and children, older persons and persons with disabilities (Goal
11.7);
o Providing the relevant information and awareness for sustainable development and
lifestyle in harmony with nature (Goal 12.8);
o Strengthening the recovery and return of stolen assets (Goal 16.4).
II. How to fill in and transmit the survey
18. The following questionnaire is to guide and assist Member States with their reporting. It aims
to collect, in a simplified manner, information on the extent to which Member States have
mainstreamed the principles of the 2015 Recommendation in their national systems, and overall
implementation issues. Responses to this questionnaire will be considered as the official national
report for each Member State.
19. Only one questionnaire per country should be submitted. It is recommended that the
questionnaire be filled by the Ministry responsible for museums.
20. Member States with a federal system of governance are invited to provide information on the
overall implementation of the 2015 Recommendation in the country rather than its implementation
in each individual sub-national state, as appropriate. Space is also provided after the last question
for Member States to include any additional information they wish to share.
21. Prior to completing the questionnaire, Member States are encouraged to organize necessary
consultations within and outside the Ministry of Culture/Government, including with key, relevant civil
society partners to collect the information/data.
22. The questionnaire can be completed electronically and emailed to the following address:
[email protected]. The survey should be sent no later than 30 August 2018.
23. If you have any difficulty in completing this survey, please contact the UNESCO Secretariat for
assistance: Mr Bernards Zako, Division for Heritage, tel.: (33) 1 45 68 17 14 or email:
[email protected]
24. In many countries, different categories of museums can experience different treatment. In
particular, there might be different administrative and jurisdictional arrangements among national,
federal, regional or city museums and private museums (even if they have public vocation). Similarly,
there can be institutions which are not museums but have collections (universities, companies,
foundations). Please provide details where different conditions apply to different categories of
museums and collections.
25. As part of the reporting process, good practices will be identified in different areas, and from
each region. If you believe your policy or programme is a best practice, please highlight them as
such in your response and provide detailed information and possibly links.
26. It is very important for UNESCO to understand how its standard setting-instruments are being
implemented globally and what are the greatest challenges faced in their implementation, in order
to better identify the goals of international cooperation in this field. This requires your support. While
CL/4223
Annex – page 6
we appreciate that resources are stretched, we would be deeply grateful if you could contribute to
this process by responding to this survey. Through comprehensive information, Member States can
have a better understanding of the global situation and benefit from each other’s experience for their
future policies and actions.
Thank you for your consideration and cooperation. We very much look forward to your report.
CL/4223
Annex – page 7
Protection and Promotion of Museums and Collections
2018 Survey of UNESCO Member States
Information about respondent
Country ___________________________________________
Name and title of the respondent ________________________
Institution/department ________________________________
Email _____________________________________________
Mailing address _____________________________________
Date of submission __________________________________
Signature: Minister of in charge of Museums or other designated official as judged appropriate (e.g.
Director-General of Culture, Heritage, Secretary-General of the UNESCO National Commission or
other)
__________________________________________________
General
1: no 2: slight 3: fair 4: good 5: full
1 2 3 4 5
1. In your country, to what extent are the guiding
principles of the 2015 Recommendation (e.g.
fundamental functions of museums, social,
cultural, educational and economic role, cultural
diversity and tolerance, equality and non-
discrimination, peace and non-violence, justice,
human rights, gender, human survival and well-
being, sustainable development, intercultural
dialogue, etc.) reflected in your domestic
legislations/policies/guidelines concerning
museums and collections?
CL/4223
Annex – page 8
Statistics
Please provide the most recent national general statistics concerning museums and collections in
your country
Please specify data source and year:
1. Number of registered museums and related institutions 2 in terms of administrative
responsibility
International
State, central or national
Federal
Regional
Municipal/Cities
District
Community
A trust (public enterprise), public foundation
A non-profit private body
A commercial enterprise
Association
Private, individual or family business
Religious institutions
University
Others (specify)
2. Number of registered museums and related institutions in terms of major themes and
collections
Art
Archaeology
World Heritage sites related museums
History (general, national, regional, federal, territorial, cities,
communities, etc.)
Memorial
2 The 2015 Recommendation also refers to collections which are not held in museums but collections, judged
important by Member States for their character of representing diversity of their heritage as subject of the
Recommendation (para. 32).
CL/4223
Annex – page 9
Natural history and natural science
Literature
Science and technology
Folk Arts, Ethnography and Anthropology
Music
General
Inter or multi-disciplinary (specify)
Others (specify)
3. Number of items by collections category (if known)
Art
Archaeology
World Heritage sites
History (general, regional, federal, national, territorial, cities,
communities, etc.)
