Strictly Private and Confidential
SOLARIS MOBILE LLC: 2 GHZ BAND MOBILE SATELLITE SERVICE
WITH A COMPLEMENTARY GROUND COMPONENT LICENSEE
ANNUAL REPORT TO THE EUROPEAN UNION AND ITS MEMBER STATES
May 2014
Strictly Private and Confidential
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SECTION PAGE
1.0 SUMMARY .................................................................................................................................4
2.0 OVERVIEW ...............................................................................................................................4
3.0 PROGRESS FOLLOWING ECHOSTAR ACQUISITION...................................................5
4.0 BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT ...........................................................8
4.1 BUSINESS MODEL ..................................................................................................................8
4.2 FUNDING FOR INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT ...................................................8
4.3 COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES ................................................................9
4.4 TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATION ......................................................................................9
4.5 SUPPORTING BUSINESS CASE............................................................................................10
5.0 SATELLITE CONSTRUCTION ..............................................................................................10
6.0 W2A .............................................................................................................................................13
7.0 ALTERNATIVE APPROACHES ............................................................................................13
8.0 SATELLITE LAUNCH AGREEMENT ..................................................................................13
9.0 REGULATORY OVERVIEW ..................................................................................................13
9.1 MEMBER STATE MSS AUTHORISATIONS ......................................................................14
9.2 COORDINATION EFFORTS ..................................................................................................14
9.2.1 W2A Satellite............................................................................................................................14
9.2.2 EchoStar 21 Satellite................................................................................................................15
10.0 CONCLUSION ...........................................................................................................................16
ii
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE PAGE
1. EchoStar 21 Satellite Bus at Systems/Loral (December 2013) ...................................................12
iii
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
1.0 SUMMARY
In compliance with Article 7.2 of Decision 626/2008/EC1 of the European Parliament and of the
Council, Solaris Mobile LLC (SML), as an authorised 2 GHz band operator, is pleased to provide to the
competent authorities of all member states an annual report detailing the status of the development of its
mobile satellite service (MSS) system. SML submits this annual report presenting technology,
commercial, and regulatory developments in the period of June 2013 to May 2014.
This report is divided into a number of sections outlining technology advancements, commercial
achievements, future focus, and regulatory issues. As demonstrated herein, the influx of resources from
EchoStar Corporation (EchoStar®) is enabling SML to make substantial progress on the deployment and
operation of its 2 GHz MSS network with a complementary ground component (CGC) in a manner fully
consistent with European Union (EU) and member state requirements. This report also highlights where
increased harmonisation of national regulatory authorisation and operational frameworks could ensure the
delivery of differentiated services utilising both satellite and terrestrial networks, including advancing the
delivery of mobile connectivity and advanced broadband services to European Union consumers. Finally,
this report, in Appendix A, introduces the new SML board members and team members responsible for
the success of SML.
Should any member state official or the European Commission require additional information, please
contact Jennifer A. Manner, Head of Regulatory Affairs for SML, at
[email protected]
2.0 OVERVIEW
On December 13, 2013, SML was acquired by EchoStar. EchoStar brings to SML the experience of
being the world’s fourth largest operator of geostationary satellites as well as a significant developer and
provider of satellite technology. EchoStar’s experience includes operating two 2 GHz geostationary
mobile satellite systems out of a fleet of 23 geostationary satellites, and being a global leader in the
development of MSS technologies, including the development of hybrid MSS technologies in the 2 GHz
band.
As part of the acquisition, SML has now joined Hughes Networks Systems, LLC (Hughes), as a
member of the EchoStar family of companies. Hughes is the worldwide leader in providing complete
mobile satellite communication solutions. In addition, Hughes is the leading global provider of Very
Small Aperture Terminal (VSAT) services, including in the EU. SML is able to leverage Hughes’ vast
experience in the satellite market as it moves forward with continued deployment and operation of its
MSS services. To further the progress of 2 GHz MSS deployment across the EU, SML is now leveraging
the development of 2 GHz and other MSS technologies that Hughes has been developing for DISH®
Network, THURAYA, and for the Mexican government – the operator of the Solidaridad system.
The EchoStar acquisition has opened the way for SML to enter into a spectrum capacity agreement
with EchoStar for access to a state-of-the-art 2 GHz MSS satellite, EchoStar® 21, which, when launched
in 2016, will have the capability to cover the entire geography of today’s EU with 28 member states.
When operational, EchoStar 21 will bring additional MSS capacity to the EU on top of that already
provided by SML’s W2A satellite.
In addition, EchoStar also brings to SML the financial and other resources necessary to ensuring its
success in the 2 GHz MSS and CGC markets. To this end, in the period of this annual report,
1 Decision No 626/2008/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 June 2008 on the selection
and authorisation of systems providing mobile satellite services (MSS)
4
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
approximately €200M has been expended by SML and EchoStar to ensure the success of SML. SML is
planning to expend significant additional funds on MSS in order to achieve the 2016 launch and
placement in operation of its next-generation MSS system, not including the significant funding necessary
to make CGC a reality.
However, this past year was not just limited to the above developments. SML has also been spending
tremendous resources on business development activities. SML’s business model remains, as it has
always been, based on a wholesale model. Accordingly, SML has and continues to pursue with potential
business partners deployment of its MSS and CGC system. Because of these efforts, SML will be well-
positioned to succeed commercially in advance of the introduction of its additional MSS capacity in early
2016.
SML has also taken significant action on the regulatory front. To date, SML has sought authorisation
for MSS in all 28 member states and has received authorisation in 21 member states to date (as provided
in Appendix B). Further, SML has completed its satellite coordination for the W2A payload, and it has
made the requisite filings with the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) in order to bring into
use EchoStar 21 in a timely manner. Further, as part of the deployment of its MSS/CGC system, SML
has actively participated in relevant standard bodies to advance 2 GHz technologies and standards in
order to facilitate the most efficient use of the 2 GHz band, enable SML and its customers to benefit from
economies of scale, and to help the EU and the member states meet their broadband goals.
Accordingly, SML is making demonstrable progress in bringing its MSS to the EU and the member
states on a timely schedule, thus meeting all its licensing commitments. Once EchoStar 21 is launched
and placed into operation, the entire geography of the current EU will have the mobile connectivity it
requires for its best or even its worst situations. Additionally, as SML begins to deploy and operate its
planned CGC system, the EU and the member states will be ensured of the most efficient use of the 2
GHz band for advanced broadband services. It is fair to say that no other frequency band being developed
today in the EU will be able to capture the efficiencies that SML’s system will be able to capture through
use of the band for both MSS and broadband mobile services.
Despite all these successes, SML continues to face significant regulatory hurdles. These include the
disparate regulations that exist both for MSS and CGC across the EU, which make it very difficult for
SML easily to enter member state markets through the licensing process. More importantly, without a
harmonised approach to the interpretation of the EU decisions on MSS/CGC, SML is faced with a
disjointed marketplace that is hindering the development of a common terrestrial broadband technology
across the EU in the 2 GHz band. Lack of harmonisation will negatively impact innovation in available
services as well as increase costs to EU consumers of SML’s services, as each market will need to have
specifically developed devices and services. This will decrease consumer choices while increasing costs.
Clearly, this is contrary to the intent and the actual language of the European Commission decisions,
which created the MSS/CGC regime. This is coupled with a disparate fee regime in certain member
states, which could act to cripple MSS/CGC services before they are even available. Accordingly, we ask
the European Commission and the member states to continue to work together in the near term to
harmonize these requirements to the benefits of EU consumers across the continent, wherever they live.
3.0 PROGRESS FOLLOWING ECHOSTAR ACQUISITION
The acquisition of SML by EchoStar has repositioned SML to become a global leader in successful
commercial deployment of next-generation hybrid MSS communication systems. SML now has direct
access to the world’s most advanced hybrid MSS communication infrastructure and technology. The
following list highlights the principal achievements since the EchoStar acquisition. These achievements
clearly demonstrate that SML is now well-positioned to deliver to the EU benefits that far exceed those
originally contemplated by the relevant EU decisions:
5
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
Satellite Capacity: The principal problem for SML prior to the EchoStar acquisition was the
inability of its shareholders to provide funding for a satellite that would meet the coverage
requirements under the terms of the harmonized European framework for MSS 2 GHz and
provide the functionality required for successful development of commercial hybrid MSS
services. Now, SML has acquired the necessary satellite capacity from EchoStar. The EchoStar
21 satellite is a state-of-the-art 2 GHz MSS communications satellite that is substantially
constructed and is scheduled to be launched and placed in commercial operation in advance of the
2016 milestone.
Development of Satellite Gateway and Related Infrastructure: In addition to its contract for
use of the entire capacity of EchoStar 21, SML/EchoStar is planning and developing the satellite
earth station gateway and all associated components of a complete MSS communications network
and state-of-the-art ground-based beam forming system. Together with the MSS capacity
agreement, this ensures that SML/EchoStar will have a complete infrastructure solution in place
to support commercial MSS operations by the time EchoStar 21 is placed into operation in early
2016.
Technology and Device Development: The final missing piece of the SML story has been
tangible progress towards the development of commercial 2 GHz band MSS services and
associated end-user devices. For many years, SML has been studying potential markets, trialing
technologies intended to exploit the capabilities of its W2A payload, and planning for additional
satellite capacity. However, successful commercialization of MSS services in the 2 GHz band
depends on actual development of end-user devices and production in commercially viable
quantities. Prior to the EchoStar acquisition, SML’s funding was limited primarily to research
and development testing of DVB-SH broadcast technologies. SML is now pleased to confirm
that, with the support of EchoStar and Hughes, it has now developed plans for an initial offering
of services that will commercialize and build upon SML’s infrastructure investments. SML has
arrangements with EchoStar to ensure the availability and distribution of these initial service
offerings to support the timing of its additional MSS capacity being placed into service.
Business Plan Development: SML, with its new owner, EchoStar, actively reviewed and
redeveloped the SML business plan for MSS and CGC. SML is committed to continuing to
utilize a wholesale model for its MSS/CGC services.
Launch Contract: EchoStar has entered into an agreement with International Launch Services
(ILS) to launch EchoStar 21 in early 2016.
Partner Outreach: SML continues to pursue discussions with a number of potential partners
about the wholesale provision of 2 GHz services, equipment, and other technology partnerships in
certain member states.
Corporate Establishment: SML has established legal entities in four member states in order to
file for regulatory authorisations.
Regulatory Authorisations: SML has filed for regulatory authorisations for MSS from nine
member states, bringing the total of applied for MSS authorisations to 28. To date, SML has
received a total of 21 MSS authorisations and four CGC authorisations. SML expects to have
MSS authorisations in all 28 member states in the near term.
Standards Bodies and Trade Associations: SML has actively participated in key European and
international standards bodies and trade associations, including the European Satellite Operators
Association (ESOA), the ITU, the Conference on European Posts and Telecommunications
(CEPT), the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI), and the Third Generation
6
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
Partnership Project (3GPP), among others. SML continues to make itself a leader in many of
these bodies.
EU and Member State Communications:
– SML has notified all member states and the European Commission of the acquisition of SML
by EchoStar.
– SML has notified all member states and the European Commission of SML’s space segment
capacity agreement for EchoStar 21.
– SML held in-person meetings with more than a dozen member states and the EU, as well as
presented updates at the January COCOM meeting.
– SML has notified all member states and the European Commission of SML filing for MSS
authorisations in member states.
– SML continues to hold regular and ad hoc meetings and conference calls with European
Commission staff, and member state regulatory bodies and ministries, to enable the
successful deployment and operation of SML’s 2 GHz MSS/CGC system.
ITU Filings and Coordination:
– SML has completed ITU notification of W2A over the EU. It has also continued efforts to
conclude coordination with terrestrial users in the Middle East.
– SML has caused to be filed two ITU API filings for EchoStar 21 through the United
Kingdom.
Standard Development:
– 3GPP: SML attended the 3GPP TSG-RAN Working Group 4 meeting in February and the
3GPP TSG RAN Plenary Meeting in March. SML advanced several key proposals on band
planning and adjacent band compatibility, such as affects handsets and CGC base stations, as
the study item continues to develop.
– CEPT: SML prepared and presented submissions to advance LTE development and to
obtain adjacent channel protection from proposed air-to-ground service in the 2 GHz band.
– ETSI: SML is actively monitoring developments in the SES TC regarding applicability of
SML offerings for emergency communications (STF 473) and all work items studying the use
of 2 GHz spectrum for integrated MSS.
7
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
4.0 BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT2
4.1 BUSINESS MODEL
SML is positioned as a wholesale infrastructure provider, enabling service providers to offer a range of
hybrid mobile satellite services to their customers and markets, including in the commercial and
government sectors. This business approach has two important advantages:
It allows a flexible basis to respond appropriately to the needs of the very diverse EU marketplace,
respecting national and regional differences in business models, services needs, and spending patterns.
It is perfectly in line with European regulatory and market trends towards “functional separation” between
core infrastructure and service companies.
The principal business challenge faced by SML to date has been an inability to invest more significantly
in customer and device development. SML is addressing this problem by assessing the level of funding
required for the development of business models, devices, and retail partners so that the promise of next-
generation hybrid MSS and CGC services can be realized in the EU. SML’s commercial development
activities currently are focused on three key areas:
1. Implementation of next-generation hybrid MSS technology standards
2. Identification of foundation service opportunities and related device development
3. Identification of potential partners
Specific developments in these three categories are discussed in more detail below.
4.2 FUNDING FOR INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT
To date, SML is planning to execute a wholesale infrastructure business plan on the basis of its space
segment (made up of EchoStar 21 and W2A and/or any alternative space segment capacity). The
EchoStar 21 satellite, and its launch and accompanying ground infrastructure, are valued at more than
€400M. SML is fully funded by its parent for these activities. Therefore, SML is financed to execute its
business plan, providing customers across the Europe Union with MSS in the 2 GHz band, as required by
the EU 2 GHz regulatory regime.
SML is purchasing its space segment from EchoStar, who is under contract for the EchoStar 21 2 GHz
band satellite. Today, EchoStar operates two MSS 2 GHz satellites over North America, so it has
substantial relevant operational experience with 2 GHz MSS satellites. EchoStar 21 is currently under
construction at Space Systems/Loral, and construction is expected to be complete in first quarter of 2016,
with launch planned for shortly thereafter by ILS. EchoStar is contractually committed to provide SML
with the necessary 2 GHz band space segment capacity to deliver innovative MSS services across the EU,
in compliance with the terms of the pan-European framework for MSS 2 GHz and its national
authorisations.
SML may procure or lease additional or alternative 2 GHz band space segment resources in due course in
order to satisfy the growing market for MSS services. SML is confident of the prospects for mobile
2 SML’s current business and technological plan, as with any such plan, is only a snapshot forecast based on
the best of SML’s knowledge to date, and in the context of the current market opportunities and regulatory
constraints. As markets are in constant evolution, driven by changes in consumer attitudes, competitive
moves, global financial conditions, and a host of other influencing factors, these plans will continue to evolve.
8
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
satellite services in Europe, given its careful review of EU market demands and the demonstrated need for
mobile connectivity across the EU, including in its territorial waterways.
4.3 COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES
SML continues to pursue partnerships with equipment vendors, mobile satellite service resellers,
terrestrial service providers, terrestrial infrastructure operators, potential customers, and other key market
players to ensure availability of the required services, technology, and equipment to meet EU market
demands. As discussed below, SML is very active in a number of standards bodies to advance
appropriate standards and technologies in order to capture the economies of scale necessary for successful
operation of its MSS and CGC system.
SML is also planning, on a case-by-case basis, to enter into specific business arrangements related, for
instance, to deployment of CGC. As is the case with MSS, SML is planning a wholesale model for CGC.
SML believes that a wholesale model will best enable it to structure its products and services in a manner
that is responsive to the individual member state markets it chooses to enter.
4.4 TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATION
With regard to technology development, SML is actively engaged in evaluating and assessing multiple
technology options and multiple device types for implementation and commercial development of its 2
GHz band MSS service. These efforts include operational considerations (e.g., finalizing orbital slot
location, gateway location) as well as commercial considerations that will drive technology decisions.
SML is currently evaluating numerous air interface standards and associated technologies for use in its
networks. While the list is quite long, SML has identified the following as the most promising.
GMR1-3G: Hughes is the world expert in the development of the GMR1-3G standard. Hughes
has supported the efforts of the U.S.-based 2 GHz band operators and other satellite customers,
including for base stations and mobile terminals utilizing this technology.
EGAL/xHRPD: Hughes has embarked on development, testing, and implementation of an
EGAL-based satellite base station.
S-MIM: SML is considering the possible use of S-MIM technology in conjunction with the
W2A satellite, and/or with EchoStar 21, for a broadcast service throughout the EU.
Development of Next-Generation Devices: One of the best ways to accelerate the development
of a robust hybrid MSS ecosystem in the EU is to sponsor development of compelling next-
generation products and services. Therefore, in addition to its funding of SML’s space segment
and related ground infrastructure, EchoStar initially is assisting SML by analyzing and
sponsoring device development to support growth of the following key hybrid MSS business
segments:
– Traditional MSS Voice and Data Services: There is a significant opportunity to capture
market share in traditional voice and other legacy MSS segments by deploying next-
generation hybrid devices integrated with terrestrial services.
– M2M and the Universe of Connected Devices: Advanced hybrid MSS networks are
expected to play a key role in providing ubiquitous and seamless connectivity to the growing
universe of connected and interoperable devices. SML expects that its networks and related
communications modules will become the cornerstone of pan-European harmonized
9
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
connectivity for many thousands of new applications that will develop organically over the
next 5-10 years.
– Mass Consumption of Hybrid MSS Connectivity: SML believes there is a large untapped
demand at the individual consumer level for seamless, harmonized, pan-European
connectivity that does not rely exclusively on terrestrial networks. Therefore, Hughes and
SML have begun development of a next-generation mass-produced consumer device that will
integrate satellite voice and data connectivity with terrestrial data networks and several other
compelling functions to drive consumer demand.
– Smartphone Integration: SML, EchoStar, and Hughes are extending the work of a
consortium of MSS players to develop and produce chipsets and software that will enable
standard smartphones to connect to SML’s satellite network. Once this goal is fully realized,
SML expects to see development of robust demand for the resulting highly cost-effective
satellite connectivity in a range of segments, ranging from general consumer demand to
public safety and many other key market segments.
With EchoStar’s assistance and support, SML is confident that by the time EchoStar 21 is launched and
commences commercial operation in early 2016, SML will have next-generation devices in production
and available to end-users to support each of the market segments described above.
4.5 SUPPORTING BUSINESS CASE
SML’s business case continues to evolve as it works with EchoStar to explore the opportunities that will
be afforded by access to EchoStar’s next-generation hybrid MSS infrastructure and technology. It is now
possible to provide a rough outline of the expected size of the different opportunities described above.
SML currently expects that approximately half of its required return on investment will derive from the
extension of existing MSS applications through the capture of market share and expansion of the
addressable market for such services. Secondarily, SML expects to generate returns through the
development of new addressable markets utilizing new mass consumer markets and smartphone
integration. Finally, SML expects to be able to partner with new and incumbent terrestrial operators to
provide wholesale terrestrial LTE connectivity on a pan-European basis. It is the combination of the
returns from these multiple and complementary opportunities that enables SML to expect attractive
returns on its investments in hybrid MSS infrastructure, technologies, and products. SML is also
continuing to develop its roadmap for CGC services, both on a standalone basis and as part of a hybrid
MSS product and service. However, as discussed below, it is important that the fragmentation in Member
State regulatory regimes be addressed to ensure that this important broadband service can be deployed
across the EU.
5.0 SATELLITE CONSTRUCTION
On December 13, 2013, SML contracted for MSS capacity on EchoStar 21 with EchoStar Satellite
Operating Corporation.3 EchoStar 21 is currently under construction by Space Systems/Loral. EchoStar
21 is a state-of-the-art 2 GHz band MSS satellite that is configured to cover the entire geographic
footprint of the EU. EchoStar 21 has a high-gain 18 m reflector that will enable communications to
mobile, internal-antenna devices sharing key terrestrial protocols (e.g., GMR1 and GMR2, S-UMTS,
DVB-SH, xHRPD) or simple designs (Omnitracs, Orbcomm). To date, approximately €225M has been
spent on construction.
3 Under this agreement, SML has rights to the 2x15 MHz band of the 2 GHz band space segment capacity on
EchoStar 21 that it is authorized to operate within.
10
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
The EchoStar 21 technical characteristics are:
General
Orbital Location: European arc
Satellite Bus: SSL 1300E
EOL Power (SS): 15.8 kW
Mass (Dry/Wet) 3848/6934 kg
Est.:
Launch Vehicle: Proton M/Breeze M-Phase IV Enhanced/Falcon 9 Heavy
Battery: 62 cell, 92 Ah Lithium-ion
TC&R: Ka-band 2.2 m reflector
Payload
Forward Link: Gateway: 27.5 – 28.0 GHz
User: 2170 - 2200 MHz
Return Link: Gateway: 17.7 – 18.7 GHz
User: 1980–2010 MHz
2 GHz Band 18 m unfurlable mesh reflector
Antenna:
2 GHz Band Feed: 62 element transmit, 78 element receive
Coverage: 28 EU countries
To date, the EchoStar 21 satellite program has completed the following significant milestones:
Propulsion/structure module is complete.
Main body/bus/structure is assembly complete.
Satellite communications payload panels RF pathways complete, and started final component
integration.
Feeder link antennas are fabricated.
2 GHz band feed array 90% fabricated and assembled.
18 m S-band antenna 90% fabricated. Currently in mechanical and performance review.
Qualification of most RF hardware components complete.
Multiple component design reviews completed.
Preliminary Design Review (PDR) completed.
Key unit and hardware critical design reviews completed.
In July 2014, SSL is scheduled to begin the assembly, integration, and subsystem testing of the satellite
communications payload. In early 2015, a rigorous campaign of overall testing will begin to ensure
system integrity and reliability. The following milestones are planned:
System Critical Design Review (CDR): July 2014
11
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
18 m antenna testing at manufacturer: July 2014
Satellite assembly and integration: July 2014 – Jan 2015
Main body and component reference performance testing complete: Jan 2015
Satellite antenna integration complete: March 2015
Satellite systems and dynamics testing: April – August 2015
Antenna electrical performance testing on test range: August – October 2015
Ready to ship: February 2016
Satellite launch: March 2016
The EchoStar 21 program execution continues to follow its plan. SML is on schedule to have the satellite
shipped to the launch base in the first quarter of 2016. All critical path items have been identified to
mitigate slips in the satellite construction schedule. The satellite manufacturer has ordered all RF
hardware, and the scheduled deliveries are factored into our overall program plan for the satellite. SML
has completed Equipment Qualification Status Reviews for all equipment, and the required unit-level
reviews have been scheduled and are ongoing.
Figure 1. EchoStar 21 Satellite Bus at Systems/Loral (December 2013)
12
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
6.0 W2A
The W2A satellite remains operational and is capable of providing meaningful MSS services that cover a
significant portion of the European landmass. SML is now in discussions with potential end users,
distribution partners, and technology vendors to explore using W2A to provide significant enhanced MSS
broadcast services, including multimedia, datacasting, and other services. These discussions are focused
primarily on building upon the prior work of SML and its prior shareholders to develop broadcast and
interactive services utilizing the DVB-SH/S-MIM-based technologies.
7.0 ALTERNATIVE APPROACHES
As noted in its initial application to the EU, SML noticed several options to offer the required MSS in the
EU, including launching and operating a satellite, purchasing capacity from another party, or sharing
infrastructure with another MSS provider. SML hereby provides appropriate notice that it is currently in
discussions with at least one other MSS provider to share infrastructure to provide its planned 2 GHz
MSS services in the EU in a manner consistent with its EU and member state obligations. If such an
agreement is reached, SML could recognize substantial cost savings for its MSS, and also could form an
important strategic partnership. SML will keep the EU and the member states advised of the progress of
these discussions.
8.0 SATELLITE LAUNCH AGREEMENT
EchoStar, SML’s space segment capacity provider, entered into a launch services agreement in
May 2013 with ILS for the launch of EchoStar 21 in the first quarter of 2016 from the Baikonur
Cosmodrome in Kazakhstan. The satellite, weighing more than 6900 kg, is planned to be
launched into geostationary transfer orbit on an ILS Proton Breeze M launch vehicle. The
planned launch remains on schedule.
9.0 REGULATORY OVERVIEW
SML has continued to work with member states and the European Commission to progress all aspects of
its regulatory agenda. This effort has focused on a number of areas, including applying for and obtaining
MSS authorisations throughout the EU, completion of the coordination of W2A, beginning the
notification process of EchoStar 21, advancing the development of key standards for MSS/CGC, and
encouraging the development of a harmonized definition of CGC, consistent with EU Decisions, that
enables the use of CGC for interactive, broadband communications throughout the EU. To date, SML is
fully compliant with all European Commission and member state requirements. Further, SML has
actively participated in a number of regulatory proceedings at the member state and EU levels, including,
for example, responding to the Radio Spectrum Policy Group on their regulatory opinion on the strategic
challenges facing Europe in addressing growing spectrum demand for mobile broadband, and
participating in OFCOM proceedings on spectrum policy. SML recognizes the importance of each
member state’s regulatory regime in its efforts to deploy an EU-wide MSS/CGC service throughout the
EU.
13
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
9.1 MEMBER STATE MSS AUTHORISATIONS
SML has applied for MSS authorisations in all 28 EU member states and has received authorisations in 20
member states. As part of this process, SML has had to establish in-country entities in Bulgaria,
Slovakia, the Czech Republic, and Latvia. This process has been both costly and time-consuming, taking
several months to achieve. Once SML receives all MSS authorisations, which it anticipates will occur
shortly, SML will be fully authorised to provide pan-EU commercial MSS.
With respect to the authorisation process for CGC, a number of member states have yet to complete and
publish their national authorisation frameworks. A number of other member states have adopted
contradictory regimes. The development of CGC and a harmonized EU-wide regulatory regime that
enables the use of two-way broadband technologies, such as LTE, is critical to achieving Pillar IV of the
European Commission’s Digital Agenda with regard to the availability of fast and ultra-fast Internet
access throughout the EU, as well as the broadband plans of may member states.
In many member states that have established a CGC regime, there is an inconsistency in implementation.
This fragmentation has a direct impact on the commercial strategy of SML, as it is not able to provide a
ubiquitous service offering across all member states. This is contrary to the goals of the single market.
These differences directly impact costs and universal service ambitions of the EU and its consumers of
terrestrial broadband services. SML believes that these inconsistencies also run counter to the intent of
the European Commission and the member states in adopting the pan-European 2 GHz band regulatory
requirements. Accordingly, SML urges the European Commission and its member states immediately to
work together to develop a harmonised CGC regime, consistent with European Commission decisions in
this area. By doing so, the EU and its member states will be able to fulfil the vision of the 2 GHz band
regime and enable the deployment of greater broadband services throughout the EU.
9.2 COORDINATION EFFORTS
9.2.1 W2A Satellite
The W2A satellite at 10°E for the 2 GHz band operations relies on the two ITU filings –3GSAT-G17R
and F-SAT-S-E-10E. Coordination of frequency assignments for the 3GSAT-G17R satellite network has
been successfully concluded for 54 cases (out of 57 coordination requests). All coordination cases with
CEPT countries, be it relating to satellite networks or terrestrial services, are complete. The notification
of frequency assignments in the 2 GHz MSS band of 3GSAT-G17R has been published by the ITU in
BR IFIC 2697, under identification number 110500239, and shows that the only remaining cases
identified for ITU filing 3GSAT-G17R include Egypt, Iran, and Pakistan. The few pending coordination
cases with 2 GHz band terrestrial services for 3GSAT-G17R and F-SAT-S-E-10E, noting that these cases
are outside of Europe, will continue to be addressed through coordination meetings and formal
correspondence.
Again, all coordination cases with CEPT countries, be it regarding satellite networks or terrestrial
services, are complete. This filing allows for the operations of the satellite to cover the whole EU and
beyond. The notification of frequency assignments in the 2 GHz MSS band of F-SAT-S-E-10E has been
published by the ITU in BR IFIC 2742 under identification number 112500206 and shows that the only
remaining coordination cases (with respect to terrestrial services only) identified for ITU filing F-SAT-S-
E-10E include Iran, Morocco, and Pakistan.
14
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
9.2.2 EchoStar 21 Satellite
EchoStar, the EchoStar 21 satellite operator, has chosen to work through the UK overseas territory,
Bermuda, for the authorisations of EchoStar 21. Bermuda, through the UK, has sent advanced
publication informations (APIs) for two new satellite networks ECHOSTAR-SM1 (17.2°E) and
ECHOSTAR-SM2 (22°E) to the ITU, which were received on March 27, 2014, on behalf of EchoStar
Bermuda. These filings both match the technical characteristics of EchoStar 21. Both APIs submitted
will provide service over the ITU Region 1 and Visible Earth, with the planned frequency band ranges of
operation for EchoStar 21 in the Ka-band and S-band. EchoStar is actively working to identify the
appropriate orbital location in this range whereby it can gain access to Ka-band feeder link spectrum.
EchoStar hopes to complete this effort in the near term so it can finalize its orbital location and gateway
station location. Currently, EchoStar is actively coordinating with several European operators for access
to the Ka-band so that SML can locate EchoStar 21 and its single European gateway in the best possible
location to provide MSS services to EU consumers.
Given the junior status of SML’s Bermuda filings, EchoStar’s ability to bring E21 into service is
dependent on the successful coordination with one or more of the incumbent EU member state Ka-band-
licensed GSO operators. Success is not ensured.
The EchoStar 21 filings mentioned above will take advantage of the 2 GHz band coordination of
frequency assignments for the 3GSAT-G17R and F-SAT-S-E-10E satellite networks, which have been
successfully concluded. In order to do this, the operations of the EchoStar 21 satellite will fall within the
filed and coordinated parameters of the W2A Notified ITU filings. If the EchoStar 21 satellite is at a new
orbital location other than the 10°E, existing coordination agreements will be reassessed, based on a
technical analysis, to ascertain if an amendment to the existing coordination agreements or new
coordination will be required.
9.2.2.1 Advancing the 3GPP Standard for the 2 GHz Band Allocation
SML, through its membership in ETSI, is an active participant at 3GPP. Through its participation at
3GPP, SML, along with other contributors, drive the implementation of the future specifications for the
MSS 2 GHz S-band frequencies as an E-UTRA (LTE) band. The current activities at 3GPP continue to
advance the on-going Study Item (SI) addressing the addition of a 2 GHz FDD E-UTRA band in the
frequency range of 1980-2010 MHz (uplink) and 2170-2200 MHz (downlink) in applicable countries in
ITU Region 1. Within 3GPP, this activity is being progressed by SML, along with other operators and
LTE device and infrastructure equipment vendors, including DISH Network, Eutelsat SA, SES SA, and
Inmarsat Plc.
SML has informed TSG RAN that they will be closing the SI in June 2014, as planned. The goal is to
introduce a Work Item (WI) at the June 2014 meeting. During the WI stage, the actual frequency band
specification process will begin, as it relates to MSS 2 GHz. Activity undertaken as part of a WI typically
could take anywhere from 9-18 months to achieve consensus on defining a new frequency band. Due to
the nature of this band, its adjacent operations and the global harmonization aspect, it is expected that it
will take the full 18 months to complete.
SML, working with its partners, continues to drive the standardization of the new 2 GHz frequency band
through analysis, offline and online consensus building, and new contributions at each of the upcoming
3GPP RAN4 and RAN meetings.
15
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
9.2.2.2 CEPT Update
SML is active in various CEPT groups, in particular, those addressing the 2 GHz MSS band.
Specifically, SML has been actively involved in ECC SE40 on technical matters, such as the
compatibility between MSS in the 2 GHz MSS band and other services in adjacent bands, and in PT
FM44 on regulatory matters. Similarly, SML also follows the activities of WGSE on technical matters
and WGFM (Frequency Management) on regulatory matters.
In WG SE40, Inmarsat has started a new Work Item (WI SE40_24) on a proposal for the use of
aeronautical CGCs in the 2GHs MSS band. Beyond the regulatory issues raised by this proposal, which
will be discussed further at EC and CEPT levels, it raises a number of critical technical issues. SML
highlights that the use of such aeronautical CGCs would cause unacceptable interference within and
outside the 2 GHz MSS band itself (i.e., interference from Inmarsat aeronautical CGCs into SML
operations). SML also highlighted the scenarios and issues of co-channel interference. In this case, the
use of such aeronautical CGCs would cause unacceptable interference, considering different operators
outside the EU.
SML will continue to be active in these CEPT groups to address any matter related to the 2 GHz MSS
band in the future and ensure the establishment of a comprehensive regulatory framework for the 2 GHz
MSS band in the EU.
10.0 CONCLUSION
SML welcomes the chance to share the exciting progress that the past year has brought to the company
and to the further development and deployment of 2 GHz services. In the past year alone, approximately
€200M have been invested in ensuring that SML achieves the goals of the European Commission and the
member states in the 2 GHz MSS/CGC regime. During the next year, SML will build on the progress of
this past year. Areas of focus include constructing EchoStar 21, obtaining MSS licenses in all member
states, beginning the ITU coordination process for EchoStar 21, advancing our technology development
for 2 GHz MSS and CGC, advancing the harmonization of the CGC regulatory regime, and working with
potential partners across the EU to ensure that the benefits of MSS and CGC are widely available across
the Europe. However, moving forward with these actions requires the continuing support of the European
Commission and the member states. Failure to address the market barriers that SML faces in the
regulatory process has a crippling effect on the development of MSS/CGC. The requirement for a
common MSS and CGC authorisation and operational structure is key to the successful deployment of an
MSS/CGC system in the 2 GHz band. SML requests member states to fulfil their national responsibility
and adopt a framework that respects Decision 626/2008/EC and affords SML with the opportunity to
continue to deliver on its commitments to EU consumers, providing additional consumer choice,
opportunity, and services at cost-effective rates for MSS and terrestrial broadband services.
Since the award of spectrum access rights to SML in 2009, much has been achieved. SML has invested
in the downstream technology required to realise services. SML has focused and tailored market
offerings to meet the demands of specific market sectors, and SML has fulfilled all regulatory conditions
of its authorisation, as mandated in Article 7 of Decision 626/2008/EC.
Respectfully submitted by,
Jennifer A. Manner
Head of Regulatory Affairs
Solaris Mobile LLC
[email protected]
16
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
APPENDIX A MEET THE SML TEAM
Board Members
Charles W. Ergen – Chairman of the Board of Directors
Charles W. Ergen serves as the Chairman of the SML Board of
Directors. Mr. Ergen also serves as executive Chairman and
Chairman of the Board of Directors of EchoStar. Mr. Ergen was
Chief Executive Officer of EchoStar from its formation in October
2007 until November 2009. Mr. Ergen also served as EchoStar’s
President from June 2008 until November 2009. Mr. Ergen is also
executive Chairman of DISH Network and has been Chairman of the
Charles W. Ergen
Board of Directors of DISH Network since its formation. Mr. Ergen
co-founded DISH Network with his wife, Cantey M. Ergen, and
James DeFranco, in 1980.
Anders N. Johnson – Board Member
Anders N. Johnson is a Board Member of SML. Mr. Johnson also
serves as President of EchoStar Satellite Services LLC. Prior to
joining EchoStar, Anders worked for SES, where he was Senior Vice
President of Strategic Satellite Development. Mr. Johnson joined SES
GLOBAL after the combination of GE AMERICOM and SES in
2001. Prior to SES, he worked at GE from 1985 in a variety of
Anders N. Johnson
executive-level roles, including Satellite Services, Aviation Services,
and Transportation & Industrial Financing.
Dean A. Manson – Board Member
Dean Manson services as a Board Member for SML. Mr. Manson is
responsible for all legal and government affairs for EchoStar
Corporation and its subsidiaries, including SML. Mr. Manson joined
Hughes, an EchoStar company, in 2000 from the law firm of
Milbank, Tweed, Hadley & McCloy, where he focused on
international project finance and corporate transactions. Mr. Manson
Dean A. Manson
began his tenure as General Counsel of Hughes in 2004. He was
instrumental in the successful consolidation of the Hughes Network
Systems and EchoStar Corporation legal departments.
17
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
Team Members
Pat Amodio – Spectrum Development
Pat Amodio provides strategic regulatory guidance and advocacy
support on spectrum issues. Prior to joining EchoStar in 2013, Mr.
Amodio was employed as Chief Engineer at US Customs and Border
Protection, Chief of RF Engineering at the US Federal
Communications Commission, Senior Electronics Engineer at the
Pat Amodio Defense Information Systems Agency, and Engineering Manager at
T-Mobile USA. Mr. Amodio is a key member of the SML spectrum
management team.
Chris Britton – Managing Director, Hughes Europe
Chris Britton spearheaded Hughes’ expansion across Europe. Mr.
Britton possesses broad senior management and specialist sector
expertise in network integration services. Prior to joining Hughes,
Chris founded European Telecommunications and Technology
(ETT), a successful virtual network operator that was sold to a US
organization. During the span of his career, Mr. Britton held a variety
Chris Britton
of engineering, sales management, and marketing roles at TMI, the
international arm of Telecom Italia, Energis, AT&T, and BT. Mr.
Britton plays a key role in Solaris Mobile’s business development.
Ken G. Carroll – Corporate and Business Development
Mr. Carroll has more than 20 years of experience in the satellite TV
and satellite broadband industry. Ken has held several positions with
EchoStar, including Chief Financial Officer, Chief Operating Officer
of EchoStar Satellite Services, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the
Ken G. Carroll company, and Executive Vice President of Business Development
and International. Ken Carroll leads SML’s corporate strategy team.
Derek de Bastos – Satellite Technology
Mr. de Bastos has managed large-scale satellite systems from
conception to in-orbit operation. Previously, Mr. de Bastos was Vice
President of Engineering at SiriusXM Radio, a position he held since
Derek de Bastos Sirius and XM merged in 2008. He also held management positions
with Worldspace and Lockheed Martin (formerly RCA) Astro Space.
Mr. de Bastos leads SML’s satellite technology team.
18
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
Team Members
Jaime Londono – Advanced Programs & Spectrum Management
Mr. Londono worked for SES as Director of Spectrum and Market
Development. While at SES, Mr. Londono developed global satellite
expansion plans in support SES’s business strategy for new satellite
markets. In addition, Mr. Londono led SES’s satellite frequency
spectrum activities before the FCC, OFCOM, GRA, ITU, and other
Jaime Londono administrations. Mr. Londono manages SML’s Spectrum
Management team.
Jennifer A. Manner – Regulatory Affairs
Ms. Manner has more than 20 years of experience in industry and in
government on a wide range of issues, including satellite licensing,
spectrum management, broadband deployment, and foreign market
access, including holding senior positions at the US Federal
Communications Commission, MCI/WorldCom, Inc., Skyterra LLP
(now LightSquared), and TerreStar LLP. Ms. Manner is the author of
numerous books and articles, including Global Communications
Market Access and Spectrum Wars, authoritative texts on global
Jennifer A. Manner telecommunications markets and spectrum from a commercial,
governmental, and legal perspective. Ms. Manner also serves as a
professor of law at Georgetown University Law Center. Ms. Manner
leads SML’s regulatory affairs department.
Seth Parkoff – Principal Engineer
Mr. Parkoff possesses a wealth of hands-on experience, leading
successful telecommunications projects in operations, engineering,
strategic planning, and network build planning. Mr. Parkoff is an
experienced RF engineer in cellular and satellite systems. Prior to
Seth Parkoff joining, Mr. Parkoff held leadership positions with TerreStar
Networks, AT&T, Comcast, and the US Air force. Mr. Parkoff is
responsible for SML’s standards and technology.
19
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
Team Members
David J. Rayner – Chief Financial Officer
Mr. Rayner has a long history with EchoStar, dating back to 2004
when EchoStar and DISH Network Corporation (DISH) were part of
the same company. At DISH, he served first as Chief Financial
Officer and later as Executive Vice President of Installation and
Service Networks. After the spinoff of EchoStar in 2008, Mr. Rayner
David J. Rayner served first as EchoStar’s Chief Administrative Officer and later as
Chief Financial Officer of EchoStar until 2011. Mr. Rayner leads
SML’s finance team.
Steven Schaver – Business Development
Mr. Schaver has served as President of EchoStar International
Corporation since April 2000. After joining the company, Mr. Shaver
worked for several years at the EchoStar office in Almelo,
Netherlands. Mr. Schaver served as DISH Network’s Chief Financial
Steven Schaver Officer from February 1996 through August 2000. He also served as
DISH Network’s Chief Operating Officer from November 1996 until
April 2000. Mr. Schaver leads SML’s business development team.
Vernon Smith – Business Development
Mr. Smith previously led the merger and acquisition activities as well
as technology investments for the Socíeté Européenne des Satellites
in Luxembourg, most notably developing business plans for SES
Astra. Prior to his work in Europe, Mr. Smith held positions with an
international pay television consulting firm and DIRECTV
Vernon Smith
International. Mr. Smith is a member of the SML Corporate
Development team.
20
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY
Strictly Private and Confidential Solaris Mobile LLC Annual Report to The European Union
June 2014
APPENDIX B MEMBER STATES WHERE SML HOLDS AUTHORISATIONS
FOR MSS
1. Austria
2. Belgium
3. Bulgaria (pending)
4. Croatia
5. Cyprus (pending)
6. Czech Republic (pending)
7. Denmark
8. Estonia
9. Finland
10. France
11. Germany
12. Greece (pending)
13. Hungary
14. Ireland
15. Italy
16. Latvia (pending)
17. Lithuania
18. Luxembourg
19. Malta
20. The Netherlands
21. Poland
22. Portugal (pending)
23. Romania (pending)
24. Slovakia (pending)
25. Slovenia
26. Spain
27. Sweden
28. United Kingdom
APPENDIX C MEMBER STATES WHERE SML HOLDS AUTHORISATIONS
FOR CGC
1. Sweden
2. Spain
3. Germany
4. Italy
21
SOLARIS MOBILE PROPRIETARY