European social partners’ joint contribution
Report by Andrea Nahles on social dialogue
18/12/20
This statement takes into account the mandate given by Commissioner Schmit to Andrea
Nahles as well as the discussions held during the workshop on 12 November
The European cross-industry and sectoral social partners are committed to a well-functioning
European social dialogue.
Four years after the signature of the first ever quadri-partite statement on a new start for social
dialogue, this joint contribution of the European social partners takes stock of the progress
made. It focuses on the role of the Commission and of Member States to further improve the
framework conditions for social dialogue at all appropriate levels, while recalling the founding
principle that social dialogue remains the autonomous responsibility of the social partners.
This contribution is elaborated at the end of a year of unprecedented Covid-19 crisis during
which social dialogue at all levels, on a tripartite as well as on a bipartite basis, has contributed
in an exceptional manner to realistic solutions to mitigate the crisis.
This joint contribution of the European social partners also takes into account that the
Commission will in a few months publish an action plan to implement the European pillar of
social rights, which will structure the Commission and Member States activities in the coming
years.
The European social partners’ joint assessment of the quadri-partite statement on a new start
for social dialogue is broadly positive. This statement has acted as a catalyser for coordinated
progress towards stronger social dialogue at EU and national levels.
The content of the quadri-partite statement remains valid, and therefore there is no need to
revise this text. However, some improvements could be made in its implementation. Process-
wise it is necessary to ensure regular information exchanges between the Commission, the
Council and the social partners with a view to identifying jointly what are the priorities shared
by the four partners and what kind of concrete actions are needed.
The European social partners draw the particular attention of the European Commission on
the need to meet and discuss with the European social partners to achieve clarity with regard
to its decision-making process and actions taken about putting forward EU social partners
agreements to the Council when it is the joint request of the social partners to implement their
agreement by a Council decision on proposal from the Commission.
There are five main areas where further progress is needed:
1. Strengthening the identification of broadly shared and consistent social affairs priorities
at EU level
It is widely understood that social policy decisions should be taken as closely as possible to
the citizens of the Union. On the labour market in particular many decisions are best taken by
or as close as possible to the employer and employees concerned.
The subsidiarity and proportionality principles, as enshrined in the Treaty, should remain at
the centre of policy orientation. The fact that economic development in the Member States is
heterogeneous should also be better accounted for in European debates on the social
dimension, to allow for realistic progress in terms of European economic and social
convergence.
It also requires to progress towards a shared understanding of what constitutes the European
added value in terms of employment and social policies, taking into account the role of social
partners at EU and national levels.
Whereas the Commission and the Member States intend to involve the social partners in the
implementation of the actions that will be agreed as part of the action plan on the European
pillar of social rights, it is essential that the proposed actions reflect a broadly shared agenda
that can unite public authorities and social partners at EU and national level.
Joint recommendation: The European social partners call on the European Commission and
the Council to propose a new approach to involve at an early stage the EU and national social
partners in the identification of priority issues/actions, the related policy instruments, and the
EU resources to be mobilised in support of the action plan to implement the European pillar of
social rights. There is a need for regular quadri-partite meetings involving the Commission,
the Member States and the social partners to regularly discuss social affairs priorities and
actions at EU and national levels and take stock of the implementation of the 2016 quadri-
partite statement on a new start for social dialogue.
2. Towards more meaningful social partners’ consultations by the Commission
The 2016 quadri-partite statement on a new start for social dialogue included the
Commission’s commitment to endeavour to:
• “promote and improve social dialogue in accordance with article 154 TFEU”;
• “involve social partners in policy- and law-making at Union level, for instance via its
consultations with the Union social partners on key initiatives included in its work
programme that do not fall under the scope of Articles 153 and 154 TFEU, but which
may have significant implications for the social and employment situation”.
These two commitments taken by the European Commission remain fully valid. In the last
years, the Treaty-based social partner consultations did not always provide the necessary
conditions for a meaningful consultation of the social partners. In this respect, the European
social partners stress the importance for the Commission to promote social dialogue solutions,
taking into account social partners respective positions.
Moreover, in the last years, the multiplication of issues for social partners hearings and/or
other forms of consultations has not always coincided with what the European social partners
suggested as priorities for consultations.
2
Joint recommendation: The European social partners call on the European Commission to
better act upon its already taken commitments in the 2016 quadri-partite statement on a new
start for social dialogue, as regards social partner involvement in policy- and law-making. In
particular, a clearer distinction needs to be made between social partner and public
consultations, and improvements are needed as regards social partners’ consultations on
initiatives which do not fall under the scope of article 153 and 154, but are of particular
relevance for social partners. It is the Commission’s role to promote the dialogue between
social partners, keeping in mind that not just negotiations but also joint recommendations from
the social partners are a possibility. To improve awareness and understanding of the role of
social dialogue within the Commission and ensure that social partners are timely consulted on
all matters that have an impact on growth and employment, and that their autonomy is
respected in the domains which are of social partners competence, the Commission should
identify a representative responsible for social dialogue coordination in each of its relevant
DGs.
3. Improving the functioning and coordination of EU Social Dialogue Committees
The role of cross-industry and sectoral Social Dialogue Committee needs to be improved, with
a view to ensuring an effective cooperation between the Commission, the EU cross-industry
social partners and the EU sectoral social partners.
Joint recommendation: It is important to improve the functioning of the Commission’s Liaison
Forum to improve coordination of cross-industry and sectoral social dialogue committees’
respective activities, as well as to increase the Commission’s awareness of the main results
of social partners project activities. The Commission should also secure the necessary
resources for an appropriate functioning of the Sectoral Social Dialogue Committees, and
respects social partner’s autonomy in all committees.
4. Improving social partner involvement in the recovery
The 2016 quadri-partite statement on a new start for social dialogue included the
Commission’s commitment to endeavour to “enhance the involvement of the Union-level
social partners in economic governance and the European semester”. And a commitment from
the Council to “closely involve the social partners in the design and implementation of relevant
reforms and policies, in line with national practices”, and “ensure the timely and meaningful
involvement of the national social partners, while fully respecting national practices, including
through the European semester, in order to contribute to the successful implementation of
Country Specific Recommendations (CSRs)”.
The European social partners acknowledge the progress made at EU and national levels in a
number of Member States. The European cross-industry social partners have themselves
scaled up their European semester related activities in the context of their 2019-2021 social
dialogue work programme activities to improve the performance of labour markets and social
systems.
However, the 2020 social partner consultation meeting on the Annual Sustainable Growth
Strategy unfortunately did not allow for a timely consultation of the European social partners
following a change of publication date by the Commission from November to September 2020.
Furthermore, the situation remains problematic in a number of countries despite the regular
discussions held between the concerned Member States, the Commission and the social
partners in the context of the Council’s Employment Committee.
Finally, the recovery and resilience facility put forward by the Commission is progressively
taking shape. Member States are active to prepare their national plans. In this respect, the
3
Commission’s guidance invites Member States to “outline in the plan how the social partners
have been consulted and involved in designing the reforms included in the plan.”
Joint recommendation: The European social partners call on the Commission to act in the
countries where this is needed to ensure that all national governments appropriately involve
the national social partners in the preparation of recovery and resilience national plans. They
also call on the European Commission to adapt the timing of the social partner consultation
on the Annual Sustainable Growth Strategy from 2021 to ensure the meaningful and timely
involvement of social partners. In the countries where the social partners are not appropriately
involved in the European semester, and those who receive country-specific recommendations
on social dialogue without sufficient progress to improve the situation, the Commission and
the Council need to agree on appropriate measures with a view to unlocking the situation with
the support of the national social partners in the countries concerned.
5. Time to act to strengthen capacity-building of social partners in the countries and
sectors where this is needed
The 2016 quadri-partite statement on a new start for social dialogue included the
Commission’s commitment to endeavour to “examine whether the use of European Structural
and Investment Funds, notably the European Social Fund, and other relevant EU budget lines,
can contribute to strengthening the capacity of national social partners by promoting social
dialogue and capacity-building”. And a commitment from the Council to “promote the building
and strengthening of the capacities of the social partners through different forms of support,
including legal and technical expertise. This should be ensured at all relevant levels,
depending on the needs of countries and social partners, including to become solid and
representative organisations”.
Since 2016, the European cross-industry social partners have continually engaged with the
European Commission, the Member States, and their respective members in the context of
the cross-industry Social Dialogue Committee sub-group, with a view to making progress at
EU and national levels, notably with respect to the mobilisation of the European social fund
for an enhanced capacity-building to social partners in the countries where this is needed. In
December 2020, they have concluded an assessment of unmet needs in eight Central and
Eastern European Member States: Bulgaria, Croatia, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania,
Poland, Romania, Slovakia. They have in parallel jointly promoted action by Eurofound in this
domain, taking into account both the cross-industry and sectoral dimensions.
Nevertheless, progress has been slow and uneven in improving the situation due to a lack of
political will at national levels, and coordination difficulties in the context of the European Social
Fund management due to its shared management. Social partners needs for capacity-building
have meanwhile become even more pronounced and urgent taking into account the Covid
crisis impact on enterprises, public services and workers.
Joint recommendation: The European social partners call on the European Commission to
engage in bilateral discussions with the ESF managing authorities in priority in the nine
countries jointly identified by the EU cross-industry social partners. Such bilateral discussions
should also take place in other Member States where national social partners agree on the
need for capacity-building support, with a view to agreeing with those Member States on an
amount of the ESF resources foreseen for the period 2021-2027 to be earmarked for social
partners capacity-building support, taking into account the needs that exist both at cross-
industry and sectoral levels. These bilateral exchanges should be followed-up in each of these
countries by tripartite exchanges between the national governments and the national social
partners with a view to reaching an agreement on priority actions for social partners capacity-
4
building, including where needed the necessary resources to achieve a better implementation
of EU autonomous agreements. To make progress on this, the European social partners call
on the European Commission to take stock of the various existing EU financial vehicles which
can be mobilised by national and sectoral social partners to this effect (DG EMPL prerogatives
lines, European Social Fund). The Commission needs to improve its financial instruments to
provide better support to national and sectoral social partners’ activities aiming to improve the
implementation of EU autonomous social partner agreements.
*****
5
Saatja: Denis Evelyne <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 18.12.2020 17:21
Teema: European social partners’ joint contribution - Report by Andrea
Nahles on social dialogue
Dear Minister,
Please find attached a joint statement that has been prepared by the
European social partners in view of the preparation of a report on the
future of social dialogue by Andrea Nahles, special adviser to
Commissioner Schmit on social dialogue. You will also find enclosed a
report that has been commissioned by the European social partners on the
state of play and needs of national social partners in 8 central and
eastern European countries as concerns the implementation of autonomous
framework agreements and capacity building.
Please do not hesitate to contact me for further information.
Best wishes,
Maxime Cerutti
(on behalf of the European social partners)
Supporting better implementation of EU
social partners’ autonomous framework
agreements and strengthening capacities
of social partner organisations
Country reports, findings and recommendations
December 2020
Report by:
Antonio Alfaiate, Expert for the European Employers’ Associations (BusinessEurope,
SMEunited and CEEP)
Peter Scherrer, Expert for the European Trade Union Confederation (ETUC)
Commissioned by the cross-sectoral European social partners ETUC, BusinessEurope, CEEP, SMEunited
This document reflects the points of view of its authors.
It lays no claim to reflect the individual or collective opinions of the European social partners at
whose request it has been drawn up, the national social partners which have participated in this
project, or the European Commission, which has given this project its financial backing.
2
Contents
Contents
Introduction ......................................................................................................................................4
Country Reports ...............................................................................................................................6
Estonia..................................................................................................................................................6
Latvia ...................................................................................................................................................9
Lithuania ............................................................................................................................................12
Slovakia..............................................................................................................................................14
Hungary ..............................................................................................................................................16
Romania .............................................................................................................................................19
Poland.................................................................................................................................................23
Bulgaria ..............................................................................................................................................27
Findings and recommendations .....................................................................................................32
A) On the Autonomous Framework Agreements (AFAs) ................................................................32
B) On the NSP Organizations (EMP and TU) ..................................................................................33
C) On the National Social Dialogue (NSD) ......................................................................................33
D) Capacity Building of the SP.........................................................................................................33
3
Introduction
The project was a follow-up project of a previous one titled “Promoting Social Dialogue and
Better Implementation of EU Social Partners” Autonomous Framework Agreements in Se-
lected Countries” that was done in 2016.
It was carried out in a similar way as the previous project but of course with the aim of
analysing possible developments in the functioning of the Social Dialogue (SD) in the cho-
sen countries. The criteria for the selection of the countries were a) the general situation of
the SD in each country, b) the particular difficulties with the SD among the Social Partners
(SP) and the SP and the Government, and c) the lack of functioning industrial relations.
Nine countries were selected for this project: Bulgaria, Croatia, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia,
Lithuania, Poland, Romania and Slovakia. Seven of the nine countries were also covered in
the previous project and Latvia and Poland are covered here for the first time.
There were two main differences between the two projects. The 2016 project was focused
on the implementation of the Autonomous Framework Agreements (AFAs). While this pro-
ject shared that goal it has also a second aim: to propose solutions for strengthening the
capacities of the National Social Partners (NSPs).
The second difference was in the methodology: all the nine countries were supposed to be
visited by two experts, and, in each country, representatives of the Government and / or
public services more related with SD and the European Social Fund (ESF) would be invited
to discuss the objectives of the project, in a meeting with the employers (EMP), the Trade
Unions (TU) and the two experts.
The sudden onset of the Covid 19 pandemic in March 2020 had an important impact on the
project, not only imposing alterations to its timetable and methodology as only the three
Baltic countries – Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania – were physically visited. Following a sus-
pension of country visits between the end of March and September due to the pandemic, a
decision was taken to replace the physical visits to the remaining six countries by digital
meetings. The pandemic also led to new priorities in the agendas of the SP and of the
members of Government and public servants, making the organisation of the meetings, and,
in particular, the involvement of public representatives, more difficult.
Despite the challenges posed by the pandemic, with the precious collaboration of the NSP
in the selected countries, it was possible to cover eight of the nine countries in question
(three physically visited and five with digital meetings), the exception being Croatia where
an agreement between the Croatian NSP on a date to do the digital meetings could not be
reached in time.
The information and the knowledge acquired with the digital meetings is of course less rich
than with the physical meetings but it was the best that could be done under the circum-
stances. However the idea to run the Zoom-meetings in the same way as the usual order
on the European level (firstly separate internal meetings of the SP, followed by a bilateral
meeting of the SP and finally a joint with representatives of the Government / public services)
proved to be the most efficient way for a fruitful and productive exchange of views and pos-
sible joint activities.
4
A final word is due to thank for the collaboration we received from the promoters of the
project (BusinessEurope, CEEP, SMEunited, ETUC), from ETUC‘s technical services that
assured that everything went well during our digital meetings, the interpreters that were al-
ways flexible in terms of the timetables of the meetings, every participant in our meetings
and, last, but not the least, the members of the NSP that have helped us the most in planning
and organizing the meetings.
To all of you a big THANK YOU!
Antonio Alfaiate
Peter Scherrer
5
Country Reports
Estonia
The information collected was obtained from the written answer to a questionnaire provided
by The Estonian Employer’s Confederation, from a telephone call on the 22 January 2020
with both Mr. Arto Aas and Ms. Eve Paarendson (respectively, Managing Director, and, Di-
rector of International Relations of The Estonian Employer’s Confederation) and from the
meetings during the visit to Tallinn, on the 9 March 2020. 1
The information from the Trade Union Confederation EAKL was sent before in written and
during a meeting in the Trade Union (President Peep Peterson and staff members) premises
on 9 March 2020.
1. Questions relating to the national dimension of social dialogue (SD)
The most important and more visible matter discussed by the social partners in Estonia has
been the minimum wage. Although it seems that there is a good relationship between em-
ployers and trade unions, and that the collective bargaining framework is considered satis-
factory in Estonia, the collective sectorial bargaining coverage is one of the lowest in the EU
but among the Baltic states it has the highest coverage. There is some visible progress as
for example, in the retail industry talks started in April. The main reasons for that could be
the view of the employers that in general (we) prefer to have social dialogue and bargaining
at company level rather than sectorial level, as it gives maximum flexibility for companies,
particularly if there is a rapid change of environment” as well as the low coverage of the
social partners, in particular of the trade unions.
For the trade unions the question of the “Minimum Wage” is a central issue too. After the
Financial Crisis 2009 the flexibilisation of the labour market led to slightly lower sectoral
collective agreement coverage. The collective agreement on road maintenance was not re-
newed. EAKL is supporting the efforts the Government is undertaking to revive the Social
Dialogue (important of course is to keep the existing budget position in the National annual
budget).
2. Questions relating to EU and national dimensions of social dialogue
2.1.The European Social Dialogue Autonomous Framework Agreements (AFAs)
According to the employers only two of the five AFAs are well implemented in Estonia :
Telework” and Active Ageing and an Inter-Generational Approach”.
They are not working on, or planning to work on in the near future, the implementation of
any of the other 3 AFAs, mainly because their main weakness is very small staff” (they
have only one person dealing with social affairs) and also because they don’t consider them
as a priority (their main priority is the building of a general capacity to effectively involve in
policy making that is relevant to economic development - work force, education, business
1
The Estonian Association of Small and Medium Sized Enterprises – EVEA, member of SMEunited, didn’t
answered our emails and so was not present at the meetings. Anyhow, the other social partners presented
sustained, as they did in 2016, that EVEA is not a “social partner”.
6
climate, innovation, resources, etc).The employers also consider that there is very little that
the AFAs can do without political will.
The trade unions see a clear need to work further on all the AFAs at a pace of two per year.
This year the new “Digitalisation” AFA is most urgent for the trade unions. It also might
influence positively the “Telework” AFA. At the same time the trade unions want to see pro-
gress in a tripartite Social Dialogue in the areas of Life-Long Learning (LLL), Gender Pay
Gap and Health and Safety. In the sectoral Social Dialogue there was a discussion about
the “four working days week” but since the Corona Crisis it is not a priority anymore. In
general the Trade Unions advocate for more “Autonomy of the Social Partners
2.2.Involvement in policy discussions at European level
They try to be involved in the main policy discussions at European level, but their participa-
tion is affected by the small staff of the confederation.
The EAKL is an active member of the European SD and regularly takes part in the respective
meetings. In particular they have an interest in being involved in the European Semester
process, the new budget line for the European Social Fund. For this, the active support and
role of the Estonian Government is essential.
3. Comparing the present situation with the one on the previous report from 2016
The implementation of the AFA agreed in 2017, Active Ageing and an Inter-Generational
Approach”, is a good sign, and maybe the proof that the national implementation of the AFAs
is easier when the matters they cover are considered as a priority from all the NSPs. For the
trade unions massive improvement of the SD has been made since 2018. The “Telework”
AFA was implemented during the last four years and a very visible sign for this improvement
was the restoration of regular tripartite meeting with the Prime Minister.
The trade unions see a clear sign of willingness in the present Government to improve the
SD in Estonia. A precondition for this would be a proper reform of the “old fashioned” labour
law. In particular, encouragement and assistance is needed for collective bargaining. The
trade unions try actively to increase their membership and for this they are supported by the
Baltic Organising Academy (BOA).
4. Conclusions and Recommendations
The main problem of the Estonian Employer’s Confederation seems to remain its small di-
mension, especially in terms of skilled staff. As a direct consequence they try to give priority
to national issues and they can’t follow as much as they should the European issues. Similar
to the employers’ association the EAKL faces the problem of being under-staffed and insuf-
ficiently financed. The increase of membership and extension into more economic sectors
is therefore of major importance.
So, capacity building is crucial for both social partners, and should also help them in increas-
ing representativeness. So far they have mainly used an isolated approach in trying to ad-
dress the financing of its capacity needs.
We think that, in the present European context, it would make sense to try to design a com-
mon approach of the Social Partners on capacity building and present it to the Government
7
for financing, having also in mind the positive reception for it shown by the representative of
the Government at the meeting on 9 March 2020.
The increase of the bilateral SD among the NSPs in Estonia around matters of common
interest, like, for instance, education, innovation, digitalisation and youth employment, could
be an important step for the growth of confidence among them and a first step for further
initiatives.
We also note the continuing validity of the recommendation made in the 2016 report to sup-
port the launch, for the Estonian social partners, of specific fact finding seminar(s) providing
expertise (i.e. on negotiation practices), transferable practices, and twinning” with other
NSP of EU member states, to be financed by specific EU funding.
8
Latvia
The information collected was obtained from:
- the written answer to the questionnaire provided from Employer’s Confederation of Lat-
via (LDDK);
- LBAS written reply to the Survey on capacity building needs for social partners in tar-
geted countries;
- LBAS presentation on social dialogue in Latvia at the CB4CB – Capacity Building for
Collective Bargaining (Brussels Workshop, Friday 15 November 2019;
- the document of the LDDK “Recent Developments: Social Dialogue and Collective Bar-
gaining” (09.10.2019);
- the document of LDDK and “Free Trade Union Confederation of Latvia” (LBAS) “Latvia:
In-vestment Priorities of National Social Partners” (for ESF+ funding after 2020);
- a telephone call on the 30.01.2020 with Mrs. Inese Stepina (Deputy Director General for
International and EU Affairs and Project Management Adviser on EU and International
Affairs at LDDK);
- the joint NSP project "Support for Longer Working Life“ (2017-2022);
- LBAS and LDDK joint national reports on the implementation of the Active Ageing and
an Intergenerational Approach Agreement in Latvia 2020
- the meetings during the visit to Riga, on the 10.03.2020 and notes sent by LBAS after
the meeting2
1. Questions relating to the national dimension of social dialogue
The benefits of a functioning and comprehensive Social Dialogue for the NSP as well as
society need to be actively promoted. There are conditions and options (i.e. sectoral) for the
improvement of bilateral social dialogue, that so far has been limited because, frequently,
the NSP preferred to negotiate separately with the Government.
The ESF funded projects Development of social dialogue in the development of a better
regulatory framework for business support”, implemented by LDDK, and Development of
the bilateral social dialogue of the Latvian Free Trade Union (LBAS) in the development of
a better legal framework for the development of the business environment”, implemented by
LBAS, have been very useful. The fact that, recently, LDDK and LBAS were able to produce
a joint document on Investment Priorities of National Social Partners” (for ESF+ funding
after 2020) is a very good sign in the right direction.
2. Questions relating to EU and national dimensions of social dialogue.
2.1.The European Social Dialogue Autonomous Framework Agreements (AFAs)
LDDK together with LBAS have been regularly producing joint reports to European Social
partners on implementation of AFAs. Latvian social partners are working jointly on the im-
2
The Latvijas Biznesa Savieniba – Business Union of Latvia, member of SMEunited, didn’t answered our emails and so
was not present at the meetings. The position of the NSPs is that they are not recognized as a “social partner”, having
mind that the status of national social partners is defined in the legislation/regulation and is based also on mutual recog-
nition among the social partners and the government.
9
plementation and in majority of cases with the help of ESF funding which definitely strength-
ens Latvian social partners abilities in this respect. For LBAS the implementation of the AFAs
would be one important contribution to the establishment of better functioning cross-sector
but also sectoral SD in Latvia. The joint NSP project “Support for Longer Working Life” is
focussed on employees 50+ and the European AFA “Active ageing and intergenerational
approach” is naturally an ideal pretext for the work in this labour market policy area.
2.2.Involvement in policy discussions at European level
LDDK has been participating in policy discussions at European level, but not as much as
they would like because of the lack of human and financial resources.
LBAS is in close cooperation with the European umbrella organisation (ETUC). Whenever
possible, targeted meetings dealing with specific policy issues, take place in Latvia. A well
established cooperation exists within the Baltic Trade Union Network. Partly the sector trade
unions have working relations with its respective European umbrella organisations.
3. Comparing the present situation with the one on the previous report from 2016
Since Latvia was not one of the countries covered by the 2016 report, we can’t compare in
this case.
4. Conclusions and Recommendations
LDDK is well aware of the importance and benefits of social dialogue but they need capacity
building, mainly as:
a) financial resources for hiring relevant expertise on permanent or long term basis (hu-
man/financial resources);
b) information and awareness related raising support (technical/financial) to organise
events, debates, information dissemination activities;
c) training on how the employers organizations work should be organized around the iden-
tified priorities;
d) international experience on the best practice of the work of employers’ organizations in
Europe.
For LBAS and its members the same priorities and challenges apply to a large extent. An
increased willingness and readiness of the employers organisations to change and improve
the SD through more bilateral agreements and the serious implementation of the AFAs
would help to improve the situation in general. A modified legal framework for the promotion
of the sectoral SD and the political support for the improvement of the collective bargaining
is what LBAS is asking for.
The social partners (LDDK un LBAS) have produced in early 2019 a joint document Invest-
ment Priorities of National Social Partners” (for ESF+ funding after 2020) and officially have
submitted it to the national authorities in September 2019. Unfortunately, so far, there has
not been any further concrete steps from the national government to plan actions in this
regard together with social partners.
10
The representatives of the Government3 at the meeting on 10 March 2020 conveyed the
impression that the Latvian Government is willing to support capacity building of the NSPs,
but they were very clear in saying that targets should be established in order that the effi-
ciency of the measures can be monitored. A budget of four million Euro has been planned
by the Government to be spent both on non-governmental organisations and on the SD in
Latvia over the coming seven years (there was a proposal from the national social partners
to distinguish activity/budgetary headings for non-governmental organisations and for social
partner organizations, and to allocate 2 million 000 EUR over the 7 year period for social
partner organisations only4).This budget was at the time of discussion not ratified by the
Latvian Parliament. Therefore, currently, it’s not sure that the national social partner invest-
ment priorities and capacity needs are expected to be met in an appropriate manner and in
accordance with recommendations issued to Latvia within the EU semester process of 2019
and 2020. NSPs should have a positive discrimination relatively to NGOs, which, however,
according to the information of the NSP is not followed in practice, for instance within dis-
cussions on the recovery and resilience plan
3
It is worth mentioning that representatives of three Ministries (Finance, Welfare and Education) and two
representatives of the state chancellery attended actively the meeting.
4
During the meeting we got the feeling that there was an agreement among the Government, trade union and
employers representatives that, because of its different nature, NSPs should have a positive discrimination
relatively to NGOs.
11
Lithuania
The information collected was obtained from the written answer to the questionnaire pro-
vided from The Lithuanian Confederation of Industrialists - LPK, from telephone calls on the
24.01.2020 with Mr. Ricardas Startatavicius, Executive Director of LPK and on the
30.01.2020 with Mr. Gintaras Morkis, Deputy Executive Director of LPK, and, from the meet-
ings during the visit to Vilnius, on the 12.03.2020 (please find attached the list of participants
in those meetings).
The three trade union umbrella organisations LDF, LPSK and LPSS sent their respective
answers to the questionnaire well in time as detailed information before the visit (12.03.20)
took place. Several individual information exchanges took place before the planned meeting
in Vilnius.
Because of the implications of the sudden raising of the Covid19 Virus, the representatives
of the Lithuanian Government announced at the very last minute that they could not attend
the meeting as previously planned.
1. Questions relating to the national dimension of social dialogue
The social dialogue is mainly tripartite. The Tripartite Council examines and consults on a
number of economic and social issues (e.g. the newly adopted Labour Code, which articles
are of major complaints from employers and trade unions, etc.), the most visible one being
the minimum wage, which is discussed once or twice a year.
So far no agreement in between the NSPs – members of the Tripartite Council on the na-
tional level – has been achieved. The main reason seems to be due to the fact that, histori-
cally, the NSPs are used to accept governmental regulations rather than negotiate bilateral
agreements. So, their activity has been mainly to lobby ministries rather than bilateral dis-
cussions between the NSPs.
The main problems seem to be the fragmentation of both employer’s and trade unions or-
ganizations (in the Tripartite Council there are 6 employers’ organisations and 3 trade union
organisations), associated to this is understaffing (LPK doesn’t not have a single person
fully dedicated to social affairs), as well as a fragile trust between the NSPs, which leads to
a low level of bipartite social dialogue. In particular in the private sector of the Lithuanian
economy the SD is underdeveloped.
It seems that there is also too much Governmental regulation which doesn’t help, because
it doesn’t leave much space for the bilateral SD.
2. Questions relating to EU and national dimensions of social dialogue.
2.1.The European Social Dialogue Autonomous Framework Agreements (AFAs)
So far the employers organisations, LPK and ALCCIC (Association of Lithuanian Chambers
of Commerce, Industry and Crafts) didn’t participate in the preparation and discussion of the
AFAs at European level, because of its limited human resources, and so they have a very
limited knowledge of them and they, as well as their members, doesn’t consider them as a
priority. From the 5 AFAs signed until now, only the 2002 AFA on Telework” was transposed
in Lithuania and that was achieved by means of national legislation rather than by agree-
ments between the NSPs. Presently there are no signs of interest on the implementation of
any of the other 4 AFAs in the near future, although the employers had expressed their
12
interest in learning more about the implementation of the AFA’s in other EU countries (how
they were adopted and how it works on the enterprise level) in order to use their experience
in implementing those agreements in Lithuania. All three trade union centers want to use
the European AFAs as a base for implementation of such a policy on national and sectoral
level. The employers don‘t exclude the possibility of a joint discussion of the AFA‘s with the
trade unions, but no initiative was shown yet.
2.2.Involvement in policy discussions at European level
The employers try to be involved as much as they can in the main policy discussions at
European level, but their participation on social issues is limited because lack of in-house
expertise and of financial resources.
For the trade unions organisation the participation in European structures is essential but
for the same reasons as for the employers often difficult, though they do take part frequently
at the European level and organise information exchange in Vilnius.
3. Comparing the present situation with the one on the previous report from 2016
The situation seems to be quite similar to the one four years ago.
4. Conclusions and Recommendations
Since fragmentation of the NSPs organisations seems to be one of the major problems for
a functioning SD, it would make a lot of sense to try to promote some mergers, although we
don’t ignore the difficulty of such a process. Some efforts have been made already among
the trade union centers. The employers are aware of the problem and are making efforts to
overcome the fragmentation of their organisations.
Since capacity building is a priority for all the NSPs, it seemed that they realized that their
chances for obtaining financing for it will be bigger if they could present to the Government
a joint approach (the trade unions raise the issue of the minimus rule”, because it can be a
big problem in the financing of capacity building projects). There was also an agreement
that, because of its different nature, NSPs should have a positive discrimination relatively to
NGOs. If the NSPs can agree in a joint approach, as referred above, this could be also an
important step to allow further initiatives of bilateral social dialogue.
The trade unions hold the view that in particular in the private sector of the economy legis-
lative preconditions have to be established. For them the quite frequently setting-up of so
called Yellow Unions is a hinderance for the development of a functioning SD. A reformed
labour code is of urgent need in the view of the trade union organisations.
We also think that it would be useful to organise specific fact finding seminar(s) providing
expertise, transferable practices, and twinning” with other members, to be financed by spe-
cific EU fun-ding. As the meeting 12.03.2020 in Vilnius was a day before the “Covid19
measures” took place and the Government representatives couldn’t attend the foreseen tri-
lateral part we did have an extended and fruitful exchange between the NSP organisations.
The positive momentum was a useful base for further development and therefore we hope
that envisaged projects will not be the “political victims” of the Corona Crisis.
13
Slovakia
ZOOM - Meeting with Social Partners in Slovakia, 12. October 2020
Participants:
Trade Unions
Miroslav Hajnoš, Int. Secretary of KOZ
Marta Hašková, Social-Economic expert in KOZ
Employers
Martin Hostak, Secretary of National Union of Employers, RUZ
Katarina , Admin. secretary in RUZ
Project Experts
Antonio Alfaiate, Expert for European Employers Associations
Peter Scherrer, Expert for Trade Unions
A possible third meeting at the same day with the participation of a Government representa-
tive was not foreseen since the trade unions and the New Labour Ministry currently have a
difficult relation. After the General Election on February 29, 2020 a Government has been
created and since the 21st of March the New Labour Minister Milan Krajniak, who is member
of the populist party “Sme-rodina“ (we are one family), is in office. Several positions and
people in the new Ministry have been changed and so far a “structured working relation”
between the trade unions and the Labour Ministry does not exist.
The meeting started at 10.00 o’clock and the two experts introduced the motivation for the
project as the work has been done so far in the framework of the project.
The representative of the employers association RUZ asked about the nature of Autono-
mous Framework Agreements (AFA) since he was not familiar with it. In particular the ques-
tion of “commitment to implementation” was subject of the discussion. He wanted to do more
analysis of the various AFAs.
With regards to the issue of “strengthening capacities” the Slovakian employers made clear
that most important is the support of administrative work and possibly financial contribution
for organizational infrastructure. It would be welcomed if the respective European umbrella
organisations would support the financial help for the Slovakian Social Partner (SP) organi-
sations. The experts advised the SP to ask jointly for this support because it would, of course
increase the chances that support will be given.
The existing SD project in Slovakia (supported by ESF) is in the view of the RUZ representa-
tive not flexible enough to support the needs of the organisations.
The following is a statement from KOZ sent in for the discussion in the SD Committee sub-
group meeting on 26. November 2020 concerning the state of affairs:
1. Questions relating to the national dimension of social dialogue
The social dialogue on national level in Slovakia is operating as a tripartite body – the
Economic and Social Council which is consultative body of government.
14
The social dialogue on national level was interrupted in August 2020 and since then
the tripartite dialogue is not ongoing at all. The reason of dialogue suspension was
a conflict with the minister of labour that is why trade unions left the tripartite meeting.
Only two tripartite meetings took place over the 2020. Moreover, the Ministry of labour
introduced a new law diminishing trade unions power and setting up new rules of
representativeness in the tripartite body.
Cooperation between Trade unions and the new government is almost non-existent.
Trade unions are not invited to negotiate legislative changes, to discuss reform pro-
posals or to create public policies.
Bipartite dialogue between trade unions and employers' unions mostly operates at
sectoral level, through collective bargaining. In many sectors, trade unions are lacking
social partners on the employer side for sectoral collective bargaining. Every year,
employers willingness to being bound by a sectoral collective agreement decreases.
Employers clearly prefer to move negotiations to the company level, which provides
them with more flexibility.
Most trade unions have to deal with insufficient human and material resources due
to the declining membership base. This problem has been exacerbated during the
2020 pandemic. The priority for trade unions is therefore to increase the membership
base and build capacity. In last 10 years trade unions as well as employer’s associa-
tions have been facing a significant fragmentation.
KOZ SR currently uses ESF funds within a project “Support to social dialogue struc-
tures”.
2. Questions relating to EU and national dimension of social dialogue
Dialogue between trade unions and employers' associations on European social di-
alogue topics, including the implementation of the AFA´s, is not taking place at all.
Employers association didn’t actively participate in preparation processes therefore
their knowledge on this topic is insufficient to set up AFA´s and their implementation
as a priority.
15
Hungary
ZOOM - Meeting with Social Partners in Hungary, 21. October 2020
Trade Unions
László Kordás, Károly György - MASZSZ
Czuglerné Ivány, Judit – MOSZ
Lajos Mayer - SZEF/FERPA
Melinda Mészáros, Hangonyi Adrienn - LIGA
Erika Koller, Géza Agg SZEF
Laci Kuti, Peter Dorogi, Szabó Gábor - ESZT
Employers
Adrienn Bálint Employers organisation - MGYOSZ Project experts
Mr. Dániel Bugár. Foreign Affair Advisor from IPOSZ
Project Experts
Antonio Alfaiate, Expert for Employers Associations
Peter Scherrer, Expert for Trade Unions
The meeting was planned in the usual format, first a separate - internal meeting of the Social
Partner (SP) organisations, followed by a bilateral meeting of the SP and at finally a tripartite
meeting which would have included the representatives of the Hungarian Government. Un-
fortunately the Hungarian SP did not succeed in their efforts to get a representative of the
Hungarian Government to join the meeting although they tried till the very last day before
the meeting. The reason for the absence was that the Government needed more time to
check our request.
The joint meeting with the Adrienn Bálint, Director for social affairs at MGYOSZ-Busi-
nesshungary and all of the trade union representatives started at 11.00 o’clock.
After a short introduction by the two experts a discussion around the implementation of the
AA on “Active Ageing , “Telework” and “Digitalisation” was initiated by the trade unions.
Regarding the modification of telework rules, MGYOSZ said that some limited negotiations
took place in the tripartite council, but consultations stopped in the last 3 months. The pro-
posal stuck in the machinery of the Government, and everybody is suffering from the lack of
information on this issue, while the new regulation is very much expected by employees and
companies. In the view of the SP, this is just an example that SD is not timely and not
meaningful today in Hungary.
The situation in the view of the employers’ representative was described as extremely diffi-
cult. The tripartite Council was changed in a way that agreements between the SPs are now
only recommendations and consequently must get the support of the Government. There
is the lack of legal background – no collective bargaining rules on a national level, in partic-
ular not for the extension of SPs agreement for the whole country. This type of law existed
before 2010.
The COVID crisis caused modification of the Labour Code. The Government changed the
labour law without consulting the SPs. In the view of the Government (and stated in its report
of the EMCO review last year) the SP are too weak to handle the situation. Therefore, what
16
is needed is solid support from EU Resources so the SPs can hire experts to have appro-
priate negotiations about the implementation of the various Autonomous Frame Agreements
(AFAs). For many issues covered by the AFAs a legal background (i.e. health and safety
rules for telework) is needed, but currently does not exist. And the progress from the Gov-
ernment side is extremely slow.
The representative of MGYOSZ noted that, as soon as the negotiations on the minimum
wage are over, they intend to contact the TUs to see if is possible to reach an agreement
for the implementation of the AFA on “Active Ageing”.
An additional challenge created by the COVID-19 pandemic is the loss of more than 10.000
jobs among the 50-55 years old workers alone. To get transitional employment for these
workers is very difficult because a legal structure for restructuring of companies is missing
in the view of the trade unions.
Another important point is the lack of sectoral collective bargaining agreements. Support for
the strengthening of sectoral collective bargaining structure was asked for by the European
umbrella organisations.
In the view of the employers the fact that there is a considerable number of TUs sometimes
makes, it more difficult to reach agreements between the SPs.
The development of a functioning and effective SD in Hungary also needs a cultural change.
The behaviour of many employers has (in the view of the trade unions) to be changed and
naturally the Government has to set good examples. But as one can see in the case of the
demand for telework in the Foreign Ministry. Still people are getting fired without warning.
The last ten years have been a period of neglect and ignorance of the Government towards
the SP.
With regards to a law regulating “Telework / office at home” the Government has made
promises but does not deliver. The Government is simply not delivering and it is “like running
in circles . There is no sign that the National Government is going to support the improve-
ment of the SD on any level. Money which was dedicated to support the SP work on e.g.
education, is now dedicated to an unknown “research institute”.
As a general line one can say both the employers association MYGOZ and the four trade
union confederations hold the opinion that the Government protracts solutions of the very
difficult legal framework concerning the use of digital technologies which consequently leads
to change of working and living conditions. There is no sign of willingness from the Govern-
ment to initiate a serious dialogue with the SP. The Government also does not involve the
SPs in the context of the European Semester.
Taking into account what was said above, a solid support from EU resources is needed in
order that the SPs can hire experts to have appropriate negotiations about the implementa-
tion of the various AFAs. For many issues covered by the AFAs a legal background (i.e.
health and safety rules for telework) is needed but currently not existing, and the progress
from the Government side is extremely slow.
Experts are needed to make the SPs stronger, because their capacity is limited to deal with
every issue which arises in their daily work. Thus, they can’t deal with European issues as
much as they would like to do. It can’t be said that financial support will make the SD stronger
in Hungary, but it would make the organisations stronger, and that is essential when it comes
to recruit/retain members. But the recent state of social dialogue depends more on the lack
17
of Government’s commitment. This influences the implementation of the EU SP AFAs as
well. It is important to highlight, that the SPs were much more successful in this type of
implementation before 2010, since they had a good tripartite structure, which enabled them
to deal with European affairs in a timely manner, including the EU SPs activities.
18
Romania
ZOOM - Meeting with Social Partners in Romania, 4. November 2020
Trade Unions
Marin Adrian
Mirela Caravan
Corneliu Constantioaia
Mihaela Maria Darle
Petru Sorin Dandea
Bogdan Hossu
Minel Ivascu
Crist. Mihai
Eva (guest)
Employers
Eduard Floria (Concordia)
Adelina Dabu (Concordia)
Alin Stoica (Concordia)
Radu Burnete (Concordia)
Government Representative
Mrs. Claudia Butuza, Director of Social Dialogue dept.
Project Experts
Antonio Alfaiate, Expert for Employers Associations
Peter Scherrer, Expert for Trade Unions
Interpreter, technical support
Vlad Ferariu
Eva Laszlo-Herbert
Niklas Franke ETUC
The meeting was planned in the usual format, first a separate internal meeting of the Social
Partner (SP) organisations, followed by a bilateral meeting of the SP and finally a tripartite
meeting with representatives of the Romanian Government and / or of the public services
related with Social Dialogue.
Employers and Trade Unions Joint Meeting
The joint meeting with all of the national social partners and project experts started at 11.00
o’clock.
After a short introduction by the two experts a discussion around the implementation of the
AFAs was initiated by the trade unions.
The Trade Unions informed that in order to implement the AFAs they have proposed to
Concordia to organise a meeting with all the Employers Organisations and all the Trade
Union Organisations to discuss the issue. Although Concordia had agreed with that meeting
they have not done it yet because of lack of human resources.
19
Concordia and other employers organisations in the region have an ongoing project about
the AFA on Active Ageing. Considering the Covid situation, the SPs feel that they should
give priority to the AFA on Digitalisation, but to start with it they need a consolidated trans-
lation in their own language. Concordia has agreed with that priority and promised to sup-
ply such a translation or to look into the use of the translation fund that is managed by the
European social partners. Concordia and some TUs in the region applied for financing of a
project for the implementation of this AFA, but they don’t know yet if they will get the financ-
ing.
The Trade Unions mentioned that, in Romania, so far, there is only one sectoral collective
agreement (in the banking and assurance sector) and another partial sectoral collective
agreement (because it only covers the public part of it) in the health sector. They hope that
if the project of the new law on social dialogue, now under discussion, is approved, the
chances of reaching more collective agreements will improve.
Concordia is not too happy with the proposal in question, because negotiation becomes
compulsory at multiple levels, but expressed their will to improve the Social Dialogue with
the Trade Unions in various areas and to try to find common ground for agreements. Both
SP were very clear that NGOs should not be involved in the SD. At this point, the question
of representativeness and the way to define it in a possible new SD regulation/organisation,
was subject of discussion and will play a key role in the further development of the SD
structure.
In a note sent after this meeting, CNIPMMR, the employer organisation representing small
and medium enterprises, stated that regarding the draft law on social dialogue and sectoral
collective agreements, it should respect the principle according to which the contract pro-
duces effects only towards the signatory parties and not erga omnes. At the same time, in
the legislative process and in consultations with the social partners, they also defend that
the protection of the specific interests of SMEs must be taken into account.
The Trade Unions mentioned also that there is the need for a methodology to reach agree-
ment to establish the minimum wage, and that it’s essential that the Government will respect
the agreements signed by the Social Partners. For the Trade Unions the efforts of the EU
Commission to establish a framework on minimum wages is of major interest because the
Romanian Government would have to act on this with national legislation.
Concordia is interested in increasing the Social Dialogue with the Trade Unions, but for that
they know that some problems must be overcome, namely, the current lack of trust between
the SPs in Romania and to the need to increase their capacity in terms of acquiring expertise
in all the areas where an employer organisation must intervene. In that context they would
like to know, for instance, the best practices in terms of the services provided to their mem-
bers (and how they are provided) of the employers organisations in the European Union.
Concordia also thinks that in order to build trust among the SPs in Romania, the European
umbrella organisations (BusinessEurope, CEEP, SMEunited and ETUC) could play an im-
portant role as neutral facilitators” on the negotiations among them on the implementation
of the AFAs at national level.
In terms of Capacity Building, projects such as this one would be a good opportunity for
improvement, but more needs to be done, especially in the context of the growing complexity
in labour relations due to new technologies and new forms of work. Concordia considers
20
that their priority is to increase its skills in order that they can have internal experts as well
as be able to hire external experts whenever would be appropriate to address these topics.
Currently, the employers in Romania are in a vicious spiral – the landscape is very frag-
mented, with 6-7 representative employers, and the limited resources are fragmented as
well. That makes it difficult to provide timely and quality input for the various social partners
consultations that are organised most of the time on very short notice. In the absence of a
quality response, the authorities tend to limit consultations even further and this is how the
social dialogue is weakened. Also, the employers mentioned they have insufficient re-
sources to a maintain permanent contact with the unions and to engage in EU & international
affairs (including from their position as member of BusinessEurope, IOE and BIAC).
Given the limited experience and tradition of the SD in Romania, a better understanding of
other countries models, both in terms of institutional set-up and work flows, and relations
with the trade unions and collective bargaining is needed.
Both employers and trade unions understand that their chance of being financed for capacity
building are greater if they apply with joint projects, and so they have expressed interest in
doing so.
Meeting with the Representative of the Government / Public Administration
The meeting stated at 15.00 o’clock
Representative Romanian Labour Ministry
Mrs. Claudia Butuza, Director of Social Dialogue dept.
After of short briefing on the discussions had so far, Mrs. Butuza gave the view of the Gov-
ernment in several areas, namely:
a) The need of a better coordination between the Social Dialogue at National and at Euro-
pean level (for example, the sectors defined by the Romanian Government are different
of those defined at European level);
b) The law approved by the government in 2018 on Telework, supported by Concordia;
c) The European directive on Working Time was transposed to law in Romania;
and last, but not the least,
d) The Government remains open to finance projects for Capacity Building of the SPs,
namely projects for training needs, increasing skills, research.
Concordia stated that they were happy with the intention of the Government to reshape the
Sectoral Committees, but they consider that in order to do it the Government needs to
change the legal framework. Concordia defended that instead of dealing in an isolated way
with the Government, the SPs should try, whenever possible, to approach it together after
reaching common positions.
The Trade Unions stressed that a new framework to develop SD is needed and that the SPs
must be respected by the Government (a case of the actual disrespect is the establishment
21
by the Government of the minimum wage without giving the possibility for the SPs to previ-
ously reach an agreement). The Trade Unions also stressed the need for an involvement of
the SP in the process of the development of Country Specific Recommendations.
The Trade Unions and Concordia also asked the Government to change the way they invite
them for the meetings in the Economic and Social Council, i.e. to avoid very short notice not
giving them enough time to prepare themselves for the agenda, and to start sending the
documents digitalized rather than scanned. They said that, in the present circumstances,
the meeting with the Government are more meetings for information instead of true meetings
for consultation.
Mrs. Butuza mentioned that in August a tripartite working group was created, including the
SPs, to establish the minimum wage, which had its last meeting the day before this meeting.
22
Poland
ZOOM - Meeting with Social Partners in Poland, 9 November 2020
Trade Unions
Barbara Surdykowska (NSZZ Solidarnosc)
Slawomir Adamczyk (NSZZ Solidarnosc)
Wojtek Ilnicki (NSZZ Solidarnosc)
Goma Renata (OPZZ)
Pawel Smigielski (OPZZ)
Employers
Marzena Chmielewska (Lewiatan)
Andrzej Rudka (Lewiatan)
Robert Lisicki (Lewiatan)
Katarzyna Siemienkiewicz (Pracodawcy RP)
Norbert Pruszanowski (ZRP)
Bogumila Frackowiak (ZRP)
Kamila Sotomska (ZPP)
Project Experts
Antonio Alfaiate, Expert for Employers Associations
Peter Scherrer, Expert for Trade Unions
Interpreter/Technical Support
Sergiusz Buschke
Katarzyna Krajewska
Lionel Fallon (ETUC)
The meeting was planned in the usual format, first a separate - internal meeting of the Social
Partner (SP) organisations, followed by a bilateral meeting of the SP and finally a tripartite
meeting with representatives of the Polish Government and / or of the public services more
related with Social Dialogue.
Employers and Trade Unions Joint Meeting
The joint meeting with all of the trade union and employers representatives and both experts
started at 11.00 o’clock.
After a short introduction by the two experts a discussion around the implementation of the
AFAs was initiated by the trade unions.
The Trade Unions considered that there are positive and negative aspects in the implemen-
tation of the AFAs: the positive aspect being the existence of a special European Social
Dialogue dedicated group within the Rada Dialogu Społecznego (Social Dialogue Council)
(and the social partners agreed on a translation of the AFA on Digitalisation”), the negative
aspects being that the representative of employers in the work of the group on H&S (”psy-
cho-social risks ) did not take part in the work. On a note sent by Lewiatan following the
23
meeting they informed that they also considered as positive the creation of the above group
and that they have been participating actively in its works.
The TUs also referred that in the case of Harassment and Violence at Work”, employers
didn’t accept a binding agreement but only a non-binding declaration. There was a general
criticism that employers don t want to conclude binding agreements. For Lewiatan this does
not necessarily mean that they do not want commit themselves to binding agreements be-
cause of their sheer rejection of them. In their opinion the present circumstances (economic
crisis, deepened by Covid-19 situation plus general instability of business regulations in Po-
land what has been a permanent feature over the last few years) do not allow entrepreneurs
to make such binding commitments. This could be simply very risky for continuity of their
businesses.
In the note sent after the meeting, Lewiatan informed that they had an active role in the
implementation of some of the AFAs, for example the telework agreement, and that on active
ageing they were a primary driving force – preparing the solutions/proposals and leading in
distribution of the necessary information. In Lewiatan’s opinion is a lack of proper capacity
that prevents employers’ organizations from entering such agreements and often even going
into negotiations on them or implementation of European level agreements (AFAs).
NSZZ Solidarnosc considers that the Social Dialogue in Poland is also negatively affected
by the high fragmentation of employers’ organizations (some of them not very familiar with
European affairs) making agreements more difficult to reach.
Concerning capacity building of the SPs, the letter that the Polish Minister of Development
Funds and Regional Policy has sent, last February, to the European Commissioner for Jobs
and Social rights, was positively mentioned, but the vague answer from the Commissioner
was considered a disappointment. In their view more pressure” should be made near the
European Commission so that in the following financial perspective of the EU, 2021-2027,
it will be possible to continue the support for building the potential of the social partners and
for strengthening social dialogue.
The SP noted that short term financial support to individual projects cannot contribute to a
consistent increase of capacity building, and so, they fully agree that in the new ESF pro-
gramming period 2021- 2027:
- capacity building of the SP should be considered a priority, and, as a consequence, a
clear legal framework to support their long term financing shall be established
- another important point was made with regards to the support of the SP at all levels. The
regional level is of particular importance for the crafts associations.
The TU considered, also, that in order to have a real impact on capacity building of the SP,
the financing should not only be long term financing but, also, direct financing from the ESF
to the SP. The trade unions raised the question whether it would be possible to change the
rules for the ESF funds at this very particular political moment/Situation.
Lewiatan also supported the view that direct financing should be radically increased or even
become a dominant form of channeling EU money to social partners, in order to prevent
politicization of funds distribution. They also think that financing could be project oriented
and that its implementation usually is more effective when there is the participation of a few
social partners, be it from the same side of the social dialogue (2 or more trade unions or
24
employers’ organizations) as well as partners from the ‘opposite’ sides of the dialogue. This
would also contribute to lowering the level of politicization of money distribution and contrib-
ute well to mutual assistance in capacity building.
In Lewiatan’s view, though problem of politicization does not fully omit regional/ local level
of social partners’ activities, it is definitely lesser there and chances for successful coopera-
tion of social partners for achieving common goals at that level are much higher. Therefore,
such opportunities should be included in funding earmarked for social partners in the new
financial perspective.
Meeting with the Representative of the Government / Public Administration And SP
Representatives of MFiPR
Ryszard Jagiello
Malgorzata Dabrowska
Joanna Fedorczyk
Maria Niewiadomska
This meeting started at 13.30 local time.
After a short briefing, by the experts and some representatives of the EMP and of the TU,
about the discussions had so far, Mr. Jagiello referred that in the current programming period
(2014-2020) the main instrument for strengthening the SD was the actions financed from
the ESF under Thematic Objective 11 – “Enhancing Institutional Capacity of Public Author-
ities and Stakeholders and Efficient Public Administration”.
Having in mind the missing equivalent of TO 11 in the specific objectives of the European
Social Fund Plus, the Polish Minister sent the aforementioned letter last February stressing
that it’s now of key importance to be able to continue the support for building the potential
of the SP and for strengthening SD in the following financial perspectives of the EU. Alt-
hough the answer was vague (the Commission said that the SP could continue to be fi-
nanced through projects and for the implementation of the different social policies), he thinks
there is still room to manoeuvre” to change that. That’s why a working group was created
in his Ministry, where the SP are represented, with the objective of making concrete pro-
posals for the future negotiations with the European Commission.
A representative of ZRP asked if the Covid situation could affect negatively the amount of
financial resources to be allocated to the SP. Mr. Jagiello doesn’t think so and even admitted
the opposite, that under the Recovery Plan it could be possible to increase the financial
resources of the ESF for the SP, although he was not sure that this would be the best way
to do it.
The TU asked if there will be the possibility of financial support for the bilateral SD, namely
for collective bargaining, having in mind that, in the past, the financial support was mainly
channelled for the tripartite dialogue. Another point the TUs wanted to stress is, that in the
future a “long term approach” for capacity building should be undertaken. In particular H&S
issues, like work related psycho - social threats need a long term strategy because of the
need for well trained experts and qualified advisors. Mr. Jagiello mentioned that the financial
support to the SP has been for their involvement in the preparation of legislation, giving the
SP the freedom to choose the nature of their projects to apply for that support. He encour-
25
aged the SP to present their ideas and proposals on how the bilateral SD should be sup-
ported, stressing that one pre-condition for them to be approved would be that they should
be joint (EMP+TU) proposals.
26
Bulgaria
Meeting with Social Partners in Bulgaria, 12. November 2020
Trade Unions and Employers
See full list at the end
Government representatives
Mr. N. Salchev, Social Dialogue dept. Labour Ministry
Mrs. Natalia Efremova, Head of ESF dept. in the MLSP
Project Experts
Antonio Alfaiate, Expert for Employers Associations
Peter Scherrer, Expert for Trade Unions
Interpreter, technical support
Petya
Histryan
Lionel Fallon, ETUC
The meeting was planned in the usual format, first a separate - internal meeting of the Social
Partner (SP) organisations, followed by a bilateral meeting of the SP and finally a tripartite
meeting with representatives of the Bulgarian Government and / or of the public services
related with Social Dialogue.
Employers and Trade Unions Joint Meeting
The joint meeting started at 12.00 o’clock local time
After a short introduction by the two experts a discussion around the implementation of the
AFAs was initiated by the trade unions.
The trade unions suggested that with regards to the implementation of AFAs the SP should
concentrate on three agreements: Active ageing, digitalsation and stress/harassment at
workplace. They asked for a pragmatic approach such a draft proposal which was developed
approx. six years ago as a basis for an agreement on work related stress and harassment
at the workplace and also using ILO conventions for this. For the trade unions the very
urgent need in the current Covid-19 crisis for using the agreement on digitalisation is more
than obvious. To make the best use of the agreement external expertise and advice in the
use of digital tools is needed.
For the employers there are several ways to implement the AFAs, the right one for each
depending on the content and nature of it. For example “telework” was implemented by a
national agreement between social partners and then on their initiative the Government
turned it into law. For other AFAs, implementation through projects is being seen as a better
tool to implement to agreements and to reach the workers and companies. The employers
mentioned as a good example the common project of BIA and CITUB (BICA is associated
partner), financed by the ESF, for implementation of the AFA on “Active Aging and Inter-
Generational Approac”, that started on October 2019 and has a duration of 26 months. They
consider this project very important for Bulgaria, having in mind the average age of the
27
workforce in the country. The project was built entirely on the basis of the Framework agree-
ment on active aging. It was envisaged to end with concluding a national bipartite agreement
between Social partners, in order to achieve sustainability of the results. However, when
assessing the project proposal the evaluation commission cut of the expenses for this activ-
ity, as BIA had already taken a commitment to implement the agreement, being a member
of BusinessEurope.
BIA remembered that NSPs need external financing for a correct implementation of the
AFAs, because that implies not only the existence of experts in the matters covered by them
in the NSPs but also their capacity to reach all their members in order to promote the con-
tents of the AFAs.
BIA and CITUB had also submitted, for financial support, a 2 year project for the implemen-
tation of the AFA on “Digitalisation”. Should the project be approved, social partners will
start an information campaign among their members. However, if the project proposal is
rejected, another approach will be considered. Employers have prepared an unofficial trans-
lation of the agreement.
The trade union representatives criticized the Government for getting support from Euro-
pean funds while being unwilling to support the work of the SP with this money. They see a
right to get funding because they provide solutions. In particular in the field of digital educa-
tion and qualification the SP can (and do already) develop curricula and teaching methods.
For the employers the sustainability of any funding but in particular by ESF is essential. The
good cooperation between the SP in the framework of the ESF on the implementation-pro-
ject was addressed too. Social partners are facing legal issues with the Commission, con-
cerning state aid and also de minimis rules. It is very difficult to prove the activities they
implement are not of economic nature and also that when talking about capacity building, a
clear distinction should be made between social partners and other NGO’s. However, when
planning the new operational program, the managing authority accepted some of the pro-
posals of the Social partners for including funds both for capacity building and joint actions
(incl. for implementation of AFA). In terms of the financing of the SP capacity building the
employers defend that:
- an appropriate amount of ESF resources should be allocated for that purpose, under a
separate budget line, that should be available for application by the SP throughout the
whole programming period of the ESF (2021-2027), according to their needs;
- another budget line should be created for the financing of smaller joint initiatives by the
SP;
- the members of the EMP organizations, including the regional associations, should also
have the possibility to apply for financing of capacity building ;
- the State Aid Rules, namely de mimimis rules, should not be applied to the financing of
the SP, having in consideration that they must perform non-profitable specific activities
established by law.
Meeting with the Representative of the Government / Public Administration
The meeting started at 15.00 o’clock local time
After a short introduction by the two experts the trade unions opened the discussion with
their view that they expect form the Governmental institutions to actively support the imple-
28
mentation of the AFAs. Most urgent in the view of the SP are the AFAs dealing with digital-
isation/active ageing and work related stress and harassment at the workplace. What is
needed is that the implementation is accompanied by a legislative process and a reliable
and sustainable funding of establishing good practices of the agreements. For achieving of
good practices the use of external advisers is essential. In addition, all efforts by Govern-
ment are expected to be made to increase the representativeness and the building of ca-
pacities of the SP organisation. .
The employers reminded the Government representative on the good example of telework
in 2008. But nowadays solid funding for joint SP projects for the new challenges in the field
of e.g. the newly concluded AFAs is expected from the Government. They consider that the
launch of joint projects by the SP, like the one now running on “Active Aging and an Inter-
Generational Approach is a good tool for the implementation of the AFAs.
Mrs. Efremova made clear that they are planning now for a long period of support, for the
coming programme period. Some projects might be supported partly and some to the full
extent. But it is important to clarify how the Government can help. What can that mean in
very practical terms? Mr. Salchev of the Labour Ministry made the audience aware of the
fact that the labour code is under discussion (social partners actively included in the process)
and in the legislation process. Therefore changes can be introduced which will foster the
progress in the SD.
Both, the speakers of the trade unions and employers made clear that the amount chan-
nelled in the past for Social Policies, not only for the SP but also for NGOs, is completely
insufficient. A strong point was that SP must be treated differently from NGOs! They also
defended that the State Aid Rules should not be applied to the financing of the SPs.
For the trade unions it is important to be able to work on the SD at any level, which means
company, local and regional, sectoral and National level. Trade unions are asking for the
setting up of dedicated working groups and that these working groups will be provided with
clearly targeted funds.
Mrs. Efremova made clear that to make exemption to State aid is a very difficult task. The
rules are pretty tight and in particular the rules of the European Commission are somewhat
rigid. With regards to structural funds she confirmed that the new programmes are under
discussion with the commission and she expects a fruitful and productive discussion.
29
Participant list
Country visit
for discussion of the national implementation of the European Social dialogue autonomous instru-
ments and the capacity building of the national social partners
12 November 2020, 09:00 – 15: 30
1000 Sofia, Bulgaria (via ZOOM)
№ Organisation Names Position
EMPLOYERS
1. BusinessEurope, CEEP , SMEunited António Alfaiate Expert, appointed by Busi-
nessEurope, CEEP , SMEunited
2. Bulgarian Industrial Association – union of Mariya Mincheva Vice-president, Industrial rela-
the Bulgarian business (BIA) tions, representative in SDC
3. Bulgarian Industrial Association – union of Silviya Todorova Director on Economic and Finan-
the Bulgarian business (BIA) cial Affairs,
Permanent Delegate to Busi-
nesseurope
4. Bulgarian Industrial Association – union of Stanislav Popdonchev Vice-president , Project and eco-
the Bulgarian business (BIA) nomic activities
5. Bulgarian Industrial Association – union of Svetlana Doncheva Head of Project management de-
the Bulgarian business (BIA) partment
6. Bulgarian Industrial Association – union of Jasmina Saraivanova Expert, Industrial relations
the Bulgarian business (BIA)
7. Bulgarian Industrial Capital Association Rossitsa Steliyanova Director, Programmes and pro-
(BICA) jects
8. Made in Bulgaria Hristiyan Hristov Chief expert, coordination of
branch organisations
TRADE UNIONS
1. ETUC Peter Scherrer Expert, appointed by ETUC
2. Confederation of independent trade unions Chavdar Hristov Vice-president of CITUB
in Bulgaria (CITUB)
3. Confederation of independent trade unions Nikolay Nedev National Secretary, Collective bar-
in Bulgaria (CITUB) gaining
4. Confederation of independent trade unions Velichka Mikova National Secretary, Legal protec-
in Bulgaria (CITUB) tion
5. Confederation of independent trade unions Asiya Goneva National Secretary, Social protec-
in Bulgaria (CITUB) tion
6. Confederation of independent trade unions Yuliya Simeonova National Secretary, Projects and
in Bulgaria (CITUB) training
30
7. Confederation of labour Podkrepa Neli Hristova Confederative Secretary
8. Confederation of labour Podkrepa Veselin Mitov International Secretary
GOVERNMENT
1. Ministry of labour and social affairs Nenko Salchev by 30th Social dialogue, Minsrty of Labour
October
2. Ministry of labour and social affairs Natalia Efremova head of ESF authority
31
Findings and recommendations
Our remarks and recommendations are based on the visits in the three Baltic states and the
five ”Zoom-meetings“ we had. It is regrettable that a meeting with the Croatian SP and with
the Government representatives did not materialize. Unfortunately the Government / public
authorities representatives in the case of Slovakia and Hungary did not react or were unwill-
ing to join the discussion. In Lithuania the Government representatives had to cancel their
participation in the very last minute because it was the day (12 March 2020) before the
Covid-19 pandemic measures were introduced.
Below we list remarks with regards to the state of affairs of the work on the Autonomous
Agreements and the efforts to strengthening the Capacities of the SP und consequently the
SD in the countries.
A) On the Autonomous Framework Agreements (AFAs)
- In the majority of the nine countries the level of implementation of the AFAs is rather low.
This is due to the fact that sometimes both SP but more often the EMP consider the
AFAs implementation not as a priority, relative to other national issues;
- the lack of skilled human resources in the organisation emerges as an underlying factor
adding to the difficulties of implementation;
- in some cases even the most important pre-condition for the implementation of the AFAs,
an agreed translation of the AFAs native language does not exist;
- some of the representatives of the EMP are not always familiar with the content of the
AFAs, which is further hampered by the lack of capacity to take part in the negotiation of
the agreements;
- in comparison with the situation four years ago, it seems that, in general, the situation
has not improved significantly;
- the Covid 19 pandemic is adding to problems of implementation/
Recommendations:
The European umbrella organisations must understand the reasons for the lack of imple-
mentation of the AFAs and try to help the NSPs on that matter, namely by:
- promoting ways to finance the translation of the AFAs in the local languages;
- spreading best transferable practices;
- promoting a bigger involvement of the NSP during the process of negotiation of the AFAs
at European level;
- maintaining a periodic monitoring of the implementation of the AFAs at European and
National level;
- providing experts assistance by engage member organisations who have successful ex-
periences with the respective implementation.
32
B) On the NSP Organizations (EMP and TU)
- In some countries, political changes took place not so long ago, therefore a culture of
SD has not yet developed. In particular the EMP organisations are relatively young,
small, and lacking financial and technical capacity;
- in some countries there is a high fragmentation of EMP / TU organisations, creating
problems of representativeness and making it more difficult to reach agreements;
Recommendations:
- Promotion of a better coordination and cooperation between the NSP organisations
- capacity building with external financial support (see D).
C) On the National Social Dialogue (NSD)
- In some countries the main problem for SD is the political behaviour of the Government.
It does not recognise what role the SP should play either socially or economically, by
e.g. not even listening to their opinion and not involving them in the European Semester.
This creates enormous problems for the SPs, putting them in a “vicious circle”: creating
a lack of awareness of their role in the country, leading to great difficulties in keeping
their members and in attracting new ones, resulting in a lack of financial and human
resources. The political behaviour of these Governments is an obstacle for a pluralistic
participation in society;
- in the majority of the countries the SD is mainly tripartite, because there is no legal frame-
work to promote bilateral SD.
Recommendations:
- The European Union (Commission) must act more effectively towards the Governments
that obstruct or that have an apathetic attitude towards SD, by creating conditions for the
development of SD in those countries;
- the European Social Partners should help their members to get out of the above men-
tioned “vicious circle”, promoting their capacity building in the long term. Helping them to
increase their awareness in the society, as well as, promoting the added value of bipartite
SD through dissemination of best practices.
D) Capacity Building of the SP
- For the vast majority of the EMP and TU organisations in the countries covered there is
great need of capacity building, mainly for the reasons mentioned in the previous points;
- an appropriate amount of ESF resources should be allocated for capacity building of the
SP, under a separate budget line, that should be available for application by the SP
33
throughout the whole programming period of the ESF (2021-2027), according to their
needs;
- another budget line should be created for the financing of smaller joint initiatives by the
SP;
- the State Aid Rules, namely de mimimis rules, should not apply to the financing of the
SP, keeping in mind that they must perform non-profitable specific activities established
by law.
34