Memorial
Natural history and natural science
Literature
Science and technology
Folk Arts, ethnography and anthropology
Music
General
Inter or multi-disciplinary (specificity)
Other (specify)
4. Do you have other data sources available than governmental/public ones concerning the
museum statistics in your country?
If yes, please specify and possibly indicate the link to such statistics:
5. Does/Do legislation/specific legal regulations, policies and guidelines concerning museums
and collections exist?
If yes, please specify:
CL/4223
Annex – page 10
Nature Title Reference number Year of issuance
Legislations/regulat
ions
Policies
Guidelines
Please provide details where differences and particularities exist concerning regulations relating to
museums and collections within your country.
6. If you answered yes to question 5, does/do decrees enforce the implementation of the
legislation(s)?
If yes, please specify the reference number and year of issuance of decree(s)
Title Reference number Year of issuance
7. Operational status: are there museums which are not operating or closed for some reasons?
If yes
Please if possible specify the number and reasons
General and functional policies
The questions below concern the implementation of section IV, General Policies and Functional
Policies, of the 2015 Recommendation
1. Adherence to existing international instruments and principles
Member States are called upon “to take appropriate measures so that museums and collections in
the territories under their jurisdiction or control benefit from the protective and promotional measures
granted by [existing international instruments relating cultural and natural heritage] and “also to take
appropriate measures to strengthen museum capacities for their protection in all circumstances”
(para 20). “Museums also should adhere to the principles of international instruments for the fight
against illicit trafficking of cultural property and should coordinate their efforts in this matter… Finally,
“museums must also take into account the ethical and professional standards established by the
professional museum community. Member States should ensure that the role of museums in society
is exercised in accordance with legal and professional standards in the territories under their
jurisdiction”. (para. 21)
1.1 Does your government have legislations, policies and guidelines which regulate the missions
and activities of museums to enforce their adherence to existing international instruments? If
so, please explain how they have been implemented in line with the Conventions outline below.
CL/4223
Annex – page 11
UNESCO 1954 Convention and its two
protocols
UNESCO 1970 Convention
UNESCO 1972 Convention
UNIDROIT 1995 Convention
UNESCO 2003 Convention
UNESCO 2005 Convention
If you have not yet ratified these Conventions
and implemented them, are you considering
the possibility of integrating the principles
expressed in these Conventions in your
museum-related legislations, policies and
guidelines? Please explain.
What are your suggestions for developing a
closer link and synergies between the
UNESCO 2015 Recommendation and other
UNESCO heritage programmes and
recommendations, including the World
Heritage, Urban Heritage, Intangible Cultural
Heritage and Cultural expressions? What are
your activities at national level, if any, to
develop the links and synergies between these
Conventions, Recommendations and
programmes?
1.2 In particular reference to the 1970 UNESCO Convention, does your government’s existing
legislations, policies and guidelines provide museums, related institutions and private
collections, and owners with guidance concerning issues below?
Please specify references (name, reference and
year)
Acquisition
De-accessioning
Collection management
Provenance research
Documentation/inventory practice
2. Allocation of human and financial resources
Member States are requested to “support and develop museums in accordance with their primary
functions, and in this regard develop the necessary human, physical and financial resources needed
for them to function properly” (22) and to take “appropriate measures to facilitate the employment of
CL/4223
Annex – page 12
qualified personnel by museums in the territories under their jurisdiction with the required expertise.
Adequate opportunities for the continuing education and professional development of all museum
personnel should be arranged to maintain an effective workforce.” (27)
2.1 Is your government’s policy of allocating human, physical and financial resources based on
the evaluation of needs for museums and related institutions?
If yes
Please specify:
2.2 Please indicate the annual budget volume for the national museum sector (global or by
activity/function) and its percentage out of the whole budget allocated for heritage/culture
Global Budget Or by % out of the total
activity/function
which receive
budgets (e.g.
conservation,
acquisition…)
Culture related museums
Science related museums
Others
2.3 Does your government have human resource policies for museums, for example, a public
examination for selecting qualified museum professionals or supplying a determined number
of graduates of relevant disciplines which is appropriate compared with the number of posts to
be filled, on short- and long-term prospects?
If yes
Please specify
CL/4223
Annex – page 13
2.4 Does your government provide scholarship and training programmes for mid-career
professionals and in general for workers of the museum sector, and/or any supporting
measures for their continued professional development including mobility?
If yes
Please specify
3. Diversity of museums and collections
The recommendation states that “the diversity of museums and the heritage of which they are
custodians constitutes their greatest value” and requests Member States to “protect and promote
this diversity, while encouraging museums to draw on high-quality criteria defined and promoted by
national and international museum communities”. (23).
3.1 During the period covering this survey, how many new initiatives reflecting the diversification
of your country’s museums and collections were launched, in particular with a view to diversity,
and what are their natures?
Please specify the number of new initiatives since 2016
Registrations and creations of new museums Number
Please specify examples
Reorganization of existing museums and Number
collections
Please specify examples
Others Number
Please specify examples
Functional policies
The questions below concern the implementation of section IV, second segment, Functional Policies,
of the 2015 Recommendation.
4. Museums’ fundamental functions and public participation
Member states are invited “to support active preservation, research, education and communication
policies, adapted to local social and cultural contexts, to allow museums to protect and pass down
heritage to future generations. In this perspective, collaborative and participative efforts between
museums, communities, civil society and the public should be strongly encouraged” (24)
4.1 Does your government have legislations, policies and guidelines to support museums to fulfil
their primary functions of preservation, research, education and communication?
If yes
Please specify:
CL/4223
Annex – page 14
Element Title of the legislations, Year of
policies or guidelines issuance
Preservation (acquisition, Acquisition
creation and maintenance of
professional inventories,
collection management, risk
Inventories
analysis, development of
preparedness capacities,
Collections
emergency plans, security,
management
preventive and remedial
conservation, restoration
Risk analysis and
preparedness
Emergency
planning
Security
Preventive/remedial
conservation
Restoration
Others
Research (study of collections,
by museums or in collaboration
with other institutions)
Communication (interpretation, Interpretation
dissemination of knowledge on
collections, monuments and
sites, organisation of Knowledge transfer
exhibitions, public events,
cultural activities and Exhibitions
interaction with the public in
physical and digital means,
access and social inclusion) Public
events/cultural
activities
Access
Social inclusion
Education (formal and non- Formal and non-
formal education, lifelong formal education
learning, development and
transmission of knowledge, Lifelong learning
CL/4223
Annex – page 15
educational and pedagogical
Knowledge
programmes, partnerships with
development and
other institutions notably
transfer
schools, about civic life,
preserving heritage, and
Pedagogical
fostering creativity and other
programmes
related social topics)
Partnership with
other institutions for
social topics
4.2 If yes, do these legislations, policies and guidelines take into account local specificities?
If yes
Please specify:
4.3 Does your government provide guidance and take concrete measures to promote participative
and collaborative efforts among different stakeholders having influence and involvement with
the museum sector (for instance, city planning authorities, educational institutions, civil society
groups, youth, people with special needs, or groups of people having specific links and
interests with collections possessed by museums)?
If yes
Please specify:
5. Documentation of museum collections
Member States should take appropriate measures to ensure that the compilation of inventories
based on international standards is a priority in the museums established in the territory under their
jurisdiction. The digitization of museum collections is highly important in this regard, but should not
be considered as a replacement for the conservation of collections. (25)
5.1 Does your government have a specific legislation, policy or guidelines to enforce the
establishment of inventories of collections, public or private, with basic elements, manual or
digital?
If yes
Please specify reference and year of issuance:
5.2 Does your government enforce a periodical inventory control of museum collections by law?
If yes
Please specify reference and year of issuance:
CL/4223
Annex – page 16
5.3 Does your government enforce a standardized/unified inventory system (manual or digital) at
national (or other appropriate) level with guidance on standards of documentation?
If yes If no, what are the main reasons why
such a unified inventory system has not
Please specify: been established in your country?
5.4 Does your government enforce or recommend digitization of collections with guidance on
standards of data formats and data storage?
If yes
Please specify
6. Code of ethics and professional standards
The Recommendation encourages Member States to promote the adoption and dissemination of
codes of ethics 3 and good practices and to use them to inform the development of standards,
museum policies and national legislation. (26)
6.1. Does your government’s existing legislations, policies and guidelines indicate the need for
adopting codes of ethics or constituency of the museums and related institutions to guide their
activities and professional behaviours so that they are in compliance with ethical standards of
conduct?
If yes
References
If codes of ethics were adopted for your country’s museums, please specify the title(s) and year(s)
of adoption, and possibly the link to the texts
7. Funding mechanism and partnerships
The effective functioning of museums is directly influenced by public and private funding and
appropriate partnerships. Member States should strive to ensure a vision, adequate planning and
funding for museums, and a harmonious balance among the different funding mechanisms to enable
them to carry out their mission to the benefit of society with full respect for their primary functions.
(28)
3 Such as ICOM’s code of ethics
CL/4223
Annex – page 17
7.1 Does your government have strategies, policies or guidelines concerning funding partnerships
or in-kind contribution schemes for museums in different sectors?
If yes
Please specify examples of good practices
7.2 Are museums/collections of your country considered as national assets, evaluated in financial
terms?
If yes
Please specify
8. Museums and ICTs
The functions of museums are also influenced by new technologies and their growing role in
everyday life. These technologies have great potential for promoting museums throughout the world,
but they also constitute potential barriers for people and museums that do not have access to them
or the knowledge and skills to use them effectively. Member States should strive to provide access
to these technologies for museums in the territories under their jurisdiction or control. (29)
8.1 Does your government provide access to ICTs for museums, as a part of e-government policy
for instance?
If yes
Please specify
8.2 Does your government have legislations, policies or guidelines concerning the use of ICTs in
the museum’s work for collection management?
If yes
References
8.3 Does your government encourage free electronic access to collections by legislations, policies
or guidelines?
If yes, please specify/provide references and/or examples of good practice
CL/4223
Annex – page 18
8.4 Does your government have legislations, policies or guidelines concerning the intellectual
property and copyrights for digital reproduction and other virtual resources which are
published, relating to the collections?
If yes
References
9. Social role of museums
Member States are encouraged to support the social role of museums that was highlighted by the
1972 Declaration of Santiago de Chile. Museums are increasingly viewed in all countries as playing
a key role in society and as a factor in social integration and cohesion. In this sense, they can help
communities to face profound changes in society, including those leading to a rise in inequality and
the breakdown of social ties. (16) Museums are vital public spaces that should address all of society
and can therefore play an important role in the development of social ties and cohesion, building
citizenship and reflecting on collective identities. Museums should be places that are open to all and
committed to physical and cultural access to all, including disadvantaged groups. They can
constitute spaces for reflection and debate on historical, social, cultural and scientific issues.
Museums should also foster respect for human rights and gender equality. Member States should
encourage museums to fulfil all of these roles. (17) In instances where the cultural heritage of
indigenous peoples is represented in museum collections, Member States should take appropriate
measures to encourage and facilitate dialogue and the building of constructive relationships between
those museums and indigenous peoples concerning the management of those collections and,
where appropriate, return or restitution in accordance with applicable laws and policies. (18)
The social role of museums, along with the preservation of heritage, constitutes their fundamental
purpose. The spirit of the 1960 Recommendation concerning the Most Effective Means of Rendering
Museums Accessible to Everyone remains important in creating a lasting place for museums in
society. Member States should strive to include these principles in the laws concerning the museums
established in the territories under their jurisdiction. (30)
9.1 Has your government taken specific measures to integrate the principles of museums’ social
roles, such as prompting social integration and cohesion and strengthening social ties by
promoting activities relating to these aspects?
If yes
Please specify:
Examples for good practices if any:
9.2 Has your government taken specific measures to facilitate the physically safe and intellectual
access for all, notably children, older persons and disadvantaged groups to museums and
collections? (it also refers to 2030 Development Agenda Goal 11.7);
If yes
References
Examples for good practices if any:
CL/4223
Annex – page 19
9.3 Has there been a specific programme promoting issues relating to contemporary societal
concerns, including human rights and gender equality, in your museum sector?
If yes
References
Examples for good practices if any:
9.4 Has your government engaged efforts in promoting dialogue and partnerships between
museums and populations having specific links with collections, and where appropriate,
initiated or responded to claims of return or restitution of heritage, in accordance with
applicable laws and policies? If so, please elaborate.
Case Number Examples for good practices if any:
Dialogue with populations
having links with collections
Engagement in dialogues for
return or restitution (either as
claimer or respondent)
10. Multi-level cooperation
Cooperation within the museum sectors and institutions responsible for culture, heritage and
education is one of the most effective and sustainable ways of protecting and promoting museums,
their diversity and their role in society. Member States should therefore encourage cooperation and
partnerships among museums and cultural and scientific institutions at all levels, including their
participation in professional networks and associations that foster such cooperation and international
exhibitions, exchanges and the mobility of collections. (31)
10.1 Does your government have data concerning cooperation and partnership established during
the period covering this survey? If yes, please specify:
Number Technical cooperation Human resource
(exchange of development
collections, touring (collection
exhibitions, joint management,
research etc.) technical skills..)
In-country
cooperation
Regional cooperation
International
cooperation
Public-private
partnerships
CL/4223
Annex – page 20
Others (please
specify)
10.2 Does your country have a national agency or section in related ministries dedicated to the
museum sector (such as the directorate general of museums, section of museums)?
If yes
Please specify name(s):
And if yes, is this agency/section autonomous management
structure or attached to a higher division?
10.3 Does your country have a non-governmental national or public association of museums,
including the national committees of International Council of Museums (ICOM)?
If yes
Please specify:
11. Collections held in other institutions
The collections defined in paragraph 5, when held in institutions that are not museums, should be
protected and promoted in order to preserve their coherence and better represent the cultural
diversity of those countries’ heritage. Member States are invited to cooperate in the protection,
research and promotion of those collections, as well as in promoting access to them. (32)
11.1 Does your government have specific definitions and legislations relating to collections which
are not stored in museums run by public authorities?
If yes
Please specify:
11.2 Does your government have specific legislations, policies and guidelines to promote the
access to collections owned by institutions and individuals other than museums run by public
authorities?
If yes
Please specify:
12. Measures concerning the UNESCO 2015 Recommendation
Member States should take appropriate legislative, technical, and financial measures, in order to
design public planning and policies enabling the development and implementation of these
recommendations in museums situated in the territories under their jurisdiction. (33) Member States
should promote international cooperation in capacity building and professional training, through
bilateral or multilateral mechanisms including through UNESCO, in order to better implement these
CL/4223
Annex – page 21
recommendations and especially to benefit the museums and collections of developing
countries.(35)
12.1 Since the adoption of the 2015 Recommendation, has your government taken appropriate
actions to promote it towards all stakeholders concerned?
Yes
Please specify:
12.2 What initiatives have been taken to review public planning and policies concerning the
implementation of the 2015 Recommendation? Please provide any information on the
measures taken by your country to incorporate the principles of the 2015 Recommendation in
constitutional, legal and policy frameworks.
Please specify:
12.3 Has there been any institutions/agencies designated and involved at national level to lead the
process of the implementation of the 2015 Recommendation?
If yes, please specify:
Governmental bodies (ministries, agencies, ...)
National Commission
Museums (Specify)
Cultural institutions (specify)
Scientific institutions (specify)
Educational institutions (specify)
National branches of international associations/organizations (specify)
Others (specify)
CL/4223
Annex – page 22
12.4 Since the adoption of the 2015 Recommendation, have there been initiatives benefitting the
implementation, including the establishment of new museums, meetings, capacity-building and
professional training in line with the provisions provided by the Recommendation, including
those with national, regional and international partnership, including UNESCO? If so, please
provide details.
Yes
Please specify:
Examples of good practices if any:
13. Audience development
In order to contribute to the improvement of museum activities and services, Member States are
encouraged to support the establishment of inclusive policies for audience development. (34)
13.1 Does your government have specific policies concerning audience development in museums?
Yes
Please specify:
Examples of good practices if any:
13.2 Does your government have specific policies to encourage quality experience of visitors?
Yes
Please specify:
Examples of good practices if any:
Museums and 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development
Museums’ scopes and works are spanning over the disciplines and fields for sustainable
development. The questions below concern the impact of your museum sector for pursuing the goals
adopted by 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.
14. Please provide number and references of national initiatives that you deem contributing to the
achievement of internationally agreed sustainable development goals.
Goals Number of museums having Number of museums’
permanent exhibitions temporary activities on
dedicated to the topics of the related goal (and
the related goal (and possibly specify
possibly specify details) details )
Food security (2)
CL/4223
Annex – page 23
Water (6)
Modern energy (7)
Economic growth (8)
Infrastructure, industrialization and
innovation (9)
Consumption and production patterns
(12)
Climate change (13)
Ocean and marine ecosystem (14)
Terrestrial ecosystem and
biodiversity (15)
Technologies (16)
Sustainable development
Sustainable lifestyles - providing the
relevant information and awareness
for sustainable development and
lifestyle in harmony with nature (12.8)
Human rights (4.7)
Gender equality (4.7)
Cultural diversity and its contribution
to sustainable development (4.7)
Ensuring women’s full and effective
participation and equal opportunities
for leadership at all levels of decision-
making in political, economic and
public life (5.5)
Sustainable tourism, promotion of
local cultures and products (8.9)
Empowering and promoting the
social, economic and political
inclusion of all, irrespective of age,
sex, disability, race, ethnicity, origin,
religion or economic or other status
(10.2)
protection and safeguarding of the
world’s cultural and natural
heritage (11.4)
Strengthening the recovery and
return of stolen assets (16.4)
CL/4223
Annex – page 24
15. Please provide additional information, opinions and remarks concerning the situation of your
country’s museum sector below. In particular, please state the challenges you have encountered in
implementing the provisions of the Recommendation and the fields for which you expect most
assistance from UNESCO and other Member States/organizations.