Margrethe Vestager Your ref. 13.01.2023 No
European Commission ARES(2023)svvdl-
[email protected] ca-03.cab
staff.dir(2023)39873
1
Our ref. 25.01.2023 No 12.1-2/598-1
Estonia's answer to letter from
Executive Vice-President
Margrethe Vestager
Dear Vice-President,
Thank you for reaching out to collect the views on how state aid framework should respond to
the challenges European industry faces. The overview of the recent initiatives and the planned
additional changes is very useful. From our perspective, state aid has always been and
continues to be extraordinary measure to respond specific market failures. It is important to
ensure that such interventions would not give rise to new market distortions.
Regarding EU's common initiatives we have to acknowledge, that we already have a huge
support package designed, approved and waiting for quick and meaningful implementation.
The Next Generation EU, being the response to the COVID-19 induced difficulties, already
includes all the objectives and corresponding measures relevant for the current circumstances.
These plans have to be put into action as quickly as possible. I expect that the state aid
framework will be supporting the implementation of ESI funds and Recovery and Resilience
Plans initiatives including its latest element - REPowerEU.
We would also call to continue the dialogue with the EU’s strategic partners to find
constructive solutions and avoid damaging unilateral measures. In addition, we find it
important that EU makes quick progress with the free trade agreements (signed, under
negotiation, awaiting initiation of negotiations).
Please find our comments to your questions below:
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / Estonia / +372 611 3558 /
[email protected]
www.rahandusministeerium.ee / Reg. code: 70000272
1. Process simplification comes with certain risks. Beyond the proposals listed below, is
any further process simplification required to allow for public support to reach the right
beneficiaries as quickly as possible?
Regarding the processes, we would like to stress that it is important to first identify and agree
on the most critical RD&I and investment needs for the green transition. It is important that
Member States would be left the flexibility to define their specific strategic sectors for green
transition. For priority beneficiaries in the green technology sectors the fast-track procedure
for state aid approval should apply.
Besides that we would like to see that the state aid approval procedure for notifications in
other sectors is carried out without undue delay and in transparent manner. E.g. it is important
that the notification procedure of large-scale RD&I projects as well as large investment
projects of developing innovative green solutions would be streamlined.
We also expect that the amendments to the general block exemption regulation (GBER) will
be adopted as soon as possible.
2. Given the very recent revision of the relevant State aid rules for the upcoming
Temporary Crisis and Transition Framework, is there anything missing to complement
the rulebook and fast-track the green transition?
The objective of the review of the state aid framework should be to allow it function
coherently and smoothly without unnecessary administrative burden, but the review should
not have the objective of relaxing the rules almost to no rules at all. It is important to maintain
internal market and the level playing field to support it.
We also consider it important to streamline the process of state aid approval of Important
Projects of Common European Interest (IPCEI projects).
3. In your view, how to balance the need for granting additional flexibility for
investments in sectors strategic for the green transition, for which public support in third
country jurisdictions would lead to relocation, and the negative effects of State support
for mass production, which include the possible fragmentation of the internal market,
likely harmful subsidy races with third countries and within the EU and possible
negative effects on cohesion within the European Union?
We must avoid the bidding war on who offers higher subsidies or other forms of public support
to the industry. Also the recent crisis response shows, that once you have provided public
support the expectations grow and the return to the normal market economy may prove to be
extremely difficult.
State aid should be used in a way that it does not harm the functioning of the Single Market
in the EU and level playing field. State aid is not always the best solution or possible for small
countries and does not guarantee equal opportunities. In long term, state aid can cause
fragmentation and enhance economic crisis on the Single Market.
Any relaxation of state aid rules should be temporary, targeted and tailored for the specific
market failure we are to solve.
2
As pointed out in the introduction, the state aid, either directly by Member State or through
EU common measures, should not become an objective in itself. There could be a case for
targeted common financing efforts in green and energy transformation. Regarding the
financing of such common efforts we are very critical to the attempts of diverting funds
already earmarked for these purposes, be it either the EU budget or the ETS revenues.
Yours sincerely,
(signed digitally)
Riina Solman
Minister of Public Administration
3