30th meeting of the Standing Committee on Precursors
10 November 2021 – 09.30-16.00
Virtually
Draft Agenda
Part I starts at 09h30
This part of the session is open to SCP Members and Observers
1. Welcome, approval of the draft agenda, and approval of the draft minutes of the 20 April
meeting
2. Tour de table: Relevant updates on the implementation and enforcement of Regulation (EU)
2019/1148, including on awareness-raising materials and which national authorities are
responsible for inspections
3. Tour de table: Incidents, suspicious transaction reports, inspections and investigations
involving explosives precursors
11.15-11.30: break
4. Update by the Commission on the baseline study for the monitoring programme and
presentation of a draft reporting template
5. Update by the Commission on the informal Q&A document
12:45-14.00: lunch break
Part II starts at 14h00
This part of the session is only open to SCP Members
6. Welcome and introduction by the Commission
7. Members only tour de table: Other incidents, suspicious transaction reports, inspections and
investigations involving explosives precursors
8. Updates from Europol: recent threats and CTPB (Counter Terrorism Program Board)
Explosive Chemical Precursors
9. Briefing by Conflict Armament Research – “Procurement networks behind Islamic State
improvised weapon programmes”
10. Closing remarks
Ref. Ares(2021)6048674 - 05/10/2021
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR MIGRATION AND HOME AFFAIRS
Directorate D: Law Enforcement and Security
Unit D.2 : Counter-Terrorism
Brussels
HOME.D.2.002/CR
Dear Madam, Dear Sir,
The European Commission’s Directorate-General for Migration and Home Affairs has
the pleasure to announce the
30th meeting of the Standing Committee on Precursors (SCP),
on 10 November 2021
in a virtual setting.
With Regulation (EU) 2019/1148 on the marketing and use of explosives precursors
having started to apply on 1 February 2021, the main aim of the meeting is to exchange
on its implementation. Inter alia, Member States will have to report certain information to
the Commission as part of the monitoring programme, by 2 February 2022 and
subsequently on an annual basis. The meeting will therefore also be used to discuss a
draft reporting template for this purpose.
Please note that it will be a virtual meeting; the draft agenda is attached. The first part of
the session is open to both SCP Members and Observers. The second part of the session
is open only to SCP Members. The meeting will be held using the virtual platform
WebEx. Please also note that this meeting will be held in English; there will be no
interpretation.
Please confirm your attendance by Friday 29 October by using the registration link in
the email accompanying this invitation.
For any questions or requests, you may contact us at
[email protected].
Yours faithfully,
Martin SCHIEFFER
Head of Unit
Attachments: 2
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
Office: LX46 03/121 - Tel. direct line +32 22983841
[email protected]
Electronically signed on 27/09/2021 16:30 (UTC+02) in accordance with article 11 of Commission Decision C(2020) 4482
V ersion of DATE \@ "dd MMMM yyyy" 05 October 2021 Draft Questions and Answers d ocument Regulation (EU) 2019/1148 on the marketing and use of explosives precursors In 2014 , Commission services , together with members of the Standing Committee on Pre cursors, create d a Q&A document on Regulation (EU) No 98/2013 . The current document aims to preserve the questions and answers in relation to Regulation (EU) No 98/ 20 13 that are still considered valid, and adds new questions and answers relevant for Regulation (EU) 2019/1148 a fter discussion in the Standing Committee on Precursors. This document is complementary to the guidelines that were adopted by the Commission in June 2020, and serve the purpose of assisting actors in the chemical supply chain and the competent authorities in the implementation of their obligations under Regulation (EU) 2019/1148. Please note that the questions and answers provided in this document are not legally binding and do not interpret the provisions of Regulation (EU) No 98/2013 or Regulation (EU) 2019/1148 on the marketing and use of explosive s precursors. Only the Court of Justice of the European Union has the power to issue a legally binding interpretation of EU legislation. Neither the European Commission nor any person acting on its behalf is responsible for the use which might be made of this document . M embers and observers of the Standing Committee on Precursors may submit questions for clarification, and may also propose amendments to the replies proposed in this document . F orward any comments or queries to the functional mailbox :
[email protected] Q&A REGARDING REGULATION (EU) 2019/114 8 1. Scope 1.1 Question: Are household products containing the addition compound sodium percarbonate (CAS RN 15630-89-4) subject to the Regulation? Answer: T he question of whether sodium percarbonate is covered by the R egulation was covered in the previous version of the Q&A document. At the time, the conclusion was that “Sodium percarbonate (2Na2CO3•3H2O2) is soluble in water (150g/l) and does release hydrogen peroxide, an Annex I substance in the Regulation (limit value of 12% w/w). However, the relatively low solubility of sodium percarbonate in water limits the release of hydrogen peroxide to a concentration of approximately 4% w/w. This concentration is not high enough to fall within the scope of the Regulation. Therefore, sodium percarbonate is not covered by the provisions and restrictions set forth in the Regulation.” In December 2019, as part of an SCP meeting, Commission services held a classified session to discuss the outcomes of a study of the Commission’s Joint Research Centre (JRC) on the potential use of sodium percarbonate to build homemade explosives. The conclusions are classified, but the study can be requested with the JRC, on the condition of having a security clearance of the right level. 