Saatja: Berggren Erik <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 30.11.2022 17:48
Adressaat: Berggren Erik <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Gonzalo Gasos <
[email protected]>; Lukas Bornemann
<
[email protected]>; Mireille Thiery <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>
Teema: Banking Package - BusinessEurope and EBF letter
Dear Minister,
Dear Ambassador,
Dear Financial Attaché,
Dear Member of the European Parliament,
Please find attached a letter from BusinessEurope and the European
Banking Federation on the ongoing negotiations in the EU institutions
regarding the implementation of the finalisation of Basel III known as
the Banking Package.
Yours sincerely,
Erik Berggren
SENIOR ADVISER
LEGAL & ECONOMICS DEPARTMENT
168 AVENUE DE CORTENBERGH
1000 BRUSSELS - BELGIUM
Tel : +32 (0) 2 237 65 55
Follow BusinessEurope on
EU Transparency register
To EU Ministers of Finance
To Coreper
To Financial Attachés
To Members of the European Parliament
30 November 2022
Dear Minister, Ambassador, Financial Attaché
Dear Member of the European Parliament,
A banking package for strong European corporates and banks
We are writing to you in view of the ongoing negotiations in the EU institutions regarding
the implementation of the finalisation of Basel III as the main part of the legislative dossier
known as the Banking Package.
A strong corporate sector in Europe is essential for economic growth and to meet the
ambitious goals of the green and digital transition. Banks are best placed to identify
productive corporates and finance their projects and business lines. The European
banking sector has recapitalised itself to levels beyond the objectives set at the beginning
of the regulatory reform, putting it in a strong footing. Against this background, one of the
objectives of the Banking Package should be that banks can continue supporting
European businesses, also in view of the expected tightening of the financing market
due to the change in monetary policy, which will significantly alter the financing
environment of the last decade in the upcoming years.
Therefore, BusinessEurope and the European Banking Federation would like to address
the following issues to you1:
Transitional arrangements for corporate exposures
When the European Commission presented its legislative proposal for the Banking
Package, a number of measures were introduced to adapt the output floor to European
specificities. Currently, we see a risk that those may be removed or rendered
meaningless through additional limitations. Given the current dependency of corporates
to bank lending, we think it is of utmost importance to maintain the solution found for
unrated corporates and maintain it until a viable and capital neutral solution has been
1
This letter represents shared interests between the European Banking Federation and
BusinessEurope. The respective positions of the EBF can be found here for the general Banking
Package and here for the more specific case of securitisation within the Banking Package. The
BusinessEurope paper is available here.
AV. DE CORTENBERGH 168 BUSINESSEUROPE a.i.s.b.l. TEL +32(0)2 237 65 11
BE-1000 BRUSSELS FAX +32(0)2 231 14 45
BELGIUM WWW.BUSINESSEUROPE.EU E-MAIL:
[email protected]
VAT BE 863 418 279 Follow us on Twitter @BUSINESSEUROPE EU Transparency register 3978240953-79
found for corporates that do not have an external rating. Limiting the transitional
arrangement to corporates with a turnover of less than 500 million cannot be the solution.
It would not be in the interest of Europe to force thousands of European corporates to
obtain external ratings. EU legislators should primarily propose EU-based solutions
making good use of the existing information about the creditworthiness of European
corporates in Europe. Also, it is important to note that the problem of the lack of rating of
EU corporates also affects banks using the standardised approach. Therefore, any
measure should include the standardised approach.
The standardised approach for counterparty credit risk
European corporates use bank hedging services to mitigate their risks, notably interest
rate risk, foreign exchange risk or commodity risk. A key factor in this respect is the
Standardised Approach for Counterparty Credit Risk (SA-CCR) whose exposure formula
uses an alpha factor of 1.4, which was established in 2005 and does not reflect the
current market environment, in particular the current shift towards increased clearing and
collateralization. Setting the alpha factor in the SA-CCR to 1 will allow businesses to
efficiently manage their risks without an increase in costs that would put European
corporates at a competitive disadvantage or discourage them from hedging their financial
risks. This adjustment should also be effective for the standardised approach in line with
the recommendations of the co-legislators2 and the High-Level Forum on CMU3. Given
that the current calibration dates from 2005 with very different market conditions, it
should be kept in place until a revision is undertaken by the Basel Committee.
Transitional arrangements for real estate
In the EU, mortgages are largely dual recourse, which means that the bank has access
to the collateral, but also the assets of the owner. This is in contrast with the situation in
the US, where low risk mortgages are sold to State-backed entities, thus leaving the
high-risk mortgages on the balance sheets of banks. This demonstrates a fundamental
difference in the risk profile of EU banks. The Basel standard does not account for such
a feature, which is a significant risk mitigant and leads to much lower losses. As a
consequence, the output floor will hit low risk mortgages with a significant capital impact,
which will reduce significantly the availability of bank financing for businesses. EBF and
BusinessEurope therefore urge to make permanent the transitional arrangements
proposed for real estate exposures until 2032. This would allow banks to continue
applying a lower risk weight to the part of their residential mortgage exposures that is
largely secured. Such a preferential regime should also be applied to banks using the
standardised approach for the calculation of capital requirements, and thus not be
subject to the exercise of a national discretion.
2
REGULATION (EU) 2021/558 OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE
COUNCIL of 31 March 2021 amending Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 as regards adjustments
to the securitisation framework to support the economic recovery in response to the COVID-19
crisis
3 Final report of the High Level Forum on the capital Markets Union, link
2
Trade finance and unconditionally cancellable commitments
European businesses rely on exports to remain competitive in the global markets. For
that purpose, it is important that the so-called credit conversion factors (CCFs) for trade
finance exposures remain at their current level of 20%. An updated study4 of the
International Chamber of Commerce and Global Credit Data has demonstrated that such
a calibration would remain sufficiently conservative. The contemplated 50% CCF, on the
other hand, would significantly increase the costs for EU businesses, thus undermining
their competitiveness. We welcome the Council’s General Approach in that sense.
Regarding unconditionally cancellable commitments (UCCs), the European
Commission’s legislative proposal had included a transitional arrangement for a more
beneficial treatment of UCCs (article 495d) with a 0% CCF. This arrangement also
included a mandate for the EBA to assess if an extension was needed. UCCs are a
useful financing tool for the real economy, as acknowledged by the Commission.
Therefore, we support maintaining the EBA’s mandate in the transitional arrangement.
Supporting factors for SMEs and infrastructure projects, and CVA exemptions
Maintaining the SME and infrastructure supporting factors will be important for the
support of SMEs, which are largely dependent on bank lending, and for the financing of
infrastructure projects, which Europe will need to meet its objectives linked to the green
and digital transitions. Therefore, we caution against limiting the application of the
infrastructure supporting factor by introducing additional environmental criteria that
would request either an EU taxonomy alignment or linking eligibility for the SME
supporting factor to environmental performance of SMEs. Such limitations to the existing
infrastructure or SME supporting factors would make it more difficult for SMEs to manage
their own green transition and would crowd out EU banks and corporates from important
non-EU infrastructure projects. Moreover, we strongly encourage to maintain the CVA
exemptions in the current legislation as this also helps to limit corporate hedging costs.
Specialised lending
Specialised lending comprises of 3 different categories of finance which play a key role
in the EU economy: project finance (e.g., sustainable infrastructure investment, financing
of export business), object finance (e.g., a ship or an airplane) and commodity finance
(e.g., finance for the import and export of agricultural goods). It is important that the
Banking Package remains risk sensitive with respect to those low risk exposures, for
example through a better recognition of collateral. This will help to make sure that
corporates can continue to easily access financing for those exposures. Similarly, the
slotting approach should be reviewed taking into account the adjustments introduced to
this asset class to ensure that there is consistency between the 3 approaches:
standardised, slotting and IRB.
4 ICC/GCD 2022 Performance Guarantees study, link
3
Brown penalising factors
We note with concern that some policy makers are considering a Pillar 1 capital charge
for so called “brown exposures”. We do not think that this is the right way to deal with the
climate crisis at this given point in time. A Pillar 1 charge will raise the costs for
businesses who are in the process of improving their environmental performance, thus
making it even more difficult to meet the public policy objectives for carbon neutrality. It
is an effect that we consider to be unintended and of a significant impact. The current
NGO proposals for a brown penalising factor estimate additional capital of 34 billion
euros5 for the 22 banks in the sample. Such impact would withdraw more than 800 billion
euros of lending to the European economy. To put this into perspective, this is more than
the entire size of the NextGenerationEU programme. In conclusion, the Pillar 1 brown
penalties proposed by NGOs will simply limit the capacity of companies to finance their
green transition and detract funds from the European economy at large.
We are confident that these recommendations will be taken on board in the articulation
of the banking package legislation contributing to a strong corporate sector in Europe
financed by a strong banking system.
We remain at your disposal for further discussion.
Yours sincerely,
Markus J. Beyrer Wim Mijs
BusinessEurope Director General EBF Chief Executive Officer
5
Finance Watch report: A safer transition for fossil banking, link
4