Rahandusministeerium · 10. veebruar 2023
Sisu (failidest)
Riina Sikkut Minister 10.02.2023 nr KA-JUH-13/50 Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium Annely Akkermann Minister Rahandusministeerium Lugupeetud Riina Sikkut Lugupeetud Annely Akkermann Tänan teid Eesti Energia AS ning Ørsted A/S nimel sisukate kohtumiste eest tänavu jaanuaris. Meretuuleenergia arendamine on meie ettevõtete südameasjaks ning oleme veendunud, et see aitab täita Eestile ja Euroopale olulisi varustuskindluse, rohepoliitika ning taskukohasuse eesmärke juba nähtavas tulevikus. Käesoleva kirja manuses leiate lisatuna ülevaate meie ühistest ettepanekutest ning selgitused eelviidatud kohtumistel käsitletud teemade osas. Oleme valmis jätkama diskussiooni taastuvenergia kiireks arenguks vajaliku kriitilise raamistiku teemal. Eesti poolt seatud taastuva elektrienergia eesmärk 2030. aastaks annab sobiva aluse viia Eesti energiasektori areng uuele tasemele. Loodame teile abiks olla ühistes jõupingutustes selle teetähise saavutamisel. Lugupidamisega (digitaalselt allkirjastatud) Hando Sutter j uhatuse esimees Eesti Energia AS Koopia: Alana Kühne a sepresident Ørsted A/S L isa : E esti Energia / Ørsted Joint Position Paper on Offshore Wind in Estonia ( ingl.k ; 4 lk.)
Joint Position Paper on Offshore Wind in Estonia By the end of 2022 , Estonian consumers had paid 830 million euros more for power than they did in 2021. This is because Estonian power prices are largely defined by fossil fuels and not by renewable energy sources . By the end of 2022 , Estonian consumers will have paid 830 million euros more for power th a n they did in 2021 . T his calculation is based on an estimated annual consumption of 8 TWh in 2022 . To put this into context, 830 million euros could finance one third of the investment needed for a 1,000 MW offshore windfarm – the intended size Liivi Offshore project being developed by Enefit . These high and volatile power prices have been determined by fossil fuel energy carriers such as imported natural gas and liquified natural gas (LNG). In 2021, CO2 and natural gas prices rose so much that power prices in the Baltic States more than doubled in 2022 : Offshore wind is crucial to achieving Estonia’s target of 100% renewable power by 2030 , reducing power prices , providing energy security , and mitigating climate change. T he Estonian government has admirably agreed that by 2030 , domestic renewable power production should equal power consumption, which is estimated to be 9 .5 TWh /year . Current domestic renewable power production totals 2,57 TWh /year , meaning that seven years remain to increase it by 37 0% . Without offshore wind, only approx. two thirds of the target will be achieved (Appendix A ). Eesti Energia started developing Liivi offshore wind farm in 2010, making it the most advanced in the Baltic States. In 2021, Eesti Energia signed an MoU to collaborate with Ørsted . This year, the transfer of Liivi offshore windfarm from Eesti Energia to Enefit Green was approved by the government. Since Enefit Green is a publicly listed company , this transfer makes Liivi offshore wind farm ’s future earnings accessible to private and institutional investors in Estonia and the region . The environmental impact assessment and research, which must be completed by 2024, and the state spatial plan for its grid connection, which must be completed by 202 5 , are the major ongoing project activities. When operational, Liivi offshore wind farm will generate power almost around the year ( >90% of the time according to E esti Energia’s measurement s ) , reducing power prices , provid ing energy security , and of course ultimately mitigating climate change . In order to take a positive investment decision and realize these benefits by 2030, in competition with offshore wind ambitions in Latvia and Lithuania, Enefit and Ørsted present a number of policy recommendations on the next pages . Policy Recommendation 1 : Introduce revenue stabilization through a two-way Contract-for-Difference ( CfD ) mechanism ( Estonia already has a one-way CfD for onshore renewables ). Since 2017, “merchant” bids ( i.e . based on market price s only without government support ) have been submitted into German, Dutch, and Danish offshore wind tenders . In some cases, developers even offered concession payments to the state on top their merchant bids. Although understandably very compelling, i t is important to be aware of the underlying conditions allowing such bids. First and foremost, although offshore wind can and should be constructed in the Baltic Sea, technical conditions for it are better in the North Sea where wind speeds are higher, icing losses are negligible, and the seabed is simpler, meaning that cheaper monopile foundations can be used. For reference, the approximately 1 m/s difference in wind speed between the North Sea and the Baltic Sea has a 15% impact on the Levelized Cost of Electricity ( LCoE ), so together, these differences are significant. Other factors underpinning past merchant bids in the North Sea (which are not present to the same extent in the Baltics Sea) include project scale, mature supply chains and synergies with existing projects, limited scope (i.e., transmission assets financed by the state), high, long-term expected power prices, and deep markets for Corporate Power Purchase Agreements. Current financial factors must also be accounted for. Wh ile the power price s have been very volatile and increased 200%, the cost of capital has nearly doubled, and cost of debt has increased even up to 400%. European markets, especially in the CEE region, still face strong geopolitical risks. U. S . interest rates have increased from 0.25% to around 4% in less than a year . As a result, most investments have moved from euros to dollars. The interest rates for renewable investments have doubled with MSCI Europe Green Bond index yield rising from 5.1% from the beginning of 2022 to 10.3% by November 2022. Levelized Cost of Electricity ( LC o E ) of wind power is more sensitive to the increased cost of capital , compared to conventional power plants. Multiple variables can have an impact on the cost of capital values, but e specially risks and interest rates play a key role (see the AURES II report from 2021). To attract investors to Estonia and realize offshore wind in the Baltic s by 2030 , we recommend implementing a two-way Contract-for-Difference ( CfD ) revenue stabilisation system , which developers could bid for competitively once they achieve their permits. A CfD is a long-term contract between a power generator and the state. Under a two-way CfD , payments can flow from state to the generator, and vice versa. When the market price for power generated by a CfD Generator (the Reference Price) is below the Strike Price set out in the contract, payments are made by state to the CfD Generator to make up the difference. However, when the Reference Price is above the Strike Price, the CfD Generator pays the state the difference , limiting excessive windfall profits and securing most beneficial socio-economic outcome . This is shown in the diagram below : According to various studies , revenue stabilisation via a CfD can lower the cost of capital of an onshore wind project by between 100-300 b asis points (see Arup report from 2018) . In 2021, Wind Europe said: “The two-sided CfD is the best form of revenue stabilization mechanism to minimize the total societal costs of offshore wind.” Also in 2021, Wind Denmark (now Green Power Denmark) and the Confederation of Danish Industry commissioned a report by Copenhagen Economics, which concluded that Contracts for Difference ( CfD ) are the best method for ensuring cost-effective offshore wind because they provide revenue stabilization, allowing developers to lower their cost of capital. In contrast, concession payments would ultimately burden consumers. These points have also been made by the European Commission, the IEA, the Danish Council on Climate Change, and AURES II. Finally, we note that if a tender is organized, and multiple developers can compete to supply power for 20+ years, the winning price provides what should be described as the long-term, market price for power. As shown in Appendix B, CfDs have provided very cost-effective energy in markets such as Denmark and the UK. A subsidy, on the other hand, is a straightforward allocation of taxpayer money by the government to support production of a good or service, offsetting market failures and externalities for a greater good. A CfD should not be seen as a subsidy. Policy Recommendation 2: Support Liivi’s qualification for cross-border status, such that part of its approximate 2.5-billion-euro cost can be covered by the EU’s Connecting Europe Facility (CEF). The CEF is a key EU funding instrument to promote growth, jobs and competitiveness through targeted infrastructure investment at European level. It supports the development of high performing, sustainable, and efficiently interconnected trans-European networks in the fields of transport, energy and digital services. CEF funding for studies and works, could for example, cover Liivi offshore wind farm’s grid connection costs; 25% co-funding would reduce the cost of power from Liivi offshore wind farm by approx. 10%. Furthermore, CEF funding could accelerate Liivi offshore windfarm’s timeline, as engineering works could start even before the superficies license is granted. In order to be eligible for European cross-border status and subsequently CEF funding, Liivi offshore wind farm would need confirmation of official support in principle and intent of cooperation with another Member State. We believe that there should be more than one officially confirmed offshore project with potential cross-border impact in this region, and that support should be allocated on a non-discriminatory and first-come, first-served basis. It would be highly appreciated if relevant public authorities, for example of Estonia and Latvia, would indicate their openness and readiness to engage in further discussions on recognizing Liivi as such a project as well. Policy Recommendation 3: The duration of the spatial planning process for Liivi offshore wind farm’s grid connection (and that of other projects) can and should be shortened. Eesti Energia has applied for, and the Government has initiated, state spatial planning for the grid connection line from Liivi offshore windfarm to the grid connection point. The total duration of the planning process is estimated at six years by the planning department of the Ministry of Finance. Considering the minimal impact of the connection cable to the environment and local population, such a long planning process is unnecessary and should be shortened. We propose using best practices for permitting and a one-stop-shop principle to shorten the timeline to two years. As written with respect to CEF, grid connection should be allocated on a non-discriminatory and first-come, first-served basis. Append ix A: Market information about onshore wind developments in Estonia as well as Liivi offshore wind farm (some additional but relatively limited capacity may come from solar PV ): Key Projects MW GWh GWh ( cumul .) Production Year Developer(s) Existing RES N/A 257 0 2 570 N/A Enefit Green, Utilitas , Eesti Energia , others Purtse (onshore) 21 45 2615 2023 Enefit Green Saarde (onshore) 38.7 135 2750 2023 Utilitas Sopi -Tootsi (onshore) 2 5 5 700 3450 2024 Enefit Green Aidu (onshore) 100 350 3 800 2025 Eleon Early-stage onshore 5 00 16 00 5 4 00 Until 2030 Enefit Green , others Liivi (offshore) 1000 4000 9 4 00 2028-2030 Enefit Green Total (GWh/year) - 9 400 - - - 14605 447675 0 0 Appendix B: Results from the application of CfD mechanisms in Denmark and the UK.