EEA and Norway Grants 2014-2021
Programme: Local Development
and Poverty Reduction
Selection Committee meeting
November 30, 2020
Open call for proposals
„Awareness raising activities on
domestic violence and to
discourage the demand for
commercial sex“
Overview
Project max duration: 24 months
Call amount: € 200,000
Project grant size: € 200,000
Project grant rate: 85-90%
Eligible applicants: legal persons under public or private law, non-governmental
organisation registered in Estonia
The call is financed from the NOR Grants FM
Eligible activities of the small grant scheme are:
a) conducting an awareness-raising campaign on domestic violence and gender-
based violence;
b) making short films on the topic of domestic violence, aimed at children and
young people;
c) conducting awareness-raising activities on the topic of human trafficking
committed for the purpose of prostitution and sexual exploitation.
Targets:
At least one awareness raising campaign targeted at reducing domestic and
gender-based violence with male role models carried out;
At least three short movies on domestic violence for children and youth
created;
At least two awareness raising activities reaching at least 12 000 people in
Estonia to discourage the demand for commercial sex.
Number Expected programme results Indicator Baseline Baseline Target
value year value
Percentage of population in
favour of criminalising the 53% 2016 60%
buying of sex
Reduced domestic and Percentage of population not
Outcome 2 gender-based violence and blaming victims of domestic 47% 2016 55%
gender inequalities violence
Percentage of population not
blaming victims of sexual 53% 2016 60%
violence
PO considers these outcome targets levels as conservative and strives to reach
higher targets.
Awareness-raising campaign on domestic and
gender-based violence must include:
o men shall also be included as positive role models in the implementation of
the activities;
o the domestic violence expert shall be actively involved in the development of
messages, texts, and visual materials in order to ensure the compliance of the
materials of the awareness campaign with the principles on combating
domestic and gender-based violence;
o the visibility period shall be at least four weeks;
o the budget shall include all copyright fees;
o a follow-up study of the campaign shall be carried out in order to assess its
performance and impact, and it shall cover the noticeability of the campaign,
comprehensibility and likeability of the creative solution, as well as the impact
of the campaign on awareness and attitudes.
Short films on the topic of domestic violence,
aimed at children and young people must:
o cover different aspects of the topic of domestic violence (noticing,
reacting, supporting victims, prevention) based on real life examples that
people relate to and that make them think about and discuss domestic
and gender-based violence;
o there shall be at least three short films;
o form a cohesive aesthetic and conceptual whole, so that each short film is
clearly identifiable as part of the series of short films;
o relevant guidance/study materials must be developed to support active
reflection and discussion on the topics discussed in the short films and
help raise the awareness of children and young people on the topic of
domestic violence;
Short films on the topic of domestic violence,
aimed at children and young people must: (2)
o a domestic violence expert shall be actively involved in the development
of short films and guidance/study materials in order to ensure compliance
of the content of short films and guidance/study materials (incl. visuals)
with the principles on combating domestic and gender-based violence;
o shall be made available with guidance/study materials to the public via a
digital learning environment (e.g. e-Koolikott);
o be shown and the guidance/study materials and information thereon shall
be distributed among children and young people, as well as the teachers;
o the budget shall include all copyright fees;
o must be available with guidance/study material) to the public and usable
for at least five years after the end of project activities.
Awareness-raising activities on the topic of
human trafficking committed for the purpose of
prostitution and sexual exploitation must:
o focus on reducing the demand for prostitution and human trafficking;
o be based on the notion that prostitution is violence against women, which
must be prevented, hindered and the victims of which must be offered
diverse assistance. The coverage of demand shall be based on ethical,
social, as well as legal consequences;
o be developed and implemented in cooperation with the prostitution expert
in order to ensure compliance with the principles on combating
prostitution;
o reach at least 12,000 people in Estonia.
Evaluation criteria of the open call
No Criterion Points
Competence and roles of the project team members and the work processes related to the
1 project team 27
2 Involvement and roles of the project partner 10
The creative solution and media strategy for the campaign on raising awareness on domestic
3 and gender-based violence 20
Short films on the topic of domestic violence, aimed at children and young people,
accompanying guidance/study materials, and the plan for the showing, introduction and
4 distribution thereof 15
Awareness-raising activities on the topic of human trafficking committed for the purpose of
prostitution and sexual exploitation (hereinafter “awareness-raising activities”), including
5 concept, schedule, and action plan 10
6 The measurability of the expected results of the activities set out in the project application 4
7 Innovation and added value of the project 4
8 Assessment and mitigation of risk factors 5
Economic efficiency of the project (necessity, justification and budget clarity of the proposed
9 expenditure) 7
TOTAL 102
Projects received within deadline:
1. NGO Eluliin (Lifeline)
project budget 222 222 euros; grant applied for 200 000 euros (90%)
with project partners:
a) NGO Eesti Naisuurimus- ja Teabekeskuses (The Estonian Women’s
Studies and Resource Centre);
b) NGO Eesti Ühiskonnaõpetajate Selts (Estonian Teachers Society of
Social Studies),
c) AS Idea AD Ltd,
d) Re:Media Ltd (Norway)
Evaluation of independent experts
Evaluator 1: Ms Anu Leps, Adviser, Criminal Policy Department,
Ministry of Justice
Evaluator 2: Ms Kaire Tamm, Adviser, Criminal Policy Department,
Ministry of Justice
The overall grant amount asked for is equal to total grant amount
available.
The difference between the scores given by the two experts was well
under 30%, so no need for a third evaluation was necessary
The evaluated project did not receive under 50% of the total score, leading
to an automatic negative decision
Ranking list of experts
NGO Eluliin
Average
No 1 Criterion Max score score
Competence and roles of the project team members and the work processes related
1 to the project team 27 22,0
2 Involvement and roles of the project partner 10 7,5
The creative solution and media strategy for the campaign on raising awareness on
3 domestic and gender-based violence 20 16,5
Short films on the topic of domestic violence, aimed at children and young people,
accompanying guidance/study materials, and the plan for the showing, introduction
4 and distribution thereof 15 9,0
Awareness-raising activities on the topic of human trafficking committed for the
purpose of prostitution and sexual exploitation (hereinafter “awareness-raising
5 activities”), including concept, schedule, and action plan 10 9,0
The measurability of the expected results of the activities set out in the project
6 application 4 3,0
7 Innovation and added value of the project 4 3,0
8 Assessment and mitigation of risk factors 5 5,0
Economic efficiency of the project (necessity, justification and budget clarity of the
9 proposed expenditure) 7 7,0
TOTAL 102 82,0
Selection Committee members
Voting members
Ms Kristiina Luht - Representative of the Ministry of Social Affairs, Equality
Policies Department;
Ms Freja Ulvestad Kärki - Representative of the Norwegian Directorate of
Health;
Ms Grete Kaju - Representative of the Ministry of Social Affairs, Equality
Policies Department
Observers
The representatives of the National Focal Point and Programme Operator
Implementing Agency (both State Shared Service Centre) as well as the donor
states (Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Financial Mechanism
Committee) shall be invited to participate as observers.
Selection Committee tasks
The goal
to confirm the list of project applications suggested to be financed and the list
of project applications not to be financed and forward its decision to the
Programme Operator Implementing Agency (i.e. State Shared Service Centre)
for formal decision making.
The tasks
review the ranking list of project applications resulting from the
mathematical average of individual expert evaluation scores;
confirm the list of project applications suggested to be financed and the
list of project applications not to be financed;
modify the ranking list of the project applications or propose only partial
financing of projects in justified cases based on transparent criteria
recorded in the minutes of the committee meeting.
After the Selection Committee
Chairman of the Selection Committee and the PO will sign the minutes of
the meeting, where decisions are laid down in a transparent and
accountable manner describing which project proposals shall be awarded a
grant and which proposals will be rejected.
PO Implementing Agency will cast a decision to award a grant or decline
awarding a grant based on the written recommendation of the Selection
Committee.
Discussion and decisions
Aitäh! Takk!
Kristiina Luht (
[email protected])
Ülar Vaadumäe (
[email protected])
EEA and Norway Grants 2014-2021
Programme “Local Development and Poverty Reduction”
Selection Committee meeting
Date and time:
November 30, 2020 from 10:30 to 11:55 (Estonian time)
Venue: Cisco Meet web platform & MoSA, 1st floor, room Vaher (Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn)
Open call for proposals
„Awareness raising activities on domestic violence and to discourage the demand for
commercial sex“
Selection Committee voting members:
Ms Kristiina Luht – Chairman of the Selection Committee; Head of Victim Support Policy,
Equality Policies Department, Ministry of Social Affairs;
Ms Freja Ulvestad Kärki – representative of Donor Programme Partner, Norwegian
Directorate of Health;
Ms Grete Kaju – adviser, Equality Policies Department, Ministry of Social Affairs.
Observers:
Ms Gudrun Gudmundsdottir – Financial Mechanism Office, Senior Sector Officer, Health,
Children and Youth, also representing the Financial Mechanism Committee
Ms Laura Pikkoja – representative of the National Focal Point; State Shared Service
Centre;
Ms Piret Marvet – representative of the donors, Royal Norwegian Embassy in Tallinn.
Ms Kelly Poopuu – representative of the PO Implementing Agency, State Shared Service
Centre.
Mr Ülar Vaadumäe – Ministry of Social Affairs, Smart Development Department, chief
specialist, PO.
Minutes of the meeting
Mr Ülar Vaadumäe gave an overview of the goals, targets and criteria of the call for proposals.
Also, Mr Vaadumäe introduced the submitted project and explained the tasks of the Selection
Committee. For more, please see Annex 1 (PO presentation).
Altogether 1 project application was received within the deadline (September 30, 2020 at 17:00
o’clock local time) set for the call.
NGO Eluliin (Lifeline)
project budget 222 222 euros; grant applied for 200 000 euros (90%).
As a result the overall grant amount asked for is equal to the total grant amount of 200 000 euros
available.
Programme Operator Implementing Agency (State Shared Service Centre) has carried out the
assessment of project application to the eligibility and administrative criteria set in the call text.
The project met the administrative and eligibility criteria and was forwarded for evaluation by two
impartial, independent and reliable experts.
These experts were:
Evaluator 1: Ms Anu Leps, Adviser, Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of Justice;
Evaluator 2: Ms Kaire Tamm, Adviser, Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of Justice.
The difference between the scores given by the two experts was under 30%, so no need
for a third evaluation was necessary (point 20.05 of the call text)
he evaluated project did not receive under 50% of the total score, leading to an automatic
negative decision
Please see also Annex 2 (Ranking list of experts).
Discussion
NGO Eluliin (Lifeline)
in cooperation with project partners:
a) NGO Eesti Naisuurimus- ja Teabekeskuses (The Estonian Women’s Studies and Resource
Centre);
b) NGO Eesti Ühiskonnaõpetajate Selts (Estonian Teachers Society of Social Studies),
c) AS Idea AD Ltd,
d) Re:Media Ltd (Norway)
Three activity areas of the call were discussed separately.
Conducting awareness-raising activities on the topic of human trafficking committed for the
purpose of prostitution and sexual exploitation
Ms Grete Kaju opened the discussion by admitting that the conception proposed “Man honour”
is quite provocative – visual association with brothel neon lights as well as the depiction of an
image of a penis. While provocative slogan and visual is understandable conception choice on
condom package then using provocative messages and visual on buildings at open streets could
generate negative reactions and therefore could work against the goal it is set to achieve.
Although the project applicant says it is ready to change course immediately, in case problems
arise, then it would not spare of fix the damage already done. It is not realistic to change (quickly)
central elements of a campaign (slogan, main messages and visual) after the campaign has
already started and posters are put up to payable billboards. So, it is very important to make
sure beforehand that the slogan, main messages and visuals work as planned on a selected
target group and that they are also suitable in the environment they are used in order for
campaign having an effect that is planned. If activities are planned in the public space, then the
message and visual must be appropriate also for example for children who will see them too.
Additionally, since the topic is sensitive at a political level, possible negative feedback from
politicians should be taken into consideration (and how to approach it so the negative feedback
would not not harm the goals set), especially when provocative approach for the campaign will
be chosen (considering there will be state logos on visual materials present etc).
Ms Kristiina Luht said that she agrees with Ms Kaju. Also, the slogan “man honour” associates
with language based word play meaning also “penis” in Estonian. The provocation is
understood, but can easily turn against the set goals in public sphere.
Ms Freja Ulvestad Kärki admitted that in such a campaign proposal should have had a previous
research (testing) done to get feedback how this kind of provocative campaign would work and
which reactions it would create.
Ms Kaju pointed out that according to criteria of the call for proposals supported activities must
demolish gender stereotypes and not strengthen the existing ones (article 6.2.3). With currently
proposed slogan and visual there is a considerable possibility that the campaign will actually
work against demolishing gender stereotypes.
Considering that honor (culture) requires different things from men and women (female honor
involves shame, chastity, and purity while male honor - in contrast – involves potency, including
strength and power) then focusing on „man’s honor“ as a key strategy in order to raise
awareness on sexual exploitation of women, might not be the most suitable option. In addition
of reinforcing typical gender stereotype (about man’s honor), the campaign message presented
as it is in the application, reinforces also honor culture and ideology1. Considering that there are
several research that have shown that honor ideology can be associated with an increased
likelihood of men actually engaging in violent and sexually coercive behaviors toward
women2,3,4 then presented slogan and visual for the awareness-raising activities on the topic of
human trafficking should be redesigned. An option to consider could be, instead of man’s honor,
putting the focus for example, on (man`s) dignity.
Ms Gudrun Gudmundsdottir agreed that stirring up emotions and controversy could backfire and
proposed whether there could be a possibility to reshape the campaign structure.
Ms Ulvestad Kärki explained that we could negotiate with the applicant in regard to modifying
the project application activity dealing with awareness-raising activities on the topic of human
trafficking.
Conducting an awareness-raising campaign on domestic violence and gender-based violence
Ms Grete Kaju noted that the evaluators have made good points to be pondered about.
Word Force as the slogan and the creation of a message that sounds similar to one of the armed
forces, is most likely to be helpful in drawing men closer to the campaign.
The selection of male figures for the campaign was focused in the direction of selecting rather
athletic male figures, which may result in the removal of many men who do not view themselves
in such a light, from the message. Younger men could certainly be included as examples in the
choice of male figures, as the involvement of young people plays an important role in creating
attitudes, while also supplementing the selection with well-known people from that age group
who are not athletes or actors, but are instead representatives from other cultural or economic
areas. It is also very important to include respected male figures from non-Estonian population.
The use of two men on campaign materials in the same scale somehow had a robust effect, and
could draw an association whether we are not talking about violence between same-sex
couples. It would perhaps be better to place one man as a larger figure in front, with one or more
1 https://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780195396607/obo-9780195396607-0160.xml
2https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321851810_Culture_Masculine_Honor_and_Violence_Toward_Women
3 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12757144/
4 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ab.21893
smaller sized male figures placed behind him, in order to emphasise the message of power. Or
use 3 men instead (one in front, 2 behind).
At present, the logo (palm stopping the fist) is clearly a sign of denial, but cannot be associated
with the power of the word and its resulting power.
And finally, men’s march “Against domestic violence with the force of the word” could be hard
to execute organically as Estonians do not have a cultural tradition of marching for a cause.
Ms Kristiina Luht commented that the idea of a petition seeking to simplify the application
process for obtaining a restraining order, would not be up to date any more as the corresponding
changes to the criminal proceedings already entered into force in May 2020, so this part requires
clarification as regards the content of the petition.
Ms Freja Ulvestad Kärki highlighted the depiction of masculinity in a new context (military). She
also suggested to include dating violence into the message palette and engage younger
influencers for spreading the word.
Making short films on the topic of domestic violence, aimed at children and young people
Mr Ülar Vaadumäe made a remark that concerning the short films activity the evaluators had
made comments on the dissemination plan of the films and guidance materials to the target
audience.
A more detailed explanation regarding how the introduction of short films would take place
primarily in schools and how, among other things, the target group of teachers will be reached
via civic society teachers in order to introduce them as working methods in the school system.
The role of the Estonian Civic Society Teachers Association requires specification.
The number of schools, which classes, how many students or teachers plan to be reached, has
not been noted. It is unclear from the application whether it is planned to collect and assess the
feedback of the materials at schools based on what suggestions to improve the materials should
be done. In order to cover the expected target group of young people in schools more broadly,
the applicant could also consider the possibilities offered by Back to School and support
specialists.
One distribution channel is seen as being Facebook; however, the target group for whom the
activities are planned is using this environment less and less. The use of Instagram has never
been mentioned, which is a much more usable channel for this target group.
Ms Kristiina Luht was on the same opinion that it needs to be clarified which schools, which
teachers/support workers would be reached (scope). Feedback on the usability of the materials
is also necessary.
Ms Grete Kaju pointed out that the applicant is not clear whether it will develop 3 or even 5 short
films. Both numbers exist in the application. And again, the dissemination part is crucial as is
collecting the feedback how the materials are understood by the target group. So, those
activities should be explained more clearly in the application.
Ms Freja Ulvestad Kärki said that the ultimate goal to get wider coverage (number of schools
reached), therefore it is important to get the children / youth on board. Engaging with pupils’
association would be positive.
Ms Ulvestad Kärki commented that the Norwegian partner Re:Media is not very widely known
in Norway. The company is UK based and the expert Mr Marius Damsleth is an economist.
Still, according to the application Mr Damsleth has led the “Dear Daddy” anti-domestic violence
campaign. Please see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gOk_qxkBphY. Ms Kaju sought it to
be a good educational video and it would be great if applicant could find a way to integrate this
(after adding subtitles) to its awareness activities that are targeted to schoolkids.
Selection Committee decision
Approve a project grant in the amount of 200 000 euros to NGO Eluliin (Lifeline) with the
following conditions:
a) Selection Committee sees substantial danger in the proposed concept “Man’s honour”
(diminishing the demand for commercial sex) in being provocative and contra productive
to its goals. Therefore, the Selection Committee proposes the applicant to redesign the
concept while keeping in mind that messages and visuals must be appropriate for the
environment they will be published (for more, please see suggestions above in the
minutes);
b) The applicant should analyse the comments made by the evaluators on the campaign
“Word force” and update / modify the strategy accordingly – different type of men, also
younger men and non-Estonian men, two-man visual, men’s march, fist-palm logo,
restraining order petition, dating violence (for more, please see above in the minutes);
c) The applicant should clarify the distribution plan of the short films and guidance
materials, how the target group is reached, what are the intervention mediums, what is
the role of the Civic Society Teachers Association, engaging Back to School programme
and pupils association. Additionally, a feedback on the usability of the materials should
be gathered (for more, please see above in the minutes);
d) The applicant should revise the project budget regarding project management and
voluntary work. The unit costs for the same line of work should not differ depending
whether it is reimbursed or considered as voluntary contribution.
It should be also clarified the contribution and reimbursement ratio project applicant and
project partners:
does the salary of IDEA AD project assistant receive a salary in line with the average
salary in this line of work?
why is the project manager of the applicant working and will be reimbursed only for
45 days, when the project runs for 24 months?
does NGO Eesti Naisuurimus- ja Teabekeskuses (The Estonian Women’s Studies
and Resource Centre) contribution require a separate administrative person to be
employed?
Mr Ülar Vaadumäe and Ms Kristiina Luht thanked everybody for their input and closed the
meeting.
Meeting chaired by
(digitally signed) minutes taken by
Kristiina Luht
(digitally signed)
Ülar Vaadumäe
Open call for proposals „Awareness raising activities on domestic violence and to discourage the demand for commercial sex“
Selection criteria
NGO Eluliin
No 1 Criterion Max score Evaluator 1 Evaluator 2 Average score
1 Competence and roles of the project team members and the work processes related to the project team 27 23 21 22,0
Competence of the project manager, domestic violence expert and prostitution expert (knowledge and experience in the
area) 12 10 8 9,0
Competence (knowledge and experience in the area) of the communication team (creative director, art director, copywriter,
technical designer, and PR consultant) 10 10 10 10,0
Roles and duties of the project team and work processes related to the project team 5 3 3 3,0
2 Involvement and roles of the project partner 10 5 10 7,5
Involvement of a partner from the Kingdom of Norway in the planning and implementation of the project 7 4 7 5,5
Involvement of Estonian or other beneficiary countries or a Russian partner in the planning and implementation of the
project 3 1 3 2,0
3 The creative solution and media strategy for the campaign on raising awareness on domestic and gender-based violence 20 15 18 16,5
The level of detail of the campaign on raising awareness on domestic and gender-based violence 5 5 5 5,0
The suitability and feasibility of creative solution for the campaign on raising awareness on domestic and gender-based
violence 5 3 3 3,0
The level of detail, suitability and feasibility of the media strategy for the campaign on raising awareness on domestic and
gender-based violence 10 7 10 8,5
Short films on the topic of domestic violence, aimed at children and young people, accompanying guidance/study
4 materials, and the plan for the showing, introduction and distribution thereof 15 9 9 9,0
The level of detail and suitability of the idea for short films and the content of study/guidance materials 7 5 5 5,0
The level of detail of the plan for the showing of short films and the introduction and distribution plan of the guidance/study
materials (hereinafter “distribution plan of short films”), relevance of activities, and inclusion of intended target groups 8 4 4 4,0
Awareness-raising activities on the topic of human trafficking committed for the purpose of prostitution and sexual
5 exploitation (hereinafter “awareness-raising activities”), including concept, schedule, and action plan 10 10 8 9,0
6 The measurability of the expected results of the activities set out in the project application 4 2 4 3,0
7 Innovation and added value of the project 4 4 2 3,0
8 Assessment and mitigation of risk factors 5 5 5 5,0
9 Economic efficiency of the project (necessity, justification and budget clarity of the proposed expenditure) 7 7 7 7,0
102 80 84 82,0
diff. 4,76%
95,24%
Ranking list of expert evaluation Grant amount (€)
NGO ELULIIN 200 000
200 000
Evaluator 1 = Ms Anu Leps, Adviser, Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of Justice
Evaluator 2 = Ms Kaire Tamm, Adviser, Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of Justice
Martin Karro
Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus
[email protected] Meie 11.12.2020 nr 2-6.3/3593-1
Avatud taotlusvooru „Teadlikkuse tõstmine
perevägivalla teemadel ja seksi ostmise
nõudluse vähendamiseks“ hindamiskomisjoni
poolt rahastamiseks kinnitatud projektitaotlused
Lugupeetud Martin Karro
Palume Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskusel kui Euroopa Majanduspiirkonna ja Norra toetuste 2014–
2021 programmi „Kohalik areng ja vaesuse vähendamine“ rakendusüksusel langetada
toetuse rahuldamise otsus MTÜ Eluliin esitatud projektitaotluse suhtes, mis laekus avatud
taotlusvooru „Teadlikkuse tõstmine perevägivalla teemadel ja seksi ostmise nõudluse
vähendamiseks“ raames ja mille on oma otsusega kinnitanud ka 30. novembril 2020. aastal
kohtunud taotlusvooru hindamiskomisjon.
Palun rakendusüksusel võtta rahastusotsuse langetamisel arvesse ka, et taotleja täiendaks
eelnevalt oma projektikirjeldust ja eelarvet hindamiskomisjoni viidatud eeltingimustel, mis
kajastuvad täpsemalt hindamiskomisjoni protokollis (lisatud).
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kristiina Hunt
nutika arengu toetamise osakonna juhataja
Lisa: Minutes of the SC meeting (Nov 30 2020)_FINAL
Ülar Vaadumäe 626 9249
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 626 9301 /
[email protected] / www.sm.ee / registrikood 70001952