dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

Kiri

Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium · 28. oktoober 2021
Viit
13-6/2021/6341-1
Registreeritud
28. oktoober 2021
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
ITSO
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
13/S Elektroonilise side korraldamine
Sari
13-6/S Telekommunikatsiooni rahvusvaheliste organisatsioonidega seotud koostööalane kirjavahetus (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
13-6/2021
Vastutaja
Tõnu Nirk (Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium, Kantsleri valdkond, Digiarengu valdkond, Sideosakond)

Failid

  • 📎E-kiri.pdf79 KB
  • 📎ITSO Chair Letter to FCC re Intelsat license application.pdf228 KB

Sisu (failidest)

Saatja: ITSO Mail <[email protected]> Saadetud: 27.10.2021 21:10 Adressaat: ITSO Mail <[email protected]> Teema: Correspondence from the Director General - Correspondence du Directeur général - Correspondencia del Director General TO: ALL PARTIES TO THE AGREEMENT RELATING TO THE INTERNATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS SATELLITE ORGANIZATION SUBJECT: Comment submitted by the Chair of ITSO Assembly of Parties reflecting ITSOs position on Intelsats Assignment and Transfer Applications Dear Colleague, On September 24, 2021, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) of USA issued a Public Notice number DA-21-1200 calling for comments from interested parties on Intelsats Assignment and Transfer Applications with a closing date for receipt of comments being set at October 25, 2021. The request can be retrieved from the hyperlink: On October 25, 2021, the Chair of ITSO Assembly of Parties submitted a response to FCC reflecting ITSOs position on the request and this response is herewith attached for the attention of the ITSO Parties. It is also available on the hyperlink: The French and Spanish versions of the Chair of ITSO Assembly of Parties letter will be sent within the next few days. Kind regards, Patrick Masambu Director General ********************************************** DESTINATAIRES : TOUTES LES PARTIES À LACCORD RELATIF À LORGANISATION INTERNATIONALE DE TÉLÉCOMMUNICATIONS PAR SATELLITES OBJET : Commentaire soumis par la présidente de l'Assemblée des Parties de l'ITSO reflétant la position de l'ITSO sur les demandes de cession et de transfert d'Intelsat Cher collègue, Le 24 septembre 2021, la Federal Communications Commission (FCC) des États-Unis a publié un avis public numéro DA-21-1200 appelant à des commentaires des parties intéressées sur les demandes de cession et de transfert d'Intelsat, la date limite de réception des commentaires étant fixée au 25 octobre 2021. La demande peut être récupérée à partir du lien : Le 25 octobre 2021, la présidente de l'Assemblée des parties de l'ITSO a soumis une réponse à la FCC reflétant la position de l'ITSO sur la demande et cette réponse est jointe à l'attention des parties de l'ITSO. Il est également disponible sur le lien hypertexte : Les versions française et espagnole de la lettre de la présidente de l'Assemblée des Parties de l'ITSO seront envoyées dans les prochains jours. Patrick Masambu Directeur général ********************************************** PARA: LAS PARTES DEL ACUERDO RELATIVO A LA ORGANIZACIÓN INTERNACIONAL DE TELECOMUNICACIONES POR SATÉLITE ASUNTO: Comentario presentado por la Presidenta de la Asamblea de Partes de la ITSO que refleja la posición de la ITSO sobre las solicitudes de cesión y transferencia de Intelsat Estimado/a colega: El 24 de septiembre de 2021, la Comisión Federal de Comunicaciones (FCC) de EE. UU. Emitió un Aviso público número DA-21-1200 solicitando comentarios de las partes interesadas sobre las solicitudes de cesión y transferencia de Intelsat con una fecha límite para la recepción de comentarios que se establece el 25 de octubre de 2021. La solicitud se puede recuperar del hipervínculo: El 25 de octubre de 2021, la Presidenta de la Asamblea de Partes de la ITSO presentó una respuesta a la FCC reflejando la posición de la ITSO sobre la solicitud y esta respuesta se adjunta a la atención de las Partes de la ITSO. También está disponible en el hipervínculo: Las versiones en español y francés de la carta de la Presidenta de la Asamblea de Partes de la ITSO se enviarán en los próximos días. Atentos saludos, Patrick Masambu Director General 1 OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL Private Bag X860, PRETORIA, 0001 – iParioli Office Park, 399 Jan Shoba Street, Hatfield, PRETORIA Tel: +27.12.427.8000- Fax +27 12 427 8016 –email: [email protected]. www.dtps.gov.za Ms. Marlene H. Dortch Secretary: Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street SW Washington, DC 20554 Dear Ms. Dortch Applications Filed for Assignment and Transfer of Control by Intelsat S.A, as Debtor in Possession, SAT−ASG−20210827−00117/00118, IB Docket No. 21-375 1. On behalf of South Africa as the Chair of the Assembly of Parties of the International Telecommunications Satellite Organization (“ITSO”), I am writing to express grave concerns regarding the application submitted by Intelsat, S.A., as debtor-in-possession (“Intelsat DIP”), seeking the Commission’s consent to the assignment and transfer of control of the Intelsat DIP FCC licenses and authorizations. Many of the licenses that are the subject of Intelsat DIP’s application are part of the ITSO Parties’ Common Heritage,1 and thus ITSO has an interest in this proceeding. 2. I would like to draw your attention to the ITSO Agreement, as amended during the Thirty-first Extraordinary Assembly of Parties, in 2007 in Paris, France. In this respect I refer to Article XII, Paragraph (c)(ii) of the ITSO Agreement: In the event that the Company, or any future entity using the Common Heritage frequency assignments, waives such frequency assignment(s), uses such assignment(s) in ways other than those set forth in this Agreement, or declares bankruptcy, the Notifying Administrations shall authorize the use of such frequency assignment(s) only by entities that have signed a 1 See, Constellation, LLC, Carlyle PanAmSat I, LLC, Carlyle PanAmSat II, LLC, PEP PAS, LLC and PEOP PAS LLC, Transferors, and Intelsat Holdings, Ltd., Transferee, Consolidated Application for Authority to Transfer Control of PanAmSat Licensee Corp. and PanAmSat H-2 Licensee Corp., 21 FCC Rcd 7368 (2006) at n. 166: The ITSO Agreement defines “common heritage” as ‘those frequency assignments associated with orbital locations in the process of advanced publication, coordination or registered on behalf of the Parties with the International Telecommunications Union (“ITU”) in accordance with the provision set forth in the ITU’s Radio Regulations which are transferred to a Party or Parties pursuant to Article XII.’ ITSO Agreement, Art. I(l). Call signs S2400, S2394, S2389, S2396, S2397, S2410, S2406, S2408, S2402, S2414, S2405, S2399, S2409, S2411, S2391, S2407, S2395, S2398, and S2404 are part of the Common Heritage. 2 public services agreement, which will enable ITSO to ensure that the selected entities fulfill the Core Principles. 3. In a decision in response to an ITSO petition filed in 2007, the Commission modified Intelsat’s Common Heritage licenses to add three conditions. IT IS ORDERED that, pursuant to sections 4(i) and 316(a) of the Communications Act, 47 U.S.C. §§ 154(i), 316(a), and section 1.87 of the Commission’s rules, 47 C.F.R. § 1.87, each of Intelsat North America’s space station authorizations, call signs S2400, S2394, S2389, S2396, S2397, S2410, S2406, S2408, S2402, S2414, S2405, S2399, S2409, S2411, S2391, S2407, S2395, S2398, and S2404, SHALL BE MODIFIED by adding the following conditions: IT IS ORDERED that Intelsat SHALL REMAIN A SIGNATORY to the Public Services Agreement between Intelsat and the International Telecommunications Satellite Organization (ITSO) that was approved by the ITSO Twenty-fifth Assembly of Parties, as amended; IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that no entity shall be considered a successor-in-interest to Intelsat under the ITSO Agreement for licensing purposes unless it has undertaken to perform the obligations of the Public Services Agreement approved by the Twenty-fifth Assembly of Parties, as amended. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Intelsat, in filing any application seeking Commission approval to modify, assign, transfer or otherwise take action with respect to this authorization, SHALL CITE TO the Order of Modification, DA 08-444, in the narrative section of the relevant application.2 4. In connection with that proceeding, the Commission received a letter from Ambassador David A. Gross, United States Coordinator, International Communications and Information Policy, U.S. Department of State (“State Letter”)3, which clearly articulated the national policy rationale for the adoption of these conditions with respect to assuring that Intelsat met its obligations under the Public Services Agreement (“PSA”) that had been entered into between Intelsat and ITSO as part of the privatization process, particularly in the context of a possible Intelsat bankruptcy. Key points made in State Letter include the following: • In the context of the decision of the Assembly of Parties and the amendments of the ITSO Agreement leading up to privatization, it is clear that the ITSO member states expected Intelsat to be bound by the Public Services Agreement (which is the agreed mechanism for satisfying the Public Service Obligations that are to ensure performance by Intelsat of the “Core Principles” stated in the ITSO Agreement). • In our view, such a “debtor-in-possession” would be a successor-in-interest” to Intelsat under the ITSO Agreement. We believe that the contingency of a possible Intelsat bankruptcy, which was not fully anticipated by the decisions of the Assembly of Parties leading up to privatization, should be addressed in the spirit of those decisions jointly made by the United States and other ITSO Parties. 2 Petition of ITSO under Section 316 of the Communications Act, as Amended, Order of Modification, 23 FCC Rcd 2764 (2008) ¶ 13. 3 Letter from Ambassador David A. Gross, United States Coordinator, International Communications and Information Policy, U.S. Department of State, to The Honorable Kevin J. Martin, Chairman, Federal Communications Commission, IB Docket No. 06-137 (dated Mar. 15, 2007). 3 • The foreign policy interests of the United States are advanced by our steady adherence to the commitments that we made at that time in the process of privatization. 5. As the State Letter made clear, the Intelsat privatization process was contingent on very fundamental principles and commitments being honored by all parties to the process, including Intelsat. Yet instead of honoring these principles and commitments, Intelsat has used its bankruptcy proceeding as both a sword and a shield to completely undermine those principles and commitments. 6. Notwithstanding the clear licensing conditions imposed in the Section 316 proceeding, Intelsat thought so little of its obligation to adhere to these conditions that it failed, as required by the third condition, to even acknowledge, much less commit to honor its obligations under the PSA in either its original application to assign the licenses to the debtor-in-possession entity or the application now before the Commission. 7. In their bankruptcy proceeding Intelsat had taken the position that the PSA is an executory contract which it has the right to reject at will, and while it never actually did so, this threat represented a major overhang in terms of subsequent negotiations between Intelsat and ITSO to resolve ongoing disputes that had lead ITSO to initiate an arbitration proceeding before the ICC against Intelsat, which was supposed to be the sole mechanism for resolving issues arising under the PSA, not a bankruptcy proceeding initiated in the United States. Yet Intelsat used its bankruptcy filing to subvert this process in various ways, including through invocation of the automatic stay, which stopped the arbitration proceeding at a very critical stage. While Intelsat subsequently agreed to lifting the automatic stay, that only occurred after the damage to the ongoing viability of the arbitration proceeding had occurred. And even the agreement to lift the stay was subject to the condition that the bankruptcy court would have final approval authority over any remedy that the arbitral panel might seek to invoke. 8. This outcome was never envisioned as a possibility during the negotiations leading up to Intelsat’s privatization and is inconsistent with the views expressed in the State Letter. Intelsat’s conduct in this regard is clearly at odds with the U.S. Party’s foreign policy interests as articulated in the State Letter and has the potential to seriously damage those interests going forward. Moreover, these measures ultimately resulted in the negotiation of a Settlement Agreement where ITSO had no leverage whatsoever. Among other things, the ITSO Director General was required, as a result of the Settlement Agreement, to terminate key staff and to commit to support a resolution calling for the termination of the ITSO Agreement at the next Assembly of Parties. 9. With respect to ITSO’s funding, the Settlement Agreement only covered the time period up to the end of June 2021, in anticipation that an Assembly of Parties meeting to consider the termination of the ITSO Agreement would have occurred by that date. Because such decision could only be considered at an in-person as opposed to a virtual meeting under the terms of the ITSO Agreement, it was not possible due to travel restrictions associated with the global pandemic for the meeting to occur by that deadline. It is now anticipated that such a meeting will take place prior to March 31, 2022. However, since June 2021, Intelsat has not provided ITSO with any additional funding whatsoever, in clear violation of the terms of the PSA, and has only offered insufficient funding on terms that are deemed totally unacceptable by the Steering Committee established at the most recent ITSO Assembly of Parties. Due to the prevailing situation, ITSO Executive Organ is currently on the brink of ceasing operations because of lack of funds, to the detriment of the 149 countries, including the U.S.A, that are Member States of ITSO. 10. Finally, Intelsat’s position before the Commission in regard to the bankruptcy concerns previously raised by ITSO, starting back in 2005, has shown a remarkable lack of candor 4 throughout various filings it has made with the FCC, including the proceeding considering the Intelsat/PanAmSat merger and the subsequent Section 316 Petition filed by ITSO. Throughout those proceedings, Intelsat tried to dampen any concerns about its possible bankruptcy as speculative and unwarranted, which as subsequent events have shown, was neither speculative or unwarranted. Furthermore, Intelsat’s asserting that the PSA would fully protect ITSO in the event of a bankruptcy proceeding has proven equally disingenuous, given Intelsat’s awareness that it could seek to escape its obligations under the PSA while in bankruptcy by casting it as an executory contract. 11. The concerns raised by Intelsat’s bankruptcy proceeding were sufficiently severe that ITSO convened an extraordinary meeting of its Assembly of Parties (AP-39) in August 2020. One of the key decisions taken at that meeting was “[t]o request the U.S. and U.K. Notifying Administrations (a) to endeavor to ensure that Intelsat remains party to a PSA with ITSO, consistent with applicable domestic procedures of the respective Parties; and (b) to approve conditioning the execution of any new PSA with post-bankruptcy Intelsat on the payment of all outstanding obligations accrued by ITSO prior thereto, taking into consideration the national regulations of the Notifying Administrations.” 12. For all of the above reasons, and taking account of the decision taken at AP-39, it is imperative that Intelsat’s obligations to honor its commitments set forth in the PSA, including funding the organization at appropriate levels and on reasonable terms, for so long as the organization continues to exist, must be confirmed in this proceeding. As such, ITSO does not support the granting of Intelsat DIP’s application until and unless the concerns raised above have been fully and successfully resolved. 13. We would further request the FCC to note that the assignment and transfer of control of the licenses in question to any new entity including a ‘post-bankruptcy Intelsat’ will be subject to confirmation by the Assembly of Parties of ITSO. Yours sincerely, _____________________________ Ms Nonkqubela Jordan-Dyani Acting Director-General Date: 22-10-2021
Allikas: Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel