EEA and No rway Grants 2014-2021 Programme “Local Development and Poverty Reduction” Selection Committee meeting Date and time : March 11 , 202 1 from 1 3 : 3 0 to 15 : 0 0 (Estonian time) Venue: Cisco Meet web platform & MoSA , 7 th floor, room Siil ( Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn) Small Grant Scheme „ Developing restorative justice measures in Estonia “ Selection Committee voting members : Ms Laidi Surva – project manager, Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of Justice; Ms Anu Leps – adviser to the Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of Justice; Mr Andres Aru – Head of Children’s and Youth’s Rights Department, Chancellor of Justice . Observers : Ms Gudrun Gudmundsdottir – Financial Mechanism Office, Senior Sector Officer, Health, Children and Youth, also representing the Financial Mechanism Committee Ms Laura Pikkoja – representative of the National Focal Point; State Shared Service Centre; Ms Piret Marvet – representative of the donors, Royal Norwegian Embassy in Tallinn. Ms Kelly Poopuu – representative of the PO Implementing Agency, State Shared Service Centre. Mr Ülar Vaadumäe – Ministry of Social Affairs, Smart Development Department, chief specialist, PO. Minutes of the meeting Mr Ülar Vaadumäe gave an overview of the goals, targets and criteria of the call for proposals . Also, M r Vaadumäe introduced the submitted project and explained the tasks of the Selection Committee. For more, please see Annex 1 (PO presentation). Altogether 1 4 project application s w ere received within the deadline ( November 1 6 , 2020 at 17:00 o’clock local time) set for the call. As a result t he overall grant Total grant amount applied for is approx . 1,2 MEUR, exceeding the total grant available by 800 000 euros . Programme Operator Implementing Agency (State Shared Service Centre) has carried out the assessment of project application to the eligibility and administrative criteria set in the call text. The project met the administrative and eligibility criteria and w as forwarded for evaluation by two impartial, independent and reliable experts. These experts were: Evaluator 1: Ms Annika Vanatoa , assistant prosecutor, Department for Juvenile Crimes and Crimes of Violence Committed in Close Relationships, Northern District Prosecutor's Office Evaluator 2: Ms Helika Saar , manager, Children’s' Rights Programme, Estonian Union for Child Welfare Evaluator 3: Ms Jana Laht-Ventmann , consultant, Department for Juvenile Crimes and Crimes of Violence Committed in Close Relationships, Northern District Prosecutor's Office There were 2 project applications where the difference between the scores given by the two experts was over 30%, therefore a third evaluation was necessary (point 20.5) There were 4 project proposals receiving less than 50% of the total score, and therefore will receive automatically a negative decision ( point 20.6). Please see also Annex 2 (Ranking list of experts). Discussion Mr Vaadumäe opened with a remark that according to the evaluators the first 4 project proposals seem to have received a qualitatively higher score and evaluation in regard to the rest of the proposals. Social I nsurance Board project proposal “ Development of a mediation model and training system ” Ms Anu Leps opened the discussion by mentioning that although the project presents a good variety of activities and includes strong experts, then there is a question to be raised whether some proposed activities are already being implemented outside the project - namely the summer school and the mediator model development. Also, the remuneration of project manager has to be sorted out, as the person ( Ms Annegrete Johanson ) is already taken up with other duties within the organisation as well as in the pre-defined project “ Specialised juvenile justice approach established “. Ms Laidi Surva agreed. The project proposal includes important activities, as well as the inclusion of the University of Tartu and service design method is positive. Still, the part regarding mediator model development and training mediators should be clarified as there is risk of overlapping of activities already being carried out. Ms Surva brought out also the risk in regard to project manager (workload as well as salary). Mr Andres Aru was glad about the scientific basis chosen and including the University of Tartu into the activities. The project holds strong expertise for achieving good results. Ms Gudrun Gudmundsdottir commented that it seems from the discussion that although the project is a strong one, there is need to disperse all doubts regarding overlapping and other vagueness in the description and budget. Police and Border Guard Board project proposal “ A community based on the principles of restorative justice ” Ms Laidi Surva stated that this is a very strong project proposal – practical with emphasis on prevention and schools. Community based approach including also Russian communities. Cost-efficient. Ms Anu Leps agreed. The project tackles important issues and interventions especially in Russian speaking communities are essential. Mr Andres Aru added that this is a strong project involving Russian speaking communities and developing an universal approach also for other communities. NGO Prevention Centre project proposal “ Development and implementation of Family Group Conference (FGC) method as an approach to restorative justice ” Mr Ülar Vaadumäe notified the Selection Committee that the proposed project manager Ms Anniki Lai has left the project and the organisation as she has taken up a new job in the Ministry of Social Affairs as an adviser to the Minister of Social Protection. The project has nominated a new project manager Ms Elo Lättemägi , who has been included in the original project proposal as project assistant and implementor of Family Group Conference (FGC) method. Ms Laidi Surva recognised the FGC method as an alternative for criminal proceedings. She highlighted the project applicant ’s ability to include local communities to ensure local level b u y-in for the method implementation. Ms Anu Leps continued that the FGC method is a method for supporting families and a promising additional initiative that can be considered as one of the restorative justice measures . She praised the NGO in guiding the local governments to financially invest in buying the service. Mr Andres Aru raised the question about the financial scope of the project. The method is here and in use, it needs to be adjusted for dealing as restorative measures for children and youth, then the question is that is the budget cost effective o r could there be some deductions. Maarjamaa Educational College project proposal “ Turning closed child care institutions into restorative institutions ” Ms Laidi Surva was very supportive of the project proposal. It deals with a very important focus area – closed children’s institutions – , and would create a new tool, new atmosphere within the target group. She pointed out that the applicant has been able to bring together all closed children’s institutions in Estonia enabling an impact throughout the field. She brought out that the project was evaluated as highly as NGO Prevention Centre, the main difference being that the latter has received 3 bonus points for having a donor partner included in the project. Ms Anu Leps also said that the project topic has high relevance and as it would change the current behaviour protocols of staff , then this activity within the project is very important. Mr Andres Aru stressed that changing the mentality of the institutions’ staff is essential and therefore it is very good to see that the staff is on - board. Engaging families is of importance as well. Overall, this is an important project regarding making a change in the methods and mentality in closed children’s institutions. ---------------------------------------- Mr Ülar Vaadumäe explained that having discussed those four above mention ed project proposals the call has already exceeded the funds available (400 000 euros vs 602 580 euros), so there should be some compromises made. The Selection Committee members did not see other projects in the evaluation ranking list should be considered for financing, but suggested that Harku and Keila municipalities as neighbouring municipalities could join forces and apply with a joint project proposal at the 2 nd trench of restorative justice measures open call, still to be launched. The Selection Committee also commended the municipality of Põltsamaa for proposing to implement a prevention and intervention programme “Breaking Point” (in Estonian “ Murdepunkt ”) as well as for including motivational interviewing activities in the proposal. Selection Committee decision s Selection Committee decisions are guided by the desire to finance three projects from this round . Approve a project grant to the following project applications as requested : Police and Border Guard Board project proposal “ A community based on the principles of restorative justice ” award a grant in the amount requested, i.e. 78 575 euros. Approve a project grant to the following project applications with conditions : Social I nsurance Board project proposal “ Development of a mediation model and training system ” award a grant for 128 585 euros, taking into account the following: Project manager and project coordinator workload and remuneration should be revised: The project is an add-on to the project already financed from the pre-defined project “Establishment of Specialised Youth Justice Approach”. In the framework of the pre-defined project, the proposed project manager is already working full-time in the name of developing the mediation service in Estonia. In addition, there is a project coordinator working full-time who could take on the coordination functions of the newly planned project. In order to avoid duplicated financing, which is not allowed by Estonian standards, it would be advisable to reconsider paying an extra fee for the project manager and coordinator but not in the amount that adds up to a total workload of 150%, as stated in the current proposal. For example, compare to Police and Border Guard Board project where the project manager receives 350 additional salary and project assistant 200 EUR. T he total salary for the project manager would also seem to be significantly higher than the salary for similar jobs in the public sector (2 400 euros before taxes for 1,0 workload) . In addition, the project manager is planned to be one of the main trainers for new mediators, but it is questionable whether a public employee can receive extra salary for activities that are a part of their job they are already being paid for. However, that remains to be judged by the project manager’s direct line manager. Proposal to be considered by the Social Insurance Board: l ower the additional salary for the project manager to 400 EUR and project coordinator to 300 EUR (leaving them both with highly generous overall salaries when compared to similar positions in the public sector) – savings of 46 200 EUR + additionally in indirect costs ´ savings of 6 930 EUR ; c ancel the r estorative j ustice summer school because it is already being organised in cooperation between MoJ and the Social Insurance Board – savings of 7 500 EUR; Use a similar flat rate for all trainers throughout the project (400 EUR/ person/ day) – savings of 3 600 EUR (budget rows No 41, 42 and 45) as the project proposal doesn’t clearly explain what is the direct impact of involving foreign experts that could not be achieved with domestic experts alone, cancel involving international experts as the whole purpose of the project is to design a model for Estonia using service design methods – savings of 2 900 EUR. The proposed suggestions add up to total savings of 67 130 EUR. NGO Prevention Centre project proposal “ Development and implementation of Family Group Conference (FGC) method as an approach to restorative justice ” award a grant for 125 70 8 euros ( corresponding to the overall reduced budget of 142 349 euros and the original grant rate 88,31%) , taking into account the following: Indirect staff costs should be calculated only for project manager and assistant, resulting in total indirect costs of 6 742,80 EUR (i.e. 0,15*44 952) – savings of 7 743 ,60 EUR. Provide in-depth feedback to the following project applica nts with regard to the next round of the restorative justice small grant scheme that will be launched in spring/summer 2021 : Maarjamaa Educational College project proposal “ Turning closed child care institutions into restorative institutions ” we kindly ask the applicant to resubmit their project proposal in the second round with some suggestions: e xpenditure type “ Cost of staff assigned to the project - Reg. Art. 8.3.1.a ” should only be used for project manager and assistant, resulting in total indirect costs of 7 060 EUR (i.e. 0,15*47 064) instead of 17 035 EUR; please c onsider lowering training costs from 90 000 to 75 000 or provide a more detailed description of all the costs related to trainings . To the Selection Committee it seems there is room for considerable budget reduction if realistic and necessary costs are taken as a starting point. Harku Municipality project proposal “ Implementing restorative justice in Harku ” and Keila Municipality project proposal “ Implementing restorative justice based way of thinking in Keila ” we kindly invite those two municipalities t o resubmit a joint project proposal in the second round with some suggestions: please p rovide a more detailed description of all the costs related to trainings . To the Selection Committee it seems there is room for considerable budget reduction if realistic and necessary costs are taken as a starting point. A better detailed description of cost articles should be provided in the budget file ( Harku Municipality) ; please c onsider not buying laptops and mobile phones for project staff, especially when considering they are already working and will continue to be working for the municipality to implement the project and hence, it is highly unlikely they do not already have technical equipment that allows them to carry out their tasks ( Keila Municipality) ; p lease revisit costs related to awareness raising events, supervision and training ( Keila Municipality) . In comparison to other project proposals, these seem unnecessary high, unless the current budget also covers expenses not clarified well enough, e.g. 450 EUR for a 2.25-hour lecture seems high when compared to similar costs being allocated in other projects for full training days. The Selection Committee advises not to over-budget activities, understanding the need to allow room for manoeuvre in every project process and hence, proposal. Mr Ülar Vaadumäe thanked everybody for their input and closed the meeting. Meeting chaired by (digitally signed) minutes taken by Laidi Surva ( digitally signed ) Ülar Vaadumäe
EEA and Norway Grants 2014-2021
Programme: Local Development
and Poverty Reduction
Selection Committee meeting
March 11, 2021
Small Grant Scheme
„ Developing restorative justice
measures in Estonia“
Overview
Project max duration: 24 months
Call amount: € 400,000
Project grant size: € 30,000 – 200,000
Project grant rate: 85%-100%
Eligible applicants: all entities, public or private, commercial or non-commercial, or
non-governmental organisation, established as a legal person in Estonia or an
international organisation acting in Estonia.
SGS is financed from the NOR Grants FM
Eligible activities of the small grant scheme (1):
The supported activities include:
a) piloting new methods based on restorative justice in working with juvenile and
young offenders;
b) testing the approaches and methods based on restorative justice in various
environments, including institutions for children and youth, social, child
protection and youth work, the police, the prosecutor’s office, courts, probation
services, and closed institutions, including prisons;
c) awareness-raising activities, including information days, information materials,
printed matter, video and audio recordings, etc.;
Eligible activities of the small grant scheme (2):
d) activities for the inclusion of community in raising awareness and improving
knowledge and skills regarding restorative justice;
e) training activities, including training courses, seminars, workshops,
exchange of practices, training courses for future trainers, etc.;
f) pilot projects with the aim of creating a community based on restorative
justice, e.g. restorative school, workplace, city, etc.;
g) production of study materials, guidelines, instructions, etc.;
h) other supporting activities that help to expand the use of restorative justice.
Targets (cumulative for the SGS):
at least 2 awareness campaigns on the topic of restorative justice;
at least 3 restorative justice initiatives in the criminal justice system, schools or
the community;
at least 10 trainers trained in the field of restorative justice.
Number Expected programme Indicator Baseline Baseline Target
results value year value
National prevalence of
Enhanced wellbeing of juvenile offending (self-
Outcome 1 children and youth reported) 18% 2014 16%
children's abnormal behaviour
survey results
Evaluation criteria of the SGS
No Criterion Points %
Justification of the project, incl. project objective and suitability of
1 activities for achieving the stated goals 7 10,77%
Activity plan of the project, consideration and involvement of target
2 groups 17 26,15%
Background, competence and involvement of team members in
project activities and involvement of partners, incl. partners from
3 donor countries 14 21,54%
4 Communication 5 7,69%
5 Sustainability and innovation of the project 10 15,38%
6 Economic efficiency and co-financing of the project 9 13,85%
7 Risk factors 3 4,62%
TOTAL 65
Projects received within deadline:
Altogether 14 project proposals were submitted by deadline
Total grant amount applied for is approx. 1,2 MEUR,
exceeding the total grant available by 800 000 euros
Evaluation of independent experts
Evaluator 1: Ms Annika Vanatoa, assistant prosecutor, Department for
Juvenile Crimes and Crimes of Violence Committed in Close Relationships,
Northern District Prosecutor's Office
Evaluator 2: Ms Helika Saar, manager, Children’s Rights Programme,
Estonian Union for Child Welfare
Evaluator 3: Ms Jana Laht-Ventmann, consultant, Department for Juvenile
Crimes and Crimes of Violence Committed in Close Relationships, Northern
District Prosecutor's Office
There were 2 project applications where the difference between the scores
given by the two experts was over 30%, therefore a third evaluation was
necessary (point 20.5)
There were 4 project proposals receiving less than 50% of the total score,
and therefore will receive automatically a negative decision (point 20.6).
Ranking list of experts
Eligibility period Applicant Grant appplied Average score
1 01.02.2021 - 31.10.2022 Social Insurance Board 195 715,00 61,5
2 01.02.2021 - 31.01.2023 Police and Border Guard 78 575,00 61,0
3 01.03.2021 - 28.02.2023 NGO Prevention Centre 150 092,00 60,5
4 01.03.2021 - 28.02.2023 Maarjamaa Educational College 178 198,60 57,0
Foundation Unique School
01.03.2021 - 28.02.2023 179 720,00
5 Development Centre 52,5
6 01.03.2021 - 30.09.2022 Harku Municipality 59 450,00 51,5
7 01.03.2021 - 28.02.2023 Keila Municipality 142 647,29 51,0
8 16.02.2021 - 15.02.2023 Põltsamaa Municipality 79 476,20 50,0
9 01.04.2021 - 30.09.2022 Põlva Municipality 86 712,27 47,5
Kuressaare Open Youth Centre
04.01.2021 - 03.01.2023 60 169,49
10 "Youth Station" 42,5
11 01.04.2021 - 31.03.2023 Tallinn University 136 100,70 32,0
12 01.04.2021 - 31.03.2023 Jõgeva Municipality 101 698,00 29,0
13 06.01.2021 - 06.07.2021 HeartSmart Ltd 35 295,00 24,5
14 01.03.2021 - 31.05.2022 NGO Dare to Speak 183 913,28 19,5
TOTAL: 1 210 755,85
Selection Committee members
Voting members
Ms Laidi Surva – project manager, Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of
Justice;
Ms Anu Leps – adviser to the Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of Justice;
Mr Andres Aru – Head of Children’s and Youth’s Rights Department, Chancellor
of Justice
Observers
The representatives of the National Focal Point and Programme Operator
Implementing Agency (both State Shared Service Centre) as well as the donor
states (Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Financial Mechanism
Committee) shall be invited to participate as observers.
Selection Committee tasks
The goal
to confirm the list of project applications suggested to be financed and the list
of project applications not to be financed and forward its decision to the
Programme Operator Implementing Agency (i.e. State Shared Service Centre)
for formal decision making.
The tasks
review the ranking list of project applications resulting from the
mathematical average of individual expert evaluation scores;
confirm the list of project applications suggested to be financed and the
list of project applications not to be financed;
modify the ranking list of the project applications or propose only partial
financing of projects in justified cases based on transparent criteria
recorded in the minutes of the committee meeting.
After the Selection Committee
Chairman of the Selection Committee and the PO will sign the minutes of
the meeting, where decisions are laid down in a transparent and
accountable manner describing which project proposals shall be awarded a
grant and which proposals will be rejected.
PO Implementing Agency will cast a decision to award a grant or decline
awarding a grant based on the written recommendation of the Selection
Committee.
Discussion and decisions
Aitäh! Takk!
Ülar Vaadumäe (
[email protected])
Martin Karro
Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus
[email protected] Meie 22.03.2021 nr 2-6.3/1022-1
Väikeprojektide avatud taotlusvooru "Taastava
õiguse arendamine Eestis" hindamiskomisjoni
otsused ja rahastamiseks kinnitatud
projektitaotlused
Lugupeetud Martin Karro
Palume Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskusel kui Euroopa Majanduspiirkonna ja Norra toetuste 2014–
2021 programmi „Kohalik areng ja vaesuse vähendamine“ rakendusüksusel langetada
toetuse rahuldamise otsused väikeprojektide avatud taotlusvooru „Taastava õiguse
arendamine Eestis“ raames laekunud projektitaotluste suhtes, mille on kinnitanud 11. märtsil
2021. aastal kohtunud taotlusvooru hindamiskomisjon.
Palun rakendusüksusel võtta rahastusotsuse langetamisel arvesse, et taotlejad täiendaksid
eelnevalt oma projektikirjeldusi ja eelarveid hindamiskomisjoni viidatud tingimustel, mis
kajastuvad täpsemalt hindamiskomisjoni protokollis (lisatud).
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kristiina Hunt
nutika arengu toetamise osakonna juhataja
Lisa: Minutes of the SC meeting (March 11 2021)_FINAL
Ülar Vaadumäe 626 9249
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 626 9301 /
[email protected] / www.sm.ee / registrikood 70001952