Brussels, 30 November 2021
Mr. Andres Sutt, Minister of Entrepreneurship and Information Technology
Cc.:
Gerrit Mäesalu, Head of the Prime Minister`s Office
Object: Regarding the 5G spectrum band allocation in Estonia
Dear Minister of Entrepreneurship and Information Technology,
I would like to bring to your attention ETNO’s concerns regarding 5G spectrum band allocation in
Estonia. Estonia is by now among the very last countries in EU that has not yet awarded the key 5G
spectrum band 3400-3800 MHz (3.6 GHz range) to operators. This delay has prevented the transition
to the next generation of mobile technology, with negative consequences for the development of e-
Estonia and digital society as well as Estonia’s leadership in digitalization.
Estonian operators have been ready to start deploying 5G in this 3.6 GHz range for almost three years.
With the political changes and judicial review having delayed the auction process since 2019, the
European telecom industry calls on the Estonian Government to allocate the 3.6 GHz spectrum band
at the first opportunity and based on best expert recommendations. Predictability in spectrum award
plans and processes is a key supporting factor to facilitate investments in telecom networks and
services, which have wider implications for Estonian citizens and society.
We also urge to provide legal certainty and clarity regarding the spectrum allocation rules, especially
when it comes to awarding sufficiently large spectrum blocks. Allocation of spectrum in a fragmented
way, for example blocks 50+50 MHz or even less, prevents its use to maximum capacity and in an
effective way to serve society demands. 5G data speeds that an operator can provide to customers is
dependent on the contiguous block size. For example, 60 MHz block may enable up to 550 Mbit/s, 100
MHz block even up to 850 Mbit/s, without additional complex and costly aggregation approaches that
would also need support in the network and in customer equipment.
Estonia has already in early 2019 decided to allow operators to win sufficiently large blocks to provide
true 5G experience. Such auction rules are still officially in force
(https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/125012019003) and take into account the heavy coordination
limitations in the upper part of the band (3600-3800 MHz) due to restrictions related to neighboring
country – Russia. We find that the current auction rules support efficient 5G competition in the market,
by allowing more than two operators to acquire sufficient blocks of spectrum (60+70 MHz) to start
deploying the bandwidth in a way that gives actual impact and user experience at reasonable cost for
ETNO – European Telecommunications Network Operators' Association - www.etno.eu
@ETNOAssociation #ThinkDigital #ETNODigital
1
Sensitivity: Confidential
consumers and enterprises. The benefit of exploiting larger contiguous blocks, preferably 80-100 MHz
has been analyzed by experts and is recommended by European Commission1, as well as repeatedly
advocated by European Radio Spectrum Policy Group2.
The importance of good auction design is borne out also by other European countries´ practices in
deploying 5G. For example, Finland, which has similar coordination limitations, made 5G spectrum
available early and in sufficiently large blocks in 3 licenses, each 130 MHz (initially 60-70 MHz of
unrestricted spectrum). Such approach provided certainty for network investment planning. 5G
deployment took off fast in Finland after proper network equipment became available in 2020. Today,
each of the three Finnish operators has a 5G network that covers over 50% of population (according
Q3/2021 reporting), and 5G networks have been deployed also in smaller municipalities.
ETNO believes that boosting fast network connectivity and 5G rollout should remain a strategic priority
of the EU and its Member States. Timely and investment-friendly access to 5G spectrum is a crucial
precondition to support operators in meeting the demands for connectivity and digitalisation.
As Estonia is facing the challenge of delayed allocation of 3400-3800 MHz spectrum range, ETNO urges
Estonian Government to deliver a framework that avoids spectrum fragmentation and supports the
investment capacity of the telecom industry, so that operators can focus on 5G deployment to serve
the interest of users and to promote Estonia’s digital leadership.
We remain at your disposal should you wish to discuss these topics further.
Yours sincerely,
Lise Fuhr
Director General
1 EU 2019/235, European commission implementing decisions to 3400-3800 MHz „Large contiguous spectrum portions of
preferably 80-100 MHz facilitate the efficient deployment of 5G wireless broadband services, for example using Active
Antenna Systems (AAS), with high throughput, high reliability and low latency in line with the policy objective of gigabit
connectivity.“
2
Radio Spectrum Policy Group, Strategic roadmap towards 5G for Europe, topic 2.1:
The RSPG considers the 3400-3800 MHz band to be the primary band suitable for the introduction of 5G -based
services in Europe even before 2020, noting that this band is already harmonised for mobile networks, and
consists of up to 400 MHz of continuous spectrum enabling wide channel bandwidth. This band has the possibility
to put Europe at the forefront of the 5G deployment.
ETNO – European Telecommunications Network Operators' Association - www.etno.eu
@ETNOAssociation #ThinkDigital #ETNODigital
2
Sensitivity: Confidential
Saatja: Lise Fuhr <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 30.11.2021 11:05
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>; Andres Sutt
<
[email protected]>
Koopia: MKM info <
[email protected]>; Maarit Palovirta <
[email protected]>;
Xhoana Shehu <
[email protected]>; Sara Ghazanfari <
[email protected]>
Teema: ETNO support on the Estonian spectrum auction
Dear Mr. Mäesalu, dear Mr. Sutt,
Please find attached a letter from ETNO (the European Telecommunications
Network Operators' Association) providing our views on the upcoming
Estonian auction of the 3400-3800 MHz band.
We hope that this will be of interest and remain open for any questions
you may have.
Best regards,
Lise Fuhr
Director General | ETNO
European Telecommunications Network Operators Association
Bld du Régent 43-44,
B-1000 Brussels
T: +32 2 227 10 87
M: +32 471 08 19 44
E:
Connect with us on: