Ref. Ares(2022)8727728 - 15/12/2022
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATE-GENERAL
REGIONAL AND URBAN POLICY
Directorate Territorial Co-operation, Macro-regions and Programmes Implementation I
Estonia, Finland, Latvia and Lithuania
Brussels
REGIO.D.4//
Annex 1
DRAFT MINUTES OF THE ANNUAL REVIEW MEETING
European Structural & Investment Funds 2014-2020
CCI 2014EE16M3OP001
Estonia
6 December 2022, Tallinn
Agenda of the meeting: 1. Opening
2. Strategic aspects of implementation
3. Overview of programme performance
4. Specific thematic focus
5. Post 2020
6. Conclusions
Participants: Please see Annex 2
1. Opening
Commission services (COM) laid down the aims of the meeting, namely taking stock of the 2014-2020 and
lay the groundwork for 2021-2027 period. COM also recognized the challenges Estonia currently faces – high
inflation, refugees fleeing the military aggression of the Russian Federation. Besides placing the state budget
under strain, they are also causing some EU funded infrastructure projects to be cancelled or delayed. To
alleviate the challenges faced by Estonia, COM highlighted the option to use CARE, FAST-CARE and SAFE
initiatives. COM also congratulated Estonia on being the third Member State to conclude the negotiations with
the Commission on all four funds (ERDF, CF, ESF+ and JTF).
Ministry of Finance (MoF) outlined the challenges the implementation of funds faces due to pandemic, the
war in Ukraine and inflation, all of which have led to issues with the completion of projects, especially
construction ones. Despite the obstacles, the absorption rate of the programme is projected to be 84% by the
end of the year. Refugees have also added an additional burden on the state finances, as in 2021 a total of 250
MEUR have been allocated from the national budget for their needs. Estonia is expecting that the number of
the refugees will increase, therefore, the country is advocating for more solidarity at the EU level. Lastly, MoF
thanked COM for the constructive cooperation in the negotiations on the multi-fund programme for the 2021-
2027 period.
The Managing Authority - State Shared Services Centre (MA) explained that the speed of the
implementation has increased even though the most complicated projects are being concluded. MA gave
account of their activities mentioning that, first, more than 120 persons have attended the trainings to boost the
efficiency of the overall system. Second, DNSH network was launched. Third, communication activities have
contributed to the visibility and the overall recognition of the structural funds. Payments in total of half a
million euros to the beneficiaries have already been made for the 2021-2027 programme.
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
[email protected]
2. Strategic aspects of implementation
2.1 Regional distribution of investments and results (NUTS 3 level), where available;
2.2 Main findings of evaluations performed in 2022;
2.3 EU Strategy for the Baltic Sea Region (EUSBR). State of play of cooperation activities in the region.
Covered in a written procedure.
3. Overview of programme performance
a) Risks and general issues affecting the implementation of the programme and achievement of the targets.
MoF presented a detailed overview of the financial implementation and progress on performance framework.
Estonia is one of the best performing Member States in terms of financial implementation in June 2022 being
on the fifth place (including EMFAF and EAFRD). Estonia is more risk averse in terms of commitments, with
101% committed for the cohesion policy funds, from which on 6 December 2022 82% had been disbursed.
Concerning REACT-EU, 17 MEUR are not yet covered by commitments, but Estonia aims to cover the whole
allocation by the end of the year. Efforts are undertaken on some priority axes with comparatively weaker
performance, for ERDF those are Priority Axis 1– the school network, PA 2 – health infrastructure, PA 12 –
administrative capacity / e-government. ESF has been overall progressing well, with two PA-s still with lower
payment rates. ESF PA4/Innovation stands at 71%, but the progress is good as this activity started only in
2019; and ESF REACT-EU with 8%, but it should catch up as the commitment rate is high. The Estonian
authorities are conducting monthly reviews and closely cooperating among ministries, making changes to the
terms and conditions of the measures, mapping the riskiest measures. Regular discussions take place in the
Government meetings from April 2021. Payment claims are expected at the end of the year. For example,
school network projects should finalize by the end of the year and also the projects from PAs 9 and 12 were
implemented in 2021 and 2022 only, so more data will be obtained in the near future. Viljandi hospital,
initially included in ERDF PA2 measures, will be financed from the RRF (modification on-going).
Concerning the performance framework, MoF expects achievement of all output indicators close to 100% or
more by the end of the period, besides one target remaining at 67% (PA 9). For REACT-EU, only 3 out of 6
studies will be completed for COVID with 50% achievement level, since, due to their higher cost, the allocated
funds can cover only 3 of them.
