EUROPEAN SOLAR MANUFACTURING COUNCIL (ESMC) MILESTONE PROPOSALS
FOR THE EU SOLAR PV INDUSTRY ALLIANCE
SUMMARY
The EU needs a holistic industrial policy approach – an entire package of support measures targeting different
important areas. For this reason, different support layers should be developed addressing the current bottlenecks
to facilitate a well-functioning European PV manufacturing ecosystem. The EU PV manufacturing industry critically
needs these key measures to be adopted by the European Solar PV Industry Alliance:
1. EQUALIZED CONDITIONS TO IRA: The US Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) framework should be transposed into an
EU PV manufacturing support framework, to ensure strong European response. The equalizing measures could be
implemented in two alternative directions: a) through implementation of a tax incentives model; b) by direct grants
to manufacturing projects.
2. TAX EXEMPTIONS, STATE GUARANTEES, CAPEX AND OPEX SUBSIDIES: An access to low interest capital and OPEX
subsidies to support (venture) capital investments (for risk mitigation) to foster investment into production
facilities. Concrete mechanisms on lowering-equalising the price for energy (for example, electricity and natural
gas) should be developed – competitive and plannable energy prices are particularly critical for the production
poly-Si, solar glass, wafers etc.
3. OFF-TAKE AGREEMENTS: Securing significant demand for EU-made PV products through off take agreements,
including pre-payments for local production. This measure would catalyze investments in large-scale PV
manufacturing capacities in Europe. An effective insurance system should be created both for the buyers (in case of
non-off take) and producers (in case of non-delivery) for the situations when the agreements can’t be entirely
fulfilled.
4. EU STANDARDS: EU standards for imported PV ingots, wafers, cells, solar glass and modules concerning labour
laws, hidden subsidization, carbon footprint, and circularity would allow to immediately exclude imports in case
any component of the imported product do not meet EU standards.
5. SUPPORT FOR INNOVATIONS: The establishment of an appropriate framework for innovative and breakthrough
European technologies is critical for the European PV manufacturing – a PV-IPCEI is a low-hanging fruit. The Alliance
should pursue the support for the development and further scaling of the technologies that might have a positive
impact for the EU strategic autonomy and PV manufacturing competitiveness in the long-term.
6. SPECIAL FINANCIAL VEHICLE: Creating and developing a separate financing vehicle of at least € 20 billion,
following the example of the European Chips Act, and allowing for easy adjustment of existing financing
mechanisms, e.g. National Recovery and Resilience Plans.
7. PERMITTING PROCEDURES: Reduce the red tape for permitting, not only of PV deployment, but also for the
construction of industrial PV manufacturing plants. Easy access and fast permits to setup manufacturing facilities
will save time – a critical element in the current global competition.
8. EU REGULATIONS: Adoption of policy measures to specific EU regulations (revision of WEEE, VAT exemptions for
integrated PV solutions) would have a cumulative positive effect for the competitiveness of European PV
production.
All these measures should be implemented not separately, but as one framework. This is the key pre-condition to
ensure both short-term and long-term competitiveness of European PV manufacturing. Dedicated efforts should
be taken to ensure 30 GW PV manufacturing capacities along the entire PV value chain by 2025 including the
ambition to raise the target to 80 GW PV manufacturing capacities by 2030, to adequately reflect the European PV
demand side.
1
I. SUPPORT FOR THE EUROPEAN PV MANUFACTURING SHOULD BE GRANTED WITHOUT DELAY
The current energy crisis in Europe is, amongst others, the consequence of under-investments in PV deployment
during recent years, as the transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy has clearly been too slow. Europe’s
current import dependency on hardware for the accelerating PV deployment, which is one of the corner stones in
the REPowerEU strategy, put the transition to renewables in Europe in an exposed position, as the continent risks
future supply chain shortages in the case of disrupted trade flows or geopolitical changes. Therefore, it is of utmost
importance that domestic PV manufacturing capacities are secured in a fast and sustainable manner. The only
alternative for Europe is to create appropriate and competitive business conditions for the domestic PV
manufacturing and leverage the competitive advantages of PV manufacturing in China.
Although the global PV manufacturing environment is highly competitive, the future of European PV
manufacturing can be secured through implementation of several concentrated key measures, which should be
introduced as soon as possible by the European Commission and the Member States. An unthreatened transition of
the EU to renewables depends on increased PV manufacturing capacities in Europe. The European Solar PV Industry
Alliance (Alliance) initiated by the European Commission, is an important step into that direction. However, the
actions and policy incentives should be developed, and more importantly – implemented – in the EU without delay,
as the global PV manufacturing environment is highly dynamic due to the additional recent support measures
under implementation in the US (Inflation Reduction Act – IRA) and India.
PV deployment targets of 600 GW until 2030 as well as the current low PV manufacturing capacities in the Member
States of the EU raise serious concerns, not only about the unused potential of the PV manufacturing sector for the
growth of the economies of the EU, but also serious concerns about the PV deployment capacities. The ambitious
plans of the European Commission and the Member States – for instance, Germany declared a target of reaching
215 GW of PV installed by 2030 – cannot be delivered successfully without establishing a competitive and
sustainable PV manufacturing value chain in Europe.
II. GENERAL OVERVIEW OF THE PROPOSED ACTIONS
In line with the target of 30 GW by 2025, the Alliance should confirm a European PV manufacturing target for 2030
on at least the 80 GW level.
The Alliance should seek to ensure all necessary measures so that the operational cost structure of the entire
European PV value chain would be as equivalent as possible to non-EU manufacturers. In parallel, the support
measures should be implemented to scale the European PV manufacturing capacities, and through this improve
the competitiveness and reduce the manufacturing costs further. The Alliance should avoid going for short-term
victories to attract some manufacturing, but rather focus on the long-term success.
Innovations and scale-up of the European PV manufacturing capacities are the key deliverables to be achieved
through various policy instruments. These policy instruments could be implemented by CAPEX and OPEX support,
including an appropriate scheme of off-take agreements in the EU:
• Next to the support on the CAPEX side, support measures for the OPEX are needed to equalize the conditions for
the competition (China – subsidised loan rates, cheap/free land, utility subsidies for electricity and water, work force
programs and relaxed labor laws; US – tax credits for each domestically produced component across the solar PV
supply chain).
• Tax incentives, tax exemptions, state guarantees, competitive (~1% interest rates) loans and PV-IPCEI should be
prioritised as the most important financial measures to be proposed by the Alliance.
• The inclusion of PV into the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism and the EcoDesign & Energy Labelling
framework, Local content requirements and off-take agreements, and Rules on circularity should be prioritised as
the most important regulatory measures to be proposed by the Alliance to secure the competitiveness and level
playing field of European PV production.
2
Realistically, the European PV deployment market should be differentiated – one market for cheap Chinese
modules and another for locally produced modules. Reasonable off-take agreements paired with tax exemptions
and incentives would be the most sustainable way to boost European production in that direction.
III. PROPOSALS FOR THE EUROPEAN PV MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY TO BE COMPETITIVE
The business case for PV manufacturing is currently not attractive enough in the EU, and global competition is
fierce, leading to low profitability margins for the European PV producers. Supporting policy frameworks for the PV
manufacturing in the EU Member States are not yet developed.
Neither 2 or 3 individual policy measures can lead to a significant restart of the European solar PV manufacturing
industry. The EU needs a holistic industrial policy approach, meaning an entire package of support measures
targeting different important areas – for this reason different support layers should be developed addressing the
current bottlenecks to facilitate a well-functioning European PV manufacturing ecosystem. EU PV manufacturing
industry critically needs these key measures to be adopted by the Alliance:
1) The US Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) framework transposition into an EU PV manufacturing support
framework ensuring a strong European response to the US IRA. The respective measures should be implemented
within the next three to five months, before the capital leaves Europe in favour of the US. Before the end of the year
the industry needs clarity on the actions to be taken in 2023. Otherwise, the investment funds will start to flow to
the US, and the raw material and equipment pipelines will be taken by US, Indian, and Chinese companies. This
could be implemented in two alternative directions:
a) Implementation of tax incentives model – tax incentives and support to local manufacturing that are directly
connected to the sales of modules / cells (direct subsidies for manufacturing or tax breaks on a per watt basis)
similar to the US, rather than further CAPEX incentives. This will support existing manufacturers and make it easier
for them to take a decision to expand, in addition to only support new companies / new investments. Such a general
support scheme, but not specific individual calls for the support, would be more efficient and targeted to the real
PV production output and not to the potentially stranded assets. However, it might not be so powerful as it is in the
US, due to the national implementation model in the EU;
b) Immediate and direct grants to mature manufacturing projects along the entire value chain – 60% grant on
CAPEX to allow EU to compete with US IRA, minimum package of € 20 billion of grants for the period to 2025 to
allow the industry to reach the 30 GW full value chain scale. This will create at least 30 000 direct and indirect jobs in
only the cells and modules part of the value chain and will reduce the current € 10 billion negative trade balance on
imported PV modules with China by half.
2) Support of local PV supply chain manufacturing through tax exemptions, state guarantees (backup of the
state to have access to low interest capital), OPEX subsidies (concrete mechanisms should be proposed on
lowering-equalising the price for energy like electricity and natural gas – competitive and plannable energy prices
are especially critical for the production poly-Si, solar glass, wafers etc.) and support (venture) capital investments
(mitigate risk) to foster investment into production facilities. Immediate availability of credit guarantees would help
to reduce initial CAPEX investment risk and accelerate access to finance. Substantial direct subsidies on CAPEX and
OPEX through a 10-year program would kick-start the EU PV value chain and help the industry to de-risk the
investments and spur a fast growth. This would create certainty and allow for the EU to build sufficient critical mass
in PV manufacturing. Investors will invest in PV if the business models are strong, attractive and with low risk.
3
3) Securing significant demand for EU-made PV products through off-take agreements for local production.
This measure would catalyze the investments in the large-scale PV manufacturing capacities – upfront commitment
from the buyers, at best supported by partial advance payments, may be one of the critical factors for the producers
to secure the financing for the investments throughout the value chain. Demand creation and acceleration through
local content requirements and off take agreements should be ensured in both the public and private sectors to
have a positive impact for the PV production capacities. An effective insurance system should be created both for
the buyers (in case of non-off take) and producers (in case of non-delivery) for the situations when the agreements
will not be possible to implement in full extend. Default insurance for down-payments on PV delivery contracts
might be a further effective tool to support investments in new PV manufacturing capacities – a special insurance
fund could be created and operationalized for this purpose. Certain remuneration measures could be proposed for
the buyers to be motivated to step in into such agreements as there are no regulatory measures for their legal
commitments, e.g., local content could be giving project additional developers tax credit or feed-in tariffs based on
the local added value on the product side.
4) Setting tough EU standards on labour laws, hidden subsidization and CO2 footprint, allows to immediately
exclude imports in case any components of the imported product do not meet EU standards. Introduction of EU
standards for imported PV ingots, wafers, cells, solar glass, modules, for i) labour conditions, ii) carbon footprint, iii)
circularity, iv) excessive subsidization will largely exclude unfair competition, and thereby ensure demand for
products produced in the EU. This will create a certainty for the EU supply chain actors and mobilize investments.
Establishing certain hurdles against huge flows of imports is a necessary tool as a certain “protection” of a growing
local manufacturing industry in the EU seems needed. EU should not block the PV hardware import, as we need the
imported modules for our energy transformation. Protectionism is not the desired approach to spur local
manufacturing, and it can hamper in the short-term PV deployment. However, considering the massive scale
advantage of the Chinese PV industry, certain higher requirements on the products placed on the EU market (in
addition to the up-coming EcoDesign and Energy Label regulations) are needed to set a level playing field,
acquiring for time to scale up, increase cost competitiveness and pursue R&D and innovations.
5) Establishing an appropriate framework for innovative European technologies leading the PV
manufacturing – support for innovative and breakthrough PV manufacturing technologies is critical to maintain a
long-term and sustainable competitive advantage of European PV manufacturing. The European Solar
Manufacturing Council (ESMC) has already initiated the Important Project of Common European Interest for PV
(PV-IPCEI) to ensure long-term and sustainable development of innovative and breakthrough technologies in
Europe. The success of the initiative will depend on Member States support for the PV-IPCEI framework. European
PV manufacturers might have the competitive advantage while encompassing innovative and breakthrough PV
technologies such as Heterojunction, Tandem, TOPcon, IBC, thin film technologies etc. – accordingly, the Alliance
should pursue the support for further development and scaling of these technologies, which could potentially
generate substantial positive impact for the EU strategic autonomy and PV manufacturing competitiveness in the
long-term.
6) Creating and developing a separate financing vehicle of at least € 20 billion following the example of the
European Chips Act and allowing the easy adjustment of existing financing mechanisms, e.g., National Recovery
and Resilience Plans, to ensure timely investments in European PV manufacturing projects. The Alliance should not
only ensure one-stop-shop financing approaches to the PV manufacturing projects, but also create new
investments and capital security measures to reduce the CAPEX and OPEX in above-mentioned directions.
7) Hugely reduce red tape for permitting, not only of PV deployment, but also for the implementation of
industrial PV manufacturing plants along the value chain. We need simplified and speedy permitting procedures
for both industrial manufacturing and PV deployment projects – easy access and fast permits to set up
manufacturing facilities will save time – a critical element in the current global competition. All these measures
should be implemented as a package, and without delay, as the measures will be started on a national level.
4
8) Adoption of policy measures to specific EU regulations will have a cumulative effect for the
competitiveness of European PV production. Creation of realistic European circular recycling processes, revision of
the WEEE (especially for PV), clear incentives for ultra-low carbon solar for all installations and irrespective of size,
ban of Flour Polymers (PFAS) in all PV modules to be installed in Europe, VAT-exemptions for all types of integrated
PV solutions, and support for the development of solar electric vehicles. These are several examples where an
appropriate coordination is needed to ensure better competitive conditions for European PV manufacturing – the
Alliance should investigate all potential along the full PV manufacturing and PV deployment value chain in the EU.
Currently, the European PV developers for 2030 are planning to have production capacities of more than 50 GW for
poly-Si, more than 20 GW for ingots and wafers, and more than 35 GW for cells and modules. These plans could be
realistically implemented only if an appropriate European PV manufacturing ecosystem will be created based on
the above-mentioned policy measures and incentives. Moreover, we must dedicate all the efforts so that the
appropriate manufacturing capacities are ensured along the entire PV value chain, as well as to raise the target to
80 GW PV manufacturing capacities by 2030, to adequately reflect the European PV demand side.
Implementation of these measures should be reflected in a concrete dedicated action plan of the Alliance to create
clarity and trust for developers and investors. With every day passing, investors are flocking to the US due to the IRA
– they will not come back fast once they have invested there. Moreover, both India and US projects will start to fill
up EU equipment supplier pipelines. The longer we wait, the more difficult it will be to actually implement large
scale European PV manufacturing projects.
All respective measures to ensure large-scale PV manufacturing capacities in Europe should be dedicated to balan-
ce the current unfair competitive conditions spreading from extensive and significant support from the
Chinese Government to local PV manufacturing companies. In a scenario of proposing off-take agreements,
appropriate capital under competitive conditions and ensuring the support for the innovative European
technologies through a PV-IPCEI, the remaining competitive advantage of Chinese producers on prices could be
comparatively easily tackled by the structural factors – logistical costs, supply chain issues, forced labor regulations
and European advantages on lower CO2 footprint. European market players would be willing to source local PV
production through off-take agreements in case the price differences vis-à-vis Chinese production will be
comparatively low.
The role of the Member States of the EU is as critical as never before. Although several Member States are already
implementing the incentives for PV manufacturing through the Recovery and Resilience Facility or planning
support for innovative PV technologies through the PV-IPCEI, a more concentrated, extended and synchronized
approach of the Member States towards European PV manufacturing is of vital importance. Considering that
Member States in the EU are responsible for turning the concrete measures into laws, it is important to coordinate
the implementation of these measures. The European Solar PV Industry Alliance, initiated by the European
Commission as a part of the European Solar Energy Strategy, might be instrumental in addressing the challenges of
a more extended and more synchronized Member States approach to the PV manufacturing industry.
All the above-mentioned measures should be implemented not separately, but as one framework. This is the key
pre-condition to ensure both short-term and long-term competitiveness of European PV manufacturing. The
positive impact of the implemented measures could be measured by net jobs created, GW of EU-manufactured PV
deployed, degree of sovereign energy independence. These are the short-term and long-term deliverables,
critically important not only for the smooth PV deployment in the EU, but also for the overarching industrial growth
of the EU.
5
To the EU Member States
Dear Head of State or Government,
Dear Minister, 18 January 2023
EUROPEAN SOLAR MANUFACTURING COUNCIL REQUESTS MEMBER STATES TO SUPPORT EUROPEAN PV
MANUFACTURING IN THE ONGOING STATE AID REVISION PROCESS
The recent actions initiated by the European Council and the European Commission on State aid exemptions for the
strategic industries in Europe go in the right direction in response to the US Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). It would also address the
EU’s already well-identified energy security and independence weakness vis-à-vis China. Without an immediate and strong EU
response, it will be difficult, if not impossible, for the EU to ensure its energy security going forward. This includes the risks of luring
EU businesses into moving investments to the US – as already communicated in the recent letter from the Executive Vice-President
of European Commission Margrethe Vestager on January 13. The Net-Zero Industry Act, together with the temporarily adapted State
aid rules to speed up and simplify investments by increased EU funding, spotlighted by the European Commission President Ursula
von der Leyen at the World Economic Forum on January 17, clearly defines a game-changing potential for European PV
manufacturing.
The European Solar Manufacturing Council (ESMC) welcomes these long-awaited measures and expects decisive changes to be
implemented very soon. This is crucial to reach the European renewables targets and freeing the appropriate
incentives for the necessary scale-up of the European PV manufacturing capacities. Once implemented, these would secure the
jump-start to scale up PV manufacturing, which is necessary, as substantially larger domestic production
volumes are critical for the long-term competitiveness of the EU PV industry and economies.
By this letter, the ESMC, uniting more than 50 industrial members of the European PV manufacturing community, kindly requests
you to support the actions taken by the European Commission to revise the State aid framework and support the European PV
manufacturing industry, by creating State aid exemptions for PV manufacturing and constructing dedicated and concrete financial
support vehicles. The ESMC proposes to implement measures as described below, while revising the Temporary Crisis and Transition
Framework without delay.
Within the establishment of the IRA, the cost gap between EU producers and their counterparts in the US is estimated to be 11-18 $
cents/W. Given the goal to establish at least 30 GW by 2025, and then grow the capacities so that at least 40-50 GW of annual PV
deployment can be covered by European PV production, there is an annual competitive gap of
approximately € 6 billion. Accordingly, € 6 billion on a yearly basis, or a total of € 48 billion until 2030, should be dedicated to
European PV manufacturers in effective support mechanisms – e.g., state guarantees, tax exemptions, capital (CAPEX) and
operational (OPEX) expenditure measures.
STATE GUARANTEES: State guarantees could be an important backup measure to function as market insurance, linking PV
manufacturing and PV off-takers. At least three types of state guarantees could be applied: a) state guarantees for
production (e.g. for banks); b) state guarantees for acceptance of modules for PV systems (by EPCs, electricity providers);
c) state guarantees for off-take agreements (as a back-up guarantee, for situations where off-take agreements are not
fulfilled).
TAX EXEMPTIONS: 5 to 10 years of tax exemption during the European scale-up period for manufacturers within the PV value chain
would make a large difference for stakeholders when setting up business plans. This measure would be almost
cost-neutral to the Member States, considering that the related tax income would be improbable without the incentive.
CAPEX AND OPEX MEASURES: The effective combination of CAPEX and OPEX measures would ensure the
competitiveness of European PV manufacturing, and would at the same time increase the investor’s trust. On the CAPEX side, the
investment incentives applied for the industry would have a considerable positive impact on establishing PV
manufacturing capacities, as 40-50 % CAPEX subsidies with € 10 billion fund would help build up to 40 GW European PV
manufacturing capacities. Considering OPEX, potential support measures regarding electricity costs for the manufacturing industry,
and support towards retraining for green jobs are key, as these are the most important cost streams of the industry.
Once implemented in an adapted temporary State aid framework, these measures would ensure energy independence, high
returns to Member States in the long run by tax revenues, job creation and competitiveness of all the value chains of European
economies. These measures must be in place and ready for use by June this year, at the very latest, to secure the
competitiveness of PV manufacturers in the EU. In this context, ESMC has already provided 8 concrete proposals to the
European Commission in December 2022, as guidance for the European Solar PV Industry Alliance. These include, but are not limited
to, the creation of a special financial vehicle as a first step to de-risk investments, developing effective
off-take agreements for local production, and setting EU standards on labour laws, CO2 footprint and circularity.
ENCLOSURE: ESMC Milestone Proposals for the European Solar PV Industry Alliance (5 pages).
On behalf of the European Solar Manufacturing Council,
Co-Chair Co-Chair Co-Chair Vice-President Secretary General
Eicke Weber Gaëtan Masson Carsten Rohr Vincent Bès Johan Lindahl
Saatja: Johan Lindahl <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 20.01.2023 15:27
Adressaat: <"RAM Info">; <"RAM Info">
Teema: Request for support to the European Commission‘s proposals on
State aid and funding for the EU strategic sectors
Dear Minister Annely Akkermann,
On behalf of the (ESMC) we are sending you this letter, kindly
requesting Estonia to support the strategic European PV manufacturing
sector in the high-level discussions and decisions during the next weeks.
We especially emphasise the need for your support in the ongoing
consultation of the European Commission and during the special European
Council meeting on 9-10 February.
ESMC, uniting more than 50 industrial members of the European PV
manufacturing community, encourages you to support the actions taken by
the European Commission to revise the State aid framework and support the
European PV manufacturing industry, by making State aid exemptions for PV
manufacturing and creating dedicated and concrete financial support
vehicles.
Once implemented in an adapted temporary State aid framework, these
measures would ensure energy independence, high returns to Member States
in the long run through tax revenues, job creation and competitiveness of
PV manufacturing and all connected value chains of European economies.
Please find the letter attached. We are looking forward to seeing
decisive and game-changing solutions in line with the interest of the
European PV manufacturing industries, and entire European economies.
Best Regards,
Johan Lindahl
Dr. Johan Lindahl
Secretary General
+46(0)768-511 773