Saatja: Enn Kreem <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 06.10.2021 15:09
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; RAM
Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: Fwd: FW: ECSA position paper on FuelEU Maritime
Tere lugupeetavad!
Saadame teile infoks Euroopa Ühenduse Laevaomanike Assotsiatsiooni
(ECSA) positsiooni ja soovitused EL Komisjoni poolt välja pakutud FuelEU
Maritime direktiivi osas, millega Eesti Laevaomanike Liit (ELL)
täielikult nõustub.
Need ECSA seisukohad võiksid kajastuda ka Eesti positsioonis
läbirääkimistel.
ECSA seisukohad: ( täismahus lisatud )
-Juriidiline vastutus kütuse standardite täitmise eest peab olema pandud
ELi kütuse tarnijatel, nagu see on teistes sektorites, mitte laevale kui
kütuse kasutajale.
-Eraldi fondi loomine ELi heitkogustega kauplemise süsteemi (ETS) raames,
et kasutada tulusid nii, et puhtamad kütused oleksid kaubanduslikult
kättesaadavad.
-Tuleb vältida laevandusettevõtete kahekordset aruandlust ja kontrolli
ning selle direktiivi jaoks lisa MRV süsteemi loomist. FuelEU
merendusmääruse rakendamiseks vajalik teave tuleks integreerida
olemasolevasse ELi MRV -süsteemi.
-Laevade sadama elektrisüsteemi kohustuslikust kasutamisest (OPS)
vabastamine juhul kui infrastruktuur pole sadamas saadaval ja kui laeva
pardal olevad elektriseadmed ei ole sadamaga ühilduvad.
Lugupidamisega
Enn Kreem
ELL peasekretär
-------- Edastatud kiri --------
Teema: ECSA C-12272 For information - Final ECSA position paper on FuelEU
MaritimeKuupäev: Tue, 5 Oct 2021 16:14:18 +0000Saatja: Sotiris Raptis
Saaja: ECSA - Committee Safety & Environment , ECSA - National
Associations , ECSA - Secretariat ToECSA - Committee Safety & Environment
ECSA - National Associations
ECSA - Secretariat
Ref.ECSA C-1227205/10/2021
For information - Final ECSA position paper on FuelEU Maritime
Dear members,
Following up on the decision of SEC yesterday, we are sending you the
final version of the ECSA position paper on the FuelEU Maritime proposal.
There are minor changes in the introduction of the paper compared to the
draft which was discussed in SEC. Please find attached a clean version
and a version with track-changes.
A draft technical annex to the position paper will be prepared by the
secretariat.
Please let us know if you need further information or any clarifications.
Best regards,
Sotiris Raptis
Sotiris Raptis Director Maritime Safety and Environment
Boulevard du Régent, Regentlaan 43-44, 1000 Brussels, BelgiumT +32 2 510
61 25 -
ECSA position paper on FuelEU Maritime proposal
October 2021
1. Introduction
ECSA welcomes the increased climate ambition of the ‘Fit for 55’ climate
package published on 14th of July, recognising that the climate crisis is one of the
greatest humanitarian, economic and environmental challenges our societies are
facing. However, European shipowners notice a lack of consistency among some
of the proposals of the package which may undermine its environmental objectives
and therefore urge for more consistency.
Even though an international solution for shipping would be preferable,
shipping should contribute its share to address the climate crisis, at EU level as well.
ECSA supports the objective of the FuelEU Maritime proposal to foster the market
uptake of cleaner fuels that are currently not affordable and/or commercially
available. However, the proposal does not seem to be consistent either with other
proposals of the ‘Fit for 55’ climate package or with the overall increased climate
ambition. ECSA has warned long before the proposal was published about its
unintended negative consequences and had commissioned a study with the
International Chamber of Shipping to explore the efficacy and implications of
potential measures.
The proposal sets up a fuel standard for ships taking the carbon intensity of fuels
used in 2020 as a reference line. It also introduces a mandate for the use of
Onshore Power Supply for two ship types, i.e. passenger ships and containerships.
The geographical scope covers energy used at berth and on intra-EU voyages as well
as 50% of the energy used on voyages departing from or arriving to the EU. The
proposed Regulation introduces a pooling mechanism allowing companies to join
forces in order meet the carbon intensity target as well as EU harmonised penalties
for missing the target or for failing to use Onshore Power Supply at berth. It also sets
up a new separate and additional MRV system as well as a methodology of life cycle
analysis of fuels.
ECSA supports the increase of the share of renewable and low-carbon fuels
in the sector’s fuel mix. However, key elements need to be taken into consideration
to ensure that the proposal delivers its objectives. ECSA has developed an initial set
of proposals to enhance the dialogue with the EU policy makers, to ensure that
increased climate ambition of the ‘Fit for 55’ package is met and to safeguard the
competitiveness of European shipping. ECSA recommends that the FuelEU Maritime
becomes more consistent with the rest of the proposals of the ‘Fit for 55’ package.
1
2. Points of concern and ECSA recommendations
FuelEU may become a missed opportunity due to enforcement
loopholes
The proposal aims to introduce mandatory EU fuel standards with respect to the
carbon content of marine fuels used by ships. These EU standards will apply to ships
purchasing fuels within the EU. However, standards will equally apply to ships
purchasing fuel blends in non-EU States. Law enforcement may be less robust in
certain non-EU jurisdictions and, in any case, businesses based outside the EU, such
as non-EU fuel suppliers, are not directly bound by the EU law.
The EU has introduced mandatory sulphur limits applicable to fuels used in the EU,
irrespective of where these fuels are purchased. To this end, a minimum number of
inspections is mandatory for the Member States through fuel sampling, which makes
technically feasible to examine whether a fuel purchased outside the EU is compliant
or not.
However, under the current proposal enforcement for biofuel blends purchased
outside the EU will rely only on paper documents provided by non-EU fuel suppliers.
While the import and purchase of biofuel blends in the EU market is already regulated
by the EU law, compliance with the EU sustainability criteria outside the EU
jurisdiction is challenging to enforce. Biofuels have a similar chemical composition as
conventional fuels. Thus, proper inspections for biofuel blends purchased outside the
EU will be challenging for competent authorities. It will be hard to ascertain the
quantity and the quality of biofuels in blends. Using paper documents provided
by non-EU fuel suppliers to calculate carbon savings contributing to the EU’s
climate targets, may create substantial loopholes and, ultimately, an
enforcement minefield.
Considering these enforcement challenges, the Commission effectively outsources
the enforcement to shipping companies and verifiers. However, shipping companies
and verifiers will also rely on paper documents when looking for cleaner fuels to meet
the standards or when verifying carbon savings. Shipowers have no means or
competence to check the composition of biofuel blends. It is possible that some
non-EU fuel suppliers will be tempted to provide only-on-paper cleaner fuels
as they are not subject to inspections or they are not bound by the EU law.
This will be a missed opportunity for the uptake of low- and zero carbon fuels
in shipping. It will also distort competition dividing the market between fuel
suppliers abiding by the law and providing more expensive fuel blends and fuel
suppliers by-passing the EU fuel standards and increasing their market share. It is
also unclear what will be the legal ramifications for shipping companies and
2
verifiers if the papers provided by non-EU fuel suppliers do not correspond to the
fuel blend in the tank of the ship.
Making the EU fuel suppliers responsible for meeting the fuel standards will
substantially address the enforcement concerns. EU fuel suppliers are directly
subject to the EU law and to inspections by European competent authorities. They
are also already subject to the same economy-wide energy targets under the
Renewable Energy Directive.
Making ships responsible for fuel standards is not consistent with
other proposals of ‘Fit for 55’ package
FuelEU Maritime makes the fuel user responsible for delivering emissions reductions
instead of the fuel suppliers. If the same measure was applied to road transport, car
drivers would be held responsible for filling up their tank with fuel blends delivering
emissions reductions. Although for all the other sectors the fuel supplier is responsible
for making cleaner fuels available in the market, the shipping sector is treated
differently.
The proposal for the Renewable Energy Directive (RED) sets up the new EU economy-
wide target of at least a 40% share of energy from renewable sources in 2030 and
the new renewables target of greenhouse gas intensity reduction of at least 13% by
2030 in the transport sector. Under the RED, the principal responsibility lies
with the EU fuel suppliers. RefuelEU Aviation also takes a similar approach
introducing requirements for the EU fuel suppliers. It will enhance the consistency
among the proposals of the ‘Fit for 55’ package if the FuelEU Maritime is aligned
with RED and introduces requirements and incentives for the EU fuel suppliers. It will
create synergies between FuelEU Maritime and RED and will make them work
together towards the increase of the use of cleaner fuels in the maritime sector.
Making ships trading to EU ports responsible for the fuel standards could have
particular implications for the majority of ships which operate non-scheduled
services where the destination of the ship is often unknown until shortly before the
next port of call.
Last but not least, there are critical safety issues associated with the use of
biofuels, including compliance with the requirement in the IMO Safety of Life at Sea
Convention (SOLAS) for marine fuels to have a flashpoint above 60 degrees Celsius.
This is another reason why any new fuel standards should be addressed to fuel
suppliers rather than to ships.
Thus, the legal responsibility for meeting the standards should lie with the
EU fuel suppliers as it is the case in other sectors.
3
Fostering demand for cleaner fuels in shipping
If the responsibility is shifted to the EU fuel suppliers, the question remains how to
foster demand for cleaner fuel in shipping. It is a matter of consistency that FuelEU
Maritime works together with the other proposals of the ‘Fit for 55’ climate package,
i.e. the EU ETS and RED.
The Commission has already proposed the inclusion of shipping under the EU’s carbon
pricing mechanism, the EU ETS. Companies would pay for the emissions under the
scope of the ETS and the intended objective of the proposal is to encourage efficiency
improvements and to provide an economic incentive to companies to use cleaner
fuels. The Impact Assessment of the FuelEU Maritime has estimated the price gap
between cleaner and conventional fuels is at least €200 per tonne CO21. Thus, a
substantial part of the price gap between cleaner fuels and conventional fuels
will be covered by the carbon price of the ETS, which is currently trading above
€60 per tonne CO2.
Importantly, any revenues generated under the EU ETS should be used to
facilitate the energy transition of the sector and should contribute to lowering the
price differential between cleaner and conventional fuels. European shipowners have
consistently asked for the establishment of a fund under the EU ETS to leverage
the revenues so that cleaner fuels become commercially available. The
Commission has embraced the idea of financially supporting the uptake of cleaner
fuels by proposing the introduction of Carbon Contracts for Difference under the
new Innovation Fund of the EU ETS. In this regard, special reference is made in
the EU ETS proposal to the energy transition of shipping.
RED also aims to support the uptake of cleaner fuels in shipping by maintaining the
multiplier for renewable energy used by ships. Shipping and aviation are the only
sectors in which the use of renewable energy is incentivised through ‘multipliers’,
allowing to account more than the actual energy content consumed. The use of
multiplier by fuel suppliers in shipping will further lower the price of cleaner fuels
contributing to bridging the price gap. ECSA supports the proposal of the
Commission to maintain the multiplier for the maritime sector. However, the
multiplier should be substantially increased to help decarbonise the sector.
New MRV system is unnecessary and burdensome
The proposal fails to keep the administrative burden low as much as possible. Instead
of using the existing EU Monitoring Reporting and Verification (MRV) system for
1
See page 46 of Commission’s Impact Assessment on FuelEU Maritime:
https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/default/files/fueleu_maritime_-_green_european_maritime_space.pdf
4
emissions from the maritime sector2, it introduces a separate reporting and
verification system for the purposes of the FuelEU Maritime Regulation. Any double
reporting and verification should be avoided and information needed for the
implementation of the FuelEU Maritime Regulation should be integrated into
the existing EU MRV system.
Flexibility is welcome but double requirements should be avoided
It is positive that the proposal provides a certain level of flexibility to the sector to
meet the fuel targets. However, the EU co-legislators should pay particular attention
so that any double reporting and/or double requirements, resembling the
introduction of a trading scheme on top of the EU ETS, are avoided.
Onshore Power Supply and lack of infrastructure
The proposal introduces a requirement for passenger ships and containerships to use
Onshore Power Supply (OPS) when at berth at a European port for more than two
hours. The requirement does not apply when the port infrastructure is not available
or not compatible with ships’ equipment. However, this exemption effectively expires
at the end of 2034, making ships responsible when the infrastructure is not
available at the port.
Such a financial penalty on ships when the infrastructure for OPS is not available in
a port does not address the right entity. Rather than the FuelEU Maritime proposal,
the Alternative Fuels Infrastructure Regulation (AFIR) proposal would be a better
instrument to incentivise the installation of OPS in ports, and as a consequence, the
use of OPS by vessels. At the very least, the exemption from the mandatory use
of OPS when infrastructure is not available in the port and when ship’s on-
board on-shore power equipment is incompatible with the port’s
installation, should not expire in 2035.
ECSA represents 19 national shipowners’ associations based in the EU and Norway.
European shipowners control 39.5% of the global commercial fleet, contribute 149
billion euros per year to the EU GDP and provide 2 million people with careers both
on board and ashore. ECSA strives for a regulatory environment that fosters the
international competitiveness of European shipping, to the benefit of the EU.
2
Regulation (EU) 2015/757 on the monitoring, reporting and verification of carbon dioxide emissions from maritime
transport
5