DIRECTOR GENERAL Mr Taavi AAS
Minister for Economic Affairs and
Infrastructure
Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Communications
Suur-Ameerika 1
EE-10122 TALLINN
Brussels, 12 July 2021
Subject: Automated driving and national traffic legislation
Dear Minister,
On the path towards automated driving in Europe, vehicle manufacturers require the
close cooperation of national regulators to create the necessary legal conditions to
realise the next step of mobility.
One of the milestones for the safe roll-out of Level 3 automated vehicles in certain
traffic environments is the Automated Lane Keeping System (ALKS) for passenger
cars. Once activated, this system will enable drivers to safely disengage from the
driving task and undertake activities other than driving.
With the purpose of establishing strict requirements for the approval of ALKS, the
UN Regulation No. 157 was adopted in June 2020 and entered into force in January
2021. To reflect the provisions laid down at UN level and allow the EU-wide approval
of Level 3 automated vehicles equipped with ALKS, the European Commission
amended the EU type approval framework.
Despite these advancements, the national traffic rules in most EU member states still
prohibit the driver to disengage from the driving. Fragmentation in national legislation
impedes the efficient and forward-looking deployment of ALKS, and thereby automated
driving and its benefits, on EU roads altogether.
ACEA
European Automobile
Manufacturers’ Association
Avenue des Nerviens 85
1040 Brussels, Belgium
+32 2 732 55 50
[email protected]
www.acea.auto 1
While the automobile manufacturers have been heavily investing in the development
and adoption of automated driving, and are now planning its market introduction, many
EU countries have not yet adapted their national traffic regime, which means that ALKS
would breach current traffic laws if activated.
We strongly encourage the competent national authorities to share with the industry
their plans or intentions concerning amending the national traffic rules in view of
implementing the changes needed to enable the roll-out and use of this technological
innovation across the European Union.
To facilitate an informed exchange, you will find in the Annex attached to this letter
three sections outlining (I) the context of the above-mentioned UN Regulation on
ALKS, (II) the status of the national traffic legislation plus the necessary adjustments
and (III) the detailed questions from the industry to the national authorities.
We thank you in advance for providing ACEA’s member companies with a response
that can support them to reliably plan the market introduction of future technologies.
We are looking forward to any discussion that might help foster the uptake of
automated driving across the European Union.
Yours sincerely,
Eric Mark Huitema
Encl.
ACEA
European Automobile
Manufacturers’ Association
Avenue des Nerviens 85
1040 Brussels, Belgium
+32 2 732 55 50
[email protected]
www.acea.auto 2
ANNEX
1. Context: UN Regulation on Automated Lane Keeping System
In June 2020, WP.29 adopted the first UN-Regulation for a Level 3 automated driving
system (UN-R 157 Automated Lane Keeping System (ALKS), entered into force in
January 2021). With this new regulation, the UNECE has paved the way to a type
approval of ALKS under the UN 1958 Agreement. The EU commission has explained
its intent to amend the European type approval regime to allow and enable the
harmonized type approval of vehicles equipped with an ALKS approved according to
UN-R 157 within the EU.
According to UN-R 157 a type approval will be granted, for the first time, to a system
explicitly designed to transfer the driving dynamic task from the driver to the system.
ALKS requirements are based on the following premises: enabling drivers, under
specific boundary conditions, to safely disengage from the driving task while the ALKS
is engaged, until the system issues a transition demand with a time buffer for the driver
to safely resume the dynamic driving task.
However, drivers of a vehicle equipped with systems like ALKS can fully experience
and benefit from such technology only when the national traffic laws fully legitimate
their intended use. In terms of the intended use of Level 3 systems, this includes that
during operation, drivers need to be allowed to remove the hands from the steering
wheel and to disengage from the driving task under defined limits (i.e. drivers must
remain in a position to take over manual driving if prompted by the system with
sufficient lead time via the transition demand).
2. National traffic legislation
As of today, such an intended use of ALKS contravene the national traffic laws in many
EU member states, as these prohibit the driver to disengage from the driving task and
to undertake activities other than driving for sustained periods of time.
As a consequence, while automated driving systems such as ALKS when engaged
enable the driver by its design to undertake activities other than driving, drivers would
legally not be allowed to use the system to its full potential. Otherwise, drivers would
in fact be considered as contravening the current traffic laws. Legal uncertainty might
arise and manufacturers may hence hesitate to introduce such systems into the
EU member states markets.
While the type approval regime has been already amended to facilitate the certification
of ALKS systems, it is now essential for the operation of the automated driving
systems, that also the driver’s duties are amended under the national traffic laws
accordingly.
www.acea.auto 1
To foster the necessary adjustments of national traffic laws further, the Vienna
convention was amended in 2020 (ECE/TRANS/WP.1/2020/1/Rev.1). The adopted
amendment enables 1968 Convention contracting parties to develop (if they wish) their
domestic legal framework to legitimate deployment and operation of automated driving
systems within their territory.
Despite the amended UN type approval regulations and the number of automobile
manufacturers currently developing ALKS systems, only a few countries, such as
Germany and Japan, have so far implemented the necessary adjustments to their
national traffic laws in order to allow the driver to disengage from the driving task when
an automated driving system like ALKS is engaged.
3. ACEA questions to National Authorities
Since the maturity of the technology has reached a phase where manufacturers plan
the market introduction of ALKS in the EU in due course, it is essential for ACEA and
its member companies to have a clear understanding of the current status of the traffic
rules in each EU member state with respect to ALKS and of the strategy that they
intend to pursue for amending the national traffic laws. We would therefore like to pose
the following questions to the competent National Authorities:
a) Are there specific requirements in your national traffic law that require the driver
to
i. perform or supervise traffic maneuvers by himself or monitor the driving
environment
ii. refrain from or limit other activities than driving
b) Do the existing current traffic laws in your country address the operation of
ALKS, especially
i. allow the driver to disengage from the driving task when driving a vehicle
with an engaged ALKS approved according to UN-R157?
ii. clarify the driver’s duties when driving a vehicle with an engaged ALKS
(e.g. to resume the dynamic driving task when ALKS issues a transition
demand)
iii. Could you indicate which paragraphs under your national traffic laws
refer to this issue?
c) If the answer to b) is negative, are there any future plans to amend the traffic
laws in your country to allow for the driver to disengage from the driving task
when driving a vehicle with an engaged ALKS?
d) If the answer to b) is negative, are there specific reasons that might hinder an
amendment to your national traffic laws?
e) If the answer to b) is yes, what is the timeline for the amendments?
www.acea.auto 2
Saatja: Marta MARAZZI <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 27.09.2021 10:04
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Joost VANTOMME <
[email protected]>; Eric Mark HUITEMA <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Automated driving and national traffic legislation
Dear Minister,
On behalf of the European Automobile Manufacturers Association (ACEA), we
would like to follow-up with you on our previous e-mail concerning
automated driving and national traffic legislation.
As extensively explained in the attached letter, vehicle manufacturers
are calling upon the national regulators to cooperate towards the
creation of the required legislative conditions for the roll-out of Level
3 automated vehicles equipped with Automated Lane Keeping Systems (ALKS).
Today these systems cannot be deployed in most EU countries, as the
national traffic rules have not been adapted yet to allow the driver to
disengage from the driving task when ALSK is activated, thereby
preventing the advancement of automated driving in the EU.
We therefore kindly remind and encourage you to send us your response to
the abovementioned letter and provide us with an indication of your plans
for amending the national traffic legislation.
We are thankful for your feedback. Please kindly address your answer to
the following contact points at ACEA:
Joost Vantomme, Smart Mobility Director ()
Marta Marazzi, Smart Mobility Advisor ()
Yours sincerely,
ACEA Smart Mobility Team
Marta MarazziSmart Mobility Advisor +32 490 58 07 62European
AutomobileManufacturers Association
From: Eric Mark HUITEMA <
[email protected]> Sent: 12 July 2021 15:51To:
[email protected]: Joost VANTOMME <
[email protected]>; Marta MARAZZI
<
[email protected]>Subject: Automated driving and national traffic
legislation
Dear Minister,
The European Automobile Manufacturers Association (ACEA) is contacting
you on behalf of its member companies on the subject of automated driving
and national traffic legislation.
To achieve the next step in mobility in Europe, vehicle makers urgently
call on the national regulators to cooperate towards the creation of the
required legislative conditions for the roll-out of Level 3 automated
vehicles equipped with Automated Lane Keeping Systems (ALKS).
While UN Regulation No. 157 has been adopted last year to allow the safe
introduction of Level 3 automated vehicles equipped with ALKS and,
consequently, the EU type-approval framework amended to enable the EU-
wide approval of those vehicles, we note with regret and concern that the
national traffic legislation in many member countries has not yet been
adapted to reflect the changes needed for the deployment of ALKS on EU
roads.
We are attaching to this e-mail a letter representing the industry's
viewpoint and encourage you to inform us of your plans for amending the
national traffic rules, so that vehicle manufacturers can prepare for the
market introduction of Level 3 automated driving systems across the
European Union in a consistent manner.
We thank you very much your response and look forward to any further
discussion that will contribute to the advancement of automated driving
in the EU.
Please kindly address your answer to the following contact points at
ACEA:
Joost Vantomme, Smart Mobility Director ()
Marta Marazzi, Smart Mobility Advisor ()
Yours sincerely,
Eric Mark Huitema
Eric-Mark HuitemaDirector General +32 497 05 88 88European
AutomobileManufacturers Association