Sotsiaalministeerium · 18. märts 2021
Sisu (failidest)
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive Agency
(CHAFEA)
The Director
GRANT AGREEMENT
NUMBER 101018346 — TaSHI
This Agreement (‘the Agreement’) is between the following parties:
on the one part,
the Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive Agency (CHAFEA) ('the Agency'), under
the powers delegated by the European Commission ('the Commission'), represented for the purposes
of signature of this Agreement by Véronique WASBAUER, Director, or his/her duly authorised
representative,
and
on the other part,
1. ‘the coordinator’:
SEMMELWEIS EGYETEM (SU), established in ULLOI UTCA 26, BUDAPEST 1085, Hungary,
VAT number: HU15329808, represented for the purposes of signing the Agreement by rector of SU,
Béla Dr. Merkely
and the following other beneficiaries, if they sign their ‘Accession Form’ (see Annex 3 and Article 40):
2. AGENZIA NAZIONALE PER I SERVIZI SANITARI REGIONALI (AGE.NA.S), established
in VIA PUGLIE 23, ROMA 00187, Italy,
3. STICHTING NEDERLANDS INSTITUUT VOOR ONDERZOEK VAN DE
GEZONDHEIDSZORG (NIVEL), established in OTTERSTRAAT 118-124, UTRECHT 3500 BN,
Netherlands, VAT number: NL007077191B01,
4. LIETUVOS RESPUBLIKOS SVEIKATOS APSAUGOS MINISTERIJA (MOH-LT),
established in VILNIAUS G 33, VILNIUS LT 01506, Lithuania,
5. SOTSIAALMINISTEERIUM (SM-EE), established in Suur-Ameerika 1, TALLINN 10122,
Estonia,
6. UNIVERSITETET I SOROST-NORGE (USN), established in KJOLNES RING 56,
PORSGRUNN 3918, Norway, VAT number: NO911770709MVA,
1
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
7. ISTITUTO REGIONALE PER IL SUPPORTOALLAE POLITICHE DELLA
LOMBARDIA (POLIS-LOMBARDIA) (PoliS-Lombardia), established in VIA TORQUATO
TARAMELLI 12/F, MILANO 20124, Italy, VAT number: IT07221390961,
Unless otherwise specified, references to ‘beneficiary’ or ‘beneficiaries’ include the coordinator.
The parties referred to above have agreed to enter into the Agreement under the terms and conditions
below.
By signing the Agreement or the Accession Form, the beneficiaries accept the grant and agree to
implement it under their own responsibility and in accordance with the Agreement, with all the
obligations and conditions it sets out.
The Agreement is composed of:
Terms and Conditions
Annex 1 Description of the action
Annex 2 Estimated budget for the action
Annex 2a Not applicable
Annex 3 Accession Forms
Annex 4 Model for the financial statements
Annex 5 Model for the certificate on the financial statements (CFS)
2
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1 GENERAL................................................................................................................................................8
ARTICLE 1 — SUBJECT OF THE AGREEMENT.........................................................................................8
CHAPTER 2 ACTION................................................................................................................................................... 8
ARTICLE 2 — ACTION TO BE IMPLEMENTED.........................................................................................8
ARTICLE 3 — DURATION AND STARTING DATE OF THE ACTION......................................................8
ARTICLE 4 — ESTIMATED BUDGET AND BUDGET TRANSFERS........................................................ 8
4.1 Estimated budget.................................................................................................................................. 8
4.2 Budget transfers....................................................................................................................................8
CHAPTER 3 GRANT.....................................................................................................................................................8
ARTICLE 5 — GRANT AMOUNT, FORM OF GRANT, REIMBURSEMENT RATE AND FORMS OF
COSTS..............................................................................................................................................8
5.1 Maximum grant amount....................................................................................................................... 8
5.2 Form of grant, reimbursement rate and forms of costs....................................................................... 8
5.3 Final grant amount — Calculation...................................................................................................... 9
5.4 Revised final grant amount — Calculation....................................................................................... 10
ARTICLE 6 — ELIGIBLE AND INELIGIBLE COSTS................................................................................11
6.1 General conditions for costs to be eligible........................................................................................ 11
6.2 Specific conditions for costs to be eligible........................................................................................11
6.3 Conditions for costs of affiliated entities to be eligible.....................................................................14
6.4 Ineligible costs....................................................................................................................................14
6.5 Consequences of declaration of ineligible costs................................................................................ 15
CHAPTER 4 RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS OF THE PARTIES........................................................................ 15
SECTION 1 RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS RELATED TO IMPLEMENTING THE ACTION................ 15
ARTICLE 7 — GENERAL OBLIGATION TO PROPERLY IMPLEMENT THE ACTION.........................15
7.1 General obligation to properly implement the action........................................................................ 15
7.2 Consequences of non-compliance...................................................................................................... 15
ARTICLE 8 — RESOURCES TO IMPLEMENT THE ACTION — THIRD PARTIES INVOLVED IN THE
ACTION.........................................................................................................................................16
ARTICLE 8a — IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTION TASKS BY BENEFICIARIES NOT RECEIVING EU
FUNDING...................................................................................................................................... 16
ARTICLE 9 — PURCHASE OF GOODS, WORKS OR SERVICES............................................................16
9.1 Rules for purchasing goods, works or services................................................................................. 16
3
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
9.2 Consequences of non-compliance...................................................................................................... 16
ARTICLE 10 — IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTION TASKS BY SUBCONTRACTORS............................17
10.1 Rules for subcontracting action tasks.............................................................................................. 17
10.2 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 17
ARTICLE 11 — IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTION TASKS BY AFFILIATED ENTITIES........................17
ARTICLE 11a — FINANCIAL SUPPORT TO THIRD PARTIES.................................................................18
SECTION 2 RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS RELATED TO THE GRANT ADMINISTRATION.............. 18
ARTICLE 12 — GENERAL OBLIGATION TO INFORM............................................................................18
12.1 General obligation to provide information upon request.................................................................18
12.2 Obligation to keep information up to date and to inform about events and circumstances likely to
affect the Agreement........................................................................................................................18
12.3 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 18
ARTICLE 13 — KEEPING RECORDS — SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION.........................................18
13.1 Obligation to keep records and other supporting documentation.................................................... 18
13.2 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 19
ARTICLE 14 — SUBMISSION OF DELIVERABLES................................................................................. 20
14.1 Obligation to submit deliverables.................................................................................................... 20
14.2 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 20
ARTICLE 15 — REPORTING — PAYMENT REQUESTS.......................................................................... 20
15.1 Obligation to submit reports............................................................................................................ 20
15.2 Reporting periods............................................................................................................................. 20
15.2a Request(s) for further pre-financing payment(s)............................................................................20
15.3 Periodic reports — Requests for interim payments.........................................................................20
15.4 Final report — Request for payment of the balance....................................................................... 22
15.5 Information on cumulative expenditure incurred.............................................................................22
15.6 Currency for financial statements and conversion into euro........................................................... 22
15.7 Language of reports..........................................................................................................................22
15.8 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 22
ARTICLE 16 — PAYMENTS AND PAYMENT ARRANGEMENTS...........................................................23
16.1 Payments to be made....................................................................................................................... 23
16.2 Pre-financing payment — Amount .................................................................................................23
16.3 Interim payments — Amount — Calculation..................................................................................23
16.4 Payment of the balance — Amount — Calculation........................................................................ 24
16.5 Notification of amounts due.............................................................................................................24
16.6 Currency for payments..................................................................................................................... 25
4
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
16.7 Payments to the coordinator — Distribution to the beneficiaries....................................................25
16.8 Bank account for payments..............................................................................................................25
16.9 Costs of payment transfers...............................................................................................................25
16.10 Date of payment............................................................................................................................. 25
16.11 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................. 25
ARTICLE 17 — CHECKS, REVIEWS, AUDITS AND INVESTIGATIONS — EXTENSION OF
FINDINGS..................................................................................................................................... 26
17.1 Checks, reviews and audits by the Agency and the Commission....................................................26
17.2 Investigations by the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF)............................................................28
17.3 Checks and audits by the European Court of Auditors (ECA)........................................................28
17.4 Checks, reviews, audits and investigations for international organisations..................................... 28
17.5 Consequences of findings in checks, reviews, audits and investigations — Extension of
findings............................................................................................................................................. 28
17.6 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 30
ARTICLE 18 — EVALUATION OF THE IMPACT OF THE ACTION....................................................... 30
18.1 Right to evaluate the impact of the action.......................................................................................30
18.2 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 30
SECTION 3 OTHER RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS.......................................................................................31
ARTICLE 19 — PRE-EXISTING RIGHTS AND OWNERSHIP OF THE RESULTS (INCLUDING
INTELLECTUAL AND INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY RIGHTS)................................................. 31
19.1 Pre-existing rights and access rights to pre-existing rights............................................................. 31
19.2 Ownership of results and rights of use............................................................................................ 31
19.3 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 31
ARTICLE 20 — CONFLICT OF INTERESTS.............................................................................................. 31
20.1 Obligation to avoid a conflict of interests....................................................................................... 31
20.2 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 31
ARTICLE 21 — CONFIDENTIALITY...........................................................................................................32
21.1 General obligation to maintain confidentiality................................................................................ 32
21.2 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 32
ARTICLE 22 — PROMOTING THE ACTION — VISIBILITY OF EU FUNDING....................................32
22.1 Communication activities by the beneficiaries................................................................................ 32
22.2 Communication activities by the Agency and the Commission...................................................... 33
22.3 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 34
ARTICLE 23 — PROCESSING OF PERSONAL DATA...............................................................................34
23.1 Processing of personal data by the Agency and the Commission................................................... 34
23.2 Processing of personal data by the beneficiaries............................................................................. 34
5
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
23.3 Consequences of non-compliance.................................................................................................... 35
ARTICLE 24 — ASSIGNMENTS OF CLAIMS FOR PAYMENT AGAINST THE AGENCY....................35
CHAPTER 5 DIVISION OF BENEFICIARIES’ ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES....................................... 35
ARTICLE 25 — DIVISION OF BENEFICIARIES’ ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES............................35
25.1 Roles and responsibilities towards the Agency............................................................................... 35
25.2 Internal division of roles and responsibilities.................................................................................. 35
25.3 Internal arrangements between beneficiaries — Consortium agreement.........................................36
CHAPTER 6 REJECTION OF COSTS — REDUCTION OF THE GRANT — RECOVERY — SANCTIONS
— DAMAGES — SUSPENSION — TERMINATION — FORCE MAJEURE................................ 37
SECTION 1 REJECTION OF COSTS — REDUCTION OF THE GRANT — RECOVERY —
SANCTIONS.............................................................................................................................................. 37
ARTICLE 26 — REJECTION OF INELIGIBLE COSTS.............................................................................. 37
26.1 Conditions......................................................................................................................................... 37
26.2 Ineligible costs to be rejected — Calculation — Procedure............................................................37
26.3 Effects............................................................................................................................................... 37
ARTICLE 27 — REDUCTION OF THE GRANT......................................................................................... 38
27.1 Conditions......................................................................................................................................... 38
27.2 Amount to be reduced — Calculation — Procedure.......................................................................38
27.3 Effects............................................................................................................................................... 38
ARTICLE 28 — RECOVERY OF UNDUE AMOUNTS............................................................................... 39
28.1 Amount to be recovered — Calculation — Procedure....................................................................39
ARTICLE 29 — ADMINISTRATIVE SANCTIONS..................................................................................... 41
SECTION 2 LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES.........................................................................................................41
ARTICLE 30 — LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES.............................................................................................41
30.1 Liability of the Agency.................................................................................................................... 41
30.2 Liability of the beneficiaries............................................................................................................ 41
SECTION 3 SUSPENSION AND TERMINATION............................................................................................41
ARTICLE 31 — SUSPENSION OF PAYMENT DEADLINE....................................................................... 41
31.1 Conditions......................................................................................................................................... 41
31.2 Procedure.......................................................................................................................................... 42
ARTICLE 32 — SUSPENSION OF PAYMENTS.......................................................................................... 42
32.1 Conditions......................................................................................................................................... 42
32.2 Procedure.......................................................................................................................................... 42
ARTICLE 33 — SUSPENSION OF THE ACTION IMPLEMENTATION................................................... 43
33.1 Suspension of the action implementation, by the beneficiaries.......................................................43
33.2 Suspension of the action implementation, by the Agency...............................................................43
6
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
ARTICLE 34 — TERMINATION OF THE AGREEMENT OR OF THE PARTICIPATION OF ONE OR
MORE BENEFICIARIES..............................................................................................................45
34.1 Termination of the Agreement, by the beneficiaries........................................................................45
34.2 Termination of the participation of one or more beneficiaries, by the beneficiaries........................45
34.3 Termination of the Agreement or of the participation of one or more beneficiaries, by the
Agency..............................................................................................................................................46
SECTION 4 FORCE MAJEURE.......................................................................................................................... 49
ARTICLE 35 — FORCE MAJEURE.............................................................................................................. 49
CHAPTER 7 FINAL PROVISIONS...........................................................................................................................50
ARTICLE 36 — COMMUNICATION BETWEEN THE PARTIES...............................................................50
36.1 Form and means of communication.................................................................................................50
36.2 Date of communication.................................................................................................................... 50
36.3 Addresses for communication.......................................................................................................... 50
ARTICLE 37 — INTERPRETATION OF THE AGREEMENT.....................................................................51
37.1 Precedence of the Terms and Conditions over the Annexes............................................................51
37.2 Privileges and immunities................................................................................................................ 51
ARTICLE 38 — CALCULATION OF PERIODS, DATES AND DEADLINES........................................... 51
ARTICLE 39 — AMENDMENTS TO THE AGREEMENT......................................................................... 51
39.1 Conditions......................................................................................................................................... 51
39.2 Procedure.......................................................................................................................................... 51
ARTICLE 40 — ACCESSION TO THE AGREEMENT............................................................................... 52
40.1 Accession of the beneficiaries mentioned in the preamble..............................................................52
40.2 Addition of new beneficiaries.......................................................................................................... 52
ARTICLE 41 — APPLICABLE LAW AND SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES.............................................. 53
41.1 Applicable law..................................................................................................................................53
41.2 Dispute settlement............................................................................................................................ 53
ARTICLE 42 — ENTRY INTO FORCE OF THE AGREEMENT................................................................ 53
7
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
CHAPTER 1 GENERAL
ARTICLE 1 — SUBJECT OF THE AGREEMENT
This Agreement sets out the rights and obligations and the terms and conditions applicable to the grant
awarded to the beneficiaries for implementing the action set out in Chapter 2.
CHAPTER 2 ACTION
ARTICLE 2 — ACTION TO BE IMPLEMENTED
The grant is awarded for the action entitled ‘Empowering EU health policies on Task SHIfting —
TaSHI’ (‘action’), as described in Annex 1.
ARTICLE 3 — DURATION AND STARTING DATE OF THE ACTION
The duration of the action will be 36 months as of 01/04/2021 (‘starting date of the action’).
ARTICLE 4 — ESTIMATED BUDGET AND BUDGET TRANSFERS
4.1 Estimated budget
The ‘estimated budget’ for the action is set out in Annex 2.
It contains the estimated eligible costs and the forms of costs, broken down by beneficiary and budget
category (see Articles 5, 6).
4.2 Budget transfers
The estimated budget breakdown indicated in Annex 2 may be adjusted — without an amendment
(see Article 39) — by transfers of amounts between beneficiaries, budget categories and/or forms of
costs set out in Annex 2, if the action is implemented as described in Annex 1.
However, the beneficiaries may not add costs relating to subcontracts not provided for in Annex 1,
unless such additional subcontracts are approved by an amendment or in accordance with Article 10.
CHAPTER 3 GRANT
ARTICLE 5 — GRANT AMOUNT, FORM OF GRANT, REIMBURSEMENT RATE AND
FORMS OF COSTS
5.1 Maximum grant amount
The ‘maximum grant amount’ is EUR 389 668.00 (three hundred and eighty nine thousand six
hundred and sixty eight EURO).
5.2 Form of grant, reimbursement rate and forms of costs
8
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
The grant reimburses 60% of the action's eligible costs (see Article 6) (‘reimbursement of eligible
costs grant’) (see Annex 2).
The estimated eligible costs of the action are EUR 649 448.27 (six hundred and forty nine thousand
four hundred and forty eight EURO and twenty seven eurocents).
Eligible costs (see Article 6) must be declared under the following forms ('forms of costs' or 'costs
forms'):
(a) for direct personnel costs: as actually incurred costs (actual costs);
(b) for direct costs of subcontracting: as actually incurred costs (actual costs);
(c) for other direct costs: as actually incurred costs (actual costs);
(d) for indirect costs: on the basis of a flat-rate applied as set out in Article 6.2.D (‘flat-rate costs’);
5.3 Final grant amount — Calculation
The ‘final grant amount’ depends on the actual extent to which the action is implemented in
accordance with the Agreement’s terms and conditions.
This amount is calculated by the Agency — when the payment of the balance is made — in the
following steps:
Step 1 – Application of the reimbursement rate to the eligible costs
Step 2 – Limit to the maximum grant amount
Step 3 – Reduction due to the no-profit rule
Step 4 – Reduction due to substantial errors, irregularities or fraud or serious breach of obligations
5.3.1 Step 1 — Application of the reimbursement rate to the eligible costs
The reimbursement rate (see Article 5.2) is applied to the eligible costs (actual costs and flat-rate
costs; see Article 6) declared by the beneficiaries (see Article 15) and approved by the Agency (see
Article 16).
5.3.2 Step 2 — Limit to the maximum grant amount
If the amount obtained following Step 1 is higher than the maximum grant amount set out in
Article 5.1, it will be limited to the latter.
5.3.3 Step 3 — Reduction due to the no-profit rule
The grant must not produce a profit.
‘Profit’ means the surplus of the amount obtained following Steps 1 and 2 plus the action’s total
receipts, over the action’s total eligible costs.
The ‘action’s total eligible costs’ are the consolidated total eligible costs approved by the Agency.
9
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
The ‘action’s total receipts’ are the consolidated total receipts generated during its duration (see
Article 3).
The following are considered receipts:
(a) income generated by the action;
(b) financial contributions given by third parties to the beneficiary specifically to be used for costs
that are eligible under the action.
The following are however not considered receipts:
(a) financial contributions by third parties, if they may be used to cover costs other than the eligible
costs (see Article 6);
(b) financial contributions by third parties with no obligation to repay any amount unused at the
end of the period set out in Article 3.
If there is a profit, it will be deducted in proportion to the final rate of reimbursement of the eligible
actual costs approved by the Agency (as compared to the amount calculated following Steps 1 and 2).
5.3.4 Step 4 — Reduction due to substantial errors, irregularities or fraud or serious breach
of obligations
If the grant is reduced (see Article 27), the Agency will calculate the reduced grant amount by
deducting the amount of the reduction (calculated in proportion to the seriousness of the errors,
irregularities or fraud or breach of obligations, in accordance with Article 27.2) from the maximum
grant amount set out in Article 5.1.
The final grant amount will be the lower of the following two:
- the amount obtained following Steps 1 to 3 or
- the reduced grant amount following Step 4.
5.4 Revised final grant amount — Calculation
If — after the payment of the balance (in particular, after checks, reviews, audits or investigations;
see Article 17) — the Agency rejects costs (see Article 26) or reduces the grant (see Article 27), it
will calculate the ‘revised final grant amount’ for the action or for the beneficiary concerned.
This amount is calculated by the Agency on the basis of the findings, as follows:
- in case of rejection of costs: by applying the reimbursement rate to the revised eligible costs
approved by the Agency for the beneficiary concerned;
- in case of reduction of the grant: by deducting the amount of the reduction (calculated in
proportion to the seriousness of the errors, irregularities or fraud or breach of obligations, in
accordance with Article 27.2) from the maximum grant amount set out in Article 5.1 or from the
maximum EU contribution indicated for the beneficiary in the estimated budget (see Annex 2).
In case of rejection of costs and reduction of the grant, the revised final grant amount will be the
lower of the two amounts above.
10
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
ARTICLE 6 — ELIGIBLE AND INELIGIBLE COSTS
6.1 General conditions for costs to be eligible
‘Eligible costs’ are costs that meet the following criteria:
(a) for actual costs:
(i) they must be actually incurred by the beneficiary;
(ii) they must be incurred in the period set out in Article 3, with the exception of costs relating
to the submission of the periodic report for the last reporting period and the final report
(see Article 15);
(iii) they must be indicated in the estimated budget set out in Annex 2;
(iv) they must be incurred in connection with the action as described in Annex 1 and necessary
for its implementation;
(v) they must be identifiable and verifiable, in particular recorded in the beneficiary’s accounts
in accordance with the accounting standards applicable in the country where the beneficiary
is established and with the beneficiary’s usual cost accounting practices;
(vi) they must comply with the applicable national law on taxes, labour and social security, and
(vii) they must be reasonable, justified and must comply with the principle of sound financial
management, in particular regarding economy and efficiency;
(b) for unit costs: not applicable;
(c) for flat-rate costs:
(i) they must be calculated by applying the flat-rate set out in Annex 2, and
(ii) the costs (actual costs) to which the flat-rate is applied must comply with the conditions for
eligibility set out in this Article.
(d) for lump sum costs: not applicable;
6.2 Specific conditions for costs to be eligible
Costs are eligible if they comply with the general conditions (see above) and the specific conditions
set out below, for each of the following budget categories:
A. direct personnel costs;
B. direct costs of subcontracting;
C. other direct costs;
D. indirect costs;
‘Direct costs’ are costs that are directly linked to the action implementation and can therefore be
attributed to it directly. They must not include any indirect costs (see Point D below).
11
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
‘Indirect costs’ are costs that are not directly linked to the action implementation and therefore cannot
be attributed directly to it.
A. Direct personnel costs
Types of eligible personnel costs
A.1 Personnel costs are eligible if they are related to personnel working for the beneficiary under an
employment contract (or equivalent appointing act) and assigned to the action (‘costs for employees
(or equivalent)’). They must be limited to salaries, social security contributions, taxes and other
costs included in the remuneration, if they arise from national law or the employment contract (or
equivalent appointing act).
They may also include additional remuneration for personnel assigned to the action (including
payments on the basis of supplementary contracts regardless of their nature), if:
(a) it is part of the beneficiary’s usual remuneration practices and is paid in a consistent manner
whenever the same kind of work or expertise is required;
(b) the criteria used to calculate the supplementary payments are objective and generally applied
by the beneficiary, regardless of the source of funding used.
A.2 The costs for natural persons working under a direct contract with the beneficiary other than
an employment contract or seconded by a third party against payment are eligible personnel costs,
if:
(a) the person works under the beneficiary’s instructions and, unless otherwise agreed with the
beneficiary, on the beneficiary’s premises;
(b) the result of the work carried out belongs to the beneficiary, and
(c) the costs are not significantly different from those for personnel performing similar tasks under
an employment contract with the beneficiary.
Calculation
Personnel costs must be calculated by the beneficiaries as follows:
- for persons working exclusively on the action:
{monthly rate for the person
multiplied by
number of actual months worked on the action}.
The months declared for these persons may not be declared for any other EU or Euratom grant.
The ‘monthly rate’ is calculated as follows:
{annual personnel costs for the person
divided by
12}
12
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
using the personnel costs for each full financial year covered by the reporting period concerned.
If a financial year is not closed at the end of the reporting period, the beneficiaries must use the
monthly rate of the last closed financial year available.
- for all other persons:
{daily rate for the person
multiplied by
number of actual days worked on the action (rounded up or down to the nearest half-day)}.
The number of actual days declared for a person must be identifiable and verifiable (see
Article 13).
The total number of days declared in EU or Euratom grants, for a person for a year, cannot be
higher than the annual productive days used for the calculations of the daily rate. Therefore,
the maximum number of days that can be declared for the grant are:
{number of annual productive days for the year (see below)
minus
total number of days declared by the beneficiary, for that person for that year, for other EU or Euratom
grants}.
The ‘daily rate’ is calculated as follows:
{annual personnel costs for the person
divided by
number of individual annual productive days}
using the personnel costs and the number of annual productive days for each full financial
year covered by the reporting period concerned. If a financial year is not closed at the end of
the reporting period, the beneficiaries must use the daily rate of the last closed financial year
available.
The ‘number of individual annual productive days’ is the total actual days worked by the person
in the year. It may not include holidays and other absences (such as sick leave, maternity leave,
special leave, etc). However, it may include overtime and time spent in meetings, trainings and
other similar activities.
B. Direct costs of subcontracting (including related duties, taxes and charges, such as non-
deductible value added tax (VAT) paid by beneficiaries that are not public bodies acting as public
authority) are eligible if the conditions in Article 10.1.1 are met.
C. Other direct costs
C.1 Travel costs and related subsistence allowances (including related duties, taxes and charges,
such as non-deductible value added tax (VAT) paid by beneficiaries that are not public bodies acting
as public authority) are eligible if they are in line with the beneficiary’s usual practices on travel.
C.2 The depreciation costs of equipment, infrastructure or other assets (new or second-hand)
as recorded in the beneficiary’s accounts are eligible, if they were purchased in accordance
13
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
with Article 9.1.1 and written off in accordance with international accounting standards and the
beneficiary’s usual accounting practices.
The costs of renting or leasing equipment, infrastructure or other assets (including related duties,
taxes and charges, such as non-deductible value added tax (VAT) paid by beneficiaries that are not
public bodies acting as public authority) are also eligible, if they do not exceed the depreciation costs
of similar equipment, infrastructure or assets and do not include any financing fees.
The only portion of the costs that will be taken into account is that which corresponds to the duration
of the action and rate of actual use for the purposes of the action.
C.3 Costs of other goods and services (including related duties, taxes and charges, such as non-
deductible value added tax (VAT) paid by beneficiaries that are not public bodies acting as public
authority) are eligible, if they are purchased specifically for the action and in accordance with
Article 9.1.1.
Such goods and services include, for instance, consumables and supplies, dissemination, protection
of results, certificates on the financial statements (if they are required by the Agreement), translations
and publications.
D. Indirect costs
Indirect costs are eligible if they are declared on the basis of the flat-rate of 7% of the eligible direct
costs (see Article 5.2 and Points A to C above).
Beneficiaries receiving an operating grant1 financed by the EU or Euratom budget cannot declare
indirect costs for the period covered by the operating grant.
6.3 Conditions for costs of affiliated entities to be eligible
not applicable
6.4 Ineligible costs
‘Ineligible costs’ are:
(a) costs that do not comply with the conditions set out above (Article 6.1 to 6.3), in particular:
(i) costs related to return on capital;
(ii) debt and debt service charges;
(iii) provisions for future losses or debts;
(iv) interest owed;
1 For the definition, see Article 121(1)(b) of Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 966/2012 of the European Parliament and
of the Council of 25 October 2012 on the financial rules applicable to the general budget of the Union and repealing
Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No 1605/2002 (OJ L 218, 26.10.2012, p.1) (‘Financial Regulation No 966/2012’):
‘operating grant’ means direct financial contribution, by way of donation, from the budget in order to finance the
functioning of a body which pursues an aim of general EU interest or has an objective forming part of and supporting
an EU policy.
14
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
(v) doubtful debts;
(vi) currency exchange losses;
(vii) bank costs charged by the beneficiary’s bank for transfers from the Agency;
(viii) excessive or reckless expenditure;
(ix) deductible VAT;
(x) costs incurred during suspension of the implementation of the action (see Article 33);
(xi) in-kind contributions provided by third parties;
(b) costs declared under another EU or Euratom grant (including grants awarded by a Member
State and financed by the EU or Euratom budget and grants awarded by bodies other than the
Agency for the purpose of implementing the EU or Euratom budget); in particular, indirect
costs if the beneficiary is already receiving an operating grant financed by the EU or Euratom
budget in the same period;
(c) costs for staff of a national (or local) administration, for activities that are part of the
administration’s normal activities (i.e. not undertaken only because of the grant);
(d) costs (especially travel and subsistence costs) for staff or representatives of EU institutions,
bodies or agencies.
6.5 Consequences of declaration of ineligible costs
Declared costs that are ineligible will be rejected (see Article 26).
This may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
CHAPTER 4 RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS OF THE PARTIES
SECTION 1 RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS RELATED TO IMPLEMENTING THE
ACTION
ARTICLE 7 — GENERAL OBLIGATION TO PROPERLY IMPLEMENT THE ACTION
7.1 General obligation to properly implement the action
The beneficiaries must implement the action as described in Annex 1 and in compliance with the
provisions of the Agreement and all legal obligations under applicable EU, international and national
law.
7.2 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under this Article, the grant may be reduced (see
Article 27).
15
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 8 — RESOURCES TO IMPLEMENT THE ACTION — THIRD PARTIES
INVOLVED IN THE ACTION
The beneficiaries must have the appropriate resources to implement the action.
If it is necessary to implement the action, the beneficiaries may:
- purchase goods, works and services (see Article 9);
- call upon subcontractors to implement action tasks described in Annex 1 (see Article 10);
- call upon affiliated entities to implement action tasks described in Annex 1 (see Article 11).
In these cases, the beneficiaries retain sole responsibility towards the Agency and the other
beneficiaries for implementing the action.
ARTICLE 8a — IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTION TASKS BY BENEFICIARIES NOT
RECEIVING EU FUNDING
Not applicable
ARTICLE 9 — PURCHASE OF GOODS, WORKS OR SERVICES
9.1 Rules for purchasing goods, works or services
9.1.1 If necessary to implement the action, the beneficiaries may purchase goods, works or services.
The beneficiaries must make such purchases ensuring the best value for money or, if appropriate, the
lowest price. In doing so, they must avoid any conflict of interests (see Article 20).
The beneficiaries must ensure that the Agency, the Commission, the European Court of Auditors
(ECA) and the European Anti-fraud Office (OLAF) can exercise their rights under Articles 17 and
18 also towards their contractors.
9.1.2 Beneficiaries that are ‘contracting authorities’ within the meaning of Directive 2004/18/EC2 (or
2014/24/EU3) or ‘contracting entities’ within the meaning of Directive 2004/17/EC4 (or 2014/25/EU5)
must comply with the applicable national law on public procurement.
9.2 Consequences of non-compliance
2 Directive 2004/18/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 31 March 2004 on the coordination of
procedures for the award of public work contracts, public supply contracts and public service contracts (OJ L 134,
30.04.2004, p. 114).
3 Directive 2014/24/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 February 2014 on public procurement and
repealing Directive 2004/18/EC (OJ L 94, 28.3.2014, p. 65).
4 Directive 2004/17/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 31 March 2004 coordinating the procurement
procedures of entities operating in the water, energy, transport and postal services sectors (OJ L 134, 30.04.2004, p. 1).
5 Directive 2014/25/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 February 2014 on procurement by entities
operating in the water, energy, transport and postal services sectors and repealing Directive 2004/17/EC (OJ L 94,
28.3.2014, p. 243).
16
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article 9.1.1, the costs related to the contract
concerned will be ineligible (see Article 6) and will be rejected (see Article 26).
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article 9.1.2, the grant may be reduced (see
Article 27).
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 10 — IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTION TASKS BY SUBCONTRACTORS
10.1 Rules for subcontracting action tasks
10.1.1 If necessary to implement the action, the beneficiaries may award subcontracts covering the
implementation of certain action tasks described in Annex 1.
Subcontracting may cover only a limited part of the action.
The beneficiaries must award the subcontracts ensuring the best value for money or, if appropriate,
the lowest price. In doing so, they must avoid any conflict of interests (see Article 20).
The tasks to be implemented and the estimated cost for each subcontract must be set out in Annex
1 and the total estimated costs of subcontracting per beneficiary must be set out in Annex 2. The
Agency may however approve subcontracts not set out in Annex 1 and 2 without amendment (see
Article 39), if:
- they are specifically justified in the periodic technical report and
- they do not entail changes to the Agreement which would call into question the decision
awarding the grant or breach the principle of equal treatment of applicants.
The beneficiaries must ensure that the Agency, the Commission, the European Court of Auditors
(ECA) and the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) can exercise their rights under Articles 17 and
18 also towards their subcontractors.
10.1.2 The beneficiaries must ensure that their obligations under Articles 20, 21, 22 and 30 also apply
to the subcontractors.
Beneficiaries that are ‘contracting authorities’ within the meaning of Directive 2004/18/EC (or
2014/24/EU) or ‘contracting entities’ within the meaning of Directive 2004/17/EC (or 2014/25/EU)
must comply with the applicable national law on public procurement.
10.2 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article 10.1.1, the costs related to the subcontract
concerned will be ineligible (see Article 6) and will be rejected (see Article 26).
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article 10.1.2, the grant may be reduced (see
Article 27).
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 11 — IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTION TASKS BY AFFILIATED ENTITIES
17
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
Not applicable
ARTICLE 11a — FINANCIAL SUPPORT TO THIRD PARTIES
Not applicable
SECTION 2 RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS RELATED TO THE GRANT
ADMINISTRATION
ARTICLE 12 — GENERAL OBLIGATION TO INFORM
12.1 General obligation to provide information upon request
The beneficiaries must provide — during implementation of the action or afterwards and in accordance
with Article 25.2 — any information requested in order to verify eligibility of the costs, proper
implementation of the action and compliance with any other obligation under the Agreement.
12.2 Obligation to keep information up to date and to inform about events and
circumstances likely to affect the Agreement
Each beneficiary must keep information stored in the Participant Portal Beneficiary Register (via
the electronic exchange system; see Article 36) up to date, in particular, its name, address, legal
representatives, legal form and organisation type.
Each beneficiary must immediately inform the coordinator — which must immediately inform the
Agency and the other beneficiaries — of any of the following:
(a) events which are likely to affect significantly or delay the implementation of the action or the
EU’s financial interests, in particular:
(i) changes in its legal, financial, technical, organisational or ownership situation
(b) circumstances affecting:
(i) the decision to award the grant or
(ii) compliance with requirements under the Agreement.
12.3 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under this Article, the grant may be reduced (see
Article 27).
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 13 — KEEPING RECORDS — SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION
13.1 Obligation to keep records and other supporting documentation
The beneficiaries must — for a period of five years after the payment of the balance — keep records
18
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
and other supporting documentation, in order to prove the proper implementation of the action and
the costs they declare as eligible.
They must make them available upon request (see Article 12) or in the context of checks, reviews,
audits or investigations (see Article 17).
If there are on-going checks, reviews, audits, investigations, litigation or other pursuits of claims under
the Agreement (including the extension of findings; see Article 17), the beneficiaries must keep the
records and other supporting documentation until the end of these procedures.
The beneficiaries must keep the original documents. Digital and digitalised documents are considered
originals if they are authorised by the applicable national law. The Agency may accept non-original
documents if it considers that they offer a comparable level of assurance.
13.1.1 Records and other supporting documentation on the technical implementation
The beneficiaries must keep records and other supporting documentation on the technical
implementation of the action, in line with the accepted standards in the respective field.
13.1.2 Records and other documentation to support the costs declared
The beneficiaries must keep the records and documentation supporting the costs declared, in particular
the following:
(a) for actual costs: adequate records and other supporting documentation to prove the costs
declared, such as contracts, subcontracts, invoices and accounting records. In addition, the
beneficiaries’ usual cost accounting practices and internal control procedures must enable direct
reconciliation between the amounts declared, the amounts recorded in their accounts and the
amounts stated in the supporting documentation;
(b) for unit costs: not applicable;
(c) for flat-rate costs: adequate records and other supporting documentation to prove the eligibility
of the costs to which the flat-rate is applied. The beneficiaries do not need to identify the costs
covered or provide supporting documentation (such as accounting statements) to prove the
amount declared at a flat-rate;
(d) for lump sum costs: not applicable;
In addition, for personnel costs (declared as actual costs), the beneficiaries must keep time records
for the number of days declared. The time records must be in writing and approved by the persons
working on the action and their supervisors, at least monthly. In the absence of reliable time records
of the days worked on the action, the Agency may accept alternative evidence supporting the number
of days declared, if it considers that it offers an adequate level of assurance.
As an exception, for persons working exclusively on the action, there is no need to keep time records,
if the beneficiary signs a declaration confirming that the persons concerned have worked exclusively
on the action.
13.2 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under this Article, costs insufficiently substantiated
19
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
will be ineligible (see Article 6) and will be rejected (see Article 26), and the grant may be reduced
(see Article 27).
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 14 — SUBMISSION OF DELIVERABLES
14.1 Obligation to submit deliverables
The coordinator must submit the ‘deliverables’ identified in Annex 1, in accordance with the timing
and conditions set out in it.
14.2 Consequences of non-compliance
If the coordinator breaches any of its obligations under this Article, the Agency may apply any of the
measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 15 — REPORTING — PAYMENT REQUESTS
15.1 Obligation to submit reports
The coordinator must submit to the Agency (see Article 36) the technical and financial report(s) set
out in this Article. These reports include request(s) for payment and must be drawn up using the forms
and templates provided in the electronic exchange system (see Article 36).
15.2 Reporting periods
The action is divided into the following ‘reporting periods’:
- RP1: from month 1 to month 18
- RP2: from month 19 to month 36
15.2a Request(s) for further pre-financing payment(s)
Not applicable
15.3 Periodic reports — Requests for interim payments
The coordinator must submit a periodic report within 60 days following the end of each reporting
period.
The periodic report must include the following:
(a) a ‘periodic technical report’ containing:
(i) an explanation of the work carried out by the beneficiaries;
(ii) an overview of the progress towards the objectives of the action, including milestones
and deliverables identified in Annex 1.
This report must include explanations justifying the differences between work expected
to be carried out in accordance with Annex 1 and that actually carried out;
20
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
(iii) a summary for publication by the Agency;
(iv) the answers to the ‘questionnaire’: covering issues related to the action implementation
and its impact;
(b) a ‘periodic financial report’ containing:
(i) an ‘individual financial statement’ (see Annex 4) from each beneficiary, for the
reporting period concerned.
The individual financial statement must detail the eligible costs (actual costs and flat-rate
costs; see Article 6) for each budget category (see Annex 2).
The beneficiaries must declare all eligible costs, even if — for actual costs and flat-
rate costs — they exceed the amounts indicated in the estimated budget (see Annex 2).
Amounts which are not declared in the individual financial statement will not be taken
into account by the Agency.
If an individual financial statement is not submitted for a reporting period, it may be
included in the periodic financial report for the next reporting period.
The individual financial statements of the last reporting period must also detail the
receipts of the action (see Article 5.3.3).
Each beneficiary must certify that:
- the information provided is full, reliable and true;
- the costs declared are eligible (see Article 6);
- the costs can be substantiated by adequate records and supporting documentation
(see Article 13) that will be produced upon request (see Article 12) or in the context
of checks, reviews, audits and investigations (see Article 17), and
- for the last reporting period: that all the receipts have been declared (see
Article 5.3.3);
(ii) an explanation of the use of resources and the information on subcontracting (see
Article 10) from each beneficiary, for the reporting period concerned;
(iii) not applicable;
(iv) a ‘periodic summary financial statement’, created automatically by the electronic
exchange system, consolidating the individual financial statements for the reporting
period concerned and including — except for the last reporting period — the request
for interim payment;
(v) a ‘certificate on the financial statements’ (drawn up in accordance with Annex 5) for
each beneficiary, if:
- the (cumulative) amount of EU contribution it requests as reimbursement of actual
21
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
costs (and for which no certificate has yet been submitted) is EUR 150 000 or
more and
- the maximum EU contribution indicated, for that beneficiary, in the estimated
budget (see Annex 2) as reimbursement of actual costs is EUR 200 000 or more.
15.4 Final report — Request for payment of the balance
In addition to the periodic report for the last reporting period, the coordinator must submit the final
report within 60 days following the end of the last reporting period.
The final report must include the following:
(a) a ‘final technical report’ with a summary for publication containing:
(i) an overview of the results and their dissemination;
(ii) the conclusions on the action and
(iii) the impact of the action;
(b) a ‘final financial report’ containing a ‘final summary financial statement’, created
automatically by the electronic exchange system, consolidating the individual financial
statements for all reporting periods and including the request for payment of the balance.
15.5 Information on cumulative expenditure incurred
Not applicable
15.6 Currency for financial statements and conversion into euro
Financial statements must be drafted in euro.
Beneficiaries with accounting established in a currency other than the euro must convert the costs
recorded in their accounts into euro at the average of the daily exchange rates published in the C series
of the Official Journal of the European Union, calculated over the corresponding reporting period.
If no daily euro exchange rate is published in the Official Journal of the European Union for the
currency in question, they must be converted at the average of the monthly accounting rates published
on the Commission’s website, calculated over the corresponding reporting period.
Beneficiaries with accounting established in euro must convert costs incurred in another currency into
euro according to their usual accounting practices.
15.7 Language of reports
All report(s) (including financial statements) must be submitted in the language of the Agreement.
15.8 Consequences of non-compliance
If the report(s) submitted do not comply with this Article, the Agency may suspend the payment
deadline (see Article 31) and apply any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
22
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
If the coordinator breaches its obligation to submit the report(s) and if it fails to comply with this
obligation within 30 days following a written reminder, the Agency may terminate the Agreement
(see Article 34) or apply any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 16 — PAYMENTS AND PAYMENT ARRANGEMENTS
16.1 Payments to be made
The following payments will be made to the coordinator:
- a pre-financing payment;
- one or more interim payments, on the basis of the request(s) for interim payment (see
Article 15), and
- one payment of the balance, on the basis of the request for payment of the balance (see
Article 15).
16.2 Pre-financing payment — Amount
The aim of the pre-financing is to provide the beneficiaries with a float.
It remains the property of the EU until the payment of the balance.
The amount of the pre-financing payment will be EUR 194 834.00 (one hundred and ninety four
thousand eight hundred and thirty four EURO).
The Agency will — except if Article 32 applies — make the pre-financing payment to the coordinator
within 30 days, either from the entry into force of the Agreement (see Article 42) or from 10 days
before the starting date of the action (see Article 3) , whichever is the latest.
16.3 Interim payments — Amount — Calculation
Interim payments reimburse the eligible costs incurred for the implementation of the action during
the corresponding reporting periods.
The Agency will pay to the coordinator the amount due as interim payment within 90 days from
receiving the periodic report (see Article 15.3), except if Articles 31 or 32 apply.
Payment is subject to the approval of the periodic report. Its approval does not imply recognition of
compliance, authenticity, completeness or correctness of its content.
The amount due as interim payment is calculated by the Agency in the following steps:
Step 1 – Application of the reimbursement rate
Step 2 – Limit to 90% of the maximum grant amount
16.3.1 Step 1 — Application of the reimbursement rate
The reimbursement rate (see Article 5.2) is applied to the eligible costs (actual costs and flat-rate costs;
see Article 6) declared by the beneficiaries (see Article 15) and approved by the Agency (see above)
for the concerned reporting period.
23
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
16.3.2 Step 2 — Limit to 90% of the maximum grant amount
The total amount of pre-financing and interim payments must not exceed 90% of the maximum grant
amount set out in Article 5.1. The maximum amount for the interim payment will be calculated as
follows:
{90% of the maximum grant amount (see Article 5.1)
minus
{pre-financing and previous interim payments}}.
16.4 Payment of the balance — Amount — Calculation
The payment of the balance reimburses the remaining part of the eligible costs incurred by the
beneficiaries for the implementation of the action.
If the total amount of earlier payments is greater than the final grant amount (see Article 5.3), the
payment of the balance takes the form of a recovery (see Article 28).
If the total amount of earlier payments is lower than the final grant amount, the Agency will pay the
balance within 90 days from receiving the final report (see Article 15.4), except if Articles 31 or 32
apply.
Payment is subject to the approval of the final report. Its approval does not imply recognition of
compliance, authenticity, completeness or correctness of its content.
The amount due as the balance is calculated by the Agency by deducting the total amount of pre-
financing and interim payments (if any) already made, from the final grant amount determined in
accordance with Article 5.3:
{final grant amount (see Article 5.3)
minus
{pre-financing and interim payments (if any) made}}.
If the balance is positive, it will be paid to the coordinator.
The amount to be paid may however be offset — without the beneficiaries’ consent — against any
other amount owed by a beneficiary to the Agency, the Commission or another executive agency
(under the EU or Euratom budget), up to the maximum EU contribution indicated, for that beneficiary,
in the estimated budget (see Annex 2).
If the balance is negative, it will be recovered from the coordinator (see Article 28).
16.5 Notification of amounts due
When making payments, the Agency will formally notify to the coordinator the amount due,
specifying that it concerns an interim payment or the payment of the balance.
For the payment of the balance, the notification will also specify the final grant amount.
24
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
In the case of reduction of the grant or recovery of undue amounts, the notification will be preceded
by the contradictory procedure set out in Articles 27 and 28.
16.6 Currency for payments
The Agency will make all payments in euro.
16.7 Payments to the coordinator — Distribution to the beneficiaries
Payments will be made to the coordinator.
Payments to the coordinator will discharge the Agency from its payment obligation.
The coordinator must distribute the payments between the beneficiaries without unjustified delay.
Pre-financing may however be distributed only:
(a) if 90% of the beneficiaries have acceded to the Agreement (see Article 40) and
(b) to beneficiaries that have acceded to the Agreement (see Article 40).
16.8 Bank account for payments
All payments will be made to the following bank account:
Name of bank: HUNGARIAN STATE TREASURY
Full name of the account holder: SEMMELWEIS EGYETEM
Full account number (including bank codes):
IBAN code: HU51100320000028281900000000
16.9 Costs of payment transfers
The cost of the payment transfers is borne as follows:
- the Agency bears the cost of transfers charged by its bank;
- the beneficiary bears the cost of transfers charged by its bank;
- the party causing a repetition of a transfer bears all costs of the repeated transfer.
16.10 Date of payment
Payments by the Agency are considered to have been carried out on the date when they are debited
to its account.
16.11 Consequences of non-compliance
16.11.1 If the Agency does not pay within the payment deadlines (see above), the beneficiaries are
entitled to late-payment interest at the rate applied by the European Central Bank (ECB) for its main
refinancing operations in euros (‘reference rate’), plus three and a half points. The reference rate is
the rate in force on the first day of the month in which the payment deadline expires, as published in
the C series of the Official Journal of the European Union.
25
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
If the late-payment interest is lower than or equal to EUR 200, it will be paid to the coordinator only
upon request submitted within two months of receiving the late payment.
Late-payment interest is not due if all beneficiaries are EU Member States (including regional and
local government authorities or other public bodies acting on behalf of a Member State for the purpose
of this Agreement).
Suspension of the payment deadline or payments (see Articles 31 and 32) will not be considered as
late payment.
Late-payment interest covers the period running from the day following the due date for payment (see
above), up to and including the date of payment.
Late-payment interest is not considered for the purposes of calculating the final grant amount.
16.11.2 If the coordinator breaches any of its obligations under this Article, the grant may be reduced
(see Article 27) and the Agreement or the participation of the coordinator may be terminated (see
Article 34).
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 17 — CHECKS, REVIEWS, AUDITS AND INVESTIGATIONS — EXTENSION
OF FINDINGS
17.1 Checks, reviews and audits by the Agency and the Commission
17.1.1 Right to carry out checks
The Agency or the Commission will — during the implementation of the action or afterwards — check
the proper implementation of the action and compliance with the obligations under the Agreement,
including assessing deliverables and reports.
For this purpose, the Agency or the Commission may be assisted by external persons or bodies.
The Agency or the Commission may also request additional information in accordance with Article 12.
The Agency or the Commission may request beneficiaries to provide such information to it directly.
Information provided must be accurate, precise and complete and in the format requested, including
electronic format.
17.1.2 Right to carry out reviews
The Agency or the Commission may — during the implementation of the action or afterwards —
carry out reviews on the proper implementation of the action (including assessment of deliverables
and reports) and compliance with the obligations under the Agreement.
Reviews may be started up to five years after the payment of the balance. They will be formally
notified to the coordinator or beneficiary concerned and will be considered to have started on the date
of the formal notification.
If the review is carried out on a third party (see Articles 9 to 11a), the beneficiary concerned must
inform the third party.
26
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
The Agency or the Commission may carry out reviews directly (using its own staff) or indirectly (using
external persons or bodies appointed to do so). It will inform the coordinator or beneficiary concerned
of the identity of the external persons or bodies. They have the right to object to the appointment on
grounds of commercial confidentiality.
The coordinator or beneficiary concerned must provide — within the deadline requested — any
information and data in addition to deliverables and reports already submitted (including information
on the use of resources). The Agency or the Commission may request beneficiaries to provide such
information to it directly.
The coordinator or beneficiary concerned may be requested to participate in meetings, including with
external experts.
For on-the-spot reviews, the beneficiaries must allow access to their sites and premises, including to
external persons or bodies, and must ensure that information requested is readily available.
Information provided must be accurate, precise and complete and in the format requested, including
electronic format.
On the basis of the review findings, a ‘review report’ will be drawn up.
The Agency or the Commission will formally notify the review report to the coordinator or beneficiary
concerned, which has 30 days to formally notify observations (‘contradictory review procedure’).
Reviews (including review reports) are in the language of the Agreement.
17.1.3 Right to carry out audits
The Agency or the Commission may — during the implementation of the action or afterwards —
carry out audits on the proper implementation of the action and compliance with the obligations under
the Agreement.
Audits may be started up to five years after the payment of the balance. They will be formally
notified to the coordinator or beneficiary concerned and will be considered to have started on the date
of the formal notification.
If the audit is carried out on a third party (see Articles 9 to 11a), the beneficiary concerned must inform
the third party.
The Agency or the Commission may carry out audits directly (using its own staff) or indirectly (using
external persons or bodies appointed to do so). It will inform the coordinator or beneficiary concerned
of the identity of the external persons or bodies. They have the right to object to the appointment on
grounds of commercial confidentiality.
The coordinator or beneficiary concerned must provide — within the deadline requested — any
information (including complete accounts, individual salary statements or other personal data) to
verify compliance with the Agreement. The Agency or the Commission may request beneficiaries to
provide such information to it directly.
For on-the-spot audits, the beneficiaries must allow access to their sites and premises, including to
external persons or bodies, and must ensure that information requested is readily available.
27
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
Information provided must be accurate, precise and complete and in the format requested, including
electronic format.
On the basis of the audit findings, a ‘draft audit report’ will be drawn up.
The Agency or the Commission will formally notify the draft audit report to the coordinator or
beneficiary concerned, which has 30 days to formally notify observations (‘contradictory audit
procedure’). This period may be extended by the Agency or the Commission in justified cases.
The ‘final audit report’ will take into account observations by the coordinator or beneficiary
concerned. The report will be formally notified to it.
Audits (including audit reports) are in the language of the Agreement.
The Agency or the Commission may also access the beneficiaries’ statutory records for the periodical
assessment of flat-rate amounts.
17.2 Investigations by the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF)
Under Regulations No 883/20137 and No 2185/968 (and in accordance with their provisions and
procedures), the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) may — at any moment during implementation
of the action or afterwards — carry out investigations, including on-the-spot checks and inspections,
to establish whether there has been fraud, corruption or any other illegal activity affecting the financial
interests of the EU.
17.3 Checks and audits by the European Court of Auditors (ECA)
Under Article 287 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) and Article 161 of
the Financial Regulation No 966/20129, the European Court of Auditors (ECA) may — at any moment
during implementation of the action or afterwards — carry out audits.
The ECA has the right of access for the purpose of checks and audits.
17.4 Checks, reviews, audits and investigations for international organisations
Not applicable
17.5 Consequences of findings in checks, reviews, audits and investigations — Extension of
findings
17.5.1 Findings in this grant
7 Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 883/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 September 2013
concerning investigations conducted by the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) and repealing Regulation (EC)
No 1073/1999 of the European Parliament and of the Council and Council Regulation (Euratom) No 1074/1999 (OJ
L 232, 18.09.2013, p. 1).
8 Council Regulation (Euratom, EC) No 2185/1996 of 11 November 1996 concerning on-the-spot checks and inspections
carried out by the Commission in order to protect the European Communities' financial interests against fraud and other
irregularities (OJ L 292, 15.11.1996, p. 2).
9 Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 966/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2012 on the
financial rules applicable to the general budget of the Union and repealing Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No
1605/2002 (OJ L 298, 26.10.2012, p. 1).
28
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
Findings in checks, reviews, audits or investigations carried out in the context of this grant may lead
to the rejection of ineligible costs (see Article 26), reduction of the grant (see Article 27), recovery of
undue amounts (see Article 28) or to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
Rejection of costs or reduction of the grant after the payment of the balance will lead to a revised final
grant amount (see Article 5.4).
Findings in checks, reviews, audits or investigations may lead to a request for amendment for the
modification of Annex 1 (see Article 39).
Checks, reviews, audits or investigations that find systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or
breach of obligations may also lead to consequences in other EU or Euratom grants awarded under
similar conditions (‘extension of findings from this grant to other grants’).
Moreover, findings arising from an OLAF investigation may lead to criminal prosecution under
national law.
17.5.2 Findings in other grants
The Agency or the Commission may extend findings from other grants to this grant (‘extension of
findings from other grants to this grant’), if:
(a) the beneficiary concerned is found, in other EU or Euratom grants awarded under similar
conditions, to have committed systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of
obligations that have a material impact on this grant and
(b) those findings are formally notified to the beneficiary concerned — together with the list of
grants affected by the findings — no later than five years after the payment of the balance
of this grant.
The extension of findings may lead to the rejection of costs (see Article 26), reduction of the grant
(see Article 27), recovery of undue amounts (see Article 28), suspension of payments (see Article 32),
suspension of the action implementation (see Article 33) or termination (see Article 34).
17.5.3 Procedure
The Agency or the Commission will formally notify the beneficiary concerned the systemic or
recurrent errors and its intention to extend these audit findings, together with the list of grants affected.
17.5.3.1 If the findings concern eligibility of costs: the formal notification will include:
(a) an invitation to submit observations on the list of grants affected by the findings;
(b) the request to submit revised financial statements for all grants affected;
(c) the correction rate for extrapolation established by the Agency or the Commission on
the basis of the systemic or recurrent errors, to calculate the amounts to be rejected, if the
beneficiary concerned:
(i) considers that the submission of revised financial statements is not possible or practicable
or
(ii) does not submit revised financial statements.
29
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
The beneficiary concerned has 90 days from receiving notification to submit observations, revised
financial statements or to propose a duly substantiated alternative correction method. This period
may be extended by the Agency or the Commission in justified cases.
The Agency or the Commission may then start a rejection procedure in accordance with Article 26,
either on the basis of the revised financial statements, the alternative method or the correction rate
announced.
17.5.3.2 If the findings concern substantial errors, irregularities or fraud or serious breach of
obligations: the formal notification will include:
(a) an invitation to submit observations on the list of grants affected by the findings and
(b) the flat-rate the Agency or the Commission intends to apply according to the principle of
proportionality.
The beneficiary concerned has 90 days from receiving notification to submit observations or to
propose a duly substantiated alternative flat-rate.
The Agency or the Commission may then start a reduction procedure in accordance with Article 27,
either on the basis of the alternative flat-rate or the flat-rate announced.
17.6 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under this Article, any insufficiently substantiated costs
will be ineligible (see Article 6) and will be rejected (see Article 26).
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 18 — EVALUATION OF THE IMPACT OF THE ACTION
18.1 Right to evaluate the impact of the action
The Agency or the Commission may carry out interim and final evaluations of the impact of the action
measured against the objective of the EU programme.
Evaluations may be started during implementation of the action and up to five years after the
payment of the balance. The evaluation is considered to start on the date of the formal notification
to the coordinator or beneficiaries.
The Agency or the Commission may make these evaluations directly (using its own staff) or indirectly
(using external bodies or persons it has authorised to do so).
The coordinator or beneficiaries must provide any information relevant to evaluate the impact of the
action, including information in electronic format.
18.2 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under this Article, the Agency may apply the measures
described in Chapter 6.
30
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
SECTION 3 OTHER RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS
ARTICLE 19 — PRE-EXISTING RIGHTS AND OWNERSHIP OF THE RESULTS
(INCLUDING INTELLECTUAL AND INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY
RIGHTS)
19.1 Pre-existing rights and access rights to pre-existing rights
Where industrial and intellectual property rights (including rights of third parties) exist prior to the
Agreement, the beneficiaries must establish a list of these pre-existing industrial and intellectual
property rights, specifying the owner and any persons that have a right of use.
The coordinator must — before starting the action — submit this list to the Agency.
Each beneficiary must give the other beneficiaries access to any pre-existing industrial and intellectual
property rights needed for the implementation of the action and compliance with the obligations under
the Agreement.
19.2 Ownership of results and rights of use
The results of the action (including the reports and other documents relating to it) are owned by the
beneficiaries.
The beneficiaries must give the Agency and the Commission the right to use the results for their
communication activities under Article 22.
19.3 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under this Article, the grant may be reduced (see
Article 27).
Such a breach may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 20 — CONFLICT OF INTERESTS
20.1 Obligation to avoid a conflict of interests
The beneficiaries must take all measures to prevent any situation where the impartial and objective
implementation of the action is compromised for reasons involving economic interest, political or
national affinity, family or emotional ties or any other shared interest (‘conflict of interests’).
They must formally notify to the Agency without delay any situation constituting or likely to lead to
a conflict of interests and immediately take all the necessary steps to rectify this situation.
The Agency may verify that the measures taken are appropriate and may require additional measures
to be taken by a specified deadline.
20.2 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under this Article, the grant may be reduced (see
Article 27) and the Agreement or participation of the beneficiary may be terminated (see Article 34).
31
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 21 — CONFIDENTIALITY
21.1 General obligation to maintain confidentiality
During implementation of the action and for five years after the payment of the balance, the parties
must keep confidential any data, documents or other material (in any form) that is identified as
confidential at the time it is disclosed (‘confidential information’).
They may use confidential information to implement the Agreement.
The confidentiality obligations no longer apply if:
(a) the disclosing party agrees to release the other party;
(b) the information becomes generally and publicly available, without breaching any
confidentiality obligation;
(c) the disclosure of the confidential information is required by EU or national law.
21.2 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under this Article, the grant may be reduced (see
Article 27).
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 22 — PROMOTING THE ACTION — VISIBILITY OF EU FUNDING
22.1 Communication activities by the beneficiaries
22.1.1 General obligation to promote the action and its results
The beneficiaries must promote the action and its results.
22.1.2 Information on EU funding — Obligation and right to use the EU emblem
Unless the Agency requests or agrees otherwise, any communication activity related to the action
(including at conferences, seminars, in information material, such as brochures, leaflets, posters,
presentations, etc., in electronic form, via social media, etc.) and any infrastructure, equipment or
major results funded by the grant must:
- display the EU emblem and
- include the following text:
“This [insert appropriate description, e.g. report, publication, conference, infrastructure, equipment, insert
type of result, etc.] was funded by the European Union’s Health Programme (2014-2020).”
When displayed in association with another logo, the EU emblem must have appropriate prominence.
32
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
For the purposes of their obligations under this Article, the beneficiaries may use the EU emblem
without first obtaining approval from the Agency.
This does not, however, give them the right to exclusive use.
Moreover, they may not appropriate the EU emblem or any similar trademark or logo, either by
registration or by any other means.
22.1.3 Disclaimer excluding Agency and Commission responsibility
Any communication activity related to the action must indicate the following disclaimer:
"The content of this [insert appropriate description, e.g. report, publication, conference, etc.] represents
the views of the author only and is his/her sole responsibility; it cannot be considered to reflect the views
of the European Commission and/or the Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive Agency
(CHAFEA) or any other body of the European Union. The European Commission and the Agency do not
accept any responsibility for use that may be made of the information it contains.”
22.2 Communication activities by the Agency and the Commission
22.2.1 Right to use the beneficiaries’ materials, documents or information
The Agency and the Commission may use information relating to the action, documents notably
summaries for publication and public deliverables as well as any other material, such as pictures or
audio-visual material received from any beneficiary (including in electronic form).
This does not change the confidentiality obligations in Article 21, which still apply.
The right to use the beneficiary’s materials, documents and information includes:
(a) use for its own purposes (in particular, making them available to persons working for the
Agency, the Commission or any other EU institution, body, office or agency or body or
institutions in EU Member States; and copying or reproducing them in whole or in part, in
unlimited numbers);
(b) distribution to the public (in particular, publication as hard copies and in electronic or digital
format, publication on the internet, as a downloadable or non-downloadable file, broadcasting
by any channel, public display or presentation, communicating through press information
services, or inclusion in widely accessible databases or indexes);
(c) editing or redrafting for communication and publicising activities (including shortening,
summarising, inserting other elements (such as meta-data, legends, other graphic, visual, audio
or text elements), extracting parts (e.g. audio or video files), dividing into parts, use in a
compilation);
(d) translation;
(e) giving access in response to individual requests under Regulation No 1049/200110, without
the right to reproduce or exploit;
10 Regulation (EC) No 1049/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2001 regarding public access
to European Parliament, Council and Commission documents, OJ L 145, 31.5.2001, p. 43.
33
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
(f) storage in paper, electronic or other form;
(g) archiving, in line with applicable document-management rules, and
(h) the right to authorise third parties to act on its behalf or sub-license the modes of use set out
in Points (b), (c), (d) and (f) to third parties if needed for the communication and publicising
activities of the Agency or the Commission.
If the right of use is subject to rights of a third party (including personnel of the beneficiary), the
beneficiary must ensure that it complies with its obligations under this Agreement (in particular, by
obtaining the necessary approval from the third parties concerned).
Where applicable (and if provided by the beneficiaries), the Agency or the Commission will insert
the following information:
“© – [year] – [name of the copyright owner]. All rights reserved. Licensed to the Consumers, Health,
Agriculture and Food Executive Agency (CHAFEA) and the European Union (EU) under conditions.”
22.3 Consequences of non-compliance
If the beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under this Article, the grant may be reduced (see
Article 27).
Such breaches may also lead to any of the other measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 23 — PROCESSING OF PERSONAL DATA
23.1 Processing of personal data by the Agency and the Commission
Any personal data under the Agreement will be processed by the Agency or the Commission under
Regulation No 23/200111 and according to the ‘notifications of the processing operations’ to the Data
Protection Officer (DPO) of the Agency or the Commission (publicly accessible in the DPO register).
Such data will be processed by the ‘data controller’ of the Agency or the Commission, for the
purposes of implementing, managing and monitoring the Agreement or protecting the financial
interests of the EU or Euratom (including checks, reviews, audits and investigations; see Article 17).
The persons whose personal data are processed have the right to access and correct their own personal
data. For this purpose, they must send any queries about the processing of their personal data to the data
controller, via the contact point indicated in the privacy statement(s) on the Agency and Commission
websites.
They also have the right to have recourse at any time to the European Data Protection Supervisor
(EDPS).
23.2 Processing of personal data by the beneficiaries
11 Regulation (EC) No 45/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 December 2000 on the protection
of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data by the Community institutions and bodies and on the free
movement of such data (OJ L 8, 12.01.2001, p. 1).
34
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
The beneficiaries must process personal data under the Agreement in compliance with applicable EU
and national law on data protection (including authorisations or notification requirements).
The beneficiaries may grant their personnel access only to data that is strictly necessary for
implementing, managing and monitoring the Agreement.
The beneficiaries must inform the personnel whose personal data are collected and processed by the
Agency or the Commission. For this purpose, they must provide them with the privacy statement(s)
(see above), before transmitting their data to the Agency or the Commission.
23.3 Consequences of non-compliance
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article 23.2, the Agency may apply any of the
measures described in Chapter 6.
ARTICLE 24 — ASSIGNMENTS OF CLAIMS FOR PAYMENT AGAINST THE AGENCY
The beneficiaries may not assign any of their claims for payment against the Agency to any third
party, except if approved by the Agency on the basis of a reasoned, written request by the coordinator
(on behalf of the beneficiary concerned).
If the Agency has not accepted the assignment or the terms of it are not observed, the assignment
will have no effect on it.
In no circumstances will an assignment release the beneficiaries from their obligations towards the
Agency.
CHAPTER 5 DIVISION OF BENEFICIARIES’ ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
ARTICLE 25 — DIVISION OF BENEFICIARIES’ ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
25.1 Roles and responsibilities towards the Agency
The beneficiaries have full responsibility for implementing the action and complying with the
Agreement.
The beneficiaries are jointly and severally liable for the technical implementation of the action as
described in Annex 1. If a beneficiary fails to implement its part of the action, the other beneficiaries
become responsible for implementing this part (without being entitled to any additional EU funding
for doing so), unless the Agency expressly relieves them of this obligation.
The financial responsibility of each beneficiary is governed by Articles 28, 29 and 30.
25.2 Internal division of roles and responsibilities
The internal roles and responsibilities of the beneficiaries are divided as follows:
(a) Each beneficiary must:
35
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
(i) keep information stored in the Participant Portal Beneficiary Register (via the electronic
exchange system) up to date (see Article 12);
(ii) inform the coordinator immediately of any events or circumstances likely to affect
significantly or delay the implementation of the action (see Article 12);
(iii) submit to the coordinator in good time:
- individual financial statements for itself and, if required, certificates on the
financial statements (see Article 15);
- the data needed to draw up the technical reports (see Article 15);
- any other documents or information required by the Agency or the Commission
under the Agreement, unless the Agreement requires the beneficiary to submit this
information directly.
(b) The coordinator must:
(i) monitor that the action is implemented properly (see Article 7);
(ii) act as the intermediary for all communications between the beneficiaries and the Agency
(in particular, providing the Agency with the information described in Article 12), unless
the Agreement specifies otherwise;
(iii) provide a pre-financing guarantee if requested by the Agency (see Article 16.2);
(iv) request and review any documents or information required by the Agency and verify
their completeness and correctness before passing them on to the Agency;
(v) submit the deliverables and reports to the Agency (see Articles 14 and 15);
(vi) ensure that all payments are made to the other beneficiaries without unjustified delay
(see Article 16).
The coordinator may not subcontract the above-mentioned tasks.
25.3 Internal arrangements between beneficiaries — Consortium agreement
The beneficiaries must have internal arrangements regarding their operation and co-ordination to
ensure that the action is implemented properly. These internal arrangements must be set out in a written
‘consortium agreement’ between the beneficiaries, which may cover:
- internal organisation of the consortium;
- management of access to the electronic exchange system;
- distribution of EU funding;
- additional rules on rights and obligations related to pre-existing rights and results (see
Article 19);
36
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
- settlement of internal disputes;
- liability, indemnification and confidentiality arrangements between the beneficiaries.
The consortium agreement must not contain any provision contrary to the Agreement.
CHAPTER 6 REJECTION OF COSTS — REDUCTION OF THE GRANT —
RECOVERY — SANCTIONS — DAMAGES — SUSPENSION —
TERMINATION — FORCE MAJEURE
SECTION 1 REJECTION OF COSTS — REDUCTION OF THE GRANT — RECOVERY
— SANCTIONS
ARTICLE 26 — REJECTION OF INELIGIBLE COSTS
26.1 Conditions
The Agency will — at the time of an interim payment, at the payment of the balance or afterwards
— reject any costs which are ineligible (see Article 6), in particular following checks, reviews, audits
or investigations (see Article 17).
The rejection may also be based on the extension of findings from other grants to this grant (see
Article 17.5.2).
26.2 Ineligible costs to be rejected — Calculation — Procedure
Ineligible costs will be rejected in full.
If the rejection of costs does not lead to a recovery (see Article 28), the Agency will formally notify
the coordinator or beneficiary concerned of the rejection of costs, the amounts and the reasons why
(if applicable, together with the notification of amounts due; see Article 16.5). The coordinator or
beneficiary concerned may — within 30 days of receiving notification — formally notify the Agency
of its disagreement and the reasons why.
If the rejection of costs leads to a recovery, the Agency will follow the contradictory procedure with
pre-information letter set out in Article 28.
26.3 Effects
If the Agency rejects costs at the time of an interim payment or the payment of the balance, it will
deduct them from the total eligible costs declared, for the action, in the periodic or final summary
financial statement (see Article 15.3 and 15.4). It will then calculate the interim payment or payment
of the balance as set out in Article 16.3 or 16.4.
If the Agency — after an interim payment but before the payment of the balance — rejects costs
declared in a periodic summary financial statement, it will deduct them from the costs declared in the
next periodic summary financial statement or final summary financial statement. It will then calculate
the interim payment or payment of the balance as set out in Article 16.3 or 16.4.
If the Agency rejects costs after the payment of the balance, it will deduct the amount rejected from
37
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
the total eligible costs declared, by the beneficiary, in the final summary financial statement. It will
then calculate the revised final grant amount as set out in Article 5.4. If the revised final grant amount
is lower than the final grant amount, the Agency will recover the difference (see Article 28).
ARTICLE 27 — REDUCTION OF THE GRANT
27.1 Conditions
The Agency may — at the payment of the balance or afterwards — reduce the grant, if:
(a) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decisions on its behalf)
has committed:
(i) substantial errors, irregularities or fraud or
(ii) serious breach of obligations under the Agreement or during the award procedure
(including improper implementation of the action, submission of false information,
failure to provide required information, breach of ethical principles) or
(b) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decisions on its behalf)
has committed — in other EU or Euratom grants awarded to it under similar conditions —
systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or serious breach of obligations that have a
material impact on this grant (extension of findings from other grants to this grant; see
Article 17.5.2).
27.2 Amount to be reduced — Calculation — Procedure
The amount of the reduction will be proportionate to the seriousness of the errors, irregularities or
fraud or breach of obligations.
Before reduction of the grant, the Agency will formally notify a ‘pre-information letter’ to the
coordinator or beneficiary concerned:
- informing it of its intention to reduce the grant, the amount it intends to reduce and the reasons
why and
- inviting it to submit observations within 30 days of receiving notification.
If the Agency does not receive any observations or decides to pursue reduction despite the observations
it has received, it will formally notify confirmation of the reduction (if applicable, together with the
notification of amounts due; see Article 16).
27.3 Effects
If the Agency reduces the grant at the time of the payment of the balance, it will calculate the
reduced grant amount for the action and then determine the amount due as payment of the balance
(see Article 5.3.4 and 16.4).
If the Agency reduces the grant after the payment of the balance, it will calculate the revised final
grant amount for the action or for the beneficiary concerned (see Article 5.4). If the revised final grant
amount is lower than the final grant amount, the Agency will recover the difference (see Article 28).
38
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
ARTICLE 28 — RECOVERY OF UNDUE AMOUNTS
28.1 Amount to be recovered — Calculation — Procedure
The Agency will — at the payment of the balance or afterwards — claim back any amount that
was paid but is not due under the Agreement.
The coordinator is fully liable for repaying debts of the consortium (under the Agreement) even if it
has not been the final recipient of those amounts.
In addition, the beneficiaries (including the coordinator) are jointly and severally liable for repaying
any unpaid debts under the Agreement (due by the consortium or any beneficiary, including late-
payment interest) — up to the maximum EU contribution indicated, for each beneficiary, in the
estimated budget (as last amended; see Annex 2).
28.1.1 Recovery at payment of the balance
If the payment of the balance takes the form of a recovery (see Article 16.4), the Agency will formally
notify a ‘pre-information letter’ to the coordinator:
- informing it of its intention to recover, the amount due as the balance and the reasons why and
- inviting the coordinator to submit observations within 30 days of receiving notification.
If no observations are submitted or the Agency decides to pursue recovery despite the observations
it has received, it will confirm the amount to be recovered and formally notify to the coordinator a
debit note with the terms and the date for payment (together with the notification of amounts due;
see Article 16.5).
If payment is not made by the date specified in the debit note, the Agency or the Commission will
recover the amount:
(a) by ‘offsetting’ it — without the coordinator’s consent — against any amounts owed to the
coordinator by the Agency, Commission or another executive agency (from the EU or Euratom
budget).
In exceptional circumstances, to safeguard the EU’s financial interests, the Agency may offset
before the payment date specified in the debit note;
(b) not applicable;
(c) by holding the other beneficiaries jointly and severally liable — up to the maximum EU
contribution indicated, for each beneficiary, in the estimated budget (as last amended; see
Annex 2)
(d) by taking legal action (see Article 41) or by adopting an enforceable decision under
Article 299 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU (TFEU) and Article 79(2) of the
Financial Regulation No 966/2012.
If payment is not made by the date in the debit note, the amount to be recovered (see above) will be
increased by late-payment interest at the rate set out in Article 16.11, from the day following the
39
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
payment date in the debit note, up to and including the date the Agency or the Commission receives
full payment of the amount.
Partial payments will be first credited against expenses, charges and late-payment interest and then
against the principal.
Bank charges incurred in the recovery process will be borne by the beneficiary, unless Directive
2007/64/EC applies.
28.1.2 Recovery of amounts after payment of the balance
If — after the payment of the balance — the Agency revised the final grant amount for the action or
for the beneficiary concerned (see Article 5.4), due to a rejection of costs or reduction of the grant, and
the revised final grant amount is lower than the final grant amount (see Article 5.3), the Agency will:
- if the rejection or reduction does not concern a specific beneficiary : claim back the difference
from the coordinator (even if it has not been the final recipient of the amount in question)
or
- otherwise: claim back the difference from the beneficiary concerned.
The Agency will formally notify a pre-information letter to the coordinator or beneficiary concerned:
- informing it of its intention to recover, the amount to be repaid and the reasons why and
- inviting it to submit observations within 30 days of receiving notification.
If no observations are submitted or the Agency decides to pursue recovery despite the observations
it has received, it will confirm the amount to be recovered and formally notify to the coordinator or
beneficiary concerned a debit note. This note will also specify the terms and the date for payment.
If payment is not made by the date specified in the debit note, the Agency or the Commission will
recover the amount:
(a) by ‘offsetting’ it — without the coordinator’s or beneficiary’s consent — against any amounts
owed to the coordinator or beneficiary by the Agency, Commission or another executive agency
(from the EU or Euratom budget).
In exceptional circumstances, to safeguard the EU’s financial interests, the Agency may offset
before the payment date specified in the debit note;
(b) by holding the other beneficiaries jointly and severally liable, up to the maximum EU
contribution indicated, for each beneficiary, in the estimated budget (as last amended; see
Annex 2)
(c) by taking legal action (see Article 41) or by adopting an enforceable decision under
Article 299 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU (TFEU) and Article 79(2) of the
Financial Regulation No 966/2012.
If payment is not made by the date in the debit note, the amount to be recovered (see above) will be
increased by late-payment interest at the rate set out in Article 16.11, from the day following the date
40
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
for payment in the debit note, up to and including the date the Agency or the Commission receives
full payment of the amount.
Partial payments will be first credited against expenses, charges and late-payment interest and then
against the principal.
Bank charges incurred in the recovery process will be borne by the beneficiary, unless Directive
2007/64/EC applies.
ARTICLE 29 — ADMINISTRATIVE SANCTIONS
In addition to contractual measures, the Agency or the Commission may also adopt administrative
sanctions under Articles 106 and 131(4) of the Financial Regulation No 966/2012 (i.e. exclusion from
future procurement contracts, grants and expert contracts and/or financial penalties).
SECTION 2 LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES
ARTICLE 30 — LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES
30.1 Liability of the Agency
The Agency cannot be held liable for any damage caused to the beneficiaries or to third parties as a
consequence of implementing the Agreement, including for gross negligence.
The Agency cannot be held liable for any damage caused by any of the beneficiaries or third parties
involved in the action, as a consequence of implementing the Agreement.
30.2 Liability of the beneficiaries
Except in case of force majeure (see Article 35), the beneficiaries must compensate the Agency for
any damage it sustains as a result of the implementation of the action or because the action was not
implemented in full compliance with the Agreement.
SECTION 3 SUSPENSION AND TERMINATION
ARTICLE 31 — SUSPENSION OF PAYMENT DEADLINE
31.1 Conditions
The Agency may — at any moment — suspend the payment deadline (see Article 16.2 to 16.4) if a
request for payment (see Article 15) cannot be approved because:
(a) it does not comply with the provisions of the Agreement (see Article 15);
(b) the technical or financial report(s) have not been submitted or are not complete or additional
information is needed, or
(c) there is doubt about the eligibility of the costs declared in the financial statements and additional
checks, reviews, audits or investigations are necessary.
41
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
31.2 Procedure
The Agency will formally notify the coordinator of the suspension and the reasons why.
The suspension will take effect the day notification is sent by the Agency (see Article 36).
If the conditions for suspending the payment deadline are no longer met, the suspension will be lifted
— and the remaining period will resume.
If the suspension exceeds two months, the coordinator may request the Agency if the suspension will
continue.
If the payment deadline has been suspended due to the non-compliance of the technical or financial
report(s) (see Article 15) and the revised report or statement is not submitted or was submitted but
is also rejected, the Agency may also terminate the Agreement or the participation of the beneficiary
(see Article 34.3.1(i)).
ARTICLE 32 — SUSPENSION OF PAYMENTS
32.1 Conditions
The Agency may — at any moment — suspend payments, in whole or in part for one or more
beneficiaries, if:
(a) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decision on its behalf)
has committed or is suspected of having committed:
(i) substantial errors, irregularities or fraud or
(ii) serious breach of obligations under this Agreement or during the award procedure
(including improper implementation of the action, submission of false information,
failure to provide required information, breach of ethical principles) or
(b) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decision on its behalf)
has committed — in other EU or Euratom grants awarded to it under similar conditions —
systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or serious breach of obligations that have a
material impact on this grant (extension of findings from other grants to this grant; see
Article 17.5.2).
If payments are suspended for one or more beneficiaries, the Agency will make partial payment(s)
for the part(s) not suspended. If suspension concerns the payment of the balance, the payment (or
recovery) of the amount(s) concerned after suspension is lifted will be considered to be the payment
that closes the action.
32.2 Procedure
Before suspending payments, the Agency will formally notify the coordinator or beneficiary
concerned:
- informing it of its intention to suspend payments and the reasons why and
- inviting it to submit observations within 30 days of receiving notification.
42
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
If the Agency does not receive observations or decides to pursue the procedure despite the observations
it has received, it will formally notify confirmation of the suspension. Otherwise, it will formally
notify that the suspension procedure is not continued.
The suspension will take effect the day the confirmation notification is sent by the Agency.
If the conditions for resuming payments are met, the suspension will be lifted. The Agency will
formally notify the coordinator or beneficiary concerned.
During the suspension, the periodic report(s) for all reporting periods except the last one (see
Article 15.3) must not contain any individual financial statement(s) from the beneficiary concerned.
The coordinator must include them in the next periodic report after the suspension is lifted or — if
suspension is not lifted before the end of the action — in the last periodic report.
The beneficiaries may suspend implementation of the action (see Article 33.1) or terminate the
Agreement or the participation of the beneficiary concerned (see Article 34.1 and 34.2).
ARTICLE 33 — SUSPENSION OF THE ACTION IMPLEMENTATION
33.1 Suspension of the action implementation, by the beneficiaries
33.1.1 Conditions
The beneficiaries may suspend implementation of the action or any part of it, if exceptional
circumstances — in particular force majeure (see Article 35) — make implementation impossible or
excessively difficult.
33.1.2 Procedure
The coordinator must immediately formally notify to the Agency the suspension (see Article 36),
stating:
- the reasons why and
- the expected date of resumption.
The suspension will take effect the day this notification is received by the Agency.
Once circumstances allow for implementation to resume, the coordinator must immediately formally
notify the Agency and request an amendment of the Agreement, to set the date on which the action
will be resumed, extend the duration of the action and make other changes necessary to adapt the action
to the new situation (see Article 39) — unless the Agreement or the participation of a beneficiary has
been terminated (see Article 34).
The suspension will be lifted with effect from the resumption date set out in the amendment. This
date may be before the date on which the amendment enters into force.
Costs incurred during suspension of the action implementation are not eligible (see Article 6).
33.2 Suspension of the action implementation, by the Agency
33.2.1 Conditions
43
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
The Agency may suspend implementation of the action or any part of it, if:
(a) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decisions on its behalf)
has committed or is suspected of having committed:
(i) substantial errors, irregularities or fraud or
(ii) serious breach of obligations under this Agreement or during the award procedure
(including improper implementation of the action, submission of false declaration, failure
to provide required information, breach of ethical principles) or
(b) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decisions on its behalf)
has committed — in other EU or Euratom grants awarded to it under similar conditions —
systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or serious breach of obligations that have a
material impact on this grant (extension of findings from other grants to this grant; see
Article 17.5.2).
33.2.2 Procedure
Before suspending implementation of the action, the Agency will formally notify the coordinator or
beneficiary concerned:
- informing it of its intention to suspend the implementation and the reasons why and
- inviting it to submit observations within 30 days of receiving notification.
If the Agency does not receive observations or decides to pursue the procedure despite the observations
it has received, it will formally notify confirmation of the suspension. Otherwise, it will formally
notify that the procedure is not continued.
The suspension will take effect five days after confirmation notification is received (or on a later date
specified in the notification).
It will be lifted if the conditions for resuming implementation of the action are met.
The coordinator or beneficiary concerned will be formally notified of the lifting and the Agreement
will be amended, to set the date on which the action will be resumed, extend the duration of the action
and make other changes necessary to adapt the action to the new situation (see Article 39) — unless
the Agreement has already been terminated (see Article 34).
The suspension will be lifted with effect from the resumption date set out in the amendment. This date
may be before the date on which the amendment enters into force.
Costs incurred during suspension are not eligible (see Article 6).
The beneficiaries may not claim damages due to suspension by the Agency (see Article 30).
Suspension of the action implementation does not affect the Agency’s right to terminate the Agreement
or participation of a beneficiary (see Article 34), reduce the grant or recover amounts unduly paid
(see Articles 27 and 28).
44
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
ARTICLE 34 — TERMINATION OF THE AGREEMENT OR OF THE PARTICIPATION
OF ONE OR MORE BENEFICIARIES
34.1 Termination of the Agreement, by the beneficiaries
34.1.1 Conditions and procedure
The beneficiaries may terminate the Agreement.
The coordinator must formally notify termination to the Agency (see Article 36), stating:
- the reasons why and
- the date the termination will take effect. This date must be after the notification.
If no reasons are given or if the Agency considers the reasons do not justify termination, the Agreement
will be considered to have been ‘terminated improperly’.
The termination will take effect on the day specified in the notification.
34.1.2 Effects
The coordinator must — within 60 days from when termination takes effect — submit a periodic report
(for the open reporting period until termination; see Article 15.3) and the final report (see Article 15.4).
If the Agency does not receive the report(s) within the deadline (see above), only costs which are
included in an approved periodic report will be taken into account.
The Agency will calculate the final grant amount (see Article 5.3) and the balance (see Article 16.4)
on the basis of the report(s) submitted. Only costs incurred until termination are eligible (see Article 6).
Costs relating to contracts due for execution only after termination are not eligible.
Improper termination may lead to a reduction of the grant (see Article 27).
After termination, the beneficiaries’ obligations (in particular, Articles 15, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 24,
26, 27 and 28) continue to apply.
34.2 Termination of the participation of one or more beneficiaries, by the beneficiaries
34.2.1 Conditions and procedure
The participation of one or more beneficiaries may be terminated by the coordinator, on request of
the beneficiary concerned or on behalf of the other beneficiaries.
The coordinator must formally notify termination to the Agency (see Article 36) and inform the
beneficiary concerned.
If the coordinator’s participation is terminated without its agreement, the formal notification must be
done by another beneficiary (acting on behalf of the other beneficiaries).
The notification must include:
- the reasons why;
45
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
- the opinion of the beneficiary concerned (or proof that this opinion has been requested in
writing);
- the date the termination takes effect. This date must be after the notification, and
- a request for amendment (see Article 39), with a proposal for reallocation of the tasks and the
estimated budget of the beneficiary concerned (see Annexes 1 and 2) and, if necessary, the
addition of one or more new beneficiaries (see Article 40). If termination takes effect after the
period set out in Article 3, no request for amendment must be included, unless the beneficiary
concerned is the coordinator. In this case, the request for amendment must propose a new
coordinator.
If this information is not given or if the Agency considers that the reasons do not justify termination,
the participation will be considered to have been terminated improperly.
The termination will take effect on the day specified in the notification.
34.2.2 Effects
The beneficiary concerned must submit to the coordinator:
(i) a technical report and
(ii) a financial statement covering the period from the end of the last reporting period to the date
when termination takes effect.
This information must be included by the coordinator in the periodic report for the next reporting
period (see Article 15.3).
If the request for amendment is rejected by the Agency (because it calls into question the decision
awarding the grant or breaches the principle of equal treatment of applicants), the Agreement may be
terminated according to Article 34.3.1(c).
If the request for amendment is accepted by the Agency, the Agreement is amended to introduce the
necessary changes (see Article 39).
Improper termination may lead to a reduction of the grant (see Article 27) or termination of the
Agreement (see Article 34).
After termination, the concerned beneficiary’s obligations (in particular Articles 15, 17, 18, 19, 21,
22, 24, 26, 27 and 28) continue to apply.
34.3 Termination of the Agreement or of the participation of one or more beneficiaries, by
the Agency
34.3.1 Conditions
The Agency may terminate the Agreement or the participation of one or more beneficiaries, if:
(a) one or more beneficiaries do not accede to the Agreement (see Article 40);
(b) a change to their legal, financial, technical, organisational or ownership situation is likely to
46
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
substantially affect or delay the implementation of the action or calls into question the decision
to award the grant;
(c) following termination of participation for one or more beneficiaries (see above), the necessary
changes to the Agreement would call into question the decision awarding the grant or breach
the principle of equal treatment of applicants (see Article 39);
(d) implementation of the action is prevented by force majeure (see Article 35) or suspended by
the coordinator (see Article 33.1) and either:
(i) resumption is impossible, or
(ii) the necessary changes to the Agreement would call into question the decision awarding
the grant or breach the principle of equal treatment of applicants;
(e) a beneficiary is declared bankrupt, being wound up, having its affairs administered by the
courts, has entered into an arrangement with creditors, has suspended business activities, or
is subject to any other similar proceedings or procedures under national law;
(f) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decisions on its
behalf) has been found guilty of professional misconduct, proven by any means;
(g) a beneficiary does not comply with the applicable national law on taxes and social security;
(h) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decisions on its
behalf) has committed fraud, corruption, or is involved in a criminal organisation, money
laundering or any other illegal activity;
(i) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decisions on its
behalf) has committed:
(i) substantial errors, irregularities or fraud or
(ii) serious breach of obligations under the Agreement or during the award procedure
(including improper implementation of the action, submission of false information,
failure to provide required information, breach of ethical principles);
(j) a beneficiary (or a natural person who has the power to represent or take decisions on its
behalf) has committed — in other EU or Euratom grants awarded to it under similar conditions
— systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or serious breach of obligations that have
a material impact on this grant (extension of findings from other grants to this grant; see
Article 17.5.2);
(k) not applicable
34.3.2 Procedure
Before terminating the Agreement or participation of one or more beneficiaries, the Agency will
formally notify the coordinator or beneficiary concerned:
- informing it of its intention to terminate and the reasons why and
- inviting it, within 30 days of receiving notification, to submit observations and — in case of
47
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
Point (i.ii) above — to inform the Agency of the measures to ensure compliance with the
obligations under the Agreement.
If the Agency does not receive observations or decides to pursue the procedure despite the observations
it has received, it will formally notify to the coordinator or beneficiary concerned confirmation of
the termination and the date it will take effect. Otherwise, it will formally notify that the procedure
is not continued.
The termination will take effect:
- for terminations under Points (b), (c), (e), (g), (i.ii) and (k) above: on the day specified in the
notification of the confirmation (see above);
- for terminations under Points (a), (d), (f), (h), (i.i) and (j) above: on the day after the notification
of the confirmation is received.
34.3.3 Effects
(a) for termination of the Agreement:
The coordinator must — within 60 days from when termination takes effect — submit a periodic
report (for the last open reporting period until termination; see Article 15.3) and a final report
(see Article 15.4).
If the Agreement is terminated for breach of the obligation to submit reports (see Articles 15.8
and 34.3.1(i)), the coordinator may not submit any reports after termination.
If the Agency does not receive the report(s) within the deadline (see above), only costs which
are included in an approved periodic report will be taken into account.
The Agency will calculate the final grant amount (see Article 5.3) and the balance (see
Article 16.4) on the basis of the report(s) submitted. Only costs incurred until termination
takes effect are eligible (see Article 6). Costs relating to contracts due for execution only after
termination are not eligible.
This does not affect the Agency’s right to reduce the grant (see Article 27) or to impose
administrative sanctions (Article 29).
The beneficiaries may not claim damages due to termination by the Agency (see Article 30).
After termination, the beneficiaries’ obligations (in particular Articles 15, 17, 18, 19, 21, 22,
24, 26, 27 and 28) continue to apply.
(b) for termination of the participation of one or more beneficiaries:
The coordinator must — within 60 days from when termination takes effect — submit a request
for amendment (see Article 39), with a proposal for reallocation of the tasks and estimated
budget of the beneficiary concerned (see Annexes 1 and 2) and, if necessary, the addition of
one or more new beneficiaries (see Article 40). If termination is notified after the period set out
in Article 3, no request for amendment must be submitted unless the beneficiary concerned is
the coordinator. In this case the request for amendment must propose a new coordinator.
The beneficiary concerned must submit to the coordinator:
48
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
(i) a technical report and
(ii) a financial statement covering the period from the end of the last reporting period to the
date when termination takes effect.
This information must be included by the coordinator in periodic report for the next reporting
period (see Article 15.3).
If the request for amendment is rejected by the Agency (because it calls into question the
decision awarding the grant or breaches the principle of equal treatment of applicants), the
Agreement may be terminated according to Article 34.3.1(c).
If the request for amendment is accepted by the Agency, the Agreement is amended to
introduce the necessary changes (see Article 39).
After termination, the concerned beneficiary’s obligations (in particular Articles 15, 17, 18, 19,
20, 21, 22, 24, 26, 27 and 28) continue to apply.
SECTION 4 FORCE MAJEURE
ARTICLE 35 — FORCE MAJEURE
‘Force majeure’ means any situation or event that:
- prevents either party from fulfilling their obligations under the Agreement,
- was unforeseeable, exceptional situation and beyond the parties’ control,
- was not due to error or negligence on their part (or on the part of third parties involved in the
action), and
- proves to be inevitable in spite of exercising all due diligence.
The following cannot be invoked as force majeure:
- any default of a service, defect in equipment or material or delays in making them available,
unless they stem directly from a relevant case of force majeure,
- labour disputes or strikes, or
- financial difficulties.
Any situation constituting force majeure must be formally notified to the other party without delay,
stating the nature, likely duration and foreseeable effects.
The parties must immediately take all the necessary steps to limit any damage due to force majeure
and do their best to resume implementation of the action as soon as possible.
The party prevented by force majeure from fulfilling its obligations under the Agreement cannot be
considered in breach of them.
49
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
CHAPTER 7 FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 36 — COMMUNICATION BETWEEN THE PARTIES
36.1 Form and means of communication
Communication under the Agreement (information, requests, submissions, 'formal notifications', etc.)
must:
- be made in writing and
- bear the number of the Agreement.
Until the payment of the balance: all communication must be made through the electronic exchange
system and using the forms and templates provided there.
After the payment of the balance: formal notifications must be made by registered post with proof
of delivery (‘formal notification on paper’).
Communications in the electronic exchange system must be made by persons authorised according to
the Participant Portal Terms & Conditions. For naming the authorised persons, each beneficiary must
have designated — before the signature of this Agreement — a ‘legal entity appointed representative
(LEAR)’. The role and tasks of the LEAR are stipulated in his/her appointment letter (see Participant
Portal Terms & Conditions).
If the electronic exchange system is temporarily unavailable, instructions will be given on the Agency
and Commission websites.
36.2 Date of communication
Communications are considered to have been made when they are sent by the sending party (i.e. on
the date and time they are sent through the electronic exchange system).
Formal notifications through the electronic exchange system are considered to have been made when
they are received by the receiving party (i.e. on the date and time of acceptance by the receiving party,
as indicated by the time stamp). A formal notification that has not been accepted within 10 days after
sending is considered to have been accepted.
Formal notifications on paper sent by registered post with proof of delivery (only after the payment
of the balance) are considered to have been made on either:
- the delivery date registered by the postal service or
- the deadline for collection at the post office.
If the electronic exchange system is temporarily unavailable, the sending party cannot be considered
in breach of its obligation to send a communication within a specified deadline.
36.3 Addresses for communication
The electronic exchange system must be accessed via the following URL:
50
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/portal/screen/myarea/projects
The Agency will formally notify the coordinator and beneficiaries in advance any changes to this URL.
Formal notifications on paper (only after the payment of the balance) addressed to the Agency must
be sent to the following address:
Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive Agency (CHAFEA)
Health and Food Safety Unit Health and Food Safety Unit
Drosbach Building
L-2920 Luxembourg
Formal notifications on paper (only after the payment of the balance) addressed to the beneficiaries
must be sent to their legal address as specified in the Participant Portal Beneficiary Register.
ARTICLE 37 — INTERPRETATION OF THE AGREEMENT
37.1 Precedence of the Terms and Conditions over the Annexes
The provisions in the Terms and Conditions of the Agreement take precedence over its Annexes.
Annex 2 takes precedence over Annex 1.
37.2 Privileges and immunities
Not applicable
ARTICLE 38 — CALCULATION OF PERIODS, DATES AND DEADLINES
In accordance with Regulation No 1182/7112, periods expressed in days, months or years are calculated
from the moment the triggering event occurs.
The day during which that event occurs is not considered as falling within the period.
ARTICLE 39 — AMENDMENTS TO THE AGREEMENT
39.1 Conditions
The Agreement may be amended, unless the amendment entails changes to the Agreement which
would call into question the decision awarding the grant or breach the principle of equal treatment
of applicants.
Amendments may be requested by any of the parties.
39.2 Procedure
The party requesting an amendment must submit a request for amendment signed in the electronic
exchange system (see Article 36).
12 Regulation (EEC, Euratom) No 1182/71 of the Council of 3 June 1971 determining the rules applicable to periods, dates
and time-limits (OJ L 124, 8/6/1971, p. 1).
51
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
The coordinator submits and receives requests for amendment on behalf of the beneficiaries (see
Annex 3).
If a change of coordinator is requested without its agreement, the submission must be done by another
beneficiary (acting on behalf of the other beneficiaries).
The request for amendment must include:
- the reasons why;
- the appropriate supporting documents, and
- for a change of coordinator without its agreement: the opinion of the coordinator (or proof that
this opinion has been requested in writing).
The Agency may request additional information.
If the party receiving the request agrees, it must sign the amendment in the electronic exchange system
within 45 days of receiving notification (or any additional information the Agency has requested). If
it does not agree, it must formally notify its disagreement within the same deadline. The deadline may
be extended, if necessary for the assessment of the request. If no notification is received within the
deadline, the request is considered to have been rejected.
An amendment enters into force on the day of the signature of the receiving party.
An amendment takes effect on the date agreed by the parties or, in the absence of such an agreement,
on the date on which the amendment enters into force.
ARTICLE 40 — ACCESSION TO THE AGREEMENT
40.1 Accession of the beneficiaries mentioned in the preamble
The other beneficiaries must accede to the Agreement by signing the Accession Form (see Annex 3) in
the electronic exchange system (see Article 36) within 30 days after its entry into force (see Article 42).
They will assume the rights and obligations under the Agreement with effect from the date of its entry
into force (see Article 42).
If a beneficiary does not accede to the Agreement within the above deadline, the coordinator must
— within 30 days — request an amendment to make any changes necessary to ensure proper
implementation of the action. This does not affect the Agency's right to terminate the Agreement (see
Article 34).
40.2 Addition of new beneficiaries
In justified cases, the beneficiaries may request the addition of a new beneficiary.
For this purpose, the coordinator must submit a request for amendment in accordance with Article 39.
It must include an Accession Form (see Annex 3) signed by the new beneficiary in the electronic
exchange system (see Article 36).
52
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
Associated with documentCHAFEA MGA — Multi:-v2.1
Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 23/02/2021
New beneficiaries must assume the rights and obligations under the Agreement with effect from the
date of their accession specified in the Accession Form (see Annex 3).
ARTICLE 41 — APPLICABLE LAW AND SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES
41.1 Applicable law
The Agreement is governed by the applicable EU law, supplemented if necessary by the law of
Belgium.
41.2 Dispute settlement
If a dispute concerning the interpretation, application or validity of the Agreement cannot be settled
amicably, the General Court — or, on appeal, the Court of Justice of the European Union — has sole
jurisdiction. Such actions must be brought under Article 272 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the
EU (TFEU).
As an exception, if such a dispute is between the Agency and ‘UNIVERSITETET I SOROST-
NORGE’, the competent Belgian courts have sole jurisdiction.
If a dispute concerns administrative sanctions, offsetting or an enforceable decision under
Article 79(2) of the Financial Regulation No 966/2012 and Article 299 TFEU (see Articles 28, 29 and
30), the beneficiaries must bring action before the General Court — or, on appeal, the Court of Justice
of the European Union — under Article 263 TFEU. Actions against enforceable decisions must be
brought against the Commission (not against the Agency).
ARTICLE 42 — ENTRY INTO FORCE OF THE AGREEMENT
The Agreement will enter into force on the day of signature by the Agency or the coordinator,
depending on which is later.
SIGNATURES
For the coordinator For the Agency
[--TGSMark#signature-999860675_75_210--] [--TGSMark#signature-service_75_210--]
Béla Dr. Merkely with ECAS id n002coer signed in the Participant Signed by Veronique WASBAUER with ECAS id wasbave as an
Portal on 26/02/2021 at 08:40:14 (transaction id SigId-80957-7Ai0Q authorised representative on 26-02-2021 11:47:24 (transaction id
n11ok8blTrSisY2AnGrEs7NJiVsWWko3pWLQ7S14KLdFvua1jbEelKXF SigId-84113-IwPkNQ5F7lMFZKhNl5X5pgBwzzQBBsHISiuJHua9rzoYD
7mmaYHqBgwwJcAN1Gzc6cGrNO-rS0vSrmBGYCg3FMBs87Zim-zOB X1TNcWHMfSMoqolwzxaf3yPKdaPmx7uqe8vMu09e9i-
Lpw9s6ZMJnUUkm6BsJKIpHiXOYHRyEX6WhDw9iczLzvCeNLicO0Ezs rS0vSrmBGYCg3FMBs87Zim-aFvyDg4xD40Es3L9HIAuDsAkh8pOT6R
DY9uUCLd0OpzgI11dEhpFPPIiWk7cv). Timestamp by third party at 3GRZPPfzwsSgBTAl5fjMso3Z2EN7a80FcXjcJFrUwga08CiNYGmLheS)
2021.02.26 08:40:20 CET 2021.02.26 11:47:29 CET
53
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive Agency
(CHAFEA)
The Director
ANNEX 1 (part A)
Project
NUMBER — 101018346 — TaSHI
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Table of Contents
1.1. The project summary................................................................................................................................. 3
1.2. The list of beneficiaries..............................................................................................................................4
1.3. Workplan Tables - Detailed implementation..............................................................................................5
1.3.1. WT1 List of work packages........................................................................................................... 5
1.3.2. WT2 List of deliverables................................................................................................................ 6
1.3.3. WT3 Work package descriptions................................................................................................... 8
Work package 1........................................................................................................................... 8
Work package 2......................................................................................................................... 10
Work package 3......................................................................................................................... 15
Work package 4......................................................................................................................... 19
Work package 5......................................................................................................................... 24
1.3.4. WT4 List of milestones................................................................................................................ 30
1.3.5. WT5 Critical Implementation risks and mitigation actions........................................................... 35
1.3.6 WT6 Summary of project effort in person-months........................................................................37
1.3.7. WT7 Tentative schedule of project reviews.................................................................................38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1.1. The project summary
Project Number 1 101018346 Project Acronym 2 TaSHI
One form per project
General information
Project title 3
Empowering EU health policies on Task SHIfting
Starting date 4 01/04/2021
Duration in months 5 36
Call (part) identifier 6 HP-PJ-2020-2
PJ-01-2020-3
Topic Support to reforms in health workforce field - Initiatives on task-shifting (Heading
1.2.1.1 of the AWP 2020)
Fixed EC Keywords
health workforce planning, health policy, optimizing care provision, skill-mix, digital
Free keywords
transformation, sustainable task shifting practices
Abstract 7
Health workforce planning systems show a high variety of maturity in the EU. Member States tend to focus on
diverse aspects of managing health workforces and health policy focuses on optimising the operation of health
systems by various measures. Initiatives on task shifting can contribute to more effective organisation of care and
human resources for health management at different levels, so committing to improve efficient and sustainable health
systems in innovative ways.The main objectives of the TaSHI project are to provide a novel understanding and up-
to-date knowledge on task shifting and on transferability and uptake of good practices in implementation. TaSHI
applies different methods of analyses in order to provide added value on the concept, notion, and implementation
of task shifting at EU-, national- and regional levels. TaSHI performs pilots at five implementation sites to gather
evidence and data on the different types of task shifting (e.g. working time re-allocation, re-considered scope of
practices in primary care, mental health care, radiology and ophthalmology, benefiting from telemedicine and digital
health).TaSHI aims to facilitate dialogues and knowledge exchanges between the relevant stakeholders. Strengthening
governance and stakeholder engagement for transferring and upscaling task shifting practices plays a crucial role in
policy-making supporting health reforms for workforce development, as well as in enhancing cultural sensitivity,
flexibility, readiness, and organizational adaptation to task shifting.TaSHI delivers a collection of good practices,
useful tools and methods, a guidebook on task shifting supporting the real-life implementation, case studies on the
pilots’ experiences, practical training materials and curriculum, and a set of recommendations. The deliverables on
tangible solutions and practical products support EU MS at policy and organisational level to initiate and implement
their own actions tailored to the local settings.
Page 3 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1.2. List of Beneficiaries
Project Number 1 101018346 Project Acronym 2 TaSHI
List of Beneficiaries
Project Project
No Name Short name Country entry exit
month8 month
1 SEMMELWEIS EGYETEM SU Hungary 1 36
AGENZIA NAZIONALE PER I SERVIZI
2 AGE.NA.S Italy 1 36
SANITARI REGIONALI
STICHTING NEDERLANDS INSTITUUT
3 VOOR ONDERZOEK VAN DE NIVEL Netherlands 1 36
GEZONDHEIDSZORG
LIETUVOS RESPUBLIKOS SVEIKATOS
4 MOH-LT Lithuania 1 36
APSAUGOS MINISTERIJA
5 SOTSIAALMINISTEERIUM SM-EE Estonia 1 36
6 UNIVERSITETET I SOROST-NORGE USN Norway 1 36
ISTITUTO REGIONALE PER IL
7 SUPPORTOALLAE POLITICHE DELLA PoliS-Lombardia Italy 1 36
LOMBARDIA (POLIS-LOMBARDIA)
Page 4 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1.3. Workplan Tables - Detailed implementation
1.3.1. WT1 List of work packages
WP Person- Start End
WP Title Lead beneficiary10
Number9 months11 month12 month13
Project management and
WP1 1 - SU 23.06 1 36
coordination of the project
WP2 Dissemination and Communication 1 - SU 20.30 1 36
WP3 Evaluation 3 - NIVEL 10.20 1 36
Preparation - Knowledge
WP4 6 - USN 20.78 4 30
management
WP5 Implementation 2 - AGE.NA.S 40.71 4 36
Total 115.05
Page 5 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1.3.2. WT2 list of deliverables
Due
Deliverable WP Dissemination
Deliverable Title Lead beneficiary Type 15 Date (in
Number14 number9 level16
months)17
Confidential,
only for members
of the consortium
D1.1 Inception report WP1 1 - SU Report 3
(including the
Commission
Services)
Dissemination and
D2.1 WP2 1 - SU Report Public 3
communication plan
Initial leaflet and roll-
D2.2 WP2 1 - SU Report Public 3
up
Websites,
D2.3 Website WP2 1 - SU patents Public 3
filling, etc.
Mid-term dissemination
D2.4 and communication WP2 1 - SU Report Public 18
report
Report on Stakeholder
D2.5 management and event WP2 1 - SU Report Public 30
execution
Dissemination and
D2.6 WP2 1 - SU Report Public 36
communication report
End of project booklet
D2.7 WP2 1 - SU Report Public 36
for the public
Confidential,
Evaluation strategy only for members
and plan: approaches, of the consortium
D3.1 WP3 3 - NIVEL Report 3
materials, methods, (including the
tools and requirements Commission
Services)
Mid-term evaluation
D3.2 WP3 3 - NIVEL Report Public 18
report
D3.3 Evaluation report WP3 3 - NIVEL Report Public 36
Collection of useful
D4.1 tools and practices in WP4 6 - USN Report Public 6
task shifting
Confidential,
Pilot materials only for members
of the practical of the consortium
D4.2 WP4 6 - USN Report 15
training materials and (including the
curriculum Commission
Services)
Practical training
D4.3 materials and WP4 6 - USN Report Public 30
curriculum
Page 6 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Due
Deliverable WP Dissemination
Deliverable Title Lead beneficiary Type15 Date (in
Number14 number9 level16
months)17
Case studies of
D5.1 WP5 2 - AGE.NA.S Report Public 20
implementation sites
Guidebook of task
D5.2 WP5 2 - AGE.NA.S Report Public 30
shifting
Set of recommendations
D5.3 WP5 2 - AGE.NA.S Report Public 36
for task shifting actions
Page 7 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1.3.3. WT3 Work package descriptions
Work package number 9 WP1 Lead beneficiary 10 1 - SU
Work package title Project management and coordination of the project
Start month 1 End month 36
Objectives
This WP of Project Management and Coordination executes the daily management of the TaSHI project and will provide
overall planning, facilitate collaboration and follow up actions. The main objective is to achieve the goals set by the call
and to design performance leading to a specific and successful outcome.
Description of work and role of partners
WP1 - Project management and coordination of the project [Months: 1-36]
SU, AGE.NA.S, NIVEL, MOH-LT, SM-EE, USN, PoliS-Lombardia
Description of work
A detailed gantt chart involves the scheduled work of this WP, based on a monthly breakdown. This WP is responsible
for delivering the milestones and deliverables of TaSHI on scheduled time to other WPs and to Chafea/EC. Besides
monitoring reporting, this WP coordinates expansively the work of the partners, partners cooperations, follows deadlines
in the project, and provides dispute resolution if necessary. WP1 is also responsible for the communication on behalf
of the TaSHI Consortium with Chafea/EC.
Planned actions in internal communication and documentation:
-Creating a common mailing list to reach the operative members of each WP
-Creating a common repository for the online work
-Monthly electronic WP leader meetings
-Bi- and multilateral meetings - on demand
-Final meeting in Rome
Communication towards Chafea/EC:
-Audio/online progress meetings with Chafea/EC - one audio meeting per project year
-Personal progress meetings, to be discussed
Participation per Partner
Partner number and short name WP1 effort
1 - SU 20.10
2 - AGE.NA.S 0.35
3 - NIVEL 0.35
4 - MOH-LT 0.78
5 - SM-EE 0.78
6 - USN 0.35
7 - PoliS-Lombardia 0.35
Total 23.06
Page 8 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
List of deliverables
Due
Deliverable
Deliverable Title Lead beneficiary Type 15
Dissemination level 16 Date (in
Number14
months)17
Confidential, only
for members of the
D1.1 Inception report 1 - SU Report consortium (including 3
the Commission
Services)
Description of deliverables
D1 - Inception Report - This deliverable is a plan of actions and timeline for conducting the project and detailed
explanation of the whole project work. (M3)
D1.1 : Inception report [3]
This deliverable is the a workplan of actions and timeline for conducting the project and detailed explanation of the
whole project work. Details will be discussed and agreed in the Kick-off meeting (Milestone 1).
Schedule of relevant Milestones
Due
Milestone
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18
months)
First official meeting with
the project team, Chafea and
the European Commission.
Discussion about the
MS1 Kick-off meeting 1 - SU 1
implementation of the
project, agreement of the final
workplan will be summarized
in the Inception report D1.
Draft Inception Report
summarizes the TaSHI
MS2 Draft Inception Report 1 - SU 2 workplan discussed and
agreed at the Kick-off
meeting.
Draft Progess Report is
the first draft summarizing
the progess of workplan
implemented by TaSHI during
MS3 Draft Progress Report 1 - SU 17
the fist half of the project
duration. Draft reports ensure
keeping the timing planned
for evaluation before delivery.
Draft Final Report is the first
draft summarizing the progess
of workplan implemented
by TaSHI during the whole
MS4 Draft Final Report 1 - SU 34
project duration. Draft reports
ensure keeping the timing
planned for evaluation before
delivery.
Page 9 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Work package number 9 WP2 Lead beneficiary 10 1 - SU
Work package title Dissemination and Communication
Start month 1 End month 36
Objectives
Well designed communication and dissemination strategy and plan have an important role in the whole duration of the
project, as they strongly support the achievement of the general and specific objectives. WP2 contributes to provide all
relevant information to the network of stakeholders, interested bodies and further beneficiaries. In this WP our primary
goal is to have a complex, efficient dissemination activity reaching out to relevant networks in HWF development
through a number of channels. We aim to provide them with up-to-date information based on a communication schedule
designed in detail, at the same time provide platforms for interaction (e.g. at the specific “Health Workforce” forum).
An essential part of this WP2 is to map the stakeholders and to engage them into an active community facilitating
knowledge transfer and exchange of experiences and evidence. Given the significant proportion of online platforms and
activities WP2 dissemination will reach all EU MS with a variety of communication channels, as well as facilitating
policy dialogue and reaching the 27 Member States and beyond.
Description of work and role of partners
WP2 - Dissemination and Communication [Months: 1-36]
SU, AGE.NA.S, NIVEL, MOH-LT, SM-EE, USN, PoliS-Lombardia
The dissemination and communication activity involves a number of activities, such as creation of dissemination
materials (e.g. leaflet, booklet), presentation of the TaSHI project and its activities in the various channels (e.g. website,
newsletters), as well as controlling and regulating the consistency of presentation of all materials for the public about
the TaSHI project.
Step 1 - Preparation of the Communication and dissemination strategy and plan, setting up and designing the TaSHI
dissemination (M1-M3)
The first activities of the TaSHI project will focus on the preparation of the Communication and dissemination strategy
and plan, which contains various elements. Design of the website, outlook of the newsletters, visual identity and
dissemination materials (e.g. TaSHI project leaflet), templates will follow defined publicity guidelines with a house
style and logo besides the mandatory elements. Figure 3 shows the logo proposals for the project.
The WP leader has a possibility to run project websites under the university’s umbrella, therefore a long term
availability is guaranteed. The WP leader is currently hosting the healthworkforce.eu website with the archive page
of the Joint Action on European Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting. The TaSHI website can be linked to
the abovementioned website, thereby ensuring a better visibility of the project. In addition, this would also ensure a
long-term sustainability of the website. We are engaged to be active in the online space especially in the times of the
COVID-19 pandemic, therefore we place a significant emphasis on our visibility utilizing the means provided by the
internet. We aim to define the relevant target groups we want to reach and their preferred online communication channels
and then we can create a more precise plan in order to engage the highest possible number of stakeholders.
The Communication and dissemination strategy and plan will also list the TaSHI project deliverables and publishable
materials on a timeline and plan their effective dissemination by target groups (e.g. the laymen report of the project or
other WP deliverables). Among the objectives of the project, we emphasized the importance of sharing the experiences
and practices, the potential aim for upscaling the pilot implementation experiences, therefore to provide a high visibility,
accessibility and availability of the results and outputs are crucial.
Step 2 - Activating channels for dissemination and communication (M3-M36)
In the second phase of preparation of the Communication and dissemination strategy and plan, a stakeholder mapping
and target audience identification will be applied. As described in the Stakeholders section in section 3 above, the main
types of the stakeholders have been already identified, however a more detailed mapping by using the tool of stakeholder
coverage evaluation from the “Toolkit on HWF planning ” - designed by the Joint Action on European Health Workforce
Planning and Forecasting - will support this exercise.
The dissemination and communication WP aims to engage stakeholders in order to increase the impact of the TaSHI
project through the channels listed below. Seven different communication channels are planned to be utilized for
dissemination (to be further specified in the Communication and dissemination strategy and plan). This activity also
requires network management and animation, as well as online event planning.
One of the main information sharing platforms will be the newly designed TaSHI project website. We will also include
the websites of the Consortium partners in order to have a wider outreach to the relevant target groups. The presentation
Page 10 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
of the TaSHI project will be strictly determined by the publicity guidelines. Partners will be asked to contribute to
increased visibility, e.g. to post the selected messages on their websites, newsletters and social media platforms, publish
short news/videos of the TaSHI project on the related websites, youtube channels, which will be also controlled and
coordinated by WP2. We will set the optimal number of posts placed on the different channels keeping the balance of
giving important and interesting information at the same time not overwhelming our target audience.
TaSHI newsletters will be released every four month - in total nine editions during the project - in order to keep the
stakeholders updated and active, and provide information sharing to a wider audience of subscribers. To disseminate
actions of the partners of the consortium we will post brief articles in the partner’s newsletters. The content of the
newsletters will be created and coordinated by the editorial team of WP2, following the pre-defined structure.
TaSHI is planning to use the EU Health Policy Platform, where the WP leader is currently moderating the SEPEN
designated group on “Health Workforce”. Management of virtual exchanges of the stakeholders through the EU Health
Policy Platform, and the organisation of webinars and online policy dialogues would highly support the widespread
visibility and accessibility of TaSHI outputs and results. On this platform, joint webinars with the other funded projects
in the related topics could be executed. An event plan will be prepared on maximising the synergies of the parallel
running projects.
Personal appearance: Currently, the online appearance is preferred due to the travel restrictions caused by COVID-19. In
the upcoming time, this situation might change, therefore we consider face-to-face events as well in our dissemination
and communication WP. In case our partners will attend conferences/events in the duration of this project we would use
the opportunity to spread the information about our work, use the opportunity of networking, attracting more experts
and stakeholders of this field. At the same time personal meetings will give the opportunity to learn and gain new
information, which could support the work of this partnership. Flyers and hand out materials will be provided by WP2
for personal meetings on demand.
Step 3 - Interim evaluation (M15-M18)
Since the TaSHI project runs for 36 months we intend to carry out an interim evaluation of dissemination and
communication activities. We aim to carry out a quick satisfaction survey among the stakeholders engaged towards
TaSHI (e.g. website visitors, newsletter subscribers, EU HPP webinar participants). This task will support the
development of methods and tools utilized in the project.
Participation per Partner
Partner number and short name WP2 effort
1 - SU 18.54
2 - AGE.NA.S 0.21
3 - NIVEL 0.21
4 - MOH-LT 0.46
5 - SM-EE 0.46
6 - USN 0.21
7 - PoliS-Lombardia 0.21
Total 20.30
List of deliverables
Due
Deliverable
Deliverable Title Lead beneficiary Type15 Dissemination level16 Date (in
Number14
months)17
Dissemination and
D2.1 1 - SU Report Public 3
communication plan
D2.2 Initial leaflet and roll-up 1 - SU Report Public 3
Page 11 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
List of deliverables
Due
Deliverable
Deliverable Title Lead beneficiary Type 15
Dissemination level 16 Date (in
Number14
months)17
Websites,
D2.3 Website 1 - SU patents Public 3
filling, etc.
Mid-term dissemination
D2.4 and communication 1 - SU Report Public 18
report
Report on Stakeholder
D2.5 management and event 1 - SU Report Public 30
execution
Dissemination and
D2.6 1 - SU Report Public 36
communication report
End of project booklet
D2.7 1 - SU Report Public 36
for the public
Description of deliverables
D2 - Dissemination and communication plan - This plan will include the design of the website, outlook of the
newsletters, dissemination materials (e.g. TaSHI project leaflet), templates will follow defined publicity guidelines
with a house style and logo besides the mandatory elements. (M3)
D3 - Initial leaflet and roll-up - These printed materials will include the main information about the project and will
support online and personal presentations.(M3)
D4 - Website - The newly designed website will be one of the main information sharing platforms of the project. The
website will be user friendly, nicely displayed and regularly updated. (M3)
D5 - Mid -term dissemination and communication report - This report discusses the results of the interim evaluation
and communication of TaSHI (Milestone 7). It summarizes experiences and changes in the plan - if necessary - for the
second part of the project in terms of dissemination and communication activities. (M18)
D6 - Report on Stakeholder management and event execution - In this report Milestone 8 (Draft report on Stakeholder
management and event execution) will be updated and complemented including all the progress carried out by M30
D7 - Dissemination and communication report - Report summarising the achieved results of the communication and
dissemination activities carried out during the project. It discusses the developemnt of work and updates information
of deliverables prepared in WP2 (D2-D6). (M36)
D8 - End of project booklet for the public - This deliverable will be a brief summary of the project achievements for
the public (10 pages Laymen report) (M36)
D2.1 : Dissemination and communication plan [3]
This plan will include the publicity guideleines and visual identity of TaSHI (e.g. house style and logo, design of
the website, outlook of the newsletters and of dissemination materials, templates, website draft, leaflet (D3-4). In
addition, it will summarize the communication and dissemination plan including stakeholder/target audience map and
channels tailored to various target audiences.
D2.2 : Initial leaflet and roll-up [3]
These printed materials will include the main information about the project and will support online and personal
presentations.
D2.3 : Website [3]
The newly designed website will be one of the main information sharing platforms of the TaSHI project. The TaSHI
website will be user friendly, nicely displayed and continuously updated during the whole project duration.
D2.4 : Mid-term dissemination and communication report [18]
Page 12 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
This report discusses the results of the interim evaluation and communication of TaSHI (Milestone 7). It summarizes
experiences and changes in the plan - if necessary - for the second part of the project in terms of dissemination and
communication activities.
D2.5 : Report on Stakeholder management and event execution [30]
This deliverable will summarize the communication and dissemination activities carried out continuously during
M3-M30, including details on the dissemination products and stakeholder management: TaSHI website, TaSHI
newsletters, Articles, short posts on EU HPP specific “Health Workforce” forum, Social media sites (linkedin,
facebook, twitter), Partners websites and newsletters, Partners Youtube channels, Webinars/Joint webinars with
related projects/online events, Rollup and leaflet, promotion material production. In this report Milestone 8 (Draft
report on Stakeholder management and event execution in M5) will be updated and complemented including all the
progress carried out by M30.
D2.6 : Dissemination and communication report [36]
Report summarising the achieved results of the communication and dissemination activities carried out during the
project. It discusses the developemnt of work and updates information of deliverables prepared in WP2 (D2-D6).
D2.7 : End of project booklet for the public [36]
This deliverable will be a brief summary of the project achievements for the public (10 pages Laymen report).
Schedule of relevant Milestones
Due
Milestone
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18
months)
Development of the
visual identity refers to
dissemination related
materials such as project
logo, templates for internal
and public documents,
Publicity guidelines, house
MS5 1 - SU 3 leaflet and newsletter
style and logo
format, etc. All guidelines
regarding dissemination
and communication will be
defined at the beginning of
the project in order to design
the project image.
This plan will cover all
aspects of the webinars,
Webinar series, event events. The planned timing,
MS6 1 - SU 4
execution plan invitation process, promotion/
publicity, execution and
followup activities.
In order to to improve all
the communication and
dissemination tools we
will carry out an interim
Interim evaluation
evaluation survey between
MS7 of dissemination and 1 - SU 18
month 15-18. Target audience
communication of TaSHI
of TaSHI will be asked to rate
the quality and quantity of the
information published on our
communication channels.
Page 13 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Schedule of relevant Milestones
Due
Milestone
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18
months)
This milestone refers to
the first version of the
Draft report on Stakeholder stakeholder analysis and the
MS8 management and event 1 - SU 5 dissemination channels and
execution networks, and refers to the
plan of the webinars, events
as well.
Page 14 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Work package number 9 WP3 Lead beneficiary 10 3 - NIVEL
Work package title Evaluation
Start month 1 End month 36
Objectives
Work Package 3 maintains two objectives: 1) to verify if the project is being implemented as planned and 2) to verify if
the defined objectives are reached. Continuous improvement of the TaSHI project is the overarching goal. An evaluation
strategy will be designed that is based on the methods for the evaluation, the indicators and measures of verification.
The indicators are directly linked with the specific objectives, deliverables and milestones and explain how they will
be measured. This WP will be executed in parallel with the project itself, while taking a position as an independent
evaluator and counsellor within the consortium.
Description of work and role of partners
WP3 - Evaluation [Months: 1-36]
NIVEL, SU, AGE.NA.S, MOH-LT, SM-EE, USN, PoliS-Lombardia
Step 1 - Develop an evaluation strategy and plan (M1-M3)
This Work Package concerns an ‘internal evaluation’, coordinated by Nivel that will conduct a systematic appraisal
of the quality of the actions of the project. The Nivel team will be supported in its evaluation tasks by representatives
from a number of relevant organisations that will be recruited for the ‘TaSHI Advisory Board’. Aimed members of this
are already approached (with positive response from, among others, WHO Regional Office for Europe). The ‘TaSHI
Advisory Board’ will consist of a minimum of five members from 5 different organisations. Involvement of health
professional organizations into “TaSHI Advisory Board” ensures the strong connection with providers as well (e.g.
European Hospital Federation, European Forum for Primary Care, European Patients’ Forum, European Federation of
Nurses Associations, European Specialist Nurse Organisation, The Standing Committee of European Doctors, Council
of European Dentists, Pharmaceutical Group of the European Union, etc.). The ‘Tashi Advisory Board’ will take into
account a good representation of EU regions and countries along with the countries in the Consortium. They are invited
to join two to three online meetings per year, depending on the planning of all projects deliverables and milestones.
An evaluation strategy and plan will be developed directly at the start of the project and be delivered in M3. The plan
will define when the project tasks are being delivered efficiently and effectively (in terms of processes and products)
based on predefined indicators. This is to assess whether the aims of the project have been met but also how these have
been achieved – and how this can be improved during the project. The plan will be aligned with all the deliverables of
the Project (see section 8) and the milestone planned between these deliverables.
The evaluation plan will provide an overview of:
● The specific objectives, deliverables and milestones to be evaluated (as described in the respective Work Packages);
● The indicators relevant to evaluate the objectives, deliverables and milestones (including the process, output and
outcome indicators as defined in section 2);
● Data that is needed to feed these indicators, taking into account different data sources such as milestones, documents,
reports, minutes, presentations, feedback reports, et cetera’
● Ways the evaluation will be executed with the relevant consortium members and the support of “TaSHI Advisory
Board” as external experts outside the consortium;
● Evaluation instruments applied, in terms of quality standards from an scientific perspective as well as assessment
standards form a policy and practical perspective (due to the variation of the deliverables and milestones, there will be
no standard format for assessment);
● Planning of the evaluation, as this WP will run along the total project and align with all the deliverables, milestones
as well as the planned division of tasks and responsibilities between the Consortium partners;
● The risks, barriers and facilitators encountered during the project, and conclusions to be drawn;
● Ways the results of the evaluation are fed back to the responsible Work Package leaders and all other partners of
the consortium.
The evaluation plan needs to be agreed upon by all Consortium Members, including the quantitative and qualitative
indicators that will be applied and used. As mentioned before, the list of deliverables and milestones as described in
the respective Work Packages and section 8 in this proposal will be the starting point of the content of the evaluation
and strategy plan.
Step 2 - Executing of the evaluation plan (M3-36)
Page 15 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
As it is pre-defined which partner is responsible for which deliverable and task, this/these person(s) will be the main
subject to the evaluation as the milestone approaches (as planned and presented in section 8). I.e., the relevant partner
is requested to submit the planned deliverable and milestone two to three weeks ahead of its deadline. This pre-
deliverable/milestone will be reviewed by the Nivel team leading of this Work Packages, consulting the other consortium
partners if necessary, and (if applicable or useful) the members from the “TaSHI Advisory Board”. The results from
this consultation and review will be summarized and suggested changes will be discussed with the responsible Work
Package leader(S). Next, the relevant partner will submit the adjusted deliverable, that will be re-evaluated by the Nivel
team as leaders of this Work Package in order to consider it final and in adjustment of the deliverable/milestone deadline.
A key evaluation task is to monitor, assure and support that the pre-defined deadlines of all the deliverables and
milestones (as described in the WPs and section 8) are met. Next to this process evaluation, the key task is to evaluate
the content of the deliverables and milestones, as outputs in itself, but also as outcomes in relation to the total project
and its specific goals. Therefore, subject to this evaluation is that each deliverable and milestone of the WPs is aligned
with each other and the process indicators as defined earlier in section 2 by the specific goals of the Project being:
Ad 1: Added value at EU-, national- and regional levels
● Suggestion of changes in legal and policy environment to provide incentives to remove legal and other barriers to the
recruitment and retention of healthcare workforce in underserved areas;
● Providing good practices for introduction of task-shifting – patient safety / HS performance;
● Providing recommendations on impact of new skills, including digital tools, disease prevention, risk detection; provide
aid in the reskilling of HWF; as well as future HWF.
Ad 2: New knowledge on task shifting processes
● Identification and analysis of the concept and implementation of task shifting;
● Providing an update on existing tools to incorporate task shifting processes;
● Mitigate the effects of changing skill-mixes and competencies – across sectors and occupational groups.
Ad 3: Dissemination and exchange of knowledge on task shifting processes
● Implementing strategies and identifying best practices, facilitating the exchange of these concepts;
● Contribution to the EU HWF network, specific “Health Workforce” forum, dissemination of knowledge;
● Organizing seminars and thematic workshops to ensure joint reflection and enhancing knowledge and lessons learnt.
Ad 4: Progress towards the implementation of task shifting processes for the HWF
● Development of practical guidelines for the public authorities and healthcare providers which will serve as operational
tools supporting their healthcare workforce policies in relation to challenges in these fields;
● Provide practical training and education materials;
● Developing curricula for digital, interpersonal, and management skills for physicians, nurses, pharmacists, and other
HWF;
● Provide recommendations for future HWF skills to aid better adaptation to new developments; provide aid in the
upskilling of nurses, including digital skills, with the involvement of IT specialists.
During its execution, the evaluation will analyse the backgrounds and reasons for any deviation from the deadline and/
or quality indicators applied. This is to act on any discrepancy or possible delay, and take ‘corrective measures’ into
place when necessary. The monitoring of the compliance of the deliverables and milestones of this project, against the
standards set in the quality checklists, will be communicated and discussed within the consortium during the evaluation
meetings that will be planned.
Due to the situation of COVID-19, the evaluation meetings will take place mostly online, and additionally face to face
in combination with the consortium meetings that are already planned. The meetings will be planned, prepared and
organised by the Nivel team, with the relevant Work Packages leader(s) responsible for the specific deliverables or
milestones to be discussed. As mentioned above, the draft deliverables and milestones are requested by the evaluation
team before two to three weeks ahead of the relevant deadline(s). Comments and feedback is provided in-text of the
deliverables and milestones, and discussed in person during the meetings. Meeting records and minutes are being kept
and exchanged for verification. These records are also exchanged with the Project Management Team.
The (online) meetings with the “TaSHI Advisory Board” take place two to three times per year, discussing sets of
deliverables and milestones in alignment with the Project planning. The Nivel team will plan, prepare and lead these
meetings as well, including records and minutes taking. In each meeting of this Board, a member of the Project
Management Team will participate, as well as one or two WP leaders relevant for the sets of deliverables and milestones
at the agenda.
Step 3 - Update of D7 with Sustainability plan M33
In addition to the evaluation strategy and plan, a sustainability plan will be included. This product will enable upscaling
exercise in the EU and provide sustainability for task shifting implementations beyond the project timeframe. Special
attention from the Evaluation WP 3 will be dedicated to the lessons learned from the Project, its planning, process and
results.
Page 16 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Participation per Partner
Partner number and short name WP3 effort
1 - SU 0.78
2 - AGE.NA.S 0.35
3 - NIVEL 6.81
4 - MOH-LT 0.78
5 - SM-EE 0.78
6 - USN 0.35
7 - PoliS-Lombardia 0.35
Total 10.20
List of deliverables
Due
Deliverable
Deliverable Title Lead beneficiary Type15 Dissemination level16 Date (in
Number14
months)17
Confidential, only
Evaluation strategy
for members of the
and plan: approaches,
D3.1 3 - NIVEL Report consortium (including 3
materials, methods, tools
the Commission
and requirements
Services)
Mid-term evaluation
D3.2 3 - NIVEL Report Public 18
report
D3.3 Evaluation report 3 - NIVEL Report Public 36
Description of deliverables
D9 - Evaluation strategy & plan: approaches, materials, methods, tools and requirements
This deliverable will define when the project tasks are being delivered efficiently and effectively (in terms of
processes and products) based on predefined indicators (M3).
D10 - Mid-term evaluation report - This report will summarize the key findings in terms of the evaluation activities in
the first half of the project. It summarizes experiences and changes in the plan - if necessary - for the second part of
the project in terms of evaluation activities. (M18)
D11 - Evaluation report - This report will summarize the key findings of the evaluation activities during the whole
project, including sustainability plan (Milestone 10). (M36)
D3.1 : Evaluation strategy and plan: approaches, materials, methods, tools and requirements [3]
This deliverable will define when the project tasks are being delivered efficiently and effectively (in terms of
processes and products) based on predefined indicators.
D3.2 : Mid-term evaluation report [18]
This report will summarize the key findings in terms of the evaluation activities in the first half of the project.
It summarizes experiences and changes in the plan - if necessary - for the second part of the project in terms of
evaluation activities.
D3.3 : Evaluation report [36]
This report will summarize the key findings of the evaluation activities during the whole project, including
sustainability plan (Milestone 10).
Page 17 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Schedule of relevant Milestones
Due
Milestone
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18
months)
This milestone is the first
draft of the Evaluation
strategy & plan including
information on approaches,
materials, methods, tools
and requirements to be used
First draft of Evaluation in WP3. This draft will list
MS9 3 - NIVEL 2
strategy & plan and predefine indicators
for efficient and effective
delivery of products and
processes for the whole
duration of the project, as
well as to define the "TaSHI
Advisory Board".
This Evaluation strategy &
plan will be updated with
information on the progress in
WP3, including for example
the efficient and effective
delivery of products and
processes, the outcomes of
the activities of the "TaSHI
Update of D9 with a Advisory Board". Based on
MS10 3 - NIVEL 33
Sustainability plan the results and outcomes
of TaSHI achieved duting
the project duration, this
updated report will attach a
sustainability plan discussing
the recommendations for
the future, as well as the
utilization of TaSHI in the
future.
Page 18 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Work package number 9 WP4 Lead beneficiary 10 6 - USN
Work package title Preparation - Knowledge management
Start month 4 End month 30
Objectives
The main objective of WP4 is 1) to explore and map existing practices in task shifting, 2) to gather evidence on
concepts and practice of implementation and 3) to develop a curriculum and training for task shifting, which are enabled
particularly by digital skills for healthcare professionals.
Description of work and role of partners
WP4 - Preparation - Knowledge management [Months: 4-30]
USN, SU, AGE.NA.S, NIVEL, PoliS-Lombardia
Description of work
Step 1 - Desk research: Collection of existing good practices in Task shifting (M3-M6)
● EU projects screening - exploring EU funded projects, concepts, tools and outcomes - grey literature
● Academic systematic literature review (e.g. books, research projects, guidelines, academic papers, survey, reports
etc.) - inclusion criteria and exact keywords to be defined: geographic coverage EU-EEA, time of the last decade etc.
● Interviewing key informants in the frames of webinars or online thematic workshops, round tables - using WP2
webinars and networking events for focus-group interviews and stakeholder engagement
These activities will address the current need for curriculum development as the impact of the rapid transformation of
medicine and healthcare management. The emerging trends call for a change in education and types of training. These
will address the following:
1) Interprofessional training and collaborative practice bringing a new approach to learning and sharing (integration
and more committed HWF).
2) Acquiring transversal skills - upskilling and upscaling HWF (knowledge, skills and competency sharing), developing
capabilities on digital health, leadership and management, good governance - assessment and evaluation.
3) Disruptive change and resiliency - technology & organizational adaptation, organizational reforms, supportive
working environments and supportive organisational culture, leading to improved working conditions in the different
levels of care)
4) Enhancing cultural sensitivity, flexibility and readiness - acquiring transversal skills (OECD 2018 ), flexibility for
skill-mix, interprofessional teams and collaborative practice in the rapidly changing times, we can identify different
levels of roles and responsibilities (health policy, organisational and individual) that facilitate avoiding of working in
silos (attitude and behavioural).
Mapping of existing practices will serve as an indicator of possible cultural differences and barriers on task shifting
across MS. The notion of task shifting is a relatively new concept, therefore a thorough overview of the situation in all of
the MS is needed to map the existing barriers or possible obstacles of the implementation of task shifting among HWF.
Step 2 - Establishing education guidelines and developing practical training materials and curriculum (M6-M30)
One of the key components of task shifting is identifying effective and efcient training methods for training para-
professionals and upskilling the HWF. Indeed, a growing number of countries have initiated direct training strategies to
facilitate task shifting processes. The so-called Just-In-Time Training method for example provides an effective strategy
for the rapid upskilling of health professionals, by focusing on only the most necessary training and knowledge specific
professionals are in need of for the carrying out of specific tasks, thereby facilitating task shifting options and competent
service delivery (McQuillin et al., 2019 ).
With this WP, we want to ensure that health professionals across the consortium are entitled to a coherent and quality-
assured educational program, where they acquire competence and achieve the learning outcomes in digital skills. We
want to ensure cohesive teaching and the use of digital learning-promoting forms of assessment that reinforce in-depth
learning and critical thinking.
The WP will lead to building new knowledge and further development of the professional environment where
pedagogical and didactic issues will be addressed, which will be discussed and further developed.
Page 19 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
The new training for task shifting will consist of modules which will cover and promote some of the transversal skills
(OECD 2018 Feasibility Study on Health Workforce Skills Assessment) , cultural sensitivity, flexibility and readiness
of the HWF:
● Ethics and professional standards - reflect on and deal with ethical issues in its service performance.
● Inclusion and equality - regardless of gender, ethnicity, religion and outlook on life, disability, sexual orientation,
gender identity, gender expression and age, so that the candidate contributes to ensuring equal services for all groups
in society.
● Communication and guidance skills that enable the candidate to understand and interact with users, patients and
relatives. Furthermore, the curriculum will enable us to guide users, patients and relatives and relevant personnel who
are in learning, mastering and changing processes.
● Interaction and interdisciplinary education - both interdisciplinary, interprofessional, cross-sectoral and across
companies and levels, and initiate such interaction.
● Public health - to understand the connections between health, education, work and living conditions, and can apply
this in their service, both to individuals and groups in society, to contribute to good public health and work inclusion.
● Knowledge-based practice - acquire new knowledge and make professional assessments, decisions and actions in line
with knowledge-based practice.
● Innovation - knowledge of new thinking and innovation processes and contribution to service innovation and
systematic and quality-improving work processes.
● Management and Leadership - learning to adapt the skills to lead effectively across geographies and culture, shared
decision making and health system awareness, change management, and adaptive problem solving skills, and
● Digital expertise - providing digital competence and assistance in the development of and usage of suitable technology
at both individual, organizational and system level.
For the development and design of online education, we will use the “Knowledge, Process, Practice (KPP) model” .
The model provides a concise map of how the educational features relate to each other and form a complete learning
sequence; a module or a programme. We will carry out a systematic literature review of learning and assessment methods
in online-education in healthcare which will feed into the three learning areas: knowledge, process and practice.
Knowledge is suitable for self-directed online learning and self-assessment. Moreover, a systematic approach allows
for blended learning. Formative assessment allows provision of links to additional learning (resource database) when
required.
Process takes the learner from assessment of existing and new knowledge to the application of knowledge in clinical
practice. We will apply a specific professional cognitive process (cases) in the learning to facilitate scaffolding of new
knowledge. Formative assessment will provide expert feedback and encourage further reflection when needed.
Practice provides the opportunity to compare new knowledge with current professional practice. We will develop
learning activities that generate opportunity for discussion.
Participation per Partner
Partner number and short name WP4 effort
1 - SU 7.73
2 - AGE.NA.S 2.06
3 - NIVEL 2.06
6 - USN 6.87
7 - PoliS-Lombardia 2.06
Total 20.78
Page 20 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
List of deliverables
Due
Deliverable
Deliverable Title Lead beneficiary Type 15
Dissemination level 16 Date (in
Number14
months)17
Collection of useful tools
D4.1 and practices in task 6 - USN Report Public 6
shifting
Confidential, only
Pilot materials of for members of the
D4.2 the practical training 6 - USN Report consortium (including 15
materials and curriculum the Commission
Services)
Practical training
D4.3 6 - USN Report Public 30
materials and curriculum
Description of deliverables
D12 - Collection of useful tools and practices in task shifting - This deliverable will involve a desk research on: EU
projects screening; academic systematic literature review; interviewing key informants in the frames of webinars or
online thematic workshops. The report will build on Milestone 11-12. (M6)
D13 - Pilot materials of the practical training materials and curriculum - Draft of the new training for task shifting
(consisting of modules which will cover and promote some of the transversal skills, cultural sensitivity, flexibility and
readiness of the HWF). This deliverable summarizes the draft curricula and training materials (Milestone 13 and 14).
(M15)
D14 - Practical training materials and curriculum - This new training for task shifting will consist of modules which
will cover and promote some of the transversal skills, cultural sensitivity, flexibility and readiness of the HWF. This
deliverable summarizes the draft curricula and training materials (Milestone 13 and 14 in M15), and incorporates the
results and lessons of the pilot implementations (carried out by WP5). (M30)
D4.1 : Collection of useful tools and practices in task shifting [6]
This deliverable will involve a desk research on: EU projects screening; academic systematic literature review;
interviewing key informants in the frames of webinars or online thematic workshops. The report will build on
Milestone 11-12.
D4.2 : Pilot materials of the practical training materials and curriculum [15]
Draft of the new training for task shifting (consisting of modules which will cover and promote some of the
transversal skills, cultural sensitivity, flexibility and readiness of the HWF). This deliverable summarizes the draft
curricula and training materials (Milestone 13 and 14).
D4.3 : Practical training materials and curriculum [30]
This new training for task shifting will consist of modules which will cover and promote some of the transversal
skills, cultural sensitivity, flexibility and readiness of the HWF. This deliverable summarizes the draft curricula and
training materials (Milestone 13 and 14 in M15), and incorporates the results and lessons of the pilot implementations
(carried out by WP5).
Schedule of relevant Milestones
Due
Milestone
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18
months)
WP4 will carry out a desk
Use of LOVU- methodology research to explore and map
MS11 on how to collect evidence 6 - USN 4 existing practices in task
and execute literature review shifting, and then establish
education guidelines and
Page 21 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Schedule of relevant Milestones
Due
Milestone
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18
months)
develop practical training
materials and curriculum.
The LOVU method enables
in addition to the KPP
educational model, a platform
and repository of learning
resources to apply to achieve
specific learning outcomes.
Findings of the desk research
and the excercise of gathering
evidence on concepts and
practices will enable WP4
to prepare a collection of
Findings of the desk research
MS12 6 - USN 6 useful tools and materials.
& analysing concepts
Findings also serve as an
input for M14, the practical
training material that will
be tested by WP5 during the
pilot implementations.
WP4 aims to develop a
curriculum and training
for task shifting, which
are enabled particularly by
digital skills for healthcare
professionals. For the
development and design
Curricula digital (including
of online education, the
MS13 digital, interpersonal and 6 - USN 15
“Knowledge, Process,
management skills)
Practice (KPP) model” will
be used. The model provides
a concise map of how the
educational features relate
to each other and form a
complete learning sequence; a
module or a programme.
Based on the previous
milestones (M11, M12, M13),
Developing pilot practical WP4 intends to develop
MS14 6 - USN 15
training materials practical training materials to
be utilized and tested in WP5
pilots.
This milestone ensures
that the experiences of all
pilots are incorporated into
Revised final version of the
the training materials and
MS15 practical training materials 6 - USN 30
curriculum on task shifting.
and curriculum
After realizing the pilot
implementations coordinated
by WP5, the experiences,
Page 22 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Schedule of relevant Milestones
Due
Milestone
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18
months)
lessons learnt and conclusions
will be included in D9.
Page 23 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Work package number 9 WP5 Lead beneficiary 10 2 - AGE.NA.S
Work package title Implementation
Start month 4 End month 36
Objectives
1. Support implementers in a mix-match approach to blend objectives and activities related to core features from
different task shifting tools and practices described by WP4.
2. Describe processes and results of the task shifting initiatives performed during the pilot exercise.
3. Support the exchange of knowledge and experiences of implementation by implementers including webinars and
online thematic workshops.
4. Identify general principles and individual characteristics of successful implementation of task shifting initiatives in
each pilot site.
5. Support the implementers to facilitate the sustainability of the practice by strategy and plans for actions at local/
regional/national level.
6. Generate set of recommendations and guidance for uptake of the pilot task shifting initiatives with new knowledge
and understanding, based on the results of implementation.
Description of work and role of partners
WP5 - Implementation [Months: 4-36]
AGE.NA.S, SU, NIVEL, MOH-LT, SM-EE, USN, PoliS-Lombardia
The WP5 will manage the implementations of task shifting initiatives in 5 EU countries: Italy, The Netherlands, Norway,
Lithuania, and Estonia. All of the implementation sites will involve health care providers, participating with a wide
variety of processes and system features. The implementation activities stand for the carrying out of task shifting and
task sharing processes on the five implementation sites. The pilot projects will focus on the implementation of some
good practices selected by WP4, using the step-wise approach suggested by the Calderdale framework (Smith, R., &
Duffy, J. Developing a competent and flexible workforce using the Calderdale Framework). The Calderdale is based on
a system-wide approach, in which those seeking change engage with stakeholders, identify and draw on existing best
practices, address governance issues, develop staffing and commit to sustainability.
A common seven-step implementation strategy will be used in the 5 pilot sites. This seven-step methodology is inspired
by the Calderdale Framework recommended for task shifting project implementation by the Expert Panel on effective
ways of investing in Health (EXPH) of the EU Commission (2019 Task shifting and health system design). It has
been defined to be appropriate from the scientific point of view, applicable considering data availability and feasible
according to the project´s timeline and resources. The pilots do not intend to use the Calderdale tools.
In addition, a common methodology on evaluating pilots will enable the Consortium to extract the experiences and
findings of the 5 pilots into various deliverables on 1) Case studies of implementation sites, 2) Guidebook of task
shifting, and 3) Set of recommendations for task shifting actions.
When preparing the implementation plan, a common methodology sets out 7 phases.
1. Awareness raising phase
The objective of this phase is to:
● describe the scope of intervention of the pilot project, identifying key actors at managerial level who can help to guide
the implementation process and incorporate the process within the service/organisation;
● involve the stakeholders identified allowing them to reflect and identify the most appropriate areas to intervene with
the framework;
● build and share the pilot project Action Plan with the identified stakeholders.
Creating and sharing a vision of the pilot project with the stakeholders will help reduce confusion and anxiety among
the staff involved about the process and potential changes.
The Power Interest Matrix stakeholder analysis (Adapted from Mendelow, A.L. Environmental Scanning - The Impact
of the Stakeholder Concept", ICIS 1981 Proceedings, 20 ) will be used to identify the stakeholders to be involved during
this first phase. The Power Interest matrix, is a simple tool that helps categorize project stakeholders with increasing
power and interest in the project. This tool helps to select and involve key stakeholders, who can implement or stop
your project. In turn, this tool helps in defining stakeholder priorities.
Implementing partners will perform this first phase by M4.
2. Service analysis
Page 24 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
In this phase, implementers will have to describe the service object of the task shifting project, identifying "who does
what" in the current setting, potential barriers to change and enablers.
In this phase, potential ideas for change to meet patients' needs arising from the stakeholders involved will also be
analysed taking into account the inputs provided by WP4.
Implementing partners will perform this first phase from M5 to M6.
3. Task analysis
At this stage, in each pilot project stakeholders will discuss and agree on the risks and mitigation of these risks when
considering a different worker performing a specific job or function.
A complete decision table will then be produced for each task/function indicating the risks and mitigations needed.
Implementing partners will perform this first phase from M7 to M12.
4. Competency identification
In this fourth phase, based on the analysis of the service (phase 2) of the tasks (phase 3), the implementers, together
with their stakeholders, will identify a set of skills needed to deliver the service and the tasks analysed.
For the activities foreseen in this phase, reference will be made to the competence framework proposed by the OECD
(2018 Feasibility Study on Health Workforce Skills Assessment). The OECD conceptual framework proposes to analyse
skills requirements in the health employment sector, including some proposed definitions of key terms. The concepts
build on the OECD’s Program for International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC), which undertakes surveys
of adult populations for their literacy skills understood as the interest, attitude and ability of individuals to appropriately
use socio-cultural tools, including digital technology and communication tools, to access, manage, integrate and evaluate
information, construct new knowledge, and communicate with others.
Rather than defining the skills associated with particular categories of health workers, the OECD conceptual framework,
by identifying the common functions and the skills associated with these functions by patient profiles, makes the process
independent of the assignment of skills to any specific category of workers.
Implementing partners will perform this first phase from M13 to M18.
5. Supporting systems
To ensure that robust governance mechanisms are in place to support new ways of working and new roles, WP5 will at
this stage analyse the governance systems in the pilot sites to support new ways of working and new roles.
Implementing partners will perform this first phase from M15 to M18.
6. Training
The objective of this phase is to ensure that all staff are trained in a manner appropriate to their role and the needs of
patients
It will be important at this stage to clarify the issues of accountability and accountability from both a clinical and
governance perspective.
WP4 will provide implementers with good practices to use to train staff involved in the task shifting initiative.
Implementing partners will perform this first phase from M19 to M24.
7. Sustainability
In this last phase, WP5, to ensure efficient use of the new roles, will assess the benefits of workforce development and
manage the barriers to implementation at each pilot site.
In addition, at each pilot site, in view of the sustainability of the system, forecasts of HWF needs will be updated,
including in the existing HWF planning system in the implementing country the task shifting initiatives tested in the
pilot project.
Implementing partners will perform this first phase from M24 to M30.
Brief description on pilots’ scopes
Lithuania - HWF working time allocation pilot
In order to solve the current challenges, Lithuania needs to free up time of the HWF towards direct service provision to
the patients, granting higher share of service hours towards result-oriented activities. Due to the complexity of current
practice routines there is no fact-based understanding of working hour consumption within primary care (GP and mental
health) to free up time of health personnel by reducing wasted time slots or delegation of routine tasks to innovative
eHealth solutions, or delegation of routine tasks towards lower skilled HWF with proper service quality control.
Current policy making processes require regular assessment of HWF working time allocation during the working time,
and the legal process in order to eliminate wasted time and provide a higher share of services. Having such a tool,
processes in the national health care system would be able to provide higher hours of HWF service hours without
increasing the burden to medical staff, without additional costs or high material investment and with improved job
satisfaction of HWF, higher satisfaction of patients to actual increases of service provision time.
In case of success of the project, it’s expected to eliminate at least 10% of HWF wasted working time and shifting at
least 10% of working time towards technology or by enhancing the role of lower level specialist in service provisions.
Overall improvement in 20% of service provisions at the country level will improve access to the quality health care
Page 25 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
services and overall job satisfaction of HWF. The financial outcome and savings are not calculated, but this is obvious
of 20% cost saving of the healthcare system.
Estonia - Reconsidering work routines of different levels of care provision pilot
There are at least two potential topics, where TaSHI project may have a direct impact on policy development during
the project period:
1) Bringing mental health nurses from hospital level special care to primary care centres. Providing mental health care
at a lower health care level might reduce pressure on psychiatric care and allows faster professional help for those in
need of mental health care services.
2) Shifting tasks from radiologists and radiology nurses to radiographers. A brand new Master level program (https://
www.nooruse.ee/radiography) was opened as part of the collaboration of several medical schools of the Baltics, Finland
and Ireland. Estonian legislation and work routines in hospitals need to be changed to allow the health system to fully
use the acquired skills of the radiographers.
On the other hand, Estonia has been a pioneer in developing e-health services, including task-shifting-to-digital
solutions. Country’s experience – both success stories and negative practice – can offer lessons for other countries
planning to shift tasks from health workers or patients to digital processes and solutions. Therefore, an experience
sharing, knowledge transfer and expertise exchange can serve the objectives of the other implementation pilots in WP5,
also add to the deliverables on tools and practices, and additionally it can contribute to the mapping exercise and
education guide in WP4.
Polis Lombardia - Increasing collaboration of health professions in primary care pilot
The intention is to primarily focus on task-shifting between GPs, nurses, and social workers (and also digital task
shifting), and to explore the possibility whether task-shifting can play a key-role in enhancing primary care services.
Indeed, Polis-Lombardia is organizing an innovative training course for primary care nurses in collaboration with the
regional government, and both local and national Orders of Nurses and Physicians. This course involves two classes
of 25 alumni (both GPs and nurses) for 78 hours of frontal learning and 300 hours of internship (only for nurses). The
main goals are to increase collaboration between nurses and GPs, to identify where task shifting is possible, and to
enhance digital skills.
After assessing and evaluating this course we aim to reach more than 3000 healthcare professionals per year in the
Lombardy region. During the assessment and evaluation, we aim to gain better perspectives on task-shifting experiences
in Lombardy and Italy, so plan to interview local and national professional associations’ coordinators as well.
Based on the experience of the first edition of the course and the conclusions of the interviews, Polis Lombardia will
implement the Calderdale framework and further methods and tools as proposed in WP4-WP5 in order to improve the
next editions of training courses.
Norway - Supportive telemedicine pilots
In Norway, two pilot implementation topics are foreseen in the frame of the TaSHI project. One is focusing on video
consultation in wound care and the other one on teleradiography with paramedic CT in rural areas. Both pilots are
demonstrating the task shifting enabled by telemedicine/video consultation/digital solutions.
The first pilot aims to introduce video consultation for patients and provide digital wound care. In order to initiate such
a telemedicine project, upskilling the workforce with the necessary skills is the first priority. The pilot will elaborate
the skill needs of the multidisciplinary teams in wound care clinics and design a curriculum and education guidance
for managing video consultations.
During the second pilot, we aim to gather experience of the multidisciplinary team on their skill needs and experiences
of the tasks executed remotely. This practice will enable supporting early diagnosis of stroke in rural areas without the
appropriate medical equipment.
The Netherlands - Task shifting in the field of ophthalmology
For the TaSHI project, regional projects, current practices in the Netherlands will be monitored in which
ophthalmologists and optometrists collaborate. In one ongoing project in the region of Twente, ophthalmologists and
optometrists work together in optics shops, causing that the number of referrals has decreased considerably. GPs
tend to refer patients to optometrists instead of the ophthalmologists, thus the workload of the different professionals
and patients pathway are modified. Also in the region of Rotterdam, cooperation and task shifting practices between
ophthalmologists and optometrists can be monitored for the TaSHI project. Both regional projects provide an opportunity
to explore the main features, advantages and obstacles in task-shifting practices. The collected information, data and
experiences of these practices can contribute to better understanding of task-shifting between health professions.
Participation per Partner
Page 26 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Partner number and short name WP5 effort
1 - SU 3.09
2 - AGE.NA.S 6.18
3 - NIVEL 3.78
4 - MOH-LT 11.59
5 - SM-EE 8.51
6 - USN 3.78
7 - PoliS-Lombardia 3.78
Total 40.71
List of deliverables
Due
Deliverable
Deliverable Title Lead beneficiary Type 15
Dissemination level 16 Date (in
Number14
months)17
Case studies of
D5.1 2 - AGE.NA.S Report Public 20
implementation sites
Guidebook of task
D5.2 2 - AGE.NA.S Report Public 30
shifting
Set of recommendations
D5.3 2 - AGE.NA.S Report Public 36
for task shifting actions
Description of deliverables
D15 - Case studies of implementation sites - The Consortium will extract the experiences and findings of the 5 pilots
into various deliverables. One of these outputs will be the case studies of implementation sites. (M20)
D16 - Guidebook of task shifting -This deliverable will summarize the guidelines and lessons learned based on the
exercises carried out in this WP. In this guidebook the Consortium will involve the findings of the 5 pilot projects.
(M30)
D17 - Set of recommendations for task shifting actions - This deliverable will involve the good practices, results and
conclusions gained through the execution of the pilot projects with the aim of strengthening the knowledge on task
shifting. (M36)
D5.1 : Case studies of implementation sites [20]
The Consortium will extract the experiences and findings of the 5 pilots into various deliverables. One of these
outputs will be the case studies of implementation sites.
D5.2 : Guidebook of task shifting [30]
This deliverable will summarize the guidelines and lessons learned based on the exercises carried out in this WP. In
this guidebook the Consortium will involve the findings of the 5 pilot projects.
D5.3 : Set of recommendations for task shifting actions [36]
This deliverable will involve the good practices, results and conclusions gained through the execution of the pilot
projects with the aim of strengthening the knowledge on task shifting.
Page 27 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Schedule of relevant Milestones
Due
Milestone
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18
months)
The preparation of the "Needs
analysis and implementation
plan" will start in month 4
and is defined as a continuous
activity in paralell to the first
pahes of implementation, e.g.,
awareness raising, service
Needs analysis and and task analysis. It will build
MS16 2 - AGE.NA.S 12
implementation plan on the WP4 milestones and
gather the evidence from
the implementation sites. In
the first year of the project
(M1-M12), all essential input
will be collected in order to
conduct the pilots efficiently
by the stepwise approach.
The findings of the 5 pilot
projects will be discussed and
MS17 Implementation lessons 2 - AGE.NA.S 24
lessons from them will be
concluded.
This milestone aims to start
drafting D11. The findings
of the 5 pilot projects will be
MS18 Implementation report 2 - AGE.NA.S 24 summarized and the content
of the D11 guidebook will be
prepared along the results of
the 5 pilots.
M19 is a continuing activity,
which aims to synthesize the
evidence gathered during
Synthesizing evidence, the 5 implementation pilots.
MS19 developing practical 2 - AGE.NA.S 29 In month 29, the milestone
guidelines will result in the practical
guidelines on task shifting,
and these guidelines will be
channeled into D11.
M20 is a continuing activity,
which aims to select good
practices, methods and
tools gathered during the 5
Selecting good practices, implementation pilots. In
MS20 2 - AGE.NA.S 29
methods and tools month 29, the milestone will
result in a collection of good
practices, methods and tools
on task shifting, which will be
channeled into D11.
This is the first draft of D12,
MS21 Draft list of recommendation 2 - AGE.NA.S 32 a set of recommendations for
task shifting actions based
Page 28 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Schedule of relevant Milestones
Due
Milestone
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18
months)
on the results, conclusions,
lessons and outcomes of the 5
implementation pilots.
Page 29 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1.3.4. WT4 List of milestones
Due
Milestone WP
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18 number9
months)17
First official meeting with
the project team, Chafea and
the European Commission.
Discussion about the
MS1 Kick-off meeting WP1 1 - SU 1
implementation of the
project, agreement of the final
workplan will be summarized
in the Inception report D1.
Draft Inception Report
summarizes the TaSHI
MS2 Draft Inception Report WP1 1 - SU 2 workplan discussed and
agreed at the Kick-off
meeting.
Draft Progess Report is
the first draft summarizing
the progess of workplan
implemented by TaSHI
MS3 Draft Progress Report WP1 1 - SU 17 during the fist half of the
project duration. Draft reports
ensure keeping the timing
planned for evaluation before
delivery.
Draft Final Report is the first
draft summarizing the progess
of workplan implemented
by TaSHI during the whole
MS4 Draft Final Report WP1 1 - SU 34
project duration. Draft reports
ensure keeping the timing
planned for evaluation before
delivery.
Development of the
visual identity refers to
dissemination related
materials such as project
logo, templates for internal
and public documents,
Publicity guidelines,
MS5 WP2 1 - SU 3 leaflet and newsletter
house style and logo
format, etc. All guidelines
regarding dissemination
and communication will be
defined at the beginning of
the project in order to design
the project image.
This plan will cover all
aspects of the webinars,
Webinar series, event events. The planned timing,
MS6 WP2 1 - SU 4
execution plan invitation process, promotion/
publicity, execution and
followup activities.
Page 30 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Due
Milestone WP
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18 number9
months)17
In order to to improve all
the communication and
dissemination tools we
Interim evaluation will carry out an interim
of dissemination and evaluation survey between
MS7 WP2 1 - SU 18
communication of month 15-18. Target audience
TaSHI of TaSHI will be asked to rate
the quality and quantity of the
information published on our
communication channels.
This milestone refers to
the first version of the
Draft report on
stakeholder analysis and the
Stakeholder
MS8 WP2 1 - SU 5 dissemination channels and
management and event
networks, and refers to the
execution
plan of the webinars, events
as well.
This milestone is the first
draft of the Evaluation
strategy & plan including
information on approaches,
materials, methods, tools
and requirements to be used
First draft of
in WP3. This draft will list
MS9 Evaluation strategy & WP3 3 - NIVEL 2
and predefine indicators
plan
for efficient and effective
delivery of products and
processes for the whole
duration of the project, as
well as to define the "TaSHI
Advisory Board".
This Evaluation strategy &
plan will be updated with
information on the progress in
WP3, including for example
the efficient and effective
delivery of products and
processes, the outcomes of
the activities of the "TaSHI
Update of D9 with a Advisory Board". Based on
MS10 WP3 3 - NIVEL 33
Sustainability plan the results and outcomes
of TaSHI achieved duting
the project duration, this
updated report will attach a
sustainability plan discussing
the recommendations for
the future, as well as the
utilization of TaSHI in the
future.
Use of LOVU- WP4 will carry out a desk
MS11 methodology on how WP4 6 - USN 4 research to explore and map
to collect evidence existing practices in task
Page 31 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Due
Milestone WP
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18 number9
months)17
shifting, and then establish
education guidelines and
develop practical training
materials and curriculum.
and execute literature The LOVU method enables
review in addition to the KPP
educational model, a platform
and repository of learning
resources to apply to achieve
specific learning outcomes.
Findings of the desk research
and the excercise of gathering
evidence on concepts and
practices will enable WP4
Findings of the desk to prepare a collection of
MS12 research & analysing WP4 6 - USN 6 useful tools and materials.
concepts Findings also serve as an
input for M14, the practical
training material that will
be tested by WP5 during the
pilot implementations.
WP4 aims to develop a
curriculum and training
for task shifting, which
are enabled particularly by
digital skills for healthcare
professionals. For the
Curricula digital development and design
(including digital, of online education, the
MS13 WP4 6 - USN 15
interpersonal and “Knowledge, Process,
management skills) Practice (KPP) model” will
be used. The model provides
a concise map of how the
educational features relate
to each other and form a
complete learning sequence; a
module or a programme.
Based on the previous
milestones (M11, M12, M13),
Developing pilot
WP4 intends to develop
MS14 practical training WP4 6 - USN 15
practical training materials to
materials
be utilized and tested in WP5
pilots.
This milestone ensures
that the experiences of all
Revised final version pilots are incorporated into
of the practical the training materials and
MS15 WP4 6 - USN 30
training materials and curriculum on task shifting.
curriculum After realizing the pilot
implementations coordinated
by WP5, the experiences,
Page 32 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Due
Milestone WP
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18 number9
months)17
lessons learnt and conclusions
will be included in D9.
The preparation of the "Needs
analysis and implementation
plan" will start in month 4
and is defined as a continuous
activity in paralell to the first
pahes of implementation, e.g.,
awareness raising, service
Needs analysis and and task analysis. It will build
MS16 WP5 2 - AGE.NA.S 12
implementation plan on the WP4 milestones and
gather the evidence from
the implementation sites. In
the first year of the project
(M1-M12), all essential input
will be collected in order to
conduct the pilots efficiently
by the stepwise approach.
The findings of the 5 pilot
projects will be discussed and
MS17 Implementation lessons WP5 2 - AGE.NA.S 24
lessons from them will be
concluded.
This milestone aims to start
drafting D11. The findings
of the 5 pilot projects will be
MS18 Implementation report WP5 2 - AGE.NA.S 24 summarized and the content
of the D11 guidebook will be
prepared along the results of
the 5 pilots.
M19 is a continuing activity,
which aims to synthesize the
evidence gathered during
Synthesizing evidence, the 5 implementation pilots.
MS19 developing practical WP5 2 - AGE.NA.S 29 In month 29, the milestone
guidelines will result in the practical
guidelines on task shifting,
and these guidelines will be
channeled into D11.
M20 is a continuing activity,
which aims to select good
practices, methods and
tools gathered during the 5
Selecting good
implementation pilots. In
MS20 practices, methods and WP5 2 - AGE.NA.S 29
month 29, the milestone will
tools
result in a collection of good
practices, methods and tools
on task shifting, which will be
channeled into D11.
This is the first draft of D12,
Draft list of
MS21 WP5 2 - AGE.NA.S 32 a set of recommendations for
recommendation
task shifting actions based
Page 33 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Due
Milestone WP
Milestone title Lead beneficiary Date (in Means of verification
number18 number9
months)17
on the results, conclusions,
lessons and outcomes of the 5
implementation pilots.
Page 34 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1.3.5. WT5 Critical Implementation risks and mitigation actions
Risk
Description of risk WP Number Proposed risk-mitigation measures
number
Strict control and monitoring of work schedule,
intensive supervision on production of
deliverables/milestones. Enable support for
1 Delays in project progress WP1
partners in case of need. Frequent reminders
and regular WP leaders meeting supports time
management.
Milestones for draft reports and careful planning
of deliverables and internal evaluation enable
CHAFEA does not accept the
2 WP1 the consortium to produce good quality reports.
periodic and final reports
Continuous communication with Chafea/EC will
aim to avoid misunderstandings on requirements.
Continuous communication between WP2 and
WP3; regular revision of target groups and
Lack of reaching
3 WP2 communication channels work, utilisation of
stakeholders
the consortium networks from other European
projects.
Lack of professional content
WP2 team continuously collects content from the
4 for the newsletter and WP2
other WPs, and the experts, stakeholders engaged.
website
Grounded decision on topics, focus on new
Low participation in
5 WP2 emerging topics and crucial topics of HWF field;
webinars/ online events
adequate preparation and invitation process.
Using and mobilising the extended personal
Lack of reaching and network of the consortium, improve incentives
6 committing members of the WP3 for academics and researchers to participate
‘TaSHI Advisory Board’ by offering publication and presentation
opportunities.
Clear communication of the evaluation plan, its
requirements and criteria, with all consortium
Poor quality of the materials
7 WP3 members and WP leaders in particular. Prompt
in evaluation
feedback on the materials and deliverables to
improve quality before publication.
Clear communication of the evaluation plan, its
requirements and deadlines, with all consortium
Delays in delivering reports
8 WP3 members and WP leaders in particular. Prompt
and materials for evaluation
feedback and ‘early warning system’ for
important publication and delivery deadlines.
Together with the local partners, attempt to find
lecturers and trainers who are known to be more
Low interest of lecturers and positive and keen on teaching new methods.
9 WP4
trainers Benefits of participation in an internationally
recognized team and project can be also
emphasised.
Re-analyse framework conditions (e.g. available
Large difference in course infrastructure, digital support, etc.) and adjust
10 WP4
outcomes outcomes to identified system based differences,
consider upscalability.