1.2 Question: What is the exact geographical scope of the Regulation? Are Switzerland and Norway for example included and must apply the Regulation? Answer: The Regulation applies in EU Member States. Moreover, it is EEA- relevant, so Norway, Iceland and Liechtenstein (will) also apply it. For Switzerland this is not the case, but they also have adopted rules. 1.3 Question: Could you elaborate on the validity of the Explosives Precursors Regulation and the procedure with the UK? Is it correct to interpret the provisions to the effect that, with regard to Northern Ireland, the goods- related provisions of Annex 2 mean that EU law would continue to apply there? As regards the previous Explosives Precursors Regulation, this would mean that the United Kingdom is to be regarded as a third country, provided it does not affect Northern Ireland. For Northern Ireland it would basically remain with the previous regulations; it would continue to be treated as belonging to the Union: Why is the new EU Explosives Precursors Regulation not listed and what are the consequences from 1 February 2021? Answer: The EU published a Notice to Stakeholders with regard to the Withdrawal of the United Kingdom and EU Rules in the field of explosives for civil use and explosives precursors. It states that since 1 February 2020, the United Kingdom has withdrawn from the European Union and has become a “third country” and stipulates that after the end of the transition period, the Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland (“IE/NI Protocol”) applies. The IE/NI Protocol makes certain provisions of EU law applicable also to and in the United Kingdom in respect of Northern Ireland. In the IE/NI Protocol, the EU and the United Kingdom have furthermore agreed that insofar as EU rules apply to and in the United Kingdom in respect of Northern Ireland, Northern Ireland is treated as if it were a Member State. The IE/NI Protocol provides that Regulation (EU) 2019/1148 applies to and in the United Kingdom in respect of Northern Ireland. More specifically, this means inter alia the following (page 6): An explosive for civil uses/explosives precursor shipped to Northern Ireland from a third country or from Great Britain is an import/introduction for the purposes of Directive 2014/28/EU, Regulation (EU) No 98/2013, and Regulation (EU) 2019/1148. As of 1 February 2021, references to the repealed Regulation (EU) No 98/2013 shall be construed as references to Regulation (EU) 2019/1148 (see Article 22(2) of Regulation (EU) 2019/1148). 2. Definitions 2.1 Question: “ Customer ” - is this only the legal entity or also each individual site (one customer can have several sites that buys the products ) ? Answer: In the context of article 8(2), customer should be understood as either a professional user or an economic operator. These terms are defined in Article 3(9) and 3(10) respectively. Both definitions start with “... means any natural or legal person or public entity or group of such persons or entities that ...”. Therefore, the regulation allows the customer to be a ‘legal person’ or a ‘group of legal persons’, among others. * * * 2.2 Question: "Represent" – is this only the person who has the authority to sign the joint purchase agreement or The persons who can make call offs from the purchase agreement The persons that are allowed to receive the products on the place of delivery ? Answer: It is for the prospective customer to decide who is the individual entitled to represent it and who therefore must provide proof of identity. The verification must happen ‘upon sale’, however, so the individual must be involved at the stage when the transaction is being finalised, for example via payment and/or delivery, and therefore the customer must make sure that the person entitled to represent it is able to show proof of identity and provide the information laid down in 8(2)(b) and 8(2)(c). It is then for Member States to decide whether economic operators must use a specific format for a customer’s statement. 3 . Verification upon sale 3.1 Question: Companies tell us that the marke t is now establishing practice where the customer only fill s in the costumer statements themselves (and provide an ID number), but there is no verification going on. Is it optional to show a proof of identity? Answer: Showing a proof of ID is not optional, as it is the only way for economic operators to verify this document upon the sale of restricted explosives precursors. Article 8(1) clearly states that “an economic operator ... shall for each transaction verify the proof of identity”. Article 8(2) also makes clear that economic operators “shall for each transactions request ... the proof of identity”, in other words, not just the document number. The guidelines point out what information should be recorded. Economic operators are not required to keep copies of ID, but they absolutely need to see it during the transaction to be able to verify anything. The practice that is referenced (only filling in the customer statement and providing the number of ID) is not enough. Economic operators cannot verify anything with only a number of ID because they do not have access to any relevant databases. * * * 3 . 2 Question: Is it mandatory for the economic operator to request a copy of the proof of identity for the verification upon sale (in particular for remote sales)? Answer: The obligation on the part of the economic operator is “ for each transaction verify the proof of identity and licence of that member of the general public” (article 8(1)) or, when it concerns a professional user or another economic operator, the economic operator “shall for each transaction request the following information ... (a) proof of identity of the individual entitled to represent the prospective customer” (article 8(2)). To do this, an economic operator logically will need to see the proof of identity. In an “offline” setting, this could be done by the customer showing the proof of identity. This is not possible online, so therefore it is recommend ed that economic operators ask their customers to provide a scanned copy. However, economic operators are not required to keep that copy of the proof of identity after they have verified the identity of the person, be it offline or online. 3.3 Question: What proof of identity is required? (photographic, signed declaration etc.) in B2B transactions? Answer: There are minimum requirements and recommendations (check Guidelines for the implementation of Regulation (EU) 2019/1148 on the marketing and use of explosives precursors) or – depending on the Member State, more specifications might exist. Therefore, check first with the Competent Authorities of the Member State(s) in which you operate. 3.4 Question: Does the customer's end-use statement have to be signed by the company's manager or an authorized person? Answer: There is no prescription in the EU Regulation, which does not go into this level of detail. Unless a Member State’s competent authority regulates who should sign, it will depend on a company’s policy. The company must make sure that the person authorised is able to comply with the obligations in the Regulation on its behalf. Q&A REGARDING REGULATION (EU) No 98/2013 For the sake of clarity, the questions below have been kept intact and have not been updated to the current Regulation. The reader should keep this in mind. 1 . Scope 1 .1 Question: Are c ar batteries covered by the Regulation? Answer: Car batteries are not included in the scope of the Precursors Regulation. The Regulation applies to substances and mixtures, whereas car batteries are “articles”. Article 3 (3) of the REACH Regulation (No 1907/2006) defines “article” as an object which during production is given a special shape, surface or design which determines its function to a greater degree than does its chemical composition. Refer to Article 2 of the Regulation. * * * 1 .2 Question: Are fireworks covered by the Regulation? Answer: Article 2.2 (b) of the R egulation exempts fireworks from the scope of the regulation. This was done explicitly, and so they are excluded irrespective of their contents. It should also be noted that, i n many Member States, it is forbidden to disassemble fireworks. Nevertheless, as soon as they were disassembled, Article 4.1 of the Regulation would indeed apply to the possession, by members of the general public, of chlorates and perchlorates above the concentration limit (equally subject, of course, to the exemptions contained in articles 4.2 and 4.3 (licensing or registration system)). Refer to Article 2 of the Regulation. * * * 1 .3 Question: Are pharmaceutical companies exempted from the Regulation? Answer: No company or sector is exempted from applying the Regulation. Exemptions are listed in Article 2 and apply to product s (articles as defined in REACH, as well as a number of pyrotechnic articles) and to one type of transaction (involving a medical prescriptions). Whether or not to give advice to companies with low probability of carrying substances covered by the Regulation is a matter of policy choice, to be decided by Member State authorities . Refer to Article 2 of the Regulation. * * * 1 . 4 Question: Are exports of restricted chemicals above the concentration limits to members of the public in countries outside the EEA excluded from restrictions ? Answer: The Regulation makes no references to exports, and its provisions are in principle strictly aimed at transactions/possession/use within the territory of Member States. Therefore, it appears that members of the general public in third countries are excluded from the scope of the Regulation and thus from the restrictions it imposes. Economic operators exporting are still subject, of course, to export controls and whatever restrictions are in force in the third country . 2 . Definitions 2 .1 Question: T he definition of ' economic operator ' in the Regulation differs from that in Decision 768/2008/EC on a common framework for the marketing of products . Is the definition in the Regulation still valid ? Answer: Yes, both definitions are valid for the scope of their respective legal acts . The broader definition of the term ' economic operators ' in Regulation 98/2013 is compatible with Decision 768/2008/EC , as the Decision allows Community legislation to depart from its provisions , whenever appropriate on account of a sector's specificities . The broader definition in the Regulation is therefore intentional . Refer to Article 3 of the Regulation. * * * 2 .2 Question: The Annexe s refer not only to 'substance ,' but also to 'sub stance contained in a substance' . How shall this be interpreted ? Answer: In the Regulation, 's ubstance' is defined within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 ( the REACH Regulation ) . Based on the current agreed interpretation of the relevant provisions of the REACH Regulation , the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) has put forth the following considerations : For the purpose of applying the restrictions in Regulation 98/2013 to 'a substance containing a substance', a substance A (restricted explosive precursor) is contained in a substance B whenever substance B includes in its composition the constituent A. Since substance B is not further defined in the Regulation, substance B could be of any nature: a mono-constituent substance, a multi-constituent substance or a UVCB substance . For the purpose of applying the restrictions in Regulation 98/2013 to chemical adducts , where a substance X (restricted explosive precursor) is reacted with a s ubstance Y to obtain the correspo nding a dduct X-Y , the following two scenarios should be considered: If the adduct X-Y contains residual starting material of substance X, then adduct X-Y falls within the scope of the Regulation. This is regardless of whether it is technically possible or not to purify the adduct X-Y from the impurity X. If the adduct X-Y does not contain residual starting material of substance X, then adduct X-Y does not fall within the scope of the Regulation. This is regardless of whether it is technically possible or not to transform the a dduct X-Y back to substance X and substance Y . Refer to Article 3 of the Regulation. * * * 2 .3 Question: Does the definition of 'member of the general public' in the Regulation apply to students ? Answer: Yes, students are 'members of the general public' as a general rule, and therefore subject to the rules set forth by the Regulation concerning the acquisition, introduction, possession and use of the restricted explosives precursors listed in Annex I of the Regulation. Only in instances where their learning institution is acting as the professional end-user acquiring and storing the restricted precursors, might students use the substances. However, it is understood that students would in these cases be acting in a professional capacity, within the premises of their institution and under its rules and supervision. Refer to Article 3(7) of the Regulation. 3 . Making available, introduction, possession and use 3 . 1 Question: At which point does acquisition/supply take place for remote sales (e.g . internet retail)? Answer: The Regulation does not clarify at which point the acquisition/sup ply take place for remote sales, but it should be noted that the intention of the Regulation is to limit the availability of the restricted substances to the general public , and to cover the largest possible number of situations. Article 4(1) is very broad in this limitation , by stating that substances “shall not be made available to, or introduced, possessed or used by, members of the general public , ” and therefore it envisages also the " po ssession” of the substances, even before any sale. “ M aking available” means any supply, in return of payment or free of charge (Article 3, pt. (4)). Nevertheless, s ince the purpose for clarifying this question is to enforce the provisions of the Regulation and to impose sanctions, and given that the measures for these (enforcement and sanctioning) are left up to Member States, then it is also left up to Member States to clarify such specifications in their implementing regulations . Refer t o Article 4 of the Regulation. 4 . Reporting of suspicious transactions, disappearances and thefts 4 .1 Question: Does the reporting obligation apply to Annex I substances below their limit values ? Answer: T he reporting obligation applies to the substances listed in both Annexes at all concentration levels , with the exception of Ammonium nitrate (Annex II), to which a minimum concentration of 16% by weight of nitrogen in relation to ammonium nitrate applies . Refer to Article 9 of the Regulation. Annexes A.1 Question: What is the difference between CAS RN numbers and CN codes? Answer: CAS Registry Numbers are unique numeric identifiers for chemical substances, assigned by the Chemical Abstracts Service . The Combined nomenclature (CN), on the other hand, is a system designed by the European Commission to classify goods and merchandise for the purpose of applying customs tariffs. Whereas CAS RN numbers remain unchanged over time, CN codes may be updated annually on the basis of commercial policy, technological changes or other statistical requirements. The CAS Registry provides the definitive reference for identifying which chemical substances are covered under the Annexes of the Regulation . Refer to the Annexes of the Regulation.
Saatja: <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 05.10.2021 12:51
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>
Koopia: <
[email protected]>
Teema: Invitation - virtual SCP meeting - 10 November 09.30-16.00
Dear SCP Members,
We are pleased to announce the 30th meeting of the Standing Committee on
Precursors on Wednesday 10 November, from 09.30-16.00. Given the
circumstances, this meeting takes place virtually. Please find attached
an invitation and agenda to the meeting.In addition, please find attached
a draft Questions and Answers document. As discussed during the last SCP
meeting, this document builds upon an earlier version of the Q&A document
and preserves questions and answers in relation to Regulation (EU) No
98/2013 that are still considered valid. It also adds new questions and
answers relevant for Regulation (EU) 2019/1148. It is a working document
that is complementary to the that were adopted by the Commission in June
2020. During the SCP meeting of 10 November you will be given the
opportunity for comments and questions.We kindly ask you to confirm
attendance by Friday 29 October, by registering using the following link:
Please do not hesitate to reach out should you have any questions.
Kind regards,Charlotte
Charlotte RenckensPolicy officer
European Commission Directorate-General Migration and Home Affairs (DG
HOME)Unit D.2 Counter-Terrorism
phone: +32 2 29 83841e-mail: