EEA and No rway Grants 2014-2021 Programme “Local Development and Poverty Reduction” Selection Committee meeting Date and time : November 02 , 2020 from 11:00 to 12:30 (Estonian time) Venue: Cisco Meet web platform & MoSA, 10 th floor, room V estmann (Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn) Small Grant Scheme „ Training of domestic violence specialists and establishment of a programme(s) for sex buyers“ Selection Committee voting members : M s Kristiina Luht – Chairman of the Selection Committee; Head of Victim Support Policy, Equality Policies Department, Ministry of Social Affairs ; Ms Freja Ulvestad Kärki – representative of Donor Programme Partner, Norwegian Directorate of Health; Ms Grete Kaju – adviser, Equality Policies Department, Ministry of Social Affairs. Observers : Ms Gudrun Gudmundsdottir – Financial Mechanism Office, Senior Sector Officer, Health, Children and Youth, also representing the Financial Mechanism Committee Ms Laura Pikkoja – representative of the National Focal Point; State Shared Service Centre; Ms Piret Marvet – representative of the donors, Royal Norwegian Embassy in Tallinn. Ms Kelly Poopuu – representative of the PO Implementing Agency, State Shared Service Centre. Mr Ülar Vaadumäe – Ministry of Social Affairs, Smart Development Department, chief specialist, PO. Minutes of the meeting Mr Ülar Vaadumäe gave an overview of the goals, targets and criteria of the small grant scheme. Also, mr Vaadumäe introduced the submitted projects and explained the tasks of the Selection Committee. For more, please see Annex 1 (PO presentation). Altogether 3 project applications were received within the deadline (August 6, 2020 at 17:00 o’clock local time) set for the call. NGO Eluliin (Lifeline) project budget 50 642 euros; grant applied for 45 415 euros (90%) NGO VAITER (Competence Centre of Mental Health) project budget 66 000 euros; grant applied for 59 400 euros (90%) NGO Pärnu Naiste Tugikeskus (Pärnu Women Shelter) project budget 63 815 euros; grant applied for 57 433 euros (90%) Additionally, NGO Avatud Ühiskonna Instituut (Estonian Open Society Institute) submitted its proposa l after the deadline , so this application was not forwarded to evaluation. As a result t he overall grant amount asked for is less than total grant amount of 180 000 euros available. Programme Operator Implementing Agency (State Shared Service Centre) will carried out the assessment of project applications to the eligibility and administrative criteria set in the call text. All three projects met the administrative and eligibility criteria and were forwarded for evaluation by two impartial, independent and reliable experts. These experts were: Ms Kadri-Ann Lee , Adviser, Public Order and Criminal Policy Department, Ministry of the Interior ; Ms Andrea Kink , Service Manager, Victim Support and Prevention Services Department, Social Insurance Board . The difference between the scores given by the two experts was well under 30%, so no need for a third evaluation was necessary (point 20.05 of the call text) There were no project proposals receiving less than 50% of the total score, and therefore would have received automatically a negative decision (point 20.6 of the call text). Please see also Annex 2 (Ranking list of experts). Discussion NGO Pärnu Naiste Tugikeskus (Pärnu Women Shelter) Partners: 1. Rótin - félag um málefni kvenna með áfengis- og fíknivanda (Iceland); 2. NGO Women’s Support and Information Centre; 3. NGO Protecting Violence-free Life. Ms Kristiina Luht opened the discussion by admitting t hat the applicant is very active in the society combating gender-based violence in Estonia. The project has a clean and solid plan for target groups and trainings as well as how to continue in the future. Continuous training is very important as the values and attitudes are changing very slowly. Ms Freja Ulvestad-Kärki admitted that the project has shown good quality and sustainability as well as expert team. Ms Kärki highlighted that as NGO Pärnu Naiste Tugikeskus and NGO VAITER are implementing their projects in the same focus area training specialists in contact with victims of domestic violence on the reasons, consequences, assistance and better inter-sectoral cooperation, then the project promoters should meet up, exchange information on their activities to avoid duplication and perceive for better impact. Ms Ülar Vaadumäe commented that the Programme Operator has designed to carry out operational meetings with the project promoters to acquire information on the progress of projects’ activities, so this idea fits nicely to our plans. In addition to that, the two projects would not run in parallel as NGO VAITER plans to start its activities in the fall of 2021. So, the projects can fine tune their activities taking into account the other project. Ms Grete Kaju agreed with the colleagues. She complemented the concept drawn up and brought out the regional aspect regarding trainings as well as adaption of activities caused by possible obstacles of the Covid-19 virus situation. Ms Kaju pointed out that the applicant should confirm that they will deliver an analytical summary on the trainings carried out based on the feedback sheets completed by participants as required by the call criteria. The applicant should also specify in more detail to whom they plan to focus one longer in-depth training (at least 32 academic hours with 20-30 trainees) as required by the call criteria. Ms Kristiina Luht described the project partners that although she is not especially familiar with the organisation Rótin from Iceland, then in general Iceland has shown good practices in the area and hopefully has lot to contribute to the project. The Estonian partners – NGO Women’s Support and Information Centre (in Tartu region) and NGO Protecting Violence-free Life (dealing with domestic perpetrators – are well known and respected organisations in their area of operation. NGO VAITER (Competence Centre of Mental Health) Partner Marta Centre (Latvia) Ms Kristiina Luht opened by saying that the project application is positively intersectoral and includes family doctors and -nurses to be trained. The project team is very strong with listed trainers with large-scale experience in the field, incl. project coordinator Ms Õnne Liv Valberg and training coordinator Ms Keete Janter, who is a therapist dealing with violence victims and perpetrators of violence (in cooperation with the city of Tallinn). Marta Centre is a distinguished actor in Latvia working with topics regarding trafficking of women and violence against women in general, also engaged in many international projects. Ms Grete Kaju mentioned that the project application has a good general composition and reasonable goals. A lthough the target group of the project is clear then it remains a bit vague how the applicant plans to reach the target groups and map the training needs of the target group prior to the trainings. She highlighted the novel topics to be included into the trainings – violence against LGBT+ groups, the elderly and people with disabilities as well as family care violence issues. Ms Piret Marvet agreed that the project applicant should elaborate on the grasp of the target groups and advised that the target groups representative organisations (i.e. LGBT+) should be consulted when training people on issues concerning the problems of these target groups. Ms Luht answered that the project team involves also experts (e.g. Ms Kai Part, Ms Agnes Alvela) who have worked with these target groups and are to a certain extent certainly aware of the burning issues of these communities. NGO Eluliin (Lifeline) No partners Ms Kristiina Luht explained that NGO Eluliin is active in the field of helping victims of tra ff icking, offering the m psychological and legal counselling as well as representing the victims in court proceedings. Although it might not be clear from their project application, then they certainly are in tight cooperation with the police and prosecutor’s office. Topic of establishing and piloting of a social programme for sex buyers for changing their attitudes and behaviour in order to prevent and tackle demand prostitution and trafficking in human beings is very acute in Estonia. We have received many negative comments about lacking action in this field from the United Nations (not decreasing enough the demand for commercial sex), so this kind of project is very important to be piloted. Ms Freja Ulvestad-Kärki inquired about how the target group is engaged as the buyers of commercial sex would not be easily approached. Ms Luht answered that the Estonian prosecutors are quite eager to offer the enrolment to a social programme as an alternative to a criminal penalty. Ms Grete Kaju recognized that the project application needs more thorough description as also the evaluators had brought out several shortages. Ms Gudrun Gudmundsdottir proposed to rely on the evaluators’ highlighted gaps in the application and ask then project applicant to update its project description in this regard. Ms Luht mentioned also that the project team has received good training in the United States and has made acquaintance with different social programmes there. Also, there are best practices to be learnt from in the Nordic countries (Sweden). Selection Committee decisions Approve a project grant in the amount of 57 433 euros to NGO Pärnu Naiste Tugikeskus (Pärnu Women Shelter) with the following conditions: the applicant confirms that they will deliver an analytical summary on the trainings carried out based on the feedback sheets completed by participants as required by the call criteria; the applicant specifies in more detail to whom they plan to focus one longer in-depth training (at least 32 academic hours with 20-30 trainees) as required by the call criteria; NGO Pärnu Naiste Tugikeskus and NGO VAITER will meet up, exchange information on their activities to avoid duplication and perceive for better impact of their projects. Approve a project grant in the amount of 59 400 euros to NGO VAITER (Competence Centre of Mental Health) with the following conditions: the applicant specifies how it plans to reach the target groups and map the training needs of the target group prior to the trainings; NGO VAITER and NGO Pärnu Naiste Tugikeskus will meet up, exchange information on their activities to avoid duplication and perceive for better impact of their projects. Approve a project grant in the amount of 45 415 euros to NGO Eluliin (Lifeline) with the condition that the applicant will update the project description regarding the following deficiencies : the action plan is superficial, which is why the content of the activities is not sufficiently disclosed; t he application does not indicate how the needs and problems of the target group have been taken into account in the planning and implementation of the project activities. The description of sex buyers as a target group is completely missin g; i t is not clear from the project application how the applicant will involve the participants of the social programme. A survey is provided as the method of involvement, however, it is not explained in more detail. It is mentioned that co-operation is established with the Police and Border Guard Board and the Prosecutor’s Office, however, it remains unclear how the involvement of the target group will be ensured. This is a very complex target group and, according to the evaluator, the methods for involving participants in the social programme have not been sufficiently explained ; t he methods of covering project co -financing are described in a superficial manner. There was only one sentence in the application to explain the co -financing, and it was not possible to obtain additional information from the budget t able. Mr Ülar Vaadumäe and Ms Kristiina Luht thanked everybody for their input and closed the meeting. Meeting chaired by (digitally signed) minutes taken by Kristiina Luht ( digitally signed ) Ülar Vaadumäe
EEA and Norway Grants 2014-2021
Programme: Local Development
and Poverty Reduction
Selection Committee meeting
November 2, 2020
Small Grant Scheme
„Training of domestic violence
specialists and establishment of
a programme(s) for sex buyers“
Overview
Project max duration: 18 months
Call amount: € 180,000
Project grant size: € 40,000 – 60,000
Project grant rate: 85-90%
Eligible applicants: NGOs, universities or higher health care institutions
SGS is financed from the EEA Grants FM
Eligible activities of the small grant scheme are:
a) Training specialists in contact with victims of domestic violence on the
reasons, consequences, assistance and better inter-sectoral cooperation in
order to offer knowledge and raise cooperation skills of specialists;
b) Establishing and piloting of a social programme for sex buyers for changing
their attitudes and behaviour in order to prevent and tackle demand prostitution
and trafficking in human beings in Estonia.
Targets:
At least 160 specialists trained on domestic violence
At least 12 people finishing the pilot of the social programme
for sex buyers
Number Expected programme results Indicator Baseline Baseline Target
value year value
Percentage of population in
favour of criminalising the 53% 2016 60%
buying of sex
Reduced domestic and Percentage of population not
Outcome 2 gender-based violence and blaming victims of domestic 47% 2016 55%
gender inequalities violence
Percentage of population not
blaming victims of sexual 53% 2016 60%
violence
PO considers these outcome targets levels as conservative and strives to reach
higher targets.
Training activities for specialists in contact with
victims of domestic violence must include:
o trainers must create a set of training materials that will systematically and
with sufficient thoroughness cover all topics of the training (incl. reasons and
consequences of domestic violence, assistance of victims and better inter-
sectoral cooperation). The training materials should be adequate for use of
further trainings for target groups;
o at least 8 trainings must be carried out. The length of one training is at least
32 academic hours and one training must involve 20-30 participants /
trainees;
o trainers must draw up an analytical summary on the trainings carried out
based on the feedback sheets completed by participants;
o trainers must take into account the structural gender-based nature of
domestic violence and use science-based sources and methodologies
Establishing and piloting of a programme for
sex buyers must:
o take into account the peculiarities of adult learning patterns, use
psychological counselling combined with therapeutic interventions and
implement the elements of enforcement;
o creators of the programme must assemble a implementation manual that will
systematically and with sufficient thoroughness cover the theoretical basis,
goals and principles (ethical, practical, group mentality) of the programme, the
needed skills of the actors, programme structure, phases (incl. assessing the
impact) and topics incorporated;
o pilot the programme with at least 12 sex buyers attending and finishing the
programme;
o the creators of the programme must draw up an analysis on the programme,
its impact and needs for development;
o the creators of the programme must take into account the structural gender-
based nature of domestic violence and use science-based sources and
methodologies
Evaluation criteria of the SGS
No 1 Criterion Max score Proportion
1 Project promoter and project partners: 15 27,27%
Competencies of project manager, trainers,
social programme authors 6
Project team involvement in activities 2
Involvement of NOR, ISL, LIE partners 4
Involvement of EST and other partners 3
2 Project action plan and target groups: 16 29,09%
Comprehensiveness, relevance and feasibility of the plan 8
Consideration of the target groups 4
Methods of involving participants 4
3 Project sustainability and innovation: 10 18,18%
Impact of the project activities 4
Perspective of the follow-up financing 2
Innovation and added value 4
4 Economic efficiency and co-fin: 9 16,36%
Justification and budget clarity 6
Co-fin covering measures 3
5 Project communication 2 3,64%
6 Project risk analysis 3 5,45%
TOTAL 55
Projects received within deadline*:
1. NGO Eluliin (Lifeline)
project budget 50 642 euros; grant applied for 45 415 euros (90%)
2. NGO VAITER (Competence Centre of Mental Health)
project budget 66 000 euros; grant applied for 59 400 euros (90%)
3. NGO Pärnu Naiste Tugikeskus (Pärnu Women Shelter)
project budget 63 815 euros; grant applied for 57 433 euros (90%)
* NGO Avatud Ühiskonna Instituut (Estonian Open Society Institute) submitted its
proposal after the deadline
Evaluation of independent experts
Evaluator 1: Ms Kadri-Ann Lee, Adviser, Public Order and Criminal Policy
Department, Ministry of the Interior
Evaluator 2: Ms Andrea Kink, Service Manager, Victim Support and
Prevention Services Department, Social Insurance Board
The overall grant amount asked for is less than total grant amount
available.
The difference between the scores given by the two experts was well
under 30%, so no need for a third evaluation was necessary
There were no project proposals receiving less than 50% of the total score,
and therefore would have received automatically a negative decision
Ranking list of experts
Pärnu Naiste
Eluliin Tugikeskus VAITER
No 1 Criterion Max score Average score Average score Average score
Team members’ background, competencies
and involvement in project activities and
1 involvement of partners 15 7,5 15,0 10,5
Action plan of the project, needs of the
2 target group and involvement methods 16 6,5 15,0 15,0
3 Communication activities 2 1,5 1,5 1,5
4 Risk factors 3 3,0 3,0 3,0
5 Sustainability and innovation of the project 10 7,0 7,0 10,0
Economic efficiency and project co-
6 financing 9 7,0 9,0 5,0
TOTAL 55 32,5 50,5 45
Selection Committee members
Voting members
Ms Kristiina Luht - Representative of the Ministry of Social Affairs, Equality
Policies Department;
Ms Freja Ulvestad Kärki - Representative of the Norwegian Directorate of
Health;
Ms Grete Kaju - Representative of the Ministry of Social Affairs, Equality
Policies Department
Observers
The representatives of the National Focal Point and Programme Operator
Implementing Agency (both State Shared Service Centre) as well as the donor
states (Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Financial Mechanism
Committee) shall be invited to participate as observers.
Selection Committee tasks
The goal
to confirm the list of project applications suggested to be financed and the list
of project applications not to be financed and forward its decision to the
Programme Operator Implementing Agency (i.e. State Shared Service Centre)
for formal decision making.
The tasks
review the ranking list of project applications resulting from the
mathematical average of individual expert evaluation scores;
confirm the list of project applications suggested to be financed and the
list of project applications not to be financed;
modify the ranking list of the project applications or propose only partial
financing of projects in justified cases based on transparent criteria
recorded in the minutes of the committee meeting.
After the Selection Committee
Chairman of the Selection Committee and the PO will sign the minutes of
the meeting, where decisions are laid down in a transparent and
accountable manner describing which project proposals shall be awarded a
grant and which proposals will be rejected.
PO Implementing Agency will cast a decision to award a grant or decline
awarding a grant based on the written recommendation of the Selection
Committee.
Discussion and decisions
Aitäh! Takk!
Kristiina Luht (
[email protected])
Ülar Vaadumäe (
[email protected])
Martin Karro
Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus
[email protected] Meie 12.11.2020 nr 2-6.3/3264-1
Väikeprojektide avatud taotlusvooru
„Spetsialistide koolitamine perevägivalla teemal
ning sotsiaalprogrammi loomine seksiostjatele“
hindamiskomisjoni poolt rahastamiseks
kinnitatud projektitaotlused
Lugupeetud Martin Karro
Palume Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskusel kui Euroopa Majanduspiirkonna ja Norra toetuste 2014–
2021 programmi „Kohalik areng ja vaesuse vähendamine“ rakendusüksusel langetada
toetuse rahuldamise otsused järgmiste projektitaotlused esitanud organisatsioonide suhtes,
mis laekusid väikeprojektide avatud taotlusvooru „Spetsialistide koolitamine perevägivalla
teemal ning sotsiaalprogrammi loomine seksiostjatele“ raames ja mille on oma otsusega
kinnitanud ka 2. novembril 2020. aastal kohtunud taotlusvooru hindamiskomisjon:
1. MTÜ Pärnu Naiste Tugikeskus;
2. MTÜ VAITER;
3. MTÜ Eluliin.
Palun rakendusüksusel võtta rahastusotsuste langetamisel arvesse ka hindamiskomisjoni
seatud eeltingimusi ja soovitusi, mis kajastuvad hindamiskomisjoni protokollis (lisatud).
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kristiina Hunt
nutika arengu toetamise osakonna juhataja
Lisa: Minutes of the SC meeting (Nov 02, 2020)_FINAL.ddoc
Ülar Vaadumäe 626 9249
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 626 9301 /
[email protected] / www.sm.ee / registrikood 70001952