Page 35 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Risk
Description of risk WP Number Proposed risk-mitigation measures
number
WP4 will carry out desk research and explore
different angles and perspectives of the available
Lack of or too specific evidence: academic literature, EU project
11 methods, tools and practices WP4 reports, on-site experiences, key informant data.
in task shifting Stakeholders can be approached in a targeted way,
if specificity of task shifting practices need to be
further explored.
The stakeholder analysis performed with two
goals: 1) in WP2 dissemination and 2) in WP5
pilots. Agile stakeholder management of a wide
target audience as well as interactive dialogue in
pilots enable improved stakeholder engagement.
12 Low stakeholder engagement WP5
Within the first step of the Calderdale framework
implementation as well as the stakeholder
involvement plan on the other 6 steps of the
framework will mitigate the probability to have a
low stakeholder involvement.
The use of the Calderdale framework as
Lack of or too specific stepwise approach to task shifting initiatives
13 WP5
priorities and goals for pilots implementations will assure to have an adequate
action plan in each pilot site.
Barriers and obstacles will be identified in
the first step of the pilot studies together with
Too many barriers and
the identification of ways to overcome them.
14 obstacles to pilot task WP5
Governance mechanisms and sustainability
shifting initiatives
actions will be discussed and agreed in step 5 and
7 respectively.
The HWF planning tools currently used by the
5 implementation countries are already known
by the WP5 leader from previous projects study
(see SEPEN and Joint Action on European Health
No progress on updating
15 WP5 Workforce Planning and Forecasting). This
HWF planning tools
knowledge enables the WP5 leader to anticipate
the potential changes needed to include the task
shifting initiatives into the specific HWF planning
tools of each implementer.
Not adequately addressing
Assuming prevalence of the risk and taking
cultural differences upon
deliberate actions to prevent such outcomes. If
16 providing education WP4
necessary, control the risk by taking adequate
guidelines and developing
measures to minimize or eliminate its impact.
practical training materials.
There is an uncertanity in
organising personal meeting
as planned. In case of travels In case of travelling restrictions, meetings will be
17 WP1
are officially not allowed, organised online. Travel budget will be revised.
travel plans need to be
revised.
Page 36 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1.3.6. WT6 Summary of project effort in person-months
WP1 WP2 WP3 WP4 WP5 Total Person/Months per Participant
1 - SU 20.10 18.54 0.78 7.73 3.09 50.24
2 - AGE.NA.S 0.35 0.21 0.35 2.06 6.18 9.15
3 - NIVEL 0.35 0.21 6.81 2.06 3.78 13.21
4 - MOH-LT 0.78 0.46 0.78 0 11.59 13.61
5 - SM-EE 0.78 0.46 0.78 0 8.51 10.53
6 - USN 0.35 0.21 0.35 6.87 3.78 11.56
7 - PoliS-Lombardia 0.35 0.21 0.35 2.06 3.78 6.75
Total Person/Months 23.06 20.30 10.20 20.78 40.71 115.05
Page 37 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1.3.7. WT7 Tentative schedule of project reviews
No project reviews indicated
Page 38 of 38
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1. Project number
The project number has been assigned by the Commission as the unique identifier for your project. It cannot be
changed. The project number should appear on each page of the grant agreement preparation documents (part A
and part B) to prevent errors during its handling.
2. Project acronym
Use the project acronym as given in the submitted proposal. It can generally not be changed. The same acronym should
appear on each page of the grant agreement preparation documents (part A and part B) to prevent errors during its
handling.
3. Project title
Use the title (preferably no longer than 200 characters) as indicated in the submitted proposal. Minor corrections are
possible if agreed during the preparation of the grant agreement.
4. Starting date
Unless a specific (fixed) starting date is duly justified and agreed upon during the preparation of the Grant Agreement,
the project will start on the first day of the month following the entry into force of the Grant Agreement (NB : entry into
force = signature by the Agency). Please note that if a fixed starting date is used, you will be required to provide a written
justification.
5. Duration
Insert the duration of the project in full months.
6. Call (part) identifier
The Call (part) identifier is the reference number given in the call or part of the call you were addressing, as indicated
in the publication of the call in the Official Journal of the European Union. You have to use the identifier given by the
Commission in the letter inviting to prepare the grant agreement.
7. Abstract
8. Project Entry Month
The month at which the participant joined the consortium, month 1 marking the start date of the project, and all other start
dates being relative to this start date.
9. Work Package number
Work package number: WP1, WP2, WP3, ..., WPn
10. Lead beneficiary
This must be one of the beneficiaries in the grant (not a third party) - Number of the beneficiary leading the work in this
work package
11. Person-months per work package
The total number of person-months allocated to each work package.
12. Start month
Relative start date for the work in the specific work packages, month 1 marking the start date of the project, and all other
start dates being relative to this start date.
13. End month
Relative end date, month 1 marking the start date of the project, and all end dates being relative to this start date.
14. Deliverable number
Deliverable numbers: D1 - Dn
15. Type
Please indicate the type of the deliverable using one of the following codes:
R Document, report
DEM Demonstrator, pilot, prototype
DEC Websites, patent fillings, videos, etc.
OTHER
ETHICS Ethics requirement
ORDP Open Research Data Pilot
DATA data sets, microdata, etc.
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
16. Dissemination level
Please indicate the dissemination level using one of the following codes:
PU Public
CO Confidential, only for members of the consortium (including the Commission Services)
EU-RES Classified Information: RESTREINT UE (Commission Decision 2005/444/EC)
EU-CON Classified Information: CONFIDENTIEL UE (Commission Decision 2005/444/EC)
EU-SEC Classified Information: SECRET UE (Commission Decision 2005/444/EC)
17. Delivery date for Deliverable
Month in which the deliverables will be available, month 1 marking the start date of the project, and all delivery dates
being relative to this start date.
18. Milestone number
Milestone number:MS1, MS2, ..., MSn
19. Review number
Review number: RV1, RV2, ..., RVn
20. Installation Number
Number progressively the installations of a same infrastructure. An installation is a part of an infrastructure that could be
used independently from the rest.
21. Installation country
Code of the country where the installation is located or IO if the access provider (the beneficiary or linked third party) is
an international organization, an ERIC or a similar legal entity.
22. Type of access
TA-uc if trans-national access with access costs declared on the basis of unit cost,
TA-ac if trans-national access with access costs declared as actual costs, and
TA-cb if trans-national access with access costs declared as a combination of actual costs and costs on the basis of
unit cost,
VA-uc if virtual access with access costs declared on the basis of unit cost,
VA-ac if virtual access with access costs declared as actual costs, and
VA-cb if virtual access with access costs declared as a combination of actual costs and costs on the basis of unit
cost.
23. Access costs
Cost of the access provided under the project. For virtual access fill only the second column. For trans-national access
fill one of the two columns or both according to the way access costs are declared. Trans-national access costs on the
basis of unit cost will result from the unit cost by the quantity of access to be provided.
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Annex 1 to the Grant Agreement
(Empowering EU health policies on Task SHIfting)
Chafea – 3rd Health Programme
Multi-beneficiary Project Grant (HP-PJ, HP-JA)
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
2. PART B
History of changes
Remark Response Change
“However, impact of these TaSHI consortium considers Additional lines were inserted
activities to the challenge of some points of the proposal into the proposal to better
task shifting at panEuropean that already provide some clarify the EU level
level might not be high.” information, how we plan to
foster the uptake of the pilot - general objectives
implementations and facilitate - specific objectives
the exchange at EU level. We - context of the project
“There is a risk that added value work
at EU level in the field of public put the emphasis of
transferability highlighted in - expected outcomes
health will be limited to
our proposal at several and benefits of the
participant countries. The project
project fulfils the requirement sections, e.g. at the “Added
value” section. All the sections - WP2 and WP3
of geographical coverage, but description on
very little beyond as there is were revised and completed.
stakeholder
nothing in the approach or management and the
method that by design takes “TaSHI Advisory Board”
the project (or its learnings)
outside the partner countries.
However there is mention of
European wide dissemination
in the WP3 evaluation plan with
little detail provided.”
“One important aspect of Our proposal pointed out some A paragraph on change
change management in this aspects of cultural sensitivity management was inserted to
area is differences in cultural already, because it has crucial the section of “Context of
contexts. Task-shifting has importance in managing WPs”. In addition, WP
different barriers, and one of change. The mapping exercise descriptions contain further
the more prominent are planned in WP4 will contribute details.
probably the tradition and to reveal the significance of this
culture of different barrier as well. Taking cultural
professional roles in each context and sensitivity in
health system. There is no account is an essential part of
discussion of this.” the project as we aim to
increase HWF responsiveness
and resiliency. Important
mission of TaSHI is to improve
cultural sensitivity and
openness of HWF to more
effective organisation of work
and developed working
environments (e.g.
multiprofessional teamwork,
interprofessional education,
collaborative practice etc.). The
1
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
mapping exercise and training
modules will also deal with the
cultural sensitivity. By
providing clear guidelines on
implementation of task
shifting, and the targeted
training modules, the various
outcomes of the project can
also serve as solutions for such
cultural differences and
barriers.
“Problem analysis Including The proposal highlights We added information on
evidence base contains a very different solutions and aspects previous project experiences
thorough review of literature from already existing literature (e.g. SEPEN tender) to the
and the concept of task- on how the emerging problems introduction and to the context
sharing. However, it can be and challenges can be of the project work.
considered more a literature mitigated by the various Implementation pilots were
review of the concept than a processes of task shifting, more thoroughly described.
problem identification and sharing and skill-mixes.
analysis. It includes important Previous projects concerning
aspect (e.g. the distinction task- system challenges have already
SHARING, co-creation by underlined the benefits of
patients, digitalisation, etc.), digital health solutions in
but does not link it clearly to healthcare management and
which problem it can solve, organization (e.g. SEPEN
only implicitly links it to HR mapping study, SEPEN
challenges”. workshop 5 outcomes, WHO
recommendations on digital
health).
“The project appears a bit too The overall knowledge sharing A paragraphs and some
ambitious in its intent to can serve a wide variety of explanation were inserted to
address a wide variety of task settings, outlines, and solutions the section of “Context of
shifting challenges in different for task shifting. Exchanging WPs”.
settings and on different good practices, case studies,
healthcare issues, by providing methods and tools can be
guidelines, curricula and beneficial for EU MS, as they
pilots.” can learn the latest information
and evidence and can utilize
them by adjusting to their own
needs. TaSHI aims to provide
and support the continuous
dialogue on the issue by various
communication channels and
dissemination products and
activities (newsletters,
webinars, dialogue on the EU
HPP “Health Workforce”
forum), and facilitate co-
creation of different actors.
Training and education
2
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
materials are useful in
curriculum development of any
level or type of training
programmes. TaSHI aims to
provide a deliverable that
benefits upskilling and
upscaling the HWF and enable
and foster capacity building as
well.
“A more thorough description With regards to the Calderdale Some changes were made in
of the Calderdale framework Framework, the proposal refers the methods section as well as
would have been beneficial, as
to the EU study on “Task the respective WP descriptions.
it would provide an
Shifting and Health System
understanding of whether the Design” (2019) and declares a
applicant's team has
step-wise approach suggested Particularly in WP4, we listed
understood it and has a plan of
by the Framework. TaSHI the means and methods to be
how to apply it.” outlines the intended use of a used during the different
7-step approach in detail, and activities, e.g. Use of LOVU-
the possible steps of methodology or the
“For WP4, the section 7.1 implementation without the “Knowledge, Process, Practice
Overview of Work Packages usage of the Calderdale tools. (KPP) model”. In addition, WP5
(WPs) does not add enough TaSHI intends to carry out includes a description of the
methodological description.” different pilot implementations Calderdale Framework
set by a common framework stepwise approach to be used
and a stepwise approach by the implementation pilots.
inspired by the Calderdale Further descriptions on these
framework. methods were added directly
to the proposal text.
More extended methodological
description was inserted in the
“Methods and means” section.
“For WP5, it is not clear from The implementation stands for No changes, since the 7 phases
the proposal if implementation the carrying out of task shifting of implementation - covering
means following task-sharing and task sharing processes on phases of design through
the given implementation sites. situation analysis (e.g.
on the five "implementation
Implementation means actually awareness raising, service and
sites", or actually designing and designing and implementing task analysis) and phases of
implementing task-shifting task-shifting pilot projects by executing the concrete actions
projects.” using a stepwise approach. (e.g. competency
identification, supporting
systems, training and
sustaining) at the
implementation sites – are
described in WP5.
“Some of the concepts The TaSHI consortium has been Few lines were added to the
proposed have clear innovative highly involved in EU level Specific objectives and Means
nature and have been activities focussing on various and methods highlighting the
3
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
successfully implemented in angles of HWF issues in the last new tools and the novelty of
some partner countries. decades. Therefore, all the expected solutions.
Technical complementarity is evolution of the HWF field, Deliverables and milestones
present, but there is a risk that including strategies for more were also revised and slightly
the collaboration will limit effective care provision and reformulated accordingly.
experience sharing, not HRH management and planning
creation of something new.” are widely known.
Improvements and action plans
in the field of strategic HWF
management and planning
might take time but
information exchange and
knowledge sharing always plays
a facilitator role. The TaSHI
consortium intends to continue
the exchanges and
collaboration of various
stakeholders in the policy
dialogue on HWF development.
The EU study on “Task Shifting
and Health System Design”
2019 also highlights
conclusions and
recommendations on task
shifting, which have been
considered during the
preparation of the TaSHI
proposal.
“The WP3 evaluation approach All of the EU MS will The description of the “TaSHI
is very general. This is however continuously be kept informed Advisory Board” was extended
mitigated to some extent in the through our existing networks, in the proposal text.
WP description section.” a particular attention could be
dedicated to the “TaSHI
Advisory Board” set by WP3 for
evaluation, which members
play a crucial role of key actors,
informants at the international
level. This international “TaSHI
Advisory Board” will be
installed within WP3, that will
take into account a good
representation of EU regions
and countries next to the
countries in the Consortium,
and additionally will ensure to
engage the target audience of
healthcare providers via the
involvement of health
professional organizations.
4
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
“The dissemination strategy The EU-wide dissemination of Some examples form the pilot
and plan includes different knowledge is covered as part of sites were added to the context
channels of communication WP2 Dissemination and of implementation sites.
with no particular focus on Communication. Stakeholder
different target audiences and analysis and management is
various stakeholders” part of the activities of WP2.
Section 5 Methods and means
details the table of different
communications channels,
purpose, frequency, method
and duration of the
communication that is
foreseen.
“The proposal has not When preparing the proposal Some explanation was inserted
adequately described partners discussed plans for the into the Budget section.
management capacity to pilots. For example, partners of
conduct this task within the Estonia and Lithuania
time-frame of the project, participated in the national
which will be very tight for such exchanges in SEPEN tender and
a complex task. Possibly received targeted guidance on
mitigating this risk is that the improvements of HWF
project partners have already planning – coordinated by
identified the types of care and AGENAS-, which resulted in
their respective very detailed situation analysis
clinics/departments during the of the current HWF challenges
preparation of the proposal, at national level. These are new
which supports a successful evidences from 2020, which
implementation.” could be further developed and
used in TaSHI.
“The proposal presents a Experience of previous projects No changes, as 9.4 Quality &
partnership of different (e.g. the JAEUHWF, SEPEN Joint Capacity of the Partnership
backgrounds (academia, Tender) proved the section highlights the essential
research, public effectiveness and feasibility of nature of reaching all target
administration, and health reaching out to and involving groups and stakeholders, as
authority). This is well justified different stakeholder groups in well as experiences from
relative to the design of the order to reach the most previous projects.
project but also a challenge in successful outcome and results.
management as very different Stakeholder involvement and
business cycles will need to engagement is a crucial step in
align.” any kind of implementation,
which is included in TaSHI WP2,
WP3 and WP5 pilots’ first
phase.
“Nevertheless, the involvement The TaSHI consortium itself has Section 3 on Stakeholders and
of healthcare providers in the no healthcare provider among target groups was extended, as
consortium is limited and its the partners, however the well as the description of the
enhancement would have strong links towards healthcare “TaSHI Advisory Board” with
strengthened the partnership.” providers is secured (see for the potential stakeholders to
example the case of Lithuania be involved (e.g. European
or Estonia, where ministries Hospital Federation, European
5
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
responsible for operation can Forum for Primary Care,
have a significant influence on European Patients’ Forum,
reorganizing and optimising European Federation of Nurses
care, or on implementing Associations, European
healthcare reforms, or AGENAS Specialist Nurse Organisation,
in Italy that is responsible for The Standing Committee of
monitoring the health system European Doctors, Council of
and contributing to enhance European Dentists,
system performance). Pharmaceutical Group of the
European Union, European
Health Management
Association, etc.). These EU-
level, international umbrella
organizations can easily reach
the relevant national actors for
different tasks.
“Financial management is SU will provide a part time In the detailed budget sheet SU
stated to be run by full time financial officer for TaSHI. provided different categories of
financial officer. There are only staff costs.
researchers in the salary list but
apparently the person will be
provided by the SU.”
“In overall budget is relevant to TaSHI team provided a more Budgeting principles were
the objectives of the proposal. detailed paragraph for the added to section 10.
Division of the budget among budget section.
cost items is valuable
information. But the proposal
does not describe any other
budgeting principles.”
“Clarification is needed for the The status of PoliS-Lombardia is
statement. "Not all the unique in the TaSHI project, as
beneficiaries have the same they requested no EU
division of national and EU contribution for their
contribution, as PoliS- participation, and they
Lombardia resigned from its EU resigned their share, which
contribution, so the share of were distributed among
other partners has been partners. Supporting
increased to 66 % EU documents were submitted to
contribution." Chafea in order to accept this
division of budget.
“The cost per month for the Indeed. These are the salary In the detailed budget sheet
researcher of AGENZIA levels declared by partners. NIVEL and AGENAS provided a
NAZIONALE and NIVEL is on the more detailed breakdown of
high side.” different categories of staff
costs.
6
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
“At the Summary of the Effort it WP leaders usually receive No changes.
is still not clear why SU is extra person days for increased
receiving 50.5 Total Person tasks in WPs they manage.
Months out of 115 in total for Semmelweis University is the
the project. These person Consortium leader, WP leader
months are mainly dedicated to of two WPs of the 5 WPs (WP1
WP1 and WP2 that includes and WP2 - and also co-lead in
management, dissemination WP4). WP1 and WP2 are
and communication. At the horizontal WPs with
same time the non-personnel continuous activities
related costs for evaluation and throughout the whole duration
dissemination receives very of the project mostly executed
little budget (less than 1.5%) by the WP leader with a
according to budget moderate contribution of other
description.” partners. Furthermore, half of
the milestones and deliverables
will be completed and
delivered by SU.
Regarding the non-personnel
costs, we modified the budget
accordingly and delegated
travel budget for the closing
conference to be organized in
Rome.
Avoiding duplications TaSHI team checked all details Deliverables and the timetable
including the information of the were revised and reconsidered,
tables filled automatically in small changes were
the platform implemented throughout the
proposal.
The proposal has not Semmelweis University will The explanation was added to
adequately described coordinate the work and 2.8 Project management
management capacity. planned activities in all WPs, structure
and ensure the adequate
infrastructure (e.g.: internal
communication and monitoring
platform) for fulfilling the
workplan and quality delivery
in the given timeframe.
The pilots do not intend to use The Calderdale framework was The clarification was added to
the Calderdale tools’. developed by a team work in 2.5 Methods and means
2011, the Effective Workforce
Solutions Ltd. Then, in the
following years was
successfully used in different
health care settings in change
management project regarding
task shifting, multidisciplinary
team building, skill mix design,
etc. The framework proposes a
stepwise approach that TaSHI
7
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
will replicate in the different
pilot sites, adopting a flexible
implementation perspective,
meaning that, based on the
needs of each pilot site, TaSHI
will go more in depth in specific
steps of the framework.
The original Calderdale
Framework proposes also, for
each step of the
implementation path, some
tools to support the
implementers. But those
specific tools are protected by
copyright and can be used only
by the Calderdale Framework
Practitioners.
5 new deliverables added WP2:
D5 - Mid-term dissemination
and communication report
(M18)
D7 - Dissemination and
communication report (M36)
WP3:
D10 - Mid-term evaluation
report (M18)
D11 - Evaluation report (M36)
WP4:
D13 - Pilot materials of the
practical training materials and
curriculum (M15)
8
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Table of contents
History of changes .................................................................................................................................. 1
2.1. Problem analysis including evidence base ................................................................................... 10
2.2. Goals and objectives of the Project .............................................................................................. 16
2.2.1 General Objectives of the Project .................................................................................... 16
2.2.2 Specific Objective(s) of the Project .................................................................................. 17
2.3. Stakeholder - Target groups .......................................................................................................... 19
2.4. Political Relevance ......................................................................................................................... 21
2.4.1. Contribution to the Annual Work Plan ............................................................................ 22
2.4.2. Added value ...................................................................................................................... 24
2.4.3. Pertinence of geographical coverage ............................................................................... 27
2.4.4. Context of the project work ............................................................................................. 27
2.5. Methods and means ...................................................................................................................... 32
2.6. Expected outcomes and benefits of the project........................................................................... 38
2.7. Gantt Chart .................................................................................................................................... 41
2.8. Project management ..................................................................................................................... 42
2.8.1. Methods ............................................................................................................................. 42
2.8.2. Governance, Roles, Responsibilities.................................................................................. 42
8.2.3. Processes & Artefacts ........................................................................................................ 43
2.8.4. Quality& Capacity of the partnership ............................................................................... 44
2.8.5. Capacity of the staff ........................................................................................................... 47
2.8.6. Financial management ..................................................................................................... 49
2.9. Budget ............................................................................................................................................ 50
2.9.1. Content description and justification .............................................................................. 50
2.9.2. Detailed budget ................................................................................................................ 51
9
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
2.1. Problem analysis including evidence base
Towards health system sustainability
Policy making in the EU has focussed on the sustainable development goals and the universal health
coverage (SDGs and UHC) for a long time, which contributes to the sustainability of health systems.
The EU sets its priorities and actions, and ensures implementation of various programmes that support
developing and strengthening the health systems in Member States (MS). Health systems do not
operate in isolation, but several factors influence their efficiency and efficacy in the cross-border arena
of the internal market. Among the key functions of health systems, e.g. service delivery, financing,
governance and resources, the appropriate distribution and allocation of human resources is essential
(Thomas et al., 20201). Health workforces need to be planned carefully in various health systems, and
efficient management of care could contribute to optimising care pathways, understanding diverse
emerging workforce issues and future trends (McKee et al., 20202).
Health workforce planning
Health workforce (HWF) planning aims to ensure the right number of healthcare personnel, with the
right skills at the right time and in the right place (European Commission, 20123). This exercise is indeed
challenging, because of the complexity of the planning processes and data requirements to design
appropriate tools for projection models (Kovacs et al., 20164). Previous international studies called
attention to the shortages and uneven distribution, as well as skills mismatches and new emerging
roles of health workforces in several MS (Buchan et al., 20145, European Commission, 20126,European
1
Thomas, S., Sagan, A., Larkin, J., Cylus, J., Figueras, J., Karanikolos, M. (2020). Strengthening health - systems resilience.
Policy Brief 36. Retrieved from: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/332441/Policy-brief%2036-1997-8073-
eng.pdf
2
McKee, M., Mercur, S., Edwards, N., Nolte, E. (2020). The Changing Role of the Hospital in European Health Systems.
European Observatory of on Health Systems and Policies. Retrieved from:
https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/448048/Changing-role-of-hospitals-eng.pdf
3
European Commission. (2012). EU level Collaboration on Forecasting Health Workforce Needs, Workforce Planning and
Health Workforce Trends – A Feasibility Study. Final Report. Retrieved from:
https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/workforce/docs/health_workforce_study_2012_report_en.pdf
4
Kovacs, E., Girasek, E., Kovács, R., Aszalos, Z., Eke, E., Cserháti, Z., Ragány, K. (2016). Report on Health Workforce Planning
Data. Joint Action on Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting. Retrieved from: http://healthworkforce.eu/archive/
5
Buchan, J., Wismar, M., Glinos, I.A., Bremner, J. (2014). Health Professional Mobility in a Changing Europe. New dynamics,
mobile individuals and diverse responses (Eds.), Vol. 2. Observatory Study Series. Retrieved from:
https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/248343/Health-Professional-Mobility-in-a-Changing-Europe.pdf
6
European Commission. (2012). EU level Collaboration on Forecasting Health Workforce Needs, Workforce Planning and
Health Workforce Trends – A Feasibility Study. Final Report. Retrieved from:
https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/workforce/docs/health_workforce_study_2012_report_en.pdf
10
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Commission, 20197, Joint Action Final Guide, 20168, Bond et al., 20179, OECD, 201810, Wismar et al.,
201111). The Companion Report (2019) published as part of the State of Health in the EU Country Health
Profiles defined task shifting as a predominant example of skill-mix innovations with great potentials
among the HWF, especially by enhancing the roles of nurses and pharmacists (European Commission,
201912).
The MUNROS project identified significant changes regarding the altering roles of health professionals
in all EU MS studied, with the most significant changes identified in the Netherlands, England and
Scotland (Maier et al., 201813). The project reflected upon the growing prevalence of the specialised
and advanced roles of nurses and health care assistants, and identified specialised roles of physicians,
as well as extended and more independent roles of nurses. The study highlighted the digital and
technological development of health care and the need for more generic competencies as the main
drivers of changes in these professions. The latest EU-level mapping study by the SEPEN tender (2020)
also highlighted that many MS still reported on the shortage or lack of HWF or access to care and a
significant decrease in supply. Some Member States are facing significant shortages of health
professionals, and reported severe geographical imbalances with regards to accessibility of care (e.g.
Estonia, Hungary, Italy or Lithuania) (SEPEN, 202014). In addition, SEPEN results concerning system
challenges have already underlined the benefits of digital health solutions in healthcare management
and organization (e.g. SEPEN mapping study, SEPEN workshop 5 outcomes). On the other hand, an
increased demand from the population has been recognised so far by several previous studies (Joint
Action - Chrodis 2014-2017 and Chrodis Plus 2017-202015). The ageing trend of the European
population poses some challenges towards EU health systems, as it increases the need for long-term
care, treatment of chronic conditions, and managing multi-morbidity (Kingston et al., 201816). New
7
European Commission. (2019). State of Health in the EU: shift to prevention and primary care is the most important trend
across countries. Press release. Retrieved from:
https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/api/files/document/print/en/ip_19_6336/IP_19_6336_EN.pdf
8
Joint Action on Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting. (2016). Final Guide of the Joint Action on Health Workforce
Planning and Forecasting. Retrieved from: http://healthworkforce.eu/wp-
content/uploads/2016/11/WP2_FINAL_GUIDE_final_version.pdf
9
Bond, C., Bruhn, H., de Bont, A., van Exel, J., Busse, R., Sutton, M., Elliott, R. (2017). The iMpact on practice, oUtcomes and
costs of New roles for health pROfeSsionals: a study protocol for MUNROS. BMJ Open, 6, 010511 . Retrieved from:
https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/6/4/e010511
10
OECD (2018), Feasibility Study On Health Workforce Skills Assessment - Supporting health workers achieve person-
centred care. Retrieved from: https://www.oecd.org/health/health-systems/Feasibility-Study-On-Health-Workforce-Skills-
Assessment-Feb2018.pdf
11
Wismar, M., Maier, C.B., Glinos, I.A., Dussault, G., Figueras, J. (2011). Health Professional Mobility and Health Systems -
Evidence from 17 European countries. (Eds.). Observatory Study Series. Retrieved from:
https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0017/152324/Health-Professional-Mobility-Health-Systems.pdf?ua=1
12
European Commission. (2019). State of Health in the EU: shift to prevention and primary care is the most important trend
across countries. Press release. Retrieved from:
https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/api/files/document/print/en/ip_19_6336/IP_19_6336_EN.pdf
13
Maier, C.B., Köppen, J., Busse, R.; MUNROS team. (2018). Task shifting between physicians and nurses in acute care
hospitals: cross-sectional study in nine countries. Hum Resour Health, 16(1), 24. doi:10.1186/s12960-018-0285-9
14
SEPEN. (2020). Mapping national health workforce planning and policy in the EU. Presented at the SEPEN webinar of July
24. Retrieved from: http://healthworkforce.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/SEPEN_Webinar_24July_Final.pdf
15
Chrodis Plus Joint Action (2017-2020). Website: http://chrodis.eu/
16
Kingston, A., Robinson, L., Booth, H., Knapp, M., Jagger, C.; MODEM project. (2018). Projections of multi-morbidity in the
older population in England to 2035: estimates from the Population Ageing and Care Simulation (PACSim) model. Age
Ageing, 47(3), 374-380. doi:10.1093/ageing/afx201
11
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
treatments, new models of care, new medicines, and even new expanded roles of health professionals
represent a new type of needs from patients, clients and citizens. The roles and responsibilities of
health professionals have changed significantly in the last few decades, therefore their transitions
needs to be managed effectively (McKee et al., 202017).
Rapid adaptation and resilience - with or without COVID-19
HWF planning and system performance monitoring aimed to analyse data, anticipate changes and find
drivers for sustainability and cost effectiveness in the long run. In the different phases of situational
analysis, planning, implementation, monitoring and evaluation, several different actions from the
fields of leadership, stewardship, finance, education and policy can be executed (WHO, 201018, WHO,
201619). While improving HWFs and system components, better health services and better health
outcomes are expected as the main goals. The recently evolving models comprise new approaches and
solutions with significant potentials, such as the paradigm shift towards integrated care, home-based
care, patient empowerment, self-care management and patient-centered provision system, and last
but not least, the adoption of digital health solutions. The current models of healthcare are not resilient
enough to completely and adequately address the emerging challenges posed by higher demand for
health services, shortages of health personnel, available fiscal space, and particularly the occurrence
of emergency risks (e.g. COVID-19).
In the case of an emergency situation (e.g. COVID-19), embracing flexibility is a key. Health policy
recommendations aimed to strengthen the health systems response to the COVID-19 outbreak, and
one particular area ensuring sufficient workforce capacity and allocation of human resources became
the center of attention in each of the EU MS (COVID response monitor20). The latest issues and
dialogues determine a new attitude, namely, that HWF planning should not focus solely on workforce
quantity, but quality, and secondly a more strategic approach is needed to combat emerging
challenges, e.g. global pandemic situations.
Task shifting
Task shifting per definition consists of delegation of tasks, and sharing roles within health professions,
different groups of health professionals, also shifts to patients or to machines (European Commission,
201921). The multiple types of task shifting and sharing - as bidirectional phenomena - tend to focus on
17
McKee, M., Mercur, S., Edwards, N., Nolte, E. (2020). The Changing Role of the Hospital in European Health Systems.
European Observatory of on Health Systems and Policies. Retrieved from:
https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/448048/Changing-role-of-hospitals-eng.pdf
18
World Health Organization. (2010). WHO HRH Action Framework. Retrieved from: https://www.who.int/hrh/tools/en/
19
World Health Organization. (2016). Global strategy on human resources for health: Workforce 2030. World Health
Organization. Retrieved from: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/250368/9789241511131-
eng.pdf?sequence=1
20
World Health Organization, European Commission, & European Observatory of Health Systems and Policies. (2020).
COVID-19 Health System Response Monitor. Retrieved from: https://www.covid19healthsystem.org/mainpage.aspx
21
European Commission. (2019). Task Shifting and Health System Design - Report of the EXPH. Luxembourg: Publications
Office of the European Union. Retrieved from:
https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/expert_panel/docs/023_taskshifting_en.pdf
12
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
enhancement, supervision-mentoring, substitution-delegation and innovation (McKee et al., 202022;
WHO, 200623).
FIGURE 1 - Multiple types of task shifting - adapted from WHO, 2006 & McKee, 2020
Nowadays, task shifting processes are apparently utilised in numerous care sectors, including primary
care (Nuttal, 201824) mental health care (Martínez-González et al., 201525), and acute hospital care
(Maier et al., 201826; Maier et al., 201827). With regards to professional groups, task shifting is mostly
utilised in the nursing (Maier, 201528), pharmacy (Jebara et al., 201829), and midwifery (Dawson et al.,
201530) professions. Task shifting between nurses and GPs in primary care is highly prevalent in some
22
McKee, M., Mercur, S., Edwards, N., Nolte, E. (2020). The Changing Role of the Hospital in European Health Systems.
European Observatory of on Health Systems and Policies. Retrieved from:
https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/448048/Changing-role-of-hospitals-eng.pdf
23
World Health Organization. (2006). Task shifting to tackle health worker shortages. HIV/AIDS Programme; strengthening
health services to fight HIV/AIDS. Retrieved from: https://www.who.int/healthsystems/task_shifting_booklet.pdf
24
Nuttall, D. (2018). Nurse prescribing in primary care: a metasynthesis of the literature. Primary health care research &
development, 19(1), 7–22. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1463423617000500
25
Martínez-González, N.A., Tandjung, R., Djalali, S., & Rosemann, T. (2015). The impact of physician-nurse task shifting in
primary care on the course of disease: a systematic review. Hum Resour Health, 13, 55. Published 2015 Jul 7.
doi:10.1186/s12960-015-0049-8
26
Maier, C.B., Köppen, J., Busse, R.; MUNROS team. (2018). Task shifting between physicians and nurses in acute care
hospitals: cross-sectional study in nine countries. Hum Resour Health, 16(1), 24. doi:10.1186/s12960-018-0285-9
27
Maier, C.B., Batenburg, R., Birch, S., Zander, B., Elliott, R., & Busse, R. (2018). Health workforce planning: which countries
include nurse practitioners and physician assistants and to what effect? Health Policy, 122(10):1085-92.
28
Maier, C.B. (2015). The role of governance in implementing task-shifting from physicians to nurses in advanced roles in
Europe, U.S., Canada, New Zealand and Australia. Health Policy, 119(12),1627-1635. doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2015.09.002
29
Jebara, T., Cunningham, S., MacLure, K., Awaisu, A., Pallivalapila, A., & Stewart, D. (2018). Stakeholders' views and
experiences of pharmacist prescribing: a systematic review. Br J Clin Pharmacol, 84(9), 1883-1905. doi:10.1111/bcp.13624
30
Dawson, A.J., Nkowane, A.M., & Whelan, A. (2015). Approaches to improving the contribution of the nursing and
midwifery workforce to increasing universal access to primary health care for vulnerable populations: a systematic review.
Hum Resour Health, 13, 97. doi:10.1186/s12960-015-0096-1
13
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
countries (Maier et al. 201731, Karimi-Shahanjarini et al., 201932; van der Biezen et al., 201733), while
task shifting in the surgical or radiography professions have also been effectively implemented in some
countries (Anthony et al., 201934; Bhanbhro et al., 201135; du Plessis & Pitcher, 201536). The so-called
non-medical prescribing also serves as an effective way to increase the quality of health service
delivery by extending the roles of health professionals and allowing medical prescribing for example
in primary care settings (Graham-Clarke et al., 201837). Moreover, the enhanced roles of the so-called
Advanced Practice Nurse (APN) are highly prevalent in the Netherlands, England, or Scotland,
increasing the quality and effectiveness of care by expanding nurses’ scope-of-practice (Lovink et al.,
201938; Lovink et al., 201939; Maier et al., 201840; SEPEN, 202041).
In general, the potentials in and significant importance of task shifting and sharing processes are
unquestionable. The contemporary literature indicates that task shifting can increase the size of the
HWF, thereby providing a way to tackle HWF shortages and geographical imbalances, as well as the
significant challenges and overburdening of the HWF. Task shifting can increase the efforts of moving
towards a more integrated and patient centered health care. Task shifting has a key role in achieving
a well-functioning health system, but it is also posing challenges related to the consequent change in
current practices and organisation of care. For this reason, well-structured concepts, guidelines, and
other supporting tools are required to reduce the negative impact of the altering ecosystem, while
maximising the benefits in parallel.
As an action to address the human resource crisis, transferring or shifting professional tasks to
individuals with fewer qualifications and less extensive training, task shifting can serve as an effective
31
Maier, C.L., Aiken, L.H., & Busse, R. (2017). Nurses in advanced roles in primary care: Policy levers for implementation.
OECD Health Working Papers, No. 98. OECD Publishing: Paris. https://doi.org/10.1787/a8756593-en.
32
Karimi-Shahanjarini, A., Shakibazadeh, E., Rashidian, A., et al. (2019). Barriers and facilitators to the implementation of
doctor-nurse substitution strategies in primary care: a qualitative evidence synthesis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 42.
33
van der Biezen, M., Derckx, E., Wensing, M., & Laurant, M. (2017). Factors influencing decision of general practitioners
and managers to train and employ a nurse practitioner or physician assistant in primary care: a qualitative study. BMC Fam
Pract, 18(1),16.
34
Anthony, B.F., Surgey, A., Hiscock, J., Williams, NH, & Charles, J.M. (2019). General medical services by non-
medical health professionals: a systematic quantitative review of economic evaluations in primary care. British Journal of
General Practice, 69(682), 304-313.
https://doi.org/10.3399/bjgp19X702425
35
Bhanbhro, S., et al. (2011). Assessing the contribution of prescribing in primary care by nurses and professionals allied to
medicine: a systematic review of literature. BMC Health Serv Res, 11, 330.
36
du Plessis, J., et al. (2015). Towards task shifting? A comparison of the accuracy of acute trauma-radiograph reporting by
medical officers and senior radiographers in an african hospital. Pan African Medical Journal, 21, 308. doi:
10.11604/pamj.2015.21.308.6937
37
Graham-Clarke, E., Rushton, A., Noblet, T., & Marriott, J. (2018). Facilitators and barriers to nonmedical prescribing – A
systematic review and thematic synthesis. PLoS ONE, 13(4), 0196471.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0196471
38
Lovink, M.H., van Vught, A., Persoon, A., Koopmans, R., Laurant, M.G.H., & Schoonhoven, L. (2019). Skill mix change
between physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and nurses in nursing homes: A qualitative study. Nurs Health
Sci, 21(3), 282-90.
39
Lovink, M.H., Laurant, M.G., van Vught, A.J., Maassen, I., Schoonhoven, L., Persoon, A., et al. (2019). Substituting
physicians with nurse practitioners, physician assistants or nurses in nursing homes: a realist evaluation case study. BMJ
Open, 9(5), 028169.
40
Maier, C.L., Aiken, L.H., & Busse, R. (2017). Nurses in advanced roles in primary care: Policy levers for implementation.
OECD Health Working Papers, No. 98. OECD Publishing: Paris. https://doi.org/10.1787/a8756593-en.
41
SEPEN. (2020). Mapping national health workforce planning and policy in EU. Presented at the SEPEN webinar of July 24.
Retrieved from: http://healthworkforce.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/SEPEN_Webinar_24July_Final.pdf
14
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
way to tackle the HWF challenges and expand available HWF (WHO, 200642; 200843). Task shifting and
task sharing processes can stand as effective ways to mitigate the negative effects of the challenges
and the overburdening of the HWF and manage and facilitate a better health care service delivery.
Due to the complexity of the issue - such as the healthcare system-specific characteristics, intersectoral
nature (e.g. involvement of the education sector, healthcare providers, IT industry), vertical and
horizontal change and task shifting processes - a comprehensive and locally customisable framework
and tools are needed. Such a framework should pool the currently fragmented approaches existing in
MS at different levels (e.g. academia, healthcare providers, governmental institutions, etc.), with an
emphasis on the main challenges and benefits observed in MS.
Meeting the needs of the patient
As chronic conditions have been becoming more frequent, the cumulative population needs for
healthcare shows an increasing trend. This requires a different professional-patient relationship, and
a new model of care. There is a shared responsibility, because nowadays patients tend to contribute
more to their own healthcare, prevention and rehabilitation as well. Patients are more empowered to
seek care, make an informed choice about care providers or treatments. Patient empowerment and
citizen engagement shows more significant relevance for optimising care and client pathways in health
and care sectors.
On the other hand, patient empowerment resulted in higher rates of self-care management. Clients
tend to dedicate more attention to health prevention, using digital health solutions to monitor for
instance their own chronic conditions (see good practices of Chrodis (2015)44). In addition, not only in
preventive measures, but higher levels of contribution have become more frequent, as health literacy
and digital health literacy of patients and citizens is rapidly emerging (Nutbeam, 200845; Gopal et al.,
201946).
Patient empowerment in itself can make a positive impact on health service delivery, and provide a
more patient-centered and personalised care. A higher proportion of self-care management among
patients can have a positive effect on the role of health professionals by providing better patient
compliance-concordance and self-monitoring, a more preventive attitude, thereby easing the burden
on professionals. Moreover, emphasising the role of e-health, m-health, telemedicine, information and
communication technology (ICT), as well as the digitalisation of patient health records can further
lessen such burdens.
Cutting edge technology and disruptive innovation
It is important to mention digitalisation and the exponential growth of accessible information and
evidence, which have the potential to bring significant benefits and offer solutions to address HWF-
related challenges. However, this opportunity can only be exploited if adequate policies and
approaches are adopted in healthcare, social care, and also in the education sector. Co-creation and
inter-professional teams are becoming the cornerstone of integrated care, which implies the need to
train individuals, with a different perspective and sectoral knowledge, on how to maximise the
42
World Health Organization. (2006). Task shifting to tackle health worker shortages. HIV/AIDS Programme; strengthening
health services to fight HIV/AIDS. Retrieved from: https://www.who.int/healthsystems/task_shifting_booklet.pdf
43
World Health Organization. (2008). Task shifting - Global recommendations and guidelines. World Health Organization.
Retrieved from: https://www.who.int/healthsystems/TTR-TaskShifting.pdf?ua=1
44
Join Action on Chrodis (2015). Good practices in health promotion & primary prevention of chronic diseases. Summary
report. Retrieved from: http://chrodis.eu/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Summary-Report-CHRODIS-WP5-Task-3_Version-
1.3.pdf
45
Nutbeam, D. (2008). The evolving concept of health literacy. Soc. Sci. Med, 67(12), 2072–2078.
46
Gopal, G., Suter-Crazzolara, C., Toldo, L., & Eberhardt, W. (2019). Digital transformation in healthcare - architectures of
present and future information technologies.Clin Chem Lab Med, 57(3), 328-335. doi: 10.1515/cclm-2018-0658.
15
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
productivity level throughout the joint work. As an example, physicians, data experts, and IT
professionals (with different sectoral knowledge) should be able to effectively communicate and have
a common understanding in order to establish and adopt an Artificial Intelligence-based image
interpretation system which supports for instance image screening in diagnostics.
From the HWF policy and planning perspective, the above-mentioned issues highlight the necessity for
establishing new approaches and the adjustment of current planning models, guidelines, and also the
proper legal environment. The new models should consider factors such as the emergence of new
professions and career pathways, vanishing professions due to automatisation of jobs, and especially
task shifting (McKinsey 201747, 201848). A more holistic, intersectoral approach and cross-planning of
workforce stock is required due to the fact that professionals from other sectors (e.g. engineers, data
scientists) are taking key roles in the healthcare digitalisation- and digital transformation process.
Digital disruption can answer several HWF-related challenges, but it also brings new complex issues
which need to be addressed adequately. Digital solutions - such as robotics showing a great potential
in surgery (Prete, Pezzolla, et al. 2018, Ren, Cao, et al. 2019)49 50 - should be considered as an additional
“actor” in healthcare provision (besides the HWF, the patients and carers), and task shifting initiatives
should incorporate them during the definition of the optimal distribution of tasks. It is also inevitable
to have a comprehensive and transparent framework, which defines roles and responsibilities, and
ensures that task shifting and digital disruption will not jeopardise quality of care and patient safety.
2.2. Goals and objectives of the Project
2.2.1 General Objectives of the Project
The HWF in Europe is facing significant challenges due to the ageing population and ageing HWF,
shortages and unequal distribution of HWF and resources, the growing demands of better-integrated
and patient centred care, as well as the rise of multi-morbidity and non-communicable diseases.
Moreover, the increased demand for health services are over-burdening the HWF, putting strains on
health care workers. Effective health service delivery requires established and clear guidelines and
sources of evidence. Health systems, therefore, need dynamic and resilient HWFs, provided with
optimal skill-mix and competencies. Consequently, evidence-based reforms are highly needed to
address and tackle the challenges health care systems and the workforce are facing.
The General and strategic objectives of the project are the following:
1) Providing added value on the concept, notion, and implementation of task shifting at EU-,
national- and regional levels, as well as an update on the existing tools and methods to support
and upscale the implementation of task shifting in EU MS.
2) Providing a novel understanding, new and up-to-date knowledge on task shifting and on
transferability of existing good practices in implementation. Investigating the feasibility,
challenges, benefits and impact of different forms of task shifting through case studies based
on hands-on experience from 5 pilot implementation sites.
47
McKinsey Global Institute. (2017). Technology, jobs, and future work. Briefing note prepared for the Fortune Vatican
Forum, December 2016.
48
McKinsey Global Institute. (2018). Skill shift automation and the future of the workforce. Discussion paper.
49
Prete, Pezzolla, et al. Robotic Versus Laparoscopic Minimally Invasive Surgery for Rectal Cancer: A Systematic Review and
Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Annals of surgery, 2018;267(6)
50
Ren, Cao, et al. Efficacy and reliability of active robotic-assisted total knee arthroplasty compared with conventional total
knee arthroplasty: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Postgraduate medical journal, 2019
16
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
3) Disseminating case studies and fostering knowledge sharing and exchange across EU MS on
the specific processes and features of task shifting via online events (e.g. webinars, thematic
workshops, and presentations).
4) Progressing implementation by facilitating the dialogues and exchanges between the
relevant stakeholders, strengthening governance and stakeholder engagement for
transferring and upscaling task shifting practices and policies supporting health reforms for
HWF development. Enhancing cultural sensitivity, flexibility and readiness, as well as
organizational adaptation to task shifting.
2.2.2 Specific Objective(s) of the Project
The Specific SMART operational objectives of the project are the following:
1) Mapping practices and developing tools - strengthening the knowledge on task shifting
● Identifying and analysing the concept and implementation of task shifting, and
providing an update on existing tools to incorporate task shifting and task sharing
processes.
● Providing suggestions of changes in the legal and policy environment to overcome the
barriers to the recruitment and retention of healthcare workforce in underserved
areas, as well as barriers regarding the implementation of task shifting processes.
● Providing good practices for introduction of task-shifting especially with the
consideration of the effects on patient safety and health service performance, and
providing recommendations on the impact of new skills, skills for utilising digital
solutions, while providing aims regarding the re- and upskilling of the HWF.
2) Provide recommendations on training and upskilling - share and utilise experiences of
implementation pilots on task shifting
● Providing recommendations on mitigating the negative effects of changing skill-mixes
and competencies across different sectors and occupational groups.
● Providing recommendations for future HWF skills to aid the better adaptation to new
developments, and providing guidance for the upskilling of nurses, including digital
skills, with the involvement of IT specialists.
● Developing curricula for digital, interpersonal, and management skills for physicians,
nurses, pharmacists, and other health personnel, and developing practical guidelines
for public authorities and healthcare providers which will serve as operational tools
supporting their healthcare workforce policies in relation to challenges in these fields.
The curricula will serve as a novel educational tool for training on task shifting and
sharing. By providing clear guidelines on the implementation of task shifting, the
outcomes of the project can also serve as solutions for tackling cultural differences
and barriers.
Specific Objectives of the project provide tangible products, practices, tools and recommendations for
policy makers and relevant stakeholders for the implementation of task shifting processes.
17
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Specific Specific Objective Title and Description
Objective ID
1)
Mapping practices and developing tools - strengthening the knowledge on task
shifting
Process Indicator(s) Target value
Set-up and execute “Dissemination and communication 1 strategy by WP2
strategy and plan” by WP2
1 strategy by WP3
Set-up and execute “Evaluation strategy and plan” by WP3
1 plan by WP4
Set up and execute “Research plan” for WP4 - Stage plan for
1 plan by WP5
desk research
Set up and execute an “Implementation plan” for pilot sites
WP5 - Stage plan for designing pilot phases
Output Indicator(s) Target value
Number of deliverables/documents:
● Deliverable of Collection of useful tools and 1 report with 5-10 tools and
practices in task shifting practices by WP4
● Deliverable of Case studies of implementation sites 1 report with 5 extended case study
● Deliverable of Guidebook of task shifting descriptions plus annexes by WP5
1 integrated guidebook by WP5
Dissemination products by WP2:
● TaSHI website 1 project website
● TaSHI newsletter 9 newsletter editions
● Articles, short posts on EU HPP specific “Health At least 24 articles, short posts
Workforce” forum, Social media sites (linkedin, annually
facebook, twitter), Partners websites and
At least 3-4 webinars/online events
newsletters, Partners Youtube channels
annually
● Webinars/Joint webinars with related
projects/online events 1 leaflet
● Rollup and leaflet, proportion material production
Outcome/Impact Indicator(s) Target value
Increased number of improved methods and tools for task Publication of 5-10 methods and
shifting tools
Increased number of pilots, case studies, initiatives, actions, Publication of 5-10 new case
practices on task shifting in the EU studies
Increased number of stakeholders informed, engaged, Reaching and involving all 27 MS
participated representing all EU Member States and the UK
18
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Specific Specific Objective Title and Description
Objective ID
2)
Provide recommendations on training and upskilling - share and utilise experiences
of implementation pilots on task shifting
Process Indicator(s) Target value
Design and execute dissemination and communication 1 strategy by WP2
strategy WP2
1 strategy by WP3
Design and execute event plan and execution WP2
Design and execute evaluation strategy by WP3
Output Indicator(s) Target value
Number of deliverables/documents: 1 report containing practical
training materials and advices on
● Deliverable of Practical training materials and curriculum
curriculum
● Deliverable of Set of recommendations for task 1 report with a set of
shifting actions recommendations on the EU and
country/MS and organisational
level
Outcome/Impact Indicator(s) Target value
Increased number of experts/stakeholders participating in Reaching and involving all 27 MS
policy dialogues on task shifting and the UK
Increased number of policy recommendations on task 1 set of recommendations
shifting
1 curriculum
Increased number of education programmes and training
materials
2.3. Stakeholder - Target groups
This section describes the main stakeholders to be considered as the primary beneficiary of the project
outcomes, and the target group to be actively engaged during the stakeholder management conducted
by WP2. It is important to highlight that the heterogeneity of the listed stakeholders implies the need
for tools/recommendations tailored to the given target group.
European institutions and organisations
The implementation of initiatives focusing on task shifting should be supported by a top-down
approach, hence the European bodies (e.g. European Commission DGs) and the relevant umbrella
organisations (e.g. European Hospital Federation, European Forum for Primary Care, European
Patients’ Forum, European Federation of Nurses Associations, European Specialist Nurse Organisation,
The Standing Committee of European Doctors, Council of European Dentists, Pharmaceutical Group of
the European Union, European Health Management Association, etc.) are key target groups of the
project. The project will produce evidence-based recommendations on supporting task shifting, which
will be disseminated and shared at the EU-level. The uptake of actions might rely on the contribution
and activation of these organisations.
19
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Regulators, health workforce planners, and policy makers
The national legal environment and policy initiatives are crucial for a successful transformation of
current models of healthcare provision, and for the modification of already existing practices,
treatment pathways, and work processes. Effective policies are needed in order to reach a sustainable
and resilient provision system, and the project aims to engage the key policy actors (ministries of
health and education and labour) by leveraging the consortium’s existing networks and further
extrapolate it during the project cycle.
Regional governing bodies, local municipalities
Actors from the meso-level are also considered as target groups in order to reach the highest possible
impact and outreach. The need for intersectoral approaches also underlines the importance of
engaging and guiding these stakeholders (e.g. regional authorities for healthcare organisation).
Educational institutions
Undergraduate and postgraduate training institutions are also the main enablers of ensuring the
knowledge base and attitudes required for an effective adoption of new roles, competencies, and skill-
mix compositions in task shifting. The educational materials and recommendations on the curriculum
development - produced during the project cycle - will especially benefit this target group (e.g.
universities and colleges with health education, associations of educators and trainers, and NGOs).
Institutions providing CPD programmes
Another important education-related pillar is the training of the current HWF stock, hence the
institutions providing life-long learning and CPD programmes are also considered as key actors and
facilitators of change. In addition, on-site training programs (e.g. learning by doing format facilitated
by a supervisor) and CPD activities are especially crucial given the constantly changing service provision
supported by innovative digital health solutions.
Professional associations
The involvement of professional associations (e.g. medical or dental chambers, orders for nursing and
pharmacists, associations of healthcare managers and/or hospital management, institutes of e-health
and digital health solutions etc.) is essential to reach a sustainable and nationally adaptable guide for
task shifting implementation. The scalability and impact of the project pilots are also highly dependent
on the support of such associations.
Healthcare providers, health professionals
As healthcare providers (both organisations and individual providers) will be the “end users” of the
policies/actions implemented at local, regional, national, or EU-level, it is important that the tools and
guidelines are designed with the initial engagement of providers - for example applying co-creation
methods during the pilots. The implementation of the project will be carried out on different levels of
care (e.g. primary care, hospitals) in each of the implementation countries to secure the adequate
involvement of healthcare providers.
Patients, clients, citizens
The general public is also a key enabler of change. Although the pilots does not include approaches
which would explicitly increase the role of patients in disease management (e.g. self-care), the project
needs to provide sufficient guidance as patients will be indirectly impacted by the organisational
changes.
20
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
2.4. Political Relevance
HWF research and policy concluded the crisis of human resources for health (HRH) two decades ago,
and several challenges have been addressed in the EU so far. With the enlargement of the EU, health
professionals entered different health systems to deliver care, while changing their place of residence.
Cross-border movement of the HWF became more significant, which called the attention of the EU
internal market to ensure safety and harmonisation of care provision across the EU MS. In 2005 with
the EU Directive 2005/36/EC51 on mutual recognition of qualifications listed the basic features of
sectoral health professions, facilitating the mobility of the workforces and automatising licencing
procedures (Kovacs et al., 201452). During the Belgian and Hungarian Presidency in 2010-2011, the
issue of HRH development received growing attention. The EU Feasibility Study53 (2012), and the EU
Action Plan for Health Workforce54 in 2012 highlighted the predicted magnitude of HWF shortage for
2020. The Action plan encouraged EU countries to work together to improve HWF planning and
forecasting, and to anticipate future skill needs and improve continuous professional development
(see also in EC, 2013)55. Therefore, the Joint Action on European Health Workforce Planning and
Forecasting between 2013-2016 aimed to strengthen collaboration and advance the issue of workforce
planning by elaborating useful tools and collecting methods and good practices from EU MS, engaging
the dialogues on related topics e.g. recruitment and retention policies (see also Recruitment and
Retention Study, EC 201556). Building on the work undertaken by the Joint Action, the SEPEN Joint
Tender “Support for the Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting expert network” aimed to
continue to sustain the actions in the field of HWF planning and policies, as well as to foster cross-
country collaborations and accelerating exchanges of increasing knowledge. Additionally, WHO
dedicates also a high level commitment to HRH development by publishing strategic documents such
as the WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel (2010)57,
the UN High-Level Commission on Health Employment and Economic Growth’s report (2016)58, the
WHO Global strategy on human resources for health: Workforce 2030 (2016)59 and the WHO European
Framework for action and the Toolkit for a sustainable health workforce in the WHO European Region
(2018)60, or also by designating 2020 as the “International Year of the Nurse and the Midwife”. The
51
European Commission. (2005). Directive 2005/36/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 7 September 2005
on the recognition of professional qualifications. 2005/36 EC. https://eur-
lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2005:255:0022:0142:en:PDF
52
Kovacs, E., Schmidt, A.E., Szocska, G., Busse, R., McKee, M., Legido-Quigley, H. (2014). Licensing procedures and
registration of medical doctors in the European Union. Clin Med (Lond), 14(3), 229-238. doi:10.7861/clinmedicine.14-3-229.
53
European Commission. (2012). EU level Collaboration on Forecasting Health Workforce Needs, Workforce Planning and
Health Workforce Trends – A Feasibility Study. Final Report. Retrieved from:
https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/workforce/docs/health_workforce_study_2012_report_en.pdf
54
European Commission. (2012). Action Plan for the EU Health Workforce.
https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/workforce/docs/staff_working_doc_healthcare_workforce_en.pdf
55
European Commission. (2013). Study concerning the review and mapping of continuous professional development and
lifelong learning for health professionals in the EU. EAHC/2013/Health/07.
https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/workforce/docs/cpd_mapping_report_en.pdf
56
European Commission. (2015). Recruitment and Retention of the Health Workforce in Europe. Final Report.
https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/workforce/docs/2015_healthworkforce_recruitment_retention_frep_en.pdf
57
WHO. (2010). The WHO Global CODE of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel.
https://www.who.int/hrh/migration/code/code_en.pdf?ua=1
58
WHO. (2016). High-level Commission on Health Employment and Economic Growth - Final Report of the Expert Group.
https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/250040/9789241511285-eng.pdf?sequence=1
59
World Health Organization. (2016). Global strategy on human resources for health: Workforce 2030. World Health
Organization. Retrieved from: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/250368/9789241511131-
eng.pdf?sequence=1
60
WHO. (2018). The toolkit for a sustainable health workforce in the WHO European Region.
https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/375547/WH11_TK_text_AW-2.pdf
21
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
constantly growing recognition in nurse leadership, and awareness raising aims to underline the
essential contribution of nurses and midwives to care provision and achieving universal health
coverage (WHO, 202061).
2.4.1. Contribution to the Annual Work Plan
TaSHI addresses the Annual Work Programme 2020 of the 3rd EU Health Programme. The Programme
underlines four objectives, among which the third one is to “Contribute to innovative, efficient and
sustainable health systems” and it also emphasises explicitly its priority areas of “Health Workforce
Planning and Forecasting”. More precisely, TaSHI responds to the call and challenges set by the
“Support to reforms in health workforce field - Initiatives on task-shifting (Heading 1.2.1.1 of the AWP
2020)”.
In addition, the latest SEPEN (2020) results on the mapping study provide an overview of the main
characteristics and a detailed description of the HWF planning systems and policies in the EU (SEPEN,
202062). SEPEN highlighted the current and future challenges of HWF to tackle, which can be stratified
into two main categories: 1) policy related issues of shortages of HWF supply and managing serious
HWF imbalances including the high outflow of HWF; and 2) newly emerging challenges reported by the
MS. These new challenges to be addressed are strengthening primary care and general practice, and
the management of preventive and rehabilitation care also seems to be a recent challenge for several
MS. Along with these, providing appropriate skill-mix and task shifting in primary care teams seems to
be a significant concern in more MS, as well as the quality of care and incorporating digital health
solutions and the support of advanced technology into daily scope of practice.
HWF and related system challenges How TaSHI addresses the priorities
Challenge Imbalances and TaSHI will carry out pilot projects in five implementation sites
maldistribution of HWF - addressing task shifting and task sharing as core strategies in
monitoring health labour combating HWF shortages and geographical imbalances. By
market dynamics (e.g. task shifting and sharing, a cost-effective organisation,
rapidly ageing population optimised care provision and services can be achieved
and HWF, migration and contributing to higher efficiency, effectiveness and
mobility patterns of HWF, sustainable management and planning of HWF.
availability of data) WP4 will gather existing practices and collect tools and
methods, which could be used in different MS to mitigate
unequal distribution of the HWF stock, specialties or
accessibility of health services. Task shifting can enable better
coverage of services and workforces, even in remote or
underserved areas.
WP5 will summarise the lessons learned from case studies of
the implementation pilots, identify guidelines on common
minimum features and conditions for effective task shifting,
and emphasise a set of evidence-informed recommendations
for policy and organisational levels in order to increase HWF
responsiveness and resiliency. TaSHI will deliver tangible and
61
WHO. (2020). State of the world’s nursing 2020. Report. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240003279
62
SEPEN. (2020). Mapping national health workforce planning and policy in the EU. Presented at the SEPEN webinar of July
24. Retrieved from: http://healthworkforce.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/SEPEN_Webinar_24July_Final.pdf
22
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
validated tools and methods tested by the pilot
implementation sites, which are scalable and transferable to
diverse settings. TaSHI will provide technical expertise to
support the development, implementation and monitoring of
good practices, methods, tools, and support peer learning.
The outcomes will improve knowledge and evidence on
access to care in disadvantaged areas and reorganisation of
care delivery.
WP2 will provide visibility and dissemination of results to
broad target audiences and engage stakeholders in fostering
actions of HWF planning and reforms in the HWF field.
Higher demand for new TaSHI will continue the investigation of current and future
primary care models, challenges of HWF. In addition, TaSHI will aim to explore
better-integrated and potential solutions and responses to these challenges at the
more patient-centred pilot implementation sites. Important mission of TaSHI is to
care, the rise of chronic improve cultural sensitivity and openness of HWF to more
diseases, and emergence effective organisation of work and developed working
of advanced technology environments (e.g. multiprofessional teamwork,
in healthcare interprofessional education, collaborative practice etc.).
WP4 will gather existing practices and collect tools and
methods, which are already addressing the reorganisation of
health systems, devoting a more prominent role for
prevention and primary care, while reducing avoidable
hospital admissions and providing treatment at the earlier
stage of disease progression. In this WP, we will reveal
practices linked to technology-enabled integrated care, and
select digital health as a key enabler in prioritising patient
empowerment, skill-mix optimisation etc. The outcomes of
this WP will produce a curriculum on digital content,
knowledge, skills and competencies. This will contribute to
improved digital skills, tools and digital health solutions in,
and strongly emphasise the role of e-health, big data, ICT, and
artificial intelligence in reforming healthcare. The importance
of interpersonal, management, and leadership skills
development will be also reflected in the WP4 activities. WP4
will also formulate conclusions on the prognosed impact of
skill-mix changes on the HWF, as well as new and vanishing
professions.
WP5 will test the collection of tools and methods, as well as
the curriculum at the diverse implementation sites. WP5
Guidebook, a new tool will summarise and list all of the
crucial components of upskilling and upscaling HWF with
digital and more comprehensive transversal skills, and further
methods and tools to be used when implementing task
shifting at various settings. The set of recommendations will
also highlight, by stakeholder types, the main actions,
initiatives, roles and responsibilities for further HWF
developments.
23
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
WP2 thereby will facilitate communication of results, as well
as fostering peer learning e.g. by webinars and online events
aiming to enhance knowledge transfer and exchange.
Moreover, TaSHI will support health system reforms focusing
on workforce policies by updating tools and methods of HWF
planning.
2.4.2. Added value
Areas – where to achieve Ways - how to achieve EU-added value
EU added value
Impact on target groups Supporting EU policies and stakeholder engagement
- Strengthen free movement of persons and implementation of EU
directives, particularly in connection with the 2005/36/EC and
2011/24/EU directives on the cross-border movement of health
professionals and patients. These directives enable cross-border
movements in obtaining or delivering care, therefore aim to
harmonise minimum qualifications and competencies of
professionals and care provision standards, as well as conditions
for continuity of care within EU MS. TaSHI will work on curriculum
and training material development that has some influence on
transferable knowledge, skills and competencies of health
professionals, therefore facilitating the mobility of knowledge as
well.
- Support the agenda for new skills and job opportunities, as well
as a European contribution towards full employment and
equipping people with the right skills for employment (COM
(2010/0682 final 23 Nov 2010). Skill development is an essential
part of activities in TaSHI, and the project will work towards
increasing the employability of well-trained health professionals
in Europe by producing useful materials on tools, methods and
evidence.
- Promote the voluntary uptake of health innovation and e-Health
and facilitate cooperation on e-Health in the European Union
(Regulation (EU) No 282/2014 of the European Parliament). The
five implementation sites will execute pilots with well-defined
objectives in task shifting and will utilise e-Health and digital
health throughout the implementation.
- As one of the main project outcomes, a comprehensive
overview will benefit the target groups of the project,
comprising recommendations on future skills required for a
resilient HWF, as well as the prognosed changes in skill-mixes,
and the new and vanishing professions.
- TaSHI will facilitate the openness, flexibility, and cultural
sensitivity of health professionals, which will better enhance the
readiness and resiliency of the HWF.
- Develop consultation mechanisms, and provide information for
stakeholders and policy makers on topics where task shifting
might be crucial.
24
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
- TaSHI also supports informed decision-making and preparation
of recommendations at the European level, particularly in
health system reforms focusing on workforce policies, access to
care in disadvantaged areas and reorganisation of healthcare
delivery.
- Supporting the sustainability of the HWF by contributing to an
effective HWF forecasting and planning at different levels, also
keeping HWF planning on the agenda has long-term benefits for
sustainability and cost-effective operation.
Long-term effect and
- Conducting analytical work is necessary to formulate,
potential multiplier
implement and assess policy projects at local, regional, national,
effect, such as replicable,
or international levels, towards which the project will
transferable and
significantly contribute.
sustainable activities
- Improving knowledge base for formulating and implementing
HWF evidence-informed reforms tailored to the national
settings enables uptake of actions.
- Raising awareness of stakeholders, developing educational
materials, and providing training (‘train the trainers’) ultimately
supports the improvement of stakeholders’ capacity to use tools
and methods, and to execute HWF development.
- Providing technical expertise to support the development,
implementation and monitoring of good practices, methods,
tools - with an emphasis of transferability needs to be a core
element of TaSHI and any EU project. The practical deliverables
will support organisational (e.g. healthcare providers) and policy
levels (e.g. Ministry of Health) in developing and strengthening
different types of task shifting in different EU MS, e.g. adoption
of digital health solutions to increase HWF productivity.
- Presenting tangible, real-world experiences of the
implementation sites and providing evidence for other
MS/organisations are useful to start fostering task shifting
initiatives. As a result of the project, TaSHI can result in a
network of stakeholders ready to implement task shifting at
various settings, which can also result in a multiplier effect on
the long run by achieving transferability and cross-validation of
implementation sites with different health system
characteristics, and different levels of care.
Dissemination and communication ensure the visibility of the
TaSHI project at different levels in the EU - internationally, at
national and sub-national levels. WP2 disseminates key
messages and project deliverables in the topics of task shifting,
as a significant strategy for HWF development. The project
outputs and messages will be adjusted according to the specific
target groups (e.g. use of layman terminology for materials
targeting citizens and patients, meeting the needs of the
beneficiaries and end-users).
WP4 develops evidence-based, fit for purpose curriculum,
training materials and practical knowledge on task shifting
education and training. By developing a new training for task
shifting covering and promoting transversal skills (e.g.
25
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
management and leadership, proficiency level, data protection
and interpretation), cultural sensitivity, flexibility and readiness
of the HWF, the HWF will be equipped with new knowledge and
tools supporting the progressive development of health
professionals and the working environment. As digital disruption
impacts all levels of care, emphasis will be placed on skills
required for an effective digital transformation.
The provision of practical training for the implementation sites
by WP4 ensures that the education tools are piloted in a real-
world setting, enabling further adjustments when the project
outputs will be extrapolated to a larger scale (e.g. national level
training programme). Furthermore, the utilisation of online
training methods will enable broad and sustainable outreach of
the training for the HWF and other stakeholders.
Achieving economies of scale, starting from the 5
implementation sites as pilots: WP5 is the core WP for planning,
executing and evaluating on-site pilot implementations, which
ensures and facilitates peer learning and knowledge sharing on
existing practices in the EU. The five implementation sites have
already emphasised initial needs for improvements, defined
some objectives and showed interest towards different types of
task shifting initiatives, and some good practices have been
identified. The sites will carry out a wide range of activities along
with a common methodology and framework of change. This will
enable WP5 to gather valuable qualitative data and on-site
experiences from different settings. The standardised 7 phases
of the implementation ensures the development of the common
minimum requirements, conditions, features, benefits and
weaknesses of task shifting initiatives. Furthermore, experiences
from real-world settings support developments in HWF by
updating HWF planning tools, and also the improvement of
stakeholders’ capacity to utilise tools and methods in their health
reforms. The involvement of five implementation sites with a
heterogeneous background - e.g. pilot countries with different
health systems, different therapeutic areas and disease patterns,
different levels of care - has an added value as it provides a
multifaceted experience and also supports the scalability of the
findings to other settings.
Contribution to
- TaSHI develops collaboration, promotes knowledge-transfer and
complementarity,
peer learning, exchanges good practices and cross-fertilisation of
synergy and
ideas across reform areas and different sectors.
compatibility with
- TaSHI avoids duplication with other EU-level actions - facilitating
relevant EU and EU
synergies with other projects funded under the different specific
Member States policies
topics of the present call “Support to reforms in health workforce
and programmes,
field” by e.g. organising joint webinars, or channelling the project
including compatibility
findings into existing repositories (e.g. EU Platform on Best
with the European
Practice Exchange)
Platform on RD
- Strengthening networking activities through the existing
registration and the
international networks of the consortium, also facilitating
intersectoral synergies are further important activities of TaSHI.
26
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
European Platform on This mission supports exploring synergies of activities and
Best Practice Exchange benefits from initiatives of various stakeholders engaged in task
shifting. WP2 will contribute to a better understanding of task
shifting and sharing in the EU, to the dialogue on different types
of task shifting in use, and reveal existing good practices in
different EU MS. By managing active communication and
dissemination, WP2 contributes to the joint progress towards
sustainable implementation of task shifting in Europe.
2.4.3. Pertinence of geographical coverage
The geographical diversity of the members of the consortium enables a better understanding of
disparities of the national- and regional dimensions in Europe. The Consortium partners are
representing six of the EU/EEA Member States, including Estonia, Italy, Hungary, Lithuania, the
Netherlands, and Norway.
With the nationalities of partners from these MS, variations and differences of health care systems can
be observed more effectively with regards to the implementation of task shifting. The different
structures and compositions of health care systems, as well as the HWF, varying possibilities with
regards to financial and human resources, as well as the different policies and regulations are all
valuable observational aspects of the processes of task shifting and the implementation of such
processes. Moreover, the ageing population, the ageing HWF, the rising needs and demand of primary
care and better integrated care, and even the private and public nature of health care are all factors
that provide valuable insight with regards to the limitations and possibilities the implementation of
task shifting processes can bring about.
2.4.4. Context of the project work
The complementarity of the partnership
The consortium shows a strong willingness to deliver added value at EU-, national- and regional levels,
to gather, disseminate and exchange knowledge on task shifting processes and practices, and to
enable progress towards the implementation of task shifting for the HWF. The special value of the
project Consortium lies in the practice-based professional partnership of members, as well as the well-
established network of organizations with significant professional experience in the development and
planning of HWF in various contexts.
The above mentioned general and strategic objectives of the project, e.g, mapping practices and
preparing recommendations, are high priorities for the Consortium members, and all of the partners
can contribute by taking specific roles to reaching the goals effectively during the project duration. The
partners from different backgrounds (academia, research, public administration, and health authority)
have long-established engagement with their national level stakeholders in the field of HWF
development. The involvement of partners as well as relevant stakeholders with various professional
backgrounds is necessary for the effective implementation of task shifting processes on the EU level.
There are already some existing good practices, for instance on the utilization of e-health solutions for
more efficient healthcare in Estonia, digital upskilling and education programmes in Norway and
Hungary, and task shifting and sharing processes in the Netherlands. The Netherlands is well-known
about the high level of readiness and responsiveness towards the benefits of task shifting, while having
extended experiences in the different types of task shifting among different health professional
groups. Besides the Netherlands, Estonia and Lithuania incentivise nationwide uptake of new roles of
27
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
nurses, and nurse prescribing is also an extended right and role of public health nurses in Norway, and
training for Advanced Practice Nurses is part of the master education in Norway. The master level
training for Advanced Practice Nurses was also introduced in Hungary a few years ago.
The Consortium members established strong collaborations in the course of previous EU-level actions
and projects. For instance, NIVEL from the Netherlands has been involved in the Health Prometheus
project, where Semmelweis University was the Work Package leader of data collection in HWF
mobility. Further collaboration was strengthened during the Joint Action on European Health
Workforce Planning and Forecasting, and the SEPEN Joint Tender. In the latter two EU actions, AGENAS
and Semmelweis University played crucial roles in Work Package leading concerning HWF planning
data and methodologies. AGENAS carried out feasibility studies and pilot projects in the Joint Action
on European Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting in Italy, Portugal, Germany, and Romania,
while Semmelweis conducted mapping studies in HWF terminology, mobility and planning data.
Currently in SEPEN, AGENAS and Semmelweis University is involved in providing technical support and
assistance for EU MS in HWF planning, in which they are providing tailored advice and guidance for
Lithuania and Estonia. Partners of Estonia and Lithuania received targeted guidance on improvements
of HWF planning in SEPEN, resulting in a detailed situation analysis of the current HWF challenges at
the national level. The TaSHI project could mean a continuity of targeted HWF actions, and sustain the
collaboration and also monitor the impact of all HWF developments in these partner countries.
These examples already show strong engagement and collaboration of consortium members in the
field of HWF development, on-site tailored interventions, exchange of expertise and disseminating and
facilitating knowledge transfer. Therefore, all partners can identify their specific role and contribution
to the TaSHI project to deliver experience and expertise to achieve project objectives.
Context of WPs
All relevant knowledge, information, and accessible good practices of the EU will be gathered as part
of WP4 to consolidate the existing information needed for the effective implementation and utilization
of task shifting processes in Member States. The general aim is to provide overarching, clear and
coherent guidelines on the process of task shifting, its prospect and possibilities, and the effective
utilization of resources for the most successful implementation. The guidelines will provide incentives
for the legal and policy environment to overcome barriers and utilize the facilitators of the process of
task shifting, as well as tools to incorporate such processes on the sectoral and occupational levels.
The WP leaders come from various academic backgrounds with experiences of curriculum, training
modules and course design, and development training materials.
The project aims to provide a deliverable that benefits upskilling and upscaling the HWF and enable
and foster capacity building. Training materials and curriculum are to be considered as prototypes to
be used in specific modules of undergraduate or postgraduate academic programmes, or CPD training
for professionally active HWF covering a high variety of health professions, (e.g. modules on transversal
skills of HWF, effective management and leadership modules, or digital health courses for health
professionals).
The implementation WP5 of the process of task shifting requires careful and thorough guidance on
different levels, including individual-, organizational-, and policy levels. The guidelines will aim to
comprise all of these levels, thereby providing maximum knowledge and understanding. The case
studies of the implementation sites, as part of WP5, will carry out proposed activities of task shifting
to achieve the defined objectives and deliver informative, useful and transferable results. Careful
implementation of task shifting and sharing processes will serve with valuable information with
regards to implementing future objectives and results into everyday practice. WP5 will be led by a well-
experienced partner, who has already consulted and coordinated technical assistance of on-site
implementations in HWF development.
28
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
WP3 will aim to evaluate internally, while WP2 will aim to disseminate externally the TaSHI project.
The WP3 evaluation will follow a systematic approach, including the definition of the evaluation
strategy (initial evaluation plan, and sustainability plan), and WP2 will also follow its dissemination and
communication plan in order to foster knowledge exchange and activate dialogue among relevant
stakeholders and target groups. Such information and knowledge is vital in order to incorporate task
shifting processes into daily practice while ensuring the utmost effectiveness as well as safety of
patient care.
Furthermore, it is essential that the target audience of the project is aware of the latest developments
and active exchanges on the products in the field of task shifting. In the framework of WP3, the project
aims to involve experts as “TaSHI Advisory Board” who can serve as key informants in the field and
further communication and dissemination activities are conducted as part of WP2 about the most
effective ways to reach the various target audiences.
With regards to the aspect of change management and the cultural aspects of task shifting processes,
The Change Management Process Model by Beckhard and Harris (1987) outlines a seven step process
for implementing change. The model outlines the steps an organization needs to go through and
navigate in order to transition from its present state to the desired outcome (Beckhard & Harris,
198763; Siegal et al., 199664). The model can serve as a good example on how to tackle and manage the
changes task shifting can bring about in the health care provider sectors.
Context of implementation pilots
In the frame of the TaSHI project, 5 pilot implementation sites from 5 countries will participate with a
variety of processes and system features, targeted actions at different levels and addressing different
types of task shifting when facing current challenges in health systems and workforces.
Partners of Estonia and Lithuania participated in the national exchanges in SEPEN tender and received
targeted guidance on improvements of HWF planning – coordinated by AGENAS and Semmelweis-,
which resulted in very detailed situation analysis of the current HWF challenges at national level. All
partners have also ongoing initiatives linked to overcoming difficulties or maldistribution in care
provision, including some practices of task shifting.
Lithuania:
The Lithuanian healthcare system faces several challenges in terms of HWF:
● Overall high number of service provision and doctor specialists, family physician’s services
consumption without clear decrease in the number of amenable death rate;
● Uneven distribution of doctors, nurses in primary care across regions;
● Regional inequalities in service provision and service quality;
● Long waiting times, limited access to doctor specialists and GP’s.
On the other hand, Lithuanian HWF structure has one of the highest densities of medical doctors,
although the density of nurses is far below the EU and OECD average. This creates additional workloads
on medical doctors, limits provision of low threshold health care services, creates high cost of basic
service provision, limits access and creates queuing. The education system, payment structure over
63
Beckhard, R. and Harris, R. T. (1987), Organizational Transitions: Managing Complex Change,
2nd ed., Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA.
64
Siegal, W., Church, A.H., Javitch, M., Waclawski, J., Burd, S., Bazigos, M., Yang, T., Anderson‐Rudolph, K., &
Burke, W. (1996). Understanding the management of change. Journal of Organizational Change Management,
9, 54-80.
29
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
the years devalues professional education and as a result attraction of nursing studies remains low,
additionally retention of nurses to the healthcare system is not meeting country needs. High
administrative burden, especially in primary care service provision, low IT skills of staff, creates high
work overload for medical doctors and dissatisfaction with the health care system.
Estonia:
The situation of Estonian HWF can be described through the following bottlenecks:
- lack of nurses (the ratio of nurses is 2/3 of EU average);
- high proportion of doctors in retirement age (1/5 of working medical doctors are over 65);
- unsystematic involvement of allied health professionals.
As the country's education system can increase the number of nurses only marginally during following
years and will struggle to provide replacement to retiring doctors (e.g family physicians and
psychiatrists), the health care system is in need of a serious innovation to increase the quality and
availability of the services.
Task-shifting has a potential to increase efficiency, quality and accessibility in health care. Learning
from positive practices of other countries and being supported by experts, the TaSHI project is
expected to support the design and implementation of national HWF policy. Although Estonia has been
a pioneer in task-shifting-to-digital solutions, other forms of task shifting may be underused. Strict
regulations and organization of health care prohibit flexibility in providing services. Mixing different
forms of task-shifting may provide flexible service provision especially in rural areas and enhance
significantly service models that link primary care and hospital level health care.
PoliS-Lombardia, Italy:
PoliS-Lombardia is the regional agency supporting the policy-making actions of the Lombardy region
in Italy. PoliS-Lombardia is also in charge of executing the training course for general practitioners
(GPs), for hospital medical unit directors, and for hospital general managers. It also provides strategic
continuing education for the HWF for the regional government.
Lombardy healthcare system stands at the top of the range in Europe and probably is the most
advanced in secondary care in Italy (Istat, 201965; PoliS-Lombardia, 201966). Nevertheless, the SARS-
CoV-2 pandemic highlighted critical needs regarding organizational aspects mainly in primary care.
At the national level, new important legislative initiatives have been established, e.g. a significant
number of medical fellowships and 9600 nurses jobs (D.L.34/2020). At the regional level also,
Lombardy government aims to seize the opportunity to review the entire healthcare system
organization (D.L23/2020). The main goal is to empower the primary care in order to meet the same
level of excellence displayed by the secondary care.
Norway:
In Norway, there are several initiatives for developing healthcare provision with the help of e-health
and digital care solutions. For task shifting, two specific areas were selected, where we could maximize
the benefits of task shifting to machines and between health professions, and reconsidering scope of
practice due to telemedicine.
65
Istat (2019) ‘Bes 2019. Il benessere equo e sostenibile in Italia’. Roma, pp. 1–237.
66
PoliS-Lombardia (2019) ‘Rapporto Lombardia 2019’. Milano, pp. 1-428.
30
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
1) Wound care is typically built up by multidisciplinary teams, where home care nurses in
collaboration with the general practitioner (GP) have the primary responsibility for treatment
and follow- up of patients with ulcers in collaboration with the specialist health care service
(Smith-Strøm et al, 201667). In the absence of access to a multidisciplinary team in the
community, it has been shown that not all patients had an assessment of the underlying cause
of the ulcer before nurses had to make a decision on local wound care (Smith-Strøm and
Thornes, 200868). The pilot is focussing on wound care in the municipal health care system;
supported by specialized services from outpatient clinic at the hospital using real-time video-
communication. In Norway, only a few nurses in the municipality have formal wound care
training, few nurses have experience from working in wound care clinics and the access to
medical doctors for advice in wound care may be completely absent.
2) Teleradiography – Remote Computer Tomography for stroke diagnosing in rural areas: A
project using telemedicine services in stroke diagnostics have been introduced this year. To
have 24/7 service in the rural area is therefore an important issue to get those who are
affected by stroke in the rural areas an equal service compared to those, who live in urban
areas with easy access to a hospital. The Norwegian guidelines for stroke treatments states
that if a patient needs thrombolysis treatment, this has to be started by 4,5 hours after
symptoms started. A CT examination is important to decide if the patient is a candidate for
thrombolysis (Helsedirektoratet, 201769). When non- radiographic professions are going to use
X- ray machines, it will be important to make customized and good training to operate the
machines to ensure the quality of the examination. The paramedic staff therefore need
procedure training to do a good quality job. Training and regular maintenance of knowledge is
an important management tool to facilitate. Cooperation and communication is also important
for the radiographers, the paramedics and the junior doctors to ensure the quality of the
examination and the treatment. Computer Tomography (CT) examinations are carried out by
a radiographer at day time and in afternoons, at nights and weekends by paramedics. The
paramedic staff performs the CT procedure using video link to the Ringerike hospital, where a
radiographer guides and has remote control of the CT machine. The paramedic staff also
conducts a neurological examination of the patient, which procedure is guided by a junior
doctor also via video link. This exercise is a type of remote care and consultation and
diagnostics is made digitally. The professional team decides about the diagnosis and if a
thrombolytic treatment is needed, the paramedic staff will be guided to inject actilyse, and
refers the patient to the hospital, located about 3 hours away.
The Netherlands:
Task shifting and taking over tasks from ophthalmologists shows an emerging practice in the
Netherlands, which is due to the diffusion of optometric technology. On the other hand, however,
barriers for this type of task-shifting are present and pending. One barrier is omission of a cost-effective
tariff for optometrists to offer eye care without a commercial incentive to get the necessary equipment
and ICT to purchase. Another barrier is that ophthalmologists see opportunities for task-shifting, but
also strive for clear rules on ensuring the quality of ophthalmic care, agreements on legal responsibility,
supervision and training. In addition, the domain battle between ophthalmologists and optometrists
67
Smith-Strøm, H., Iversen, M. M., Graue, M., Skeie, S., & Kirkevold, M. (2016). An integrated wound-care pathway,
supported by telemedicine, and competent wound management—essential in follow-up care of adults with diabetic foot
ulcers. International journal of medical informatics, 94, 59-66. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27573312/
68
Smith-Strøm, H., & Thornes, I. (2008). Patient Safety regarding Leg Ulcer Treatment in Primary Health Care. Nordic
Journal of Nursing Research, 28, 29 - 33. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Patient-Safety-regarding-Leg-Ulcer-
Treatment-in-Smith-Str%C3%B8m-Thornes/cd5f014a63ea7992d486e58d76988d9a79627a6d
69
https://www.helsedirektoratet.no/tema/hjerneslag
31
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
is influencing the attention for case mix aggravation and associated financial arrangements are
important to motivate ophthalmologists to (further) realize shifting of tasks.
In the Netherlands, regional projects are ongoing in task shifting:
1) In the region of Twente, ophthalmologists and optometrists work together in optics shops,
causing that the number of referrals has decreased considerably. In almost 80% of the less
complex eye care demands, optometrists appear to be able to serve these independently
instead of ophthalmologists. Since the start of the pilot, 2,000 people have already been
referred by the GPs to the optometrist instead of the ophthalmologist. More than 400 of those
patients were referred to the ophthalmologist, but the other 1,600 could be helped by primary
care. This is considered as a ‘relief‘ for the ophthalmologists’’ workload and an advantage for
the patients’ pathway that can go much faster.
2) Also in the region of Rotterdam, cooperation and task shifting practices between
ophthalmologists and optometrists can be monitored for the TaSHI project.
Considering the above, successful completion of the TaSHI project on the diverse pilot implementation
sites will provide novel solutions, synthesized evidence, tools and methods tested for overcoming and
mitigating some HR challenges and barriers by task shifting.
2.5. Methods and means
When implementing the project, several methods and means will ensure the optimal and effective
execution of activities. The project will benefit from qualitative and quantitative methods as well
throughout the whole project duration, which are contributing to more reliable and valid results.
The TaSHI project is divided into 5 WPs with a great level of interconnectedness. There are three
horizontal WPs on “Project Management and coordination”, “Dissemination and communication” and
“Evaluation”. These three WPs continuously feed each other's activities, also highly dependent on the
vertical WPs. WP4 is focusing on the preparatory activities of implementation (WP5), and knowledge
management. There will be parallel activities and tasks, therefore WP1 and WP leaders will have the
responsibility to harmonise the activities relying on each other. Additionally WP1 can support the
synergies of the diverse WPs. WP4 will produce deliverables to be used in WP5, and WP5 experiences
and deliverables will be evaluated, and then incorporated into revised deliverables of WP4. In WP5, 5
implementation sites will pilot task shifting. These will concentrate on specific types of task shifting
during the implementation of their pilots. The pilots will run and gather information based on the
common methodology and evaluation, therefore conclusions can be drawn to benefit and upscale
further implementations in EU MS. The TaSHI project will be evaluated internally by WP3, and intends
to involve an advisory board to ensure external supervision. The messages and results of TaSHI will be
disseminated EU-wide by WP2. Communication and continuous stakeholder involvement and
engagement will mean a high priority. As the WP leader of WP2 has extended experience on network
management and animation, activities e.g. organizing and running webinars and online dialogues will
be a crucial part of knowledge sharing and exchanging information and evidence of different
stakeholders, target groups.
32
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Overview of work packages
WP1 will utilize Project Management methods and tools. In this WP we will involve the guidelines of
PM2 Project Management Methodology of the European Commission. This methodology is
transferable for a project like this and supports us to effectively coordinate and control the partner’s
ongoing activities, monitor deadlines, deliver the planned outputs on time and keep up the working
efficiency in the entire lifecycle of the project.
WP2 will explore different potential means in communication and dissemination, also including a
crucial stakeholder/target group mapping and analysis (see also Lewin force field analysis), which aims
to map the different target groups in depth for the broad audience of dissemination. The stakeholder
coverage evaluation tool from the Toolkit on Health Workforce Planning (designed by the Joint Action
on European Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting) will support this task. The sustainability of
the results will be considered here as well. The project will provide a platform for collaboration for
HWF experts (potentially on the EU HPP specific “Health Workforce” forum) and foster the dialogue in
various topics relating to HWF development. This WP will manage the stakeholders during the project.
An interim evaluation will use a satisfaction survey method to increase the quality of dissemination
and communication activities based on stakeholders’ feedback. WP2 foresees seven channels to be
used during the TaSHI project, considering the synergies of the other funded projects under the specific
topics of the call.
33
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Channel type Purpose of the Frequency/D Method of the Date of
communication uration communication the
activity
Continuous
information platform
for the stakeholders
TaSHI project Uploading news, M3-M36
and public of the
website Continuous publications, events
project, about the
related to the project
activity of the partners,
outputs, events,
developments
Occasional
communication tool Depends
Partners websites Posts, short news,
for the partner’s main Occasionally on
pictures
activities, project activities
outcomes, events
In order to
Based on the
communicate up-to-
TASHI Project communicati
date news, information Sendinblue - marketing
newsletter on plan, 9 M1-M36
about the project communication software
editions
status, events,
altogether
outcomes
Partners Share information Depends
newsletters about the partner’s Occasionally Brief news on
activity in the project activities
EU HPP specific
“Health EU HPP platform to
Articles, short posts,
Workforce” keep the stakeholders Continuous M3-M36
forum polls
informed.
Social media sites
(linkedin; Attract attention and
facebook, targeted calls for Occasionally Short posts, pictures M1-M36
twitter) actions
34
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
3-4 event
Webinars / Joint Sharing experiences annually,
webinars with
and information by based on the Webinars, thematic
related
projects/Online online events in webinar workshops, online M1-M36
events synergies with other series, event events
projects execution
plan
Share video Depends
Youtube channel Recorded Video
recordings, promoting on
online events recordings/streamings
videos of the project activities
Face-to-face meetings
Personal Conference Depends
with the objective of
appearance Occasionally participation, workshop on
dissemination and
attendance activities
networking
Rollup and leaflet Support presentations,
Main information about
production personal Occasionally M3
the project
communication
WP3 will develop and conduct an evaluation methodology for internal evaluation of the project run
and provide indicators, which will measure and assess the impact of the activities carried out by the
project. The “TaSHI advisory board” will be set up in order to ensure objective project evaluation and
assessment of the impact of different activities.
WP4 will use a research methodology, where desk research will employ different methods in order to
collect and analyse concepts and implementation practices. The mapping exercise and the collection
of good practices will be facilitated by USN and will be done through an academic literature review, EU
project screening by using predefined keywords for exploring the most important projects, tools,
concepts and previous findings. In addition, key informant interviews and partner’s contributions will
result in a list of existing good practices. All partners will be invited to provide examples of the good
practices on task shifting from their own experiences along the participatory design method. In
addition, further methodology will be applied to establish education guidelines and develop practical
training materials and curriculum. The KPP model is a generic educational model designed for
continuing health education programs. The model shows how the learning resources, learning and
assessment tasks are connected as a complete learning process, i.e. how learning and assessment
should take place. Knowledge (K) can be tested and reviewed by self-assessment, reinforced by video
resources, and assessed through formative assessment. Process (P) connects new knowledge with
prior knowledge, a cognitive or practice-based framework, and can be enhanced through online
facilitation or virtual classroom discussion. The learning is assessed formatively. Internships provide
practice (P) experience and should be an essential part of shared learning, and is well suited for clinical
practice and clinical audit. The assessment can be summative, such as a practice assessment. In
essence: identification and processing of new knowledge, use of cognitive frameworks in ‘authentic’
or ‘situated’ learning environments, reflective and collaborative learning promote learning outcome
35
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
and competency by three key learning activity domains: knowledge acquisition (K), knowledge
processing (P) and knowledge application in professional practice (P). The LOVU method enables in
addition to the educational model, a platform and repository of learning resources to apply to achieve
specific learning outcomes. Co-creation and sharing of learning materials related to common learning
outcomes are key processes of LOVU methodology.
WP5 will also use a complex set of methods for the 5 different implementation sites. There will be a
common methodology to set the framework of the pilots and in order to provide some comparability
of the diverse actions, and a common evaluation on the pilot results. The scope and the phases of the
pilots will follow the same methodology, and then a variability of on-site experiences can add to the
currently existing evidence. Inspiration from the Calderdale Framework70 will support the common
methodology, e.g. use of Power Interest Matrix stakeholder analysis, OECD Assessment tool etc.
The Expert Panel on effective ways of investing in Health (EXPH) of the EU Commission consulted in
2019 on task shifting and health system design recommended that “decisions to engage in task shifting
should be planned carefully, taking full account of the implications both for the individuals concerned
and for the wider health sector”. Moreover, they suggested one approach capable of guaranteeing
those requirements, the Calderdale Framework, stated that “we see the elements contained within it
as being important”. The Calderdale Framework (CF) is a 7-step process used to improve the way a
healthcare team works. It provides a clear and systematic method for reviewing the team's skill-mix,
developing new roles and new ways of working and linking these workforce changes to the redesign
of the service to ensure safe and effective patient-centred care. The Calderdale Framework focuses on
the workforce elements of a health care model, complementing the model with service redesign. The
main principle of the Calderdale Framework is patient-centred care. The final goal of the Calderdale
Framework implementation process is to develop a competency-based training program for
healthcare professionals that ensures quality and patient safety while maximizing the capacity of the
workforce. The Calderdale framework was developed by a team work in 2011, the Effective Workforce
Solutions Ltd. Then, in the following years was successfully used in different health care settings in
change management project regarding task shifting, multidisciplinary team building, skill mix design,
etc. The framework proposes a stepwise approach that TaSHI will replicate in the different pilot sites,
adopting a flexible implementation perspective, meaning that, based on the needs of each pilot site,
TaSHI will go more in depth in specific steps of the framework.
The original Calderdale Framework proposes also, for each step of the implementation path, some
tools to support the implementers. But those specific tools are protected by copyright and can be used
only by the Calderdale Framework Practitioners.
Expected results include:
1) a comprehensive map of the functions and tasks provided by the team to deliver the service,
2) an analysis of the tasks determining whether each of them should be:
(a) performed only by the profession(s) currently performing the task,
(b) shared to one or more additional professions, or
(c) delegated to an allied health care assistant or other support worker,
70
Smith, R., & Duffy, J. Developing a competent and flexible workforce using the Calderdale Framework. Int J Ther Rehabil,
17(5):254–262. https://www.magonlinelibrary.com/doi/abs/10.12968/ijtr.2010.17.5.47844
(https://www.calderdaleframework.com/ )
36
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
3) instructions on support to provide the training, skills assessment and governance processes
necessary to implement a task shifting initiative (sharing of skills or delegated practice)
4) an evaluation and monitoring process to incorporate the new way of working into regular
practice.
In summary, the successful completion of the TaSHI project will provide novel solutions for overcoming
and mitigating some HR challenges and barriers by task shifting. After synthesizing the evidence and
the lessons from the implementations, the problems and the solutions might be grouped together to
better explore where task shifting could be the optimal solution.
Specific Description of methods and means by objectives
Objective ID
1)
Mapping practices and developing tools - strengthening the knowledge on task
shifting
Deliverables
● Deliverable of Collection of useful tools and practices in task shifting
● Deliverable of Case studies of implementation sites
● Deliverable of Guidebook of task shifting
Activities and tasks - List of methods and means
● Desk research (e.g. screening EU projects)
● Systematic literature review
● Participatory design of a list of existing good practices by consortium partners
● Interviews with key informants (semi-structured or focus-group, or Delphi)
● LOVU framework and KKP model
● Common methodology and evaluation of pilots
● Identification of phases inspired by the Calderdale Framework
● Power Interest Matrix stakeholder analysis
● Assessment by the OECD study
Specific Description of methods and means by objectives
Objective ID
2)
Provide recommendations on training and upskilling - share and utilize experiences
of implementation pilots on task shifting
Deliverables
● Deliverable of Practical training materials and curriculum
● Deliverable of Set of recommendations for task shifting actions
Activities and tasks - List of methods and means
● LOVU framework and KKP model
● Common methodology and evaluation of pilots
● Identification of phases inspired by the Calderdale Framework
37
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
● Power Interest Matrix stakeholder analysis
● Assessment by the OECD study
● Collecting recommendations - validation by the implementers
2.6. Expected outcomes and benefits of the project
The expected outcomes of this project can be differentiated by level (general and specific), type
(product and process) and target group (stakeholders). Below, these three ‘dimensions’ are applied to
categorize expected outcomes of the project. The expected outcomes will be aligned with the
predefined deliverables and milestones as described in the ‘horizontal’ and ‘vertical’ Work Packages
of this proposal.
As the general expected outcomes of this project we distilled from the Call text the following four
objectives:
1. Added value at EU, national and regional levels;
2. New knowledge on task shifting processes;
3. EU-wide dissemination and exchange of knowledge on task shifting processes;
4. Progress towards the implementation of task shifting processes for the HWF.
Related to these four objectives, the specific objectives as described in the Call text can be classified
as follows:
Ad general outcome 1: Added value at EU, national and regional levels:
● Providing good practices for introduction of task-shifting – patient safety / HS performance;
● Providing recommendations on the impact of new skills, including digital tools, disease
prevention, risk detection to provide aid in the reskilling of HWF, as well as future HWF.
Ad general outcome 2: New knowledge on task shifting processes
● Identification and analysis of the concept and implementation of task shifting;
● Providing an update on existing tools to incorporate task shifting processes;
● Mitigate the effects of changing skill-mixes and competencies across sectors and occupational
groups.
Ad general outcome 3: Dissemination and exchange of knowledge on task shifting processes
● Implementing strategies and identifying good practices, facilitating the exchange of these
concepts;
● Contribution to the EU specific “Health Workforce” forum, EU-wide dissemination of
knowledge;
● Organizing seminars and thematic workshops to ensure joint reflection and enhancing
knowledge and lessons learnt.
Ad general outcome 4: Progress towards the implementation of task shifting processes for the HWF
● Development of practical guidelines for the public authorities and healthcare providers which
will serve as the operational tools supporting their healthcare workforce policies in relation to
challenges in these fields;
● Provide practical training and education materials;
● Developing curricula for digital, interpersonal, and management skills for physicians, nurses,
pharmacists, and other HWF;
38
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
● Provide recommendations for future HWF skills to aid better adaptation to new developments;
provide aid in the upskilling of nurses, including digital skills, with the involvement of IT
specialists.
With regard to the stakeholders or target groups, these can be linked with the four general objectives
as follows:
Ad general outcome 1: the authorities and policy makers at the MS, national and regional level can be
considered as the main target group. In particular, the alignment between these actors on the different
geographical and policy levels is important to include in evaluating this outcome. Ensuring and
acknowledging that the policy development and implementation, including that on task shifting
processes, is not an exclusive domain for national authorities.
Ad general outcome 2: new knowledge on task shifting processes - the current research and policy
community in the EU and worldwide can be considered as the main target group.
Ad general outcome 3: policy organisations and governing bodies that are responsible for, and research
organisations working on task shifting in the EU MS can be considered as the main target group. These
organisations are the ‘agents’ to disseminate the outcomes of the project, i.e. the new knowledge.
Ad general outcome 4: progress towards the implementation of task shifting processes for the HWF -
the health care providers (both professionals and organisations) can be considered as the main target
group. Here, patient organisations and citizen representatives are also important target groups.
To summarize the expected outcomes and relate it to the deliverables planned in this project on the
one hand, and the benefits on the other, the next table is presented:
Deliverable Outcome Benefit
Increased number of improved
Collection of useful tools and methods and tools for task The benefit of these ensure
practices in task shifting useful methods and tangible
shifting in the EU
Case studies of tools for developing HWFs in
Increased number of
implementation sites EU MS, also increasing
pilots/case
efficiency and productivity of
Guidebook of task shifting studies/initiatives/actions/pra
the HWF for the long-term
ctices on task shifting in the
EU Enabling countries to
develop and exchange
Increased number of
more sophisticated
stakeholders
and effective
engaged/participated in the
knowledge on task
EU representing more EU MS
shifting in the EU
The case studies aim to
Guidebook as a direct tool to
summarize pilot experiences,
be utilized for the
which can be upscaled to
implementation of task
broader fields and countries
shifting.
by diverse stakeholders in the
EU
Enhanced readiness, flexibility
and preparedness of the EU
39
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
HWF is expected in facing
challenges and emergency
situations
Increased cultural sensitivity
towards resiliency and
organisational adaptation in
the EU
Increased number of
Practical training materials experts/stakeholders The benefits of these enable
and curriculum capacity building and
participating in policy
Set of recommendations for dialogues on task shifting in upskilling of HWFs in the EU
task shifting actions the EU
Action plans,
Increased number of policy recommendations on diverse
recommendations on task aspects of task shifting and
shifting in the EU HWF development can
Increased number of contribute to better coverage
education programmes and and distribution of resources
training materials in the EU in the EU
Supporting health system
reforms focusing on
workforce policies, access to
care in disadvantaged areas
and reorganisation of
healthcare delivery by case
study experiences in the EU
Supporting the sustainability
of the HWF by contributing
to an effective HWF
forecasting and planning at
different levels by updated
HWF planning tools
40
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
2.7. Gantt Chart
41
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
2.8. Project management
2.8.1. Methods
Project management and coordination carried out by the Semmelweis University, is in charge of
enabling an efficient and supportive working environment for the partners where they are encouraged
to perform and collaborate in order to keep the project schedule, produce deliverables and provide
quality work. Semmelweis University will coordinate the work and planned activities in all WPs, and
ensure the adequate infrastructure (e.g.: internal communication and monitoring platform) for
fulfilling the workplan and quality delivery in the given timeframe.
An internal interactive repository will be established for the partners in order to support the internal
communication in the project. This repository will operate as a central document database/library and
follows the different stages of documents and deliverables. This repository will follow data privacy and
security regulations and be available only by authorisation with personal username and password for
the project partners.
2.8.2. Governance, Roles, Responsibilities
Roles and responsibilities are clearly defined for each WP, work package leaders are appointed and
each partner agreed with the participation. The internal reporting system will allow the Project
coordinator to follow and control the progress of the activities.
FIGURE 5 - Governance of TaSHI
Consortium Leader
The Consortium Leader, acting as the project coordinator, is the highest decision making unit within
the consortium. Its main responsibility is to ensure the correct implementation of the contract with
the European Commission, and the Consortium Agreement (CA), being the primary contact point for
all formal written and verbal communication with the European Commission on behalf of the
consortium.
The Project coordinator will clearly define roles and responsibilities, agree on deadlines in the
Consortium Agreement, and apply a transparent monitoring system in order to follow up the work of
the Consortium. Semmelweis will be also responsible for ensuring proper reporting according to
reporting guidelines, requirements, and the timely delivery of these reports. Managing the legal,
42
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
contractual, ethical, financial and administrative control of the project with supporting documentation
will be within the remit of Semmelweis. The Project coordinator is also responsible for the risk
management of the project, which is intended to ensure the production of concrete and high-quality
results in line with the project work plan, and ensure that standards and procedures are defined,
applied and evaluated.
Project support office
A project support office is set up at the site of the project coordinator. The project support office
consists of the project manager, a project assistant and a financial officer. The primary task of the
project support office is to assist the coordinator in the financial, technical and administrative
management of the consortium. It will supply advice, prepare documents, obtain information and
documents from participants (and other parties). When necessary, the office will be expanded with a
legal and/or ethics expert to support the coordinator or an independent third party will be consulted.
The financial offices will assist the project coordinator in the budget monitoring and the financial
reporting to the EC and will be available to the consortium for questions of a financial/budgetary
nature.
Work package leaders and other partners’ contribution
All Work package leaders and Co-leaders collectively work with the project coordinator in ensuring
that the objectives of the project as a whole are met. The appointed WP leaders for each WP, are
primarily responsible for the coordination of the work, including the organisation of technical meetings
as required, reporting work in progress to the project management at the regular monthly electronic
WP Leader Meetings and the Executive Board Meetings every 6th month, preparation and submission
of the technical deliverables and reporting (major) changes to the project plan. WP-leaders organise
communication and exchange of knowledge and documents regarding their WP with the participant
organisations and experts involved. In case of new insights or problems that require alterations in the
planning and execution of activities, WP-leaders are responsible for proposing adequate changes
within the WP schedule and possible reallocation of responsibilities and reporting it to the Consortium
Leader. Problems that cannot be resolved within the WP are reported to the project coordinator, who
will undertake appropriate actions to resolve the problem. Partners of the implementation sites will
be responsible to report to the respective WP leader.
TaSHI Executive Board
Executive board meetings will be held every 6th month of the project, as a part of the regular electronic
WP Leader meeting. The Executive Board consists of WP Leaders and involves the part time financial
officer in charge of the financial management of TaSHI.
TaSHI Advisory Board
The advisory board plays a crucial role in WP3, the WP responsible for evaluation and quality
assurance. The ‘TaSHI Advisory Board’ will consist of a minimum of five members from 5 different
organisations, while considering the geographical coverage in the EU as well as the variety of health
providers via health professional organizations. They are invited to join two to three online meetings
per year, depending on the planning of all projects deliverables and milestones. The external experts
will increase and improve the quality of TaSHI deliverables, and WP3 Leader will share the
responsibility for ensuring a high quality of the WP deliverables.
8.2.3. Processes & Artefacts
Processes for the whole duration of the project are summarised and visualised in a gantt chart, where
each WP can check the dueness of the milestones and deliverables of the project.
The Project Management organises monthly electronic WP leaders’ meetings, to ensure the progress
of the work and handle the emerging issues. This is the most important internal forum to discuss any
43
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
issues within the project that allows the leading partners to oversee the project work and spread the
responsibility.
Beyond the electronic WP leaders’ meeting, some bi- and/or multilateral online meetings are also
needed to improve the efficient work of the consortium. These meetings will be organised by WP
leaders based on the project schedule before deliverables/milestones are due, or reporting needs
more attention for certain WP or partner. After each meeting the minutes, action points and the urgent
tasks of the partners will be summarised in a meeting minutes template and will be uploaded to the
project’s meetings folder. In this reporting system project management will verify that the set
deadlines will be kept.
2.8.4. Quality& Capacity of the partnership
The partnership consists of governmental bodies, research institutes and academia, and healthcare
providers, who are active in the field of HRH issues specifically at European and national and regional
level. The consortium has a well-established working relationship and extensive knowledge-base from
previous international projects, which brings added value from the project partnership perspective.
The Project coordinator will drive the overall work plan and support the experts and follow up quality
assurance processes that are put in place. The WP leaders will manage their resources and planning
and report regularly on their achievements to the Project coordinator.
Semmelweis University (SU) is the largest medical university in Hungary. The University has plenty of
important experiences in participating in EU funded projects of the Health Programme. The institute
Health Services Management Training Centre (HSMTC) is part of the Faculty of Health- and Public
Services, and will be the coordinator of the TaSHI project.
The HSMTC’s goal is to assist the development of health services in Hungary and on the international
level by generating better management knowledge and practice. Through its activities HSMTC aims to
generate learning and development opportunities, knowledge and new understanding for those who
work on the improvement of healthcare and health services organizations. International cooperation
and knowledge transfer has a dominant role in its activities. HSMTC is a member of several
international professional organisations, such as the European Health Management Association
(EHMA), European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT Health) and the European Health
Property Network (EUHPN). The Centre has a strong collaboration among others with the World Health
Organisation and the World Bank. In the framework of international development and research
projects, the Centre is honoured to work together with the leading institutes and professionals of the
world. As recent activities, HSMTC is actively involved in several national and international projects in
the field of big data, healthcare digitalisation, artificial intelligence (AI) and change management.
With regards to HSMTC’s experience in projects related to HWF, HSMTC was responsible for the Health
PROMeTHEUS and ECAB FP7 research projects as WP leader; associate partner in the CHRODIS PLUS;
partner in the Joint Actions to support the e-health network and for European Health Workforce
Planning and Forecasting. Having significant experience in the Human Resources for Health (HRH) field
both at national and at international level, HSMTC is currently leading the consortium of the ‘Support
for the Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting Expert Network‘ SEPEN joint tender. The key
objective of the three-year duration tender is to support and strengthen the cooperation of experts in
the field and to disseminate and share the constantly accumulating knowledge. This tender has
become an important driver for expertise and knowledge sharing in the HWF field, and it also focuses
on collecting research evidence and experience of Member States, and supports improvements and
implementation of HWF development in the EU.
Semmelweis University is furthermore a WHO Collaboration Centre (WHO CC) in HRH Development.
The centre was appointed in 2015 and the WHO CC title re-designated in 2018 for the second 4 years’
44
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
mandate. The institute is committed to represent the professional program of the WHO in the
European Region as well as supporting the professional research and educational tasks in the following
main areas: research and publication activities, dissemination and knowledge exchange, professional
expertise and guidance, supporting the professional program on the regional and global level, and
teaching and training activities, and event organisation. These days for instance, our WHO CC is
working together with three other WHO CC’s globally in designing targeted HRH Leadership and
Management Training Courses (shorter training and master level programmes).
In connection with digital upskilling of the HWF, HSMTC led a consortium with partners of Universidad
de Navarra, IESE Business School and E-Group in a summer school programme funded by EIT Health.
L-ead Summer School “Leveraging e-health workforce by advanced skills” aims to generate awareness
raising and knowledge sharing about changes of healthcare systems in the digital age. With the help
of change management and evidence-based policy making, participants will understand the
functioning of health systems, the context and rationale of workforce development. HSMTC ran the
programme face-to-face in 2019 and online in 2020.
The Italian National Agency for Regional Healthcare Services - AGENAS
As required by its institutional role, AGENAS is committed to monitor the health system and contribute
to enhance its performances. As partner of the Task Shifting proposal, that aims to support EU Member
States in designing and implementing their policies related to healthcare workforce task-shifting, can
give its contribution through two types of action:
A methodological, due to the great experience of AGENAS in relevant European projects as:
- Joint Action on European Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting coordinated by Belgium and
funded by the third EU Health Programme, brought together knowledge and expertise on HWF from
all over Europe. This group of experts, including AGENAS’, has produced Handbooks and Guidelines,
describing the most advanced planning methodologies of 7 countries. AGENAS oversaw the pilot-
testing in Italy with a feasibility study running in Germany.
- SEPEN call for tender Support for the hEalth workforce Planning and forecasting Expert Network: it is
a project with the aim to sustain cross-country cooperation and provide support to Member States to
increase their knowledge, improve their tools and succeed in achieving a higher effectiveness in HWF
planning processes and policy. AGENAS , together with the Italian Ministry of Health, has the role of
leader of the Work Package 4; it is engaged in providing support to member states (MS) about, not
only a better understanding of available data in their territory, but, above all, HWF planning according
to their request.
Moreover, AGENAS is part of the SEPEN team which is organizing an online technical workshop entitled
“Digital health: what are the implications for supply, demand, monitoring and organisation of health
workforce?”. It deals with the impact of the development of digital technologies and information
technology on the current and future HWF, it will be characterized by a great interactivity as all the
participants will be able to give their contribution in sharing their knowledge and proposing solutions
to the problems discussed.
- Joint action on implementation of digitally enabled integrated person-centered care - JADECARE
whose goal is to reinforce the capacity of health authorities to address all the important aspects of
health system transformation successfully, in particular the transition to digitally enabled, integrated,
person-centered care to support the best practice transfer from the systems of the “early adopters”
to the “next adopters”. AGENAS represents the Competent Authority for Italy and, above all, it is Co-
leader of Work Package 4 with the specific role to support “next adopters” of each JA partner for the
implementation in their territory of the selected best practices.
- A technical, as the task shifting interventions can also materialize in the development of training
courses for healthcare personnel, in which AGENAS has acquired a great experience through ECM
45
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
(Educazione Continua in Medicina - Continuing Medical Education): it is a national programme of
training activities, active in Italy since 2002. The ECM provides the maintenance of a high level of
knowledge related to health theory, practice and communication; it includes training of health staff
and regulatory development courses.
Moreover, an important role has been recently assigned by the Italian government according to the
last Finance Law, as AGENAS has been involved in the “National Observatory for the specialized health
training” with the aim to support the National Healthcare System to define the needs of doctors and
healthcare professionals.
Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research - NIVEL
NIVEL, Netherlands institute for health services research, is the national institute for health services
research in the Netherlands. More than 150 researchers are active in the multidisciplinary field of
health services research that examines how health systems, structures and processes affect access to
health care, the quality and costs of health care. HWF research has been conducted by NIVEL since its
foundation in 1975, in particular by model development for HWF planning and forecasting. Task
shifting and substitution are studied in different health sectors to support policies on an operational,
tactical as strategic level.
The Ministry of Health of the Republic of Lithuania – MOH-LT
The mission of the Ministry is to form and implement health policy that ensures public health, high
quality health promotion activities, and rational use of resources - in compliance with the requirements
of EU regulations. In addition, the Ministry of Health is responsible for the supervision of healthcare
service provision, prevention and control of diseases, and improvement of the population health. In
order to achieve the above mentioned goals, the Ministry is taking part in a number of projects also in
EU-financed actions and has a deep understanding and vast experience in EU projects.
Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs – SM-EE
One role of the Ministry of Social Affairs is to plan and implement the health care policy. Health System
Development Department (HSDD) is a unit of the Ministry responsible for health care policy
development to ensure availability, quality, and safety of health care and guarantee the awareness of
and satisfaction with health services among residents. This project is expected to support the design
and implementation of national HWF policy as smart task-shifting has a potential to increase efficiency,
quality and accessibility in health care. Mixing different forms of task-shifting may support flexible
service provision, especially in rural areas and enhance significantly service models that link primary
care and hospital level health care.
University of South-Eastern Norway - USN
The Faculty of Health and Social Science (HS) at the University of South-Eastern Norway includes
committed professionals with extensive experience. In addition to professional study programs, we
offer a number of master degree programs, including: Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, Preventive
Work with Children and Young People, Health Promotion, Midwifery, and Optometry, as well
Radiography- and the master course "Justification and skill-mix in radiology". USN also offers a PhD
programme in person-centric research. The faculty offers tailor made courses, studies and research in
line with society's needs for increased knowledge. The program offering is developed in collaboration
with the business community. USN has extensive experience in development of supporting tools –
guidelines, scaling up of good practices, creating a platform for policy dialogue to advance regional
research.
46
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
The Faculty of Health Sciences develops programs for person-centered and multidisciplinary
healthcare with a special focus on primary health care and through digital transformation, which is
enabled through the Science Centre for Health and Technology (Science Centre), a cross-faculty and
interdisciplinary research centre, hosted by HS. The Science Centre has already established itself as an
internationally and regionally preferred partner in the field of (e)health innovation and
communication research. It has a real multidisciplinary approach with members coming from different
disciplines within health services research. The Science Centre is actively involved in the region, serving
as an innovation partner for municipalities, hospitals, small and medium enterprises, and third sector
organisations. In addition, the Science Centre educates for person-centred innovation at the
intersection of healthcare, digitalisation and technology. The Center's interdisciplinary educational
program brings research into practice, and conversely, brings practice into research. The Centre has
facilities for testing and simulations of new models of collaboration and service delivery in addition to
training facilities for students and practitioners. The Science Centre cooperates with national and
international researchers and actors in the primary and specialist health services around research on
health services and clinical health care.
PoliS-Lombardia
PoliS-Lombardia is an agency that supports the policy setting process of the Lombardy region. It
provides support for integrated education, training and work policies, in line with the objectives set by
the Directorate-General responsible for education, training and work. It is in charge of the training
course for general practitioners (GPs), hospital medical unit directors and hospital general managers.
It also provides continuing education for the healthcare workforce for the regional government
(approximately 80 events per year for 3000 participants). PoliS-Lombardia is doing research activities
with the aim of providing scientific support for the definition, implementation, evaluation and
monitoring of regional policies. PoliS-Lombardia has substantial experience in the training of
healthcare professionals and it is deeply connected to regional and national professional associations
Orders, Universities and primary and secondary care.
2.8.5. Capacity of the staff
Semmelweis University
The Team of Semmelweis University in the TaSHI project will be composed of at least seven experts.
The team of the “Human Resources for Health Development Knowledge Centre” of HSMTC has been
participating in projects collecting, analysing and reporting HRH-related data for more than twenty
years. In addition to research, our institute is consulting with health policy makers in different levels in
supporting and planning actions for HWF development and policy. Most members of the team are
currently involved in the SEPEN activities of communication and dissemination, which ensures
experience in implementing EU funded projects in the specific topic of HWF.
Two senior experts, who are highly experienced in the field of HWF research, managing planning and
forecasting projects, and have many years of experience in EU level project design and
implementation. They will act as project leader and scientific leader of TaSHI.
The team will involve furthermore two full time researcher colleagues, one communication expert and
one communication assistant, one project coordinator, and one financial officer. The communication
expert is leading currently all external communication and dissemination processes of our institute in
different projects, and has many years of experience in the PR field and has a communication team.
The Italian National Agency for Regional Healthcare Services
The AGENAS Team involved in TaSHI, is composed of an expert collaborator and 2 full time permanent
employees under the direction of a head of Research and International relations Department office.
47
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
The expert collaborator is a senior project manager, with experience on health care projects at
regional, national, EU level and a specific expertise in health care organization and HWF planning and
management.
The Chief of the office is a Medical Director with a strong experience in Epidemiology of infectious
diseases, Emerging infections and revisioning and monitoring of clinical networks and organizational
development.
Competences of the team dedicated to the Joint Action include long-standing experience in the area
of EU and national projects, commitment to enhancing international cooperation and exchanging best
practices, research abilities, proficient command of writing and translation in English and other
European languages (French, Spanish, German, Portuguese). Specific studies and working experiences
include both national and international relations and economics and organization of governmental
agencies and enterprises.
Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research
The head of the project at NIVEL is a leading PhD researcher and Professor in Health Workforce and
Organisation Studies at the Radboud University Nijmegen. He will lead WP3. He was coordinator of the
EU project ‘Core Competences of Healthcare Assistants in Europe’ (CC4HCA) in 2015-2016, active
member of the SEPEN network and (formerly) the Joint Action on European Health Workforce Planning
and Forecasting on behalf of the Netherlands. He worked as a scientific consultant for WHO on the
development of the National Health Workforce Accounts (NHWA). Currently he is president of the
Special Interest Group (SIG) on the Health Workforce of the European Health Management Association
(EHMA), and vice-president of the European Public Health Association section (EUPHA) on Health
Workforce Research. At NIVEL, he coordinates the development, application and governance of the
mathematical HWF planning model for physicians, paramedics and specialized nurses. He is an editorial
member of several national and international journals and authored more than 100 papers and reports
on health policy, systems, organisation and workforce.
The Ministry of Health of the Republic of Lithuania
Project leader – Advisor to the Minister of Health of the Republic of Lithuania.
Senior expert A – Assistant to the Minister of Health of the Republic of Lithuania. The Assistant works
with healthcare workforce planning and forecasting topics. Also, she was working in project No. 08.4.2-
ESFA-V-617-01-0001 and was participating in project No. 10.1.2-ESFA-V-916-01-0013, and was working
with the Government Strategic Analysis Center on creating the Model for Forecasting the Demand of
HWF in 2018. As well, she attended SEPEN workshops in Hungary and Belgium, and coordinated
collaboration between the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Lithuania and SEPEN.
Senior expert B – General practitioner who works at the Hospital of Lithuanian University of Health
Sciences.
Senior expert C - Psychiatrist who works at the Hospital of Lithuanian University of Health Sciences.
Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs
There are two staff members of the Ministry contributing directly to this project. Head of HSDD is an
acknowledged health policy expert who has 20+ years of experience in the sector. In this project he
will mainly act as an advisor on planning the country's task-shifting case. A senior specialist of the same
department who is coordinating HWF policy in the Ministry has over 10 years of experience in the field
of health care policy. He has worked as health policy analyst and policy designer, including in
collaborations focusing on Estonian HWF policy. His main role in this project will be coordinating
48
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
communication with international team and Estonian partners and coordinating implementation of
local task-shifting cases.
The key staff members will be supported by other specialists and advisers of the same department (e.g
coordinators of primary care, health insurance policy etc), and colleagues from the Smart Development
Department (responsible for e-health developments).
University of South-Eastern Norway
The key team from University of South-Eastern Norway will be lead by a professor of Faculty of Health
and Social Sciences, who covers areas of expertise in person-centred communication, how welfare-
technology and e-Health can improve healthcare and patient care (including task shifting and new ways
of service delivery), and innovation and implementation as well as transformation of services in digital
wound care. Other members bring extensive research in person-centred care, co-creating healthcare
and digital transformation of healthcare, as well as healthcare management and leadership. Further,
expertise and development of curricula in radiography, radiological services in rural areas, as well as
extensive expertise in advanced clinical nursing, development of the nursing profession and task
shifting processes in radiology. In addition to international collaborations, the team collaborates within
a broad regional ecosystem for health innovation and health services research, such as Municipalities,
Regional Councils and Networks of Municipalities, The Regional Hospital Trusts, Local Hospitals, Local
Medical Centre, Local Companies and Chambers of Commerce and Industry, User and Patient
Organizations and Professional Associations, and Research Council of Norway.
PoliS Lombardia
Director of Academia (PoliS-Lombardia)
The director is in charge of the three-year full-time training course for general practitioners (GPs) which
involves the participation of approximately 700 trainees per year, along with the training for directors
of hospital medical units (four-month training), and hospital general managers (six-months training).
He is also in charge of the strategic continuing education for healthcare workforce for the regional
government (approximately 80 events per year attended by 3000 participants). His decennial
experience in education and regional politics is crucial in the process of reviewing the regional primary
healthcare system.
Fellow of Academia
The fellow is in charge of a project regarding task-shifting in primary healthcare in the Lombardy
region. Her qualifications include a background in biotechnology, a PhD in bioethics, and experience in
clinical ethics consultation. Her cross-cutting experience in the medical field helped her gain
perspective regarding the needs of the healthcare workforce.
2.8.6. Financial management
The Coordinator will appoint a part time financial officer to be in charge of the financial management
of TaSHI. This officer will be responsible for TaSHI financial reporting and budgetary issues, and will
support associated partners in the preparation of their institutions’ reports. Each partner will, in turn,
provide a contact person to liaise with the financial officer for all financial matters. In addition, the
financial management will be included always as a point in the agenda of all TaSHI Executive Board
meetings.
The required Interim and Final Financial Reports will serve as a base for the Coordinator and WP
leaders to have an overview of the budget and expenditure on a regular basis. The Financial officer will
also collect data on expenditures and working time contributions by WP, and partners within them,
49
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
every six months. These data will be returned to WP leaders for adjustment of their activities, plans
and budget distributions, as appropriate, adjustments that will be agreed with the governing bodies.
There is double control, as the Coordinator monitors the budget execution both by WP and by
individual partners. Detailed financial rules will be included in the consortium agreement as standard
operation procedures to be agreed among the partners.
2.9. Budget
2.9.1. Content description and justification
The consortium of the project is composed of 1 partner as coordinator plus 6 other partners. After the
definition and agreement on objectives, purpose and deliverables of horizontal and core WPs and their
corresponding tasks, participants indicated their skills and desired contributions to the different tasks,
and the corresponding number of PMs they could allocate to the project over its entire duration.
Budget distribution in terms of percentage is 90.37% for personnel costs and 3.08% for other direct
costs, (including travels and subsistence and other goods and services). The remaining 6.54% are for
the indirect costs, calculated, as per CHAFEA rules, to be 7% of the direct costs.
When calculating the other direct costs, the consortium preferred to use mainly online communication
channels, it is the reason for its low share of the total costs.
The status of PoliS-Lombardia is unique in the TaSHI project, as they requested no EU contribution for
their participation, and they resigned their share, which were distributed among partners. Not all the
beneficiaries have the same division of national and EU contribution, as PoliS-Lombardia resigned of
its EU contribution, so the share of other partners has been increased to 66 % EU contribution.
50
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
2.9.2. Detailed budget
Applicant No. & Short Name 1. SU
(If affiliated entity: Affiliated to
which Applicant number/Short
name)
(A) Direct personnel costs
Staff function Monthly Cost Estimated Sum Cost (€)
Person-month
project manager WP1 3600 15,1 54356,4
financial officer WP1 3200 5,0 16000
communication expert WP2 3600 18,54 66744
researcher WP3 3600 0,78 2804,4
researcher WP4 3600 7,73 27820,8
researcher WP5 3600 3,09 11106
Total person Total Costs (€) for
month (A)
50,23 178 832
Justification
WP1 and WP2 leader; WP3, WP4 and WP5 participant
(B) Direct costs of sub- Costs (€) Task(s)/Justification
contracting
Total Costs (€) of (B)
(C) Other direct costs
(C.1) Travel Costs (€) Justification
3000 Travel to kick-off in Brussels and closing
conference in Rome.
(C.2) Equipment Costs (€) Justification
51
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
(C.3) Other goods and services Costs (€) Justification
1500 Dissemination materials - website, printed
materials, publication costs.
Total Costs (€) of (C) 4500
(D) Indirect Costs Total Costs (€)
(Max. 7% on A, B and C) 12 833,24
Total estimated eligible costs 196 165,24
Applicant No. & Short Name 2. Agenas
(If affiliated entity: Affiliated to
which Applicant number/Short
name)
(A) Direct personnel costs
Staff function Monthly Cost Estimated Sum Cost (€)
Person-month
Project Manager 5194 2,34 12133,18
Medical Doctor 11869 4,41 52342,29
Administrative staff 2645 0,4 1058
Researcher 4274 2,0 8548
Total person Total Costs (€) for
month (A)
9,15 74 081
Justification
Project manager will coordinate all AGENAS activities
Medical Doctor will be in charge of coordinate AGENAS scientific
activities especially regarding WP4 supported by the Researcher
Administrative staff will care monitoring AGENAS expeditures
and financial reporting
Researcher will support the Medical doctor in the coordination of
AGENAS scientific activities
(B) Direct costs of sub- Task(s)/Justification
contracting
52
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Total Costs (€) of (B)
(C) Other direct costs
(C.1) Travel Costs (€) Justification
500 Travel to kick-off in Brussels and closing
conference in Rome
1000 WP5 travels
(C.2) Equipment Costs (€) Justification
(C.3) Other goods and services Costs (€) Justification
Total Costs (€) of (C) 1500
(D) Indirect Costs Total Costs (€)
(Max. 7% on A, B and C) 5 290,67
Total estimated eligible costs 80 871,67
Applicant No. & Short Name 3. NIVEL
(If affiliated entity: Affiliated to
which Applicant number/Short
name)
(A) Direct personnel costs
Staff function Monthly Cost Estimated Sum Cost (€)
Person-month
Senior researcher and 8200 6,87 56317,6
coordinator
Senior researcher 8000 4,63 37024
Mid level researcher 6800 1,71 11634,8
Total person Total Costs (€) for
month (A)
13,21 104 976
Justification
Leading WP3, co-leading WP4 and WP5 and contributing to the
other WPs. Senior staff takes supervisory and coordinating role.
53
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Mid-level researchers responsible for carrying out work along set
lines and directing junior staff in their work.
(B) Direct costs of sub- Task(s)/Justification
contracting
Total Costs (€) of (B)
(C) Other direct costs
(C.1) Travel Costs (€) Justification
3000 Travel to kick-off in Brussels and closing
conference in Rome.
200 WP5 travels
(C.2) Equipment Costs (€) Justification
(C.3) Other goods and services Costs (€) Justification
Total Costs (€) of (C) 3200
(D) Indirect Costs Total Costs (€)
(Max. 7% on A, B and C) 7 572,32
Total estimated eligible costs 115 748,32
Applicant No. & Short Name 4. MOH LT
(If affiliated entity: Affiliated to
which Applicant number/Short
name)
(A) Direct personnel costs
Staff function Monthly Cost Estimated Sum Cost (€)
Person-month
researcher WP1 3453 0,78 2686,89
researcher WP2 3453 0,46 1602,19
researcher WP3 3453 0,78 2689,89
researcher WP5 3453 11,59 40027,18
54
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Total person Total Costs (€) for
month (A)
13,61 47 009
Justification
Detailed staff effort per WP
(B) Direct costs of sub- Costs (€) Task(s)/Justification
contracting
Total Costs (€) of (B)
(C) Other direct costs
(C.1) Travel Costs (€) Justification
3000 Travel to kick-off in Brussels and closing
conference in Rome.
200 WP5 travels
(C.2) Equipment Costs (€) Justification
(C.3) Other goods and services Costs (€) Justification
Total Costs (€) of (C) 3200
(D) Indirect Costs Total Costs (€)
(Max. 7% on A, B and C) 3 514,63
Total estimated eligible costs 53 723,63
55
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Applicant No. & Short Name 5. SM EE
(If affiliated entity: Affiliated to
which Applicant number/Short
name)
(A) Direct personnel costs
Staff function Monthly Cost Estimated Sum Cost (€)
Person-month
researcher WP1 3410 0,78 2656,39
researcher WP2 3410 0,46 1582,24
researcher WP3 3410 0,78 2656,39
researcher WP5 3410 8,51 29008,87
Total person Total Costs (€) for
month (A)
10,53 35 904
Justification
Detailed staff effort per WP
(B) Direct costs of sub- Costs (€) Task(s)/Justification
contracting
Total Costs (€) of (B)
(C) Other direct costs
(C.1) Travel Costs (€) Justification
3000 Travel to kick-off in Brussels and closing
conference in Rome.
200 WP5 travels
(C.2) Equipment Costs (€) Justification
(C.3) Other goods and services Costs (€) Justification
Total Costs (€) of (C) 3200
(D) Indirect Costs Total Costs (€)
56
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
(Max. 7% on A, B and C) 2 737,28
Total estimated eligible costs 41 841,28
Applicant No. & Short Name 6. USN
(If affiliated entity: Affiliated to
which Applicant number/Short
name)
(A) Direct personnel costs
Staff function Monthly Cost Estimated Sum Cost (€)
Person-month
researcher WP1 7927 0,35 2742,74
researcher WP2 7927 0,21 1632,96
researcher WP3 7927 0,35 2742,74
researcher WP4 7927 6,87 54450,56
researcher WP5 7927 3,78 29971,99
Total person Total Costs (€) for
month (A)
11,55 91 541
Justification
Detailed staff effort per WP
(B) Direct costs of sub- Costs (€) Task(s)/Justification
contracting
Total Costs (€) of (B)
(C) Other direct costs
(C.1) Travel Costs (€) Justification
3000 Travel to kick-off in Brussels and closing
conference in Rome
200 WP5 travels
57
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
(C.2) Equipment Costs (€) Justification
(C.3) Other goods and services Costs (€) Justification
500 E-education materials, online tools for material
development.
Total Costs (€) of (C) 3700
(D) Indirect Costs Total Costs (€)
(Max. 7% on A, B and C) 6 666,87
Total estimated eligible costs 101 907,87
Applicant No. & Short Name 7. PoliS-Lombardia
(If affiliated entity: Affiliated to
which Applicant number/Short
name)
(A) Direct personnel costs
Staff function Monthly Cost Estimated Sum Cost (€)
Person-month
researcher WP1 8100 0,35 2802,6
researcher WP2 8100 0,21 1668,6
researcher WP3 8100 0,35 2802,6
researcher WP4 8100 2,06 16718,4
researcher WP5 8100 3,78 30626,1
Total person Total Costs (€) for
month (A)
6,74 54 618
Justification
Detailed staff effort per WP
(B) Direct costs of sub- Costs (€) Task(s)/Justification
contracting
Total Costs (€) of (B)
58
TaSHI - proposal No. 101018346
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
(C) Other direct costs
(C.1) Travel Costs (€) Justification
500 Travel to kick-off in Brussels and closing
conference in Rome.
200 WP5 travels
(C.2) Equipment Costs (€) Justification
(C.3) Other goods and services Costs (€) Justification
Total Costs (€) of (C) 700
(D) Indirect Costs Total Costs (€)
(Max. 7% on A, B and C) 3 872,26
Total estimated eligible costs 59 190,26
59
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI — HP-PJ-2020-2
ESTIMATED BUDGET FOR THE ACTION Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Estimated eligible1 costs (per budget category) EU contribution Action's estimated receipts
Financial
B. Direct D. Indirect Reimbursement Maximum EU Maximum Income contributions
A. Direct C. Other Action’s
costs of Total costs generated given by third
personnel costs direct costs costs2 rate %3 contribution4 grant amount5 total receipts
subcontracting by the action parties to the
beneficiaries
A.1 Employees C.1 Travel
(or equivalent)
C.2 Equipment
A.2 Natural
persons under C.3 Other goods
direct contract and services
and seconded
persons
Cost form6 Actual Actual Actual Flat-rate7 7%
d=
a b c e = a+b+c+d f g=e*f h i j k=i+j
0.07 * (a+b+c)
1. SU 178 832.00 0.00 4 500.00 12 833.24 196 165.24 60.00 117 699.14 129 567.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
2. AGE.NA.S 74 081.00 0.00 1 500.00 5 290.67 80 871.67 60.00 48 523.00 53 375.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
3. NIVEL 104 976.00 0.00 3 200.00 7 572.32 115 748.32 60.00 69 448.99 76 394.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
4. MOH-LT 47 009.00 0.00 3 200.00 3 514.63 53 723.63 60.00 32 234.18 35 458.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
5. SM-EE 35 904.00 0.00 3 200.00 2 737.28 41 841.28 60.00 25 104.77 27 615.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
6. USN 91 541.00 0.00 3 700.00 6 666.87 101 907.87 60.00 61 144.72 67 258.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
7. PoliS-
54 618.00 0.00 700.00 3 872.26 59 190.26 60.00 35 514.16 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Lombardia
Σ consortium 586 961.00 0.00 20 000.00 42 487.27 649 448.27 60.007 389 668.96 389 668.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1 See Article 6 for the eligibility conditions.
2 The indirect costs claimed must be free of any amounts covered by an operating grant (received under any EU or Euratom funding programme). A beneficiary that receives an operating grant during the action's duration
cannot claim any indirect costs for the year(s)/reporting period(s) covered by the operating grant (see Article 6.2.D).
3 See Article 5.2 for the reimbursement rate.
4 This is the theoretical amount of the EU contribution, if the reimbursement rate is applied to all the budgeted costs. This theoretical amount is capped by the 'maximum grant amount'.
5 The 'maximum grant amount' is the maximum grant amount decided by the Agency. It normally corresponds to the requested grant, but may be lower.
6 See Article 5 for the cost forms.
7 Flat rate : 7% of eligible direct costs.
Page 1 of 1
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
ANNEX 3
ACCESSION FORM FOR BENEFICIARIES
AGENZIA NAZIONALE PER I SERVIZI SANITARI REGIONALI (AGE.NA.S), established
in VIA PUGLIE 23, ROMA 00187, Italy, (‘the beneficiary’), represented for the purpose of signing
this Accession Form by the undersigned,
hereby agrees
to become beneficiary No (‘2’)
in Grant Agreement No 101018346 (‘the Grant Agreement’)
between SEMMELWEIS EGYETEM and the Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive
Agency (CHAFEA) ('the Agency'), under the powers delegated by the European Commission ('the
Commission'),
for the action entitled Empowering EU health policies on Task SHIfting (TaSHI).
and mandates
the coordinator to submit and sign in its name and on its behalf any amendments to the Agreement,
in accordance with Article 39.
By signing this Accession Form, the beneficiary accepts the grant and agrees to implement it in
accordance with the Agreement, with all the obligations and conditions it sets out.
SIGNATURE
For the beneficiary/new beneficiary/new coordinator
[--TGSMark#signature-959886490_75_210--]
Giovanni Baglio with ECAS id n005dqdx signed in the Participant
Portal on 26/02/2021 at 12:14:02 (transaction id SigId-84688-xmXL
NSuIMVC1pbxXQ9MPBO6Izt8CethQlbe9V9ggsNfhHwu9NZfMvp2k5
Thn8ci5QsXiJW6Ep4u2cxuHVwTCMO-rS0vSrmBGYCg3FMBs87Zim-g
8lVzJgIjkl0PYmxnHBkYRBVrTqPVJWtSg5UHOBzcybG7YEJHRV2xKqlco
PIzfFLmgZ84zWDcTn9p4eI0ypgXa0). Timestamp by third party at
2021.02.26 12:14:08 CET
1
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
ANNEX 3
ACCESSION FORM FOR BENEFICIARIES
STICHTING NEDERLANDS INSTITUUT VOOR ONDERZOEK VAN DE
GEZONDHEIDSZORG (NIVEL), established in OTTERSTRAAT 118-124, UTRECHT 3500 BN,
Netherlands, VAT number: NL007077191B01, (‘the beneficiary’), represented for the purpose of
signing this Accession Form by the undersigned,
hereby agrees
to become beneficiary No (‘3’)
in Grant Agreement No 101018346 (‘the Grant Agreement’)
between SEMMELWEIS EGYETEM and the Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive
Agency (CHAFEA) ('the Agency'), under the powers delegated by the European Commission ('the
Commission'),
for the action entitled Empowering EU health policies on Task SHIfting (TaSHI).
and mandates
the coordinator to submit and sign in its name and on its behalf any amendments to the Agreement,
in accordance with Article 39.
By signing this Accession Form, the beneficiary accepts the grant and agrees to implement it in
accordance with the Agreement, with all the obligations and conditions it sets out.
SIGNATURE
For the beneficiary/new beneficiary/new coordinator
[--TGSMark#signature-998294125_75_210--]
Cordula WAGNER with ECAS id nwagncor signed in the Participant
Portal on 01/03/2021 at 09:37:30 (transaction id SigId-92574-XEgcA
GOztzn7Q3lQM9QelWItnRVROEbOl0iC3nSJJryIjLQBzwR3vDoKzl7Xq
LcqjnH2RrdpnedcIJH81wrMRnK-rS0vSrmBGYCg3FMBs87Zim-8mq
89bzUtgwN4mlxsHlIUNmADtZo90dueNgO5pJPMF67DlLqhu16JKpr
zH1NAii2YVLTkFrzbzJtczw9JVF36nR). Timestamp by third party at
2021.03.01 09:37:36 CET
2
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
ANNEX 3
ACCESSION FORM FOR BENEFICIARIES
LIETUVOS RESPUBLIKOS SVEIKATOS APSAUGOS MINISTERIJA (MOH-LT),
established in VILNIAUS G 33, VILNIUS LT 01506, Lithuania, (‘the beneficiary’), represented for
the purpose of signing this Accession Form by the undersigned,
hereby agrees
to become beneficiary No (‘4’)
in Grant Agreement No 101018346 (‘the Grant Agreement’)
between SEMMELWEIS EGYETEM and the Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive
Agency (CHAFEA) ('the Agency'), under the powers delegated by the European Commission ('the
Commission'),
for the action entitled Empowering EU health policies on Task SHIfting (TaSHI).
and mandates
the coordinator to submit and sign in its name and on its behalf any amendments to the Agreement,
in accordance with Article 39.
By signing this Accession Form, the beneficiary accepts the grant and agrees to implement it in
accordance with the Agreement, with all the obligations and conditions it sets out.
SIGNATURE
For the beneficiary/new beneficiary/new coordinator
[--TGSMark#signature-933839468_75_210--]
Marius Ciurlionis with ECAS id n005qy0i signed in the Participant
Portal on 17/03/2021 at 07:17:55 (transaction id SigId-33582-0EMY9j
HS1sQRyDrYp1bhkhMCzYhCgCOHRQp5ZfaTqQswDRIztHK14TdB8SS
uK7Wfd51EzspUSkcXrW37Xc8Mf5m-jpJZscgsw0KR3zhT7zb0ozG-vH7
GstiDznHzcFVgxDzsxMaLzW1K0NfzpoSPuCyHRdFIBwUhX8fmsxw8l1
Bvos6P6lEk6gUNc0xOPzVEQY0MAdd0). Timestamp by third party at
2021.03.17 07:18:04 CET
3
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
ANNEX 3
ACCESSION FORM FOR BENEFICIARIES
SOTSIAALMINISTEERIUM (SM-EE), established in Suur-Ameerika 1, TALLINN 10122,
Estonia, (‘the beneficiary’), represented for the purpose of signing this Accession Form by the
undersigned,
hereby agrees
to become beneficiary No (‘5’)
in Grant Agreement No 101018346 (‘the Grant Agreement’)
between SEMMELWEIS EGYETEM and the Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive
Agency (CHAFEA) ('the Agency'), under the powers delegated by the European Commission ('the
Commission'),
for the action entitled Empowering EU health policies on Task SHIfting (TaSHI).
and mandates
the coordinator to submit and sign in its name and on its behalf any amendments to the Agreement,
in accordance with Article 39.
By signing this Accession Form, the beneficiary accepts the grant and agrees to implement it in
accordance with the Agreement, with all the obligations and conditions it sets out.
SIGNATURE
For the beneficiary/new beneficiary/new coordinator
[--TGSMark#signature-998429731_75_210--]
Marika PRISKE with ECAS id nprmaika signed in the Participant
Portal on 18/03/2021 at 10:48:16 (transaction id SigId-48736-8aMY4
xaG4yyx2vMrWTqfg5bAbrvTznzQ4YGm4oxlTuvsEoxlb70ErznWMiI6
1IzVvF0iXAdo4FW0SguLID99vPq-jpJZscgsw0KR3zhT7zb0ozG-LfDNJr
q5jTXcmYnSn1kH8VRXzKzormsnhfuRxn3WMFzu5F3TShGgNfrO0RF
bPYqzPXZhgAPcxf6wdeWn9upZzzxm). Timestamp by third party at
2021.03.18 10:48:26 CET
4
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
ANNEX 3
ACCESSION FORM FOR BENEFICIARIES
UNIVERSITETET I SOROST-NORGE (USN), established in KJOLNES RING 56,
PORSGRUNN 3918, Norway, VAT number: NO911770709MVA, (‘the beneficiary’), represented for
the purpose of signing this Accession Form by the undersigned,
hereby agrees
to become beneficiary No (‘6’)
in Grant Agreement No 101018346 (‘the Grant Agreement’)
between SEMMELWEIS EGYETEM and the Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive
Agency (CHAFEA) ('the Agency'), under the powers delegated by the European Commission ('the
Commission'),
for the action entitled Empowering EU health policies on Task SHIfting (TaSHI).
and mandates
the coordinator to submit and sign in its name and on its behalf any amendments to the Agreement,
in accordance with Article 39.
By signing this Accession Form, the beneficiary accepts the grant and agrees to implement it in
accordance with the Agreement, with all the obligations and conditions it sets out.
SIGNATURE
For the beneficiary/new beneficiary/new coordinator
[--TGSMark#signature-921767430_75_210--]
Pia Cecilie Bing-Jonsson with ECAS id n003s65q signed in the
Participant Portal on 26/02/2021 at 12:34:53 (transaction id SigId-
85065-gVsZzt4CZ66gQmCllLu6Avq5HR0QKvv8VzLbYpnO2lKSXvRy3gyh
qPZf6aOUrMVGGBW2yht4p1xusB6EmlH7pu-
rS0vSrmBGYCg3FMBs87Zim-VOfLsUIK3kLw9wgjXbKXedgXhEU5f31qxF
RIMPj2hvcr7SYkqSRrc7O78izNT94Pkq4F5Np0RNBAZYywWMLOQu).
Timestamp by third party at
2021.02.26 12:34:59 CET
5
Grant Agreement number: 101018346 — TaSHI
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
ANNEX 3
ACCESSION FORM FOR BENEFICIARIES
ISTITUTO REGIONALE PER IL SUPPORTOALLAE POLITICHE DELLA LOMBARDIA
(POLIS-LOMBARDIA) (PoliS-Lombardia), established in VIA TORQUATO TARAMELLI 12/F,
MILANO 20124, Italy, VAT number: IT07221390961, (‘the beneficiary’), represented for the purpose
of signing this Accession Form by the undersigned,
hereby agrees
to become beneficiary No (‘7’)
in Grant Agreement No 101018346 (‘the Grant Agreement’)
between SEMMELWEIS EGYETEM and the Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive
Agency (CHAFEA) ('the Agency'), under the powers delegated by the European Commission ('the
Commission'),
for the action entitled Empowering EU health policies on Task SHIfting (TaSHI).
and mandates
the coordinator to submit and sign in its name and on its behalf any amendments to the Agreement,
in accordance with Article 39.
By signing this Accession Form, the beneficiary accepts the grant and agrees to implement it in
accordance with the Agreement, with all the obligations and conditions it sets out.
SIGNATURE
For the beneficiary/new beneficiary/new coordinator
[--TGSMark#signature-906213480_75_210--]
Alessandro Colombo with ECAS id n005epmx signed in the Participant
Portal on 03/03/2021 at 15:09:48 (transaction id SigId-122571-9JmkllV
p7zPIC0yWyliDJHVbLTGkzMMLK41rBCYgHJEVXIGzQFv3MxDlt5NmkTk7
mx584Pd5ZyEJ4QTSfVjmzg4-rS0vSrmBGYCg3FMBs87Zim-F1DkKa30A4
atdzwFYdKeW9C0zzNfGfbC35QgyN0yBzyQPsGVi2kCNCMbgzgzs2bdm
kIEE9zy2ngrzQ9FKn1CzYzWW). Timestamp by third party at
2021.03.03 15:09:53 CET
6
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
i print format A4
MODEL ANNEX 4 CHAFEA MGA — MULTI
landscape
FINANCIAL STATEMENT FOR [BENEFICIARY [name]/AFFILIATED ENTITY [name]] FOR REPORTING PERIOD [reporting period]
1 Receipts EU contribution
Eligible costs (per budget category)
Financial
contributions Reimburseme Maximum EU
A. Direct personnel B. Direct costs of C. Other direct 2 Income generated Requested EU
D. Indirect costs Total costs given by third Total receipts 3 4
costs subcontracting costs by the action nt rate % constribution contribution
parties to the
beneficiaries
A.1 Employees (or
C.1 Travel
equivalent)
A.2 Natural persons
C.2 Equipment
under direct contract
and seconded persons
C.3 Other goods and
services
6
5 Actual Actual Actual Flat-rate
Cost form
7%
d= e=
a b c f g h= f + g i j k
0,07 * (a + b + c) a+ b + c + d
[short name beneficiary
/ affiliated entity]
The beneficiary/affiliated entity hereby confirms that:
The information provided is complete, reliable and true.
The costs declared are eligible (see Article 6).
The costs can be substantiated by adequate records and supporting documentation that will be produced upon request or in the context of checks, reviews, audits and investigations (see Articles 12, 13 and 17).
For the last reporting period: that all the receipts have been declared (see Article 5.3.3).
i Please declare all eligible costs, even if they exceed the amounts indicated in the estimated budget (see Annex 2). Only amounts that were declared in your individual financial
statements can be taken into account lateron, in order to replace other costs that are found to be ineligible.
1
See Article 6 for the eligibility conditions.
2
The indirect costs claimed must be free of any amounts covered by an operating grant (received under any EU or Euratom funding programme). A beneficiary that receives an operating grant during the duration of the action cannot
claim any indirect costs for the year(s) covered by the operating grant (see Article 6.2.D).
3
See Article 5.2 for the reimbursement rate
4
This is the theoretical amount of EU contribution that the system calculates automatically (by multiplying the reimbursement rate by the total costs declared). The amount you request (in the column 'requested EU contribution') may
have to be less.
5
See Article 5 for the cost forms.
6
Flat rate : 7% of eligible direct costs.
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
ANNEX 5
MODEL FOR THE CERTIFICATE ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENT (CFS)
This document sets out:
- the objectives and scope of the independent report of factual findings on costs declared
under a EU grant agreement financed under the Health Programme (2014-2020) or
Consumer Programme (2014-2020) and
- a model for the certificate on the financial statement (CFS).
1. Background and subject matter
[OPTION 1 for actions with one RP and NO interim payments: Within 60 days of the end of
the reporting period, the coordinator must submit to the Commission a final report, which
should include (among other documents and unless otherwise specified in Article 15 of the
Grant Agreement) a certified financial statement (CFS; see proposed model below) for each
beneficiary and (if applicable) each affiliated entity, if:
- it requests an EU contribution of EUR 150 000 or more as reimbursement of actual
costs and
- the maximum EU contribution indicated for that beneficiary/affiliated entity in the
estimated budget (see Annex 2) as reimbursement of actual costs is EUR 200 000 or
more.]
[OPTION 2 for actions with several RPs and interim payments: Within 60 days of the end
of each reporting period, the coordinator must submit to the Commission a periodic report,
which should include (among other documents and unless otherwise specified in Article 15 of
the Grant Agreement) a certified financial statement (CFS; see proposed model below) for
each beneficiary and (if applicable) each affiliated entity, if:
- the cumulative amount of EU contribution the beneficiary/affiliated entity requests as
reimbursement of actual costs is EUR 150 000 or more and
- the maximum EU contribution indicated for that beneficiary/affiliated entity in the
estimated budget (see Annex 2) as reimbursement of actual costs is EUR 200 000 or
more.
The CFS must be submitted every time the cumulative amount of payments requested (i.e.
including in previous financial statements) reaches the threshold (i.e. a first certificate once
the cumulative amount reaches 150 000, a second certificate once it reaches 300 000, a third
certificate once it reaches 450 000, etc.).
Once the threshold is reached, the CFS must cover all reporting periods for which no
certificate has yet been submitted.]
1
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
The beneficiary must provide the CFS for itself and, if applicable, for its affiliated entity(ies).
The purpose of the audit on which the CFS is based is to give the Agency ‘reasonable
assurance’1 that costs declared as eligible costs under the grant (and, if relevant, receipts
generated in the course of the action) are being claimed by the beneficiary in accordance with
the relevant legal and financial provisions of the Grant Agreement.
The scope of the audit is limited to the verification of eligible costs included in the CFS. The
audit must be conducted in line with point 3 below.
Certifying auditors must carry out the audits in compliance with generally accepted audit
standards and indicate which standards they have applied. They must bear in mind that, to
establish a CFS, they must carry out a compliance audit and not a normal statutory audit. The
eligibility criteria in the Grant Agreement always override normal accounting practices.
The beneficiary and the auditor are expected to address any questions on factual data or
detailed calculations before the financial statement and the accompanying certificate are
submitted. It is also recommended that the beneficiary take into account the auditor’s
preliminary comments and suggestions in order to avoid a qualified opinion or reduce the
scope of the qualifications.
Since the certificate is the main source of assurance for cost claims and payments, it will be
easier to consider amounts as eligible if a non-qualified certificate is provided.
The submission of a certificate does not affect the Agency’s right to carry out its own
assessment or audits. Neither does the reimbursement of costs covered by a certificate
preclude the Agency or the Commission, the European Anti-Fraud Office or the European
Court of Auditors from carrying out checks, reviews, audits and investigations in accordance
with Article 17 of the Grant Agreement.
The Agency expects the certificates to be issued by auditors according to the highest
professional standards.
2. Auditors who may deliver a certificate
The beneficiary is free to choose a qualified external auditor, including its usual external
auditor, provided that:
- the external auditor is independent from the beneficiary and
- the provisions of Directive 2006/43/EC2 are complied with.
1
This means a high degree of confidence.
2
Directive 2006/43/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 May 2006 on statutory audits of
annual accounts and consolidated accounts or similar national regulations (OJ L 157, 9.6.2006, p. 87).
2
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Independence is one of the qualities that permit the auditor to apply unbiased judgement and
objective consideration to established facts to arrive at an opinion or a decision. It also means
that the auditor works without direction or interference of any kind from the beneficiary.
Auditors are considered as providing services to the beneficiary/affiliated entity under a
purchase contract within the meaning of Article 9 of the Grant Agreement. This means that
the costs of the CFS may normally be declared as costs incurred for the action, if the cost
eligibility rules set out in Articles 6 and 9.1.1 of the Grant Agreement are fulfilled (especially:
best value for money and no conflict of interests; see also below eligibility of costs of other
goods and services). Where the beneficiary/affiliated entity uses its usual external auditor, it is
presumed that they already have an agreement that complies with these provisions and there is
no obligation to find new bids. Where the beneficiary/affiliated entity uses an external auditor
who is not their usual external auditor, it must select an auditor following the rules set out in
Article 9.1.1.
Public bodies can choose an external auditor or a competent public officer. In the latter case,
the auditor’s independence is usually defined as independence from the audited beneficiary
‘in fact and in appearance’. A preliminary condition is that this officer was not involved in
any way in drawing up the financial statements. Relevant national authorities establish the
legal capacity of the officer to carry out audits of that specific public body. The certificate
should refer to this appointment.
3. Audit methodology and expected results
3.1 Verification of eligibility of the costs declared
The auditor must conduct its verification on the basis of inquiry and analysis,
(re)computation, comparison, other accuracy checks, observation, inspection of records and
documents and by interviewing the beneficiary (and the persons working for it).
The auditor must examine the following documentation:
the Grant Agreement and any amendments to it;
the periodical and/or final report(s);
for personnel costs
o salary slips;
o time sheets;
o contracts of employment;
o other documents (e.g. personnel accounts, social security legislation, invoices,
receipts, etc.);
o proofs of payment;
for subcontracting
o the call for tender;
o tenders (if applicable);
o justification for the choice of subcontractor;
o contracts with subcontractors;
o invoices;
o declarations by the beneficiary;
o proofs of payment;
3
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
o other documents: e.g. national rules on public tendering if applicable, EU
Directives, etc.;
for travel and subsistence costs
o the beneficiary’s internal rules on travel;
o transport invoices and tickets (if applicable);
o declarations by the beneficiary;
o other documents (proofs of attendance such as minutes of meetings, reports,
etc.);
o proofs of payment;
for equipment costs
o invoices;
o delivery slips / certificates of first use;
o proofs of payment;
o depreciation method of calculation;
for costs of other goods and services
o invoices;
o proofs of payment; and
o other relevant accounting documents.
General eligibility rules
The auditor must verify that the costs declared comply with the general eligibility rules set out
in Article 6.1 of the Grant Agreement.
In particular, the costs must:
be actually incurred;
be linked to the subject of the Grant Agreement and indicated in the beneficiary's
estimated budget (i.e. the latest version of Annex 2);
be necessary to implement the action which is the subject of the grant;
be reasonable and justified, and comply with the requirements of sound financial
management, in particular as regards economy and efficiency;3
have been incurred during the action, as defined in Article 3 of the Grant Agreement
(with the exception of the invoice for the audit certificate and costs relating to the
submission of the final report);
not be covered by another EU or Euratom grant (see below ineligible costs);
be identifiable, verifiable and, in particular, recorded in the beneficiary's accounting
records and determined according to the applicable accounting standards of the
country where it is established and its usual cost-accounting practices;
comply with the requirements of applicable national laws on taxes, labour and social
security;
be in accordance with the provisions of the Grant Agreement (see, in particular,
Articles 6 and 9-11a) and
have been converted to euro at the rate laid down in Article 15.6 of the Grant
Agreement:
3
To be assessed in particular on the basis of the procurement and selection procedures for service providers.
4
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
o for beneficiaries with accounts established in a currency other than the euro:
Costs incurred in another currency must be converted into euros at the average
of the daily exchange rates published in the C series of the EU Official Journal
determined over the corresponding reporting period.
If no daily euro exchange rate is published in the EU Official Journal for the
currency in question, the rate used must be the average of the monthly
accounting rate established by the Commission and published on its website;
o for beneficiaries with accounts established in euro:
Costs incurred in another currency should be converted into euros applying the
beneficiary’s usual accounting practice.
The auditor must verify whether expenditure includes VAT and, if so, verify that the
beneficiary:
- cannot recover the VAT (this must be supported by a statement from the competent
body) and
- is not a public body acting as a public authority.
The auditor should base his/her audit approach on the confidence level following a review of
the beneficiary's internal control system. When using sampling, the auditor should indicate
and justify the sampling size.
Specific eligibility rules
In addition, the auditor must verify that the costs declared comply with the specific cost
eligibility rules set out in Article 6.2 and Articles 9.1.1, 10.1.1, 11.1.1, 11a.1.1 and 11a.2.1 of
the Grant Agreement.
Personnel costs
The auditor must verify that:
personnel costs have been charged and paid in respect of the actual time devoted by
the beneficiary’s personnel to implementing the action (justified on the basis of time
sheets or other relevant time-recording system);
personnel costs were calculated on the basis of annual gross salary, wages or fees (plus
obligatory social charges, but excluding any other costs) specified in an employment
or other type of contract, not exceeding the average rates corresponding to the
beneficiary’s usual policy on remuneration;
the work was carried out during the period of implementation of the action, as defined
in Article 3 the Grant Agreement and
the personnel costs are not covered by another EU or Euratom grant (see below
ineligible costs);
for additional remunerations: the 2 conditions set out in Article 6.2.A.1 are met (i.e.
that it is part of the beneficiary’s usual remuneration practices and is paid in a
consistent manner whenever the same kind of work or expertise is required and that
the criteria used to calculate the supplementary payments are objective and generally
applied by the beneficiary, regardless of the source of funding used);
for in-house consultants: the 3 conditions set out in Article 6.2.A.2 of the Grant
Agreement are met (i.e. that the in-house consultant works under the beneficiary’s
5
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
instructions, that the result of the work carried out belongs to the beneficiary, and that
the costs are not significantly different from those for personnel performing similar
tasks under an employment contract).
The auditor should have assurance that the management and accounting system ensures
proper allocation of the personnel costs to various activities carried out by the beneficiary and
funded by various donors.
Subcontracting costs
The auditor must verify that:
the subcontracting complies with best value for money (or lowest price) and that there
was no conflict of interests;
the subcontracting was necessary to implement the action for which the grant is
requested;
the subcontracting was provided for in Annex 1 and Annex 2 or agreed to by the
Agency at a later stage;
the subcontracting is supported by accounting documents in accordance with national
accounting law
public bodies have complied with the national rules on public procurement.
Travel and subsistence costs
The auditor must verify that travel and subsistence costs:
have been charged and paid in accordance with the beneficiary's internal rules or usual
practices;
are not covered by another EU or Euratom grant (see below ineligible costs);
were incurred for travels linked to action tasks set out in Annex 1 of the Grant
Agreement.
Equipment costs
The auditor must verify that:
the equipment is purchased, rented or leased at normal market prices;
public bodies have complied with the national rules on public procurement;
the equipment is written off, depreciation has been calculated according to the tax and
accounting rules applicable to the beneficiary and only the portion of the depreciation
corresponding to the duration of the action has been declared and
the costs are not covered by another EU or Euratom grant (see below ineligible costs).
Costs of other goods and services
The auditor must verify that:
the purchase complies with best value for money (or lowest price) and that there was
no conflict of interests;
public bodies have complied with the national rules on public procurement;
the costs are not covered by another EU or Euratom grant (see below ineligible costs).
6
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Ineligible costs
The auditor must verify that the beneficiary has not declared any costs that are ineligible
under Article 6.4 of the Grant Agreement:
costs relating to return on capital;
debt and debt service charges;
provisions for future losses or debts;
interest owed;
doubtful debts;
currency exchange losses;
bank costs charged by the beneficiary’s bank for transfers from the Agency;
excessive or reckless expenditure;
deductible VAT;
VAT incurred by a public body acting as a public authority;
costs incurred during suspension of the implementation of the action;
in-kind contributions from third parties;
costs declared under other EU or Euratom grants (including those awarded by a
Member State and financed by the EU or Euratom budget or awarded by bodies other
than the Agency for the purpose of implementing the EU or Euratom budget); in
particular, indirect costs if the beneficiary is already receiving an operating grant
financed by the EU or Euratom budget in the same period;
costs incurred for permanent staff of a national administration for activities that are
part of its normal activities (i.e. not undertaken only because of the grant);
costs incurred for staff or representatives of EU institutions, bodies or agencies.
3.2 Verification of receipts
The auditor must verify that the beneficiary has declared receipts within the meaning of
Article 5.3.3 of the Grant Agreement, i.e.:
income generated by the action (e.g. from the sale of products, services and
publications, conference fees) and
financial contributions given by third parties, specifically to be used for costs that are
eligible under the action.
3.3 Verification of the beneficiary’s accounting system
The auditor must verify that:
the accounting system (analytical or other suitable internal system) makes it possible
to identify sources of financing for the action and related expenses incurred during
the contractual period and
expenses/income under the grant have been recorded systematically using a
numbering system that distinguishes them from expenses/income for other projects.
7
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
Certificate on the financial statement (CFS)
To
[Beneficiary/affiliated entity’s full name
address]
We, [full name of the audit firm/organisation], established in [full address/city/country],
represented for signature of this audit certificate by [name and function of an authorised
representative],
hereby certify
that:
1. We have conducted an audit relating to the costs declared in the financial statement of
[name of beneficiary/affiliated entity] (the [‘beneficiary’][‘affiliated entity’]), to which
this audit certificate is attached and which is to be presented to the Consumers, Health,
Agriculture and Food Executive Agency under Grant Agreement No [insert number] —
[insert acronym], covering costs for the following reporting period(s): [insert reporting
period(s)].
2. We confirm that our audit was carried out in accordance with generally accepted
auditing standards in compliance with ethical rules and on the basis of the provisions of
the Grant Agreement and its Annexes (and in particular the audit methodology
described in Annex 5).
3. The financial statement was examined and all necessary tests of [all][[X]%] of the
supporting documentation and accounting records were carried out in order to obtain
reasonable assurance that, in our opinion and on the basis of our audit
total costs of EUR [insert number] ([insert amount in words]) are eligible, i.e.:
actual;
determined in accordance with the [beneficiary’s][affiliated entity’s]
accounting principles;
incurred during the period referred to in Article 3 of the Grant Agreement;
recorded in the [beneficiary’s][affiliated entity’s] accounts (at the date of this
audit certificate);
comply with the specific eligibility rules in Article 6.2 of the Grant Agreement;
do not contain costs that are ineligible under Article 6.4 of the Grant
Agreement, in particular:
costs relating to return on capital;
debt and debt service charges;
provisions for future losses or debts;
interest owed;
doubtful debts;
currency exchange losses;
8
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)1431961 - 23/02/2021
bank costs charged by the [beneficiary’s][affiliated entity’s] bank for
transfers from the Agency;
excessive or reckless expenditure;
deductible VAT;
VAT incurred by a public body acting as a public authority;
costs incurred during suspension of the implementation of the action;
in-kind contributions provided by third parties;
costs declared under other EU or Euratom grants (including those
awarded by a Member State and financed by the EU or Euratom budget
or awarded by bodies other than the Agency for the purpose of
implementing the EU or Euratom budget); in particular, indirect costs if
the [beneficiary][affiliated entity] is already receiving an operating
grant financed by the EU or Euratom budget in the same period;
costs incurred for permanent staff of a national administration, for
activities that are part of its normal activities (i.e. not undertaken only
because of the grant);
costs incurred for staff or representatives of EU institutions, bodies or
agencies;
[are claimed according to the euro conversion rate referred to in Article 15.6 of
the Grant Agreement;]
total receipts of EUR [insert number] ([insert amount in words]) have been declared
under Article 5.3.3 of the Grant Agreement and
the [beneficiary’s][affiliated entity’s] accounting procedures are in compliance with
the accounting rules of the state in which it is established and permit direct
reconciliation of the costs incurred for the implementation of the action covered by the
EU grant with the overall statement of accounts relating to its overall activity.
[However, our audit opinion is qualified for:
costs of EUR [insert number]
receipts of EUR [insert number]
which in our opinion do not comply with the applicable rules.]
4. We are qualified/authorised to deliver this audit certificate [(for additional information,
see appendix to this certificate)].
5. The [beneficiary][affiliated entity] paid a price of EUR [insert number]) (including VAT
of EUR [insert number]) for this audit certificate. [OPTION 1: These costs are eligible
(i.e. incurred within 60 days of the end of the action referred to in Article 3 of the Grant
Agreement) and included in the financial statement.][OPTION 2: These costs were not
included in the financial statement.]
Date, signature and stamp
9
Digitally sealed by the European Commission
Date: 2021.02.23 14:36:13 CET
This electronic receipt is a digitally signed version of the document submitted by your
organisation. Both the content of the document and a set of metadata have been digitally
sealed.
This digital signature mechanism, using a public-private key pair mechanism, uniquely
binds this eReceipt to the modules of the Funding & Tenders Portal of the European
Commission, to the transaction for which it was generated and ensures its full integrity.
Therefore a complete digitally signed trail of the transaction is available both for your
organisation and for the issuer of the eReceipt.
Any attempt to modify the content will lead to a break of the integrity of the electronic
signature, which can be verified at any time by clicking on the eReceipt validation
symbol.
More info about eReceipts can be found in the FAQ page of the Funding & Tenders
Portal.
(https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/portal/screen/support/faq)
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111