dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Kultuuriministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

AIPPI soovitused intellektuaalomandi õiguskaitse valdkonnas

Kultuuriministeerium · 18. jaanuar 2018
Viit
1-12/275-1
Registreeritud
18. jaanuar 2018
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
AIPPI Estonian National Group
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
1 Ministeeriumi ja valitsemisala tegevuse planeerimine ja juhtimine
Sari
1-12 Kirjavahetus õigusalastes küsimustes (sh ministeeriumile kooskõlastamiseks saadetud õigusaktide/dokumentide eelnõud)
Toimik
1-12/2018 Kirjavahetus õigusalastes küsimustes ( sh eelnõude kooskõlastamine)
Vastutaja
Merle Põld
Lahendamise tähtaeg
16. veebruar 2018

Failid

  • 📎17.01.2018 AIPPI kiri kultuuriministrile.bdoc39 KB
  • 📎Resolution on Bad faith trademarks_English.pdf30 KB
  • 📎Resolution on Gene Patenting_English.pdf22 KB
  • 📎Resolution on Patentability of computer implemented inventions_English.pdf28 KB
  • 📎Resolution on Protection of graphical user interfaces_English.pdf31 KB
  • 📎Resolution on Quantification of montary relief_English.pdf40 KB
  • 📎Resolution on Requirements for protection of geographical indications and appellations of origin_English.pdf54 KB
  • Summary of Sydney Resolutions 2017.pdf

Sisu (failidest)

2017 AIPPI World Congress – Sydney Adopted Resolution October 17, 2017 Resolution 2017 – Study Question (Trademarks) Bad faith trademarks Background: 1) This Resolution concerns bad faith in relation to trademarks. 2) This Resolution focuses on bad faith in the context of trademark applications and registrations. It does not address bad faith in the context of use, nor does it cover the role of bad faith in the context of the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property (Paris Convention) and TRIPS references as described in the Study Guidelines in paragraphs 7) and 8). 3) The factors that should be taken into account when assessing whether there is a situation of bad faith and the types of proceedings in which it should be possible to invoke bad faith are current and important topics. Situations of bad faith often involve cross-border elements. Harmonisation in these respects is desirable. 4) Given the variety of the situations which might involve "bad faith" elements, this Resolution will not attempt to attribute a legal definition to that term, which should remain flexible enough to cover all kinds of situations. 5) 47 Reports were received from AIPPI's National and Regional Groups providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Reporter General Team of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (see below links). 6) At the AIPPI World Congress in Sydney in October 2017, the subject matter of this Resolution was further discussed within a dedicated Study Committee, and again in a full Plenary Session, following which the present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI. AIPPI resolves that: 1) An action should be available to a Party B against the application or registration for a trademark in a jurisdiction by a Party A, if that sign or a similar sign is already used in one or more jurisdictions by Party B, but is not registered by Party B in the jurisdiction where Party A has registered or applied for the trademark, provided that Party A filed the application in bad faith, as determined in accordance with paragraph 2 below. 1 2) At a minimum, the following factors should be taken into account in assessing an action described in paragraph 1 above, but without prejudice to any other relevant factors, or the weight to be accorded to the factors listed below, depending on the circumstances of the case: a) Party A knew or ought reasonably to have known of use of an identical or similar sign in the same jurisdiction and/or abroad for identical and/or similar goods or services; b) Party A intends to prevent Party B from using the sign of Party B or to allow such use only under certain conditions (e.g. a licence); c) the degree of legal protection enjoyed by Party A's or Party B's sign, including but not limited to the degree of distinctiveness of the signs; d) the degree of similarity between the signs; and e) the degree of similarity between the goods/services. 3) When establishing whether Party A knew or ought reasonably to have known as described above in paragraph 2a), at a minimum the following factors should be taken into account, without prejudice to any other relevant factors, or the weight to be accorded to the factors listed below, depending on the circumstances of the case: a) whether Party A operates in the same or a similar field of business as Party B; b) whether the sign of Party B is well known or enjoys a reputation; and c) whether there have been formal or informal dealings or contact between Parties A and B (e.g. an agreement, written communication, etc.). 4) Where a trademark the subject of an application or registration is identical or substantially identical to a trademark the subject of an earlier trademark registration in the same jurisdiction and in the name of the same owner, the later filed application or registration may be challenged on the basis of bad faith. 5) When assessing whether a trademark as described above under paragraph 4 was applied for in bad faith at a minimum the following factors should be taken into consideration, without prejudice to any other relevant factors, or the weight to be accorded to the factors listed below, depending on the circumstances of the case: a) the prior registration failed to meet genuine use requirements; b) the subsequent filing or registration was filed for the sole purpose of circumventing genuine use requirements; c) the applicant had no intention to use the trademark; d) the degree of overlap between the goods/services; e) if the signs are not identical, the degree of difference; and f) whether legitimate reasons for the repeat filing exist. 2 6) It should be possible to challenge an application or registration on the basis of the conduct described above under paragraphs 1 and 4 in the following proceedings: a) an opposition proceeding before the trademark/IP Office; b) a cancellation action before the trademark/IP Office; or c) a court proceeding concerning a bad faith application or registration including, without limitation, a cancellation action or any action aiming at obtaining the assignment of a trademark. Links: • Study Guidelines http://aippi.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/FINAL-website-version-Bad-faith- trademarks3.pdf • Summary Report http://aippi.org/wp- content/uploads/2017/08/SummaryReport_Trademarks_BadFaithTrademarks_15August 2017_final.pdf • Reports of National and Regional Groups and Independent Members http://aippi.org/committee/bad-faith-trademarks/ 3 2017 AIPPI World Congress – Sydney Adopted Resolution October 17, 2017 Resolution Gene Patenting ____________________________________________________________________ Background: 1) For almost the past 40 years, isolated genes and genetic material have enjoyed general patentability worldwide. However, more recently, a series of legal decisions, most prominently the Myriad cases, has called into question the patentability of such material per se in several jurisdictions including the United States of America (U.S.) and Australia. The scope of this Resolution concerns the patenting of genetic materials, whether in a form isolated from nature by a technical process or artificially synthesized by man. 2) This Resolution does not address the requirements of patentability for genetic materials other than patent eligible subject matter, morality and utility. 3) There is a stark lack of harmonisation between jurisdictions as to the patentability of genetic materials. For example, even the EU Directive 98/44/EC is not implemented in a consistent manner across the EU Member States. 4) The Court of Justice of the European Union in Decision C428/08 has ruled that national patent legislation is precluded from offering “absolute protection” to patented DNA as such “regardless of whether it performs a function in the material containing it”. 5) TRIPS Article 27(1) provides that patents shall be available for any inventions, whether products or processes, in all fields of technology provided they are new, involve an inventive step and are capable of an industrial application. 6) TRIPS Article 27(2) and (3) allows members to exclude from patentability inventions the commercial exploitation of which would be contrary to ordre public or morality, diagnostic, therapeutic and surgical methods for the treatment of humans and animals, plants and animals other than microorganisms, and essentially biological processes for the production of plants and animals, but does not require them to do so. 7) The patenting of genetic materials isolated from nature by a technical process or artificially synthesized is not something which appears inherently amenable to exclusion under TRIPS Article 27(2) and (3), for reasons including: a) genes and other nucleic acids once isolated are not in the same form as in situ in nature; 1 b) mere existence in nature does not equate to having an application in an applied setting; and c) jurisdictions which permit patenting of genetic materials require that the patent specification cite at least a credible industrial application for the molecule, and in some cases, to be demonstrated. 8) Genes isolated from microorganisms, plants, insects and animals, as well as humans, including disease-associated variants, have been found to have industrial, agricultural, diagnostic and therapeutic applications. Patenting such molecules facilitates funding for further research by public bodies and academic institutions, and pharmaceutical and agricultural development more generally. 9) Exclusion from patentability deters such effort in genetic research preventing beneficial developments being available for the benefit of the public worldwide. AIPPI resolves that: 1) As a matter of principle clearly reflected in TRIPS Agreement, patents should be granted for any inventions in all fields of technology including genes or parts thereof isolated from nature by a technical process or nucleic acid molecules artificially synthesized, provided an industrial, agricultural, diagnostic and/or therapeutic application is identified and other patentability criteria are met. 2) Genetic materials should not be regarded as subject matter excluded from patentability by virtue of TRIPS Article 27(2) and (3), and in particular, should not be regarded as inventions contrary to ordre public or morality. 3) Genetic material “isolated” from nature by a technical process, should not be treated as a mere “product of nature” and should not be treated as patent ineligible for this reason alone. 4) Isolated genetic material, whether or not identical to that which occurs in nature, should be treated for patent purposes as a chemical compound, its production and uses being “a manner of manufacture”. 5) EU Directive 98/44/EC should be implemented in each EU Member State in a consistent manner. 6) A patent claim to a nucleic acid molecule per se should provide a scope of protection no different to that afforded by any other claims defining a chemical compound. 7) AIPPI strongly urges governments to implement the necessary legislative measures to ensure that genetic materials, when isolated from nature or artificially synthesized, constitute patent eligible subject matter. 8) AIPPI also strongly urges governments to avoid any measures that would apply a different scope of protection for patent claims to genetic materials and nucleic acids solely by reason of the subject matter of those claims. 2 Links: • http://aippi.org/library/q114-resolutions/ • http://aippi.org/library/q150-resolutions/ • http://ec.europa.eu/dgs/legal_service/arrets/08c428_en.pdf • http://aippi.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Gene-Patenting-AIPPI-Position-Paper.pdf 3 2017 AIPPI World Congress - Sydney Adopted Resolution October 17, 2017 Resolution 2017 – Study Question (Patents) Patentability of computer implemented inventions ____________________________________________________________________ Background: 1) This Resolution concerns the issue of patentability of computer implemented inventions (CIIs). 2) For the purpose of this Resolution: • The abbreviation CII refers to an invention which involves the use of a computer, computer network or other programmable apparatus, where one or more features are realised wholly or partly by means of a computer program and/or implemented in hardware; • The term patentability of CII refers to the question of whether CII may properly be the subject of a patent claim. 3) Patentability of CIIs has been hotly debated since the 1960s in many countries, and national/regional laws and practices have significantly evolved over time. However, the development of the various practices has not been at all linear. Rather, the patentability of CIIs is a dynamically changing and scattered landscape. This has created a high degree of confusion and frustration among users of the patent system and practitioners. 4) Practices even diverge on the question of how to name CIIs. 5) AIPPI has previously taken positions regarding the patentability of CIIs, in particular in the Resolutions on Q133 – "Patenting of computer software" (Vienna, 1997) and on Q158 – "Patentability of business methods" (Melbourne, 2001). Broadly speaking, these Resolutions generally represent a position that any computer software should be eligible for patent protection, irrespective whether or not the claimed invention makes a contribution to any specific fields of human endeavour or technology. 1 6) AIPPI wishes to update its position with the aim of improving harmonisation in national/regional laws. 7) 44 Reports were received from AIPPI's National and Regional Groups and Independent Members, providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Reporter General Team of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (see links below). These Reports indicate a broad consensus that harmonisation is desirable. 8) At the AIPPI World Congress in Sydney in October 2017, the subject matter of this Resolution was further discussed within a dedicated Study Committee, and again in a full Plenary Session, following which the present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI. AIPPI resolves that: 1) As a question of principle clearly reflected in the TRIPS Agreement, and taking into account other reasons of a legal, economic and practical nature, patents should be available, and patent rights enjoyable, without discrimination for inventions in all fields of technology, including CIIs. 2) There should be no general exclusion from patentability of CIIs, including computer programs. 3) A claim directed to a CII should be eligible for patent protection if it defines an invention in at least one field of technology. A claim directed to a CII should be examined using the same criteria as applied to other kinds of inventions. 4) Eligibility of a CII for patent protection should not depend on the prior art or any assessment of novelty or inventive step. 5) The assessment, including examination, of whether one or more claims directed to a CII define an invention in at least one field of technology should be made on a claim by claim basis, and in relation to each claim as a whole. 6) A claim directed to a CII can be a claim directed to, inter alia: a) a system or apparatus; b) a method or process executed by at least one processor; c) instructions that can be executed or interpreted by at least one processor to execute steps of a method or process, whether stored in or on at least one storage medium or in the form of at least one signal or data carrier, whether in the form of a computer program or otherwise; or d) a data structure generated by a computer-implemented method or process, whether stored in or on a storage medium, or in the form of at least one signal or data carrier. 2 Links • Study Guidelines http://aippi.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/FINAL-website- version-Patentability-of-CII.pdf • Summary Report http://aippi.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Summary- Report_Patents_CII_160817_final.pdf • Reports of National and Regional Groups and Independent Members http://aippi.org/committee/patentabililty-of-computer-implemented-inventions/ 3 2017 AIPPI World Congress - Sydney Adopted Resolution October 17, 2017 Resolution 2017 – Study Question (General) Protection of graphical user interfaces Background: 1) This Resolution concerns the issue of whether and how graphical user interfaces (GUIs) may be protected by various intellectual property rights (IP rights). 2) For the purposes of this Resolution, the term GUI refers to an interface which allows users to interact with electronic devices through graphical elements (e.g. icons, menus, scroll bars, windows, transitional animations, dialogue boxes) instead of typing characters. 3) This Study Question is primarily concerned with the issue of whether GUIs should be protected by means of "traditional" IP rights, namely: • patents • design rights • copyright; and • trademarks. Where jurisdictions permit intellectual property protection for GUIs by means of similar rights, such as trade dress protection, such rights are within the scope of this Study Question. 4) Broader forms of legal protection that may also have application to GUIs, such as laws relating to unfair competition, unfair business practices or general contractual principles are generally outside the scope of this Study Question, other than in those jurisdictions where unregistered trademarks and trade dress may be protected under general principles of unfair competition. 5) GUIs are directly connected to user experience, so can significantly impact consumers' choice of products. As a result, companies devote significant resources to the development of GUIs. This means that both appropriate IP rights protection of GUIs, and freedom to operate in the IP rights landscape, are very important economic issues for incumbent companies and new market entrants. GUIs may potentially be protected by IP rights including patents, design rights, copyright and trademarks. 1 6) By its nature, software is generally developed to have broad application. Computers, smartphones, tablets, gaming and other stationary and handheld machines are just some of the industries in which GUIs are relevant. These industries are highly competitive and their operations extend beyond national boundaries. Different types of IP rights protection may apply to different aspects of GUIs, leading to questions about what type, or combination of types, of protection is or should be available. Further, with variation between jurisdictions as to how and whether particular types of IP rights apply (or not) to GUIs, harmonization of the available IP rights protection in relation to GUIs is desirable. 7) 39 Reports were received from AIPPI's National and Regional Groups and Independent Members providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Reporter General of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (see below links). 8) At the AIPPI World Congress in Sydney in October 2017, the subject matter of this Resolution was further discussed within a dedicated Study Committee, and again in a full Plenary Session, following which the present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI. AIPPI resolves that: Patents 1) GUIs should generally be capable of protection by patents. 2) Involvement of a user’s mental activities in an interaction with a GUI should not preclude the patentability of the GUI. 3) It should not be a prerequisite that a claim to a GUI includes a physical feature. 4) No specific claim format should be required for patent protection of GUIs. Designs 5) GUIs should generally be capable of protection by design rights. 6) Movements and transitions in a GUI should generally be capable of protection by design rights. 7) A GUI should generally be capable of protection by design rights without requiring any connection to a physical device. Copyright 8) GUIs should generally be capable of protection by copyright. 9) The fact that GUIs are computer generated should not exclude their eligibility for copyright protection. 10) The threshold for copyright protection of GUIs should not be higher than for other works. 2 Trademarks 11) GUIs should generally be capable of protection by trademark rights. 12) Movements and transitions in a GUI should generally be capable of protection by trademark rights. 13) A GUI should not be required to acquire distinctiveness through use to be capable of protection as a trademark. Where a GUI is not inherently distinctive, acquired distinctiveness should be required. Other forms of protection 14) Having regard to the IP rights that should be available for protection of GUIs as set out in paragraphs 1), 5), 8) and 11) above, sui generis protection for GUIs should not be necessary. Authorities' procedures 15) Authorities for patent, design, copyright and trademark rights should adopt measures to accept and publish electronic data that can dynamically represent movements and transitions in a GUI. Links: • Study Guidelines http://aippi.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/FINAL-website-version-GUIs.pdf • Summary Report http://aippi.org/wp- content/uploads/2017/08/SummarReport_General_GUIs_15August2017_final.pdf • Reports of National and Regional Groups and Independent Members http://aippi.org/committee/protection-of-graphical-user-interfaces/ 3 2017 AIPPI World Congress – Sydney Adopted Resolution October 17, 2017 Resolution 2017 – Study Question (General) Quantification of monetary relief Background: 1) This Resolution concerns the quantification of monetary relief in relation to the infringement of intellectual property (IP) rights. This Resolution is not concerned with statutory damages, or accounts of profit and other relief in which the unlawful profits of the infringer are rendered to the right holder. 2) Specific issues in relation to FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) royalties in the context of standard essential patents are outside the scope of this Resolution, other than to the extent that reasonable royalties are relevant to the quantification of damages more generally. 3) The primary objective of this Resolution is to formulate methods of quantification of damages to assist with a more harmonised and consistent recovery of damages. A purpose of this Resolution is to determine how monetary damages should be calculated in accordance with fair and objective methodologies. 4) In this Resolution: • the term IP rights includes patents and supplementary protection certificates, petty patents and utility models, trade marks, rights to prevent unfair competition or passing off, copyrights, semiconductor topography rights, database rights and design rights, but excludes trade secrets, rights of confidence and rights in know-how; • the term damages refers to monetary relief as provided for in relation to IP rights, including but not limited to i) actual loss suffered by the right holder as a result of the infringing activity, e.g. loss of sales or price erosion; ii) the “injury proven” as referred to in paragraph 6(a) of AIPPI's Resolution on Q134 – "Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights – TRIPS" (Rio de Janeiro, 1998); and iii) reasonable royalties awarded when actual loss is not proven; • the term IP rights in suit refers to those IP rights found infringed in respect of which the court will need to quantify damages; • the term price erosion refers to sales of products or services that implement the IP right in suit made at a lower profit margin than the right holder would have made but for the infringement; 1 • the term convoyed sales refers to sales of products or services not protected by the IP rights in suit that are in fact sold together by the infringer with the products or services that implement the IP rights in suit, regardless of whether or not those products are sold together by others or customarily. 5) It is a premise of this Resolution that quantification of damages should proceed from the starting point that damages compensate for the loss suffered by the right holder. 6) Due to the obvious fact-sensitivity of the enquiry, and the inevitable lack of critical facts (e.g. the right holder’s lost sales that never happened), estimation mechanisms and proxies may need be employed. Rather than leaving a right holder without any relief, the court should be prepared to make a judgment based on the evidence that is available, but not go outside the bounds of that evidence. The court is entitled to assess and give the appropriate weight to the evidence that is available. 7) By increasing the possibilities for obtaining evidence in relation to quantum, and providing for effective methods of maintaining confidentiality in the right holder’s confidential information (and also in the infringer’s confidential information), better quality financial evidence on losses may become available to courts. 8) 40 Reports were received from AIPPI's National and Regional Groups providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Reporter General Team of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (see below links). 9) At the AIPPI World Congress in Sydney in October 2017, the subject matter of this Resolution was further discussed within a dedicated Study Committee, and again in a full Plenary Session, following which the present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI. 10) The study leading to this Resolution focused on the consequences of infringing sales. Quantification of monetary relief in relation to infringing acts other than sales should be considered for future study by AIPPI AIPPI resolves that: 1) Damages should compensate the right holder: a) for its lost profits in respect of sales of products or services that the right holder would have made but for the infringement; and/or b) for its lost profits in respect of price erosion; and/or c) by a reasonable royalty in respect of infringing sales that are not proved to have been lost sales of the right holder, save that the right holder cannot recover twice for the same loss. 2) In assessing lost profits, courts should recognise that the task is by its nature one of estimation and be prepared to make a judgment based on such evidence as is available, seeking to ensure that the right holder is fully compensated in respect of its loss. 3) Lost profits should be assessed taking into account relevant circumstances including, without limitation: a) the similarities and differences between the parties’ competing products or services (e.g., design, quality, price, sales channels); 2 b) the availability of other substitutable products or services in the market; c) the capacity of the right holder to meet demand; d) sales, service and warranty offerings of the parties; e) geographic reach; f) reputation of the parties in the market; g) advertising spend; h) price of the products or services; i) the change in turnover of the right holder following the commencement of infringing sales. 4) For the purpose of assessing lost profits, evidence in the possession, custody or control of the infringer relevant to the circumstances referred to in paragraph 3 above should be made available to the right holder and the court. 5) For the purpose of the quantification of damages, the right holder’s lost profits should be calculated as the net revenue from the right holder’s sales (i.e., after discounts and rebates) less the right holder’s costs directly attributable to those sales. 6) Damages should also be recoverable where sales of goods or services of the right holder that compete with the infringement but do not embody the IP right have been lost because of the infringement, as long as the right holder proves a causal nexus between the infringement and the lost sales. The court may take the degree or strength of causation into consideration when considering the appropriate quantum of damages. 7) Mechanisms should be available to preserve the confidentiality of a party’s commercial and financial information relevant to assessing damages from disclosure to the public or the other party. 8) Paragraph 7 above is not intended to prevent disclosure of evidence in the possession, custody or control of the infringer in accordance with paragraph 4 above, where appropriate confidentiality protection measures are in place. 9) In assessing a reasonable royalty, a court should have regard to factors including, without limitation: a) other licence agreements of the same IP right as the IP right in suit (but taking due account of the circumstances in which any such other licence agreement was negotiated and, in particular, but not limited to, whether infringement and/or validity of the IP right in suit had been determined); b) other licence agreements of similar IP rights to the IP right in suit; c) the cost of non-infringing alternatives; d) advantages of the IP right in suit when compared with alternatives (including any applicable licence fees for alternatives); e) profitability of the products or services encompassing the IP right in suit; 3 f) development costs of the IP right in suit; and g) the absence and/or circumstances of prior licensing discussions between the parties. 10) In assessing a reasonable royalty, the parties should be considered as if they were willing licensor and licensee respectively, with the attributes of the actual right holder and infringer, but disregarding the fact that one or both parties would not in practice have agreed to license the IP right in suit. 11) A reasonable royalty should be assessed on the basis that the IP right in suit is valid and infringed where validity and infringement have been determined in the same proceeding or, otherwise, if warranted in the circumstances. 12) In assessing lost profits, compensation should be available in respect of convoyed sales made by the infringer to the extent that such sales are found to result from the lost sales of goods or services that implement the IP right in suit. 13) Where the IP right in suit relates to a part of a multi-component product or service sold by the infringer, the value to be attributed to the IP right in suit (and the compensation available by way of lost profits or reasonable royalty) should be assessed having regard to the extent to which the infringing component provides the basis for customer demand for that multi-component product or service. 14) In assessing lost profits, regard should be had to the present value of future losses that will be sustained by the right holder after the date of the damages award. The mere fact that an injunction is also granted in addition to damages does not mean that there will be no future losses. 15) Where an injunction is granted, future losses may include the effects of: a) price drops; and/or b) lost market share; and/or c) the time necessary to restore the market to pre-infringement profits. Where no injunction is granted, future losses may include the effects of a) and b), but not c). 16) In assessing a reasonable royalty where no injunction is granted, the royalty should include a royalty in respect of future infringements, if any. 17) The principles in relation to the quantification of damages expressed in this Resolution should apply to claims for infringement made by an IP owner and any licensee of the IP owner, provided such licensee has standing to sue for infringement or to intervene in an action for infringement. However, where the interests of the IP owner and any such licensee are different, the quantification of any resulting damages should reflect that fact. Links: • Study Guidelines 4 http://aippi.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/FINAL-website-version-Quantification-of- monetary-relief.pdf • Summary Report http://aippi.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Summary-Report-Quantification-of-monetary- relief_16August2017.pdf • Reports of National and Regional Groups and Independent Members http://aippi.org/committee/quantification-of-monetary-relief/ 5 2017 AIPPI World Congress - Sydney Adopted Resolution October 17, 2017 Resolution Requirements for protection of geographical indications and appellations of origin ____________________________________________________________________ Background: 1) This Resolution concerns several aspects of the protection of geographical indications (GIs) and appellations of origin (AOs)1. 2) The definition of GIs and AOs, the process for their registration, their scope of protection and several other aspects thereof are current and important topics, in relation to which harmonisation is desirable. 3) This Resolution does not deal with the relationship between GIs/AOs and trademarks and domain names. 4) 28 Reports were received from AIPPI’s National and Regional Groups and Independent Members providing detailed information and analysis regarding national and regional laws relating to this Resolution. These Reports were reviewed by the Reporter General Team of AIPPI and distilled into a Summary Report (see below links). 5) At the AIPPI World Congress in Sydney in October 2017, the subject matter of this Resolution was discussed in a full Plenary Session, following which the 1 The difference between GIs and AOs is explained by WIPO in the following terms: “Appellations of origin are a special kind of geographical indication (GI). GIs and AOs require a qualitative link between the product to which they refer and its place of origin. Both inform consumers about a product’s geographical origin and a quality or characteristic of the product linked to its place of origin. The basic difference between the two concepts is that the link with the place of origin must be stronger in the case of an AO. The quality or characteristics of a product protected as an AO must result exclusively or essentially from its geographical origin. This generally means that the raw materials should be sourced in the place of origin and that the processing of the product should also take place there. In the case of GIs, a single criterion attributable to geographical origin is sufficient – be it a quality or other characteristic of the product – or even just its reputation." (see http://www.wipo.int/geo_indications/en/faq_geographicalindications.html) present Resolution was adopted by the Executive Committee of AIPPI2. AIPPI resolves that: 1) There should be harmonized definitions of GIs and AOs. 2) A GI should be defined as an indication which identifies a good as originating in the territory of a country, or a region or locality in that territory, where a given quality, reputation or other characteristic of the good is essentially attributable to its geographical origin. 3) An AO should be defined as a particular type of GI, being a geographical denomination of a country, region or locality, which serves to designate a product originating therein, the quality or other characteristics of which are due exclusively or essentially to the geographical environment, including natural and human factors. 4) There should be a registration procedure which has the effect of protecting GIs and AOs, including at least the following features: a) a detailed application requesting protection for a GI or AO (as the case may be), which should at least contain: i) identification of the applicant and its legal standing; ii) identification of the type of product to be protected; iii) the specific name of the product to be protected; iv) the geographical area of origin; v) demonstration of the link between the product’s characteristics and the geographical area; vi) a description of the manufacturing process; vii) any regulations on the use of the GI or AO, including any controls on such use; and viii) the producers allowed to use the GI or AO; b) substantive examination of the application by an independent public authority; c) publication of the application; d) the possibility for third parties to oppose the registration; and 2 Nothing in the present Resolution deviates from or supersedes AIPPI's Resolution on Q191 – "Relationship between trademarks and geographical indications" (Gothenburg, 2006), except for the issue of registration of GIs/AOs. 2 e) a decision on registration. 5) GIs/AOs should be protected against at least: a) any use of the GI/AO for a product, where that use is misleading or deceiving for consumers as to the origin or the characteristics of the product; b) any conduct which harms or unduly exploits or takes advantage of the reputation of the GI/AO. 6) Domestic and foreign GIs/AOs should be protected on an equal basis. 7) In the event of violation of rights in relation to a GI/AO, the following should have legal standing to protect the GI/AO: a) the owner or right holder of the GI/AO; b) any person authorised to use the GI/AO provided that the person obtains prior authorisation from the owner or right holder of the GI/AO; c) groups, consortiums, organizations, associations and/or managing entities administering the GI/AO and representing the interests of the producers of the relevant products; and d) public authorities, either at the governmental or local levels. 8) In the event of violation of rights in relation to a GI/AO, at least the following remedies should be available: a) an injunction; and b) monetary compensation. 9) Grounds of refusal of an application for, or invalidity or other loss of rights in relation to, a GI/AO should include at least: a) the fact that the indication does not qualify as a GI/AO and/or the conditions for protection do not exist or subsequently cease; b) the indication being or becoming generic; c) non-use of the GI/AO for a specified number of years; and d) the fact that the indication is or the GI/AO subsequently becomes liable to mislead the public. 3 Links: • Questionnaire http://aippi.org/wp- content/uploads/2017/06/Questionnaire_Geographical_Indications_Resolution_ Sydney_2017.pdf • Summary Report http://aippi.org/wp- content/uploads/2017/08/SummaryReport_SC_GIs_Resolution_Sydney2017_fi nal_160817.pdf • Reports of National and Regional Groups and Independent Members http://aippi.org/committee/?committee_type%5B0%5D=19&status=Active&searc h_post_type=committee 4 Summary of Resolutions – AIPPI World Congress, Sydney 2017 Patentability of computer implemented inventions This Resolution concerns the patentability of computer implemented inventions (CIIs), an issue which has been highly debated for decades. While national/regional laws and practices have significantly evolved over time, the development of the various practices has not been at all linear. This has created a high degree of confusion and frustration among users of the patent system and practitioners. This Resolution updates AIPPI's position regarding the patentability of CIIs which, in broad terms, had been that any software should be eligible for patent protection. AIPPI reconsidered that position in view of diverging practices around the world. In the U.S., after Alice, examination practice differs significantly from the European "modified inventive step" test, which is in further contrast to the "whole claim concept" in Asia. By this Resolution, AIPPI resolved that, as a question of principle clearly reflected in the TRIPS Agreement, and taking into account other reasons of a legal, economic and practical nature, patents should be available, and patent rights enjoyable, without discrimination for inventions in all fields of technology, including CIIs. The Resolution contains important guidelines for a harmonised practice of patentability assessment of CIIs. In particular, it was resolved that a claim directed to a CII should be eligible for patent protection if it defines an invention in at least one field of technology. That assessment should be made on a claim by claim basis, and in relation to each claim as a whole. This aims to address the current European practice of a selective assessment of inventive step. In keeping with that position, AIPPI also resolved that the eligibility of a CII for patent projection should not depend on the prior art or any assessment of novelty or inventive step. The Resolution also sets out a non-exhaustive list of permissible subject matter for claims directed to CIIs. Bad faith trademarks Bad faith most commonly arises if a trademark is used by a party in one or more jurisdictions, and is then registered by another party in another jurisdiction. Repeat filings and filing of defensive marks may also qualify as bad faith. There are differences in the treatment of bad faith between jurisdictions, causing a lack of predictability. AIPPI resolved that an action should be available to a Party B against the application or registration for a trademark in a jurisdiction by a Party A, if the sign or a similar sign is already used in one or more jurisdictions by Party B, but is not registered by Party B in the jurisdiction where Party A has registered or applied for the trademark, provided that Party A filed the application in bad faith. The Resolution sets out a number of factors to be taken into account in assessing bad faith, including whether Party A knew or ought reasonably to have known of use of an identical or similar sign in the same or another jurisdiction for identical and/or similar goods or services, and the factors to be taken into account in establishing whether Party A knew or ought reasonably to have known those matters. AIPPI also resolved that it should be possible to refuse or cancel a "repeat filing", being the filing of a trademark which is identical or substantially identical to an existing trademark owned by the applicant in the same jurisdiction. This assessment may also depend on a number of factors. The Resolution states that any factors set out are the minimum criteria to be considered, but without prejudice to any other relevant factors or the weight to be accorded to the various factors, and always depending on the circumstances of the case. The Resolution also sets out the types of proceedings in which bad faith can be invoked, namely opposition or cancellation proceedings before IP offices, as well as court proceedings. 1 Protection of graphical user interfaces Graphical user interfaces (GUIs) are interfaces which allow users to interact with electronic devices through graphical elements (e.g. icons, menus, scroll bars, windows, transitional animations, dialogue boxes) rather than by typing commands. This Resolution addresses the protection of GUIs by means of "traditional IP rights", namely, patents, design rights, copyright and trademarks. In each case, the Resolution holds that GUIs should generally be capable of protection by each of these types of IP rights. Concerning patents, AIPPI resolved that involvement of a user's mental activities in an interaction with a GUI, or lack of a physical feature, should not preclude the patentability of a GUI. The Resolution also states that a specific patent claim format should not be required. In relation to designs, AIPPI resolved that design protection should generally extend to movements and transitions in a GUI projected on a screen. Further, design protection should not require any connection to a physical device. In relation to copyright, AIPPI resolved that the fact that GUIs are computer generated should not exclude their eligibility for copyright protection, and that the threshold for copyright protection should not be higher than for other works. Regarding trademarks, AIPPI resolved that movements and transitions in a GUI should generally be capable of protection by trademarks. Further, AIPPI resolved that protection should not depend upon acquired distinctiveness through use. However, acquired distinctiveness is required if a GUI has no inherent distinctiveness. A goal of the Resolution was to determine whether other forms of protection for GUIs should be available, such as a sui generis right. Having regard to the other forms of IP protection detailed, the Resolution holds that sui generis protection for GUIs should not be necessary. By this Resolution, AIPPI also urges the competent authorities to adopt measures to accept and publish electronic data that can dynamically represent movements and transitions in a GUI. Quantification of monetary relief This Resolution formulates methods of quantification of damages to assist with a more harmonised and consistent recovery of damages. The principles apply equally to an IP owner and their licensee, provided the licensee has standing to sue for or intervene in an action for infringement (but any difference of interests should be reflected in the quantification of any resulting damages). AIPPI resolved that damages should compensate the right holder for lost profits in respect of sales of products or services the right holder would have made but for the infringement, lost profits in respect of price erosion, and/or by a reasonable royalty in respect of infringing sales that are not proved to have been lost sales of the right holder, save that the right holder cannot recover twice for the same loss. The Resolution provides a non-exhaustive list of the circumstances to be taken into account when assessing lost profits and a reasonable royalty. The Resolution also provided harmonised guidelines as to the information that can be useful to a court in assessing damages. The Resolution also addresses a number of specific damages scenarios, including: damages from convoyed goods sold together with the infringing products; damages when a part of a larger assembly infringes; and damages for future losses. AIPPI also resolved that relevant evidence in the possession or control of the infringer should be made available to the right holder and the court, and courts may consider ordering the discovery of relevant information if it is not otherwise provided. Where available methods for obtaining evidence have been exhausted, the Resolution states that the court should be prepared to make an assessment even if it can only be approximate. The Resolution also recognises that parties may have a legitimate interest in preserving confidentiality of certain information, whether from disclosure to the public or each other. It was resolved that mechanisms to preserve confidentiality should be available. Gene Patenting This Resolution was prepared by AIPPI's Sub-committee for Biotechnology and Plant Variety Rights (Standing Committee on Pharma and Biotechnology). Until recently, isolated genes and genetic material have enjoyed general patentability worldwide. However, legal decisions in several jurisdictions have called into question the patentability of such material. There is also a lack of harmonization between jurisdictions as to the patentability of genetic materials. By this Resolution, AIPPI states that, as a matter of principle clearly reflected in TRIPS Agreement, patents should be granted for any inventions in all fields of technology including genes or parts thereof isolated from nature by a technical process or nucleic acid molecules artificially synthesized, provided an industrial, agricultural, diagnostic and/or therapeutic application is identified and other patentability criteria are met. It follows that AIPPI also resolved that genetic materials should not be regarded as subject matter excluded from patentability by virtue of the exclusions in TRIPS, and in particular, should not be regarded as inventions contrary to ordre public or morality. AIPPI also resolved that genetic material "isolated" from nature by a technical process should not, for that reason alone, be treated as a mere "product of nature", and therefore patent ineligible. Rather, isolated genetic material, whether or not identical to that occurring in nature, should be treated for patent purposes as a chemical compound, its product and uses being "a manner of manufacture". AIPPI also resolved that a patent claim to a nucleic acid molecule per se should provide a scope of protection no different to that afforded by any other claims defining a chemical compound. The Resolution concludes with AIPPI urging governments to implement the necessary legislative measures to ensure that genetic materials, when isolated from nature or artificially synthesized, constitute patent eligible subject matter, and to avoid any measures that would apply a different scope of protection for patent claims to genetic materials and nucleic acids solely by reason of the subject matter of those claims. Requirements for protection of geographical indications and appellations of origin This Resolution was prepared by AIPPI's Standing Committee on Geographical Indications. By a previous Resolution, AIPPI adopted the “first in time, first in right” principle for settling conflicts between geographical indications (GIs) and trademarks, and recommended protection for GIs either via trade mark laws or a sui generis right. This Resolution expands on AIPPI's previous position in a number of ways. This Resolution covers and adopts definitions for the terms “geographical indication” and “appellation of origin”, noting that appellations of origin (AIs) are a kind of GI, and require a stronger qualitative link between the product and its place of origin. The Resolution sets out eight requirements for the content of an application for registration of a GI or AO, and proposals for the registration procedure, which include the availability of a process for a third party to oppose the registration. AIPPI resolved that GIs and AOs should be protected against use that is misleading or deceptive to consumers as to the origin or characteristics of a product, and use that harms or unduly exploits or takes advantage of the reputation of the GI or AO. The Resolution also states that there should be no discrimination in the protection afforded to domestic and foreign GIs and AOs. The Resolution states that GI or AO right holders, those authorized by them, groups administering the GI or AO, and public authorities should all have standing to protect the GI or AO in the event of infringement. The remedies available should include at least an injunction and monetary compensation. The Resolution also provides that a GI or AO should be invalid if it does not meet the definition of GI or AO, if it becomes generic, if it is not used for a specific period, or if it becomes misleading. Lp kultuuriminister hr Indrek Saar Kultuuriministeerium Suur-Karja 23 1 5076 Tallinn 17. jaanuar 20 18. a. AIPPI soovitused intellektuaalomandi õiguskaitse valdkonnas Austatud kultuuri minister hr Indrek Saar, Intellektuaalom andi Kaitse Rahvusvaheline Assotsiatsioon ( International Association for the Protection of Intellectual Property , lühidalt AIPPI ) on rahvusvaheline organisatsioon, mis on pühendunud intellektuaalomandi õiguskaitse arendamisele ja parendamisele ning millel on üle 9000 liikme, kes esindavad enamat kui 1 25 riiki. AIPPI Eesti Rahvuslik Töörühm on tegev alates 1992 aastast. AIPPI maailmakongressil Sydneys 2017 aasta oktoobris võttis AIPPI vastu kuus resolutsiooni erinevatel intellektuaalomandi teemadel, mis katsid valdkondi alates patendi- ja kaubamärgi õigusest ning muudest üldisematest intellektuaalomandi teemadest. AIPPI peasekretariaadi ülesandel edastame käesolevaga alljärgnevad AIPPI resolutsioonid: Patendid : Arvutil põhinevate leiutiste patentsus Patentability of computer implemented inventions Geenide patentimi ne Gene Patenting Kaubamärgid : Pa hauskselt registreerimiseks esitatud kaubamärgid Bad faith trademarks V aralise kahju kindlaksmääramine Quantification of monetary relief Geograafilised tähised : G eograafiliste tähiste ja päritolunimetuste kaitse nõuded Requirement for protection of geographical indications and appellations of origin Üldine : Graafilise kasutajaliidese kaitse Protection of graphical user interface Osundatud resolutsioonide alusmaterjalid ( Working Guidelines , National and Regional Reports and Summary Reports ) on täiendavaks tutvumiseks kättesaadavad AIPPI veebilehel ( http://aippi.org/library/?publication_title=&publication_categories%5B%5D=10&start_date_range=&end_date_range= ). Lisad: AIPPI peasekretariaadi selgituskiri ( Summary of Sydney Resolutions ); Vastu võetud resolutsioonid. Lugupidamisega, /digitaalselt allkirjastatud/ /digitaalselt allkirjastatud/ Urmas Kauler Reet Saks AIPPI Eesti Rahvusliku Töörühma juhataja sekretär Cc : Ettevõtlus- ja infotehnoloogiaminister Justiitsminister Peaminister Patendiameti peadirektor Tallinna linnapea
Allikas: Kultuuriministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel
📎
35 KB