POSITION PAPER OF THE BALTIC NATIONAL
REGULATORY AUTHORITIES
ON
THE AMENDED BALTIC TRANSMISSION SYSTEM
OPERATORS’ REQUEST FOR DEROGATION FROM
ARTICLE 53(1) OF COMMISSION REGULATION (EU)
2017/2195 OF 23 NOVEMBER 2017 ESTABLISHING A
GUIDELINE ON ELECTRICITY BALANCING
1 December 2020
1. INTRODUCTION
This document elaborates an agreement between Baltic National Regulatory Authorities1
(NRAs) of 1 December 2020 on the Baltic Transmission System Operators’ (TSOs) request for
derogation from Article 53(1) of the Commission Regulation (EU) 2017/2195 of 23 November
2017 establishing a guideline on electricity balancing (EB GL) (Derogation request).
Given that according to Article 5(4) h) of the EB GL the Derogation request should be
approvable by each NRA, this agreement is intended to constitute the basis on which NRAs
will subsequently issue a reasoned decision concerning the Derogation request.
2. LEGAL CONTEXT
The legal provisions relevant to the submission of the Derogation requests and granting the
derogation from Article 53(1) of EB GL, and NRAs agreement can be found in Articles 3, 5(3)
n), 5(4) h), 6(1), Article 53(1) and 62 of the EB GL.
Article 3
1. This Regulation aims at:
(a) fostering effective competition, non-discrimination and transparency in balancing
markets;
(b) enhancing efficiency of balancing as well as efficiency of European and national
balancing markets;
(c) integrating balancing markets and promoting the possibilities for exchanges of
balancing services while contributing to operational security;
(d) contributing to the efficient long-term operation and development of the electricity
transmission system and electricity sector in the Union while facilitating the efficient
and consistent functioning of day-ahead, intraday and balancing markets;
(e) ensuring that the procurement of balancing services is fair, objective, transparent and
market-based, avoids undue barriers to entry for new entrants, fosters the liquidity of
balancing markets while preventing undue distortions within the internal market in
electricity;
(f) facilitating the participation of demand response including aggregation facilities and
energy storage while ensuring they compete with other balancing services at a level
playing field and, where necessary, act independently when serving a single demand
facility;
(g) facilitating the participation of renewable energy sources and support the achievement
of the European Union target for the penetration of renewable generation.
2. When applying this Regulation, Member States, relevant regulatory authorities, and system
operators shall:
(a) apply the principles of proportionality and non-discrimination;
(b) ensure transparency;
(c) apply the principle of optimisation between the highest overall efficiency and lowest
total costs for all parties involved;
(d) ensure that TSOs make use of market-based mechanisms, as far as possible, in order to
ensure network security and stability;
1
Estonian Competition Authority (ECA), Public Utilities Commission of Latvia (PUC), National Energy
Regulatory Council of Lithuania (NERC)
2
(e) ensure that the development of the forward, day-ahead and intraday markets is not
compromised;
(f) respect the responsibility assigned to the relevant TSO in order to ensure system
security, including as required by national legislation;
(g) consult with relevant DSOs and take account of potential impacts on their system; (h)
take into consideration agreed European standards and technical specifications.
Article 5(3) n)
3. The proposals for the following terms and conditions or methodologies shall be subject to
approval by all regulatory authorities of the concerned region:
[..]
(n) the exemption, at synchronous area level, to the harmonisation of the imbalance
settlement periods pursuant to Article 53(2).
Article 5(4) h)
4. The proposals for the following terms and conditions or methodologies shall be subject to
approval by each regulatory authority of each concerned Member State on a case-by-case
basis:
[..]
(h) the derogations to one or more provisions of this Regulation pursuant to Article 62(2).
Article 6(1)
1. Where one or several regulatory authorities in accordance with Article 37 of Directive
2009/72/EC require an amendment in order to approve the terms and conditions or
methodologies submitted in accordance with paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 of Article 5, the relevant
TSOs shall submit a proposal for amended terms and conditions or methodologies for
approval within two months following the requirement from the relevant regulatory
authorities. The relevant regulatory authorities shall decide on the amended terms and
conditions or methodologies within two months following their submission.
Article 53(1)
1. By three years after the entry into force of this Regulation, all TSOs shall apply the
imbalance settlement period of 15 minutes in all scheduling areas while ensuring that all
boundaries of market time unit shall coincide with boundaries of the imbalance settlement
period.
Article 62
1. A regulatory authority in accordance with Article 37 of Directive 2009/72/EC may, at the
request of a TSO or at its own initiative, grant the relevant TSOs a derogation from one or
more provisions of this Regulation in accordance with paragraphs 2 to 12.
2. A TSO may request a derogation from the following requirements:
(a) the deadlines by which a TSO shall use the European platforms pursuant to Articles
19(5), 20(6), 21(6) and 22(5);
(b) the definition of the integrated scheduling process gate closure time in a central
dispatching model pursuant to Article 24(5) and the possibility to change the integrated
scheduling process bids pursuant to Article 24(6);
(c) the maximum volume of cross-zonal capacity allocated on a market-based process
pursuant to Article 41(2) or a process based an economic efficiency analysis pursuant
to Article 42(2);
(d) the harmonisation of the imbalance settlement period in Article 53(1);
(e) the implementation of the requirements pursuant to Articles 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51,
54, 55, 56 and 57.
3
3. The derogation process shall be transparent, non-discriminatory, non-biased, well
documented and based on a reasoned request.
4. TSOs shall file a written request for derogation to the relevant regulatory authority at the
latest six months prior to the day of application of the provisions from which the derogation
is requested.
5. The request for derogation shall include the following information:
(a) the provisions from which a derogation is requested;
(b) the requested derogation period;
(c) a detailed plan and timeline specifying how to address and ensure the implementation
of the concerned provisions of this Regulation after expiration of the derogation period;
(d) an assessment of the consequences of requested derogation on adjacent markets;
(e) an assessment of the possible risks for the integration of balancing markets across
Europe caused by the requested derogation.
6. The relevant regulatory authority shall adopt a decision concerning any request for
derogation within six months from the day after it receives the request. That time limit may
be extended by three months before its expiry where the relevant regulatory authority
requires further information from the TSO requesting the derogation. The additional period
shall begin when the complete information has been received.
7. The TSO requesting the derogation shall submit any additional information requested by the
relevant regulatory authority within two months of such request. If the TSO does not supply
the requested information within that time limit, the request for a derogation shall be deemed
withdrawn unless, before its expiry, alternatively:
(a) the relevant regulatory authority decides to provide an extension;
(b) the TSO informs the relevant regulatory authority by means of a reasoned submission
that the request for a derogation is complete.
8. When assessing the request for derogation or before granting a derogation at its own
initiative, the relevant regulatory authority shall consider the following aspects:
(a) the difficulties related to the implementation of the concerned provision or provisions;
(b) the risks and the implications of the concerned provision or provisions, in terms of
operational security;
(c) the actions taken to facilitate the implementation of the concerned provision or
provisions;
(d) the impacts of non-implementation of the concerned provision or provisions, in terms
of non-discrimination and competition with other European market participants, in
particular as regards demand response and renewable energy sources;
(e) the impacts on overall economic efficiency and smart grid infrastructure;
(f) the impacts on other scheduling areas and overall consequences on the European market
integration process.
9. The relevant regulatory authority shall issue a reasoned decision concerning a request for a
derogation or a derogation granted at its own initiative. Where the relevant regulatory
authority grants a derogation, it shall specify its duration. The derogation may be granted
only once and for a maximum period of two years, except for the derogations in paragraphs
2(c) and 2(d) which may be granted until 1 January 2025.
10. The relevant regulatory authority shall notify its decision to the TSO, the Agency and the
European Commission. The decision shall also be published on its website.
4
11. The relevant regulatory authorities shall maintain a register of all derogations they have
granted or refused and shall provide the Agency with an updated and consolidated register
at least once every six months, a copy of which shall be given to ENTSO-E.
12. The register shall contain, in particular: (a) the provisions from which the derogation is
granted or refused; (b) the content of the derogation; (c) the reasons for granting or refusing
the derogation; (d) the consequences resulting from granting the derogation.
3. THE AMENDED DEROGATION REQUEST
The Derogation request together with a Concept Document After Public Consultation (Concept
Document) was submitted to the ECA on 2 April 2020, the PUC on 3 April 2020 and to the
NERC on 3 April 2020. NRAs assessed the Derogation request and concluded that information
provided in the Derogation request is not sufficient for NRAs to adopt a decision. Therefore,
on 3 September 2020 based on Article 5(4), 6(1) and 62(2) of the EB GL the NRAs sent to the
TSOs a request for amendments. The NRAs requested the TSOs:
− to supplement and expand the range of the reasons (arguments) for requesting a
derogation,
− to provide a justification for the derogation period specified in the Derogation request
(31 December 2024);
− to indicate and justify the actions that cannot be taken to implement provision of Article
53(1) of EB GL to apply the imbalance settlement period of 15 minutes (15 minutes
ISP) in scheduling area within the deadline set by EB GL;
− to indicate and justify difficulties in fulfilling actions for the implementation of
automatic frequency restoration reserves in balancing energy market;
− to provide additional information about Baltic-Nordic balancing market cooperation as
well as an explanation of how the different implementation times of 15 minutes ISP will
affect the liquidity for Baltic and Nordic balancing market;
− to specify information on the actions to be taken in relation to metering data in 15
minutes resolution for balancing responsible parties scheduling;
− to provide additional information with detailed justification or additional explanation of
what is set out in the Concept Document regarding the impact of 15 minutes ISP
implementation on moving to 15 minutes time resolution, Baltic-Nordic balancing
market cooperation, balancing responsible parties scheduling, single day ahead market
coupling as well as on metering data allocation.
The amended Derogation request was submitted to the ECA on 17 November 2020, the PUC
on 16 November 2020 and to the NERC on 16 November 2020.
On 1 December 2020 NRAs received letter with information, that TSOs have re-evaluated
arguments for Derogation request, therefore development of amendments in the Concept
Document After Public Consultation is not relevant anymore. To provide information and
necessary explanation requested by NRAs, TSOs with this letter submitted Summary of
responses.
The NRAs have assessed the amended Derogation request and submitted comments on Concept
Document and note that the TSOs have amended the Derogation request to describe reasons
(arguments) for requesting a derogation from Article 53(1) of EB GL and the requested duration
of the derogation, difficulties related to the implementation of the provision of Article 53(1) of
EB GL regarding applying 15 minutes ISP, the consequences of derogation on adjacent
5
markets, actions taken to facilitate the implementation of the Article 53(1) of EB GL provision,
overall consequences on the European market integration process in sufficient clarity.
4. THE NRAS POSITION
The NRAs, in close co-operation and co-ordination, have carefully assessed the amended
Derogation request to reach an agreement that it meets the requirements of Article 62 of EB GL
and agree to grant a derogation from the provision of Article 53(1) of EB GL to apply 15
minutes ISP until 31 December 2024.
5. CONCLUSION
In accordance with Article 53(1) of EB GL by 18 December 2020 the TSOs shall apply 15
minutes ISP. Thereby, NRAs must take their decisions to grant derogation from the provision
of Article 53(1) of EB GL to apply 15 minutes ISP, based on this agreement, by 17 December
2020 at the latest.
6
OTSUS
17.12.2020 nr 7-26/2020-011
15-minutilise tasakaaluarveldusperioodi rakendamise erandi andmise kohta (EBGL
artikkel 53 lõike 1)
1. Haldusmenetluse alustamine
Elektrituruseaduse (edaspidi ELTS) § 93 lõike 6 punkti 1 kohaselt kontrollib Konkurentsiamet
Euroopa Parlamendi ja nõukogu määruses (EÜ) nr 714/2009 sätestatud tingimuste täitmist.
ELTS § 93 lõike 6 punkti 6 kohaselt Konkurentsiamet väljastab ELTS-s sätestatud juhul
kooskõlastamise otsuseid.
Vastavalt Euroopa Parlamendi ja nõukogu määruse (EÜ) nr 714/2009 artiklile 8 töötati välja
Komisjoni Määrus (EL) 2017/2195, millega kehtestatakse elektrisüsteemi tasakaalustamise
eeskiri (EBGL). EBGL sätestab nõuded ühiste reguleerimisturgude ja bilansiselgituse reeglite
kohta Euroopa Liidus.
EBGL artikli 53 lõike 1 kohaselt, hiljemalt kolm aastat pärast EBGL jõustumist kohaldavad
kõik põhivõrguettevõtjad 15-minuti pikkust tasakaaluarveldusperioodi (bilansiperioodi) kõigis
planeerimise piirkondades (hinnapiirkondades), tagades samal ajal, et kõik turu ajaüksuse piirid
langevad kokku tasakaaluarvestusperioodi (bilansiperioodi) piiridega.
EBGL artikli 5 lõike 3 punkt n järgi peavad kõigi asjaomase piirkonna reguleerivate asutuste
heakskiidu saama erand sünkroonala tasandil tasakaaluarvestusperioodide ühtlustumise osas
vastavalt EBGL artikli 53 lõikele 2.
EBGL artikli 5 lõike 4 punkt h järgi peavad kõigi asjaomase piirkonna reguleerivate asutuste
heakskiidu juhtumipõhiselt saama erandid EBGL ühest või mitmest sättest vastavalt EBGL
artikli 62 lõikele 2.
EBGL artikli 6 lõike 1 kohaselt, kui üks või mitu reguleerivat asutust taotlevad direktiivi
2009/72/EÜ artikli 37 kohaselt artikli 5 lõigete 2–4 alusel esitatud tingimuste või meetodite
muutmist enne nende heakskiitmist, peavad asjaomased põhivõrguettevõtjad esitama muudetud
tingimuste või meetodite ettepaneku heakskiitmiseks kahe kuu jooksul pärast reguleerivate
asutuste sellekohast nõuet. Asjaomased reguleerivad asutused peavad tegema muudetud
tingimuste või meetodite kohta otsuse kahe kuu jooksul pärast nende esitamist.
02.04.2020 esitas Elering AS Konkurentsiametile kooskõlastamiseks Baltikumi
põhivõrguettevõtjate poolt ühiselt koostatud 15-minutilise tasakaaluarveldusperioodi
rakendamiseks erandi taotluse (edaspidi Erandi taotlus).
2 (5)
2. Menetlusosaline
Elering AS, äriregistri kood 11022625, asukoht Kadaka tee 42, Tallinn, 12915, e-post:
[email protected].
3. Asjaolud ja menetluse käik
02.04.2020 esitas Elering AS Konkurentsiametile kooskõlastamiseks Balti süsteemihaldurite
poolt koostatud dokumendi, millega taotleti ühiselt erandit EBGL artikli 53 lõikest 1 artikli 62
lõike 2 punktile d vastavalt (Erandi taotlus). Arvesse on võetud EBGL-s ettenähtud põhimõtted,
mille kohaselt peab erandite tegemine olema läbipaistev, mittediskrimineeriv, erapooletu, hästi
dokumenteeritud ja põhinema põhjendatud taotlusel.
Viimane asjaomane reguleeriv asutus sai Erandi taotluse kätte 03.04.2020.
02.09.2020 jõudsid kõik asjaomased reguleerivad asutused kokkuleppele taotleda Erandi
taotluse muutmist. 03.09.2020 edastati sellekohane taotlus Balti põhivõrguettevõtjatele.
17.11.2020 esitas Elering AS Konkurentsiametile muudetud Erandi taotluse.
01.12.2020 leppisid Balti riikide reguleerivad asutused seisukohadokumendis (lisa 2) kokku
erandi andmises tähtajaga kuni 31.12.2024
Kõik asjaomased reguleerivad asutused peavad tegema otsuse enne 17.12.2020.
4. Baltikumi põhivõrguettevõtjate poolt esitatud Erandi taotlus
Erandi taotlusele eelnevalt viisid Baltikumi põhivõrguettevõtjad perioodil 10.05-10.06.2019
läbi avaliku konsultatsiooni 15-minutilise tasakaaluarveldusperioodi (bilansiperioodi)
rakendamise kontseptsioonkavandi ja rakenduse teekaardi kohta. Balti põhivõrguettevõtjate
algne eesmärk oli rakendada 15-minutiline tasakaaluarveldusperiood (bilansiperiood)
õigeaegselt ehk alates 01.12.2020 päevasisese turu tootele, bilansiplaanide esitamise
andmevahetusele, reguleerimisturu standardtootele, mõõteandmete jaotusele ning
bilansihalduritele bilansienergia koguste arvutamisele. Tagasiside tulemusena pooldasid
turuosalised 15-minuti tasakaaluarveldusperioodi (bilansiperioodi) edasilükkamist tuues
olulisemate põhjustena välja lisainvesteeringute vajaduse, ebapiisava ajaressursi IT süsteemide
kohaldamiseks, seadusandluses kehtestatud mõõteandmete edastuse nõuete täpsustamise, üle-
Euroopaliste reguleerimisreservi platvormide hilisemad rakendusajad, Põhjamaade otsuse
esitada samuti erandi taotlus, süsteemijuhtimises 15-minutilise rakenduse vajaduse puudumine
jms. Turuosaliste tagasisidest lähtuvalt koostasid Balti põhivõrguettevõtjad uue 15-minutilise
tasakaaluarveldusperioodi (bilansiperioodi) rakendamise kontseptsiooni dokumendi, milles
selgitatakse põhjalikumalt 15-minutilise tasakaaluarveldusperioodi (bilansiperioodi)
rakendamise sisu, mõju erinevatele turuetappidele ning on toodud välja uuendatud ajakava
järgnevateks arenduseetappideks. Vastav kontseptsiooni dokument avaldati 17.12.2019
põhivõrguettevõtjate veebilehtedel.
Erandi taotluses esitavad Balti süsteemihaldurid kahe-astmelise rakenduskava, mis näeb ette
15-minutilise tasakaaluarveldusperioodi (bilansiperioodi) rakenduseks:
a) Etapp 1 tähtajaga Q4 2022 – töötada välja 15-minutilise tasakaaluarveldusperioodi
(bilansiperioodi) andmevahetuse võimekus bilansihalduses koos reguleerimisturgude
muudatustega (sh näha ette valmisolek liituda MARI platvormiga);
b) Etapp 2 tähtajaga Q4 2024 – 15-minutilise tasakaaluarveldusperioodi (bilansiperioodi)
täisrakendamine koos jaotusvõrkude tasemel mõõteandmete edastusega ning samuti
3 (5)
automaatsete sagedustaastamise reservide protsesside ja toodete väljatöötamine kui
eeltegevused Baltikumi sünkroniseerimiseks Mandri-Euroopa sünkroonalaga.
Balti süsteemihaldurid esitasid ühiselt Eesti, Läti ja Leedu regulaatoritele erandi taotluse 15-
minutilise tasakaaluarveldusperioodi (bilansiperioodi) kohustusliku rakenduse
edasilükkamiseks tähtajani kuni 31.12.2024.
5. Asjaomaste reguleerivate asutuste seisukoht
EBGL artikli 62 lõike 5 kohaselt peab erandi taotlus sisaldama järgmist teavet:
a) sätted, millest erandit taotletakse;
b) taotletud erandi kohaldamisaeg;
c) üksikasjalik kava ja ajakava, milles on täpsustatud, kuidas käsitletakse käesoleva
määruse asjaomaseid sätteid ja tagatakse nende rakendamine pärast erandi
kohaldamisaja lõppemist;
d) taotletud erandi mõju lähiturgudele;
e) hinnang selle kohta, millised võimalikud riskid taotletud erandiga kaasnevad Euroopa
tasakaalustamisturgude lõimimise seisukohast.
EBGL artikli 62 lõike 8 kohaselt eranditaotluse hindamisel või erandi omaalgatuslikul
tegemisel kaalub asjaomane reguleeriv asutus järgmisi tahke:
a) asjaomase sätte või asjaomaste sätete rakendamisega seotud probleemid;
b) asjaomase sätte või asjaomaste sätetega seotud riskid talitluskindluse seisukohast;
c) asjaomase sätte või asjaomaste sätete rakendamise hõlbustamiseks võetud meetmed;
d) asjaomase sätte või asjaomaste sätete rakendamata jätmise mõju teiste Euroopa
turuosaliste mittediskrimineerimise ja konkurentsi seisukohast, eriti seoses tarbimiskaja ja
taastuvate energiaallikatega;
e) mõju majanduse üldisele tõhususele ja tarkvõrgutaristule;
f) mõju teistele plaanimispiirkondadele ja üldised tagajärjed Euroopa turgude lõimimise
seisukohast.
Asjaomased reguleerivad asutused hindasid Erandi taotlust ja jõudsid järeldusele, et Erandi
taotluses esitatud teabest ei piisa riigi reguleerivatele asutustele otsuse vastuvõtmiseks.
Asjaomased reguleerivad asutused taotlesid muuhulgas, et põhivõrguettevõtjad täiendaksid ja
laiendaksid erandi taotlemise põhjuseid (argumente), põhjendaksid erandi taotluses määratletud
erandi tegemise perioodi (kuni 31. detsember 2024), näitaksid ja põhjendaksid raskusi
automaatsete sageduse taastamise reservide rakendamise meetmete täitmisel
tasakaalustamisturgudel ning annaksid lisateavet Balti- ja Põhjamaade tasakaalustamisturu
koostöö kohta ning selgitaksid, kuidas erinevad 15-minutilise ISP rakendamise ajad mõjutavad
Balti- ja Põhjamaade tasakaalustamisturu likviidsust
Asjaomased reguleerivad asutused hindasid muudetud Erandi taotlust ja on seisukohal, et
põhivõrguettevõtjad on seda muutnud vastavalt asjaomaste reguleerivate asutuste nõuetele.
01.12.2020 leppisid Balti riikide reguleerivad asutused seisukohadokumendis (lisa 2) kokku
erandi andmise tähtajaga kuni 31.12.2024.
Kokkuvõte
Konkurentsiamet töötas läbi Eleringi poolt 17.11.2020 ametile kooskõlastamiseks esitatud
Erandi taotluse ning asub seisukohale, et nimetatud dokument arvestab kehtivast
seadusandlusest tulenevate alustega ning ei ole vastuolus EBGL-st tuleneva regulatsiooniga.
4 (5)
EBGL artikli 7 kohaselt, tingimuste või meetodite väljatöötamise eest vastutavad
põhivõrguettevõtjad peavad need internetis avaldama pärast asjaomastelt reguleerivatelt
asutustelt saadud heakskiitu või, kui heakskiitu ei ole vaja, siis pärast nende tingimuste või
meetodite väljatöötamist, välja arvatud juhul, kui selline teave on EBGL artikli 11 kohaselt
konfidentsiaalne.
Arvestades eeltoodut ja tuginedes ELTS § 93 lõike 6 punktile 6
otsustan:
anda Elering AS-le erand EBGL artikli 53 lõike 1 nõude 15-minutilise
tasakaaluarveldusperioodi kohaldamisele kuni 31.12.2024.
Käesoleva otsusega mittenõustumise korral on õigus esitada kaebus otsuse tühistamiseks
Tallinna Halduskohtule. Kaebuse halduskohtule võib esitada 30 päeva jooksul arvates
käesoleva otsuse teatavakstegemisest.
/allkirjastatud digitaalselt/
Märt Ots
peadirektor
Lisad:
Lisa 1 - Baltic TSOs request for derogation from Article 53 (1) of Commission Regulation (EU)
2017/2195 of 23 November 2017 establishing a guideline on electricity balancing (11.11.2020).
Lisa 2 – Position Paper of the Baltic National Regulatory Authorities on the amended Baltic
Transmissioon System Operators request for derogation from article 53(1) of Commission
Regulation (EU) 2017/2195 of 23 November 2017 establishing a guideline on electricity
balancing 01.12.2020).
5 (5)
Updated 11 November 2020
Baltic TSOs request for derogation
from Article 53 (1) of Commission
Regulation (EU)
2017/2195 of 23 November 2017
establishing a guideline on
electricity balancing
Elering AS
AS “Augstsprieguma tīkls”
LITGRID AB
Baltic TSOs, considering the following:
Whereas
1) Commission regulation (EU) 2017/2195 of 23 November 2017 establishing a guideline on
electricity balancing (hereafter referred to as “EB GL”) sets requirements for target
balancing markets and settlement in European Union. According to Article 53 (1) of EB GL
by three years after the entry into force of EB GL, all transmission system operators
(hereafter referred to as "TSOs") shall apply the imbalance settlement period of 15 minutes
in all scheduling areas while ensuring that all boundaries of market time unit shall coincide
with boundaries of the imbalance settlement period.
2) According to Article 62 (1) of EB GL a regulatory authority in accordance with Article 37 of
Directive 2009/72/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 July 2009
concerning common rules for the internal market in electricity and repealing Directive
2003/54/EC may, at the request of a TSO or at its own initiative, grant the relevant TSOs a
derogation from one or more provisions of this Regulation in accordance with paragraphs
2 to 12. Furthermore, in accordance with Article 62 (2) of EB GL a TSO may request a
derogation from the following requirements: "(d) harmonization of the imbalance
settlement period in Article 53(1)".
3) According to Article 62 (5) of EB GL the request for derogation shall include the following
information:
a) the provisions from which a derogation is requested;
b) the requested derogation period;
c) a detailed plan and timeline specifying how to address and ensure the implementation of
the concerned provisions of EB GL after expiration of the derogation period;
d) an assessment of the consequences of requested derogation on adjacent markets;
e) an assessment of the possible risks for the integration of balancing markets across
Europe caused by the requested derogation.
4) According to Article 62 (8) when assessing the request for derogation (..) the relevant
regulatory authority shall consider the following aspects:
f) the difficulties related to the implementation of the concerned provision or provisions;
g) the risks and the implications of the concerned provision or provisions, in terms of
operational security;
h) the actions taken to facilitate the implementation of the concerned provision or
provisions;
i) the impacts of non-implementation of the concerned provision or provisions, in terms of
non-discrimination and competition with other European market participants, in
particular as regards demand response and renewable energy sources;
j) the impacts on overall economic efficiency and smart grid infrastructure;
k) the impacts on other scheduling areas and overall consequences on the European market
integration process.
considering the criteria established in the EB GL for the requests for derogation and the
following information, jointly submit request for derogation to the national regulatory
authorities of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania.
I Introduction
This document is request for derogation from obligation to implement 15-minute ISP until 18
December 2020 as described in Article 53 (1) of EB GL until the 31 December 2024 developed
by Baltic TSOs in accordance with Article 62 (2) (d) of EB GL (hereafter referred to as
“Derogation request”).
Derogation request is developed taking account principles stipulated in the Article 62 (3) of
EB GL saying that "the derogation process shall be transparent, non-discriminatory, non-biased,
well documented and based on a reasoned request".
According to Article 53 (1) of EB GL by three years after the entry into force of this Regulation,
all TSOs shall apply the imbalance settlement period of 15 minutes in all scheduling areas
while ensuring that all boundaries of market time unit shall coincide with boundaries of the
imbalance settlement period. Since EB GL has entered into force on 18 December 2017, the
deadline for implementation 15-minute imbalance settlement period (hereafter referred to as
''ISP'') is 18 December 2020.
In order to timely and properly implement 15-minute ISP, Baltic TSOs jointly developed Baltic
15-minute ISP implementation Concept Document, that initially envisaged the
implementation of 15-minute ISP within the deadline set in Article 53 (1) of EB GL. After that
Baltic TSOs carried out the public consultation on the Baltic 15-minute ISP implementation
Concept Document from 10 May 2019 to 10 June 2019.
As mentioned before, the preliminary Concept Document aimed to implement 15-minute ISP
on 1 December 2020. Feedback was received from 14 market participants, of which balance
responsible parties (hereafter referred to as "BRPs"), distribution system operators (hereafter
referred to as "DSOs") and balancing service providers (hereafter referred to as "BSPs") were
represented. The majority of respondents submitted negative feedback to the Baltic TSOs
preliminary Concept Document, outlining the following main aspects:
• the two-step approach for the transition to a shorter ISP seems impractical: step I of
the proposal provides no added value when compared to existing arrangements,
stakeholders do not see added value from proposed changes if it does not motivate
self-balancing closer to real time and does not create signals and incentives for it;
• insufficient time to develop or make changes to IT systems in order to accommodate a
shorter ISP including quality of measurement data and measuring resolution,
stakeholders see IT implementation challenging and costly, need more time to prepare
and allocate budget;
• potential reduction of liquidity of market products traded on the power exchange
shorter than the existing 60-minute resolution taking into account the publicly
available information1, that Nordic TSOs have requested derogation to implement 15-
minute ISP until 22 May 2022;
• differences in balancing product characteristics in the Baltic-Nordic balancing market,
stakeholders indicate that changes to balancing market should not affect liquidity for
Baltic-Nordic balancing market cooperation.
1 See ''Nordic Balacing model'' hompage: https://nordicbalancingmodel.net/nordic-tsos-15-minutes-balancing-period-
from-22-may-2023/
By evaluating the feedback from market participants, Baltic TSO's concluded, that 15-minute
ISP implementation till 18 December 2020 is not possible.
II Reasons for derogation request
Requirements for proper 15-minute ISP implementation
According to Article 17 (1) of EB GL in real time each BRP shall strive to be balanced or help
the power system to be balanced. Furthermore, it should be noted, that according to Article 44
(1) of EB GL and Article 6 (5) of Regulation (EU) 2019/943 of the European Parliament and of
the Council of 5 June 2019 on the internal market for electricity (hereinafter referred to as
''Regulation 2019/943'') the settlement processes shall:
1) establish adequate economic signals which reflect the imbalance situation;
2) ensure that imbalances are settled at a price that reflects the real time value of energy;
3) provide incentives to BRPs to be in balance or help the system to restore its balance.
To comply with these requirements 15-minute ISP must be implemented properly. Proper
15-minute ISP implementation means, that occurred imbalance has been allocated and settled
with BRP within the time frame of relevant ISP. Namely, imbalance settlement includes
attribution of the imbalance to the relevant ISP and the calculation and application of
imbalance price of the relevant ISP. Imbalance price calculation, as indicated above, must
reflect the real time value of energy. Therefore, it should be linked to balancing energy price.
According to Article 45 and 46 of EB GL balancing energy price calculation is based on the
activated volume of balancing energy. The time frame for balancing energy activations is
balance control period. In order to implement 15-minute ISP properly, described components
shall be done in time frame, that does not exceed 15 minutes. If this is not ensured, implement
15-minute ISP concept does not comply with the requirements of Article 44 (1) of EB GL and
Article 6 (5) of Regulation 2019/943.
Components for proper 15-minute ISP implementation
Since balancing energy activations in the Baltic balancing market are done in 60-minute time
frame, there is only one balancing energy price for each 60 minutes. Balancing energy
activations in the Baltic balancing market are related to balance control procedure, that
currently is done in 60 minutes. Namely, currently Baltic States power systems work
synchronously with the Russian combined (IPS / UPS) system, where Baltic TSOs have
obligations to control balance within pre-defined limits within 60minute time frame. For this
purpose, Baltic TSOs operates mFRR process with common Baltic mFRR balancing market and
all balance discrepancies within 60 minute time frame are handled by Russian system
operator. Financial settlement of total imbalance of Baltic States is handled between Baltic
TSOs and open balance provider and relevant costs are included in the targeted component
for imbalance prices to ensure financial neutrality of TSO in accordance with common Baltic
rules for imbalance settlement.. Until Baltic power systems will be synchronized with power
system of continental Europe (hereinafter referred to as ''Synchronization''), implementation
of automatic FRR (hereinafter referred to as ''aFRR'') process and creation of aFRR market in
Baltics before Synchronization is not necessary and justified. This means, that also balance
control until Synchronization in the Baltics will be done in 60 minutes, and there will not be
possible to determine different imbalance prices for shorter periods. This argument is also
justified although after implementation of requirements of Article 21 of EB GL for joining MARI
platform2 activations will be done according to the 15 minute balancing market time unit and
balancing price will be determined for each quarter of an hour, because imbalance price
calculation until Synchronization will be based on balancing energy price of 60 minute
timeframe and settlement with open balance service provider. Therefore, proper
implementation of 15-minute ISP until 31 December 2024 is not possible.
Other actions for 15-minute ISP implementation.
After evaluation of all elements of current Baltic balancing market setup, Baltic TSOs
concluded, that for 15-minute ISP implementation also following actions must be performed:
1. by joining MARI platform (and obligation under Article 20 of EB GL) following changes in
Baltic balancing market shall be implemented:
1.1. implementation of 15-minute balancing energy market time unit (hereinafter
referred to as ''MTU'');
1.2. implementation of standard manual frequency restoration reserve (hereinafter
referred to as ''mFRR'') energy product;
1.3. implementation of 15-minute settlement for BSPs;
1.4. implementation of balancing energy pricing within 15-minute time frame;
1.5. modification of the processes of BSPs (e.g. updates in production planning systems).
2. Baltic local developments and adaptation to ensure that all boundaries of MTU, such as
intraday and day ahead MTUs, shall coincide with boundaries of the 15-minute ISP;
3. Development of relevant IT solutions of market participants (changes in data hubs and 15-
minute metering) and modification of the processes of BRPs (e.g. updates in trading and
balance management and production planning systems), that are necessary for metering
data actual resolution in 15 minutes, collection, use and ensure the availability and proper
usage of short-term electricity, including balancing.
Actions listed above are significant for 15-minute ISP implementation, but implementation of
those actions without 15-minute balance control does not ensure proper implementation of
15-minute ISP. Since joining MARI platform requires to implement EB GL requirements for
Baltic mFRR balancing market, including mFRR energy Standard product and 15-minute
balancing MTU, Baltic TSOs are planning to implement them by the time when it is feasible
for Baltics to join the MARI platform, which is expected not later than Q3 2024. Therefore,
detailed roadmap specifying how to address and ensure the implementation of the concerned
action to implement 15-minute ISP and relevant deadlines are included in Section IV of this
Derogation request.
2
MARI platform - European platform for the exchange of balancing energy from frequency restoration
reserves with manual activation
III The provisions from which a derogation is requested and the requested derogation
period (according to Article 62 (5) a) and b))
Baltic TSOs ask regulatory authorities to grant a derogation from obligation implement 15-
minute ISP until 18 December 2020, as described in Article 53 (1) of EB GL, until the 31
December 2024.
The deadline for granting the derogation is justified with the estimate of the time period, that
is necessary to meet all requirement for proper implementation of 15-minute ISP. Namely, the
last action, that will be taken to implement 15-minute ISP is organize Baltic total balance
control in 15-minute time frame. As explained in Section I of this Derogation request Baltic
total balance control in 15-minute time frame cannot be implemented before Synchronization,
that according to Agreement on the conditions of the future interconnection of power system
of Baltic States and power system of continental Europe shall be done until 31 December 2024.
IV Roadmap specifying how to address and ensure the implementation of the
concerned provisions of EB GL after expiration of the derogation period (according to
Article 62 (5) c))
Taking into account the implementation of MARI platform, which includes 15-minute mFRR
balancing products and preparation for Synchronization, that requires introduction of aFRR
processes, the proper implementation of 15-minute ISP in Baltics is foreseen to be done by
completing 2 major milestones which corresponds to major changes to market participants:
Milestone 1– joining MARI platform – changes in Baltic balancing setup shall be made
according to the EB GL requirements concerning mFRR processes and for joining
MARI platform and sequential implementation of related 15-minute data exchange
capability on TSO-TSO, TSO-BRP and TSO-BSP business processes level;
Milestone 2 with target date Q4 2024 – a) introduction of aFRR processes in Baltics
for preparation to Synchronization and sequential joining PICASSO platform; b) 15-
minute ISP measurement data collection on DSOs level according to national
legislation.
These milestones have been chosen to mark two most important preconditions for proper 15-
minute ISP implementation:
1) finalization of 15-minute resolution implementation for data exchanges at TSO-TSO,
TSO-BRP and TSO-BSP level (since MARI project implements overall data exchange
standardization and 15-minute mFRR products), and
2) introduction of Baltic total balance control in 15-minute resolution, that is only
possible after establishment of Baltic aFRR process.
Baltic total balance control in 15-minute resolution will be ensured as a result of establishment
of Baltic aFRR processes by 31 December 2024. This is required by Agreement on the
conditions of the future interconnection of power system of Baltic States and power system of
continental Europe. It should be also noted, that implementation of aFRR process in Baltic
states is required also by Article 2(2), 2(4) and Annex I of Commission Regulation (EU)
2017/1485 of 2 August 2017 establishing a guideline on electricity transmission system
operation. Establishment of Baltic aFRR processes will also lead to Baltic TSOs obligation to
join PICASSO platform3 and create Baltic aFRR market, that is mandatory under Article 20 of
EB GL.
Reaching these milestones will ensure that all elements of Baltic balancing setup and energy
markets (Balancing and Intraday) are in place for effective and self-balance motivating
Baltic 15-minute ISP functioning. More detailed roadmap is provided in Table 1.
Table 1 "Roadmap for 15-minute ISP implementation'
2021 2022 2023 2024
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
Derogation request submited to NRAs
NRA approval
Amendment of standard terms and
mFRR platform
Milestone 1 conditions for BSPs and BRPs
MARI
NRA approval of BSP and BRP TC*
IT implementation
Expected go-live
Concept for Picasso implementation
Baltic balancing market rules
amendment with aFRR balancing energy
market
aFRR platform
Milestone 2 Amendment of standard terms and
Picasso
conditions for BSPs and BRPs
NRA approval of BSP and BRP TC**
IT implementation
Expected go-live
For the implementation of 15-minute ISP following national regulatory authorities
(hereinafter referred to as ''NRA'') decisions are expected:
1. Each NRA approval of national standard terms and conditions for BSPs and BRPs for
joining MARI platform while introducing the changes as further described in Table 2.
2. Each NRA approval of national standard terms and conditions for BSPs and BRPs for
joining PICASSO platform while introducing the changes as further described in Table 2.
Table 2 ''Changes to the elements of the Baltic balancing setup and energy markets''
Expected changes and interrelation with
milestones
Market Current situation
elements Milestone 1 Milestone 2
BRP 60-minute resolution schedules According to national BRP terms and
scheduling conditions:
Gate closure time (hereinafter referred to as
- 15-minute schedules – LT and LV
''GCT'') GCT 45 minutes before ISP (LV, LT)
- 60-minute and 15-minute schedules - EE4
GCT 20 minutes before ISP (EE)
GCT 25 minutes before ISP
ID market Established Single Intraday Coupling (XBID)
allows trading with 15-minute intraday market Baltic local developments and adaptation to
products, but TSOs and nominated electricity ensure that all boundaries of market time unit
market operator's (hereinafter referred to as (hereinafter referred to as MTU) shall coincide
''NEMOs'') local systems and joint business with boundaries of the ISP15
processes shall be addressed
mFRR 60-minute products Requirements as defined for European mFRR
Balancing Common merit order list for each 60 minutes balancing energy platform
market GCT 45 minutes before ISP
Full activation time 15 minutes
Marginal price for each 60- minute ISP
Settlement
for BSPs 60 minutes 15 minutes
3
PICASSO platform - European platform for the exchange of balancing energy from frequency restoration reserves
with automatic activation
4
EE TSO would enable for BRPs to submit balance plans according to market product resolution (1h or 15min).
Settlement Imbalance volume and imbalance price for 60 15 minutes 15 minutes
for BRPs minutes Imbalance price Imbalance price
methodology update methodology update
to include European to include European
mFRR balancing aFRR balancing energy
energy standard standard product and
product and pricing pricing
aFRR Not established Requirements as defined for European aFRR
Balancing balancing energy platform
market
Balance
control by 60 minutes 60 minutes 15 minutes
TSOs
15 minutes at TSO 15 minutes at TSO
Metering level level
data 60 minutes At DSO level – At DSO level –
according to according to national
national rules and rules and regulations*
regulations*
* With the objective of implementing 15-minute ISP as a full package primary metering data
in 15-minute resolution are needed. In order to have 15-minute resolution metering data the
meters should be changed or reconfigured, if possible. Therefore, specific requirements to
implement 15-minute resolution metering must be included in relevant amendments to the
national legislation. Where, 15-minute metering data will not be available, technical solution
to allocate 60-minute resolution data to relevant 15-minute ISP shall be in place (detailed
information is included in the Baltic 15-minute imbalance settlement period implementation
Concept Document after PC).
Detailed changes in day-ahead and intraday markets, balancing market, imbalance settlement
and metering data allocation and 15-minute ISP implementation that are needed for the full
implementation of 15-minute ISP are described in the Baltic 15-minute imbalance settlement
period implementation Concept Document after public consultation. The derogation is
requested only regarding 15-minute ISP, not market time unit, meaning that Baltic TSOs would
implement 15-minute market time unit for intraday markets in cooperation with NEMO's by
supporting the initiative of NEMO's.
V An assessment of the consequences of requested derogation on adjacent markets
(according to Article 62 (5) d))
Currently balancing energy exchange between Baltic and Nordic TSOs is performed on
bilateral agreements between Finish TSO and Elering for high-voltage direct
current interconnections Eslink I and Estlink II, and Swedish TSO and Litgrid for high-voltage
direct current interconnection NordBalt. Main principles on balancing energy exchange on
these cross borders are harmonized and allows balancing energy exchange between Baltic-
Nordic areas not only in emergency situations, but also for the purposes to utilize the most
economical balancing resources for power system balancing. Meanwhile cooperation with
Polish balancing market is done only in emergency situations.
Derogation from Article 53 (1) of EB GL regarding implementation of ISP 15 until 18 December
2020 will not affect established cooperation with Nordic and Polish balancing markets. Baltic,
Nordic and Polish TSOs are participants of MARI project. Therefore, further development of
Baltic, Nordic and Polish balancing markets is done according to requirements of
Implementation framework for the European platform for the exchange of balancing energy
from frequency restoration reserves with manual activation, that are basis for MARI project.
Any amendments of balancing energy exchange between Baltic and neighboring areas (Nordic,
Poland) is foreseen in the framework of implementation of MARI platform, which shall be
coordinated with all relevant parties. Baltic TSOs have intention to implement MARI platform
in parallel with Nordic and Polish TSOs in order not to reduce the liquidity of the established
cooperation of Baltic, Nordic and Polish balancing energy market as further described in Baltic
TSOs proposal for the Baltic balancing market rules published in October 20205.
VI An assessment of the possible risks for the integration of balancing markets across
Europe caused by the requested derogation (according to Article 62 (5) e)).
The derogation from Article 53 (1) of EB GL until the 31 December 2024 will not cause any
direct or indirect risk for integration of balancing markets across Europe.
No changes to Baltic balancing market setup will be made until joining MARI platform.
Implementation of European mFRR balancing energy platform is foreseen as the first
milestone of implementation of 15-minute ISP in Baltics, By joining MARI platform following
changes will be implemented:
implementation of 15-minute balancing energy MTU;
implementation of standard mFRR energy product;
implementation of 15-minute settlement for BSPs;
implementation of balancing energy pricing within 15-minute time frame;
modification of the processes of BSPs (e.g. updates in production planning
systems).
Changes in the Baltic balancing market listed above can be implemented without
implementing 15-minute ISP.
By reaching compliance with Article 21 (1) of EB GL Baltic TSOs are planning to ensure that
Baltic mFRR balancing market is integral part of European mFRR balancing market by joining
MARI platform when it is feasible - which is expected not later than Q3 2024.
Also, the derogation from Article 53 (1) of EB GL until the 31 December 2024 will not cause
any direct or indirect risks for operational security as operational procedure of balancing
market will comply with requirements of synchronous area. For the implementation of new
operational procedures for aFRR and mFRR balancing energy market for the synchronization
to Continental Europe power system the operational security requirements will be followed
as defined in Commission Regulation 2017/1485 of 2 August 2017 establishing a guideline on
electricity transmission system operation.
VI the impacts of non-implementation of the concerned provision or provisions, in
terms of non-discrimination and competition with other European market
participants (in particular as regards demand response and renewable energy
sources) and the impacts on smart grid infrastructure (according to Article 62 (8) i) j))
The derogation from Article 53 (1) of EB GL until the 31 December 2024 should not negatively
impact development of smart grid infrastructure since certain level of implementation of
smart grid infrastructure is considered as precondition for the full implementation of 15-
5
https://www.ast.lv/en/events/baltic-tsos-have-commonly-prepared-baltic-balancing-market-rules-operation-
european-mfrr
minute ISP. The current smart grid infrastructure in the Baltics has not been sufficiently
developed. Namely, in order to have 15-minute resolution metering data the meters should be
changed or reconfigured, if possible. Such changes have impact for all electricity grid users and
especially distribution system operators, therefore specific requirement 15-minute resolution
metering should be included in relevant amendments to the national legislation.
Complete implementation of 15-minute ISP is indirectly linked to the demand response
development, but since 15-minute ISP later implementation, as previously mentioned, is not a
cause of delay of development of smart grid infrastructure, the derogation from Article 53 (1)
of EB GL until the 31 December 2024 will not negatively impact development of demand
response in Baltic energy markets.
The derogation from Article 53 (1) of EB GL until the 31 December 2024 will not negatively
impact usage of renewable energy sources.