Currently 650 MEUR of programme`s funding remains unpaid, which leaves approximately 56 MEUR to be
paid per month and is well within the current trend. Therefore, Estonia expects to reach 100% absorption in Q1
2024.
b) Utilisation of end-of period flexibilities, possible reallocations between Priority Axis and measures,
possible last amendment of the OP (including FAST-CARE).
MoF had used an option to overbook the programme, but with Viljandi hospital to be financed from the RRF,
the overbooking will be reduced to 101%. The authorities have used the 100% co-financing, which has helped
to accumulate a buffer of 193 MEUR for the closure. At this stage, no phasing of projects is foreseen, albeit
non-functioning projects will occur.
MoF will establish in 2023 if an amendment of the programme is needed.
c) Preparation for the closure.
MA stated that one project will definitely be non-functioning (study on radioactive waste disposal site),
whereas five additional ones might be added to the list. Currently there are 12 191 completed projects, with
1850 projects still ongoing (15% of total). 227 are to be completed in December 2023. Guidelines on how to
prepare non-functioning projects are being prepared.
2
COM agreed that Estonia is performing comparatively well. Nevertheless, overbooking is very minimal and
this might pose some risks. There might also be risks for REACT-EU. COM highlighted that the possibilities
offered by FAST-CARE and SAFE can be helpful. Concerning the 2021-2027 period, COM reminded that it is
important to use the lessons learned from the start of the 2014-2020 period.
MoF admitted that Estonia has been conservative in their budgeting with limited overbooking. Phasing cannot
be considered due to constrained flexibility in PO4 and strict thematic concentration rules. No remaining
funding for SAFE is available as more than 100% has been committed.
COM suggested that MA is in an excellent position to share with other Member States its vast knowledge and
experience in successful implementation of the EU funds, to which MA confirmed the readiness to do so.
COM also asked for a clarification on the study of nuclear waste, which was highlighted as a non-functioning
project by the MA. More information was provided that the project concerns a former Soviet nuclear reactor in
Paldiski, which was used for training purposes and contains nuclear waste. The purpose of the study was to
decontaminate (de-radiate) the immediate area and materials (metal) in it. Preparation of the project was done
with the EU funding and the project will be completed with the national one.
4. Specific thematic focus
4.1 Information from the Audit Authority on:
a) Environmental Investment Centre (uptake of recommendations, follow-up audit);
b) Merger of KredEx and Enterprise Estonia and implications on the implementation.
Audit Authority (AA) presented an overview of past and future audits, covering Environmental Investment
Centre in more detail. According to AA, in 2021 42 audits were conducted, covering 28 MEUR and 15
MEUR from financial instruments with error rate of 1.67%. DAC was broadly in agreement with the
conclusions and one case was adjusted where DAC asked for 10% correction, whereas AA had considered 1%
sufficient.
In 2022, 5 ESF and 25 ERDF/CF audits were conducted and with financial instruments the sample size was
35.6 MEUR (4,6% of financing). There are still a number of procurement cases which are not completely
correct. Error rate to be expected below 2%, which is in line with the past experience. There are three findings
which AA explained in more detail. First concerns a case where SCO unit price had not been identified.
Second – potential gold-plating where internal project rules were not followed. Third - eligibility period was
fixed to 1.5 years, which was too short and did not allow the payments to be made in that timeframe. All these
can be fixed retrospectively according to the AA. Overall procurements still tend to be too restrictive.
Kredex merger with Enterprise Estonia will be audited in 2024. Current interest for the AA is to control
comparable offers in case beneficiary is not a subject to public procurement law (across all funds). Audit on
the quality of public procurement verifications is still ongoing. Management and control system works, but,
overall, procurement is still an issue – too many mistakes by contractors – the system is generally complex
and gold-plating does occur, however, procurement controls are improving. Beneficiaries find the procedures
complex. Use of SCOs is quite limited and it is possible they are at the maximum level.
AA also outlined that a low risk remains with the RRF double financing. In Estonia overlaps are not numerous
between multi-fund programme and the RRF, and common IT system helps to minimize the risks.
Regarding Environmental Investment Centre, AA and MA are working on the solution, however, COM`s
required deadline to solve the issues by the acceptance of accounts of the 2021/2022 period, will not be met.
COM emphasized that the payment claims should not contain expenditure related to the Environmental
Investment Centre and it should be clearly indicated by the authorities when submitting them. MA confirmed
the compliance with the request. AA confirmed that to their knowledge no expenditure has been declared in
the payment claims regarding Environmental Investment Centre.
3
COM also outlined that simplification should be sought for and more exchange between MS could be helpful.
FNLC were also promoted by the COM. COM asked about the level of engagement in the Kredex and
Enterprise Estonia merger. AA replied, that no engagement so far as the merger has been quite recent.
AA noted that on FNLC limited examples from other Member States are available. COM in turn will look for
examples internally.
4.2 Accommodation of needs of the Ukrainian refugees in the ESF measures: overview, challenges, and future
plans.
MoF presented the agenda point. As of 20 November 2022, temporary protection has been requested by 40
125 people. Number of Ukrainians registered as unemployed in November 2022 is 6 250 and 75% of
registered unemployed person have found a job. More than 8 000 Ukrainian students have been registered,
53% of them attend school or kindergarten in Tallinn. Under the ESF, the refugees entered mainstream
measures (together with other target groups), and Estonia has provided a wide range of education, active
labour market and social support measures (including FEAD – food aid) so far. The main challenges are the
lack of opportunities due to increasing number of refugees and lack of Ukrainian speaking teachers. Estonia
expects another wave of refugees in the winter of 2022/2023 due to attacks on energy infrastructure.
COM acknowledged the efforts made to accommodate significant number of refugees compared to the overall
population and the timely support provided to them. COM enquired whether it would be possible to get an
assessment of how many have received ESF support (could be an estimate if ESF data collection does not
allow for this level of detail). Secondly, whether the ESF funding could facilitate bringing additional
teachers/support specialists to the schools (could be from amongst Ukrainian refugees). The lack of them was
brought out as one challenge Estonia is facing now, however, ESF should have appropriate measures and still
some funding available to tackle this issue. COM thanked the authorities in advance for providing more
precise answers in written form.
4.3 ESF PA1 measures (education/skills): progress, remaining challenges, achievement of final targets.
MoF presented the progress and remaining challenges with PA 1 measures on education and skills. Overall,
these have been progressing well, and apart from some small adaptations, like need to extend the provision of
education support services for war refugees in schools, there are no major problems in implementation. Most
output indicators are well over 2023 target levels, and no significant issues with absorption expected.
COM acknowledged the good results for the ESF education and skills development measures under PA 1.
Next year the upskilling and reskilling of adults will be more in focus, with the launch of the European Year
of Skills 2023 expected in late spring/early summer. The aim is to promote better skills matching, cooperation
with social partners, and facilitate recognition of qualifications. Estonia is also invited to actively disseminate
good practices from EU funded education and skills’ development projects.
4.4 Implementation progress of financial instruments - progress achieved towards the targets, identified
remaining bottlenecks.
4.5 State of play with Liikva project.
Covered in a written procedure.
5. Post 2020
a) By fund: gradual implementation of the Specific Objectives and measures, elaboration on selection
criteria as requested in the letter of 27 July 2022.
MoF stated that the general selection criteria and the methodology was approved in the shadow Monitoring
Committee in May 2022. All ministries already follow it. Estonia would like to continue with the current
4
practice where stakeholders are involved through the IT platform for all draft legislation - eis.ee (in place for
about 10 years). It works the following way – the responsible ministry introduces the documents in the
aforementioned IT system and the stakeholders can comment it. The IT system is public. The Ministry
responsible for the terms of support has to provide the feedback to the comments made on the IT platform.
The authorities are flexible to extend the consultation to 15 working days in compliance with the CPR.
COM emphasized that the compliance with the CPR is key. In line with the Partnership Principle, Monitoring
Committee (MC) has to approve all the selection criteria. COM asked for a clarification on how the
compliance with the CPR will be ensured. COM asked if there is a way how a member of MC can vote
against. MoF promised to provide a more detailed reply on how the system works in a written format.
b) Planned use of Simplified Cost Options in 2021-2027 period.
MA would like to increase the use of SCOs in 2021-2027 and has one expert working full time to contribute
to that. Consultations with the ministries are ongoing. According to MA, the ERDF is less flexible for the
SCOs, challenge is too turbulent macroeconomic situation (fluctuation of prices).
c) Introduction of the new data collection information system.
MA introduced the new system which will reduce the reporting time for beneficiaries to 20 hours from 40
hours and for the administration from 5.5 hours to 0.5 hours. The calculations were made on ESF data, but the
changes in the system apply also to the ERDF. The data will be aggregated and the process streamlined.
System will be used in the 2021-2027 period.
d) Introduction of ex-ante evaluation of the planned financial instruments.
The substantial study by consultants (Praxis and EY) focused on entrepreneurship, housing, environment and
social fields.
For financial instruments to address the market failures in entrepreneurial sector (inadequate collateral, high
interest rates, creditworthiness of start-ups, poor access to financial services, difficult market introduction of
innovative and/or research-intensive technologies), the consultants suggest rollout of subordinated loans,
combined start-up loans and loan guarantees.
For dwellings 1/3 of the target could be achieved with the financial instruments. For that to happen the
authorities should offer financial products to apartment associations to which the financial institution has not
granted a loan or has done so under unreasonable conditions, offer longer loan repayment period, involve
local governments. Consultants suggest implementation through renovation loan and apartment loan
guarantee.
According to consultants, Estonia is one of those EU countries that has to make a bigger leap in development
in the field of environment compared to other countries, and the grants must help overcome major obstacles
caused by the investments connected to the environment fields. Consultants recommend that non-refundable
grants to companies are provided and also more favourable terms and conditions for the provision of loans and
loan guarantees for the financing of investments related to environmental goals compared to other types of
investments are laid down.
For social field FI are not suitable.
COM welcomed the approach in the study such with mixing grants with the financial instruments. COM
enquired how the rollout of the financial instruments to counties where the uptake is lower can be increased.
According to experts, the main tool would be offering lower co-financing rates and also their promotion is
important. Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications (MoEAC), responsible for the
implementation promised to evaluate the recommendations.
5
COM enquired on the recommendation to reduce bureaucracy and make the system more flexible. Ministry of
MoEAC replied that the IB (Kredex) is already is functioning well. The aim of the ministry is to create one
page pooling all the information for enterprises (one stop shop).
To COM`s question why energy efficient renovation rate is comparatively higher in Lääne-Virumaa county,
MoEAC, could not provide a conclusive answer.
6. Conclusions
COM concluded with summarising the main challenges and conclusions of the meeting. COM will evaluate
the improvements concerning the management and control system of the Environmental Investment Centre
and thanked the authorities for including the information when submitting the next payment claims that no
expenditure concerning the IB has been declared. Concerning SCOs, COM will internally look how to
coordinate more among the Member States and will work to obtain more good examples of the
implementation. COM recognized that FNCL might be sent by Estonia. Lastly, COM thanked the Estonian
authorities for the extensive presentations and organizing the site visits, while also emphasizing the
importance to engage with the beneficiaries to the extent possible.
MoF confirmed that their priority is to successfully conclude the 2014-2020 period to reach 100% and the
ministry is currently working on the successful launch of the 2021-2027, despite the overlapping periods. MoF
will reply to two questions regarding refugees (p. 4.2 above) and continue a written exchange on the adoption
procedures of the selection criteria.
MA will focus on the speeding up the implementation to reach full absorption. As the most complex projects
usually are completed close to the end of the period, therefore some respective discussions and decisions
might be needed. MA thanked COM for the cooperation.
6
Ref. Ares(2022)8727728 - 15/12/2022
Ref. Ares(2022)8727728 - 15/12/2022
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATE-GENERAL
REGIONAL AND URBAN POLICY
European Territorial Cooperation, Macro-regions, Interreg and Programme Implementation I
Estonia, Finland, Latvia and Lithuania
Brussels
REGIO.D.4/EO/(2022)9701578
Subject: Draft minutes of the Annual Review Meeting on December 6, 2022
Dear Mr Kirsipuu,
Please find attached the draft minutes of the Annual Review Meeting, held on December
6, 2022, for your comments and approval.
Your response is welcome as soon as possible, but at the latest by January 16, 2022.
Yours sincerely,
Electronically signed
Andreas VON BUSCH
Head of Unit
Enclosure: Annex 1 Draft minutes of the ARM
Annex 2 List of participants
c.c.: Linda Sproģe, Renaldo Mändmets, Pekka Jounila, Edijs Ostrovskis
(Directorate-General for Regional and Urban Policy)
Aurimas Andrulis, Riin Saluveer, Angeelika Rooden (Directorate-
General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion)
Mr Sven Kirsipuu
Deputy Secretary General
Ministry of Finance of Estonia
Suur Ameerika 1
10122 Tallinn, Estonia
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
[email protected]
Electronically signed on 15/12/2022 14:37 (UTC+01) in accordance with Article 11 of Commission Decision (EU) 2021/2121