dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Rahandusministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

Ettepanek

Rahandusministeerium · 21. veebruar 2023
Viit
11-3.1/1316-1
Registreeritud
21. veebruar 2023
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
Eesti Liisingühingute Liit MTÜ
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
11 RAHVUSVAHELINE SUHTLEMINE JA KOOSTÖÖ
Sari
11-3.1 EL institutsioonide otsustusprotsessidega seotud dokumendid (eelnõud, töögruppide materjalid, õigustiku ülevõtmise tähtajad) (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
11-3.1/2023
Vastutaja
Andres Kuningas (Rahandusministeerium, Kantsleri vastutusvaldkond, Euroopa Liidu ja rahvusvahelise koostöö osakond)
Lahendamise tähtaeg
13. märts 2023

Failid

  • 📎DMFSD Direktiiv 2002_65_EC.asice291 KB
  • 📎E-kiri.pdf65 KB
  • 📎image001.png

Sisu (failidest)

Brussels, 0 6 February 20 2 3 Subject : Commission proposal for a Directive amending Directive 2011/83/EU concerning financial services contracts concluded at a distance and repealing Directive 2002/65/EC (DMFSD) Eurofinas and Leaseurope are the European Federations representing the consumer credit industry, and the leasing and automotive rental industries at EU level . Eurofinas brings together associations throughout Europe that represent finance houses, specialised banks, captive finance companies of car, equipment, etc. manufacturers and universal banks. The scope of products covered by Eurofinas members includes all forms of consumer credit products such as personal loans, point of sale credit, credit cards and store cards. Leaseurope brings together 44 member associations in 31 European countries. The scope of products covered by Leaseurope members’ ranges from hire purchase and finance leases to operating leases of all asset categories (automotive, equipment, machinery, ICT and real estate), with both B2B and B2C operations depending on market/products. Eurofinas and Leaseurope endorse the goal of the Commission’s proposal for a DMFSD to improve consumer protection online and to ensure the free movement of financial services in the single market by harmonising certain rules related to contracts concluded at distance. To achieve the high-level consumer protection and a real single market, legal certainty is key. It is crucial to prevent any unintended market confusion by introducing a balanced and clear framework . We would like to highlight some key points which we believe are necessary to clarify and strengthen this framework : 1 / Scope – financial leasing v. operational leasing In light of the overall approach of the Commission , the European Parliament and the Council that the DMFSD sh ould remain a safety net where sectoral legislation ha s precedence and should not overlap or duplicate ( lex specialis principle) , we support the recent Presidency compromise text that further clarifies the application of lex specialis as set out in recital (13) and Article 16a(6) : “ irrespective of the level of detail of these rules ” . Under this this, we would propose also add ing this wording to Article 16b(6) on the right of withdrawal, for the sake of clarity : “ Where another Union act governing specific financial services contains rules on the exercise of the right of withdrawal, only the right of withdrawal rules of that Union act shall apply to those specific financial services, irrespective of the level of detail of these rules , unless provided otherwise in that act. Furthermore , it is crucial to highlight that applying the DMFSD rules to the financial services that are excluded from the scope of sector-specific rules may have some unintended consequences which will bring about further confusion. When introducing general rules that will apply to products and services explicitly excluded from a sector-specific legislation , attention should be paid to the reasons why the EU legislators have chosen to exempt these from the sector-specific legislation. Th ere could be a variety of specific reasons, e.g. applicability, proportionality and/or low risk, etc.. Particularly, there is a n important difference between financial leasing and operational leasing services which the Revised Consumer Credit Directive, currently under examination by the EU legislators, takes into account. Under Annex I of the Capital Requirements Directive ( Directive 2013/36/EU ), it is clear that financial leasing is a financial service. However, operational leasing and (long-term rental of motor vehicles) are not among the financial services listed in Annex I . In general, financial leasing covers a long period and is aimed at full payment of the property value, whereby the lessee usually acquires ownership of the leased asset upon the expiry of the agreement. On the other hand, in operational leasing, the risk of ownership is fundamentally borne by the lessor; the duration of the service does not cover most of the economic “life” of the property in question; the lessor offers not only the use of an asset but also a variety of associated services; and the lessee does not, as a rule, acquire ownership upon expiry of the agreement . The European Commission together with the EBA (European Banking Authority) , took the same position. In response to the question whether operational leasing was included in Annex I to Directive 2013/36, i.e. whether companies engaging in it are financial institutions within the meaning of Regulation 575/2013, the Commission and EBA assessed that the list in Annex I to Directive 2013/36 is closed, that it does not include operational leasing, and that a company engaged exclusively in operational leasing cannot be considered a financial institution . For the above reasons, the Revised Consumer Credit Directive currently under final discussions between the EU co-legislators explicitly excludes “ hiring or leasing agreements with no obligation or option to purchase ” from its scope of application. Applying to operational leasing rules for financial services concluded at distance, on the grounds that they are excluded from the sector-specific rules, could prove problematic and create uncertainty in the market. Moreover, many of the provisions on distance marketing for financial services could be incompatible with such services. For example, newly ordered vehicles lose a significant amount of their value as soon as they are registered for first use, regardless of mileage. This brings about implications in relation to the amount to be repaid in the case that the consumer exercises the withdrawal right. In addition to repayment, consideration should be given to the leasing agreement's impact on the leased object, e.g. how the leased item must be returned and the damages assessed by an independent third party, etc. Allowing Member States to freely decide to apply the DMFSD requirements to products not covered by Union sector - specific legislation or giving Member States the option to apply Union sector-specific rules to products already assessed and exempted therefrom (back door application) , goes against the Better Regulation principles . As a result, this will foster an uneven playing field across the European Union and will go against the objective of fostering of the Capital Markets Union. 2/ Right of w ithdrawal S ervice/product providers should be allowed relevant flexibility to t he manner in which they will e nsure simple and rapid access to the right of withdrawal . This manner should be appropriate to the nature of their business, to the products at hand and to the more precise forms of distribution (sector by sector evaluation). While a mandatory and prescriptive requirement to maintain a withdrawal button will not e nhance consumer protection, as consumers can declare their withdrawal in any durable manner, the prescriptive approach will entail for the obliged traders additional costs for the technical changes needed to be made (e.g. IT infrastructure, study of the interface and computer developments). In any case, as proposed above, it should be explicitly clarified in the legal text that the DMFSD requirements on the right of withdrawal should only be applicable where the sector-specific legislation does not at all provide for a right of withdrawal . For instance, since the Consumer Credit Directive already provides for a right of withdrawal , the DMFSD rules should not apply, irrespective of the level of details of the CCD . Careful consideration should be paid before applying horizontal rules for financial services to services which are exclude d from the scope of Union sector-specific rules, especially because they are not considered as financial services, such as operational leasing (see in particular the amendment proposed in the 5 th Presidency compromise text, Article 16b(6a)(b) . Saatja: Liising <[email protected]> Saadetud: 21.02.2023 13:52 Adressaat: <"RAM Info">; <=?iso-8859-1?Q?Siiri_T=F5niste?=> Teema: DMFSD Direktiivi ettepanek Tere, Edastan ettepaneku. Lugupidamisega, Reet Hääl Tegevdirektor
Allikas: Rahandusministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel