Saatja: Inga Volosovska <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 29.10.2021 11:29
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; Eda Rembel <
[email protected]>; MKM info
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Māris Vaics <
[email protected]>
Teema: Inquiry on how to determine the conditions to be met by
undertakings and transport managers in order to satisfy the requirement
of good repute
Dear colleagues,
We would appreciate if you could share your practice and answer a few
questions in accordance with Regulation (EC) No 1071/2009 establishing
common rules concerning the conditions to be complied with to pursue the
occupation of road transport operator and repealing Council Directive
96/26/EC, Article 6, on how Member States determine the conditions to be
met by undertakings and transport managers in order to satisfy the
requirement of good repute laid down in Article 3(1)(b).
When we in Latvia evaluate requirement of good repute for a transport
manager and official representatives (board members), information about
criminal offences committed in Latvia are received from criminal record
database only on relevant fields as mentioned in Article 6 of Regulation
1071/2009. Our national legislation determines that if information on
criminal offences committed in other Member states is received from our
national criminal record database (that is connected to The European
Criminal Records Information System (ECRIS)), it must be taken into
account without further assessment and the licence is refused. Such
conditions were established due to various legislation on criminal
offences in different countries and according to our interpretation
Member states send information on active criminal offences to ECRIS and
such information must be taken into account by other Member states.
We would highly appreciate if you could share your practice on this
matter:
1. Do you evaluate criminal offences of respective persons? Do you take
into account a field of law in which an offence was committed, limitation
period (how long ago it was committed), regularity, other similar
violations and infringements of non-criminal nature in the evaluation
process? Are there cases when even if a person has one or, in some cases,
multiple offences you determine that the particular person can be still
determined as a person of good repute?
2. Do you take into account only those criminal offences for which a
person is held criminally liable at present or the past history of
criminal records as well?
* If your country takes into account only those criminal offences with
ongoing criminal liability, then on what principles is based your
evaluation of a persons good repute (considering that every member state
has different terms of serving the sentence)?
* If your country takes into account also historical offences, have you
established a limitation period for historical records [of offences] to
be taken into account in the evaluation of a persons repute (for example,
in the evaluation of good repute only those offences committed during the
past 10 years are taken into account). In case you take into account all
historical offences, do you separately evaluate the character of each
offence, violation and infringement and their impact on the loss of good
repute as appropriate measure?
3. Do you request information on criminal offences not only from your
own country but also from other Member States through The European
Criminal Records Information System (ECRIS) as well? If yes,
* Is an offence committed in another Member state assessed/evaluated,
in accordance with your national legislation? For example: a person is
found guilty of causing a traffic accident in another Member State and
sentenced in this particular country for 20 years. In case the punishment
imposed on such an offender in this particular Member state is tougher
than the punishment that would have been awarded to the same individual
pursuant your national legislation would you determine this person as a
person deprived of good repute in your country for the period of time
stated by the Member State in which the criminal offence was committed
(even if such persons are no longer held criminally or administratively
liable, but their records remain in the system until this person is 100
years old like it is provided for in the UK)?
4. Do you continue to receive and evaluate offences committed in the
United Kingdom after the Brexit?
5. Could you please share the link to your legislation, where good
repute compliance requirements are specified nationally?
We would highly appreciate, if you could respond till the beginning of
December.
Best regards,
Inga Volosovska
Road Transport licensing expert
State Ltd. Road Transport Administration
Phone: (+371) 67686436, mob.: (+371) 27015662