dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Kultuuriministeerium
Väljaminev kiriAvalik

Kiri

Kultuuriministeerium · 17. jaanuar 2018
Viit
12-6/257-1
Registreeritud
17. jaanuar 2018
Dokumendi liik
Väljaminev kiri
Adressaat
UNESCO, SA UNESCO Eesti Rahvuslik Komisjon
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post, e-post (bcc)
Funktsioon
12 Kultuuriväärtuste kaitse kavandamine ja rakendamine. Haldusjärelevalve teostamine
Sari
12-6 Kirjavahetus muinsuskaitsega seotud küsimustes
Toimik
12-6/2018 Kirjavahetus muinsuskaitsega seotud küsimustes
Vastutaja
Liina Jänes

Failid

  • 📎180117_Questionnaire_FINAL_EN_Estonia.DOCX43 KB
  • 📎Questionnaire_of_the_1970_Convention.pdf.pdf3117 KB

Sisu (failidest)

Questionnaire for States parties to UNESCO’s Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property INTRODUCTORY REMARKS At the 5th session of the Subsidiary Committee of the Meeting of States Parties to the 1970 Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultura l Property (1970 Convention) , held from 17 to 19 May 2017 at UNESCO Headquarters, Paris, France, the Members of the Subsidiary Committee adopted Decision 5.SC 6 bis requesting the Secretariat to : establish, in coordination with the Bureau of the Subsidiary Committee, a questionnaire in order to identify potential measures to strengthen the implementation, efficiency and visibility of the Convention in all its aspects especially legal, political and structural, including the opportunity to establish a List of Good Practices; send the questionnaire to the Bureau of the Subsidiary Committee for approval; send the questionnaire to all States Parties before the end of September 2017, asking States Parties to submit their responses before 15 January 2018; consolidate the answers of the States Parties and send a summary of the results to all States Parties before the end of April 2018 . The present Questionnaire is prepared in application of the aforementioned decision of the Subsidiary Committee. The Secretariat would appreciate receiving the replies from States Parties to the Questionnaire before 15 January 2018 . Please send the completed Questionnaire to [email protected] . EFFICIENCY IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE CONVENTION The questions below relate to the implementation of paragraph 3 of the Decision 5.SC 6 bis with regard to the efficiency in the implementation of the Convention. How does your country wish to improve the implementation of the Convention ( please elaborate briefly ) . We see international cooperation and synergies with other relevant instruments as the main pillar in terms of strengthening the implementation of the Convention. Estonia believes that the Convention should be seen as part of the package that includes other instruments that have an important complimentary relationship to the 1970 Convention. Notably the UNIDROIT Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural Objects that was elaborated for the specific purpose to address gaps in the 1970 Convention concerning private law provisions. The Council of Europe Convention on Offences relating to Cultural Property that was adopted in 2017 is also an important addition to the legal framework. It is open for signature to all countries in the world and is the only international treaty specifically dealing with the criminalisation of the illicit trafficking of cultural property. Strengthening the synergies of these instruments is the key to fight more effectively against illicit trafficking and clandestine excavations. W hich pillar (s) of the Conventi on should be given priority in terms of strengthening the implementation? (please tick the box (es) and provide explanation s if need be ) . ( ) Prevention ( ) Return and Restitution ( x ) International Cooperation ( ) other Does your country have any specific proposals and examples regarding the strengthening of the implementation and efficiency of the 1970 Convention? If yes , please provide your input under the most relevant section. Prevention Return and Restitution International Cooperation Estonia has entered into a number of bilateral agreements and programmes on cultural cooperation that include also the issue of import, export and return of cultural property . It is also relevant to participate in international projects dealing with restitution matters . Other With regard to Return and Restitution, does your country have any suggestions regarding the interaction between the Subsidiary Committee and the Intergovernmental Committee for Promoting the Return of Cultural Property to its Countries of Origin or its Restitution in case of Illicit Appropriation (ICPRCP ) ? Considering the momentum gained through the establishment of the Meeting of the States Parties, the creation of the Subsidiary Committee and the adoption of Operational Guidelines for the implementation of the Convention, how could th ese governing bodies be better utilized in order to strengthen the Convention and support States Parties ’ interests ? The governing bodies could reach out to the relevant governing bodies of other international conventions in order to cooperate and build synergies; also to support UNESCO’s aim to increase the number of ratifications of the Convention. How useful in your experience, are the existing legal and practical tools produced by the Secretariat? Do you have proposals for possible future deliverables by the Secretariat? If so, would you be prepared to provide resources to deliver them? Estonia has benefit ted from the practical tools produced by UNESCO such as Model Export Certificate for Cultural Objects and Cultural Heritage Laws Database. Given the growth of the use of the Internet to sell cultural objects which are stolen, clandestinely excavated from archaeological sites, or illegally exported or imported cultural objects, the guidelines elaborated by UNESCO together with Interpol and ICOM on b asic actions concerning cultural objects being offered for sale over the Internet are especially relevant. It is up to the each State Party to ensure that the national officials and experts are aware of those tools and make us e of them. Do you have further suggestions to improve the dissemination of the tools produced by the UNESCO Secretariat? Once a tool is produced to support the implementation of the Convention , endorsed by the relevant governing bodies, what steps should be taken by the national authorities in order to ensure that all relevant governmental or related experts are aware of the existence of the tool and make use of it? Have you or other stakeholders in your country benefited from capacity - building activities/tools related to preventing illicit trafficking of cultural property developed by the Secretariat? If so, give examples and indicate briefly the resulting effect or change. Do you have suggestions for how the capacity-building programme could be further improved, should financial resources be available? VISIBILITY AND PROMOTION OF THE CONVENTION The questions below pertain to the implementation of paragraph 3 of the Decision 5.SC 6 bis with regard to the visibility of the Convention. What steps have been taken by your national authorities to promote the Convention and its implementation in your country? The information about the convention and the relevant UN Security Council resolutions is shared at professional level ( National Heritage Board, Ministry of Culture, Tax and Customs Board, Police and Border Guard Board ) in order to sensitize the professionals of the current situation. National Heritage Board has established good cooperation with the local equivalent of E-Bay ( www.osta.ee ) and requested them to be vigilant. The platform discloses all necessary information about the sold goods and persons selling it when requested by the National Heritage Board . Estonia has also made effort s to inform general public through media of the situation regarding the cultural heritage in Iraq , Syrian and other most affected countries. Does your country have any proposals regarding the improvement of the visibility and further promotion of the Convention including through the following organs/activities? Statutory bodies Capacity-building activities Awareness-raising activities Education material and activities Publications Online resources and web-pages Media Does your country benefit from the information and links available on the 1970 Convention webpage. Do you find information to be easily accessible and useful? If no, how would you recommend the Secretariat to develop its webpage? Please provide any additional suggestions to increase the visibility of the Convention. CAPACITY BUILDING AND GOOD PRACTICES The questions below pertain to the implementation of paragraph 3 of the Decision 5.SC 6 bis with regard to the opportunity to establish a List of Good Practices . Does your country maintain a List of Good Practices pertaining to the implementation of the Convention? I f yes, which criteria are used to establish such a national List? Estonia reports regularly to the Secretariat about the implementation of the Convention . The reporting system, which is universal for the Member States, provides the Secretariat with relevant good practices. Does your country inform the Secretariat on national good practices concerning the protection of cultural property? ( ) yes ( ) no What in your view should be the criteria and assessment mechanism for a possible international list? Does your country support the idea of the creation of an international list on the best practices of return and restitution cases? ( ) yes ( x ) no How could Good Practices be better integrated in capacity building initiatives to strengthen the implementation of the Convention? Estonia is hesitant about the proposed idea to establish an international List of Best Practices of return and restitution cases in order to increase the visibility of the Convention. In our view the possible international list with established criteria and assessment procedure would be quite a heavy mechanism. Rather, we would welcome a simpler way in which all State Parties could inform the secretariat about their good practices of return and restitution. This information could then be used by the Secretariat for awareness-raising and promotional activities and would serve as an example of the effectiveness of the Convention. Additional Comments: We believe that the Operational Guidelines adopted in 2015 should be seen as the main tool to facilitate the implementation of the Convention as they contain a comprehensive set of agreed measures for the States Parties.
Allikas: Kultuuriministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel