Saatja: Kai Rosin <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 17.02.2021 17:24
Adressaat: Birgit Parmas <
[email protected]>; Imre Banyasz
<
[email protected]>; Taimo Aasma <
[email protected]>; Kristel
Järve <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; Jaanus Uiga
<
[email protected]>; Johann Peetre <
[email protected]>; Ivo Jaanisoo
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; Mari Lahtmets
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; 'Hanna-Lii
Kupri' <
[email protected]>
Koopia: SM Info <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; Liis Siinor
<
[email protected]>; Kati-Liis Kensap <
[email protected]>;
Taimar Ala <
[email protected]>
Teema: IPCC raport kommenteerimiseks avatud
Tere
Pöördun Teie poole palvega osaleda Valitsustevahelise kliimapaneeli
(IPCC) raporti kommenteerimises. Ülikoolidele olen info juba eraldi
saatnud.
IPCC on nii ekspertidele kui valitsuse esindajatele kommenteerimiseks
avanud kolmanda töögrupi raporti: WGIII AR6 Climate Change 2021:
Mitigation of Climate Change.
Kirjale on lisatud raporti lühikokkuvõte (Summary for Policimakers, SPM)
ning tabel, kuhu kommentaarid sisestada saab.
Kommentaare esitades on soovitav silmas pidada järgmist:
- Oodatud on soovitused
konkreetse teksti, tabeli, joonise parema sõnastuse või esitamise viisi
kohta. Juhul kui viidatakse täiendavatele artiklitele, tuleb lisada ka
täisviited.
- Kommentaarid on kooskõlas
WGIII mandaadiga ega nõua, et autorid läheksid sellest ulatusest välja
(täiendavat infot leiab siit: )
- Kommentaarid SPM soovituste
osas on kooskõlas aruande peatükkides toodud infoga.
- Raporti autorid peavad
arvestama rangete pikkusepiirangutega ning nende ülesanne on anda edasi
ülevaade tänastest teadmistest, mitte koostada teaduslikku ülevaadet
selle kohta, kuidas nende teadmisteni jõuti.
- Oodatud on ettepanekud SPMi
ja peatükkide lühendamise võimaluste osas.
Täismahus raporti ülesehitust näeb siit:
Kuna see on väga mahukas, siis konkreetsed peatükid või kogu raporti sisu
edastaksin meeleldi vaid neile, kes tõesti kommenteerimisest osa võtta
plaanivad. Palun andke märku, kui on soov need täiendavad materjalid
saada!
Kui Teie mõtted lähevad kolleegile, kes võiks samuti kommenteerimises
osaleda, siis edastage see info ka temale. Seejuures pidage palun silmas,
et kõik materjalid on konfidentsiaalsed ning hetkel neid tsiteerida ega
neile viidata ei ole lubatud.
Palun tagastage kommentaaride tabel mulle hiljemalt 11. märtsiks. 1
koondtabel üksuse (nt osakond või asutus) kohta on tervitatud,
kommenteerimine on anonüümne.
Kõik täiendavad küsimused on oodatud.
Parimate soovidega
Kai Rosin
Nõunik
6660957 |58877361 |Skype: kai.rosin2
Keskkonnaagentuur
Mustamäe tee 33 | 10616 Tallinn
6660901| |
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
WORKING GROUP III CONTRIBUTION
TO THE IPCC SIXTH ASSESSMENT REPORT (AR6)
Summary for Policymakers
Draft for Expert and Government review
Do not cite, quote, or distribute
Date of Draft: 18 January 2021
Drafting Authors:
1 Jim Skea (United Kingdom), Priyadarshi R Shukla (India), Andy Reisinger (New Zealand), Raphael Slade
2 (United Kingdom), Minal Pathak (India), Alaa Al Khourdajie (United Kingdom/Syria), Renée van Diemen
3 (the Netherlands/United Kingdom), Amjad Abdulla (Maldives), Mustafa Babiker (Sudan/Saudi Arabia),
4 Quan Bai (China), Igor Bashmakov (the Russian Federation), Göran Berndes (Sweden), Gabriel Blanco
5 (Argentina), Kornelis Blok (the Netherlands), Luisa F. Cabeza (Spain), Carlo Carraro (Italy), Leon Clarke
6 (the United States of America), Felix Creutzig (Germany), Diriba Korecha Dadi (Ethiopia), Heleen de
7 Coninck (the Netherlands), Fatima Denton (Gambia), Shobhakar Dhakal (Nepal/Thailand), Navroz K.
8 Dubash (India), Michael Grubb (United Kingdom), Kirsten Halsnaes (Denmark), Tae Yong Jung (Republic
9 of Korea), Suzana Kahn Ribeiro (Brazil), Silvia Kreibiehl (Germany), Franck Lecocq (France), Shuaib
10 Lwasa (Uganda), Nagmeldin Mahmoud (Sudan), David McCollum (the United States of America), Jan
11 Christoph Minx (Germany), Catherine Mitchell (United Kingdom), Rachid Mrabet (Morocco), Gert-Jan
12 Nabuurs (the Netherlands), Peter Newman (Australia), Lars J. Nilsson (Sweden), Chukwumerije Okereke
13 (Nigeria/United Kingdom), Anthony Patt (Switzerland), Ramón Pichs-Madruga (Cuba), Lavanya Rajamani
14 (India), Keywan Riahi (Austria), Joyashree Roy (India/Thailand), Roberto Schaeffer (Brazil), Karen Seto
15 (the United States of America), Shreya Some (India), Linda Steg (the Netherlands), Ferenc L. Toth
16 (Hungary), Diana Ürge-Vorsatz (Hungary), Purvi Vyas (India), Yi-Ming Wei (China), Harald Winkler
17 (Republic of South Africa).
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-1 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 A. Introduction and framing
2 The Working Group III (WG III) contribution to the IPCC’s Sixth Assessment Report (AR6) assesses
3 literature on the scientific, technological, environmental, economic and social aspects of mitigation of
4 climate change. It assesses the current state of knowledge 1 building on the WG III contribution to the
5 IPCC’s Fifth Assessment Report (AR5) and the three Special Reports in the Sixth Assessment cycle. 2
6 The report reflects developments and changes in approaches in the literature on climate change mitigation
7 published since the AR5:
8 • A changed global landscape since AR5. The development of the literature reflects the goals of the
9 Paris Agreement {see Chapters 14, 15} and its novel governance structure, and the UN 2030 Agenda
10 for Sustainable Development {1, 4, 17}. Literature further highlights the growing role of non-state
11 actors such as cities, businesses, transnational initiatives, and public-private entities in the global effort
12 to address climate change {8, 13}. It draws attention to the falling cost of low carbon technologies {2,
13 6} and the evolving role of international cooperation {14}, finance {15} and innovation {16}. An
14 emerging literature addresses the global spread of climate policies and the growing number of
15 developed countries with sustained reductions in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions {2, 13}, and the
16 mitigation challenges and opportunities posed by the COVID-19 pandemic {TS-Box 1, and Cross-
17 Chapter Box 1 in Chapter 1}.
18 • Close linkages between climate mitigation, development pathways and the pursuit of sustainable
19 development goals. The literature shows that the risks and co-benefits of mitigation action differ
20 according to stages of development and national capabilities {1, 2, 4}. Choices of development
21 pathways affect the portfolio of available mitigation options. The feasibility and cost of limiting
22 emissions to any given level depend on both underlying development pathways and choices made about
23 enabling conditions (Figure SPM.1) {1.4, 1.5, 4}. Climate change mitigation framed in the context of
24 sustainable development, equity and poverty eradication, and rooted in the development aspirations of
25 the economy and society within which they take place, is likely to be more acceptable, durable and
26 effective {1, 4}.
27 • Novel aspects of the assessment. In addition to the well-established sectoral and systems chapters {6,
28 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12}, the report includes, for the first time, chapters dedicated to demand, services and
29 social aspects of mitigation {5}, and innovation, technology development and transfer {16}. The
30 assessment of future pathways combines a near- to medium- future perspective up to 2050, including
31 ways of shifting development pathways towards sustainability {4}, and a long-term global perspective
32 up to 2100 {3}. Collaboration between Working Groups is reflected in Cross-Working Group boxes
33 which address topics such as the economic benefits from avoided impacts along long-term mitigation
34 pathways {Cross-WG Box 1 in Chapter 3}, cities and climate change {Cross-WG Box 2 in Chapter 8},
35 and mitigation and adaptation via the bioeconomy {Cross-WG Box 3 in Chapter 12}. This assessment
FOOTNOTE 1 The draft covers literature submitted for publication by 14 December 2020.
FOOTNOTE 2 The three Special reports are: Global Warming of 1.5°C: an IPCC Special Report on the impacts of
global warming of 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels and related global greenhouse gas emission pathways, in the
context of strengthening the global response to the threat of climate change, sustainable development, and efforts to
eradicate poverty; Climate Change and Land: an IPCC Special Report on climate change, desertification, land
degradation, sustainable land management, food security, and greenhouse gas fluxes in terrestrial ecosystems; IPCC
Special Report on the Ocean and Cryosphere in a Changing Climate.
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-2 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 gives greater attention than AR5 to social, economic and environmental dimensions of mitigation
2 actions, including from land-based actions {7, 12, 17}, and institutional, legal and financial aspects
3 {13, 14, 15}.
4 • Broader and more diverse analytic frameworks and multiple disciplines. This report identifies
5 multiple analytic frameworks relevant to assessing the drivers and barriers to, and options for,
6 mitigation action. These include: economic and environmental efficiency; ethics and equity; innovation
7 and transition dynamics {16}; and psychology, sociology, and political science {1.6, 5}. These help to
8 identify and explain synergies and trade-offs, challenges and windows of opportunity, including for just
9 transitions at national and global levels. {1, 5, 13, 14, 16}.
10 • Accelerating the response. The climate risks assessed by Working Groups I and II have increased
11 since AR5, contributed to by rising global GHG emissions up to 2018. Limiting global warming cost
12 effectively to 1.5⁰C above pre-industrial levels, or to likely below 2⁰C, implies that global carbon
13 dioxide (CO2) emissions peak before 2025 and reach net zero in the third quarter of this century. This
14 would imply greater near-and medium-term ambition, accelerated action and effective implementation.
15 {1, 3, 4, 14}.
16 This Summary for Policymakers (SPM) is structured as follows. Section B: Where are we now and where
17 are we headed, addresses recent emission trends and drivers including recent sectoral, financial,
18 technological and policy developments. Section C: System transformations to limit global warming
19 identifies emission pathways consistent with limiting global warming to different levels, along with
20 possible mitigation portfolios. It assesses individual mitigation options at the sectoral level, along with costs
21 and feasibility. Section D: Mitigation, adaptation, and sustainable development addresses links between
22 mitigation, adaptation, and sustainable development, including the risks and trade-offs associated with
23 specific mitigation actions. Section E: Strengthening the response summarises our knowledge of how
24 institutional design, policy, finance and governance arrangements can deliver climate mitigation while
25 minimising risks and maximising co-benefits.
26 References to the underlying report and the Technical Summary are given in {} brackets. Confidence in
27 key findings is indicated using the IPCC calibrated language. 3
FOOTNOTE 3 Each finding is grounded in an evaluation of underlying evidence and agreement. A level of confidence
is expressed using five qualifiers: very low, low, medium, high and very high, and typesets in italics, for example,
medium confidence. The following terms have been used to indicate the assessed likelihood of an outcome or a result:
virtually certain 99–100% probability, very likely 90–100%, likely 66–100%, about as likely as not 33–66%, unlikely
0–33%, very unlikely 0–10%, exceptionally unlikely 0–1%. Additional terms (extremely likely 95–100%, more likely
than not >50–100%, more unlikely than likely 0–<50%, extremely unlikely 0–5%) may also be used when appropriate.
Assessed likelihood is typeset in italics, for example, very likely. This is consistent with IPCC AR5.
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-3 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1
2 Figure SPM.1 | Shifting development pathways to accelerate mitigation and increase sustainability: Choices by a wide range of actors at key decision
3 points along development pathways influence emissions and the availability of options for climate mitigation and system transformation.
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-4 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 B. Where are we now and where are we headed?
2 B1. Annual global GHG emissions have continued to rise since 2010 reaching
3 59±5.9 GtCO2-eq in 2018. Although the rate of growth has fallen compared to the previous decade
4 (high confidence), 2018 GHG emissions were higher than at any previous time in human history
5 (medium confidence). Emission growth has been varied, but persistent across different gases (high
6 confidence). (Figure SPM.2) {2.2, Cross-Chapter Box 1 in Chapter 1}
7 B1.1. Global anthropogenic GHG emissions were 59±5.9 GtCO2-eq in 20184: 11% (5.9 GtCO2-eq)
8 higher than in 2010, 51% (20 GtCO2-eq) higher than 1990, and higher than at any previous time in
9 human history (medium confidence). Average annual GHG emissions for 2009–2018 were 56±5.6
10 GtCO2-eq compared to 47±4.7 and 40±4.0 GtCO2-eq for 2000–2009 and 1990–1999, respectively (high
11 confidence). GHG emissions growth slowed since 2010: while average annual GHG emissions growth
12 was 2.3% between 2000 and 2010, it was 1.3% for 2010–2018. {2.2}
13 B1.2. Emission growth has been varied, but persistent across different gases (high confidence). In
14 2018, CO2 emissions from fossil fuel and industry (FFI) were 38±3.0 Gt, CO2 from agriculture, forestry
15 and other land-use change (AFOLU) 5.4±2.7 Gt, methane (CH4) 12±2.3 GtCO2-eq, nitrous oxide (N2O)
16 2.5±1.5 GtCO2-eq and fluorinated gases (F-gases) 1.8±0.35 GtCO2-eq. While F-gas levels and CO2
17 emissions from FFI have grown by 430% and 66% between 1990 and 2018, emissions increased by
18 25% and 28% for CH4 and N2O. The group of fluorinated gases have jointly grown much faster than
19 other GHGs and makes a non-negligible contribution to global warming today. CO2 remains the major
20 driver of warming. (Figure SPM.2) {2.2}
21 B1.3. Net cumulative emissions of CO2 remain the dominant driver of global warming from human
22 activities. Between 1850 and 2018 total cumulative CO2 emissions from FFI and AFOLU were
23 2400±390 GtCO2. About 980±98 GtCO2 has been added to the atmosphere since 1990, with about
24 330±31 GtCO2 added since AR5 (2010). {2.2}
25 B1.4. The global COVID-19 pandemic has led to a historic drop in CO2 emissions from fossil fuel
26 and industry (medium confidence). Preliminary data for 2020 suggest a decrease in FFI CO2 emissions
27 relative to 2019 of about 7% (2.7–13%) or about 3 GtCO2, but emission growth has picked up with
28 economic activity again since April 2020. {Cross-Chapter Box 1 in Chapter 1, 2.2}
29
FOOTNOTE 4 Emissions of GHGs are weighed by Global Warming Potentials with a 100-year time horizon
(GWP-100) from the Sixth Assessment Report. GWP-100 is commonly used in wide parts of the literature on
climate change mitigation and is required for aggregate UNFCCC GHG emissions reporting by the Paris rule
book. All metrics have limitations and uncertainties. For further details, see Box 2.2 and Annex B Section A.B.10.
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-5 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1
2 Figure SPM.2 | Total anthropogenic GHG emissions (GtCO2-eq yr-1) 1990-2018: CO2 from fossil fuel
3 combustion and industrial processes (FFI); CO2 from Forestry and Other Land use (FOLU); methane (CH4);
4 nitrous oxide (N2O); fluorinated gases (F-gases). Panel a: Aggregate GHG emission trends by groups of gases
5 reported in GtCO2-eq converted based on global warming potentials with a 100-year time horizon (GWP-100)
6 from the IPCC Sixth Assessment Report. Waterfall diagrams juxtaposes GHG emissions for the most recent
7 year 2018 in CO2 equivalent units using GWP-100 values from the IPCC’s Second, Fifth and Sixth Assessment
8 Report, respectively. Error bars show the associated uncertainties at a 90% confidence interval. Panel b:
9 Individual trends in CO2-FFI, CO2-FOLU, CH4 and N2O emissions in (original) mass units
10 (Gt yr-1) for the period 1990–2018, normalised to 1 in 1990.
11
12
13 B2. Growth in global per capita GDP and population has outpaced a fall in the global average
14 use of energy per unit of GDP. However, a growing number of countries have entered a period of
15 sustained GHG emission reductions in the absence of economic crises (high confidence). (Figure
16 SPM.3) {2.2, 2.3, 5.2, 9.3}
17 B2.1. Materials and energy consumption associated with rising incomes have been the strongest
18 driver of CO2 emissions growth from fossil fuel combustion, with a smaller contribution from
19 population growth. Continued growth in per capita GDP and population between 2010 and 2018
20 increased FFI CO2 emissions by 2.3% and 1% per year, respectively. This growth continuously
21 outpaced a reduction in the use of energy per unit of GDP (-2.2% per year, globally) (high confidence).
22 Technological change driving energy efficiency improvements and a switch to lower carbon energy
23 sources have led to a decoupling of economic growth and emissions in many countries, but fewer
24 countries have experienced absolute emissions reductions. (high confidence). {2.3}.
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-6 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 B2.2. Expansion in GHG intensive economic activities includes aviation (+28.5% from 2010 to
2 2020), SUVs (+17% from 2010 to 2020) and meat consumption (12% from 2010 to 2020) (high
3 confidence). However, there was a slight but significant shift from high carbon beef consumption to
4 medium carbon intensive poultry consumption. Global energy demand for cooling in the residential
5 sector increased by 40% from 2010 to 2018 (high confidence). {5.2, 9.3}
6 B2.3. Energy demand has only decoupled from economic growth in relative terms, not in absolute
7 amounts. A substantial decarbonisation of the energy system was only noticeable in North America,
8 Europe and Eurasia, whereas globally the amount of CO2 per unit of energy has practically remained
9 unchanged over the last three decades (high confidence). {2.2}
10 B2.4. There are at least 36 countries that have sustained territorial-based CO2 and GHG emissions
11 reductions for longer than 10 years. While total cumulative GHG reductions of these countries are small
12 compared to recent global emissions growth, individual countries have cut their emissions by 50% from
13 peak levels. Similarly, national GHG reduction rates in some years are in line with scenario pathways
14 that limit warming well below 2°C at 66% probability (e.g., -4% average annual reductions), even
15 outside of periods of economic decline (high confidence). (Figure SPM.3) {2.2}
16
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-7 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1
2 Figure SPM.3 | Change in regional GHG emissions and rates of change compatible with warming targets.
3 Panel a: Regional GHG emission trends (in GtCO2-eq yr-1 (GWP100 AR6)) for the time period 1990–2018.
4 GHG emissions from international aviation (AIR) and shipping (SEA) are not assigned to individual countries
5 and shown separately. Panel b: Historical GHG emissions change by region (1990–2018), compared to rates of
6 reduction compatible with 1.5°C and 2°C warming targets, assessed via reduction rates in AR6 IAM scenarios
7 over the period 2020-2040.
8
9
10 B3. GHG emissions differ significantly between nations, and between rich and poor people
11 within nations, mirroring global income inequalities (high confidence). The top 10% emitters (the
12 global wealthiest 10% on a per capita basis) contribute ten times as much to global emissions as
13 the poorest 10% (high confidence). Providing universal access to modern energy globally will
14 have negligible emission impacts (medium confidence). {2.2, 2.3, 2.4, 2.5, 2.6}
15 B3.1. Average per capita GHG emissions in 2018 were 13.1 tCO2-eq/cap in developed countries, 14.7
16 tCO2-eq/cap in Eastern Europe and West Central Asia, 5.8 tCO2-eq/cap in Latin America and
17 Caribbean, 5.7 tCO2-eq/cap in Asia and Developing Pacific, and 4.2 tCO2-eq/cap in Africa and Middle
18 East. Inequality in GHG emissions between countries has decreased over the last decades in
19 correspondence with steady global economic growth and a decline in the global carbon GINI (high
20 confidence). {2.2, 2.4}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-8 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 B3.2. 35% of global cumulative GHG emissions between 2010 and 2018 were from developed
2 countries and 3% from least developed countries; developed countries account for 17% and least
3 developed countries 13% of the world’s population. Consumption-based CO2 emissions from the
4 production of goods and services finally consumed in developed countries peaked in 2007 at about 17
5 GtCO2 and declined subsequently. 46% of developing country CO2 emissions in 2010 and 41% in 2015
6 were from export production to developed countries (medium confidence). {2.2, 2.3}
7 B3.3. Within countries, inequalities increased for both income and GHG emissions between 1980 and
8 2016, with the top 1% accounting for 27% of income growth. The global richest 10% contribute about
9 36–45% of global GHG emissions, while the world’s poorest 10% contribute around 3–5% (high
10 confidence). The richest 10% live on all continents, with two thirds in high-income regions and one
11 third in emerging economies. Most of the lowest 10% emitters live in sub-Saharan Africa, South East
12 Asia, Central Asia and Latin America. These regions are home to the almost 20% of global population
13 lacking access to electricity and the 37% lacking access to clean cooking. Eradicating extreme poverty
14 would increase global CO2 emissions only slightly (high confidence). {2.5}
15 B3.4. The consumption patterns of higher income consumers are associated with large carbon
16 footprints. Top emitters dominate emissions in key sectors, for example the top 1% account for 50% of
17 GHG emissions from aviation (high confidence). Growing within country inequality in GHG emissions
18 creates distributional and social cohesion dilemmas, compromises social trust, and affects the
19 willingness of both rich and poor to accept mitigation and other policies to protect the environment
20 (medium confidence). {2.5}
21 B4. Changes in sectoral emission patterns since AR5 can be attributed to developments in
22 technology, policies, investment patterns, and behaviour (high confidence). The cost,
23 performance and adoption of many individual technologies have progressed, but deployment
24 rates, deployment patterns, and the global reach of technological change is currently insufficient
25 to achieve climate and sustainable development goals (high confidence). Many technological
26 advances have not benefitted developing countries to the same extent as developed countries, nor
27 have they necessarily led to the enhancement of technological capabilities, with the least-
28 developed countries particularly disadvantaged (medium confidence). (Figure SPM.4, Figure
29 SPM.5) {2.2, 6.3, 6.4, 7.2, 12.2, 16.2, 16.5, 16.6, Cross-Chapter Box 8 in Chapter 16}
30 B4.1. In 2018, 34% (20 GtCO2-eq) of global GHG emissions came from the energy sector, 23% (13
31 GtCO2-eq) from industry, 23% (13 GtCO2-eq) from AFOLU, 14% (8.3 GtCO2-eq) from transport and
32 6% (3.4 GtCO2-eq) from buildings. Once indirect emissions from energy use are considered, the relative
33 shares of industry and buildings emissions are 33% and 17%, respectively. While average annual GHG
34 emissions growth between 2010 and 2018 slowed significantly compared to the previous decade in the
35 energy (from 3.2% to 1.4%) and the industry (from 5.0% to 1.7%) sectors, average annual growth in
36 the transport sector has remained roughly constant at about 2% per year (high confidence). (Figure
37 SPM.4) {2.2}
38 B4.2. Since 2010, the rapid cost decreases of solar (87%), wind (38%), and batteries (85%), and the
39 capacity installed has exceeded previous expectations. Solar and wind energy now provide 7% of total
40 electricity supply. In the last 12 years the AFOLU sector has achieved mitigation of ~0.7 GtCO 2 yr-1
41 (medium confidence) with biomass contributing two-thirds of modern renewable heating and cooling in
42 buildings and industrial processes, and biofuels contributing 90% of renewable energy use in the
43 transport sector (high confidence). Policy instruments have been a key driver for change in several
44 countries (medium confidence), though recent reversals of past gains illustrate the difficulty of
45 sustaining policies. (Figure SPM.5) {1.3, 1.5, 2.5, 6.3, 6.4, 7.2, 12.2}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-9 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 B4.3. The scale-up, diffusion and global spread of carbon capture and storage (CCS), nuclear energy
2 and carbon dioxide removal (CDR) technologies have not progressed as rapidly. Economic barriers,
3 institutional challenges and public concerns about safety and sustainability are amongst the reasons
4 inhibiting their diffusion (high confidence). {2.5, 6.3, 11.3, 12.7, 16.3, 16.4}
5 B4.4. General Purpose Technologies (GPTs), such as digital, artificial intelligence or biotechnology,
6 have already found applications across sectors, and have led to both synergies and trade-offs between
7 mitigation and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) (medium evidence, high agreement).
8 Digitalisation is fundamentally changing all economies and societies. Digital
9 technologies, and associated innovation, can contribute to more efficient industrial processes and
10 power, but they may also increase energy demand and demand for goods and services
11 (medium confidence). {Cross Chapter Box 8 in Chapter 16, 5.3, 10, 12.6, 16.3}
12 B4.5. Some governments have strengthened innovation systems and policies by adopting a holistic
13 approach. Such policies have accelerated deployment and diffusion of existing and new low-emission
14 technologies, increased cooperation, and strengthened domestic innovation capabilities (high
15 confidence). Systemic approaches are still not widespread and international technology cooperation as
16 envisaged under international climate agreements is still limited in scope and size (medium evidence,
17 high agreement). {16.6}
18
19
20 Figure SPM.4 | Direct versus indirect emissions. The stacked bar on the left indicates total global greenhouse
21 gas emissions in 2018, split by sectors based on direct (scope 1) emissions accounting. The pull-out section for
22 Electricity & heat depicts the reallocation of these emissions to final sectors as indirect (scope 2) emissions.
23 This increases the contribution to global emissions from the industry and buildings sectors (central stacked bar).
24 The stacked bar on the far right indicates the shares of subsectors in global emissions when indirect emissions
25 are included.
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-10 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1
2
3
4 Figure SPM.5 | Cost reductions and adoption in dynamic energy technologies. Upper panel shows levelised
5 costs of electricity (LCOE) for renewable energy technologies and battery storage. Blue areas show the range
6 between the 5th and 95th percentiles in each year. Lines indicate average cost in each year. Range of fossil fuel
7 (coal and gas) LCOE indicated as grey area $50-177 per MWh. Lower panel shows cumulative worldwide
8 adoption for each technology, in GW of capacity for renewable energy and in vehicles for electric vehicles.
9 Vertical dashed line placed at 2010 to indicate change since AR5.
10
11
12 B5. Since AR5, there has been a substantial growth in climate policy and corresponding
13 institutional arrangements at national and sub-national levels (high confidence). Many countries
14 have developed cross-sectoral frameworks with multiple objectives that have climate mitigation
15 as a co-benefit. Gaps remain in terms of the extent of coverage and the ambition of climate
16 commitments and effective enabling conditions for implementation, such as sufficient policies,
17 their stringency and suitable institutions (medium evidence, high agreement). {5.6, 13.2, 13.4, 13.5,
18 13.6, 14.3, 14.4, 14.5, 15.3, 15.5}
19 B5.1. Little new climate legislation and few additional national strategies were added between 2012
20 and 2017, but climate targets have become more prevalent (high confidence). The share of global GHG
21 emissions subject to mitigation policies has increased (high confidence). However, CH4, N2O, and CO2
22 from the production of industrial materials and feedstocks, as well as fossil fuel combustion in many
23 developing and some developed countries, are not yet covered by mitigation policies (robust evidence,
24 medium agreement). {13.2, 13.6}
25 B5.2. Sub-national jurisdictions and cities, businesses and investors, international organisations, legal
26 institutions, indigenous peoples and civil society groups, are engaged in climate mitigation. Climate
27 actions, including partnerships, voluntary initiatives and the collective action of citizens, are taking
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-11 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 place across multiple scales. These are having impact through: framing and shaping targets; knowledge
2 generation; emissions disclosure; climate litigation; role models, local decision-making; and fostering
3 experimentation (high confidence). {5.6, 13.3, 13.4, 13.5, 14.5}
4 B5.3. The Kyoto Protocol was instrumental in building institutional capacity to support international
5 carbon markets and voluntary cooperation. The Paris Agreement has shifted international cooperation
6 towards encouraging and supporting rising levels of ambition and the ability of Parties to achieve their
7 mitigation objectives within the framework of sustainable development. The effectiveness of the Paris
8 Agreement, on which views differ, depends on the success of its facilitative approach to mitigation
9 ambition built on procedural commitments, normative expectations, transparency, and peer pressure
10 (high confidence). {14.3, 14.4, 14.6}
11 B5.4. Recognition of the need to align financial flows with climate goals has created significant
12 momentum in the financial industry. However, financial flows, for both adaptation and mitigation, have
13 increased only modestly, from USD 343-385 billion annually in 2010-2012 to approximately USD 546
14 billion in 2018 (medium confidence). Financial flows linked to mitigation are a factor of five below the
15 average levels needed to limit warming to 2⁰C (medium confidence). Flows are unevenly distributed
16 across regions and sectors and stakeholders (high confidence). {Figure 15.3, 15.3}
17 B5.5. The balance of public and private financial flows has been relatively stable over the past five
18 years, at 40% and 60% respectively. The private sector has driven increased financial flows towards the
19 renewable energy sector. In other sectors, where financially viable business models and appropriate risk
20 assessments are less well established, there are barriers to the mobilisation of private sector finance
21 (high confidence). Markets for green bonds and sustainable finance products have expanded
22 significantly since AR5, reflecting investor preferences for scalable and highly standardised investment
23 opportunities. {15.5}
24 B6. Global emissions in 2030 as projected on a continuation of current policies exceed current
25 national pledges. In turn, current pledges are not consistent with long-term emission pathways
26 that would likely limit global warming to 2°C during the 21st century (high confidence). Existing
27 and planned infrastructure and investments, institutional inertia and a social bias towards the
28 status quo are leading to a risk of locking in future GHG emissions that may be costly or difficult
29 to abate, due to early decommissioning, underutilisation and devaluation of stranded assets.
30 (Figure SPM.6) {2.7, 3.3, 3.5, 4.2, Cross-Chapter Box 3 in Chapter 4}
31 B6.1. Current policies lead to median projected global GHG emissions of 63 (57–70) GtCO2-eq yr-1
32 by 2030. Unconditional and conditional NDCs lead to projected emissions of 59 (55–65) and 56 (52–
33 61) GtCO2-eq yr-1 respectively (medium evidence, high agreement). The emissions gap in 2030 between
34 unconditional NDCs and cost-effective long-term mitigation pathways is 25-34 GtCO2-eq (22-31
35 GtCO2-eq) for limiting warming to 1.5°C with no or low (<0.1°C) overshoot (50% chance) and 14-23
36 GtCO2-eq (11-20 GtCO2-eq) for limiting warming to 2°C (66% chance). The comparable gaps for
37 conditional NDCs are 23-29 GtCO2-eq and 6-10 GtCO2-eq respectively. (medium evidence, high
38 agreement) (Figure SPM.6) {3.5, 4.2, Cross-Chapter Box 3 in Chapter 4}
39 B6.2. Estimates of committed CO2 emissions from current fossil energy infrastructures are 658 (455-
40 892) GtCO2 depending on assumed decommissioning rates and capacity utilisations. Estimated
41 committed CO2 emissions from current and planned fossil energy infrastructures are 846 (597-1126)
42 GtCO2. Estimates for committed emissions from fossil energy infrastructure are nearly double the
43 remaining carbon budget for limiting warming to 1.5°C with 50% probability (390 GtCO 2) (medium
44 evidence, high agreement). These estimates do not cover planned infrastructure from industry, buildings
45 and transportation for which there is no data. {2.7, 6.7, WGI SOD Chapter 5}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-12 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 B6.3. Current average lifetimes for coal and gas power plants are 39 and 36 years respectively. To
2 limit warming to 1.5°C, it is estimated that, without reducing utilisation rates, or large-scale retrofitting
3 enabling biomass use and/or CCS, and assuming that no plants proposed or under construction come
4 online, the average lifetime of coal and gas power infrastructure would need to be limited to 9 (5-20)
5 and 12 (9-14) years respectively. To limit warming to 2°C with 66% probability, the comparable
6 estimates are 16 (6-28) and 17 (10-25) years. These estimates are further reduced if it is assumed that
7 plants proposed or under construction come online (medium confidence). {2.7}
8 B6.4. Factors limiting ambitious transformation include structural barriers, an incremental rather than
9 systemic approach, lack of coordination, inertia, lock-in to infrastructure and assets, and lock-in as a
10 consequence of vested interests, regulatory inertia, and lack of technological capabilities and human
11 resources. (high confidence) {1.5, 2.8, 5.5, 6.7, 13.8}
12
13
14
15 Figure SPM.6 | Aggregate GHG emission outcomes of NDCs and long-term mitigation pathways consistent
16 with global temperature limits. Shown are emission ranges that would emerge from the implementation of
17 current unconditional and conditional NDCs (grey bars) and global pathways from the AR6 scenario database that
18 can be grouped into six types:
19 • Pathways with near-term emissions developments in line with (1) current policies and (2) NDCs,
20 respectively, and extended with comparable ambition levels beyond 2030,
21 • Pathways holding warming below 2°C (66% chance) with near term emissions developments reflecting
22 (3) ambition levels in current NDCs and (4) a gradual strengthening of mitigation action beyond NDCs,
23 respectively, and
24 • Mitigation pathways undertaking immediate action from 2020 onwards towards (5) holding warming
25 below 2°C (66% chance) and (6) limiting warming to 1.5°C by 2100 with low (<0.1°C) overshoot (50%
26 chance), respectively.
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-13 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 The figure shows the emission pathways until 2050 (median and 25th-75th percentiles) with their emissions ranges
2 in 2030 and 2050 broken out in full (median and 5th-95th percentiles). Projected emissions for the NDCs from
3 Section 4.2.2 (Table 4.1) show median and full range.
4 [Notes: GHG emissions are expressed in CO2-equivalent based on 100-year GWPs from AR6. The NDC estimates
5 are based on the first round of submission to the UNFCCC and do not include recent updates most notably those
6 submitted since November 2020.]
7
8
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-14 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 C. System transformations to limit global warming
2 C1. Global warming associated with published emissions pathways ranges from less than
3 1.5°C at peak to greater than 5°C by 2100 compared to pre-industrial levels. Baseline scenarios
4 without any new climate policies lead to a median global warming of 3.3°C-5.4°C by 2100 (medium
5 confidence). Limiting warming to below 1.5°C or 2°C compared to preindustrial levels requires
6 rapid GHG emissions reductions and fundamental structural changes at global scale (high
7 confidence). Weaker near-term action would place limiting warming to these levels out of reach
8 as it would entail assumptions about subsequent accelerated policy development, and technology
9 development and deployment, inconsistent with evidence and projections in the assessed
10 literature (high confidence). (Table SPM.1) {3.3, 3.8}
11 C1.1. In the absence of new climate policies and without the implementation of current pledges,
12 annual GHG emissions in baseline scenarios increase from 58 to 59-80 GtCO2-eq yr-1 by 2030 and to
13 63-110 GtCO2-eq yr-1 by 2050, resulting in global warming of 3.3°C to 5.4°C by 2100 (medium
14 confidence). The highest emissions scenarios in the literature combine assumptions about rapid long-
15 term economic growth and pervasive climate policy failures, leading to a reversal of some recent trends
16 and a fossil fuel dominated future. {3.3}
17 C1.2. In pathways that limit global warming to below 3.0°C by 2100, CO2 emissions peak around
18 2035 (range: 2020-2060). In pathways that limit global warming to below 2.0°C by 2100 (50% or
19 greater probability), CO2 emissions peak immediately (range: 2020-2025). Many pathways in the
20 literature limit global warming to 1.5°C by 2100 (50% probability) with a temperature overshoot of less
21 than 0.1°C (low overshoot), but only a few limit global warming to 1.5°C by 2100 (50% probability)
22 without overshoot during the course of the 21st century. (high confidence) (Table SPM.1) {3.3}
23 C1.3. Mitigation pathways likely to limit global warming to below 2°C by 2100 are associated with
24 net global GHG emissions of 34–56 GtCO2-eq yr-1 by 2030 and 14–25 GtCO2-eq yr-1 in 2050. These
25 correspond to GHG emissions reductions of 4–40% by 2030, and 55–74% by 2050 relative to modelled
26 2020 emission levels. Pathways that limit global warming to below 1.5°C by 2100 with 50% probability
27 and with low overshoot require a further acceleration in the pace of the transformation, with GHG
28 emissions reductions of 35–60% by 2030 and 73–94% in 2050 relative to modelled 2020 emission
29 levels. (medium confidence) (Table SPM.1) {3.3}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-15 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 Table SPM.1 | Key characteristics of the global emissions pathways: Summary of CO2 and GHG emissions, net-zero timings and likely temperature outcomes. Scenarios
2 are categorised by their climate outcome (rows), according to their likelihood of staying below threshold warming levels, according to both peak and 2100 temperature.
3 Values shown are for the median (p50) and 10th-90th percentiles, noting that not all scenarios achieve net-zero CO2 or GHGs. Baseline range corresponds to 10-90th
4 percentile of baseline emissions across different socioeconomic pathways (SSPs).
5
6
7
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-16 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 C2. In most pathways, global average temperature peaks or stabilises roughly when global
2 CO2 emissions reach net zero. The timing of peak temperature also depends on non-CO2
3 emissions. The level of peak warming is determined by the remaining carbon budget until the
4 time when net zero CO2 emissions are reached and the level of non-CO2 emissions by that time.
5 A more rapid transition towards net zero CO2 emissions limits peak warming levels and avoids
6 temperature overshoot and net negative CO2 emissions. (high confidence) {3.3, 3.5}
7 C2.1. The remaining carbon budget until global CO2 emissions reach net zero is the key determinant
8 of the level of peak warming, along with the level of non-CO2 emissions at that time. The remaining
9 carbon budget, from the year 2019, in pathways that limit warming to 1.5°C with 50% probability is
10 around 525 (345-680) GtCO2 in the case of low overshoot, and around 710 (540-900) GtCO2 in the case
11 of higher overshoot. Pathways likely to limit warming to below 2.0°C have a higher carbon budget of
12 around 870 (700-1075) GtCO2. Cumulative CO2 emissions from 2019 to 2100 in pathways that limit
13 median warming to below 3.0°C are around 2685 (2345-3065) GtCO2. (Table SPM.1) (high confidence)
14 {3.3}
15 C2.2. In most pathways, temperatures peak or are stabilised roughly at the time global CO2 emissions
16 reach net-zero. Lower peak temperatures are associated with earlier carbon neutrality. A warming level
17 of 1.5°C with 50% probability and both low and high overshoot corresponds to reaching carbon
18 neutrality around 2055 (2050-2065), while limiting warming to below 2.0°C with a likely chance
19 corresponds to reaching carbon neutrality around 2070 (2060–2095). (high confidence) {3.3}
20 C2.3. Net-zero GHG emissions imply deeper emissions reductions than do net-zero CO2, and result
21 in a gradual decline of temperature over time (high confidence). The net-zero year for GHG emissions
22 is around 15 (11-24) years later than for CO2 in pathways that limit warming to below 2oC and 12 (5-
23 26) years later for pathways that limit warming to below 1.5oC (medium confidence). {3.3}
24 C2.4. In pathways that employ CO2 removal and reach net negative CO2 emissions, the remaining
25 carbon budgets up until the year of net zero-CO2 are considerably higher than cumulative CO2 emissions
26 to 2100 (high confidence). This is due to the overshoot of the carbon budget and temperature in
27 pathways with net negative CO2 emissions. {3.3, 3.5}
28 C2.5. Early mitigation of short-lived non-CO2 forcers which act as warming agents, such as CH4 and
29 black carbon, can contribute to limiting warming to a specified level. Reducing non-CO2 emissions
30 more rapidly does not avoid the need to reduce CO2 emissions to net-zero but can expand the remaining
31 carbon budget for a specific peak warming level. In deep mitigation pathways, non-CO2 forcing prior
32 to 2030 can be driven upwards by reductions in cooling aerosols, which override the effect of warming
33 agents such as methane (medium confidence). {3.5}
34 C3. This assessment draws on a set of illustrative pathways selected from those available in
35 the literature. Comparison of these shows how different socio-economic conditions, levels of
36 ambition, technology emphases, and policy choices can lead to distinctly different
37 transformations. Pathways consistent with limiting global warming to below 2°C and 1.5°C entail
38 rapid emissions reductions and a fundamental transformation of all sectors and all regions in
39 order to reach net zero CO2 emissions globally along with deep reductions in non-CO2 emissions.
40 In a global net zero CO2 emissions system, different sectors and regions may act as either sources
41 or sinks as part of an overall balance. (high confidence) (Figure SPM.7) {3.2, 3.3, 3.4, 6.6}
42 C3.1. Pathways that avoid net negative CO2 emissions (“2.0-NBZ” and “1.5-NBZ” in Figure SPM.7),
43 thus limiting temperature overshoot, require more rapid near-term emissions reductions in order to reach
44 net zero CO2 emissions earlier than in other pathways. Such pathways include some CO2 removal (e.g.,
45 afforestation) in order to compensate for remaining positive emissions in some sectors (e.g., industry).
46 (high confidence) {3.4}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-17 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 C3.2. In pathways that assume lower demand (“1.5-LD” in Figure SPM.7) or shift development
2 pathways towards sustainability (“1.5-SP” in Figure SPM.7), mitigation challenges are significantly
3 reduced. These pathways entail reduced dependence on CO2 removal, reduced pressure on land, and
4 lower carbon prices (high confidence). {3.4, 3.8, 4.3}
5 C3.3. A gradual strengthening of ambition (“2.0-GS” in Figure SPM.7) could reduce GHG emissions
6 to 10 GtCO2-eq below the level implied by current pledges by 2030. This would avoid some carbon
7 lock-ins and reduce potential disruptive developments associated with the immediate near-term
8 emissions reductions. Such gradual strengthening of ambition would keep options open to limit
9 warming to below 2°C but would place limiting warming to below 1.5°C with low overshoot out of
10 reach. (medium confidence) {3.4}
11 C3.4. In all illustrative pathways, the AFOLU and energy supply sectors reach net zero CO2 emissions
12 earlier than the buildings, industry and transport sectors. Emissions from the latter sectors remain
13 positive throughout the century in several of the illustrative pathways and are thus compensated by CO2
14 removal in the AFOLU and energy supply sectors (high confidence). (Figure SPM.7) {3.4}
15 C3.5. Different regions may reach net zero CO2 emissions at different points in time. In modelled
16 pathways, regions with higher potential for land-based mitigation tend to reach net zero CO2 emissions
17 earlier than other regions. In most scenarios that limit global warming to below 2°C or 1.5°C, all regions
18 reach net zero CO2 emissions before the 2080s. (medium confidence) (Figure SPM.7) {3.4}
19 C3.6. The growing number of published mitigation pathways aids understanding of the potential
20 contribution of technological solutions to limiting global warming. Less literature is available on low-
21 demand pathways, similar to “1.5-LD”, that emphasise mitigation potential from behavioural and
22 technological options on the demand side, and on systems-analytical studies that bring together supply-
23 and demand-side solutions in an internally consistent way (robust evidence, medium agreement). {3.3,
24 4.4}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-18 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1
2 Figure SPM.7 | Alternative net-zero CO2 emissions strategies. a. Global CO2 emissions ranges (p10-p90)
3 under baseline, <1.5oC and <2oC pathways (C1-2, C3 categories respectively), with the 11 Illustrative Pathways
4 (IPs) marked by their year of global net-zero CO2 emissions (2050-2070). b. The IPs differ with respect to the
5 net-zero CO2 emissions systems and the respective sectoral composition of CO2 emissions sources and sinks. c.
6 Timing of when individual regions reach net-zero CO2 emissions can differ considerably. d. Sectoral timing also
7 differs, with AFOLU and Energy Supply sectors decarbonising relatively earlier, balancing out residual
8 emissions in Buildings, Industry and Transport sectors (many of which may not reach net-zero by 2100).
9 #scenarios: C1: 71, C2: 82, C3: 285, Baseline: 104. Shaded ranges and boxplot whiskers show 10-90th
10 percentiles. The percentages to the right represent the proportion of assessed pathways which do not attain net-
11 zero CO2 for the region or sector in question before 2100.
12
13
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-19 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 C4. The potential for demand-side mitigation and new ways of providing services exist within,
2 and cut across, the socio-behavioural, infrastructural and technological domains. The GHG
3 emissions reduction potential in end-use sectors is as high as 50-80% in 2050. Providing basic
4 services and meeting decent living standards everywhere requires transformations in
5 infrastructure (high confidence). (Figure SPM.8) {5.3, 8.2, 9.4, 10.2, 12.4}
6 C4.1. Demand-side options in end-use sectors can reduce 50-80% of global GHG emissions by 2050
7 compared to emissions under a scenario based on stated policies. Energy end-use technologies
8 contribute most to mitigation in the transport, building and industry sectors. Physical infrastructures,
9 such as compact cities, co-location of jobs and housing, and the reallocation of street space, can
10 contribute a third of GHG emission reductions in the transport sector. In the building sector adopting
11 zero energy/carbon buildings standards, and reducing overheating and overcooling, and hot water, and
12 fitting buildings with renewable energy can all reduce GHG emissions. (high confidence) (Figure
13 SPM.8) {5.3, 8.2, 9.4, 10.2, 12.4}
14 C4.2. Lifestyle options such as heating and cooling set-point adjustments, reduced appliance use,
15 shifts to human-centred mobility and public transit, reduced air travel, and improved recycling, which
16 form part of the demand-side potential, can deliver an additional 2 GtCO2-eq savings in 2030 and 3
17 GtCO2-eq savings 2050 beyond the savings achieved in conventional technology-centric mitigation
18 scenarios (medium confidence). {5.3, Table 5.5}
19 C4.3. Smaller scale modular technologies in energy end-use and energy supply diffuse more rapidly
20 into markets, improve in cost and performance faster through technological learning, offer efficiency
21 benefits, escape technological lock-in more easily, and create more employment than centralised larger
22 scale technologies (high confidence). {5.3, 5.5, 9.8}
23 C4.4. A shift to diets with a higher share of plant-based protein in regions with excess consumption
24 of calories and animal-source food can lead to substantial reductions in GHG emissions, while also
25 providing health benefits (high confidence). Diets low in meat and dairy are already prevalent in many
26 countries and cultures and their take-up is increasing from current low levels elsewhere. Plant-based
27 diets can reduce GHG emissions by up to 50% compared to the average emission intensive Western
28 diet. {5.3, 12.4}
29 C4.5. Providing better services with less energy and resource input is possible and consistent with
30 providing wellbeing for all (medium confidence). The impacts of improved service provision on the
31 constituents of wellbeing has many more positive than negative impacts. In low-energy demand
32 scenarios, final energy demand is 40% lower in 2050 than in 2018, while wellbeing is maintained or
33 improved. {5.1, 5.2, 5.3}
34
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-20 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1
2 Figure SPM.8 | Climate change mitigation potentials classified in socio-behavioural, infrastructural, and
3 technological options can reduce GHG emissions by 50-80% in end-use sectors by 2050. Drawing on the
4 full potential requires changes in social norms, the provision in low-carbon infrastructures, and wide-range
5 adoption of granular efficient end-use technologies. Electrification of transport, building and industry sector
6 increases the demand on the electricity sector and associated indirect emissions, while demand side measures
7 and load management compensate for this increased load. Based on review of studies estimating demand-side
8 potentials associated with demand-side GHG emission reduction strategies. Reported are median values and full
9 ranges (minimal to maximal potential). To be able to give approximation for the full potential across sectors,
10 interaction effects between the three categories are ignored. Potentials are estimated against 2050 values of
11 IEA’s stated policy scenario. Data sources and explanations: see Chapter 5, Section 5.3
12
13 C5. Scenarios that limit warming to 2°C and 1.5°C imply energy system transformations over
14 the coming decades. These involve substantial reductions in fossil fuel use, major investments in
15 low-carbon energy forms, switching to low-carbon energy carriers, and energy efficiency and
16 conservation efforts. Institutional and technological ‘lock-in’ to emitting infrastructure and
17 energy system management approaches is a major risk arising from delaying mitigation action
18 beyond the 2020–2030 timeframe. (high confidence) {6.6, 6.7, 16.4}
19 C5.1. Global energy sector emissions need to decline at about 2.2–3.3% per year through to 2050 to
20 limit warming to 1.5⁰C and about 1.2–1.8% to limit warming to 2⁰C (high confidence). {6.7}
21 C5.2. Carbon-neutral energy systems can combine: zero- or negative carbon electricity systems;
22 widespread electrification of end uses; targeted use of alternative fuels such as hydrogen, bioenergy,
23 and ammonia in hard-to-decarbonise sectors; energy conservation and efficiency measures; greater
24 integration across energy systems; and use of CDR to offset emissions from hard-to-decarbonise
25 sectors. The approaches chosen would depend on national circumstances. The transformations needed
26 for carbon-neutral energy systems will not occur without changes involving technologies and
27 infrastructure, institutions, firms, and individuals. (high confidence) {6.6, 16.4}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-21 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 C5.3. Since AR5, there have been rapid improvements in key energy system technologies, notably
2 batteries, wind power, solar power, and digitalisation. Low-carbon electricity is now the cheapest option
3 in many applications. Low-carbon transitions can be more economically attractive than carbon-
4 intensive transitions in many circumstances. Nonetheless, deployment of energy system mitigation
5 options significantly lags what would be needed to limit warming to 2⁰C or 1.5⁰C. (high confidence)
6 {6.4}
7 C5.4. Low-carbon technologies will need to supply 90% or 100% of global electricity by 2050 to
8 limit warming to 2⁰C or 1.5⁰C, compared with less than 40% today. At the same time, the proportion of
9 electricity in final energy would need to increase to over 35% by 2050 to limit warming to 2°C, or by
10 40% by 2050 to limit warming to 1.5°C, compared with about 20% today. (medium confidence) {6.4}
11 C5.5. Investments in fossil infrastructure are at risk of being “stranded” if warming is limited to 2⁰C
12 or 1.5⁰C. Investments in coal generation without carbon capture are particularly vulnerable. Natural gas
13 without carbon capture is largely eliminated in scenarios with carbon-neutral energy systems. Petroleum
14 refining investments may be stranded with a move to electro-mobility. Limiting warming to 2⁰C or
15 1.5⁰C will lead to substantial reductions in the value of fossil resources. The combined economic
16 impacts of stranded fossil fuel resources and capital could amount to trillions of dollars. (high
17 confidence) {6.7}
18 C6. The majority of GHG emission reductions by 2050 in the transport sector are projected
19 to come from the electrification of light-duty vehicles. These technologies are now commercially
20 available. Further innovation in batteries, hydrogen fuel-cells, biofuels and synthetic fuels, along
21 with vehicle design and efficiency, is occurring. Emission reductions in long-haul trucking,
22 shipping and aviation will depend on substantial additional R&D and demonstration. Digital
23 substitution and changes in logistics, urban form, pricing, and behaviour can help transform all
24 transport modes. (medium confidence) {10.2, 10.3, 10.4, 10.5, 10.6}
25 C6.1. In scenarios that limit warming to 1.5°C or likely below 2°C GHG emission reductions in the
26 transport sector are in the range 20% to 80% (10th to 90th percentile) i.e., from 1.8 to 7.2 GtCO2 yr-1.
27 Greater reductions are possible in electrified cars, bikes, tuk-tuks, motorbikes, and buses where
28 technology is already commercial. With expanded low-carbon electricity infrastructure, electro-
29 mobility can allow leapfrogging in developing countries. Long-range heavy vehicles (trucks, ships,
30 planes) will likely require substantial R&D breakthroughs and policy interventions. Technologies for
31 this vehicle segment are not yet commercial. (medium confidence) {3.4, 10.3, 10.4}
32 C6.2. Alternatives to oil-based mobility since AR5 are due mostly to battery technology. Further
33 improvements in material and energy efficiency in battery production and recycling will reduce critical
34 mineral risks and the environmental footprint of electrification. Novel battery chemistries with higher
35 energy density, along with hydrogen, biofuels, and synthetic fuels, are emerging as commercial options
36 for all transport modes. (medium confidence) {6.3, 10.3}
37 C6.3. Demand reduction programs, energy efficiency, and infrastructure improvements continue to
38 assist GHG mitigation in passenger and freight systems. Enabling transit, active transport, local shared
39 mobility, and associated urban planning and land use, with digital communication replacing the need to
40 travel, would help transformative change in all transport modes. (medium confidence) {5.3, 10.2}
41 C6.4. Technologies are not yet commercial for transformative reductions in shipping, aviation, and
42 long-haul trucking GHG emissions. Substantially more R&D into alternative fuels, especially drop-in
43 fuels, alongside policy interventions, could increase the options available. Reviewing governance
44 arrangements for emissions from international transport would assist this process. (medium confidence)
45 {10.4, 10.5, 10.6, 16}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-22 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 C7. There is a large emissions reduction potential associated with existing urban and rural
2 settlements and scope to avoid emissions from settlements yet to be built, including the design,
3 size and use of buildings. The scale and pace of urbanisation around the world risks carbon lock-
4 in but also provides an opportunity to design and build low-carbon cities conducive to low-carbon
5 lifestyles and technologies. (high confidence) {8.2, 9.3, 9.4, 9.5}
6 C7.1. Building new cities could require 90 billion tonnes of raw materials per year by 2050 in a
7 baseline scenario, up from 40 billion tonnes in 2010. Embodied emissions from construction materials
8 represented 18% of total GHG emissions from the building sector in 2018. Embodied emissions can be
9 reduced through extending the lifetime of buildings and their components and reducing waste. Using
10 bio-based/wood-based materials and nature-based solutions are opportunities for temporary carbon
11 storage in buildings (medium confidence). In scenarios likely to limit global warming to 2°C or below
12 while meeting sustainable development goals, indirect emissions would be reduced by 91%, direct
13 emissions reduced by 69%, and embodied emissions by 31%. This reflects the expected role of
14 embodied emissions if the zero energy/carbon concept is applied. (medium confidence) {8.3, 9.3, 9.4,
15 9.5}
16 C7.2. Decarbonisation of the building sector requires: sufficiency measures, such as building design,
17 size and use, to reduce the demand for energy and materials; efficiency measures to reduce energy
18 consumption by providing access to the best available technologies; and on-site renewables to address
19 remaining energy demand. Buildings are moving from a passive to an active role in the energy system,
20 generating decarbonised power that can contribute to the flexibility of the energy system. Direct F-gas
21 emissions from heating and cooling systems can, with policy support, be addressed through
22 technological solutions. (high confidence) {9.4, 9.5, 9.10}
23 C7.3. Reducing urban per capita emissions through resource-efficient and compact urban growth
24 would help offset increases in urban population (high confidence). Urban and land-use planning that
25 prioritises resource-efficient infrastructure, promotes strategic densification, and creates compact,
26 walkable neighbourhoods connected by transit, with associated price instruments can reduce urban
27 energy use and GHG emissions by 36-54% in 2050, compared to a “business-as-usual” baseline
28 (medium confidence). {8.2, 8.3, 8.4, 8.5, 8.6, 8.7}
29 C7.4. Nature-based solutions to mitigate climate change, such as urban forestry and green
30 infrastructure can sequester carbon while achieving multiple co-benefits (high confidence). Green roofs
31 and green facades, networks of parks and open spaces, protection of urban nature, urban agriculture,
32 and water-sensitive design offer a wide range of adaptation co-benefits including flood mitigation,
33 reduced pressure on urban sewer systems, reduced urban heat island effects, and public health (high
34 confidence). {8.4}
35 C8. Reaching zero GHG emissions from industry would require coordinated action
36 throughout value chains and take-up of the full range of mitigation options. These include: end-
37 use demand management; energy and materials efficiency; circular material flows; emission free
38 electricity, fuel and feedstock; and carbon capture storage and utilisation. (high confidence) {11.2,
39 11.3, 11.4}
40 C8.1. The basic materials industries account for 60-70% of industrial GHG and CO2-emissions.
41 Material intensity, defined as the stock of manufactured capital per unit of GDP, is increasing as demand
42 for higher material living standards increases. Per capita material stocks in several developed countries
43 have saturated. (high confidence) {11.2}
44 C8.2. Emissions from the production of primary materials could reach zero or become negative with
45 combinations of direct and indirect electrification, biofuels, CCU and CCS. This could involve higher
46 production costs but small increases in costs to final consumers. Many technology options are in pilot
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-23 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 stages and require intensive commercialisation efforts. A transition of industry towards zero emissions
2 requires substantial scaling up of electricity, gas, hydrogen, recycling, and other infrastructure. It also
3 entails the phase-out of blast furnaces in steelmaking and conversion of chemical industries to low GHG
4 feedstocks and fuels. (high confidence) {11.3}
5 C8.3. Some scenarios achieve close to net zero emissions from the most energy intensive industries
6 (steel, chemicals, and cement) by 2050. Reduced materials demand, more recycling, and electrification
7 can lower mitigation costs and the need for CCS, but these options are not well represented in published
8 scenarios. Demand for plastics has been growing more than for any other material since 1970.
9 Mitigation challenges include the more than 99% reliance on fossil feedstocks, very low recycling rates,
10 and high petrochemical process emissions. At the same time, plastics can also help reduce emissions,
11 for example, as an insulation material in power cables or for preserving food. There are no shared
12 visions for fossil-free plastics. (high confidence) {11.4, Box 11.2}
13 C8.4. Demand management, materials efficiency and more circular material flows can substantially
14 reduce the demand for virgin basic materials (e.g., steel, cement, aluminium, and plastics) and
15 associated emissions, but are less explored and practically applied than other mitigation options (high
16 confidence). {11.3, 11.4}
17 C8.5. Reaching zero emissions may reshape where energy intensive industry is located, how value
18 chains are organised, and what gets transported. Regions with bountiful solar and wind resources, or
19 methane co-located with CCS geology, may become exporters of hydrogen, hydrogen carriers, and
20 energy intensive basic materials. (medium confidence) {Box 11.1}
21 C8.6. Light industry and manufacturing can be largely decarbonised through switching to low GHG
22 fuels (e.g., biofuels and hydrogen) and electricity (e.g., for electrothermal heating and heat pumps) (high
23 confidence). {11.4, Table 11.4}
24 C9. The Agriculture, Forestry and Other Land Use (AFOLU) sector can provide large-scale
25 GHG emission reductions and land-based CDR at relatively low cost, but cannot compensate for
26 slow mitigation in other sectors. The provision of renewable resources can facilitate mitigation in
27 other sectors through substitution for fossil fuels and other GHG-intensive products (high
28 confidence). Implementation is challenging and context specific. Achieving sustained results,
29 under climate change pressures, while maximising co-benefits related to food and fibre
30 security, social and biological diversity, ecosystem services and sustainable development, requires
31 appropriate country specific policies and significant investment. {7.4, 7.6, 7.7, 12.5, 12.6}
32 C9.1. The mitigation potential from AFOLU is approximately 9±3 GtCO2-eq yr-1 between 2020 and
33 2050 at a cost of up to 100 USD/tCO2-eq (medium confidence). Reduced land conversion/increased
34 land protection, enhanced management, and restoration of forests, wetlands, savannas and grasslands
35 can reduce emissions and/or sequester carbon by 6.1±2.9 GtCO2-eq yr-1. The agriculture mitigation
36 potential from soil carbon management in croplands and grasslands, agroforestry, biochar, rice
37 cultivation, and livestock and nutrient management is 3.9±0.2 GtCO2-eq yr-1. Demand-side measures
38 including shifting to plant-based diets and reducing food waste, can provide 1.9 GtCO2-eq yr-1 potential
39 through diverted agricultural production (excluding land-use change). In scenarios published since
40 SR1.5, the mitigation estimate from CCS (BECCS) has fallen and is now 0.8 median (0–6.3)
41 GtCO2 yr-1 in 2050. Bioenergy (especially from side streams) can have substitution effects in the energy
42 and transport sectors of 2.8–7.0 GtCO2 yr-1 (medium confidence). {7.4}
43 C9.2. In scenarios that limit warming to 1.5⁰C and 2⁰C, global mitigation efforts in AFOLU are
44 increased 5-fold within the next decade, and more than 10-fold by 2050. Given current institutional and
45 policy constraints, an estimated investment shift of more than $400 billion yr-1 and potential trade-offs
46 with other ecosystem services, this level of abatement is difficult to achieve despite the technical
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-24 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 potential (high confidence). AFOLU is challenging because of its decentralised nature and the distinct
2 value systems associated with land tenure and management, with millions of landowners under diverse
3 cultural, economic and political circumstances (high confidence). {7.5, 7.6}
4 C9.3. Agricultural land requirements may be reduced through sustainable intensification, reduced
5 food loss and wastes, and dietary change (medium confidence). Active management approaches that
6 maintain carbon stocks on the land while sufficiently producing food, feed, fuel and fibre can deliver
7 mitigation while making land available for other uses, including agricultural and forestry renewables
8 resources. {7.4, 7.7}
9 C9.4. Improved quantification of land-based mitigation activities and their additionality in recent
10 years has provided better insights about where and which land-based activities can be implemented,
11 their positive and negative interactions mitigation activities with other ecosystem services, and their
12 potential costs. These data products and new technologies will allow a wider array of actors, including
13 private businesses to take more meaningful actions and provide funding (medium confidence). The
14 move to ‘net zero’ cities, buildings, industries and organisations is expected to increase the financing
15 for carbon offsets and production of renewable materials in the AFOLU sector (high confidence). {7.4}
16 C10. Carbon dioxide removal (CDR) is necessary to achieve net zero GHG emissions and is an
17 element in most scenarios that limit warming to 1.5°C–2°C by 2100 (high confidence). The
18 amount of CDR deployment depends largely on supply- and demand-side emission reductions.
19 CDR options vary in their mitigation potentials, technology readiness, co-benefits and trade-offs
20 with other societal goals, and governance requirements. {12.3, 12.7}
21 C10.1. In the context of net zero emissions, CDR can counterbalance residual GHG emissions that
22 are difficult to abate (e.g., from, aviation, shipping, agriculture and some industrial activities). CDR
23 could also provide net negative emissions at the global level enabling the return from temporary
24 overshoot of temperature thresholds. {12.3}
25 C10.2. Biological CDR methods are generally less expensive but more vulnerable to reversal than
26 technological approaches. Some biological methods such as afforestation/reforestation or ecosystems
27 restoration (e.g., wetlands) have long been practiced. Practical experience with technological
28 approaches such as, Direct Air Capture and Carbon Storage (DACCS), Enhanced Mineral Weathering
29 or Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement, or hybrid approaches such as BECCS, is still limited, with greater
30 needs for R&D. {7.4, 12.3}
31 C10.3. The potential for DACCS is limited primarily by access to low carbon energy and cost (60-500
32 USD tCO2-1). Enhanced Weathering has the potential to remove 4-100 GtCO2 yr-1, at costs ranging from
33 24–578 USD tCO2-1. Ocean-based approaches have the potential to remove 1–100 GtCO2 yr-1 at costs
34 of 40-500 USD tCO2-1 (medium confidence). {12.3}
35 C10.4. Governance challenges for CDR options at the national level are not fundamentally different
36 from those for emissions reduction measures. CDR options may have positive or adverse side effects
37 on ecosystem services and the SDGs. Incentivising CDR is currently hampered by a range of socio-
38 economic, technical and governance barriers (medium confidence). {12.3, 12.7}
39 C11. Achieving ambitious mitigation depends on costs as well as on overcoming a wider range
40 of societal feasibility challenges. Mitigation likely to limit global warming to below 2⁰C may affect
41 global GDP growth by less than 0.1 percentage points per year, without accounting for the co-
42 benefits of mitigation, and the benefits of avoided climate change impacts. Costs in each sector
43 depend on the realised mitigation potential; in aggregate, low-cost abatement options could
44 reduce emissions by more than 50% below 2018 levels by 2030. Early action and a diversified
45 mitigation portfolio can smooth out feasibility challenges and reduce disruptions, while delayed
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-25 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 action increases challenges to both economic and societal feasibility after 2030. (high confidence)
2 (Figure SPM.9, Figure SPM.10) {3.6, 3.8, 12.2, 12.3}
3 C11.1. The total mitigation potential achievable by the year 2030, based on sectoral assessments, is
4 sufficient to reduce global GHG emissions to half of their 2018 level. Options with mitigation costs
5 lower than USD 20 tCO2-1 make up more than half of this potential, and some have benefits that exceed
6 costs. The potential for such options has increased since AR5. Low-cost options are available for all
7 sectors. (high agreement, medium evidence) (Figure SPM.9) {12.2}
8 C11.2. Pathways likely to limit global warming to below 2˚C entail losses in global GDP between 1.6%
9 and 3.5% of baseline levels in 2050, and between 2.1% and 4.3% in pathways that are likely to limit
10 global warming to below 1.5⁰C with or without temperature overshoot. The aggregate economic costs
11 of least-cost mitigation pathways likely to limit warming to 2°C are likely to be smaller over the long-
12 term than the aggregate economic benefits in terms of avoided impacts, even without accounting for
13 the co-benefits of mitigation and non-market damages from climate change. These monetary estimates
14 undervalue impacts on the well-being of poorer households and countries. (high confidence) {3.6}
15 C11.3. Modelled mitigation pathways which limit global warming to 1.5⁰C or likely 2⁰C without
16 temperature overshoot are characterised by high upfront investments and rapid near-term
17 transformations, but have lower long-term costs than those with temperature overshoot. The modelled
18 cost-optimal balance of mitigation effort over time strongly depends on the social discount rate used.
19 Lower discount rates favour earlier mitigation, reducing both temperature overshoot and reliance on net
20 negative carbon emissions. {3.6}
21 C11.4. The feasibility challenges associated with response options depend on sector-specific enabling
22 conditions and barriers. Solar energy, wind energy, demand side management, changes in building
23 construction methods, fuel efficiency, electromobility and transitions in urban systems generally
24 experience more enabling conditions and face fewer barriers than nuclear energy and technological
25 CDR options (high confidence). (Figure SPM.10) {Table 12.2, 12.3}
26 C11.5. The feasibility of transitions at the system level is context-specific and depends on development
27 levels and institutional capacity. Feasibility challenges are linked to emission reduction rates rather than
28 emission levels. Early action to mitigate climate change can smooth out feasibility challenges and
29 reduce disruptions, and avoid increasing challenges to feasibility beyond 2030. A diversified portfolio
30 of mitigation options can improve the feasibility of transitions at the system level (high confidence).
31 (Figure SPM.10) {3.8, Cross-Chapter Box 4 in Chapter 4}
32
33
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-26 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1
2 Figure SPM.9 | Overview of emission reduction options per sector, providing an indicative value of the emission reduction potential in 2030 (GtCO2-eq), broken
3 down into cost categories. {Table 12.2}
4
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-27 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1
2 Figure SPM.10 | Feasibility challenges of sectoral transitions and system wide changes: The left panel
3 shows that the feasibility of response options depends on geophysical, environmental, technological, economic,
4 social and institutional enabling conditions and barriers which vary across sectors. The right panel shows the
5 time evolution of a composite indicator of feasibility challenges, aggregating multi-dimensional metrics
6 computed from AR6 scenarios compatible with 1.5°C-2°C end-of-century temperatures. The 'black' and 'grey'
7 lines represent averages of scenarios with global climate policy starting in 2020 or in 2030 respectively. {3.8,
8 6.4, 7.4, 8.6, 9.10, 10.8, 11.4, 12.3}
9
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-28 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 D. Mitigation, adaptation, and sustainable development
2 D1. Ambitious mitigation and development goals cannot be met through incremental change.
3 Shifting development pathways towards sustainability opens up a wider range of options than
4 focusing on mitigation alone (medium evidence, high agreement). The way countries develop
5 determines their capacity to accelerate mitigation and at the same time achieve other sustainable
6 development objectives (medium confidence). (Figure SPM.1) {Cross-Chapter Box 4 in Chapter
7 4, 4.3}
8 D 1.1. In the absence of climate mitigation, development objectives are likely to be compromised.
9 With the careful design of mitigation policies, reducing GHG emissions and the achievement of other
10 development objectives can go hand in hand. Mitigation may nevertheless entail trade-offs with the
11 achievement of other national development objectives, which need to be addressed in policy
12 implementation. Conflicts between mitigation and other development objectives can act as an
13 impediment to climate action and can be amplified by vested interests. {Cross-Chapter Box 4 in Chapter
14 4, 4.3, 13.2}
15 D 1.2. Continuing along existing development pathways is unlikely to achieve rapid and deep emission
16 reductions. Mitigation conceived as incremental change would achieve less than approaches which
17 broaden the set of levers and enablers of transformational change. Adopting policy packages aimed at
18 shifting development pathways towards sustainability opens up opportunities to achieve multiple
19 development objectives, including climate mitigation, simultaneously (medium confidence). Pathways
20 in which policies are designed to reach multiple sustainable development objectives can in some cases
21 entail additional costs that are lower than the benefits. {3.6, 4.3, 13.8, 13.9, WGII SPM}
22 D 1.3. Choices made by decision-makers, citizens, the private sector and social stakeholders can
23 influence societies’ development pathways. Such shifts can be enabled by drawing upon a range of
24 policies and actions going beyond mitigation. Shifting development pathways entails fundamental
25 changes in energy, urban, building, industrial, transport, and land-based systems, as well as changes in
26 behaviour and social practices. Overcoming inertia and locked-in practices may face opposition. The
27 necessary transformational changes are likely to be more acceptable if rooted in the development
28 aspirations of the economy and society within which they take place (medium confidence). {13.8}
29 D2. Transition pathways entail distributional consequences such as changes in employment
30 and economic structure (high confidence). Pathways that prioritise equity and allow broad
31 stakeholder participation can enable broader consensus for the transformational changes implied
32 by deeper mitigation efforts (high evidence, medium agreement). {4.3, 4.5, 13.2, 17.3, 17.4}
33 D 2.1. Transition pathways depend on countries’ specific resource endowments, equity considerations,
34 existing development patterns, the speed of action, and context-specific issues that may enable or act as
35 a barrier. They may imply large employment and economic structural changes, and stranded assets, and
36 may have distributional consequences (high confidence). Ambitious mitigation pathways will affect
37 industries, individuals, and societies that depend on fossil revenues and fossil-related jobs with
38 particular challenges in developing countries. {4.3, 4.5, 17.3}
39 D 2.2. The just transition concept has become recognised internationally, tying together social
40 movements, trade unions, and other key stakeholders to ensure equity is better accounted for in low-
41 carbon transitions. Just transitions at international, national, regional and local scales can ensure that
42 workers, frontline communities and the vulnerable are not left behind in low-carbon pathways (medium
43 confidence). Estimates show larger employment opportunities associated with cleaner forms of energy
44 than fossil fuels. In the land sector, mitigation is most successful where synergies with other functions
45 of land are addressed in an equitable manner. {4.5, 6.3, 7.4,17.3}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-29 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 D 2.3. Lack of integration of environmental justice in climate mitigation activities, including inclusive
2 participation and distribution of institutional capacities, risks growing inequality at all levels. Pathways
3 that take into account equity can enable broader consensus for the transformational changes implied by
4 deeper mitigation efforts. (high confidence). Equity and justice are important enabling conditions for
5 effective climate mitigation. Institutions and governance that address equity and supporting narratives
6 that promote just transitions can build broader support for climate policymaking (medium confidence).
7 Multiple countries now have ‘Just Transition’ institutions or framework agreements. {4.5, Figure 4.10,
8 13.2, 13.3, 13.6, 13.8, 13.9, 17.4}.
9 D3. Mitigation options are linked to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in multiple
10 ways, involving both synergies and trade-offs. The linkages are context specific, depending on the
11 sector, the timing of mitigation actions, policy design and effectiveness. Many adverse linkages
12 can be compensated or avoided with complementary policies, integrated cross sectoral responses,
13 finance, and partnerships (medium confidence). {5.3, 7.4, 9.8, 10.1, 11.5, 12.4, 12.6, 13.8, 17.1, 17.3}
14 D 3.1. Ambitious mitigation is a pre-requisite for achieving the SDGs, with particular challenges in
15 relation to vulnerable populations and ecosystems whose capacity to adapt to climate impacts is limited
16 (medium confidence). Synergies and trade-offs between mitigation and sustainable development
17 concern access to food, water and energy and rivalry for resources. Synergies and trade-offs can result
18 directly from mitigation action in a given sector or indirectly from mitigation actions in other sectors.
19 {3.7, 12.6, 13.8, 17.1, 17.3}
20 D 3.2. In the building sector, energy efficiency and integration of renewable energy contribute to
21 achieving almost all SDGs (high confidence). In the transport sector, the adoption of electro-mobility,
22 shifts to public transport and active travel can benefit air quality, health, improve access to education
23 and financial services and promote gender equality (medium confidence). In the AFOLU sector,
24 agroforestry, avoided deforestation and reforestation can provide land carbon storage and biomass for
25 multiple uses, while enhancing biodiversity and essential ecosystem services. Practices such as soil and
26 livestock management can promote conservation of biodiversity and ecosystem services as well as
27 human well-being. Depending on the starting point, dietary choices involving food with low GHG
28 emissions can be associated with health co-benefits (high confidence). (Figure SPM.11) {5.3, 7.4, 9.8,
29 10.1, 12.4}
30 D 3.3. Potential trade-offs between mitigation measures and sustainable development exist in areas
31 such as employment, food deprivation, water stress, land use, biodiversity and local building materials,
32 as well as access to and the affordability of energy, food and water. If deployed poorly, AFOLU options
33 that displace other land uses, such as widespread planting of monoculture plantations providing biomass
34 for biochar, bioenergy and other biobased products, can cause negative outcomes for food security and
35 other aspects of sustainable development. At very high deployment, bioenergy with CCS (BECCS)
36 could lead to adverse side effects (medium confidence). Trade-offs can be addressed by complementary
37 policies and investments or with the design of integrated cross sectoral policies (medium confidence).
38 (Figure SPM.11) {3.7, 7.4, 17.1, 3.7}
39 D 3.4. Increasing welfare and meeting the SDGs implies an increase in demand for materials, products
40 and services. Meeting demands for renewable materials and products and access to services has positive
41 impacts on human wellbeing and participation in mitigative action. Literature published since AR5
42 shows that decent living standards, encompassing many SDG dimensions, are achievable with lower
43 energy use. Development pathways involving lower energy demand and greater use of land-based
44 resources have overall lower trade-offs with sustainable development than those involving high levels
45 of energy demand and large-scale deployment of CDR. (medium confidence) {5.2, 11.5}
46
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-30 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1
2
3 Figure SPM.11 | Impact of mitigation options on SDGs. Trade-offs and synergies between sectoral mitigation
4 options and the SDGs. Dark blue implies that synergies are expected, light blue that both synergies and trade-
5 offs could be expected, and brown/red that trade-offs can be expected. Grey is used to indicate that the measure
6 is not applicable for the particular SDG based on the literature.
7
8
9 D4. Some response options have implications for both adaptation and mitigation, involving
10 both synergies and trade-offs. Integrated approaches to adaptation and mitigation planning and
11 implementation could lead to more efficient and cost-effective policies aligned with sustainable
12 development, providing trade-offs are identified and addressed. {13.8, 17.1, 17.3}
13 D 4.1. Both climate change mitigation and adaptation are scale dependent and context specific.
14 Especially in developing countries, there is a strong link between sustainable development, vulnerability
15 and climate risk because limited economic, social and institutional resources can result in low adaptive
16 capacities (high confidence). Resource constraints also lead to low capacities in relation to climate
17 change mitigation. {17.3}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-31 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 D 4.2. Many mitigation actions in urban settlements have adaptation benefits. Green roofs and green
2 facades, networks of parks and open spaces, protection of urban nature (e.g., forests and wetlands),
3 urban agriculture, and water-sensitive design can support flood mitigation, reduced pressure on urban
4 sewer system and reduce urban heat island effects. {8.2}
5 D 4.3. Many land-related actions that contribute to climate change mitigation can also contribute to
6 adaptation, combatting desertification and land degradation, enhancing food security through increases
7 in yields, and improving resilience by maintaining the productivity of the land. Restoration of
8 mangroves and coastal wetlands increases carbon sinks, reduces coastal erosion and protects from storm
9 surges, and can also mitigate the impacts of sea level rise and extreme weather along the coastline (high
10 confidence). Careful integration of mitigation options with existing land uses helps to minimise trade-
11 offs and maximise synergies (medium confidence). {4.4, 12.5, 13.8}
12 D 4.4. Some mitigation options in the agriculture, food and land use sectors have mixed impacts on
13 food and water access, and poverty alleviation, despite having positive mitigation and adaptation
14 impacts. These include agroforestry and large-scale bioenergy plantations. Fast growing monocultures
15 and hydropower plants can compromise food and water access and poverty alleviation. {17.3}
16 D 4.5. Financial, technical and human resources for implementing joint mitigation and adaptation are
17 limited. International climate finance has been dominated by mitigation projects. Financial constraints
18 in relation to joint mitigation and adaptation relating to the agricultural and forestry sectors apply to
19 green funds, government organisations and international climate finance, including multilateral
20 development banks. {17.3}
21
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-32 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 E. Strengthening the response
2 E1. Accelerated system transitions consistent with sustainable development can be supported
3 by enhancing enabling conditions, including governance and institutions, international
4 cooperation, policy instruments, finance and investment, innovation, capacity building, and
5 behaviour and lifestyle change. Successful system transitions require different combinations of
6 enabling conditions that depend on local contexts. No single enabling condition, nor any single
7 policy instrument, is sufficient. (very high confidence) {3.8, 4.4, 5.6, 13.9, 13.2, 15.6, 16.5, 17.4}
8 E 1.1. Stringent mitigation pathways are associated with accelerated system transitions. Different
9 emission pathways face different feasibility challenges and patterns of lock-in. Context-dependent
10 combinations of enabling conditions can accelerate and strengthen system transitions, initiate self-
11 reinforcing dynamics, and overcome barriers, realising both mitigation and broader sustainable
12 development goals (high confidence). {3.8, 4.4, 13.8, 13.9, 17.4}
13 E 1.2. Strong institutions and governance arrangements enable ambitious climate action and can help
14 bridge implementation gaps. Key challenges include strategy setting, coordination and mediating
15 divergent interests. Climate governance includes both direct efforts to target greenhouse gas emissions,
16 as well as mitigation outcomes resulting from efforts that achieve multiple mitigation and development
17 objectives. (medium confidence) {13.2, 13.4, 13.8}
18 E 1.3. Governance for climate mitigation and shifting development pathways is enhanced when
19 tailored to national and local contexts. Climate governance is impacted by material endowments,
20 cultural-institutional understandings, levels of economic development, domestic political systems, and
21 national regulatory systems. (very high confidence). Sub-national and urban actors are playing a
22 growing role, reflecting local concerns and context in decision-making and stimulating experimentation
23 (high confidence). {13.2, 13.3, 13.4, 13.5, 13.8}
24 E2. Accelerating action on climate mitigation and shifting development pathways requires the
25 presence of enabling conditions that integrate policy goals and cross-society responses to meet
26 multiple, linked objectives. Policy mixes can help address multiple objectives. (very high
27 confidence) {9.9, 13.6, 13.7, 13.8, 13.9, 16.5}
28 E 2.1. Climate legislation can incentivise mitigation by providing directional signals to actors via:
29 targets; creating institutions and legally enforceable implementation mechanisms; enabling
30 coordination; creating a basis for transparency and accountability; mainstreaming mitigation into
31 development processes; establishing and reinforcing changes in technology and infrastructure; and
32 creating focal points for collective action (medium confidence). {13.2}
33 E 2.2. Market-based instruments are increasingly prevalent, with carbon pricing covering about 20%
34 of global CO2 emissions (high confidence). Design decisions such as coverage, exemptions,
35 adjustments to the emissions cap or tax level and redistribution of the revenue generated affect the
36 outcome of these instruments. Carbon pricing is most effective if implemented along principles of
37 fairness and equity. Earmarking revenue for green infrastructures or transparently returning it to
38 taxpayers increases the political acceptability of carbon pricing (high confidence). {5.4, 9.9, 13.6}
39 E 2.3. Regulatory instruments can play an important role in mitigation. Financial incentives and
40 regulations have contributed to cost reductions and increases in the deployment of renewable energy
41 (high confidence). Voluntary approaches may also reduce GHG emissions and support transformation
42 towards low emissions systems (medium confidence). {9.9, 13.6}
43 E 2.4. International interactions of national mitigation policies can both negatively and positively
44 impact other countries. Reductions in quantities and prices of fossil fuels produced and exported and
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-33 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 the value of fossil fuel assets tend to negatively affect other countries (medium confidence). Markets
2 for emission reduction credits and spill over effects from technology development and diffusion tend to
3 benefit other countries (high confidence). Emissions ‘leakage’ – the change in emissions arising from
4 shifts in production, consumption and investment elsewhere as a result of mitigation policies in one
5 country – has been limited in practice (high confidence). {13.7}
6 E 2.5. Climate mitigation, shifting development pathways, and exploiting synergies between multiple
7 objectives can be achieved by integrating policy across different domains. Well-designed policy mixes
8 can address multiple objectives and enable a transition, if they are comprehensive, balanced across
9 objectives, and consistent in terms of design. (very high confidence) {13.8, 13.9, 16.5}
10 E3. People act and contribute to climate change mitigation as consumers, role models,
11 citizens, investors, and professionals. In all roles, individuals can contribute to overcoming
12 barriers and enable climate change mitigation. (high confidence). Individual behavioural change
13 in isolation cannot reduce GHG emissions significantly (medium confidence). {5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 5.5,
14 5.6, 9.9, 13.2, 13.5, 13.8}
15 E 3.1. Social, infrastructural, and cultural lock-in can act as a barrier to change at individual and
16 sectoral levels. Behavioural change cannot reduce GHG emissions significantly if it is not embedded in
17 structural, cultural and institutional change (medium confidence). Behavioural nudges, choice
18 architectures and the provision of information can make modest contributions to reduce GHG emissions
19 at the individual level, and work in synergy with price signals. The coordination of policies, choice
20 architectures, physical infrastructures, new technologies and related business models could realise rapid
21 system-level change (medium confidence). {5.4, 5.4.5.1, 5.5, 9.9, 13.8}
22 E 3.2. Intermediaries such as building managers, landlords, energy efficiency advisers, technology
23 installers and car dealers can influence patterns of mobility and energy consumption by establishing
24 low-carbon professional standards and practices (medium confidence). Providing them with greater
25 capacity and motivation to play these roles enables climate mitigation. Individuals with high socio-
26 economic status have the capacity and the flexibility to reduce their GHG emissions by, for example,
27 avoiding flying, living car free, switching to electro-mobility, becoming role models for low-carbon
28 lifestyles, investing in low-carbon businesses, and actively supporting ambitious climate policies. If 10-
29 30% of the population were to demonstrate commitment to low-carbon technologies, behaviours, and
30 lifestyles, new social norms would be established (high confidence). {5.2, 5.4, 5.5, 5.6, 9.9, 16.4}
31 E 3.3. Social equity increases social trust and thus the capacity for good governance and the
32 implementation of direct mitigation efforts as well as those embedded in multiple objectives. Mitigation
33 policies that take account of diverse perspectives and knowledge bases can build social trust, establish
34 new coalitions and legitimise change, thus initiating a self-reinforcing cycle in governance capacity and
35 policy development (high confidence). Increasing the participation of women, and racialised and
36 marginalised groups, amplifies the impetus for climate action. Collective action through formal social
37 movements and informal lifestyle movements expands the potential for climate policy and supports
38 system change. (high confidence). Climate strikes have given voice to youth in more than 180 countries.
39 {5.2, 5.4, 5.5, 5.6, 13.5, 13.8}.
40 E4. Effective international cooperation, including financial flows, technology development
41 and transfer, and capacity-building for developing country parties, particularly the least
42 developed and most vulnerable, can support ambitious climate goals. New forms of international
43 cooperation have emerged since AR5 in line with an evolving understanding of effective
44 mitigation policies, processes, and institutions. (high confidence) {14.1, 14.2, 14.3, 14.4, 14.5, 14.6}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-34 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 E 4.1. International cooperation is a driver of enhanced national ambition and is a pre-requisite for the
2 fulfilment of many national pledges. International cooperation enables and strengthens national and
3 sub-national action, at multiple levels involving diverse actors. (high confidence) {14.3, 14.4, 14.6}
4 E 4.2. The Paris Agreement’s enhanced transparency-related requirements, and the increased
5 information flow, enables adequacy assessments and comparisons by diverse actors at multiple levels.
6 The extent to which transparency requirements lead countries to increase the ambition of and implement
7 their pledges will depend in part on the successful implementation of other forms of international
8 cooperation. (medium confidence) {14.3, 14.4}
9 E 4.3. Transnational partnerships involving a range of non-state actors, including cities, non-
10 governmental organisations, and private sector entities are playing a growing role in stimulating low-
11 carbon technology diffusion and emissions reductions (medium confidence). {13.3, 14.2, 14.5}
12 E 4.4. Some sectoral agreements and institutions focus on reducing emissions and help push sectors
13 on to a low-carbon development pathway. Others, particularly related to trade and investment, tend to
14 reinforce the prominence of fossil fuels in specific sectors. At the national scale, smaller-scale efforts
15 have been more effective than REDD+ in achieving emissions reductions from deforestation. (medium
16 confidence) {14.5, 14.6}
17 E 4.5. The ability of countries to produce clean technologies domestically depends on the complexity
18 of the technologies, domestic capabilities, and the policy framework (medium confidence). International
19 cooperation can play a role in building global capacity, adapting technologies to local conditions, and
20 developing local innovation, analysis and transition planning capabilities. Enhancing financial support
21 through existing or other arrangements for technology development and transfer may contribute to
22 improving their implementation and effectiveness. The lack of enhanced action on technology and
23 capacity building has the potential to undermine climate ambition and action. (high confidence) {16.5,
24 16.6}
25 E5. Financial flows fall short of what is needed to achieve climate goals across all sectors and
26 regions. The ability to mobilise finance varies substantially by country, resulting in a varied
27 outlook for the accelerated deployment of funding (high confidence). Political leadership and
28 signalling, along with fiscal interventions and central bank regulation can facilitate the role of
29 finance in tackling climate change (medium confidence). (Figure SPM.12) {14.4, 15.2, 15.3, 15.4,
30 15.5, 15.6}
31 E 5.1. Current financial flows across all sectors and regions are not consistent with climate goals (high
32 confidence). In particular, international climate finance flows are not on track to meet goals established
33 under the UNFCCC, including mobilisation by 2020 of USD 100 billion per year and progression
34 beyond previous efforts. This has the potential to undermine climate ambition and action. (high
35 confidence) {14.4, 15.1, 15.2, 15.3, 15.4}
36 E 5.2. Near-term barriers to increased funding include rising levels of income inequality,
37 macroeconomic uncertainty, mismatch between capital and investment needs, and bias towards
38 investing in domestic markets. Substantially increased levels of credible public finance commitments
39 are a crucial element of a just transition. (high confidence). COVID-19 is exacerbating national
40 differences in terms of fiscal headroom and the ability to tap capital markets and is burdening many
41 developing countries. {15.2, 15.5}
42 E 5.3. A strong alignment of COVID-19 recovery packages with climate targets has the potential to
43 address financing needs efficiently, and to reduce lock-in effects. This reduces the burden for taxpayers
44 in the mid-term (high confidence). Misalignment bears a substantial risk of an increase in stranded
45 assets. {Cross Chapter Box 1 in Chapter 1, 15.2, 15.5}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-35 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
1 E 5.4. Aligning financial sector and real economy regulation will facilitate an accelerated
2 transformation of the financial sector. Relying only on financial sector regulation and the financial
3 sector’s own initiatives is unlikely to result in substantial progress in the short-term (medium
4 confidence). Credible signaling by governments and the international community reduces uncertainty
5 for financial decision makers and closes transition risk gaps (high confidence). The role of the financial
6 sector as an enabler of climate action can be strengthened through political leadership and intervention
7 that ensures an alignment between the financial sector and mitigation policies (high confidence). {15.6}
8 E 5.5. Given the inertia of the financial system, its vulnerability to physical and transition climate risk
9 in terms of financial stability as well as current lengthy cycles between the commitment and
10 disbursement of international public climate financing, short-term action is required to meet 2030
11 funding needs. {15.2, 15.5}
Sector Type of Economy
Mitigation Needs and Flows Mitigation Needs Needs Flows GDP
Figure SPM.12: Breakdown of average investment needs until 2030.
Left chart: Inner boundary represents current flows (mean average of 2017 and 2018), outer boundary represents
average mitigation investment needs until 2030. Wing area in between represents resulting finance gaps by sector.
Agriculture and Forests (USD 145 billion) are based on The Food and Land Use Coalition adjusted for higher
afforestation needs based on New Forest Declaration Progress Reports. Energy Efficiency needs (USD 1099
billion) are based on IRENA (2020). Electricity sector needs (USD 974 billion), including T&D and storage, are
derived from the AR6 scenario database. These are estimated as the incremental investment needs for pathways
which limit warming to 1.75°C–2.25°C compared with the average of those consistent with warming of 3.0°C–
4.0°C. Transport needs (USD 425 billion) are based on estimates for new rail infrastructure from the G20
Infrastructure Initiative. No estimates for new EVs are available. Flows represent only mitigation pegged flows
(including multiple objectives, which accounts around 2% of total flows) by sectors provided by CPI. Cross-
sectoral flows such as policy and national budget support and capacity building are excluded (2% of total non-
adaptation flows).
Right chart: ‘Emerging’ represents BRICS countries. ‘Developing’ and ‘developed’ country classifications are
according to the IPCC country classification (See Annex B). Flows: Mean average of 2017 and 2018 as per CPI
breakdown, trans-regional and non-regional flows (approximately 20% of flows) allocated pro rata. Breakdown
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-36 Total pages: 37
Document for Govt and Expert Review
49410737
First Draft Summary for Policymakers IPCC AR6 WGIII
of needs for agriculture and forests is based on current Bonn Challenge commitments due to lack of better data,
afforestation needs represent >50% of total needs; power (electricity sector) by type of economy based on AR6
IAM database; energy efficiency needs based on IRENA data; transport needs based on Global Infrastructure
Outlook for Rail Infrastructure needs. Total GDP 2018 in constant 2017 international dollars, World Bank
Indicator (NY.GDP.MKTP.PP.KD).
1
2
3 E6. The development, deployment and transfer of climate technologies can help achieve
4 climate and sustainable development goals synergistically. Achieving this potential entails taking
5 a system perspective, covering the social, economic, environmental, financial, institutional,
6 infrastructural, capacity and behavioural dimensions of technological change. (high confidence)
7 {4.4, 5.3, 5.6, 9.9, 14.4, 16.1, 16.2, 16.3, 16.5, 16.6, Cross-Chapter Box 8 in Chapter 16}
8 E 6.1. Technology can contribute to decoupling growth in human well-being from increased
9 emissions, environmental impacts, and demand for natural resources. Yet, if current patterns of
10 technological change continue, it may also lead to higher emissions or other side-effects, for instance
11 through rebound effects whereby falling costs incentivise higher levels of consumption. (medium
12 confidence) {16.1, 16.2}
13 E 6.2. Digitalisation is fundamentally changing all economies and societies. Digital technologies can
14 increase energy and material efficiency, making transport and building systems less wasteful, and
15 improving access to services. Without active governance or management, they could increase energy
16 demand, exacerbate inequalities and the concentration of power, raise ethical issues, reduce labour
17 demand and compromise citizens’ welfare. (medium confidence) {4.4, 5.3, 5.6, 9.9, 16.3, Cross-Chapter
18 Box 8 in Chapter 16}
19 E 6.3. Technological change, technology development and diffusion processes, and innovation
20 policies and practices are not fully represented in modelled emission pathways. Many modelling
21 exercises have underestimated cost reductions in renewable energy supply and granular end-use
22 technologies. The role of innovation in accelerating systems transitions and triggering socio-technical
23 tipping points, especially for deep emission reductions, may also be underestimated. (medium
24 confidence) {5.4, 16.3, 16.4}
25 E 6.4. Policy instruments used to promote innovation and the deployment and diffusion of new and
26 improved technologies include public research, development and demonstration (RD&D) investments
27 and innovation procurement. Direct technology policy instruments have had a positive impact on
28 innovation outputs and outcomes as measured by patents, publications, and cost reductions (medium
29 confidence). {16.3, 16.5}
30 E 6.5. Policy approaches that involve a holistic perspective, encompassing all aspects of the
31 innovation process along with sustainable development goals are more effective than those that do not
32 (medium confidence). Mixes of climate, industrial and trade policies could induce progress in low-
33 emission technologies, with spill-over effects across regions contributing to global emission reductions.
34 {16.4, 16.5}
Do Not Cite, Quote, or Distribute SPM-37 Total pages: 37