Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn 10122
[email protected]
Rahandusministeerium
Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn 10122
[email protected]
27.02.2023
RE: riigiabi reeglite kavandatavad muudatused seoses rohelise kokkuleppe tööstuskavaga
Lugupeetud Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Lugupeetud Rahandusministeerium
MTÜ Eesti Era- ja Riskikapitali Assotsiatsioon („EstVCA“) on Eesti era- ja riskikapitalifonde, äriingleid ning antud
valdkonna tugiteenuse pakkujaid ühendav organisatsioon. EstVCA peaeesmärk on arendada Eesti era- ja
riskikapitalitööstust ning tõsta ambitsioonika ettevõtluse kultuuri Eestis.
Käesolevaga pöördub EstVCA Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooni- ning Rahandusministeeriumi poole seonduvalt
praktikas üha enam üles kerkiva kitsaskohaga riigiabi reeglite rakendamisel. Antud küsimus on muutumas veelgi
enam põletavamaks Euroopa Komisjoni nn rohelise kokkuleppe tööstuskava välja kuulutamise raames.
Arusaadavalt on üheks tööriistaks rohepöörde ambitsioonide elluviimisel muudatused riigiabi reeglites. Lisaks
suunistele kaalub Euroopa Komisjoni üldise riigiabi grupierandi määruse (EL) nr 651/2014 („GBER“)
ajakohastamist. EstVCA tervitab nii rohepöördega seotud ambitsiooni, kui näeb ka, et muudatused riigiabi reeglites
võimaldavad paljudel tema liikmetel panustada selliste eesmärkide saavutamisesse veelgi suuremal määral.
Samas on era- ning riskikapitalifondidest investeeringuid saanud ettevõtetele juba aastaid olnud takistuseks
asjaolu, et lähtuvalt GBER Lisa I artiklist 6 ja artikli 3 lõikest 3 tulenevast sidusettevõtja mõistest, loetakse tihtilugu
nii fondivalitseja, era- või riskikapitalifond, kui ka tema portfelliettevõtjad sidusettevõtjateks. Vastavalt on ka väga
tihti portfelliettevõtjate puhul välistatud nende lugemine väike- ja keskmise suurusega ettevõtjaks („VKE“). VKE-
ks mittelugemine omakorda välistab pahatihti võimaluse osaleda avaliku sektori toetusmeetmetes (nii GBERi kui
ka muul riigiabiõiguslikul alusel rakendatavates) või alternatiivselt vähendab ettevõtjale kättesaadava avaliku
sektori finantseeringu intensiivsust. Eelnev omakorda tähendab, et võimalikud innovatiivsed ideed jäävadki ellu
viimata või otsustavad ettevõtjad leida rahastust Euroopa Liidust väljast.
EstVCA hinnangul on eelnev vastuolus era- ja riskikapitali fondide toimimise loogikaga ning eeldab põhjendamatult,
et fondivalitseja, tema valitsetav fond (fondid) ja portfelliettevõtjad moodustava ühe majandusüksuse. Eelnev on
olemuslikult ekslik: (i) riskikapitali investeering on üldiselt kindla ajaraamiga, mistõttu ei ole tegemist nn jääva
korporatiivstruktuuriga, mille eesmärk on luua üks tervikuna toimiv ärikontsern; (ii) portfelliettevõtjatel ei ole
lubatud üksteist (finantsiliselt) toetada; ja (iii) portfelliettevõtjate juhtimine ei allu samalaadsele korporatiivsele
juhtimise põhimõtetele nagu nn tavalises kontsernis.
Antud kitsaskoha lahendamine on võimalik piiratud muudatusega GBER Lisa I artikli 3 punktis 3. Vajalik täiendus
peaks täpsustama, et ettevõtjaid, kes on saanud riski- või erakapitali finantseeringut, ei loeta ei fondi ega üksteise
MTÜ Eesti Era- ja Riskikapitali Assotsiatsioon Maakri 30, 10145, Tallinn
[email protected] www.estvca.ee
sidusettevõtjateks, kui investeeringu teinud fond: (i) suudab näidata, et tal oli investeeringu tegemise ajal
strateegia investeeringust väljumiseks; (ii) fondi ja portfelliettevõtjate finantsaruandlus on eraldiseisvad ning
finantsaruandluse konsolideerimist aset ei leia; ja (iii) portfelliettevõttel ei ole võimalik saada finantsilist toetust ei
fondilt ega teistelt portfelliettevõtetelt.
Antud ettepanek, koos detailsemalt lahti kirjutatud põhjendustega, on toodud käesoleva kirja manusesse lisatud
Invest Europe positsioonipaberil (lisa 1). Invest Europe on maailma üks suuremaid erakapitali
esindusorganisatsioone, mille liikmeks on ka EstVCA.
Tulenevalt eeltoodust palub EstVCA nii Rahandus- kui ka Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumil kaaluda
Euroopa Komisjonile ettepanekute edastamiseks GBERi muutmiseks vastavalt käesolevas kirjas toodule ja
manuses kirjeldatule.
EstVCA kinnitab oma valmisolekut toodud positsiooni täiendavaks selgitamiseks, küsimustele vastamiseks kui ka
panustamiseks Euroopa Komisjonile edastatavate ettepanekute koostamisel.
Lugupidamisega
/allkirjastatud digitaalselt/
Antti Perli
Juhatuse liige
MTÜ Eesti Era- ja Riskikapitali Assotsiatsioon
MTÜ Eesti Era- ja Riskikapitali Assotsiatsioon Maakri 30, 10145, Tallinn
[email protected] www.estvca.ee
February 2023
Invest Europe Position Paper
Treatment of venture capital-backed companies in EU State Aid law
Executive summary
• We strongly support the objectives of the EU Green Deal Industrial Plan, including the
revision of EU State Aid rules to incentivise investments in innovation
• For EU to be competitive in the innovation space, it is essential that venture capital-backed
businesses can remain eligible for national state aid irrespective of the level of ownership,
as venture ownership is a testament to the innovative nature of a business
• Unfortunately, the current General Block Exemption Regulation (GBER) framework, based
on the EU SME Definition, is not fit for purpose as it considers that, beyond a certain
threshold, a VC-backed business is equivalent to being a subsidiary in a trade group.
• This is despite the specificities of private equity ownership – which are detailed in this
paper
• A review of the GBER framework, either as part of the temporary set of measures or of a
tailored revision, could ensure that venture capital and growth-backed businesses could
remain eligible for state aid, taking into consideration the specific nature of their
ownership
• Such a change would help the EU innovation ecosystem by ensuring that the venture capital
model of financing remains available to EU innovative businesses in the appropriate
circumstances
1. Introduction
We support the European Commission objective of adapting the EU State Aid measures to ensure
Member States can incentivise investments in sectors strategic to the green transition and can
develop innovative sources of energy.
As industry representatives, we share the Commission’s belief that we are now at a crossroad for our
continent – and that the combined shock of the aggression of Ukraine and the competition from allies
– meaning that Europe needs to adopt a “whatever it takes” approach to grow its green industrial
sector.
The private equity and venture capital industry is no stranger to the dynamics and benefits of
innovation investment. In 2021, private equity firms supported more than 8895 companies with a
total of €138 billion of investments. Over the years, venture capital has for good reasons become
synonymous with innovation – and it is rare for businesses in innovative sectors not to have at least
received partial funding from venture and growth funds.
From where we stand, our members know perhaps better than any other market players how much
innovative businesses still rely on state aid until the can become European champions. It is often only
with the combined strength of public financing and private support that companies can make it on
the global stage.
This is a virtuous relationship. While private funding from venture capitalists can act as a signal to
the public of which companies have passed a market test, public support can help growing companies
navigate the high seas of international competition.
2. Why is there an issue?
As the Commission is planning to adapt state aid rules to further speed up and simplify state aid in
innovative and green technologies, we want to attract the attention of policymakers to the fact EU
state aid rules still do not acknowledge the nature of venture capital ownership – with the
consequence that any business backed by venture capital, any business that is by nature
innovative and by nature has shown that it has passed a market test, could at some point lose
access to national funding.
This is because the EU definition of an “SME”, which is cross-referred into many EU legislative pieces
including the GBER and the Risk Finance Guidelines, is detrimental to companies backed by private
equity and venture capital.
The two main reasons for this stem from:
(i) the use of the “linked enterprise” concept, which determines that any SME (including
venture owned) which is deemed linked to another is not eligible to the SME status (unless
the two enterprises are together meeting the SME criteria); and
(ii) the reference to venture capital companies (indeed private equity and venture capital
Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) may take the legal form not only of companies but
also mutual funds).
Even though this issue was noticed more than 5 years ago by the European Commission as part of the
revision of the SME definition (which is used in the General Block Exemption Regulation), it has not
yet been tackled. The review of the General Block Exemption Regulation provides a perfect
opportunity resolve it.
3. What is the impact on innovative businesses?
The concept of a linked enterprise has the (largely unintended) consequence that SMEs in which a
(venture or private equity) manager fulfils one or more of the four criteria set out in Article 3,
paragraph 3 (a) – (d) of Annex I of the GBER are considered part of said manager’s group (along with
the manager itself and the other portfolio companies supported by the fund) and a presumption of
dominant influence applies.
This means that venture-capital backed companies will be at a competitive disadvantage for the sole
reason they receive a type of private funding that is specifically designed to cover the needs they
have as innovative businesses.
We already hear examples of businesses that will lose access to EU funding if they are backed by EU
managers and which may either fail or have to resort to receive backing from US managers.
Case study – Company “MEDICAL”1
The company “MEDICAL” (3 employees, balance sheet EUR 2.4 million) was created in 2017. It was
funded by a venture capital fund which currently owns 83% of its capital. It is at risk of losing its
SME status and, as a consequence, of losing the benefit from national aids and subsidies (“Projets
Structurants pour la Compétitivité” programme, part of BPI’s “Investissements d’Avenirs”
Programme).
MEDICAL was created to develop a device preventing serious heart failures. It is a very young - and
small - company, which develops a solution to a key medical issue.
Due to the fact that a venture capital fund owns more than 50% of its capital, MEDICAL may not
qualify for SME status. This implies dramatic consequences for MEDICAL. Indeed, this may limit or
even prohibit its access to aids and subsidies, even though the aim of these programmes is to
promote the financing of upcoming technologies and the development of projects which are key for
the competitiveness of France and of the EU.
In other words, it is not only the entire venture financing ecosystem that is put at risk by the
current design of the EU State Aid rules – but the very competitiveness of the EU industry.
4. Why should a difference be made?
The “linked enterprise” definition is obviously relevant to ensure companies within trade groups
cannot benefit from SME related advantages. We do not question this.
However, we can demonstrate that companies backed by venture capital and private equity do
not share the same advantages as companies that are part of a trade group and should not be
treated in the same way.
The significant differences between private equity ownership and a conglomerate / trade group
relate to:
- the lack of ability, for a private equity backed SME, to rely on the success of the fund or of
other companies within the fund
- the desire of the private equity firm, as of the start of the investment to exit the company
in the foreseeable future
- the lack of integration of different portfolio companies / businesses within or across funds
This means there is an absolute absence of strategic interest: portfolio companies owned by a private
equity fund are not at all linked to each other in the way an industrial group is and the private equity
firm does not have an overarching plan for all of them. This translates into the following
characteristics:
1. Separate accounts
A manager will maintain separate accounts between its firm and the company it invests in, as
documented in the financial contract between the private equity firm and its investees.
2. Absence of consolidated financial statements
Typically, no consolidated financial statements exist for the various portfolio companies held by
different investment funds that are part of the same private equity firm.
1
The case study comes from our sister association France Invest and is based on a portfolio company owned by
one of their member firms.
3. No centralised management
Private equity backed companies do not enjoy joint administration of services or joint legal advice
and are treated completely separately.
4. No right to receive aid from its investors
Private equity backed companies which suffer economic loss generally do not receive financial aid
from the private equity manager or other portfolio companies. Because of the separate accounts
maintained by the manager, the companies will generally also not have access to portfolio-wide
funds, such as cash pool.
5. No involvement in day-to-day management
The private equity manager typically does not get involved in the day-to-day management of the
firm. It usually gets involved at the level of the board, always with the objective of increasing the
value of the company.
6. Number of investors in the entity
Private equity firms act as intermediaries for the investors into the fund. The investors typically
participate as limited partners in investment funds and normally do not have the ability to exercise
control.
5. What is our proposed solution
In light of the above, we call for an amendment to be introduced to the GBER to ensure that, when
owned by a private equity (including venture capital) structure, a company always remains eligible
for state aid. This would acknowledge differences between private equity ownership and trade
groups.
Background
This objective could have been achieved through a change to the SME Recommendation, which
Annex I of the GBER copies. Although such a change was potentially envisaged, the recent SME
Definition Evaluation clarified that no modification of the Recommendation was to take place in the
medium-term2.
While closing the door to a modification of the definition, the Evaluation did however point out that
companies that are backed by venture firms with a majority ownership would “lose the possibility to
access EU funding and other benefits reserved for SMEs” due to the way the current definition is
drafted. It then pointed out that "issues of a specific nature could be better examined within their
particular policy context, while recognising the need to ensure consistency and equal treatment in
view of the horizontal SME Definition”.
Given the European Commission’s recognition that the current GBER setting has a real impact on
start-ups and scale-ups (and its acknowledgment that the issue should be examined) and in the
context of the efforts in making it easier for EU innovative companies to compete with their US
counterparts, there is a legitimate, justified and proportionate case for Annex I of the GBER to be
modified to avoid the confusion between private equity and trade group ownership.
To ensure consistency and to avoid any unwanted loopholes, we propose that such a modification be
restricted to the private equity model meeting the criteria defined in the section above.
Considering this, we would therefore suggest the following changes to Article 3, paragraph 3 of
Annex I of the GBER:
2
SWD(2021) 279 final.
There is a presumption that no dominant influence exists if the investors listed in the second subparagraph of
paragraph 2 are not involving themselves directly or indirectly in the management of the enterprise in question,
without prejudice to their rights as shareholders.
Enterprises which received capital from a venture or private equity fund shall not be deemed linked to
that fund or to other enterprises in which that fund has invested provided that the fund can show that it
has had an exit strategy since the time it acquired its interest the enterprise in question, there are
separate accounts between the manager and the enterprise in question, and the enterprise in question
has no ability to receive financial aid from that fund or the other enterprises in which that fund has
invested.
Terminology issues: the use of the “venture capital company” term
Further to the issue laid out above, another reason why the EU definition of an “SME” has long been
considered detrimental to companies backed by private equity and venture capital is the use of the
term “venture capital companies” to determine eligibility for venture-backed businesses. Indeed,
venture capital AIFs may take the legal form not only of companies but also of mutual funds. As a
result, an SME whose capital is held by a venture capital mutual fund cannot obtain public subsidies.
The reference should therefore be clarified in order to encompass all relevant types of legal forms.
Contact
For further information, please contact Martin Bresson (
[email protected])
Christophe Verboomen (
[email protected]) at Invest Europe.
About Invest Europe
Invest Europe is the association representing Europe’s private equity, venture capital and infrastructure
sectors, as well as their investors.
Our members take a long-term approach to investing in privately held companies, from start-ups to
established firms. They inject not only capital but dynamism, innovation and expertise. This
commitment helps deliver strong and sustainable growth, resulting in healthy returns for Europe’s
leading pension funds and insurers, to the benefit of the millions of European citizens who depend on
them.
Invest Europe aims to make a constructive contribution to policy affecting private capital investment
in Europe. We provide information to the public on our members’ role in the economy. Our research
provides the most authoritative source of data on trends and developments in our industry.
Invest Europe is the guardian of the industry’s professional standards, demanding accountability, good
governance and transparency from our members.
Invest Europe is a non-profit organisation with 25 employees in Brussels, Belgium.
For more information please visit www.investeurope.eu.
Saatja: Antti Perli | Ellex <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 27.02.2023 18:06
Adressaat: <"MKM info">; <"RAM Info">
Teema: Üldise riigiabi grupierandi määruse muutmine (SME definitsioon)
Manused: EstVCA kiri RAMi_ MKMi - SME definitsiooni muudatused.asice
Lugupeetud Rahandusministeerium
Lugupeetud Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Edastan käesolevaga pöördumise MTÜ Eesti Era- ja Riskikapitali Assotsiatsioon esindajana
(„EstVCA“).
Lühidalt palub EstVCA Eesti riigil edastada Euroopa Komisjonile seisukohti muutmaks nn üldise
riigiabi grupierandi määruse (EL) nr 651/2014 sätteid, mis defineerivad väike- ja keskmise
suurusega ettevõtja mõiste riigiabi reeglite kontekstis. Antud mõiste on muutunud vägagi
piiravaks era- ja riskikapitaliinvesteeringuid kaasanud ettevõtjate osas. Edastatud pöördumises
on ka konkreetsed ettepanekud.
Võimalikele küsimustele oleme meelsasti valmis vastama.
Lugupidamisega
Antti Perli
Eesti Era- ja Riskikapitali Assotsiatsioon
Juhatuse liige
This email was produced by law firms Ellex Raidla, Ellex Klavins or Ellex Valiūnas ir partneriai
offices, authorised and regulated by each country‘s legislative acts. The standard terms applicable
to our services are available for the specific office: Ellex Raidla, Ellex Klavins, Ellex Valiunas ir
partneriai, and the privacy policy is available here. This email and its contents are confidential. If
you are not the intended recipient of this email, please delete it and notify the sender.