Selection criteria and the methodology for post-2020 in EE
Compared to the 2014-2020 period, there has been no substantive change in the concept of what is
meant by selection criteria and the methodology and the role of the Monitoring committee (MC) has
remained the same in the CPR. Therefore, we plan to continue with current, well-functioning practice.
Estonian Monitoring committee (MC) approves selection criteria and methodology in accordance with
Article 40(2)(a) of Regulation (EU) 2021/1060 (2021-2027 CPR) and Article 73 (1), ensuring full
compliance with the Regulation.
In the regulations of the terms for granting support on the intervention level the same selection criteria
and methodology is used, what has been already approved in MC and those criteria and methodology
can be fulfilled or specified according to specifics of the field of the interventions. Therefore, the
criteria and methodology on the intervention level can be clarifying, but not going beyond the criteria
and methodology approved in the MC. Thus in the context of the CPR, it is not a case where new criteria
would be created at the intervention level or criteria and methodology are changed contrary to CPR
art 40.
According to internal legal framework of Estonia, the responsibility for preparing and adopting legal
acts of the terms for granting support from EU funds rests with the relevant ministry and those
regulations of the terms for granting support are prepared in co-operation with stakeholders, including
also some members of the MC or using sub-committees depending on the specific field and best
coordination practice established by the ministry for stakeholder engagement.
Discussions in the preparation process of draft legislation of the terms for granting support involve also
selection criteria and methodology and whether they need to be specified for the particular
intervention. Updated drafts are shared usually multiple times in preparation process with
stakeholders and other parties involved via sub-committees or other co-operation format.
As the draft is mature, it will be sent to the official public consultation that is usually 10-15 days and
again- all the stakeholders, including members of MC can have a say including on selection criteria and
methodology in a transparent and effective way.
Public consultation of draft legislation of the terms for granting support is done in public online
platform called EIS and this is a co-decision approach- the comments and feedback given by other
ministries and by stakeholders is considered within the same, joint process.
Description of the approval process in EIS
The IT-solution System (EIS - https://eelnoud.valitsus.ee) is a public online platform where documents
are coordinated between institutions, submitted to the government and the parliament, and public
consultation takes place.
In addition to national documents, drafts of European Union legislation and other documents related
to the decision-making process of the European Union are also available in the EIS. Through the EIS,
anyone, including social partners and stakeholders can monitor the processing of drafts, find
documents on the platform using a search, participate in public consultations and submit comments
on the documents under consultation/approval process.
EIS is managed by the Government Office of Estonia and drafts intended for public consultation can be
obtained, for example, here: https://eelnoud.valitsus.ee/main#D1dKaE2P
Using the EIS is easy, the instructions are available to everyone and can be found here:
https://eelnoud.valitsus.ee/abi.html. Although the EIS enables the search of all documents that have
been and are being coordinated, reading the instructions shows that it is also possible to request
notifications based on the relevant keywords. EIS is a well-known working environment for many and
all partners who want to be involved are actively using it.
Coordination of drafts is governed by the regulation of the Government of the Republic, which states
the following about involvement: Relevant interest groups are involved in the preparation of a draft
or other issue in accordance with the good practice of involvement, which is approved by the
Government of the Republic. The good practice of involvement is published on the website of the
Government of the Republic.
Coordination is process regulated by Article 6. Article 8 regulates also very clearly the consideration of
proposals submitted during coordination and the resolution of disagreements, where it is stated as
follows: The draft and other documents necessary for the preparation of the issue are corrected based
on the proposals submitted during coordination.
The coordination process in the EIS is simple and familiar to ministries, stakeholders, umbrella
organizations, journalists, etc.
The consultation/approval process is carried out using the following steps:
1) The representatives of the ministries upload the legislation that is under
consultation/approval. Those whose feedback must be asked for, are marked separately (and
an official letter is also sent to them, so it´s not possible that the uploading of the draft will not
be noticed). EIS allows you to mark designated ministries, stakeholders, umbrella
organizations and other institutions as official coordinators (including members of MC). For
example, the Ministry of Culture has just uploaded materials where feedback is also requested
from the Union of Cities and Towns, who is also a member of the MC (e.g. here:
https://eelnoud.valitsus.ee/main/mount/docList/babc7055-8e84-446c-8e2a-e2c3d1d9cdb8
2) A deadline is also set for coordination process. Usually, it´s 10 working days but it can be
changed by agreement with the ministry.
3) The feedback is submitted to the responsible ministry by an official e-mail but is available to
all parties, since it is uploaded to the EIS. It is also possible to add public comments on EIS
platform.
4) Via EIS it is possible for the parties to: give the approval without comments; give the approval
with comments; give the approval only if the changes mentioned in the comments are made;
not to approve the documents. In all the cases, all the answers and their rationale are public
and will be uploaded to EIS. An example is available here:
https://eelnoud.valitsus.ee/main/mount/docList/356e34d6-79ce-4dc2-b66d-aa7e3617ddfb
As you can see, each coordinator's response is also publicly visible.
5) At the end of the coordination process, the ministry responsible for the draft will prepare a
table of comments, where there is a precise explanation/answer for each comment. For
example, how the drafts were changed or supplemented according to the comment.
Kommentaarid
meetme määruse eelnõule_17112022.docx
It is possible to guarantee a notification to European Commission and to members of MC (an e-mail to
one dedicated address with the link to the particular consultation page with access to the files) as soon
as the public consultation starts for all the regulations of the terms for granting support of CP 2021-
2027 interventions (including the ones listed in EC risk-assessment), enabling members of MC to give
feedback to the draft legislation, including to be against the selection criteria and methodology
described in the draft or to other elements of the regulation. Ministry responsible for the draft will
prepare a table of comments, where there is a precise explanation/answer for each comment. For
example, how the drafts were changed or supplemented according to the comments. In any case,
according to the publicly given or direct feedback, also by the Commission or members of MC, draft
legislation is being modified and improved before it is enforced. If any of other ministry or the majority
of the members of the monitoring committee do not approve the draft as it is (including selection
criteria and methodology), the draft is not accepted and is withdrawn by the responsible ministry and
as the draft is renewed according to the feedback it will be sent to the new consultation round.
For the sake of formal certainty, this procedure can be added to the rules of procedure of the MC as
soon we have agreed with Commission using this approach.
Establishing duplicate, parallel procedures creates unnecessary administrative burden for stakeholders
and administration and provides no added-value. Instead- this existing transparent and effective
coordination with MC, which ensures the compliance with CPR Art 71 (1) and Art 40 (2) (a), enables to
concentrate not only on formal approval of the selection criteria and methodology, but on substantive
cooperation for preparing the interventions and regulations of the terms for granting support.
We consulted about this case also with stakeholders and according to the feedback we received the
procedure described above is considered as a best practise for engaging MC to the preparation of draft
legislation of the terms for granting support, including validating selection criteria and methodology.
As shadow-MC2021-2027 approved selection criteria and methodology in May 2022 and as compared
to previous period, the concept of selection criteria and the methodology and the role of the
Monitoring committee (MC) has remained the same in the CPR, we have already started with some of
2021-2027 interventions based on the criteria and methodology approved by MC. Information about
the calls already open with relevant links is available on: https://rtk.ee/2021-2027-meetmepohised-
oigusaktid. In co-operation with Government Office of Estonia and other ministries we´ll make sure as
soon as possible, that in case of next regulations of the terms for granting support of CP 2021-2027
interventions (including the ones listed in EC risk-assessment) that will be prepared, a notification is
sent to European Commission and to members of MC (an e-mail to one dedicated address with the
link to the particular consultation page with access to the files) as soon as the public consultation starts.
However, we would like to emphasize that both the Commission and MC already have access to all the
drafts currently in EIS.
European Commission
[email protected]
16.12.2022 REGIO.D.4/EO/(202
Follow-up of the Annual Review 2)9701578
Meeting on December 6, 2022 16.01.2023 Our ref. No
Dear Mr Andreas von Busch
Thank you for the fruitful Annual Review Meeting (ARM) and for the ARM minutes, also for
all questions and comments. You can find answers to the questions raised at the ARM and
comments to the minutes of the meeting in Annex I. Annex II provides an overview of
Estonian process for selection criteria and methodology
If you require any further information, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Yours sincerely,
(signed digitally)
Triin Tomingas
Head of Foreign Funds Unit
/*Encl.
Annex I Follow-up
Annex I Estonian process for selection criteria and methodology
Kairi Nisamedtinov +372 611 3096
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / Estonia / +372 611 3558 /
[email protected]
www.rahandusministeerium.ee / Reg. code: 70000272
1. Comments on the minutes
There is one comment on the minutes. Page 5: IT platform for all draft legislation - eis.ee; the
correct address is https://eelnoud.valitsus.ee/.
2. Ukrainian war refugees and ESF support
Most of the interventions aimed at helping war refugees started in spring-summer 2022. This
means that the latest project reports will not be available until January 2023. They are usually
presented in late January-February. Below is a small overview of the ongoing activities and
projects where refugees can receive assistance and interventions where they can enter.
Interventions have also been mentioned, where aim is to support local government workers so
they can help more efficiently war refugees. The Ministry of Social Affairs has confirmed that
they add refugees throughout their various interventions, without making major changes in
projects or legal acts, because there is no need to.
1) Ministry of Education and Research, sub-measure 1.6.2 Providing adults high-quality and
relevant continuing education and retraining. The refugee crisis that arose in the spring led
to the need to provide further training to the beneficiaries of temporary protection and they
were added as a new target group. Unfortunately, the ability of educational institutions to
offer training in Ukrainian or Russian is limited. The construction courses planned by the
Tallinn Lasnamäe Mechanics School can be given as positive examples (there is a shortage
of labour in the field and the target group can find a job after the training).
2) Ministry of Social Affairs, sub-measure 2.2.1 Welfare services for elderly, people with
special needs and those with coping difficulties and their family members to support their
employment.
The refugees were added as one target group of intervention. The purpose of the grant is to
support the integration of beneficiaries into Estonian society. Call for proposals was opened
in July and closed in December 2022. All available budget is covered with application.
Applicants were local governments and the total EU support for projects is 1.4 million
euros.
3) Ministry of Social Affairs, sub-measure 3.1.1 Development, implementation and provision
of labour market services and respective support services for the target group of the work-
ability support reform, in order to maintain a job or find a new job.
The project of the Social Insurance Board “Enabling the use of technical aid”. As of March
2022, the need for counselling for persons fleeing war has been added to the usual regular
counselling on aid equipment. For this purpose, work processes were developed in
cooperation with Social Insurance Board own crisis team and service providers in order to
ensure rapid and needs-based availability of aid and initial knowledge of the possibilities of
the Estonian state for refugees who need aid.
4) Ministry of Social Affairs, sub-measure 3.1.2 Activities supporting employers and
employees to enhance working conditions.
Labour Inspectorate updated their homepage. The most important new topic on the Working
Life Portal is “Ukraine War Refugees and Employment Relations”, which contains several
newsletters (Labour Inspectorate’s newsletter, Human trafficking information for refugees
and their helpers, Working in Estonia —home from work healthy, Say “no” to the envelope
salary!). The information is available in Ukrainian.
5) Ministry of Social Affairs, sub-measure 16.1.1 Providing labour market services.
The intervention “My first job in Estonia”: since the number of people with temporary
protection started increase from March of 2022, the provision of the service began to grow
exponentially. Due to the high number of Ukrainian war refugees and their readiness to
move to the labour market and the willingness of employers to recruit, a new measure to
support work for beneficiaries of international protection was launched and implemented
from June 2022.
3. Whether the ESF funding could facilitate bringing additional
teachers/support specialists to the schools (could be from amongst Ukrainian refugees)?
Yes, ESF funds are already being used to facilitate bringing additional teachers to the
schools. Due to the war in Ukraine, there are many refugee children in our educational
institutions. Some Ukrainian refugee teachers and support specialist are already working
with refugee children in our education institution. They usually have temporary contracts
because they do not meet our qualification requirements. We have planned special measures
from ESF, state budget and Swiss-Estonian cooperation programme for those teachers and
support specialists who would like to meet the qualification requirements and work in our
education system with a permanent contract. We offer them Estonian language training and
professional development courses to help them meet our qualification requirements.
We also need to focus on our in-service teachers and school leaders, who need to ensure
that refugee children can continue their education in Estonia. ESF funding is used to prepare
them for teaching in a multicultural and multilingual environment.